Chapter Text
Far away to the West, leagues and leagues from the Lonely Mountain, King Thorin II, son of Thrain, son of Thror, wakes with his sword by his side and a pouch of cheap pipeweed upon his breast. The room is dark; dawn’s first light is hours away, so Thorin’s first act upon waking is to fumble for the lamp and light it. His eyes are keen in the dark, but he has need of light just now. Thorin has waited many years for this day, and he will sit idle no longer.
“Ugh,” comes a groan from one of the two lumps laying in the oversized bed. “Uncle, it cannot be morning yet.”
“Get up, Kíli,” Thorin counsels, his voice rough from sleep, “And wake your brother. We cannot tarry.”
Kíli sits up in bed and stretches before kicking his brother awake. Thorin finds it difficult to believe that his heir could remain asleep in a room flooded with light, to which their people are especially sensitive. More likely than not, Fíli is only feigning sleep now. Of course, any reasoning along these lines from Kíli will likely lead to a wrestling match for which they have no time.
“I’m awake,” Fíli grumbles. He has managed to monopolize all of the blankets in his sleep, and he stirs beneath them now. “What time is it?”
“It’s the middle of the night,” Kíli reports without a glance toward the clock as he kicks off the single sheet that covers him. “But Uncle Thorin is ready to go, so we must be as well, or we’ll be left behind.” Even at this hour, Mahal has blessed Kíli with seemingly inexhaustible stores of energy.
His brother is not so lucky. Fíli curses under his breath and makes no move to rise. “Left behind, or carried off and tied to ponies whether we’re ready to go or not?”
“Wanna find out? I’ll give you, mmm… three gold coins if you stay right where you are and wait for His Majesty to deal with you,” Kíli jokes. Blessedly, he begins shoving his meager possessions into his pack, which he left in the middle of the floor, presumably in order to make it as much of a tripping hazard as possible.
“You don’t have three gold coins,” the Crown Prince points out.
His brother shrugs. “I’d take them from Uncle’s pack. He’d be distracted carrying you off and tying you to the pony.” He moves on to Fíli’s pack, although this is largely unnecessary, as the bag is stuffed nearly to bursting and propped against the wall.
Thorin is endeared, despite himself, as he always is by these two boys. The three of them have spent the past several weeks on the road, doing what they can to gather coin and support in anticipation of their oncoming quest. From here, Fíli and Kíli will lead their uncle to the meeting where he will seek formal aid from the other Dwarven kingdoms. Then, they will proceed to the Shire, where Thorin will meet them several hours later. Assuming, of course, that he does not lose his way coming from the meeting, which is a legitimate possibility.
Since they first left the Blue Mountains, Fíli and Kíli have taken every possible opportunity to make Thorin’s life harder. They have stolen his pipe more than once, replacing it by turns with sticks and stones and, on one particularly memorable occasion, a dagger, still warm from long hours spent concealed somewhere on Fíli’s person. Kíli has spent the entire journey chattering incessantly, no matter what kinds of glares Thorin shoots in his direction. His brother is even worse, finding the least opportune moments to grill Thorin about the particulars of kingship for future reference. All in all, they cause him more grief between them than any all the other members of his paltry court combined.
And yet, the king loves his sister-sons with all his heart. Their childhoods were not easy, and they have each of them seen things that no prince of any realm should ever have to see, but they’ve been brought up with plenty of love and no shortage of mirth. This much, Thorin has been able to give them. Mischievous though they may be, Fíli and Kíli are good lads. At mealtimes, they wait until others have been served before filling their own bowls, and on the road, they ride ahead of their elders to scout for dangers without having to be asked. They’ll give Thorin no end of grief about the waking-up issue, but when push comes to shove, they’ll be hot on his heels as he storms out the door. He won’t be tying anybody into their saddle this day.
“Are we not entitled to our rest?” Fíli demands of his uncle, all of a sudden every inch the prince. It is not a skill he uses often, having no real need of it in his typical dealings. He has never known a life of courtly manners, never slept beneath an embroidered canopy, never dined on fine foods or strode through marble halls. But he’s a good mimic and can adopt Thorin’s most regal mannerisms when it suits him. Coming from any but his heir, this would annoy Thorin to no end. Coming from Fíli, it fills him with hope.
Should things go poorly, should Thorin fall, his nephew will step forward to claim the throne. Fíli may not be prepared to reclaim Erebor single-handedly. He may be forced to lead their party back to the Blue Mountains. He may need to wait until he is older and more accustomed to the particulars of ruling before he makes another attempt on their Mountain. But at the very least, Thorin’s people will be in good hands in his absence.
“We’ll miss our appointment with our Burglar if we’re not careful,” Kíli reminds his brother, finally hopping out of bed, “And we’ve got to see Uncle to his meeting. We’d best not keep him waiting, lest we face his wrath.” This they have both seen on more than one occasion, and yet, still they follow Thorin. “Even worse if we let him go alone. If he gets himself lost, you’ll have to be king, and then what?”
“Listen to your brother,” Thorin advises, “Or you truly will be left behind.” He is lying, and Fíli knows this, but he does at least draw back the covers. Despite their protests at being woken, Thorin knows very well that his sister-sons are just as eager as he is for the journey ahead.
They do not need to see him to his meeting, as Kíli puts it. They could spend hours more lazing about and take whatever shortcuts they please to the distant Shire. But Thorin’s sister-sons are loyal and serious about their duty to their people. They have long hours of pony-riding ahead of them, and they’re experienced enough to plan their journey so that they arrive in time for their scheduled dinner.
“Fine,” Fíli concedes, rising and stretching with theatrical flourish. “We can sleep in the Maker’s halls, I suppose, and besides, somebody’s got to keep His Majesty from getting lost. May as well be us.”
Bilbo finds himself sitting in his garden with a pipe in his mouth. The pipe is similar in shape and quality to one that he lost on his adventure, and the pipeweed inside of it is very fine, as well. Sweet and aromatic, proper Old Toby, not that bland stuff they gave him in Rivendell or the bitter mix preferred by his Ereborean friends. Certainly not the nonsense that Merry and Pippin brought back from Isengard, improperly dried on the side of the road by somebody who was familiar with the good stuff but lacked the skill to cultivate it properly. And, naturally, the gardens are beautiful, although that isn’t really saying much; the gardens of Bag End have always been beautiful. And this is certainly Bag End.
Bilbo would not have expected to see his old home transplanted into the afterlife for his perpetual enjoyment. His understanding of the Dwarven afterlife is that he will be expected to wait upon Mahal, though what that might entail, Bilbo still has not managed to figure out. He’d always believed that Mahal’s children returned to the stone from whence they had come upon their deaths, but Balin had told him otherwise when…
No. Bilbo swallows that memory. This is supposed to be a happy time, and so Bilbo will be happy. There is no point mourning Thorin or the lads all over again, no point remembering the three of them, laid out on stone slabs, hands placed strategically to obscure the gaping holes they all sported on their persons. There is no point thinking of that conversation with Balin, the comforting hand on Bilbo’s trembling shoulder as he sobbed and sobbed in front of the company. He had thought, at the time, that he’d been very subtle about his feelings for Thorin, but of course, they all must have known. After all, they, too, were mourning their friends, their royal family, and none of them had broken down sobbing, clutching uselessly at Thorin’s cold, unfeeling hand…
No. This is a happy time. This is a happy day and Bilbo will be seeing his friends again very soon. He has a fine pipe and a beautiful garden anda comfortable home, or something that looks like one, at least, and as Galadriel promised, he will find his family soon. Frodo will certainly be along shortly, even if Bilbo needs to travel far to meet the others. There is no point dwelling on the past. It is over and done with.
He tries his best to focus on the production of smoke rings. Bilbo sucks in smoke and directs all of his attention to the careful shaping of it. Beautiful. A perfect ring. That’s good. He’s sure the lads will love to see his smoke rings, and perhaps even Thorin will be impressed, though he doubts it. From what he remembers, the king could send smoke rings floating about at will, up the chimney or out the window or round and round in circles, depending on his mood. Bilbo should like to see that again. It’s a good thing they’ve still got pipes here in the afterlife.
It isn’t long before a figure approaches, grey-clad and towering. That stops Bilbo in his tracks, mouth hanging open and pipe resting in his hand. He could not make a smoke ring if he tried as his heart plummets into his stomach. “Gandalf?” He is catching flies, he knows, but he cannot help but gape. “What are you doing here?”
Of course, Bilbo knew that Gandalf was planning on accompanying him and Frodo to the Undying Lands. The fact that the Wizard is finally out of business, as it were, does not surprise Bilbo half as much as the fact that the Wizard is here, in this strange afterlife where Bilbo is to be reunited with Thorin and the rest of the company. Gandalf did travel with them initially, though he made himself quite scarce during the journey, particularly when having a Wizard about would have been most useful. Still, if he is here, does that not mean that he is dead? It is one thing for Bilbo to make such a choice; his life was stretched beyond its natural confines by the Ring before accelerating rapidly toward an end he’d put off for some time. But Gandalf? As far as Bilbo knows, Wizards live forever. What on Earth is Gandalf doing here?
“My dear fellow!” Obviously, Gandalf was expecting to find Bilbo just outside this facsimile of Bag End. He must have spoken with Galadriel and concluded that he’d be more needed here than in the Undying Lands, which may very well be true. Bilbo still has no idea how he’s supposed to get to Thorin and the others. He can’t imagine they’ve been knocking about in this copy of his homefor so many decades, and if they have, he can only imagine the state of the place on the inside. “It’s good to see that you remember me!”
“Remember you?” What is he on about? “Well, of course I remember you, Gandalf! But what are you doing here?” Bilbo looks around for emphasis and sees movement out of the corner of his eye.
A Hobbit lass, carrying the washing in from the clothesline. Is that… Begonia Proudfoot? She looks amazing for her age, but then, Bilbo supposes, this is the afterlife. Although that does not explain what she is doing in this afterlife at all. He cannot imagine any Proudfoot agreeing to spend eternity in the Dwarven afterlife. And he can’t imagine that Mahal would want Begonia waiting on him for the rest of time. She has an awful lot in common with her cousin Lobelia, and Bilbo remembers her making off with more than a few of his father’s best vases during the auction of Bag End. And there’s her husband Tom, who makes his wife look well-mannered and refused to return any of the furniture he’d pillaged from Bilbo’s home before the auction even took place! Unlike Begonia, who does have a very deft hand in the herb garden, it must be said, Tom has no redeeming qualities at all. Why would they be chosen to wait upon any of the Valar?
Clearly, this is not Mahal’s realm. Bilbo does not know if he has reached the place where Hobbits go when they die and must now fight his way to his friends, or if this is a new plane of existence created especially for the ring-bearers and their kin, but either way, it is not what he expected. But that would explain Gandalf’s sudden appearance. Perhaps the Wizard is here to help guide Bilbo from the Hobbit section of the afterlife to the Dwarven realm. But if that's the case, it seems a little circuitous. Why not just drop him directly where he’s meant to be?
Gandalf studies Bilbo’s expression with eyes that have seen many an age. He does not betray whatever thoughts are swimming there. He never has done, and apparently, death has not changed him. “I’m looking for someone to share in an adventure!”
“Again?” Bilbo demands. This is really too much. He’s already got to put up with his nosy neighbors for the rest of time, and now he has to face the perils of the road? If they’re letting in the Proudfoots, Bilbo can easily imagine that a couple of trolls and maybe even an orc or two have also made the cut. “Yes, alright. When are we leaving? I must say, at my age, I’m looking forward more to the destination than the journey, but I suppose there’ll be much to see along the way that I’ve yet to encounter, so I can’t say it’ll be for nothing.” And it won’t hurt to accumulate a couple of new stories to share with Frodo when they meet him.
“At your age? My dear chap, you’re not a day above fifty,” Gandalf informs him, “That’s not quite so old for a Hobbit. And I would hardly count your youthful forays into the woods as proper adventures. You’ll soon find there’s more to the world than you’ve been told, Mister Baggins.”
Bilbo only blinks at him. Gandalf is a strange creature, it must be said. He is long-lived and powerful, like an elf, but impulsive and self-interested, like a man. Bilbo has come to expect a little bit of oddness from the Wizard. But referring to Bilbo’s adventure as a youthful foray? A youthful foray that got two princes and a king killed? “Excuse me?” Bilbo demands.
“Have you even been so far as Bree?” Gandalf asks him.
What kind of a question is that? Bilbo searches the Wizard’s eyes for mirth and finds none. “What are you saying?”
“I’m saying,” Gandalf explains, “That I think you could use a bit of adventure.”
It is clear that the Wizard does not mind Bilbo’s obvious distress in the slightest, but Bilbo is not a stupid Hobbit. It is also clear that Gandalf has no recollection of bringing Bilbo on an adventure before. And he thinks Bilbo is fifty. And there are Hobbits here, along with the Wizard, and Bilbo’s garden, and Bag End, and his missing pipe. All the wishful thinking in the world could not obscure the truth from Bilbo, and he is not at all pleased about it.
An adventure is one thing. Bilbo loves adventures! But the same adventure another time? To do everything over again? To relive all of the peril, all of the terror, and every single awkward moment? Bilbo’s head is spinning with the broader implications.
“Oh, by the Valar,” Bilbo grumbles, “This is really just Hobbiton, isn’t it?” More likely than not, he’d have figured that out much sooner if he’d not had his heart set on sharing eternity in a peaceful afterlife with all those closest to him. Certainly, the fleeting images shown to him by Lady Galadriel make a lot more sense now.
Bilbo had thought that they’d been memories, context for the other, more concrete pictures into which they’d resolved themselves. But no. He’d been looking into his future the entire time. He never could’ve thought that it was even within the Lady’s power to do something like this. Sending Bilbo back in time, to reside in his younger body and retrace his steps? Why, it’s like something out of a fairy tale! Bilbo is not looking forward to being chased across the map by Orcs, attacked by spiders, or imprisoned by Elves. And those are just the things that he can expect to happen based on his previous adventure! Who knows what changes might take place as a result of Bilbo’s altered actions?
“Why, yes,” Gandalf replies, clearly confused by the question. “But you’ve left Hobbiton many times before.”
Right. He thinks that he’s dealing with the fifty-year-old Bilbo who has never properly left the Shire and does not wish to. He’s trying to coax a homebody Gentehobbit into following him on an adventure for the first time, not to comfort him about the fact that, apparently, he has been hoodwinked into going through with everything again. Why couldn’t Galadriel just tell Bilbo what she meant, in words, rather than leaving him to interpret a barrage of cryptic images?
But that’s hardly fair. After all, Bilbo could have asked for clarification, but he was certain that he knew exactly what the Elf was trying to communicate. It’s not her fault she’s an ancient being who has wielded a ring of power since before Bilbo’s earliest known ancestor was born. No doubt she has no idea the sort of gap that exists between her and any mortals with whom she might wish to interact.
Bilbo rolls his eyes. “Yes,” he tells the Wizard, “I most definitely have.”
“So it won’t be too much hardship for you to leave it once again.”
Not too much hardship? Not too much hardship to watch his friends suffer and die? Gandalf must be joking. Bilbo has to bite his lip, reminding himself over and over again in his head that the Wizard has no idea what will come to pass. And Bilbo isn’t going to tell him.
He can’t, can he? Never mind that Gandalf would be insufferable if he knew anything about Bilbo’s feelings for Thorin, which are so integral to the tale that Bilbo doesn’t think he’d be able to tell it without making them apparent. Never mind that Gandalf would be forced to lie to Elrond, Galadriel, and everyone else, telling them that everything would be fine when he knew that it would not. Never mind that it would change the entire course of the adventure if Gandalf knew what would happen to the company, thereby creating new peril for them to avoid.
If the Wizard knew about the Ring, the entire quest would be derailed. Maybe he’d forbid Bilbo from going, or maybe he’d encourage him to collect the thing and then destroy it right away. Perhaps he’d seek counsel from the wise. No doubt he’d come up with his own plan, and no doubt it would be convoluted, foolish, and dangerous. Perhaps he’d still encourage the company to undertake their own journey while spiriting Bilbo away to Mount Doom to take on Frodo’s burden. But that won’t do at all! Bilbo knows he needs to be there for his friends, whatever happens. He’ll be forced to lie to Gandalf, whether he likes it or not.
“Oh, alright.” Bilbo sighs. He doesn’t have much choice in the matter.
If he refuses to go, Thorin will proceed to Erebor anyway, and probably get himself and his company killed along the way. How many times did Bilbo save their lives on the journey, after all? And besides, Bilbo knows that no matter what he says, Gandalf will invite the company to Bag End for tea tomorrow. He knows that tea will turn into dinner, which will turn into supper, and he will be asked to come with them to reclaim their home. He could not refuse the first time, when he did not know these people, and now that they are his friends? Oh, goodness. Bilbo won’t be able to say no.
But if he’s there, he can do something. Didn’t Galadriel show him a future where the company lived? Where Thorin bore unfamiliar battle scars, and Kíli had a beard halfway down his chest, and Fíli stood beside them in the proper regalia of the Crown Prince of Erebor? Does that not mean that, should Bilbo succeed, he can protect his friends from their fates? Not that he has any idea how to do so. If he knew that, he’d have done it already, and they wouldn’t be in this mess.
“That’s wonderful to hear,” Gandalf beams at him, pleasantly surprised by the fact that he has managed, with minimal effort, to talk a perfectly respectable Hobbit into coming on an adventure. “Wonderful indeed.”
Bilbo only shakes his head. “Come back for tea tomorrow,” he orders, “And please, invite your whole party.” He can’t stop the sarcasm from seeping into his tone as he says that. Gandalf never gave him any warning, after all, which would have been the polite thing to do. And if Bilbo had known to expect fourteen visitors, he certainly would’ve been better prepared to host them all at one time. “Oh, and Gandalf? Do. Not. Mark. My. Door.”
Truth be told, Bilbo doesn’t care so much about the marked door. He tried painting over it, of course, but some magical property kept the rune perfectly visible for many years after his adventure. Though, the scratch faded in time, resolving itself eventually into the faint outline of a rune amidst a sea of lovely green. Really, it’s the principle of the thing, that Gandalf would presume to put an enchanted mark on Bilbo’s door without even warning him first. Honestly, the Wizard could use a lesson or two in manners. He is Bilbo’s dear friend, but his rudeness truly knows no bounds. Anyway, speaking of boundless rudeness, Bilbo has a party to prepare for.
He rises, puts out his pipe, and strides back into Bag End without a glance behind him. He hears the Wizard’s chuckling, and for what it’s worth, Bilbo cannot restrain his own smile when the mirthful sound is followed by the audible scraping of the Wizard’s staff against his freshly-painted door.
Bilbo’s first order of business, once Gandalf has retreated back onto Hobbiton’s only road, is to make himself a pot of strong tea and some elevensies. It’s obvious what’s going on, and Bilbo knows that he can’t very well face it on an empty stomach. He’s going to need tea and biscuits and perhaps a couple sausages before he can really get to thinking about the adventure he’s being sent on once again. He would have much preferred to join his kin in the Dwarven afterlife, but he sees now that it was ridiculous of him to expect Galadriel to give him an easy way out. She would not have expended so much power to grant a single Hobbit such a monumental boon.
If showing him that frightful series of images made her sweat, what did it do to the Lady to send Bilbo more than eight decades into the past? Even with her ring on, did she have that much power to spare? Could she have destroyed herself in the casting of such a spell? Bilbo does not know. He has no understanding whatsoever of how these things operate. Thinking about it for longer than a few seconds makes his head spin: if Bilbo changes things as he intends to, then the future will not happen as he remembers it. Galadriel would have no reason to send him back, and therefore he would not be back here to begin with. But if she did not intend for him to change then future, then why would she have done this? And the visions that she showed him clearly depicted events that had never come to pass. This only confirms the Hobbit’s conviction that he was sent back for the express purpose of making changes.
Bilbo knows why he is here, and it’s not merely to see his old friends again, nor to save the lives of loved ones he has lost. He does intend to do both of those things, of course, but the lives of a few mortals would not warrant such intervention from a power so great as the Lady Galadriel. Bilbo has an important task on his hands, and one that he does not take lightly. He finishes his food and does the washing up, and then he makes his way to his study. It is not what he remembers at all.
He is missing many of his favorite books, because he acquired them after his adventure. There are no volumes on Dwarven culture, which might have been helpful if he’d had them the first time around, and the section of his library devoted to history is embarrassingly scant. Nothing about dragons, because he only became interested in those after he riddled with one, and nothing about rings of power, either. If Bilbo had done any reading on that subject prior to his journey, he probably would’ve left the ring in that goblin tunnel all those years ago. Or, rather, all those months in the future, which is how he should remind himself to look at it now.
Well. There’s nothing for it. Bilbo has a job to do, and he is going to do it. He finds a scrap of paper and a pen, a pot of ink which…. Oh, really, this is terrible stuff. Bilbo cannot believe that he ever spent any money on something of such inferior quality. When did those Men start selling that new type of ink in Bree? After Bilbo’s adventure, apparently. He sighs, resigning himself to the use of this clumpy stuff.
This will be much easier if Bilbo can break it into manageable steps. It surely seems like a daunting task, enduring his adventure all over again, facing a dragon for the second time, picking up a cursed ring, and, oh yes, protecting his friends from their horrific fates while he’s at it. But Bilbo Baggins does not do things by half, and he does not give up when things look daunting. No. He must take one thing at a time.
At the top of the page, Bilbo writes To do. The first item is a simple one:
1. Party
Bilbo wants to do it right this time. Even if his guests had fun the first time around, Bilbo knows that he was lacking food and space, and it seems a shame to deprive them of the best evening that he can plan just because he’s done it once before. His first order of business should be to prepare and host the best party he has ever given. And after that?
2. Adventure
That won’t be so hard, will it? After all, Bilbo has done this before. He only needs to remember everything that he did the first time (which won’t be so hard, considering he’s written a book about it, and told all of the stories over and over again over the past several decades, at Frodo’s insistence) and do it exactly the same way again. Well, until he gets to the mountain, that is. That’s when things will need to change.
3. Face Dragon
If he can, Bilbo would like to protect the people of Lake-town this time. This means that he and his friends may have to be the ones to kill the dragon, if it comes to it. Or perhaps he could warn Bard in advance, just in case the dragon does come to Lake-town, and the bowman will be ready to shoot before Smaug has done any real damage. Maybe it would be better to invite Bard to come with them to the mountain? Oh, but Thorin would never allow that, and Bard would not go if it meant leaving his children. Bilbo will have the entire journey to think of what to do, will he not? Surely he can come up with something in that time. And, if worst comes to worst, Bard will still be able to slay the dragon as he did before. Things cannot possibly be worse than they were the first time around.
4. Save Thorin & Lads
That one might prove to be more of a challenge than anything else on his list. But, then, Bilbo knows about the trap on Ravenhill, the ambush that the orcs have planned, and he’ll be able to warn Thorin about it sooner, assuming that the king will listen to him. Before, Bilbo underestimated the power of dragon sickness and the hold that it had on Thorin. He truly believed that the unspoken… thing between the two of them would be enough to stave off the illness, that Thorin would listen to reason from him, if nobody else. That he would understand the logic behind Bilbo’s betrayal and forgive him, that he would come around and do what was necessary to preserve his honor and the lives of his friends.
And he did. But it was too late, and he died anyway, and Bilbo can still remember the feeling of that stiff hand clutched in his own, that cold and silent chest against which he pressed his ear so as not to look at those brilliant blue eyes, waxy, staring at nothing. But even if Bilbo cannot save Thorin from his madness, even if he tries and fails, perhaps he can keep Fíli and Kíli from walking into a trap. He can protect them, at least. They will listen to him. They will both see reason. And maybe if they do, Thorin will come around. Clearly, Bilbo will have to come up with a new plan on that front as well. He does not like relying on the hope that Fíli and Kíli will act rationally and choose their own safety over what they would surely perceive as their duty to the Kingdom of Erebor.
Of course, there is that other thing, the real reason why Galadriel sent him on this journey. Bilbo knows it, and he understands it. Even if he fails to save his friends, he can still save Middle Earth. More importantly, he can still save Frodo. He can allow the lad to have a better life, a free life, with none of the torment he experienced while Bilbo was helpless to protect him. While Bilbo was jealous of him, envious of the fact that his nephew had the ring in his possession and got to go on an adventure. Bilbo wonders if his mind is so much clearer now simply because he is younger, or because he is free of the ring.
But it matters not. He will have to pick up the ring again in order to complete his adventure. He will have to carry it. And he will have to destroy it before it can destroy him or, Valar forbid, before it can destroy Frodo. It surely won’t be easy, but Bilbo Baggins is not the type to stand back and do nothing when it is in his power to help. If Lord Elrond was correct, and none but a Hobbit can carry the ring, then the task should fall to the Hobbit who found it, should it not?
5. Destroy ring.
That’s sorted, then. Only five things that Bilbo must do. That’s not so terrible, is it? Most of them, he has done already, at least in some capacity, and when dealing with the other items on his list, he will at least have the befit of foresight. Anyway, there’s no point worrying about the ring or the battle right now. Those trials are months away, and he’ll have many hours of monotonous travel and late-night watches which he can devote to such musings. For the moment, Bilbo has a party to plan.
Bilbo spends the afternoon in the Shire’s market, selecting what provisions he might need for the party he’ll be hosting tomorrow and for the long journey ahead. He’s not stingy with his purchases by any means. After all, he has no intention of returning to Bag End. If his plan succeeds, he’s going to stay in Erebor, and if it fails… well, if Bilbo fails, he doesn’t think he can stomach another long, lonely life as the laughingstock of Hobbiton. But even if he does return, he’ll be coming back with a chest full of gold, which will more than make up for any irresponsible spending before he sets out.
He buys frosted cakes and loaves of bread, heavy cream for churning butter and the best cuts of meat that he can get his hands on at such short notice. He buys more potatoes than he can carry at one time and pays a neighbor to lend him a wheelbarrow for their transportation. He buys spices and sweets and ale, so much ale; a very nice red wine that Gandalf will enjoy and a fancy sparkling tea that he knows will tempt Dori. He purchases about fifty of the seed cakes that Bofur and Fíli devoured the last time around, and roughly an entire school of the fish that Dwalin so enjoyed. He buys wheel upon wheel of cheese for old Bombur and does not forget about Bifur’s sweet tooth. When he thinks he has enough, Bilbo buys another three barrels of ale, just in case.
And then he gets himself a nice, heavy cloak with a proper hood. He won’t be borrowing from anybody this time. As soon as he’s back in Bag End, he stuffs the pockets full with handkerchiefs, because he won’t be taking any scraps from anybody’s clothing for that purpose, either. Once that’s sorted, he spends the rest of the afternoon cooking. He bakes all through the evening, stopping only for meals and bathroom breaks. The next day is much the same, so that by the time the first knock comes on his door, Bilbo is fully prepared to host the party of his life. And that is saying something, considering he is a Hobbit, after all.
“Dwalin, at your service.” It’s strange to see his old friend looking so very young, but Bilbo supposes he’ll need to get used to such things. After all, everybody will look much younger than they did when last he saw them, considering he is several decades in the past.
“Bilbo Baggins at yours,” he responds with much more enthusiasm than he did the last time. “Come inside, please. Help yourself to the fish and ale, and do wipe off your boots first.”
“Fish and ale? Now, this is a party.” It seems Dwalin, too, likes Bilbo better than he did the first time that they met.
But that would follow, wouldn’t it? Before, Bilbo was rude, confused, and awkward. He didn’t turn Dwalin away, of course. That would be terrible manners, even when a stranger waltzed into his house without a word of explanation. But Bilbo was terse, and he did not respond well.
Bilbo doesn’t have much time to make conversation with his guest, and a good thing, too. Dwalin was never much the talkative one, and Bilbo fears if he’s allowed to ramble then he will give himself away. He is hyper-aware of just who will be knocking on his door next. He has not seen Balin, Lord of Moria, in ages, and it will be difficult to navigate this interaction.
“That’ll be the door.”
“Yes, thank you, Dwalin!” Bilbo calls over his shoulder. “I had no idea!”
Dwalin snorts, digging back into his meal. If only Bilbo had been dropped back into his fifty-year-old body a few months before his adventure, then he’d have had more time to commission a new and larger table, which might better accommodate his guests. But of course, the Lady Galadriel would not have thought of such things. She almost certainly did not send Bilbo back in hopes that he might improve this specific party.
Bilbo throws open his door. He remembers dimly that Balin seemed elderly to him when first they met, but not so now. Balin’s eyes hold a hopeful twinkle, and his face is nowhere near as weathered as it was when last Bilbo saw him. Certainly he looks much younger than Bilbo did yesterday. “Balin, at your service!” He sweeps into a sprightly bow.
“Bilbo Baggins at yours and your family’s,” Bilbo beams at him. At least this time around, he’s learned the proper response to such an introduction. “Please, come inside. We’ve plenty to eat and plenty to drink! You must be hungry after your long journey, even on such a fair evening as this one.” He has to stop himself from embracing his friend, who, of course, does not know him. Well, not yet, at least.
“A fair evening indeed, though I think it might rain later,” Balin observes absently. Not the same phrasing as the first time, but apparently, he really wants to share this information with his host. Bilbo can’t help but smile. “Am I late?”
“Not at all,” Bilbo assures him. “This way, please, we’ll find you something to eat.”
While Balin and Dwalin re-unite, complete with forehead-butting, embracing, and comments that still seem somewhat rude to Bilbo after all this time, the Hobbit sets about moving the furniture to make more space for the many guests that will be coming. He remembers exactly which chairs were moved when he last hosted this party, and exactly where they were moved to, because he was rather upset about it at the time. Before, Bilbo was slightly addled by his shock and confusion, but now, he has no excuse. No guests will be doing anything even resembling manual labor at Bag End now that he’s got his full faculties behind him, not on Bilbo’s watch.
There comes another knock at the door, and Bilbo sighs heavily. He can handle this. He can handle this. He has no choice. Bilbo takes a deep breath and puts on the neutral face he always used to wear for Frodo. The little lad didn’t need to know that every look he cast toward his uncle with Primula’s eyes was a knife in Bilbo’s chest, and the Princes of Erebor don’t need to know that their new burglar has already cried himself hoarse at their funeral.
He throws his lovely, marked-up green door open again and is greeted by two smiling faces. Oh, by the Green Lady, they’re barely more than tweens. For some reason, Bilbo remembered them seeming much older. Perhaps that’s because the last time he saw them their faces were cold and lifeless and constricted by pain. Perhaps it’s because this quest will age them and rob them of any innocence they managed to hold onto in the Blue Mountains. Perhaps it’s because Bilbo knows that if he had been only a little bit faster running through that battle, he’d have been able to stop them from rushing off and getting themselves killed, but instead they died, and it was his fault.
“Fíli,” Fíli says.
“And Kíli,” Kíli rejoins.
“At your service,” they announce in unison, sweeping into twin bows.
Bilbo is frozen in shock. He cannot help it. He cannot compose himself, but oh, by the Valar, he must. He is not going to ruin this night for them by making them worry about their awkward host. “How many times have you rehearsed that, exactly?” Bilbo is well-versed in schooling his features to hide behind a one-liner. If he could fool Frodo, he can very well fool these lads, who do not even know him yet.
“Only a few times,” Kíli lies with that brilliant grin of his. “You must be Mr. Boggins!”
Bilbo can only shake his head. “Baggins,” he corrects the prince, “And second, come inside, please. There’s plenty to eat and plenty to do.” Conversations to be had, cards to play, that sort of thing.
“And plenty to drink?” Fíli presses. His face is so expressive, so full of genuine glee in anticipation of the coming adventure. He’s clearly looking forward to this. He does not know that he will die. He does not know that his last act will be to tell his uncle to run, that his advice will not be heeded, that Kíli and Thorin will outlive him by mere minutes. He does not know that it will take hours to locate his body once the battle dies down, that his remains will ultimately have to be heaved out of a crevasse, that this process will be significantly lengthened by Dwalin’s shaky hands and Bilbo’s utter uselessness as he clings to the empty shell of Thorin.
“Oh, yes, I thought that was a given.” Bilbo falls with his full weight upon his racing thoughts, immobilizing them where they stand. He cannot sink into despair. Fíli will not die if Bilbo has anything to say about it, and nor, for that matter, will anybody else. But he will only raise suspicion if he acts overly familiar or overly melancholy.
“Careful with these; I just had them sharpened.” Fíli is oblivious to the thoughts that pull Bilbo’s ancient mind in all directions as he steps forward with an impressive bundle of swords, knives, and axes, all wrapped up in far too little protective leather for any Gentlehobbit’s comfort. What could he possibly do with them all, even in the most involved of battles? No doubt the entire lot will end up in Goblin hands when the company is waylaid in the Misty Mountains. But Bilbo can’t protest at having a heavy load of weapons dumped into his arms, because Fíli is alive.
“It’s nice, this place. Did you do it yourself?” Kíli asks absently, and Bilbo doesn’t even mind that the lad is scraping his filthy boots against Bilbo’s mother’s glory box when the floor mat is right there (and specifically purchased for this occasion, too), because Kíli yet draws breath. Which is more than Bilbo could’ve asked for two days ago.
Bilbo needs to force himself to answer. “My father designed it as a wedding gift for my mother. I’m afraid I’m not much for carpentry, so it’s nothing short of a gift from the Valar that I didn’t have to build my own smial.” He watches the Crown Prince of Erebor, already halfway to the dining room, make mental note of the unfamiliar word.
Kíli just laughs at Bilbo’s comment. Good. It’s good to see him laughing, with so much color in his cheeks. “There was talk of drink?”
“And food, too,” Bilbo reminds him. “I doubt you’ve been eating properly on the road, and I’ve got a feast ready, besides. Right this way.”
Bilbo spends the next several minutes puttering around, waiting on his guests. There is always ale to be poured, and more food to be heated. This party will go on for a very long time, tea blending into dinner blending into supper; if he’d cooked everything before Dwalin’s arrival, it would all be cold by the end of things. He’s fully prepared for the next knock on the door, and not in anything even resembling the foul mood that he remembers from the last time that he did this, so he’s gentle with the door and nobody is knocked over.
Bilbo allows Gandalf to introduce him to each of his friends, and they all inform him that they’re at his service. Bilbo responds in kind with his Hobbit-y approximation of a Dwarven bow before whisking them away to be served. “I’ll tell you this right now,” he addresses Bofur and Nori in particular, holding up two very different crochet projects. “Dishcloth, doily. See the difference? I’ll not have you mistaking one for the other in my house.” Best to get out ahead of that problem before it manifests itself. The stains never did come out of that doily, which was an awful shame, considering it was some of Bilbo’s best work.
Nori, naturally, rolls his eyes at Bilbo and saunters off. No doubt he’s taking some kind of inventory of the contents of Bilbo’s home, and before the end of the evening, his sticky fingers will find more to pocket than just linens. When Bilbo returned to Erebor, Nori presented him with no fewer than seven of his own napkin rings, which Bilbo had previously presumed had been among Lobelia’s plunder. Apparently, Nori managed to hold onto them through most of the journey, but had them confiscated in the Elven dungeons. It was only after Bilbo left that he was able to get them back, and the two did not see one another for sixty more years. Naturally, Bilbo took the napkin rings back to Rivendell and displayed them proudly in his small apartment there.
Bofur jabs at the dishcloth. “Well, this is obviously the better of the two. That other thing is full of holes. Why ever would you waste your time making that?”
“Because I happen to enjoy crochet!” Bilbo can’t help sputtering at his old friend, though his smile never falters. Bofur loves getting a rise out of him, apparently even on this odd timeline where Bilbo, a complete stranger, is shoving the contents of the linen closet in his face.
“Aye, and a wonderful game it is, too, if you’ve got the balls for it.” Bilbo would be lying if he pretended that he hadn’t just intentionally set Bofur up for that particular joke. He’s always enjoyed his friend’s sense of humor. In fact, he found that, after Thorin and the lads, he missed Bofur most of all during his estrangement from the company.
The pair of them exchanged a few letters, of course, and saw one another when Bilbo returned to Erebor in his old age. Two of Bofur’s daughters attended Bilbo’s eleventy-first birthday, though of course, their father was unable to travel as far as the Shire at that time with both Bifur and Bombur in such poor health. One of Bilbo’s greatest regrets in life is not carrying on the sort of correspondence he’d have liked to with the friends that he had left after his adventure.
“Go and have some seed cake,” Bilbo orders, unable to restrain his glee. He’s missed this very much. It has been ages since Bag End was so full of noise.
“Oh, I love seed cake.” Bofur grins at him. “How’d you know?”
But Bilbo is already off, riflingthrough the many barrels and bottles that he’s purchased to find that sparkling tea for Dori, and some glasses to serve it in. Bilbo will not have anybody drinking directly from the bottle in his home. Well, except for Kíli, who happens to be guzzling ale right from the barrel, which is not what the spout is for. There is ale going everywhere, because the prince does not seem inclined to bother with shutting the spout between gulps. Bilbo rushes off to put a stop to that before any permeant damage is done to his floor. He may not be returning to Bag End, but he fully intends to leave the property in the care of the Gamgee family, and the last thing he wants is for them to be left with a stinking and soggy stained floor.
“But Mr. Boggins,” Kíli gives him that big-eyed expression, which, no doubt, would have worked wonders on Bilbo at the start of their first journey together. Unfortunately, the Hobbit has too many vivid memories of looking into those large eyes while Kíli explained why Bilbo absolutely needed to participate in the lads’ latest half-baked scheme. He won’t be falling for it this time. “You’re all out of mugs. Do you want me to die of thirst?”
“Nothing so dramatic as that, but you can close the spout between drinks, at least,” Bilbo offers, making a valiant effort to restrain his laughter. “Look what you’re doing to the floor!” He gestures at the puddle of ale.
Kíli shrugs. “I was going to clean it up,” he announces. This may be true, considering that Bilbo has no recollection of coming home to a sticky floor after his last adventure.
Bilbo fixes the prince with a hard stare. “And you still are.” Apparently, Kíli finds this very funny. Hopefully his attitude will be similar when he’s mopping the floor, because Bilbo is not joking, whatever his own chuckles may suggest.
Another shock comes when Bilbo returns to the dining room to find Fíli, once again, walking across the kitchen table with his boots on. Bilbo knows from experience that the caked-on mud will be a struggle to remove, and that’s not even considering the scuffs beneath it.
“Shoes off, if you’re going to do that, please!” Bilbo yelps, after a brief wave of recognition. Yes, he has watched this happen once before, that first night in Bag End. But this, too, was one of the images from the vision given to Bilbo by Lady Galadriel. He does not quite have time to process what that means, however, because he is met with exactly the sort of indignant response one might expect when one rains upon an uproarious parade.
The first time, Bilbo was absolutely stricken by the lad’s unparalleled rudeness. He had no idea then that Fíli was Crown Prince of Erebor, though that would not have changed much vis a vis his trek across the dining table. It did not occur to Bilbo that perhaps in Dwarven culture, such behavior might be entirely typical, that a boot-clad people might construct their furniture to withstand such abuse, and that the lad might be so unfamiliar with Hobbits as to assume that they did things the same way. These considerations aside, Bilbo is now incredibly aware of what Fíli is actually doing.
He’s handing out mugs of ale (which explains where all of them have gotten to), delivering beverages like a barkeep to people who, strictly speaking, are his social inferiors. But the prince is a good lad and doesn’t seem to care that if anything, the others should be serving him. Although Bilbo would be hard-pressed to say that someone tracking mud across his father’s table has good manners, he can at least appreciate that Fíli isn’t trying to be rude. Though the table itself did nothing to deserve such treatment.
“He’s fine,” Glóin calls, “It’ll hold him!”
“Not if he keeps at it with the mashed potatoes!” Bombur argues, and Fíli responds by trying to kick him. Bombur dodges the blow with ease that might be shocking to one who had never seen him in battle.
“We are guests of Master Baggins,” Dori points out. “We should at least make an effort to respect his house rules.” Ah, yes. Bilbo has always found an ally in Dori when it comes to politeness and common courtesy, and he’s very grateful for his friend’s intervention on his behalf at this juncture. Nobody in the company knows Bilbo, and despite the fact that they are in his home, they have more than proven that none of them has any inclination whatsoever to listen to a word he says. Figures.
Of course, Bilbo only has another fire to put out when Nori, Kíli, and Bofur take it upon themselves to divest Fíli of his boots while he is still trying to walk across the table. More than one fork clatters to the ground, and ale is spilled in copious amounts. Bilbo gets the feeling that if Thorin were here, he’d be considering disinheriting his nephews and naming Dáin as his heir. Though if Dáin were here, he’d probably have broken the table before Fíli could even consider stepping onto it.
“You can deal with that,” Bilbo informs a chuckling Gandalf. The Hobbit is very fond of his friends, indeed, but he feels it was rather rude of Gandalf to invite them all into Bag End without warning Bilbo. If anybody deserves to be kicked, it is the Wizard. Anyway, Bifur is already signing furiously, lecturing the group with verbiage that might make Bilbo laugh, were he not so busy trying to conceal his knowledge of the secret sign language. It’s been difficult enough restraining himself from simply signing to Óin so that the healer might actually have some idea of what the Hobbit is trying to tell him.
Bilbo hardly gets a chance to sit down throughout the party, though he does manage to wolf down several dozen mini-quiches and one full-sized blueberry pie in between his errands. He’s still a Hobbit, after all. He’s not about to go hungry. Of course, he is stopped in his tracks when Ori approaches him asking where to put a dirty plate.
Ori is the youngest member of the company by far, even younger than the princes, and he looks so small, so fragile, so inexperienced, at least by Bilbo’s still elderly assessment. This lad does not belong on a quest to fight a dragon, even if he isn’t half as afraid as he should be. And when Bilbo looks at him, all he can think of is the skeleton that Samwise described closest to the book of records. As Bilbo understands it, Gimli had been the one to recognize Ori’s handwriting in the book, and he’d been fairly confident, in his grief, that the remains nearby had belonged to the scribe. What a brutal, awful way to die. Worse, even, than if the dragon had taken him. Worse than falling in battle. Had he been slain? Suffocated? Starved? Perhaps Frodo and his friends had their theories, perhaps they saw evidence that would have answered these questions, but they knew better than to share any of that with Bilbo. His heart would not have been able to take it.
Ori is barely more than a boy now. His beard has not come in all the way. His expression is shy, his accent provincial, his fingers trembling ever so slightly as he holds up the plate. He’s out of his depth here, despite any bravado he might later display. His brothers have sheltered him and he does not know the horrors of the world in which he lives. This quest will age him, too.
“Oh,” Bilbo stammers, “Well—“
“Here you go, Ori, give it to me.” Fíli snatches the plate out of Ori’s hand. He tosses the dish to Kíli, who throws it into the dining room with a mischievous grin.
Bofur and the others are already banging their knives on the table, which has Bilbo shaking his head. “Those knives will never be the same,” he laments. And he knows that for a fact, too. With the condition they were in at the end of the evening, even Lobelia didn’t dare to touch them.
“You hear that, lads?” Bofur calls, “He says we’ll blunt the knives!” Which is not what Bilbo actually said this time, but it is true enough.
And of course, that leads into a song about the destruction of Bilbo’s dishes, and this time, Bilbo allows himself to tap his feet in time with the music. If it wouldn’t raise so many questions and set a bad example for those who might wish to join him with shoes on, he would get up on the table and dance along. He more-or-less remembers the words, and it is a blessing beyond measure to be able to move so freely once again.
“You people all got together and wrote this!” Bilbo exclaims between verses. It’s something that has always bothered him, though he never found the right time to ask about it. “And rehearsed it!” He can’t help but laugh at the idea.
“Well, Gandalf did tell us a little bit about you,” Kíli reports as the others continue their song. He seems to be making an active effort to look sheepish, though the effect is quickly ruined when he waves a blue porcelain plate at Bilbo. “Mr. Boggins, catch!”
Bilbo really does try to catch it, but of course, he fumbles. He’s never been the most coordinated of Hobbits at the best of times, his impulse when things are flying at him is to duck, not to dive for them, and he’s stunned by the novelty of this interaction. Flattered, actually, that the boys are trying to include him in their antics. He’s made them feel welcome and managed to avoid putting them off with whatever heavy grief is lurking behind his eyes. The plate hits the floor and shatters.
Kíli stares at him with wide eyes. “I didn’t mean to—“
“Oh, it’s no trouble,” Bilbo assures him. He finds he really doesn’t care about the plate. In fact, he hopes that Kíli will live to break many more of Bilbo’s dishes in the years to come. “You can just owe me one. There must be more than a few plates laying around in that mountain of yours, eh? Once we reclaim it, you can pick one out for me. A suitable payment, I think.”
“We will find you a golden plate,” Fíli assures Bilbo, tossing a teacup in his brother’s direction. Bilbo is surprisingly unbothered by the fact that dishes are flying every which way in his home.
“No, no, absolutely not.” Bilbo shakes his head vehemently. “The broken one is porcelain, so the replacement should be as well.”
“Porcelain with gold leaf,” Kíli muses.
“No,” Bilbo groans, “What would I do with that?”
“It’s a plate,” Fíli informs him, “You would eat off of it. What else?”
“Would one of you please just go fetch a broom?” Bilbo shakes his head fondly. By the Valar, he missed these lads. They’d have been a good influence on bookish, withdrawn Frodo. It’s not difficult to imagine Fíli and Kíli acting as older brothers for the young Hobbit, helping him through the loss of his parents in a way that Bilbo never could. It dawns on him, then, that he has always thought of these two, even more than the others, as members of his family.
Bilbo is too distracted by his musings, on top of sweeping up the remains of his poor plate, to notice the end of the merrymaking, though, of course, he’s incredibly aware of the knock at his door. It would be hard to miss a thing like that, especially considering Gandalf’s overly dramatic and largely unnecessary comment: “He is here.”
There are butterflies in Bilbo’s stomach and his hands are trembling. He’s not sure whether he’s excited at the prospect of seeing Thorin again or nervous that this is when the rug will be ripped out from under his feet. In good dreams, this is always when he wakes up. In nightmares, he opens the door of Bag End and steps out onto the snowy waste of Ravenhill. But neither of those things happen this time.
Bilbo opens the door with Gandalf’s large hand on his shoulder. And there is Thorin, in all his kingly glory, just as beautiful as Bilbo remembered. Dark hair streaked with grey, icy blue eyes, features Bilbo has memorized a million times over. It is impossible to believe now that the damage done by age and the ring ever managed to purge this image from his mind. How could Bilbo ever forget Thorin Oakenshield? How could he lose such an important moment? He longs to reach out, to touch the king and assure himself that all of this is truly happening. Bilbo’s mouth hangs open as he struggles to think of something to say, tries to get a handle on how to act as though he is not head-over-heels in love with the King Under the Mountain, who, at this juncture, does not know Bilbo’s name.
The illusion is shattered when Thorin pushes into Bag End, taking his cloak off and thrusting it in Kíli’s general direction. He ignores Bilbo altogether, leaving the Hobbit to scramble out of his way or risk being trampled. “Gandalf. I thought you said this place would be easy to find. I lost my way, twice. I wouldn’t have found it at all had it not been for that mark on the door.”
“How did you manage to get lost twice in Hobbiton?” Bilbo asks.
He’d forgotten how infuriating Thorin could be. Coming into Bilbo’s home already complaining, treating his own nephew like a coatrack, all while having the audacity to look like that. Of course, Bilbo knows that Thorin has a horrible sense of direction; he and the others spent a good deal of their adventure teasing him about it. But honestly, he could’ve asked anyone, and they’d have pointed him right down the road to Bag End. It would’ve been the start of much muttering, but Bilbo finds it difficult to believe that Thorin ever would’ve cared about such things. More likely, he simply failed to think things through. It wouldn’t be the first time, and Yavanna knows that it will not be the last.
“So. This is the Hobbit,” Thorin regards him with unkind eyes, not allowing Gandalf a chance to make any proper introductions. He does not trust outsiders, Bilbo knows. He does not trust anyone, and he isn’t going to engage with Bilbo’s playful ribbing. “Tell me, Mr. Baggins, have you done much fighting?”
“A fair amount,” Bilbo grumbles. The warmth in his chest and the writhing in his guts and the headache beginning to percolate are pulling him every which way, but it’s hard not to fall into that old rhythm of antagonistic banter with Thorin.
“Axe or sword?” Thorin demands. “What’s your weapon of choice?”
“Sword,” Bilbo replies truthfully.
Thorin does not look as though he believes this at all. “And may we see this sword of yours?”
“I don’t have it on me,” Bilbo informs him, arms crossed. “Or rather, I don’t have it yet. But I do know how to use it when it matters.” This is more or less true. The last time Bilbo picked up Sting was to hand it to Frodo, and before that, it’d been some fifteen years, at least. And even longer since he actually tried to fight with it. But Bilbo does not fancy explaining these nuances to Thorin, who will no doubt become even more distrustful in the face of Bilbo’s odd story.
Thorin does not dignify this with a response, which Bilbo supposes is fair. After all, he doesn’t know about the troll hoard. “He looks more like a grocer than a burglar.”
That sets Bilbo seething, just like it did the first time. Thorin doesn’t know a single thing about him, has no idea how brave Bilbo can be or how useful the Hobbit will become on this quest. Honestly, his dismissive behavior is downright rude, especially considering that he is a guest in Bilbo’s home. And it’s awfully high and mighty of somebody who managed to get lost in Hobbiton of all places to be throwing around insults about other people’s competence.
“And you look more like a blacksmith than a king,” Bilbo shoots back, “So it seems that looks can be deceiving, because I know who you are, Thorin Oakenshield, and I know that you are a great king, indeed.”
Thorin only looks at him, long and intense, keeping eye contact for a moment more than is comfortable. He is sizing Bilbo up, reassessing his initial judgment, which Bilbo hopes has proven unfair and inaccurate. He refuses to look away, meeting Thorin’s eyes defiantly. He may be in love, but he’s not going to roll over and accept whatever treatment Thorin decides to throw at him. Bilbo is not that kind of Hobbit, and it will save everyone a lot of trouble if His Majesty gets used to that now.
Neither of them says anything. The silence in the room is tense until Balin speaks up, asking Thorin about the meeting in Ered Luin. The King finally looks away from Bilbo, striding purposefully into the dining room as if he owns the place. Bilbo will consider this a win, even if he isn’t sure it is one.
He takes advantage of the discussion about the meeting to wash what dishes remain following the song and dance. A lot of plates and cups were tossed into the sink, but very few were scrubbed and rinsed, and none were put away where they actually belong. “Bilbo, my boy, you may want to hear this!” Gandalf calls from the dining room.
“I’m listening,” Bilbo assures him, “I can hear you all just fine in here.”
Gandalf mutters something about stubborn Hobbits, Thorin says something unintelligible under his breath, and Bilbo shakes his head, returning his attention to his dishes. He knows all about the map and key, after all, and he won’t leave Bag End a mess for the poor Gamgees. He gets a nice refresher about the dragon, the key, and the door while he finishes his dishes.
“Where’s my contract, then?” He asks, upon entering the kitchen.
“Pardon?” Thorin, apparently, is not accustomed to having this tone taken with him. Bilbo had forgotten that. A pity, but he’ll get used to it before their journey is through. Before they even get to Rivendell, if Bilbo’s memory serves him.
“You need a burglar,” Bilbo replies, “And I’m the best burglar that you’re going to be able to convince to walk into a treasure hoard with a live dragon inside. Furnace with wings, right?”
“Aye, that’s about the shape of it,” Bofur agrees.
“Right,” Bilbo nods once. “Which I think entitles me to one fourteenth share of the treasure. The contract, please?”
“That’s the spirit!” Fíli cheers. “I told you he’d do fine.”
Balin glances to Thorin, who only shrugs. Clearly, he has no clue what to make of Bilbo, who is not sure whether he wants to rush across the table to kiss Thorin or to engage him in some sort of duel. He can’t imagine that either course of action would end very well. “Here you are, laddie,” Balin says eventually.
“That’s perfect.” Bilbo does not have the heart to read the section about funeral arrangements. He does not want to be reminded of the funeral arrangements that he witnessed the last time he completed this quest, though of course, he already has been, even without digging into the relevant section. He simply signs his name and passes the contract back to Balin.
“Are you sure you don’t want to read it first?” Glóin inquires from across the table. “There’s important information in there.”
Bilbo shrugs. “I think I’ve got the gist. Now, we’ve got an early start in the morning, don’t we? So I’ll be heading to bed. Feel free to use any of the guest rooms, sofas, et cetera as you will. Gandalf, can you make arrangements?” That’ll teach the Wizard to plan a party in Bilbo’s home without bothering to notify the host.
Once he’s alone in his room, Bilbo’s confident facade crumbles to dust. The excitement fades, and he is left with the memory of Ravenhill.
Funeral arrangements.
In the event of your death…
Funeral.
Arrangements.
Thorin and Fíli and Kíli and their funeral arrangements. The stone slabs. Hands placed deliberately to hide the sword wounds, all three of them with sword wounds. Unmendable. Funeral arrangements. Dwalin’s shaking hands. The company carrying their leader and his kin back to Erebor across the battlefield. Funeral arrangements. Dori spending twenty minutes trying in vain to fix an odd cowlick in Kíli’s hair, giving up because it was just as hopeless in the lad’s death as it was in his life. Óin tending to each of Fíli’s shattered bones, not because there was any hope of healing, but because he feared that the sight of the Prince’s body as it was would be upsetting to the company and the newly-established population of Erebor. Funeral arrangements. Nori and Bofur hunting frantically through the royal suites of Erebor, trying to find something that would fit Thorin, because try as they might, nobody could get the blood stains out of his clothes. In the end he’d been laid to rest in an old robe of his father’s, moth-eaten and dusty. Bilbo knows far more than he would like to about the funeral arrangements.
He lays down in bed, still in his clothes, and he sobs. He releases the tears that have lived in his body for decades now, the pain and anguish that he has bottled up inside. He can’t do this again. He can’t watch his friends die. He has no choice but to go with them, to protect them as best he can. He has his list to follow. He cannot allow himself to think about the funeral arrangements or any other part of it. He just has to push through, because though some of them may perish even with his help, all of them will surely die without it.
For a moment, Bilbo cannot imagine sleeping, cannot imagine his thoughts ever settling enough to allow him to follow in their wake. But then the singing begins, singing Bilbo has not been able to shake from his head for decades. He is intimately familiar with the song about the Misty Mountains, the way Thorin’s voice fits around the harmonies hummed by the others. It has been stuck in Bilbo’s head at intervals for the majority of his life. He recorded it from memory in his book and he did not do a bad job. And it brings him comfort now, to cling to the timbre of his beloved’s voice, to allow himself to be carried off to a much needed sleep, his mind and body exhausted by the events of the day. Tomorrow, whether he likes it or not, Bilbo will be going on an adventure, and he needs whatever rest he can get.
But no song at all could protect Bilbo from nightmares on a night like tonight. In his dream he is wandering the halls of Bag End; he floats with confused purpose down to the old master bedroom, to which he knows in his stomach that Gandalf will have directed Thorin and the lads. The door opens of its own volition and there, on the bed, lie three ancient skeletons with their hands deliberately placed to obscure wounds that have long since decomposed. The one in the center has a glowing rock upon his breast: the Arkenstone balanced atop his ribcage. It shines, blinding Bilbo momentarily. Who is Bilbo kidding, to think that he can save his friends?
This is his fault. They are dead and it is his fault. He wasn’t fast enough. He knew what was going to happen and he couldn’t get there in time to deliver a warning. All three of them died terrible, painful deaths, and it was Bilbo’s fault. They will die again. He will watch them die again, helpless and culpable. The bed in which his parents once slept is soaked in the blood of his friends and it is all Bilbo’s fault.
He wakes up cold and clammy and thoroughly disturbed. He hasn’t had a nightmare this bad since his late visit to Erebor, but of course, it makes sense that such a troubling dream would find him after such an utterly overwhelming evening. He did not expect that it would be so distressing for him to see his friends again, but then again, he had forgotten about a few of the lines in that contract. And he has spent so long thinking of the departed as characters in an adventure he once lived through that perhaps he has forgotten what it felt like to be in their presence.
No memory could be as vivid as what he experienced last night. The years stole so many details from him, so many little things that, even by the time he sat down to work on his book, escaped him entirely. It is one thing to remember and quite another to live through a moment anew. And it only makes sense that such a carnal experience of all he’d thought he’d lostwould lead to an equally carnal nightmare about the other reality. Because when he was last in Erebor, Thorin and the lads really were…
Bilbo shakes himself. Why dwell on it? It’s not true anymore. A quick glance at the clock by his bedside tells him that it’s early in the morning, perhaps earlier than any respectable Hobbit would be awake, but late enough that it feels permissible for him to get out of bed with the excuse of getting started on breakfast. Bilbo has no idea what time the others are leaving because he did not leave with them on his original adventure, but he fully intends to pack them all full of good food and strong tea before they head off. And the preparation of another great meal will be a welcome distraction from his increasingly dour thoughts.
He puts on his dressing gown and pads into the hallway, taking care to be as quiet as possible. Which is very quiet indeed, because after everything that he has been through and all the lifetimes he has lived, Bilbo is still a Hobbit. Every one of his armchairs is occupied, and it seems that poor Ori has been relegated to the study. There’s no good place for a bedroll, cluttered as it is, but Bilbo is pleased to see his young friend sleeping soundly. Bilbo makes his way into the kitchen and nearly jumps out of his skin when he discovers that his dining room table is already occupied. It is far too early for anyone to be up and about!
“Master Baggins. You’re awake,” Thorin observes.
“And so are you.” Bilbo has no business blushing at him, that’s for certain. His emotions must be confused by his nightmare and the general oddness of his situation, but he needs to pull himself together. He can’t let on that he thinks of Thorin as anything other than someone who has disrupted his routine and invaded his home. Politeness, then, is the most appropriate route. “Did you get any sleep at all?”
“I couldn’t,” Thorin tells him with shocking vulnerability, “Not in a strange place like this.”
Of course, Thorin has no inkling that Bilbo knows just how many strange places the king has had to sleep in since being deposed from his home. He’s not necessarily trying to confess that he almost never sleeps well, but that’s the message that comes across. If they were having this conversation in Beorn’s hall, Bilbo would put a gentle hand on Thorin’s shoulder. In the Dungeons of Mirkwood, he’d interlace their fingers and offer a reassuring squeeze. If they were in Erebor, Bilbo might press his forehead to Thorin’s in a patently Dwarven gesture of comfort and affection. But they are still in Bag End, and they just met last night, and so he has nothing to offer.
Bilbo sighs, putting the kettle on and turning his attention to the contents of his pantry. He’ll be packing what he can carry, but he likes to think he has enough beyond that to feed his guests a breakfast that will rival the supper-dinner-tea they had before bed. After all, he did plan for this. He knows how much his friends can put away when the mood suits them. “You’ll be wanting coffee, then.”
“Yes, and ham and eggs, if you have them.”
Bilbo is well aware that Thorin is studying him, and he has to fight the urge to turn around and look at the expression on the king’s face. The last thing Bilbo wants right now is to give himself away. Let Thorin believe that Bilbo is jittery and nervous about the beginning of his first adventure, let him think that Bilbo is weak and a burden and unworthy of the title of burglar. Even if Bilbo could explain the real reasons for his obvious discomfort, he doubts that Thorin would believe him. What could Bilbo even say?
He settles for cooking breakfast, which Thorin allows him to do in complete silence. Bilbo had forgotten about this aspect of it all, how easy it always was for him to just exist beside Thorin. It’s not something Bilbo has experienced with anybody else before, and it’s strange to come back to it after all this time. Even if Thorin is silently judging him, there’s something comforting about his presence. It’s a balm to Bilbo’s frayed nerves, knowing that Thorin is here and alive and there is still a chance to set things right this time around.
Bilbo looks over his shoulder and nearly falls backwards onto the stove at what he sees. Thorin is standing there, more casual than Bilbo ever would have expected. He’s leaning forward against the counter, mug in hand. Just like in the vision. When Bilbo saw this the first time, he assumed that it was tea. The coffee is weak; clearly, Thorin was impatient and did not even wait for it to finish brewing, let alone for Bilbo to serve it to him properly. Does he not care about the flavor? Does he drink it only for the wakefulness it brings him? That thought might break Bilbo’s heart, were it not already shattered into pieces somewhere behind his ribs.
He cannot do this. He cannot spend months upon months tiptoeing around Thorin, pretending that he does not love him. He cannot waste what little time they have together. He cannot bank on the fact that he will succeed in saving his king. He cannot expect that they will have all the time in the world after the battle, once Erebor is reclaimed. Bilbo cannot restrain himself from throwing his arms around his love and begging for forgiveness.
But he must. He must do all of those things. Any emotional outburst at this juncture would only make Thorin suspicious, and then what would happen? He may not allow Bilbo to come on the adventure at all. And if Bilbo isn’t there to step between Thorin and Azog, will the king be killed? If Bilbo can’t free the company from the Spiders, or from the clutches of the Elves, will they all die in Mirkwood? If Bilbo does not vouch for them in Lake-town, will they starve to death before they reach their home? If he is not there to riddle with the dragon, what will Smaug do to his friends?
Bilbo has no choice. He’s spent eight decades pointedly refusing to think about how it felt to watch Thorin Oakenshield breathe his last breath. What’s another few months of the same? “It won’t go any faster just because you’re watching,” Bilbo quips, because he has to. He must say something or he may break down crying. Or start yelling and throwing things, which would feel a lot better and make everything much worse. “Why not set the table while you wait, if you don’t mind?”
“Set the table?” Thorin echoes.
Bilbo turns back toward the stove and squeezes his eyes shut. What is he doing? “Yes. It needs doing, and as you can see, I’m busy. You’re awake and standing around. Why not help?” Normally, he’d never ask such a thing of any guest. But he desperately needs Thorin to stop looking at him, stop trying to see him, stop trying to figure Bilbo out before he learns more than is good for him.
For a moment, Bilbo thinks that Thorin will refuse. After all, he’s been nothing but antagonistic thus far, and Bilbo knows from experience that this isn’t going to change any time soon. “Very well,” Thorin says eventually. “I will set the table.”
And he actually does. Granted, he uses the wrong plates (That gaudy old green set? Were the yellow ones not available?) and he distributes only forks and knives (could he not find the spoons? Why didn’t he ask after them?), but still, he sets the table.
The others begin to file in a few minutes later, which Bilbo cannot make sense of for the life of him. How are they all able to spring up out of bed before the sun has risen? But there’s not much time to ponder when Bilbo is making fifteen orders of eggs (closer to thirty, actually, since most of them have seconds), plate after plate of sausages, bacon, and ham, and several trays’ worth of toast to be devoured with all the jam that he can scavenge from his pantry.
“Let’s go,” Thorin orders, as soon as he has finished eating. Many of the others are still working on their meals. Bombur in particular seems to be savoring what he knows will be his last proper breakfast in a very long time, and Bilbo cannot blame him. They have always been kindred spirits when it comes to the art of eating.
Bilbo whirls around to face the king. Oh, honestly. He should have known that the companionable silence and light banter of the early morning would not last long. “I’m not leaving all these dishes for my gardener and his family. You can wait twenty minutes. It’s not even light out yet! Surely you don’t mean to travel in the dark.” He remembers that he and Thorin have only just met, and that he has already perhaps pushed things a little bit too far with the table-setting conversation. “Your Majesty.”
“Master Baggins has a point, Your Majesty,” says Dori, never one to tolerate rudeness.
“Aye,” Balin agrees, “That he does.”
Thorin does not look pleased. But then, he never looks pleased when he doesn’t get his way. It is something by which Bilbo refuses to be endeared, despite his inclinations to the contrary. “Fíli, Kíli, help Master Baggins with the dishes. Dwalin, you can carry their bags outside and start getting the ponies ready.”
“Do we both have to?” Kíli gives his uncle a big-eyed look, which Bilbo knows from experience is generally fairly effective in bending people to the prince’s will. He truly has a lion’s courage, trying a trick like that on his fuming uncle. Unfortunately, it does not work this morning.
“It will not take so long that way,” Thorin reasons through gritted teeth.
“Shouldn’t be too hard,” Fíli decides, assessing the state of the kitchen. “Twenty minutes.” He winks at Bilbo and flashes a winning smile. He, too, is taking control of the situation through facial expressions alone. Truly, Bilbo wonders if the lads learned this trick from their mother. They certainly didn’t pick it up from Thorin, who appears to be trying his best to set the tablecloth on fire with his mind.
“You have fifteen.” But that’ll be plenty, with three of them working, and Bilbo not caring quite so much about whether all the plates come out intact.
Bilbo gives a satisfied little huff and makes room by the sink for the princes to join him. That’s step one taken care of, then. Despite the perils ahead, at least the party was a smashing success. Bilbo is certain he’ll be able to look back on it fondly when he’s freezing his feet off, dripping wet from the rain and with sore legs from days of riding and walking, wondering why in Yavanna’s name he agreed to do this all over again.
