Chapter 1: By the Sea
Chapter Text
Far away to the East, beneath the Lonely Mountain, King Thorin II, son of Thrain, son of Thror, rests with Orcrist at his side and the Arkenstone upon his breast. Some believe that he has returned to the stone whence he was hewn, melting into the very flesh of Erebor, becoming one with the Mountain that he sacrificed so much to reclaim. His people know that he dwells now in the halls of Mahal, waiting upon the Maker as all their departed have done since death took the very first of their race. For decades, now, he has been at peace, undisturbed by the cares that dogged him in life, and thus he shall remain until the end of time.
...
The gentle sound of waves against the shore resounds through the Grey Havens. The air carries the scent of salt, and strange birds which do not come to the Shire call to one another as they fly overhead. The old Hobbit follows his four companions out of the carriage, matching their expressions of wonder as his eyes devour his surroundings. As he has been all his life, Bilbo Baggins is ravenous, though at his advanced age, he has rather lost his appetite for hearty food and gripping books. His zest for adventure, however, remains as strong as it has been since the morning he abandoned his home to reclaim a stolen mountain with a group of total strangers and not so much as a handkerchief in his pocket.This place is much closer to their home than Erebor, Mordor, Rohan, or Gondor, and yet none of these well-traveled Hobbits have ever before laid eyes upon it.
Bilbo steadies himself on his cane and pauses, inhaling the salty air. He closes his eyes, awash per usual with over a century’s worth of cluttered memories and no more able to parse them than he was when he left the Shire twenty years ago. Bilbo has outlived every Hobbit he has ever known; the past two decades have battered him about, restoring him at a breakneck pace to a physical and mental state appropriate to a Hobbit of his age. When he carried the ring, of course, things were much different. Bilbo misses the old thing dearly, but there is nothing for it. That useful little trinket has been lost somehow on one of Frodo’s adventures. A pity, but not worth half as much as his nephew’s life.
Why is Bilbo here, in this strange and beautiful place? He considers asking Frodo, but the poor boy has already set him straight three times since their departure from the Shire. It was odd to see Bag End again, as though Bilbo were staring back into his past. That’s a location where he prefers not to dwell, now that he has seen his nephew to adulthood and finished his book. What Bilbo can remember makes his guts churn almost as much as the knowledge that many of his once-cherished memories have slipped from his mind like a little golden bauble from a pocket with a hidden hole. But Bilbo could live a thousand years, forget everything he’s ever known, and still retain his taste for novelty.
“Pippin wants to see the waves,” Frodo announces. Bilbo must have drifted out of focus again, because he has no recollection of any comment to this effect from his young cousin. Nor, for that matter, did he notice his nephew’s approach. “Will you come with us, Uncle?”
Bilbo waves him off. “You lads don’t need me slowing you down. I’ll be seeing the waves soon enough in my own time. You run along with Pippin and keep him out of trouble.”
Frodo offers a rare smile, but there is a shadow behind it, as though he is only playing the part of the happy-go-lucky young master of Bag End.This act might fool his cousins, and it might even fool his dear Samwise, but it does not fool Bilbo. The shadow has been present since Frodo returned from his journey, waxing and waning with his moods but never retreating far enough away to leave the boy in peace.
“If you say so.” Frodo rejoins the other young Hobbits, and they rush off at an enviable pace, as though they believe that the waves may notbe waiting for them if they tarry here a moment longer.
But this way of thinking is typical among young folk. How old is Frodo, again? He must be out of his tweens by now, but compared to Bilbo, he will always be a child. Too young for all that has happened to him as a result of his uncle’s negligence. Far, far too young to be here in the Grey Havens, preparing to accompany Bilbo and the Elves on a journey from which none of them will return. Because that, Bilbo now recalls, is where they are going. He sighs. It is a bittersweet thing to remember, but at least he remembered it on his own.
Leaving feels right, and so Bilbo shall leave. He would prefer it if Frodo could stay, if he could be happy in the Shire with his maps and his friends, but Bilbo is not naive. Frodo has changed. He cannot enjoy life as he once did, cannot find meaning in cooking or cartography or anything else that Hobbiton has to offer. Whatever the ring did to Bilbo, stowed away in his pocket in the Shire, it did to Frodo tenfold in the far-away land of Mordor, and much more quickly, too. Ah, if only Lord Elrond had agreed to let Bilbo bear the ring on its final journey. Then he could have saved his nephew all of that pain and torment, could have kept him from this fate.
Bilbo should have been permitted to take responsibility for his own errors, to shelter Frodo from the evils of the world. But he would not have made it to Mordor, Bilbo knows. He would not have been so strong as his nephew, would not have been able to carry the ring all that way without putting it on and making himself known to the enemy. He would not have been able to resist after so many long years with the ring, all stretched out and twisted up in its destiny as he had become. Once, such a journey may have been possible, but by the time of Elrond’s Council, Bilbo was far too old to undertake the trip, and in no state of mind to do battle with such a powerful force of evil. It had to be Frodo, but it should have been Bilbo.
There is nothing for it now, of course. There are things that Bilbo has carried long and far, burdens far heavier than the one ring. There is much that Bilbo would have done differently, had he been given the chance. Many changes he would make for Frodo’s sake. And there were others as well, for whom Bilbo would have made any sacrifice required, had he known the outcome of events. They flit around like ghosts at the corners of his mind, familiar but unknown to him as he struggles to remember the names and faces of those he has lost. Bilbo forces himself to focus on the beautiful stone work in front of him instead, contemplating the craftsmanship required to create the sculpture toward which he has directed his blank stare.
It once was some sort of fountain, Bilbo thinks, but it is ancient now, the carved stone playing host to moss in a shade of green as rich as any emerald. The stonework consists of intricate curled carvings that must have required time and patience create. Considering that it was made by Elves, in all likelihood, the crafter could very well still be alive, and no doubt unchanged by the millennia that have passed since they put down the chisel and stepped away from this now-crumbling work of art. The piece is fascinating, with boughs coming over a bowl in the center, each one hewn with equal care.Bilbo finds himself captivated by its beauty, its longevity, and all the careful work that must have gone into its production.
Someone Bilbo knew once was fond of such things. He had an eye for good craftsmanship, though he never would have admitted to finding it in anything made by an Elf. He’d have complained about this place to no end, Bilbo is certain. He’d have invented issues with the breeze, the salt-smell, and the bird calls, would have taken the opportunity to describe the superior stonework in the Dwarven Halls of Erebor and Khazad-Dûm. And Bilbo would have been very polite and not mentioned that his friend, whose name escapes him now, never set eyes on the halls of Khazad-Dûm. No point rubbing salt in that terrible wound. Despite the way his friend had treated him at first, Bilbo, even in his darkest moments, could never be so very cruel. Instead, he’d have said something funny, to elicit laughter. To coax out that smile from a face so accustomed to frowning.
What was he called, again? Bilbo finds, to his horror, that he can’t remember. More slips away from him each day. He loses time, he loses focus, and he loses memories. The longer he stares at the sculpture, trying in vain to puzzle out what, exactly, it is meant to depict, the more he struggles to recall where he is and what is going on. Did he come here with Primula? She was always the adventurous sort. Bilbo’s favorite cousin, really, though he would never admit it to poor Drogo. They were married, weren’t they? And they had a son. What was the little lad’s name?
A hand comes down on Bilbo’s shoulder, soft, gentle, and large. Not broad and calloused, not armored with a gauntlet, not the hand he has been dreaming of. This, instead, is a soft and slender hand, graceful and cool. Instantly, clarity washes over Bilbo in time with the waves that lap the shore in the middle distance. It is as though he has awoken from a very long dream, as though somehow his mind, once spread impossibly thin, has returned to the state that it was in fifty years ago. “What?” Bilbo asks. “Where is Frodo?”
This has become his chief concern: his charge, his ward, his nephew. Frodo. For years, Bilbo could think about his adventure only in terms of the story it made for him to tell to young Hobbits. None of the nasty bits, none of the terror, none of the fear. For his nephew’s sake, Bilbo could gloss over the moments when his heart nearly stopped, reducing his adventure to prose and verse all woven together between the covers of a red leather book. He busied himself with child-minding, and then with child-rearing, forcing anything else upon which he might dwell out of his mind. When he is startled, nervous, or confused, he finds it is best to focus on Frodo. Though now that Frodo bears the scars of his own adventure, Bilbo finds that even this line of thinking leads him down avenues he’d rather not travel.
“He has gone ahead to look at the waves with his friends,” Lady Galadriel tells Bilbo. There is no mockery in her gentle smile. It is plain that she does not begrudge Bilbo his age, that she understands, perhaps better than others of her folk, the toll that time can take on those with mortal bodies. “I thought I might speak to you for a moment.”
He has seen her before, of course, once or twice, in passing.But they have never had a real conversation. She has always seemed remote to Bilbo, distant and strange. Not like the elves of Rivendell, who once delighted in hearing Bilbo’s poems, nor the elves of Mirkwood, who seem to take joy in causing as much trouble as possible for everyone that they encounter. The Lady’s hair is long and fair, her eyes as clear and sharp as dyed glass. Bilbo’s gaze is drawn, just for a moment, to the ring on her finger, the dazzling stone set in a silver band. Perhaps because of the burden that Bilbo once carried, he is able to discern that Lady Galadriel stands in a similar position. But even without the ring, this elf would be powerful. Bilbo can feel it coming off of her in waves, especially now that she has granted him such clarity.
“Ah, yes, of course, of course.” Bilbo will not be rude to one so ancient, noble, and wise. If she would like to speak to him, then he will not deny her the chance, baffled though he is by her desire to do so. Anything one might gain from a conversation with Bilbo could be found in his book, though he will admit to embellishing certain events and omitting others in his retelling. “What would you like to speak about, then, my Lady?”
“You would go West with us now, to the Undying Lands.” It is difficult to tell how the Elf feels about this. Galadriel is an ancient creature, powerful beyond Bilbo’s comprehension. She has seen many things in all three ages. The brief life of a Hobbit, even a long-lived Hobbit, must seem only a blink of an eye by her reckoning, no matter how sympathetic she might be to Bilbo’s relative age. But clearly, in all her many years, Galadriel has learned how to conceal her emotions.
“Yes, I am going, my Lady. Frodo and I are coming with you,” Bilbo explains, smiling up at her. “One last adventure, and I must say that I’m looking forward to it.” Who would not be excited about seeing the Undying Lands? Bilbo and Frodo will be the first Hobbits ever to do so. That almost compensates for the fact that so many of his closest friends have gone where Bilbo cannot follow.
Galadriel returns his smile, though it does not reach her eyes. Through the cut glass exterior, he sees the light of stars, full of thoughts and magics which Bilbo cannot fathom. Though Bilbo is wrinkled enough to be her great-grandfather, the Elf’s ancient wisdom is unmistakable when he stares into those eyes. “I thought I might offer you an alternative, though of course, you are welcome to sail on should you so choose. Frodo has done his task and born his burden well. I can sense a peace returning to this land, though I sense also that the age of Elves has at long last come to an end. It is time even for those of us who have lingered to depart from Middle Earth.”
“Yes, Frodo has done very well,” Bilbo agrees, ignoring the bit about the age of Elves. That conversation seems like one which will take up time that Bilbo does not have. “I’m quite proud of him. But I don’t know what you mean about… an alternative, My Lady. You’ll have to speak plainly to an old Hobbit like me, I’m afraid.”
“You have traveled far, Bilbo Baggins,” Galadriel replies. “And you will travel far once more, no matter what you choose.”
Bilbo is dimly aware that this is not an answer to his request, though he doesn’t know why he’s surprised. Has he not learned his lesson, after so many years of taking counsel from Elves? Not only do they answer both yes and no, but they do so in the most ridiculous and confusing terms imaginable! Bilbo wonders, for a moment, why he has elected to spend his last days amongst such folk. With his mind restored, he finds he longs for loud, boisterous parties, with food and ale and friends who dance on tables, kings who hide their smiles in their mugs and tap their feet to bawdy tunes.
“Yes,” Bilbo agrees, “I suppose it is quite the journey to the Undying Lands. But I’ll have you know that I’m more than up for it, My Lady.”
He does hope she doesn’t try to persuade him to return to Rivendell, or, worse, to join young Aragorn in Gondor. Bilbo knows that to sit beside any throne would only make him long for the impossible presence of a different king. Though, perhaps when Galadriel leaves him, Bilbo will forget once more about Thorin Oakenshield. He sincerely hopes so. This remembered pain feels as fresh as it did when he first took the wound, and, ancient coward that he is, Bilbo would rather lose the ability to feel it than carry the hurt any further. Is that not why he has chosen to sail West now, before age takes him? Was that not his primary reason for his first great westward journey, many years ago?
He could have stayed in Erebor if he had wished, Bilbo reminds himself. It was his decision to return to the Shire, and against the counsel of his friends, too. If he’d wanted, he could’ve styled himself a Lord of the Lonely Mountain and been hailed as a hero for the rest of his days, but that was not the path he took. He has no business longing for things that he turned down of his own volition, does he?
“And is that what you would do, if given the choice?” Galadriel searches Bilbo’s eyes for the answer. She seems to find it, after a moment, because she smiles, nods, and hums as though he’s just said something very clever. Bilbo, for his part, still has no clue what is going on or what the Lady wants from him. She means to offer something, but what it is, he cannot say.
“Forgive me, Lady,” Bilbo replies, throwing caution to the wind. He’s never been the type to walk on eggshells, anyway, and as he nears the end of his life, he finds his patience is running rather thin. “I am old now, and not as sharp as I once was. I do not know what you’re implying, though I should like to, if you’d be so kind as to explain.” There. That’s plenty polite. His father would be very proud, though Bungo Baggins would no doubt be turning in his grave at the sight of Bilbo now, about to step onto a boat, of all things, with Elves, of all people.
Galadriel’s soft smile widens, sending a ripple as far as her cool blue eyes. It is like staring into the sea and watching the tide rise. Bilbo has no right to draw such a comparison, having never seen the sea before, but he has read enough about it to understand the general concept. Is this what it will be like, sailing West? Will the same enchantment shimmer over the Undying Lands? Bilbo thinks that he should like to see that if he can. He should like for Frodo to see it, too. Yavanna knows it will be better than what the lad has put up with over the course of the past few years. “Perhaps I should show you,” she breathes.
“Of course,” Bilbo agrees, “Please show me.” Galadriel’s ability to grant vivid visions is not news to him, after all.
Maybe this will be better. She seems to have trouble articulating whatever it is she wants to say in a manner that an old Hobbit can understand, but it would be difficult even for Bilbo to fumble the interpretation of clear images.
Galadriel reaches out, cupping his cheek in her long, graceful hand. Her skin is cool and vibrant, youthful in its smoothness and ancient in its surety. Bilbo feels unsettled by this even before the barrage of images begins.
He cannot make sense of them all as they bombard him from every direction. He catches snatches of familiar faces: Bofur, grinning broadly by the light of a fire. Dwalin, hefting an axe in battle, killing an orc in one fell swoop. Gandalf on horseback, riding through the rain. Beorn the bear-man in his verdant garden, tending to a swarm of giant bees. It is too much; the images swirl too quickly for Bilbo to pick out more than a few specific scenes. It feels as though he is experiencing them all at once, and he cannot decide whether seconds or decades are passing around him as he does so.
And then time slows down again, and he is in a large, ornately decorated stone chamber. There is something familiar about it, and it takes a moment for him to realize that he is in the Throne Room of Erebor. It is not decorated as it was when he last visited. The golden lamps that lined the walls have been replaced with silver ones, and beside the stone throne upon which Dáin might sit is a slightly smaller chair designed in similar fashion. Thick tapestries line the walls, and Bilbo recognizes his own likeness amidst those of his one-time travel companions. He can see the reclamation of Erebor, stitched with painstaking care by a very talented artisan. Against his will, Bilbo is whirled around, faster than he has been able to move in decades, to face a troika of ghosts.
Thorin looks well. Healthier than Bilbo remembers him, his dark hair neatly brushed and freshly braided, his fur-trimmed coat in pristine condition. He wears a silver crown upon his head, more understated than the Raven Crown that Bilbo knew him to wear in his final days. His air of authority comes from the set of his shoulders, instead, and there is no mistaking that Thorin is a great and mighty king. He is smiling. It would, perhaps, be a bit of a stretch to describe him as carefree, but he is clearly not burdened as he was when Bilbo knew him. He is flanked on either side by his nephews: Fíli, in dark blue, and Kíli, wearing green. All of their beards are longer than Bilbo remembers. They look very pleased to see Bilbo, indeed. He opens his mouth to speak, but no sound comes out.
Once again, he is swept up into a sea of images which crash against him with battering force. He is pulled under the memory of a moment shared with Bifur, watching his friend whittle while they shared a watch in the moonlight. Time spits Bilbo back up again, and he watches as Óin’s careful hands prod at his midsection, conducting an exam, no doubt, after some skirmish or another. When did this happen? More images slam against Bilbo; he tries to close his eyes against them but finds, to his horror, that it is not possible. He is forced to watch but can do nothing to sway the passage of events. This is becoming a bit of a theme for him.
And then Bilbo is in a different room, one he has never seen before, a bed chamber, dimly lit. He is laying on a bed he cannot feel, with black silken sheets that he is certain would be pleasantly cool to the touch, smooth and comfortable. It is opulent beyond his wildest dreams, the blue curtains on the four-poster bed embroidered with glimmering silver thread, the pillows perfectly fluffed, and a heavy grey fur thrown over the sheets to top it all off. And there is someone in the bed beside Bilbo, a dark-haired someone, laying on his side. The figure’s broad back is crossed with battle scars, some familiar, some that Bilbo has not seen. He stares in awe for a moment at this sight which is beyond even the wildest fantasies that he entertained during his quest.Bilbo cannot help himself from reaching out, extending a shimmering hand, but before he can touch Thorin, the horrible flurry of memories takes him again.
He watches, upside down, as Fíli walks across the table in the dining room of Bag End. Then, Bilbo is jerked to the side, where he sees three trolls, poised to eat him for dinner. He watches Elrond studying a familiar broken sword. Bilbo is dragged beneath the surface of a pond, it seems, and there he is treated to the full force of a thunder battle, witnessed once and never forgotten. Spiders. Goblins. Wargs. A ball of pure light flying through the air. For a moment, Bilbo is sure that he is back at Ravenhill, that terrible, cursed place. Or else he is in the dungeons of the Woodland realm, but something is wrong, because he spent weeks there, and he is fairly certain that even in his sleep-deprived and hungry stupor, he’d have remembered any time passed inside a cell.
Bilbo’s world resolves itself again and he stands in a library, jam-packed with ancient tomes and fresh volumes, scrolls and maps and papers to rival even the collection in Rivendell. Ori is there, his face buried in a book, and Balin watches fondly, the way a father might, his arms full of scrolls. Óin is present, too, carrying a heavy stack of medical tomes, with Glóin beside him, elbowing his brother in the side with little care for the fate of the books in his hands. The room is crowded, but Bilbo catches sight of Dori and Nori, Bofur, Bifur, and Bombur, all huddled around a table, engaged in the sort of conversation that any good librarian would frown upon. Even Dwalin isstanding sentinel at the door. It has been a long time since he’s seen all his friends together in one place. Not since he left Erebor after that horrible funeral.
This time, Bilbo is expecting it, and he steels himself against the breaking wave of memory. These images are not fair. He has spent decades trying to forget about Thorin Oakenshield and that smile of his, the way his eyes lit up on the Carrock. Bilbo should not have to be subjected to the sight of his long-dead beloved, grinning amidst a field of flowers, should not have to see him leaning against the kitchen counter in Bag End, a mug of tea in his hand, as he never could have done in life. But it is even worse to see Thorin laying on the ground, his blood staining the teeth of the warg that looms over him. Fire. So much fire. A snarling dragon. A stone precipice. The feathers of an Eagle surrounding Bilbo as he travels through the air on the great bird’s back. Thorin’s arms around him. A rising tide of liquid flame.
Then Bilbo is in a garden, though it is not like any that he’s ever encountered before. This garden is indoors, with walls and a ceiling made of glass, and it is full of plants of all kinds. Some, he knows from the Shire. Some, he has never seen before. Even knowing that he cannot interact with the contents of this vision, Bilbo feels compelled to get his hands dirty tending to this miraculous treasure-trove. And Frodo is there, looking young and free and happy, with dirt under his fingernails and a freshly-harvested beet in his small hands. The shadows are gone from under his eyes, and he carries some healthy weight around his middle. This is not the thin, troubled waif who returned to Bilbo after so long on the road but a gleeful Hobbit in his prime, pleased to be among his plants. Though the dagger strapped to Frodo’s belt and the Elven brooch pinned to his lapel are more than enough to set the lad apart from any respectable Hobbit. Good. Bilbo should not like to think that he raised his nephew to be entirely respectable.
And then Bilbo is back in the Grey Havens with Lady Galadriel. He wheezes for breath, taking slow notice of her trembling fingers centimeters from his flushed face. She draws back, and the beads of sweat that dot her forehead are not lost on Bilbo. In showing him all of this without the aid of her mirror, the Lady has exerted herself. So, too, has the Hobbit. “One moment, please,” says Bilbo, adjusting once more to his creaky limbs and aching muscles. He quite appreciated being outside of his body for a few moments, and he is not particularly pleased to have been returned to it.
“Of course.” It is difficult to tell whether Galadriel is amused or impatient, but she does not seem angry, at the very least.
Once he has his bearings, Bilbo is prepared to wrestle with the sequence of images that he has just been shown. Most of them moved too quickly for him to make much sense of them; already, he is beginning to forget the contents of his vision. But he will never forget the sight of the throne room and what he saw there. His friends. His dead friends. All three sons of Durin: Fíli, run through with a sword and thrown from a prodigious height, his life snuffed out as a threat to his uncle. Kíli, taken in battle, the circumstances murky because the only witness was beyond speech when Bilbo found her, sobbing over the prince’s lifeless body. And Thorin, dear Thorin, who died in Bilbo’s arms. Thorin, who would not heed Bilbo’s pleas to hold on, who slipped away from him, who would not stay no matter how Bilbo begged. Thorin, who ruined any thought of future romance for Bilbo, made the idea of courtship with a nice Hobbit lady from a good family seem cheap and flimsy by comparison to what the pair of them had endured side-by-side.
To see all his friends together again was overwhelming enough for Bilbo. But to see himself so clearly sharing a bed with Thorin, an unfair glimpse at something that could never have come to pass, borders on the painful. Even if Thorin had lived, he would not have wanted Bilbo that way. They were close friends, and there was, at one point, a chance for more. There were glances shared, words heavy with meaning, gestures lost on Bilbo at the time which made more sense to him later on, as he learned more about Dwarven culture. But Bilbo betrayed Thorin, and the king sought revenge, nearly killing Bilbo over the stolen Arkenstone. Things were made complicated, irrevocably damaged by Bilbo’s folly. Oh, there was a time when Bilbo might have dreamed of a position by Thorin’s side, serving as his advisor, or something to that effect. But to think that they could sleep side-by-side in such a marvelous place, where there would be plenty of other beds to spare? That they might choose to share such intimacy when other options were available? The thought would never have crossed Bilbo’s mind, had Galadriel not planted it there.
And, then, of course, there was the vision of the rest of the company, gathered together in the library. Bilbo knows that Balin died as Lord of Moria. He knows that Oin was killed there as well, though nobody has told him precisely how. Frodo and his fellows did not exactly have time to identify bodies while they traveled through the ruins of Moria, though they did manage to find where Ori had been slain. With a pen and one hand and a book of records in the other, the lad had died the way he lived. Though by then, he was no longer the shy young scholar that Bilbo had befriended on their quest but a master scribe of Erebor and Moria with decades of experience behind him.
When Bilbo last visited the Lonely Mountain, most of his friends were in fine health. Bifur complained of more frequent headaches, but that was only to be expected, what with the damage from the axe. Bombur was not well, suffering from limited mobility in his old age after a long life of many pleasures, exacerbating issues which had plagued him even in his poverty, but Dáin had accommodated him when a team of attendants to carry him from place to place. Although, that was before the War of the Ring, and who knows what kinds of troubles came to Erebor at the hands of the enemy? Is it possible that all of Bilbo’s friends could have been slain? That is the only way that he could imagine them all in the same location as Ori, Balin, and Óin, who are now beyond the reach of the living.
For all that he never would have dared to dream about Frodo’s healing anywhere but in the Undying Lands, for as implausible as it might seem for Bilbo to be allowed to visit his dead friends, these, at least, seem possible through the intervention of the Valar. Bilbo does not struggle in the slightest to believe that Yavanna and Aulë might be able to restore the dead to life, or, more likely, send Bilbo to his death and place him in an afterlife more to his liking than the one typically reserved for Hobbits.
“This is… the alternative?” Bilbo asks, tentative.
“Yes.” Galadriel does not expand upon this sentiment.
Bilbo considers it. Obviously, if he accepts Galadriel’s offer, he will get to see his departed friends. And Frodo will be there. Perhaps Galadriel has already made him the same offer, and he has already accepted it. Or perhaps if Bilbo accepts, Frodo will follow, eager for another adventure. Because there is only one possible explanation: Bilbo and Frodo are being offered passage to the Dwarven afterlife. That is the only place where he might see Thorin and the others again, unless some other arrangement has been made. Perhaps the Valar have constructed a new afterlife for Bilbo and Thorin and their kin, in payment for the service that they have done for Middle Earth. Without Bilbo and Frodo, the enemy might be in possession of his ring, after all. And without Thorin and his irresponsible gift of mithril armor, Frodo would not have survived his journey to Mount Doom.
Bilbo does not question Galadriel’s authority to make this offer. After all, if anyone could carry off such a thing, surely it’d be her. Unless, of course, Galadriel is merely a conduit for the will of the Valar. He will not pretend to understand or care how these things work.
“I would see them all again, then?” Bilbo asks, his voice thin. It is not possible. It is far too good to be true, to think that he could be granted such a privilege. This is a boon beyond anything that Bilbo deserves, surely.
“Yes,” says Galadriel again. “You would.”
“And Frodo.” Bilbo will not get his hopes up just yet. He has not only himself to think of but his nephew as well, and in Frodo’s delicate condition, even the smallest matters have taken on a great importance. “He’ll still get to make his own decision? I’m not choosing for him, am I?”
“No.” Galadriel laughs, and it is a beautiful sound. “Frodo will travel his own path regardless of any choice that you might make.”
But he will choose to join Bilbo. Of course he will. They have always spoken about going on an adventure together, and this is the perfect opportunity. It may be a bit strange, meeting Thorin again after so long, but Bilbo will manage. He had long since given up on his old friend. On all of them, in fact. He would be over the moon, now, to be able to meet with any one of his onetime companions. But to have the entire company, together, once more, in the same place?
And to think that he might lay in bed beside Thorin, as anything more than friend, companion, and advisor? To think that, once they talk things through and sort things out, once Bilbo makes it clear that he has long since forgiven Thorin, and, presumably, Thorin says his piece about the Arkenstone, they could be together? To think that Thorin would want to be with Bilbo in any capacity, even as ghosts, after everything that has happened? Galadriel, Gandalf, and all the Valar combined could not make it so. But it has been shown to Bilbo alongside the other things, as though it is equally possible. None could change Thorin’s will. If he will see Bilbo, and if he will have him as depicted in the vision, then perhaps their relationship was not so damaged as Bilbo once thought.
That decides it, then. Thinking of Thorin, waiting for him in the afterlife all this time, and Bilbo, puttering around for decades longer than expected? He’s going to get a talking-to for that, he knows, but it will be more than worth it. He and Thorin could watch Frodo heal together, in this strange place. Or maybe Frodo will not come to them for some time. Maybe he will sail to the Undying Lands as intended, and reunite with Bilbo in many years. Will it matter, when Bilbo no longer needs to worry about the condition of his aging body, no longer needs to linger on the constraints of time?
“I accept,” he tells Galadriel. “Of course I accept.”
“That is wise,” she replies. Well, of course she would think that; it was her idea. Once again, Bilbo questions the wisdom of taking counsel from Elves. But it is too late now. He has already agreed to go through with the Lady’s scheme, for better or for worse.
Galadriel reaches out again to cup Bilbo’s face, and this time, he accepts the touch without hesitation. He closes his eyes, unsure of what to expect, and the world around him dissolves in a blinding flash of white light.
Chapter 2: A More-or-Less Expected Party
Summary:
The truth comes to light.
Notes:
Thank you to everyone who read the last chapter and left comments/kudos! I'm going to try and keep up with weekly updates, but no promises since some of these chapters are likely to be pretty long.
I've included quite a bit of dialogue and actions directly from the film here. My logic is that most of the characters have no real reason to have a completely different response to the very same stimuli just because Bilbo is experiencing all of this for the second time. There are still plenty of changes and quite a bit of new stuff, too, and hopefully Bilbo's introspection will make the more familiar sections worthwhile! Please be forewarned that there is even more talk of death and dying in this chapter than in the last one as Bilbo struggles to reconcile his grief with the fact that the people he's grieving are alive and right in front of him.
With that out of the way, enjoy!
Chapter Text
Far away to the West, leagues and leagues from the Lonely Mountain, King Thorin II, son of Thrain, son of Thror, wakes with his sword by his side and a pouch of cheap pipeweed upon his breast. The room is dark; dawn’s first light is hours away, so Thorin’s first act upon waking is to fumble for the lamp and light it. His eyes are keen in the dark, but he has need of light just now. Thorin has waited many years for this day, and he will sit idle no longer.
“Ugh,” comes a groan from one of the two lumps laying in the oversized bed. “Uncle, it cannot be morning yet.”
“Get up, Kíli,” Thorin counsels, his voice rough from sleep, “And wake your brother. We cannot tarry.”
Kíli sits up in bed and stretches before kicking his brother awake. Thorin finds it difficult to believe that his heir could remain asleep in a room flooded with light, to which their people are especially sensitive. More likely than not, Fíli is only feigning sleep now. Of course, any reasoning along these lines from Kíli will likely lead to a wrestling match for which they have no time.
“I’m awake,” Fíli grumbles. He has managed to monopolize all of the blankets in his sleep, and he stirs beneath them now. “What time is it?”
“It’s the middle of the night,” Kíli reports without a glance toward the clock as he kicks off the single sheet that covers him. “But Uncle Thorin is ready to go, so we must be as well, or we’ll be left behind.” Even at this hour, Mahal has blessed Kíli with seemingly inexhaustible stores of energy.
His brother is not so lucky. Fíli curses under his breath and makes no move to rise. “Left behind, or carried off and tied to ponies whether we’re ready to go or not?”
“Wanna find out? I’ll give you, mmm… three gold coins if you stay right where you are and wait for His Majesty to deal with you,” Kíli jokes. Blessedly, he begins shoving his meager possessions into his pack, which he left in the middle of the floor, presumably in order to make it as much of a tripping hazard as possible.
“You don’t have three gold coins,” the Crown Prince points out.
His brother shrugs. “I’d take them from Uncle’s pack. He’d be distracted carrying you off and tying you to the pony.” He moves on to Fíli’s pack, although this is largely unnecessary, as the bag is stuffed nearly to bursting and propped against the wall.
Thorin is endeared, despite himself, as he always is by these two boys. The three of them have spent the past several weeks on the road, doing what they can to gather coin and support in anticipation of their oncoming quest. From here, Fíli and Kíli will lead their uncle to the meeting where he will seek formal aid from the other Dwarven kingdoms. Then, they will proceed to the Shire, where Thorin will meet them several hours later. Assuming, of course, that he does not lose his way coming from the meeting, which is a legitimate possibility.
Since they first left the Blue Mountains, Fíli and Kíli have taken every possible opportunity to make Thorin’s life harder. They have stolen his pipe more than once, replacing it by turns with sticks and stones and, on one particularly memorable occasion, a dagger, still warm from long hours spent concealed somewhere on Fíli’s person. Kíli has spent the entire journey chattering incessantly, no matter what kinds of glares Thorin shoots in his direction. His brother is even worse, finding the least opportune moments to grill Thorin about the particulars of kingship for future reference. All in all, they cause him more grief between them than any all the other members of his paltry court combined.
And yet, the king loves his sister-sons with all his heart. Their childhoods were not easy, and they have each of them seen things that no prince of any realm should ever have to see, but they’ve been brought up with plenty of love and no shortage of mirth. This much, Thorin has been able to give them. Mischievous though they may be, Fíli and Kíli are good lads. At mealtimes, they wait until others have been served before filling their own bowls, and on the road, they ride ahead of their elders to scout for dangers without having to be asked. They’ll give Thorin no end of grief about the waking-up issue, but when push comes to shove, they’ll be hot on his heels as he storms out the door. He won’t be tying anybody into their saddle this day.
“Are we not entitled to our rest?” Fíli demands of his uncle, all of a sudden every inch the prince. It is not a skill he uses often, having no real need of it in his typical dealings. He has never known a life of courtly manners, never slept beneath an embroidered canopy, never dined on fine foods or strode through marble halls. But he’s a good mimic and can adopt Thorin’s most regal mannerisms when it suits him. Coming from any but his heir, this would annoy Thorin to no end. Coming from Fíli, it fills him with hope.
Should things go poorly, should Thorin fall, his nephew will step forward to claim the throne. Fíli may not be prepared to reclaim Erebor single-handedly. He may be forced to lead their party back to the Blue Mountains. He may need to wait until he is older and more accustomed to the particulars of ruling before he makes another attempt on their Mountain. But at the very least, Thorin’s people will be in good hands in his absence.
“We’ll miss our appointment with our Burglar if we’re not careful,” Kíli reminds his brother, finally hopping out of bed, “And we’ve got to see Uncle to his meeting. We’d best not keep him waiting, lest we face his wrath.” This they have both seen on more than one occasion, and yet, still they follow Thorin. “Even worse if we let him go alone. If he gets himself lost, you’ll have to be king, and then what?”
“Listen to your brother,” Thorin advises, “Or you truly will be left behind.” He is lying, and Fíli knows this, but he does at least draw back the covers. Despite their protests at being woken, Thorin knows very well that his sister-sons are just as eager as he is for the journey ahead.
They do not need to see him to his meeting, as Kíli puts it. They could spend hours more lazing about and take whatever shortcuts they please to the distant Shire. But Thorin’s sister-sons are loyal and serious about their duty to their people. They have long hours of pony-riding ahead of them, and they’re experienced enough to plan their journey so that they arrive in time for their scheduled dinner.
“Fine,” Fíli concedes, rising and stretching with theatrical flourish. “We can sleep in the Maker’s halls, I suppose, and besides, somebody’s got to keep His Majesty from getting lost. May as well be us.”
Bilbo finds himself sitting in his garden with a pipe in his mouth. The pipe is similar in shape and quality to one that he lost on his adventure, and the pipeweed inside of it is very fine, as well. Sweet and aromatic, proper Old Toby, not that bland stuff they gave him in Rivendell or the bitter mix preferred by his Ereborean friends. Certainly not the nonsense that Merry and Pippin brought back from Isengard, improperly dried on the side of the road by somebody who was familiar with the good stuff but lacked the skill to cultivate it properly. And, naturally, the gardens are beautiful, although that isn’t really saying much; the gardens of Bag End have always been beautiful. And this is certainly Bag End.
Bilbo would not have expected to see his old home transplanted into the afterlife for his perpetual enjoyment. His understanding of the Dwarven afterlife is that he will be expected to wait upon Mahal, though what that might entail, Bilbo still has not managed to figure out. He’d always believed that Mahal’s children returned to the stone from whence they had come upon their deaths, but Balin had told him otherwise when…
No. Bilbo swallows that memory. This is supposed to be a happy time, and so Bilbo will be happy. There is no point mourning Thorin or the lads all over again, no point remembering the three of them, laid out on stone slabs, hands placed strategically to obscure the gaping holes they all sported on their persons. There is no point thinking of that conversation with Balin, the comforting hand on Bilbo’s trembling shoulder as he sobbed and sobbed in front of the company. He had thought, at the time, that he’d been very subtle about his feelings for Thorin, but of course, they all must have known. After all, they, too, were mourning their friends, their royal family, and none of them had broken down sobbing, clutching uselessly at Thorin’s cold, unfeeling hand…
No. This is a happy time. This is a happy day and Bilbo will be seeing his friends again very soon. He has a fine pipe and a beautiful garden anda comfortable home, or something that looks like one, at least, and as Galadriel promised, he will find his family soon. Frodo will certainly be along shortly, even if Bilbo needs to travel far to meet the others. There is no point dwelling on the past. It is over and done with.
He tries his best to focus on the production of smoke rings. Bilbo sucks in smoke and directs all of his attention to the careful shaping of it. Beautiful. A perfect ring. That’s good. He’s sure the lads will love to see his smoke rings, and perhaps even Thorin will be impressed, though he doubts it. From what he remembers, the king could send smoke rings floating about at will, up the chimney or out the window or round and round in circles, depending on his mood. Bilbo should like to see that again. It’s a good thing they’ve still got pipes here in the afterlife.
It isn’t long before a figure approaches, grey-clad and towering. That stops Bilbo in his tracks, mouth hanging open and pipe resting in his hand. He could not make a smoke ring if he tried as his heart plummets into his stomach. “Gandalf?” He is catching flies, he knows, but he cannot help but gape. “What are you doing here?”
Of course, Bilbo knew that Gandalf was planning on accompanying him and Frodo to the Undying Lands. The fact that the Wizard is finally out of business, as it were, does not surprise Bilbo half as much as the fact that the Wizard is here, in this strange afterlife where Bilbo is to be reunited with Thorin and the rest of the company. Gandalf did travel with them initially, though he made himself quite scarce during the journey, particularly when having a Wizard about would have been most useful. Still, if he is here, does that not mean that he is dead? It is one thing for Bilbo to make such a choice; his life was stretched beyond its natural confines by the Ring before accelerating rapidly toward an end he’d put off for some time. But Gandalf? As far as Bilbo knows, Wizards live forever. What on Earth is Gandalf doing here?
“My dear fellow!” Obviously, Gandalf was expecting to find Bilbo just outside this facsimile of Bag End. He must have spoken with Galadriel and concluded that he’d be more needed here than in the Undying Lands, which may very well be true. Bilbo still has no idea how he’s supposed to get to Thorin and the others. He can’t imagine they’ve been knocking about in this copy of his homefor so many decades, and if they have, he can only imagine the state of the place on the inside. “It’s good to see that you remember me!”
“Remember you?” What is he on about? “Well, of course I remember you, Gandalf! But what are you doing here?” Bilbo looks around for emphasis and sees movement out of the corner of his eye.
A Hobbit lass, carrying the washing in from the clothesline. Is that… Begonia Proudfoot? She looks amazing for her age, but then, Bilbo supposes, this is the afterlife. Although that does not explain what she is doing in this afterlife at all. He cannot imagine any Proudfoot agreeing to spend eternity in the Dwarven afterlife. And he can’t imagine that Mahal would want Begonia waiting on him for the rest of time. She has an awful lot in common with her cousin Lobelia, and Bilbo remembers her making off with more than a few of his father’s best vases during the auction of Bag End. And there’s her husband Tom, who makes his wife look well-mannered and refused to return any of the furniture he’d pillaged from Bilbo’s home before the auction even took place! Unlike Begonia, who does have a very deft hand in the herb garden, it must be said, Tom has no redeeming qualities at all. Why would they be chosen to wait upon any of the Valar?
Clearly, this is not Mahal’s realm. Bilbo does not know if he has reached the place where Hobbits go when they die and must now fight his way to his friends, or if this is a new plane of existence created especially for the ring-bearers and their kin, but either way, it is not what he expected. But that would explain Gandalf’s sudden appearance. Perhaps the Wizard is here to help guide Bilbo from the Hobbit section of the afterlife to the Dwarven realm. But if that's the case, it seems a little circuitous. Why not just drop him directly where he’s meant to be?
Gandalf studies Bilbo’s expression with eyes that have seen many an age. He does not betray whatever thoughts are swimming there. He never has done, and apparently, death has not changed him. “I’m looking for someone to share in an adventure!”
“Again?” Bilbo demands. This is really too much. He’s already got to put up with his nosy neighbors for the rest of time, and now he has to face the perils of the road? If they’re letting in the Proudfoots, Bilbo can easily imagine that a couple of trolls and maybe even an orc or two have also made the cut. “Yes, alright. When are we leaving? I must say, at my age, I’m looking forward more to the destination than the journey, but I suppose there’ll be much to see along the way that I’ve yet to encounter, so I can’t say it’ll be for nothing.” And it won’t hurt to accumulate a couple of new stories to share with Frodo when they meet him.
“At your age? My dear chap, you’re not a day above fifty,” Gandalf informs him, “That’s not quite so old for a Hobbit. And I would hardly count your youthful forays into the woods as proper adventures. You’ll soon find there’s more to the world than you’ve been told, Mister Baggins.”
Bilbo only blinks at him. Gandalf is a strange creature, it must be said. He is long-lived and powerful, like an elf, but impulsive and self-interested, like a man. Bilbo has come to expect a little bit of oddness from the Wizard. But referring to Bilbo’s adventure as a youthful foray? A youthful foray that got two princes and a king killed? “Excuse me?” Bilbo demands.
“Have you even been so far as Bree?” Gandalf asks him.
What kind of a question is that? Bilbo searches the Wizard’s eyes for mirth and finds none. “What are you saying?”
“I’m saying,” Gandalf explains, “That I think you could use a bit of adventure.”
It is clear that the Wizard does not mind Bilbo’s obvious distress in the slightest, but Bilbo is not a stupid Hobbit. It is also clear that Gandalf has no recollection of bringing Bilbo on an adventure before. And he thinks Bilbo is fifty. And there are Hobbits here, along with the Wizard, and Bilbo’s garden, and Bag End, and his missing pipe. All the wishful thinking in the world could not obscure the truth from Bilbo, and he is not at all pleased about it.
An adventure is one thing. Bilbo loves adventures! But the same adventure another time? To do everything over again? To relive all of the peril, all of the terror, and every single awkward moment? Bilbo’s head is spinning with the broader implications.
“Oh, by the Valar,” Bilbo grumbles, “This is really just Hobbiton, isn’t it?” More likely than not, he’d have figured that out much sooner if he’d not had his heart set on sharing eternity in a peaceful afterlife with all those closest to him. Certainly, the fleeting images shown to him by Lady Galadriel make a lot more sense now.
Bilbo had thought that they’d been memories, context for the other, more concrete pictures into which they’d resolved themselves. But no. He’d been looking into his future the entire time. He never could’ve thought that it was even within the Lady’s power to do something like this. Sending Bilbo back in time, to reside in his younger body and retrace his steps? Why, it’s like something out of a fairy tale! Bilbo is not looking forward to being chased across the map by Orcs, attacked by spiders, or imprisoned by Elves. And those are just the things that he can expect to happen based on his previous adventure! Who knows what changes might take place as a result of Bilbo’s altered actions?
“Why, yes,” Gandalf replies, clearly confused by the question. “But you’ve left Hobbiton many times before.”
Right. He thinks that he’s dealing with the fifty-year-old Bilbo who has never properly left the Shire and does not wish to. He’s trying to coax a homebody Gentehobbit into following him on an adventure for the first time, not to comfort him about the fact that, apparently, he has been hoodwinked into going through with everything again. Why couldn’t Galadriel just tell Bilbo what she meant, in words, rather than leaving him to interpret a barrage of cryptic images?
But that’s hardly fair. After all, Bilbo could have asked for clarification, but he was certain that he knew exactly what the Elf was trying to communicate. It’s not her fault she’s an ancient being who has wielded a ring of power since before Bilbo’s earliest known ancestor was born. No doubt she has no idea the sort of gap that exists between her and any mortals with whom she might wish to interact.
Bilbo rolls his eyes. “Yes,” he tells the Wizard, “I most definitely have.”
“So it won’t be too much hardship for you to leave it once again.”
Not too much hardship? Not too much hardship to watch his friends suffer and die? Gandalf must be joking. Bilbo has to bite his lip, reminding himself over and over again in his head that the Wizard has no idea what will come to pass. And Bilbo isn’t going to tell him.
He can’t, can he? Never mind that Gandalf would be insufferable if he knew anything about Bilbo’s feelings for Thorin, which are so integral to the tale that Bilbo doesn’t think he’d be able to tell it without making them apparent. Never mind that Gandalf would be forced to lie to Elrond, Galadriel, and everyone else, telling them that everything would be fine when he knew that it would not. Never mind that it would change the entire course of the adventure if Gandalf knew what would happen to the company, thereby creating new peril for them to avoid.
If the Wizard knew about the Ring, the entire quest would be derailed. Maybe he’d forbid Bilbo from going, or maybe he’d encourage him to collect the thing and then destroy it right away. Perhaps he’d seek counsel from the wise. No doubt he’d come up with his own plan, and no doubt it would be convoluted, foolish, and dangerous. Perhaps he’d still encourage the company to undertake their own journey while spiriting Bilbo away to Mount Doom to take on Frodo’s burden. But that won’t do at all! Bilbo knows he needs to be there for his friends, whatever happens. He’ll be forced to lie to Gandalf, whether he likes it or not.
“Oh, alright.” Bilbo sighs. He doesn’t have much choice in the matter.
If he refuses to go, Thorin will proceed to Erebor anyway, and probably get himself and his company killed along the way. How many times did Bilbo save their lives on the journey, after all? And besides, Bilbo knows that no matter what he says, Gandalf will invite the company to Bag End for tea tomorrow. He knows that tea will turn into dinner, which will turn into supper, and he will be asked to come with them to reclaim their home. He could not refuse the first time, when he did not know these people, and now that they are his friends? Oh, goodness. Bilbo won’t be able to say no.
But if he’s there, he can do something. Didn’t Galadriel show him a future where the company lived? Where Thorin bore unfamiliar battle scars, and Kíli had a beard halfway down his chest, and Fíli stood beside them in the proper regalia of the Crown Prince of Erebor? Does that not mean that, should Bilbo succeed, he can protect his friends from their fates? Not that he has any idea how to do so. If he knew that, he’d have done it already, and they wouldn’t be in this mess.
“That’s wonderful to hear,” Gandalf beams at him, pleasantly surprised by the fact that he has managed, with minimal effort, to talk a perfectly respectable Hobbit into coming on an adventure. “Wonderful indeed.”
Bilbo only shakes his head. “Come back for tea tomorrow,” he orders, “And please, invite your whole party.” He can’t stop the sarcasm from seeping into his tone as he says that. Gandalf never gave him any warning, after all, which would have been the polite thing to do. And if Bilbo had known to expect fourteen visitors, he certainly would’ve been better prepared to host them all at one time. “Oh, and Gandalf? Do. Not. Mark. My. Door.”
Truth be told, Bilbo doesn’t care so much about the marked door. He tried painting over it, of course, but some magical property kept the rune perfectly visible for many years after his adventure. Though, the scratch faded in time, resolving itself eventually into the faint outline of a rune amidst a sea of lovely green. Really, it’s the principle of the thing, that Gandalf would presume to put an enchanted mark on Bilbo’s door without even warning him first. Honestly, the Wizard could use a lesson or two in manners. He is Bilbo’s dear friend, but his rudeness truly knows no bounds. Anyway, speaking of boundless rudeness, Bilbo has a party to prepare for.
He rises, puts out his pipe, and strides back into Bag End without a glance behind him. He hears the Wizard’s chuckling, and for what it’s worth, Bilbo cannot restrain his own smile when the mirthful sound is followed by the audible scraping of the Wizard’s staff against his freshly-painted door.
Bilbo’s first order of business, once Gandalf has retreated back onto Hobbiton’s only road, is to make himself a pot of strong tea and some elevensies. It’s obvious what’s going on, and Bilbo knows that he can’t very well face it on an empty stomach. He’s going to need tea and biscuits and perhaps a couple sausages before he can really get to thinking about the adventure he’s being sent on once again. He would have much preferred to join his kin in the Dwarven afterlife, but he sees now that it was ridiculous of him to expect Galadriel to give him an easy way out. She would not have expended so much power to grant a single Hobbit such a monumental boon.
If showing him that frightful series of images made her sweat, what did it do to the Lady to send Bilbo more than eight decades into the past? Even with her ring on, did she have that much power to spare? Could she have destroyed herself in the casting of such a spell? Bilbo does not know. He has no understanding whatsoever of how these things operate. Thinking about it for longer than a few seconds makes his head spin: if Bilbo changes things as he intends to, then the future will not happen as he remembers it. Galadriel would have no reason to send him back, and therefore he would not be back here to begin with. But if she did not intend for him to change then future, then why would she have done this? And the visions that she showed him clearly depicted events that had never come to pass. This only confirms the Hobbit’s conviction that he was sent back for the express purpose of making changes.
Bilbo knows why he is here, and it’s not merely to see his old friends again, nor to save the lives of loved ones he has lost. He does intend to do both of those things, of course, but the lives of a few mortals would not warrant such intervention from a power so great as the Lady Galadriel. Bilbo has an important task on his hands, and one that he does not take lightly. He finishes his food and does the washing up, and then he makes his way to his study. It is not what he remembers at all.
He is missing many of his favorite books, because he acquired them after his adventure. There are no volumes on Dwarven culture, which might have been helpful if he’d had them the first time around, and the section of his library devoted to history is embarrassingly scant. Nothing about dragons, because he only became interested in those after he riddled with one, and nothing about rings of power, either. If Bilbo had done any reading on that subject prior to his journey, he probably would’ve left the ring in that goblin tunnel all those years ago. Or, rather, all those months in the future, which is how he should remind himself to look at it now.
Well. There’s nothing for it. Bilbo has a job to do, and he is going to do it. He finds a scrap of paper and a pen, a pot of ink which…. Oh, really, this is terrible stuff. Bilbo cannot believe that he ever spent any money on something of such inferior quality. When did those Men start selling that new type of ink in Bree? After Bilbo’s adventure, apparently. He sighs, resigning himself to the use of this clumpy stuff.
This will be much easier if Bilbo can break it into manageable steps. It surely seems like a daunting task, enduring his adventure all over again, facing a dragon for the second time, picking up a cursed ring, and, oh yes, protecting his friends from their horrific fates while he’s at it. But Bilbo Baggins does not do things by half, and he does not give up when things look daunting. No. He must take one thing at a time.
At the top of the page, Bilbo writes To do. The first item is a simple one:
1. Party
Bilbo wants to do it right this time. Even if his guests had fun the first time around, Bilbo knows that he was lacking food and space, and it seems a shame to deprive them of the best evening that he can plan just because he’s done it once before. His first order of business should be to prepare and host the best party he has ever given. And after that?
2. Adventure
That won’t be so hard, will it? After all, Bilbo has done this before. He only needs to remember everything that he did the first time (which won’t be so hard, considering he’s written a book about it, and told all of the stories over and over again over the past several decades, at Frodo’s insistence) and do it exactly the same way again. Well, until he gets to the mountain, that is. That’s when things will need to change.
3. Face Dragon
If he can, Bilbo would like to protect the people of Lake-town this time. This means that he and his friends may have to be the ones to kill the dragon, if it comes to it. Or perhaps he could warn Bard in advance, just in case the dragon does come to Lake-town, and the bowman will be ready to shoot before Smaug has done any real damage. Maybe it would be better to invite Bard to come with them to the mountain? Oh, but Thorin would never allow that, and Bard would not go if it meant leaving his children. Bilbo will have the entire journey to think of what to do, will he not? Surely he can come up with something in that time. And, if worst comes to worst, Bard will still be able to slay the dragon as he did before. Things cannot possibly be worse than they were the first time around.
4. Save Thorin & Lads
That one might prove to be more of a challenge than anything else on his list. But, then, Bilbo knows about the trap on Ravenhill, the ambush that the orcs have planned, and he’ll be able to warn Thorin about it sooner, assuming that the king will listen to him. Before, Bilbo underestimated the power of dragon sickness and the hold that it had on Thorin. He truly believed that the unspoken… thing between the two of them would be enough to stave off the illness, that Thorin would listen to reason from him, if nobody else. That he would understand the logic behind Bilbo’s betrayal and forgive him, that he would come around and do what was necessary to preserve his honor and the lives of his friends.
And he did. But it was too late, and he died anyway, and Bilbo can still remember the feeling of that stiff hand clutched in his own, that cold and silent chest against which he pressed his ear so as not to look at those brilliant blue eyes, waxy, staring at nothing. But even if Bilbo cannot save Thorin from his madness, even if he tries and fails, perhaps he can keep Fíli and Kíli from walking into a trap. He can protect them, at least. They will listen to him. They will both see reason. And maybe if they do, Thorin will come around. Clearly, Bilbo will have to come up with a new plan on that front as well. He does not like relying on the hope that Fíli and Kíli will act rationally and choose their own safety over what they would surely perceive as their duty to the Kingdom of Erebor.
Of course, there is that other thing, the real reason why Galadriel sent him on this journey. Bilbo knows it, and he understands it. Even if he fails to save his friends, he can still save Middle Earth. More importantly, he can still save Frodo. He can allow the lad to have a better life, a free life, with none of the torment he experienced while Bilbo was helpless to protect him. While Bilbo was jealous of him, envious of the fact that his nephew had the ring in his possession and got to go on an adventure. Bilbo wonders if his mind is so much clearer now simply because he is younger, or because he is free of the ring.
But it matters not. He will have to pick up the ring again in order to complete his adventure. He will have to carry it. And he will have to destroy it before it can destroy him or, Valar forbid, before it can destroy Frodo. It surely won’t be easy, but Bilbo Baggins is not the type to stand back and do nothing when it is in his power to help. If Lord Elrond was correct, and none but a Hobbit can carry the ring, then the task should fall to the Hobbit who found it, should it not?
5. Destroy ring.
That’s sorted, then. Only five things that Bilbo must do. That’s not so terrible, is it? Most of them, he has done already, at least in some capacity, and when dealing with the other items on his list, he will at least have the befit of foresight. Anyway, there’s no point worrying about the ring or the battle right now. Those trials are months away, and he’ll have many hours of monotonous travel and late-night watches which he can devote to such musings. For the moment, Bilbo has a party to plan.
Bilbo spends the afternoon in the Shire’s market, selecting what provisions he might need for the party he’ll be hosting tomorrow and for the long journey ahead. He’s not stingy with his purchases by any means. After all, he has no intention of returning to Bag End. If his plan succeeds, he’s going to stay in Erebor, and if it fails… well, if Bilbo fails, he doesn’t think he can stomach another long, lonely life as the laughingstock of Hobbiton. But even if he does return, he’ll be coming back with a chest full of gold, which will more than make up for any irresponsible spending before he sets out.
He buys frosted cakes and loaves of bread, heavy cream for churning butter and the best cuts of meat that he can get his hands on at such short notice. He buys more potatoes than he can carry at one time and pays a neighbor to lend him a wheelbarrow for their transportation. He buys spices and sweets and ale, so much ale; a very nice red wine that Gandalf will enjoy and a fancy sparkling tea that he knows will tempt Dori. He purchases about fifty of the seed cakes that Bofur and Fíli devoured the last time around, and roughly an entire school of the fish that Dwalin so enjoyed. He buys wheel upon wheel of cheese for old Bombur and does not forget about Bifur’s sweet tooth. When he thinks he has enough, Bilbo buys another three barrels of ale, just in case.
And then he gets himself a nice, heavy cloak with a proper hood. He won’t be borrowing from anybody this time. As soon as he’s back in Bag End, he stuffs the pockets full with handkerchiefs, because he won’t be taking any scraps from anybody’s clothing for that purpose, either. Once that’s sorted, he spends the rest of the afternoon cooking. He bakes all through the evening, stopping only for meals and bathroom breaks. The next day is much the same, so that by the time the first knock comes on his door, Bilbo is fully prepared to host the party of his life. And that is saying something, considering he is a Hobbit, after all.
“Dwalin, at your service.” It’s strange to see his old friend looking so very young, but Bilbo supposes he’ll need to get used to such things. After all, everybody will look much younger than they did when last he saw them, considering he is several decades in the past.
“Bilbo Baggins at yours,” he responds with much more enthusiasm than he did the last time. “Come inside, please. Help yourself to the fish and ale, and do wipe off your boots first.”
“Fish and ale? Now, this is a party.” It seems Dwalin, too, likes Bilbo better than he did the first time that they met.
But that would follow, wouldn’t it? Before, Bilbo was rude, confused, and awkward. He didn’t turn Dwalin away, of course. That would be terrible manners, even when a stranger waltzed into his house without a word of explanation. But Bilbo was terse, and he did not respond well.
Bilbo doesn’t have much time to make conversation with his guest, and a good thing, too. Dwalin was never much the talkative one, and Bilbo fears if he’s allowed to ramble then he will give himself away. He is hyper-aware of just who will be knocking on his door next. He has not seen Balin, Lord of Moria, in ages, and it will be difficult to navigate this interaction.
“That’ll be the door.”
“Yes, thank you, Dwalin!” Bilbo calls over his shoulder. “I had no idea!”
Dwalin snorts, digging back into his meal. If only Bilbo had been dropped back into his fifty-year-old body a few months before his adventure, then he’d have had more time to commission a new and larger table, which might better accommodate his guests. But of course, the Lady Galadriel would not have thought of such things. She almost certainly did not send Bilbo back in hopes that he might improve this specific party.
Bilbo throws open his door. He remembers dimly that Balin seemed elderly to him when first they met, but not so now. Balin’s eyes hold a hopeful twinkle, and his face is nowhere near as weathered as it was when last Bilbo saw him. Certainly he looks much younger than Bilbo did yesterday. “Balin, at your service!” He sweeps into a sprightly bow.
“Bilbo Baggins at yours and your family’s,” Bilbo beams at him. At least this time around, he’s learned the proper response to such an introduction. “Please, come inside. We’ve plenty to eat and plenty to drink! You must be hungry after your long journey, even on such a fair evening as this one.” He has to stop himself from embracing his friend, who, of course, does not know him. Well, not yet, at least.
“A fair evening indeed, though I think it might rain later,” Balin observes absently. Not the same phrasing as the first time, but apparently, he really wants to share this information with his host. Bilbo can’t help but smile. “Am I late?”
“Not at all,” Bilbo assures him. “This way, please, we’ll find you something to eat.”
While Balin and Dwalin re-unite, complete with forehead-butting, embracing, and comments that still seem somewhat rude to Bilbo after all this time, the Hobbit sets about moving the furniture to make more space for the many guests that will be coming. He remembers exactly which chairs were moved when he last hosted this party, and exactly where they were moved to, because he was rather upset about it at the time. Before, Bilbo was slightly addled by his shock and confusion, but now, he has no excuse. No guests will be doing anything even resembling manual labor at Bag End now that he’s got his full faculties behind him, not on Bilbo’s watch.
There comes another knock at the door, and Bilbo sighs heavily. He can handle this. He can handle this. He has no choice. Bilbo takes a deep breath and puts on the neutral face he always used to wear for Frodo. The little lad didn’t need to know that every look he cast toward his uncle with Primula’s eyes was a knife in Bilbo’s chest, and the Princes of Erebor don’t need to know that their new burglar has already cried himself hoarse at their funeral.
He throws his lovely, marked-up green door open again and is greeted by two smiling faces. Oh, by the Green Lady, they’re barely more than tweens. For some reason, Bilbo remembered them seeming much older. Perhaps that’s because the last time he saw them their faces were cold and lifeless and constricted by pain. Perhaps it’s because this quest will age them and rob them of any innocence they managed to hold onto in the Blue Mountains. Perhaps it’s because Bilbo knows that if he had been only a little bit faster running through that battle, he’d have been able to stop them from rushing off and getting themselves killed, but instead they died, and it was his fault.
“Fíli,” Fíli says.
“And Kíli,” Kíli rejoins.
“At your service,” they announce in unison, sweeping into twin bows.
Bilbo is frozen in shock. He cannot help it. He cannot compose himself, but oh, by the Valar, he must. He is not going to ruin this night for them by making them worry about their awkward host. “How many times have you rehearsed that, exactly?” Bilbo is well-versed in schooling his features to hide behind a one-liner. If he could fool Frodo, he can very well fool these lads, who do not even know him yet.
“Only a few times,” Kíli lies with that brilliant grin of his. “You must be Mr. Boggins!”
Bilbo can only shake his head. “Baggins,” he corrects the prince, “And second, come inside, please. There’s plenty to eat and plenty to do.” Conversations to be had, cards to play, that sort of thing.
“And plenty to drink?” Fíli presses. His face is so expressive, so full of genuine glee in anticipation of the coming adventure. He’s clearly looking forward to this. He does not know that he will die. He does not know that his last act will be to tell his uncle to run, that his advice will not be heeded, that Kíli and Thorin will outlive him by mere minutes. He does not know that it will take hours to locate his body once the battle dies down, that his remains will ultimately have to be heaved out of a crevasse, that this process will be significantly lengthened by Dwalin’s shaky hands and Bilbo’s utter uselessness as he clings to the empty shell of Thorin.
“Oh, yes, I thought that was a given.” Bilbo falls with his full weight upon his racing thoughts, immobilizing them where they stand. He cannot sink into despair. Fíli will not die if Bilbo has anything to say about it, and nor, for that matter, will anybody else. But he will only raise suspicion if he acts overly familiar or overly melancholy.
“Careful with these; I just had them sharpened.” Fíli is oblivious to the thoughts that pull Bilbo’s ancient mind in all directions as he steps forward with an impressive bundle of swords, knives, and axes, all wrapped up in far too little protective leather for any Gentlehobbit’s comfort. What could he possibly do with them all, even in the most involved of battles? No doubt the entire lot will end up in Goblin hands when the company is waylaid in the Misty Mountains. But Bilbo can’t protest at having a heavy load of weapons dumped into his arms, because Fíli is alive.
“It’s nice, this place. Did you do it yourself?” Kíli asks absently, and Bilbo doesn’t even mind that the lad is scraping his filthy boots against Bilbo’s mother’s glory box when the floor mat is right there (and specifically purchased for this occasion, too), because Kíli yet draws breath. Which is more than Bilbo could’ve asked for two days ago.
Bilbo needs to force himself to answer. “My father designed it as a wedding gift for my mother. I’m afraid I’m not much for carpentry, so it’s nothing short of a gift from the Valar that I didn’t have to build my own smial.” He watches the Crown Prince of Erebor, already halfway to the dining room, make mental note of the unfamiliar word.
Kíli just laughs at Bilbo’s comment. Good. It’s good to see him laughing, with so much color in his cheeks. “There was talk of drink?”
“And food, too,” Bilbo reminds him. “I doubt you’ve been eating properly on the road, and I’ve got a feast ready, besides. Right this way.”
Bilbo spends the next several minutes puttering around, waiting on his guests. There is always ale to be poured, and more food to be heated. This party will go on for a very long time, tea blending into dinner blending into supper; if he’d cooked everything before Dwalin’s arrival, it would all be cold by the end of things. He’s fully prepared for the next knock on the door, and not in anything even resembling the foul mood that he remembers from the last time that he did this, so he’s gentle with the door and nobody is knocked over.
Bilbo allows Gandalf to introduce him to each of his friends, and they all inform him that they’re at his service. Bilbo responds in kind with his Hobbit-y approximation of a Dwarven bow before whisking them away to be served. “I’ll tell you this right now,” he addresses Bofur and Nori in particular, holding up two very different crochet projects. “Dishcloth, doily. See the difference? I’ll not have you mistaking one for the other in my house.” Best to get out ahead of that problem before it manifests itself. The stains never did come out of that doily, which was an awful shame, considering it was some of Bilbo’s best work.
Nori, naturally, rolls his eyes at Bilbo and saunters off. No doubt he’s taking some kind of inventory of the contents of Bilbo’s home, and before the end of the evening, his sticky fingers will find more to pocket than just linens. When Bilbo returned to Erebor, Nori presented him with no fewer than seven of his own napkin rings, which Bilbo had previously presumed had been among Lobelia’s plunder. Apparently, Nori managed to hold onto them through most of the journey, but had them confiscated in the Elven dungeons. It was only after Bilbo left that he was able to get them back, and the two did not see one another for sixty more years. Naturally, Bilbo took the napkin rings back to Rivendell and displayed them proudly in his small apartment there.
Bofur jabs at the dishcloth. “Well, this is obviously the better of the two. That other thing is full of holes. Why ever would you waste your time making that?”
“Because I happen to enjoy crochet!” Bilbo can’t help sputtering at his old friend, though his smile never falters. Bofur loves getting a rise out of him, apparently even on this odd timeline where Bilbo, a complete stranger, is shoving the contents of the linen closet in his face.
“Aye, and a wonderful game it is, too, if you’ve got the balls for it.” Bilbo would be lying if he pretended that he hadn’t just intentionally set Bofur up for that particular joke. He’s always enjoyed his friend’s sense of humor. In fact, he found that, after Thorin and the lads, he missed Bofur most of all during his estrangement from the company.
The pair of them exchanged a few letters, of course, and saw one another when Bilbo returned to Erebor in his old age. Two of Bofur’s daughters attended Bilbo’s eleventy-first birthday, though of course, their father was unable to travel as far as the Shire at that time with both Bifur and Bombur in such poor health. One of Bilbo’s greatest regrets in life is not carrying on the sort of correspondence he’d have liked to with the friends that he had left after his adventure.
“Go and have some seed cake,” Bilbo orders, unable to restrain his glee. He’s missed this very much. It has been ages since Bag End was so full of noise.
“Oh, I love seed cake.” Bofur grins at him. “How’d you know?”
But Bilbo is already off, riflingthrough the many barrels and bottles that he’s purchased to find that sparkling tea for Dori, and some glasses to serve it in. Bilbo will not have anybody drinking directly from the bottle in his home. Well, except for Kíli, who happens to be guzzling ale right from the barrel, which is not what the spout is for. There is ale going everywhere, because the prince does not seem inclined to bother with shutting the spout between gulps. Bilbo rushes off to put a stop to that before any permeant damage is done to his floor. He may not be returning to Bag End, but he fully intends to leave the property in the care of the Gamgee family, and the last thing he wants is for them to be left with a stinking and soggy stained floor.
“But Mr. Boggins,” Kíli gives him that big-eyed expression, which, no doubt, would have worked wonders on Bilbo at the start of their first journey together. Unfortunately, the Hobbit has too many vivid memories of looking into those large eyes while Kíli explained why Bilbo absolutely needed to participate in the lads’ latest half-baked scheme. He won’t be falling for it this time. “You’re all out of mugs. Do you want me to die of thirst?”
“Nothing so dramatic as that, but you can close the spout between drinks, at least,” Bilbo offers, making a valiant effort to restrain his laughter. “Look what you’re doing to the floor!” He gestures at the puddle of ale.
Kíli shrugs. “I was going to clean it up,” he announces. This may be true, considering that Bilbo has no recollection of coming home to a sticky floor after his last adventure.
Bilbo fixes the prince with a hard stare. “And you still are.” Apparently, Kíli finds this very funny. Hopefully his attitude will be similar when he’s mopping the floor, because Bilbo is not joking, whatever his own chuckles may suggest.
Another shock comes when Bilbo returns to the dining room to find Fíli, once again, walking across the kitchen table with his boots on. Bilbo knows from experience that the caked-on mud will be a struggle to remove, and that’s not even considering the scuffs beneath it.
“Shoes off, if you’re going to do that, please!” Bilbo yelps, after a brief wave of recognition. Yes, he has watched this happen once before, that first night in Bag End. But this, too, was one of the images from the vision given to Bilbo by Lady Galadriel. He does not quite have time to process what that means, however, because he is met with exactly the sort of indignant response one might expect when one rains upon an uproarious parade.
The first time, Bilbo was absolutely stricken by the lad’s unparalleled rudeness. He had no idea then that Fíli was Crown Prince of Erebor, though that would not have changed much vis a vis his trek across the dining table. It did not occur to Bilbo that perhaps in Dwarven culture, such behavior might be entirely typical, that a boot-clad people might construct their furniture to withstand such abuse, and that the lad might be so unfamiliar with Hobbits as to assume that they did things the same way. These considerations aside, Bilbo is now incredibly aware of what Fíli is actually doing.
He’s handing out mugs of ale (which explains where all of them have gotten to), delivering beverages like a barkeep to people who, strictly speaking, are his social inferiors. But the prince is a good lad and doesn’t seem to care that if anything, the others should be serving him. Although Bilbo would be hard-pressed to say that someone tracking mud across his father’s table has good manners, he can at least appreciate that Fíli isn’t trying to be rude. Though the table itself did nothing to deserve such treatment.
“He’s fine,” Glóin calls, “It’ll hold him!”
“Not if he keeps at it with the mashed potatoes!” Bombur argues, and Fíli responds by trying to kick him. Bombur dodges the blow with ease that might be shocking to one who had never seen him in battle.
“We are guests of Master Baggins,” Dori points out. “We should at least make an effort to respect his house rules.” Ah, yes. Bilbo has always found an ally in Dori when it comes to politeness and common courtesy, and he’s very grateful for his friend’s intervention on his behalf at this juncture. Nobody in the company knows Bilbo, and despite the fact that they are in his home, they have more than proven that none of them has any inclination whatsoever to listen to a word he says. Figures.
Of course, Bilbo only has another fire to put out when Nori, Kíli, and Bofur take it upon themselves to divest Fíli of his boots while he is still trying to walk across the table. More than one fork clatters to the ground, and ale is spilled in copious amounts. Bilbo gets the feeling that if Thorin were here, he’d be considering disinheriting his nephews and naming Dáin as his heir. Though if Dáin were here, he’d probably have broken the table before Fíli could even consider stepping onto it.
“You can deal with that,” Bilbo informs a chuckling Gandalf. The Hobbit is very fond of his friends, indeed, but he feels it was rather rude of Gandalf to invite them all into Bag End without warning Bilbo. If anybody deserves to be kicked, it is the Wizard. Anyway, Bifur is already signing furiously, lecturing the group with verbiage that might make Bilbo laugh, were he not so busy trying to conceal his knowledge of the secret sign language. It’s been difficult enough restraining himself from simply signing to Óin so that the healer might actually have some idea of what the Hobbit is trying to tell him.
Bilbo hardly gets a chance to sit down throughout the party, though he does manage to wolf down several dozen mini-quiches and one full-sized blueberry pie in between his errands. He’s still a Hobbit, after all. He’s not about to go hungry. Of course, he is stopped in his tracks when Ori approaches him asking where to put a dirty plate.
Ori is the youngest member of the company by far, even younger than the princes, and he looks so small, so fragile, so inexperienced, at least by Bilbo’s still elderly assessment. This lad does not belong on a quest to fight a dragon, even if he isn’t half as afraid as he should be. And when Bilbo looks at him, all he can think of is the skeleton that Samwise described closest to the book of records. As Bilbo understands it, Gimli had been the one to recognize Ori’s handwriting in the book, and he’d been fairly confident, in his grief, that the remains nearby had belonged to the scribe. What a brutal, awful way to die. Worse, even, than if the dragon had taken him. Worse than falling in battle. Had he been slain? Suffocated? Starved? Perhaps Frodo and his friends had their theories, perhaps they saw evidence that would have answered these questions, but they knew better than to share any of that with Bilbo. His heart would not have been able to take it.
Ori is barely more than a boy now. His beard has not come in all the way. His expression is shy, his accent provincial, his fingers trembling ever so slightly as he holds up the plate. He’s out of his depth here, despite any bravado he might later display. His brothers have sheltered him and he does not know the horrors of the world in which he lives. This quest will age him, too.
“Oh,” Bilbo stammers, “Well—“
“Here you go, Ori, give it to me.” Fíli snatches the plate out of Ori’s hand. He tosses the dish to Kíli, who throws it into the dining room with a mischievous grin.
Bofur and the others are already banging their knives on the table, which has Bilbo shaking his head. “Those knives will never be the same,” he laments. And he knows that for a fact, too. With the condition they were in at the end of the evening, even Lobelia didn’t dare to touch them.
“You hear that, lads?” Bofur calls, “He says we’ll blunt the knives!” Which is not what Bilbo actually said this time, but it is true enough.
And of course, that leads into a song about the destruction of Bilbo’s dishes, and this time, Bilbo allows himself to tap his feet in time with the music. If it wouldn’t raise so many questions and set a bad example for those who might wish to join him with shoes on, he would get up on the table and dance along. He more-or-less remembers the words, and it is a blessing beyond measure to be able to move so freely once again.
“You people all got together and wrote this!” Bilbo exclaims between verses. It’s something that has always bothered him, though he never found the right time to ask about it. “And rehearsed it!” He can’t help but laugh at the idea.
“Well, Gandalf did tell us a little bit about you,” Kíli reports as the others continue their song. He seems to be making an active effort to look sheepish, though the effect is quickly ruined when he waves a blue porcelain plate at Bilbo. “Mr. Boggins, catch!”
Bilbo really does try to catch it, but of course, he fumbles. He’s never been the most coordinated of Hobbits at the best of times, his impulse when things are flying at him is to duck, not to dive for them, and he’s stunned by the novelty of this interaction. Flattered, actually, that the boys are trying to include him in their antics. He’s made them feel welcome and managed to avoid putting them off with whatever heavy grief is lurking behind his eyes. The plate hits the floor and shatters.
Kíli stares at him with wide eyes. “I didn’t mean to—“
“Oh, it’s no trouble,” Bilbo assures him. He finds he really doesn’t care about the plate. In fact, he hopes that Kíli will live to break many more of Bilbo’s dishes in the years to come. “You can just owe me one. There must be more than a few plates laying around in that mountain of yours, eh? Once we reclaim it, you can pick one out for me. A suitable payment, I think.”
“We will find you a golden plate,” Fíli assures Bilbo, tossing a teacup in his brother’s direction. Bilbo is surprisingly unbothered by the fact that dishes are flying every which way in his home.
“No, no, absolutely not.” Bilbo shakes his head vehemently. “The broken one is porcelain, so the replacement should be as well.”
“Porcelain with gold leaf,” Kíli muses.
“No,” Bilbo groans, “What would I do with that?”
“It’s a plate,” Fíli informs him, “You would eat off of it. What else?”
“Would one of you please just go fetch a broom?” Bilbo shakes his head fondly. By the Valar, he missed these lads. They’d have been a good influence on bookish, withdrawn Frodo. It’s not difficult to imagine Fíli and Kíli acting as older brothers for the young Hobbit, helping him through the loss of his parents in a way that Bilbo never could. It dawns on him, then, that he has always thought of these two, even more than the others, as members of his family.
Bilbo is too distracted by his musings, on top of sweeping up the remains of his poor plate, to notice the end of the merrymaking, though, of course, he’s incredibly aware of the knock at his door. It would be hard to miss a thing like that, especially considering Gandalf’s overly dramatic and largely unnecessary comment: “He is here.”
There are butterflies in Bilbo’s stomach and his hands are trembling. He’s not sure whether he’s excited at the prospect of seeing Thorin again or nervous that this is when the rug will be ripped out from under his feet. In good dreams, this is always when he wakes up. In nightmares, he opens the door of Bag End and steps out onto the snowy waste of Ravenhill. But neither of those things happen this time.
Bilbo opens the door with Gandalf’s large hand on his shoulder. And there is Thorin, in all his kingly glory, just as beautiful as Bilbo remembered. Dark hair streaked with grey, icy blue eyes, features Bilbo has memorized a million times over. It is impossible to believe now that the damage done by age and the ring ever managed to purge this image from his mind. How could Bilbo ever forget Thorin Oakenshield? How could he lose such an important moment? He longs to reach out, to touch the king and assure himself that all of this is truly happening. Bilbo’s mouth hangs open as he struggles to think of something to say, tries to get a handle on how to act as though he is not head-over-heels in love with the King Under the Mountain, who, at this juncture, does not know Bilbo’s name.
The illusion is shattered when Thorin pushes into Bag End, taking his cloak off and thrusting it in Kíli’s general direction. He ignores Bilbo altogether, leaving the Hobbit to scramble out of his way or risk being trampled. “Gandalf. I thought you said this place would be easy to find. I lost my way, twice. I wouldn’t have found it at all had it not been for that mark on the door.”
“How did you manage to get lost twice in Hobbiton?” Bilbo asks.
He’d forgotten how infuriating Thorin could be. Coming into Bilbo’s home already complaining, treating his own nephew like a coatrack, all while having the audacity to look like that. Of course, Bilbo knows that Thorin has a horrible sense of direction; he and the others spent a good deal of their adventure teasing him about it. But honestly, he could’ve asked anyone, and they’d have pointed him right down the road to Bag End. It would’ve been the start of much muttering, but Bilbo finds it difficult to believe that Thorin ever would’ve cared about such things. More likely, he simply failed to think things through. It wouldn’t be the first time, and Yavanna knows that it will not be the last.
“So. This is the Hobbit,” Thorin regards him with unkind eyes, not allowing Gandalf a chance to make any proper introductions. He does not trust outsiders, Bilbo knows. He does not trust anyone, and he isn’t going to engage with Bilbo’s playful ribbing. “Tell me, Mr. Baggins, have you done much fighting?”
“A fair amount,” Bilbo grumbles. The warmth in his chest and the writhing in his guts and the headache beginning to percolate are pulling him every which way, but it’s hard not to fall into that old rhythm of antagonistic banter with Thorin.
“Axe or sword?” Thorin demands. “What’s your weapon of choice?”
“Sword,” Bilbo replies truthfully.
Thorin does not look as though he believes this at all. “And may we see this sword of yours?”
“I don’t have it on me,” Bilbo informs him, arms crossed. “Or rather, I don’t have it yet. But I do know how to use it when it matters.” This is more or less true. The last time Bilbo picked up Sting was to hand it to Frodo, and before that, it’d been some fifteen years, at least. And even longer since he actually tried to fight with it. But Bilbo does not fancy explaining these nuances to Thorin, who will no doubt become even more distrustful in the face of Bilbo’s odd story.
Thorin does not dignify this with a response, which Bilbo supposes is fair. After all, he doesn’t know about the troll hoard. “He looks more like a grocer than a burglar.”
That sets Bilbo seething, just like it did the first time. Thorin doesn’t know a single thing about him, has no idea how brave Bilbo can be or how useful the Hobbit will become on this quest. Honestly, his dismissive behavior is downright rude, especially considering that he is a guest in Bilbo’s home. And it’s awfully high and mighty of somebody who managed to get lost in Hobbiton of all places to be throwing around insults about other people’s competence.
“And you look more like a blacksmith than a king,” Bilbo shoots back, “So it seems that looks can be deceiving, because I know who you are, Thorin Oakenshield, and I know that you are a great king, indeed.”
Thorin only looks at him, long and intense, keeping eye contact for a moment more than is comfortable. He is sizing Bilbo up, reassessing his initial judgment, which Bilbo hopes has proven unfair and inaccurate. He refuses to look away, meeting Thorin’s eyes defiantly. He may be in love, but he’s not going to roll over and accept whatever treatment Thorin decides to throw at him. Bilbo is not that kind of Hobbit, and it will save everyone a lot of trouble if His Majesty gets used to that now.
Neither of them says anything. The silence in the room is tense until Balin speaks up, asking Thorin about the meeting in Ered Luin. The King finally looks away from Bilbo, striding purposefully into the dining room as if he owns the place. Bilbo will consider this a win, even if he isn’t sure it is one.
He takes advantage of the discussion about the meeting to wash what dishes remain following the song and dance. A lot of plates and cups were tossed into the sink, but very few were scrubbed and rinsed, and none were put away where they actually belong. “Bilbo, my boy, you may want to hear this!” Gandalf calls from the dining room.
“I’m listening,” Bilbo assures him, “I can hear you all just fine in here.”
Gandalf mutters something about stubborn Hobbits, Thorin says something unintelligible under his breath, and Bilbo shakes his head, returning his attention to his dishes. He knows all about the map and key, after all, and he won’t leave Bag End a mess for the poor Gamgees. He gets a nice refresher about the dragon, the key, and the door while he finishes his dishes.
“Where’s my contract, then?” He asks, upon entering the kitchen.
“Pardon?” Thorin, apparently, is not accustomed to having this tone taken with him. Bilbo had forgotten that. A pity, but he’ll get used to it before their journey is through. Before they even get to Rivendell, if Bilbo’s memory serves him.
“You need a burglar,” Bilbo replies, “And I’m the best burglar that you’re going to be able to convince to walk into a treasure hoard with a live dragon inside. Furnace with wings, right?”
“Aye, that’s about the shape of it,” Bofur agrees.
“Right,” Bilbo nods once. “Which I think entitles me to one fourteenth share of the treasure. The contract, please?”
“That’s the spirit!” Fíli cheers. “I told you he’d do fine.”
Balin glances to Thorin, who only shrugs. Clearly, he has no clue what to make of Bilbo, who is not sure whether he wants to rush across the table to kiss Thorin or to engage him in some sort of duel. He can’t imagine that either course of action would end very well. “Here you are, laddie,” Balin says eventually.
“That’s perfect.” Bilbo does not have the heart to read the section about funeral arrangements. He does not want to be reminded of the funeral arrangements that he witnessed the last time he completed this quest, though of course, he already has been, even without digging into the relevant section. He simply signs his name and passes the contract back to Balin.
“Are you sure you don’t want to read it first?” Glóin inquires from across the table. “There’s important information in there.”
Bilbo shrugs. “I think I’ve got the gist. Now, we’ve got an early start in the morning, don’t we? So I’ll be heading to bed. Feel free to use any of the guest rooms, sofas, et cetera as you will. Gandalf, can you make arrangements?” That’ll teach the Wizard to plan a party in Bilbo’s home without bothering to notify the host.
Once he’s alone in his room, Bilbo’s confident facade crumbles to dust. The excitement fades, and he is left with the memory of Ravenhill.
Funeral arrangements.
In the event of your death…
Funeral.
Arrangements.
Thorin and Fíli and Kíli and their funeral arrangements. The stone slabs. Hands placed deliberately to hide the sword wounds, all three of them with sword wounds. Unmendable. Funeral arrangements. Dwalin’s shaking hands. The company carrying their leader and his kin back to Erebor across the battlefield. Funeral arrangements. Dori spending twenty minutes trying in vain to fix an odd cowlick in Kíli’s hair, giving up because it was just as hopeless in the lad’s death as it was in his life. Óin tending to each of Fíli’s shattered bones, not because there was any hope of healing, but because he feared that the sight of the Prince’s body as it was would be upsetting to the company and the newly-established population of Erebor. Funeral arrangements. Nori and Bofur hunting frantically through the royal suites of Erebor, trying to find something that would fit Thorin, because try as they might, nobody could get the blood stains out of his clothes. In the end he’d been laid to rest in an old robe of his father’s, moth-eaten and dusty. Bilbo knows far more than he would like to about the funeral arrangements.
He lays down in bed, still in his clothes, and he sobs. He releases the tears that have lived in his body for decades now, the pain and anguish that he has bottled up inside. He can’t do this again. He can’t watch his friends die. He has no choice but to go with them, to protect them as best he can. He has his list to follow. He cannot allow himself to think about the funeral arrangements or any other part of it. He just has to push through, because though some of them may perish even with his help, all of them will surely die without it.
For a moment, Bilbo cannot imagine sleeping, cannot imagine his thoughts ever settling enough to allow him to follow in their wake. But then the singing begins, singing Bilbo has not been able to shake from his head for decades. He is intimately familiar with the song about the Misty Mountains, the way Thorin’s voice fits around the harmonies hummed by the others. It has been stuck in Bilbo’s head at intervals for the majority of his life. He recorded it from memory in his book and he did not do a bad job. And it brings him comfort now, to cling to the timbre of his beloved’s voice, to allow himself to be carried off to a much needed sleep, his mind and body exhausted by the events of the day. Tomorrow, whether he likes it or not, Bilbo will be going on an adventure, and he needs whatever rest he can get.
But no song at all could protect Bilbo from nightmares on a night like tonight. In his dream he is wandering the halls of Bag End; he floats with confused purpose down to the old master bedroom, to which he knows in his stomach that Gandalf will have directed Thorin and the lads. The door opens of its own volition and there, on the bed, lie three ancient skeletons with their hands deliberately placed to obscure wounds that have long since decomposed. The one in the center has a glowing rock upon his breast: the Arkenstone balanced atop his ribcage. It shines, blinding Bilbo momentarily. Who is Bilbo kidding, to think that he can save his friends?
This is his fault. They are dead and it is his fault. He wasn’t fast enough. He knew what was going to happen and he couldn’t get there in time to deliver a warning. All three of them died terrible, painful deaths, and it was Bilbo’s fault. They will die again. He will watch them die again, helpless and culpable. The bed in which his parents once slept is soaked in the blood of his friends and it is all Bilbo’s fault.
He wakes up cold and clammy and thoroughly disturbed. He hasn’t had a nightmare this bad since his late visit to Erebor, but of course, it makes sense that such a troubling dream would find him after such an utterly overwhelming evening. He did not expect that it would be so distressing for him to see his friends again, but then again, he had forgotten about a few of the lines in that contract. And he has spent so long thinking of the departed as characters in an adventure he once lived through that perhaps he has forgotten what it felt like to be in their presence.
No memory could be as vivid as what he experienced last night. The years stole so many details from him, so many little things that, even by the time he sat down to work on his book, escaped him entirely. It is one thing to remember and quite another to live through a moment anew. And it only makes sense that such a carnal experience of all he’d thought he’d lostwould lead to an equally carnal nightmare about the other reality. Because when he was last in Erebor, Thorin and the lads really were…
Bilbo shakes himself. Why dwell on it? It’s not true anymore. A quick glance at the clock by his bedside tells him that it’s early in the morning, perhaps earlier than any respectable Hobbit would be awake, but late enough that it feels permissible for him to get out of bed with the excuse of getting started on breakfast. Bilbo has no idea what time the others are leaving because he did not leave with them on his original adventure, but he fully intends to pack them all full of good food and strong tea before they head off. And the preparation of another great meal will be a welcome distraction from his increasingly dour thoughts.
He puts on his dressing gown and pads into the hallway, taking care to be as quiet as possible. Which is very quiet indeed, because after everything that he has been through and all the lifetimes he has lived, Bilbo is still a Hobbit. Every one of his armchairs is occupied, and it seems that poor Ori has been relegated to the study. There’s no good place for a bedroll, cluttered as it is, but Bilbo is pleased to see his young friend sleeping soundly. Bilbo makes his way into the kitchen and nearly jumps out of his skin when he discovers that his dining room table is already occupied. It is far too early for anyone to be up and about!
“Master Baggins. You’re awake,” Thorin observes.
“And so are you.” Bilbo has no business blushing at him, that’s for certain. His emotions must be confused by his nightmare and the general oddness of his situation, but he needs to pull himself together. He can’t let on that he thinks of Thorin as anything other than someone who has disrupted his routine and invaded his home. Politeness, then, is the most appropriate route. “Did you get any sleep at all?”
“I couldn’t,” Thorin tells him with shocking vulnerability, “Not in a strange place like this.”
Of course, Thorin has no inkling that Bilbo knows just how many strange places the king has had to sleep in since being deposed from his home. He’s not necessarily trying to confess that he almost never sleeps well, but that’s the message that comes across. If they were having this conversation in Beorn’s hall, Bilbo would put a gentle hand on Thorin’s shoulder. In the Dungeons of Mirkwood, he’d interlace their fingers and offer a reassuring squeeze. If they were in Erebor, Bilbo might press his forehead to Thorin’s in a patently Dwarven gesture of comfort and affection. But they are still in Bag End, and they just met last night, and so he has nothing to offer.
Bilbo sighs, putting the kettle on and turning his attention to the contents of his pantry. He’ll be packing what he can carry, but he likes to think he has enough beyond that to feed his guests a breakfast that will rival the supper-dinner-tea they had before bed. After all, he did plan for this. He knows how much his friends can put away when the mood suits them. “You’ll be wanting coffee, then.”
“Yes, and ham and eggs, if you have them.”
Bilbo is well aware that Thorin is studying him, and he has to fight the urge to turn around and look at the expression on the king’s face. The last thing Bilbo wants right now is to give himself away. Let Thorin believe that Bilbo is jittery and nervous about the beginning of his first adventure, let him think that Bilbo is weak and a burden and unworthy of the title of burglar. Even if Bilbo could explain the real reasons for his obvious discomfort, he doubts that Thorin would believe him. What could Bilbo even say?
He settles for cooking breakfast, which Thorin allows him to do in complete silence. Bilbo had forgotten about this aspect of it all, how easy it always was for him to just exist beside Thorin. It’s not something Bilbo has experienced with anybody else before, and it’s strange to come back to it after all this time. Even if Thorin is silently judging him, there’s something comforting about his presence. It’s a balm to Bilbo’s frayed nerves, knowing that Thorin is here and alive and there is still a chance to set things right this time around.
Bilbo looks over his shoulder and nearly falls backwards onto the stove at what he sees. Thorin is standing there, more casual than Bilbo ever would have expected. He’s leaning forward against the counter, mug in hand. Just like in the vision. When Bilbo saw this the first time, he assumed that it was tea. The coffee is weak; clearly, Thorin was impatient and did not even wait for it to finish brewing, let alone for Bilbo to serve it to him properly. Does he not care about the flavor? Does he drink it only for the wakefulness it brings him? That thought might break Bilbo’s heart, were it not already shattered into pieces somewhere behind his ribs.
He cannot do this. He cannot spend months upon months tiptoeing around Thorin, pretending that he does not love him. He cannot waste what little time they have together. He cannot bank on the fact that he will succeed in saving his king. He cannot expect that they will have all the time in the world after the battle, once Erebor is reclaimed. Bilbo cannot restrain himself from throwing his arms around his love and begging for forgiveness.
But he must. He must do all of those things. Any emotional outburst at this juncture would only make Thorin suspicious, and then what would happen? He may not allow Bilbo to come on the adventure at all. And if Bilbo isn’t there to step between Thorin and Azog, will the king be killed? If Bilbo can’t free the company from the Spiders, or from the clutches of the Elves, will they all die in Mirkwood? If Bilbo does not vouch for them in Lake-town, will they starve to death before they reach their home? If he is not there to riddle with the dragon, what will Smaug do to his friends?
Bilbo has no choice. He’s spent eight decades pointedly refusing to think about how it felt to watch Thorin Oakenshield breathe his last breath. What’s another few months of the same? “It won’t go any faster just because you’re watching,” Bilbo quips, because he has to. He must say something or he may break down crying. Or start yelling and throwing things, which would feel a lot better and make everything much worse. “Why not set the table while you wait, if you don’t mind?”
“Set the table?” Thorin echoes.
Bilbo turns back toward the stove and squeezes his eyes shut. What is he doing? “Yes. It needs doing, and as you can see, I’m busy. You’re awake and standing around. Why not help?” Normally, he’d never ask such a thing of any guest. But he desperately needs Thorin to stop looking at him, stop trying to see him, stop trying to figure Bilbo out before he learns more than is good for him.
For a moment, Bilbo thinks that Thorin will refuse. After all, he’s been nothing but antagonistic thus far, and Bilbo knows from experience that this isn’t going to change any time soon. “Very well,” Thorin says eventually. “I will set the table.”
And he actually does. Granted, he uses the wrong plates (That gaudy old green set? Were the yellow ones not available?) and he distributes only forks and knives (could he not find the spoons? Why didn’t he ask after them?), but still, he sets the table.
The others begin to file in a few minutes later, which Bilbo cannot make sense of for the life of him. How are they all able to spring up out of bed before the sun has risen? But there’s not much time to ponder when Bilbo is making fifteen orders of eggs (closer to thirty, actually, since most of them have seconds), plate after plate of sausages, bacon, and ham, and several trays’ worth of toast to be devoured with all the jam that he can scavenge from his pantry.
“Let’s go,” Thorin orders, as soon as he has finished eating. Many of the others are still working on their meals. Bombur in particular seems to be savoring what he knows will be his last proper breakfast in a very long time, and Bilbo cannot blame him. They have always been kindred spirits when it comes to the art of eating.
Bilbo whirls around to face the king. Oh, honestly. He should have known that the companionable silence and light banter of the early morning would not last long. “I’m not leaving all these dishes for my gardener and his family. You can wait twenty minutes. It’s not even light out yet! Surely you don’t mean to travel in the dark.” He remembers that he and Thorin have only just met, and that he has already perhaps pushed things a little bit too far with the table-setting conversation. “Your Majesty.”
“Master Baggins has a point, Your Majesty,” says Dori, never one to tolerate rudeness.
“Aye,” Balin agrees, “That he does.”
Thorin does not look pleased. But then, he never looks pleased when he doesn’t get his way. It is something by which Bilbo refuses to be endeared, despite his inclinations to the contrary. “Fíli, Kíli, help Master Baggins with the dishes. Dwalin, you can carry their bags outside and start getting the ponies ready.”
“Do we both have to?” Kíli gives his uncle a big-eyed look, which Bilbo knows from experience is generally fairly effective in bending people to the prince’s will. He truly has a lion’s courage, trying a trick like that on his fuming uncle. Unfortunately, it does not work this morning.
“It will not take so long that way,” Thorin reasons through gritted teeth.
“Shouldn’t be too hard,” Fíli decides, assessing the state of the kitchen. “Twenty minutes.” He winks at Bilbo and flashes a winning smile. He, too, is taking control of the situation through facial expressions alone. Truly, Bilbo wonders if the lads learned this trick from their mother. They certainly didn’t pick it up from Thorin, who appears to be trying his best to set the tablecloth on fire with his mind.
“You have fifteen.” But that’ll be plenty, with three of them working, and Bilbo not caring quite so much about whether all the plates come out intact.
Bilbo gives a satisfied little huff and makes room by the sink for the princes to join him. That’s step one taken care of, then. Despite the perils ahead, at least the party was a smashing success. Bilbo is certain he’ll be able to look back on it fondly when he’s freezing his feet off, dripping wet from the rain and with sore legs from days of riding and walking, wondering why in Yavanna’s name he agreed to do this all over again.
Chapter 3: Sweets and Swords and Unkind Words
Notes:
Many thanks to everyone who read, commented, and left kudos this week! Here's another long chapter; enjoy!
Chapter Text
Thorin cannot wrap his mind around the Halfling. Never in all his years has he encountered a creature so confusing, so nonsensical, so utterly and entirely strange. Master Baggins is only a little thing, with large eyes, a narrow frame, and no shortage of roundness about his middle. He’s not bad to look at, Thorin supposes, if one has time to linger on such matters, which Thorin does not. He keeps his eyes resolutely forward, making a conscious effort at all times to stop them from wandering over to the Hobbit as the company trudges onward.
That has proven to be quite the feat over the course of their week on the road together. More than once, Thorin has caught Master Baggins with a book balanced between the ears of his pony. Does he fear nothing? There may not be many orcs in these parts, but there are plenty of other hazards deserving of one’s attention. The Hobbit always seems to know when it’s going to rain several hours in advance; twice now, he has removed his hood from his pack on a clear morning and been the only one spared the indignity of rifling through his belongings when the sky opened up. And that pack! Oh, by the Maker, that’s the worst thing of all.
Master Baggins has no weapons whatsoever in his possession, not even a knife, despite his claims about knowing his way around a sword. He does, however, carry some fifty monogrammed handkerchiefs, which he seems to have no qualms about distributing amongst the members of the company at the slightest provocation. He has no shoes to speak of, but during the first few days of their journey, Thorin watched the Halfling withdraw a glass butter dish, complete with a generous block of yellow butter, from the depths of that odd pack. Naturally, the butter was gone before they left the Shire, considering the force with which Master Baggins applied it to the crusty bread he’d also brought with him.Once, he cajoled Thorin into eating some sort of sweet bun with the excuse that Master Baggins and Bombur had already made “fine work” of the other seven rolls between them. Who in their right mind would bring eight sweet rolls on a quest?
It is evening now, and the party has made camp under the cover of a sturdy rock formation. Thorin has permitted a modest fire for cooking, though he does not like the idea of sending a smoke signal to any potential assailants. Now that they’ve had dinner, Master Baggins has produced a large bag of sweets and is in the process of showing the company how to roast the confections over an open flame.
Bofur, true to form, bypasses the careful cooking procedure demonstrated by the Halfling and sticks about six of the treats into the fire at once.“Quick, blow it out!” Master Baggins orders, laughing and clapping his hands, delighted by the performance on show as Bofur waves around the flaming stick. The Hobbit's luminous joy floats across the camp and slugs Thorin in the stomach. How can this little creature find pleasure in these unfamiliar wilds, teeming as they likely are with trolls and wolves and bandit-men?
Bofur does as instructed, then inhales the charred mess he has created. Such nonsense has no place on an errand like theirs, and all of Thorin’s companions should know as much by now. They are wasting time, and moreover,Master Baggins is wasting vital baggage space on a single evening’s entertainment. Why would he do this? “Not bad,” is Bofur’s verdict.
“I told you,” Master Baggins replies, his fond gaze shining on Bofur like the glowing sun, despite their short acquaintance. But Mahal made his children to live always underground, deep within mountains that shelter them from such brilliant light. It is not needed, and Thorin is not pleased that he’s responsible for the wellbeing of this ridiculous, easily-trusting, impractical little creature. “It’s even better if you do it properly.”
Kíli devours one of the confections and grins the way he did when he was small and Thorin showed him how to make nails in the forge. “What did you say these were called again, Mister Boggins?”
“Marshmallows,” the Hobbit replies. “They’re tricky enough to make, but worth it, don’t you think?”
Thorin watches as the Halfling catches sight of Fíli, who has been lingering behind the group, watching the proceedings unfold with palpable interest. There is not space for everyone around the fire, and Fíli has learned from Thorin’s example of self-deprivation. The lad would never rob one of their people of any joy for his own sake. He always serves others before himself, as well, though back in Erebor, such behavior from the Crown Prince would have been nothing short of scandalous. Still,selflessness is a good quality for a king to have, and Thorin is silently proud of his nephew.
“Here, Fíli, you should take this.” The Hobbit holds out the stick he’s using to roast the marshmallows. “I’m getting too old to spend so long in this position. Need to stretch my legs.”
It’s nothing more than a flimsy excuse. The Hobbit isn’t old at all. In fact, he’s probably decades younger than Fíli and Kíli, obvious maturity differences aside. Clearly, Fíli knows this. “Do Hobbits really age so quickly, Master Baggins? You can’t be over a hundred.”
“Oh,” Master Baggins begins, “Well, I suppose I’m only fifty, but don’t you know, lad, I feel old, just looking at you two young things hopping around.” Another excuse, surely. The Halfling is going to great lengths to look after Thorin’s sister-sons.
This is not right. They are Thorin’s responsibility, after all, and he does not appreciate the implicit insinuation that he is doing a poor job at it. The lads are fully grown and should not need to be entertained while undertaking a quest to claim their birthright. If he’d thought they needed to be plied with sweets and games around the fire, Thorin would have left them both at home. But Master Baggins has no shame about his blatant attempts to buy the affection of the princes. This is not the first time that Thorin has caught the Hobbit hovering around his sister-sons, checking on them or eliciting laughter with some inane comment or other. Thorin makes a mental note to think more of his own heirs.
“Hopping?” Kíli asks, apparently delighted by this odd verbiage.
“The sheer sight of your roughhousing makes my knees ache,” Master Baggins claims.
“You’re younger than I am,” Fíli declares. “But if you’re sick of roasting marshmallows, I’d be happy to take on the burden. Least I can do for such a venerable and respectable Hobbit.”
“Yes, well, that’d be much appreciated,” the Halfling says. “Come out of the shadows and have a go at it.”
Putting on an exaggerated expression of courtly duty which makes even Thorin chuckle, Fíli accepts the stick and settles onto the rock which Master Baggins has lately vacated. “If you’re really just sick of my brother, you could’ve said something.”
This earns him a well-deserved elbow to the gut. “Please,” says Kíli, “Mister Boggins loves me, and he loves spending time with me. I’ll have you know that I’m his favorite. Isn’t that right?”
“I’m just going to take a couple of these,” Master Baggins ignores the good-natured scuffle he has caused and uses some sort of biscuit (yet another useless item taking up vital space in the Halfling’s over-stuffed pack) to remove the marshmallows from the stick.
Before Thorin can pretend that he’s been doing anything other than keeping an eye on the Hobbit, Master Baggins makes his way across the camp, brandishing the roasted marshmallows in one hand and extending his other arm for balance. Thorin wills a bucket of cold water to fall over the fond forge burning in his chest. It would be much easier if he held no attachments to any members of his company, but he feels it is especially problematic to get close to the one he’s sending into the dragon’s lair. It’s best to keep his distance from the Halfling.
“Here.” Master Baggins places his burden in Thorin’s hands. “Eat up.”
Thorin only glares at him, which earns him a dramatic huff and an exasperated look from the Hobbit. Master Baggins has fine eyes, and Thorin finds that, despite himself, he enjoys teasing this strange creature, though it seems that the Hobbit prefers the company of Thorin’s sister-sons. But perhaps that is for the best.
Thorin has no right to these feelings, and he needs to do something about them before they cause him trouble. No amount of comeliness will protect the Hobbit from the sort of violent death that somebody so soft and foolish can expect out here on the road.
“I’ve had about fifty already; I’ll be sick if I eat these,” the Hobbit prattles on in response to Thorin’s silence. “And you haven’t had one yet.”
“You should not have wasted space in your pack on sweets.”
Master Baggins shrugs, establishing himself on the ground beside Thorin. “We’ll get more provisions when we stop in Rivendell, I’m sure. May as well enjoy ourselves until then. And there’s no knowing how long our packs will be with us, but I can’t imagine we’ll be lugging them all the way to the Lonely Mountain. Plenty of stops to make, even if everything goes according to plan.”
“We will not stop in Rivendell.” Thorin spits the name of the Elven city out like a curse. “Despite what the Wizard has told you. I won’t jeopardize this quest by putting any part of it in the hands of an Elf.”
“Of course not.” Master Baggins gives him a knowing smile, which perplexes Thorin to no end. What does this Burglar think that he knows? Something silly, no doubt. Thorin should not bother paying heed to the opinions of a creature who cannot even be trusted to pack prudently for a journey, no matter how fine he is of face. “Those are getting cold. They’re really better when they’ve just come out of the fire. Do you not like marshmallows?”
“I don’t know.” Why is Thorin even engaging with this? Perhaps he’s simply tired. He hasn’t had a proper night’s sleep in weeks, and that is a conservative estimate. “I’ve never had one.”
“Oh, you have to try them,” Master Baggins urges, “You may as well, since I’ve already wasted the pack space.” He looks very pleased with himself for this ridiculous logic.
To shut him up (and not because Thorin is at all curious about the confection that’s been placed in front of him. Certainly not because he has any interest in wasting his time this way) Thorin takes a bite. And… oh, Mahal below. That is good. He’s not going to say anything about it, of course. It would not be wise to encourage such behavior from the Burglar. If Thorin had his way, the marshmallows and the butter dish and the book would be left behind at the campsite and never seen again. Ridiculous wastes of space.
“Good, isn’t it?” Master Baggins sounds very smug, which Thorin does not appreciate.
It is a delicate business, eating the marshmallows without getting the gooey mess stuck in one’s beard. The faces of his sister-sons are evidence enough of that. “You would have been better served by packing a weapon,” he says, after finishing the morsel as neatly as possible.
The Hobbit has the audacity to wave him off. “I’ll find one eventually.” He gives Thorin a long look, which makes the king uncomfortable. He does not like the feeling of being sized up, especially not when it comes from the most confusing creature that he has ever laid eyes upon. “Well. I’ll leave you to your brooding, then.” And he bounces off, back towards the fire and the remainder of the company.
He is greeted with wide grins and excited chatter. Already, he’s endeared himself to the company with his foolishness. They do not seem to find it even remotely troubling that Master Baggins has no idea how to survive out in the wild. It’s strange. The Halfling clearly knows the basic skills that come with travel: he can build a fire with no trouble, he lays out his bedroll with expert precision, and he takes only a few moments to dig a latrine, which is better than can be said of the younger members of the company. And, yet, as far as the Wizard knows, Master Baggins has barely left his home in the past half-century. Where would he have learned such skills, and why could he not have also garnered a little bit of sense somehow in the process?
After only a moment or so, Balin comes to take the Hobbit’s place. Thorin is comforted by the presence of his old advisor. He allows himself to breathe a sigh of relief, though he has no idea what he’s so relieved about. “Do you remember,” Balin begins, “That stall in the market that sold those meringues?”
“Yes.” Thorin does remember. He and Frerin used to sneak away from their lessons to visit that stall, before the dragon came to Erebor. Dís was too little to liberate from the care of her minders at that time, but they often brought her something as well, if they could muster the funds and if they could remember. Balin usually caught them before they actually made it to the stall, although he tended to look the other way until the princes had their hands and pockets full of sweets. “But this is nothing like that.”
The flavor is different, and the meringues were served cold, not hot. Not to mention the fact that Thorin was a child then, a spoiled prince with all the time in the world to waste on the procurement and devouring of sweets. He glances reflexively toward his sister-sons, who have, naturally, discovered the value of flaming marshmallows as projectile weapons. Thorin watches as his lads take to bedeviling Bombur who, after one shocked intake of breath, opens his mouth to catch the confections being flung at him.
“No,” Balin exhales a heavy fog of smoke, his trusty pipe held loosely in his hand. He, too, has his eye on the chaos at the fireside. “I don’t suppose it would be.”
Bilbo seriously considers steering the company away from the trolls. It’ll be a terrible hassle to deal with them again, and now that he knows what’s coming, Bilbo isn’t particularly looking forward to the encounter. He also isn’t entirely certain that everything will pan out exactly the same way. What if Bilbo forgets some vital detail, does something a little bit differently, and sends the entire ordeal careening out into disaster? What if somebody has a different opinion of him this time around and decides not to help him, or to help him too early on in the proceedings, and the trolls are spurred by these changed actions into changed reactions? What if Thorin is too busy brooding about the contents of Bilbo’s pack to pick up on the Hobbit’s stalling strategy in the heat of the moment?
But the structural integrity of the entire adventure begins to crumble when Bilbo considers avoiding the incident with the trolls. If they never find the troll hoard, he won’t pick up Sting, and Thorin will never find Orcrist. Who knows what could happen to Thorin in the goblin tunnels if he isn’t armed the same way? And Bilbo is not confident that he’ll be able to fight the spiders off with any weapon other than Sting. It might handle differently, more slowly, perhaps, and he might not be quick enough to prevent the beasts from feasting upon any of his friends.
Better not to risk it, then. Bilbo huffs and puffs a little on his way over to Fíli and Kíli. The last thing he needs right now is to be coated head-to-toe in troll snot. Before the lads can begin to explain the situation, Bilbo sets down the bowls he was asked to bring them and holds up his hands. They’re in for a battle, so he can at least save the poor princes a few minutes of wheedling.
“Obviously, our ponies have been snatched up by trolls,” Bilbo decrees. “I can’t imagine what else could be lurking around here that might be stupid enough to try and pull of a heist like that, though I’m still baffled as to how you two managed to miss a fully-grown troll lumbering over and making off with two of our beasts. For the life of me, I cannot think what could possibly have been more important than keeping an eye on them, and I’ve had—“ He cuts himself off before he can say eighty years to mull this over.
“Still?” Fíli demands. Bilbo winces. How careless he has been, throwing words around as though they mean nothing. His nerves are no excuse when he might inadvertently reveal his secret with a careless phrase. “You’ve only known about it for half a minute!”
“You shouldn’t make fun of how Mister Boggins talks,” Kíli advises, “It’s not his fault he’s from a strange place with strange ways of speaking.” Oh, lovely. Now the entire company is going to think that the word still is used differently in the Shire than in every other Westron-speaking corner of the world.
“Will you two please focus?” Bilbo forces himself to abandon his linguistic fretting. He can set the record straight once Erebor is reclaimed. For now, he’ll allow Kíli’s (admittedly very charitable) explanation to stand.
“Right,” Fíli drawls. “Focusing.” He pats his breast pocket, which no doubt contains at least one weapon. Not that it’ll be much use against the trolls.
“Yes, okay.” Kíli makes a big show of straightening his back and standing at attention, though his grin gives him away.
They’re not taking this seriously. But then, why would they? For all they know, Bilbo is simply going to pop over, liberate the ponies, and lead them back with the trolls none the wiser. The boys have no reason to suspect that their Burglar is about to lead them into a trap.
He ignores the gnawing feeling in his stomach and presses forward. “No doubt that glow over there is coming from their fire,” Bilbo says, as though only just noticing the faint light in the distance. “I’m going to go over there and see what’s going on. If I don’t come back in, say, ten minutes, please come and help me.”
It occurs to him, as he’s creeping over to the fire around which the trolls are bickering, that this may not have been the wisest idea. Bilbo, in his exasperation, has already changed things. He really should have just let the lads tell him to screech like an owl and have it be their idea to send him off. Perhaps they won’t be so willing to intervene now that Bilbo was the one to propose the entire venture.
But he need not have worried. Just like last time, the entire company comes rushing forward, slashing at the trolls’ legs and feet, giving Bilbo the chance to slip away and begin untying the ponies. Then, of course, Bilbo is snatched up again, and stretched uncomfortably by the trolls. This time, Bilbo notes, Thorin curses under his breath in Khuzdul before dropping his weapon, though the life-and-death stakes of the moment prevent Bilbo from ruminating too much about that particular difference. Does this mean that Thorin is especially fond of him this time around, or especially infuriated? Maybe his opinion of his Burglar has been lowered by the Hobbit’s changed behavior.
Perhaps it wasn’t so wise of Bilbo to bring a book along. It’s just that he’s had that volume on his shelf forever, and he knows for a fact that he wasn’t going to read it otherwise, not in eighty years! Considering the relative monotony of the first few weeks of their journey, Bilbo felt it wouldn’t be such a bad idea to take his book with him, to distract him from the unpleasant thoughts that have been plaguing him since he landed in the garden at Bag End. But he can easily see how, to Thorin, it might look as though he does not understand the dangers present on the road. Bilbo understands them perfectly well; he just knows when to expect them and when he’d be better served by keeping himself out of his own mind.
Still, vanquishing the trolls proves just as simple the second time as it did the first. Easier, actually, now that he’s confident in the results. Bilbo employs the exact same stalling method, and contrary to his wildest fears, Thorin picks up on his tactics right away and discourages his company from arguing against Bilbo’s claims, just as he did the last time. Everything unfolds the same way, nearly verbatim. The trolls bicker for several minutes about the best way to kill and eat their captives, and then, of course, they turn to stone when Gandalf arrives and reveals the morning sun. It’s as cut and dry as it was when Bilbo put it in his book, though he will admit to downplaying his own role in the entire debacle. It felt cheap, then, to boast about his cleverness when his friends were nearly killed after fighting to defend him.
Naturally, Bilbo’s first act when the Wizard cuts him free of his sack is to go and assist those members of the company who were tied to a log rotating over the fire. Bilbo has always wondered about what compelled the trolls to do this; it seems like an awful lot of work. If they hadn’t wasted so much time divesting everybody of their weapons and then securing so many of the company to the pole, perhaps they would have come to a decision about what to do with their captives before the break of day. Still, everything worked out in the company’s favor, so Bilbo supposes that he shouldn’t borrow trouble.
“Could you help me out, lad?” Óin flags Bilbo down, clearly looking for an extra set of hands. “I’ve got to see to Bifur.”
Bilbo follows Óin’s gesture to see Bifur sitting on a rock with a very conspicuous hand clamped over what appears to be a cut on his arm. “How bad is it?” He asks, worried. He knows that some members of the company were wounded during their first fight with the trolls, but he can’t recall if Bifur took any damage to his arm.
Óin calls to Bifur in Khuzdul, and his interlocutor responds in kind. “Nothing so terrible, don’t you worry,” Óin assures Bilbo, “No bone showing at least, but there’s stitches needed and I don’t trust any hand but my own for that.”
“Of course,” Bilbo replies, raising his voice a touch to ensure that the healer can hear his next question. “What do you need?”
“Nori’s got a nasty burn,” Óin reports, “Just rub some of this on it and he’ll heal in no time. Not too much, now, or it’ll be more trouble than it’s worth. Then roll the bandage around, tight enough to stay but not enough to stop the blood flowing.”
“I’d be glad to,” Bilbo assures the healer, accepting the jar of salve and roll of bandages.
If Óin hears him, he doesn’t reply. Bilbo brings his newly-acquired medical supplies over to Nori, who is seated on a rock, attempting to lace his boots up one-handed. As promised, his left hand sports a truly nasty burn. Much worse than a sunburn, Bilbo would say, with blisters and all, but with the help of the salve, Nori will probably recover within a few days. Though it is a bit odd, considering nothing like this happened the first time around. Bilbo may not have been paying much attention back then, but he would’ve noticed if one of the company were trying to do everything one-handed. He would have helped.
“Óin sent me,” Bilbo reports.
Nori snorts at him. “Could’ve done it myself, you know.” He clearly resents the suspicion that the others harbor towards him, even if he does understand where it comes from. Nori has a reputation as a thief, after all.
Bilbo shrugs. “You’re welcome to, if you’d like, but for what it’s worth, I think I’m here more to help you wind the bandage than because Óin thinks you’re going to steal his salve.” Not that he knows this for certain, but it’s a nice thought, isn’t it?
“Go ahead, then,” Nori instructs, still fiddling with his laces.
Bilbo has never tied any kind of shoe before in his life. He’s never worn any kind of shoe before in his life. Rather than embarrassing himself by trying to fiddle with the laces, he waves Bofur over. “Can you help him?” He asks. “He’s wounded.”
“Aye, of course I’ll help,” Bofur says, settling down on the ground beside Nori and reaching for the boot laces. Bilbo probably could have done it, of course. He’s tied a bow before, after all. He just doesn’t want to be responsible for anybody’s laces coming undone during an inopportune moment, and he needs to be extra careful about this sudden departure from the events of his original adventure. “Shouldn’t we tell Dori?”
“Oh, Mahal’s anvil, no,” Nori groans. “He’ll lose his mind.”
“I don’t think there’s any reason to,” Bilbo decides, “He’ll find out soon enough, anyway. Let’s let Nori enjoy a few minutes of freedom at least before he starts getting smothered.” He opens the jar and begins spreading the salve on Nori’s wounded hand. “Do you want to tell me what happened?”
“I was roasting a marshmallow,” Nori reports.
Bilbo suddenly has about a million questions. He’s not even remotely surprised that Nori apparently secreted a marshmallow or two away when Bilbo was showing the company how to roast them. But that is the least of the Hobbit’s concerns right now. “In your hand?”
“Well, I didn’t have a stick on me, did I?”
“I’d have thrown you one, if my hands were free,” Bofur muses.
“So….” Bilbo shakes his head. “You managed to get your hand out of your bindings and to get ahold of the marshmallow that you already had… somewhere on your person… and… you stuck your hand into the fire… to roast it?”
Nori shrugs. “I figured if I was going to die, I may as well go out happy.”
Bilbo can’t begrudge him this at all. “That was downright Hobbit-y of you,” he decrees. That is to say that neither Bilbo himself nor any of his neighbors would turn down something sweet even in a time of crisis. He remembers with sudden clarity the vinegar pies his mother made during the Fell Winter to keep the family’s spirits up. That’s the same logic as Nori’s last-minute marshmallow roasting, all things considered.
“I think I roasted my hand more than the marshmallow,” Nori confides.
Before Bilbo can think of something to say, Thorin is stomping over to their huddle. “Master Baggins!” He calls. “Bofur, Nori, Glóin! Come and look at this.”
“Why us?” Bofur asks, apparently not intimidated at all by his visibly irritated king.
It does not escape Bilbo that Thorin did not invite him to participate in the inspection of the troll hoard on their first adventure. Obviously, something has changed to induce the King to include Bilbo instead of Dwalin. But it does make perfect sense, now that Bilbo thinks about it. He’s the resident Burglar, allegedly an expert in treasure. Glóin is an actual treasure expert, and it was wise of Thorin to include him as well. Nori, a professional thief, would no doubt be familiar with the tactics of other thieves and may be able to shed some light on unexpected hiding places. Bofur, on the other hand, has lots of mining experience, and would be instantly aware of any structural issues with the underground hoard. And now that Bilbo thinks about it, it really does make more sense to leave Dwalin to guard the rest of the group. They’ll have the Wizard with them in the cave, after all. Thorin clearly knows his people, and he knows how to deploy them for best results.
He does not, however, know a thing about diplomacy. He doesn’t even answer Bofur’s question, just storms off with a vague gesture over his shoulder. “Come along!” He barks.
Bilbo rolls his eyes. “I suppose we’d better go before he starts getting impatient.” This burst of sarcasm earns him a couple of appreciative snorts.
“I suppose we should,” Bofur agrees, patting Nori’s recently-tied boot with exaggerated affection. It earns him a kick in the hand that might’ve broken Bilbo’s bones, had it been aimed in his direction.
By far, the worst aspect of the troll hoard is the overpowering smell. Bilbo did not get close enough last time to experience it, and some part of him wishes that Thorin had not invited him to join their little party this time. Based on the odor alone, Bilbo has to imagine that the trolls have been using this place to store their garbage as well as their treasure. He would not be surprised to learn that it has also served them as an outhouse.
“Oh, what’s that stench?” Nori demands, making a futile attempt to waft it away from him.
“It’s a troll hoard,” Gandalf replies imperiously, as if every member of the company should be familiar with the particulars of such locations. Sometimes, it feels as though the Wizard forgets that not everyone has lived a thousand lifetimes and seen every sight that Middle Earth has to offer. “Be careful what you touch.”
Thorin walks behind the Wizard, sword raised, as though he thinks a fourth troll might be lurking somewhere in this cave. If that is the case, Bilbo isn’t sure what a single broadsword could do against such a foe, but he appreciates the sight nevertheless. It’s embarrassing, to say the least, but Bilbo could stare at Thorin for hours, especially when he’s got his sword raised and that warlike expression on his handsome face. It’s almost enough to make up for the assault on the Hobbit’s poor nose.
“You’d think the trolls could do a little tidying up from time to time,” Bilbo grumbles. He doesn’t know why he’s surprised. Like the goblins, Smaug, and Gollum, the trolls do not seem to take much pride in their home. Even knowing all that he does about the world, it makes Bilbo sniff distastefully. And then, of course, he is assaulted once more by the terrible smell.
“They are trolls,” Thorin reasons. “They do not care whether they live in splendor or in filth.”
“There’s no ventilation system,” Glóin observes, studying the walls as though he expects to find a grate which might free them from their peril upon being turned.
“Why would there be?” Gandalf, apparently, sees the obvious segue into a conversation on Dwarven architecture, and clearly, he is not interested. “As I said, this is a troll hoard.”
Bilbo might laugh, were he not too busy coughing and gagging. The smell is truly terrible, but knowing what waits for them here, Bilbo forges ahead. He’s got to have Sting, and Thorin has got to have Orcrist. Who knows what Glamdring will do for Gandalf in the many long years that he bears it? And besides, this is hardly the worst smell that they’ll encounter on this journey. The Goblin tunnels come to mind again, and Gollum’s little pool, and the place where the spiders dump the remains of their victims. The battlefield might not be as bad as the troll hoard, but that’s only because the fighting won’t take place in an enclosed space. And all that dragon dung in Erebor…
Bofur has already discovered a mid-sized wooden chest overflowing with golden coins. “Seems a shame just to leave it lying around,” he muses, examining his find with interest. “Anyone could take it.”
“Agreed,” says Glóin. “Nori, get a shovel.”
Naturally, Nori seems very glad indeed of the excuse to leave the troll hoard for a moment, and he bounds off, injured hand forgotten. Bilbo watches him go with no small degree of envy, but nobody would’ve asked the Hobbit to fetch any of their heavy metal shovels. Even if he could carry it, he’d be slow in bringing it over. Still, he wouldn’t mind the fresh air.
“These swords were not made by any troll.” Thorin’s low voice carries across the cave, and Bilbo shudders despite himself.
This is a propitious moment. It’s important. And Bilbo should feel grateful that he gets to witness it this time, that Thorin has, for whatever reason, chosen him to participate in this excursion. Instead, he feels his heart drop into his stomach at the thought of Orcrist buried by Thorin’s side beneath the Mountain. The king now holds the blade that he will take with him to the halls of his Maker.
Gandalf approaches and accepts the second sword, which Thorin holds out to him. “Nor were they made by any smith among men,” the Wizard breathes. “These were worked in Gondolin by the High Elves of the First Age.” Bilbo must stifle his laughter as Thorin makes to put the sword back where he found it. Does he truly hate Elves that much? What a silly question. Of course he does. “You could not wish for a finer blade,” Gandalf adds.
But something else has caught Thorin’s eye. He keeps Orcrist close, but peers into the cache whence it came. “What’s this?”
Sting. It is Sting. Bilbo would know his little sword anywhere, even just by its dusty hilt. “An Elven dagger, I suspect,” Gandalf states the obvious.
Thorin studies the small, sleek weapon, which has saved Bilbo’s life on countless occasions. Its scabbard must still be somewhere in the crate. The blade is in alright condition, considering, but it wants cleaning and polishing. Maybe a little sharpening as well, though Bilbo certainly would not have made such considerations on his first adventure.
“I shall give this to my sister-son,” Thorin decides, “Fíli is fond of knives and will enjoy fighting with one so well-made.”
Well, that’s unexpected. “Or,” Bilbo suggests, before he can think better of it, “Instead of giving it to the most heavily-armed creature between here and the Gap of Rohan,” he pauses to accommodate Bofur’s chuckle and Glóin’s knowing snort, “You could give it to the only member of your company without a sword to speak of.”
“This is not a sword,” Thorin argues.
“Perhaps not for a giant such as yourself,” Bilbo concedes, plucking the short sword out of the king’s hands. It is not lost on Bilbo that Thorin is significantly stronger than he is; he would not have been able to take the blade if the king did not will it, but take it he has. He tries a few stilted jabs at the air off to his side, relishing the familiar feeling of having Sting in hand. “But it will suit me just fine. I shall call it Sting, I think.” The last time, Bilbo didn’t name his sword until the debacle with the spiders, but why wait?
“The blade is sharp,” Thorin counsels, “Do not hurt yourself.”
“Yes, I’m aware that swords can cut people. Thank you for pointing that out.” Bilbo is really pressing his luck, but honestly!
“Must you test my patience every time the opportunity presents itself?” Thorin murmurs in a tone of voice that confuses Bilbo to no end.
He reminds himself that he’s supposed to be annoyed with the king for attempting to give away Bilbo’s sword. “Funny. I could ask you the same thing.” The verbal sparring is almost enough to melt the icy ache that has lately settled deep within Bilbo’s chest. Almost.
“Take your knife, then,” Thorin decides eventually, as though Bilbo has not already taken it. “Perhaps you can use it for peeling potatoes.” This is an insult, Bilbo knows. In any Dwarven kingdom, the insinuation that someone might use a tool for anything other than its intended purpose would be grounds for a physical confrontation.
But Bilbo is a Hobbit of the Shire, and his people have their own way of handling such slights. “Oh, please tell me you don’t actually think this would work for that,” Bilbo protests. “Surely you must know that I know my way around a kitchen. Unlike a certain monarch I might mention.”
“That may be,” Thorin replies coolly, “But I fail to see what other use you might find for any blade.”
Bilbo sputters for a moment before collecting himself enough to speak. He should be infuriated, he knows, but instead, he is perplexed. Is Thorin actually trying to hurt him or are they merely bickering for the sport of it? The insults he’s been offered are pointed enough, but he’s been giving quite as good as he gets, and neither one of them has backed down as of yet. “In case you hadn’t noticed, I’m on the same dangerous quest as all the rest of you. Don’t you think I should be armed?”
Thorin blinks at Bilbo, Orcrist hanging forgotten in a limp grip by his side. “You should have been armed when you left your… Hobbit den.”
“The word you’re looking for is smial.” He just can’t stop pressing his luck. He doesn’t know what he’s expecting. It’s as though the moment he starts arguing with Thorin, the rest of the world melts away, a feeling Bilbo can’t stop chasing, despite his better judgment.
“Very well,” says Thorin. He looks as though there might be more than this on his mind, but if there is, he does not give it voice.
“I hope it is,” Bilbo replies, more to fill the sudden permeating silence than for any other reason.
Apparently, His Majesty has had enough of this conversation. It certainly is awkward, what with their audience staring on and the smell of the troll hoard hanging over their heads. “Let’s get out of this foul place,” Thorin declares, turning on his heel and storming out of the cave. Typical. “Come on, let’s go.” Everyone follows him out of the cave, leaving Bilbo alone with Sting and the buried treasure in the stinking hoard.
A few harrowing hours later, the company is welcomed in the House of Elrond. They are all exhausted after being chased so far by the band of orcs, and many of them are somewhat disgruntled at what they view as underhanded machination on Gandalf’s part. But from Bilbo’s perspective, there was nowhere else they could have gone. They’ll need Elrond’s help with the moon runes, after all, and it will be good to restock their provisions, not to mention all that they’re about to learn regarding their new weapons. They enjoy a very hectic meal, during which every member of the company manages to cause his own particular kind of chaos. Bilbo will admit that it takes all of his restraint to keep from spoiling the future for everyone when they tease Kíli about his alleged romantic interest in Elves. Oh, if only they knew!
After dinner, of course, Gandalf manages to talk Thorin into allowing Elrond to look at the map, a process only slightly more perilous than pulling teeth from a live warg. Bilbo lingers in the room, trying to look surprised at each unfolding development and paying more attention to the rhapsodized expression on Thorin’s face than to the glowing runes which have monopolized the king’s attention. After all of that excitement, Bilbo is more than ready for a good night’s sleep.
Last time, he accepted the bedroom that the Elves offered to him, but now, he joins the rest of the company at their camp in the corridor. None of them seem to trust the Elves very much, but Thorin’s brusqueness stands out even among the less-than-polite reactions of his companions. It strikes Bilbo as more than a little unfair, considering that Elrond is not by any means in league with Thranduil, but Thorin has no way of knowing that. Bilbo understands that the king probably would not trust anybody offering his people any kind of shelter after the horrors that he has endured. He doesn’t even trust Bilbo, of all people, and it does seem a bit too good to be true for Elrond to happily shell out fifteen bedrooms for the shelter of a company that led a band of orcs into his lands, intentionally or otherwise.
“Where did you get those?” Thorin demands when Bilbo returns to the hallway that the company has taken over.
If Bilbo didn’t have three plump pillows under each arm, which is no small feat for somebody of his size, he might shrug. “From one of the bedrooms,” he explains, “I did ask Lord Elrond first.” Bilbo doesn’t know why it matters to him, but for some reason, he doesn’t want his friends to think that he’s the sort to just pilfer somebody’s belongings without asking.
Which feels a little ridiculous, because he has been hired as an expert Burglar. They’re expecting him to have experience with pilfering things, and strictly speaking, he does. Actually, Bilbo has wondered many times over the years why Thorin didn’t just ask Nori to be his Burglar and have done with it. Perhaps, it was because Gandalf thought that Smaug’s lack of knowledge of Hobbits would protect Bilbo from the dragon in some way, though he can’t see why. The dragon wouldn’t need to be familiar with Bilbo’s scent to set him on fire or gobble him up.
“I thought you’d produced them from that magic pack of yours,” Thorin says. It takes Bilbo a moment to realize that he’s making a joke.This is certainly a new development. It never would have happened the first time around, that’s for certain, not this early on. Maybe in Beorn’s hall, or after they washed up in Lake-town, but never in Rivendell.
Still, here they are at the Last Homely House, and here is Thorin, ostensibly trying to make Bilbo laugh. Maybe Thorin takes him less seriously than he did on the original adventure, on account of the reading and the snack distribution. Or maybe, now that Bilbo is far less fussy and somewhat more prepared for travel through the wilderness, Thorin has decided that he likes his Hobbit much earlier in the proceedings. Of course, it may also have something to do with the fact that Bilbo is not actively avoiding him this time around. On the first adventure, he’d all but hidden from Thorin, refusing to meet his eyes and speaking to him only when forced to do so by the situation. All that time he wasted! All those nights when they were both awake and could have spoken but did not! All those hours of silence which Bilbo could never get back, in the end, which haunted him until the end of his days.
“No,” Bilbo smiles. Sometimes it’s like a knife in his side, being around Thorin, but he still smiles. He’s on a quest much more momentous than the one he left for eighty years ago, with much more responsibility, but he can’t help but grin at the stubborn old king. He will not fail Thorin this time. “There wouldn’t have been much space, what with all those cinnamon buns. Thank you again for helping me take care of them.”
“I still have no idea why you felt it was necessary to drag those along. You could have brought a sword instead, if you’re so skilled with one.”
Unfortunately, Bilbo did not have much of a chance to prove himself on that score during their latest confrontation with the orcs. In truth, he never came to blows with any of them, preoccupied as he was with running away and trying to continue breathing while his friends were in such serious danger. Try as he might, he could not stop remembering the Battle of the Five Armies. He was so distracted by the foes of his memory that, on one occasion, Dwalin was forced to physically carry him away from the foes presently hunting them. All in all, it was not Bilbo’s best moment.
But Thorin does not say more about it. He leaves the little teasing barb hanging in the air, eying Bilbo as he waits for a response. Very well, then. If he’d like to engage in a little bit of back and forth rather than flaying Bilbo from crown to toe for his uselessness in battle, the Hobbit isn’t going to complain.
“I have a sword,” Bilbo points out, patting Sting’s handle. He’d missed the little dagger very much when it was with Frodo, glad as he may have been at the knowledge that his nephew bore an Elven blade. “Despite your best efforts to the contrary.”
“You did not have it when we set out,” Thorin recounts. “You could not have expected to stumble upon a troll-hoard as we did.”
Bilbo can’t help but tease him a little bit. “Ah, but if I’d packed a sword, I would never have had room for the cinnamon rolls. Or the bread, or the butter, let alone the butter knives.” In all honesty, Bilbo had only brought those along because he is quite fond of them, and would rather not have them going to Lobelia and Otho any time soon. He’d prefer to see them in the goblin tunnels.
“Or your book.” Thorin is clearly amused, though he is also clearly trying very hard to hide this fact. So he does like Bilbo then, or at least, he finds him funny. But Bilbo already knows that this changes nothing, not for Thorin Oakenshield. Whether he likes the Hobbit or not, he won’t get close to anyone if he can help it.
“Or my book,” Bilbo agrees, “I’m almost done with it now.”
In truth, the novel has proved to be something of a disappointment. Prior to his travels, Bilbo often indulged in adventure stories, and this one was no exception. A brave knight slaying a dragon to protect a princess, classic stuff. Only the dragon wasn’t written very well and the princess had no personality, and the knight was just as boring but exceptionally long-winded, always yapping at every character cursed to share a scene with him. If he could do this all over again (which Bilbo sincerely hopes he won’t have to) he would probably bring an old standby, a volume of poetry or a story he knew he would enjoy. Although, his irritation at the characters in his book and the way it was written has been a welcome distraction from the more troubling reminders he’s been given on this journey.
“Master Baggins!” Kíli calls to him from the floor, as though summoned by Bilbo’s wandering thoughts. It is physically painful for Bilbo to see the lad reclining on the ground like that. It reminds him far too much of Ravenhill, even if Kíli is grinning from ear to ear, even with no Elf maiden weeping over him this time. “Throw me one of those?”
Ah, the pillows. “I’ll not be throwing anything in Lord Elrond’s hall,” Bilbo protests, walking over to Kíli and handing him a pillow. “And neither will you.” He knows the prince well enough, after all, to know what the next words out of his mouth will be. True to form, Kíli pouts at him with perfectly-polished puppy-dog eyes.
“Good luck with that,” Nori snorts.
“Is that a candelabra in your pocket?” Bilbo demands of the thief. Honestly, what’s he even planning to do with that? Perhaps he only wants to prove that he can steal the light fixtures from right under Elrond’s nose if he so chooses.
“I think he’s just happy to see you,” says Bofur, never one to miss an opening for a joke.
For a moment, Bilbo attempts to restrain his laughter. But why bother? These are his friends, and he has missed him very much, and there is no point in hiding his amusement from them. Not when he’s already doing so very much to protect them from his grief. So he laughs out loud, and continues distributing pillows, and successfully prevents three separate pillow fights from breaking out in his presence. They’ll be on again as soon as he turns his back, but at least there’ll be peace when he’s around.
“I’m going back for more of these,” Bilbo announces, gesturing at the pillow he’s just handed to Dori. Mother hen that he is, Dori has already started fluffing it and seems to be eying the space between his youngest brother’s back and the cool stone wall as a potential place to slide the pillow. “Six won’t be enough for all of us, and believe me, these Elves have no shortage.”
Thorin mutters something under his breath about how that doesn’t surprise him, an utterance which Bilbo pointedly ignores as he retreats back down the corridor.
It doesn’t take long for Bilbo to rediscover his long-standing love of Rivendell. This place is truly beautiful: every corner is perfectly clean, scrubbed and shined and dusted by unseen hands or magical forces on a daily basis. Nearly every comfort imaginable is available to the company, from books to cakes to scenery, although meat seems to be in short supply. Unlike last time, Fíli and Kíli stick to Bilbo’s sides, though he has no clue why. Perhaps they think they’ll be getting more marshmallows, or perhaps they’re simply more comfortable with him now that he’s indulged them by going along with a few of their antics. Of course, there is also the possibility that Thorin has ordered his nephews to keep an eye on the Hobbit. If so, Bilbo is impressed by Kíli’s ability to obscure that particular secret, though such comportment is no surprise coming from Fíli. Bilbo always knew there was much more to that lad than meets the eye.
“This harp music isn’t bad,” Kíli observes as they pass a huddle of Elven musicians. “Though I think Uncle Thorin is more skilled.”
“He brought his harp, you know,” Fíli points out, “I’ve been lugging it along with my fiddle.”
“And all forty-thousand of your weapons,” Bilbo grumbles. Truly, Fíli’s poor pony has been bearing an arsenal that would outfit the entire company twice over in a pinch. Actually, Bilbo wouldn’t be surprised if the prince had enough knives for everybody strapped to his person at this moment. And Thorin wanted to give him Sting as well?
“Well, yes,” Fíli admits. “But I had to pack extra to share with the people who didn’t bring any.”
“That was exactly my logic with the food,” Bilbo quips. Honestly, none of his companions seemed to even consider, when they set out from the Blue Mountains, that they would need to eat something on the journey. None of their foodstuffs were very nutritious the first time around, and all were severely lacking in the flavor department, despite Bombur’s best efforts.
“Maybe we can talk him into playing something with us at dinner tonight,” Kíli is as single-minded as his uncle, though evidently he’s much more optimistic. “He’s very pleased with Bofur for all that ruckus he caused yesterday evening, though of course he can’t say anything. It wouldn’t be very kingly of him.”
Bilbo shakes his head. “When I taught Bofur that little song, I didn’t think he was going to start belting it at the top of his lungs on Elrond’s table.” At least, he didn’t expect that turn of events when first he lived it. This time, however, Bilbo knew exactly what he was doing when he traded songs with Bofur.
“You’re part of the company now.” Fíli pats Bilbo on the shoulder with surprising restraint, a fine approximation of the sorts of gestures they saw exchanged between Hobbits as they traversed the Shire. The prince will make a fine diplomat when he’s older. If he’s ever older. “He was trying to include you.”
Bilbo shakes his head. He needs to stop thinking this way. Rumination will change nothing. He always will have lived through the deaths of his friends, but if he can make a solid plan, he’ll at least be able to help them on this timeline. He should focus on what he can do to put things right, and not what happened because he was too slow scrambling up Ravenhill. And speaking of…
“Well,” he says, fighting irrational tears. “I’m off to the library, then. Care to join me?”
“Absolutely not.” Kíli claps him on the shoulder with no small amount of force. Unlike his brother, he does not seem to have picked up yet on the fact that Hobbits are smaller and more fragile than the Dwarven warriors with whom he is accustomed to roughhousing. “Have fun with your books, though, Mister Boggins. See you at supper!”
“That you will,” Bilbo mutters, darting into the library before the lad can tempt him away from his quest with the promise of food.
Bilbo has a job to do, after all. He won’t get much outside help when it comes to altering the fates of his friends; rerouting the outcome of the Battle of the Five Armies is entirely Bilbo’s affair. Thankfully, he’s sure it can be done if only he changes a few things, if he’s faster, if he thinks on his feet, if he takes advantage of his foreknowledge and, most difficult of all, convinces Thorin, Dwalin, and the lads to listen to him. But the fifth step of his quest poses a much greater challenge.
Bilbo was present at the council here in Rivendell a few years ago. Or, he will be present at the council, several decades from now. Or, he was present at it, several decades in the future, but he will not be there again, because it will not take place, because, hopefully, by that point on this timeline Bilbo will have already destroyed the ring. Goodness, but this time-travel business is confusing!
Regardless, Bilbo has never been daunted by the prospect of a bit of research. Elrond’s library is grand: extensive, tidy, and well-organized. The shelves are labeled by subject and the books are alphabetized within their subheadings. Bilbo catches sight of three librarians, all of whom are hard at work. This is one of Bilbo’s favorite places to visit in Rivendell, and where he spent much of his time while waiting for Frodo to return from his own quest.
Unfortunately, the last time Bilbo was here, he did not think to do any serious research on the Rings of Power. He saw no point in it, considering that Frodo was already off and away. Bilbo was bogged down by his guilt, which still affects him, and his shame, and his anger, and his fear. Since he’d been told in no uncertain terms that he could do nothing to help Frodo but give up his mithril shirt and Elven blade, Bilbo had turned to escapism, reading novels and poetry and memoirs about happy people who had lived in better times.
He does not even know where to look. Bilbo scans the shelves, searching amongst the jewelry craft guides and the histories of Middle Earth, but after more than an hour of this, he is unsuccessful. He checks a few less-intuitive locations, but finds nothing there, either. There is nothing, not a single volume in this entire library, that appears to be about the Rings of Power. Of course, just because a book is not explicitly about the Rings of Power does not mean that it will not make any mention of them.
So Bilbo spends another several hours paging through histories of Middle Earth, searching in vain for anything that might help. He finds mentions of the Rings, yes, but nothing that will actually be useful to his errand. He knows already how many Rings were made, how they functioned and what happened to their bearers. He knows more than the historians seem to about where the Rings all ended up, and none of this information is remotely helpful to him, anyway.
Bilbo needs to know how to destroy a Ring of Power. He needs to know how to destroy the One Ring. He needs to know if there is any way to do that, other than by taking it to Mount Doom, but of course, he has forgotten the details given by Lord Elrond at the council. He didn’t bother to memorize the details, his logic at the time being that it was Frodo’s tale to tell, and that the lad would tell it much better than Bilbo ever could.
He is shaken from his perusal of yet another useless history by the clearing of a throat. “Oh!” Bilbo exclaims. “Hello, Dori.”
“Have you seen my brother by any chance, Master Baggins?” Dori inquires, polite as usually.
Bilbo grits his teeth. “Which one?” The thought of Ori loose in the library is much less concerning to the Hobbit than the idea that Nori might be wandering around unattended. He’s the type to make mischief when bored, as Bilbo knows very well.
“Ori came to look at books some hours ago.” Well, that’s a relief, then.
“It seems I didn’t even notice,” Bilbo chuckles nervously. He was so caught up in his research that he would not have noticed if the Valar themselves all filed in and formed a circle around his table.
“I wouldn’t be surprised if he didn’t notice you, either,” Dori replies, and he’s probably correct. Ori is a scholar, after all, and would not be able to resist the pull of the library any more than Bilbo has.
“I’ll help you look for him,” Bilbo decides, shutting his latest volume. His eyes are beginning to get tired, and it’s clear that he’s not going to find much of anything here. Wherever Elrond keeps his literature on the Rings of Power, there’s nothing to be discovered on that score in his public library. “And then we can all have supper. It’s about that time, isn’t it?”
The Elves, naturally, do not serve dinner, let alone tea, elevensies, or second breakfast, so the meal that they call supper comes several hours earlier than its equivalent in the Shire. But Bilbo has gotten used to that, after two decades living in Rivendell.
“Mmm,” Dori agrees, and once more, Bilbo is distracted by a secondary task.
After they find Ori, they head to the dining hall, passing the entrance to a corridor which Bilbo has walked many times before. Out the corner of his eye, he sees Elrond, bent in concentration over a broken blade on a dais. He is speaking, his voice too low for Bilbo to hear at this distance. Here is yet another scene that Bilbo was shown by Lady Galadriel.
He watches, rapt, as a small, dark-haired creature steps into view, getting closer to the sword that is his birthright, his face a comical mirror of Elrond’s stern expression. Bilbo finds himself moving forward, though he does not know what he might say to young Aragorn. This child is decades away from becoming the Man that Bilbo once knew, the reluctant monarch who shocked his people by bowing publicly to four perplexed Hobbits.
“Come on, Bilbo, I’m starving.” Ori steers him bodily away from the corridor, and a good thing, too. Who knows how the future could change if Bilbo interfered with the destiny of the long-lost King of Gondor? “Maybe they’ll have some real food on offer today.”
Bilbo winces. In his twenty years staying with Elrond, he was never served anything very different from the meal that they received last night. Breakfast and luncheon weren’t too different, either, but perhaps Ori was holding out hope for suppertime. “I’m afraid you may need to get used to greens as long as we’re here, Ori. I doubt the fare will change any time soon.”
Bilbo waits for Lord Elrond at the same overlook where they had their discussion last time, around what he thinks is the same time. He underestimated, when he made his (admittedly very loose) plan, how difficult it would be to place himself in the exact same location he once occupied at the exact same moment. The more circumstances and relationships depart from the way they were on his first adventure, the more trouble it is to try and figure out what should be happening and to drag himself away from what is happening in order to endure it.
But this is easy. The Elf Lord must be hoping to speak to Bilbo. He knows, of course, what quest the company embarks upon, and though he may have been willing to help with the moon runes, he is certainly opposed to the undertaking. And he wants to talk the Hobbit out of it, because he is a kind Elf who takes no joy in sending any creatures off to their deaths. Elrond knows, of course, that Thorin and his company would never listen to him, but he must think that Bilbo, by virtue of his being a Hobbit, is disconnected enough from the rest of them that he might be swayed.
Unfortunately for Elrond, that is not the case this time. “You won’t talk me out of this, Lord Elrond. I’m going on the quest.”
Elrond sidles up beside him, tall and ethereal. Bilbo must remind himself that at the moment, they are not old friends but complete strangers. “You are certain, then.”
“I’ve just said that I am.” Bilbo does not appreciate this prodding. Elrond is only trying to puzzle out what to make of him, he knows. There haven’t been Hobbits in Rivendell in many an age, if there ever were any, and Elrond’s limited dealings with Shire folk won’t have prepared him for Bilbo Baggins. That brings a smile to the Hobbit’s face, if nothing else. “But I did have… another question.”
Bilbo really wanted to avoid doing this. He knows that it’s going to raise suspicion, that Elrond will be clued into things that he should not know for many years. But then, if all goes according to plan, it won’t matter whether Elrond knows or not. And in order for Bilbo to formulate a plot, he’ll need more information than he has at present. If only the Lady of Lorien had allowed him to take his book back with him! Then he could simply have consulted Frodo’s notes on the council and had done with it.
But nothing is ever that easy. If it were, Bilbo would simply have invited all of his friends to come live with him in Hobbiton, Lonely Mountain be damned. This is a risk that he is willing to take.
“What kind of question?” Elrond sounds amused. Perhaps he thinks he knows what Bilbo is going to ask.
“I was wondering,” Bilbo begins, “About the Rings of Power. I did look in your library, but I’m afraid I didn’t find anything. Perhaps I was searching in the wrong place.”
“Some knowledge is better left away from prying eyes and wandering hands,” Elrond intones, ever cryptic. Oh, honestly. Bilbo never should have taken any counsel from Elves, let alone repeated his adventure at the behest of one! “But what is it that you want to know?”
“I was wondering how one might… destroy one.” Better to just say it flat out. “A Ring of Power, that is.”
Ideally, Bilbo would like to ask about the One Ring in particular, but that would raise too many questions. Elrond might want to know what Bilbo knows already, at which point, Bilbo would be forced to hedge around the fact that he knows far too much. Also, it is possible that Elrond might leap to the wrong conclusions. He already does not trust Thorin, after all, and to be completely honest, the thought of the One Ring in the hands of Thrain’s son is a harrowing one, even for Bilbo. He might be forced to tell the truth, which would not do at all. Elrond would want to interfere, and who knows who else he might inform? And if all this knowledge is truly meant to be kept secret, it is possible that Elrond might simply refuse to answer Bilbo’s questions at all.
“Ah.” Elrond stares out at his city, eyes unreadable. “Have you come into possession of a Ring of Power, Mister Baggins?”
“Me?” Bilbo forces a laugh. He’s very good at this. He’s been dealing with nosy relations all his life. He can put on a fine show if he sets his mind to it, and Elrond doesn’t even know him yet! “No, no, of course not. It’s just intellectual curiosity! I’m interested in artifacts. Like Thorin’s sword.” Bilbo finds himself stepping back a little from the edge as the blood rushes to his face. Oh, yes, Bilbo Baggins, you are interested in that, aren’t you? “Not… well, but…“
Elrond laughs. “You wish to impress your new friends with your knowledge of treasure? Of the history of their people?”
Oh, thank the Valar for the Elven tendency to underestimate all other peoples. Bilbo is saved. Elrond does not yet see the full picture, though, when things begin to change, he almost certainly shall. Hopefully he won’t be too upset about Bilbo’s mild deception. As wise as he is, the Elf Lord will surely understand that this was for the best. “Yes, yes exactly. That’s exactly it.”
“It is not easy to unmake a Ring of Power,” Elrond informs him, “The best way is to throw the ring back into the fires whence it was forged.” He does not elaborate on the location of these fires. He likely does not want to scare Bilbo, and since the Elf Lord believes that he is only satisfying an intellectual curiosity, it’s not as though Bilbo can press further. If it is all hypothetical, it should not matter that Mount Doom is deep inside Mordor. “Though you must be most interested in the Dwarven rings.”
“Yes,” Bilbo manages. No. But he cannot ask about the One Ring. He wonders, with a rising sense of dread, if the ring holds influence over him even now, if it is stopping him from speaking up in an attempt at self-preservation. But no, he assures himself, that is ridiculous. Bilbo would know it if the ring were working on him. He would recognize its presence in his head, would he not? And he does not even bear the thing! He has never even seen it yet! Even such a powerful object as the One Ring surely cannot have such reach. “Yes, I am. Most interested in those.”
Elrond chuckles. “I have watched you with the princes. They are very fond of you.” For all of Thorin’s grumbling about disrespectful Elves, Elrond clearly acknowledges the status of Erebor’s deposed royal family.
“And I am fond of them,” Bilbo replies. He does not know what Elrond is implying here, or how his friendships with Fíli and Kíli are at all relevant to the Rings of Power. “Lord Elrond, the company… well, they are fond of telling stories, around the fire. I’d like some of my own to contribute.”
“Do your own people not have stories?” Elrond studies him with ancient eyes and a mind as sharp as steel.
“Not stories that would impress warriors such as… the ones I travel with,” Bilbo replies carefully. If he did not know Elrond so well, Bilbo would imagine that he was being tested. But the Elf Lord is only trying to make friends.
“You mean that you do not believe your stories are fit to impress a king.” Ah. Well. That’s out in the open, then.
Bilbo blushes. He knows he was not this obvious the last time around. But then, Bilbo is the one who cannot take his eyes off of Thorin, cannot stop looking to make certain that his king is safe. Perhaps Elrond has picked up on Bilbo’s grief and misinterpreted it in a way that makes sense in context. Bilbo supposes he would do the same, in the Elf Lord’s position.
“I suppose that is what I mean, yes.” At least his blushing and fidgeting are advantageous in the present conversation.
“There were seven rings made for the Dwarven Lords,” Elrond explains, “Most are missing.” Yes, because the enemy probably has them already. Bilbo vaguely remembers something about this being said at the council here in Rivendell, all those years ago. “But at least two were destroyed by dragon fire long ago.”
“Dragon fire,” Bilbo echoes. He hadn’t thought of it before. “Dragon fire is effective against the Rings of Power?” Of course it is! Of course it would be! And it explains perfectly why the Valar would trouble themselves with Bilbo and his adventure, why he’d be sent back to do it again. He’s already going to stumble across the One Ring, and he’ll be taking it directly to the stronghold of an ancient and powerful dragon. It feels almost preordained, and Bilbo wonders if he isn’t very foolish for not thinking of it before.
“Oh, yes,” Elrond assures him, “Though it is a dangerous method.”
“Not more dangerous than hunting down some fire-mountain in a far away land and climbing to the top of it,” Bilbo reasons. He cannot keep the bitterness from his tone. Frodo should not have had to endure that. If only Bilbo had been wiser, if only he had been less easily swayed by the malice of the ring. “Let alone actually going inside.”
Bilbo is here to put things right, and he cannot stand around feeling sorry for himself. He does not wish to travel to Mordor and will do everything in his power to avoid it, but if he had to, then he would. Still, if this dragon fire method pans out, Bilbo will not need to be diverted from his adventure at all. He’ll have to rearrange things, of course, and come up with a few new plans after the ring is gone, but he was counting on that, anyway.
“No, no more dangerous than that.” Thankfully, Elrond misinterprets Bilbo’s utterance as sarcasm. Which is quite fair, considering Bilbo’s typical modes of interaction. Much of what he says is quite sarcastic, and Elrond does not know him well enough to tell the difference.
“Thank you, Lord Elrond. This will be a great help.” It’s true enough, isn’t it? At least Bilbo knows the sort of legs he stands on. He’ll leave Rivendell with the seed of a plan, and that seed will sprout and flower by the time he arrives at the Mountain to carry it out. Very convenient, and another sign that Bilbo’s characteristic luck is perhaps something more than he had thought.
Elrond only laughs once more. “I have not even told you the stories yet, Master Hobbit.”
Ah, yes, the stories. Bilbo tries to be grudging about this. He really should get back to the company, should he not? Elrond is actively trying to prevent their adventure. It will not put Thorin in a pleasant mood to see Bilbo fraternizing with Elves; he knows this from experience. And, yet, he cannot help himself. Not only would it be incredibly rude for Bilbo to simply walk off now that he’s gotten what he wanted from Elrond, but, despite himself, he longs to hear the tale of the Rings of Power and how they were forged and destroyed. Bilbo loves stories, especially old stories, even the ones that have no bearing whatsoever on his own life. Especially those ones, actually.
“So silly of me.” He has to laugh at himself. “Please, tell me all you know.”
“All I know?” Elrond raises an eyebrow. Apparently, Bilbo has succeeded once again in endearing himself to the Lord of Rivendell.
Bilbo shrugs. “As much as you’re willing to share.” That should be a pleasant way to spend a few hours.
Bilbo stands on a landing, overlooking yet another part of Rivendell.He initially planned to avoid this interaction. After all, he’s had it once before, and once was quite enough. He did not know then what he knows now, and the memory has been colored for him by subsequent events. But then he thinks of Thorin enduring the encounter alone, and as irritated as Bilbo might be with the leader of their company, he cannot allow that to happen.
“Of course I was going to tell you; I was waiting for this very chance,” Gandalf is saying, as he and Elrond traverse the path below. “And really, I think you can trust that I know what I’m doing.”
“Do you?” Elrond demands. When Bilbo sat down to write his book, he could not remember this dialogue, but he has an odd sense of familiarity, hearing it again. He may not know for certain the next words that the Elf Lord will say, but he certainly recalls the gist. “That dragon has slept for sixty years. What will happen if your plan should fail? If you wake that beast?”
“What if we succeed?” Gandalf counters. This time around, Bilbo hears Thorin’s footsteps behind him. He’d been so busy eavesdropping before that he hadn’t noticed the king’s approach at all. He wonders, now, why Thorin would even bother coming over. Is he trying to listen in on Gandalf and Elrond, or is he curious about what Bilbo is doing away from the rest of the company? "If the Dwarves take back the mountain, our defenses in the East will be strengthened.”
That much is certainly true. Bilbo remembers hearing about the Ringwraith’s arrival at Erebor, and he cannot imagine how the War of the Ring would have gone without a friendly presence there. If only Bilbo knew more about what actually happened! But unfortunately, anything said to him about the fate of Erebor after Frodo’s return went in one ear and out the other as he devoted his limited energy to looking after his nephew.
“It is a dangerous move, Gandalf.” But Elrond, too, is correct. Bilbo knows that first hand.
“It is also dangerous to do nothing! The throne of Erebor is Thorin’s birthright. What is it you fear?” Gandalf must be acting deliberately obtuse, though Bilbo can’t imagine why. Actually, when he thinks about it, yes, he can.
Bilbo is no longer the muddled old Hobbit who had his mind warped by the One Ring. He remembers everything that has happened to him over the course of the past eight decades with much more clarity than he’d been able to spare at the time. He knows very well that Gandalf allowed Frodo to carry the ring to Mordor, expecting that the lad would be greatly harmed by the proceedings. Believing, probably, that the lad would perish, but understanding that there was no other way. None but a Hobbit could carry the ring without becoming a monster, and Bilbo was no longer up to the task. Gandalf had made a strategic decision at the expense of one Hobbit. Here, he is making yet another strategic decision.
Bilbo will not go so far as to say that Gandalf does not care that Thorin and his nephews will die. Of course, even the Wizard has no inkling of what will come to pass, should Bilbo fail. Rather, Gandalf is willing to accept the deaths of any of the company if it means that Erebor will be reclaimed. It’s hard not to resent the Wizard for urging Bilbo and everyone close to him to embark upon terribly risky quests without sufficient preparation for the sake of Middle Earth, but then, the fate of Middle Earth is in play. Even Bilbo can admit that this outweighs the fate of any one person.
“Have you forgotten?” Lord Elrond pushes on. “A strain of madness runs deep in that family.” This time, Bilbo does not need to look to see that Thorin is still behind him. He is not surprised by what he is hearing, either. He has seen it first hand. “His grandfather lost his mind. His father succumbed to the same sickness. Can you swear Thorin Oakenshield will not also fall?” The Wizard says nothing. “Gandalf, these decisions do not rest with us alone. It’s not up to you or me to re-draw the map of Middle Earth.”
Thorin turns to leave, and Bilbo follows him. He didn’t, the last time. He only stood there, trying in vain to hear the rest of their conversation. The Elf Lord and the Wizard moved out of earshot and Bilbo stayed behind, content to let the king brood over the fruits of his eavesdropping. But Bilbo, now, knows more about dragon sickness than Thorin does. And he wants to help, even if only a little bit.
“Don’t listen to him,” Bilbo counsels, though Thorin has yet to acknowledge him in any way. “Lord Elrond has no idea what he’s talking about.”
“You seemed quite fond of him, the last time I looked,” Thorin retorts, still not looking at Bilbo. Is that envy in his tone? Surely not. Yes, toward the end, Thorin was quite possessive of Bilbo, but they are early in their journey yet. Bilbo must be hearing what he wants to hear, interpreting a jealous note in a perfectly plain statement.
“Yes, well,” Bilbo hedges, “Either way, he’s wrong.”
Now, Thorin does turn around. “What do you know of madness?” He demands. Ah, yes, lovely. Bilbo has deliberately placed himself on the receiving end of Thorin’s wrath out of… compassion? Love? Stupidity?
He has grown accustomed to Thorin as a figure from his past, a character in the stories Bilbo tells about his travels. He’s gotten used to the idea that Thorin will always respond the way Bilbo expects him to, will always follow the same pattern, over and over again. As Bilbo has lived a varied life, he has written and re-written and edited and re-told, watching Thorin take the same actions over and over again. But here, Thorin lives and breathes and has a mind of his own. He will respond to changes in Bilbo’s behavior, and not always in the way the Hobbit might predict.
“More than you might think,” Bilbo replies.
Can he judge Thorin for trying to kill him, all those years ago, several months in the future? After all, Bilbo himself attempted to lash out at his own nephew when he first saw the ring around Frodo’s neck. If he’d had the physical strength, if he hadn’t just handed over Sting and the mithril coat, Bilbo would likely have killed Frodo then. It is his greatest shame by far. “But that’s beside the point.”
“And what is the point, then?” Thorin is not pleased.
He’s so high strung, in this place. Hyper-vigilant, constantly aware of everything around him. Hovering on the outside, content neither to join in the singing, dancing, and communal baths enjoyed by his company nor to sit with Gandalf and Elrond at their high table. And now he is receiving unsolicited advice from a near-stranger. That is all that Bilbo is to him, here, in this place. They were not ever lovers, but whatever unspoken feelings once existed between them have not yet begun to bloom.
Bilbo considers lying, if only to ease Thorin’s obvious pain. He considers telling him that nothing will happen, that Thorin will be able to walk through Erebor’s vast halls of treasure and be completely fine, that there is no curse on his gold and no madness in his veins. But no. That would be wrong. Bilbo will not build a relationship, a friendship, a companionship, on a foundation of lies. Although, isn’t that what he’s already doing, considering he knows the future but keeps it to himself?
“You are not your grandfather,” Bilbo reminds Thorin, and he means it. “You have seen things that he couldn’t even imagine. Everybody out there,” he nods in the general direction of the hallway where the company resides, “Believes in you. I believe in you. Now, you have to start believing in yourself.”
“Oh, aye?” Thorin’s annoyance is plain, but he hasn’t walked away. He would be well within his rights to do so, but he stays.
“Anyway,” Bilbo continues, “You don’t even like Elves. Why are you so worried about what Lord Elrond thinks of you? You already have Gandalf’s support, and the support of your people, and of your Burglar, for that matter. We’ll just have to go out there and prove him wrong.”
Thorin only stares at him for a moment. Clearly, he’s not accustomed to being spoken to this way by anybody save Dwalin and perhaps Dís, but Bilbo could care less about that. His priority at the moment is stopping Thorin from getting himself killed, and though he knows it’s irrational, there’s some small part of Bilbo that wonders if perhaps… perhaps if Thorin has more confidence in himself this time around, the dragon sickness won’t affect him so badly. He fought it off before, didn’t he? He came around eventually, all on his own, while still in the Mountain with the treasure hoard. It was his decision to leave, wasn’t it? So maybe… maybe with a little bit of compassion, Bilbo can guide him around it. Lessen the impact. Something like that.But he knows he can’t bank on that kind of outcome. He can hope for the best, but Bilbo must plan for the worst.
“You are right,” Thorin decides eventually, “A credit to all Halflings that you should understand so well the burden of kingship.” His sneering tone is unmistakable. He probably thinks he’s being very clever.
Bilbo intends to put a stop to that. “You shouldn’t use that word,” he snaps, “Halfing, I mean. It’s very rude. I know diplomacy isn’t your strong suit, but you can at least make a little bit of effort. You don’t see me saying nasty things to you every time I lose an argument.” Not that Bilbo has lost any of their arguments hitherto, but he’s nice enough to keep that particular comment to himself.
“It was not my intention to offend you,” Thorin lies smoothly, showing off the diplomatic talent that must indeed have been ingrained upon him during his youth and abandoned sometime prior to his arrival in the Blue Mountains.
“Was it not? You’ve done a very good job of it, anyway.”
Thorin shakes his head. The ghost of a smile plays at his lips but straightens out quickly as he steadies himself on serious ground. “It was not my intention to offend you on the basis of your race. Had I known the connotation it carried, I’d never have said such a thing. I am sorry.”
Bilbo shakes his head. “Well, thank you.” He knows that Thorin is, at his core, a kind and honorable person, even if he uses brusqueness and poor manners as weapons of self-defense. He was almost certainly raised to distrust outsiders, and the events of his early life did very little to disabuse him of those notions. But the apology is genuine, and Bilbo knows that Thorin will never call him a halfling again.
An awkward pause passes between them. For quite a while, neither of them makes any move to fill it. They simply look at the city laid out below them, pretending as though they do not wish to say any more than they already have.
“You should go and get some sleep,” Thorin orders eventually. “You’ll only slow us down if you’re sluggish in the morning. We leave at first light.”
Eighty years ago, Bilbo might have asked what Thorin was talking about. He might have put up a fight, tried to argue in favor of restocking their supplies or taking a longer rest. But this time, he doesn’t bother. He knows that even without the prospect of interference from Wizards and Elves, even without Gandalf’s advice, Thorin would be resolute about pushing ahead. There are points to argue and points to let alone, and this, Bilbo decides, is very clearly one of the latter. So he only shrugs and turns on his heel. “Good night, Thorin,” he says, “You should get some rest, too.”
Though he knows that this, also, is a matter on which there is no debate to be had. Thorin is still out on the balcony when Bilbo falls asleep, and that is where he finds the leader of their company when he wakes up in the morning.
Chapter 4: Burdens Carried Over Hill and Under Hill
Notes:
Thanks as always for all the comments and kudos this week, and thanks for reading!
It's an angsty one today! Lots of grief and mourning, talk of death and dying, and battle flashbacks. I did not expect this chapter to be as heavy as it was, but considering we've got the thunder battle AND the finding of the ring to contend with I guess it had to be this way. Still, hopefully the middle part balances that out? Either way, please enjoy.
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
It is nigh on impossible to see through the storm. The rain falls in thick, heavy sheets, and thunder echoes through the peaks and valleys of the Misty Mountains. Brief flashes of lighting are veins of metal in the sky, but utterly useless in clearing the way. There is too much wind even for keen Dwarven eyes to parse anything through the rain. Thorin pushes forward, despite his sodden hair and clothes, battered by the icy wind. They cannot turn back and they cannot stop where they are. They must continue on, whatever happens. They’ve done it before. They’ll have to do it again before their journey is through. They may as well get used to it, even the Hobbit, who has been shooting Thorin charged looks since they left the House of Elrond.
Thorin has ignored these glances to the best of his ability. He has no idea why Master Baggins has become so invested in him and his quest, nor why the odd creature felt compelled to offer him encouragement at Rivendell. The King Under the Mountain does not require counsel from anyone, least of all someone less than half his age who has never seen a battle or faced any hardship more harrowing than running out of butter for the porridge at breakfast time. It occurs to Thorin that he is being unfair, but then, fairness is a dangerous thing, out here in the wild. It is one thing to apologize for accidental use of insensitive language, an overstep which Thorin genuinely regrets. He knows well enough what it is like to be looked down upon, having spent years of his life toiling in the towns and villages of Men.
But this does not mean that Thorin should allow himself to get close to Master Baggins. A friendship with the Hobbit would be a very poor idea. Thorin has no need of friends. He is the leader of an exiled people, with burdens enough on his back, without taking up responsibility for an entertaining and attractive creature who seems determined to place himself in harm’s way at every opportunity. Master Baggins was the one who rushed off to challenge the trolls alone, and then he had the nerve to complain about his lack of a weapon as he snatched the Elven blade from Thorin’s hands. Such erratic behavior will surely lead the Hobbit to a bad end, and Thorin does not have the time or energy on hand to drag himself through another loss.
What in Durin’s name is Thorin doing, thinking about the Hobbit while traversing the side of a mountain? Is he trying to get himself killed? That can’t happen, not until the quest is through. Thorin will not put the reclamation of Erebor on Fíli’s shoulders. He would be a fine King Under the Mountain, but he is young yet, and deserves a few more years of practice before he starts ruling in earnest. He should not have to be the one to take back their homeland. It should be Thorin. By the grace of Mahal, it will be Thorin.
This is his burden, and his burden alone. His birthright and his task. He is not his grandfather. He has proven himself as a brave and pragmatic leader. He has provided well for his people during their sojourn in the Blue Mountains, and now, he must provide them with a restored homeland, their own kingdom, an end to the decades of living on whatever scraps are thrown to them. Should he fall, his people will be taken care of, but he owes it to his heirs to keep himself alive so that they might never be forced to carry the great weight that now lays across Thorin’s shoulders.
A particularly strong gust of wind reminds him that this is not the time to be lost in thought. Brooding, his sister-sons would call it. Dwalin, too. And the Hobbit used that word by the campfire, a sly smile on his handsome face, his head cocked to the side as he regarded Thorin with oddly trusting eyes. Master Baggins is a fool to trust his safety to a company of thirteen strangers.
Why is Thorin thinking about the Hobbit again? He should consider the rest of his companions. He should be more fair. He should stop thinking altogether and focus on getting all of them to relative safety. They are still in the mountains, after all, and the storm is getting worse. He must keep his wits about him. He must not fall to sentimental musings. He can trust no one but himself to lead the company through this. If anything goes wrong, it will be on Thorin’s head alone. He must not pass his responsibility along to his sister-sons or his advisors.
“Hold on!” Thorin orders his company, as if they would have done anything else. He hears scuffling behind him, but pays it no mind. Had anything serious happened, he’d have been informed. He must not dwell on whatever calamity was avoided; that way lies madness. “We must find shelter!”
“Look out!” Dwalin roars, and then a rock comes careening into the side of the mountain. The pieces of the boulder rain down around them, and Thorin is painfully aware of all of the lives in his care at the moment. If any of them fall, it will be Thorin’s fault for leading them here.
“This is no thunderstorm,” Balin realizes, “It’s a thunder battle! Look!”
Thorin can only stare in horror. A thunder battle? Stone giants, throwing boulders at each other, with his company in the middle of it? He can only pray that they will all have the sense to keep under cover, and that Mahal will preserve them from an early journey to his halls.
“Well, bless me!” Bofur dashes his king’s hopes immediately, as though trying to remind Thorin of how little control he truly has. “The legends are true! Giants! Stone giants!” Bifur scolds his cousin sharply for his behavior, in low tones that do not travel to Thorin’s position. Not that the Khuzdul reprimand has any affect on Bofur, who continues to stand there gawking.
“Take cover, you fool!” Thorin cannot deal with this.
He cannot lose any member of his company. He simply cannot. He is not his grandfather, and he will not fail. He is the custodian of his people, and he will not fail. He will get his company across these mountains and then on to Erebor, and then he will use his newfound power and the resources that accompany it to search every corner of the known world for his missing father. He will not fail.
But he is powerless to do anything but stand there clinging to the stone as the rock face he thought so stable begins to move. Boulders rain down to hammer the mountainside, and Thorin finds himself thinking once again of the Hobbit. Oh, what in Durin’s name was Gandalf thinking, sending such a weak little creature on a journey like this? Master Baggins has never left his cozy home before. Whatever skills he learned play-acting at adventures in peaceful Hobbiton will do nothing to protect him from the perils of the road. He does not belong in the Misty Mountains, of all places! He’ll be killed. He’ll be killed, violently and horribly and tragically, and it will be Thorin’s fault for not putting his foot down. More blood on his hands, just like Thrór, just like Frerin. A better king with more foresight could have prevented this.
The rock splits where the company stands. Thorin can hear his nephews calling out to one another, and he does not look behind him, does not, cannot, cannot think about it now, needs to keep himself from falling to his death before his duty is done. He owes a debt to his people, to his ancestors and his Maker. He owes a debt to his company, each and every member. Panting from the strain and buzzing with nerves, Thorin scrambles to more steady ground, following what little stone-sense he has, his mind frantic with a nonsensical prayer. Only once he has braced himself against the rock can he bring himself to look behind him. To his horror, he finds only four of his companions. Glóin, Óin, Balin, Kíli.
The others stand on a disembodied ledge, brandished in the monstrous hand of one of the giants. Thorin is single-minded in his terror. His heir is in danger, his sister-son. And Dwalin, his dearest friend. Foolish, comely Master Baggins. And the other six, steadfast and loyal folk who chose to follow their king on this journey because, as the Hobbit made so very clear, they believe in Thorin. He has failed them now. He has failed all of them.
He can only stand and watch, can only scream, “Hold on!” As if that will do anything, can only cling to the rock to hide his trembling as the trajectory of his companions becomes obvious. They are in for a collision with the mountain’s face, and there is nothing Thorin can do to stop it. At the front of the group is Fíli, looking decades younger in his terror, his back to the stone as he braces himself. That will do nothing.
Thorin remembers Fíli as a little lad, always standing back, always keeping himself and his brother out of the way, stepping into shoes too large for any child to fill. He remembers reading stories to the boy, braiding golden hair and bandaging skinned knees. He remembers waking up to find that his nephew had climbed into his bed at night, ostensibly afraid of the dark, though this fear only seemed to plague the boy on the nights when Thorin’s nightmares were the worst. He remembers training Fíli with a sword, watching him grow, watching him become skilled. Telling him that under no circumstances could he come on this quest. He remembers being worn down, acquiescing, by the argument that Erebor was Fíli’s birthright, too. The rock hits the mountain, and Thorin’s blood freezes in his veins.
“No!” He screams, “No, no!” He is senseless now, unable to compose himself, unable to think straight, unable to remember that he is supposed to be a king.
It is beyond Thorin’s comprehension to lose any member of his company this way. He knows that in the days to come, he will mourn for loyal Dwalin, who followed Thorin to this horrific end. All the others, the Burglar and the near-strangers who nevertheless devoted themselves to Thorin’s cause. But now, his heart cries for his sister-son, the boy he helped raise from a pebble. Thorin could not have stopped Dwalin from coming on this quest. It would dishonor him as king to stoop to such a level, refusing the service of a talented soldier for petty personal reasons. Nor could he have refused the service of the others without giving them a major slight.
But he could have protected Fíli. He could have had the final word, not as the lad’s king but as his uncle. No one would have blamed him. Dís would have supported him. She did not wish for her sons to come with Thorin, after all. In fact, she begged him to set them straight, and he refused, with pretty words about Sons of Durin and their duty to their people and how cruel it would be of him to steal this opportunity from the boys. Thorin was proud, and he wanted every sword he could get for use against the dragon. And look what has come of all that.
Horrible images float through Thorin’s head. Blood and gore and stained armor and Thrór’s head twenty feet away from the rest of his body and half of Frerin’s young face ripped away and dragon fire and the smell of burning flesh and burning trees and burning fabric and the roar of the wyrm and the cold glare of an Elf turning his back on his allies and little Fíli tugging at Thorin’s sleeve to get his attention and and Dís, sobbing over her husband the same way she will soon sob for her son. Thorin’s body moves of its own volition and gets him over to the space where he knows that the carnage will be.
He steels himself. He does not have the luxury of responding to this as any other person would. He does not have the luxury of shock and horror. He will have to put on a brave face and lead what remains of his company past the mangled remains of their fallen comrades. Past the mangled remains of the little boy who noticed his uncle’s nightmares and began to sing him lullabies to try and calm them. He will have to be a king, and then, when night falls and the mask comes off, he will have to be an uncle. Kíli yet lives, but he will never be the same. Thorin wasn’t. He knows. Kíli will lose that glimmer in his eyes, that bounce in his step, just as his uncle did before him. And he will need to learn how to lead, how to rule. How to mourn.
Thorin takes a ragged breath and forces himself around the corner. He stops dead, nearly sending himself and those behind him tumbling over the side of the mountain when he sees all of them there, fully intact, huddled together and shaking but alive, all of them alive. He feels flimsy with relief and residual anger, heavy with sudden awareness of his utter lack of control.
Somehow, Bilbo, with all of his foreknowledge, manages to topple over the same ledge again the second time around. It’s impressive, really, that he put himself in the exact same place at the exact same time, resulting in the exact same outcome. Of course, that’s not as much of a comfort as one might imagine. Bilbo knows that he can’t hold onto this slippery ledge indefinitely, and that his being rescued before is not a guarantee of his being rescued again.
“Where’s Bilbo? Where’s the Hobbit?” At least Bofur is aware of his absence.
“There!” Someone shouts, and the company’s attention is drawn to the spot where Bilbo hangs.
Perhaps it is not the same exact spot. Perhaps there was never any guarantee that Bilbo was going to go flying off the side of a cliff during the thunder battle, and he is just incredibly unlucky. It would only be fair, for him to have poor luck in this venture when the Valar have been so diligent in guiding him along the rest of his journey. What will happen if he does fall? Will he wake up in the care of Yavanna, like a proper Hobbit, or will Lady Galadriel collect him somehow and take him back to the start? And what will become of the company, either way? Bilbo begins to hyperventilate at the thought of what might happen if he falls now.
“Get him!” Someone screams, and the company responds by extending their arms to Bilbo. But he knows he cannot support his weight one-handed, and he also knows how he was saved the last time. It’s a gamble and a risk he shouldn’t take, but he closes and eyes and waits for Thorin to come to his rescue.
I will return the favor, Bilbo promises silently. I will save your life. I will not let you fall in battle. I will stick Sting into Azog’s eye and teach him what happens when he tries to lay his hands on my beloved.
As expected, Thorin is able to scramble down the side of the rock in a split second and haul Bilbo up by the back of his jacket. The king gives Bilbo a firm push toward the others, who pull him back onto the ledge with haste. That warm, rough hand moves him so deftly, with such ease, as though the Hobbit weighed no more than a bag of flour.
Oh, those hands. Those hands, those powerful king’s hands, those calloused smith’s hands, those hands which Bilbo has gripped until all the warmth seeped out of them. Those hands of which Bilbo has dreamed for so very long. Those hands which are, at the moment, the only thing standing between Thorin Oakenshield and certain death. What a stupid, needless risk. Clearly taken without thinking, or with some skewed sense of honor in mind, because for the purposes of the quest, they’d be better off without a burglar than without their leader.
Thorin nearly loses his grip, but Dwalin is strong and fast and constantly aware of his king’s position and wellbeing. Bilbo attempts to lie to himself, to pretend that Thorin was never in any real danger, but he knows that isn’t true. They have both been lucky this day, and it doesn’t matter that Bilbo had prior expectations. Things could have turned out very badly indeed. I will return the favor.
“I thought we’d lost our Burglar,” Dwalin comments, because somebody needs to say something.
Bilbo knows what is coming next, although perhaps things will be different this time around. After all, he and Thorin have been closer on this journey than the one that came before. Bilbo has shared his food and even pipeweed with Thorin, and they have bickered good-naturedly about how he chose to fill his pack. He has offered Thorin comfort in a time of need and been gentle with him about his rude comments. It seems that one of them is always staring at the other, then looking away in embarrassment when he is caught. None of that could have been said at this point on the first adventure.
“He’s been lost ever since he left home.” No. Of course not. Bilbo should have known. Thorin offers the same scathing words that he threw at Bilbo before, only this time around, Bilbo feels he is much less justified in doing so. “He should never have come. He has no place amongst us.”
The last time, Bilbo was stunned by these words, speechless as he was submerged in the truth of them. He remembers blinking away tears, believing Thorin completely, trusting his judgment for some inexplicable reason. He was fooled by the king’s modulated tone, and did not know him well enough to understand what was going on. Last time, perhaps, one could have argued that Bilbo did not belong with the company. He kept his distance from them, laying out his bedroll in an isolated corner or near the Wizard whenever he could. He did not share in their jokes, and at the start, they’d taken bets about whether he would even come on the adventure at all.
This time, however, Bilbo has integrated himself into the company quite well. He tells stories and sings drinking songs with Bofur, he’s treated Nori’s injuries, and he’s rather close with Fíli and Kíli. He’s shared food with everybody, and his disappointing book is currently in Ori’s pack. He even let Glóin spend an entire day regaling him with tales of little Gimli! One could argue that perhaps Bilbo is not the best fighter among them (alright, he is easily the worst fighter among them, but that’s beside the point) but to say that he does not belong at all? To say that he has been lost? Bilbo has barely thought of the Shire since he left it. He’s been exceptionally prepared for all of their encounters. He’s been nonchalantly reading while the rest of them were fretting about orc attacks, and Thorin still has the nerve to talk about him like that!
Obviously, Bilbo thinks huffily as he follows the rest of the company into the convenient cave where they’ve decided to make camp, Thorin’s unkind words had nothing to do with Bilbo. The king was only lashing out, hitting the closest target as hard as he could with as much force as he could muster. And it doesn’t take a genius to figure out why. He’d nearly lost half his company. Bilbo understands, as he did not understand the last time, that Thorin feels personally responsible for all of them. It does not matter that Thorin had no way of knowing about the thunder battle, that even if he had known, there would have been no way around it, that everybody in their company is an adult who made a conscious decision to come along. If anything had happened, Thorin would’ve taken it personally. He would have blamed himself.
And he chose to blame Bilbo instead, rather than sitting with the guilt. Rather than tearing himself up inside, he went after the Hobbit. And really, Bilbo should leave it there. He should be supportive and understanding. After all, he knows that Thorin will come around eventually. They won’t be dancing about one another forever. He’ll prove himself in battle and Thorin will apologize for doubting him; they’ll hug, and after that, they will be friends. Simple and straightforward, exactly as it should be.
But Bilbo Baggins cannot leave well enough alone. If he could, he’d be in the Undying Lands right now, reclining on green grass and staring up at a blue sky, not soaked to the bone and trembling with cold while an emotionally immature monarch uses him as a training dummy. He at least has the courtesy to wait until they’re inside the cave to make his move, though. Unlike Thorin, Bilbo has no desire to publicly humiliate anybody.
“What are you doing, lad?” Glóin demands with a hand on the Hobbit’s shoulder as Bilbo makes his way over to Thorin. “Best not to make it worse, I’d say.”
Bilbo pays him no mind, shaking the hand off and striding past, ignoring Balin’s amused snort and quiet comment with equal resolve. “What’s he doing now?” Óin inquires at such a volume that the goblins in their tunnels below can probably hear him with perfect clarity.
Thorin, too, can hear, of course. He looks up and meets Bilbo’s eyes. “Let’s see about supper,” Bombur says conspicuously to the little gaggle of spectators. “There’s no fire, but I know I can work something up. Who’d like to help?”
“And miss the show?” Kíli, unfortunately, somehow manages to be even more conspicuous.
Bilbo doesn’t blame him one bit for trying to find amusement in this dismal place. The color is gone from his cheeks, and he has been gripping the strap of his pack with white knuckles since they arrived in the cave.Thankfully, he has his brother nearby to drag him away, with cheerfully articulated threats and no trace of whatever terror plagued him only moments before. These lads are accustomed to wearing brave faces, as is every member of the company.
Well. This isn’t awkward at all. So much for a private conversation. Their companions may not be watching openly, but Bilbo knows that they’ll be paying attention as he speaks to Thorin. Still, he can’t let this wait until they’re clear of the tunnels. He wants to fix it now, before the wounds have a chance to fester. He needs to speak up for himself, and, even worse, he wants to help. The one he loves is suffering, and Bilbo, despite his better judgment, wants to put it right.
“Hello,” he says, sitting down beside the king. Everyone else has given him a wide berth, joking comments aside, probably owing to some sense of self-preservation which Bilbo apparently lacks.
Thorin only grunts at him in vague acknowledgment as he withdraws his bedroll from his pack and begins to lay it out just so. Well, Bilbo should have known that it would be like this. Just because he understands what Thorin is going through doesn’t mean that the king is going to open up and let him in at the first knock.
“Look,” Bilbo tries again, “I understand that you’re upset. You’ve just had a shock, we all have. And I can’t imagine what it must be like for you, having your heirs out there, and everything. And considering what they’re like… well, I’m sure I’d be terrified out of my mind, if those were my nephews.” Thorin pauses briefly in his methodical preparation of his bedroll, but says nothing and returns to his work just as quickly. “And obviously, you’ve got to look after the entire company as well. It’s a heavy burden on your shoulders, and no mistake.”
“What do you want?” Thorin growls.
Bilbo blinks at him. Well, so much for that, then. He may as well double down, if he’ll be met with anger no matter what he says. “To express my sympathy, first of all, because what you’re doing isn’t easy, and I can see that, even if nobody else can.”
“Thank you.” Thorin does not sound remotely grateful.
“But second of all,” Bilbo presses on, “I’ll thank you not to talk to me like that ever again. I signed a contract to work as your Burglar, not to dangle off the sides of mountains. And you signed the same contract, if I recall. If we’re to have a working professional relationship, then you’re going to have to treat me with civility. I’ll not have you yelling at me in front of the company every time you feel you need something to control.”
“And what gives you the right to speak to me this way?” Oh, goodness, he’s as ornery as ever.
“Well, for a start, you’re not my king,” Bilbo points out, “And I’m not afraid of you. I’ve been minding faunts for years, and I know what sulking looks like when I see it. Besides, if you can’t handle a talking-to, you shouldn’t be throwing them around yourself, now, should you?” Bilbo receives no response, but Thorin, at least, has the grace to look chastened. “Now, chin up. You’re a fine king, like I told you at Bag End, and I know you know better than to speak to any of your subjects the way you spoke to me back there. Everybody’s well, and of course nobody blames you for anything those giants were doing! It’ll all look better in the morning, I’m sure.”
Which is not strictly true, because in the morning they’ll be fumbling along through the goblin tunnels, running for their lives. But that won’t help Thorin sleep any sounder, and anyway, Bilbo knows for a fact that after that battle, the king will feel better about his ability to lead. He pats Thorin on the shoulder before taking his leave and wandering over to set up his own bedroll.
But no. This conversation isn’t over yet. There is one crucial think that Bilbo has forgotten. He turns back. “Have you come to strike me another killing blow, then, Master Burglar?” Thorin drawls.
“Not this time,” Bilbo admits. He’s very well put his foot in it now, and it would be nothing short of cowardly for him to back down now that he’s made his decision. “I almost forgot to thank you for saving my life.”
Thorin laughs. Really laughs, the sound abrupt and shocking. Judging by his wide-eyed expression, the king was not expecting that any more than Bilbo was. “I could do nothing else. You are a member of my company,” he says, by way of explanation.
Bilbo can only stare at him. A member of his company? Oh, sure, yes, that is the bare minimum for Thorin to admit, and true in point of fact, but they never would have gotten this far on the first adventure. Not even by a long shot. Not until the Carrock. Apparently, Bilbo’s stammering attempt to stand up for himself has earned him some grudging respect.
Thorin still looks amused as he regards Bilbo across his bedroll, which is now ready for a night of fitful sleep. “Did you have something more to say?” Still, that fondness Bilbo senses in his tone must be a product of the Hobbit’s hopeful mind, and nothing more. Perhaps in another life, Thorin Oakenshield did love him, but here and now, Bilbo knows better than to expect such a thing. It is far too soon for all that.
“No, no, of course not, that’ll be all then, thank you.” Bilbo shakes himself and begins backing away. “Good night, Thorin. I suppose I’ll see you in the morning.” That is more or less true, anyway.
Once the issue with Thorin is resolved, the company’s present peril dawns on Bilbo. None of the others know anything about the goblins, of course, so they can be forgiven for their foolishness, but Bilbo certainly understands what awaits them on the other side of the wall. He contemplates speaking up, but the minute the idea enters his mind, it begins to fall apart.
For one thing, he knows that Thorin would never listen to him. Such a conversation would immediately reverse whatever progress Bilbo managed to make with his earlier assertion. Bilbo would voice his concern, but of course, he wouldn’t be able to say anything specific, so Thorin would accuse him of pining for home, and Bilbo would point out that there are goblins in these mountains, and Thorin, almost definitely, would contend that Bilbo knows not of what he speaks. And then the goblins would catch them anyway, in the middle of an argument, with the rest of the company no doubt gathered around like spectators at a midsummer dance.
Also, just like with the trolls, their encounter in the goblin tunnels will play a vital part in their adventure. If Bilbo never faces Gollum, he will never get his hands on the ring, and therefore will not be able to turn invisible. He won’t save the company from the spiders or the Elves, and he does not know how his encounter with Smaug will go, if he ever actually gets to see Erebor. And, of course, he won’t be able to destroy the ring if he does not have the ring, even assuming that he manages to concoct completely new plans for dealing with everything else. Moreover, Bilbo doesn’t like the company’s chances out there on the mountain. They may not find another place to camp, and it’ll be a lot worse trying to navigate this stretch of their journey in the dark. The stone giants are still out there, and Yavanna only knows what else.
And who knows how long it will take them to pass through the Misty Mountains without the shortcut through the goblin tunnels? It’s not a chance they can take with limited time. Better the goblin that you know than the warg that you don’t, Bilbo decides. He can’t afford to take new chances. He’ll do everything the same way he did it before. Except, no he won’t, because he does not intend to leave, nor to tell Bofur to his face that their people do not belong anywhere. Bilbo didn’t mean that when he said it, and he’s spent eight decades regretting it. For a moment, Bilbo wonders if he should just stay in bed.
But that’s not possible, either. Last time, Bofur saw the glow of Sting and said something, and Thorin roused the rest of the company. Of course he had. He’d been wide awake, listening to the nasty things that Bilbo said about his people. No wonder he’d been so angry with the Hobbit when they were reunited later. All of Bilbo’s righteousness about Thorin’s use of insulting language, and yet, on the first journey, he was no better! Worse, even. Thorin had no way of knowing that halfling was an offensive term, but a moment’s reflection would’ve reminded Bilbo of the Dwarven cultural heritage regarding their status as an unwanted people. Which they emphatically are not, because even if every Elf, Man, Orc and Wizard in Middle Earth turns up their nose at this company, Bilbo loves each of them with all his Hobbit heart.
Regardless of all that, though, they were all awake and aware when they tumbled into the tunnels. Who knows what could happen to them in any other state? He has to go and talk to Bofur, then.
“You should get some rest while you have the chance,” Bofur advises when he catches sight of Bilbo, “No telling how long we’ll be staying here.” He does not add any commentary about Thorin’s apparent restlessness, but this assessment is implied with the way he nods toward their leader.
Bilbo passes his gaze over each member of the company in turn, but quickly deems this practice too distressing. He’s improved a lot since setting out from Bag End, truly. He was able to distract himself well enough with his book and his snacks during the first leg of the journey, and then, in Rivendell, he was preoccupied with the question of the ring. But he’s had strange dreams every night since they left the Last Homely House, and these have shaken him. He’s taken to sleeping slightly apart from the company, just as he did on the original adventure, though this time, it is to shield them all from his kicking and whimpering as he contends with the same nightmares that drove him from Erebor all those years ago.
Nobody has said anything about it to him, but he imagines that his fellows must know his predicament. It would be hard to miss something like that, on watch, although Bilbo doesn’t know for certain that he’s been kicking and whimpering. Only, he can’t imagine he would be so lucky as to have no embarrassing reaction whatsoever to the dreams. They’re not fantastical like the one he had the first night at Bag End; they are true to life, his worst memories repeated ad nauseam. He has watched Fíli fall and seen the light leave Thorin’s eyes and found Kíli laying on the ground upwards of a thousand times by now, and yet, the pain is still fresh with every nightmare.
It’s just a little too much, to look at them all like this. The lads are sleeping on their backs, bedrolls pulled up close to conserve warmth, and even in the narrow light of the cave, he can see the rising and falling of their chests. They are both breathing, he reminds himself. They are both alive. There is no blood to be seen, and there are no limbs forced into awkward positions. This is not Ravenhill.
Thorin, however, is laying on his side with his back to Bilbo, who has to resist the urge to start stepping over people to get a better look and check that the king is breathing. Oh, yes, that’d go over well. No doubt he’d wind up with a sword in his own chest before Thorin even opened his eyes to see who was pestering him. It’s not wise to sneak up on any warrior, but somebody as high-strung as Thorin is particularly dangerous when teetering between wakefulness and sleep. Bilbo’s only comfort is the logical conclusion that Thorin has no reason to be in any state other than perfect health at this juncture on their journey.
“What’s bothering you?” Bofur asks.
Bilbo has long since learned that his friend’s jovial front is just that: a front. It’s not that Bofur doesn’t find joy in life, because of course, he does, but he’s not the jolly fool that he often makes himself out to be. He can more than hold his own in a fight, and when it suits him, he can be very perceptive. More likely than not, he has his own set of hypotheses about what’s bothering Bilbo, but he knows better than to ask a leading question. It didn’t occur to Bilbo the first time, how closely he was being observed by every member of the company, but now, it’s obvious to him.
He does not think that any of his companions suspect him of the grief he bears so heavily. Why would they, after all? Bilbo’s circumstances are far beyond the realm of possibility that he’d have comprehended prior to the onset of his second adventure. But it is plain that they can tell that something is off about him. They may think he’s too trusting, or too kind to possibly be genuine. Perhaps they’ll attribute these apparent qualities to Hobbit nature or culture, just as once they did with his standoffishness. Some of the more perceptive fellows may even think that Bilbo has a little crush on Thorin. They don’t know the half of it, of course, but no use saying any more.
Bilbo sighs. He can’t very well tell the truth, can he? “Well,” he begins, pithy as ever, “I nearly fell to my death out there.”
“True enough,” Bofur shrugs. That’s something Bilbo appreciates about him. He doesn’t sugar-coat. “But as far as I can tell, you’re still alive. That’s something to be happy about.”
“Oh, yes, I’m very pleased. And you should be, too. As long as I’m alive, none of you have to face the dragon.”
Bofur snorts. “Oh, I imagine we’ll be facing it sooner or later whether you’re with us or not.” With us, he says, not simply alive, as though he thinks there is some possibility of Bilbo leaving.
“Hm.” Bilbo can’t really argue with this point. Well, actually, he could argue; he could tell Bofur that some people will be hungover in Lake-town when the dragon attacks and therefore will not have to do very much wyrm-fighting, but then, of course, he’d be showing his hand. If he were going to confess to anybody about his foreknowledge, it would probably be Bofur, but Bilbo isn’t planning to reveal his secret at this point in the journey, especially not while Thorin is eavesdropping. “I don’t suppose you’ll ever have to find out, because I’m certainly not going anywhere.”
“That’s the spirit.” Bofur wraps his arm around Bilbo and jostles him to and fro.
In the Shire, this would be considered incredibly rough treatment, and if anybody had tried it on Bilbo eighty years ago he would’ve balked and said something snarky. But he understands now that in Dwarven culture, it is a gesture of affection between equals. He’s seen his companions engage in it many times, and if anything, he should be honored that Bofur apparently views him as friend enough to justify such informality. But, then, he’s had Bofur’s friendship for so long that it’s strange to think of having to win him over again, even if the circumstances are perfectly explicable.
Oh, by the Valar, what kind of life has Bilbo led that he considers circumstances such as these ones perfectly explicable? “Anyway, I’m sure you lot will need me long before we get to Erebor.” He has to bite his tongue once more to keep from telling any tales that should not come to light just yet. Bofur will live through them soon enough, and it won’t do for him to be lulled into a false sense of security by the knowledge that Bilbo managed to carry things off once before. Moreover, it would be patently unfair to force poor Bofur to keep such a heavy secret from his brother, his cousin, and his friends, not to mention his king.
“Oh, aye,” Bofur agrees. “Who’d be handing out handkerchiefs if you were to leave us?”
“You’ve already had four,” Bilbo reminds him with a laugh, “I don’t know what you keep doing with them. I don’t suppose I want to know, either.”
“One of them was for Bifur,” Bofur recounts, “He did thank you for it, didn’t he?”
“I don’t speak Khuzdul!” Bilbo protests gleefully. It’s easy to forget his troubles around Bofur. He can almost imagine that they’re not about to fall through the floor. “Was he thanking me? I didn’t know! Oh, goodness, I hope I haven’t offended him.” If only Bilbo had taken the time to learn the secret language on his return to Erebor! He’d have had to petition Dáin for permission, of course, and that could easily have been denied, but it would have served him well had he been granted the opportunity.
“Shh, you’ll wake the company,” Bofur, too, is smiling. “I don’t think Bifur’d be offended by you not speaking Khuzdul. It’d be worse if you did understand him, actually. Secret language and all.“
“Right.” This does make Bilbo feel a bit better. Still, he resolves to find some way to communicate better with Bifur in the future. He can’t wait until the Elven dungeons to start learning simple signs the way he did the last time.
“Anyway, you know the trolls took the first handkerchief you gave me,” Bofur continues his litany of excuses.
“I continue to find that very difficult to believe.” Not that Bilbo cares. But it’s good fun, going back and forth with Bofur.
“And Nori took the next one, if you can believe that. He got a few of them out of your pack, too, and won himself a couple of coins from Dwalin.” Bofur winks conspiratorially. “Says he’s gotta keep himself sharp, and you’re good practice.”
“Dwalin was placing wagers on Nori stealing from me?” Actually, when he says it out loud, this doesn’t surprise Bilbo very much. “Of course he was. I suppose everyone has to find something to entertain themselves with, out on the road.” Besides, Bilbo has plenty of handkerchiefs to go around, and those left in his pack won’t even survive the night. Perhaps it’s a good thing that Nori has taken some of them; those might yet remain with the company after they’ve left the goblin tunnels.
“And I still have the fourth one,” Bofur plows right on ahead with accounting of the whereabouts of Bilbo’s handkerchiefs. Oh, how Bilbo missed such mischief, all those long lonely years he spent holed up in Bag End! “And a great honor it is, too, carrying the favor of a gentlehobbit such as yourself.”
Bilbo rolls his eyes. “Oh, please shut up, and don’t embarrass yourself.” But they’re both grinning. That much Bilbo can tell, even in the dark.
He’s glad he hasn’t threatened to leave this time around, and somewhat sad, too. Given the choice between the two conversations, Bilbo decides that he’d much rather have this lively discussion than the talking-down that Bofur attempted the first time around. And it didn’t even work. Bilbo really would’ve walked out on the company, and then where would they all be? On the off chance that he ever made it home to the Shire, Bilbo would be miserable for the rest of his days without ever knowing why. And Thorin would probably be killed by Azog the Defiler after the company escaped the goblin tunnels. What would become of the others then?
Bilbo shudders to think about it. “But there’s still something the matter, isn’t there?” Bofur observes.
“Yes, there is.” Bilbo isn’t going to lie to him. He’s just so tired of carrying so many secrets around, so sick of obsessing over the horrible things he has witnessed. It’s frustrating, being so in love with Thorin, knowing in his heart exactly what kind of person the king is, but having to contend with the distrustful, brooding disaster on legs who is presently leading their company. Not to mention the princes, who have been nothing but nice to Bilbo, going out of their way to include him whenever they can. Bilbo feels guilty for not telling them what he knows, and personally responsible for their fates. Perhaps he could have convinced them to stay in Rivendell. But no, that’d never have gone over. Bilbo might have managed to make Fíli see reason with a solid argument about ensuring the safety of the heirs to the throne, but Kíli would almost certainly have talked his brother out of that within the hour.
“Wanna talk about it?” Bofur prods, jabbing Bilbo in the side while he’s at it.
Bilbo takes a moment to collect his thoughts. He can feel Bofur’s eyes on him, scanning his face with keen vision and palpable concern. The Hobbit sighs heavily. “I know that Thorin did not mean what he said to me out on the ledge.”
“No, of course he didn’t,” Bofur agrees, “Sometimes our dear king can say things without meaning them. Especially when he’s had a shock.”
“Still,” Bilbo continues, knowing that he must tread carefully. After all, Thorin is almost certainly listening in. Bilbo cannot help being aware of that fact. He finds himself absently fiddling with Sting, taking the blade from its sheath and turning it over in the dim light of the cave. “It hurts, being told I don’t belong. I wish he knew that I would gladly lay my life on the line for… well, for anybody in the company, just the same as he would. Just the same as any of us would, I imagine.”
“And did you tell him as much, when you went over?” Bofur is shameless with his prying.
Bilbo would have to be a fool, indeed, to believe that his little interview with Thorin went unnoticed by any member of the company. “No. I told him to keep his head up and stop brooding, because he’s a perfectly fine king."
Bofur offers him a disbelieving laugh. “And how did that work out for you, lad?” At least someone can find humor in this situation.
Bilbo knew that it would be an uphill battle, getting back into Thorin Oakenshield’s good graces. He knew he’d be contending with decades of distrust and fear and trauma, that any love he might feel is entirely unrequited, at least for the time being. He knew all of this, and yet, it is torture, to look into Thorin’s eyes and see none of the affection which once he found there. It was torture, to be heaved back onto the ledge by those strong arms without being held in them after. Torture, that Bilbo should have to be the one to comfort Thorin after such a harrowing ordeal, when the smallest and most selfish part of him wished to share in a moment of mutual consolation. Even when Thorin is being cordial, he keeps Bilbo at a painful distance.
“He has every reason to distrust me, I suppose,” Bilbo says deliberately. “I would, I’m sure, in his position. I’m a stranger to you, and I know I’m not much in battle even on my best day. No, I’m not at all angry with Thorin for what he said.”
“He can be a prickly one when he sets his mind to it,” Bofur observes. “Still doesn’t give him the right to speak to you the way he did. You know we all think of you as one of our own. Couldn’t get along without you.”
“Oh, believe me, I am well aware.” Bilbo assures him, forcing a smile. The problem is that he has no reason to be so troubled by Thorin’s rejection of him. Why would Bilbo care so much that a stranger far above his station does not like him? Thorin has proven that he is willing to risk his life for Bilbo’s, no matter what he feels about the Hobbit as a person. He’d have jumped for joy if Thorin had called him a member of the company at this point on the first adventure. Now, though, his shoulders sag at the realization that weeks of loving effort on his part have yielded nothing more than an acknowledgement of the truth from Thorin. At this rate, they may have a conversation about their true feelings on Bilbo’s next eleventy-first birthday. “But it doesn’t matter. You can’t get rid of me that easily.”
Bofur laughs at that. “I hope you don’t expect to be falling off many more cliffs in the future. Once was quite enough for me to watch a thing like that.”
“I’m a Hobbit,” Bilbo reminds him, “We’re not built for heights, and our feet aren’t made for climbing on rocks. It’s not my fault that… Oh.” Sting’s blade shines in a faint but unmistakable shade of blue. “Oh no.” How did he manage to forget where they were?
“What is it?” Bofur asks.
Bilbo brandishes his sword. “It’s glowing blue. There must be goblins nearby.“
“Wake up! Wake up!” Thorin roars, but of course, just like last time, he is too late. A small crack in the wall turns into a rather large chasm in the floor, which leads into a tunnel, through which everybody tumbles.
It is absolute madness. Utter pandemonium, really. Bilbo just barely manages to put Sting away before he can do any serious bodily harm to himself or somebody else. He flails his arms as he slides down the rather convenient chute. Somebody, Bofur, maybe, tries to grab at Bilbo’s jacket, but to no avail. Bilbo manages to right himself so that he’s sliding on his bottom rather than tumbling head-over-heels, though he knows he’s going to be nursing a nasty set of bruises for days to come. The last time, he’d been sore well into Mirkwood.
Someone slams into him from behind (Dori, Bilbo thinks) and actually does manage to get ahold of Bilbo just before they hit the ground. Is it called the ground in a goblin tunnel? Surely the ground is several hundred feet above them. But, then, they were on a mountain to begin with, which would imply that the ground is now several hundred feet below them. That thought makes Bilbo feel a little dizzy, and it doesn’t help that Dori just flipped them over midair so that the Hobbit would not be crushed in the fall. Very thoughtful fellow, that Dori. He did this same thing the last time, too.
“Terribly sorry,” Bilbo mutters, springing off of Dori as quickly as he can while the goblins begin to close in around them, muttering and hissing in their foul tongue. “Are you alright?”
“I’ve just fallen through a hole in the floor,” Dori points out. “I can’t say this is my best evening, Master Baggins.”
Before they can have any more such riveting conversations, the company is being prodded by goblins on all sides. The creatures are worse than Bilbo remembers. He’s never been terribly clear on the cultural differences between these goblins and proper orcs like Azog. He knows that the goblins of the Misty Mountains are smaller than most orcs, though both groups are equally violent and horrible, as far as he’s concerned. These goblins may not be working for Azog, and they may not be his allies yet, but they certainly will be by the time of the battle. Especially considering that Bilbo’s friends are about to kill the Great Goblin.
Bilbo decides to table that problem for the moment. He really will have to do more research, though. Absolutely abysmal that he managed to write a book in which goblins feature heavily without clarifying the terminology issue. He’d thought it irrelevant when he sat down to write, defaulting to the language most common in the Shire for the benefit of his fauntling audience, but perhaps that was the wrong decision. This is the problem with doing everything for a second time. Bilbo has questions now, for which he wants answers, and it distracts him from the task at hand. He almost misses the corner around which he is supposed to be slinking.
Bilbo knows what he has to do. As the company is driven away at the mercy of the goblins’ whips, Bilbo slips into the shadows, catching Nori’s eyes as he does. Good. Just like last time. Nori can tell the others what has become of Bilbo, once they all make it out of the mountain. It fills him with guilt, abandoning them all to their fates, but what else can Bilbo do? He can’t follow his friends, no matter how much he may want to. For one thing, he knows that his presence would change the logistics of the fight that they’re about to undertake. They made it out without him the last time, and it’s much wiser to trust that they’ll be able to do the same again than to introduce new variables and see how it pans out. They do not need his help.
And he can’t very well drag anybody down with him. Never mind that the fall itself will be dangerous. Who knows how Gollum would react to two intruders? And having a friend with him would change the interaction in unpredictable ways. It’s far better, Bilbo decides, to trust in his friends and undertake the meeting with Gollum alone, though he has no desire whatsoever to do so. He’d be perfectly happy to skip over this exchange altogether.
But he understands that the has no choice. Bilbo has to riddle with Gollum, because he has to pick up the ring, because he has to be invisible to fight the spiders and to help the company escape the Elves, not to mention the fact that his primary purpose here in the past is to destroy the One Ring. Bilbo wracks his brain to remember how he fell down into Gollum’s cave before. If he can remember the spot, maybe he can slide down more gracefully and avoid the bruises he incurred the first time he did this.
But of course things couldn’t be that simple. Before Bilbo can remember where and how he fell in the first time, there’s a goblin charging at him. Oh, yes. Now he remembers. That was how he got down to Gollum. Lovely.
Bilbo draws Sting and grapples with the goblin, trying to approximate the fighting style he would have used eighty years ago. Which is to say that he sort of stabs forward a little bit, taking little care with his aim, prioritizing blocking blows above landing them and hoping that his assailant will throw him in the same direction as last time. Once more, the goblin charges at him, and they topple together over the side of the rickety bridge and into the chasm below. Bilbo can only hope that he’s been pulled down into the same odd tunnel that he was in before. The goblin cushions his fall, but it isn’t so lucky as Dori, because it lands on some very hard and sharp rocks with Bilbo’s entire weight on top of it. It’s still alive, he thinks, but not for much longer.
He retreats to the shadows, hiding just out of sight in this dark and damp cavern, because that is what he distinctly remembers doing the last time. If he wants to escape with his life, then he’d better not make any last-minute changes. Certainly not for the sake of a goblin that would gladly have killed him, had their positions been reversed.
It only takes a moment for Gollum to make his presence known. Bilbo watches, from his obscure position, as the waif appears, pale and starving, to make a meal of the groggy goblin. If there was any doubt in his mind as to whether the goblin is still alive, it is completely quashed by the loud screeching that ensues. The first time around, Bilbo supposes, he was concerned that the noise would attract attention. He had no idea, then, where he was, who he was with, or what was going to happen. He’d been worried about his friends, as well. He didn’t know about the price on Thorin’s head, but he hadn’t needed to. After all, there were only thirteen of them facing off against what could only be thousands of goblins. That couldn’t have gone well, no matter how well-trained they were.
This time, however, Bilbo is distracted by something else. He keeps his eyes on Gollum and watches as the Ring flies out of the creature’s… pocket? Does Gollum have pockets, on that little rag he wears? He must. Or perhaps the very problem is that he does not. The writer in Bilbo could spend hours pondering the logistics of this. The Hobbit in Bilbo worries that his heart rate might accelerate to such a pace that the organ beats right out of his chest. Once he spots it, he cannot shift his gaze from the ring.
The pull is much weaker than he remembers it being, but it is present all the same. Bilbo has no physical connection to the ring now, but it is still a Ring of Power. It is still the One Ring. It is still calling out constantly to every being that gets close to it, eager to take hold of any mind it can get its hands on. And Bilbo would really rather leave it there. The ache of desperation in his gut unnerves him. He could put it on and have done with it. It would be so easy to slink out of these tunnels. Bilbo already knows the way. And easier still, to sneak up on Gollum and dispose of him now, to protect the world from his crimes. Are these his own thoughts? Or do they belong to the ring? The enemy? Is Bilbo using the dark magic he knows lurks here as an excuse to indulge the worst parts of himself?
The ring wants him to think this way, he understands. The ring wants him to distrust himself and his resolve. Bilbo did not comprehend Frodo’s stories when first he heard them, did not internalize them. By that point, his long years in Middle Earth had begun to catch up with him. Half the time, Bilbo couldn’t remember where he was or what he was doing. More than once, alone in Rivendell, he thought he was still on his adventure. He wandered out of his rooms in search of his companions, and became turned around in the halls of Elrond’s home when he did not encounter their makeshift campsite. He spoke to the air as though to members of the company, and the Elves apparently decided that he was too far gone for anyone to bother doing anything about it.
Bilbo was in no state, then, to understand the true power of the little ring. He could not comprehend its malice, its capacity to manipulate. He could not draw the parallel between the torments Frodo underwent and little voice that spoke inside his own mind sometimes, urging cruelty and selfish violence. Bilbo rarely ever acted on the suggestions of the little voice, and it had all but disappeared by the time he learned the ring’s true nature.
Bilbo does not know whether his decline had anything to do with the destruction of the ring itself. He does know that there were times when he could not remember that the ring was destroyed, when he forgot about what it really was, though he longed for it nevertheless. He remembers asking Frodo, on their journey West, whether he could see the cursed thing again. By this point, of course, Frodo had explained it to him many times, and every time, the story had distressed Bilbo to no end. To think that his little ring was responsible for so much pain, for hurting his own nephew, for nearly causing him to hurt his own nephew? Oh, it was unbearable.
But Bilbo must bear it now. He can’t just sit here looking at the ring. He needs it to get out of the tunnels, he reminds himself, and to save his company from the spiders and the Elves. He’ll need it when dealing with Smaug, and he needs to destroy it. If what Frodo once told him is true, the ring was trying to get away from Gollum in the first place. Who’s to say what kind of creature would pick it up next, if not for Bilbo? A goblin? An orc? For all he knows, it could be Azog the Defiler.
Bilbo does not have the luxury of refusing the ring. He does not get to choose for all of Middle Earth. He cannot shrug off the heavy cloak of duty, not just now. He may yet have peace, once the ring is gone, but for the moment, he has no choice but to take the thing and continue his adventure. So take it he does. He lunges forward and collects the ring, which is cool in his hands. It is not what he remembers.
The last time he held it, after his birthday party, in Bag End, the ring was warm and comforting. Thrumming, always thrumming, a soft murmur of incomprehensible voices. Powerful, yes, of course it was powerful. Bilbo remembers feeling as though he could take on just about anything, so long as he had his ring with him. He couldn’t bear to part with it. It was like a pair of arms forever wrapped around him, a perpetual piggy-back-ride for a power beyond his comprehension. It was as though he was wearing armor always, protected and cocooned, no matter how stretched or warped his mind became. Now, however, it is little more than a cool piece of metal.
It’s not any heavier than a regular ring, and it certainly doesn’t have anything to say. The ring is weaker now, Bilbo supposes, because its master is weaker. He never noticed as the power contained within the ring increased, but obviously, it must have done so, tucked away in the pocket of his waistcoat. It was a gradual process, and as the ring grew more powerful, its hold on Bilbo grew tighter. For now, though, Bilbo truly thinks that he could put it down if he needed to.
No, he couldn’t. He does need the ring to complete his quest, so its relative power and his relative reliance on it are both moot points. Bilbo briefly considers putting the ring on now, making himself invisible, and slinking out of the tunnels that way, but there are several problems with that plan. For one thing, he’s not entirely certain that he remembers the way out of the tunnels. It was eighty years ago, after all, and he was highly preoccupied, and to Bilbo’s Hobbit-y eyes, all these stalactites and stalagmites really just look the same. He’s not convinced that he’ll be able to navigate out of here without Gollum’s help.
Also, the issue of timing is not far from his mind. If Bilbo leaves too early, he may not be able to catch up with the company. He may get lost searching for them in the woods before they’re even out of the tunnels. He may come to the exit and find it blocked, because Gandalf and the company have not yet been through. He may find goblins down there. And if he comes out too early, there is always a chance that he could run into some hitherto unknown threat. There are orcs and wargs prowling these woods, after all, and for all he knows, they were lucky enough the last time to have missed a scouting party.
Yes, the Valar are on his side, but that does not mean that Bilbo should take unnecessary chances. He’s gotten past Gollum before, hasn’t he? And that all turned out fine. So, sighing, he steps out of the shadows and endures the whole rigamarole again. He riddles with Gollum, just like he did the first time, though now, he is much less frightened, because he knows almost exactly what will come to pass. Bilbo has told and re-told and written and re-written this conversation many times, so, at the very least, he remembers the riddles he used and how Gollum responded to them. And, of course, he remembers all of the answers to Gollum’s riddles.
It feels a bit unfair, tricking the poor creature with the ‘what have I got in my pocket’ question, but Bilbo decides that he would rather deal with the same sticky situation a second time than put himself in an even stickier situation by coming up with a different riddle. After all, Gollum might guess that, and then produce a new riddle that poor Bilbo has never heard before. It won’t do anybody any good if he gets eaten by that creature. And he’s already playing it fast and loose. He’s made one very significant change by refusing to give the creature his name. That way, even if he fails, nobody will ever come to the Shire to bother Frodo. Even if Gollum is tortured (poor creature, Yavanna save him) he won’t have any information to give up.
As expected, Gollum is not pleased with Bilbo’s victory, or the fact that Bilbo has stolen the ring. Which he has done. It wasn’t his to take, and he took it, took it from this poor, pathetic creature who has nothing else in the world. Bilbo does feel somewhat sorry about that, though it would by no means be a good thing if Gollum retained the ring. Bilbo puts the ring on and follows the creature, just as he did the last time. He loses just as many buttons, and if he’d had more, he’s certain he would lose more. Thanks to his provisions, Bilbo hasn’t lost as much weight on this journey as he did on his first go. He’s much healthier, which means that he has more energy and can move faster. A good trade off, especially considering that, being a Hobbit, he is still small enough to fit through most of the tight spaces he encounters. And, anyway, all that weight will fall off him in Mirkwood no matter how much food he stores away. He could carry Beorn’s larder on his back, and still the company would end up going hungry in those awful woods.
At the end of the tunnel, with Sting poised over Gollum’s neck, Bilbo hesitates. It would be so easy to end everything right now. He knows this creature’s future, after all. He knows that Gollum will spend decades wandering around in search of his Precious, alone and lonely and miserable and angry. He knows that eventually, the enemy’s forces will capture poor Gollum and do unspeakable things to him. And then, of course, Gollum will follow Frodo, who will show him kindness and pay the price for it. Ultimately, Gollum will do bodily harm to Bilbo’s beloved nephew before falling into a fire mountain and dissolving in the heat.
Wouldn’t it be kinder to prevent all of that misery now? Gandalf’s advice about mercy surely doesn’t apply when Bilbo knows exactly what Gollum will do to Bilbo’s own kin. He would only do it to protect Frodo. And Gollum’s life can’t be worth very much, anyway. He’s just going to suffer for another eighty years until he dies a painful death. Bilbo could save everyone a lot of trouble by getting rid of him right now. But, then, who is Bilbo to decide that one creature’s life is worth more than another’s? Who is Bilbo to decide who deserves life and who deserves death? Not to mention that, should Bilbo succeed, Gollum will never enact the horrible deeds that Bilbo remembers. He can’t punish this lonely, tortured person for crimes he might have committed under circumstances that will never come to pass.
So he spares Gollum once again, darts out of the tunnel just like he did the first time, and makes his way, only slightly shaken, over to the clearing where the company awaits him. Bilbo is so busy bracing himself for Thorin’s scathing words and unfounded accusations that he forgets, if only for a moment, what he knows will happen after.
Notes:
... Now that I think about it, the next chapter is going to be even angstier, so brace yourselves, I guess?
Chapter 5: Into the Fire
Notes:
Thanks as always for reading, commenting, and leaving kudos!
This chapter is... something. Suffice it to say that Bilbo does not react well upon meeting Azog again. Be warned that there is some violence, quite a bit of blood, and lots and lots of angst and grief and mourning. But there's also the scene on the Carrock, so you have that to look forward to, I suppose. Please enjoy!
Chapter Text
Thorin is unable to think straight as his company scrambles out of the Goblin tunnels. Moments ago, he was certain that they’d met their ends. He was afraid, terrified, paralyzed with fear at the thought of watching his sister-sons die. After that, Thorin figured, his own demise would be welcome. He does not think that he could go on, knowing that he’d caused harm to Fíli and Kíli. But then the Wizard arrived, and the company fought like Durin himself, reclaiming their weapons and taking advantage of the confusion caused by Tharkûn’s magic light.
It took you long enough, Thorin growled to the Wizard sometime during their escape. The twinkly-eyed smile he received in response was neither welcome nor appreciated.
They got past the goblins through some precarious blend of ingenuity and luck, and now they are clear of the Misty Mountains. No more thunder battles, no more odd caves, no more Hobbits dangling over ledges. Thorin does not know what to make of the conversation that he overheard between Master Baggins and Bofur, but he does know that he disapproves. Bofur has no business joking about receiving a favor from a Hobbit who obviously has no idea what connotations such a gift might carry in Dwarven culture. Thorin is not jealous. There is nothing for him to envy. The tightness in his chest at the thought of Master Baggins’s handkerchiefs in the pockets of his fellows must be some other breed of irritation.
It matters not. Everything Thorin does is the act of a king, and everything he says is effectively a royal decree. He is not only Thorin Oakenshield, but Thorin II, Son of Thráin, Son of Thrór, King Under the Mountain, as well. If he wishes to court, he must choose wisely, for his intended will, in effect, be courting the entire Kingdom of Erebor. Which feels foolish when at present there is no kingdom to speak of, only a distant mountain infested by a vile wyrm. And even were he not king, Thorin would not bother with such nonsense. He cannot handle another loss. Was he not resolved to avoid getting close to Master Baggins at all costs? He should not think of the Burglar as anything more than a mercenary. Courtship is entirely out of the question.
They reach a clearing, slowing to a stop. Plainly, they have not been followed. The goblins must be mourning their king, or worse, selecting a new one. Perhaps they are sounding the alarm for whatever allies they might have in these parts, sending out a signal that Thorin Oakenshield and his company have escaped their grasp.
The Wizard knows all sorts of odd passages in all sorts of odd places, and he has led them through one of these now. How he came by the details of this route, Thorin does not know and does not want to. Tharkûn-Gandalf-Mithrandir, is a strange creature bearing many names and many simultaneous errands. No doubt the Wizard was slinking around in the goblin tunnels as part of some scheme and only happened upon their company again out of chance. He was content to abandon them to the thunder battle, after all! There is no way that one so ancient and powerful could be oblivious to the hazards of the pass he sent them on.
Tharkûn conducts a head count, his finger twitching and his lips moving as he settles his gaze on each member of the company in turn. “Where’s Bilbo?” He murmurs, and suddenly, Thorin forgets his musings altogether. Louder, the Wizard demands, “Where is our Hobbit? Where is our Hobbit?”
Thorin cannot explain the feelings this question brings up. His head snaps to and fro as he glances frantically around for any sign of the Burglar. His chest tightens, his stomach sinks, and his boots, all of a sudden, seem to be filled with lead. Master Baggins is not with them.
“He’s a little fellow,” Glóin announces, as though he is an expert on the subject. “Easy enough to lose track of if you’re not careful. We should’ve had our eyes on him from the moment we fell. I thought he was with Dori!”
“Don’t blame me!” Dori yelps.
“Well, where did you last see him?” The Wizard attempts to steer the conversation in a more productive direction.
“I think I saw him slip away when they f—“ Nori begins, but Thorin cuts him off.
“He is still inside the Goblin tunnels.”
If he is alive. If he is even still alive. The thought that the Hobbit may not yet live makes Thorin’s chest constrict further. Oh, Mahal’s anvil! That hapless little creature would not have survived a confrontation with a single goblin, let alone an entire horde of them. And even if he hasn’t been confronted, he has been separated from his ridiculous pack. The Hobbit has no food, and he requires sustenance more frequently and in greater quantities than any creature that Thorin has ever known. If Master Baggins is still alive, he won’t be for much longer. He will starve to death in those tunnels. “We must return for him.”
“No, we mustn’t, laddie,” Glóin argues. “He’ll find his way out. We did.”
“There are thirteen of us,” Thorin reports, “Fourteen, counting the wizard, and we barely escaped. For our sake, he abandoned his soft bed and his warm hearth. No. We will not be leaving our Hobbit behind. He cannot be far!”
“Not we,” Dwalin protests, hand heavy on Thorin’s shoulder, offering comfort which is entirely undeserved. Thorin has failed yet again. There is more blood on his hands. Always more blood on his hands, no matter what he does. “You and the lads should stay behind with the rest of the company. The Wizard and I will go.”
Ah, yes. Thorin remembers this part well. His father, too, told him to stay behind and far from the worst of the fighting, to look after Frerin and keep him safe. Little Frerin, barely more than a child. But Thorin was proud, then, so certain of his own indestructibility. So certain that his brother would stay put when asked to do so, though Thorin refused to heed those same instructions. And how had that turned out? Thorin had been too late to save Thrór, and in his mad dash to avenge his grandfather, he’d lost track of Frerin and Thráin. One had died and the other had gone missing, and Thorin found himself, all of a sudden, the head of a bereaved family and of a people displaced. He will not make the same mistake again. He will not lose track of one of his own.
“That’s ridiculous!” Kíli protests, “Fíli and I have the best eyes here, and you all know we’re the fastest.” He speaks true.
“We’ll find Master Baggins quicker than you can, Dwalin,” Fíli agrees, “And if Thorin is staying, you should be the one to defend him. Anyway, no point keeping all the heirs in the same place. It’s better if we split up.” This, too, is true enough.
Thorin glances to Tharkûn. The Wizard shakes his head, and they come to a silent agreement. If Thorin’s sister-sons seem young to him, he cannot imagine what they must look like to Tharkûn, who has lived many lifetimes and seen many things.They are agreed, at least, that Fíli and Kíli should not be risked for this.
And Thorin can understand the logic of protecting himself, as well. He is dimly aware that were any other member of his company lost, save perhaps for his sister-sons, he would be perfectly content to send others back into the tunnels and use this time to marshal his forces and gather his wits. That is the kingly thing to do, after all.
“No. The Burglar is my responsibility,” Thorin resolves. “I must go.” This much he knows, deep in his soul.
“You must listen to Dwalin,” Balin advises, “You heard what that Great Goblin said. There’s a price on your head already. You shouldn’t go back, not now that we’ve gotten away.”
“I will go, Your Majesty,” Dori pipes in, “I should have lifted him onto my back when I had the chance. It is my fault that he isn’t with us now.”
Bifur protests vehemently against this, signing something along the lines of, Not your fault! You too were in the middle of a battle! The Hobbit did not know to look to you! As long as Thorin has known him, Bifur has struggled with the sort of quick speech necessitated by an argument such as this one. He plays to his strength, his agile crafting hands flying from word to word with practiced ease.
“We shouldn’t split the company up when we’ve just escaped,” Bombur reasons, “We know what’s behind us, and we have no clue what’s ahead of us.”
“Master Baggins is still trapped in that fell place,” Thorin growls, “I will not stand by while he suffers, alone and scared, and Mahal only knows what else!”
“No!” Comes a voice from somewhere in the trees. “No he’s not! Alone and scared, I mean.” Where just a moment ago, Thorin could have sworn there was nothing but thin air, Master Baggins materializes. He seems to flicker into existence all of a sudden, a round little Hobbit appearing from nowhere.
It must be the light and the relief playing tricks on Thorin. The Hobbit must have simply come out from behind a tree. “Mister Baggins!” Kíli yells, running up and throwing his arms around the Burglar. “We were just about to go back for you.”
“No, you weren’t,” Thorin tells his nephew sharply. “I was.”
He needs to make this clear. He does not want Fíli and Kíli thinking that they have won this argument, that they will ever win this argument. Thorin refuses to put his boys in danger when it can be avoided. Not after what happened during the thunder battle.
And furthermore, he wishes for the Hobbit to know that Thorin would be the one to take responsibility for him, to protect him. He will personally see to the safety of every member of his company. This fire in his chest cannot be envy. What concern is it of Thorin’s if Master Baggins wishes to embrace Kíli? The Hobbit slips out of Kíli’s grip and is immediately scooped up into Fíli’s arms. Thorin decides that the wisest course of action is to look away.
Besides, it is true, what Master Baggins guessed in the cave. Thorin did not mean what he said before they made their camp. He would not have the Hobbit thinking that he has no place among them, or even that the leader of their company believes as much. Master Baggins is odd, and Thorin would not accuse him of bearing any skill with that knife of his (he still insists upon calling it a sword!), but the Hobbit has proven his loyalty and devotion. If he did not believe Thorin to be a fine king, he’d never have said as much.
Or, perhaps Thorin only wishes to believe that Master Baggins approves of him. Why? He has no reason to seek the approval of one so strange. He has no reason to seek the approval of anyone at all! And yet, here he is.
“You all thought I was lost in the goblin tunnels,” Master Baggins grins. His teeth are straight and well cared-for, his lips a fine shape. His skin glows golden from time spent in the sun. “And you were bickering about who’d have the honor of saving me?”
“Yes,” Ori agrees, ever honest. “That’s exactly what happened.”
“Well, in all the time you wasted doing that,” the Burglar announces, “I managed to save myself. Though I did lose a few buttons along the way. Dreadful, really, and I didn’t even think to stop and pick them up! Such a terrible thing to happen to my favorite waistcoat! I should never have brought it. And I knew this was coming, too! Why didn’t I bring something more practical? That old brown one would’ve done just fine, no matter what I may have looked like. I’m sure I make a pretty picture now!” Yes, he does.
Thorin is pleased to learn that his Hobbit at least as some basic survival instincts, though this joy is tempered by the discussion of waistcoats. “Are you injured?”
Master Baggins blinks at him. “No,” he replies, allowing the word to trail off into silence as though he is expecting Thorin to say more. “Aren’t you going to ask me why I came back?” The Hobbit inquires when the silence becomes uncomfortable.
Thorin considers this strange question. “Why would I ask that? You have proven several times that you will not leave us, even when it’s in your best interests to do so.” It stings a little to think that his burglar doubts him so. “Though of course, we would not have abandoned you in those tunnels.”
Master Baggins scrunches up his nose as though he is working through a particularly difficult puzzle. The expression suits him. Apparently, Thorin’s words were a shock to the Hobbit, which makes little sense. Has Thorin not proven himself to be an honorable king? Has he not made it clear that he is personally responsible for every member of his company, even those fools who go rushing off to place themselves in danger? Evidently not.
Balin, thankfully, has the sense to interrupt whatever is taking place between Thorin and his Burglar. “I must say, Bilbo, you’re the first person ever to get past my lookout. How did you ever manage that?”
Before the Hobbit can begin to explain, Bofur cuts in. “He slipped past while you were busy nagging His Majesty, of course. Wouldn’t’ve gotten past you if you’d been facing the right way, there, Balin.”
“He makes a good point,” Thorin concedes.
“Aye,” says Óin, though Mahal only knows how he heard Thorin’s mumbling. Perhaps he’s responding to Bofur’s exclamation, which would be difficult even for one with Óin’s poor hearing to miss. “If you’d not been arguing against the will of our mighty king, you’d have seen the wee Hobbit sneaking past.”
“I doubt it,” Master Baggins chirps. His left hand is poised just outside his pocket, as though he dares not slip it in but knows nothing else to do with it. So very comely, but so very strange. That much, at least, has not changed during his brief separation from the company. “I can be very sneaky when I need to be. Isn’t that what you hired me for? Now, if you don’t mind, I’d like something to eat before we start running again. Does anyone have anything on them?”
He sounds awfully sure that they’ll be on the move again in short order, but Thorin doesn’t get a chance to press any further on this matter, because the moment he opens his mouth, he is interrupted by an awful howl that chills him to the bone. Wargs. Several of them, if the responding howls are anything to go on.
“Out of the frying pan,” Thorin huffs.
“And into the fire,” the Wizard, annoyingly, takes it upon himself to finish the turn of phrase.
“So much for elevensies,” says Master Baggins. His terror is palpable despite his best efforts to conceal it. “We’d best be off.”
Thorin, at least, can agree with that sentiment. “Run!” He orders. None of his companions need to be told twice.
Bilbo knows exactly what’s about to happen, of course. He was distracted from this inevitability by his conversation with Gollum, by the active recall necessary to escape with his life. Then, he was distracted by the ring on his finger, and the oddness of the exchange with Thorin when Bilbo finally caught up to the company.
The first time, Thorin was convinced that Bilbo had abandoned them at the earliest opportunity, and he hadn’t been entirely incorrect. Bilbo’s initial plan, as expressed quite clearly to Bofur, had been to abandon the company and return to Rivendell. He’d felt scorned, and overcome with self-doubt, and Elrond had offered him solace before the company departed. It all made perfect sense. Thorin was baffled by Bilbo’s return, and, Bilbo now suspects, the lack of control engendered by his imperfect understanding of the Hobbit caused no small degree of irritation for the king.
This time, however, Thorin seemed baffled by the implication that he might question Bilbo’s motives. Which, no doubt, Bilbo would happily spend a good few hours unpacking, were he not running for his life. Cocky words aside, Bilbo understands the danger that they face better than anybody else does. He is conscious of his place within the company, who’s around him as he tries to reconcile this sensory data with his memory of who was near to him before. This proves more difficult than he would have thought. The first time, Bilbo was too distracted by the wargs on his tail to worry much about where he was relative to his friends.
Now, Bilbo is distracted by the racing of his heart. He cannot settle his thoughts. He cannot stop his limbs from trembling as he forces his tired legs to run onward, dodging wargs and the fights that engage his companions. He does not know the last time he ate, nor the last time he slept, but it does not matter now. He’ll run or die. And he can’t die, not when the fate of Middle Earth sits in his pocket and the fate of the Line of Durin rests in his hands. Bilbo must keep his wits about him. Only he feels that he may vomit, and his legs are buzzing, and his head spins at an impossible speed.
Thorin dispatches a warg with Orcrist. Gandalf swings his staff and knocks a few of their assailants aside. Bilbo knows that the orcs are only biding their time, setting their beasts on the company to tire them out before the actual challenge takes place. He does not think before joining the fray. The last time, Bilbo was unsure, unaware of how to defend himself from the wargs. Now, he slashes with Sting, fending off a few of the beasts, though it would take too much of his strength to actually kill one. He cannot help but notice the way the others leap to his defense.
Glóin steps between Bilbo and an oversized warg, and while the creature is distracted, Bifur finishes it off. Ori shoots one in the eye with a rock at close range, and though the beast does not die, it whimpers and steps back, giving Bilbo a chance to weave away. Fíli throws a knife that lands in the neck of a warg, and seems inclined to retrieve the weapon, before Balin grabs him by the arm and drags him away. Good. At least one member of the company has some sense. For his own part, Bilbo feels the sudden urge to dry-heave. Because he alone knows what is coming.
Once again, the Wizard leads them to a grove of fir trees overlooking a cliff. There is no other option. The orcs and their wargs have herded the company here on purpose. There is no escape, or, at least, none that Azog can foresee. “Up into the trees!” Gandalf orders. “All of you! Come on, climb!”
Even with his foreknowledge, Bilbo is unprepared for the warg that comes after him next. Reflexively, he stabs it with Sting, burying his sword in its brain. The creature’s end is quick, thank Yavanna, and when it falls to the ground, Bilbo is left to struggle with the blade. He has a distinct recollection of doing this the first time around, as well. “Hurry, Master Baggins!” Thorin yells. He’s already gotten himself up into a tree, as have the rest of the company. “More are coming!”
“I can see that!” Bilbo snaps, all nerves. He’s not going to stand there like a lamb in the road, the way he did the last time. And yet, seeing all those wargs coming, he doubts himself.
Bilbo really should have done something. Couldn’t he have warned the others, rather than leaning against a tree and acting all smug about his relative utility? No. He couldn’t have. Thorin may feel differently about him this time around, at least at this juncture, but no revolutionary change has taken place. If Bilbo had attempted to steer the company elsewhere, he’d surely have started an argument with the king or the Wizard or both at once. Then, they all would’ve gotten their throats ripped out by wargs. But, even so. Bilbo could have come forward earlier. He did not need to spend so long lurking in the shadows, listening to his companions’ conversation. It’s just that he was utterly mesmerized by Thorin’s insistence upon rescuing the Burglar. That certainly didn’t happen the last time.
“This way, Master Baggins.” Dori urges, ripping him from his thoughts. “You must climb!”
Bilbo must look horrible. He must be shaking. Azog the Defiler is coming this way. The monster from Bilbo’s nightmares is coming this way. “Up you go,” Bofur encourages him with a false smile, which Bilbo cannot even bring himself to return as he scrambles over the branches. He has no choice.
It is the same tree again, because once more, Bilbo is the last of the company to make it to this place. He might be faster, were he in better condition, but as it stands, he can barely stand. His stomach is a pit which threatens to implode or overflow with bile. His hands are useless, jittering. His mind is a mess. Bilbo can barely sort out where he is right now, can only gag on air as the orcs approach.
Yes, they’ve fallen out of the frying pan and into the fire, but at least Bilbo can expect the metaphorical fork of an Eagle’s talons to scoop him up with minimal burning. Still, the writhing in his guts intensifies at the thought that he’s just led Thorin to a serious injury. Because last time, Bilbo could be excused for allowing this to happen. This time, however, Bilbo knows. He knows that Thorin will challenge Azog, that there is nothing he can do to stop it. He knows what the warg will do to their king. He knows the expression on the pale orc’s face, smug and gloating. Bilbo knows all of it, but can do nothing to prevent it from happening a second time
And, as the small rational voice clinging on for dear life inside his mind is only too happy to remind him, it would not be wise for Bilbo to alter the sequence of events by intervening earlier. Azog might kill him, and then where would he be? Or, even worse, Azog could see him coming and….
As expected, Azog makes his presence known, leading his warg mount forward at a leisurely place. “Azog,” Thorin breathes, shocked.
Right. Until this moment, he believed Azog to be long dead. The pale orc delivers what is sure to be a very threatening little speech in his own tongue, which seems a bit counterintuitive to Bilbo. After all, none of the company could possibly understand it, save, perhaps Gandalf. Though if Bilbo put the ring on… he would know everything that Azog was saying, wouldn’t he? Just as he could understand the spiders, just as Frodo could understand the orcs in Mordor, Bilbo could understand the words of Azog the Defiler. He could use this knowledge to protect his friends.
“It cannot be,” says Thorin. And who is Bilbo, to have kept this information from him? To have led him here? To have allowed him to face this threat once again?
Azog shouts, something unseemly, no doubt, and the wargs charge forwards, pawing at the trunks of the trees and snapping their jaws at the members of the company. Nobody does anything. Why does nobody do anything? Bilbo shakes with rage. A few extra moments would not have helped them. They’d only end up cornered here on this ridiculous cliff once again. The trees tip, one by one, forcing Bilbo’s friends to leap to the one fir that remains standing, right on the edge of the cliff. Just like last time. Exactly like last time.
Azog cackles. Bilbo hates him. Never in all his life has he felt such disgust, such anger, such terror. Never in all his life has he wanted so badly to harm another living creature. Hobbits are a gentle and peaceful folk, but perhaps that’s because they do not, as a rule, have their loved ones murdered by orc lords. All Bilbo can see is Thorin’s eyes, blank, staring at nothing. All he can feel is a cold hand clutched in his own. And Azog has the nerve to laugh.
A flaming fir cone falls into Bilbo’s hands. Right. Bilbo doesn’t have time to waste on the horrific images that he’s repressed for eighty years. He’s got to stay present in this fight, because he’s got to win it, for Thorin’s sake and the sake of the company. Bilbo has to do everything exactly as he did it before, which didn’t seem like such a major challenge at all when he was making his to-do list in Bag End. He wrote about this, after all.
He thought he’d been reliving his adventure over and over again for eight decades, but he was wrong. He did not mention this part. He implied that they just sat in the trees waiting for rescue, listening to a scary song. He did not write about the feeling of plunging his sword into the body of another being, of taking a life. He did not write about standing in front of Thorin, motionless on the ground, fearing that the king was dead. Now, he forces himself to stay aware of Thorin’s every movement, even as Bilbo throws down flaming cones at the orcs and wargs.
At first, the orcs hiss and grumble amongst themselves; the wargs howl and yelp. It looks as though the company is winning. But Bilbo cannot join in the cheer. He can do nothing but force air into and out of his lungs as the tree begins to fall, until it is nothing more than an extension of the cliff. Ori loses his grip on the branch he’s been perched upon and falls, clinging for dear life to his eldest brother’s legs. Then, the orcs seem to cheer up a bit. More of that horrible laughter, more of that horrible speech.
Nothing they are saying is anything like the little tune Bilbo composed for his book about fifteen birds in five fir trees. It makes him sick to his stomach, which he’s certain is the intended effect. Or perhaps the illness comes from watching Thorin set his shoulders as he makes his inevitable decision: he will go out and face the Defiler. Bilbo is going to vomit. He’s going to combust. He throws his last fir cone and it hits a warg, but that means nothing, nothing at all. One orc incapacitated for a moment will not change what is to come.
Bilbo knows by now that Thorin has never taken anything laying down. If there’s an opportunity for a fight, Thorin will leap to it, even if wiser folk might deem the odds insurmountable. There was never any chance of Thorin hanging back and letting the orcs taunt the company. This time, Bilbo is ready, prepared to spring into action when he’s needed. He forces himself to wait, though his limbs are twitching with the need to leap down and rush to Thorin’s aid.
The king steps forward, walking across the broken trunk of the tree with determination. Bilbo focuses on his hair, long and lovely, even after the storm and the fall and the trip through the goblin tunnels. He focuses on the way that Thorin grips his sword, the tight hold he keeps on the shield that gave him his name. They got through this before. Thorin lived through this before. Bilbo cannot prevent this. He must allow Thorin to act. He cannot steal this moment from him. He cannot become a distraction for Thorin, not here, not now.
Azog has not taken his eyes off of Thorin. Oh, but it would be so easy! Bilbo knows now what the ring can do. He could slip out of this tree, entirely unseen. He could go up to Azog and stab him in the gut with Sting. No, worse. Bilbo could do worse. He wears a Ring of Power, does he not? Could he not use that power to destroy the orc, slowly and painfully? It is all that the bastard deserves. Better than he deserves, actually.
Bilbo would take his time. He would draw it out. He’d go as slowly as possible, and the power of the ring could help him. Could keep the other orcs at bay. Bilbo would make them watch, would make them see what happens to meddling creatures who dare to lay their hands on his beloved. He’ll make Azog beg him for death. The ring has the power to do all of this, and it is at Bilbo’s command, and that would solve his problem, wouldn’t it? There would be no Ravenhill to speak of if only Bilbo could put a stop to it now.
No. No. No, absolutely not. Bilbo cannot take that risk. He has not only his friends to think of but Middle Earth as well. He’s got to destroy the ring, and if he tries to do it that way, who knows the kind of grip that it could get on him? Thorin survived this last time because Bilbo defended him. Would he still survive whatever awful power Bilbo might release upon the orcs? Would Bilbo himself survive? Thorin is so close to Azog now. Bilbo is losing time. He must go. He must help. He must do something.
Thorin breaks into a run, and Azog spurs his warg on in turn. The beast knocks the king to the ground easily, so easily. The pale orc draws back, circling, giving Thorin time to sit up. Because how could a single sword and a wooden shield defend anyone against the wrath of an entire pack of wargs, led by a contingent of warrior orcs? Thorin is alone down there. Time will not help him.
Not yet. Not yet. Not yet. Bilbo must do exactly what he did before. He cannot stop thinking about that icy day on Ravenhill, cannot stop remembering over and over again a scene he did not witness. He has no idea how Azog killed Thorin, let alone how Thorin killed Azog. For the first few days, all he could do was torture himself, trying to imagine the logistics of it all. The sword tearing through all that armor into the tender flesh of his beloved. Bilbo gags. He can’t help it. It’s just as bad as it has been every night at camp, only worse, because now Bilbo knows that the danger is real. Azog’s mace strikes a mighty blow to Thorin’s chest, and Bilbo feels himself moving into the fray before he realizes what is happening.
He forgets his plan to wait, to hesitate just as he did when he was still unsure of whether he might be prepared to die for Thorin. He forgets all about the ring and his mission and his list of five tasks. Now, Bilbo knows that he would give his life for Thorin in a heartbeat. That he will give his life for Thorin right this minute, if he has to. Bilbo can see nothing but Thorin, bleeding, picked up and shaken between the jaws of a warg, and nothing else matters.
“Almost there, my love,” Bilbo snarls. Such sweet words he has never allowed himself to speak, said now in such a foul tone. Thorin will live. Thorin must live.
Bilbo is vaguely aware of shouting behind him, but he can’t make out what anyone is saying, can’t even parse what language they’re speaking. It may as well all be Khuzdul, for how little he comprehends. He’s unaware of the ground beneath his feet; it feels as though he’s floating on air, carried by a vengeful wind, faster than before, desperate. His body becomes the weapon, an extension of Sting, a projectile. Bilbo does not need to push himself because every fiber of his being is in perfect, harmonious agreement: protect Thorin at all costs.
He keeps seeing Thorin dead, laying on that ice. The great blood stain beneath him, all over his clothes, and all over Bilbo, too. His hands, his coat, his face. Because he refused to believe that Thorin was gone until he confirmed that he could not hear a heartbeat, and even then, he kept talking to him, kept begging him to stay, as though he might hear and turn around, deferring his journey to the halls of his Maker. Bilbo kissed him, only on the forehead, in the manner of Hobbits, as was perfectly appropriate following a death. The skin was cold. Thorin’s hand had carried the imprints of Bilbo’s tight grip even at the funeral. Nobody said a word.
Still, Bilbo begged. Begged as he had never done before and has never done since. He pleaded with the Valar. He offered his own life in exchange for Thorin’s, any service he could possibly give, so senseless was he with grief. All that blood. What a stupid, useless waste, and there was nothing Bilbo could do to fix it. Nothing anyone could do but throw together the funeral arrangements and go home to the safety of the Shire, where there was never any battlefield to get slaughtered upon.
Azog delivers an order, and another orc dismounts, steps toward Thorin with blade raised. But the Hobbit is already there. Bilbo wails, cries, screams, releases the sound of grief and rage that has been living in his body since Ravenhill. He drives Sting into the neck of the orc meters away from Thorin, who is laying on the ground, covered in blood. Dead.
Dead again, and Bilbo was too late. Dead, as he always was; this must only be a dream, because Bilbo watched Thorin die, and how could anyone come back to life after having bled out? Dead on the ice, dead on the grass, dead on a stone slab. Bilbo stabs the orc again, spattering its blood all over his face. The stuff tastes foul, but he repeats the motion once more and pulls back, panting. Bilbo rises, Sting twitching to and fro in his vibrating hands.
Azog has the nerve to laugh. He says something else in that awful tongue of his. The other orcs seem to find this uproariously funny. How funny will it be for them when their leader has Sting buried in his neck? An order is delivered.
The Hobbit has no clue why he is not dead yet, why he has been permitted to carry out his little production. And he does not care. If the orcs wish to underestimate him, they will do so at their peril. Next, he will kill Azog the Defiler. Slowly, painfully, brutally. He will have vengeance. If he cannot have Thorin, if he cannot keep his king safe, cannot keep the lads safe, then at the very least he will have this.
Bilbo rushes forward, keeping his own small body between the orc and the king. This is the creature that killed Thorin. Bilbo will not allow the orc to survive. He drives his sword into the snout of the Warg the pale orc mounts. Azog looks shocked, for one brief moment. He must have expected Bilbo to lay down in despair and wait for the creature to gobble him up. Bilbo yanks with all his might, unable to withdraw Sting from the head of the warg as Azog raises his mace. Bilbo scrambles backwards in the nick of time as the orc slides off his falling mount.
The other wargs are closing in. Bilbo positions himself between Thorin and the orc, though now he has no weapon to speak of. He will die, then. He will fail once more. But he has failed already. He does not need to turn around to see Thorin laying on the ice behind him, dead. So close to his home, reclaimed, empty, waiting for him, but it did not matter in the end. And the poor princes, barely more than children, murdered by this evil orc and his wicked son.
“You will not touch him!” Bilbo screams, vicious. A tone that he has never used before, never needed to. He is no longer a respectable Hobbit, only a vague assemblage of grief and terror and rage. Azog advances, mace raised. Bilbo picks up a stone, prepared to make use of his prodigious throwing skills. Even if he can’t protect himself, he can at least go down protecting Thorin. “Stay back!”
And then Bilbo is on the ground with something heavy laying over him. He fights furiously, throwing his elbows, trying to reach Sting. The blade is too far away.
“Thorin lives,” A familiar voice. Kíli. But Kíli has been dead for eighty years. Bilbo saw him, dead on the ice, dead on the stone slab. And yet he can feel how warm the lad is, how vital, how utterly and completely alive as he shelters Bilbo with his body. Bilbo stills, then, breathing heavily. Kíli eases off of him with surprising grace. “We must defend him!”
The whole exchange takes only a few seconds, and Bilbo struggles to understand what has happened. Kíli hauls him to his feet, pushes Bilbo behind him. He drags the Hobbit toward the fallen warg and frees Sting with a single tug. The blade is a mess. So much blood. That is another thing Bilbo did not write about: the blood. “Master Baggins, go!” Kíli urges, passing Sting to Bilbo. Somehow, unbeknownst to the Hobbit, this has become a proper battle.
Fíli, Nori, and Dwalin have engaged Azog and driven him back, forcing him away from Bilbo. They must have mounted their attack just after Kíli knocked Bilbo out of the way, which was very good thinking, indeed. Those members of the company who have been able to get out of the trees are fighting the orcs off, keeping them far from Thorin, but Bilbo is needed as the last line of defense. Only a few moments until the Eagles arrive. But the Eagles are always too late. Bilbo is still trembling, ready to drive his blade through the eye of anyone who even dreams of touching his king.
He rushes to Thorin, and Kíli covers him, drawing his bow, firing expertly at the orcs and somehow managing to avoid shooting the other members of the company. Bilbo would be impressed if he weren’t so preoccupied. Thorin is right there, so close, his shield having rolled away from him and his sword still clutched in his hand. Bloody. Breathing. Breathing. Bilbo watches their leader’s chest rise and fall in ragged disarray. This is not Ravenhill. Or maybe it is.
Bilbo remembers doing this before, running to Thorin’s side, watching with naive hope as the king drew breath. In and out, shaky and violent, but Bilbo had taken it to mean that Thorin would survive. And he had not. He died in Bilbo’s arms. His blood stained Bilbo’s clothes and his mind and his soul. And now it is happening again; it is all happening again; Bilbo has failed once more because he is weak and unworthy. Because once again, he was not fast enough. He falls to his knees with a loud sob. Dead. Thorin Oakenshield is dead.
“On your feet!” Kíli orders, hauling Bilbo back up before loosing another arrow. This one falls short of its mark, hitting a tree instead, and Bilbo stands still, on the verge of another collapse. “We fight!” Kíli follows this with a Khuzdul phrase, vaguely familiar, a battle cry. His next arrow finds its home in the forehead of an orc.
Thorin is already dead. Thorin has been dead for eighty years. Bilbo cannot force himself to breathe. And then an Eagle swoops down from above and catches Thorin, ever so gently, in its talons. “The eagles are coming,” Bilbo whispers. “Thorin, the eagles.” Exactly what he said the last time, and what good did it do then?
“Leave him alone!” Kíli roars at the Eagle.
Bilbo sobs. He is in no position to comfort anybody, but he has no choice. He doesn’t get to fail. He doesn’t get to resign himself to despair. Kíli is still very much alive, and Thorin is breathing, and, Bilbo reminds himself this is not Ravenhill. This is not Ravenhill. This is not Ravenhill.
Bilbo looks around him and sees his friends fighting tooth and nail. Those who could get out of the trees to fight have done so, but where are Dori and Ori? Gandalf? And what can Bilbo do for any of them? What can Bilbo do but stand and watch? He may be covered in blood, but he has proven that there is nothing he can do to prevent the horrors he has endured from coming, once again, to pass. Nothing is different. Nothing has changed.
“Hush,” he says, voice creaky, torn asunder by his earlier scream. “They’re friends, Kíli. The Eagles, they’re our friends.” Seeing what’s coming, Bilbo steps away from Kíli, giving the Eagles more space to safely lift the two of them to safety. His legs nearly give out as he does so.
Bilbo goes completely slack as an Eagle grabs him, then, and drops him onto the back of one of its comrades. Kíli does not seem particularly pleased about being picked off the ground and tossed around, Bilbo notes, but at least he does not attempt to stab at the Eagle with his sword. For his part, Bilbo cannot look away from Thorin. Even as the Eagles carry them over rolling green hills, past waterfalls and splendid trees, Bilbo keeps his eyes on the king.
A few of the others call out to their leader, but the Hobbit does not bother. He knows that, just like last time, Thorin will not respond. Bilbo tries to use logic to comfort himself: yes, this fight was different from the original, yes, Bilbo’s timing was all wrong, but that should not have changed anything for Thorin, because he was already on the ground when Bilbo charged at Azog. The Eagles must have showed up at the exact same time as they did when this battle last took place. And they still have Gandalf with them; he can still heal Thorin when the time comes.
But Bilbo’s heart refuses to listen to his head. It is an active struggle to stay away from Ravenhill and the days that followed, to keep the pain at bay as Bilbo is carried to safety. He is not severely injured, but he is covered in orc blood. His breathing is rough, labored, and he is trembling something awful. When the Eagle finally sets him down on solid ground, Bilbo does not hesitate to rush toward his love.
Bilbo wants nothing more than to shove Gandalf out of the way and check that his beloved is breathing. Thorin is just laying there, his back pressed to the stone just as it was at his funeral. Bilbo can’t stop seeing him, face waxy, eyes closed, hands posed deliberately. The company carried out Dwarven funeral rites about which Bilbo had not asked, too preoccupied was he with sobbing and lamenting and blaming himself. If he’d gotten to Ravenhill faster, Fíli would have been spared and could have protected Kíli. Thorin would not have been so flippant with his own life if he’d believed that his sister-sons still lived.
That is not true. Thorin died believing that Kíli was alive. Bilbo could have saved the lads, had he been faster, yes. But that would not have helped Thorin. Nothing would have helped Thorin save sticking a sword through Azog’s heart, and Bilbo has missed his chance to do so. The next time he sees the orc, it will be too late. And that, too, is Bilbo’s fault. Just like every other horrid thing.
Bilbo forces himself to stand back and let the Wizard work. He reminds himself that this is not that part of the journey, this is too early, he did everything right. He did everything he was supposed to, and the Valar have favored him, and he was promised more time with Thorin. Galadriel showed him visions of Erebor, himself and Thorin and the lads in Erebor. So it will not end here. It isn’t happening again. Still, Bilbo cannot calm his breathing, not even as Fíli’s hand comes down on his shoulder, light and comforting. Sweaty, though, and nearly as twitchy as Bilbo’s own hands are at the moment.
Knowing that the prince is present and alive helps Bilbo nevertheless. “Steady, Master Baggins,” Fíli counsels, his voice strained. “Thorin will be alright. Gandalf knows what he’s doing.”
“He’s fine,” Kíli agrees, materializing off to the side. “He’ll be fine.” Though he sounds rattled, and he looks pale.
This certainly did not happen before. Bilbo had thought that he was close with Fíli and Kíli the first time around, but now, it’s clear to him that they were holding back. By giving them his trust and his care, by sharing his food with them, by laughing at their jokes, Bilbo has proven himself as a friend, and they both seem resolved to look after him. Oh, by the Valar! Kíli saved Bilbo’s life a moment ago, and Bilbo didn’t even say ‘thank you.’ And he must have elbowed the poor boy more than once, with all his thrashing and struggling! Where are Bilbo’s manners?
But then Gandalf finishes his ministrations, and Thorin stirs, and Bilbo forgets that the two of them are not alone together in this place.
Thorin is breathing. That simple fact makes Bilbo stagger with relief, his sore muscles catching up with him. Every fiber of his being, now, seems to be rebelling in protest against all the running and leaping and being tackled to the ground. But Thorin is alive. Bilbo watches as the king’s chest rises and falls, and then, to his immense relief, Thorin sits up. “Master Baggins?” He asks, sounding just a little bit frantic. Last time, he had asked after the Halfling. Clearly, he has learned his lesson on the score.
“It’s alright. Bilbo is here. He’s quite safe,” Gandalf assures Thorin. That seems a bit premature, considering Bilbo is covered in orc blood and trembling like a leaf, but he supposes that compared to Thorin, yes, he is fine. A few sore muscles will mend in no time, and his clothes can be washed.
Thorin pushes Gandalf aside and rises, making his way over to Bilbo in a few quick strides. That seems inadvisable, in his condition. Bilbo remembers well the last time that they had this conversation. He remembers Thorin confronting him, outright yelling at him, saying some very rude things, before contradicting himself with a smile and pulling the Hobbit into a hug.
Bilbo braces himself, but there is no yelling whatsoever. Thorin throws his arms around Bilbo far too early, and Fíli steps back, allowing the Hobbit to collapse a little into Thorin’s embrace. He smells of smoke, of blood, of earth, of battle, and under all of that, he smells of himself. Bilbo cannot help but cling to him, cannot help but breathe in their leader’s scent. He feels as though he has finally come home, more than he did in Bag End. He feels as though the story has ended, as though everything has come full circle. Oh, yes, this is worth reliving everything for. Bilbo never, in his long years of life, would have expected to be granted the opportunity to hold Thorin in his arms once again.
Of course, after a time, Thorin pulls away, and Bilbo reluctantly lets him go. “Do not do anything so foolish ever again, Master Burglar,” Thorin advises, with his typical blunt formality. Well, Bilbo can’t have expected that his kindness would produce any monumental change. Things are different, sure, but Thorin has still endured the same lifetime of hardship. “You won’t always be so lucky.”
Unfortunately, Bilbo, too, is still the same Hobbit that he always was. He’s not one to take orders, especially not ridiculous ones from monarchs who could learn to take their own advice. “I’ll do plenty more foolish things, Thorin Oakenshield,” he promises, “If it keeps you from getting yourself killed.”
Thorin looks into Bilbo’s eyes. His expression is complex, warm and cold at once, holding years of pain along with whatever affection and hope he’s managed to muster up over the course of their journey together. Bilbo must remind himself that though he has known Thorin for eight decades, Thorin has known him for only a few months. “I owe you my life,” the king murmurs. Ever so gently, he brushes his thumb across Bilbo’s cheek, wiping away the blood. Smearing it, probably.
It’s all very dramatic, but Bilbo is not interested in any form of debt. Even the first time around, he’d have jumped in front of an orc to defend any member of the company. Now, he’d do it without hesitation. “Don’t be ridiculous,” Bilbo scolds him, “You owe me absolutely nothing.”
They stay that way for a moment, studying one another, much closer together than would be considered necessary in polite society. Bilbo isn’t quite certain whether this counts as a standoff or not, but whatever it is, it is charged. He wants to kiss Thorin, or to push him away and scream at him for being so reckless, for scaring Bilbo so much. He wants to break down crying, to grab Thorin by the hand and lead him back to the Blue Mountains where he can be safe. He wants to charge toward Erebor and take it back to see the glow in Thorin’s eyes as they come home.
“Alright, that’s enough,” Óin announces with typical gusto. Apparently, their resident healer has gotten tired of watching the emotional exchange. “Both of you, go sit down so I can look at you.”
“I’m fine,” Bilbo assures him, at the same time that Thorin grits out, “That is not necessary.” Still, Thorin steps away from Bilbo, suddenly conscious of their many spectators.
“I won’t hear it,” Óin declares, and he seems to mean it, too, because his trumpet is a mangled mess. “You, laddie,” he gestures at Bilbo, “Can barely stand up, and you,” he turns his attention to Thorin, “Are lucky to be alive at all, my King. You are both in serious need of medical attention.”
Thorin grumbles about this, but Bilbo cuts him off. “He’s right, you know. I didn’t save your life so you could throw it away again for lack of care. Since you won’t look after yourself, it’s down to Óin and I.”
The King rolls his eyes. “As you wish,” he huffs, as though it is some great hardship to have his wounds seen to. “Though you are also injured.” Ah. He’s being self-sacrificing, then, and implying that Bilbo should be looked at first.
“Cheer up,” Bilbo orders. “I’m perfectly alright.” Well, aside from the ache in his side, the twinge in his shoulder, the wobble in his step, and those few minutes where all sense abandoned him and he attempted to face Azog the Defiler with only a throwing stone for a weapon. But Bilbo is no stranger to aches and pains, and though he may be covered in blood, not a drop of it is his own. Óin should see to Thorin first. “And look behind you. There’s your Erebor, waiting up ahead.”
The thing is that Bilbo is still, perhaps, not thinking straight. If he’d been in his right mind, he would’ve realized that pointing out the silhouette of Erebor on the horizon would have a profound effect on the entire company.
“Oh, bless me,” Bofur mutters, “That really is the Lonely Mountain.”
“Aye,” says Balin with palpable reverence, “That it is.”
“Erebor,” Dori breathes, gripping Ori’s hand. Shockingly, Nori joins their little huddle, taking Dori’s other hand without comment.
“Our home,” Thorin murmurs.
Bifur whispers something reverent in Khuzdul, and not for the first time, Bilbo wishes he could understand. “Strength, cousin,” Bombur counsels. “Strength.”
A bird flits by, just as it did the last time. Bilbo wonders absently if it is indeed the same bird. “A raven!” Óin exclaims, apparently having forgotten all about his wounded king. Yes this is a significant moment and all, but there are other relevant concerns as well! “The birds are returning to the mountain!”
“That, my dear Óin, is a thrush,” Gandalf observes mildly. He, too, seems to have forgotten about Thorin’s many injuries. Honestly. It’s a wonder they ever managed to get to Erebor at all, the first time around. Bilbo is the only person here with even a lick of common sense.
“But we’ll take it as a sign,” Thorin says, turning to Bilbo with a small smile. “A good omen.” Oh, the joy in those brilliant blue eyes of his! The love for his home which shines so brightly, the hope that the journey from this point will be smooth. Thorin is wrong, of course.
Putting aside the remainder of their harrowing trip, only Bilbo knows what lies inside the Lonely Mountain. Only Bilbo has any clue of all the horrible things that will happen to them there, how painful it will be for everyone to witness Thorin’s decline. Although… things are different now, aren’t they? Thorin has already been behaving differently, showing Bilbo much more warmth. Isn’t it possible that things might be different once they reach Erebor, as well? That Thorin might be better able to resist the pull of the gold with Bilbo’s support?
But that is foolish wishful thinking. Bilbo can hope for the best to his heart’s content, but he knows full well that he is also obligated to plan for the worst. “Okay, that’s plenty,” Bilbo announces, addressing an enraptured Óin, “His Majesty is wounded, remember?”
“See to Master Baggins first,” Thorin orders. Unfortunately, he is no match for an irate Hobbit, which he should know well by now.
“Don’t you dare,” Bilbo shoots a glare in Óin’s direction.
By the grace of the Green Lady, this is not Óin’s first time tending to the wounded following a battle, nor is it his first time managing a surly monarch. He is Thorin’s cousin, after all, and probably well accustomed to his moods. “Sit yourself down, now, lad, and let me get a look at you.” Given that Thorin has been demoted from my King to lad in a matter of minutes, Óin must share Bilbo’s conviction about whose injuries are most serious.
The Hobbit makes to walk away in triumph, but apparently, the healer’s reign of terror has only just begun. “And don’t you be going anywhere, now, Master Burglar. You’re next. Not another step until I’ve checked you over, understand?” And Bilbo finds that he is too tired to argue as he settles onto the warm stone of the Carrock.
The walk from the Carrock is far longer than Bilbo remembers it being. Perhaps this is because he is in no small amount of pain. Now that he’s had a chance to calm down and been seen to by Óin, he can report that his back aches, as do his legs, as does his sword-arm. His head is pounding, as well, and no wonder, when his sleeping and eating have been so poor and so erratic as of late, not to mention recent events. Perhaps it is just his imagination, but the ring feels like a rock in his pocket, and it takes genuine concentration to keep from reaching inside and running his fingers over it.
Last time, Bilbo remembers marching through this segment of the journey in a near-euphoric haze. Finally, he’d proved himself to Thorin Oakenshield and earned some measure of the king’s respect. And that embrace had merited not a single complaint, Bilbo can say now with certainty.
This time, though, it felt much different. To be held in those strong arms once again, to rest his face against that warm, broad chest. The last time, Bilbo was baffled, hesitant. It took him a moment to realize what was going on. This time, he threw his arms around Thorin, in turn, taking care not to agitate the king’s injuries. If only Óin had not ruined the moment! Bilbo could have stayed there all day, all night, for the rest of time.
But they are in the middle of a quest, and the Eagles have been kind, but Bilbo knows better than anyone that they are not out of the woods yet. They’ve got a head start, and they should make use of it. They must get to Beorn’s hall, where Thorin can recover from his wounds, where all of them can catch up on sleep and get something to eat. They cannot delay. Bilbo might’ve liked to soak his waistcoat in warm water, at least, in a vain attempt to get the blood out of it, but that will have to wait until they are safe. Any fire they might build should not be wasted on heating water for laundry, nor should any of their scant water supply be used for such a purpose. He’s gotten his face cleaned up, at least, and his hands, and he’s choked down a bitter brew of herbs and water.
Bilbo jumps and loses his train of thought when an arm comes down around his shoulders. “You scared me!” He scolds.
Nori does not seem particularly put off by this. “Apologies,” he says, attempting a sort of mocking bow while still clinging to Bilbo. “Got time for a word or two?”
“I’ve got nothing but time, it seems.” Truly. From what Bilbo remembers of his last adventure, he may as well have closed his eyes on the Carrock and opened them again at Beorn’s door. Apparently, this recollection is not entirely accurate, or else Gandalf is leading them on a different and more taxing route this time. “This walk is dragging ever on and on.”
“That’s the spirit,” Nori agrees vaguely. “I suppose that’s normal, though, coming down from a battle-rage like you are.”
“Battle-rage?” Bilbo echoes.
“That’s the way to say it in Westron, I think,” Nori explains, “Not sure, to be honest, but even I’m not the sort to go handing out Khuzdul like it’s candy.”
Ah, yes. The secret language, not for the ears of outsiders. Bifur gets some kind of pass on this score on account of his injury, but for the others, it is strictly forbidden. Bilbo elects not to mention the fact that Kíli has already spoken to him in Khuzdul once on this journey, and does not even consider bringing up all of the major cultural transgressions that will be made in future.
“I’ve never seen any of the little folk fight like that,” Nori continues, before Bilbo can think of an appropriate response, “And before you ask, Master Burglar,” there’s a mocking emphasis on this title, which might upset Bilbo coming from anybody else, but he’ll allow it from Nori, “I have seen little folk before. Even seen ‘em fight, a time or two.”
“Please don’t keep me in suspense,” Bilbo deadpans. He is in no mood for showmanship.
Unfortunately, Nori does not cater to the moods of others. “I’ve spent my fair share of time in Bree. More than my fair share, as a matter of fact. Good place to hide, nice enough market. You pop off to Bree for a few weeks, pop back with a few coins and some drivel about selling your wares, and now there’s bread on the table and a smile on your baby brother’s face.”
Bilbo had never thought of it that way, but now that Nori is telling him, this does make a certain sense. He knew from the beginning that Nori was a thief. It did not occur to him that perhaps Dori’s impeccable manners were some sort of shield, that perhaps the three brothers did not have the money to keep themselves in food, or at least, not without Nori’s lifting and re-selling of things, collection of bets, and other such nonsense. None of the company lived in splendor in the Blue Mountains, Bilbo reminds himself, and things were far worse for their people before they arrived in Ered Luin. All of them did what they had to in order to survive once their home was taken from them.
He might not have understood it, eighty years ago, but now, he does. If Bilbo ever had to steal to keep Frodo fed, he’d have done it in a heartbeat. And worse than that, too, if it had come down to it. “And you’ve seen Hobbits fighting in Bree?”
“A few times,” Nori replies. “You know how it is: ale flowing, purse missing, fists flying.”
“I can’t say I do know how that is, no,” Bilbo admits, “But I’ll take your word for it.” He does not know how he feels about the idea of Nori picking the pockets of Hobbits, but then, it isn’t so very different from pillaging the larder of Bag End or removing light fixtures from the Last Homely House.
“Yours are a peaceful folk,” Nori decides. “That much I know. No training, no technique. You’ve got a little of one and less of the other, though I’d guess you’re better off than your neighbors in the Shire. Still, I didn’t think the battle-rage would touch you.”
“I have no idea what you’re talking about.” But Bilbo isn’t being entirely truthful anymore.
Of course he knows what Nori is talking about. When Bilbo faced Azog, he saw red. All he could think of was Ravenhill, of the blood on that orc’s hands, of everything that was stolen from him and from Erebor and from the world on that cold day. But when he faced down the first orc, the one who had his sword raised to harm Thorin, Bilbo saw nothing at all. Sting moved of its own volition, killing, rending flesh, fury embodied as Bilbo defended Thorin from an enemy that had long since ceased to be a threat. Bilbo could not have gathered his thoughts in that moment if he’d had the wherewithal to wish to. He could only act, could only slash, could only fight.
Nori snorts. “You’ve gotta work on your lying eyes. Trick of the trade, you know. Maybe this lot can’t see through you, but as far as I’m concerned, you’re carved out of clear quartz.” What a lovely idiom. Bilbo should make note of it, if he decides to write about this iteration of his adventure.
Hopefully, Nori is referring only to Bilbo’s inability to hold himself together in battle and not to any of the other secrets that the Hobbit is presently keeping. “You don’t mean to tell me that every fight is going to be like this!” That would not be sustainable. Bilbo must keep his wits about him, remember his purpose, and follow his plan. He cannot afford another reckless, senseless incident.
“I dunno,” Nori admits, “Nobody knows what sets it off. Some fighters get it, some don’t. I’ve seen it from Men, from time to time. Never from an Elf, though I’ve not met many of them. And never from a Halfing, neither, ’til this afternoon. Shows what I know about it. Not much of a warrior myself, I’ve got to say. Haven’t seen a proper battle, just a few scuffles that got out of hand. You’d be better off asking someone with more experience.” He jerks his head in Balin’s direction.
“Hobbit,” Bilbo corrects him reflexively. “Not halfling.” Clearly, whatever time Nori spent in Bree was not given over to cultural education. Why is Bilbo not surprised? Anyway, it gives him a good excuse to drop the other thread of this conversation.
“Right.” Nori gives him an odd sort of squeeze. Bilbo can’t decide whether this is an overstep or not. The two of them are friends, after all. Maybe not the closest of friends (at least, they weren’t on the first adventure), but friends nevertheless. “Still, if I were an orc, I’d steer clear of His Majesty when you were around.”
Oh. Alright. So Nori knows, then. Well, Bilbo supposes that it’s better than anybody working out his other secret. “How long have you known?”
“Told you,” Nori jostles Bilbo to and fro as they walk. “You’ve gotta work on your lying eyes. Anybody with half a brain would guess just from the way you look at him. And the way he looks at you—“
“Don’t be ridiculous,” Bilbo scolds him. He is not up for being teased about this. He would know it if Thorin were looking at him. Of course, he did not know it eighty years ago, but that was then, and this is now, and many things have changed.
Nori only smirks and makes a big show of waving Bilbo’s last remaining handkerchief at him as he saunters off. But before the Hobbit can chase after him, they are interrupted by the booming voice of a tired, injured, and apparently very irritated king. “We will camp here,” Thorin declares gruffly.
“This looks a fine spot for that,” Gandalf agrees. Bilbo isn’t always pleased with the Wizard, but at the very least, he trusts Gandalf’s assessment of the security of their campsites. He’s never been wrong about that before, after all. “We should be safe enough with the fire blazing, so long as we set a watch.”
Thorin mutters under his breath as he abruptly throws himself onto the ground. What could have happened over the course of the past several hours to set him off? He was in a perfectly pleasant mood on the Carrock (a pleasant mood indeed, Bilbo thinks, remembering the feeling of Thorin’s arms around him), and it’s not as though they’ve been attacked since then. No doubt he’s exhausted, and now he can’t even have his ritual of laying out his bedroll as though he’s expecting company. All of their baggage was lost in the goblin tunnels, after all. Or Thorin and Gandalf have exchanged words, and these have set him off. Or, it was Óin’s prodding, which, while usually helpful and necessary, is never very pleasant.
“Well, now he’s in a mood,” Kíli says aloud what perhaps everyone is thinking.
“And we haven’t even taken his pipe this time,” Fíli replies with mock solemnity. “I’ll bet Gandalf told him more about this friend we’re staying with. No doubt he disapproves.”
“Yes, but Thorin disapproves of everyone,” Bilbo puts in before he can think better of it.
The lads laugh aloud at this. “Maybe at first,” Kíli concedes, “But usually, he comes around.”
“Perhaps he’ll be sweeping this Beorn fellow off his feet next,” Fíli muses. It’s a comical thought, if not a very likely one.
“No, I’m sure Beorn is far too big for that,” Bilbo replies with no regard for the consequences. Then the implications of the broader discussion catch up with him, and he finds heat rising to his cheeks. “The cheek of you two, I swear!”
“Master Baggins,” Thorin calls, preventing what would surely evolve into a lecture on manners and minding one’s own business. “Take the first watch.”
That startles Bilbo more than any hug ever could. He’s not been trusted to keep watch alone on this journey yet, and on the last one, nobody asked him until after Lake-town. It’s no small thing, being the only one awake when everyone else is asleep. A gesture of trust if he’s ever seen it. Though perhaps it’s not the compliment Thorin thinks it is, considering that keeping watch will stand between Bilbo and some much-needed sleep. Nori has the audacity to wink at him.
Chapter 6: A Rest
Notes:
Well. Here's 14k words of... basically just fluff? Thanks as always, everyone, for reading, commenting and leaving kudos. Please enjoy!
Chapter Text
Thorin sits by the window in the house of Beorn, with Fíli standing to his right and Kíli on his left. Sometime between the confrontation with Azog, the incident with the warg, and the intervention of the Eagles, one of Thorin’s braids came loose. After the utter indignity of spending the night in a barn, Tharkûn’s harebrained attempt to coax the skin-changer into hosting their company, and the much-needed breakfast that followed, Fíli and Kíli insisted on fixing Thorin’s hair for him. It is rare that his sister-sons should fuss over him, but then, in their mother’s absence, they are his closest kin.
Kíli braids Thorin’s hair tightly, with the precision of an archer. He’s uncharacteristically neat about it, a skill no doubt developed on the training grounds as he pulled bowstring after bowstring taut. Fíli, on the other side, moves his fingers with the smooth finesse of a sword fighter. The braid he creates is loose and easy, effortless. Thorin knows that the two sides do not match, and that neither looks the way his braids did when they set out from the Blue Mountains. Dís has always taken pride in her clean braiding, the same encyclopedic knowledge of imagery and symbolism that informs her metalwork showing plainly in the way she handles her kin’s hair. Even Thorin does not know the meanings of each crossing of hair she chooses to make. Frerin was the same way, and their father, as well, all three of them favoring complex, meaningful braids whenever possible. Thorin, like his mother before him, prefers simpler braids.
Not that Dís did anything spectacular to his hair before this journey. No. She welcomed Thorin home prior to his meeting, dismissed her sons with cheek-kisses and admonitions, and strong-armed her brother into a chair in front of a mirror in his own chambers. As she worked through the tangles acquired on the road, she detailed all the bodily harm she’d do him if anything should happen to her sons on their quest. As she produced two clean, even plaits, made meaningful only by the mithril beads keeping them in place, she detailed all the bodily harm she’d do him if anything should happen to him on his quest. Yet another awful fate from which Thorin has been saved thanks to Master Baggins.
“There,” Kíli says, “Done.”
Fíli passes Thorin a heavily polished knife. “This’ll have to do. The goblins took my mirror glass.”
“But not your knives, I see.” It would take roughly an hour to divest Fíli of all his hidden weapons. It is comforting for Thorin to know that his heir is always protected, that he is always armed, even when his enemies assume otherwise.
Thorin does not bother to check his reflection in the blade. He does not care how he looks, and he strongly suspects that it will not matter in a few days’ time. Once they leave Beorn’s protection, the company will be beset by orcs once more. Should the need arise, Thorin will fight, and then his braids will fray again. In Mirkwood, they will not have the luxury of time to sit around braiding one another’s hair. All told, Thorin is lucky that his nephews do not share their mother’s knowledge, that they do not know how to produce the ostentatious kings’ braids once worn by Thrór. They’ve done him up like a warrior, which is what he is, until Erebor is his again.
“Not possible.” Fíli takes his dagger back and places it inside his boot. “How are you feeling?”
“Fine.” Actually, Thorin feels as he imagines anyone might feel after taking a mace to the chest, getting bitten repeatedly by a warg, then carried in the air between the claws of a giant bird for miles before being set down heavily upon strange stone, but he does not wish to trouble his sister-sons.
“That’s good to hear.” Kíli claps him hard on the shoulder, making Thorin wince.“You’ll be battle-ready in no time, Uncle, I’m sure.”
“I am battle ready now.” Thorin is distracted, staring out the window into the skin-changer’s garden.
Thorin has seen gardens before, though his people do not keep them. Many years has he spent in the towns of Men, after all. He can appreciate that, through some mysterious set of procedures, foodstuffs can be coaxed to spring up from the soil. Thorin has always found greens unpleasant, but he remembers the days when no food could be refused, and he is reluctantly grateful for the farmers of Arda, even if he cannot comprehend their lifestyles. Plants do not tend to grow beneath mountains, after all, and Thorin has never had any interest in anything so trivial as flowers.
Master Baggins, however, comes from a land of many blossoms. Thorin recalls the gardens at Bag End. He remembers stomping through them, crushing flowers under his feet in his haste to get to the door. He was late, and frustrated, and tired, and hungry. He did not care to consider whether flowers held any cultural meaning for Hobbits, or whether he might offend his Burglar by stepping on them. He did not even stop to note the colors of the blooms he crushed. Now, however, he finds that he does care. All of a sudden, Thorin feels that it is pressing to apprehend every detail of whatever complex relationship exists between Hobbits and plants.
“What is Bilbo doing out there?” Kíli asks, following Thorin’s gaze out the window.
“He’s digging in the dirt,” Fíli answers, and he isn’t wrong. The Hobbit does, in fact, appear to be digging in the dirt.
Thorin does not miss the sight of the skin-changer standing several yards away, hatchet in hand, eyeing Master Baggins periodically. It annoys him, that Beorn should feel entitled to stare so openly at the Burglar. Whether or not the bear-man has ever seen a Hobbit before, Thorin knows that Master Baggins would be troubled by the attention, were he aware of it. And Thorin, too, is troubled, for reasons he does not care to articulate.
“Is he harvesting something, or planting?” Kíli wonders, curious as usual.
“I am not sure,” Thorin admits. It seems such a simple question, and yet he cannot answer it.
“It’s summertime,” Fíli announces, “That’s when most crops are harvested, if I understand it right.” Thorin’s experience navigating trade arrangements leads him to believe that this is more-or-less correct.
“So he’s harvesting, then,” Kíli decides.
“Perhaps,” Thorin considers the idea. Why Master Baggins would choose to devote his limited rest time to something like this is utterly beyond him. Greens are not worthwhile to take on a journey, and certainly not a journey through Mirkwood. Master Baggins would be better off baking more of that crusty bread or burgling some butter.
“But I don’t know. It’s all very confusing. In the Shire, they plant garlic in winter,” Fíli points out. How he came by this knowledge, Thorin could not say. “And asparagus is harvested in spring.”
“What do you know about asparagus?” Kíli asks with a grin. “You’ve never eaten it. Assuming that it’s edible in the first place, which Ori tells me it is not.”
“I do listen when our Master Bilbo speaks,” Fíli explains, equally cheerful. “You might try it. You could learn something.”
“Master Baggins has been teaching you about farming schedules?” Thorin wonders, not for the first time, at what goes through his Hobbit’s head.
“No, of course not. He’s been complaining about his cousins, mostly, but plants are important in the Shire. They keep coming up. Half the stories, somebody’s in the garden, or somebody insulted somebody’s prize tomatoes and caused an uproar at the market. That sort of thing.”
“So you have no idea what he’s doing.” Kíli presses his face to the window, as though getting closer to it will help him to make sense of the Hobbit’s activities. “Look at how he moves his hands! It’s like watching a craft. I can see he’s very skilled, even if I can’t make sense of what he’s skilled at.”
Thorin will gladly accept the excuse to stare at Master Baggins. As promised, those small hands move quickly, efficiently, with practiced ease. Whatever he is doing, it is something he knows well.
“There is magic in this place,” Thorin muses, “Even if we knew the rules of planting, we have no reason to believe they would be the same here as elsewhere.” And Master Baggins is almost as strange as Radagast the Brown. Mahal only knows what he’s doing out there under the sun.
“He’s definitely pulling something out of the ground,” Fíli observes, stepping closer to the window. “Look at the pile next to him.”
Yes, there is a pile next to Master Baggins on the grass, a mass of green things which Thorin could not identify with a sword to his throat. He sincerely hopes he will not be asked to eat such things. Though, could he refuse, if Master Baggins offered?
Kíli grabs Thorin by the shoulders and jostles him in what he probably believes is a gentle manner. “Why don’t you go out and ask him, Uncle? And then you can report back to us about what he’s up to.”
As though either of these lads actually cares about what Master Baggins is doing in the garden. Thorin is not so oblivious as they seem to believe. Ever since they climbed down off the Carrock, his sister-sons have been pushing him toward the Hobbit.
“I will go out,” Thorin decides, “If only to get away from you.” He’s not good at discussing his feelings, that’s for certain. Thankfully, the boys are accustomed to this behavior from their uncle and do not seem bothered by it.
“I’m sure Master Baggins will appreciate your company,” Fíli winks at Thorin.
The king only rolls his eyes. “Do not break anything while I am gone,” he orders. He shouldn’t have to say this to two adult princes, but Fíli and Kíli tend to defy logic in their mischief-making, and Thorin does not imagine that the bear-man will be able to laugh off a broken plate as Master Baggins has.
“What’s all this?” As if Thorin were not under enough scrutiny already, Dwalin takes the opportunity to materialize before them.
“Our dear uncle is about to have a word with the burglar,” Fíli explains.
“He’s going to learn something about plants,” Kíli clarifies.
“Getting into gardening, are you?” Dwalin shoots Thorin a knowing look. “Never thought you’d be the type for that. Then again, you’re just full of surprises these days, My King.”
Oh, not the mocking title. Mahal, anything but that. Dwalin even feigns a little bow, something that would probably get him executed, were Thorin a proper king with a proper kingdom. And were there other guards in Thorin’s employ to carry out the execution. It’s tempting to initiate a scuffle regardless, but in that case, Óin would be the one calling for heads to roll.
“I can’t remember the last time Uncle hugged either of us like that,” Kíli pouts, and he does a rather fair job of it, too. He learned that trick from Dís, though unlike his mother, he has no concept of subtlety. Perhaps it is Thorin’s own fault for embracing Master Baggins.
He simply could not help himself. When his eyes had fluttered shut, when the pain had sent him far from the battlefield and too close for comfort to the arms of his Maker, Thorin’s last sight was of Master Baggins, single-handedly facing down Azog the Defiler, armed with only a single stone. When he woke, Thorin was overcome with dread, certain that there was no way his little Burglar could survive such an encounter. But there was Master Baggins, pale and stricken but alive. He’d been willing to give his life for Thorin, but by the grace of Mahal, Master Baggins had survived. Thorin did not think for a moment about the consequences before drawing the Hobbit into his arms.
“Well, we can’t really blame him for what happened on the Carrock.” Fíli, apparently, has elected to add to Thorin’s misery. And why not, when the entire world is doing the same? “Bilbo gives good hugs.” Yes, because he and Kíli have been throwing their arms around the Burglar on a regular basis since practically the beginning of the journey.
“Aye, I think your uncle knows that,” Dwalin agrees, “Even if all sense has left him.”
“I am right here,” Thorin reminds the three of them. “At least wait until I have gone to speak of me this way.”
He has no wish to discuss this. And it matters very little, regardless. Master Baggins may be a member of the company, and he may be fine to look upon, but that is all he can be to Thorin for the time being. Even if he were Thorin’s One, which he cannot possibly be, it would not be wise to pursue anything.
“Oh, right here, are you? I had no idea!” Dwalin punches him in the arm. Apparently, he has decided, in his infinite wisdom, that Thorin is not too injured for roughhousing. This is some comfort, though his words leave much to be desired. “Not all of us are so busy staring at the Burglar that we lose track of our surroundings, Your Majesty. If I were an orc, you’d never have seen me coming.”
“If you were an orc, my sister-sons would have killed you minutes ago.”
“You wouldn’t have even got through the door,” Fíli agrees, brandishing the knife that he’s been using as a mirror.
“Either way, you’re distracted,” Dwalin informs Thorin. That is the voice of a teacher, one who has trained more than a few remarkable young warriors. It is not a positive sign that he has turned this tone on his friend and king. “Now’s not the time for this, Thorin. Wait until we get to Erebor, at least. Then you and the Burglar can sort it all out.”
“Don’t listen to him,” Kíli slaps Thorin on the shoulder with startling force. Apparently, he still believes his uncle to be indestructible. Thorin sincerely hopes that nothing further happens on this journey which might disabuse him of that notion. “Now’s the perfect time.”
“I do not know what any of you are talking about.” Thorin rises, ignoring the reactions earned by this blatant falsehood. He knows what they are talking about, but there is no cause for concern. Surely Thorin can have a conversation with the Burglar with no effect upon that fond forge burning in his chest. “I would speak to Master Baggins. He saved my life.”
“And what’s that got to do with plants?” Dwalin demands.
Thorin continues to ignore him and makes his way, if a little slowly, to the door. Dwalin may not approve (not that there is anything going on for Dwalin to approve of or not), but he doesn’t stop Thorin, either.
Bilbo is grateful for the opportunity to work in a garden again. His first order of business, after choking down the disgusting tonic that Óin prescribed, was to ask Beorn what he could do to help. The skin-changer seemed fascinated and perhaps a little endeared by Bilbo’s offer and asked him whether he’d prefer an outdoor or indoor task. Bilbo elected to work outside. Oh, it has been so long since he’s gotten to putter around in his gardens! Normally, he isn’t one to get his hands dirty on a daily basis. He’s always had a gardener for that, of course.
But Bilbo is still a Hobbit of the Shire. Even the wealthiest folk with sprawling gardens and armies of gardeners know how to weed. Bilbo is perfectly content to sit outside pulling choking plants out while Beorn chops wood. The skin-changer is efficient, that’s for certain, and Bilbo appreciates his devotion to the land under his care.
“Little Bunny has a good hand for plants,” Beorn observes as he sets down his axe. “Don’t think I need to keep such a close eye on you, then. You will not kill anything that needs to live if I go and tend to my bees now, will you?”
“No, I wouldn’t dream of it!” Bilbo assures him. “I may not be much of a gardener, but I know a weed when I see one!”
Beorn laughs and ruffles his hair. “That is good news! Keep to your task, then, Little Bunny, and I will bring us honey to have with our supper.” The skin-changer may not be fond of the company as a whole, but once again, he has taken quite a shine to Bilbo. The Hobbit knows that there is no chance of shaking the nickname, and so he does not even try.
“Thank you,” Bilbo beams at him, “I look forward to it.” He watches Beorn mosey off and then returns to his weeding.
Bilbo can’t deny that he enjoys the process of caring for plants. It was always a nice pastime at Bag End, especially in the years following his adventure. For a time, when he first returned from Erebor, working among plants was cathartic for Bilbo, or at least a way to distract himself from his grief. He would occasionally work alongside Hamfast, pulling out weeds so Ham could focus his expert attention on more delicate work. Of course, that all came to an end when young Samwise got older and insisted upon joining his father in the garden, but Bilbo enjoyed it while it lasted.
It’s nice to be out in the sun in such a peaceful place as Beorn’s gardens. Alongside the sprawling fields of clover, there are cultivated patches containing vegetables and flowers. Bilbo missed this place and its master more than he knew. When Bilbo returned to Erebor, Beorn had been dead for many long years. His grandchildren tended this land. How Beorn managed to have children, and whom he had them with, has always remained an mystery to Bilbo, who, even after all this time, is far too polite to ask. The skin-changer doesn’t talk much, and Bilbo knows better than to go prying out other people’s secrets. That surely won’t end well for him.
“What are you doing?” A familiar voice asks.
Bilbo is shocked to see that Thorin has come to find him. He doesn’t know why. Perhaps because last time, they barely spoke at all when staying with Beorn. “Weeding,” Bilbo explains. He’s got quite a good collection of uprooted weeds on the grass beside him. “Care to join me?” It’s not a serious offer.
“Not at all,” Thorin replies.
“You’re welcome to sit down and keep me company,” Bilbo informs the king, pulling out another weed. “Though I’d really appreciate it if you’d bring me something to drink first, please.”
He won’t lie. This is very close to a fantasy he’s harbored for decades upon decades. It is bittersweet, having his wildest dreams come true in this way, in this place. To think that Bilbo might be working in his garden, and Thorin might be coming out here just to talk to him… It is everything, and it is nothing, and none of it will matter if Bilbo cannot get things right at Ravenhill.
“Are you thirsty?” Thorin asks, as though this could possibly be a matter of dispute. He’s still looming overhead like a particularly regal storm cloud.
“Yes, if you don’t mind,” Bilbo replies, “Beorn said there was water with berries in it in his kitchen, if you could fetch us some. I don’t want to wash my hands just so I can get them dirty again.”
“You would order me around,” Thorin observes. Bilbo can hear the slight smirk in his voice. He is amused, then. “I knew that you were bold, but I confess that this impertinence is worse than anything that I could have imagined.”
“I’ve been ordering you around since Bag End,” Bilbo argues, “Have you not noticed? Get some for yourself, too. I don’t suppose you’ve had anything but tea since we got here, and that’s bad for the nerves at the best of times.”
He does not expect the king to comply with his wishes. But Thorin really does stalk off, back to the house, and he really does return a few moments later with two glasses of cool water. Several of the promised strawberries are floating in each glass. Bilbo truly appreciates the effort that Beorn puts into crafting such delicious beverages. The flavor of the berries will linger in the water, not too overpowering, but very refreshing indeed. Something similar is done in the Shire, and Bilbo hopes that if berries are available once Erebor is reclaimed, he’ll be able to follow the same custom in his new home.
There’s that awful wishful thinking again. Erebor will not be a home to Bilbo without Thorin and the lads, and there is still the ring to think of, after all. Even if he saves his friends, he may not end up living in peace with them after the battle. But such thoughts will do nothing to help him at this time.
“I think whatever Óin gave you for the pain is making you loopy,” Bilbo decides, giving his complete attention to Thorin. “You’re actually taking direction from other people. It’s quite disconcerting, though I must say it’s a welcome change.”
Thorin snorts. “I seem to recall being directed to set the table in your smial. Did my efforts not please you?” He takes a long sip, then sets his glass down on the grass beside him.
Bilbo bites his lip. He considers dishonesty but decides against it. “You could have put out spoons,” he says eventually.
“I will remember for next time.” Thorin manages to say this with a straight face, which is quite impressive, really. “Do you enjoy… weeding?”
Bilbo laughs. “Well, it certainly needs doing, and Beorn is busy enough. I know none of the rest of you are any use in a garden. Besides, after the week I’ve had, I could use some mindless work.”
“And you can get dirty in the process,” Thorin observes, lips turning up ever so slightly. “Why would you wear a white shirt to do this?” He’s full of questions this morning, isn’t he?
“Because I don’t have any other color of shirt with me!” Bilbo protests. “In fact, this is the only shirt I own now, since those blasted goblins took the rest of them! What on Earth are they going to do with a bag full of Hobbit shirts?”
“I’m sure it will end up on a garbage heap along with your butter-dish and your book,” Thorin decides.
“Do goblins not eat butter?” Bilbo wonders. Now that he thinks about it, he’s not entirely certain what Goblins eat. “What an awful way to live.”
“No, I can’t imagine they do.”
“Still, the dish was empty, so perhaps they’ll find some use for it. I don’t suppose you know what they do eat?” Bilbo’s curiosity has gotten the best of him once again.
Thorin shoots him a look that Bilbo might charitably describe as grudgingly fond. “I have never, in my life, for a single moment, considered it before.”
“Neither have I!” Bilbo replies with a laugh. “But I don’t suppose they can catch people to eat all that often, and it’s not as though they can grow food in those horrible tunnels. Fish, maybe? Bats?”
Thorin shakes his head. “I do not know,” he admits. And of course he doesn’t. Why would he? Why would anyone? “It must be fish.”
On their first adventure, Thorin would not have suffered a discussion with Bilbo about goblin eating habits. He would never have allowed such frivolity, such a waste of precious time when their quest was afoot. For whatever reason, he is making an active effort right now, deliberately letting his guard down just enough to humor Bilbo. Why? What has Bilbo done differently?
He has not tried to leave. He has used his knowledge of the company to help each of them as much as he can. He has been exceptionally kind to Thorin’s nephews. Of course, the king does not know why Bilbo does this. Thorin thinks that Bilbo has never seen battle, and Bilbo has allowed him to labor under this misapprehension for the good of all involved.
“They have my pipe as well,” Bilbo forces himself to savor this conversation. It does not matter that he was not fast enough, scrambling up Ravenhill. It matters only that Thorin is coming out of his shell, that he feels comfortable enough with Bilbo to waste time by his side. To rest, or almost rest, for the first time in more than a century. Bilbo will take it, he decides. He will take it and run with it and cherish it. “The goblins.”
“Aye, and mine,” Thorin muses, “And all of my pipeweed, too.”
“We’ll have to replace them,” Bilbo decides.
“And where do you suggest that we do that?” Thorin stares straight ahead, over the gardens, past Beorn and his bees. “The comforts of home are not commonly found out in the wilderness, Master Burglar.”
Bilbo rolls his eyes. Obviously, he knows this. He also knows that he must tread lightly. He doesn’t want Thorin to guess yet at how much Bilbo knows about the journey ahead of them. “There must be a town or two between here and Erebor. Men will build their cities in the silliest places.”
“That they will,” Thorin agrees, “Though I’m curious to see how you’ll manage to pay for a pipe. You’ve lost your fine buttons and your cinnamon rolls, along with any coin you might have carried in that awful pack. What have you to trade?”
Bilbo snorts. “That’s true. I shouldn’t bother, should I?” He can’t remember getting ahold of another pipe on his journey the first time around, now that he thinks about it.“We’ll just have to deprive ourselves until we get to Erebor.”
“And then will you be taking a golden pipe as part of your fourteenth share?” A smile plays at Thorin’s lips.
“A golden pipe? Goodness no!” Bilbo can’t help but laugh again. It feels peaceful, talking with Thorin like this. Bilbo can almost pretend that they’re going to stay here forever, in this garden, enjoying one another’s clunky, awkward company. “First your nephews try to push a golden plate off on me, and now you want to give me a golden pipe? Wouldn’t it get hot?” Not that Bilbo knows what it is like to smoke a metal pipe.
“The entire thing would not be made of gold,” Thorin informs him, suddenly serious. “Only the bowl. The mouthpiece would be clay. Have you never seen one?”
“Have I never seen a golden pipe? No, your majesty, I have not.” Perhaps this is a little unfair. After all, the life that Thorin has led has been far from sheltered. It’s not as if he has resided in opulence, smoking golden pipes for all his years.
But he does not seem offended. After all, Bilbo is far from the first member of the company to tease Thorin about his royal title. “Pity. I will select one for you when we arrive,” Thorin resolves, staring out at the horizon with steely determination. “And you will see that the goldsmiths of Erebor of old excelled in pipe-making as they did in all their crafts.”
“It sounds heavy and impractical,” Bilbo admits, “But I’m sure it’ll make a nice ornament to put on our mantlepiece.”
His words do not dawn at him until several moments after he has said them. Our mantlepiece. Our mantlepiece. He really has gotten caught up in the fantasy, hasn’t he? Dreaming, apparently, of a future with Thorin, something domestic, something simple and Hobbit-y and altogether improbable. Bilbo has allowed himself a venomous hope, one that has distracted him from the facts of his situation. They are not in love. Bilbo may love Thorin, but that does not mean his feelings are returned.
Thorin raises his eyebrows. “I do not think you have seen a Dwarven hearth before.”
“No, I haven’t. Do they not have mantlepieces?” Bilbo is relieved that, for whatever reason, Thorin has decided to breeze past Bilbo’s embarrassing faux-pas. Our mantlepiece, as though he expects them to have a home together. How presumptuous of him. It might have been a possibility, had things turned out better the first time around, but it is by no means guaranteed on this iteration of the adventure.
“Not in the way you might imagine,” Thorin explains cryptically. “Perhaps you could put it on an end table.”
“An end table,” Bilbo muses, “That might work. Though I’ve never seen a Dwarven end table, either. Are they very different from the ones in the Shire?”
Thorin shrugs. “I’m afraid I didn’t pay any attention to your end tables when I was in your home.”
“You were busy insulting me and drinking far too much of my wine,” Bilbo recounts.
“As I recall, you kept pouring,” Thorin points out with a small smile. “I could not refuse your hospitality.”
Bilbo is thoroughly endeared. He shakes his head and returns to weeding. It isn’t until several moments later, when Thorin has finished his strawberry-water and elected to take the glasses back into the house, that a sudden epiphany takes Bilbo’s breath away. Thorin did not simply ignore his reference to their shared home. Rather he seemed to take it in stride, giving Bilbo a more practical suggestion for where he could keep his ridiculous golden pipe. Perhaps… but no. Bilbo must be misreading the situation.
He is looking for something that could not possibly be there yet. He and Thorin never reached anything remotely resembling an understanding until the Elven dungeons, at least. Even then, they’d spent much of their time arguing. In retrospect, it was undeniable in Erebor, but they were barely friends when they stayed with Beorn. Bilbo should not look for fairy rings where mushrooms grow in rows, to use the Shire saying. Thorin’s friendship is more than enough, better than he could ever have hoped for. Bilbo shouldn’t get greedy, trying to read between the lines for more.
As far as Bilbo can tell, he and Thorin are both healing rather nicely after their enounter with Azog. Although, of course, this may be due to the fact that Bilbo was barely injured to begin with, and Thorin has had decades of practice hiding his pain from the people around him. Still, the king seems able to walk around, and he looks perfectly content laying on his back on the makeshift bed of blankets that he’s set up for himself on Beorn’s floor.
Not that Bilbo can stand to look at him in that position for very long. It brings back horrible memories. Every day that they spend with Beorn, the Hobbit must distract himself from thoughts of Ravenhill, the same musings that have plagued him since the beginning of this new adventure. But blessedly, there is no shortage of tasks, with sixteen of them staying in such a small space, not to mention all of those brilliant animals, and Beorn’s sprawling gardens always seem to require attention. There’s a nice spring nearby to bathe in, and this time around, Bilbo has no qualms about joining the other members of the company there. He’s still so grateful to be seeing them at all that he really doesn’t mind seeing them in states of undress that would be considered deeply inappropriate among Hobbits. He is not, after all, among Hobbits, and if he’d wanted to be, he could have stayed in the Shire.
But that was never a serious possibility. Bilbo has a job to do, after all, and speaking of, he is constantly conscious of the ring and its whereabouts. He leaves it in his pack as often as he can, nervous about wearing it more than he has to. He hopes that the manufactured distance will keep the horrid thing from prying too much into his mind, but he doesn’t know if this will be effective in the slightest. And he cannot leave the thing entirely unattended. What if one of his friends were to pick it up? In Thorin’s hands, the ring could do unfathomable amounts of damage, and Bilbo shudders to think what might happen to any of the others should it come into their possession.
Not that Bilbo has much time to worry about all that. On top of the many housekeeping tasks that living indoors again has afforded to him, Bilbo is also perpetually at the mercy of Óin. “I don’t understand,” he protests, when he is called for yet another check-up after breakfast on the second day. “I’m barely injured. Just a few bruises, is all.” He certainly never had to go through this during their other stay with Beorn.
“You ingested orc blood, in case you had forgotten,” Óin reminds him, not for the first time.
“Well, yes, but…” That hardly seems relevant. “Obviously I’m fine, and I drank the tonic. What more is there to say?“ Bilbo does not know why he is arguing with a professional healer about the profession of healing.
“Just a precaution,” Óin explains. He’s more patient with Bilbo than he might be with one of his own people, having lately learned about Hobbit medicine. Bilbo’s people have great knowledge of plants, and can set a bone if necessary, but not even the most experienced healers know a thing about battle wounds. “If the orc you killed had anything wrong with it, any sickness in its blood, that tonic can only do so much. If anything does set in, I’d like to treat it as quickly as I can. And I’d like our king to stop straining himself worrying over you. A hundred years I’ve been at this, but my own cousin thinks I can’t handle looking after one wee Hobbit!”
Bilbo snorts. “He’d be better off worrying about himself, if you ask me.”
Really, there’s very little to justify Thorin’s concern. Aside from the orc blood that Bilbo has apparently ingested (in a very small quantity, but try telling that to Óin), he is also bruised from being thrown to the ground under Kíli’s entire weight. The lad isn’t very large, as far as creatures go, but he’s much larger than a Hobbit, and Bilbo has the marks to show for it. By now, the soreness in his muscles has faded, but he still looks a bit purple in places and greenish in others.
When Thorin discovered this during a poorly-timed excursion to the springs, he interrogated Bilbo about the cause of these injuries. Your nephew saved my life, Bilbo informed him with a grateful nod in Kíli’s direction. Unfortunately, Thorin proceeded to scold the lad for failing to be careful, at which point Bilbo retorted sharply that he’d rather be bruised than dead. This, naturally, devolved into quite the argument between Bilbo and Thorin, and Kíli slipped out of the water, collected his clothes, and returned to the house. Oddly, Nori and Dwalin stayed in the spring to watch the proceedings, while Beorn and the Wizard spectated from a distance. Some amount of money may have changed hands, though Bilbo has no clue what his friends could possibly have placed wagers upon.
“Aye,” Óin agrees. “He’s popped one stitch already, pacing around fretting like he is. Whatever we can do to keep His Majesty calm before he takes another one out is for the best, I say. And something tells me you’ve got more solutions in that vein than I do.”
“Oh, goodness.” Bilbo suddenly can’t look directly at the healer, who, naturally, is currently in the process of examining Bilbo’s eyes. What could possibly be found there, the Hobbit has no clue.
Fortunately, Óin moves on. Unfortunately, Óin moves on to examine the interior of Bilbo’s mouth. “Any sores developing?” As though he wouldn’t be able to feel that for himself. But Bilbo has long since learned that Dwarven medicine is nearly as invasive and impertinent as Dwarven friendship.
Bilbo tries say no while having the inside of his cheeks prodded at, and does about as well as anyone could. He ends up shaking his head at the healer. “That’s good,” says Óin.
“How is he?” Thorin demands in a raised voice, not bothering to greet the healer. Or Bilbo, for that matter. Apparently, no amount of timeline-changing on Bilbo’s part seems able to convince Thorin of the virtues of using his manners even when he’s nervous or upset. Honestly.
“Oh, just fine,” Óin informs the king. “But you’d best sit down before you end up on a stretcher. A short walk now and again will do you good, but you shouldn’t push your luck.”
“No signs of infection?” Thorin ignores the astute medical advice and instead elects to stand behind his cousin, looking over his shoulder into Bilbo’s mouth as if he’ll be able to make heads or tails of what he sees. If Thorin had any medical knowledge whatsoever, he would likely be sitting down and waiting to have his multiple warg bites examined.
“None at all.” Óin finally releases Bilbo’s poor head and takes up his trumpet.
“That’s quite enough of that, thank you!” Bilbo complains, though he really is glad that he doesn’t appear to have contracted any kind of disease. He should have taken advantage of his eighty-year sojourn to learn more about how illness spreads, particularly in battle. He’s not convinced that this whole orc blood thing is not some archaic Dwarven superstition. “As you can see, I’m perfectly fine. I’m not the one going about popping stitches.”
“Only one stitch,” Óin corrects him, “But I see your point.”
“And I see you’ve had your trumpet repaired,” Thorin grumbles, though he seemed perfectly content to have a two-way conversation with Óin when the healer was bothering Bilbo. Then again, it’s entirely possible that Óin could not hear a word Thorin was saying and simply assumed he’d ask about Bilbo. “How nice.”
“Are you going to listen to the expert and sit down?” Bilbo demands. “You’ll never heal properly if you keep acting like this.”
“I’ve already healed,” Thorin declares. Bilbo would accuse him of lying, but he fears the king might genuinely believe that he’s perfectly fine. That was certainly the case the first time around. Thorin spent their entire stay with Beorn pacing and sulking, and then declared himself fit to travel days before Óin and Gandalf gave the all-clear. Bilbo was not part of the decision-making process, but he strongly suspects that if Fíli, Kíli, Balin, and Dwalin had not come down firmly on Óin’s side of the dispute, the company’s fate in Mirkwood would have been much worse.
Clearly, Thorin is impatient, and he wants to get back on the road as soon as possible. The first time, Bilbo couldn’t blame him. After all, Thorin was forced out of his home, and it must be torturous to see that home looming on the horizon and not be able to rush toward it. However, this time, Bilbo knows exactly what is waiting for their party in Mirkwood, and exactly what they’re going to find on the other side of it as well. The entire company needs to get their strength up, and a little while here won’t hurt them. They’ll still make it to Erebor by Durin’s Day.
Bilbo seriously regrets not taking detailed notes the first time around. He wasn’t certain he would survive to write about his adventure, and then, when he did survive, the guilt and grief and the headaches distracted him from any serious attempts to remember how many days they’d spent in one location or another. Furthermore, Bilbo left many details out of his tale. He didn’t write much about specific conversations, and he certainly didn’t touch on his relationship with Thorin. He outright lied about Gollum, the first time that he wrote the tale, and only amended it when Gandalf filled him in on the creature’s fate and told him the truth about the ring. Even then, he pretended to have told the company that story much earlier than he actually did. Oh, and he took the creative liberty of giving himself a head injury much earlier in the Battle of the Five Armies. After all, Dwalin was the only person alive to contradict Bilbo’s claims about what had taken place, and he made it very clear that he had no interest in reading about events that he had already lived through. Horrible events, to boot.
But it would help Bilbo now to know for certain just when they should set out. He can’t help but worry that his own alleged injuries might hold the company back, or that any of the other minor scrapes, bruises, or burns they’ve accrued might make things look different as they progress through the wild. It doesn’t help his nerves at all to have Thorin constantly hovering, although it does, at least, remind Bilbo that his beloved still breathes. Not that he can say a word about this to anyone, but at least he can content himself in the knowledge that Thorin is more-or-less alright.
“That’s ridiculous and you know it.” Óin, thankfully, has no qualms whatsoever about impertinence. Bilbo is in precisely the same boat and greatly appreciates having the healer on his side. “Now sit, and let me check your bandages.”
Thorin groans but complies. “It’s not necessary,” he announces, though he is already shrugging off his outermost shirt, revealing the second shirt he has on underneath. Even after so many years, Bilbo cannot understand the compulsion to cover oneself in so many clothes. He distinctly remembers getting very sweaty indeed under that old mithril mail of his, and he cannot possibly imagine having so many layers on all the time. Yet it is taking Thorin an awfully long while to grant Óin access to his bandaged wounds.
“It’s very necessary,” Bilbo points out, after perhaps a beat too long of silence. “You’re worried about me, but you were hurt much worse than I was. How do you think I feel right now?”
“You may have contracted a disease of the blood because you couldn’t stop stabbing an orc that was already dead,” Thorin alleges, “I have only a few bites and bruises.”
“Might I remind you that I’ve seen those bites and bruises, and you won’t fool me if you try to say they’re not causing you trouble.”
“And you have drunk orc blood, for reasons which I cannot comprehend.”
“I didn’t drink it, I ingested it,” Bilbo corrects him haughtily. “Right, Óin?”
But it appears that the healer has placed his trumpet conspicuously on a table just out of his present reach. He won’t be backing Bilbo up, apparently. There is another short silence.
“You should not waste too much effort on a single enemy,” Thorin informs Bilbo sagely. He has finally gotten all of his many layers off, and suddenly, Bilbo finds the floor very interesting. “Kill it quickly and move on.”
“Oh,” Bilbo can’t help but laugh, incredulous. “But it’s perfectly alright to go charging, alone, through fire, at an entire pack of orcs and wargs?”
“That is different,” Thorin alleges. “It is my responsibility to—“
“No.”
“Azog the Defiler—“
“No.”
“The company—“
“No.”
“Will you not let me speak?” Thorin demands. He hardly seems to notice that Óin is presently rubbing a stinging salve onto his wounds, which, Bilbo notes, are beginning to close up nicely. Not that he’s looking! It’s just difficult to miss. And this set of old bandages looks significantly less bloody than the ones that Óin removed yesterday. That must be a good sign.
“Go ahead,” Bilbo offers with a perfectly pleasant smile.
“It is my responsibility to defend the company at all costs,” Thorin claims. “And that beast murdered my grandfather. I could not allow Azog to draw breath for a moment longer.”
Bilbo can hardly argue with that. After all, he does recall, if very dimly, charging toward the pale orc in a mad rage, unable to see through his own grief and anger. “Be that as it may, you’re wrong about one thing.”
“Oh, please enlighten me.” Thorin does not seem too happy about being corrected, but he does seem to be waiting for Bilbo to speak. Probably because he thinks that this is an argument which he will have some chance of winning.
But Bilbo doesn’t even need to take advantage of his foreknowledge to prove their leader wrong. “It’s the company’s job to defend you, not the other way around. You’re their king, Thorin. All of them are loyal to you. Do you think anybody here wouldn’t lay down their life to protect you?”
Thorin shakes his head. “That would be foolish of them. I have two heirs with me; Fíli would become king in the event of my death.”
Bilbo can’t help but roll his eyes at Thorin’s stubbornness. “Oh, get over yourself!” He scolds. “We both know you’d never put your burden on that lad’s shoulders if you could help it. You weren’t thinking clearly out there; neither was I. But we’ve both got to try and get our wits about us. Don’t pretend that you’re just a king to these people, some figurehead, as though you were only a… a… a cultural heirloom! These are your family and friends, Thorin. They care about you. None of us want to see you hurt.”
Thorin just looks at him. It’s a long look, and Bilbo recognizes his mistake almost immediately. He has shown far too much of his hand just now. “And do you care about me, as well, then, Master Baggins?” Oh. Is that all?
Bilbo blinks at him. What a stupid question from someone so intelligent. “Would I have risked my life for you if I didn’t?”
“I have not given you any reason to,” Thorin elaborates. “I have been cruel to you. Dismissive. Unfair.”
Bilbo can’t help but laugh at that. Oh, if only Thorin could see how cruel, dismissive, and unfair he was to Bilbo the first time around! “Yes, I suppose you have,” the Hobbit says eventually. There is no point in lying, after all. “And you’ve also been quite rude, I have to add. But… you’ve also shown great kindness and bravery and… I find I enjoy your company very much.”
“Very much?” Thorin looks pleased with himself. Smugness suits him well, unfortunately.
“I’m not going to say it again.” Bilbo’s chest swells with affection. In moments like this one, he can truly forget the context under which they are operating.
“Despite how rude you claim I’ve been to you—“
“You just said you were cruel and dismissive and unfair!”
“Yes, well, you were annoying and confusing and you didn’t bring a sword.” It’s amusing, hearing Thorin list all of Bilbo’s supposed faults.
“I’m glad you can look past all that,” Bilbo deadpans. It’s steadying, spending time with Thorin. It reminds Bilbo of why he agreed to do all of this. Perhaps Beorn might let them stay here forever, with Bilbo tending to his house and gardens. Thorin could… make a forge, maybe, and work on his craft. He’d be content with that, wouldn’t he?
No. He wouldn’t. Thorin will never be content until he has reclaimed Erebor. Bilbo can see as much in his stance when he catches the king staring out at the horizon. He knows, firsthand, that the contents of that mountain will not make Thorin happy, but it’s clear that nor will being far away from it.
“It is difficult.” Thorin feigns solemnity. It’s rather cute. “But I can manage.”
Before Bilbo can say anything embarrassingly sappy, they are interrupted by the sound of running. Inside of Beorn’s house. “Uncle!” Kíli calls, skidding to a stop in front of them. “Uncle!”
Bilbo crosses his arms in front of his chest. “Why are you running in the house?”
Kíli blinks at him momentarily. “Because… I wanted to get here quickly?”
“That’s no excuse.”
Thorin snorts, but does not say anything. Kíli just shrugs, turning his attention away from Bilbo. “Uncle, Fíli stole all my arrows, and he won’t give them back.”
Thorin presses his fingers to his temples, reaching awkwardly around Óin to do so. “It has been many years since you have come to me with this sort of problem.” Bilbo thinks this is rather too polite, considering the situation. “I thought you’d grown out of it.”
“Which is to say, please act your age,” Bilbo translates bluntly. Unfortunately, Kíli seems to think that this is some sort of joke, because he laughs aloud.
Fíli arrives in the house, then, bearing a quiver. He moves at a much more sedate pace than his brother did, and his steps are far more purposeful. “He was talking about shooting a beehive,” he announces.
“I was joking!” Kíli claims.
“And he took three of my knives,” Fíli continues.
“You didn’t stop me!”
“And he put Glóin’s clothes up a tree at the spring.”
Apparently, Kíli has managed to make no shortage of mischief over the course of the past few hours. “That was funny!” Kíli protests, “And you did the same thing yesterday!”
“Glóin is going to murder you both,” Bilbo decides, and immediately regrets his words. Actually, Bolg and Azog are going to murder them both, and it will all be Bilbo’s fault.
“Fíli, give your brother back his arrows,” Thorin takes charge of the situation while Bilbo grapples with the truth. All three of them are fine, and alive, and right here, and Bilbo will do nobody any good by dwelling on the events of a battle that hasn’t taken place yet. “Kíli, give your brother back his knives. Both of you go apologize to Glóin, and do not bother us with this nonsense again.”
“Fine,” Kíli grins.
“Of course, Uncle.” Fíli, too, seems far too enthusiastic about these instructions. If they knew not to do these things (which, doubtlessly, they did), then why did they bother in the first place? And why would they demand that Thorin settle such a minor difference for them, rather than sorting it out with a simple wrestling match? They’ve certainly had no shortage of those on the road thus far. “What were you talking about?”
“None of your business,” Bilbo says sharply.
Thorin only shakes his head. “You heard the Burglar.”
“How are your gardening lessons coming, Uncle?” Kíli presses. Bilbo no longer has any clue what is going on. “Bilbo, what have you been teaching him?”
“Nothing whatsoever,” Bilbo replies, brow furrowed.
“Then what were you talking about yesterday?” Fíli asks.
Why, he’s as nosy as a Hobbit! Bilbo can easily imagine Thorin’s lads leading young Frodo into all sorts of mischief, and vise versa, now that he thinks about it. More likely than not, the same skills that allow them to steal one another’s weapons without being noticed could easily be transferred to the procurement of mushrooms and other foodstuffs.
Thorin rubs at his temples. Bilbo doesn’t blame him. “Find something else to do with yourselves.”
“As you say, My King.” Fíli sweeps into an elaborate bow and drags his brother down with him.
“Your wish is our command,” Kíli adds, though he seems barely able to contain his laughter.
They’re gone as quickly as they came, bolting out the door with no regard for the fact that they are guests in Beorn’s home. Then again, Bilbo can remember seeing folk running about indoors in Erebor, and the skin-changer himself has not said a word about this practice. Perhaps only Hobbits and Elves consider such behavior impolite.
“We left them alone for… what, two hours?” Bilbo still cannot get over how young the Princes are, how mischievous.
Thorin sighs heavily. “My sister-sons are not so childish as they wish you to believe,” he intones. “That was a terrible display. Far from their best work.”
“Their best work?” Bilbo echoes.
There is a fond light in Thorin’s eyes. “Kíli once interrupted a council meeting in Ered Luin to tell me about a frog he’d caught.”
“There are frogs in the Blue Mountains?” This is news to Bilbo. He supposes he doesn’t know enough about mountains to have any clue whether frogs may live there, but he will readily admit that he has never considered the possibility before.
“Perhaps not,” Thorin replies. It seems that if there are, Kíli did not bring evidence of this to the meeting he barged into. “But there were plans for future hunting being discussed in that closed council meeting.”
“And he wasn’t supposed to be a part of the discussion?” Bilbo can’t see why Thorin wouldn’t cut his losses and include his nephew in the conversation. Kíli is easily the most skilled archer of their company, and Bilbo can’t imagine that there’s anybody better lurking in the Blue Mountains.
“Absolutely not. He was far too young. The elder members of the council are sticklers for tradition, even in exile, though the plan Kíli proposed once he got himself into the meeting wasn’t half bad,” Thorin recounts, “His brother is worse. Fíli once followed me forty miles to return a tobacco pouch I’d never seen before, and then just happened to be present for the skirmish with the orcs I’d been tracking. I thought my sister might breathe fire when I brought him home.”
“No stopping those lads when there’s something they want, I suppose,” Bilbo muses.
“They are Sons of Durin,” says Thorin by way of explanation. Perhaps he sees a little of himself in that tenacity, and that is why he permits such behavior from his nephews. “Mahal has blessed me with two clever and passionate heirs.” A small pause. “He has not seen fit to grant me peace or quiet.”
“But you mean to say,” Bilbo can barely contain his laughter, “That your nephews manufactured a tall tale about arrows and knives and pulling a prank on Glóin just so they could eavesdrop on our conversation?” Actually, when he puts it that way, Bilbo can easily believe this story. “Oh. Well, I suppose it’s quite a relief to know that your heirs can have their wits about them when they choose to do so.”
“Not even those two young fools would be daft enough to steal from my brother,” Óin declares. Apparently, he’s deemed this part of the conversation important enough to warrant the use of his trumpet.
“Of course not,” Thorin agrees, “They have more sense than they seem to. I would not have brought them along if they did not.”
“They’re bright lads,” says Bilbo, “And very kind. Brave, too. You must be proud.”
Thorin smiles. Perhaps he’s going to elaborate on just how proud he is of his nephews, but he never gets a chance, because the sound of Glóin’s irate voice carries over to them from the general direction of the spring. “When I get my hands on you two, I’ll have your hides, princes of Erebor or no!”
Apparently, not everything Fíli and Kíli told them was part of their confusing ruse. Why make up an excuse, anyway? Bilbo would’ve welcomed them to join the conversation in the normal manner, and Thorin would have done the same, surely. Perhaps the boys were only trying to catch them off guard. Though what they think they’d gain from it, Bilbo doesn’t know.
The king sighs heavily and stares up at the rafters. If only this were the worst sort of problem that he ever had to deal with. “I’d better go and rescue your boys,” Bilbo decides. “If only to keep poor Glóin out of prison. I can’t imagine he’d like it very much, and I suppose attacking the heirs to the throne must constitute treason. I’m sure Óin won’t have you up and about any time soon, so it’s got to be me, hasn’t it?”
Óin only grunts in agreement as he begins to bandage Thorin’s injuries anew.
“You are right,” Thorin concedes, “Besides, I must have at least one of my sister-sons alive to be my heir. My cousin Dáin might murder me if I threatened to make him King of Erebor.”
Bilbo elects not to think too hard about that. He’s got to stay present in the moment to negotiate between the princes and Glóin, after all. He can’t afford to mope about, ascribing prophetic qualities to Thorin’s idle words.
“Hm,” Bilbo forcibly ignores the memories that threaten to intrude upon this peaceful moment. “Well, perhaps once I’ve rescued the lads, I can give them a little bit of a talking-to. They should know it’s rude to listen in on other people’s conversations.”
For some reason, Thorin’s ears turn red. “Yes,” he says eventually. “That is rude.”
Interesting. “Off you go, lad!” Óin urges, before Bilbo can press the matter. Whether he’s taking pity on his king or simply sick of listening to the two of them, Bilbo isn’t sure, but he takes the advice regardless.
All told, the company has a fine time in the home of Beorn. They eat good food, interact with clever animals, and generally recover from the harrowing events of the past few months.
“Thank Mahal that’s over, huh?” Says Bofur one morning, throwing his arm around Bilbo. Everyone always seems to be throwing their arms around Bilbo these days.
But maybe that’s for the best, especially right now. He was watching Beorn with rapt attention, caught up in yet another moment of deja vu. Bilbo remembers, if perhaps a little vaguely, that Lady Galadriel showed him this very scene. He supposes that this means he’s still on the right track, though there is nothing particularly noteworthy about it. He’s certain that several other scenes from his vision have passed him by without his knowledge, so many images were there in the horrible barrage that inundated him at the Grey Havens. Not that he’d be able to explain any of this to a soul.
“What’s over?” Bilbo echoes, not following.
“All that business with the orcs,” Bofur explains helpfully. “You’ve got to drag yourself away from that window, now, though, I’m sorry to say. You’re needed in the kitchen.”
“Of course I am.” Not a moment of peace for this Hobbit. But, then, if he’d wanted that, he was perfectly free to sail to the Undying Lands. Bilbo chose this, even if it means being set to odd tasks from time to time.
When he arrives in the kitchen, still with Bofur’s arm draped all around him, Bilbo is not even remotely surprised to see Bombur commanding a small army of intelligent dogs. “What’ve you gotten yourself into now, my friend?” He inquires gently.
Bombur is the quiet sort, which suits Bilbo perfectly fine. A fair listener, and a good companion to have in the kitchen. The dogs seem to like him, anyway. “Bilbo!” He greets the Hobbit with a big grin. “Come here and stir this cheese in, will you? I trust no one else to do it properly.”
“Well, of course not.” Bilbo allows himself to be moved over to the stove, where Bombur has got a pot of what appears to be milk heating. There’s a bowl of shredded cheese off to the side, and Bilbo can see what’s required of him. “Should I wait for it to boil?” Still, he feels he should at least make a show of deference.
“Please,” Bombur says.
Bofur settles down on a conveniently placed stool, and Bilbo can easily imagine him pestering his brother in the kitchen, perhaps while whittling or working on some other small task. That’s where these two have been this entire time, then. On the last adventure, nobody would’ve invited Bilbo to help in the kitchen, that’s for sure. He was slightly less standoffish than he had been at the start, clearly a member of the company, but they all left him to his own devices. Not so now.
“Keep your hands where I can see them,” Bombur orders his brother. “I know your tricks, even if Bilbo doesn’t, and I’ll not have you taking advantage.”
“Oh, like he’s going to reach his hand into the… fondue?” Bilbo makes the connection with delight. What sort of Hobbit is he, that it took him so long to figure out the recipe? “You’ve outdone yourself, Bombur!” This certainly never happened the last time. Beorn fed them well, but there was no fondue to be had.
“You’re right, he really doesn’t know my tricks.” Bofur grins at his brother, brandishing a slice of bread. Where did he get that? “Maybe I should teach ‘em to him.” Ah.
“It’s not even melted yet!” Bilbo yelps, at the same time that Bombur says, “I’ll cut off your hand.”
Two different approaches to the same problem, Bilbo supposes. He can’t imagine what it’s like, having to cook every day with a nosy brother in the kitchen. Little Frodo was bad enough, but he wasn’t Bilbo’s elder and could easily be dismissed, set to another, more appropriate task. And anyway, Frodo grew out of his food-stealing tendencies rather quickly after he moved into Bag End and realized that the skills he’d picked up in the bustling Brandy Hall were not needed in the little smial. How Bombur manages, though, Bilbo will never understand.
“Oh, are you cooking?” Ori pokes his head into the kitchen. “How’d you get Master Beorn to allow that?”
Bombur shrugs. “Talked to him.”
“You did?” Ori sound genuinely surprised. Bilbo, too, is a little taken aback. The last time, he rarely heard Bombur speak to anybody.
“My dear brother’s getting better at talking to outsiders,” Bofur explains, pretending to choke up. “We’re all very proud.”
“Bilbo’s easy company,” Bombur elaborates, “So I figured, maybe Beorn could be, too. He’s not much like the other Men I’ve met.”
“Not much like other bears I’ve seen, either,” Bofur quips, though he does have a point. Beorn is a skin-changer, always somewhere in between his two forms, both Man and bear regardless of his outward appearance.
Bilbo has always suspected that there was some reason behind Bombur’s continued silence. The two of them didn’t talk much on their first adventure, outside of the regular pleasantries that can be expected when traveling. But now, Bilbo wonders what sorts of experiences Bombur must’ve had with Men to put him off of other folk. He can certainly infer, and nothing he imagines is particularly pleasant. Better not to make Bombur relive it. Still, Bilbo is pleased if his friendship can help to make Bombur feel more comfortable.
“Thank you,” Bilbo says to Bombur, ignoring Bofur’s comment, “And this fondue will be excellent.” He adds the cheese to the pot and takes up his spoon. Stirring frequently is important to avoid burning.
“We can’t try it yet,” Bofur informs Ori. “Or we’ll have both of them after us with their butcher knives and wooden spoons.”
“I’m not afraid of a wooden spoon,” Ori announces. Brave lad.
“What’s going on here?” Balin materializes in the doorway. “Is that cheese I smell?”
“Fondue, courtesy of Bombur,” Bilbo calls. “I’m just an extra set of hands.”
“That was the intention of hiring a fourteenth member,” Balin claims, “And what a fine set of hands yours have turned out to be.” He winks.
“Old flatterer,” Bilbo groans. “Nobody is getting any fondue before it’s ready. You wouldn’t want it anyway! Wait for the cheese to melt.”
“You've hired a mercenary to keep me out of your cooking,” Bofur complains to his brother. “I see that now. Well played, I have to say, but while he’s guarding the stovetop, nobody’s guarding the ale; did you think of that?”
“I don’t care how much you drink, brother-mine,” Bombur says. He’s busy slicing strawberries for what will surely turn out to be a fabulous dessert. “But I’ve no shame about getting a warrior-Hobbit to guard my fondue.”
“Warrior-Hobbit,” Bilbo snorts. “If I am one, I’m the only one.”
“Then you’re the only one,” Balin informs him.
“So there’s not many soldiers in the Shire?” Ori withdraws an impressively-sized notebook from seemingly nowhere. Has he had that on him the entire time? Of course he has.
“Not a one,” Bilbo informs him, stirring gently. The cheese is melting well, but it’s best to keep stirring so that it doesn’t stick to the bottom of the pan. Hitherto, Beorn’s animal servants have refused to allow the company to help them wash dishes, and he doesn’t want to stick them with a cheese-encrusted pot. “Your brother knows that, I’m sure. He says he’s spent time with Hobbits.”
“You can’t mean Dori,” Ori guesses. “Is that where Nori goes off to, then? The Shire?”
“It’s where I’d go, if I were a pickpocket,” Bofur muses. “I don’t expect folks are looking out to be burgled.”
“Bree,” Bilbo corrects.
“Are there Hobbits in Bree?” Ori asks. Perhaps he’s passed through, but he clearly hasn’t spent any meaningful amount of time there, to be asking a question like that.
And Bilbo spends the rest of the afternoon discussing the differences between the Shire and Bree, which devolves quite quickly into a series of anecdotes. By the end of it, he manages to drill a little bit of Shire geography into the heads of his friends, and he regales them with his entirely unbiased opinions about Bree and the Breelanders. In return, he hears of the Blue Mountains and of Erebor.
By the time dinner rolls around, Bilbo, Bombur, and Beorn’s animal friends have managed to put together quite the feast. There is no meat to be had, of course, but nobody seems to mind that when presented with the delicious fondue. “Little bunny is a good hand in the kitchen as well,” Beorn announces after tasting Bilbo’s creation.
Thorin audibly growls at this. Perhaps he’s not pleased that Bilbo was on his feet cooking with his alleged injuries. “I barely did anything,” Bilbo assures the group, “Just stirred the pot, really. It’s Bombur’s recipe.”
“Even so, it’s better than anything I could make,” Dori announces, before dipping another bread cube into the fondue pot.
“And don’t we all know it,” Nori agrees.
“Dori never made us anything we couldn’t eat,” Ori leaps to his eldest brother’s defense.
“So no greens, then,” Bilbo mutters. He doesn’t envy Dori, having to cook for two young ones while also working to support the family, and no doubt worrying over Nori all the time.
“Eat up, now,” Beorn counsels laughingly. He never takes his eyes off Bilbo. “You must get nice and fat again before you leave my hall, Little Bunny. There’ll be no one to look after you out in the forest.” He pokes Bilbo in the stomach, which, while expected, is not necessarily very welcome.
Thorin’s fork clatters to the table. When Bilbo looks up, he finds that the king has risen abruptly and is now looming over the table as though preparing to do battle. “Is something the matter?” Bilbo asks as gently as he can. He’s beyond confused by this development.
“Excuse me,” Thorin grits out. He storms off, then, leaving a stunned company to try and figure out what upset him so much this time.
Thankfully, Fíli and Kíli seem to understand what’s going on better than Bilbo does. They exchange a meaningful look, and then Fíli sighs and rises. “I’ll go talk to him,” he says.
“Good luck.” Apparently the situation isn’t too serious, because Kíli takes the liberty of throwing three bread cubes at his brother’s back in quick succession.
“Bombur worked hard on those!” Bilbo scolds him absently.
Bombur shakes his head, laughing. “They’re as good for throwing as they are for eating!” As though to prove his point, he opens his mouth.
Bofur, who seems to catch onto this odd signal, dutifully tosses a bread cube in his brother’s direction. When Bombur catches this, the others seem to take this as an invitation to pelt him with all manner of food. He does manage to eat a fair bit of it, to his credit.
Yes!” Ori cheers. “Three in a row!”
“Now try it with your sling,” Nori urges with a nefarious grin. He’s almost definitely joking. Bilbo is fairly certain that Ori could take a window out with a single bread cube propelled from that little slingshot of his.
Bifur puts a stop to this plan in Khuzdul before Dori even finishes chewing. At least someone is still using the food for its intended purpose, which is to say, eating rather than throwing.
“Could I trouble you for a glass of wine?” Gandalf inquires of Beorn, rather politely, too. “Perhaps we might take it outside.”
“Yes,” says Beorn. “You bring strange folk to my home, Gandalf, with strange ways and customs.”
“They’re no more strange to you than you are to them,” Gandalf points out, standing and pushing in his chair.
Bilbo watches them go and considers following. Then he glances once more to his friends, who continue to toss food about, somehow managing to consume the vast majority of what flies through the air.
“Go on, then, Bilbo,” Balin urges, “You know you want to.”
“I don’t see you throwing bread cubes,” says Bilbo, as primly as he is able.
Balin only shrugs, catching a piece of potato in his (thankfully empty) water goblet. He throws it right back at Dwalin, who grabs it in midair and pops it into his mouth. Mealtimes with the company are always like this, when there is no danger looming over their shoulders. One might think that Bilbo would be used to it by now. Kíli has taken to using the contents of his brother’s abandoned plate as further projectiles, with a laughing Bifur on the receiving end.
“Oh, why not?” Bilbo shrugs. He picks a strawberry off the beautifully-done shortcake and tosses it at Bombur. The resultant cheer is loud enough that they can probably be heard in Lake-town.
After a few more days in Beorn’s hall, Bilbo has resolved (if a little reluctantly) that he must ask Gandalf for help. The entire company has grown restless beyond belief, and it has become clear to Óin that Bilbo has not contracted any type of illness through his contact with orc blood. Thorin, too, has healed enough that he can reasonably be expected to continue the journey, which, of course, he is itching to do. And the others have patched up their cuts, bruises, and burns.
They will have to go into Mirkwood. They will have to face the spiders and the Elves. Bilbo won’t be able to leave the ring inside the house while he works in the garden. His peace, he knows, will be destroyed. In all likelihood, the ring will be angry with him for manufacturing so much distance. He knows now that it has a mind of its own, and that the mind in question is beyond evil. But Bilbo sees no way around it.
Even if he could find a way to navigate through the remainder of their journey without making use of the ring, Bilbo wouldn’t exactly be able to leave it with Beorn. The skin-changer is good, kind, and just, but who knows what he would become in the clutches of the ring? Bilbo can’t bet on the fact that Beorn would simply never find the bauble. He knows his home, after all. And Bilbo knows that telling Beorn the truth would not be enough to prevent disaster, either. He has heard Frodo’s stories, and was deeply troubled to learn of how easily Boromir of Gondor fell to the influence of the ring. What would happen to Beorn after decades living alongside it?
All this is assuming that nothing more sinister would be pulled in by the ring during one of Beorn’s long absences. No, Bilbo simply cannot take the chance. He must carry the ring to Erebor and destroy it in dragon fire. But he needs to protect himself as best he can. After listening to Frodo’s tale, he’s a bit suspicious that part of the company’s disorientation in Mirkwood was caused by the ring. Moreover, he is just generally very uncomfortable with it, and more than a little worried that if the bond between himself and the ring deepens, it will be difficult for Bilbo to get up the courage to destroy it. Look at what happened to Frodo, after all.
Bilbo approaches Gandalf in the garden. The Wizard is staring off into the distance, making smoke rings and then sending smoke ships through them, an old trick which Bilbo has always appreciated greatly. If he were a Wizard, he thinks, he’d make all kinds of smoke shapes for the delight of the young ones in the Shire. And the young ones in the company, now that he thinks about it. Competent warriors though they may be, Fíli and Kíli would doubtlessly appreciate a good smoke ship, were they not so busy literally poking the bear by bothering Beorn. And Ori could probably write a ten-page essay on the magic of smoke ships, complete with solid theories about how they are produced.
“Ah, Bilbo,” Gandalf sighs, “You’ve been very busy as of late. I haven’t gotten much chance to speak with you.” The twinkle in his eyes suggests that he is very aware of what has kept Bilbo so busy, and that he is very amused by it.
“Yes, well.” Bilbo sits down on a rock beside the one Gandalf is using as a chair. “You know. Healing, and all that. Very important.”
“Of course.” More of that knowing twinkle. “You and Thorin seem to be getting along very well.”
“We are,” Bilbo agrees, unable to restrain his smile. It’s foolish of him, he knows. But the knowledge of how horribly things might go has given him a great appreciation for these quieter moments, which were fewer and farther between before. He still picks fights, of course, still refuses to allow the king to walk all over him, but Bilbo has also permitted himself to indulge a bit during this brief interlude in their journey. Still, he knows it must come to an end.
“But you are not here to talk about that, are you?” Gandalf prods, holding his pipe out to Bilbo. By the Valar, this Wizard is perceptive. He always has been. If Bilbo’s not careful, he’ll guess exactly what’s going on and try to put a stop to it. Or, even worse, he will sign onto Bilbo’s plan. That’s an indication that he’s on the wrong track, if anything is.
“No, I’m not,” Bilbo admits, accepting the pipe and taking a puff. He doesn’t bother with smoke rings, so glad is he to taste proper pipeweed again. “Gandalf… Do you…” How to phrase this? “Do you know of… any way to dilute the power of a… magical object?” There. That’s nice and vague. Gandalf will never suspect. He let Bilbo walk around carrying the One Ring for sixty years, after all. He may be perceptive, but many things still manage to clear that impressive hat of his and go over his head.
“A magical object,” Gandalf echoes thoughtfully. “Bilbo, has Thorin spoken to you about the Arkenstone?”
Oh, yes, this is perfect. Bilbo can’t believe his luck. He knows it’s not generally advisable to lie to Wizards, but he has plenty of practice with it as-is, and Gandalf has given him the perfect cover. “He has,” Bilbo confirms. He’s not even technically lying! Thorin has spoken to him about the Arkenstone at length, though not on this particular timeline. “I worry that it might… have some power over him. What Elrond said about the madness… I just… I worry.” He hands the pipe back over.
Gandalf takes a contemplative puff, then exhales another perfect smoke ring. “I have hope that Thorin will prove stronger than his father and his grandfather.”
Bilbo sighs. Gandalf is supposed to be all-knowing and all-seeing, but not only did he encourage Bilbo to leave an evil ring in Frodo’s possession, he used his flimsy hope as an excuse to send Thorin to his death. Bilbo clenches his fists, forces a few deep breaths, and reminds himself that none of that will happen if he has anything to say about it. Gandalf isn’t as wise as he pretends to be, but only because he doesn’t have the context that Bilbo has. All that Bilbo can do now is make the most of his foreknowledge.
“But even so, that stone has a great power,” he points out, “I want to know what I can do to stop it from… harming him.” The words are difficult to speak around the lump in Bilbo’s throat.
Gandalf studies Bilbo for some time. “Unions between different folk of Middle Earth are rare,” he says slowly, as if imparting new information upon Bilbo, “But not unheard of.”
Bilbo huffs. Oh, really, this is just too much. Here he is, trying to be patient, seeking information about how to prevent the One Ring from poisoning his mind while he journeys through a dangerous forest, under the pretext of asking about how to disarm the Arkenstone(information which might help him, actually, when it comes down to it), and Gandalf dares to speak to him about unions?
“There will be no union at all if we starve to death inside that mountain!” Bilbo snaps. “Assuming that we even make it there.” It is a struggle to restrain eight long decades of grief and rage and pain. He may not have understood everything, at the end, may not have been able to piece it all together, but now, oh, now, Bilbo is fully capable of seeing the full picture. He is staring it in the face, and he does not like the Wizard’s role in it.
Gandalf continues to study him, which Bilbo does not appreciate. “Very well,” he finally says, placing a gentle hand on Bilbo’s shoulder. “You have a good heart, Bilbo Baggins, a very good heart.” Bilbo cannot help but wonder if these are the sort of words that Gandalf said to Frodo when he sent him to Mount Doom. What did the Wizard say to Thorin to induce him to initiate this quest in the first place? Must Gandalf lead everyone that Bilbo loves toward a cursed mountain? “There is not much that can be done for such things.”
Bilbo sags. Of course there wouldn’t be. And if he can’t do anything to dilute the power of the Arkenstone, then Yavanna knows that there is nothing to be done about the ring, either. “However,” Gandalf continues, “You may have some luck wrapping it in cloth or paper and keeping it as far away from people as you can get it. Casting it off entirely, if you can. Though I do not know if that would be enough. If an item has some enchantment upon it, the worst thing you can do is touch it.”
“We have to do this,” Bilbo groans. He suspects that wrapping the ring in cloth won’t be very effective, but what else can he do? It’s better than nothing, surely. “There’s no way around it.”
“No, I’m afraid there isn’t,” Gandalf agrees. “Though it must be said that not everyone is affected the same way by the same object. We have no reason to expect that Thorin will fall to the influence of the Arkenstone.”
“Does it matter what kind of cloth?” Bilbo must shove his anger aside. He has to do what he can, even if it doesn’t work. Even if everything turns out exactly the same, at least Bilbo can say that he tried. But he knows, even now, that it will not be possible for things to turn out exactly the same way they did eighty years ago.
“Not particularly,” Gandalf admits. Bilbo wonders if the method the Wizard has described has any actual bearing, or if Gandalf was simply pulling something out of thin air to placate the Hobbit. Bilbo supposes that he will find out in Mirkwood.
“Master Baggins!” Thorin addresses Bilbo formally, on edge, as always, in the Wizard’s presence. “We are going now.” He’s moving more quickly than he would’ve been able to a few short days ago, and already dressed for the journey in his fir-trimmed coat. “You’d best come collect your things.”
“Of course, Your Majesty,” Bilbo rolls his eyes. It’s ridiculous of Thorin to keep up this whole ‘Master Baggins’ pretense, but then, they haven’t exactly talked about their feelings, have they? “Just a moment.”
“Not just a moment,” Thorin argues. “Now.” On the last adventure, they stayed for luncheon with Beorn on their last day together. Perhaps Bilbo is imagining it, but it seems to him as though Thorin likes the skin-changer less than he did the first time around.
Bilbo ignores Gandalf’s meaningful look and follows Thorin back to Beorn’s home in a very charged silence. Neither one of them bothers to say what’s on their mind. For reasons entirely his own, the Wizard ambles after them. “Give me five seconds,” Bilbo orders. “I have to get my pack ready.”
“You should have gotten it ready this morning,” Thorin complains.
“The sun is barely up,” Bilbo protests, “I’ve only had one breakfast.” He’s not looking forward to returning to the road, where he will no doubt be skipping second breakfast, elevensies, afternoon tea, and supper once again.
Thorin grumbles about traveling with Hobbits, and Bilbo shoots him a glare. They appear to be at a stalemate, which seems to be their perpetual state of affairs. “You had time enough to gabble with the Wizard.”
“Run along,” Bilbo orders, because he is feeling particularly bold, and particularly incensed about that last comment. “I’ll join you shortly.”
“I will accompany you,” Thorin declares, “To keep you to your task.”
Oh, if only. Bilbo does not understand why Thorin might wish to help him put together his pack, and under any other circumstances, he’d be delighted to have the king’s company. But for the moment, Bilbo has other things to worry about. He’s got to deal with the ring, after all, and he can’t have Thorin seeing it. That wouldn’t end well at all.
“No need,” Bilbo assures him with a feigned smile. “I’ll only be just a moment. Feed Peony and Honeysuckle some apples for me, won’t you?”
“Who?” Thorin looks genuinely baffled.
Bilbo rolls his eyes. “The ponies,” he clarifies, “Mine and yours. Do you mean to tell me that you never asked Beorn what Peony’s name was when he introduced you?” Then he thinks on it for a moment. “Of course you didn’t.”
“I suppose I owe her two apples, then,” Thorin deadpans, and Bilbo snorts.
“And more than a couple of sugar cubes, for such impertinence,” Bilbo agrees. “Off you go.” Once more, despite all odds, Thorin listens to him. Gandalf watches these proceedings with palpable glee. Typical.
“Not a word from you,” Bilbo orders the Wizard before turning on his heel and sauntering off.
“Hurry up with your bag, my friend,” Gandalf gives him an order in return. This is also typical. “It would be best not to keep His Majesty waiting!” Very funny.
Bilbo does hurry, but only because he wants to get this over with. They moved quickly when they entered Mirkwood the first time, didn’t they? So they’ll have to move quickly this time around, as well. He steals one of Beorn’s shirts (desperate times call for desperate measures) and a piece of fur that somebody left behind, wrapping both around the ring as many times as possible before shoving it into the compartment of his pack that will put it furthest from his body. He’ll have to return it to his jacket pocket before they meet the spiders, of course, but this, at least, will offer some protection in the meantime.
Chapter 7: Mirkwood
Notes:
Thanks as always for reading and leaving kudos/comments! This chapter was an interesting one to write, because everybody is so disoriented, especially Bilbo. As it turns out, it's not so easy to tell a story when your POV character has no idea what's going on.
Chapter Text
When Thorin was young, a spoiled little prince with a kingdom guaranteed to him, he was frightened of the Greenwood. He did not like the Elves, with their long bodies and unblinking eyes. He did not like the thought of trees, with their constant noise and constant movement, nothing like the steady, solid stone of Erebor. He did not like the idea of a place that teemed with creatures, the birds that fluttered and the rodents that crawled along the ground. Much like his grandfather, Thorin avoided the Greenwood at all costs. His first true experience of the forest came when he fled through it, leading his family and his people away from the dragon that had stolen their home. It seemed a fell place, unfamiliar and crowded.
But Thorin would gladly take a hundred years in that forest over whatever shadow of it he now travels through. The Hobbit spoke, just before the Wizard left them at the edge of the woods, of a sickness lurking among the trees. Thorin cannot sense it, but he believes the Burglar nevertheless. Master Baggins would not lie to him. There is some malady hanging over these lands, something horrible, unspeakable. He can feel it reaching into his brain and scrambling his thoughts, misdirecting him.
He sees things that he knows cannot be there. Large eyes watching through the trees. Small eyes, blinking in the night. Mithril glinting between branches above him as he tries and fails to sleep. The more he sees these things, though, the more he begins to wonder if perhaps he can trust his perception, after all.
The days blur together. Thorin does not know how long he has been in these woods, how long it was since Tharkûn left them at the edge of the forest, since they sent off Beorn’s ponies. He does know that their supplies are dwindling already, that there are fewer honey cakes than he would like to see and far too little cheese. What fruit Beorn sent with them is beginning to spoil, and the other provisions will soon follow, assuming they last long enough to do so.Thorin cannot remember the last time there was meat to be had. But then, he can barely remember what he’s doing in this cursed forest to begin with.
Erebor, he tells himself when his steps begin to drag, when the air feels thin and the trees seem to crowd him, Erebor. That is why he does this.
Once, Thorin swears that he sees Thráin, old and haggard, wandering aimlessly just a little to the left of the path. Balin grabs hold of the back of Thorin’s coat before he can even think about darting after his father. “Thorin,” Balin counsels him, “No. The Wizard said not to leave the path.”
“My father is out there,” Thorin tries to tell him. “He is out there. I must go to him.”
“I can assure you that he is not,” is Balin’s assertion, but Thorin isn’t so sure.
But when he looks again, his father is gone, as though he were never there. Perhaps Thorin only caught sight of his own reflection. How much has this quest aged him, in only a few short months? No. There is nothing there for his image to be reflected in. It must have been some trick of this wicked forest, he tells himself. That is all.
Thorin is not going mad. His proximity to Erebor is not driving him to dragon sickness. He has not fallen to Thrór’s malady. He is well. He is strong. He is not his grandfather. He is not his grandfather. Only, his hands look older in the faint light that seeps through the trees than they did in the skin-changer’s hall. Sometimes, he swears that he can see his grandfather’s ring on his finger, but that cannot be. It went missing with his father. His father. Where is Thráin? Thorin must search for him! Why did he stop searching?
This time, it is Master Baggins who pulls him back onto the path. He shudders at the touch of the soft hand, even through his heavy coat. Thorin feels as though he is being dragged deep into the ground, back into the safety of a mountain, while simultaneously floating far above his own head. He is being spun around in circles, yet his inertia could kill him.
“Don’t go,” the Hobbit whispers, eyes wide.
Thorin can see himself reflected in those brilliant irises. He is not his grandfather. He is Thorin, son of Thráin, and he is strong. The King Under the Mountain. He will take his homeland back and he will rule it well and he will have this Hobbit as his consort. When they reach Erebor, Thorin will find all the best jewels in his possession and he will give each and every one to Bilbo Baggins. He will fall to his knees, he will shower this lovely and perplexing creature with gifts, he will protect him at all costs.
“You must stay,” the Hobbit pleads, “You must stay with me. Don’t go, Thorin; please don’t leave me again.”
Thorin has no intention of going anywhere. He wants to tell Bilbo as much, to catch the Hobbit in his arms and never let him go. He does not like the way the others look at Bilbo. Thorin feels a sudden rage at the concerned expression on Bofur’s face. What business is it of Bofur’s if Bilbo and Thorin want to have a conversation? The Hobbit is his.
He takes two more steps forward and it all falls away. Why is Thorin angry? Of course Bofur would be concerned. The Hobbit looks to be near tears. And why? Because Thorin nearly stepped off the path. Stupid of him, yes, but not worth crying over. “Are you alright, Master Baggins?” He asks softly, trying not to startle his Burglar.
The Hobbit’s eyes are glazed over. He does not look as though he is entirely here, entirely present in the moment as he continues to grip at Thorin’s sleeve, muttering nonsense about not leaving him. As though Thorin ever could. He turns back to Bofur, in search of aid, the comfort of knowing that someone else here is aware enough to notice that something is not right, but when he glances back, Bofur is glaring daggers at a tree.
“This place is cursed,” Thorin mutters. “We should not linger here. Forward!”
His words don’t have very much effect on the rest of the company, but at least they appear to shock Bilbo out of whatever reverie has lately gripped him. “Oh my goodness, I’m so sorry!” He exclaims, letting go of Thorin’s coat with a sheepish little laugh. Thorin wishes never to take his eyes off of the Hobbit. He would be pleased, he thinks, to do nothing but look upon Bilbo for the rest of his days. No treasure in any mountain could ever compare. “I was clinging to you like a leech.”
Thorin is just about to offer Bilbo his hand, but his next step assures him that this is not a sound plan. Mirkwood itself is already distracting enough. Thorin cannot focus on the warmth of the Hobbit’s touch, the softness of his skin. He must direct whatever energy he can muster toward getting his company out of these woods.
Bilbo’s face radiates heat as he steps away from Thorin. Oh, how terribly embarrassing! The memory is fuzzy now, which is troubling, considering its recency, but Bilbo knows that he had no idea where he was just then. Seeing Thorin confused him. He thought the king was a ghost, a spirit, but he wasn’t able to restrain himself from reaching out. And when his hand made contact with the cool cloth of Thorin’s coat, Bilbo burst into tears.
It makes perfect sense to Bilbo. This place is under some fell enchantment, and the entire company is on edge. Bilbo in particular is especially on edge, because he alone knows exactly what is going to happen to them in Mirkwood. First, their minds will weaken. Then, they will forget the Wizard’s advice and wander off the path. Next, they will be attacked by giant spiders. Finally, they’ll be thrown into Elven dungeons, and only then will they begin to think clearly again. And poor Bombur is going to fall into the enchanted stream at some point. When? Now? No, not now, they aren’t by the stream.
Shouldn’t there be a boat? And a stag. Last time, there was a stag. Bilbo distinctly remembers. Was it a stag? Perhaps an elk?
A dragon. There was a dragon, breathing heavy fire over the land, nearly killing Bilbo.
No, no, a stag. It was definitely a stag, pure white. Who shot at it? Somebody tried to kill it and failed. Succeeded? Bilbo can see the dead deer in front of him, flies swarming its great white body, stained red. But nobody else seems bothered. “Look,” he says, “Look, look.”
“There’s nothing there.” Dwalin claps his hand on Bilbo’s shoulder. Bilbo looks at his friend’s grim face, then back at the deer, and he finds that Dwalin speaks true. There is nothing blocking their path.
Right. But there was a deer the first time. Someone tried to kill it. Who? Bard killed the beast, but Bilbo had not been there to watch. He waited and waited for the dragon to return, stared out at Lake-town and thought of his friends burning to death on that little island, only to find that they were all miraculously alive and well, the dragon lying in the middle of the lake. No. That was later. There was a deer. What about the deer?
Thorin shot at it, but he missed, and the creature ran away. It reminds Bilbo of another arrow, fired from a much nicer bow and a much greater height, a warning shot placed at the feet of an Elven king. That was the beginning of the end, the day that Thorin sealed his fate. Would things have turned out differently, if he’d offered gold to the Men and Elves, friendship rather than war? But that does not matter. Things will not turn out any differently. The moment Thorin sets foot inside that mountain, the dragon’s hoard will begin to poison his mind.
What are they doing, going to Erebor? What is Bilbo doing, going to Erebor when he knows that his friends will die there? He cannot do this. He cannot do this. Oh, but he must! He must follow Thorin, because there is no universe where he can force his king to stay behind. Not if Bilbo locked him up, as though that were possible. There is no way around this; Bilbo and the company must press forward. He must keep going.
Bilbo forces his feet to move. He follows blindly, allowing himself to be led, trusting the company. Why is he trusting the company? He knows what’s going to happen. He knows what to expect from this place, and he is letting it happen again. Bilbo knows what to expect. He knows what’s coming next.
What is coming next? He wracks his brain and can’t remember. The only thing he is sure of is the padding of his feet against the root-strewn ground, the heavy rhythm of his steps on the forest floor. The trees are blurry, and he loses track of each of his companions.
“We found the bridge!” Kíli announces.
It takes Bilbo a few seconds to get his bearings, to figure out where everyone is. After that, it takes a few more seconds to look ahead and notice the bridge, or rather, the lack thereof. “Something… took it out,” Bilbo muses. He is fascinated by this idea. What could be big enough, strong enough, to destroy a bridge? There is a large chunk missing from the middle of it, making the stream impassible. But… where is that chunk? Bilbo looks down into the water in a vain attempt to locate the stones. “Where did it go?”
“We could try and swim it,” suggests an echoing voice behind him. Bilbo cannot place the speaker.
“Didn’t you hear what Gandalf said?” But that voice, Bilbo would know anywhere. Thorin is here. Bilbo feels safer all of a sudden. He knows, in his heart, that he will be perfectly secure so long as he travels with Thorin Oakenshield. No, that’s not right. It’s the other way around. He’s supposed to be the one keeping Thorin safe. “A dark magic lies upon this forest. The waters of this stream are enchanted.” But it is difficult to think about the words when the voice that speaks them is so pleasant. This is a voice from Bilbo’s dreams, a voice that gave him comfort across long years when he was all alone in the world.
“Doesn’t look very enchanting to me,” Bofur mumbles, staring into the stream.
“Do you see the rest of the bridge anywhere?” Bilbo asks. He cannot imagine where it could have gone. It would be very large, after all.
“I do not,” Balin pipes in. Bilbo turns and finds his friend staring behind them, which might explain his inability to locate the rest of the bridge. Although, then again, Bilbo is staring in front of them, and he can’t find it either.
“Not up here, neither,” Ori reports helpfully. He is looking skyward, up among the branches.
“We must find another way across,” Thorin resolves. At least someone is thinking clearly. Ha! Thorin, thinking clearly. This would be the first time.
“These vines look strong enough,” Kíli suggests, placing one boot on the base of a tangling mass of vines that seems to reach out across the river. Something about this feels very familiar to Bilbo. He has been here before. There were vines before.
“I remember this place,” Bilbo mutters. He can hear his own heartbeat in his ears.
“You’ve been here before?” Fíli seems to think that this might be plausible. “When?”
“I don’t know,” Bilbo admits. “But it isn’t right.”
“Kíli!!” Thorin calls his younger nephew back, though Kíli was making good headway. “We send the lightest first.”
“Why?” Bilbo asks. “Even if I make it across, it doesn’t mean the rest of you have any hope.”
But for some reason, he knows that he will make it across. He is certain of it, in his heart. He has already navigated these vines, and he has already cleared them. He can do it once more. But he has a strange feeling that something horrible will happen once he does, and he does not want to find out what comes next.
“Master Baggins,” Thorin does not sound particularly patient. Well, that’s nothing new. Bilbo is beginning to forget precisely who Thorin is, but he remembers that his friend is impatient. And demanding. And very handsome. Bilbo has seen him before somewhere. In Bag End? On a battlefield. There was a battle, and something went wrong. “Do not worry. I am right behind you.”
“What if you fall in?” Bilbo asks.
“I will not,” Thorin resolves. Bilbo trusts him.
There was a battle, he thinks as he steps out onto the first vine. And something went horribly wrong. Only Bilbo cannot remember exactly what happened. There was an Elf queen involved, and a bear that rode a giant bird, and an evil eye watching from a dark tower. The party tree, a disappearing trick, and Gandalf’s fireworks. A sword, and blood. A long fall. The sound of bones cracking. Goblin tunnels. Spiders. The broken scales of a dragon’s belly. A young Hobbit, getting caught stealing mushrooms. The Shire, ravaged. A mountain under siege.
Bilbo nearly falls off of the vines, which reminds him where he is. Where is he? The woods somewhere, crossing some water.
“Keep going,” Thorin urges, his voice sounding oddly soft, though he remains on the bank of the stream while Bilbo makes his crossing.
“I’m fine,” Bilbo assures him, “It’s all fine.” If there was a battle, it must have been a thousand years ago. Bilbo has been in this forest for as long as he can remember. He slips a few more times, but manages to cling to the branches with his legs. The water seems to ripple. Ah, of course. Just his luck. Is it speaking to him? No. That is not possible. There was a battle. Bilbo can remember rushing through it, orcs and Elves slashing at each other as he barreled past. A hill he had to climb. “Everything’s fine.”
Before he knows it, he is scrambling onto the bank. Something terrible is going to happen. Bilbo does not know what, but something. He can feel it in his heart, in his head, in his very bones and all his muscles.
“Something’s not right,” he realizes. The words feel strange in his mouth, as though he has spoken them before. “It’s not right at all. Stay where you are!”
But the company is already scrambling across, and having much less luck than Bilbo did. They are all heavier than he is, after all, and not so lithe. They get stuck. They stare into the water. They teeter precariously, clinging to vines which do not look strong enough to hold their weight.
Bilbo blinks, and Thorin is beside him on the bank. How? When did he get here? “Are you alright?” The king inquires. Thorin is the king of something, Bilbo can remember that.
“Fine,” Bilbo manages.
A hand reaches out for him. To choke him, Bilbo realizes. To hold him over a ledge and shake him. Why? Why would Thorin do something like that? Because Bilbo betrayed him. How? Bilbo cannot recall. He flinches away from Thorin’s touch.
“I will not harm you,” Thorin resolves, “I will never harm you. Have I not proven that to you by now?”
The king looks hurt, which Bilbo thinks is somewhat unfair. Thorin is the one who attacked Bilbo before, the one who tried to attack him again just now. Is Bilbo not entitled to flinch away from that? He doesn’t want to be thrown into the water, thrown down from the battlements, thrown out into the fighting.
“But I took it.” The moment Bilbo says this, he knows it to be true. He stole something from Thorin. “It’s all my fault.”
There are Elves and orcs slashing at each other down there, a hill Bilbo must climb. He has to climb the hill. He can’t stay here standing around waiting for Thorin to kill him.
“Yes.” Thorin smiles then, ever-so-slightly, though his eyes remain cautious and his hands upheld. “You have taken something important, my Burglar.”
A confused response dies on Bilbo’s lips when a white stag bounds into the clearing. The sounds of the company behind them fade, and Bilbo turns his head to focus on the stag. He remembers this. And he remembers remembering this. He has seen this creature before.
He can feel a bowstring being pulled taught in his peripheral vision. “What are you doing?” Bilbo asks, though he knows already. Thorin is going to kill the deer.
The king does not seem to hear him. He stares straight ahead, locking eyes with the stag before loosing his arrow and missing. Thorin breathes heavily, and his hair is a mess, the careful braids his nephews wove into it in Beorn’s hall having come entirely undone. When did this happen? Just how long have they been in Mirkwood, that this could have time to happen?
“You shouldn’t have done that,” Bilbo murmurs, laying a hand on Thorin’s arm. Despite himself, he finds he likes the feel of the warmth underneath all those clothes. Too many clothes, in Bilbo’s opinion, but that is of no consequence in these woods. Still, he could keep his hand on Thorin’s arm all day. “It’s bad luck,” Bilbo realizes.
“I don’t believe in luck,” Thorin snarls, though he doesn’t move away from Bilbo’s touch. “We make our own luck.”
Bilbo blinks at him. A face that beautiful should not exist. It is not possible. How does Bilbo know that Thorin is really here? He’s been dead for eighty years, of course he isn’t here. This is another nightmare. Bilbo is in another of his nightmares, that is the only possible explanation. He needs to wake up! But how?
A loud splash answers his question. Bombur has fallen into the stream! Of course he has! Bilbo remembers this, as well. Bombur fell into the stream before, didn’t he? “We have to help him,” Bilbo declares, but Thorin holds out an arm, barring his way.
“You will stay here,” the king orders, a decided edge to his tone. “By my side, where you belong.”
“Bombur has fallen into the stream!” Bilbo protests.
“The others can get him out. You will not leave my side,” Thorin reiterates. “I will not see harm done to you.”
“But what about Bombur?” Bilbo feels as though he is trying to have a conversation with a stone wall.
Thorin grips his shoulders and stares at him for a moment that seems to drag on a little too long. “I will not see you harmed.”
Bilbo says nothing, only stares up at Thorin for what feels like only a few seconds. When they pull apart, however, he realizes that it has been much longer. The rest of the company has already heaved Bombur out of the stream and onto the bank. “We should make something to carry him,” Bilbo breathes. He distinctly remembers Bombur being brought through the forest on a stretcher.
“Stay by my side,” Thorin orders. Single-minded as always, even when his mind is falling apart. He was like that before, too.
Before? What happened before? There was a rock involved. Bilbo gave away a rock, and Thorin was not pleased with him.
In the time that it takes Bilbo to wrack his brain for memories that will not come, the others manage to heave Bombur onto a makeshift stretcher, someone’s bedroll slung over two strong, heavy boughs, and they press onward. It takes four of them to carry him.
They make camp. Over and over again, they make camp. The forest stretches on forever and Bilbo does not know what to make of it, does not know how long they have traveled or how far. It is perpetually hazy outside, so it is difficult for Bilbo’s Hobbit eyes to tell when it is night and when it is day. His friends can all see perfectly well in the dark, but when they grow too tired to proceed, they rest. The bedding they carry is courtesy of Beorn and Dori, who worked together during their stay to supplement what could be found among the skin-changer’s stores. Some of the stronger members of the company carry man-sized bedrolls, though why Beorn would need these, Bilbo does not know. Could he not simply transform himself into a bear whenever he gets tired? But perhaps there are places he travels to where it is safer to be a man than it is to be a bear. Bilbo should like to stay a Hobbit for as long as he is able.
“By my side,” Thorin orders.
Usually, their leader does not sleep. He keeps watch for most of the night, laying down when he is forced to but keeping his eyes open. Sometimes, he sets his bedroll down beside Bilbo’s, though he does this only once he is certain that the Hobbit is asleep. But even when he is awake, Bilbo feels as though he’s deep in dreams. The pack he carries is over-large, taken from Beorn as everything else is, and it weighs him down, despite being near-empty.
“You could ask nicely,” he grumbles. But he does as he is told and throws his bedroll on the ground beside Thorin’s. Why?
Because he would have done it anyway, even if he hadn’t been ordered to. “You must not stray far,” Thorin informs him, as though there were a chance of him doing so. “I would keep you by my side, where it is safe.”
“A spider could scoop me up and eat me just as well next to you as it could if I were by myself,” Bilbo points out, “You didn’t do this last time, and it all turned out just fine.”
“No,” Thorin argues against Bilbo’s very reasonable statement. “I will defend you.”
“You will be asleep,” Bilbo reminds him.
“Even so, I will defend you.” This makes no sense at all!
But Bilbo is exhausted from so much walking, and he doesn’t understand why he is even fighting on this score. It’s not as though he isn’t pleased to sleep beside Thorin! Just that he is perplexed as to why they are having a conversation about it, and why it has to be this conversation, of all the discussions they might possibly undertake. Mirkwood has shortened everybody’s tempers. They are running out of food and water, they are tired, and Bombur must be carried and guarded at all times.
“Oh, whatever,” Bilbo grumbles. He lays his bedroll beside Thorin’s and settles down to sleep.
He dreams of a million eyes above him, watching as he sleeps. Or he does not dream and wakes periodically to see a million eyes above him, watching as he rests. Beside him, Thorin sleeps like the dead. Bilbo laughs wetly at that, a dark joke that isn’t very funny and brings tears to his eyes. He never could find humor in it all, no matter how he tried. He searched for irony, old lines about what happens on adventures and why respectable Hobbits should never endeavor to undertake them. But Bilbo has never considered those jokes very funny, and he finds himself reaching for Thorin, just to feel that he is warm and breathing and alive. Then he remembers himself and jerks his hand back. It is only one night, or it is two nights, or three, or four, or five. Bilbo has no idea. He loses count easily in this horrible place.
But in the morning he wakes to see Thorin looming over him, brandishing a bundle of cloth. “Why do you have this?” The king demands.
“Why do I have what?” Bilbo asks, groggy.
The other members of the company are breakfasting, eating the last of the honey-cakes in deliberately tiny bites, trying to trick their bodies into believing that it is a proper meal. With Bombur unconscious, Bifur has taken up role of company chef, though his skills don’t seem to extend beyond handing out the provisions from Beorn. Bilbo would gladly cook for his fellows, but he lacks the strength to carry all of their foodstuffs. Or, he did when they set out. Now, Bilbo suspects that he could lift that particular bag easily, and not because he’s gotten any stronger.
Some of the company are polite enough to avert their eyes. Most of them lack the decency even to disguise their staring. And they are not the only ones.
The day is young and new and fresh and the sun is slow to come to Mirkwood and the tiny little eyes that dance above them like blinking stars are ever-present. Bilbo hopes he is imagining them. He knows, in some deep part of himself, that he is not. “This.” Thorin shoves the bundle in Bilbo’s face.
Óin curses loudly, somewhere off to the side. Probably, he thinks he’s being quiet. Presumably, he recognizes the thing being waved around and understands its significance. Bilbo, however, takes a moment to process what is being show to him.
A shirt. An over-large shirt. A Man’s shirt. A skin-changer’s shirt. “What do you mean, why do I have it?”
“Why did he give you this?” Thorin growls, apparently not pleased. He shakes the garment once more.
A small, fur-wrapped bundle tumbles out and onto the forest floor. It lands amongst the dead leaves on the ground beside Bilbo’s bedroll, but Thorin does not seem aware of it.“Why did he give you this?” He demands again.
“He didn’t,” Bilbo tells the truth, exasperated. Who is Thorin to make demands about what’s in Bilbo’s pack. “Why were you going through my things? I stole it, if you must know. I had need of the fabric.”
“What need?” Thorin snarls.
Bilbo picks up the smaller bundle and slips it into his pocket. Thorin doesn’t even notice. He is so focused on the stupid shirt, this shirt of Beorn’s that Bilbo took to disguise the magic of the ring. Instantly, Bilbo feels at ease, more able to make sense of his surroundings. It is as though the spell of the forest has forgotten about him, passed over him. “I was hoping to make a smaller shirt out of it,” Bilbo lies primly, “One that might actually fit me. I can’t imagine I smell very good, wearing the same thing every day. May I have it back, please? Nothing to do with Beorn, just that he was the only one nearby with fabric for the taking. Well, save Dori, but he’d have gotten me with those scissors of his if I even tried it.”
“Lay off, Thorin,” Dwalin advises. “Let the Halfling have his shirt back.”
“Hobbit,” Bilbo and Thorin correct him at the same time.
Bilbo knew that Thorin didn’t like Beorn. He never did, not really, but he tolerated him better on the first adventure. “You shouldn’t go through other people’s things,” Bilbo informs the king.
He should be more careful in his concealment of the ring. Thank the Valar for Thorin’s jealousy! Otherwise, who knows what could have happened? If he’d not been distracted by the shirt, would he have discovered the ring? But what reason does Thorin have to be jealous of Beorn? He could not possibly… oh. Oh, goodness. Bilbo finds, all of a sudden, that the dead leaves littering the ground are quite interesting.
“Did you not go through the skin-changer’s things when you took this shirt from him?” Thorin asks. He could not possibly return Bilbo’s feelings. Not yet. Not now.
But why not? Plenty of things on this journey have been different from Bilbo’s first adventure. He and Thorin have spent more time together than they ever did before. Thorin excused himself from the dinner table when Beorn ventured to tease Bilbo, and now, the king is upset with Bilbo for carrying one of the skin-changer’s shirts in his pack.
Not that it matters. Bilbo’s first priority is to keep his secret and defend the ring. He must protect Thorin from the wicked magic, and he must ensure the safety of the company as they traverse the forest. They’ve still got to deal with the spiders and the Elves and the blasted barrels, and then they’ll be nearly there. If there is a conversation to be had, Lake-town is the place to have it. But not here.
“Yes, well, that’s different. I didn’t get caught,” Bilbo replies, forcing himself to keep a light tone. “And you marched up to me and turned yourself in. And by the way, it’s barely even morning yet. I would’ve liked to get a little bit more sleep before another day of traipsing through the woods, you know.”
Thorin only scowls at him and marches off. He must know that he’s being ridiculous. He can’t be angry with Bilbo for carrying someone else’s shirt in his pack for perfectly practical reasons. Especially not when the two of them have not arrived at any sort of understanding! And now Thorin is going to be in a foul mood for the remainder of the journey through Mirkwood. Bilbo had better steer clear of him as much as possible.
It troubles Bilbo that Thorin’s behavior is different than it was the last time they did this. They survived last time, yes, but most of that was due to chance. Bilbo happened to be above the trees when the spiders attacked, enabling him to save his friends. All of them were caught and strung up alive, and the spiders did not happen to kill anyone before Bilbo could pull off a rather slapdash rescue. The Wood Elves were in the right place at the right time to intervene, and the entire company just so happened to be together. But what might happen if Thorin’s priorities have changed? Will he fight differently, when the spiders attack? Will he be more aggressive with the Elves? Or will he be distracted, looking for an invisible Hobbit in the midst of an important skirmish?
It all sounds very vain to think about, but Bilbo must consider these things. He cannot change anything at this point in the adventure. Already, he has been too casual, too free with his actions and words. He cannot distract Thorin, and it won’t do to let Thorin distract him in return, either. Bilbo had better keep his distance from the king for the time being.
A sound and solid plan, or the soundest and most solid of plans concocted within the bounds of Mirkwood. Bilbo takes up the shirt again and carefully wraps the ring, shoving it back into his pack. Well. That’s no more sleep for him, then.
They break camp and start walking again. There is nothing else to do here, with their food supplies dwindling dangerously and the enchantment of the forest wreaking havoc on their minds.It isn’t long before Bilbo becomes aware of the heavy silence that hangs over the woods. Odd. Bilbo knows for a fact that the last time he was here, he heard whispering in the trees overhead. “There should be voices,” Bilbo murmurs. “Does anyone hear voices?”
“I hear nothing,” Thorin growls, “No wind. No birdsong. What hour is it?” His voice seems distorted, as though he is calling up to Bilbo from the bottom of a very deep well.
“I do not know,” Dwalin confesses, “I do not even know what day it is.”
“I can’t remember what year it is,” Bilbo realizes. This is not good.
“This is taking too long! Is there no end to this accursed forest?” Thorin ignores Bilbo altogether and shouts into the trees. His voice echoes, coming back to them again and again.
Bilbo knows that he should remember exactly how long it takes to navigate this forest, and how to get out of it, too. But that can’t be. Bilbo has no idea how to get out of this forest.
“Not that I can see,” Glóin says. He looks so terribly young, nothing like the old graybeard Bilbo last met at Rivendell. Can people age backwards, here in this horrid place? “Only trees and more trees.”
“There. This way!” Thorin roars. The others protest, but their leader ignores them, pushing past them in his effort to abandon the path. “Do as I say! Follow me!”
Bilbo would follow Thorin to the end of the earth, he decides, but he is a little hesitant to leave the path. There is something not quite right about this forest. Bilbo is distracted by a silvery mess in front of him. What is that? Fishing line? No, no… a spiderweb. A very large spiderweb.
All of a sudden, Bilbo remembers something very important. “Spiders!” He yells to no avail. The company is already too far ahead of him. They cannot hear him. “There are giant spiders in these woods! They will catch you all! I will have to fight them!” He distinctly remembers cutting each member of the company out of the spiderwebs, one by one.
“There are no spiders, Bilbo.” Fíli has turned back to collect Bilbo, grabbing him by the arm and dragging him forward. Bilbo would not move otherwise. He wants the company to turn around, but he knows he cannot argue with Thorin. He will only be told to stay by his leader’s side, over and over again, until Bilbo runs out of things to say in return. “We are the only creatures in these woods.”
“No,” Bilbo protests. “There was a dragon.” There was a dragon, fire-breathing and fierce. Was it not in these woods?
“The dragon is in Erebor,” Fíli reminds him very helpfully, “I don’t know anything about the spiders.”
“What spiders?” Bilbo is confused beyond belief.
“I have no idea.” Fíli drags him back into line with the rest of the company, and their conversation fizzles out. Bilbo tries to figure out what the lad was talking about. Spiders? Where would he get a silly idea like that?
Bilbo marches onward, trying to remember where he is. He stares down at his feet, feeling as though he is floating and flying. Is he moving forward or backward? Forward. He’s moving forward. He must be in the Old Forest. That’s not something a respectable Hobbit would do. It’s more suitable behavior for a faunt, one who doesn’t know better. A faunt! Frodo must have run into these woods, and Bilbo must be following him. Yes, that makes sense. Little Frodo has been living at Brandy Hall since the deaths of his parent, and Bilbo often visits to watch over the lad and his young cousins. Frodo is the adventurous sort, though, always dashing off. Bilbo looks ahead. Frodo is not there.
Bilbo has lost his nephew. He has lost young Frodo somewhere in the woods! The trees here are alive! This is not a safe place for a little one to wander alone. What was Bilbo thinking? He must find Frodo before it is too late. His heart accelerates, remembering what happened to Drogo and Primula. If Bilbo isn’t careful, something even worse could happen to poor Frodo. This is what Bilbo gets, all caught up in his books and maps all day, stuck in the past. He’s a horrible guardian.
An awful one, really. Because Frodo is not in the Old Forest, nor is he safe in Bag End. He is in Mordor. Gandalf and Elrond have sent young Frodo away from Bilbo, off to his death, and it is Bilbo’s fault for being so irresponsible. For picking up a cursed ring and giving it to his nephew in the first place.
“Look,” says a voice behind him. Is that Ori? Bilbo hasn’t seen Ori in years!
“A tobacco pouch. There’s Dwarves in these woods.” And Dori! They must have come to visit him in the Shire. It’s happened before, after all. Perhaps they could help him find young Frodo.
“Dwarves from the Blue Mountains, no less.” And Bofur is here as well. What are they all looking at? Why have they all stopped walking? Frodo is missing! They must make haste. “This is exactly the same as mine.”
All of a sudden, Bilbo is stricken with a sense that he has lived this out before. He remembers shouting at the top of his lungs: Because it is yours. Do you understand? We’re going round in circles, we are lost! But this makes no sense. They are not going around in circles. Bilbo has never seen this place before. Has he? He must have, if he remembers it so vividly. “I think we’ve been here before,” Bilbo says, “We must be lost.”
“We’re not lost,” Thorin argues. He just loves to contradict Bilbo, does’t he? They’ll never find Frodo if they keep bickering like this. “We keep heading East.”
The others break down into various complains. Bilbo has heard all of this before. When has he heard this before? If only he could remember, perhaps he might also recall the way out. If there is a way out.
“That’s the problem, then. We should be going West. Home is to the West,” Bilbo knows this much for certain.
“I think we are going West,” Nori declares, “Sun’s off that way.” He gestures through the trees, though Bilbo cannot see this alleged sun for the life of him.
There is a murmur of voices in response to this, but Bilbo pays it no mind. He is busy looking up above his head. It must not be too far to the highest canopy of the forest. Hobbits do not typically have very much love for heights, but Bilbo is willing to make an exception under these circumstances. If he can climb up high enough, perhaps he’ll be able to see Frodo on the ground. His old friends are no help. Bilbo will have to take matters into his own hands.
Bilbo ignores the squabbling behind him and steps forward, using some conveniently low branches to get a foothold on a nearby tree. There is a vague sense of rightness about this action, as though Bilbo must do it, because he has done it before. When? He can’t remember. But he does know that he has done it, and it will be easy to do it again. All he needs to do is scurry up the trunk, get himself into the higher branches, and…
A strong hand comes down on his shoulder, gripping his jacket more tightly than would be necessary simply to stop him from climbing up. Who is stopping him from climbing up?
“No,” Thorin’s ghost tells him resolutely. “It is too dangerous.”
“You’re not being reasonable,” Bilbo complains. “I want to make sure we’re going the right way.”
“We are going the right way,” the spirit assures him, “We are heading East, as I told you. I can feel it in my blood.”
Bilbo shudders. It is news to him that ghosts have blood, and he isn’t sure he appreciates it. “All the same,” he manages to say. Something feels very wrong about this, indeed. “I don’t know where he is, and I want to see if I can find him.”
“And who is ‘he,’ exactly?” Thorin demands, not sounding very pleased. “The skin-changer said himself that he would not look out for you here.”
Bilbo rolls his eyes. Now is really not the time for this. He knows that Thorin is capable of great possessiveness, but to assume that Bilbo would love anybody else after Ravenhill? To assume that Bilbo could ever move on from that, could ever trust anybody with that part of himself, even if he wanted to? To assume that he would ever have any desire to paper over the memory of what they shared together? It’s preposterous. And to suggest that Bilbo might have some interest in Beorn, of all people!
“You know you were the only one, but I have to get up there.” Bilbo tells him directly. Why is Thorin’s ghost here in the Old Forest, anyway? And why does the Old Forest look so different from how Bilbo remembers?
Because this is not the Old Forest. Because this is Mirkwood. Because Bilbo is back on his adventure again, and Thorin is alive again, and these facts slipped Bilbo’s mind entirely. He begins to tremble, nearly losing his grip on the tree.
“It is not safe,” Thorin’s gaze bores into Bilbo’s eyes, as if he can see the turmoil behind them. Bilbo tries to remember what he did the last time this happened, but he can’t. He still has this nagging feeling that Frodo is in these woods somewhere, or perhaps that Bilbo is on the way to Mordor to meet Frodo, or that they’re in the Shire, or the Old Forest. He can’t stop remembering dragon fire. He tries to force himself to remember the battle instead and he can’t, he simply can’t.
“There is something wrong in this forest,” Bilbo breathes, “I need to see to the end of it. Let me just take one look, Thorin. It will help us.”
Thorin glances up at the top of the tree, then at Bilbo. “I do not wish to let you out of my sight,” he informs the Hobbit.
“Only for a moment,” Bilbo promises through the haze that has begun to establish itself between himself and Thorin. Even though they are touching, even though Bilbo can feel Thorin’s grip, which is beginning to bruise, he can’t be sure that his old friend is really here. He can’t even be sure of where here is. “I’ll come right back down. At least I’ll let you know if we’re going the right way.” The right way back to Bag End, where he and Thorin can spend the rest of their days together in peace.
Or to the afterlife that they were supposed to share together. Didn’t Lady Galadriel promise that? Bilbo’s thoughts are all jumbled up. He has to keep reminding himself that he is in Mirkwood, with the company, on their adventure, or he will forget where and when he is. When Thorin only continues to stare at him (though who knows what the King is really seeing) Bilbo adds a quiet, big-eyed entreaty. “Please.”
That seems to do the trick. Thorin releases him. “Fine,” he says, “But be quick about it.”
He really seems to dislike the idea of letting Bilbo climb the tree. Why? He was perfectly happy to let Bilbo climb over an enchanted stream. He held Bilbo over a great height once, as well. For what reason? Something nags at the back of Bilbo’s mind, but he cannot remember what it is. “Thank you,” he says, flashing a genuinely grateful smile over his shoulder as he begins to climb the tree.
As he gets higher and higher, inching out of Mirkwood’s mist, his thoughts begin to realign. The facts of the matter: Bilbo is repeating his adventure for a second time. He is in Mirkwood, and every member of the company is still alive, and Frodo has not been born yet. Thorin is not a ghost but a living person Bilbo has sworn to protect, and the same can be said for Fíli and Kíli. But Bilbo forgot all of that.
He does not remember being so disoriented in Mirkwood the first time. Why? What’s different? What has changed? Yes, his relationship with Thorin is certainly better than it was the last time they did this. That much is obvious from the king’s possessive behavior, which Bilbo will have to revisit at a later date, because honestly, they’re not going to get anywhere if Thorin won’t let Bilbo out of his sight without a lengthy argument on the matter, but that doesn’t seem reason enough for such utter confusion.
A more significant difference occurs to him just as he nears the top of the tree. This time, before they left Beorn’s hall, Bilbo did everything in his power to dilute the influence of the ring. He wrapped it in cloth and shoved it into his pack as far away as he could get it from his body, hadn’t he? All of a sudden, Bilbo remembers a story Samwise told him, about putting the ring on in the tunnels of a giant spider. A giant spider… oh, by the Valar! The spiders will be upon the company soon!
He pokes his head above the canopy, and suddenly, he can see it all. The sky, the sun, the Lonely Mountain. Wispy clouds and deep valleys and the fantastic pink leaves below him. It is autumn now, then. Durin’s Day is fast approaching. Blue butterflies flutter around Bilbo, settling beside him, in his hair, on his clothes. But none of it matters in the slightest. He must get back to his friends.
Bilbo feels his chest constrict, his heart rate quicken. No. He cannot come down yet. He needs to spend the same amount of time up here that he did the last time. He needs to sort things out and get his bearings. If he’s there when the company gets caught, then he’ll get caught, too, and he won’t be able to help them.
Perhaps he got it wrong, when he put his plan together in Beorn’s hall. Perhaps it wasn’t the ring that caused the company’s disorientation in Mirkwood, but the enchantment on the forest, as Bilbo had suspected to begin with. In that case, his proximity to the ring might have spared him from the worst of it the first time around. Young Samwise once told him that the ring enabled him to hear voices which otherwise would have been too far away. It’s perfectly possible that Bilbo experienced equally heightened senses, for those sixty years that he carried the ring, but grew so accustomed to the extra gifts that he did not notice them as anything special. Then, when those gifts of improved sight and hearing faded, he must have chalked it up to his sudden, rapid aging.
It’s certainly possible that wrapping the ring diluted its power and prevented it from protecting Bilbo from the worst of the forest’s evil. Or perhaps the layers of cloth did absolutely nothing, and the ring is punishing him for trying to get away from it. Regardless, his next course of action is clear. Sighing, Bilbo reaches into his pack and pulls out the bundle of cloth. He unwraps it, shoves the fur and the shirt back into his pack, and gingerly places the ring into his jacket pocket.
“No,” he tells it in a stern voice, “Enough from you. I’ll not be dealing with any more of your wicked nonsense today.”
He is so angry with the ring that he wants to toss it back down into the forest, but he understands that this is probably what the ring wants. If Bilbo discards it, it will no doubt fall into the hands of a giant spider or an Elf, which would furnish the ring with far more power than Bilbo ever could. It is his burden to bear, and significantly lighter now than it was when Frodo carried it.
Of course, there is always the possibility that Bilbo is wrong again, and that the ring has nothing whatsoever to do with his disorientation. It could be because Bilbo has lived much longer and had many more experiences now than the first time that he was in Mirkwood. The forest had much more to fall upon, more to tug at, more to twist and reassemble than it did originally. If that’s the case, then Bilbo won’t be protected at all when he goes back down. He’ll have to muddle through with his mind half-gone, but he has no other choice. His friends need him.
The same thing happens again. Bilbo should probably have expected this. The moment he steps down from the trees and hears the spiders murmuring, his vision begins to blur. Bilbo has spent eight decades not thinking about the spiders. Even when he wrote about this encounter, he invented most of what he put onto the page.
In his book, Bilbo sang a little song and danced around and led the spiders on a merry chase. He cut his friends free and, groggy as they were, they helped him fight the monsters off. Bilbo expressed a little of the danger in his tale, but he deliberately kept the details vague. He made it one more silly story, one more episode of comic peril on their long and winding journey. A time for him to show his valor, to prove himself to his companions by keeping them safe.
That is not what really happened. What really happened is that Bilbo was shaking with fear, convinced that his friends were dead inside those hanging bundles and that he was left alone in that cursed forest. He cut them out with little hope. By some miracle, all of them lived, but before they could regroup, there was a battle to be had.
In his book, Bilbo claimed that Thorin was not with them for this interaction. It was selfish of him, this obfuscation of the truth. Only he didn’t want to write the stabbing feeling in his gut when he found Thorin, unmoving, wrapped in spiderwebs. He had no desire to record the terror, the sickening feeling of helplessness, the unfairness of it all. The idea that a great king could be felled by a nameless arachnid in the woods, simply because the beast was hungry. The idea that Bilbo’s love could be taken from him at the drop of a hat, for some noble cause or by some wicked accident, and that he would be powerless to do a thing about it.
But there is nothing for any of that now. Bilbo will have to fight, whether he likes it or not. He’s more careful this time. He knows what he’s doing, what he’s looking for. He doesn’t fall and the spiders do not catch him.
He sneaks along, quiet, invisible, climbing silently as any Hobbit would. Not that any respectable Hobbit would ever dare to make an attempt on any trees of this size, especially not trees in the middle of Mirkwood. Bilbo wears the ring, and he can sense the spiders, see them, hear them, understand them. He does not think. He proceeds, invisible, and slashes at every beast he sees. Some, he kills. They make awful, wailing noises.
Some, he pushes out of the trees. Others feel the bite of Sting and back away. Bilbo dimly remembers throwing a stone to lure the spiders off, the last time that he did this. Not so now. This time, he slashes through them, inciting panic and pandemonium. None of the spiders seem to remember their quarry, the bundles bound in sticky webs and strung from trees. Bilbo darts over to cut his friends free. He can only hope that, just as last time, their fall is broken by the webs beneath them.
There is Bombur, kicking his legs against spiders that have long since left him alone. He must not be able to see though all the spiderwebs. There is Dori, troublingly still, though Bilbo is relieved to hear him breathing. Ori yelps when Bilbo cuts his cocoon, and Nori and Dwalin both offer him several choice words. In Westron, not Khuzdul, because apparently, even having been injected with spider venom, neither of them is prepared to share their secret language with outsiders. Even outsiders with eight legs and a million eyes and terrifying pincers; even curly-haired, pointy-eared, furry-footed outsiders who mean well, truly.Bilbo frees Bofur, another silent, still one. Then Bifur, with his axe sticking out through the sticky floss. Glóin, as it happens, also has an axe sticking out, and he nearly takes Bilbo’s head off with it as he goes down.
Fíli says something that sounds like, “Careful; don’t bruise me.” His long nose has evidently enabled him to breathe under all his wrappings, and even whatever he’s endured at the hands of the spiders has not robbed him of his quick wit.
Óin gets an arm free and tries to strangle Bilbo with it, clearly thinking that his Hobbit savior is another menacing arachnid. Thankfully, Bilbo has been on the receiving end of Óin’s medical ministrations more than once, and he knows how to dodge the healer’s hands. Balin adjusts his position as best as he can within the sack of spider webbing, then drops like a rock when Bilbo cuts him free. Kíli’s hands twitch somewhere deep in his cocoon, and his bow, slung over his back, pokes Bilbo in the shoulder.
Thorin, like Dori and Bofur, makes no sound and does not move. Bilbo’s hands are shaking as he cuts him free. “You’re going to be alright, my love,” he mutters, ignoring the risk. He should not be saying things like this, things Thorin could hear and misinterpret, or, worse, hear and interpret with perfect accuracy. But would that really be so bad? Bilbo is fairly certain, after that ridiculous incident with Beorn’s shirt, that Thorin returns his feelings. “I’ll be down in a jiffy. But you’ve got to be alright.” It is not that time yet.
Bilbo watched Thorin die, and he did not die this way. He was still and silent the last time Bilbo freed him from the spiders, as well. And Thorin was neither still nor silent as he died. There is no blood to be seen. Thorin falls, then, and is caught by a layer of spider webs. His quiet huffing noise is audible even to Bilbo. So he is alive, then. Yes. Just as on the last adventure.
Bilbo has no time to ponder this, though, because more spiders come at him. He fights them off, not thinking, barely seeing. Keeping his grip on the ring as he slashes and rends. Yes. Those spiders deserve what is coming to them, for daring to harm Bilbo’s friends. They deserve death and pain and suffering.
He keeps the ring on his free hand, which he shoves into his pocket for safety as he slashes with his sword arm. Then his sword arm gets tired and he abandons this practice, fighting tooth and nail, with no regard for his own safety. At some point, Bilbo finds Bofur’s hat in the trees and throws it down after his friends, hoping it is returned to its owner. Hoping Bofur is alive to take his hat back. Bilbo feels a stab of guilt as he realizes he didn’t even bother to check his friend’s breathing, but he doesn’t have time to dwell on that, either.
He’s got to get down out of these trees. For one thing, this is where the spiders dwell, and the longer he spends up here, the more the beasts will dog him. Bilbo can guess that much without being told. And also, he is dimly aware, though the haze of metal-against-shell and the heaviness of rage, that something will be taking place in short order below him. So he jumps, when he can, bouncing as his friends did against one layer, and then another, of spider webbing. Yes. This is how it should be. This feels right. When he gets to the ground, there are more spiders, and these, Bilbo fights as well.
They cannot see him, and they cannot catch him, and they seem to understand this. No more spiders are forthcoming; the creatures have evidently decided to direct their ire toward the rest of the company rather than risk Bilbo’s wrath. So he stands there, sword in hand, panting, twitching, ready for a fight that never comes.
It is not like the last time. With the orcs, Bilbo felt so much he couldn’t stand it, felt so much that it clouded his thoughts and forced him to fight when perhaps to do so was not advisable. With the spiders, though, he feels nothing at all. Now that he is spared from the fighting, if only for a moment, it occurs to Bilbo that he has not been not in control of himself. It is as though his body enacted the entire battle of its own volition. Fair enough. He’s done well, all things considered. Let all the spiders in Mirkwood come and try their hand against Mad Baggins! Bilbo will show them what a warrior-Hobbit can do.
And then he hears his friends. They are loud, all of them always so very loud. They were loud in Bag End and they are loud here in Mirkwood and they will be loud in Erebor, this he knows. And they are all of them alive. Bilbo sags, his entire body exhausted from yet another hearty fight. The Wood Elves begin swinging down from boughs, though how they do this, Bilbo has not managed to figure out in eight long decades. He longs to join his companions, but Bilbo is aware that he has important work to do. He must stay back. He ensures that the ring is securely on his finger, hides himself, and waits.
Chapter 8: Change of Plans
Notes:
Thanks as always for reading/commenting/giving kudos!! This chapter is another long one.
I know in the movie it's heavily implied that the company is only imprisoned for a short time, but I chose to go with the timeline from the books, where the Elves hold them captive for weeks on end. I think that just makes more sense with how the relationships between the characters need to progress. Enjoy!
Chapter Text
Perhaps being captured by Elves is marginally better than being eaten alive by giant spiders, but only marginally. It’s humiliating, watching as bowstrings twitch and knives fly and spiders fall in neat heaps upon the forest floor, the Elves accomplishing in a few moments what Thorin’s company could not manage over the entire course of their prodigious fight. Thorin is still groggy from the spider venom, and the ensuing battle did nothing to aid the healing of his recent wounds. He is tired, confused, and aching.
His company is at the mercy of the Elves. They very nearly let Kíli die, trapped and cornered as he was. It would mean little to them, Thorin is certain, having one less prisoner to bring back to their cowardly king. The red-headed guard who now handles Kíli so roughly likely only stopped the spider to protect herself from its wrath. Elves do not, as a rule, risk their lives for other folk, as Thranduil proved perfectly on the day when he watched Thorin’s people fleeing their burning home and did nothing. Nothing. Nothing.
“Where did you get this?” An infuriatingly clean Elf demands. His grip on Orcrist is confident, as though he owns the blade.
“It was given to me,” Thorin replies. It is the truth, but the less these Elves know, the better. He owes them no explanation, anyway.
“Not just a thief, but a liar as well.” The Elf points Thorin’s own sword at him before shouting an incomprehensible order over his shoulder. The Elvish language sounds more like wind through the trees than proper speech, as though Thorin and his kin were being led away at the mercy of the wicked forest itself. Is there any meaningful difference, though, between these Wood Elves and the cursed land they occupy?
Thorin would rather have been eaten by spiders. That would have been far less shameful. He has no love for any Elves, but these are the worst folk imaginable. They are cruel and selfish, and Thorin knows that they will not treat his people well. His fists clench as he watches one of the guards removing knife after knife from Fíli’s person. He knows that his sister-son conceals those weapons well. In order to find them, the guard must be conducting an intimate search. A violation.
“Thorin, where’s Bilbo?” Bofur hisses as he is dragged away, quietly enough for only his king to hear. It seems that Thorin must put aside his fantasies of kicking the haughty blond Elf hard enough to bruise. This would be ill-advised, he knows, but the thought is a comfort. Were Thorin alone, had he no fear of retaliation against his companions for his own behavior, his fists and feet would be flying already. “Where’s the Hobbit?”
As Thorin processes the words through the spider venom and the fog of Mirkwood presently clouding his thoughts, a chill settles over his heart. Where is Bilbo, indeed? Where is the Hobbit?
Thorin’s first thought is that the little creature is dead. That would be the most logical explanation. This forest is no place for a Hobbit. There are plenty of fell beasts here aside from the spiders, not to mention the curse of the forest itself. Bilbo is no master of the sword at the best of times. How would he fare with his mind muddled by Mirkwood? And this is Thorin’s fault, for not fighting hard enough. Not killing enough of the spiders. Not killing any of the Elves. Allowing the Hobbit to leave his sight for any length of time, which he knew was a foolish idea. Bringing Master Baggins along on this quest in the first place.
“He was the one to cut me out of my cocoon,” Ori shares, quietly enough that Thorin isn’t certain even Bofur heard the answer to his question.
And it isn’t much of an answer, not really. It certainly sheds no great light on the Hobbit’s current whereabouts. But it does tell Thorin one thing: Master Baggins was alive before their battle with the spiders. He somehow managed to avoid being taken, and he had the presence of mind to free the company. This would have required climbing, careful sword work, and enough vigilance to dodge the spiders while he worked. So Bilbo must have been at least semi-lucid at the time.
Perhaps he would also have had the presence of mind to flee. He might even make it back to Beorn. The Hobbit is lithe and clever, and a friend to things that grow. He was able to scramble over the vines at the stream with ease, and he attempted more than once to prevent Thorin from leaving the path. And Bilbo, too, was the one to suggest that perhaps the company might be lost. At the time, Thorin argued with him, but now, he suspects that the Hobbit may have been right. He could get himself out of this forest, Thorin is sure of it.
But he is also sure that Bilbo will not do this. “Mahal watch over him,” he mutters, followed by a quick prayer in Khuzdul that he hopes the guards interpret as more cursing. Spare my Burglar, and I will do whatever you wish. Guide him safely on whatever foolish mission he’s taken it upon himself to enact.
Several of Thorin’s companions shoot him sharp looks for that. Under normal circumstances, he would be of complete accord. It is frowned-upon to speak Khuzdul in front of outsiders, and Elves are the worst outsiders imaginable. But Thorin must speak to his Maker. He must make it clear to the Smith that he is willing to do anything for the sake of Master Baggins. Besides, he doubts the Elves are paying attention to any words their prisoners might say as they are led single-file into the halls of the Woodland King.
Thorin knows Bilbo well enough by now to be fairly certain that the Hobbit is plotting something odd and inadvisable. Almost definitely, it will involve the Burglar flinging himself into danger for the sake of the company, and the stubborn little creature will accept no thanks for it afterwords. It gives Thorin hope, but it also fills him with fear for the wellbeing of his Hobbit. But, then, Master Baggins has proven himself time and time again. Perhaps he has something surprising up his sleeve for this situation, as well.
This is not Bilbo’s first time in the Halls of the Woodland King. On his original journey, the Hobbit spent several weeks wandering around Thranduil’s very impressive palace. He dedicated himself to the liberation of the company through whatever means necessary, entertaining even the flimsiest of escape plans and each one until it proved itself inviable.He spied on guards, gathered information, and haunted the kitchens, nabbing little bits of food that would not be missed. He kept his cover by wearing the ring for days on end. He slept in dusty cobwebbed corridors and had little time to spend with the members of the company, so busy was he plotting their escape.
This time is quite different. Bilbo already has their escape plotted out to the letter. He knows where to find the empty barrels that will convey them to Lake-town, and from there, the Lonely Mountain is only a hop, skip, and a jump away. Of course Bilbo cannot simply march down to the cellars and steal the keys now. He must wait for the Festival of Starlight, as he did the last time.The guards will be distracted then, making it easier to release the company from their cells. Also, Bilbo can be certain that the barrels will be available then, and not full of wine or something equally cumbersome and difficult to get rid of. Not to mention that while they might very well be able to avoid the orc scouts if they depart ahead of schedule, they will doubtlessly meet other, unforeseen dangers, and there is no guarantee that Bard will be waiting for them when they arrive on the outskirts of Lake-town.
It is better, Bilbo decides once again, to do everything the same way they did it before. So he resolves to wait until the night of the festival to make their escape. This should give Kíli time to charm the Captain of the Guard, as well, which, though it will make Thorin furious, will induce Legolas and Tauriel to fight alongside the company in the battle of the Five Armies, just as they did before. Of course, that didn’t go over so well the first time (don’t think about it, don’t think about it, don’t think about it) but Bilbo would rather not lose their alliance the second time around.
The long and short of it is that Bilbo has a good deal of time to kill in the Woodland realm. He’s certainly not going to waste it spying on guards again. He might have a look at the library, or pilfer the pantry. Maybe he’ll visit with his friends a bit, too. He could try to find where the Elves are hiding the weapons taken from the company, or any other weapons Bilbo can get his hands on. This will help them in their fight with the orcs. Granted, it will be difficult for a single Hobbit to smuggle out such an impressive arsenal, but he’ll probably be able to get his hands on a few of Fíli’s knives. Actually, now that Bilbo thinks about it, it’s entirely possible that the lad has a few weapons on him even still. Bilbo seems to remember a knife being thrown at some point as they traveled down the river.
But there is also another matter to consider. Something that has been bothering Bilbo since he climbed down from the canopy and found, much to his mortification, that the ring had a steadying effect on his thoughts. Bilbo knew on the Carrock that his relationship with Thorin is different this time around than it was on his first adventure. They shared inane conversation at Beorn’s, which never would have happened eighty years ago. But in the forest… Thorin was downright possessive. It was a battle to get him to agree to letting Bilbo out of his sight at all, and he wasn’t shy about it, either. Something is different, and Bilbo isn’t certain whether it’s a good thing or a bad one.
Nothing has changed on his end, anyway. He’s still very much in love with Thorin,and he wants to make sure that the king is alright. Logically, of course, Bilbo knows that Thorin is just fine. He was just fine last time, was he not? But that’s not necessarily a guarantee, and, anyway, Bilbo doesn’t need to make up an excuse. He has time on his hands and can do what he wishes with it.
So he does not linger outside watching Prince Legolas brood, and he does not follow the guards who shuffle the company off for the removal of their outer clothes and various other invasive procedures. Strange, that this should be done before anybody has been asked what they are doing in the forest.
Bilbo has always been fond of Elves, but this interval in Thranduil’s kingdom never sat right with him. Their company did nothing wrong, but the king imprisoned them anyway, and he wasn’t particularly kind to them during their stay. No wonder Thorin refused to treat with him before the battle. Granted, Bilbo would have done differently, in the honor of diplomacy, and he still thinks he was correct to suggest the same course of action to Thorin, but on principle, he understands where his king is coming from. Came from. Will be coming from? This is all still far too confusing!
Bilbo is standing just below Thranduil’s imposing throne when the guards drag Thorin into the great chamber. Pushing aside his reservations, the Hobbit steps forward, careful to stay out of the way of the guards so that he can put himself by Thorin’s side. It’s stupid of him, Bilbo knows, but he does not like to see the rage on Thorin’s face. It reminds him of terrible times past, and terrible times to come. It reminds him of the complexity of this whole affair. It makes him want to roll his eyes at Thorin’s stubbornness, yes, but Bilbo also wouldn’t mind rushing up that ridiculous treelike staircase and throttling the Woodland King. His thoughts are all muddled up, and that is not a good position in which to find himself while all his friends are being held prisoner.
Thranduil regards Thorin with a cold, haughty stare. He really isn’t helping his own cause. There should not be any need for bargaining, by Bilbo’s reckoning. Thranduil is decidedly in the wrong, holding people prisoner because he thinks he can get something out of them.
“Some may imagine that a noble quest is at hand. A quest to reclaim a homeland and slay a dragon,” the king begins what Bilbo imagines is about to become a monologue. "I myself suspect a more prosaic motive: attempted burglary, or something of that ilk.”
Bilbo nearly cannot help himself. He is so angry that he thinks he really might rush forward and challenge the Woodland King. It’s hard not to to feel that he is watching events unfold which will culminate in Thorin’s death. Eighty years ago, Thranduil acted as though he was entitled to anything he wished from the Lonely Mountain. Bard made a deal with Thorin, yes; the people of Lake-town had been promised aid and then refused it. But Thranduil? Thranduil was nothing but cruel to the entire company, and he made war for purely selfish reasons, when clearly, he had wealth enough in his fine kingdom. He egged Bard on and taunted Thorin and showed no sign of regret when it was all over and the King Under the Mountain lay dead upon Ravenhill. It was his fault.
Still, this is not a battle, and Bilbo knows that he must stay his hand. Thranduil may be annoying, but who is Bilbo to decide that the Elven King deserves death? All of this assuming that Bilbo would actually be able to deliver it, invisible as he is, with so many guards around. Even if Bilbo were fool enough to attack Thranduil, to seek vengeance for slights not yet committed, the consequences for the other members of the company would not be good. No doubt Legolas would inherit the throne and promptly retaliate. He might later regret his actions, whatever those might be, but it would be too late. Bilbo cannot imagine Gimli ever becoming friends with one who would visit such horrors upon his people. And what would that mean for the future of Middle Earth?
No. Bilbo will not lash out. He will be here for Thorin, where he is needed. He will offer support and serve as a witness, but he will not interfere. He cannot change the course of history in this way, cannot risk the ramifications. Besides, he is not here for vengeance. He is here for the love of his friends.
“You have found a way in,” Thranduil drawls, "You seek that which would bestow upon you the right to rule. The king’s jewel, the Arkenstone. It is precious to you beyond measure. I understand that.”
As a steadying gesture, Bilbo places his hand on Thorin’s arm. He clearly isn’t thinking, because if he were, he’d know that was a risky move. Thorin has no way of discerning that it’s Bilbo beside him, considering that the Hobbit is invisible. He would be well within his rights to attack, even having no weapons. He glances, briefly, in Bilbo’s direction, but of course he sees nothing, even as Bilbo clings to his sleeve.
“There are gems in the mountain that I, too, desire. White gems, of pure starlight,” Thranduil continues, "I offer you my help.” He almost looks as though he is telling the truth.
“Don’t listen to him,” Bilbo whispers into Thorin’s ear, “We will escape whether he wills it or not.”
This way, at least, there will be no deal upon which Thorin might renege. As much as Bilbo knows that he should be on the side of peace, it is better to ensure that there are no debts to be settled when they reach the mountain. Besides, it’s not as though Thorin would have listened if Bilbo tried to talk him into making a deal with Thranduil. Really, all he can do here is provide the assurance that he has a plan.
Thorin chuckles. Thranduil might believe that the king is reacting to his offer, but Bilbo knows that he’s received tacit approval. “I am listening.” Thorin sounds every inch the monarch.
“I will let you go… if you but return what is mine,” Thranduil proposes.
“A favor for a favor,” Thorin muses, turning on his heel and pacing toward the ledge overlooking much of the palace’s grand interior. Bilbo scurries after him, pleased that his Hobbit feet are silent as they hit the fine floors.
“You have my word. One king to another.”
“I would not trust Thranduil… The great king… To honor his word… Should the end of all days be upon us!” Thorin roars. His voice carries down to Thranduil’s people, many of whom look up in utter shock, that such words could be spoken, here of all places. Many others simply continue about their daily business, as though their monarch is dressed down each day by exiled Dwarven royalty.
One might imagine, Bilbo supposes, that Thorin’s left hand is clenched in a fist as demonstration of his anger. In reality, however, he is gripping Bilbo’s shirt like a vice, clearly drawing some degree of strength from his proximity to the Hobbit. Would he have said these things anyway? Bilbo does not doubt it. He knows Thorin well enough to understand that there was never any possibility of a deal being struck. It did not happen the first time, after all. But Bilbo hopes that he is at least able to give some hope and some comfort in this awful situation.
“You, who lack all honor!” Thorin has sealed his fate now, and he knows it. His hand is sweaty, and his body trembles. He may be practiced at hiding this, but Bilbo is close enough to detect it either way.
“Steady, now,” Bilbo counsels quietly. He does not wish to see Thorin receive any harsh treatment as a penance for his rough words, and he can’t put such barbaric behavior past Thranduil. Though Bilbo is fond of Legolas, he has never been particularly friendly with the lad’s father. For obvious reasons, which are becoming progressively more obvious to Bilbo as he is forced to stew in the unseen context for his decades of grief.
“I have seen how you treat your friends,” Thorin continues, releasing Bilbo and turning around slowly to face Thranduil. Bilbo keeps a gentle hand on his back, rubbing soft circles as a silent gesture of support. Thorin is correct, of course, though it is perhaps unwise to yell such things at the top of his lungs. “We came to you once, starving, homeless, seeking your help. But you turned your back! You turned away from the suffering of my people… and the inferno that destroyed us.” Thorin proceeds to release a selection of choice words in Khuzdul.
Bilbo once again wishes that he took the time to learn the secret language.It was too painful after the battle, and then, years later, when he returned to the mountain, his mind was too battered by the ring and his old age to allow for much retention of new words. It seemed disrespectful, somehow, to try and learn the language on his own. A closed cultural practice to which he was not entitled, not having married into that culture. He would’ve, if he’d been given the chance, but the opportunity had died with Thorin. Died in battle. Impaled on a sword. Bilbo is going to need to find someone to hoist him up on their shoulders so that he can take Azog’s head off, slowly and painfully.
“Do not talk to me of dragon fire,” Thranduil hisses. “I know its wrath and ruin. I have faced the great serpents of the North.” For a moment, his beautiful face flickers away, showing the burned flesh beneath. Is this an illusion, or is the visage he wears the rest of the time a mere trick of magic? The ring offers Bilbo no answers. “I warned your grandfather of what his greed would summon. But he would not listen. You are just like him. Stay here if you will, and rot.”
Bilbo has to spring out of the way as two guards seize Thorin by the arms and begin hauling him in the direction of the dungeons. Unfortunately, Bilbo’s leap takes him further down the stairs, forcing him to scramble to the bottom at speed to avoid being bumped into. He cannot risk discovery.
“A hundred years is a mere blink in the life of an Elf!” Thranduil calls after them. “I’m patient. I can wait.”
But he is lying. He will descend upon Erebor the moment he thinks he can get in. He will take his people to war over a handful of jewels. He has no right to accuse Thorin of greed when he himself is just as greedy. Many Elves will die in the name of those white stones.
Bilbo doesn’t get much time to ponder this, however, because as he is herded out of the room. This was a major flaw in his plan: he can’t stay where he is, because the guards will run into him. He can’t jump to the side, because there is no side to jump to. The corridor they’re taking Thorin down is narrow, and whenever Bilbo attempts to turn, he finds the way blocked by more guards. Right. They think there’s some chance that Thorin might try to escape, and they are entirely correct. And he certainly can’t scramble back up to the throne room with Thorin and the guards blocking his way.
The procession arrives at the block of cells where the company is detained, and Bilbo considers rushing up the stairs to the higher level where he knows that Kíli and some of the others are being held, but of course, just his luck, there are guards standing up there, as well. He would not get very far, and he cannot risk discovery.
His options, it appears, are to try and dart between the legs of the guards, which does not seem particularly wise, to allow himself to be herded into a cell, or to jump off the ledge to his death. Slim pickings, for sure.
While Bilbo is dithering, a guard approaches and opens the door to the cell at Bilbo’s back. The door opens inward. With dawning horror, Bilbo realizes that he has no choice but to scramble into the cell. As though that were not a problem enough, the guard shoves Thorin into the tiny space behind Bilbo, and, naturally, he slams into the Hobbit with his full weight, knocking Bilbo to the ground. Thankfully, Thorin is able to right himself and maintain his footing, because Bilbo is not certain that he would be able to survive being pressed between an irate Thorin and the hard stone floor. For any number of reasons.
“Bother stone floors and everything to do with them!” Bilbo mutters under his breath. The impact has not exactly been kind to the bruises he’s carried since the confrontation with Azog, not to mention the many injuries that he unknowingly incurred during the fight with the spiders. This is just lovely. Now, Bilbo is trapped in Thorin’s cell. There will be no spying and no sneaking, and Bilbo is more than likely to get an earful from their fearless leader.
The Elf guards may not have heard Bilbo, but Thorin is staring at the spot on the ground where Bilbo happens to be laying with an utterly illegible expression on his face. Yes, Bilbo is in for an earful, indeed.
“Did he offer you a deal?” Balin’s voice echoes from a neighboring cell.
But Thorin remains silent. Bilbo looks around to find the king staring back at him, though, of course, Thorin cannot see Bilbo. Ever so gently, he nudges the Hobbit in the thigh with the tip of his boot. Probably, he wasn’t aiming for Bilbo’s thigh, considering he must not know what position Bilbo is laying in. Still, it’s a good thing Bilbo is invisible, so that Thorin cannot see the expression on his face.
“Thorin.” Balin breaks the tension that has accumulated at a mind-boggling pace inside the little cell. “Did he offer you a deal?"
“He did,” Thorin confirms slowly. “But I refused.” His eyes are wide as he continues studying what must, to him, appear to be nothing more than empty air.
“Well, that’s that, then,” Balin echoes Bilbo’s sentiments exactly. “A deal was our only hope.” That’s not so true, of course, but Bilbo isn’t very well about to give himself away by arguing the other side.
“He would not have kept his word,” Thorin resolves. “He lied to me and taunted me. He is holding us here when we have done nothing wrong! Thranduil would not honor any deal we might make.”
Bilbo takes the opportunity to get a handle on his surroundings. The room is slightly larger than the coat closet in Bag End, with a stone bench for resting or sitting on. There are minimal blankets and no pillow. It is a tiny space, and Bilbo does not look forward to sharing it with Thorin. Doubtlessly, the king will be angry with him for managing to get captured without getting caught, for failing in his plan to find them a way out. And time spent together in such tight quarters will probably produce a level of intimacy that Bilbo has never experienced with anyone before. Who knows how long they will be in here? The cell is fully plumbed, but there is no semblance of privacy. Even less of it than they’ve had on their journey hitherto.
“I do not think we will find another mode of escape,” Balin informs his king dryly.
“None of us know what we will find in this foul place,” Thorin murmurs, so quietly that even Balin might not be able to hear him.
They both wait, then, to see if any of their companions will offer Thorin any further conversation. But it seems that, truly, that is that. They have all resigned themselves to whatever fate they might suffer as a result of Thorin’s refusal to treat with Thranduil. Or, even worse, they are all plotting in retaliation.
Not that Bilbo has time to think about that just now. He must trust that his friends will behave in the Elven prison exactly as they did the last time, and he must contend with whatever questions Thorin is about to throw his way.
“Master Baggins,” Thorin finally whispers. His voice is so low that Bilbo nearly does not hear him. “Am I going mad, or have you managed to find your way into my cell?”
“I’m here,” Bilbo sighs, “Unfortunately.”
“You were with me in the throne room, as well.” There is a slight uncertainty lurking under Thorin’s authoritative tone, but he does not seem particularly angry. Or, at least, he does not seem particularly angry with Bilbo. The Elves are another matter altogether.
“Yes.”
“You can turn invisible?” This is framed as a question, at least.
“Yes.”
Thorin sighs. “That explains a great deal. I can see how you got out of the goblin tunnels, even if I cannot see you. I take it that you have a plan.”
“Well, of course I do,” Bilbo replies, “Though admittedly, getting locked in here with you wasn’t part of it.”
Thorin regards the space slightly to Bilbo’s left with a hard glare. Bilbo wishes he could take the ring off and become visible again. He’s sure it makes Thorin uncomfortable, not being able to see him, and it certainly makes Bilbo uncomfortable having to wear the blasted thing. The longer he has it on, the more he grows accustomed to the hazy quality of the world around him, and this troubles Bilbo deeply. “But you have found a way to escape?”
“I have.” This much is true at least.
“Quite a lot of exploring that you managed to do in such a short time,” Thorin observes with a palpable edge of skepticism.
Bilbo does not feel that now is the best time to explain things to Thorin. He will have questions that Bilbo won’t be able to answer and still keep his wits about him. “Isn’t that what you hired me for? Sneaking around, quickly and quietly? Not that it matters. All of it will be for nothing if I can’t get out of this cell.”
“Tell me what you have in mind.” This is the problem with getting Thorin involved in Bilbo’s escape plan. The first time around, Bilbo had the upper hand, and could simply announce that he’d found a way out. After weeks in the Elven dungeons, Thorin hadn’t been in any position to argue, let alone to try and take command.
But now, Bilbo needs to manage not only the company’s escape from the Woodland Realm, but also his own escape from this cell and the serious control issues of a certain Dwarven king. “I don’t think that’s such a good idea.”
“I can’t help you if you refuse to tell me your plan,” Thorin protests.
“No, we shouldn’t speak of it,” Bilbo argues. “Not openly, at least. We don’t know who’s listening, do we?”
“I must confess, Master Burglar, I’m beginning to suspect that you don’t have any plan at all.”
“I do,” Bilbo assures him, hoping against hope that Thorin will believe him. “But I’m afraid we must be patient. It will take several weeks to come to fruition.” After all, they’re going to have to wait for the feast, when Thranduil and his guards alike will be distracted enough for Bilbo to steal the keys to his friends’ cells. All of this, of course, is assuming that he can slip out of Thorin’s cell somehow.
“Not sooner?” Thorin asks.
“I don’t think so.” Bilbo knows that the company only escaped the first time through sheer luck. The guards were distracted, there were empty barrels available, and Bilbo happened to think of the right idea at the right time. It is extremely unlikely that similar conditions will be replicated under any different circumstances.
“And what would you have done in the meantime, had you not been locked in my cell?” Thorin, at least, seems to find some humor in this, if the slight quirk of his lips is any indication. Bilbo, too, is reluctantly willing to admit that it is a little funny.
He shrugs, though of course Thorin can’t see him. “To wander around spying until then. I’d have liked to find our weapons and get a few of them back.”
“You could not carry many.”
“Yes, thank you, I had no idea.” Is Thorin trying to infuriate him? “But I could make multiple trips, you know.”
“What would you have eaten?” Such an odd thing to focus on.
“I’m sure I would have found something.” Bilbo does not understand. This is new territory for him, something completely different. For the first time since restarting his adventure, he genuinely does not know what’s going to happen next, and he has to think up a completely original plan for how to get out of this cell.
“Then it is good that you are here,” Thorin decides, “Where I can keep an eye on you.”
“You can’t see me!” Bilbo sputters. “And this is not good at all! We are locked in a cell, Thorin! A cell, in the Woodland realm, and Yavanna only knows what the Elves will do to you for how you spoke to Thranduil!“
“You didn’t seem so opposed to it at the time,” Thorin growls.
“Well, you didn’t say anything that wasn’t true,” Bilbo admits, “But I don’t trust Thranduil not to… enact retribution of some kind, and—“
“Shh.” Thorin holds up his hand in what he seems to think is Bilbo’s general direction. Honestly, no wonder he got lost in Hobbiton, of all places, if he can’t parse where in this tiny cell Bilbo’s voice is coming from. And they are below stone now, are they not? Perhaps the caves of the Elven king simply do not count. Is it the wrong type of stone? Is there some magic here which hinders stone-sense? Or is Thorin’s perception of direction terrible in all unfamiliar places? “Enough chatter. The others will hear you.”
“Now you worry about that.” Bilbo makes a rude gesture, before realizing that Thorin can’t see him. He takes off the ring to make the gesture again, and Thorin’s eyes widen. It’s almost satisfying to see the small, gentle smile that graces the king’s face.
But then Thorin’s gaze hardens, and he shakes his head. “Make yourself invisible again, Master Baggins,” he orders. “No one can know that you are here. I will not jeopardize your safety.”
Bilbo rolls his eyes but does as he’s told. Only because Thorin has a point, of course.“Maybe it is better that I’m here,” he lies, trying to lighten the mood. He and Thorin will both need to keep their spirits up if they’re to concoct an escape plan. “Where I can keep an eye on you.” If Thorin thinks anything of having his own words tossed back at him this way, he does not give those thoughts voice.
Somehow, Bilbo manages to find sleep in the halls of the Elven King. It’s a real wonder than he does so, because the torches in the corridor are perpetually lit, and he can hear not only the snoring and hushed conversations of his companions, but also the footsteps of the guards. Still, the journey through Mirkwood exhausted Bilbo more than he was willing to admit before his arrival here, certainly more than it did the first time around. He does not fully understand why, but he suspects that his advanced years and the damage done to him during them played some role. And then there is the matter of the ring. Wearing it at all is much more draining than Bilbo remembered, and wearing it perpetually without any hope of imminent removal puts him in a lamentable state of lethargy.
He did not notice this feeling when last he visited Thranduil’s realm. It was hard to pay attention to how tired he was when he was busy searching for a way out, constantly moving, never safe to rest his eyes for longer than a few moments. Now, however, Bilbo has plenty of time to sleep. Little time, in fact, to do anything else, and there is no chance of his being discovered. Even if the Elves were foolish enough to open the door to Thorin’s cell, they would not step inside it with him. And none of them have any reason to suspect Bilbo’s presence. A fourteenth member of the company slinking around, invisible, and menacing the Elves is much more plausible than the same invisible fourteenth member secreting himself away inside Thorin’s cell.
Bilbo curls up in a corner, his coat wrapped around him as best as he can get it. His pack has been left behind somewhere in the forest, and he doubts he will eversee it again. Its contents were limited to his bedroll, a shirt he never would have fit into, and a little bit of rationed food. His only remaining possessions at this juncture are the ring and the clothes on his back.
He dreams of Ravenhill. Always, over and over again, he dreams of Ravenhill. This should come as no surprise. He should not be so affected by it, after having the same nightmare so very many times, but still, he can feel the icy wind stinging his face and the tears pricking his eyes each time that Fíli falls. He can taste the dry air as he listens to the heaving sound of Thorin’s last breath, can see the blood all over his own hands. And even though he knows what is coming, he forces himself to run down those stairs again, in search of Kíli, and though it is no surprise, in his dreams, Bilbo always falls to his knees when he sees the poor Elf sobbing over the body of her lost love.
When he wakes, Bilbo jolts and taps his head against the stone wall behind him. Ah, yes. He is still trapped in the dungeons of the Woodland realm. How lovely. He rises, stretches (by the Valar, his poor back is very stiff) and looks around him. The facilities are probably older than Bilbo is, and they leave more than a little to be desired, but he is grateful for their presence nonetheless. There is a faucet, so he will not die of thirst. It only takes a little bit more scanning of the room for his eyes to fall on Thorin.
The king is laying on his back on a stone bench in a dimly lit room. Bilbo’s vision is flooded, all of a sudden, with the same image in a different context: Thorin, in eternal slumber on a carefully carved stone slab, his eyes closed, his hands resting just over that fatal wound. To cover the gaping hole. To cover the bloody mess. His hair, freshly braided by Dáin, his technical next of kin. It should be you, Dwalin muttered to Bilbo while the braiding was going on.
Why? Bilbo asked. Why should it be me? Dáin is his cousin and the next king, he has every right to… I wouldn’t know how to do it, even if… I couldn’t. I can’t…
Because Bilbo’s hands had been shaking worse than anything. Completely useless. He could not be in the same room as Thorin and the lads without bursting into tears. And anyway, Dáin was not their next of kin. That honor belonged to Dís, who would find, after many months, that the worst had happened and she had lost her entire family. Bilbo never met her. She stayed in the Blue Mountains when she heard the news, and she died there before Bilbo ever thought of visiting Erebor again. Well-respected, prosperous, a great leader of her people, and entirely alone. Bilbo could have visited, but he chose not to because he knew that the deaths of her family were all his fault. If he had only arrived five minutes earlier…
That is not true. Bilbo did not try to visit Dís because he did not want to see how closely she resembled Thorin. He did not want to look into blue eyes that he knew but had never seen before. He did not want to see Kíli’s easy smile on another face or hear Fíli’s turns of phrase coming from different lips. He wanted to forget all about the three of them, to pretend that their deaths were easy for him to overcome. To pretend that he had not been gutted. To pretend that he had continued to be a whole and functional person even after he heard the sound of Fíli’s bones shattering against the rock, even after he felt the life leave Thorin’s body, even after he rushed to find Kíli and discovered that the lad was long gone.
Bilbo had no desire to share that pain with anyone. He wanted the ache to go away, so he drove it down. He left the gory details out of his book. He pretended that he never witnessed such horrible events at all, claimed that he’d been unconscious for them. He never even reported the story. Let Frodo and the other children of the Shire believe what they would about the ends that Bilbo’s companions met. Let the tale of Thorin’s death be about the lesson he learned and not the love that was taken from Bilbo on that horrible, cold day. Leave out the part about the bodies on stone slabs, the grieving mother, the poor Hobbit sobbing so hard that his nose bled. Leave out Dwalin’s trembling and Dori’s inability to fix the lads’ hair and the poor Elf maiden, clinging to the lifeless body of her love. Leave out the pitying looks that Bilbo had received. Make it about the treasure, make it about the importance of home. Make it a story to keep Hobbit faunts grateful. Nothing more. Nothing more at all.
“Hush.” Bilbo did not notice Thorin’s approach. He barely registers the cool hand on the top of his head. Probably, Thorin was going for his shoulder but miscalculated. There must have been some fumbling involved. Bilbo is unsure whether he is glad or sorry to have missed it. “Hush, now. There is nothing to cry about.”
Apparently, this is Thorin’s way of giving comfort to a Hobbit who is sobbing openly and therefore in serious danger of being discovered by the looming Elven guards. He’s not doing such a bad job, all things considered. At the very least, Thorin’s touch reminds Bilbo that they are both alive and well and here, which is better than Bilbo could’ve said six months ago. Thorin is breathing, and Bilbo is much more than the rapidly-aging shadow of himself who last visited the halls of Erebor.
Bilbo says nothing but throws his arms around Thorin, burying his face in his friend’s sturdy chest. How embarrassing, to cry like this. And Thorin does not even know what Bilbo is crying about! In fact, he cannot even see Bilbo. The sound of sobbing must have woken him up, and Bilbo hadn’t even been aware that he was doing it!
“We will escape soon,” Thorin assures him, gently stroking his hair. “You have a plan already, and now all we must do is wait.” Of course, the gentle words do not last very long. “You will only draw attention to yourself, carrying on like this.”
“Thanks,” Bilbo grumbles against Thorin’s chest. But neither one of them releases the other.
Thorin does not ask why Bilbo is crying. Perhaps he does not care. Perhaps he imagines that Bilbo would not wish to tell him, which, in all fairness, is entirely correct. Perhaps he would rather not have this conversation in the first place, or perhaps he does not know how to go about initiating such a discussion. Instead he says, “I would protect you, if I could. I will not allow any harm to come to you while you travel in my company.”
Bilbo sniffles. “You hired me to face a dragon for you,” he points out.
Thorin stiffens. Bilbo can feel the king’s muscles tensing. Did he… forget about the dragon? No, that can’t be. Thorin is constantly thinking of Erebor. He would not be able to lose the thought of Smaug completely, even in his happiest moment, which this is certainly not. He must simply have forgotten that Bilbo would be the one to face the beast. “I will go inside the mountain with you, if you wish,” Thorin offers instead, “It is my birthright, not yours, and the dragon’s wrath is my burden to bear.”
This is actually much more effective than the hair-stroking in helping Bilbo to return to himself. For one thing, it is a shocking contrast with Thorin’s attitude on the first adventure. Oh, yes, things have certainly changed between them. Bilbo has had the courage to challenge Thorin’s assumptions from the start, and this has clearly endeared him to the king more than his irritated fumbling did the first time around. That, or he has proven himself trustworthy more quickly than he did before. Or any number of things.
“Don’t be ridiculous,” Bilbo protests as quietly as he is able. It is the middle of the night, and he cannot hear the voices of any of the company, but that does not mean that he and Thorin should behave as though they are the only ones awake. Even if they were, which Bilbo highly doubts, they would not be for much longer. “Did you not listen to a word Gandalf said at Bag End?”
“I believe it was you who slunk off to another room—“
“To wash the dishes!”
“— And did not read the contract you were given,” Thorin pushes ahead. “You want looking after, clearly.”
“And I suppose you’ve taken that task upon yourself?” Bilbo tries very hard to be annoyed. Considering that he’s been in love with Thorin for eighty years, it’s easy to interpret this protectiveness as a romantic gesture. But Thorin has only known Bilbo for a scant matter on months, which colors the entire affair in a significantly different light.
“I have,” Thorin resolves, his expression entirely serious. He seems to be looking into Bilbo’s eyes, though of course, he is not. He cannot see Bilbo’s eyes. “This is strange, like holding a spirit in my arms. I don’t care for it.”
“Well, I don’t care for being locked up in an Elven prison, myself,” Bilbo quips. He simply can’t help himself. He’s trying to take this seriously, and half the time, the emotions just come bubbling up, boiling over the edges of the cauldron that is his ancient mind. But the rest of the time, he finds he is still the same sarcastic Hobbit who set out from Bag End all those years ago. “We must all make sacrifices on this journey, apparently.”
“You’ve lost your handkerchiefs, then,” Thorin decides.
“Not all of them.” Bilbo withdraws one of these from his pocket, as best he can while held in a vice grip, and waves it about in front of Thorin, who, of course, cannot see it. Bilbo takes the ring off, only for a moment, and repeats the motion. He cannot dwell in the lightness of his sudden freedom, the brilliant saturation of the colors of the world. He knows that he must hide himself again, and so he does, quick as a flash.
Thorin only blinks at him, which is very endearing indeed. If it weren’t for Bilbo’s sore body and his occasional involuntary sniffling and the glaring lights of the torches all around them, he might even be able to forget where they are. Of course, that was the whole problem to begin with. Bilbo genuinely believed, for just a moment, that he was back upon Ravenhill, in the aftermath of the Battle of the Five Armies. Which has not happened yet. Which will not happen the way that Bilbo remembers it. He will give his own life before letting any of his family fall on that battlefield.
“If you still have a handkerchief,” Thorin drawls, once he has gotten his bearings, “Then what excuse have you for using my shirt as one?”
“I seem to recall being gathered up in your arms and pressed against your chest like a faunt,” Bilbo recounts. “Which I did not ask for, by the way.”
“You’d have given yourself away with your crying,” Thorin points out.
“And here I thought you were comforting me, when you only wanted to shut me up!” But Bilbo can’t help but laugh. Things are strange between them, different. He does not know how to navigate this changed dynamic. And he can’t help but feel a little bit hurt by it, as well.
He did hope that Thorin returned his feelings eighty years ago. But clearly, back then, something held Thorin back, either from developing feelings for Bilbo or from expressing them. Granted, now that Bilbo thinks about it, there isn’t very much of a question at all. Bilbo was the one who constantly pushed Thorin away, refusing to speak to him unless spoken to. Bilbo was the one who said rude things about the company, implying and then directly stating that they didn’t belong anywhere. Bilbo was the one who isolated himself for the first month of the journey. Fíli and Kíli practically had to force him to talk to them, and even then, he wasn’t happy about it. Could Thorin really be expected to give his love to someone who had been so dismissive toward his beloved nephews?
“And it did not even work,” Thorin pretends to lament with a soft smile. “I must find a new tactic before we’re discovered.”
“We won’t be discovered,” Bilbo argues. I wasn’t the last time, he almost says, but thank the Valar, he stops himself at the last moment. That’s not a can of worms that he’s prepared to open just yet.
“You will not sleep on the floor again,” Thorin decrees with a meaningful look.
He will not ask Bilbo directly to join him in his bed, if the stone slab upon which he has slept can even be called a bed. Bilbo knows this. Thorin is too proud for that, and far too awkward, as well. He does not have much practice in making gentle requests, or in expressing his worry, or in giving comfort beyond whatever he must have offered to his nephews when they skinned their knees as children. Thorin is pragmatic, a warrior king if ever there was one, and he is never going to be any more forward than this.
“I don’t want to aggravate your injuries,” Bilbo informs him. He can be forward enough for both of them.
“I was barely injured, and have healed thanks to Óin’s incessant hovering,” Thorin assures him.
“You’ll tell me if I cause you any pain.” Two can play at this game. Bilbo isn’t really one for the gentle request-making, either.
“Of course,” Thorin says. “As long as you promise to do the same.”
Bilbo chuckles. “Fair enough,” he decides. It’s an agreement he can work with, at the very least.
It is difficult to keep track of the passage of time inside the cell. They are definitely not being given the requisite seven meals per day, though of course, Bilbo has gotten plenty used to that on his travels. He’s grown accustomed to settling for three meals, perhaps four, if his traveling companions are at all familiar with Hobbit-y ways. But either the time is dragging on at an alarmingly slow pace, or the Elves only feed them twice each day.Not that their meals were much more frequent while the company traveled through Mirkwood.
The food isn’t bad, Bilbo supposes. He’s always been fond of leafy greens, and the porridge, while lacking the butter and cream that he would probably add to it if he were cooking it at home, is not so terrible, either. A few times, they are given eggs, though Bilbo does not know what bird these come from. Thorin, when asked, does not know either, and does not seem to understand why Bilbo would be at all interested in finding out. But then, his general comportment seems to indicate that since arriving here, Thorin has thrown what little common sense he had to begin with entirely by the wayside.
“You’re being ridiculous,” Bilbo complains, and not for the first time, after their evening meal is delivered.
“It could be poisoned,” Thorin decrees. Bilbo doubts this, but explaining as much has not gotten him very far hitherto. He’ll have to change tack, then.
“So, in that case, surely the Burglar should taste it before the King does?” He knows this is a losing battle.
“No. You are my responsibility,” Thorin tells him firmly. “I will not see you harmed.”
Bilbo rolls his eyes, though, of course, Thorin cannot see the gesture. To compensate, the Hobbit heaves a dramatic sigh. “I’m the one that saved your life, Thorin. Shouldn’t I be responsible for you? And I’m not your subject, by the way. You can’t order me around.”
Thorin shoots him a look that confirms Bilbo’s suspicions well enough. Though the king has yet to breathe the word One in Bilbo’s presence, let alone to try and explain his feelings to the Hobbit, it’s clear what he’s thinking. This is not about debt or propriety, and it has nothing to do with the quest. True, Thorin would sacrifice himself for any member of the company in a heartbeat, but this seems a little much.
Not that any of that matters now. Bilbo is getting awfully full of himself, assuming that he might mean so very much to Thorin when they haven’t even spoken about it. It’s not unheard of, he knows, for the call of the bond to go completely ignored. Even if there is some cosmic connection between the two of them, that doesn’t mean that Thorin will wish to pursue it. He may be acting on instinct now, but once he survives the battle, he might prefer to focus on his duties. And Bilbo is perfectly okay with that.
He’s not doing this because he expects to get something from Thorin in the end. Far from it, actually. He’s doing this because he cares about his friends, and he does not wish to see them die. And even if he did have some definite intention of pursuing a future relationship with Thorin, now would not be the time. Bilbo cannot become a distraction. Though he’s beginning to worry that it’s a little late for that, and he will be a distraction no matter what he does.
The more time they spend here, the more Bilbo thinks on this. The more pressing matters of their escape and the quest and Bilbo’s nightmares slip away, and they are left alone in a room with very obvious feelings that neither of them dares voice. They have distracted themselves with conversation, idle tales of Erebor and the Shire. Bilbo has heard stories of the games the royal children got up to in their ample free time, before they could comprehend the particulars of their grandfather’s madness and before the dragon drove them from their home. In return, Bilbo has recited family trees and spoken at length about his youthful antics and those of his more adventurous relations. But mostly, they have stayed silent, preserving their voices and Bilbo’s secret in the face of the lingering guards.
Regardless, Bilbo is not naive enough to believe that adding a courtship into the mix at this point on their adventure would be wise, and clearly, Thorin does not believe so, either. And why would he? Dwarven customs dictate the exchange of gifts, which is virtually impossible when neither of them has anything more than the clothes on their back. Perhaps Thorin could give away one of the beads in his hair, but what would Bilbo give him in return? A handkerchief? The One Ring?
Oh, what a ridiculous thought to pop into Bilbo’s mind! He knows where it came from, of course, though he does not know whether to be relieved or troubled by the knowledge that it was not his own idea. Bilbo loves Thorin and would never curse him with this burden. Although, he loved Frodo as he would love his own son, and that didn’t stop him from passing that same awful weight down to the lad. And it destroyed him. Painfully, slowly, irrevocably, the ring pulled the strings of Frodo’s mind apart until the tapestry was damaged beyond restoration, and Bilbo could do nothing but stand back and watch.
Your fault, a voice hisses in his mind, That was your fault.
“It is safe to eat,” Thorin decides when nothing happens after what seems to be an arbitrary amount of time. Perhaps he was trained for this as a young Prince of Erebor. It would be a handy thing to know. How long before one can expect the Royal food-taster to start dying after ingesting poison?
“You’d better have more than that,” Bilbo scolds him. The ring seems to get stronger by the day, but he cannot risk taking it off. “I won’t have you going hungry.”
He is doomed, no matter what you do, says that same voice. But Bilbo shakes it off, ignores it, pushes it away. He’s had the ring on far too long, if it is speaking to him. Did it do this the last time?
Probably. Almost definitely. But it would never have occurred to Bilbo that the voice speaking in his head was not his own. He knows better now. He cannot trust his own thoughts, especially not while he is wearing the ring. After all, the cursed thing has some ability, at least, to reach into Bilbo’s mind and rifle through it. It has some knowledge of its own destruction, some knowledge of the future that Bilbo has been dreading since he found himself outside Bag End. It knows what he would do to it, and though it may not be as powerful as it was when Frodo bore it, the ring will still do everything it can to protect its own interests.
“I am fine.” Thorin is lying. Of course he isn’t fine. Every time they are offered a meal, he barely picks at the food before claiming he isn’t hungry and passing the plate to Bilbo.
“I already had most of breakfast.” And it still wasn’t enough to feed a Hobbit, but that is beside the point. “And last night’s dinner. It’s your turn to have the lion’s share.”
“I have traveled with you long enough to know that you require more food than I do, Master Baggins,” Thorin explains with remarkable patience. Well, remarkable for Thorin. If any Hobbit tried that tone on Bilbo, he’d slam his door in their face, and they would not be invited back for tea. Case in point: Lobelia Sackville-Baggins. “Why must you make everything so difficult?”
“You need your strength,” Bilbo hisses, “I don’t know how you expect me to sneak you out of here if you’re half-starved, seeing as I can’t very well carry you, and you’re going to need to be able to—“
“Someone’s coming.” Thorin cuts him off, taking back the plate and snatching the fork out of Bilbo’s hand.
Well, that wasn’t how Bilbo would’ve liked to win that battle, but he’s relieved to see Thorin eating, at the very least. He knows the king would not risk seeming as though he does not enjoy or appreciate the food. This is entirely for Bilbo’s sake, of course, because Thorin clearly neither enjoys nor appreciates the food itself or the fact that it is given, sparingly, by Elves who are holding him prisoner. But it’s plain that he does not wish for his jailers to believe that it is a waste to bring him meals in the first place. Anyway, he won’t touch the greens, so Bilbo will have those, but the porridge and eggs should make a good enough meal. They have the same argument every day, each of them urging the other to eat more, as though that were possible in their present circumstances.
There are, indeed, footsteps approaching. Elven footsteps, long and soft, though not as soft as the ones that a Hobbit would take. Bilbo has not seen Legolas since the party was taken in the forest, but here is the prince now, standing with his back as straight as any of his arrows, beside the red-headed guard.
The two Elves come to a stop outside of the cell that Bilbo and Thorin have been sharing. Bilbo is not pleased with this at all. He knows from Frodo’s stories that young Legolas (who is probably about seven times Bilbo’s age, though he looks barely older than a child) has keen sight and hearing. He may pick up on Bilbo’s breathing, if the Hobbit is not careful.
Thankfully, the prince seems distracted this night. “You are spending too much time in the dungeons, Tauriel,” Legolas scolds in his native tongue. Of course, Bilbo can understand Sindarin far better than he can understand Khuzdul. He has gotten his hands on far more Elvish tomes, comparatively.
“I am merely doing my job,” Tauriel protests. “The prisoners are in my charge.” This is not strictly true, Bilbo knows. He distinctly remembers another Elf saying the same thing, just before Bilbo snatched his keys away. While it may be Tauriel’s right to pass time in the dungeons, it is by no means an obligation.
“But you seem only to be guarding one of them,” Legolas returns. It’s very polite of him not to mention Tauriel’s stretching of the truth. “And he does not seem poised to escape.”
There is a long pause, where Tauriel glances down at the ground. Surely, she isn’t being bashful. “Do not tell me you are jealous of a Dwarf locked in a cell.”
Bilbo knows from his earlier spying that Thranduil believes there to be something romantic between Tauriel and Legolas. But seeing them together now, he finds he has his doubts. Legolas glances up at the ceiling, as though exasperated.
“I am not jealous,” the prince announces, “Only confused.”
“I do not see what there is for you to be confused about.” Her tone is sharp, though she continues looking downward. “Is it a crime now to speak to the prisoners?”
“A crime?” Legolas sounds genuinely offended at the thought that he might be accusing the guard of any wrongdoing. “No, it is not a crime, my friend. And even if it were so, I’m sure you’d be exempt by virtue of your position. But it is foolish.”
“Is it indeed?”
“He has no reason to be interested in you, other than that you hold the keys to his cell.”
Bilbo is still not entirely certain to whom they are referring, though he has his suspicions. Judging by the expression on Thorin’s face, the king cannot even understand the words. That is probably for the best. He would not be pleased to learn that his nephew is fraternizing with Elves. “He is kind and funny to speak to,” Tauriel replies sharply. “And he is interested in the stars.”
“Ah, yes, the stars he cannot see while locked away,” Legolas says. His small smile is unreadable. Does he pity the prisoners, then? “Perhaps he thinks his kindness and his humor will entice you to open his cell.”
“I am not a fool, Legolas. I will not be seduced into freeing the prisoners.”
“Seduced?” Legolas echoes. “I was not aware that you were being seduced in the first place, Tauriel. But whatever the Dwarf has been saying to you—“
“His name is Kíli,” she interrupts the prince, which has to be a great impertinence. Thorin shoots to attention at that, his back stiffening and his fists clenching.
Bilbo places a gentle hand on the king’s thigh. He wishes to calm him, somehow, but of course, he cannot risk the words.
“Fine,” Legolas does not seem to miss a beat. “Then whatever Kíli has been saying to you, I would not trust. He has much to gain from earning your friendship. You, however, have little to gain from earning his. At best, he will escape with his people and be gone from here forever. He would have to be a fool to return, even for you. And where will that leave you?”
“It will leave me here, with a friend who lives in another kingdom,” Tauriel argues, “Not such a bad fate.”
“Is that all it is, then, really?” Legolas asks, eyes penetrating.
“What concern is it of yours?” Tauriel demands. “And besides, that is all it can be. I will not plant my hopes where there is no soil for them.”
“As you should not,” Legolas agrees.
“Your father thinks that you are interested in me,” the guard changes the subject abruptly, and Bilbo can see why. “And you are not helping matters by getting jealous of the prisoners.”
“I am not jealous,” Legolas assures her, “As I said. I am confused.”
“It looks very much like jealousy,” Tauriel says, “And it will look that way to your father.”
“My father does not look often into his dungeons,” Legolas retorts, “And I do not see why you care what he thinks.”
“I care because he is my king,” she explains, “And because he is the father of my dearest friend. In every way but blood, he has been a father to me, as well.” Though not a very kind father, if he would tell her to her face that he does not think her good enough for his son.
“He expects me to be interested in Elf Maids.” Legolas seems to have come to terms with this idea, though he does not appear quite pleased with it. “And you are the only Elf Maid with whom I spend any time. It is natural for him to make assumptions, but you have nothing to fear. He will expect nothing.”
Bilbo recalls a story told gleefully by Pippin Took, in which Prince Legolas rode off into Fangorn Forest with Gimli, son of Glóin, perched on the back of his horse. Apparently, Legolas prefers the company of Dwarven fellows to that of Elven maidens, at least when he is choosing a companion for his rides into the sunset. Bilbo can only imagine how Glóin would feel about this, if he knew.
Tauriel does not say what she said the last time Bilbo eavesdropped. She does not express to Legolas that Thranduil does not think her worthy. Instead, she says, “I do not think that these Dwarves pose any serious threat.”
“Tauriel…”
“I cannot understand why your father would insist upon locking them up,” she proceeds, ignoring the Prince’s warning. “Kíli’s brother still carries several knives, but has made no attempt to use them.”
“If one of the prisoners is still armed,” Legolas replies cautiously, “You should have disarmed him immediately.”
“Many of them are warriors, but none have caused any trouble,” Tauriel continues, “And I do not remember when it became a crime for any to pass through your father’s lands.”
“My father is afraid,” says Legolas, “Between the spiders and the orcs—“
“Then we should be fighting spiders and orcs, not locking up travelers who have committed no crime.” Tauriel takes a breath. “I will follow the orders of my king. But surely I am permitted to my own opinion.” Bilbo doubts this, actually. He can’t image that Thranduil is fond of dissent within his kingdom, especially not when it comes from his primary enforcer.
“It seems the young Prince of Erebor has stolen something quite precious from the Woodland Realm,” says Legolas with a soft smile. There is a mocking note to his tone, however, one that shows precisely what he thinks of the Prince of Erebor. Bilbo is thankful that Thorin cannot understand the Elves, or else this might quickly become a mess that even Bilbo’s remarkable problem-solving abilities could not clean up. “The heart of its chief guard.”
He is joking, of course. He has to be. No Elf, not even a kind one like Legolas, would take so easily to such an idea. Bilbo remembers that Legolas and Gimli did not get on well at the Council in Rivendell. Their bond must have formed slowly, over the course of their journey, which is something Bilbo can relate to. Regardless, the prince was not kind to the company in the forest, and he is not being particularly kind now.
“I still have my bow,” Tauriel warns him, though the threat does not sound genuine, “And even if my heart were stolen, which it has not been, I would not give my love so freely to one I hardly know.”
“But it does not bother you that he is a Dwarf.”
“No, it does not.” The words fly out of Tauriel’s mouth, and she quickly qualifies them: “It bothers me that his people are being held here against their will, and that our resources are being spent upon them.”
“That is how prisons tend to operate, Tauriel,” Legolas reminds her. “We have a duty to the realm and to its King. We must—“
“Legolas,” Tauriel levels him with a shrewd glare. “You know as well as I do who these prisoners are.”
“It would be obvious to anyone who paid attention.” Easy for him to say, Bilbo thinks.
“They seek only their homeland. The dragon will not bother us, should they release it. Your father has no reason to hold them here.” She pauses. “Not when the threat upon our own doorstep grows greater each day. You cannot believe that these thirteen starving warriors have anything to do with the illness that plagues our forest.”
“You would see them free, then, if the choice rested in your hands?” Legolas asks.
“You would not?” Tauriel seems equally taken aback. “I would rather have my guards free, at least, to tend to other matters. It has been only a fortnight since we last cleared the spiders from that area of the woods, and yet, already they are back again in such great numbers!”
But then Legolas laughs. He throws an arm around her shoulder, a seemingly uncharacteristic gesture that Bilbo recognizes. He has seen Dwalin and Thorin interacting the same way. It is the behavior of a comrade in arms, the sort of bond that transcends social status and, apparently, the strict boundaries of Elven gender roles.
“I would see them free,” the prince decides, “If only to see your heart-thief on his way. I feel as though a wandering marauder has made a pass at my little sister. Perhaps I should speak to him.”
Tauriel swats at Legolas’s arm, but this apparently does not deter him. It is easy to imagine the two of them establishing this routine when they were much younger, before the broad gap in their social positions made itself apparent. “You should not!”
“Perhaps I should speak to his brother, and you will wind up with a Dwarven blade lodged in your throat. Then you’d learn to disarm prisoners, whether you’re fond of them or no.”
But he is clearly playing, joking. He is much different when chatting with his friend than he was when taking the company prisoner in the woods. It’s a good thing he isn’t serious. Bilbo doesn’t know how it would play out if Legolas attempted to have a conversation with Fíli about Kíli’s relationship with Tauriel, but that doesn’t sound like the wisest or safest course of action for anyone involved. Also, Thorin would probably overhear and start shouting.
“I would catch the knife,” Tauriel assures her friend.
“Oh, I don’t doubt it. So there would be no risk whatsoever.”
“Enough of that. Your father will soon miss you, and once you explain that you were with me, neither of us will hear the end of it.”
The captain elbows the prince in the ribs, and the two of them pass out of sight. Once their footsteps have retreated far enough that Bilbo is confident he won’t be overheard, he turns his attention back to Thorin. The king does not look well. His face is pale and tight with palpable anger. Of course. He could not understand what the Elves were saying, and caught only a few mentions of his nephew’s name, perhaps a couple of ‘Erebors’ here and there.
“Relax,” Bilbo breathes, “They mean Kíli no harm.”
“You understand Elvish?” Thorin snaps. Clearly, he’s elected not to follow Bilbo’s advice.
Bilbo shrugs. Of course, the gesture goes completely unobserved, but he cannot stop his natural reflexes. “I understand Sindarin far better than I speak it, but most of what I know comes from reading.” He’s spent years poring over Elvish books, though it’s best not to go down that road. He’s been reading Sindarin for longer than he’s supposed to have been alive, which is not something that he feels particularly inclined to explain to Thorin at this juncture. “Anyway, you have nothing to worry about.”
“They mentioned my sister-son by name several times.”
“Yes, they did,” Bilbo concedes. He doesn’t want to get Kíli in trouble, but he also has no desire to let Thorin worry needlessly. “Apparently, he’s made friends with the Captain of the Guard.”
“Friends?” Thorin echoes, “With an Elf? That is not possible. She must be using him somehow for her own gain.”
“That’s not too different from what the prince was telling her,” Bilbo continues, “And you’ll be happy to know that she would rather see the company free, if only so she could use the guards to patrol the forest and fight the spiders instead. It seems that Kíli has won her over, which you should also be glad about. That friendship may save his life one day.” Bilbo knows the story, after all, of what transpired between Kíli and Tauriel in Lake-town. “Also, Fíli is still armed.”
“They know this?” Thorin sounds doubtful. “Are you sure you understood them correctly?”
“Tauriel seemed to take it as a sign of our innocence that Fíli has knives on him still but has not used them,” Bilbo elaborates. “And Legolas thought it was all very funny.”
“He would laugh, while we are detained so unjustly in his kingdom?”
“He was raised by Thranduil,” Bilbo points out. He can’t imagine that Legolas was brought up to behave respectfully toward those less fortunate. Any kindness on his part must be entirely his own.
“Aye, that he was.” Thorin does not seem pleased with this at all. “All their talk of friendship, when they would speak at such length in front of me as though I were a piece of furniture.”
“That part’s not so good,” Bilbo admits. “But Kíli has done well. It doesn’t sound like Tauriel will work very hard to stop us if we tried to escape. He seems to have convinced her that we really only want to go to the mountain, that we have no quarrel with Thranduil.”
“I have plenty to quarrel about with that dishonorable—“
“Yes, I know,” Bilbo cuts him off. “But at least someone in your family is skilled with diplomacy.”
“I cannot see why this Elf has any interest in my sister-son,” Thorin says to the ceiling. “I hope she doesn’t harm him in her sport.”
Bilbo can understand what he means, and gives the king’s strong thigh a reassuring pat. He has no way of knowing that Tauriel is being genuine, and every reason to suspect a trick. “It could be worse,” Bilbo offers. “Besides, we’ll be out of here soon enough, anyway. Nothing to worry about.”
“I’d nearly forgotten that you are only biding your time, Master Burglar.” This, at least, does seem to cheer Thorin up. Bilbo neglects to mention that when they finally leave the Woodland Realm, they will by no means be seeing the last of Tauriel.
After two weeks in the dungeons, very little progress has been made. By which, of course, Bilbo means that he has not come any closer to escaping from the cell. The guards do not open the door wide enough for even a Hobbit to sneak through when they come bearing food, and the cell is never opened for any other reason. It is clear that if Bilbo wants to get out, he will have to manufacture some reason for the cell door to be opened all the way.
The company, too, grows restless. Bilbo cannot blame any of them. He knows that Kíli has been chatting with Tauriel; on quiet nights, he can hear their hushed voices carrying down the stairs, though he can never make out the precise words. The others, however, have very little to entertain them, and it is beginning to show.
“We’ve been here for weeks,” Ori laments, “We’ll be here forever, most likely.”
“Not forever,” Dori tries to comfort his brother.
“Oh, and how do you expect we’re going to get out?” This from Nori, always the realist. “Took my lock picks, they did, and the pins out of my hair.”
“They saw you coming a mile away, eyebrows braided like that,” Dwalin grumbles. It’s hard to tell whether this utterance is fond or grudging.
“Took back all what I stole from Rivendell, too,” Nori continues, ignoring Dwalin entirely.
“I’m impressed you managed to carry that this far,” says Balin from the cell beside Thorin’s.
Bombur mutters something which, typically, is too quiet for Bilbo to hear clearly at this distance, though Bofur clearly has no trouble hearing and cackling at whatever comment his brother just made.
“The goblins still have my candelabra,” Nori grumbles, either ignoring Bombur as well or unaware that he has spoken. Or, perhaps responding to whatever he said. Since Bilbo has no clue what that was, he has no clue how one might respond to it respectfully.
“Elrond’s candelabra, you mean,” Glóin puts in.
“I didn’t see his name on it.”
“Because you scratched it off.”
“No, I scratched off ‘made in Rivendell,’ and I’m sure the goblins are using it to light their tunnels now!”
“Well, good,” Dori groans, “You’ve brought them some culture. Congratulations.”
“When we take back Erebor, we’ll be sure to send you as an envoy with more light fixtures,” Fíli quips, though he doesn’t sound particularly joyful.
Nori mutters something very dark-sounding in Khuzdul. “None of that!” Dori scolds him. “I don’t want your brother picking up such language.”
“Ori swears worse than that all the time,” Kíli pipes in helpfully. He, at least, seems cheerful. Ah, young love. “I’ve heard him.”
“What are you trying to do?” Ori demands, though the entire company must know that Kíli’s announcement was entirely accurate. Ori certainly has a way with words, and not all of them are entirely polite.
“It doesn’t matter,” Glóin huffs, “We won’t be getting out any time soon. You’re safe from your brother’s wrath for now, lad.”
“And if we do get out, I’m sure Ori will be plenty old enough to swear by then,” Bofur joins in with his characteristic gallows humor, “That is, if we’re anything more than dust and bones.”
Now it’s Bifur’s turn to make a comment in Khuzdul. Óin laughs. “That’s just what I was thinking!”
“You need a new trumpet, my friend,” Balin counsels, “I doubt you’re thinking what he’s thinking, unless you’ve developed a death wish.”
“Nothing so dishonorable about that,” Fíli calls, “I’d rather die in battle than rot in a cell.”
“Not a battle at all, thirteen against however many thousand,” Bofur points out.
“At least not a battle we can win,” Bombur agrees.
“We could win it if we had our weapons,” says Dwalin, “I say, if we get out, the best we can do is take our chances.”
“Tauriel would look the other way,” Kíli seems convinced of this, though Bilbo knows that he’s being rather too optimistic. Tauriel might not agree with Thranduil’s decision to hold the company prisoner, but that doesn’t mean she’ll disobey direct orders from her king. Not yet, anyway.
“Seems she spends a lot of time looking your way!” Nori says. Thankfully, there are no guards nearby to overhear. There rarely are at this hour. “Think you could use that to our advantage?”
“No,” Kíli says firmly. “I won’t use her for anything.”
“She locked you in a cell,” Fíli reminds him, quite reasonably, Bilbo thinks. “I don’t think we should trust her any more than any of the other guards.”
“The other guards don’t speak to us,” Kíli alleges, “And they do not return the things they’ve taken.” He does not elaborate on this oblique reference any further. “Tauriel is… different. She didn’t even search me.”
“Not even after you asked her to,” Fíli recounts. “Mahal knows why you did that.”
“Mahal knows why Kíli does anything,” Thorin murmurs, quietly enough that only Bilbo can hear him.
“He’s been bewitched by that Elf,” Glóin decides, “It’s a sad thing to see. Do you know the cure for witchcraft, brother?”
“You’re asking if I know leechcraft? After all these years, of course I do!” Óin calls back indignantly.
“This is a mess,” Bilbo grumbles. He makes a mental note to reclaim Óin’s trumpet from the Elves at the earliest opportunity. It must be horrible, being imprisoned without being able to hear properly.
“My second heir has taken up with an Elf,” Thorin grumbles. “His mother will not be pleased.”
“And we’re all locked in a dungeon, and I’m fairly certain some of our friends are about to get violent, which won’t help us at all.” Bilbo is focused on slightly more pressing concerns. “But definitely the worst thing is that the poor boy has a little crush.”
“I do not trust the Elf Captain.”
“Yes, but you don’t trust any Elves at all, so it’s difficult to take your assessment with anything more than a grain of salt.”
“She is too friendly.” That is not how Bilbo would describe Tauriel at all. In fact, she seems rather reserved, even with Kíli. A practical lass, with a good head on her shoulders. Privately, Bilbo thinks the prince could do a lot worse.
“You’ve still got knives, haven’t you, Fíli?” Nori asks, far too loudly for Bilbo’s comfort. The guards could be back at any moment.
“Just a few,” Fíli concedes.
Bilbo places a gentle hand on Thorin’s arm. “You’ve got to do something before they try to start a fight they can’t win.” Not that they could do very much from behind bars, to begin with, but it’s still not a chance Bilbo wants to take.
Thorin sighs, but evidently sees the wisdom in Bilbo’s words. “Enough, all of you!” He roars. “There will be no mutiny this night.”
“Don’t think it is night, My King,” Dwalin protests, “It’s got to be nearly dawn.”
“Whatever time of day it is,” Thorin grits out, “You will stay your weapons. Or, rather, you will stay your hands. Because none of you have weapons. Is that clear?”
“Oh, very clear, uncle,” Fíli replies. He is probably the only one armed now, anyway, unless one of the others has managed to hide something away. Bilbo has his suspicions about Nori, for one.
“Good. Now, go about as you have been,” Thorin orders, “And do not fear. Master Baggins has a plan.”
The dungeons fall silent after that. Eventually, Bofur pipes in. “Um, begging your pardon, Your Majesty,” he begins, full of bluster. “But the last time we checked, Bilbo wasn’t here.”
Thorin chuckles. “Then you have not checked very closely.” He does not inform the group that Bilbo happens to be locked up in his cell, and allows them instead to leap to the conclusion that their Burglar is presently wandering around unseen in the Elven halls. “We must remain silent and guard his secret closely. Not a word to any of the Elves.” He shoots a sharp glare up the stairs, though Bilbo doubts that Kíli is able to see this.
The resultant cheer has calmed down by the time the Elf guards return, but the emotional environment in the dungeons seems to have changed for the better.
“It’s about time,” Balin says just loudly enough for the sound of his voice to carry into the adjoining cell. “I was wondering when you’d deign to let the rest of us in on your little ‘secret.’”
“Aye,” says Dwalin, also nearby, “You two have been keeping me up nearly every night with your chattering.”
“We were being quiet,” Bilbo protests. At least no one can see him blushing or fidgeting.
“You may’ve been trying to.” This, coming from Dwalin, is very charitable indeed. Bilbo doesn’t know why he expected any member of the company to allow Thorin to have the last word with his dramatic declaration.
Bilbo knows that the Feast of Starlight is fast approaching. If he wants to get his friends to safety, he will have to get out of this cell, and soon. He’s slept plenty over the course of the past several weeks, if fitfully, and he’s eaten more than he did when he was last here. He’s done his best to keep Thorin well-fed, too, though that was a challenge Bilbo wouldn’t like to repeat. He makes a point of not asking the king about his experience with food scarcity and self sacrifice. The evidence is right there, and Bilbo can draw his own conclusions.
“The Elves will be having their feast soon,” he informs Thorin, early in the morning, or possibly very late at night. Bilbo has done his best to mark the days, but he isn’t always certain of the precise time. The constant artificial light does not help things. “I have to get out of here and get the keys.”
If Bilbo didn’t understand the language of the Elves, he would not be at all confident on this point, but thankfully, he’s fairly certain of the impending schedule. Thorin sighs heavily. He is clinging to Bilbo, but that is only a matter of practicality: the stone bench they’re forced to sleep on is Man-sized, which gives them plenty of lengthwise space, but it is still a tight fit for them horizontally. There’s a significant chance of Bilbo rolling off onto the stone floor, and it makes sense that Thorin would not want to draw the attention of the guards with the loud thud of a Hobbit hitting the ground.
It’s more than that, of course. But neither of them would be stupid enough to even entertain the idea of acting upon that extra substance here, in the dungeons of the Elven King. Not physically; they could be caught. Not emotionally; they do not have the time or privacy for such a conversation. In Lake-town, though, things will be different. Bilbo will say something in Lake-town.
“I do not wish to see you go,” Thorin murmurs.
Bilbo can’t help rolling his eyes at that. “You do not wish to see me escape an Elven prison? Noted. I’ll file that away for later, and we can discuss it once we’re free.”
But it’s some relief to find that he’s not the only one enjoying this embrace. He still has nightmares, of course. They are graphic and vivid as they always have been. The strange ones with cryptic undertones are a welcome relief from watching his friends die night after night, but they are still deeply disturbing. Even so, Bilbo is comforted by Thorin’s presence, and embarrassed by how much comfort he is able to take in this awful situation. It’s such a horrible mess, and Bilbo does not have time to dwell on it, because he has to save his friends. And quickly, too, before they veer too far off the course of the original adventure.
“Obviously, I was not referring to that,” Thorin grumbles. “I only wish I could go with you.”
“Ah, yes, and how would that work?” Bilbo asks. He’s very fond of Thorin, indeed, but his king can be a little obtuse when he sets his mind to it. “I’d be invisible, and you’d… what, follow around behind me? I’m sure nobody would be any the wiser. How are you going to let me face the dragon alone if you can’t even stomach having me wander around Thranduil’s halls for a few days?”
“Smaug is a stupid beast and will be easy to kill if we sneak up on him,” Thorin resolves. Oh, by the Valar, does he actually believe this? That would explain a lot about his otherwise inexplicable refusal to make any sort of plan for fighting the dragon. “Assuming he is still alive after all these years of silence. Thranduil is unpredictable and would use you to get to me, as he is using the rest of my kin.”
“He’d have to catch me first.” Bilbo forces himself to sit up, because he feels incredibly compelled to kiss Thorin on the lips, and that is not happening. Not here, not now, for any number of reasons. “Anyway, I’m the only one here with anything even resembling an escape plan, and we need to get to Erebor by Durin’s day. You’ll have to let me go.”
Thorin sighs again. He, too, sits up, and his fingers twitch as though he is restraining himself from reaching out for Bilbo. Probably, now that they’re no longer in direct contact, the king isn’t entirely certain of where Bilbo actually is. His spatial awareness is truly abysmal. “I suppose I will,” he admits eventually.
Bilbo does not gloat. He knows that this victory was not easily gotten, and that he should accept it with grace. He may gloat later, though, once they’ve escaped. Lake-town will be a nice place for that, as well, he supposes. “Thank you.” Once more, Bilbo restrains himself from going in for the kiss. That would not help anything.
“You will return to me each night and tell me how you fare,” Thorin orders. Ah, well, Bilbo should not have expected him to give up control of the situation so easily.
“Of course.” It’s only a few nights, anyway. Three or four at the most. And Bilbo likely would’ve come back on his own, if only to make sure that Thorin was eating and sleeping. And then there is the rest of the company to consider. “Do you have some sort of plan?”
“Yes.” This is not typical. “I do not like it.”
“Well, that’s good. I’ve found the best plans are the ones that you don’t like,” Bilbo quips.
Truthfully, he doesn’t enjoy ceding control any more than Thorin does, but he doesn’t see what choice he has. Bilbo can’t see a way out of the cell. If he makes himself known, he’ll be hauled off to a cell of his own, and he knows he can’t win in a physical confrontation with the Elves. He has Sting, but they’re all armed as well, and there must be hundreds of them.
Thorin sighs again. “If I am killed—“
“What?”
“Please do not interrupt.” And now he’s saying please. He is asking Bilbo nicely for something. Oh, by the Green Lady, this really is going to be a horrible plan, isn’t it? “If I am killed or transferred to a deeper dungeon that you cannot find, save the others first. When Fíli has the throne back, he can make arrangements with Thranduil.” Arrangements to reclaim the body, he does not say.
Bilbo blinks at him, then remembers that Thorin cannot see his confused expression. “What exactly are you planning to do?”
“Be silent,” Thorin orders. At least, Bilbo takes it as an order, and not a response to his question. “When they open the door to take me, you must follow.”
Bilbo doesn’t like the sound of that at all. “What?”
“Be silent,” Thorin repeats. Oh, well, Bilbo asked for this, didn’t he? He made his bed, and now it seems that he is going to have to lay in it. “The guards will be here soon.”
Bilbo doesn’t see how Thorin could possibly know that, but maybe he’s better at judging the passage of time without natural light than Bilbo is. Still, the king is correct; after only a few moments, two guards approach, passing the cell on their regular rounds.
“I wish to treat with Thranduil,” Thorin announces the moment that the Elves are within earshot.
Not the most graceful approach, but then, Thorin has been living in a cell for several weeks, and he is making a major sacrifice so that Bilbo can enact his plan, without any knowledge whatsoever about what the plan is. This is not good. It is different from what happened last time, which means that it could change the outcome significantly. But what choice does Bilbo have? He needs to get out of the cell, and he needs to get the company to safety, and anyway, it’s already happening, whether he wants it to or not.
So, as instructed, when the guards open the cell door wider than he’s ever seen it opened before, Bilbo takes his chance and darts away. He feels guilty leaving Thorin, but it’s only for a few nights. And Thorin was just being dramatic, talking about being killed. Bilbo frantically pushes down the emotions boiling in his gut at present, because he knows they will not serve him. He has to rescue the company.
True to his word, he returns to Thorin’s cell at night, and, thankfully, finds the king in one piece. There is a fresh bruise spreading across his face, which Bilbo does not appreciate, but at least Thorin has not managed to get himself killed during Bilbo’s brief absence. “What happened?” Bilbo asks, ghosting his invisible fingers across the irritated skin.
“Nothing,” Thorin lies. “At least, nothing that I would not expect from an coward and a traitor lacking in all honor.”
“He struck you?” Bilbo is going to kill Thranduil. He is going to sort out the battle, ensure the safety of all three kingdoms, and personally stick his sword in Azog’s neck. And then, after all that, he is going to murder the king of the Woodland realm.
No. That is not who Bilbo Baggins is. He is not a murderer. He is entitled to his anger on Thorin’s behalf, but seeking vengeance will not help. Thranduil, really, is no different from Gollum: a pathetic and wicked creature, yes, but that does not mean that Bilbo is allowed to decide whether he lives or dies. He will focus on his own king instead.
Thorin leans into Bilbo’s touch as best he can through the bars of his cell. “No. One of the guards did this.” He does not elaborate with further context, and Bilbo does not request it. There will be time for this, too, in Lake-town.
“Right, well.” Bilbo has to collect himself. “We can talk about that later. For now, I think I’ve found where they’re keeping our weapons. I won’t be able to carry very many, but I should be able to smuggle out a few knives. Not enough for everybody, but—“
“Anything you can find, we can use,” Thorin informs him. “Even small weapons are better than nothing.”
“Yes. Right, then.” At least Bilbo has clear instructions now.“I’ll do my best. And I was wrong about the timing: the feast is tomorrow evening. We’ll have to move quickly. I’ll be back for you as soon as possible.” He moves to turn away, but finds Thorin grabbing his wrist through the bars of his cell. His grip is gentle, but there is urgency in the gesture nevertheless. It is a wonder to Bilbo that Thorin even managed to locate his wrist in order to grab it.
“Take care, Master Baggins,” Thorin orders.
Bilbo shakes his head, before remembering that he is invisible. It’s somewhat troubling, that he is so easily able to forget he’s got the ring on. But he does not have time to dwell on it. “I will,” he promises. “I’ll see you tomorrow night.”
Chapter 9: The King's Faithful Servant
Notes:
So... the original chapter nine was more than 20k words long, so I had to chop it in half to be able to post it this week. I guess we're going to have two (2) Lake-town chapters. There was just so much banter, and everything got out of hand with the Elves...
Thanks as always for reading, commenting, and leaving kudos! Please enjoy!
Chapter Text
“How’d you manage to hide a Halfling in your cell for three weeks?” Dwalin inquires as the company follows Master Baggins into the Elven King’s cellars.
It’s a fair question, despite the offensive language. Thorin can understand why Dwalin might not have processed the correction he was given in the depths of Mirkwood. After all, the entire company was delirious then, and until they met Master Baggins, they all used ‘Hobbit’ and ‘Halfling’ interchangeably to refer to the residents of the Shire. “A Hobbit. He can turn invisible,” Thorin replies.
“Explains a lot,” Dwalin decides.
“That it does,” says Balin. He’s got quite the spring in his step, now that he knows how the Hobbit got past his lookout after they escaped from the goblin tunnels. Apparently, that particular puzzle was bothering him until he began eavesdropping on Bilbo and Thorin in their shared cell. Thorin is somewhat preoccupied by other matters.
He knows that there is a plan, but he does not know what that plan is. He knows that Master Baggins has armed some of the company, but he does not know whom or with what. He also knows that his beloved nephew has been bewitched somehow by an Elf, which is perhaps the worst fate that could befall anyone of Durin’s line. Thorin can only hope that Kíli will see sense once they are free of the Woodland realm.
Master Baggins leads the group down to the cellars. This is the plan that he’s been touting for the past several weeks? Of course it is. What was it he said, right before Thorin’s ill-advised confrontation with Thranduil? I’ve found the best plans are the ones that you don’t like. In that case, he will be pleased to know that Thorin absolutely hates this ridiculous plot.
“Right. Into the barrels,” the Hobbit instructs.
Thorin feels compelled to trust him. It is as though his body is doing the trusting without his mind’s consent, and he does not care for the feeling. He does not care for any feelings, really. He’s been pushing them down as long as he’s been aware of them, but that is no mean feat around Master Baggins. Thorin will reluctantly admit that his feelings about the Burglar are becoming more than a simple distraction. They are becoming a liability.
He nearly did not allow the Hobbit to leave his cell. For a few moments, Thorin was prepared to spend the remainder of his life rotting in an Elven dungeon if it meant keeping Bilbo Baggins within his reach. Which was ridiculous, and a selfish line of thinking, and counterintuitive to his very important quest. That is why Thorin swallowed his pride and feigned contrition, requesting an audience with the Elven King.
That part wasn’t so bad. Perhaps the swearing and spitting was a little much, but Thranduil deserved it. Actually, Thranduil deserved worse, and had Thorin’s hands not been bound on that occasion, he’d have gotten it, too. As it stands, Thorin wasted about twenty minutes of the Elf’s time, said nothing that was not known already by all, and earned a harsh reprimand from an Elven guard. The Woodland King, of course, is too much of a coward to deal with his own prisoners, not that this came as any sort of surprise. And that son of his! Thorin fully intends to reclaim Orcrist from the Elven Prince at the earliest opportunity.
“Do as he says,” Thorin instructs his company when they greet the Hobbit’s instructions with grumbling.
“Really? Barrels?” Kíli does not seem convinced. “I still think Tauriel would look the other way if we did something less…” At least he doesn’t seem to be trying very hard to find the right word to describe Bilbo’s plan. Something tells Thorin that truly voicing such an adjective would not go well for the lad at all.
“You are blinded by your own affection,” Bilbo tells Kíli with false cheer. “And anyway, she’d lose her job, and then what would happen to her? Into the barrels, now, please, unless you’d like to try and swim the river.”
“Do as he says,” Thorin repeats, much more harshly this time. He is not pleased with his sister-son.
Kíli rolls his eyes and mutters under his breath but allows Bilbo to help him into the barrel. The rest of the company responds in more or less the same way. “I’m going to send you down the river now,” Bilbo announces. “I’ll be right behind you. Be ready for battle.”
“Battle?” Óin demands. “Did I hear that right, lads?”
“It seems you did,” Bofur confirms.
Bifur asks what Master Baggins is talking about, and Thorin finds that he would also like to know. But before he can translate the question to the common tongue for the Hobbit’s benefit, his barrel is turned on its side, and he is tumbling with the rest of them down into the icy river.
In eighty years, Bilbo has still not found a way around the obvious problem with the barrel-riding plan: he, himself, is not in a barrel, and he has nobody to pack him into one, because all his friends are already floating away.
“Where is the keeper of the keys?” And that’d be Tauriel, again, hot on Bilbo’s heels.
Thankfully, he distinctly remembers shuffling backwards in a panic the last time he was caught here, and in doing so, inadvertently opening the chute. This time, he goes at a run, rushing to the same spot where once he stood by mistake and tipping the balance of the large plank so that it pushes him into the water. He manages to paddle his way to his friends, which is no small feat. Strangely, upon his return to the Shire, Bilbo did not take the time to teach himself to swim.
“Well done, Master Baggins,” Thorin tells him solemnly. And then the lads are ushering Bilbo over to their barrels as best they can, setting him up so that he’s posed at an awkward angle between the two of them. Still, at least he isn’t drowning.
They are out of the frying pan and into the fire once again, Bilbo knows. There will be an orc attack just as they reach the gate, which will, of course, be shut on them. And Bilbo remembers all too well what happened the last time they were here. The waterfall is not any more pleasant this time than it was on the last adventure, that’s for certain.
He’s come up with a plan, though, and it’s foolproof. Well, actually, it’s incredibly dangerous and may result in his death, but he’s willing to take the risk anyway, which he knows is stupid of him. Everything worked out just fine the last time, didn’t it? Nobody died. And his friends were a lot of help in Lake-town when push came to shove. He knows that Fíli in particular did some wonderful fighting to protect Bard’s family, though the lad was appropriately bashful about it when Bilbo asked for more details.
But Bilbo cannot allow himself to stand by while one of his friends suffers, especially not if he can prevent it. He doesn’t remember the exact details of the confrontation, because he wasn’t paying much attention when it happened, but he does remember the basics of the situation. The Elves closed the gates, and the orcs attacked while the company was trapped beneath the bridge, an outcome which seems imminent at present. Kíli went to lift the gate and was hit in the leg by a poisoned arrow.
Bilbo would love to have more accurate information than his dim recollection on which to base his assessment of where the enemy will come from, but unfortunately, that isn’t possible. He will have to do his best to protect the lad.
There is distant shouting in Sindarin and the blowing of a horn. An Elven guard in full armor pulls a lever, and the gate slams shut, barring the company’s progress through the river. “No!” Thorin roars. And then an arrow hits the Elf, and orc speech can be heard, even by those so far under the bridge that they cannot see what is taking place above them.
“Watch out!” Bofur shouts. “There’s orcs!”
And their enemies fall upon them then, leaping at the Elves overhead and the company down below. There is much slashing and swinging of fists, much ducking and dodging and grunting. The last time, Bilbo was too overwhelmed by it all to act. But this time, he does not have that option. He has no choice but to act.
“Listen, Kíli,” Bilbo orders, catching the lad before he can try something stupid and dangerous. “I see the lever, too, and I’m going to go for it. I need you to stay in your barrel and cover me. Aim for those archers.”
“Are you going to turn invisible?” Kíli hisses. He couldn’t get out of his barrel if he wanted to, with Bilbo clinging to the side the way he is.
“I am,” Bilbo agrees, “Don’t move. I might kick you, and you won’t see it coming.”
And with that, Bilbo slips the ring onto his finger and makes for the lever. Climbing up onto the shore using his friends’ barrels as a foothold is simple enough. Only, reaching the lever itself looked far easier when an agile and practiced Dwarven warrior was doing it. For an underfed Hobbit, who, after all these years and all this adventuring, has still not done very much in the way of athletics, the passage is a bit more precarious. Still, Bilbo makes it to the bridge, probably with no small measure of help from whichever Valar have become so invested in his quest and its fate. He crawls along on his belly, trying his best to avoid the flying arrows and to dodge between the legs of the orcs.
Fíli and Kíli are doing what they can. Unfortunately, that is little help, considering that they have perhaps one proper weapon between them and are otherwise armed with pinecones and small river stones. They’ve both got strong arms, but Bilbo knows he can’t rely on them to cover him with impunity. He must behave as though there is a poisoned arrow always headed in his direction. Dwalin throws a spear, commandeered from one of the orcs, either in an attempt to arm Bilbo (who, mind you, is already armed) or to take out some of his potential assailants. Not that any of them pay much mind to the Hobbit sneaking between their legs. They seem a bit preoccupied with the fact that they’re being pummeled on all sides by the Elves.
Fíli throws a well-timed knife, felling the orc who has been guarding the lever, though he can’t possibly know how close Bilbo is to his goal. Last time, Bilbo distinctly remembers watching Kíli decapitate another orc immediately before getting shot. This time, Bilbo slashes at the final guard’s legs with Sting, sending him topping into the water. He can only hope that his timing is good enough and his friends are placed well enough to avoid being crushed or impaled on the falling orc’s weapon.
When Bilbo reaches the lever, he becomes aware of yet another feat which he should have foreseen. He wasn’t paying enough attention before, plainly. And he did not think this through. It was a struggle enough for Kíli to open the gate. So why does Bilbo think that a Hobbit with no upper body strength to speak of will be able to manage the same task? But then, Kíli was already injured when he pulled the lever, and Bilbo is well enough.
Tauriel appears, then, and Legolas. The two of them fight well, in tandem, clearly practiced at working together to achieve such ends. Bilbo cannot afford to stand around watching. He must act. He trusts his friends and the Elves to cover him as he wrestles with the lever.
Shouts down below alert Bilbo to the partial opening of the doors. But he knows there’s more to go. He’s got to put more force into it, force that he doesn’t have. Just as Bilbo is trying to figure out how to do that, he feels a sharp, sudden pain just at his hip. An arrow. An orc arrow. Probably the same poisoned arrow that would have been stuck in Kíli’s thigh, had he been the one to come up here.
Bilbo utters a string of words that would’ve induced any Hobbiton matron to box his ears, even at his advanced age, the sort of phrase he’d never have dreamed of uttering in Frodo’s impressionable presence.
“Bilbo!” Kíli calls, scrambling onto the bridge. He’s fast. He’s very fast. And he would have to be, to have executed this maneuver so seamlessly the last time. He plucks a weapon from a dead orc and makes his way to Bilbo, making quick work of those few orcs who are not engaged with Elves. “I can’t find you. Where are you?”
The Elven archers have taken out the orcs with bows, at least. Bilbo knows without having to look behind him that one Elven archer in particular will be paying close attention to this interaction, and, if the Green Lady is merciful, covering Bilbo and Kíli for the moment. Still, Bilbo does look. As expected, Tauriel does not take her gaze from Kíli.
But the lad is distracted, frantic. Searching for Bilbo, who must get the gate open. The pain is excruciating. Bilbo cannot believe that Kíli was even able to hold a conversation in Lake-town, let alone to walk around. “Here,” he mutters. He needs Kíli to get out of the way before he gets himself shot and negates whatever sacrifice Bilbo just made. Then, remembering the obvious solution, Bilbo slips the ring off his finger and into his pocket. He throws himself to the ground, clinging to the lever with full force and using the momentum of his fall to push the gates the rest of the way open.
If Tauriel is surprised by the sudden appearance of a Hobbit, she does not show it, but an arrow flies over Bilbo’s head, and it’s clear that she is still paying attention. Kíli breathes a few mysterious words in Khuzdul, then scoops Bilbo up. “Are you alright?” Kíli asks.
“Poisoned,” Bilbo murmurs.
“Shot, you mean,” Kíli corrects him.
Before Bilbo can argue, the lad tosses him in the general direction of their friends’ barrels (ill-advised plan, that) and follows after.
Bilbo comes down around Nori’s shoulders, just barely missing being thrown into the river and probably drowning or hitting his head on a rock. He couldn’t swim before he got hit with an orc arrow. Yavanna knows how he’d fare in the water afterwards. Perhaps Bilbo should’ve mentioned that to Kíli, who, he realizes, has now saved his life on two separate occasions. And Bilbo still has not thanked him!
“Sorry,” Bilbo manages to say to Nori, once they are over the second of what will probably be many waterfalls. He grits his teeth through the pain. He does not have the option of suffering. It is a luxuryhe cannot afford. Their fight with the orcs, after all, is just beginning.
“Oh, no problem,” Nori grits out. “Didn’t hurt at all.”
“Yes, well, Óin can see to your bruises when we’re not in the middle of a battle,” Bilbo quips.
Bilbo has endured worse pain, he reminds himself. He watched Thorin Oakenshield die. He saw little Frodo come back from Mordor, irrevocably changed, unable to enjoy any of the simple pleasures which once defined his life. If Bilbo could handle those horrors, surely a poisoned puncture wound is only a small matter.
“Why didn’t you send down an extra barrel for yourself?” Nori asks. He has claimed an orc’s hammer and is currently making very liberal use of it. Bilbo decides that this is not an ideal position for him to occupy.
“Because I didn’t think of that.” And he had eighty years to do it, too. Honestly, Nori is the real expert Burglar here.
“Should’ve run your plan by me instead of Thorin.”
“You think I ran this by Thorin?” Bilbo manages to impale an orc on Sting, and Nori reaches his arm into the water to paddle a little, steering the barrel away from the corpse. “He never would’ve agreed if he’d known what my plan was.” He’s not going to be happy that Bilbo is injured. Still, better him than Kíli.
“I’m surprised he let you out of his sight long enough to find a way out.” Nori’s tone is knowing. Of course it is. On the last adventure, at least, people were polite enough to keep their thoughts about Bilbo and Thorin to themselves. But then, on the last adventure, Thorin was never so very possessive as he is these days. Bilbo supposes that he might say something, too, if he were watching his fearless leader fret over a Hobbit all the time.
“Oh, so am I,” Bilbo agrees.
And then the battle is in full swing, and there isn’t much time for conversation. Luckily for the company, the orcs prove once again to be a distraction for the Woodland Folk. They seem to forget their original objective of reclaiming their prisoners, and instead direct their attention to slaughtering the orcs. And if Bilbo catches Tauriel’s worried stare more than once during the skirmish, well, that’s hardly much of a surprise, is it?
The company washes up, once again, on the shores near Lake-town, and it seems that any surviving orcs have retreated. Bilbo works automatically, helping to pull his compatriots out of their barrels. He’s not even shocked when Thorin corners him, both of them soaking wet and shivering.
“Burglar.” So it’s back to just Burglar, then. Thorin is apparently not going to acknowledge the fact that they just spent three weeks perpetually in each other’s arms, which is fine by Bilbo. He doesn’t particularly want to acknowledge that, either.
Bilbo’s annoyance is not justified. Obviously, Thorin can’t go about telling the whole company that the two of them have been sharing the stone slab that the Elves were cruel enough to call a bed. As if everybody and his brother doesn’t know that already! And why would Thorin feel the need to bring it up? They’re away from it now. Perhaps he wouldn’t have done it for just anybody, but it no longer matters very much that he shared his bed with Bilbo.
Besides, Bilbo should enjoy these next few moments, while Thorin is entirely unaware of his injury. He knows that the king will become insufferable the moment he figures out that Bilbo has been shot. Though some small part of the Hobbit does want to see the sort of passionate reaction that he knows Thorin is capable of. Can he really blame Thorin for being so protective of him, when Bilbo himself acts just the same way? They really do need to have a conversation about this, and soon.
Or is that not the best idea? Will it change how Thorin reacts in Erebor, if Bilbo is upfront about his feelings? Will he be weakened somehow? Will he pay less attention to the dragon? But what if knowing all the ways in which he is loved is a strengthening agent for Thorin? Bilbo has no clue how to proceed.
He elects to meet Thorin where he is. “Your Majesty.” Bilbo feigns a little bow, wincing as the motion jostles his injury. Thankfully, his face is turned downward, preventing Thorin from getting a good look at his pained expression. No doubt that would lead to all sorts of pointless nonsense. After all, there is perhaps nothing for Bilbo’s oncoming illness now but the healing magic of an Elf, and there don’t appear to be many of those on hand.
“I thought I told you never to put yourself in danger for my sake again.” Thorin actually sounds serious. As though he thought Bilbo would simply roll over and follow the instructions he gave on the Carrock!
Bilbo shakes his head. “And I told you that I’d do any number of dangerous things in the name of protecting the company.”
Even though he didn’t say that. No, he’d been very clear when he’d said that he’d stick his neck out for Thorin in particular. But he would risk himself for any of them. Case in point, it is a struggle to hold himself upright at present. And still, Bilbo would do it again.
“You should not have been the one to pull that lever. You are the weakest among us and not trained for fighting. Fíli or Kíli—“
“Would have been shot with an orc arrow,” Bilbo nips this line of conversation in the bud.
It is only then that Thorin notices the wound on Bilbo’s hip. Honestly, Bilbo doesn’t know what he was expecting. Perhaps he thought that Thorin might scold him further, or thank him for protecting the lads from such a painful fate. Certainly, he would not have put any money on the idea of Thorin falling to his knees upon the rocks before him. “You are wounded,” Thorin observes, before lapsing into incomprehensible Khuzdul.
“Only a little.” Bilbo does not wish to worry the king, after all, and besides, they have places to be. They’ve got to get to Lake-town, away from the orcs and Elves, before any more of them get shot. They’ve got to follow the path of the last adventure exactly. Bilbo can’t very well go around moping about his injury. If Kíli could do this, so can Bilbo. “It’s really just a scratch.”
Thorin shoots him a sharp look. “I am not a fool, Master Baggins.”
Well, at least that brought him back to himself. “Alright, fine, a bit more than a scratch,” Bilbo concedes, “But we can hardly do anything about it now. The arrow’s out, and that tumble through the river has cleaned it better than anything else could. The wound is very shallow. I’ll be fine.” He is not being entirely truthful.
But at the same time, he knows that Óin will not be able to do anything about the poison. He couldn’t help Kíli the last time, could he? Bilbo remembers how sick the lad was when they were boarding the boats to cross the Long Lake. What he needs is Elven medicine, and until he can get it, there’s no point worrying the rest of the company. Besides, Bilbo is a Hobbit. His people are hardy and can withstand the sorts of injuries that would fell any of the big folk. Maybe he’ll be spared the worst effects of the poison, at least long enough to get to Erebor. Bilbo can destroy the ring and riddle with the dragon, at least, before he meets his end.
“You should not have risked yourself,” Thorin scolds him.
“And whom should I have risked?”
“Nobody.” Ah, such a wise and logical monarch that Bilbo has chosen to follow!
“Nobody,” Bilbo echoes. “Forgive me, My King, but if nobody had pulled that lever, then we would probably all have been shot or stabbed or who knows what else, and then no doubt taken back into the custody of the Elves! Do you think Thranduil would’ve let us escape a second time?”
“Let me see to you,” Thorin resolves. And oh, isn’t this just the same argument all over again? But this time, Bilbo will admit that he has no ground to stand on. “And once we are safe, Óin should have a look.”
After all, Thorin is not injured, and he has a point about Bilbo’s need of aid. Unfortunately, Bilbo knows that this is not an option right now. “There’s no time,” he protests, “We’ve got to get to Lake-town before the orcs catch up with us. Or worse, the Elves.”
The joke falls flat. “You will go nowhere with an open wound on your leg.” Thorin was nowhere near this obstinate when Kíli was the injured party.
Then again, that may have had something to do with the fact that Fíli insisted upon seeing to his brother’s leg, and Thorin had no one to argue with. He was concerned about making a quick escape then, as he is now. And it does make sense that he would worry less about a trained warrior than he does about a gentlehobbit who, apparently, bears an awfully close resemblance to some sort of fruit seller. In all his years, Bilbo still has not entirely forgiven that grocer comment.
“Don’t be ridiculous! We’re in the middle of the wilderness. I’m perfectly alright with providing a show for our company, but we’re bound to start attracting nasty visitors sooner or later if you keep this up.”
“If I keep this up?” Thorin echoes, his resolve faltering. He drops his hand, which is probably a good thing, because it looked suspiciously as though he was planning to grab the back of Bilbo’s thigh.
“You heard me. We can have this conversation later, my—“ Not my love. Do not call him that in the middle of an argument, Bilbo Baggins, you fool! Perhaps the poison from the arrow is getting to his head already. Then again, if he’s got to save the term of endearment for a time when he and Thorin are not bickering, in all likelihood, Bilbo will never get the chance to say it at all. “Anyway, we’ll discuss it once we’re safe.”
“Mahal save me from stubborn Hobbits,” Thorin grumbles under his breath. Bilbo gets the feeling that this is not the first time the king has uttered those very words. “You cannot walk around with an open wound. It will only take two minutes to bind.”
“Well, let’s see if Óin has two minutes.” The last thing Bilbo needs is for Thorin to start touching his legs with those strong hands of his, tending to his battle wounds with such firm care. And Thorin should be pleased that Bilbo is willing to endure a pointless visit with a healer who bears no supplies whatsoever. The Elves took all their baggage, after all, and Óin’s medicines and bandages with them.
They are interrupted by the clearing of a throat. “Thorin,” Balin hisses, “We are under attack.”
For a moment, Bilbo thinks that the orcs have returned. That would be a pretty pickle, indeed: to be cornered here on this little strip of land, where they had not been cornered before. It would be an indication of a serious change to the plot of their adventure, which Bilbo would not know how to handle in itself or as a sign of things to come. After all, their last serious confrontation with the orcs was very different from the one that Bilbo remembers, and almost exclusively because of his actions. It’s perfectly possible that something could have changed.
But, no. It’s only Bard. “Oh,” Bilbo says absently, “Hello, Bard.”
Not his smartest move by a long shot, but Bilbo is flustered by his recent fear, and he still has orc poison in his veins, and he has not yet cooled down from his argument with Thorin. But really, that’s his own fault. Bilbo should realize that things aren’t going to get much easier for him any time soon if he can’t handle being antagonized a little by an obstinate king.
“How do you know my name?” The bowman demands. It is a very fair question, and one Bilbo cannot answer.
Thorin shoots Bilbo a shrewd look, but says nothing. Clearly he would also like to know how Bilbo knows the Bowman’s name. Drat it all! Apparently, being injured is making Bilbo careless. Maybe Thorin has a point, and Óin should see to him.
But then, Bilbo can’t very well say that he’s done all of this before, can he? He has to think on his feet. Thankfully, Hobbit feet are very sturdy indeed, and Bilbo is a good talker in a pinch. “Is Bard your name?” He puts on his best confused expression. He’s had a lot of practice with confusion, after carrying out most of his adventure two times over. “In my homeland, it is a common mode of address. A polite way to greet a stranger, nothing more.”
“And where is this homeland of yours?” Bilbo can’t tell if Bard is buying what he’s selling. The Man is truly unreadable.
“Do not tell him,” Thorin urges quietly.
Bilbo ignores this advice. As a general rule, one should never take direction from Thorin while dealing with people. “The Shire, in the far West. A very lovely place, if I do say so myself.”
“And what brings you to Lake-town, then, Halfling, with such an odd company?”
It never occurred to Bilbo before that Bard was familiar with Hobbits. There was simply too much going on, and he was distracted with worry for the company and the quest. If he remembers correctly, he was also concerned about poor Gandalf. He had believed (perhaps erroneously) that the Wizard was in some serious danger and might be killed without his friends even knowing where to look for him.
“We are simple merchants from the Blue Mountains, journeying to see our kin in the Iron Hills,” Balin cuts in before Bilbo can try to come up with another clever answer, which shows Bilbo what his friend thinks of the completely falsified cultural heritage he’s just manufactured for the Shire.
“And the Halfling?” Bard seems more suspicious this time than he did before. Probably because Bilbo greeted him by name. He watches with narrowed eyes as Thorin steps in front of Bilbo, as though he seriously believes that Bard poses some threat. This will not make things easier when battle comes to the slopes of Erebor, but Bilbo supposes he’ll have to cross that bridge when he gets to it. If he gets to it. “Ah, I see. You are their servant, then.” It’s refreshing that he addresses this false accusation to Bilbo directly.
Before the Hobbit can protest, which he means to do quite vehemently, Thorin cuts him off. “Yes.”
Bilbo is sure that his eyes give him away completely. He’s about to start sputtering, but Dori puts a hand on his shoulder. “You’d best go along with it, Master Baggins. Thorin seems to have a plan.”
He’s probably wrong, of course, and if he’s right, Bilbo fears a little for their lives, but he understands the sentiment. He can’t very well contradict Thorin and expose him as a liar, can he? But he is not pleased by this development. He will have words with Thorin later. But perhaps this is a good thing. The more irritated Bilbo becomes, the less his hip pains him, or, at least, the less aware he becomes of the pain. Perhaps he should stick with Thorin, after all.
“Well,” Kíli whispers to his brother, in a voice that is thankfully too quiet for the bowman to hear, “You may become King sooner than expected when Bilbo murders our uncle.”
Fíli snorts. “My first act would be to grant him pardon.”
“We need food, supplies, weapons,” Thorin ignores his nephews entirely. “Can you help us?”
“I know where these barrels came from,” Bard muses.
“What of it?” Thorin is doing an excellent job of hiding whatever emotional turmoil lurks beneath the surface.
“I don’t know what business you had with the Elves, but I don’t think it ended well. No one enters Lake-town but by leave of the Master. All his wealth comes from trade with the Woodland Realm. He would see you in irons before risking the wrath of King Thranduil.” All of this, of course, is entirely expected, at least as far as Bilbo is concerned.
Thankfully, Balin takes over from here. There is some more discussion, but Bilbo pays it little mind, affronted as he is by Thorin’s recent words. Also, his pain, while bearable for the time being, is no small matter. Balin offers a few smooth words and more money. The bowman seems persuaded by this, if only because he has three children to feed, and they are allowed onto the boat. Bilbo makes a big show of sitting as far away from Thorin as he can get.
“Trouble in paradise, eh?” Bofur asks, which doesn’t help Bilbo’s dark mood in the slightest. Couldn’t he join the others in fussing about money or staring out at the Lonely Mountain on the horizon? No, he can’t. And he’s not going to fret about Bilbo’s injury, either. No doubt, Bofur can tell that Bilbo is in pain, and he’s trying to distract him from it with his impertinent question.
“Not a word from you,” the Hobbit warns. The last thing that he wants is to tip Bard off to the fact that Thorin is, apparently, a liar. But he will admit that this conversation, too, is a welcome distraction from the nagging pain.
“Oh, no, of course not.” But obviously, Bofur can tell what’s going on. He might not know the specific, time-travel related details, but he seems well aware of the growing tension between Bilbo and Thorin. It would be hard not to be aware of it, Bilbo supposes, but there’s nothing to be done about it now. They’ll have to sort out this whole servant business, anyway, before they touch on any of that other stuff. “You spent the whole three weeks in his cell, did you?”
“Not a word,” Bilbo protests with a fond eye-roll. Thankfully, Bard is too distracted dealing with the boat and making a plan for how to hide them all to eavesdrop on this very telling conversation.
“It’s quite the high honor, you know, being a servant to the king.”
Bilbo smacks Bofur in the arm, eliciting laughter. “I said not a word!”
Bofur holds his hands up in surrender, though Bilbo didn’t hit him very hard. The whole roughhousing business really doesn’t sit to too well with Bilbo, even after all these years. It is simply not the done thing among Hobbits. “And we’ll speak no more of it.” This seems too easy. “Until we get to Erebor.”
Bilbo sighs. “I’m not talking about it then, either. This is between me and Thorin.” And what an admission that is! But it is the most obvious thing in the world, truly. And Bilbo has spent weeks now planning to speak to Thorin about their feelings in Lake-town. Now he can throw this other business into the mix.
Bofur starts to say something else, but one glance from the king shuts him right up. So Thorin was eavesdropping again? Good. Bilbo hopes he was. He should know what to expect the moment they’re alone.
Until then, though, Bilbo elects to be as contrary as possible. Bard packs them into the barrels again, much to everyone’s dismay. Even Bilbo had forgotten about that, after the whole servant fiasco, and, of course, the feeling of a thousand rusty knives ripping into his hip. The bowman steps away to purchase the fish he’s about to have dumped on them. Perhaps the reason why Bilbo forgot that detail was because the moment was somewhat traumatic for him the first time around, though it is nothing compared to the quarter-hour that they’ll have to spend navigating the interior of a privy. That can’t be a wise move for somebody with an open wound. But then, Bilbo has already done what he can to dress his injury.
Regardless, once again, Bilbo is the only one in any position to see what’s going on as Bard procures the fish. “What do you see?” Thorin asks from a neighboring barrel.
“I see nothing, My King,” Bilbo replies in his best imitation of a servile tone.
Someone in another nearby barrel snorts. Bombur, it sounds like. “You are being immature,” Thorin growls. Perhaps Bilbo is imagining the sheer intensity of this edict. After all, he and Thorin tease one another often. Their dynamic involves a great deal of back-and-forth. Thorin can’t be surprised that Bilbo would play the situation this way, arrow wound or no arrow wound.
“I hope that you would forgive your faithful servant such impertinence, My King,” Bilbo says, smiling to himself.
“Should I have introduced you as my burglar instead?” He is definitely not imagining the slight emphasis on the my in that question. Bilbo’s heart gives a little spike. Not helping, he tells himself resolutely. He should not find this attractive. And, yet, if he did not, then he and Thorin would likely not be in their present situation. “And given us all away?”
“How you choose to introduce your humble servant is entirely at your discretion, My King.” Bilbo manages to keep from laughing when the King Under the Mountain has a barrel full of stinking fish dumped onto his head. It does help that Bilbo is in precisely the same position. At least the fish isn’t salted. That would’ve worsened the pain in his hip, surely, if such a thing is even possible.
After that, of course, there isn’t much time for conversation. Everyone, Bard included, falls silent as they approach Lake-town. It is much less grand than Bilbo remembers, and he is stricken with a series of other relevant recollections instead. Many of the townspeople that he passes in the market are going to die when Smaug comes in and rains down fire upon them.
Bilbo may be quite annoyed with Thorin, and he might be in quite a bit of pain, but that’s no excuse to ignore the suffering of the Men of the Lake. There must be something to be done, some extra step that he can take to lessen the damage. Bilbo will not be able to prevent the dragon from escaping altogether. He can refrain from calling himself Barrel Rider, but Smaug is not so stupid as Thorin seems to believe. Probably, the wyrm will figure out for himself that Bilbo has come to the mountain through Lake-town. After all, there are only so many ways to go. And even if Bilbo did not know the Men of the Lake personally, surely Smaug would seek to cause as much harm as possible.
Also, the fact stands that Bard is the only person in Middle Earth who has a decent shot at killing the dragon. He has a black arrow, and a bow, and good aim. Perhaps if Bilbo could warn him in advance and tell him about the imperfection in the dragon’s armor, Bard could simply wait at the top of the tower and shoot the dragon before any serious harm is done. That’s a long shot, of course, but what choice does Bilbo have?
Thankfully, he’s got time to think it through as the company undergoes the long process of getting into Lake-town. First, they sit through the whole rigamarole with the customs officials and guards, who seem intent on dumping the ‘unauthorized fish’ back into the lake until Bard talks them out of it. Then, they are led through the town. Bard orders them to keep their heads down and keep moving, but considering they are surrounded by Big Folk, it’s difficult to avoid being conspicuous. A chase ensues, of course, and Bilbo staggers along as best he can, aggravating his wound as he does so. There’s a bit of fighting, just the same as last time, and then Bard somehow manages to talk them out of another jam. Those diplomatic skills will serve him very well in future.
Sneaking through the privy, of course, is less than ideal. Many of the company grumble about this particular facet of Bard’s plan for concealing them, and Dwalin even threatens young Bain as he emerges, but the fact stands that all of them are living and in one piece. Bilbo never liked Lake-town, and his second experience with it is not proving any more pleasant than the first.
Bilbo can only hope that his makeshift bandage prevents him from acquiring some sort of infection from the privy. Not that it matters much, anyway. Either he will find an Elven healer, his Hobbit strength will save him, or an infection will be the least of his troubles.
“Da, why are there Dwarves climbing out of our toilet?” Sigrid, Bard’s eldest daughter, inquires.
“Will they bring us luck?” His youngest asks.
“Absolutely not,” Bilbo disabuses young Tilda of that particular notion straight away. There’s no reason for her to go around thinking that proximity to this particular company will bring anything but trouble.
“The opposite, in fact,” Fíli offers the little girl a conspiratorial wink, betraying no sign of the present danger or any animosity he might bear toward her father. “We bring mischief aplenty.”
“Hobbits are lucky, though,” Kíli declares, “I think Master Baggins cancels the rest of us out.”
“No, no I do not,” Bilbo protests.
Bard distributes blankets and what clothing he can offer, which, admittedly, is not very much. The company is as gracious about it as anybody could expect them to be. Just as he did on the first adventure, Bilbo finds Thorin by the window, marveling at the Dwarfish windlance at the top of the city’s watchtower. The last time, Bilbo initiated a conversation. This time, all he does is put his hand on the king’s back. There’s no point in forcing Thorin and Balin to drudge up their horrible memories of the day the dragon came.
Thorin closes his eyes, leaning his forehead against the cool, smudged glass of the window. He does not say anything, and Bilbo returns his silence. It is as though the great warrior king is gathering strength and courage from the gentle touch of a wounded Hobbit. Then, he steels himself, visibly. Bilbo watches as his king’s shoulders rise and stiffen, as Thorin replaces the mask that he must wear as the leader of his people. “You took our money,” he reminds Bard, skipping the conversation about Girion’s arrow entirely, “Where are the weapons?”
The weapons are out in the lake, apparently, hidden beneath a boat in a fishing net. Bilbo watches as Bard collects them, listens patiently as the bowman describes each implement, and rolls his eyes as the company grumbles about the sorry state of things. As far as Bilbo is concerned, everything Bard has offered them looks perfectly deadly.
“We paid you for weapons,” Glóin complains. “Iron forged swords and axes!”
“It’s a joke,” Bofur protests. They all begin to throw their weapons back down on the table.
“Please,” Bilbo shakes his head. “I’m sorry, but you’re all being very rude! We are guests in Bard’s home, in case any of you had forgotten.” He cuts his eyes to Glóin in particular.
“That’s true,” Dori concedes. He, at least, has the decency to look abashed, though his grumbling was barely audible to begin with. The lack of a dent in the table also demonstrates that he was exceptionally gentle when he set down his weapon. With his prodigious strength, Dori could easily destroy any piece of Mannish furniture with such a hammer.
“And,” Bilbo continues, “What’s more, nobody ever promised us fancy-forged weapons. We paid for a means of defending ourselves, in a town where the people are willing to help a band of strange travelers escape the guards of their own Town Master. Clearly, all is not well here, and Bard has given us what he can. Not even Orcrist would be any use against the dragon, by the way, so it doesn’t matter what sort of weapons we bring with us.”
Balin opens his mouth, presumably in an attempt to join Bilbo in making Thorin see reason. Though, Bilbo already knows that’s a doomed venture. He can practically see the inner workings of the king’s mind, and knows in that moment that nothing will deter His Majesty from rushing forward with a half-baked plan. But before Balin can try, someone else beats him to it.
“This handles well,” Fíli informs Bard, brandishing his new hammer. “Even if you did steal it from a smithy.” This seems to be a diplomatic act, judging by the way the rest of the company regards the implements the bowman has distributed.
“Easy for you to say,” Glóin complains, “You still have knives.”
“Only four,” Fíli chirps.
“How many did you have to begin with?” Tilda seems particularly interested in this information.
“Hold on a moment, I’ll have to do the math,” Fíli tells her. He’s probably exaggerating, but the look in his eyes shows that there’s a little bit of addition and subtraction involved to get to the answer. “Thirty three.”
“Did you count the three that I stole at Beorn’s?” Kíli asks with a grin. So they weren’t making up the knife-stealing story, after all.
“Of course I did,” Fíli reports. “Since I got them back within the hour. I forgot you ever took them.”
“Where do you put them all?” Tilda ask.
“That should be all for now,” Bard cuts in. Bilbo can’t really blame him. He wouldn’t have wanted Frodo learning about where to conceal dozens of knives on one’s person, either. “My children have no need to know such things.”
“Why should we not be armed?” Sigrid, places her hands on her hips. “There is much we could do to help you, Da, if only—“
“There is nothing for you to help me with,” Bard assures her smoothly. “And if there were, I think you will find that there is not a father in Lake-town who would allow any of his children to put themselves in so much danger.”
Unfortunately, young Bain keeps a keen eye on Fíli, probably tracking any odd lumps in the prince’s clothing that could indicate hidden weapons. It’s clear that even the children understand that there is something seriously wrong in Lake-town. The Town Master is greedy, and in his avarice, he has allowed his people to starve. It will not be long before civil unrest breaks out, dragon or no dragon.
“You might share a few of those daggers, lad,” Óin suggests.
“You have a perfectly good fishing rod!” Fíli protests, though his laughter gives him away. He wasn’t this jovial in Lake-town the first time around, but then, he wouldn’t be, not when his brother was wounded.
The implement in Óin’s hands has been sharpened like a spear, yes, and barbs have been added in place of the loops to hold the line, but it really is still just a fishing rod. “We’ve all made due with less,” Balin points out. “Why not leave now?”
“You’re not going anywhere,” Bard declares. He proceeds to tell them all about the spies watching the house and urges them to wait until nightfall to take their leave.
This suits Bilbo just fine. He was already planning on passing some time here in Lake-town, after all, and he and Thorin still have that conversation to have. So he lets the company grumble and joins his ornery king by the window.
“I am sorry,” Thorin says quietly.
“Oh?” Bilbo feigns innocence. “What are you sorry for?”
“Do you not know already?”
Bilbo supposes that this is more than he ever would’ve gotten the first time they were in Lake-town. “You could’ve just told him I was your friend. You know, as that’d be the truth?”
Thorin sighs. “That would have raised questions.”
“But it doesn’t raise any questions at all that you might travel with an antagonistic Halfling servant?” Bilbo rolls his eyes. He does realize being that he’s being a bit unfair. But better to be a little snappish than to focus on his impending peril. If he isn’t healed in time, will he be allowed to continue to the Lonely Mountain with the rest of the company, or be left behind, as Kíli was before? And if that’s the case, who will stay with Bilbo?
Thorin cannot. He may wish with all his heart to remain by Bilbo’s side, though perhaps it is a little vain of Bilbo to tell himself as much, but that will never be possible. Thorin must be the one to reclaim Erebor. Óin would linger, for certain, but who else? Bilbo is closer now with all the company than ever he was on the first adventure, but how could any of them be asked to stay in Lake-town to tend to a dying Hobbit rather than reclaim their home?
“I was not thinking. He was going to shoot you.”
“He wasn’t going to shoot any of us.”
“You cannot be sure of that,” Thorin protests. Bilbo can be sure of it, actually, but of course, Thorin doesn’t know that. “He suspected you already. How did you learn his name?”
Bilbo bites his lip. This is not a conversation he’s prepared to have at this juncture. Before long, Thorin will start making other connections: Bilbo’s odd behavior in Mirkwood, his assertions that they’d done all this before. His lack of fear at the beginning. His intimate understanding of every member of the company and their interpersonal relationships. His utter confusion about who is king of what kingdom or master of what city and his unfortunate propensity to name the son or grandson of the current ruler. He doubts that Thorin will arrive at the very specific truth, but he may get somewhere in its general vicinity, which will bring up subjects that Bilbo isn’t prepared to broach.
“I’m an Expert Burglar, aren’t I? I know things,” Bilbo says weakly.
“Too much, some might say.”
“Or too little, as you’ve been saying this whole time,” Bilbo points out, “Anyway, didn’t you want to look at my wound?”
“Not here.” There is a certain heaviness to these words, as though Bilbo is expected to take some secondary meaning from them. Perhaps Thorin does not wish for Bilbo to be so vulnerable in front of Bard. Or perhaps he has actually been swayed by Bilbo’s entirely false assertions that the arrow wound does not hurt one bit and the binding Bilbo applied on the boat is all the first aid that he is going to need.
This will pose a problem shortly, Bilbo knows, but there are so many other things to accomplish! And really, if he were dying, wouldn’t he know it? Hobbits are hardy folk. Perhaps all Bilbo needs to do is get his hands on some kingsfoil, bring it to Óin, and explain the situation. Then he’ll be right as rain. No need to worry Thorin.
“Ah, I see. It would not be appropriate to behave so familiarly with your servant. Would you like me to care for your armor now, my King? We’d best keep up appearances.” Bilbo must tease Thorin now. He must lift the king’s spirits by flirting with him. Gone, now, are his plans for giving voice to his true feelings. That would be too heavy. Too much.
“I no longer have any armor,” Thorin complains, “It was stolen from me by Elves, and my Burglar failed to reclaim it.”
“If only you’d had a faithful servant at that time, instead of a Burglar, my liege. I’d have rushed in and risked my life to have the honor of retrieving your gauntlets for you.”
Thorin snorts. “I do not mind this,” he waves his hand to encapsulate Bilbo’s present behavior, “As much as you seem to think I do.”
Bilbo tries to keep himself from blushing or taking any nervous steps away from Thorin. After all, that would clearly be the intended reaction. “Oh.” He manages to reply. “Thank you for letting me know. I’ll knock it off right away, then. Best not to give you the satisfaction.”
Thorin sobers then, all of a sudden. “How’s your leg?” He asks softly. Bilbo should have known he couldn’t keep Thorin away from this subject for long.
“Fine, thank you,” Bilbo tells him.
It’s not technically a lie. Or at least, it won’t be a lie, once everything is set right. Tauriel and Legolas will be along shortly, will they not? Tauriel will see to Bilbo’s injury and cure him of the poison. And then he will truly be fine.
Well, that’s assuming that they show up in the first place. There is always the possibility that Tauriel came to help Kíli because she cared for him personally, and that she might not extend the same courtesy to an unfamiliar Hobbit, especially not at such great cost to herself. There’s also the chance that they were only tracking the orc pack and happened to stumble into Lake-town just in time, and that Bilbo’s changed actions may have altered the course of events in this sphere as well. But he cannot afford to think about that now.
The next natural step, of course, is a journey to the city’s armory for better weapons than what Bard can provide. Bilbo finds this quite silly, in the scheme of things. He knows he won’t make any headway trying to get through to Thorin (he can barely get the king to concede that blind self-sacrifice is not always the best course of action, and it surely doesn’t help that Bilbo himself has begun to rely increasingly upon the same method), but he’s grateful for Bofur’s presence behind him as they file into the dark building.
“I don’t think a professionally-forged spear will be any more use against a dragon than that sharpened fishing rod,” Bilbo grumbles to his friend. “Why are we risking our lives?”
“I don’t think Thorin likes the idea of you going in to face the beast unarmed,” Bofur, of course, takes the opportunity to tease Bilbo yet again. It’s very annoying.
“I have a sword,” Bilbo points out, “And, anyway, he can’t expect me to just walk up and stab the dragon on my own. Even if I could get close enough to do it, it wouldn’t do much damage. The only effective weapon against a dragon is a black arrow. You all know as much, don’t you?”
“Oh, sure, but our people like to be armed,” Bofur reasons, “And, anyway, it’s a laugh, isn’t it, sneaking around?”
“You, my friend, find joy in the most unworthy places,” Bilbo protests, but he can’t help being fond.
“What are we talking about?” Kíli asks, turning around to face them.
“How utterly stupid this entire enterprise is becoming.” Bilbo is more than happy to fill the lad in, and very pleased to see him scurrying around Lake-town. Thus far, his greatest achievement has been sparing Kíli the pain of being shot with an orc arrow. Of course, it will change his relationship with Tauriel, but Bilbo supposes that’s a small price to pay if the lad does not spend the next few days on death’s doorstep. And who knows? Perhaps having the entire company together at the mountain will change things for the better. It has beenseveral hours, and Bilbo still does not feel as though he’s going to die.
Last time, of course, Kíli’s injury caused him to falter and sent his armful of weapons tumbling down the stairs. But this time, they are spared that particular calamity. The lad carries his burden perfectly well, earning him more than a few pats and slaps on the back when he reaches the bottom of the stairs. Fíli, accustomed to carrying far too many weapons, manages even more than his brother did.
“Do you seriously expect your nephews to march to the Lonely Mountain weighed down with all that nonsense?” Bilbo hisses in Thorin’s general direction.
“We will distribute the weapons once we reach the other shore,” Thorin shares. Bilbo cannot see the king’s eyes rolling, but he can imagine the sight well enough.
“But why do we need so much? This, on top of what Bard gave us? Erebor has an entire armory.”
“We might meet something on the way to Erebor. Have you forgotten about the orc pack?”
Bilbo is about to point out that, no matter how many weapons they might carry, there are still only fourteen of them to use those weapons, when he is accosted by a sudden stabbing pain. Ah. That’d be the poison, then. This time, it is not the noise of swords and spears clattering down the stairs that alerts the Master’s guards to their presence, but the sound of a Hobbit taking the same tumble, cursing all the way. Thorin’s shocked roar and rushing footsteps probably don’t help matters very much.
Ori is the first to recover from the stupor that has fallen over the company. “Bilbo!” He exclaims, “Are you okay?”
“Fine,” the Hobbit murmurs from the ground. He won’t be running anywhere any time soon, and his leg feels poised to fall off, but at least he is still living.
Of course, they’re all caught, with swords to their throats and all the other trappings. Bilbo is scooped up off the ground and marched forward, and he makes a fair job of it, too, all things considered. The pain increases steadily with every step he takes, but Bilbo does not fall again, and he does not make a scene. All will be well, he assures himself.
“What is the meaning of this?” The Town Master demands when the company is brought before him. Lake-town is very cold at night, apparently. Far colder than Bilbo remembers from the first time around.
“We caught ‘em stealing weapons, sire,” his sniveling servant replies. Bilbo truly does not understand how the ruling class can stomach being surrounded by such people. He resolves to make certain that Thorin’s court in Erebor includes plenty of advisors that will check the king’s whims without any hope to take advantage of his power. They may be difficult to find, but Bilbo would do anything to avoid being trapped in a larger-scale Lake-town for the remainder of his days. He shakes himself. Bilbo does not have the time right now to wallow in fantasies of his future as the consort of Erebor.
The Town Master and his servant then make a few unkind accusations about the company, and Dwalin, naturally, takes issue with this and introduces the town to Thorin. Bilbo has to fight against rolling his eyes. He’s heard it all before, naturally. He can’t bring himself to pay attention to Thorin’s speech, either, well-spoken as the king may be. The first time, Bilbo was enraptured, but then, the first time, Bilbo had no reason to disbelieve Thorin’s words. Now, he knows better, and it eats away at him.
If he vouches for Thorin when called upon, Bilbo will be cosigning a promise that he knows will not be kept. Thorin may genuinely believe that he’ll give gold to the people of Esgaroth. In fact, Bilbo knows that Thorin believes this. He does not know what the treasure in the mountain will do to his mind. He underestimates the power of the Arkenstone. But Bilbo understands all of these things with perfect clarity. How can he tell the people that Thorin will keep his word when the opposite is true?
“Death!” Bard roars, so loudly that even Bilbo is distracted from his thoughts. “That is what you will bring upon us! Dragonfire and ruin. If you waken that beast, it will destroy us all.”
He’s right, of course. Bilbo looks around at the faces of the people of the Lake. Some of them are very young, and some of them are very old. Some of them look hopeful, while others seem to have their doubts. A beautiful young woman with deep skin, twinkling eyes, and a thoughtful expression that reminds Bilbo very much of his cousin Primula is looking at Nori, of all people, with hopeless admiration. The typical business, Bilbo supposes. If a group of handsome strangers had sauntered into the Shire when he was barely grown, he, too, probably would have developed a little crush on one of them on sight. But for all he knows, this young woman will be dead in a few days time, burned beyond recognition in the wrath of the dragon. And it will be all Bilbo’s fault.
“You can listen to this naysayer, but I promise you this.” Thorin really is an amazing speaker. Bilbo could listen to him talk all night. “If we succeed, all will share in the wealth of the mountain. You will have enough gold to rebuild Esgaroth ten times over.” If only that were true.
“Why should we take you at your word, eh?” The Master’s servant demands. “We know nothing about you. Who here can vouch for your character?”
This is the moment that Bilbo has been dreading. For a split second, he considers saying nothing. What is the worst that can happen if he does? The company will be turned out of Lake-town, and they will march, weaponless, and without provisions, to Erebor.
If they don’t starve to death on the way, they will wake the dragon just as they did the last time, and he will come here, and he will kill these people regardless of the welcome that they gave to Thorin’s company. And if they do starve to death on the way, the ring will just be laying there, in Bilbo’s pocket. Orcs will find their corpses, certainly. They are actively being hunted. Or the Wood Elves will come looking for their lost prisoners and discover a dead Hobbit bearing a Ring of Power. Not that Bilbo will live long enough to starve to death with the rest of the company. Regardless, somebody new will come into possession of the ring, and who knows what horrible things it could make them do?
Bilbo cannot allow that to happen. He’ll do his best to warn Bard about the dragon and to mitigate the damage to Esgaroth, but at the end of the day, his allegiance is to Thorin and Company. Even though he knows that Thorin will not keep his word. Though, Bilbo doesn’t know that, actually. He only knows that Thorin did not keep his word the last time, but things were very different then. Perhaps the Dragon Sickness will not be so bad this time, or perhaps the company will have the courage to take charge of the situation and override Thorin’s poor governance. Or perhaps Bilbo’s warning will be effective and Lake-town will be evacuated early. He tells himself quite fervently that he is not necessarily dooming all these people, but really, he can’t be sure of that. Their blood will be on his hands.
“Me,” he says anyway, raising his hand. “I’ll vouch for him.” Well, now Bilbo has got everybody’s attention. Last time, he spoke of Thorin’s loyalty and honor, but those words would feel hollow now, considering all that Bilbo knows about the future. Yes, Thorin Oakenshield is a loyal and honorable king, completely worthy of the title he holds and the responsibility it carries with it. But a few days in the mountain will surely change all that.
“I… I have known Thorin Oakenshield many months, and he has proven that he will go to great lengths for the safety and wellbeing of others. He is a great king, wise and just. You will have your gold.” And even if everything goes haywire, which Bilbo suspects it might, he isn’t technically lying. Just skirting the truth, because apparently, Thorin’s ability to march toward his doom is more important to Bilbo than the lives of the Men of the Lake. Every single death among them will be Bilbo’s fault.
“All of you! Listen to me! You must listen! Have you forgotten what happened to Dale?” Bard attempts to reverse the damage that Bilbo has done. The words are familiar, but they were no use before, and they will be no use now. The promise of gold is too much for these starving people to deny. “Have you forgotten those who died in the firestorm? And for what purpose? The blind ambition of a mountain king, so riven by greed he could not see beyond his own desire!” Bilbo takes advantage of the momentary distraction caused by Bard’s outburst to clutch at his wounded hip and curse under his breath. It seems to pain him more with every passing moment, though being a Hobbit, Bilbo can put up with an awful lot.
The town master cuts in then and speaks about the failure of Bard’s ancestor, as though it were Bard’s own fault. Naturally, his slimy second backs him up. Thorin looks sympathetic. If anyone here is familiar with the burden carried by the descendants of reckless kings, it is him. But in the end, he says nothing. Why does he not say something? Why does he not leap to Bard’s defense? Bilbo is about to, but then the bowman addresses Thorin directly.
“You have no right,” he spits, “No right to enter that mountain.” Bilbo could tell him that that’s the wrong way to go about things with Thorin Oakenshield.
“I have the only right,” Thorin replies, smooth and a little smug.
Bilbo should not feel that sentence in any part of his anatomy other than his rapidly sinking stomach. The tingling in his extremities must be another symptom of the poison running through his veins. Thorin will die, he reminds himself. Because of this, because of you, because you vouched for him here, because you signed on to a promise that you know he’s not going to keep, war will come to Erebor. It will be your fault when he and the lads are killed, even more than it was last time.
“I speak to the master of the Men of the lake,” Thorin continues. “Will you see the prophecy fulfilled? Will you share in the great wealth of our people?” He looks so noble, so handsome and brave. Bilbo loves him, whether he can keep this promise or not. Whether he goes mad in that mountain or not. Whether he is slain upon Ravenhill or not. “What say you?”
“I say unto you… Welcome! Welcome!” The town master shouts, after a moment of brief political calculation. Bilbo knows that they should not trust this person. And yet, they are all tired and hungry, and Bard could not offer them much. He barely has the means to feed his own family, let alone fourteen hungry travelers. “And thrice welcome, King under the Mountain!”
The feast to which the company is treated isn’t half bad. There’s plenty to go around, at least, which is a relief to Bilbo, after weeks of splitting meals with Thorin. To the Wood Elves’ credit, they thought they were feeding only one person, and had they been (assuming that person was not a Hobbit), the sustenance provided would have been sufficient.
“Go slowly,” Thorin counsels during dinner, “Or you’ll make yourself sick.”
He seems to be in much better spirits after being welcomed by the Master of the town. Probably because he does not know what kind of person the Master is. Bilbo knows it’s unfair to hold the Man responsible for something that he did on a completely different timeline, but he can’t help but clench his fists a little at the sight of the person who refused Kíli medical treatment while he was dying.
“I know how to eat, thank you very much.”
Bilbo pushes all thoughts of death from his mind. This is no mean feat, because most of his thoughts at the moment are death-related. Truthfully, he is barely holding himself together, but hold himself together he must. He cannot be a cause for alarm. During their brief interlude in Lake-town, he must recover his strength, help Thorin to do the same, procure more food than they took with them the last time, and warn Bard about the dragon. He doesn’t have time to wallow in self-pity. And there is the matter of his injury, which makes itself apparent every time he moves. Sometimes it’s even obvious when he is not moving.
Bilbo’s mother always used to say that good meal could fix anything. He sincerely hopes that this remedy applies also to poisoned arrows delivered by orcs, but of course, why would it?
“Clearly.”
Bilbo takes the liberty of elbowing the king in the gut. “Watch your mouth,” he orders playfully. Not something he’d have done the first time around, by any means, but three weeks locked in a tiny cell together with someone who is kind enough not to say a word about your constant nightmares can really do wonders in the intimacy department. Also, the pain is becoming too great for Bilbo to focus on keeping it under wraps and minding his manners at the very same time.
“You are still giving me orders, little Hobbit?” Thorin asks quietly.
Bilbo has plenty of thoughts and feelings about this, which is very nice. If he is thinking about the quality of Thorin’s voice, the king’s relative proximity to Bilbo, and the fact that they are in public right now, then he’s not thinking about his injury. Or, for that matter, about the fact that he could have saved everyone in Lake-town and chose not to, because he has the hubris to believe that he can change the future on his own.
“You are pestering me in the middle of a meal,” Bilbo counters, “Not a wise move, my King.”
“What are we interrupting?” Kíli asks cheerfully as he flops into the chair across from Bilbo. Fíli sits beside him, observing the aftermath of whatever was just taking place. Oh, this is lovely. Of course the lads have to be their witnesses.
“I am having a conversation with my burglar,” Thorin replies coolly. He’s still none too pleased about Kíli’s flirtation with Tauriel. From the way he talks about it, one would think that his nephew had taken up with an entire troupe of trolls rather than one particularly well-mannered and noble Elf.
“Our burglar, you mean,” Fíli quips. Apparently he can’t help himself.
“I meant what I said.” Thorin lets these words hang in the air.
Bilbo opens his mouth to speak, but then decides that he has no idea what he would say. Yes, three weeks in a tiny cell together can certainly change a lot.
“Anyway.” Thankfully, Kíli seems to have a lot of practice dealing with his uncle and does not seem at all put off by his boldness. “Have you tried the ale yet? It’s delicious.”
“It’s not wise to drink too much when recovering from… a journey,” Thorin counsels, complete with a long pause as he tries to think of a good word for the escapade with the barrels. He’s just full of advice today, isn’t he?
“Tell that to Bofur,” says Fíli. He jerks his head in the direction of their friend, who bears an oversized tankard of ale in each hand.
Bilbo stares up at the ceiling. Here he was, hoping to enjoy a nice evening with Thorin before setting off for Erebor, and instead, he’s got to manage Bofur’s alcohol consumption. “I hope this doesn’t become a habit. Maybe I should put a stop to it before it gets out of hand.” He really does not want to see a hung-over Bofur left behind in Lake-town for a second time.
The door to the Master’s hall bangs open before Bilbo and Thorin can even have the impending argument about whether Bilbo, personally, must be the one to see to Bofur. Everyone falls silent. They put down their tankards and turn to face the intruder, brows furrowed as they try to piece together the scene before them. An Elven lady, looking as bedraggled as it is possible for an Elf to look. Her hair is tousled, her clothes rumpled, though of course, her skin is still without blemish, and despite her obviously frantic state, her movements are still graceful as she barges into the hall.
“Say, Kíli,” Bofur makes it immediately apparent that he’s had too much to drink, just as the lads warned, “Isn’t that your Elf?”
What a thing to say in a silent hall! Even Kíli knows better than to respond to a question like that at a time like this. Ori, who happens to be the closest, shushes Bofur and snatches away one of his friend’s tankards. Tauriel, for her part, seems to have other matters on her mind. She strides through the hall with single-minded purpose.
“What is the meaning of this?” The Town Master’s sniveling second demands. “You have not been invited to this feast!”
Bilbo has never really made much sense of the Man’s official position in the town, but his title matters very little. He’s antagonistic, self-interested, and cruel. Not to be trusted, obviously. Anything beyond that is mere window dressing. The Master of Lake-town, however, is another beast altogether.
“Now, hold on a moment.” He extends an arm in front of his servant, as though to bar him from accosting Tauriel. Bilbo gets the feeling that wouldn’t go very well for the Man, if he was truly foolish enough to try it. “Let the lady speak, Alfrid.”
Tauriel doesn’t even bother to send the Man the glare he deserves. “Good evening,” she addresses the Town Master, falling into an awkward, stiff sort of bow. That’s likely common practice in Thranduil’s court, but it’s clearly a novelty to the people of Lake-town. Still, it endears Tauriel to the Town Master, which can’t be a bad thing, whatever she’s here for.
This definitely did not happen on Bilbo’s first adventure. Yes, Tauriel did come to Lake-town, but only after several days. The majority of the company had already departed for the Lonely Mountain by the time she arrived. What could possibly have changed? Well, that’s a silly question, Bilbo’s aching hip reminds him. This time, he took the arrow that would otherwise have struck Kíli. But why would that alter Tauriel’s motivations? Surely she’d be more worried about her beloved than about some Hobbit she’s never seen before.
All of Bilbo’s questions answer themselves when Prince Legolas marches into the hall. He looks slightly more put-together than Tauriel does, as though he stopped to smooth his hair down before demanding audience with the Town Master. The glare he shoots Tauriel suggests that he is not at all pleased with her running ahead, but the fact that he keeps silent about it proves that he bears her no genuine ill will. Bilbo cannot help but feel a little annoyed despite himself. Where was this timely reaction last time?
“Ah, your Highness.” The Master of Lake-town inclines his head ever-so-slightly. He might appreciate bowing and scraping when he’s on the receiving end, but he’s clearly not going to make a big show of it for anybody else. “What brings you and your fair companion to Lake-town?”
Legolas says nothing, making it abundantly obvious that Tauriel is the captain of this venture. Interesting. “We seek a wounded Halfling,” she announces. Before Bilbo can even think of making himself known, Thorin wraps a protective arm around his shoulders. Ah, yes, of course.
“They have been tracking us,” the king hisses.
“Hush,” Bilbo scolds him. “I would like to get this orc poison out of my leg, you know. If they’re going to help—“
“What is a Halfling, Lady?” The Master asks. “I have never heard of such creatures.”
“No Elf will be touching a hair on your feet,” Thorin snaps, perhaps less quietly than he might have thought he was being.
“I should certainly hope not.” That would be very intimate indeed. From what Bilbo has been told, Tauriel might sing over him for a little while, and the process will likely involve a few weeds plucked from the garden, but otherwise, no scandal will take place.
“They are little folk from the West,” Legolas explains, “Like Men, only smaller. The one we seek was injured by an orc arrow as he was freeing prisoners from my father’s dungeons.”
Now it is Tauriel’s turn to glare at him. “Time is of the essence, sir.” She quickly turns her attention back to the Town Master. “If you know of this Halfling, I would have you direct me to him so that I might offer my services as a healer. We believe the arrow may have been poisoned.”
“Even one who has violated the laws of my father’s land does not deserve such a painful death,” Legolas puts in. Oh, goodness.
Bilbo certainly doesn’t feel as though he’s on the verge of a painful death. It stings, surely, and he could happily do without it, but if he hadn’t seen Kíli’s state when they set off from Lake-town the last time, Bilbo would hardly assume that there was anything seriously amiss.Then again, Hobbits are hale folk in general, and it’s possible that Legolas is just exaggerating. Elves can be rather dramatic when they put their minds to it.
Unfortunately, they aren’t the only ones. “Fíli,” Thorin hisses to his heir, “Get Master Baggins to safety.”
“Aye, of course, Uncle.” The prince is at Bilbo’s side immediately.
“Bifur, go with them.” Thorin has evidently started handing out orders. And what’s worse, Bifur seems just as willing to go along with it as Fíli does!
“Oh, no.” Bilbo can see where this is going. “Thorin, the Elves are here to help me. Tauriel wants to heal me.”
“She wouldn’t hurt him,” Kíli, too, joins the huddle.
Thorin turns to Bilbo. “Can Óin not handle it?”
Bilbo worries his lip. “He threw together something for the pain while we were waiting for night to fall.” This probably explains why Bilbo does not feel as though he is dying. Still, he remembers the horrible, contorted expression on Kíli’s face when the company set off from Lake-town the first time around. The lad certainly did not look long for this world. “But I fear the Elves are right. I may die if they do not see to me. The arrow must have been poisoned, to cause this much pain.”
It is as though something snaps deep within Thorin, then. “He is here,” he announces, cutting the Town Master off mid-word. “See to him, if you will. But if you harm him—“
Legolas, apparently keen to remind everyone present that he is, in fact, the son of Thranduil, takes the opportunity to draw Orcrist from his belt. Perhaps not the smartest move, considering Thorin already distrusts him. “You are not in any position to bargain with anyone, Dwarf,” he announces. “I have half a mind to carry you back to my father now and let you face the consequences.”
“I’d like to see you try, lad.” This from Dwalin, who has almost certainly been furnished with proper weapons by the people of Lake-town.
“Enough of this,” Tauriel says sharply, “The Halfling will die if I do not see to him. That poison is enough to kill a Man or an Elf twice over.”
“Hobbits are far hardier than Men or Elves, Captain,” Bilbo informs her. “But I see your point.”
Thorin is seething beside him. He mutters something in Khuzdul, a prayer, no doubt. Bilbo truly does hope that the Valar will be kind to them this day. “Please,” Tauriel says. Annoyingly, she directs this entreaty toward Thorin, as though it is up to him whether she may treat Bilbo’s injury. “For the sake of the Halfling.”
“He is a Hobbit,” Thorin growls, “And you will not be alone with him.”
“Remind me when this became your decision?” Bilbo hisses. He may be slightly delirious, if he’s picking fights with Thorin when he’s at death’s door. But then, going back and forth with the king is a pleasant enough distraction from the perils Bilbo faces.
Thorin shoots him a sharp glare. “You want looking after. I told you.”
“So it was decided by royal decree, without any input from the common folk,” Bilbo shakes his head.
“You’re hardly common,” Thorin sneers, “I have been inside your smial. It is very fine, indeed. And if you are not capable of acting to preserve your own life—“
“Thorin,” Balin cuts him off with a warning glance toward the Elves and Men. Really, this is quite the mess they’ve gotten themselves into.
“Very well.” Tauriel pretends as though Bilbo’s little digression never happened. Hopefully, everyone will give him the benefit of the doubt on account of his injury. “You may watch over me, along with two of your guards. Prince Legolas, you must stay here.”
“Tauriel,” Legolas warns, but she shakes her head at him. Bilbo has great sympathy for her, truly. Dealing with royalty is never easy.
“We are enjoying the hospitality of the Town Master,” she points out, “And I doubt he’d be content having all of his guests crowded together far away from him. Take some wine and rest.”
“Fine.” They must be close, indeed, if Legolas is willing to take such counsel. But he adds to it in Sindarin afterwords, giving her a sharp reminder of the sort of folk she is dealing with.
A sharp pain in Bilbo’s hip reminds him that time truly is of the essence. Thankfully, things seem to happen very quickly after that. Bilbo is supported between Fíli and Thorin as Tauriel trails them into a room indicated by a servant. It’s a modest guest bedroom, not half as lovely as the Master’s feast hall. Something about this doesn’t surprise Bilbo in the slightest, but he hardly has time to worry about it as he is lowered onto the bed.
Thorin grips his hand like a vice. “I am watching you,” he informs Tauriel, though he has his back turned to her, his eyes still on Bilbo even as he addresses the Elf. “You will not harm him.”
“I do not plan to,” Tauriel resolves.
“I’m fine,” Bilbo assures Thorin, patting his hand. “Honestly. It must only be a small bit of poison. I’m sure Captain Tauriel will have it out in a jiffy.”
For some reason, this does not calm the king in the slightest. “Rest now,” Thorin orders. “You will need it.”
Bilbo means to argue. He really does. But the pain is too great, and the bed is too soft, and his lack of sleep has begun to catch up to him. Besides, he thinks, he and Thorin had something more important to talk about. What was it, again? Well, clearly, it couldn’t have been all that pressing if Bilbo has forgotten it. He sighs, shuts his eyes, and lays back against the paltry pillows, waiting to be healed.
Chapter 10: Kingsfoil
Notes:
Thank you all for reading and for leaving kudos/comments!
Once again, we're defaulting to the book timeline, so they spend about a week in Lake-town. I thought this made more sense since Bilbo needs time to recover from his injury... and for other things also...
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Thorin does not even need to look behind him to know that Kíli has followed their party into the room where the healing is to take place. “No,” he says, “Fetch Bifur and send him here. You must stay with Dwalin.”
He knows already why his sister-son would wish to be present. Kíli was the one to remove Bilbo from the field of battle, so it makes sense that he would feel personally invested in the situation, not to mention the fact that the Hobbit has been his friend since the very beginning. And then there is the matter of the Elf, about which Thorin would rather not think if he can help it. Not that he is capable at the moment of dragging his thoughts away from Bilbo for any meaningful amount of time. Regardless, Kíli trusts the Elf too much. If she truly meant any of them harm, he would hesitate to act. He will not be looking for signs of betrayal, and so he will miss them when the time comes. Since Thorin is only permitted to have two of his company with him as guards, he will not take this chance.
Bilbo must be here, obviously, under the care of the Elf Captain. Thorin cannot leave the Hobbit’s side. And Fíli is by far the quickest fighter of the company. It would be foolish to leave him behind, whether he is Thorin’s heir or not. But it would be equally foolish of Thorin to pen everyone closest to him up together in one room to be held hostage by the Elves. If anything goes awry, Dwalin can lead Kíli to safety. Pick him up and carry him there, even, if it becomes necessary.
“But—“ Kíli sounds exactly as he did when he was but a Dwarfling, trying his hardest to wheedle ten more minutes of play before bedtime out of his mother and uncle. And just as he did when he was small, he falls silent when Thorin shoots him a glare.
Without another word, he files out of the room, though the set of his shoulders proves that he isn’t happy about it. No doubt Thorin will be hearing an earful from his sister-son later, so long as they are both still alive. But Thorin can take a talking-to well enough. He would not survive a conversation with his Hobbit if he could not.
“Oh, that’s smart,” Bilbo muses. His voice is faint, weak. How much pain is he in?“One heir with you, and the other with Dwalin. They couldn’t be safer, really.”
Thorin was a fool to believe the Hobbit’s assurances that he was in good health. From Bilbo’s conduct when the Elves arrived, it is clear that the Burglar understood himself to have been poisoned prior to the appearance of their enemies. Somehow, he knew the threat that he was under, but chose to keep this information from Thorin. Why?
“It is a good plan, Uncle,” Fíli says gently. As though Thorin needs to be coddled! Bad enough that his One should keep things from him, but to have his own sister-son speaking to him as though he were a child on the verge of a temper tantrum!
“Yes,” Tauriel agrees, “Very wise. Know that if you kill me, your Halfling will die as well.”
Thorin snarls in response to this, and is prepared to tell the Elf exactly what he thinks of her little threat. He knows it to be true already. The helplessness is infuriating. And besides, she does not seem to have realized yet that he can still kill her after she is finished saving Bilbo’s life. If, indeed, Bilbo’s life is in danger. Thorin is still not entirely convinced that this is not simply a ploy, that these Elves have not been sent by Thranduil for the express purpose of manipulating Thorin. But it is not a risk he is willing to take. Not when Bilbo’s very safety is on the line.
“Excuse you,” Bilbo blurts out before Thorin can speak. “I am no one’s Halfling. I am my own Hobbit, for your information.” He pats Thorin’s hand in what is probably intended to be a gesture of comfort. But Thorin does not feel soothed by the touch of sweaty, feverish fingers, the small hands of a dying Hobbit. How did Thorin not notice sooner the extent of his Burglar’s injuries?
Ah. Yes. Master Baggins deliberately deceived him about the severity of the wound. But, once again, why?
“Very well.” The Elf produces a bundle of white flowers from her tunic. “But the point stands.”
“What does a guard know of the healing arts, anyway?” Thorin sneers. He does not wish for her to feel comfortable. He wishes for her to understand that if she harms Bilbo in any way, he will kill her. And he will not do it quickly.
Bifur shuts the door, muttering in Khuzdul about how the kindness of Elves is not to be trusted. Fíli nudges Thorin in the back, and he looks up in time to see Bifur furiously signing, over and over: Do not give her a reason to harm the Burglar.
“It is a useful skill to have on the field of battle,” Tauriel explains. She turns to Bilbo. “You may feel some pain as I draw the poison out of your wound.”
Thorin grits his teeth, but elects to take Bifur’s advice. He can murder this Elf afterwords, if the need arises. He still does not trust her in the slightest. But this seems to be what Bilbo wants, confused though he may be. And Thorin will not take the chance of letting the poison fester. He will not continue his quest without his Burglar.
Tauriel kneels beside Thorin at Bilbo’s bedside. “Oh, move over, you great lump,” his Hobbit grumbles, “Give her some room. How’s she supposed to heal me if you’re in her way?”
Thorin grunts. “Do not waste your words, my Burglar,” he counsels, trying to sound comforting. He is not good at this. Illness is not common among his people. On those rare occasions when his lads were small and they got sick, he would offer food, rest, and medicine and leave the comforting to Dís. Who was never very good at it, either, for the record. Thorin distinctly remembers being at a total loss of what to do.
Still, he gives the Elf the space to work. Without warning, she begins to lower Bilbo’s trousers, just enough to reach the wound. Thorin finds his fists clenching, and eases up only when the Hobbit gives a small whimper of pain, his hand caught in the king’s stone grip. He does not like the thought of anyone seeing his Hobbit in this state, least of all one of Thranduil’s guards.
“Hold him down,” Tauriel orders. Who does she think she is to give such instructions to Thorin?
But he cannot argue with her. Bifur’s point stands: Bilbo is entirely at the mercy of this Elf. If she has the power to heal him, then Mahal only knows what mischief she could cause with these abilities if she were given reason to do so. And if she cannot heal him, then it seems the Burglar’s fate is sealed. Gently, Thorin places his hands on Bilbo’s shoulders, keeping him secure. Not applying too much pressure. After all, the Hobbit does not appear to be in any danger of injuring himself with thrashing or fighting. He looks subdued, compared to his usual fiery spirits.
As Tauriel studies the wound, Bilbo bites his lip to suppress a whine of pain. His suffering appears to worsen by the moment. Perhaps he should not have taken ale at supper. Thorin should have prevented him from taking ale at supper. He should not have allowed Bilbo to accompany them to the armory. But it was Bilbo’s silver tongue that got them supper in the first place! And Bilbo’s tumble down the stairs that got them caught. He has bruises on his arms, and another is visible just beside his arrow wound.
Thorin should have done more to protect him. Tauriel mashes the crushed weeds onto the Hobbit’s wound, and Bilbo releases a yelp unlike anything that Thorin has ever heard from him. What pain must he be in, for his composure to falter so? “Peace, Master Burglar,” Thorin says, because he can think of nothing else. He is not entitled to voice the sweeter turns of phrase that leap into his mind.
The Elf begins to sing in her own language, chanting with a passion that Thorin hopes against hope is not feigned. He does not understand, just as he did not understand when she spoke of his nephew’s friendship all those weeks ago.
Please, Mahal, spare him. Spare him and I will do whatever you wish. Take my life instead, if that pleases you, Thorin prays inside his head. Not aloud. Never aloud, never Khuzdul, not in the presence of an Elf.
But he does not know why he bothers. Surely the Maker has no control whatsoever over the lives of Hobbits. “Thorin,” Bilbo breathes.
“I am here.” Who knows what sort of trance this Elf magic has sent Bilbo into?Thorin does not trust it. Would that he could spare his Hobbit from such suffering, such manipulation.
“Thorin,” Bilbo repeats, as though he did not hear Thorin’s voice. Perhaps he didn’t. He tries to raise his arm to reach for Thorin, but the king has him pinned. He was told to hold Bilbo down, and though it makes him bristle to take any kind of orders from an Elf, Thorin will not risk the Hobbit’s safety even for his comfort. “Forget about the stupid rock. You do not need it. You are a great king without it.”
“The rock,” Thorin repeats dumbly. He is not thinking about any rock right now.
“And,” Bilbo continues, gripping Thorin’s hand with more force than he would ever have imagined any Hobbit’s body to possess, “You must stay away from Ravenhill. And keep the lads safe, no matter what they tell you. Do not send them in alone.”
“Ravenhill.” Thorin remembers such a place, of course. He does not know what it has to do with his sister-sons.
“Promise,” Bilbo hisses, “Promise.” Then he screams. Tauriel continues to chant, continues to grind the healing herbs into Bilbo’s wound. Thorin will not forget the sound of his Hobbit’s suffering. No, this scene will stay in his mind for the rest of his life.
Thorin does not bother to explain that he does not know what he is agreeing to. With the Hobbit in this state, Thorin thinks he would sign onto anything. He would hand his kingdom over to the Elves, if it meant keeping Bilbo safe. Which is a dangerous thought to have, when he is inches away from an Elf who may very well ask as much. “I promise,” Thorin says.
Bilbo’s eyes are glassy as he stares at Thorin. Then, he begins to look around frantically. “Fíli,” he calls. He is not strong enough to break free of Thorin’s grip, but he thrashes nevertheless, as though he thinks he might cross the room to speak to Thorin’s sister-son.
The crown prince seems startled, but he comes to Bilbo’s other side. If Óin were here, he would probably have something to say about disturbing the patient or distracting the healer. Thorin adjusts his grip ever so slightly so that Bilbo can raise his arm and clutch at Fíli’s hand. He pushes down any emotions that this may bring forth in him. Thorin has staked no claim upon Master Baggins. They are friends only, just as the Hobbit is friends with Fíli. “What is it, Bilbo?” The lad’s voice shakes, ever so slightly. He was so young when his father died. He must not remember the face of one who is suffering so greatly.
“Do not go to into the tower,” the Hobbit urges. “It is a trap. Stay with your brother. Don’t let them separate you.”
Fíli looks panicked for a moment. “You must be seeing things,” he realizes. “Shh, it’s okay. Just rest now, Bilbo.”
It is shameful, that Thorin’s sister-son is the one giving comfort to the Hobbit while Thorin can do nothing but gape. “No,” Bilbo argues, though whether this is because he has suddenly regained the presence of mind to offer contradictions or because he thinks he’s having a completely different conversation, Thorin does not know. “It happened before. It’s going to happen again if you Sons of Durin can’t keep yourselves in line. Stay away from Ravenhill, I mean it, my boy. Bring Kíli in here, now, will you? I’ve got words for him, too.”
Fíli shoots Thorin a panicked look. He should not have to be the one to handle this. If Bilbo is senseless with terror and pain, if the Elven healing ritual has muddled his mind somehow, Thorin should be the one to tend him. No matter how terrible it may be for Thorin, he cannot pass his responsibility for the Burglar over to his sister-son.
“Hush,” Thorin orders, his voice rough. “You can speak to Kíli once you have healed.” It would not be wise to allow the conversation to take place now. Best not to distract the Elf further. And best not to scare the lad.
Tauriel’s chanting intensifies, making all other conversation impossible. Bilbo winces and writhes, releasing a few pained whimpers and one particularly upsetting wail. Thorin does not drop his grip on the Hobbit’s hand, though Fíli moves away to stand sentinel with Bifur. Just in case.
When all is said and done, Tauriel steps back. She looks exhausted. Thorin can tell from the slump of her shoulders, the slight trembling of her fingers as she pulls away from the Hobbit. “He should be well within a few hours,” she announces to Thorin. “Watch over him. The toxin is gone and the wound is closed, but it is not healed.”
“It will be difficult to watch over him, if I am returned to the dungeons of your wretched king.” Thorin should really try to be more diplomatic. He does feel grateful that Bilbo’s life has been saved, but still, he does not like the Elf. Whatever game she is playing with his nephew cannot be negated by a single act of kindness.
“Oh, goodness, Thorin,” Bilbo complains. So he is present, still, and able to speak. “Leave the poor girl alone. She just saved my life.”
Tauriel snorts. “How do you expect the two of us to subdue thirteen Dwarves? Are your warriors so lacking in skill?”
Fíli reaches for a knife on his belt, as though to remind her how skilled Thorin’s warriors are. Bifur steps closer to the door, effectively cutting Tauriel off, should she wish to flee. “No, they are not,” Thorin tells her. If they did not wish for her to leave this room, then she would die here. She must know this. She must have known this going in. And yet she still chose to help Bilbo. Thorin cannot help but wonder if her reaction might have been different, had another member of his company taken that arrow.
“Then Legolas and I will take our leave,” she says, “There is still an orc pack to track. That is more a threat to the Woodland realm than your band of marauders.”
She rises, then, and makes her way to the door. Bifur steps aside after a nod of assent from Thorin. Naturally, Kíli is waiting just outside the room. Did he hear Bilbo’s rambling? Perhaps he might make more sense of it than Thorin and Fíli did, though that is doubtful. More likely than not, the Elf managed to send Bilbo into one of the nightmares that plagued him in the dungeons.
“Will Bilbo be okay?” Kíli asks gently, steering Tauriel back into the chamber where the healing took place.
“Yes,” she murmurs. Thorin does not like the thought of any Elf murmuring at his nephew. “I have healed him. He may be weak for the moment, but the poison is gone.”
“That’s good to hear,” Kíli beams, “How are you?”
She only shakes her head at him. Then, she removes her bow from the strap at her back. Only, it cannot possibly be hers. It is of Dwarven make, clearly enough. No Elf could ever carve anything so skillfully.
“I fear you will need this.” Her tone is solemn, but the fondness in her eyes is unmistakable.
Kíli accepts his bow with a thoughtful expression. “Thank you,” he says. As though he owes gratitude to his jailer for deigning to return his property to him.
“I am sorry that I could not salvage any of your arrows. Most were lost in the forest.” Tauriel turns away from Kíli then, as she should do.
“You are not staying?” He sounds so hopeful, and once again, Thorin is reminded of the Dwarfling that he raised from a pebble. Kíli is little more than a child, and this Elf who is toying with him could be over a thousand years old.
“Of course she is not staying, brother,” Fíli places himself between Thorin and the horrible scene occurring in the doorway. “Who would want to lounge around all day with you when they could be off slaughtering orcs? Even Elves have more sense than that.” But there is some steel in his voice, and he does not take his hand off the hilt of his knife. Yes. Good. Thorin does not need to interfere. His heir has it in hand, and with much more diplomacy than Thorin would have managed. “Thank you for saving Bilbo.” Yet another oversight that Fíli takes care of on Thorin’s behalf.
Kíli does not seem to have a good argument against his brothers assertion. “Will I see you again?” He inquires of Tauriel.
“I do not know,” is her truthful answer. “Your people need you, and my prince needs me.”
“After Erebor is reclaimed.” Apparently, Kíli seems to have entirely forgotten their audience. “Expect me in your realm as soon as it’s diplomatically permissible.”
Before Thorin can remind his nephew that it will never be diplomatically permissible for any Son of Durin to venture into the Woodland Realm, the Elf moves closer to the door. Good. “Perhaps it would be better if I am the one to come to you. Farewell, Kíli.” And with that, she exits the room, not even waiting to be dismissed.
“She’s a clever girl,” Bilbo mutters.
“She is an Elf,” Thorin counters. He does not know how much Bilbo is able to process, how much he understands of this odd situation.
“Saved my life, though.” And how can Thorin argue with that?
Bilbo comes to his senses a few hours later in one of the Town Master’s guest rooms, sparse and bare. Ah, yes, of course it would be, that greedy creature. He blinks the sleep out of his eyes and rolls his sore shoulders as best as he can when reclined. Thorin, naturally, is by his side, and notices the change in Bilbo’s state of consciousness immediately. “You’re awake.” And oh, to wake up every morning to that rough but loving voice.
Loving. Yes, Bilbo knows. Bilbo has known for quite some time, if he is being honest with himself. But he has plenty of other things to worry about right now. “How long was I asleep?”
“Only a few hours.”
This is not something that he remembers from the tales he was told of his friends’ stay in Lake-town. From Bilbo’s understanding, the moment Kíli was well again, the orcs descended, and he was forced to join the fighting along with the rest of them. But it seems that Bilbo has been granted respite by virtue of his being healed a few days earlier than Kíli was. Though, that does not mean that all is well. There are other threats on their way to Lake-town, after all.
“The orcs!” Bilbo tries to sit up.
Thorin, annoyingly, pushes him very gently back down to the bed. And oh, the thoughts that move sets spinning in Bilbo’s head really have no place there. He has no business whatsoever thinking about strong Dwarven hands when the people of Lake-town are in such serious danger.
“The Elves have gone to deal with them.” He still spits the word Elves out as though it is a nasty curse, but at least Thorin seems to have faith that Tauriel and Legolas will have no trouble dispatching the entire pack of orcs. Or, at least, he is willing to pretend not to be concerned for Bilbo’s sake.
“You must be pleased,” Bilbo deadpans. “The lads?”
Thorin shuts his eyes for a moment, exhales heavily, and then returns Bilbo’s gaze. “Fíli is guarding his brother.”
“Is Kíli in danger?”
“In danger of following one of Thranduil’s guards into the forest to ‘help battle the orcs.” This, Thorin does not sound pleased about at all. “Though he swore he would be back in time for our journey to Erebor, I thought it best that Fíli distract him. I believe they are with Bofur now.”
“Drinking enough ale to fell a cave troll, I imagine,” Bilbo concludes. Well, let the lads have their fun. Considering what’s coming, it might be nice for them to have a fond memory to look back on. And though he may not agree with Thorin’s prejudice against all Elves, he can see the wisdom in stopping Kíli from running into the clutches of a group of orcs with a vendetta against the line of Durin in particular.
“Mhm,” Thorin hums. “As they should be, at their age.”
Bilbo does not ask what Thorin was doing when he was his nephews’ age. He knows already that the king was leading his people through exile. He can’t imagine that any alcohol involved in this venture carried with it the sort of happy connotation that the lads are sure to tie to their activities tonight. “I don’t suppose I’m allowed to join them.”
Bilbo has no wish to, not really. He’s seen the way his friends handle their drink, the sort of business they get up to, and as amusing as it may be to watch, as little as Bilbo has come to care about respectability, he is still a Hobbit. Dancing on tables is all well and good, but a line has to be drawn at cups and tankards tossed onto the floor.
“No,” Thorin tells him firmly. “You will stay here and you will rest to regain your energy. We will not make any move on Erebor until you are well enough to travel.”
Bilbo rolls his eyes at that, but inside, he is panicking. “Oh, Thorin, you can’t mean that. I’d be well enough to travel right now, if you wanted to go.” He wouldn’t be. “We have to reach the door by Durin’s day, you know that.”
“If you are not well enough by Durin’s day, we will leave you behind.”
“If I’m not well enough to march to the Mountain, I can’t see how you think I’d be prepared to battle a dragon.”
Thorin’s eyes narrow. “The dragon will not come to Lake-town.” He sounds very certain. “If it is alive—“
“It is alive.” Bilbo can be sure of this.
“Hm.” Thorin does not seem to believe him. “Why do you think so?”
There’s a question.“I only mean that I think we should proceed as though the dragon is alive,” he says eventually. “If not, then that’s a pleasant surprise, isn’t it? But if so, it’s best to be prepared. And seeing as I’m the one who’s going to have to face him—“
“You just said you were not well enough to do so.”
“Your listening skills need work, Your Majesty. I accused you of thinking that I’m not well enough to face the dragon, there’s a difference. I’m perfectly healthy.” Not necessarily true. Bilbo’s hip still twinges, and he could use a good meal. “Now, is it suppertime yet?”
“We’ve just eaten,” Thorin tells him, “Three hours ago.”
“Yes, that was dinner,” Bilbo waves his hand, “And now it’s time for supper. A late supper, mind you, but still supper. Honestly, how can you be King of anything when you don’t know proper mealtimes?”
Thorin sighs. Clearly, his worry has not abated, but he is plainly pleased to see Bilbo groaning and grumbling about food. If the Hobbit knows this, and if he is using it to his advantage to soothe his love, well, he can hardly be blamed for it, can he? If they’re going to be on the doorstep by Durin’s Day, then Thorin must be confident in the health of his Burglar by that time.
“Perhaps you might instruct me,” Thorin rumbles. And oh, that is simply unfair! Apparently he, too, knows what he is doing.
“Oh, believe me, I will.” Bilbo is not fantasizing about what, exactly, that might entail. He is certainly not planning any menus. Definitely not daydreaming about candlelit dinners or cozy breakfasts or prolonged conversations over tea.
Just then, the door opens, without even so much as a knock, and Óin comes bustling in, followed closely by Dori. Oh, brilliant. “So I am to be prodded and mothered all at once,” Bilbo groans.
Thorin chuckles. “It would appear so.”
“Thorin, lad, I told you to fetch me the moment he woke!” Óin scolds. Once again, he has forsaken Thorin’s royal titles in a vain attempt to convey his displeasure to his monarch. “In one ear and out the other, as usual!”
“Only one blanket, too.” Dori, for some reason, seems to believe that Bilbo’s recent illness has magically transformed him into a Dwarfling, rather than a fully-grown Hobbit. He’s procured three plush blankets from somewhere. Actually, considering their quality, Bilbo suspects that Nori was the one to procure them. If Dori had asked, he’d likely have received much less impressive linens. But if he sent his brother, and Nori employed his own methods, results such as these seem much more likely. “He’ll freeze.”
“I won’t freeze,” Bilbo assures his friend, though he is a little chilly. Well, but he’ll warm right up soon enough. “At least, not when our stubborn king stops fretting and deigns to come to bed.”
For some reason, this seems to embarrass Thorin. He suddenly finds the ceiling very interesting. Óin laughs aloud at that. He’s got his trumpet in one hand, apparently well prepared to eavesdrop on whatever conversation Bilbo and Thorin might be having. “Now, Master Baggins, how are you feeling?”
Bilbo considers this. “As though I was pierced by an arrow laced with poison and healed by an Elf after a trip through the river and a privy besides.”
“Well, it’s good enough news you’re not suffering much from that tumble down the stairs!”
“I’d forgotten about that,” Bilbo admits. “Did Tauriel say anything about how long I must wait before I can eat?”
“No, she didn’t,” Thorin mutters. Having evidently explored all the fascinating possibilities of the ceiling, he is now staring at the floor.
“Then why has nobody brought me any food?” Bilbo can’t help sounding a little petulant. After all, he’s been awake for several minutes, he’s hinted very hard, and nobody has given him anything to eat!
“I’ll fetch something, Master Baggins,” Dori assures him.
“Thank you, Dori.” Bilbo isn’t without his manners, after all.
Just like last time, Bilbo spends the first half of their week in Lake-town building up his strength, recovering from their journey down the river. Where before, he suffered from nothing more serious than a cold, now, he is contending with the after-effects of the poisoned wound on his hip. Which, now that Tauriel has treated him, are not half as bad as the after-effects of falling down the armory stairs. Or, for that matter, the after-effects of going with barely anything to eat for months on end.
Unlike last time, Thorin insists upon the most insufferable hovering for the duration of Bilbo’s recovery. He doesn’t say anything about it, of course, doesn’t bother to qualify his constant presence or his regular harassment of poor Óin with any explanation of his feelings. He is simply there. More than once, he gets on Bilbo’s nerves, as the Hobbit really would like a little bit of time alone to try and think through all of the many problems that are his alone to solve. The King Under the Mountain will simply have to wait until all the other matters have been sorted out.
First, Bilbo must find a suitable way to warn Bard about the dragon without betraying his own foreknowledge. Then, he must come up with at least a passable plan for the destruction of the ring, which will involve not only riddling with a dragon but also placing himself directly in the path of dragon fire, all while defying the will of the single most powerful artifact ever to have been forged. And after all that, Bilbo imagines that changing the outcome of the Battle of the Five Armies just enough to preserve his friends’ lives without losing Erebor will be as simple as a walk through Hobbiton market. Working through these many problems would be difficult enough to manage when merely recovering from a poisoned wound, but Thorin’s constant presence adds to the challenge.
“Does your hip pain you?” He demands around lunchtime on the fourth day. Bilbo has been permitted onto the balcony for a bit of fresh air, but this apparently does not mean that he has been permitted any respite from Thorin’s constant worry.
“Just as I told you yesterday,” Bilbo grumbles, “No, it does not. Only when I bump it against something, which I do not plan on doing on our walk to Erebor.” He does not add that slipping around on mounds of treasure inside the mountain very likely will have adverse effects where his health is concerned.
Thorin does not seem to like this response.“And your fever has not returned?”
“I never had a fever,” says Bilbo. He assumes this is true, though his memory of being healed feels rather fuzzy. He remembers Tauriel warning him about the pain he might experience, and he remembers her departure, but all that came to pass between those two moments is a blur.
“You were poisoned.”
“Yes, I believe we’ve been over that.” Thorin only reminds him twice a day. What he thinks he’ll accomplish by doing so, Bilbo is not sure.
“And you over-extended yourself afterwards,” Thorin complains. This, at least, is a new issue. “You should not have come to the armory.”
“I told you it was a bad idea,” Bilbo points out. “None of us should have gone.”
Thorin closes his eyes. “Yes. It was a bad idea for you to be there, and yet you went anyway.”
“Well, of course I went.” Bilbo rounds on the king with his hands on his hips. “As I’ve been telling you for the past several days, Thorin, I have no intention of leaving you to carry out your hare-brained schemes alone.”
Thorin seems to consider this for a moment. Then, infuriatingly, he says, “Are you warm enough?”
“If I were cold, Your Majesty, I like to think that I would know how to handle it myself! I know you mean well, Thorin, and I appreciate that you care about me, but I could do without your constant hovering!” And here Bilbo is, snapping at Thorin.
How foolish he is being. If Bilbo is unsuccessful, if his luck runs out, then their days together are numbered. He should be pleased that Thorin wishes to spend those days with him, that they are closer now than they were the last time. He should be proud of himself for overcoming his scruples and being far kinder (if much less polite) than he was eighty years ago. Instead, Bilbo is getting annoyed with Thorin as if they were an old married couple, as if they had years behind them and years ahead of them.
But that being said, after three weeks of constant contact, Thorin has apparently gotten much less tired of Bilbo than Bilbo is starting to become of him. Which, of course, makes Bilbo feel very guilty and only enhances his snappish mood.
“I hover,” Thorin snarls, “Because I can no longer trust you to tell me whether you are well or not. Because you concealed your condition from me, and you lied to me.”
“I did not lie,” Bilbo protests. “I misled you, because I knew you would take it badly, and I didn’t wish to distract you from the task at hand. Or would you rather Bard had left us washed up on the shore for the orcs to find?”
“I would rather you had told me truthfully how you fared,” Thorin announces. “Rather than risking your own life for the sake of my quest.”
“I’m not sure it’s any of your business how I fare.” This is preposterous! Why is Bilbo digging his heels in this way? Well, because he’s a Baggins, and therefore very stubborn. “And if I wish to risk my life, that is my decision, not yours. In fact, I seem to recall that the contract you had me sign made it perfectly clear that you were not responsible for my fate.” He is deflecting, and he knows it, too.
But he’s not going to have this conversation now. No. Thorin will not bully Bilbo into confessing his feelings first. If he wants to make his affection plain to Bilbo, then he’ll have to do it properly. None of this controlling fretting, none of this growling. How obstinate Bilbo is being! How vain, how selfish, to demand so much of Thorin without giving the same in return. But apparently, living through the same events twice does not necessarily make a body any wiser when it comes to matters of the heart.
“You told me that your wound did not pain you,” Thorin recounts, “And yet the Elf said that you were near death.”
“Very dramatic, Elves.” But Bilbo feels a stab of guilt. He cannot deny that he lied to Thorin. But it was only to protect the king’s feelings. The last thing they needed was for Thorin to be fretting about Bilbo when he should have been focused on evading the Town Master’s forces. That would change the course of the adventure, and who knows what might have happened then?
“What is more,” Thorin continues, taking their argument in a new direction, “You knew you had been poisoned. You told me as much, before the Elf even mentioned it. You said you wished to get the orc poison out of your leg.”
Oh. Yes, perhaps Bilbo did say that. Foolish of him, really. “I didn’t wish to worry you,” is the only defense he can offer. He can’t very well tell Thorin that he was worried about the structural integrity of their quest. “You had other things to focus on. And as I’ve told you, it was none of your business. My health is between me and Óin.”
“It is my business.”
“Oh? And how do you figure?” Say it, then, King Under the Mountain. Say it and have done with it.
“You are my burglar. I would have sent you into the mountain to face the wyrm with a fatal wound that I knew nothing about.”
Bilbo does not mention that, had Tauriel not treated him, there is every possibility that he would have been dead before they reached the Mountain in the first place. “Well, be that as it may,” Bilbo waves his hand. He is pleased that Thorin has offered him an easy exit from this conversation. They will not ever have to tell the story about how they confessed their feelings to one another in the middle of an argument about Bilbo’s deceit and Thorin’s overbearing behavior. “I don’t see what that has to do with you not giving me a moment of breathing space right now. I can look after myself, Thorin. I’ve been doing it for years.” Because you died and left me alone, he does not say.
“You wish me to leave?” Thorin hides his hurt behind a wall of anger.
“Not permanently,” Bilbo assures him, though he knows he sounds entirely exasperated. But Thorin never even asked him what he’d think about continuing to share a bed after their imprisonment had ended. He merely assumed that Bilbo would appreciate it and divvied up the rooms that way.
That certainly wasn’t the case on their first trip. Bilbo was given his own room, an effective quarantine zone, and Thorin had shared with Fíli and Kíli, as he was accustomed to doing.
“Then I will not keep you.” Thorin storms off, not looking at Bilbo over his shoulder.
Well, wonderful. Bilbo has gotten himself into yet another mess, from which he will now have to claw his way out. As if it wasn’t bad enough before, now he has to sort his priorities between soothing Thorin’s nerves, destroying the Ring of Power, keeping the Royal Family of Erebor alive, and protecting hundreds of Lake Folk from the indescribable suffering brought by dragon fire. He doesn’t even bother telling the king to wait.
If Thorin stayed, Bilbo would have yelled at him. They’d have gone back and forth for a time, and Bilbo would have been without the much needed thinking time which may make the difference between life and death as they undertake the final leg of their quest. Bilbo was a fool to believe that Lake-town was the place to make his feelings known. If Thorin behaves so possessively when he does not even know for certain that Bilbo returns his regard, what will he do when he learns that the Hobbit loves him?
Too many things would change. Bilbo should keep Thorin at arms’ length, should carry out the rest of the journey exactly the way he did before. Perhaps once the dragon is dead, he will tell Thorin that he loves him. That might even stave off the gold-sickness. Or, says a bitter little voice in Bilbo’s head, that might make it worse. Is there no safe time for Bilbo to make his feelings known?
A few hours later, Kíli appears on the balcony where Bilbo has taken up residence. The time to himself hasn’t gotten Bilbo very far. He still can’t think of a way to ensure that Smaug will not attempt to enact revenge on Lake-town, and he doubts that Bard will listen to any warning that Bilbo could give. Still, he now has a rough plan in place which may save a few lives. And he’s got a couple of ideas for how to get rid of the ring without also getting rid of himself, so he’s better off now than he was when he started. Also, he has arrived at the conclusion that he should not, under any circumstances, share the depth of his feelings with Thorin. Not yet, at least.
“You shouldn’t stay out here too long, Master Boggins,” Kíli advises, returning to his silly nickname for Bilbo from all those months ago. “Not with your health the way it is.”
“Did your uncle send you?” Bilbo asks, looking Kíli up and down. At the very least, one positive change has been made: the prince is not presently nursing a wound from a poisoned arrow. He looks very healthy, his skin warm and his eyes bright.
Kíli makes an expression of distaste so comical that Bilbo must bite back his laughter. “No, he’s busy brooding. But I hadn’t seen you for a while, and I was worried, so I thought I’d check on you.”
Bilbo sighs. May as well just get it out there in the open. “I snapped at him earlier.”
Kíli laughs, establishing himself beside Bilbo near the railing. The view is beautiful, overlooking the Long Lake with Erebor on the horizon. Bilbo could love that mountain, if he did not know what it contained. A dragon, halls upon halls of cursed gold, thousands of bodies charred beyond recognition.
“Of course you did.” The lad takes out his pipe and begins to pack it with pipeweed, no doubt furnished by the Men of the Lake. They have given the company everything they’ve asked for thus far, and naturally, everyone has taken complete advantage. “Uncle Thorin can be horrible when the people he cares about are sick. I remember once, when we were small, Fíli had the flu. That’s not normal for our people, you know.”
“I can imagine.” Last time, in Lake-town, when Bilbo was ill, none of the others seemed remotely affected.
“Anyway, Fíli was, you know, coughing and sneezing and sweating and all, and our mother was beside herself, of course, but she was so busy back then.” Kíli continues his tale and lights his pipe, setting it between his lips.
“Oh, with two young children, she would have to be.” Bilbo knows this feeling all too well. Only one of Frodo was quite enough for him, and the lad was always placid enough, at least once he learned that he did not need to pillage anybody’s fields to get mushrooms on his plate at Bag End. Bilbo cannot imagine trying to care for Fíli and Kíli both at the same time while also working for a living and helping to keep house.
“So Uncle Thorin looked after him. Wouldn’t leave his side, actually. He closed down the forge and everything.” Kíli makes an attempt at a smoke ring, which comes out as a vague elliptical puff. Still, he is young yet, and Bilbo will do everything in his power to ensure that the lad has plenty of time to get the hang of the trick. “Even after Fíli got better, for months afterwards, Thorin wouldn’t let either of us outside without a hat and scarf. Even in the springtime!”
Bilbo doesn’t know where this story is going. “That sounds like Thorin.”
“So the next time I got sick,” Kíli continues, “I though it would be better not to tell him.”
“Did you, now?”
“I kept it all to myself,” Kíli recounts, “I must have had a fever, though I was young enough not to fully understand. I remember being very weak, at least. Thorin would often take us to the forges, if that was less dangerous than the work our mother was doing. And if he hadn’t been right beside me when I collapsed, taking probably the only break he allowed himself all day, he’d never have caught me. I’d have gone right into the forge.”
“That’s hardly—“
“He still blames himself,” Kíli continues, not permitting Bilbo’s interjection. “He still thinks that he should have noticed something was wrong sooner. And I am only his sister-son. You’re… well, you can’t imagine he’d be very happy with you keeping things from him, even on a normal day. But on top of that, he has good reason to believe that you were going to die. You didn’t see yourself, Bilbo. When you fell down the stairs… that frightened all of us. Thorin especially.”
“And now he’s blaming himself for things that didn’t happen,” Bilbo grumbles. But he sees the point well enough. “I’m not a child, and I’m not bound to him. He shouldn’t hover so much.”
“Of course,” says Kíli. “But you can’t be surprised about how he reacted. I don’t know what happened between you two in those dungeons, but whatever it was, it couldn’t have changed who my uncle is.”
“I know that,” Bilbo admits, “And I’m not angry with him. I’ve been nothing but polite!”
“I know you have.” The lad offers the pipe to Bilbo now, and the Hobbit gratefully accepts. It’s been far too long since he’s had anything good to smoke, and while this is certainly not Longbottom Leaf, it’ll do in a pinch. “Just… don’t expect things to straighten out, is what I mean. It’s the will of Mahal that you and Thorin should… well. That you should feel as you do for one another.” This is coming dangerously close to implying that Bilbo is Thorin’s One. To admit to knowing as much before either party concerned has announced it is a serious taboo. Bilbo has gathered this much, at least, over the years. “If you think you can calm Thorin down by not talking to him, I can tell you right now, it isn’t going to work.”
“Are you… telling me how to court your Uncle?” Bilbo is so gobsmacked that his aborted attempt at a smoke ring is even worse than the one that Kíli produced earlier.
“Oh, no,” Kíli assures him. “You’ve got that well in hand. I’m just saying, I think you should speak with him. Even if you don’t want…” He snatches the pipe back, then, takes a long drag from it, and blows it out in lieu of describing all the things that Bilbo might want with Thorin. It is a surprising display of tact from the prince, and Bilbo cannot help feeling proud of him.
The fact stands that Bilbo does want. He wants to be with Thorin. He wants to wake up beside the king each morning and make him breakfast. He wants to be an uncle to Fíli and Kíli, a consort to the people of Erebor. He wants all that a partnership with Thorin Oakenshield might entail, the life that was denied him in the aftermath of Ravenhill. Oh, yes, Bilbo wants indeed.
“I shouldn’t have to explain to him why I want him to give me some space from time to time,” Bilbo grumbles. “Surely he should know that it doesn’t… change anything. And if you all know…. That is, with the entire company making jabs about it… surely Thorin doesn’t think I’ve suddenly stopped loving him because I asked him to leave me alone for an afternoon.”
Kíli is a very good sport, and therefore he swallows whatever comment he might have made about Bilbo’s romantic declaration. Has Bilbo ever admitted, aloud, to anyone, that he loves Thorin? “You’d be surprised,” the lad declares. “Your people are different from ours. Mahal made us to love jealously. The hovering, all that, it’s not considered strange for us. It might be annoying, sometimes, sure, but getting snapped at… it might send the wrong message. Which I don’t think you want to do.”
Bilbo hums noncommittally, and the lad continues. “Besides, isn’t it better to have it all sorted out now, before you try to battle a dragon and rule a kingdom together? If you mean to stay in Erebor, that is. If you mean to be with Thorin. Isn’t it better if you start all of that on level footing?”
“I don’t know if I should be taking relationship advice from you,” Bilbo grumbles, though he won’t pretend he doesn’t understand. “Considering you’re courting our jailor.”
“Courting?” The flush on his face belies his easy laugh. “Oh, no. I haven’t even given her a gift yet.”
“So you expect to see her again?” Bilbo almost adds before the battle, but he cuts himself off.
Kíli tries at another smoke ring and fails once more before speaking. “Well, once we’re back in Erebor, I’ll have to see her, won’t I? Somebody will have to be envoy to the Woodland realm, and who else will Thorin choose but me?”
“I think it’ll be an uphill battle convincing your uncle to make any attempt at diplomatic relations with Thranduil,” Bilbo admits. He can almost believe that everything is going to be okay, talking to Kíli about what things will be like once they have their kingdom. Of course, when Bilbo thinks about it for a moment, he is deeply troubled by the undertones of this conversation. The implication is that Kíli has no idea what he is in for. He should be worrying more about the dragon and less about Tauriel.
“Hm.” Kíli’s face lights up with the onset of a new idea. The sight is nothing short of endearing. “Well, what if you first tell him how you feel, and explain all that Hobbitish stuff about… what do you call it? Personal space? And then he’ll be in a good enough mood to at least consider my diplomatic ideas.”
Bilbo can’t help laughing at the lad’s clumsy joke. Perhaps on the first adventure, he might truly have believed that only Hobbits entertained such a concept as personal space, for all the jostling he was subjected to on the journey and all the head-butting and wrestling that he witnessed. Now, though, he understands that the two cultures simply draw the bounds of propriety in drastically different places. And Kíli, too, understands the difference enough to make light of it.
“I’ll talk to Thorin when I’m good and ready,” Bilbo decides. Though perhaps he might be ready sooner than anticipated. “Not before.”
“That’s probably for the best,” Kíli concedes, “I think it’ll take Fíli a lot longer with Uncle than it’s taking me with you. Still, it’s best to be thorough. You have no idea how many wagers have been placed over you two and your…” He still seems at a loss for words to describe what is going on between Bilbo and Thorin, which is fair enough. Bilbo isn’t quite sure what word he would use, either.
“Do I sense a plot in the making, Your Highness?” Bilbo, burglar that he is, commanders the prince’s pipe and takes a long drag.
“In the making? No, we’re past that stage.” Kíli offers him an impish grin. “We’re well into the execution, I’d say. Keep the pipe; I’ll buy another with my winnings.” He claps Bilbo on the shoulder before stalking off, leaving Bilbo to wonder just how much money the princes have riding on his relationship with Thorin.
On the fifth day in Lake-town, Bilbo is ready to swallow his pride. He’s stewed for a single night, laying awake in bed beside a silent king. He knows, of course, that Thorin’s sleep was as troubled as his own. He knows, of course, that both of them have spent far too long not saying what needs to be said, that neither of them is particularly prepared to go about it, even with the new revelations granted by those meddlesome princes. Yavanna only knows what Fíli said to Thorin while Kíli lectured Bilbo on the balcony.
They’ll be leaving Lake-town soon, and there is much to do before that time. Bilbo has a multi-pronged plan for this day. “Good morning,” he says to Thorin when the king finally wakes up.
Thorin has not been sleeping well. He’s been kept awake by worry all week, and Bilbo’s restlessness and snappishness probably haven’t helped. Not to mention the dreams (just the usual stuff, dragon fire and vengeful orcs and halls upon halls of treasure) which have no doubt caused the Hobbit to kick and whimper in his sleep. So Bilbo has restrained himself from waking Thorin, leaving him to rouse as he will while the Hobbit buzzes about the room, preparing for the day.
“Mhm,” Thorin grunts, rolling over onto his back and staring up at the ceiling. He is always groggy when he wakes. “What hour is it?”
Apparently, their sharing a bed is such an ingrained habit by now, after their time side-by-side in Mirkwood and in that cell in Thranduil’s realm that even their brief fight has not been able to disrupt the practice. Thorin gave Bilbo plenty of space during the day, but still, they settled into bed side-by-side. Really, they’ve been perfectly civil, as neither one of them seems eager to discuss their feelings or the particulars of their relationship.
But, if Kíli is to be believed, that matters very little. Whether they discuss them or not, the feelings are there. They cannot be avoided. And if Bilbo wishes for Thorin to learn to control himself in the face of such passion, then they will need to have a conversation. Boundaries will need to be set.
“I’m feeling better,” Bilbo announces, ignoring the question altogether. Truthfully, his leg has not caused him any trouble for several days, but it never hurts to make such things apparent. “I thought you might want to come shopping with me. I know you’ll hardly let me go alone, but I have a few things I need to pick up before we make for the Mountain.”
“Shopping?” Thorin sits up now and observes Bilbo’s position across the room in a rather uncomfortable chair. There is nothing Hobbit-sized in Lake Town. Bilbo has forgotten what it feels like to sit on a piece of furniture and have one’s feet touch the floor.
“Yes, shopping,” Bilbo confirms. “I want to pick up some provisions for our journey.”
“Provisions?” Thorin really must sleep more, and then, perhaps, he won’t seem so tired first thing in the morning.
“Foodstuffs,” Bilbo elaborates.
Thorin sighs, as if Bilbo has bullied him into going along with the plan. “You do love your foodstuffs, don’t you?”
“Yes, I do.” Bilbo will readily admit it, “So please get dressed, and let’s be off. I’ve been waiting for hours.”
“You could have woken me,” the king informs him as he shrugs off the covers and begins to get dressed. “You need not have waited.”
“I know,” Bilbo replies, “But you were tired, and you needed sleep. I’ll not rob you of that. And don’t argue, because I’m not in the mood for it.”
“You are not in the mood to argue?” Thorin sounds incredulous. “I am beginning to worry that your fever has had some ill effects.”
“I never had a fever,” Bilbo protests, for what has to be the thousandth time.
“And you are always in the mood to argue.” Thorin looks very pleased with himself indeed as he puts on his new coat. The folk of Lake-town really have been far too kind, considering what’s about to happen to them, though of course, they do not know yet about what the dragon will do. “Have you eaten?”
“I’ve had breakfast,” Bilbo assures him, “And we can have second breakfast at the market. Come on.”
“Demanding,” Thorin complains, but he follows Bilbo out of the room nevertheless.
The house they’ve been given is very grand indeed, especially considering its location. Bilbo cannot help but seethe at the fact that the Master of the Town has provided for them this way when he refuses to offer similar treatment to any of his own people. Rather than giving the company coin to spend, the Master has simply instructed his subjects to give their guests whatever they ask for. This means, in effect, that they are robbing the people of Lake-town. Bilbo dislikes this prospect, but he knows he has very little choice.
Their first stop at the town market is a little stall selling spiced buns. After thanking the shopkeeper profusely, Bilbo leads Thorin to their next destination. “You seem to know where you are going,” Thorin observes.
“I suppose everybody must seem that way to you.” Bilbo can’t help but tease him. “But if you must know, I have a list.” He brandishes the paper in one hand and his roll in the other.
Thorin, who has already made quick work of his own second breakfast, which is really just plain breakfast for him, snatches the list out of Bilbo’s hand. “Dried meats,” he reads, “Cheese, berries, bread, apples… no, no apples.”
“No apples?” Bilbo finishes the roll in a few bites. It is much less messy than the iced variety sold in the Shire, but much less tasty for it.
“Fíli’s gone off them,” Thorin explains, “He claims his barrel stank of them, and that riding in it was ‘like being tortured.’” Is this what they spoke of, then, while Kíli had Bilbo cornered on the balcony?
“Because of the smell, or because of the orc attack?” Bilbo inquires, making a mental note to seek out some other kind of fruit.
“I did not ask,” Thorin admits.
“Do you think he would eat pears, if we could get them?” Bilbo is finally back in comfortable territory. If there’s one thing he excels at, besides storytelling, it’s being a good host. And what is hosting, really, if not purchasing foodstuffs that people will like and preparing them in a way the guests will appreciate?
“How should I know?”
“You brought it up!”
Thorin mutters a prayer or an oath of some kind in Khuzdul. Once again, Bilbo wishes that Lady Galadriel had given him some forewarning about the nature of his journey. He’d have done a little studying, then, and been a lot better prepared for this trip.
“I hope I didn’t make you think you weren’t wanted the other day,” Bilbo finds himself blurting out as he fills his basket with pears from the fruit stall. He makes sure to take the smaller specimens, those with bruises, and especially the ones that aren’t quite ripe yet. Let the paying customers have the best produce. He didn’t mean to start this conversation this way, but apparently, he cannot help himself. “When I sent you away.”
“You are entitled to send me away, of course,” Thorin assures him, “I don’t intend to be a nuisance to you. I’d prefer it if you…“ he seems to be considering his words very carefully. “If you were pleased with my presence. I do not wish to impose.”
For Thorin Oakenshield, this is tantamount to an admission that he’d be willing to shave off his beard to please Bilbo. If the Hobbit’s suspicions are correct, and if he understood what Dáin was implying on his last visit to Erebor, and if Kíli can be trusted, it is only natural that Thorin would be overprotective of Bilbo. The fact that he is willing to admit not only that he was wrong but also that Bilbo is entitled to some measure of privacy shows great restraint and great willingness to compromise, especially from someone as stubborn as Thorin.
“Did Fíli… talk to you about… things?” Bilbo asks.
“Yes.” Thorin does not elaborate. So this is as difficult for him as it is for Bilbo. Good. The lads will be pleased. Level footing, indeed.
Bilbo bites his lip. “Kíli told me that you and I will have to work out a long-term solution for your possessive behavior if I’m to be your consort.” Well. There it is. Out there in the open. No going back now. “In so many words.”
“I wasn’t aware of this,” Thorin says eventually. He does not remove his hand from the small of Bilbo’s back, where it has rested since they entered the market. For a moment, Bilbo wonders what he’s talking about. Was Fíli less obvious than Kíli was about the particulars of their matchmaking plot? “You wish to be my consort?”
Bilbo cannot help but tease. Truly, in moments such as this, he is willing to entertain the idea that he and Thorin are merely any other couple, engaging in such mundane and domestic activities as buying fruit at the market. He can almost forget about the dragon, the battle and the ring. Almost. “Would I put up with your constant fretting if I didn’t?”
“Would you not?” Thorin asks, though it can’t be a serious question. He is merely speaking to fill the silence, saying something in a space where nothing need be said. Surely he must know that Bilbo would not hesitate to set him right about such things, as he has done in the past and will continue to do in the future.
“No,” Bilbo says. “I would not.” But he, too, is only filling the silence.
Thorin closes his eyes, then. The two of them stand at a perfectly respectable distance from one another, like two friends at the market in Hobbiton. Yet still there would be gossip if they did this in the Shire, and still there will be gossip here. Does Bilbo care? Once, he might have.
Once, he might have said that he would not risk his reputation by doing anything foolish in such a public place. And then, once they were in private, he’d have convinced himself that the action would be impertinent. He’d have lectured himself internally about the impropriety of his own thoughts, how idiotic he was to believe that a Hobbit from the Shire might deserve the affection of the King Under the Mountain. Once, he’d have had no trouble burying any sentiment he might harbor towards Thorin Oakenshield.
That was how Bilbo handled things before. He never spoke words of love to Thorin, never voiced what might have existed between the pair of them. He believed he had all the time in the world, and when that belief was proven false, he folded in upon himself, refusing to speak of it. He wrote a very nice book about it, and lived a lovely long life full of adventure. And then he came here, and everything happened so quickly, and Bilbo told himself that his first priority was to keep his friends safe. To prevent their deaths, and sort everything out afterwards, because that would be the logical thing to do.
But now, with Thorin in front of him and the Lonely Mountain at his back, all of that seems like an awful waste of time to Bilbo. Why suffer through that again? Why make Thorin suffer through that again? Why deny what is so obvious to everyone? And besides, it is already in the open now. So there is no harm in it, not really.
He reaches up, placing a gentle hand in Thorin’s hair, careful not to pull as he guides the king closer. Bilbo leaves plenty of space, moves slowly enough to give Thorin time to pull away if he wishes. But the king only opens his eyes, wide and blue and so young-looking, all of a sudden, as though for a moment, he might be free of the troubles which have haunted him all his life. And really, how could Bilbo not kiss him, staring into eyes like that?
At first, Thorin does not respond, standing stunned as Bilbo kisses him. But before the Hobbit can wonder if perhaps this was not such a good idea, perhaps he did not give enough warning, perhaps he was too forceful, he feels a pair of strong arms settling around his waist, and Thorin kisses him back. Gently. So gently, so tentatively, as though he isn’t certain of what to do. Is this his first kiss? It may very well be, from what Bilbo knows of Dwarven courtship, which, admittedly, isn’t very much.
He pulls away, if a little reluctantly, before things can escalate beyond the bounds of propriety. Or, rather, before things can escalate further beyond the bounds of propriety than they have already gone. After all, Bilbo and Thorin are in the middle of a marketplace, and though they might be hidden by the crowd, they are both very recognizable personages.
“I have not even given you a gift yet,” Thorin informs him with a stunned little laugh. He brings his fingers to his own lips, ever-so-gently confirming that the kiss truly took place.
“Well, then.” Bilbo refuses to be embarrassed by his own scandalous behavior. There are too many things to worry about right now to concern himself with what is or isn’t proper. “Consider this an open invitation to do so at your earliest convenience.”
Before Thorin can reply, they are interrupted by some very familiar laughter. Bilbo whips around to see Balin and Dwalin standing only a few paces away. Balin, the source of the laughter, offers him a smile, while Dwalin only scowls. “Now?” Dwalin demands. “Of all times, right now?”
“It was not my decision.” Thorin doesn’t even bother fighting the smile that accompanies these words.
“‘Course it wasn’t,” Dwalin shakes his head and grumbles something too low for Bilbo to make out in full. The word Burglar features heavily, along with several other more colorful terms.
“Good for you, lads.” Balin beams at them. “Good for you. We were all wondering when you’d get to sorting things out.”
“Well.” There is only so much that Bilbo can take of this awkward sort of conversation. “We’ve got plenty of shopping to do, now, haven’t we, Thorin?”
“Yes,” the king agrees, still seeming vaguely dazed as a result of the kiss. Is this better than the brooding and sulking? In Bilbo’s opinion, very much so, though he’s not certain it’ll be any more conducive to a successful conclusion of their quest.
“You’re welcome to join us if you’d like.” But he knows that they won’t want to. He wouldn’t have invited them if he’d thought they did.
“We’ll be going, then,” Balin tells them with far too much cheer. Bilbo allows himself a brief moment of speculation as to which bets the sons of Fundin may have placed regarding his relationship with Thorin. “See you at dinner.”
“Don’t do anything stupid,” Dwalin advises. The two of them take their leave.
All things considered, the fruit seller is perfectly polite. She doesn’t say a word about the impropriety of a king and a burglar locking lips in front of her stall.
Two days later, the company is set to leave from the old port of Esgaroth in a fleet of boats provided, of course, by the Town Master. Bilbo bears a sack of crusty bread, sturdy cheese, and dried fish, and he has already sent forward another sack full of fruit. No apples whatsoever, for Fíli’s sake. He owes the lad that much, for his meddling.
“We are leaving,” Thorin announces, holding out his hand for Bilbo’s bag as he enters their bedroom.
No more kisses have been shared between them since Bilbo made his feelings known, but they have continued sharing a bed. It would be silly to do anything else, now that everything is out in the open. “Just a moment,” Bilbo says, handing over the bag, “I want to make sure everyone is ready.”
“Of course everyone is ready. We must make haste.” Thorin obviously didn’t sleep last night. Bilbo didn’t get much rest either, troubled as he was by thoughts of Smaug. Even their conversation at the market and the promise of things to come could not protect them from such worries. “Come, now.”
“Just a moment,” Bilbo repeats. Before Thorin can stop him, he darts down the stairs and into the kitchen. As expected, he finds Bofur laying under the table, sleeping peacefully with his hat covering his face.
“We’re about to leave,” he informs his friend, shaking him gently. “It’s time to get up.”
He considers singing the wake up song that he always used for Frodo, but that seems a bit odd under these circumstances. When Bofur does not respond to Bilbo’s gentle jostling, he gives a particularly hard shove, and that seems to do the trick. “What?”
“Thorin was about to leave you behind,” Bilbo explains, “I trust you have your things packed?” He knows that couldn’t possibly be true, but a Hobbit can dream.
“I hope Bombur got ‘em. But if not, I can get new things from Erebor.”
Bilbo just blinks at him. “Let’s go get your bag. I’ll come with you.”
“Good thinking,” Bofur reasons, sitting up and nearly hitting his head on the bottom of the table. This little space might be the only Hobbit-sized thing in this entire town. “Thorin definitely won’t leave you behind.”
News has certainly traveled amongst their company over the course of the past few days. Apparently, Balin and Dwalin have no sense of discretion, and have filled everyone in on what they saw in the marketplace. Subsequently, Bilbo has received many hugs and congratulations from his friends. Kíli even picked him up and swung him around, earning himself a thorough talking-to, though it was delivered with a smile. Ori, perhaps the only member of the company with his wits about him, offered to teach Bilbo about Dwarven courtship rituals, in hopes that the subject will become very relevant to his life very shortly.
Bilbo doesn’t even dignify Bofur’s comment with a response. Instead he leads his friend upstairs and helps him pack up what few things Bombur did not see to. “What is taking so long?” Thorin demands after about five minutes of this.
Unfortunately for him, it’s difficult for Bilbo to be intimidated when this is just another instance of the same rigamarole they went through at Beorn’s place. Thorin probably isn’t actually going to leave any of them behind. If anything, he’s just going to reach out to grab Bilbo and drag him away, in which case, Bofur could follow them out the door. No harm done. But if there’s any chance of everyone sufficient supplies, well, then Bilbo would like to ensure it if he can. Also, he doesn’t fancy the idea of poor Bofur trekking through the ruins of Dale by his lonesome, which is surely what would happen if he were left in Lake-town.
“Bofur was asleep and didn’t pack anything,” Bilbo reports.
“And he needs your help to do it now?”
“I begged him to let me do it myself, but the Burglar refused,” Bofur puts in helpfully. He seems to find the awkward pre-courtship between Bilbo and Thorin very entertaining. “And you know I cannot argue with the future consort of Erebor.”
Bilbo takes the liberty of elbowing him in the side. “Please be quiet, or I’ll make sure we really do leave you behind.”
“You have two minutes,” Thorin growls, “After that, I will consider banishment.” He’s probably joking.
Bilbo shudders. He has no desire to be banished from Erebor again. “We’ll be quick,” he assures the king with a pasted-on smile. As soon as Thorin is gone, he turns an accusatory glare towards Bofur. “What were you thinking, saying something like that?”
“I was thinking it’d be funny, lad,” Bofur replies, and unfortunately, Bilbo cannot argue with him there.
“Just one more stop to make,” Bilbo declares as the company makes their procession to the docks.
Thorin looks as though he is seriously considering just picking Bilbo up and depositing him in a boat. Physically, he’d be able to do it, but he seems to understand that it would mean the end of their courtship, which technically has not yet started. “Where?” He asks heavily.
“I need a word with Bard the bargeman.”
“Why? What kind of word?” Thorin is instantly suspicious.
“A private word.” Bilbo understands that he’s poking the bear, but frankly, if Thorin can’t handle these occasional diversions for the sake of Middle Earth, he can’t handle a relationship with Bilbo. “It’ll only take a moment. You can help Glóin with that baggage while you wait for me.”
Not that Glóin needs much assistance, per se, but Bilbo doesn’t like the thought of Thorin pacing around waiting for him. Best that he at least redirect his anxious, protective energy towards a productive task. “Very well.” This seems to be a struggle for Thorin to say, but say it he does, which is a major improvement upon his behavior when they first arrived in Lake-town. He is making an effort for Bilbo, then. It’s all very sweet.
“You won’t even notice I’m gone,” Bilbo lies with a reassuring smile. Then he slips the ring onto his finger and disappears, weaving through the crowd to a familiar house.
He finds Bard at home, and only just remembers to take off the ring before he knocks on the door. “What do you want?” Bard demands when he catches sight of Bilbo. “Have your masters sent you to collect more weapons? More food?”
“I’m no servant,” Bilbo informs him flatly. “And if I were, it would be very rude to speak to me that way.” He can respect that Bard is annoyed at having his warnings ignored, and probably terrified for the safety of his children, but that does not excuse his tone.
“That’s not what your king seems to think.” Bard’s eyes are hard, unyielding. This may be more difficult than Bilbo expected, but he has to try. For the sake of the People of the Lake, he must do what he can.
“He panicked because he thought you were going to shoot me.” Honesty, Bilbo decides, will not hurt his chances at swaying Bard. If Bilbo fails in this, people will die. If he succeeds, he may yet save at least a few lives.
“Who is it, Da?” Sigrid asks, appearing behind her father. “Oh, hello, Mister Baggins! Are you not leaving for Erebor with the rest of your company?”
“Soon,” Bilbo assures her, putting on a smile, “I’ve just got to have a small word with your father first.”
Bard glances at his daughter, and then back at the Hobbit. “What is this about, then? Shut the door, Sigrid. I’ll be back to help with the dishes in a moment.” Ah. They must be just finishing breakfast, then. Bilbo feels a bit bad about disturbing them during a meal, but this truly cannot wait.
It’s obvious that Bard does not trust Bilbo, but he also clearly knows better than to turn away what information is offered. Bilbo can appreciate this. He sighs heavily. There’s no way around it, then.
“You know as well as I do what’s going to happen when we get to that mountain,” Bilbo begins.
“I do,” Bard agrees, “You are going to wake the dragon and bring death and ruin upon us all.”
Bilbo cannot argue with that. He doesn’t think it would be very good form to tell Bard that it’s all going to be okay because his family will survive. In fact, he doesn’t know that for certain. Now that he thinks about it, Bard’s family may only have survived because they were under the protection of Tauriel, Fíli, Kíli, Bofur, and Óin. The five of them surely would be a force to be reckoned with in any crisis, and Bard may have trouble wrangling the young ones and slaying Smaug at the same time.
Bilbo’s stomach sinks like a stone. What has he done? He should not have meddled with Kíli’s injury. Even if it would have meant seeing the lad in pain, Bilbo knows that everything would have turned out fine in the end. He should not have taken this risk.
“Yes, well.” Bilbo has to force himself to continue this discussion, however little he might want to. Ultimately, Bard must know how to kill the dragon, and Bilbo cannot expect a third chance. His choices are made already and cannot be undone. “I have some information that may help you in killing the beast.”
Bard laughs mirthlessly. “So I must be the one to do it?”
“Yes, you must,” Bilbo agrees. He won’t beat around the bush. “It’s your birthright, isn’t it? Just like it’s Thorin’s birthright to enter the Mountain. Besides, I doubt any of your neighbors have a Black Arrow on hand.”
“You are not his servant,” Bard decides, looking Bilbo up and down. “What are you to him? You told us all to trust him, though you know exactly what will happen when he wakes the beast.”
“I hardly see how that’s relevant,” Bilbo says, less because he feels ashamed of his relationship with Thorin and more because it will take too much time (and test Bard’s patience and goodwill) if Bilbo starts spouting nonsense about alternate timelines and magic rings and cursed gems. “But you must understand that nobody could stop Thorin from finishing his quest. If your people had refused him aid, he’d have led us all onward. If your Town Master had detained us, we’d have broken out.”
“As you did with the Elves.” So Bard has put two and two together on that score.
“As we did with the Elves,” Bilbo agrees.
“And now that we have aided Thorin Oakenshield, he will repay us with death by fire, the same fate that befell his own people when the mountain first was taken. Do you really think it better that Lake-town should burn than that your… king should fail to claim the throne of his mad grandfather?”
Bilbo has no excuse. He could discuss the future of Middle Earth, the necessity of defending the North, keeping Erebor out of the hands of the orcs. He could explain that Thorin’s people deserve to return to their homeland, that the rebuilding of Dale, whether Lake-town burns or not, will take power away from the greedy tyrant who rules here now. Or he could admit that, for him, it has never been about the fate of the world. It has been about the fate of one doomed king, and Bilbo will do everything in his power to keep Thorin from falling again, even if it means taking a few risks with the security of Lake-town.
“It doesn’t matter what’s better,” Bilbo resolves. “We will reach Erebor in a few days time, and the dragon will come here. Would you like to keep asking me questions, or would you like to know how to slay Smaug?”
Bard does not look happy about this, but he grunts in acknowledgment. “Go on, then. Though I do not think that I can trust your word.”
“I travel with many who have seen the dragon,” Bilbo forces himself back on track to the not-quite-a-lie that he has rehearsed over and over again this week. “And I have it on good authority that he, Smaug, that is, has a small weak spot on his chest. If you can wait in the watchtower with a black arrow ready three days hence, you can slay the dragon before he does any serious damage to your town. Aim for the gap in his armor.”
“Is that so?” Bard asks. “A gap in the armor. Can you really be sure that such a thing is still there?”
“Even if it isn’t,” Bilbo replies, “You know that you’re the only one who can slay him. Get your children out, send them to the Wood Elves, then go and wait. I’ll do what I can to keep the dragon’s attention, but I can’t be sure he won’t come here. ”
“You would have me evacuate only my children, then, and not the rest of my people?” His people. Some part of Bard is ready, even now, to be King.
Bilbo swallows. “That is up to you,” he decides. “Though I would not alert the Town Master.” Bilbo feels awful saying this, deciding who will live and who will die, but he knows that the Master of Lake-town would prioritize his treasure over the lives of his people. And really, how Bard manages this crisis as the rightful King of Dale is entirely at his discretion. “What matters is that you be in position to kill the dragon before he can attack the town. And be sure your children have weapons. We may have been tracked by orcs.” Perhaps he should have led with that.
“Not a problem!” Tilda sings from the other side of the door. Bilbo can imagine all three of Bard’s children huddled together behind the thin wooden plank, eavesdropping, as any trio of young people would do.
Bard startles. He clearly did not think that his children would be listening to this conversation. “What are you talking about, darling?” He asks gently. He may be a stern man, but clearly, he is a perfectly loving father. Bilbo respects that about him.
“I took two knives off of Prince Fíli while he was distracted,” the little girl reports. “He didn’t even notice!” Bilbo is certain that the lad did notice, but he probably thought that Tilda was well old enough to be armed to the teeth. Different cultures, different standards, and possible confusion about relative maturity levels must be at play here. Bilbo makes a mental note to have that conversation with the crown prince once the dragon has been slain.
“By the Valar,” Bard mutters. “She should not have those.”
“No, she probably shouldn’t. You should sort that out.” He feels this is his cue to leave. He really doesn’t envy Bard. Even in the most typical of circumstances, Bilbo would not have felt entirely comfortable with the idea of young Frodo carrying a knife. In fact, when he handed Sting over to the lad, he had to resist the urge to protect his nephew somehow from the sharpness of the blade. “Just, be prepared to fight the dragon.”
“Aye, thank you for the advice.” Bard’s gaze is unreadable, but Bilbo appreciates the fact that he has yet to openly refuse compliance with the plan. There is hope, at least, of a different fate for Lake-town.
Notes:
Well, they finally kissed! I did not plan to write it that way. I was going to make them wait until after the battle, but it just felt right that they have a nice little moment in Lake-town before... you know, all that other stuff.
Edit 2 June, 2026: The next update will be on 17 June! I'll be traveling for a bit and won't have any time to edit. I was hoping to get chapter 11 posted tomorrow, but right now it's 16k words and I just won't be able to edit it to my satisfaction before I leave home. Thank you all for understanding.
Chapter 11: The Many Uses of Dragon Fire
Notes:
I'm back!! Thank you once again for reading and all the kudos and kind comments that you left while I was away. Hopefully this longer chapter is worth the wait. As always, enjoy!
Chapter Text
Thorin does not speak to the Burglar at all as the company crosses the Long Lake. He does not know what to say. He did not like that Bilbo went out of his way to speak to the bargeman any more than he liked that Bilbo went out of his way to ensure that Bofur was awake and ready for the journey. Bofur should be perfectly capable of handling his own sleep schedule, and if not, then his kin should see to it. Thorin’s Hobbit should not be responsible for the wrangling of any member of the company, nor should he have any reason to consort with Men.
But Bilbo made it very clear in Lake-town that he did not wish to be smothered, that he found Thorin’s behavior quite overbearing, and that his sending Thorin away for an afternoon did not mean that Thorin was not wanted at all. And before the king could request clarification, the Burglar kissed him on the lips, in public, as though they were a married couple. Perhaps this is typical among Hobbits. Perhaps they offer kisses freely, and insinuate a desire for marriage at the start of each dalliance. Perhaps it did not mean as much to Bilbo as it did to Thorin.
He did not ask. There was no time, between the preparations for their departure and the chaos of embarking, and besides, there did not seem to be any point to it. Thorin knows, at least, that Bilbo cares for him, and would like to someday become the consort of Erebor. Does he need more than that, when he cannot even procure a gift for the Hobbit? Traditionally, such a conversation would follow the first gifting and precede the second. But they have been bucking tradition since their imprisonment in the Woodland Realm, sleeping side-by-side for several weeks. Sharing a kiss certainly did not help matters.
Thorin is at war with himself as they disembark from their boats and bid farewell to the Lake-men who have ferried them across. He knows very well that he should be focused right now on his kingdom and the dragon that has stolen it. He must think of Master Baggins as an expert burglar, and he must permit the Hobbit to enter a Mountain with a sleeping dragon inside for the express purpose of removing the Arkenstone and securing Thorin’s right to rule. But he does not wish to allow Master Baggins out of his sight in any capacity, least of all a capacity that might involve a tussle with a wicked wyrm. He knows that Smaug would delight in killing Bilbo, and he does not wish to see that done.
In his dreams, when he finds sound enough sleep for them, Thorin watches his Hobbit burn. It is a blessing that he is usually kept awake by his worry until the small hours, and woken again before sunrise by the same energy that has propelled him every morning hitherto. Thorin will rest when his kingdom is restored. He will rest, he will find a courting gift, and he will have a conversation with his Hobbit. Not that this does much to assuage his fears.
Thorin knows that Bilbo is a stubborn little creature that will not take kindly to being refused the opportunity to do what he was hired for. They both signed the contract, and the stipulations could not be more clear.There is no going back now, and Thorin has no better plan. He’d like to follow Bilbo inside the mountain, but he knows that he cannot. Smaug would recognize his scent and Bilbo would lose the element of surprise. What was the point of bringing a Hobbit on this journey, if not that he’d be unfamiliar to the dragon?
When the contract was drafted, of course, Thorin had not yet met the comely Hobbit. When it was signed, he refused to acknowledge his attraction to Master Baggins. By the time of their stay with Beorn, though, Thorin knew that he harbored more than simple professional admiration for the Burglar. And now, in Lake-town, everything has been confirmed, far too early, and in an inappropriate fashion. Knowing that Master Baggins cares for him has changed Thorin’s outlook significantly, even if it has not altered his larger plans. He knows precisely who to blame for this development.
“You should not have meddled in my personal affairs,” he growls to his sister-sons when, finally, he is able to corner them away from the rest of the group. Thorin neglected to bring this matter up in Esgaroth, largely because he was too stunned by Bilbo’s sudden boldness to even consider the source of the idea planted in his Hobbit’s lovely head. “And to exchange bets over such matters was below your station as princes of Erebor.”
“Who says we were betting?” Fíli looks affronted.
Kíli purses his lips. “I may have implied as much to Bilbo when I was giving him advice.”
“Why?”
Kíli shrugs. “I didn’t want to embarrass him.”
“You don’t think he’d be less embarrassed knowing we want him to be happy than thinking we had money riding on his coupling with our uncle?” But Fíli seems to find this more amusing than horrifying. Thorin does not know whether to be more concerned for the Burglar’s fragile feelings or for what Bilbo will do to his sister-sons if he ever learns the truth.
“It was not your place to speak with my—“ Thorin cuts himself off with a huff because he doesn’t know how to describe his relationship with Bilbo. They are not properly courting, despite Bilbo’s clear announcement of intent, because neither of them has given the other one a gift. Thorin would have done, if he’d found anything fine enough in Esgaroth, but it seems more prudent to wait until they have secured Erebor. He wishes Bilbo to have the best courting gift imaginable, and also, he would very much like to stave off the distraction of full courtship (and serious acknowledgment of the bond that has formed between himself and Master Baggins) until he has his kingdom well in hand.
They have years ahead of them to discuss such things. The dragon, however, must be seen to now. It is straightforward. Thorin will not pretend that he did not enjoy the brief kiss he shared with Bilbo, but it would be foolish to initiate another before their work is done.
Ah, but it was such a pleasant thing. Thorin was surprised, at the time, by the force with which the Burglar accosted him, the way the kiss melted into something soft and sweet. Thorin should have stopped him, should have explained that such an act in Dwarven society was tantamount to a proposal of marriage. Then again, Bilbo did admit aloud that he would like to serve as Thorin’s consort. Not that there is any question of the kiss springing from the Hobbit’s political aspirations alone. No, that could not be possible. Thorin could feel his Burglar’s affection, could taste it on his lips.
“But he would not be your intended if I hadn’t interfered,” Kíli points out shamelessly.
Thorin looks around frantically, but of course, they are too far ahead of the rest of the company for their voices to be heard with the wind at their backs. “He is not my intended now,” the king growls.
“Why not? He’s interested.”
“I’m starting to see how you wound up courting an Elf,” Fíli observes. Much like his brother, he fails to see the seriousness of the situation. Still, at least he defends Thorin’s position. “Mutual interest isn’t the only factor. There’s timing to consider.”
“Wouldn’t you want to secure the match before he slays a dragon and starts getting other offers?” Kíli muses.
“I don’t think Bilbo will be the one to slay the dragon,” Fíli protests in a vain attempt to steer the conversation in a more pleasant direction.
“Still, he means to face Smaug on his own,” Kíli points out. He does not seem to comprehend the danger in this, or else he is very confident indeed in the Burglar’s abilities. “That’ll catch some attention, especially when the mountain starts filling up again.”
Thorin’s blood does something violent in his veins, a physical sensation he’s never experienced before. “He will not consider other offers. He’s made his intent clear enough.”
“Thanks to me,” Kíli sings. “Honestly, Uncle, this is only too simple. Master Baggins will make a fine consort, and he’ll treat you very well, and you’re obviously besotted with him. I just thought he should know the way our people love.”
“Even if you don’t start courting now, it’s better if he knows what to expect,” Fíli agrees. “In case anything happens, you both know where you stand.”
“I do not know anything.” Thorin is embarrassed to share as much with his sister-sons, but he’ll not have them thinking that they’ve changed his life in any meaningful way with their underhanded meddling. Why they care about the nature of his relationship with the Burglar escapes him entirely.
“He didn’t tell you that he loves you?” Kíli sounds surprised.
“Why would he say such a thing?”
To feel the pull toward a One is not the same as to be in love. Obviously, Master Baggins cares for Thorin. Obviously, he wishes to be with him, once they have taken back the Mountain. There is no question of whether the Hobbit is prepared to rule Erebor by Thorin’s side. But that does not mean that Bilbo loves Thorin, only that he is willing to entertain the notion of loving him. And it certainly does not mean that he would say such a thing aloud.
“Oh.” Fíli seems to realize what is happening before Thorin does. “Oh, Mahal, no. Tell me I’m wrong?”
“He said it,” Kíli sings. “I did tell him to talk to you. I don’t know why he didn’t. Honestly, you’re both lucky you have us to do the communication for you.”
“He kissed you without saying anything?” Fíli asks, incredulous. Among their people, such an act would be unimaginable. Thorin supposes that it does make sense that, after hearing about what happened in the marketplace, the rest of the company might leap to some premature conclusions.
Thorin shakes his head, fighting off the swooping sensation in his stomach. Whether Master Baggins loves him or not is immaterial. It cannot be addressed now. When the dragon is dead, Thorin will give his Hobbit a courting gift. He will say all the things that he has kept from his tongue in recent days. They will continue as they have done, not discussing it. Why do any more? It seems foolish to plan for a future that they cannot envision, not yet knowing the state of Thorin’s kingdom or the fate of the beast lurking inside. “It is still none of your business. I would have you stop meddling.”
“Until our kingdom is restored?” Kíli asks, still far too glib. Even after all he has seen, as far as Kíli is concerned, the dragon is only a monster from a story, not worth a second thought. Thorin might be endeared, were he not so troubled by the implications.
“That seems fair,” Fíli decides. “We’ll start meddling when you’ve got your crown back, how does that sound?”
“You will not need to,” Thorin grits out, much to the delight of the lads. When Thorin has his crown back, he will make his intentions known to the Hobbit before his nephews even have time to concoct another poorly-thought-out plot.
The journey to Erebor is spent in relative silence for Bilbo. Worry eats away at him from all sides. He isn’t certain that his warning to Bard will be effective in protecting the Men of the Lake. After all, the Town Master distrusts Bard, and though the bargeman does seem to have some friends, most of his fellow citizens refused to heed his initial warning. It is entirely possible that he will be detained somehow before he can kill the dragon. And what if the journey is of a different length this time, and Bard is waiting in the watchtower too early? What if he gets there too late?
Moreover, there is the small matter of Bilbo’s impending confrontation with a dragon. Yes, he’s done it before, and he was terrified then, too. Now, he knows exactly what Smaug is capable of, precisely the feeling of having a dragon attempt to slither into one’s mind and corrupt one’s thinking. He knows exactly what the Arkenstone is capable of, besides, and he knows what the treasure in the mountain is going to do to Thorin. And he knows that he will need to take advantage of Smaug’s presence and force the dragon to unknowingly destroy the ring somehow without accidentally adding the One Ring to an already massive hoard, thereby empowering the creature to do great harm.
The dragon is not the greatest threat, whispers a slimy voice in Bilbo’s mind. Thorin Oakenshield seeks to possess every treasure he sees. He could easily take your Precious from you if he wished.
Bilbo very nearly takes the ring out of his pocket and leaves it on the cold ground of the desolation. He can see the battered skyline of a ruined city in the middle distance. When did they get so close to Dale? For how long, exactly, has Bilbo been trapped in his own thoughts? Oh, this blasted ring! Yes, Bilbo would do well to leave it here!
But no. He knows that he wouldn’t be able to give it up so easily if the ring didn’t want to be given up. Probably, the Valar-forsaken thing would be over the moon if Bilbo simply handed it over to Thorin. He’d like to think highly of his love, of course, but Bilbo knows in his heart that Thorin would not be able to part with the ring once he had it, would not be able to see through its influence until after it was too late. After all, the Arkenstone is nothing compared to the ring.
Bilbo, on the other hand, has parted with the ring before, when it was stronger and had a tighter hold on him. So it will be no trouble to part with it now, he assures himself. He can handle it, and he’s going to have to. If it isn’t him, then it will be Frodo, and that will be far worse. Anyway, on top of all of that, Bilbo has arrived at a significant hitch in his plan. If he destroys the ring while the dragon still lives, then he will not have the ability to turn invisible during the Battle of the Five Armies. The last time, he had a great advantage and still was not able to warn Thorin and the lads in time to save them. Now, Bilbo will be without this advantage, and he’ll have to come up with a new plan that will probably involve a lot more fighting than he had to do the last time.
“You alright there, Bilbo?” Bombur asks from beside him. Since when is Bombur beside him?
Perhaps it’s only Bilbo’s imagination, but the sun seems lower on the horizon than it was when last he looked. Bilbo does not recall losing so much time to the ring on his first adventure. But then, he wouldn’t, would he? He had no reason to fear the little trinket. He did not understand what it truly was. He could have lost hours of the journey and never been any the wiser.
All of these thoughts together are perfect fuel for nightmares. On the first night, Bilbo dreams of Thorin’s death again. He wakes abruptly, then falls asleep again to watch the lads drowning in molten gold while Thorin stares on placidly, entirely corrupted by dragon sickness. On the second night, he wakes up to find the king wrapped around him, holding him close against the chilly Northern air.
The two of them have been setting their bedrolls side by side without a word about it since they left Lake-town. It would be silly not to, now that they’ve spent the past month in each other’s arms. But Thorin seems to be just as preoccupied as Bilbo is (no great wonder, that) and therefore equally content to simply allow the situation to unfold as it will without a running commentary. Neither of them needs further clarification. Bilbo knows what he is to Thorin because Dáin told him twenty years ago, sixty years in the future, on a timeline that will hopefully never come to pass. Thorin knows what he is to Bilbo because Bilbo made it abundantly clear at the market in Lake-town. So, that’s that, then.
If all goes well, they’ll be able to make a more formal arrangement after the battle. And if not… well. Bilbo cannot think about what will happen if all does not go well. Perhaps it wouldn’t be so bad. If Thorin does not survive the battle, if Bilbo fails another time, he might be compelled to simply pitch himself into Mount Doom and have done with it. For one dark moment, he wonders if perhaps that was Galadriel’s intent. Did she truly show him his future, or did she merely show him a series of images that she knew would have him agree to her plan? If she could see into his mind, surely she would know what losing Thorin again might do to Bilbo. And those boys!
“You were talking in your sleep,” Thorin informs Bilbo.
He worries at his lower lip. That’s not good. Just how often does he do this? Is there some possibility that Thorin has heard his mutterings before, the dialogue from previous nightmares, and leapt to conclusions? Bilbo is uneasy with his lack of knowledge of the things he says while in the grip of his trauma. And the ring, which certainly does not make things easier.
It would be easy for him, the ring taunts Bilbo. He could take your precious away. Kill him now and stop him. He would not expect it. He’d let you do it.
It is pulling out all the stops this time, doing everything in its power to regain control of Bilbo. To gain control of Bilbo, he corrects himself. Whatever influence it had on him during his first lifetime does not seem to have carried over. But its power is comparatively weak, and Bilbo’s mission is too important for him to entertain such ideas. Also, Thorin would sooner chop off his own hand than rifle through Bilbo’s pockets while he slept. After all, if he didn’t do it while he was overcome by dragon sickness, then he’s not likely to do it while he’s more or less in his right mind.
And even the ring could not believe that Bilbo would ever deliberately harm Thorin. No. It must want Bilbo to give in, to simply hand it over to Thorin and have done with it. To believe that he is protecting himself by doing so. But he will not allow Thorin to suffer as he and Frodo have.
“You were muttering about fire and gold,” Thorin breathes when Bilbo does not say anything. “I could not stand by and do nothing when it was clear that you were suffering.”
“How often do you do this for me?” Bilbo asks around his dry throat. He wishes there were something to do to get the ring to stop whispering to him, but he knows that is far too much to ask. He knows he should not be worrying right now about Thorin’s hands in his hair, Thorin watching him sleep, Thorin going out of his way to care for him on the eve of what the king likely believes will be a great success.
“Your dreams trouble you.” Thorin’s non-answer is answer enough for Bilbo’s purposes. “Why is that?”
Bilbo swallows. How is he supposed to respond to a question like that? So he gives his own non-answer: “Because I am on a quest to slay a dragon, and I am terrified that I will fail.”
“You will not fail,” Thorin assures him. He seems to actually believe this. “The Wizard would not have sent you if you were poorly suited to the mission.”
Bilbo attempts to sit up on the bedroll, but he doesn’t get very far with Thorin’s arms encircling him. They may not be talking about it, but that doesn’t mean it isn’t happening. Bilbo would never have dared to dream about anything like this the first time around. “You trust Gandalf now?” That seems highly unlikely.
“You heard him telling Elrond at Rivendell about how important it was to see Erebor reclaimed,” Thorin replies. The anger lurking in his tone is unmistakable and clears up Bilbo’s misapprehension immediately. “He would not put his own plan at risk by sending someone who could not complete the task.”
“I don’t know,” Bilbo grumbles, “I don’t think he’s half as bright as people imagine he is. I mean, really. What did he think was going to happen, having us walk through Thranduil’s realm? And sending us over the Misty Mountains when he knew there were goblins there? Always leaving off, going one way or another… I don’t think he has any clue what he’s doing at all. He should be with us now.” Is this Bilbo’s own justified resentment at the Wizard’s erratic behavior, or is it the ring which causes him to feel this way?
“He should not,” Thorin muses, adjusting his grip on Bilbo so that those big hands spread out across the Hobbit’s ribcage. “The first sight of Erebor should be for Durin’s folk and those we claim as kin. I would not share it with a meddling vagabond.”
Bilbo lets that hang in the air. He does not ask Thorin if this means that he claims Bilbo as kin. More likely than not, Thorin would have no qualms if the wizard suddenly reappeared and offered his aid in fighting the dragon. Bilbo would not be surprised if this were only Thorin’s way of easing his own nerves. A discussion of this nature at this juncture would likely not be wise, Bilbo decides, nestling into Thorin’s embrace and pretending to go back to sleep.
The interval on the doorstep is much less tense than Bilbo remembers it being. He takes a pear out of his pack and munches on it while he leans against the spot where he knows the door will be. Bilbo has gone in and out of it so many times by now; there is no doubt in his mind of its location. Finally, he has completed the second step of his plan. Bilbo got the company through their adventure a second time, and now everyone is whole and hale and poised for entry to the Lonely Mountain. He has every reason in the world to be as relieved as he is. The others stare at him incredulously.
“Something you’re not telling us, laddie?” Glóin inquires testily. He is perhaps getting a little sick of eating dried fish, which does not bode well for the time that Bilbo knows they will spend stuck in the mountain with their meagre rations alone. “You seem comfortable."
“Tomorrow is Durin’s day,” Thorin reports, looking very tense indeed. His jaw is set and his eyes do not leave the side of the mountain. Bilbo pretends that this has nothing to do with the gold inside, that this time, his love has rescued Thorin from the terrible fate that awaits him. He knows it isn’t true, of course, but he cannot help but indulge in a little bit of wishful thinking. If he starts fretting, the rest of the company will start fretting.
“Then we’ll have to wait until tomorrow, won’t we?” Bilbo puts on a casual tone. From the look that Fíli shoots him, at least one person is aware that their Burglar’s thoughts are not truly so rosy, but Bilbo thinks he can count on the crown prince to keep his secret.
“I think we should figure out a plan before then,” Balin decrees. Bilbo can recognize that this would likely be very helpful, were there anything to make a plan about.
“I don’t think that’s really necessary,” he explains gently, rather than raising his voice to point out that they should’ve made a plan before they left the Blue Mountains. “The moon runes were quite clear. The thrush will be along at the keyhole sometime tomorrow, to show us where it is, and then all we’ve got to do is wait for the moon to rise and show us where to put the key.”
Actually, Bilbo could probably find the keyhole without the last light of Durin’s day, but he neglects to mention this to the company, let alone to try it out. After all, it is best not to fiddle with the timing of things. He gave Bard a particular date for the dragon attack, and he does not want to trigger the carnage too early when the bowman will be unprepared.
“You think it is the moon?” Dwalin does not sound particularly convinced.
“The sun is not truly the last light of any day, is it?” Bilbo asks, putting on a smug expression. “That’d be the moon. So we’ll have to look out for a thrush, wait for the moon to rise, and unlock the door. Simple.”
Thorin rather abruptly falls to his knees before Bilbo, so that the pair of them are at eye level. He’s been doing this a lot lately, as he never did on their first journey together.Before Bilbo can make sense of what is happening, he is in the king’s arms once again. He shouldn’t be so taken off guard, considering how often this happens, but he knows he’ll never get used to it. “Oh, my clever Burglar,” Thorin mutters into Bilbo’s hair. “What would we do without you?”
Ah, yes. Yet another difference. “Your gratitude is much appreciated,” Bilbo admits, “Though getting inside is only half the battle.”
“A lot less than half, I’d say.” Balin is entirely correct, though he has no way of knowing about anything that will come to pass, let aloneBilbo’s plans to challenge fate.
“Oh, sure, but the other seventy percent is really just logistics,” Bofur reasons, “Once Bilbo gets inside, all we’ve got to do is kill the dragon. There’s fourteen of us and only one of him, so that shouldn’t be too much trouble.”
Bombur takes the liberty of elbowing his brother in the side, for which Bilbo is thankful. It would have been a great feat indeed, worming out of Thorin’s embrace just to smack Bofur upside the head, but he’d have done it if necessary. “Now is not the time to jest,” Thorin declares, though he does not release Bilbo. “We are on the threshold of our kingdom. The time has come to reclaim what was taken from us.”
The sight of them must be comical for the rest of their company. In fact, Bilbo can see that both princes are making a valiant effort to fight off laughter. Nori wears an amused expression as he fiddles with his knife, and Ori is furiously scribbling something in a leather book he managed to obtain in Lake-town. Bilbo hopes that the lad is composing a song or a poem about the heroism of the King and the Burglar, but more likely than not, it’s actually a piece about the way that they are touching right now. Thorin’s intentions, at least, are undeniable.
“You should let him breathe, Uncle!” Kíli calls eventually, which is very bold, considering Thorin just made it clear that he would not entertain joking comments at this time. “We’ll have no chance against Smaug with a squashed Burglar.”
“And some of us would like to preserve our innocence for as long as we can,” Fíli grumbles.
“Oh, aye, you’ve been preserving that a long time,” Bofur shoots back with a wide smile.
“Even here, upon the face of Erebor, my own subjects do not listen to me,” Thorin pouts, though there is something playful about it.
Of course. The king must be nearing hysterics, and why would he not be? For decades, he has wandered, kept away from this home of his which has ever meant so much to him. Now, here he is, so close to entering the mountain and yet so very far away.
“Oh, quit griping.” Bilbo isn’t sure whether he has any right to be as proud of himself as he is with his successful restoration of a cheerful mood. After all, cheerful or not, they’re all going to have to face a dragon in the coming days. And with the entire company present, things will undoubtedly be different than they were the first time, even if Bilbo didn’t intend to destroy the ring. He won’t have the advantage of complete foreknowledge from this point on. “You have to let them cope with what’s to come in their own ways.”
Thorin doesn’t seem to like this course of action, but he doesn’t argue with Bilbo, either. Then again, he also refuses to take his hands off of the Hobbit for several hours after this. But Bilbo will humor being used as a security blanket if it has any chance of preventing the onset of dragon sickness.
The next evening, Bilbo finds himself inside the mountain, just like last time. The actual opening of the door was much less climactic than it was on the original adventure; the company simply waited until the moon was in the sky and placed the key in the keyhole when the light shone on it. Bilbo was right about the placement of the keyhole, by the way, and could have gotten in at any time if he’d so chosen. But he is not going to complain about a delay in having to face Smaug once more.
It’s just as terrible as it was the first time, though for different reasons. Before, when Balin walked him inside, Bilbo was distracted by the uncertainty of what lay before him. Now, Bilbo is distracted by the certain knowledge of everything that will come to pass. The treasure hoards will pose a challenge for Thorin no matter what, and there is only so much Bilbo can do to help him. The Arkenstone is down there, and the dragon, and Bilbo is confronting them both with a Ring of Power in his pocket. And not just any Ring of Power, either. What could possibly go wrong?
“Are you alright, lad?” Balin asks, placing a gentle, paternal hand on Bilbo’s shoulder. Well, not paternal, exactly. Bungo Baggins would probably pick his son up and carry him as far away from the dragon as he could get, could he see what was happening. And Bilbo knows that if he ever found Frodo in his present situation, he’d have to sit on his hands to keep himself from intervening. Case in point: he did exactly that during the council at Rivendell, and a fat lot of good it did him, too.
“Fine,” Bilbo chokes out, “Just about to face a dragon, is all.”
“Thorin did not come up with very much of a plan for this section of the journey,” Balin admits.
“Watch over him for me,” Bilbo advises. He only means that Balin should keep an eye on Thorin while Bilbo is alone inside the mountain with Smaug, but of course, it sounds much worse than that to poor Balin.
“Bilbo—“
“You know that this treasure carries… some sort of curse,” Bilbo elaborates, “Just… please make sure that Thorin is well. The princes, too.”
“Thorin won’t be well until he knows that his intended is safe and the dragon is slain.”
“It’s news to me that I am his intended,” Bilbo quips. “I don’t think putting his hand on my back and refusing to let me out of his sight necessarily constitutes a proposal.” It would be improper and reckless to talk about the kissing right now. “And for the record, I do hope he doesn’t expect me to go slaying the dragon.”
“He knows how you feel,” Balin decides, refusing to take the ridiculous bait that Bilbo has set for him. Nobody in their right mind could believe that Thorin seriously expects Bilbo to slay a dragon for him. “And you know how he feels. That’s enough for the heart, if not for the law. And what the two of you were doing in the Marketplace only happens between Ones.” His eyes twinkle, and his smile is knowing, as though he thinks that he and Bilbo are co-conspirators in some sort of inside understanding.
Bilbo sucks in a breath. Does he know how Thorin feels? Yes. Yes, and that knowledge has brought him a surprising amount of pain, because Thorin’s expressiveness on this journey has been a direct contradiction to the way he treated Bilbo the last time. If Thorin loves and trusts Bilbo now, and this is how he behaves, how did he feel about the Hobbit before? He clearly cared for Bilbo enough to give him a mithril coat, but not enough to defend him so passionately from every threat, real or perceived. If he had more time, Bilbo would revel in the conflicting emotions that have begun to bloom inside his ribcage in response to Balin’s words. But he does not have time. Every moment that he spends with the ring, it digs a few more of its foul roots into his mind. Every fraction of a second that it stays in his pocket, he becomes less able to destroy it.
“Right,” Bilbo says, steeling himself. He didn’t linger this long in the passageway the last time. This is a waste of seconds that he really cannot spare. What if Smaug wakes up before Bilbo gets down there? “Can’t argue with that. I’ll be off, then.” He seriously considers just going ahead without a further word, but remembering his plan, it occurs to Bilbo that there is some chance that things will go differently this time than they did the last time. “Balin, if I don’t— if the worst happens, will you tell Thorin that…” Oh, how to put it into words? “Will you tell Thorin that—“
“I will, laddie, I will.” Balin does not patronize Bilbo by pretending that it won’t be necessary, or that he doesn’t understand what the Hobbit means. It may very well be necessary, and Bilbo’s meaning could not be more clear, after the conversation they’ve just had. And Balin is a good friend, whether he is leading Bilbo down the passage to his death or no.
Bilbo follows the same path into the treasury that he took the last time. He steps over piles upon piles of gold, more riches than any one creature could ever hope to enjoy. He makes no effort to quiet the racket he is making, knowing as he does that he was just as loud prior to his first confrontation with the dragon. He ignores the lovely Dwarven architecture of which he knows that Thorin is so proud, the lovely carvings from a type of green stone that Bilbo cannot, for the life of him, identify. It shines, and it sparkles, and even Bilbo, even a Hobbit, even one who has done all of this before, must close his eyes for a moment against the sheer brilliance of it, the desire that the hoard engenders to take and take and take.
The beast wakes, naturally. Smaug opens his eyes and breathes fire and makes threats, just as before. Clever though the dragon may be, he cannot see into the Hobbit’s mind, as was Bilbo’s fear when first they had this conversation. If Smaug knew who Bilbo was, or how he had come to be here in Erebor once again, he would not repeat the same tired quotations that he used the first time. But Smaug appears to be reading from the same script.
Bilbo refuses to listen to the dragon’s words this time around. He forces himself to shut his ears, to focus on other things, and pays just enough attention to get his own two cents in. He knows the dangers of listening to dragon speech, and even with his careful inattention, he begins to wonder if Smaug might not have a point. If Bilbo’s friends might not be deceiving him. But, no. Smaug is a manipulative creature who does not know any member of the company as well as Bilbo does. And if Bilbo can resist the One Ring, can tell it to shut its mouth and leave him alone, please and thank you, then he can resist the warbling of a silly little dragon. A silly little dragon that could kill him by breathing in his direction.
Bilbo reluctantly slips the ring onto his finger, trying frantically to remember his exact dialogue in the heat of a scorching moment. But Bilbo has the confidence of foresight and hindsight. He has done this all before. He knows what makes Smaug angry, and he knows what the dragon likes. Just as he did with Gollum, Bilbo pulls the riddles he used before out from his memory and recites them again, with a little more showmanship and a little less fear. There is no reason why this should not work. Besides, Bilbo has the advantage of knowing when Smaug is going to attack, how he’s going to move, and what that’s going to do to the treasure. His memory isn’t perfect, but he has a better understanding this time than he did the last time about how the mounds of treasure happen to be balanced. All things considered, his conversation with Smaug is not much different from the way it was the last time.
It all feels a little bit pointless, this expedition of his. The last time, he was sent to see what waited in the mountain and, theoretically, to steal the Arkenstone back from Smaug. Now, Bilbo is here exclusively to wake the dragon so that he can be killed. How? How can the company kill the beast?
Something occurs to Bilbo, then, something so obvious that he’s a little ashamed not to have thought of it before. All that work to protect the people of Lake-town! But that is not true. No. Bilbo did what he could for them, of course. He warned Bard, and he felt terrible about vouching for Thorin, but the best possible outcome involves the dragon attacking Lake-town. If Smaug flies into Bard’s trap, he will be killed. If the company has to face him, they will all be burnt to a crisp. If Thorin and company had some secret weapon hiding up their sleeves, they would have used it the first time around.
Bilbo can tell himself all he likes that Kíli is their best archer, and that he was not here the first time around, but the fact stands that Kíli does not have a black arrow. And even if he did, he does not have a bow large enough from which to fire it. Moreover, Smaug would never allow the lad into a position to even see the broken spot on his underbelly, even if the company were able to procure some sort of miniature wind lance. Bard is, and always has been, their only hope. Bilbo should have introduced himself as Barrel-rider and had done with it. If he wanted a clean conscience, he’d have done better to stop Thorin from entering the Mountain at all. He has been a fool to think otherwise.
Bilbo ignores the glow of the Arkenstone when it flashes at him from amongst the coins. When the dragon moves, displacing more gold and covering the stone with shiny coins, Bilbo feels genuine relief. The decision has been taken out of his hands.
Even giving that meddlesome rock to Bard and Thranduil did not prevent Thorin’s destructive actions. Bilbo knows that having the Arkenstone would be worse for Thorin than not having it, but he also knows that collecting the Arkenstone will ultimately result in Thorin’s death. He was strong enough last time to resist handing it over, but what he did with it only made things worse. Besides, last time, Thorin actually let Bilbo out of his sight long enough that he could sneak down to the army below and deliver the Arkenstone. At this point, Bilbo is not convinced that the king will leave him to his own devices long enough to take a breath of fresh air. Thorin was bad enough in Lake-town, without the influence of a cursed hoard hanging over him. Who knows how he’ll treat Bilbo when he’s reclaimed his Mountain and the treasure it contains?
But most importantly, Bilbo has another priority. He must destroy the ring. He cannot allow it to threaten him any longer. Maybe, he tells himself, the Arkenstone had nothing to do with it. Maybe it was the ring which corrupted Thorin, all those years ago. Perhaps he became so covetous through sheer proximity to the thing, never knowing why. Perhaps that is why he recovered only in Bilbo’s absence.
You fool, the ring hisses, Do not give up your chance to save the one you love. The Dwarf will suffer greatly from his madness if you destroy the only thing that could control his mind.
Control his mind? Even if Bilbo believed that this were possible (which he doesn’t, knowing Thorin Oakenshield), he would not wish to do it. The ring seems to believe, for reasons unbeknownst to him, that Bilbo craves power. That he wishes to wed Thorin for the scepter he would wield as Consort Under the Mountain rather than for the love of the king. “You’re the fool,” Bilbo mutters.
The way forward is clear enough. He finds a convenient pillar, which he hopes is heat resistant, like the ones in the forges. It must be, if it is still standing after decades of Smaug’s occupation. At least, Bilbo must tell himself as much. He may die in this venture. “Over here, O Smaug, great and terrible!” He calls. Then he wrenches the ring off his finger with no small amount of difficulty and sets it on the other side of the pillar, behind a golden cup. The very same golden cup that inspired his invention in his book.
He should keep the ring. He should cling to it forever. He should let it help him, let it grant him invisibility. The ring will not hurt Frodo if Bilbo only keeps it close. It will grant him what he wishes. It will give him the power to protect the ones he loves. Azog and Bolg are stupid and weak, blinded by their senseless desire for revenge. With a little cunning and a little magic borrowed from the ring, Bilbo can kill them easily. But he need not choose to do so. The ring could give Bilbo the power to make them both suffer, to punish them for harming those close to him. Why struggle through a battle, blind to what the future holds, when he could change it all with a wave of his hand?
These thoughts are only the ring trying to manipulate him. He had it last time, and it didn’t help him protect Thorin. He kept it very close, and still, it did unspeakable damage to poor Frodo. Whether or not it is capable of these feats, the ring will not perform them. If Bilbo keeps it, the ring will break its promises and twist his mind. This single, stupid piece of metal nearly killed Bilbo’s nephew, tortured him, in fact, and now it is using Thorin and the lads to try and lure Bilbo into letting it do the same thing again. Bilbo has cast it off before, when its power was much greater than it is at the moment, and Bilbo’s spirit much weaker, to boot. If he could place the ring into Gandalf’s envelope and walk out of Bag End with his pockets empty, then he can just as easily do this. For Frodo. If nothing else, Bilbo can do this for Frodo. As Smaug lumbers over, he wrenches the little metal circle off his finger and throws it down in front of the pillar.
It is agony, not stepping forward to rescue his ring. Even in its weakened state, he can feel it calling for him, screaming his name, begging for help. He can feel its pain, its rage, its betrayal. The ring will not forget if he leaves it, but of course it will forgive him if he takes it. If he steps into the dragon fire and puts the ring back on, it will take care of him. It will give him the courage to save the ones he loves. Does he really think he can do it on his own? Does he really think that one little Hobbit without the power of invisibility can save Thorin from himself? And then the ring is silent.
“Are you dead yet?” Smaug roars. Bilbo comes to his senses. No, he isn’t dead, by some miracle.
It is the luck of Hobbits, or the indestructible nature of Dwarven stonework, or the kind act of some Vala who would prefer not to see three Sons of Durin and a Baggins of Bag End dead on a mountainside. Not that Bilbo thinks the Lady Yavanna has any power over stone or fire. No, if he was saved by anyone, it was his Lady’s husband, to whom he will be grateful for the rest of time.
“Were you trying to kill me, o Smaug the magnificent? I had thought that an estimable dragon lord such as yourself would be able to think of a much more creative method for doing away with a puny little creature like me.” He can’t very well make himself invisible, he realizes belatedly, and he just practically asked the dragon to come and kill him. Really, Bilbo has forgotten the perils of thinking on his feet. He’s been spoiled, with all this foreknowledge. But no more.
“Is that so?” Smaug turns around, presumably for dramatic effect. Bilbo takes advantage of this to reach out and fumble for the ring. He must make sure that it was really destroyed. For a moment, he does not find it, and he is willing to believe it dissolved, as Elrond promised him it would. Then, his finger brushes the familiar metal circle, and his hopes are dashed. The One Ring is fully intact.“You ask very much of me, thief. I must entertain you with a creative death?”
Well. That plan failed. Bilbo’s body is buzzing with the terrible realization that he has failed to destroy the ring, and the grateful knowledge that, at the very least, he will be able to make a clean break with it on his finger. He slips it on and nothing happens. He takes it off again and puts it on again and once more, nothing happens. Has the ring forsaken him? Is it able to refuse its power to those it deems unworthy? There is no response, and that is how Bilbo knows that something has changed. The ring could never resist an opportunity to criticize him and increase his reliance upon its power.
But he doesn’t have much time to think about it now as he takes advantage of Smaug’s distraction and dashes down the closest narrow passage he can find. It is the same one that he took before. At least he remembers that much. Ring or no ring, Bilbo must now run for his life.
Bilbo races up the stairs as fast as his legs will carry him. It’s odd. What little rational thought still remains inside his head reminds him that he has done this before and been successful, and yet he just can’t quite bring himself to shed his fear. He knows that the attitudes and actions of his companions have been altered by small changes in Bilbo’s behavior; it only makes sense to think that the dragon would be much the same way. For all he knows, Smaug will be even worse this time around. He can’t let his guard down quite yet. And, distracted by his own thoughts, Bilbo nearly barrels into Thorin at the top of the stairs.
“You’re alive,” the king breathes with palpable relief.
“And no thanks to the dragon behind me.” Bilbo does not have time for an emotional reunion. He can appreciate that Thorin must have been very scared by the loud noises and obvious bursts of heat that he witnessed from his position outside the mountain, but now is not the time to talk about it. Also, Bilbo knows what is coming, and he wants to avoid it if he can. Maybe it’ll be different if he handles the situation differently.
“Did you find the Arkenstone?” So, not very different at all, then.
“There is a dragon chasing me, Thorin!” Bilbo takes his usual tack and addresses Thorin directly. Calling him on his nonsense, as he’s been doing this entire trip.
But it isn’t enough. Bilbo can tell from Thorin’s eyes that the madness has already begun to take root. “The Arkenstone! Did you find it?”
“I didn’t even begin to look,” Bilbo hedges. There is still time for things to go differently, he reminds himself. Thorin may surprise him yet. “I was preoccupied. You know, with the dragon?”
Bilbo tries to step forward to join Thorin in the doorwaybut the king blocks his exit with his sword. It isn’t Orcrist, but it’s still a good blade, and even the dullest of swords could do irreparable damage to Bilbo, especially in Thorin’s practiced hands. “You are not thinking clearly,” Bilbo tries. He has to try, not just for his own sake, but for Thorin’s as well.
Those intense blue eyes do not leave him as Thorin twists his wrist, realigning his sword so that it is pointed directly at Bilbo’s chest. Thorin doesn’t even blink. This has happened before, so Bilbo should not be so troubled by it, should not be trembling as he is. He knows that Thorin will not kill him, after all. But he is shaking with the realization that there is nothing he can do to prevent the dragon sickness from taking root. Bilbo has been kind to Thorin, has given him the benefit of the doubt, shown him nothing but compassion and cut him more slack than he deserved at many points on the journey. Bilbo has indulged the king’s over-protective nonsense and fed him affirmations on countless occasions when he would’ve been well within his rights to stomp off like he did the first time. All of it the product of a foolish hope that Bilbo’s affection alone could be enough to stave off dragon sickness. All of it deriving from the naive belief that the first time, it had been Bilbo’s fault for not loving Thorin properly, not doing enough to help him avoid the call of the treasure and the madness that would claim him.
And it has all been for naught. No, Thorin will not kill Bilbo. He does not have time to do so, and he must know that he’ll be hard-pressed to get his hands on the Arkenstone without a Burglar by his side, but he is apparently perfectly content to point his sword at the one loves. He is already not himself, and this will only get worse, the more time he spends in the Mountain. And this is where Bilbo’s plans begin to fall apart, because he may have fighting spiders and escaping from Elves well in hand, but he does not know how to help someone who is suffering from Dragon sickness. If he did, he would be with Yavanna now, waiting for Thorin to join him after many years of successful rule.
The last time, Bilbo merely stood there in shocked silence, watching in horror and waiting to see what Thorin would do. He genuinely believed that the king would see reason on his own. Now, Bilbo knows better. He is not surprised in the slightest. He led Thorin to Erebor, into this obvious trap, toward the hoard that Bilbo knew would make him sick. He has no right to be shocked that his king is now showing symptoms of that sickness.
“I did not think,” Bilbo speaks up, which may be a very stupid thing to do. After all, Thorin did not kill him the last time, when Bilbo was silent. He really should be doing everything the same. But some small, foolish part of him still wants to prove that he is able to save Thorin with his words alone. That he can mend whatever the dragon sickness has broken and protect Thorin from the worst of it. “I did not think that you would be pleased, to come down to your treasure halls and find me burned to a crisp and the Arkenstone destroyed by dragon fire in my hands.”
He does not know why he thinks that will have any any effect. Thorin only stares at him with those sharp, molten eyes. “No,” he agrees, jabbing at Bilbo with the tip of his sword. This is not good at all. “I would not be pleased.”
They continue to stare at each other. Bilbo is waiting for the dragon, hoping that Smaug’s arrival will force Thorin back to his senses. Thorin is apparently waiting for Bilbo to produce the Arkenstone from somewhere on his person. There isn’t much logic to all of this. If Thorin wants Bilbo to rush back down and steal the Arkenstone, he should probably ease up with the sword and let the burglar get back to his burglary. But that does not happen. Thorin’s eyes do not leave Bilbo’s.
The sound of footsteps breaks whatever trace they’d both fallen into. “Uncle?” Fíli calls. He steps into Bilbo’s line of sight, and it’s clear that he, at least, has witnessed more than he should’ve. He can see Thorin pointing a sword at Bilbo. “What are you doing?” The lad reaches for his own blade, and Bilbo doesn’t know whether Fíli intends to join Thorin in his attack or to defend Bilbo if it comes to it.
Thorin continues to stare at Bilbo, the fire in his eyes rapidly cooling into a sort of stunned shock. He heaves out a heavy breath, glances down at his sword arm, and quickly lowers his blade. “By Mahal, I—“ His eyes are wide and frantic, panicked, which is not good.
“It’s alright, Thorin,” Bilbo assures him, grabbing the king by the arm and steering him back just as the dragon begins lumbering toward them. Thank the Valar for Fíli, though Bilbo doesn’t know why the lad’s voice was more effective than his own in combatting Thorin’s dragon sickness. “I’m not angry with you.” How could he be? It isn’t Thorin’s fault that he’s succumbed to an ancient curse he did not believe in. It is Bilbo’s fault for knowing this would happen and bringing Thorin here anyway. “But we really need to go.”
The rest of the company bursts out of the shadows. From the looks on their faces, they didn’t witness anything to make them question their loyalty to Thorin. Fíli, however, wears a troubled expression, and opens his mouth as though to voice a question better not asked. Bilbo shakes his head at the lad. Now is not the time to discuss dragon sickness and the impact that it’s already begun to have on Thorin. Bilbo would like to help, of course, but for the moment, their primary concern is getting away from the dragon that is chasing them.
“You will burn!” Smaug roars, and Bilbo barely has time to drag Thorin through the nearest passageway before the dragon is breathing fire at them.
This time, Bilbo is the last one through the door, using force he didn’t know he had inside his body to urge Thorin forward. His king can point a hundred swords at Bilbo, and it will not change a thing about the way he feels. Bilbo will protect Thorin if it’s the last thing he does, and it may very well be, because Bilbo can feel dragon fire on his back, burning the nice blue tunic that he picked up in Lake-town. Instinctively, he flops to the ground and rolls a little, putting out the flame.
“Bilbo!” Thorin cries, rushing to Bilbo’s side when he really should be rushing away from the dragon that is chasing them. Oh, this is not good at all. Bilbo has distracted Thorin from the task at hand twice over. “You are hurt.”
“I am not,” Bilbo protests, sitting up. It stings a bit, yes, but the pain is by no means agonizing. His tunic got the worst of it, and anyway, the rush of battle is working wonders for him at the moment. “We have to keep going. Óin can see to my back later.”
“Aye,” Óin agrees, “It looks like a second-degree burn to me. Nothing that can’t wait, though I’d like to get it bandaged once we’re through this fight.”
The fire returns to Thorin’s eyes. For some reason, this, too, feels wrong to Bilbo. Something is off, and he can’t put his finger on it. “That worm hurt you.” If he heard his cousin’s words just now, he does not react to them.
“Yes, well, he is a dragon,” Bilbo reasons, scrambling to his feet before attempting to pull Thorin up as well. “They do tend to do that sort of thing.” He doesn’t feel the need to remind Thorin that Smaug has hurt many of his kin already.
“Come on, Uncle,” Kíli urges. “We must keep going. Is there another way out?”
“Yes.” Thorin breathes. He does not sound well at all. Bilbo tries to steady him with a hand on his bicep, but the effects are unclear as Thorin begins shouting directions and the company scrambles to follow.
Bilbo can think of little other than his aching legs and the change in Thorin as they navigate the passages of Erebor. He cannot bring himself to pay attention. He can barely bring himself to move his body forward, step by step. If he were thinking clearly, he might steer them away from the entryway, where he and he alone knows what they will find. But he does not think of it. He’s thinking only of the rage and dread that he saw in Thorin’s eyes, the danger that all of them are in, and the uncertain expression on Fíli’s face when he walked in on Thorin and Bilbo with the sword.
When they enter the hall of corpses, Kíli grabs Bilbo by the arm and exclaims in Khuzdul. “Our kin,” he breathes in the common tongue. “They are our kin.”
On the first adventure, the lads did not have to see this. They did not have to watch the utter despair on their uncle’s face before he schooled his expression into something more worthy of a fearless leader. They did not have to listen to him calling their dead subjects cowards. Truthfully, this is not Thorin’s greatest moment, though Bilbo knows it will not be his worst, either.
He does not quite know why Kíli is clinging to him, though. Perhaps the archer simply knows better than to try and seek out comfort from his uncle right now. “It’s alright, my lad,” Bilbo assures him, “We’re going to make it out.”
“I know.” Kíli releases Bilbo instantly, as though remembering himself. “But—“
He is cut off by Thorin shouting orders at the company once again. Fíli stands behind his uncle like a shadow, watching, waiting. Now that they are in their kingdom, ruined as it may be, they are each of them every inch the royal. Bilbo could stand here and marvel, were he not busy following Thorin to what might become their doom.
But Bilbo does follow. He scuttles along dutifully, ignoring any pain that he might feel in his back and waiting for instructions from Thorin, which, when he receives them, he follows to the best of his ability. Just like last time. They wind up near the forges once again. Apparently, not enough has changed on this journey to dissuade Thorin from enacting his utterly foolish scheme.
“The plan’s not gonna work,” Dwalin announces. He is wrong, but Bilbo can forgive him that. It does seem downright ridiculous. “These furnaces are stone cold.”
“He’s right. We’ve no fire hot enough to set them ablaze,” Balin agrees, matter of factly.
“Have we not?” Thorin demands.
Bilbo would very much like not to be distracted right now, but he feels something in his guts watching Thorin take charge this way. Part of it is guilt, of course. After all, it is Bilbo’s fault that Thorin never truly got a chance to rule his beloved mountain. But part of it is something else, something Bilbo did not want to unpack eighty years ago and does not particularly want to unpack now. It matters very little, anyway. Now would hardly be the appropriate time to initiate another kiss, especially considering what Bilbo now knows about the significance of such gestures in Dwarven society. Bilbo can’t afford to be distracted, and it would be unthinkable to do anything that might distract Thorin at this juncture. He cannot undo what he has already done, and he knows there is little he can do to assuage Thorin’s constant worry, but at the very least, Bilbo can stop himself from making things worse. They can lock lips all they like when they’ve escaped this mountain with their lives.
“I did not look to see you so easily outwitted!” Thorin yells in the dragon’s general direction while the company stares on in shock. “You have grown slow and fat in your dotage! Slug!” He turns to his people, as though it is completely normal for a king to deliberately provoke a dragon into blowing fire at him. “Take cover, go!”
“This is suicide,” Nori grumbles from beside Bilbo. But Dori is hauling his brother behind a pillar with hurried admonitions before the Hobbit can say anything. Whether Thorin’s plan is solid or not, the fact remains that Smaug is about to breathe fire at all of them, and the best thing they can do is follow their king’s instructions.
Bilbo knows from his brief interval staying with Dáin that the pillars in the furnace chamber are built to resist fire, which makes him slightly more confident ducking behind one of them than he was the first time around. Truly, Bilbo believed that he was going to die. He supposes that none of the company were in a position to explain it to him, and does not blame any of them, but his fear at the time was entirely genuine. Now, at least, he has a better idea of what is going on. He cowers behind a pillar and waits for the fire to pass.
Smaug is not half as clever as he believes, if he fell victim so easily to Thorin’s manipulation. Probably, he didn’t know about the pillars, either, and he thought that he’d make quick work of the company, whether that meant lighting the furnaces or not. But he plays right into Thorin’s practiced hands. It would be impressive, maybe, if the entire situation weren’t so ridiculous. There’s a good reason why Bilbo left this sequence out of his book. It all feels very silly, now that he’s not distracted by the fear of death and confusion about why Thorin threatened to impale him in the name of a single stupid rock.
As Bilbo mulls things over, Thorin shouts more orders to the company, directing them to carry out his latest hare-brained scheme. Honestly, if Bilbo didn’t know for a fact that this would work, he’d have intervened now three times over. Fíli seems to be having similar thoughts, and he meets Bilbo’s eyes once again with a look of utter bafflement.
Bilbo is too far away to reassure the prince, and in many respects, he’s glad of that. What could he say? Oh, don’t worry, I know it seems like your uncle is going mad, and he very much is, but I happen to know from the last time I did all of this that we’ll all survive to the end of the night! And if I can get my act together in time for the battle only I know is coming, you might even live to be king some day!
“Bilbo!” Thorin calls, shaking the Hobbit from his thoughts. “Up there, on my mark, pull that lever.” The same directions as last time, then. Good. Bilbo knows how to follow them, and he knows what will happen when he does, though Thorin could’ve explained it better the first time. “Fíli, Kíli.” This is new. “Cover him, and help him with the lever if he needs it.”
“Do I need cover?” Bilbo asks, but the lads are already ushering him up toward their goal. “I don’t need cover. And I certainly don’t need help with that lever.” After all, he managed it well enough on his own the last time. And what’s more, Thorin knew that, and did not send anybody to aid Bilbo in such a simple venture.
“No, you don’t,” Fíli agrees. “But try arguing with him.” Bilbo ignores the edge to his tone. Everything can be explained later. For now, they’d better get to pulling that blasted lever.
“You may need help getting up those stairs,” says Kíli as the three of them run at top speed toward the lever.
“Excuse you!” Bilbo scolds him. “I’m not that old, thank you very much, and I’m not that small, either, before you say it.”
“I think Uncle Thorin is trying to preserve the bloodline,” Fíli mutters, hoisting Bilbo onto the first step. The Hobbit tries and fails to be annoyed by this. After all, he got up these stairs perfectly well on his own the first time. But then, Fíli is the future King of Erebor. It is second-nature for him to offer aid, whether it is strictly necessary or simply helpful. “And protecting his intended along with us.”
That much never occurred to Bilbo, but he does see the logic in it. After all, they’re going to be as far away from the dragon as any of the company could get, and they’re going to be right next to a rush of water. Easy cover from the dragon and his fire. “He could be a little more subtle,” Bilbo grumbles. He doesn’t like being hoodwinked into safety like this, though he’s pleased to see that the lads, at least, are being protected. “And I’m not his intended.”
“I think this is about as subtle as Thorin gets,” Kíli decides, helping Bilbo up to the lever. “And I’d wager he’ll be giving you a gift as soon as the dragon’s dead.”
“Well, that’s something to look forward to,” Bilbo grumbles. He’s had enough of Kíli’s meddling to last a lifetime.
He will reluctantly admit, if only to himself, that there is much less jumping involved this time around as Bilbo pulls the lever, with an embarrassing amount of help from Kíli. Still, perhaps Bilbo is being too hard on himself. He is injured, after all, twice over, counting his hip. And the last time the Hobbit tried to pull a lever, Kíli had to rush through an armed skirmish to extricate a severely wounded Bilbo. “There,” Fíli announces with a smile when the water begins gushing out. “That should do it.”
“Do what?” Kíli asks. “What is uncle planning?”
Fíli gestures at the mill that will use the forthcoming water to move a series of buckets. “I think that’s our escape route.”
“He isn’t thinking clearly,” Bilbo grumbles. He really shouldn’t have said anything, because Fíli now looks far too thoughtful for Bilbo’s comfort. He resembles his uncle more and more by the minute. Clearly, he can see that Thorin is faltering, and he’s preparing to take on the mantle of leadership. Dreading it, no doubt, but preparing nevertheless. But now is not the time to be questioning their loyalty to Thorin. His plan is absolutely ridiculous, but Bilbo knows for a fact that it will keep the company alive for the time being.
“He threatened you,” Fíli points out.
“What?” Kíli, obviously, has not been filled in. “When?”
“Now isn’t the time to talk about it,” Bilbo declares, “Come on. Are you going in the buckets, or are you coming with me?”
The lads take a moment to study the rickety-looking buckets. The things are made of wood, and they’ve been out of use for over a century. “We’ll go with you,” Fíli decides. “Let Uncle take his wild risks.”
“I’d prefer it if he didn’t,” says Bilbo, but the lads are already practically carrying him down the stairs. Kíli’s hand on his shoulder does not feel as comforting or steadying as it might if Bilbo had not been burned by dragon fire in that exact spot, but he doesn’t want to make the lad feel guilty and therefore says nothing about it.
“Master Baggins,” Kíli observes, “Your face is red.”
“Yes, well, I am running through a furnace!” Bilbo shouts back.
Neither of the lads seem to be particularly affected by the heat. Bilbo knows that many of the residents of Erebor burned in dragon fire. He’s heard the song, after all, and he has spoken to Thorin for more than five minutes. But he has also seen his king riding down a river of molten metal, an activity which would easily kill a Hobbit from the heat alone. Clearly their line bears some measure of heat-resistance with which, unfortunately, Bilbo has not been blessed.
“You can go faster,” Fíli realizes, after they’ve scrambled down the stairs and set off at a run through the halls of Erebor. “We’re slowing you down.”
“No,” Bilbo protests weakly, but it’s true enough. He’s always been a fair runner, and he’s not bogged down by weapons as the lads are. Also, he has no reason to preserve his energy. Nobody could possibly be expecting Bilbo to fight a dragon.
“It’s true,” Kíli agrees, “Don’t lie to us, Master Baggins. We’ll be alright.”
“I’m not going to just abandon you with a dragon chasing you!” Bilbo sputters. He doesn’t like that they’re here at all, though he supposes it’s preferable to allowing a severely injured Kíli to do battle with orcs in Bard’s home.
“This heat will kill you!” Fíli gives him a shove. “Go! We’re right behind you. We’ll be fine.”
“Durin’s folk do not fear a little fire,” Kíli offers with a grin. To his credit, it would be difficult for any but his closest friends and relations to discern that the smile is entirely false. “We were born for the forges of Erebor.”
Thankfully, Bilbo has the presence of mind to actually believe what the lads are telling him. He knows that Fíli would not risk his brother’s safety by initiating an attack on the dragon, even if Kíli would happily charge toward Smaug with his flimsy wooden arrows. He knows that their heat-tolerance is far superior to his own. He also knows that the lads will not take no for an answer, and that they will probably tattle to Thorin about his refusal to flee once the company is safe. He feels profoundly guilty about it, but he does as he’s told and bolts forward at top speed.
He uses his large, quiet feet and the light clothes he’s wearing to his advantage and scrambles through the passageway, until he is very close to something exit-like. Of course, the way is barred by a door intended to be opened by several people together, all of whom are individually much stronger than any Hobbit. Bilbo is here now, with no chance of escape until the lads join him. He should have conserved his energy. He should have—
The dragon bursts through the wall, and Bilbo changes his tune immediately. He’d forgotten about this part, but he’s glad the lads are well behind him. If Smaug is here, then it stands to reason that he is not wherever Fíli and Kíli are, and that the brothers, therefore, are safe from dragon fire for the time being.
Smaug catches sight of Bilbo, who has dragged a fallen tapestry over himself to no avail. “Do you take me for a fool?” The dragon bellows. “You have come from Lake-town; I can tell it from your dress.” Of course. Smaug has eaten his fair share of Lake Men and he would be familiar with their designs. Bilbo’s heart sinks as he realizes that all his careful talking in the treasury meant nothing. Whether or not he presented himself as Barrel-rider, the dragon was always going to attack Lake-town. “This is some sordid scheme hatched between these filthy Dwarves and those miserable tub-trading Lake Men. Those sniveling cowards with their long bows and black arrows. Perhaps it is time I paid them a visit.”
Bilbo distinctly remembers attempting to plead with the dragon the last time. It didn’t go well. Smaug rightly guessed that Bilbo cared about the town and flew off to destroy it. Maybe if Bilbo takes the opposite approach, Smaug will do something different. But does he truly want Smaug to do something different? After all, if Bilbo could convince Smaug not to attack Lake-town, would the dragon not then turn his ire upon the company? If that’s the case, then Bilbo really should simply do exactly as he did the last time. But how could he possibly? How could Bilbo knowingly encourage Smaug to harm those innocent people, even with Bard waiting with a black arrow?
When Bilbo spoke to the bowman, he convinced himself that he was setting up a sort of failsafe. But that is not true. Bilbo never seriously expected that the company would be able to fell Smaug. In his shame, he can say nothing and do nothing, only gape at the dragon in shocked disbelief.
Bilbo can hear footsteps coming to a stop behind him. He can only hope that Fíli has the presence of mind to pull his brother behind a wall, out of sight of the dragon. He already knows that Kíli would never avoid a fight of his own accord. Bilbo would really prefer it if the lads had someone sensible with them to keep them out of trouble. Unfortunately, he has no choice but to focus on the dragon for the time being. If he turns around, he might divert the wyrm’s attention toward the princes.
“Nothing to say?” Smaug sounds amused. “No matter. You will watch as Esgaroth burns, and then you will burn!”
“Here! You witless worm!” Thorin calls from an adjoining room. Oh, not this again, for Yavanna’s sake…
Bilbo thought it was very stupid of Thorin to attempt to cover the dragon in molten gold the first time. He never figured out how Thorin managed to make the large gold statue melt, and considering that dragons are very famously heat-resistant and well-known for covering themselves in jewels and treasure to protect their underbellies, he never figured out why Thorin thought that this plan would result in anything other than a shiny, infuriated dragon. This will not hurt the wyrm in the slightest, but it will put the entire company at risk.
Of course it will. Thorin is not in his right mind. He is defending Erebor, not himself or his friends. Their lives are not his primary concern.
“You!” Smaug roars, turning on his heel and stomping off toward Thorin. Well, at least the lads are relatively safe now, unless they decide to follow their uncle’s example and do something stupid, which Bilbo cannot pretend is not a possibility.
“I am taking back what you stole,” Thorin informs the dragon. There is no fear whatsoever in his tone. Bilbo should not be attracted to such self-sacrificing idiocy, but here he is, biting his lip and pretending that the warmth in his cheeks is due exclusively to the heat radiating from the dragon. Because even in the grip of madness, Thorin still has such a beautiful voice.
Perhaps Bilbo is wrong. Perhaps he’s being overly cautious, seeing what he wants to see, projecting the madness from before onto this version of Thorin. Perhaps he imagined that blue fire in the king’s eyes; perhaps it was the echo of a memory. Or perhaps it does not matter. Perhaps Bilbo might kiss Thorin again, and that might reverse whatever damage has been done. But he is lying to himself.
“You will take nothing from me, Dwarf,” Smaug snarls. Bilbo has heard these exact words before, of course, but they still make him shiver against his will. “I laid low your warriors of old. I instilled terror in the hearts of men. I am King Under the Mountain.”
“This is not your kingdom. These are Dwarf lands.” Truly, Thorin may be the best speaker that Bilbo has ever encountered. His voice is beautiful on its own, and when he turns it to such meaningful proclamations, it is impossible to stifle the urge to follow him across the world. They are all in mortal danger. “This is Dwarf gold. And we will have our revenge!” Thorin shouts an order in Khuzdul, and the company does something behind the scenes to reveal the golden statue.
That blue fire is back in Thorin’s eyes again. In fact, it seems to surround him, radiating out from the king’s imposing person, in Bilbo’s imagination, if not in reality. He is staring through the gaping hole in the wall, watching as Thorin challenges the dragon. Bilbo feels compelled to run to his king and to fight alongside him, a stupid notion that will get him nowhere. He’s got to be the voice of reason. He’s got to keep the lads safe, got to keep Thorin safe, got to make sure that whatever is happening now does not lead to any deaths.
“Come away, Master Baggins.” Fíli pulls Bilbo away from the broken wall, leading him as far from the dragon as it’s possible to get him. “This way.”
“Revenge! Revenge?” The dragon roars, “I will show you revenge!”
“What is he doing?” Kíli, meanwhile, has established himself in Bilbo’s old lookout spot.
“I don’t know,” Fíli admits, sounding much older than he is. Yes, he has taken on the mantle of leadership indeed. Does he see it too, the flame in his uncle’s eyes? Or is it the fact that he is in Erebor, the homeland stolen from him? Has the reclamation of his birthright made him bolder? “Get away from there.” And he pulls his brother back from the wall just before the statue… explodes.
“I’m only the spare,” Kíli protests jovially, though he follows well enough. “As long as you’re safe, it doesn’t matter what happens to me.” He must be terrified. Anyone would be. But just as Fíli forces himself to take charge, to protect his brother and his maybe-would-be-uncle, Kíli forces himself to lighten the mood, to keep all of their spirits up.
This is how they work in tandem. All those years of harmless little plots, smug swaggering and big grins, have prepared them for this moment. For stepping into their roles as Princes of Erebor. Bilbo couldn’t be more proud. He hopes that Thorin will share this emotion, but if he does not, Bilbo will be the one to communicate it to the princes.
“Say that again and I’ll take you to the sparring ring right now!” Fíli hisses. Bilbo wonders if the sparring rings in Erebor are even still intact, though he suspects that even if they are not, Fíli will make good on his threat with a circle drawn in the sand. “If Thorin falls we will both be needed in the coming fight.”
“If Thorin falls, I don’t think the rest of us will be very far behind,” Bilbo mutters, shoving his anxiety down into the very depths of his stomach. Dragon fire at this close range wouldn’t do anybody any good, and the king, in his infinite wisdom, has led the company and the beast all to an enclosed space together. If Smaug remembers that he can, in fact, breathe fire, they’re all done for. But Smaug will not remember. He didn’t the last time.
But before Fíli can answer, the dragon, now coated in gold and thrashing something awful, destroys yet another wall and sails through the side of the mountain with yet another deafening roar. At least he no longer poses any threat to Thorin. Bilbo can only hope that Bard has heeded his warning and is prepared to confront the dragon before Smaug can do too much damage.
“Well,” Kíli breathes after a moment, “I can’t imagine that was part of Uncle’s plan.”
“I can’t imagine that your uncle’s plan extended very far beyond theoretically using that statue as some kind of weapon,” Bilbo grumbles. He should’ve remembered all this sooner, and then he could have lectured Thorin about wasting time trying to attack a dragon… with gold. Although he doubts that Thorin would listen very carefully to any lecture in his present state.
He did enough lecturing the last time. On the first adventure, Bilbo convinced himself that Thorin was perfectly fine. And where did that get them? Ravenhill. It got them to Ravenhill.
“He should not have done that,” Fíli decides, “It makes no sense.”
“But what else could he have done?” Kíli asks. “He had nothing else with which to attack the dragon.”
Fíli purses his lips. “Perhaps we should’ve brought something to use against it.”
“You’re just thinking of that now?” Bilbo exclaims. Honestly, bother this entire company! They should’ve brought him into this venture much sooner, and he’d have set them right from the very beginning.
Before the lads can offer any excuses for the general lack of foresight, the sound of pounding footsteps alerts them to Thorin’s presence. “Bilbo,” he pants upon entry to the chamber. “You’ve survived.”
“We’re alright, too, Uncle, thank you for noticing,” Kíli announces in a teasing tone. If he is genuinely hurt, he doesn’t show it.
Thorin murmurs something in Khuzdul as he wraps Bilbo in his arms, ignoring his nephews entirely. This is not good. But Bilbo cannot help but return Thorin’s embrace. He may have known with some level of certainty that the king would survive this confrontation, but that didn’t do very much to steady Bilbo’s nerves.
“I’m alright,” Bilbo assures Thorin, “Are you injured?”
“Not at all.” These words are muffled, spoken as they are against Bilbo’s shoulder, and they are followed by more Khuzdul muttering. Bilbo wishes that he understood.
“We shouldn’t linger here,” Fíli points out. He looks very uncomfortable, though whether that’s because he can understand what his uncle is saying or because they are standing in a room that was just partially destroyed by a dragon, Bilbo isn’t sure. Still, the lad has good sense. He will make a fine king some day, in many, many years. But Bilbo does not imagine that he will live to see that. If all goes according to plan, Thorin’s reign will be longer and more prosperous than the life of any Hobbit.
“That is true,” Thorin decides. He attempts to lift Bilbo up, but the Hobbit shoots him what he hopes is a blood-curdling glare.
“What do you think you’re doing?” Bilbo demands.
“I would carry you to safety,” Thorin explains. His voice is heavy with meaning and emotion. Naturally, he puts none of this into words.
And Bilbo does not ask. Nor does he let Thorin know how pleased he is to see him. He feels that came across perfectly well in the hug, and anyway, it would be unwise to distract the king further. “I’m perfectly capable of walking to safety myself,” Bilbo points out. “And you have no reason to strain yourself by carrying me.”
“It would not be a strain.” Thorin looks at him with obvious affection. He is himself. At least for this moment, he is himself. Bilbo wants to kiss him again, to grab him by the shoulders and shake him, to physically drag him out of Erebor and away to safety. “You’re very small.”
No. They can’t turn their backs on this. The battle must take place. The battle will take place, whether Thorin is here for it or not. And even if he could convince the King Under the Mountain to abdicate, which feels more far-fetched than anything else that has happened on their quest to date, he cannot imagine that Fíli and Kíli would accompany them. They, like Thorin, have been raised on their duty to Erebor. And even in a perfect world, where Bilbo could get all of them away from here, the battle might be lost without their presence.
The ring is not destroyed. It is weak, but it is not destroyed. What would happen, if the orcs claimed Erebor? Terrible things. Terrible things, even if Bilbo went off to go throw the ring into Mount Doom right this instant. Even in the grip of madness, Thorin did not falter in his devotion to the Mountain itself. He is a great king. He will not leave his kingdom, not even for Bilbo. Not even for the threat of madness.
“Yes, thank you, but I’m putting my foot down.” Bilbo holds out his hand to Thorin. “We can hold hands, but that’s it. No carrying.” He doesn’t know why it’s so important to him. Maybe he just wants to be certain that Thorin will listen to him when he says no.
“Very well,” Thorin grumbles. “Though if your back troubles you, you must say something.”
“Fine,” Bilbo agrees, and they set off back down the passageway.
On their journey through Erebor, Bilbo is almost able to convince himself that perhaps he misjudged Thorin’s condition. After all, the king listened to Bilbo when he drew the line at being carried, and after a few minutes of fretting over the Hobbit (and not saying a word about the gold, mind you), he seemed to register his nephews’ presence and asked the lads if they were alright. Bilbo is slightly cheered, remembering that first encounter eighty years ago. He tried to warn the lads away from the treasure, but Fíli rushed to it, eyes wide and blazing. Bilbo suspected, for a moment, that the heir to the throne was just as enchanted by gold as the king was. But Fíli snapped out of it quickly.
Now, the prince hasn’t even glanced at the hoard, hasn’t made any move toward the treasury. Nor, for that matter, has his uncle, which Bilbo takes as a positive sign indeed. Maybe he really was wrong. Maybe Thorin is going to be okay, and that moment with the sword was just a little hiccup. Yes, because that’s how dragon sickness works, isn’t it? It can be shaken off. Thorin was normal by the end of the Battle, and all it took was a confrontation from Dwalin. Maybe seeing his nephews in danger has grounded him somewhat. After all, wasn’t it Fíli this time, and not the dragon, who interrupted Thorin at his most volatile and helped him come back to himself?
And that changed things. Thorin knew he did something wrong, when he dropped his sword and stared at Bilbo in horror. He was well aware that he’d not been himself the moment before, and guilty for it. There is still hope.
Either way, they’re all here now, and the Men and Elves will be coming whether Thorin is stable or not. Bilbo will have to come up with a plan for that which does not involve stealing the Arkenstone (bad idea) or using the ring (impossible). Then, he’ll have to try and convince Thorin and the lads to avoid springing the trap that Bilbo alone is expecting Azog to set, which he knows is much easier said than done.
“I’m just going to sit down and think for a moment, if that’s alright with you,” Bilbo says to the company. Really, though, he’s just talking to Thorin. He can’t imagine that anybody else would have any problem with him just sitting and thinking.
“Fine,” the king says.
Bilbo settles himself down on a rock and tries to work through the same problems that have been bothering him for months. Years, actually. Decades, if he’s honest. Can he prevent the battle of the five armies entirely? No. He cannot stop the Orcs. Not even if he had a functioning Ring of Power, not even if he were fool enough to try and use it, could Bilbo prevent Azog’s attack. But still, he may be able to talk the other powers involved into fighting as one. Bilbo is good at talking. It’s one of his primary skills.
Will Bard see reason? It’s possible. Will Thranduil see reason? Not unless Bilbo offers him some other vital piece of foreknowledge, and even then, he can’t be certain. Will Thorin see reason? Not in a million years. Back to the drawing board.
“Durin’s beard,” Balin mumbles, and the pain in his voice shakes Bilbo from these selfish thoughts.
He is, therefore, paying complete attention when the dragon falls. Smaug bucks forward, then jerks back before tumbling into the Long Lake. Bilbo is too far away to make out the arrow in the dragon’s breast, but he knows that it is there. So Bard has killed the beast, earlier than he did the last time, and the third step of Bilbo’s (admittedly shaky) plan is now complete. He has saved countless lives, though it is plain to see that much of the city of Lake-town is still on fire. Bilbo is not naive enough to believe that there were no deaths or serious injuries at all.
It’s hard to concern oneself with the future when one’s present is so utterly horrific. Bilbo cannot focus on the impending battle when Lake-town is ablaze before him. Though he should. He really should be stronger than this, enough to recognize that his attentions are needed elsewhere. If he goes into the battle with no plan, then Thorin and the lads will die, just like before. “Yavanna save them,” Bilbo murmurs. The destruction doesn’t look as bad as it did the last time, but it does not look good.
“Aye, and Mahal as well,” Bofur agrees. “They’ll need all the help they can get.”
Ori sniffles and wipes frantically at his eyes with the sleeve of his sweater. Bifur offers him a pat on the back and a few words (presumably of comfort) in Khuzdul, but the warrior’s grief is as plain as the scribe’s. They are all affected, and how could they not be, watching the flames leap?
“The family we stayed with,” Fíli’s eyes are wide with pity and compassion, “Do you think they’re alright?”
“I made sure they were armed before I left,” Bilbo tries to comfort the lad. The last time, of course, Fíli was there with Bard’s family when the dragon arrived, and he helped get them to safety. “And I warned the father about the dragon. He said he might send his children to the Wood Elves for safety.” Actually, Bard never said this, but he didn’t argue much when Bilbo proposed it. And if Bilbo were in the bowman’s position, he’d have happily sent Frodo off to live with Thranduil rather than be traumatized watching his home burn.
“Arms won’t have helped them much against a dragon,” is Dwalin’s steady reply. “Neither will that bastard who calls himself King of Mirkwood.” Bilbo does not bother to mention that Thranduil has likely never referred to his own home by such a derogatory name.
“Don’t the Men of the Lake have some sort of alliance with the Elves?” Kíli muses, “Or at least a trading partnership. Maybe the Greenwood can help them.”
The Greenwood, not Mirkwood. So Tauriel has been teaching him about her home. More likely than not, the exchange of knowledge has been mutual. Bilbo wonders whether Kíli chose to tell Tauriel the stories he grew up on of the splendor of Erebor, or to share his experiences of a childhood spent in relative poverty in the Blue Mountains. He wonders how many hours the two of them spent in those dungeons, separated by the bars of a cell, trading stories about their respective worlds.
“I don’t think you can expect your lass to drop by anytime soon,” Nori quips, though it’s clear his heart isn’t in it. His attempt to lighten the mood falls flat; nobody laughs.
“When have Elves ever helped anyone?” Glóin snarls.
Kíli opens his mouth to protest, but then apparently remembers that it would be very rude to bring up Bilbo’s near-death experience at this juncture. The company is silent for a moment, allowing Bilbo ample time to count their numbers. A chill runs down his spine as it occurs to him that there are only thirteen of them.
Slowly, dreading the worst, Bilbo turns around. He hopes against hope that he is wrong, that he is only jumping to unfair conclusions and his apprehensions will soon be set to right. But there, as he feared, is Thorin, his back turned to the company and the carnage in Lake-town. He is staring at the Mountain. Oh, this is not good at all.
The last time, Bilbo left Thorin to his own devices. He didn’t understand the magnitude of all this, didn’t see it as the sign that it was of terrible things to come. He thought, of course Thorin would want to see the Mountain, after so much time away from Erebor. Of course he’d be thinking about the people he’d lost there, the trauma that ruled his life for more than a century. Bilbo was too charitable then, too trusting, even after the incident with the sword. He won’t make the same mistake again.
Taking his chances, Bilbo decides to approach the king. He tries to make his footsteps as loud as possible to alert Thorin to his presence, but of course, the king is lost to the world, at least until Bilbo puts a hand on his arm. Then he jolts, but doesn’t take his gaze away from Erebor. “Thorin,” Bilbo begins, somewhat hesitant. He doesn’t have any particular desire to be impaled on a sword at this juncture. “Are you alright?”
“Mhm,” Thorin hums in response. “I have never been better.”
“Lake-town is burning behind you,” Bilbo points out. He doesn’t like this one bit. He tried to prepare for it, of course, to remind himself amidst even his most wishful of thinking that this was a genuine possibility, that Thorin was more than likely to develop dragon sickness this time just as he did before. But he apparently could not steel himself for the true horror of watching his beloved descend into madness with complete understanding. “Do you not care?”
“No,” Thorin says, “I do not care. The wyrm is dead, and the mountain is mine again.”
“Those people helped us.” Why is Bilbo even bothering? What does he think, that a gentle touch will be enough to make Thorin return to his senses? “And they have paid dearly for it.”
Now, Thorin does look at him. “Come here,” the king orders. And it really is an order, with more authority than Bilbo has heard from Thorin in a very long time. That is saying something, and not a particularly cheery something. “Join me.”
Bilbo should not go along with this. He should turn on his heel and rejoin the company. Perhaps that might coax Thorin away from his present preoccupation. But Bilbo feels ragged after his confrontation with the dragon, and the sight of Lake-town has not helped. He does not want to be reminded of his own failure to prevent a catastrophe. He does not want to be reminded of his own uselessness, his apparent inability to do anything that he set out to do. He was supposed to save Lake-town, and yet it has burned. He was supposed to destroy the ring, and yet it still rests in his pocket. He was supposed to help Thorin, but the king has already started down the path to madness.
“Okay.” Bilbo steps forward and allows Thorin to position him so that the Burglar’s back is pressed against the king’s chest. There isn’t really much to see in this direction: just the cold stone of the Lonely Mountain, etched with age but otherwise uninteresting. But it feels nice, having Thorin’s arms around him. Despite himself, Bilbo can’t complain about that.
“Erebor is mine,” Thorin breathes, “All of it is mine.” What a fool Bilbo was, to believe it meant anything that Thorin ceded to his wishes as they were leaving the Mountain!
Even at the height of his madness, Thorin had moments of compassion. Moments of love, some might call them. A particular instance with an acorn comes to mind. For the Green Lady’s sake, Thorin gave Bilbo a mithril shirt while the dragon sickness gripped him! It was not as though his spirit left his body to be replaced by some wicked creature who cared only for treasure. No, Thorin was still Thorin, even at his darkest moment. Even when he tried to kill Bilbo, still, he cared, underneath it all. And now, he might care more, but that does not mean that he is not a threat. It certainly doesn’t mean he’s entirely well.
“Ours, you mean,” Bilbo corrects him. He’s referring to the company, but from the way Thorin tightens his grip around Bilbo, it’s possible that the king may have misunderstood.
“In the morning, we will go back inside,” Thorin informs Bilbo in a gentle murmur. That tone of voice should have no effect on him, but Bilbo is only a Hobbit like any other, and he cannot help but shudder. He wants… no, what he wants matters very little. He cannot afford to be distracted, and he cannot take advantage of Thorin’s current mental state. Bilbo has waited eighty years, and he can wait longer. “I will show you my treasure, and you may take your pick.”
“Take my pick?” Bilbo doesn’t understand. Last time, Thorin was deeply protective of the entire hoard. He wouldn’t let anybody take anything, although he did bestow a mithril coat upon Bilbo.
“As you say,” Thorin whispers into Bilbo’s ear. Just what is he trying to do? “It is ours. All of it is ours.”
Chapter 12: Bad Ideas All Around
Notes:
Yikes. Welcome to the first of the dragon sickness chapters! For the foreseeable future, nobody will be doing well, in any way, at all. But please enjoy anyway, and thank you for reading/commenting/leaving kudos!
Chapter Text
Thorin is surrounded by beautiful things. Gold and jewels and gems beyond his wildest imaginings, which are very wild, indeed. Silver, too, and fine woodcraft. Lesser metals, forged with care. Crowns and coins and the most elegant of swords. Fine Dwarven work, yes, supplemented with only the best of imports from other peoples in other lands. And the Arkenstone, as well. Thorin aches to touch it, to hold it in his hands. He wants to find it, needs to find it, must find it and return it to its rightful place above his throne. For the time being, he settles for lifting a handful of golden coins and dropping them again, letting them fall through his fingers one by one. The cool metal against his skin is a comfort; it brings him great joy. Or, it would bring him great joy, if only he had the Arkenstone in his possession.
“Thorin?” Yet another beautiful thing enters the chamber. Beside Bilbo, the golden trinkets littering the floor appear quite dull. The Hobbit’s eyes are like prisms, his voice like the song of the mountain and his hair more lovely than the ridiculous emerald necklace that Thorin has lately picked up.
The king tosses the jewelry aside in disgust. It will not do. Not any piece would be good enough for his One. In fact, most pieces fall short of this lofty mark, even those crafted by the Ereborean masters of old. “Come here,” Thorin orders. He wants Bilbo near him. It sets him on edge, the thought of his Hobbit mingling with the rest of the company. They might become covetous, if left to their own devices.
“I thought you’d be hungry.” Bilbo’s voice is so lovely that Thorin is momentarily unable to parse the words the Hobbit speaks. “I brought you something to eat.” He is always doing this, always trying to feed Thorin. Perhaps it brings the little creature some pleasure to do so, to prove his ability to provide even for a king. It is endearing, if a touch silly, and so Thorin entertains the practice, no matter how annoying it might be coming from anyone else.
“I am not hungry,” Thorin assures him. “Join me, please.” He needs to have Bilbo in his arms, he decides. Perhaps that will sate the ache that has settled in his belly.
It does not. He is pleased when Bilbo settles obediently into his embrace, under his arm, leaving his other hand free to search through the treasure. He can appreciate the Hobbit’s pleasant warmth, the surprising sharpness of his shoulders, the gratifying softness of the rest of him. But it is not enough. Thorin needs all of his treasures together in one place: the hoard, the Hobbit, and the Arkenstone. Only then will he be able to justify concerning himself with such trivial matters as food and drink.
“You have not been hungry for days,” Bilbo protests. “Please eat just a little. You’ll need your strength for things to come.” What could that mean?
“The Arkenstone cares not whether I have eaten,” Thorin reasons. He only needs to find the jewel, and then he will settle down and do as Bilbo wishes.
“Nor whether you have slept,” is Bilbo’s dry retort.
“It will not be long before I find it, ghivashel,” Thorin murmurs in an attempt to soothe Bilbo. He does not like to see his One so agitated, but he cannot for the life of him understand the little creature’s worry. Perhaps Bilbo feels that it is taking Thorin too long to locate the Arkenstone. Perhaps he will lose interest and try to leave if Thorin cannot prove his divine right to the throne. “Do not worry.”
“I’m very worried,” Bilbo informs Thorin, grabbing modest handfuls of his luxurious fur cloak. “But I couldn’t care less about the Arkenstone.” Before Thorin can argue with him, the Hobbit continues, “I care about you.”
“That is a great honor, indeed.” And Thorin means it. To be more important than the Arkenstone? That is a concept that Thorin cannot comprehend. The Arkenstone is the most valuable thing in Middle Earth, and yet Bilbo places Thorin above it. He hardly seems to notice the lovely things that surround him; he simply steps over them with his eyes trained on Thorin. As it should be.
“I came to Erebor for you, my dear,” Bilbo reminds him, “Not for the Arkenstone. And you came to give your people back their home.”
“And now they will have it.” It is exquisite, hearing his Hobbit singing his praises. Bilbo may not understand the significance of the Arkenstone, but nobody in their right mind could doubt that he returns Thorin’s feelings. He would not betray his king, would not be unfaithful. He has done everything in his power to bring Thorin closer to his treasure, and now, here he is, dressed in Thorin’s colors, fretting over his king in the most endearing manner.
The Hobbit has refused the gems he’s been offered, but Thorin cannot fault him for that. He imagines that the Arkenstone would feel just as offended if he tried to cover it in rubies. He wonders absently if the Arkenstone’s touch will feel anything like Bilbo’s, warm and living and full of palpable affection.
“Please.” There is something strange in Bilbo’s tone, a sliver of pain or doubt that makes no sense to Thorin. “Please, you must rest. Just for a few moments. This is not healthy, Thorin. The Arkenstone is here anyway, isn’t it? And it’s yours already. What does it matter if it’s in your hand or amongst your other treasures? And you’ll be able to look for it faster if you eat, maybe sleep a little.”
Thorin looks at him, baffled by the Hobbit’s concerned gaze. “You wish to have my company?”
Is that it, then? Bilbo is jealous of the rest of the treasure. He is jealous of the Arkenstone. He wishes to be the sole recipient of Thorin’s attention, at least for the time being. Of course he would. Thorin cannot fault him for that, either. It is sweet, to be desired so. To be revered, a great king, worthy, now, of such devotion.
“Yes,” Bilbo breathes out shakily, “Please?”
“You do not need to beg,” Thorin assures him, voice heavy with longing. Longing for the Arkenstone, yes, but for Bilbo as well. It will be easier when he has them both in the same place. To look upon two such jewels at once would be bliss beyond anything Thorin has ever known. He grows impatient, combing the treasury and finding nothing of any particular value.
“Then come and rest with me? Just for a moment.” The pleading look in his Hobbit’s eyes is too much to resist. Perhaps Bilbo has a point, after all. Whether the Arkenstone is in his hands or not, it still belongs to Thorin. It is still his, still within his mountain. And he has other treasure to enjoy at the moment.
“Yes,” Thorin decides, “Yes, I will sit with you. Then you will stay and help me look for the Arkenstone.”
Bilbo swallows. He looks to be on the verge of tears, his eyes swimming as he stares up at Thorin. So it is true, then. He is jealous of the stone. He does not understand that Thorin loves them both equally, each with his whole heart. “As you wish,” the Hobbit breathes with palpable trepidation. “My dearest love.”
As Bilbo leads him back down the passage that runs to the throne room, Thorin thinks about what kind of gift he might bestow to make his love and loyalty clear to the Hobbit. To keep him in place and protect him from harm, to communicate the sheer extent of Thorin’s devotion. For now, a strong arm around the perplexing creature will have to be enough.
Over the course of the past few days, Bilbo’s successes have been few and far between, but notable nevertheless. He’s gotten Thorin to take more than a couple of meals, which is better than he managed the last time, and though Bilbo doubts that Thorin is capable of finding sleep in his present state, at the very least, he has agreed to lay down beside the Hobbit for a few hours on two separate occasions. It took an awful lot of cajoling and no shortage of vaguely subservient drivel, but Bilbo can endure such things if it means that Thorin eats and rests.
It’s far worse than last time. Not the sickness itself, necessarily, but the watching of it. Eighty years ago, Bilbo managed to convince himself that Thorin was still the same noble being that he got to know during their time on the road. He genuinely believed that if his tone were sharp enough, if his words were true enough, then the person he’d fallen in love with would blink and shudder and reveal himself. If Bilbo hadn’t thought that, he never would have bothered with the Arkenstone. Which, he supposes, is why this time, he’s left the blasted thing to rot in the depths of the treasury.
Although, one would think that Thorin would have no trouble finding the gem, considering how much time he spends amongst his treasures. When he’s not down there himself, he’s seated on his throne, with Bilbo at his side, waiting for his kin to provide him with his prize. If Bilbo didn’t know any better, he’d be able to delude himself into believing that this is a good sign. Oh, yes, Thorin will allow other people to put their hands on his gold if it means he might get closer to the Arkenstone, but this means very little. Thorin certainly would not allow any of the company to remove anything from the mountain, not even to purchase food or security from attack.
“Why have they not found it already?” Thorin demands from his position on the throne. He looks so regal there, poised like one of the majestic kings of old. A character from a storybook, better than even Bilbo could have written him. “I have given them more time than is reasonable, and yet it still it is not in my hands.”
“I’m not sure.” He doesn’t bother to ask what it is. He knows well enough already. Bilbo must tread lightly. His feet are sore from standing beside the throne all day, but his priority is keeping the company safe. Perhaps it is wishful thinking, but it seems to Bilbo that he has been able to soothe Thorin with his presence hitherto. Nobody has been screamed at or threatened yet, at least. And with the way Thorin looks at him, it’s clear that any love he might’ve felt prior to entering the mountain is still present in some capacity. “Would you like something to drink?”
There’s wine and ale aplenty in Erebor. Apparently, the dragon would not touch the stuff, though perhaps that had more to do with Smaug’s inability to access the cellars than with a lack of interest in drink. Regardless, the other rations have run low enough that Bilbo does not have much to offer in the way of snacks, but pouring wine is no trouble.
“Yes,” says Thorin. “Bring me something.”
Bilbo hates this more than he has hated any other part of the journey. He does not take well to being ordered around, but he knows that Thorin is suspicious and irritable from his illness, and it probably isn’t helped much by the lack of sleep and proper nutrition. Bilbo could try to argue, yes. He did it the last time, and it didn’t work. Thorin attempted to murder Bilbo for it before, and then he died in guilt that could not be assuaged no matter what anyone said to him. Bilbo would not wish that fate upon his worst enemy, and certainly not upon his greatest love. He hates pretending at anything even resembling subservience, and desperately wants to grab Thorin by the shoulders and shake him, but playing along a little bit seems to mean that Thorin’s basic needs are seen to.
Isn’t that better, in the long run? Maybe he’ll be stronger by the time of the battle. Because Bilbo knows that there will be a battle no matter what he does. Even in a perfect world where he could prevent the Elves and Men from attacking, where he could somehow stay Dáin’s hand, where he could talk some sense into Thorin, the orcs would still press forward. Thorin will have to fight sooner or later, whether he charges into battle or the battle charges up to him. They must be all prepared, but Thorin especially.
So Bilbo pours wine into a golden cup that he would personally prefer to toss over the battlements, never to be seen again. “Here you are, My King.” The sound of his own voice makes him cringe. He should not be indulging Thorin in any of this nonsense.
The smile that he receives in return is not entirely hollow. Bilbo refuses to allow himself the hope. “Come and sit with me,” Thorin orders. Orders.
“Where, exactly?” Bilbo pushes, ever so slightly. He doesn’t know what he’s expecting. He knows that no amount of playful prodding will be enough to snap Thorin out of this, but maybe— oh, he doesn’t know. He has no plan. As it happens, plotting is not easy when you’re watching someone you love fall into madness.
“You may share my throne.” Well, if that isn’t a symbolic gesture, Bilbo doesn’t know what is.
Is this a positive development? Does it mean that Thorin trusts him more than he did the last time? Or simply that he feels more entitled to Bilbo’s time and space than he did eighty years ago? Bilbo wishes there was someone he could ask, but he can’t exactly march up to Balin and demand to know why Thorin is behaving differently than he did on the original timeline. Actually, now that Bilbo thinks about it, the King’s advisor would probably offer him a great deal of insight about just what happens when one allows Elves to rule one’s destiny, and he’d probably be entirely correct.
“Great,” Bilbo mutters, climbing awkwardly onto the throne. “Surely the consort must have their own throne. Perhaps a smaller one? I wouldn’t mind a proper cushion, either.”
Thorin waves his hand. “My grandmother did not care very much about such matters.” He wraps a possessive arm around Bilbo, pulling him close. Bilbo can feel the way the king’s chest relaxes in response to the touch, and he considers allowing himself to pretend that this is an indicator of Thorin coming back to himself.
It isn’t. He’s treating the golden cup in his other hand with almost the same reverence. At best, he sees Bilbo as a second Arkenstone, which is a disturbing enough prospect without taking into consideration the fact that when he looks at the Hobbit, Thorin certainly does not see Bilbo. Whatever love exists between them has been muddied significantly by the dragon sickness. Worse than last time, because last time, Bilbo never made the mistake of encouraging Thorin.
“I don’t think I care much about it, either, but I can’t very well sit here while you hold court.” He’s throwing everything at the wall. Perhaps Thorin will snap out of it if he remembers that sooner or later, he is going to have to actually act as king. He’ll have a kingdom to rule, and lots of responsibilities, and no time to worry about shiny stones.
But if that had worked, then Balin would already have pulled Thorin out of his trance on their first day in the mountain. He’s been delivering lectures about kingly duties since before they arrived in Erebor, and this has not let up with the onset of Thorin’s illness.
“And why not?” Thorin murmurs, “You are mine, are you not? I can have you here if I wish.”
Bilbo cannot help but roll his eyes. This is Thorin, he reminds himself, And you love him. You’re here to save his life. Telling him to shove it and marching yourself back to the Shire won’t do anybody any good, no matter how tempting it may feel right now.
Perhaps it’s only Bilbo’s imagination, but he thinks he hears a sudden, sharp intake of breath from the gallery above. He looks around, but sees nothing more than a flash of gold out the corner of his eye. A trick of the light, perhaps, from the torchlight catching on the glint of the treasure.
“And do I get a say in the matter at all?” He may be treading carefully, but he’s still Bilbo Baggins. He’s not going to abandon the sarcasm entirely, not even in a situation like this. And it’s a nice middle ground between bending completely to Thorin’s whims and demanding to know what His Majesty thinks he’s doing. Not that either of those strategies seems any more effective than the one he’s apparently settled on. “Or is it only up to you?”
Thorin gently wraps one of Bilbo’s curls around his finger. Bilbo forces himself to find the gesture unsettling. He has watched while Thorin grabbed handfuls of coins and played with them in much the same way. It would be unfair of Bilbo to pretend that there is any genuine romance in this touch. He has no doubt that Thorin loves him, somewhere deep down. But the king is not in his right mind at the moment.
“Of course it is up to me,” Thorin breathes, “I am the King of Erebor. Everything that happens here is up to me, and everything in this mountain is mine.” He follows this insight up with some murmuring in Khuzdul. Bilbo tries to remember the words so he can ask someone to translate them later. That is forbidden, but surely it will be okay if the future consort requests it.
Bilbo kicks himself internally for thinking of himself as the future consort of Erebor. Is he so shallow as to allow himself such fantasies in a situation such as this? Perhaps. But maybe that is just the ticket. “I think I rather have something else in mind,” Bilbo blurts out. This is a risk, he knows it, but he’s starting to feel that every conversation with Thorin is a risk. Antagonize him too much, and Bilbo might be dangled over the battlements by his neck once again. Indulge him too much, and the Valar only know what will happen.
“Oh?” Thorin continues playing with Bilbo’s hair, and it is distracting for any number of reasons.
But Bilbo pushes forward. This will not work. It couldn’t be so simple. But he must at least try. He wishes he could ask Dwalin and Kíli what they said to help Thorin the first time, but of course, they would not remember things that have not happened to them yet.
“We could find ourselves some nice, cozy rooms,” Bilbo pretends to muse, trying to steady the trembling in his voice, “With our very own kitchen, and I could cook for you. We’d have… a greenhouse, that’s what it’s called, isn’t it? And I’d grow fruits and vegetables and herbs. And a library, and a nice fireplace, and we could read and eat and blow smoke rings all day long. Perhaps we could have the lads over now and again, feed them some pie and make them dust the chandeliers or what have you.”
“The servants will do our dusting for us, ghivashel,” Thorin assures Bilbo.
“You’re missing the point, darling,” Bilbo protests, “And I don’t know how I feel about having servants. I like keeping care of my own house.” Someone else would only do it wrong. It’s one thing to dole out chores to rambunctious nephews (Bilbo has plenty of experience with that) but he doesn’t like the thought of leaving someone else to dust and scrub in his place. In fact, he gets many of his best ideas while engaged in idle housework.
“You should not have to do any work at all,” Thorin declares. “I would rather keep you in a fine place with fine things and not a care to trouble you.”
“And if I happen to find joy in my work?” So much for Bilbo’s gentle fantasy.
He should have known better than to think that his plan would work. And he didn’t, not really. It’s only that he had a little hope, and now it has been dashed. No, Thorin does not want a peaceful future by Bilbo’s side. He has no interest in cozy rooms or laughing nephews or well-made meals. He cares only for gold, and with his blurred vision he has mistaken Bilbo for a part of his treasure hoard.
“You would be safe there,” Thorin muses. He does not seem to realize how disturbing this prospect is.
“Would I?” Bilbo laughs nervously, bordering on hysteria. Did Thorin wish to imprison him last time, as well? If Bilbo had not given away the Arkenstone, is that what would have happened? Is that what’s going to happen this time? Will Bilbo be rewarded for his compassionate care with a life locked away?
“No one could get to you,” Thorin decides, “No one could dispute my claim upon you.”
“I don’t think anyone is trying to do that, Thorin,” Bilbo replies honestly. “I really don’t.” And he doesn’t care for that phrasing, either.
“I do not like the way that Balin looks at you.”
“Balin?” Bilbo echoes, dumbfounded. “You’re jealous of Balin? He’s old enough to be my grandfather! And however you think he’s looking at me, you must be misreading it.”
“He looks as though he wishes to take you from me,” Thorin resolves.
Ah. That makes sense. Bilbo can only imagine how horrified poor Balin must be by this situation. After all, Thorin is functionally holding Bilbo hostage while Bilbo tries desperately to wake the king from an endless nightmare. It would be difficult for anyone to watch, but for someone who witnessed Thrór’s descent into madness as well? For someone who swore to watch over Thorin and protect him from this very thing? Bilbo knows that feeling intimately, and he would not recommend it.
“But it isn’t up to him, or anyone else, where I spend my time.” Bilbo hopes that Thorin will catch the deeper meaning behind these words, though he sincerely doubts it. “I want to stay with you, and that’s that, Thorin. As long as you’ll have me, I’ll be here.” And that must be true, because if Bilbo had any sense, he’d have run away the moment Thorin started clinging to him so closely. But he’s still here, still promising to stay knowing what could happen if he does.
“Yes, you will be,” Thorin agrees. “I will have you for the rest of time.”
Bilbo does not mention the relatively short lives of Hobbits or the fact that Thorin, too, is mortal. He merely sighs. “But it really does sound nice, doesn’t it, making a life together?”
That’s what Bilbo has wanted, all this time. A marriage between the life he lived with Thorin on the road and the years he spent in Bag End after Thorin was gone. To be with his king, his love, in a happier context. To see Thorin, well-fed, well-rested, and stable. To spend their days relaxing, enjoying one another’s company between their respective undertakings. Oh, yes, they would both be very busy. Bilbo would have his writing, and Thorin would still be king, but could they not make some time for each other?
“I will find you a comfortable bed,” Thorin decides, “And I will hire the best chefs to cook for you.”
“Oh, really?” This sounds promising. Bilbo fights the hope that blooms within his chest. It isn’t possible, is it? That his daydream would be enough to break such an ancient and all-consuming curse as the one from which poor Thorin suffers?
“Mhm,” Thorin hums against his neck. The position is intimate, to say the least, and goosebumps rise on Bilbo’s skin. “I will have all of your things imported from the Shire. The family heirlooms, your own little treasures.” This is very promising, indeed, if Thorin is thinking of porcelain cups and Belladonna’s glory box as treasures. “I will find a way to recreate your garden, all of the flowers that you love so much.”
“Will you?” Bilbo grins. Yes, this is the way that it’s supposed to be. His love is enough to drag Thorin from the madness. A seed planted, hope grown. And apparently, Thorin wants this as much as Bilbo does: to build a life together. To live happily and peacefully, to share their unique blend of the Shire and Erebor, two cultures meeting and meshing in their little household. There will be second breakfasts and weapons training and multi-lingual sweet nothings breathed against bare skin, and—
“Yes. I will bring all these things into the vaults for you, ghivashel. And then you will be safe there, with all that you hold dear.”
As Thorin’s words sink in, Bilbo feels his own chest heave. Of course. It is just more of the same. Thorin is not cured, not any better, not thinking any more clearly or more rationally. He does not wish to build a life together with Bilbo. No, Thorin wishes to cage Bilbo here in Erebor, but he is willing to concede to bringing some things from the Shire to entertain Bilbo during his imprisonment. It would not be an act of love, having Bilbo’s things sent for, furnishing him with a soft bed and good food. It would only be another act of greed.
Bilbo releases a choked sob, mourning the demise of his small hope. He truly believed that Thorin was turning a corner. He allowed himself to dwell in the land of fantasy and for his troubles he has received only pain, only sadness. Bilbo does not know why he expected anything different.
Thorin wraps his arms around the Hobbit, and it is, unfortunately, very nice. Those strong arms are still a great comfort. That soft, low voice by his ear, muttering endearments in a language that he does not speak, still soothes Bilbo, still grounds him, still makes him feel impossibly close to Thorin. This greedy, jealous, and suspicious creature who wants to lock him away from the world is still the love of Bilbo’s life. Nothing could change that. But he must remind himself to be unsettled, not to melt so easily into this.
“Do not cry,” Thorin orders very softly. Over the course of the past several days, the king has grown accustomed to having his orders obeyed. He must be taken aback at Bilbo’s lack of compliance, though he does not seem angry. “It will all be over very soon. I will have the Arkenstone, and none will be able to deny my right to rule. Do not fret.”
Bilbo needs to collect himself, he knows. He can’t waste time feeling sorry for himself, or even feeling sorry for Thorin. He needs to do something about this, but he can do nothing to stay the frustrated tears which stream down his face.
The time continues to pass in the Lonely Mountain. Bilbo continues fretting over Thorin’s increasing madness, despite all orders to the contrary. Things are different this time, yes. The bond between the Burglar and the king is greater now than it was eighty years ago, but no words or actions that Bilbo can muster seem capable of shaking Thorin out of the grip of his sickness. Bilbo has tried everything. Arguing failed, acquiescing fell flat, and even silent sobbing had very little effect. Thorin seems concerned for him, yes, but he does not seem to understand why Bilbo is so agitated. He will not listen to logic or reason.
Bilbo shouldn’t be surprised. He should have known better than to believe, as he apparently did, that love would be an effective cure for dragon sickness. If he’s being honest, the most shocking part of all of this is that Thorin has yet to actually find the Arkenstone. The last time, of course, that was perfectly explicable: Thorin never found the Arkenstone because he did not think to rifle through Bilbo’s pockets. Now, however, Bilbo definitely does not have the stone on his person, which leaves, in his mind, three distinct possibilities.
The first is that Thorin has actually found the gem, but for reasons entirely his own, he is pretending not to know where it is as a test of loyalty. Perhaps he wishes to see who in the company is devoted enough to him to continue searching indefinitely for a useless rock simply because he desires it. This, admittedly, seems a little far fetched. For one thing, Bilbo doubts that Thorin would be able to stop himself from displaying the Arkenstone if he ever got his hands on it. For another, Thorin does not seem to be operating based on any kind of logic at all, and it seems beyond him at this juncture to orchestrate such a cunning plot. Not to mention that there is no need to test anybody’s loyalty after the quest they’ve all just endured.
The second possibility is that the Arkenstone has hidden itself somehow. Bilbo does not know why the gem would do this, but he’s familiar enough with magic objects to understand that they often have their own minds. It’s perfectly possible that the stone wished only to be found by Bilbo, although he suspects that in that case, he would’ve stumbled upon it again. He’s spent more than his fair share of time combing through the treasury, if only to keep an eye on Thorin. He’d have seen it, then. And he has no reason to believe that the stone has the ability to hide itself in the first place. Surely, if that were the case, and if it were in any way averse to being placed above the throne of Erebor, it would have kept itself safe from discovery in the first place and the whole business would’ve been done with before it even began.
The third possibility, admittedly, the one toward which Bilbo is leaning as an explanation for the stone’s notable absence, is that somebody has picked it up and is keeping it from Thorin for the same reason that Bilbo hid it in his pocket on the first adventure. It would make sense, surely, that others in the company might be disturbed by their king’s behavior. Thorin has been single-minded, snippy, and downright rude, often ignoring everyone but Bilbo for hours, even days, at a time. And much of the attention that he pays to the Hobbit is so tainted by his gold sickness that the conversations are one-sided and nonsensical. It would be upsetting for anybody to observe.
The real question, Bilbo thinks, is who? Who has the Arkenstone? Thorin seems to believe that Balin is behaving suspiciously, and Bilbo wouldn’t put it past his friend to take the stone. Wasn’t he the one who advised Bilbo against giving it to Thorin in the first place? But Dwalin, too, seems deeply disturbed by Thorin’s behavior, and there is no question that he could overpower the king in a physical contest. Perhaps he has taken it upon himself to guard the stone. Nori has notoriously sticky fingers, and Bilbo finds it difficult to believe that if the Arkenstone were available for the taking, their resident thief would not simply pick it up. Bilbo finds it difficult to believe that Nori would have any interest in keeping the stone for himself, of course, but who knows how any of them are faring in the face of the dragon’s curse?
Glóin rarely leaves the treasury of late, so busy is he picking up the contents of his fourteenth share, and though Óin has spent most of his time in Erebor attempting to recover medical supplies from the old apothecary’s stalls and the half-burnt infirmary, his evenings are passed often at his brother’s side. Ori has been guarding Erebor’s half-ruined library, with the same jealous fervor that Thorin has devoted to the reminder of the treaure. Dori paces often and at length, which could be a sign that he is worried for his king and his brothers just as easily as it could be an indication of guilt.
Bombur has made it clear on multiple occasions that they are running out of food. Would he take the Arkenstone as a bargaining piece to push Thorin toward some kind of trade deal? Bifur has certainly made himself scarce lately. Could he be hiding something? And Bofur is incredibly observant. Last time, he proved that he was willing to undermine Thorin’s rule when he helped Bilbo sneak away on the eve of battle. He may very well have decided to hold onto the stone until such time as the king could be trusted with it.
And on the subject of observant people, Fíli was the one to witness Thorin’s display with the sword just before their fight with the dragon. Perhaps he was disturbed by his uncle’s behavior and took it upon himself to guard the Arkenstone. But it would be treasonous for Thorin’s heir to take the stone, as though he was claiming the crown for himself. Would Fíli really be so bold as to commit treason? Probably not, unless his brother’s safety were on the line.
Kíli might do it, though. Bilbo could see that easily. He may not understand the seriousness of the situation, though that stretches the imagination rather painfully. More likely than not, the lad knows this moment to be very grave indeed, though he’d be believed if he said he didn’t. He could hide the stone for everybody’s safety and then pretend at the last minute that he he was merely playing a child’s game of keep-away. Thorin wouldn’t fall for it, Bilbo knows, but Kíli has no reason to believe that his uncle wouldn’t be melted by his antics, per usual.
No. Bilbo refuses to believe that Kíli has the Arkenstone. That would be a disaster waiting to happen. It’s probably Balin. The old advisor can take care of himself. He’s a quick thinker and he knows Erebor well, not to mention his understanding of dragon sickness. He could easily get away from Thorin if he needed to; he’d know where to go and what to do to ensure that he never ends up held over the battlements. Probably, he’s already destroyed the stone, if it can be destroyed, or hidden it deep within the mountain. He’d never be so foolish as to simply carry it around inside his cloak. When Balin does something, he does it well, and with careful consideration for all possible outcomes. Bilbo trusts him to do what needs to be done, to make the right decision.
There is little else that he can do. He rarely sees the rest of the company anymore, save for the awkward intervals that they spend reporting to Thorin, while the king keeps Bilbo by his side. Any joviality that was present on the first night, when his friends frolicked and sang and played with tuneless harps like Hobbits underneath the party tree, has melted away in favor of a stern solemnity. Thus far, nobody has dared to attempt a private conversation with Bilbo. Not that he has any privacy for anyone to interrupt in the first place.
“Master Baggins, can we talk?”
Bilbo nearly falls off the side of the mountain at the sound of Fíli’s voice. Well, wouldn’t that be lovely. “You scared me,” he scolds. He should not have gotten so wrapped up in his thoughts. There are plenty of threats afoot, and it would not do to trifle with any one of them. “But alright.”
Fíli shuffles over, looking nervous. The past few days have aged him; that much is obvious from the bags beneath his eyes and the tired set of his formidable shoulders. And yet he looks so very young. He looks very much like Frodo did at Rivendell, before that terrible quest, and that sends a pang to Bilbo’s heart. The sensation is nearly unbearable, and the Hobbit sways, catching himself against the stone ledge. He makes a mental note, in a moment of hysteria, to encourage Thorin to have some proper railings put in once this whole Arkenstone business is over with. At this altitude, safety precautions must be taken, whether they damage the cultural heritage of Erebor or not.
“Bilbo,” Fíli begins, establishing himself beside Bilbo on the overlook. “Do you think Uncle Thorin has been acting strangely?”
Bilbo can’t help but snort at that question. “Do I think… yes, my boy, yes, I think your uncle has been out of his mind ever since we got here.”
Not the smartest thing to say, but Fíli asked, and Bilbo is sick of beating around the bush. He spends most of his time thinking strategically about how to help Thorin, speaking deliberately to the king to no avail. The only reason he was able to get out here at all was because he started hyper-ventilating in the treasury after another failed conversation, and Thorin mistook his panic for a want of fresh air. Even then, even thinking that the state of the treasury had put Bilbo into some sort of physical shock, the king was not willing to leave his hoard.
“I thought so,” Fíli breathes, looking out over the desolation with oddly steely eyes. He is not the same carefree, clever lad who waltzed into Bilbo’s smial all those months ago, but neither is he sprawled lifeless upon the stone below the watchtower on Ravenhill. Bilbo hasn’t seen that soft, playful smile of his since before they arrived at Erebor, but Fíli yet lives, and therefore any damage done is not irrevocable. “My mother warned me that this might happen.”
“Your mother?” Bilbo echoes, though of course, it makes perfect sense. Dís may be the only person in Middle Earth with the understanding and the courage to have spoken openly about the possibility of Thorin’s dragon sickness before he contracted the illness.
“She was very worried before we set out,” Fíli explains, “She thought often about the treasure. She remembered her grandfather when he had the,” he waves his hand, “The illness. It is gold sickness, isn’t it? That’s what Thorin has.”
“Yes.” Bilbo won’t lie to any of his friends. It is bad enough that he knew this was coming and did nothing to stop it, bad enough that he was so foolish as to genuinely believe that his affection would be enough to protect Thorin from the curse. Thorin is suffering because, despite having an entire journey to think of a way to help him, Bilbo has failed to do so. The least he can do is tell Fíli the truth. “Dragon sickness compounded by the curse of Durin’s line, I’d guess.” It is the gentlest warning he can give.
“I thought it was something like… when your mother says that your beard won’t grow unless you eat the crusts of your bread,” Fíli continues, “She didn’t want me to go with Thorin at all, and she seemed on the brink of losing her own mind when Kíli said he was coming along. I just thought she was trying to talk us out of it. You know how parents can be.”
Bilbo considers this. “You couldn’t possibly have known,” he assures the lad, “Thorin isn’t himself now, but… he never had any sign of gold sickness before, when he lived in Erebor. Even if your mother had some idea… well, it was only a small possibility, wasn’t it?” Bilbo regrets not learning more about the history of Erebor, the curse of Durin’s line, and the effects of dragon occupation upon a hoard of gold. It’s only that he didn’t want to know more, in the aftermath of his tragedy. He wanted things to have been different so badly that it took him years to even consider any meditation on the way they actually were.
“Yes,” Fíli agrees, if a little tenuously. “I just… is there nothing we can do for him? Nothing to reverse it? He is not thinking clearly. He is not ruling, only playing with his coins and jewels all day. We are running out of food, Bilbo.”
“I know.” And Bilbo does know. Despite his best efforts, the provisions from Lake-town are running thin. Even the members of the company who do not require seven meals a day are beginning to suffer the pangs of hunger, and it will only get worse from here.
“So, what can be done? You spend the most time with him. Is there any sign that it might get better on its own? Has he made any… progress, in the past few days? I have not spoken to him since the night before last.”
Bilbo swallows a lump in his throat at the obvious hope in the lad’s voice. Fíli is clever, brave, and a good leader. He’ll make a fine king some day. Bilbo refuses to entertain the possibility of what might happen on Ravenhill, not now, not when he has so many other things to worry about. He forces it down, deep into his guts, the same way he’s been doing for the past eight decades. Bilbo does not have the option of lingering on what might take place several days hence, because Fíli requires guidance that he won’t find anywhere else. Bilbo may be the only person alive who has seen someone recover from gold sickness, if only very briefly.
“I don’t think it will stop on its own,” Bilbo says finally, “I think we have to take responsibility and do what we can to help Thorin.”
“He does not listen to you,” Fíli points out. “I’ve seen you two together.”
He means, of course, that he has been spying, which Bilbo has suspected from the beginning. Thorin may be too wrapped up in his gold to notice when he’s being watched, but Bilbo is not. In fact, he imagines that most of the company has been spying, but it makes sense that Fíli would take it upon himself to do something about what he has witnessed. He is the heir, after all.
He did not intervene last time, but many things were different then. For a start, Thorin was much less attached to Bilbo, much less protective of him. Whether that was because he did not return Bilbo’s feelings or because he did not think that the Hobbit would receive his advances, Bilbo does not know. But, in keeping with Kíli’s warning in Lake-town, Thorin’s mild possessiveness has twisted in on itself since they arrived in Erebor. There is much more to object to this time around. And besides, Fíli witnessed something that nobody else saw on the first adventure.
“That thing with the sword,” Bilbo gestures to encompass the strange interaction. “Thorin wasn’t really going to hurt me.”
“No,” Fíli agrees, “Not any sooner than he would hurt his crown or his throne or the golden cup he drinks from.”
Bilbo cannot even pretend that isn’t a fair assessment. “It does seem that I’ve become a part of the hoard.” It’s a relief to speak these words aloud, though it does not stop them from weighing on his gut and his heart in equal measure. Why did he expect things to be different? Why did he expect things to be better? Why did he believe that his love would have any meaningful effect on Thorin’s mental state?
“When our people love, we love jealously,” Fíli shares. “And Thorin in particular can be…” He trails off, apparently trusting that Bilbo knows exactly how Thorin can be. “I know Kíli already warned you, but this is… excessive.”
Bilbo snorts. “Oh, is it?”
“It’s a good thing you don’t speak Khuzdul. Some of what Uncle says to you, if you knew what it meant, you’d be well within your rights to leave Erebor forever.”
“Maybe I would be, but you must know I wouldn’t do that. It’s not really Thorin saying those things, my boy. It’s the sickness.” Bilbo must believe this. In fact, he has clung to this belief for eighty years. Yes, Thorin tried to kill him, but he wouldn’t have done it if he’d been in his right mind. It was only the sickness, the blind greed brought on by proximity to a cursed treasure. “He’ll feel terrible about it when this is all over. I wouldn’t— I will not harm him. Not in any way.” No matter how many lifetimes Bilbo lives, he will never forget the despair in Thorin’s eyes when he learned that it was Bilbo who betrayed him. The Hobbit hopes sincerely never to see such a look again.
“Not even when he locks you in the treasury?” When. Not if. Bilbo is not sure if Fíli was eavesdropping when Thorin made that threat, or if he simply knows his uncle and understands the situation well enough to read the writing on the wall.
“Not even then.” It’s not even a question.
Fíli sighs. “I do not wish to be king before my time. I hope— I would hope that Thorin returns to his senses quickly. I cannot— Mahal, I can’t rule this Kingdom. I know he won’t accept a regent. And if he ordered the others to— to do something about it, well… he is still our king. He is mad, but he is our king, and he is my uncle, and…. Bilbo, I don’t know what to do.”
Bilbo doesn’t ask what the prince is talking about. He understands perfectly. If anybody had a right to step in and take the crown from Thorin, it would be Fíli. Bilbo is a little surprised by this turn of events, but clearly, whatever Fíli has witnessed lately, whatever Thorin has been saying to Bilbo, has been enough to push him toward this line of thinking. Bilbo does not know whether it is a good or bad thing that the lad is questioning his loyalty to his uncle now.
“I don’t think that would help him,” Bilbo says eventually. “I think maybe that might make it worse.”
Last time, Thorin nearly attacked Fíli for disobeying his order to execute Bilbo. If the prince tried to take the Raven Crown, things could very well get bloody. Bilbo doesn’t think that Fíli could kill his uncle, if it came down to that, but he knows that in his madness, Thorin would have no qualms about murdering any member of the company. Even Bilbo is not safe. Thorin would be destroyed by it, once he came back to himself, but he would do it.
“I know.” Clearly, Fíli has thought things through on his own. Of course he would have. “I don’t know what to do.”
“I don’t either,” Bilbo admits, fighting tears. He must be the strong one now. The lad needs support and guidance, things that his uncle can no longer provide. “Come here, my boy. It’s alright.” These may be empty words, but Bilbo pulls the prince into a hug regardless. It is the least he can do.
“We’re going to figure this out,” Fíli announces, returning Bilbo’s embrace. He is shaking ever so slightly, and Bilbo wonders who, exactly, the lad is trying to comfort with his optimistic declaration. “It’s going to be fine. We’ll figure something out. We have to, don’t we?” The typically quiet prince is rambling like a Hobbit. “I have no other choice.”
Bilbo does not know, because he has not been there, but all of a sudden, he can imagine what things have been like for the rest of the company. Fíli has been leading them, hanging on by a thread, presenting a front of regal certainty. Perhaps they expect him to have some sort of plan, some magical work-around for his uncle’s illness which will save them from the coming peril. But Fíli has nothing. None of them have anything in the face of Thorin’s madness.
“What is the meaning of this?” The snarl from the doorway chills Bilbo to his bones.
It is almost the same tone that Thorin used when he banished Bilbo from Erebor the first time around. Fíli releases Bilbo with lightning speed and turns to stare at his uncle in shock and horror. Bilbo has seen the prince wearing that expression only once before, when he was held with a sword at his throat moments prior to his death. Oh, what a fool Bilbo has been!
Gingerly, he steps away from Fíli. “Thorin,” he greets this person he loves so much, more than Bilbo has ever loved anyone else. More than Bilbo ever will love anyone else. “We were just talking about—“
“You think you can put your hands on what is mine?” Thorin all but growls at his nephew, ignoring the Hobbit entirely.
And Bilbo is trembling, whether with ire or fear he does not know. Yes, this is Thorin, his love. But this is also the dragon sickness, the spirit of Smaug and the horrible burden of Durin’s line all mingled together inside one strong but tired body, wreaking havoc on the king’s great mind. Oh, certainly, Thorin would not behave like this at all, were he well. He’d never raise his sword to any member of his family, were he thinking clearly.
But he is not thinking clearly, and he is not well, and Bilbo knows in the deepest reaches of his writhing guts that unless someone stops him, Thorin will not hesitate to hurt Fíli. All this time, Bilbo has been tip-toeing around it, trying to convince himself that he can love Thorin back to his senses. That at the very least, he can ensure that when the battle comes and the king returns to himself as he did the last time, he will be better fed and better rested than he was when he fell.
But all of that has flown out the window, and Fíli is still staring, wide-eyed, at the horrible, twisted expression on his uncle’s face. Does he notice the hand on the sword? Would he even look for something like that, from the person who helped raise him, his hero, his king? It does not matter. Bilbo’s heart is broken and he is no longer able to hold himself in check. Whatever Tookish part of him concocted this fantasy to begin with takes flight, and the Baggins wakes, shakes himself off, and plants his hands firmly on his ample hips.
“Don’t be preposterous, Thorin!” Bilbo steps between uncle and nephew. He must look ridiculous, trying to shield a strong Dwarven warrior with his soft little Hobbit body. He does not care. “Have you entirely lost your mind?” Yes. He has. “This is your nephew. Your sister-son. Practically your own child! Do you have any sense left to you at all?”
“He was touching you,” Thorin snarls. “Why have you allowed him to touch you?”
Bilbo is at an utter loss. His mouth opens and closes several times before he says. “Because the poor boy was close to tears fretting about you and that ridiculous rock you’re looking for.” Technically the truth. “And anyway, he’s your kin, and you and I are… well. We are… as we are, aren’t we? Aren’t you glad to know that your family approves of the match? Surely you should be pleased that your nephew treats me as an uncle already.”
“My sister-son,” Thorin mutters. His hand does not leave the pommel of his sword, but he does not step any closer. If he wanted to, he wouldn’t meet much resistance shoving Bilbo out of the way. Would Fíli fight back, in the event of an attack? Against his king? Against his uncle? Probably not.
“Yes, your sister-son, whom you love very much, when you have your wits about you,” Bilbo reiterates.
“Uncle,” Fíli breathes, hesitant. All of a sudden, he withdraws a white rock from his pocket. For a moment, Bilbo thinks that it might be the Arkenstone. But no. It is only a regular crystal, round and smooth, with none of the Arkenstone’s awful brilliance. The light catches it, and Bilbo can see that there is a perfectly round hole in the center of the stone. “Do you remember this stone? We found it in that village, I forget the name. You told me that it was a blessing from Mahal, to find one so well-shaped upon the earth. You told me it would bring clarity of mind, so that I would always remember the sort of leader the Maker shaped me to be. I’ve carried it all this time. Do you remember?”
“I am your king,” Thorin says quietly.
“But you are also my uncle,” Fíli ventures. Foolishly brave, really, coming from one who is effectively bargaining for his own life. He sets the little rock upon the ledge overlooking the desolation. “You must remember. It was a cloudy day, and Kíli was just learning to walk, so Mum had her hands full with him, and—“
“I am your king!” Thorin roars. Any trace of the flawed but loving uncle has disappeared entirely in the shadow of the mad monarch.
Grief and terror flash in Fíli’s eyes, and his mouth drops open as words fail him. He has seen his uncle in battle, Bilbo knows. It’s not as though he’s never heard Thorin use such a tone before. But this is likely Fíli’s first time hearing Thorin yell that way at anyone other than a foe. He is taken aback, more a wounded young lad than a warrior prince in this moment. He does not know what to do, and any hope he might’ve had of his uncle’s recovery has surely begun to evaporate at speed.
Bilbo is the one with the advantage of foresight. The only one, perhaps, who has any idea what’s going on. The only one, certainly, who has any idea of how to get Thorin back to himself. Not that his ideas have proven to be very good hitherto. But still, Bilbo must be the one to try. “You are a good king, Thorin,” Bilbo points out. It is true, or it was true, before this whole Arkenstone business began. “A just king. As I told you in Rivendell, remember? You are not your grandfather. And now you’ve reclaimed Erebor! Don’t throw that away, my love. Don’t do anything you can’t undo.”
“You are too trusting,” Thorin complains. “Someone has stolen the Arkenstone from me. Someone is keeping it. And yet you would—“
“Fíli is loyal to you,” Bilbo says flatly. This, too, is true. If Fíli were not loyal to Thorin, he’d not be waffling about taking the crown from his mad uncle. From a political standpoint, that would surely be the wisest move. Fíli, at least, would do something to prevent his people from starving to death. “Loyal enough to indulge the whims of your silly old consort.”
“You are not yet my consort, ghivashel,” Thorin breathes. He sounds almost like himself again, but Bilbo knows better now than to be fooled. After all, the ‘real Thorin’ has always been present to some degree within this violent stranger.
“Oh, well, not yet, I suppose, but I’ve been doing the job since we got here, haven’t I?” Bilbo tries to sound casual. He tries not to sound as though his heart has shattered, tries not to sound as though he hates himself for how manipulative he’s being. But then, what choice does he have? He cannot allow Thorin to harm any member of the company. “Now. Enough of this nonsense. It’s a waste of time, really, with our food stores running out.” He swallows, hoping that this is the right decision, “And the Arkenstone still not found.”
“Yes,” Thorin agrees, finally taking his hand off his sword. He comes forward and drapes an arm around Bilbo’s shoulders in a clear gesture of possession. Bilbo has to remind himself that the king’s mind is still addled by his illness. “Fíli, you should find your brother in the armory. There is much to be done.” The dismissal is pointed, but not as sharp as it could be. And seeing as it’s not a sword to the lad’s throat, Bilbo feels he has averted catastrophe, at least for the time being.
“Back to the throne room, then, my love?” It’s better than the treasury, at least.
“Mmm,” Thorin hums. “No. I think not. We will look for the Arkenstone ourselves, since my subjects have failed in its recovery thus far.”
Bilbo doesn’t like the sound of that, but at least Thorin has decided not to murder his own nephew for the apparent crime of accepting Bilbo’s hug.
“I will go and assist with the restoration of the armory, my king,” Fíli announces, but he continues to stand stock-still. And Bilbo cannot blame him for being in shock, if that is in fact the case.
“Very well.” Thorin maneuvers Bilbo back toward the darkness of the Mountain. “Come along, my Hobbit.”
Bilbo spares a glance behind him even as he follows Thorin inside. Fíli stands with his back to the retreating couple, staring out over the desolation once more. He has his right hand on the hilt of his own sword, as though he thinks that Thorin may attack him after all. His left hand rests in his pocket. No doubt he’s clutching that old stone of his, wondering how such a monumental change could lately have overcome the person who gave it to him. Just for a moment, staring out over the battlements with a thoughtful expression and every sign of exhaustion upon his regal face, the prince looks very much like his uncle.
Chapter 13: Kings and Their Nonsense
Notes:
This is another long one! Only a few more chapters left to go, although, of course, there are plenty of loose ends to be tied up. As always, thanks for reading/engaging, and enjoy!
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Thorin is positively fuming. He cannot believe the utter nonsense to which he has lately been subjected. The sheer idea that he might give over some of his treasure, not only to the Men of the Lake, but to the Elves as well? And why? Because the Men begrudged his company a few morsels of food and some ill-fitting clothes? Surely they did this only in the hope that they might someday get their hands on some of Thorin’s gold. And that says nothing of the Elves, who could claim no right to anything in the Mountain even if their intentions were true. It is below the dignity of the King Under the Mountain to be taunted and threatened by the Vassal of Dale, if Bard the Bargeman can be called as much.
“Begone!” Thorin yells through the gap in the wall. “Ere our arrows fly!”
He means that to the core of his being. He will shoot. His aim is not as true as his nephew’s, but he knows that he could do serious damage to that haughty bargeman, if he so chose. He has no love for the apparent leader of the Lake-Men who, only a few days ago, was speaking ill of Thorin in the streets and extorting him for coin as payment for the series of humiliation rituals to which Bard subjected his company. It was perhaps always some great conspiracy, the Elves and the Men putting their wicked heads together and concocting a plan to steal from Thorin. He would not put it past the Elves to be so conniving, nor the Men to be so greedy.
Thorin does not bother to watch as the Man departs on horseback. Instead, he returns to his company, in need of… something. Something that he cannot name. The Arkenstone, perhaps, though he still cannot find it, nor can he sense its presence as once he believed he might upon entry to the Mountain. His One, perhaps.
He is cheered, at least, by the sight of his Hobbit. Bilbo did not follow Thorin to the confrontation with Bard, and why would he? His place is inside the Mountain It would not do for any part of Thorin’s hoard to be seen by outsiders. Better for his One to remain unobserved, alongside the other precious things in Thorin’s keeping. He is pleased that Bilbo seems to understand this.
Thorin sighs in response to a gentle touch on his arm. Bilbo is always so warm, so alive and vibrant, so unlike the gold and jewels. It is a welcome change of pace but slightly dizzying nevertheless, as though Thorin’s body cannot fully adapt to the contrast between the hot, earthy beauty of his One and the cool splendor of his other treasure. “Bilbo,” he breathes, allowing his rage to leave him. Yes, this is much better after all, far preferable to spending any time with Elves and Men.
“Thorin,” Bilbo swallows heavily. Something troubles him. Perhaps the encroachment of Men and Elves upon Dwarven lands, their greed trained on Dwarven treasure. “Are you really going to do this? A war would be devastating for our people, not to mention for the Mountain itself. It would leave us open to attacks from the North. The goblins have been laying in wait since we killed their leader, and Azog’s orcs have been tracking us for even longer. If they should find us already besieged, already half starved—“
“This does not concern you.” Thorin cuts his One off with a gentle smile.
Of course the Hobbit would fret. He knows nothing of war, nothing of the world outside his cozy home. Thorin must protect him from the horrors of battle, from the inevitable confrontation with the Elves and Men. He must lock Bilbo up inside the Mountain where nobody will touch him. He must preserve the sweet innocence that causes Bilbo to believe that greedy creatures like Bard of Esgaroth will keep their word.
“Please, Thorin,” Bilbo tries again. “The Men and Elves are not our enemies. We have to prepare for battle, yes, but not against them.”
“Who, then, ghivashel?” Thorin runs a finger along Bilbo’s jaw, relishing the way his love swallows in response. He watches as Bilbo blatantly fights the urge to allow his eyes to flutter shut. Yes, the Hobbit is talking nonsense, but Thorin enjoys his company nevertheless.
“The orcs,” Bilbo replies, a little agitated now. “I just told you. They’re still tracking us.”
“You think they’re going to attack again?” Kíli asks, sounding genuinely concerned.
Annoyance bubbles up from somewhere deep within Thorin. Bilbo can be excused for expecting an orc attack, for failing to see the danger posed by the Men and Elves. He comes from a land of peace and plenty. He knows nothing of war, nothing of greed. But Kíli has been well educated in the ways of their people. He should know better than to excuse the threat of one war for the specter of another.
“I know they’re going to attack again,” Bilbo persists, “And they’ll bring wargs and goblins with them. Trolls, too, and worm monsters and all sorts of other horrible things. In case you’ve forgotten, Azog survived our last encounter. He seeks to end the line of Durin, does he not? Well, now there are three, four, how many of you?” Bilbo does not pause long enough for Thorin or anyone else to begin explaining their family tree to him, though it will be important for him to be familiar with this information when he is consort. “And all penned up inside a mountain with no clear plan of escape.”
“But that’s only if our enemies can get inside,” Fíli points out. “Couldn’t we hold the Mountain?” A foolish question. Of course they can hold the Mountain. And if they cannot, then better to die here among their treasures than cold and filthy on the field of battle.
“The Men and Elves will weaken our defenses,” Bilbo reasons, “We must do what we can to stop this war. Thorin, if you give them just a little bit of gold, they’ll all be beholden to you forever. If you personally financed the rebuilding of Dale—“
“You worry too much,” Thorin scolds lightly. He is not angry with Bilbo. Of course the Hobbit does not know any better than to fret, though Thorin is none too pleased with his nephews for encouraging this line of thinking. “Go and wait in the treasury. I will come and find you once the preparations have been made.” He does not believe that there will be an orc attack. Such stupid creatures could never break through the fortifications that their company has lately built, let alone the ones forged by Thorin’s ancestors.
“I will not wait anywhere,” Bilbo protests. It is endearing, this desire of his to remain by Thorin’s side. Unfortunately, Thorin would rather see his beloved safe and unhappy than allow him to put himself into danger. The separation, he is sure, would be bearable under such circumstances. “We are running out of food, and there are only fourteen of us. We are weakening ourselves for no reason and wasting time we could be using to prepare!” That, at least, makes sense. Yes, time is being wasted, standing here talking when Thorin should be arming his subjects and instructing them on the best methods to defend the hoard. “What, exactly, do you propose we do?”
“You should never underestimate Durin’s folk,” Thorin assures Bilbo warmly. Well, as warmly as he can manage. It’s difficult to muster too much mirth when the Men and Elves have brought armies to his door, intent on stealing from his hoard. “We have reclaimed Erebor. Now, we defend it.”
“You have sent word to Dáin already, then.” Bilbo sighs heavily. Why is he disheartened by this news?
“I have,” Thorin replies, “He will come with an army and defend the Mountain.”
“That’s all well and good, but the Elves and Men are not our enemies.” Bilbo repeats himself, gripping onto Thorin’s sleeve as though his life depends on it. “Listen, please listen. We are wasting vital time trying to fight each other when we should be doing everything we can to cut the orcs and goblins off! If we only parlay with the Men—“
“I will do no such thing.”
“Even if we survive,” Bilbo argues, “And even if the Mountain really is impassible, which, I’m sorry, no offense to all of you, you’ve done a lovely job, but I highly doubt, considering how quickly the twelve of you were able to put it together with your bare hands—“
“I do not doubt the skill of my people.” Thorin waves him off.
“A day ago you were doubting their loyalty!” Bilbo snaps.
And this is true enough. It is not as though Thorin has forgotten about the Arkenstone, of course. He knows that one of his own people has stolen the stone and is keeping it from him. But he knows, also, that failure to construct a proper barrier would put everyone at risk. “No one would be fool enough to steal the Arkenstone and then throw away his own life leaving the door open to our enemies. Relax, ghivashel. It is none of your concern.”
“Listen, Thorin, please listen.” The king’s Hobbit is clearly very upset, but the desperation in his tone is oddly gratifying. He cares so much about Thorin’s wellbeing that he would be willing to befriend Elves to protect him. Misguided though this logic may be, it’s rather sweet.“You are not yourself right now. When you come to your senses, you’ll be angry and guilty and you’ll regret what you’re doing now! If you still want to fight the Elves and Men later, then by all means, after we’ve dealt with the real threat, you can have your stupid, pointless war! But for now, we should be doing everything in our power to make sure that our people have food. Are you not hungry?”
“You worry too much, my Hobbit,” Thorin decides once more with finality. “Even if the orcs do come, Dáin’s army will dispatch them once the Men and Elves are dealt with. They are the ones who insist upon making war. I did not bring an army to their gate.”
“Yes, I know, it’s all terribly unfair, and Thranduil is being very greedy.” Thorin is pleased to see Bilbo finally coming around. Not that it matters very much what the Hobbit thinks. He does not know enough to have a serious opinion. Soon, he will be educated in the ways of the Ereborean court, and he will understand what it means to be consort to a king. For now, however, he must be kept away from danger at any cost. Even if it means that Thorin must drag Bilbo into the deepest vaults kicking and screaming. “But we must do what we can to prevent needless bloodshed.”
The others look on in silence, clearly waiting to see how Thorin will react to this odd challenge. “Then we are agreed.” They are, aren’t they? “I will not allow those thieves to touch my treasure. Dáin will assist us in defending the mountain, be it from Men or Elves or orcs. I have spoken.”
“You have a funny definition of ‘agree,’” Bilbo grumbles. “Come back to yourself, please, my love. As soon as possible.” He wraps his arms around Thorin, then, and though the words the Hobbit speaks make little sense, Thorin is content to return the embrace.
The only advantage to all of this battle-preparation business is that Bilbo now has more time than ever to himself. It is almost like being back in Bag End, save for the fact that his days, and those of all of his friends, are numbered. And, of course, there is virtually no food remaining. Second breakfast would be laughable to consider now, let alone elevensies, and even luncheon has become a thing of the past. Dinner and supper, already merged into one meal called interchangeably by either name, in keeping with the Dwarven custom, seem also to be on the way out. Really, it is not like Bag End at all, save for the all-encompassing loneliness.
He knows why. He understands perfectly. For anyone other than Thorin to speak to him privately at this juncture would pose a major risk. Bilbo does not know whether Fíli chose to tell the others what happened on the battlements, but surely he has warned them against getting too close to their Hobbit. Some members of the company, however, do not seem to take very well to warnings.
Nori and Kíli approach Bilbo while he is puttering about, ostensibly looking for the Arkenstone while Thorin rants nonsensical battle plans in Dwalin’s general direction. Bilbo does not wish to know the substance of these plans, and it troubles him that Thorin is so drawn in by them as to release his possessive hold for a moment. It seems that whatever he plans to have done to Thranduil is more important to him than Bilbo’s apparent well-being, which would be troubling under the rosiest of circumstances. These most certainly are not those.
“Our king’s gone insane,” Nori observes casually. Nobody else has said it aloud, but he’s right, of course. They all know he’s right. Thorin has gone insane and cannot be trusted to rule his kingdom. He would lead them to war and ruin, if not outright starvation, for the sake of his hoard, just as he did eighty years ago.
“It’s the gold,” Kíli explains when Bilbo makes no comment. Because what can Bilbo say? He can’t very well defend Thorin against accusations that are entirely true. “All this cursed dragon’s gold. That’s what’s making him like this.”
“Mmm,” Bilbo hums noncommittally. He will not make the same mistake twice. Thorin will not hesitate to harm even his own kin if he believes they’re getting too close to Bilbo.
“I’m sorry,” Kíli blurts out. “All of this is my fault.”
“Your highness,” Nori scolds him, delivering the title with his characteristic irreverence, “Shut up. That’s not what we’re here for.”
“No,” Kíli does not take instructions, as a general rule. If he did, no doubt he’d be in the armory with his brother, away from the gold but presumably doing something tangentially related to the security of Erebor. This arrangement seems to suit everyone involved: kept away from the treasure, Fíli and Kíli appear to have remained relatively healthy, and Thorin has no reason to suspect either of his nephews of any treachery of treason. “Bilbo, I’m so sorry. I told you to… in Lake-town, I mean, I said you and Thorin should… I didn’t think he’d get like this. I thought, if you just told him that you didn’t like the… possessiveness, then he’d stop. I should never have— Oh, Mahal, Bilbo, I’m sorry. I’m so sorry.”
Ah. Of course. Kíli encouraged Bilbo to initiate a proper relationship with Thorin, and now, because of that connection, Thorin’s behavior has expanded to unacceptable levels of possessiveness and paternalism. It makes sense that Kíli might blame himself, Bilbo supposes, though it is certainly not the prince’s fault that his uncle has lost his mind.
“Hush, lad, it’s alright.” But Bilbo knows better than to offer any genuine comfort. He won’t touch Kíli. Thorin will view it as threat, and he will retaliate.So Bilbo grips the nearest railing like a vice. Such a coward he has become! “It’s not your fault. You couldn’t possibly have known.” Just as he told Fíli earlier. Just as he will tell Thorin when all of this is over and the king comes back to himself. Bilbo should get used to these words, if he’s chosen to throw his lot in with the Line of Durin.
Bilbo has one goal. Never mind the silent, nonfunctional Ring of Power in his pocket. Never mind the fact that he is living in a dusty old mountain full of dragon dung. Never mind the madness of his king. Never mind the that useless, gaudy, thrice-damned rock.Bilbo needs to keep all of his friends alive, however he can. If that means manufacturing distance and keeping Thorin happy until a better plan can be worked up, then that is what Bilbo will do.
Yes. Alright. He’s been avoiding the company, the princes especially. He has chosen to isolate himself, elected to suffer alone under Thorin’s penetrating gaze. What else can he do? How else can he protect them? The Arkenstone is missing, even if Bilbo were fool enough to think of trying to trade it for assurances of securityagain. Thorin would only grow angry, and he would not be swayed.
Nori pats the prince awkwardly on the shoulder. What is needed is a proper Hobbit hug, un-self-conscious, soft, and warm. But that is not an option right now. Bilbo cannot take that risk, cannot put Kíli in any more danger than he is already in, with an orc host marching toward them and the Men and Elves gathered down below.
“Listen, Bilbo,” Nori begins. “None of us have any sway with Thorin anymore. He’s not even listening to Balin. Never thought I’d see that day, I can tell you. But do you think you could—“
“No,” Bilbo cuts him off. “I couldn’t.”
“You didn’t even let me finish.”
Bilbo closes his eyes. He can imagine the sorts of plans that may have circulated among the company in his and Thorin’s absence. “If you’d like me out of the way so you can mount a coup, I have to decline,” he growls. When did Bilbo Baggins start growling at people? “Thorin won’t hesitate to kill any of you, unless you killed him first. And if any of you did that, I’d never forgive you.”
“We wouldn’t dream of a coup,” Nori assures him, “Besides, Fíli won’t go along with it. I’ve asked.” Strange. Bilbo can’t imagine that happening the last time he did all of this.
“At least someone still has some sense.”
“You think we should let Thorin go to war?” Nori demands. “Let him send us to our deaths? Let him send our brothers to their deaths? When we’re all gone, there won’t be anybody left to unlock whatever chamber he puts you in once the Mountain’s under siege.”
“There must be some way to stop it,” Kíli manages, making a valiant effort to smother his sniffles. The poor lad is blaming himself for all of this, though he has no reason to. Thorin’s condition is nobody’s fault but Bilbo’s, and even he couldn’t have seriously stopped the king from entering the Mountain. “He won’t listen to any of us, but if we could go down and parlay behind his back, maybe—“
“No, no, absolutely not.” Bilbo has done this before, after all. He knows how that story ends. With a convenient Wizard at the last moment, or else with a broken body splayed out on the ground beneath the battlements. “It’s too much of a risk.”
“I’m quick and quiet,” Nori reminds him. “I’ve got noble blood, strictly speaking, if anyone wants to get technical about it. I know how to put on a good face. All you’ve gotta do is distract Thorin, and I’ll make my way down the Mountain and see what I can do.”
“No.” Bilbo says it firmly. “Nori, no. Absolutely not.”
“Someone’s got to do something.”
“Yes, someone has.” That much, Bilbo can agree to. “But Thorin will catch you, and he’ll have you killed. Both of you. Anyone who was involved. Anyone he suspects might have been involved. And then when he gets better, he will hate himself for the rest of his days. Do you understand? Thorin isn’t himself right now. Do you think he’d hesitate? And you can’t parlay behind his back, anyway. Even if you had the Arkenstone, which I sincerely hope you don’t, it wouldn’t work as leverage against Thorin. Trust me when I tell you that he wouldn’t listen. He’d only get angry, and he’d never give over any gold to get the wretched thing back. Short of murder—“
“No,” Kíli protests. “Never. It’s like you said. This isn’t really him. We can’t— For Durin’s sake, we can’t…” He never finishes the sentence, and Bilbo doesn’t blame him.
Bilbo closes his eyes. “Let me think of something. Let me take care of it. I’ve got you out of every mess until now, haven’t I? This shouldn’t be harder than a stroll to Buckland.” The Shire saying sounds out of place here in this Mountain darkened by the twin shadows of a fire-breathing dragon and a mad king.
“Last time you got us out of a mess, you left me with a nasty bruise on the back of my neck.” Apparently, Nori still isn’t over the little incident where a wounded Bilbo toppled into his barrel as they were escaping from the Elves.
“Have Óin put some salve on it, if it’s still bothering you,” Bilbo instructs.He honestly can’t believe that Nori hasn't done anything about the bruise until now. No, the thief is only teasing him, trying to lighten the moment, almost certainly for Kíli’s sake. The lad does not look any better than his brother did the other day. Oh, those poor young princes, gathering up their uncle’s slack as best they can, to no avail. There is nothing any of them can do to force Thorin to give over the gold, at least not in his present state. “I’ll put a stop to this. But in the meantime, none of you should do anything stupid.”
Kíli laughs, if a little weakly. He seems to be bordering on hysteria. “Do you think we could get in touch with Tauriel? Would the Ravens go to her? If only I could get to Ravenhill. Is that not where they roost?”
“No,” Bilbo’s blood is ice in his veins. Ravenhill. Ravenhill, of all places? That is Kíli’s plan? It would be a good one, perhaps, if not for the oncoming orcs. Suddenly, Bilbo’s focus shifts. His sole reason for drawing breath at this time is to keep Kíli from rushing to his death.“No, you’ll not be going to Ravenhill. As I said, I’ll take care of this. You’d better go and look like you’re doing something warlike, both of you, before Thorin notices anything amiss. If Tauriel can be reached, Kíli, then I’ll do my best. But for now, none of you should try to sneak about. You don’t send warriors or thieves do do a Burglar’s job.”
Nori whistles. “Well, the consort has spoken.” He affects a smug expression that fools nobody. The thief may be a quick thinker, and he may have plenty of experience bluffing, but he’s as terrified as any of the rest of them. “That’s that, then.”
Bilbo is not the consort, not technically, at least. But they all know that he’s been fulfilling that role since their arrival in Erebor. And if his friends seeing him that way keeps them from doing anything that might get somebody killed, Bilbo is more than happy to go along with it.“We really should be going,” Kíli decides, gathering himself. “Bilbo’s right. Uncle Thorin is going to notice that we’re gone.” Bilbo can only pray that his advice will be taken.
Time does not render Bilbo any aid in concocting a plan that might return Thorin to his right mind. He spends his days pacing and thinking, trying to work something out, with scant results. Everything he tries has fallen flat, and now the company is being armed for war. They rifle through the armory while Bilbo paces in tight circles outside the door.
“Ghivashel.” Thorin’s voice distracts Bilbo from his mounting anxiety, as it always does. He struggles not to feel comforted by the sheer presence of his lost love. There is some tiny, selfish part of him which is indiscriminately happy to be by Thorin’s side, even when the king is so obviously in such a terrible state. “Come here.”
Bilbo sighs heavily. He could have avoided this, if he really wanted to. He could have done as he was told and waited in the treasury. He could have chosen to do his pacing as far from the armory as possible. He could have secreted himself away and slunk out of the Mountain at the earliest opportunity, though what he would do, he isn’t certain. The ring in Bilbo’s pocket no longer grants him invisibility, but he is still a Hobbit and could easily have hidden from the company if he wished to. He can pretend, he supposes, that he only wants the benefit of armor. He can pretend that this is a tactical maneuver, that his head is focused solely on his goals of saving his friends and destroying the ring. But really, Bilbo is being incredibly weak.
It was a struggle not to close his eyes and melt into Thorin’s embrace when the king was spouting nonsense about the necessity of defending his treasure from thieves. It is a struggle every day for Bilbo not to go completely boneless, to respond as his body wishes to the attention lavished upon him. He has spent eight decades longing for Thorin’s touch, for the love that was ripped away from him upon Ravenhill. His mind and body have cried out, loudly at first, then quieter and quieter as the years progressed, for this person who now seems to crave Bilbo’s company just as openly.
But Thorin is not well. It would not be right for Bilbo to fold, to allow him anything more than a few chaste touches. Not because he doesn’t want it, but because it would be taking advantage. Thorin cannot make sure decisions at this juncture. And it is clear that no matter how gentle his caresses might be, he does not presently regard Bilbo as an independent person but as simply one more piece of treasure in his hoard. He is going to give Bilbo a beautiful gift, one that could very well serve as a symbol of his love, but instead it will be nothing more than an act of possession. And Bilbo will lean into it, because he needs the stupid impenetrable shirt, and he loves Thorin, and he wants it to be no more complicated than any other gesture of affection. It breaks Bilbo’s heart, but he lacks the luxury of time to be heartbroken.
Emotions aside, he needs that mithril mail. There is nothing more to be said on the matter. Bilbo finds himself standing in front of Thorin, just as he did the last time. Only now, he understands so much more about Dwarven customs and the nature of dragon sickness. He’s had his suspicions about this moment, of course, but they have been largely irrelevant until now. What did it matter what Thorin’s intentions were when the king was laying motionless in the crypts beneath the Mountain with the Arkenstone upon his breast?
“You’re going to need this.” Thorin shakes the mithril shirt, and the mail rattles prettily. The way it sparkles in the torchlight is undeniably beautiful as well. “Put it on.” Another command. Bilbo has long wished that he could have shared this moment with a more stable version of Thorin, that his dear friend who hugged him on the Carrock could have been the one to bestow this armor upon him. But not so. And even still, Bilbo does as he is told.
“This vest is made of silver steel,” Thorin explains. “Mithril, it was called by my forbears. No blade can pierce it.”
And Bilbo knows all this, of course. He knows that this mail saved Frodo’s life on more than one occasion when the lad went on his quest to Mordor. He knows that the fate of Middle Earth lays in Thorin’s hands at this moment.Because last time, it may have been Frodo, but this time, Bilbo will be the one to throw that ring in Mount Doom.
He didn’t realize this was his plan until the thought popped so clearly into his head, but now, he knows that it is what he must do. He knows that there is no other choice, no other way to ensure that the ring is fully destroyed. He’ll show it to Gandalf first, of course, and see what the Wizard thinks, but Bilbo was a fool to believe that his quest will be over so easily. If he survives the battle, no matter what happens to any of his friends, Bilbo knows that he will have another long journey ahead of him.
But he does not have time to dwell on it now. There is a war coming, and Bilbo can’t imagine he’ll get to Mount Doom any time soon. He knows that he’ll have to stay and fight, to do everything in his power to protect Thorin and his heirs, before he can worry any more about the ring. Bilbo also knows that he does not look as ridiculous in this getup as he thought he did the last time. What had he said before? I’m not a warrior, I’m a Hobbit.
But Thorin has not dressed him in the vestments of a warrior. That much is plain to see with a single glance into the armory. The others are dressed in heavy armor, complete with plates and helmets. Their bodies are obscured by the blocky metal, which will be difficult to pierce by virtue of its construction. They are the warriors, and Bilbo is dressed like the Consort of Erebor. Precious to the king and fine to look at. A piece of treasure, not a weapon to be deployed upon the battlefield. Yes, Bilbo is going to need armor, but Thorin must intend this only as last line of defense.
“It is a gift,” the king explains. “A token of our love.” The word falls heavily from his lips, laden with meanings that were not so apparent the last time they did this.
And Bilbo is a very weak Hobbit indeed, to swoon and melt as he does at the sound of it. Love. Love. It is not love. Or it is love, of course it is love, but this act is not demonstrative of that. Thorin does not remember what it feels like to love Bilbo. He knows now only what it is to covet, to crave the presence of the Hobbit by his side. He would hurt Bilbo, if he felt betrayed, if he felt justified in doing so.
And yet this is a moment of which Bilbo has dreamed for many years. Receiving a gift from Thorin, being told in no uncertain terms that he is loved, that the feelings blooming in his mind and body are not his alone. That he and Thorin are at a solid, healthy understanding, that they have a future together. That Thorin wants a future with him, when he could have anyone else. Still, Thorin would choose Bilbo. Even when his mind is gone, even when he cannot remember what it is to love or how one should behave toward one’s partner, still, some central part of him would choose Bilbo.
It is a knife in Bilbo’s side. It is a knife and it is twisting and it is worse than bearing the One Ring, worse than learning Frodo’s fate, worse than living for all those years alone in the Shire. But it is not worse than watching Thorin bleed out upon the ice, hearing him beg for forgiveness, knowing that the king went to his grave thinking that he’d ruined things, that Bilbo did not return his feelings. It does not matter what a stronger Hobbit would do. Bilbo asks the question he was too afraid to ask the last time. “Is this a proposal, Thorin?”
Thorin laughs, then, the same way that he did both times on the Carrock. The same way that he does whenever Kíli makes a stupid, well-timed joke, deliberately engineered to catch his uncle off guard. Just like when Dwalin does something uncharacteristically gentle or Balin’s nagging borders on the hyperbolic. This is the same laugh that Thorin hid inside his mug of ale when Bofur danced on the table at Rivendell, the same laugh that bubbled forth one night on the road when Fíli elected to entertain the company with his rather impressive juggling skills. This laugh is the real Thorin Oakenshield, not the King Under the Mountain he was raised to be or the trauma that has toughened him or the dragon sickness that has lately poisoned his great mind.
“It is,” he replies eventually, swallowing his mirth. Bilbo could kiss him. Because this is not the mad monarch, but Thorin Oakenshield, truly, the only one Bilbo has ever loved with such passion, such levity, such intensity. “What say you?”
“Do you really have to ask?” Bilbo can’t help but smile up at Thorin. He stares into those beautiful, gleeful blue eyes. There is so much hope there, so much love. And nerves, too, as if Thorin ever seriously believed that Bilbo would deny him. Bilbo, who has stayed by his side through the worst of the dragon sickness and everything else. The idea of refusing Thorin now is simply laughable. “I say yes, of course. I told you already, I intend to be your consort once this whole mess is sorted out.”
Tell me that you’ll sort it out now, Bilbo pleads inside his head. Tell me that you’ll send a Raven to Bard, that you’ll parlay, that you’ll give them a little gold and turn your focus and your cousin’s army to the Goblins and Orcs. Tell me that you’re sorry. Tell me that you need to go apologize to Fíli for the way you spoke to him the other day. Tell me—
“You are loyal to me, then.” Bilbo watches as the blue flame returns to Thorin’s eyes. “That is hard to come by.” Thorin places a heavily-armored hand on his shoulder and steers him just a little too roughly away from the armory where the rest of the company resides. “I have been blind. But now I begin to see. I am betrayed.”
Bilbo’s heart falls to his stomach as he realizes he has heard these words before. Nothing he does matters, does it? No matter what he tries, Thorin still falls into the same dark patterns that he traced before. “Betrayed?” Bilbo echoes uselessly, just as he probably did the first time.
He keeps falling into this same ridiculous trap. He keeps convincing himself, even momentarily, that he has somehow managed to save Thorin with romance alone. He is no better than the princes on that score, blaming himself for something that is clearly not his fault. Thorin did not die upon Ravenhill because Bilbo failed to communicate his feelings. He died because Azog stabbed him. He died because he was fighting through grief. He died because he was weak and tired and hungry and drained from his sickness. He died because that is what happens in battle: people die. Kings die, and the young die, and Men and Elves and orcs die, and there is nothing Bilbo can do about any of that.
Not unless he prevents the battle. Not unless he stops his friends from marching on Ravenhill. Not unless he secures an impossible alliance. Even if he could cure Thorin’s madness, he tells himself, staring into the king’s hot eyes, the outcome of the battle would not automatically be changed.
“The Arkenstone,” Thorin clarifies. “One of them has taken it. One of them is false.”
Last time they had this conversation, the Arkenstone was in Bilbo’s pocket. Now, he does not know where it is, though of course, he has his suspicions. Balin is still the most likely candidate, but then, Bombur has been particularly reclusive lately, and Bofur has been shooting worried looks in Bilbo’s direction for the past several days. Fíli had his hand in his pocket when Bilbo saw him on the battlements, and Kíli has tried to talk Thorin into helping the people of Lake-town more than once. Dwalin has been oddly quiet, as well, and Dori continues to pace. Ori rarely leaves the library, even for what scant meals the company can manage to scrape together. Nori was prepared to go down and parlay with the Men and Elves, but what could he possibly have to offer, save for the stone? It could be any of them.
“Thorin,” Bilbo begins, “I don’t think—“
“Betrayed by my own kin,” Thorin cuts him off.
“Maybe you just haven’t found it yet.” These words sound hollow and false even to Bilbo. Of course somebody has the Arkenstone. There is not enough gold in Erebor to hide its shine indefinitely. After so many long days with so many of them looking, someone has to have stumbled upon it. “Maybe it will come to you in time.”
“In time?” Thorin echoes. “We do not have time. There is an armed host at our gates.”
“So we should be worried about how we will prevent the oncoming siege,” Bilbo reasons, “Or at least how we will feed ourselves during it.”
“You are wise and noble,” Thorin decides, though Bilbo feels these words are just as empty as his own. If Thorin truly thought Bilbo wise, he’d listen to him, which he clearly does not intend to do. And as for nobility, it means very little to have noble motives when they do not carry any action with them. “A fine consort you will make.”
“Could you not give just a little bit to Bard, just to help his people get back on their feet?” Bilbo asks. “Whatever you would give to me as a wedding gift, give to them instead. They need it far more than I do. I am content just with your company, and the company of our kin. I don’t need any more than that.”
“The treasure does not belong to the people of Lake-town.” Thorin cups Bilbo’s face in his hand. It might be romantic, were he not dressed for battle, were his eyes not blazing with a fire hotter than any burning coals could produce. “This gold… is ours. And ours alone. By my life, I will not part with a single coin. Not one piece of it.” His intensity makes Bilbo shudder. The implication is clear. Bilbo may be the future consort of Erebor, but his betrothed will never grant him the authority to give away any of the treasure.
Bilbo wants to ask Thorin whether he himself is included in that treasure, whether the king would allow Bilbo to leave his sight if the Hobbit so wished. He wants to know what it was that made Thorin’s glare soften, ever so briefly, and what it was that made those haunting flames come back. He wants to say something that will help, something that will make Thorin reconsider his decision to send the company to war. Would a wedding make things better or worse?
But before Bilbo can say anything, he is interrupted by the sound of footsteps. The company marches out of the armory, single-file, dressed for war. The torchlight makes their breastplates gleam. They all bear impressive weapons, most of which Bilbo cannot imagine lifting on his own. He has a distinct memory of the last time this happened. Thorin stepped back, as did Bilbo, and the others marched in between them, an impassible divide. Thorin’s warlike behavior drove a wedge between them, forced apart what might have been a significant pairing.
Now, however, Thorin grabs Bilbo around the waist and drags him out of the way. It is such an easy, fluid motion. Not premeditated at all. Was Thorin restraining himself the first time, then? Has Bilbo, in agreeing to marry him, taken away some of Thorin’s meagre self-restraint? Or did Thorin suspect that Bilbo had taken the Arkenstone? Did he fight with himself, the small part left of the Thorin Bilbo knew assuring the mad monarch that the Hobbit would never betray him? Is that why he became so violent when he learned that he was wrong?
“I know you do not have it,” Thorin murmurs into Bilbo’s ear as Bofur marches past them, a metal helmet balanced oddly atop his favorite hat. “I would have felt it as I held you close.” Yes, he would have. They have been in such proximity lately that Thorin would doubtlessly have noticed if the Arkenstone were on Bilbo’s person. “And since Mahal has bound you to me as my One, you could not betray me if you wished.” That’s not strictly true, but Bilbo is not about to correct Thorin on his misapprehension. “But it could be any of them.”
Bilbo does not know what to say. He does not wish to lie, but he certainly has no desire to put whoever has bravely taken the Arkenstone into any more danger than they are already in. Instead, he speaks the truth. “Everyone here is loyal to you,” he points out, “They all came this way with you, didn’t they? But there is a curse upon this treasure. You may not be the only one affected.”
Everything is going to be fine. Balin must have the Arkenstone, as Bilbo concluded earlier. He would know to take it and destroy it. He probably threw it into some deep mine, or off the side of the mountain, or passed it off to a Raven to drop into Mount Doom. Or something of that nature. Balin, surely, would not hesitate to keep the gem from Thorin. He’d know what to do. Bilbo should not be worrying about the possibility that someone more volatile, someone with more of a claim to the throne, someone less objective about Thorin’s present state, might have claimed the rock.
“There is no curse,” Thorin declares, as if he did not personally drag his grandfather from the treasury during a dragon attack. Thrór was so addled at that time that he was willing to burn to death so long as he did not have to leave his treasure behind. But if Thorin believed in the curse, he’d be aware of his own madness, which would be too much to ask. “None would steal from my hoard but by his own will. I will find the thief and chop off his hand as penance for his crime before I kill him.”
“These people are your kin, Thorin,” Bilbo points out. The company has long since passed them by. They received a few odd glances, a knowing smirk from Bombur and a heavy sigh from Balin, but nobody spoke. Nobody would dare intrude on what appeared to be a very private moment. More likely than not, they thought that Thorin was whispering sweet nothings in Bilbo’s ears, as opposed to paranoid rambling. Or, at least, they prefer to believe the former to the latter, which, considering Thorin’s condition at the moment, must be known to all to be more likely.
“And that makes the betrayal all the worse.”
There is no swaying him, no changing Thorin’s mind once he has set it on something. Bilbo knows this from experience. So he settles for leaning back, resting his head uncomfortably against the king’s metal-clad chest. Neither one of them says anything for a very long while, and nobody makes any move to interrupt them.
The next day or so passes by in a blur. Coaxing Thorin out of the treasury at all is a genuine feat, and getting him to stay out long enough to eat a proper meal or get a full night’s sleep is, apparently, beyond the capacity of a single loving Hobbit. Bilbo does what he can, but as he watches his king frantically sorting gems and coins in a fruitless search for the Arkenstone, apparently unconcerned with the dark circles under his eyes, his rapidly loosening clothes, and the armies waiting at his gate, it is difficult to feel like anything more than a failure.
Rarely does he see the others, for all that Thorin keeps him close. Balin has managed a few visits to the treasury in his capacity as advisor, with a few long looks in Bilbo’s direction when Thorin is distracted. The king seems to welcome his sister-sons to his domain well enough, though Bilbo could not parse the frantic hand-gestures with which they tried to communicate with him behind Thorin’s back. Dwalin once told Thorin directly to ‘let the Hobbit breathe a minute,’ which resulted in his immediate dismissal from the king’s line of sight, coupled with a threat against his life.
Regardless of the obvious fears harbored by his companions, Bilbo, thankfully, is still the same frightfully organized and quick-thinking Hobbit who first set out from Bag End all those years ago. He may be deeply troubled by all that has happened since the company’s arrival at Erebor, but he will not be cowed. He cannot allow his friends to sit inside the mountain waiting for their doom. Bilbo must act, and he must act quickly.
Obviously, his original plan is out of the question. Even if Bilbo had the Arkenstone, which he does not, he knows full well that giving the gem to Bard will solve absolutely nothing. Thorin has proven that he is no more likely to be swayed by logic or honor than he was the last time. The king is not in his right mind, and Bilbo must tread carefully if his aim is to prevent a war.
The best he can hope for, of course, is to resolve the conflict between the three free kingdoms before the confrontation with the orcs. If Bard, Thranduil, and Dáin all send their warriors to meet the oncoming orc host, with perhaps a small contingent left behind to defend Erebor, then the Mountain will be safe enough. Thorin can recover inside, as he did the last time, while his kin and the Eagles take care of the orcs. They’ll be better prepared, with fewer dead and wounded at the start of the battle, and the advantage provided by an ambush. Yes, Thorin and the lads in particular will feel anger and guilt at being left behind inside their stronghold while others fight their battles for them, but they will also be safe.
After all, Azog seeks to destroy the line of Durin, does he not? Bilbo cannot see the sense in allowing the royal family to leave Erebor only to be driven into a trap. The pale orc will be distracted, searching the Dwarven ranks for absent leaders, and Dáin’s folk will take advantage of the confusion to dispatch the evil creature. Right? Doesn’t that make sense? Isn’t that a reasonable solution?
Bilbo wishes he had somebody to ask. But even if Thorin were in any position to have a conversation with him, he couldn’t very well reveal any of his foreknowledge. This is the same wall that he’s been running up against since the very beginning. Bilbo will, once again, have to take care of everything alone and hope that it works out for the best. But how to go about it?
He can’t use the Arkenstone. He could bring Thranduil the white gems that the Elf King so covets, except that Bilbo would have to carry a chest of precious stones down the side of a mountain without being seen by either side. Too difficult, even if he thought it would be effective, which he does not. Thorin would be angry about the loss of any piece of his hoard, and though he might not attempt to have Bilbo executed for it, the Hobbit would probably wind up locked in the treasury for the rest of his very brief life while the company waited for the orcs to come kill them. The long and short of it is that giving away treasure behind Thorin’s back, while it might be the right thing to do in terms of honor and propriety, is not a sound strategy for preventing a war.
What other options does Bilbo have? He could beg Bard and Thranduil to leave, though he doubts that would be effective, either. Would they believe him if he told them about the orcs? They would probably assume that Thorin had sent him to drive them off, especially if he arrived empty-handed. Thranduil is power-hungry and Bard has lived a very rough life; both of them have made suspicious by their circumstances.
Is there nobody down in that camp who will listen to reason? Yes, Bilbo realizes with sudden surety, there is. Of course! Gandalf could help! Didn’t the Wizard come to warn Bard and Thranduil about the orcs in the first place? That failed, obviously, or the battle would have turned out differently. But perhaps… maybe if Bilbo could find Gandalf and explain Thorin’s symptoms, the Wizard could do something to help! Bard and Thranduil do not want a war. Would they not allow Gandalf to parlay with the King Under the Mountain? It would only be the logical thing to do, especially if it might lead to Bard being given his share of the treasure. Bilbo cannot help Thorin on his own, but Gandalf has power beyond his comprehension. Could he not set things right?
It isn’t as though Bilbo has any other choice. The food stores are running low enough that even if, by some miracle, Erebor withstands the siege, the entire company will starve to death inside before the Battle is even through. He makes up his mind, slinking out of the treasure hoard while Thorin is distracted by his latest handful of gleaming coins. Bilbo refuses to allow himself any meditation on his feelings about this, the fact that his beloved is more interested in gold than he is in Bilbo. That was always going to be the case, after all. Bilbo doesn’t get to be surprised.
He sneaks through the halls of Erebor which he has come to know so well and makes his way up the battlements. Even after all these years, he does not like them. The memory does not sit well in his stomach. He doesn’t blame Thorin, of course, but it isn’t exactly a pleasant experience to be dangled over a great height by one’s neck, staring into the flaming eyes of one’s mad love. But that is only one more thing about which Bilbo does not have time to think. He is in the process of attaching a rope to the wall for easy climbing when he is interrupted by footsteps.
“You should be inside. Out of the wind.”
Of course it is Bofur. Who else would it be? This happened last time, too. Bilbo lied about it in his book, fabricated a conversation with Bombur which never took place. He doesn’t know quite why he did it. Perhaps because the whole affair takes on a different meaning when the story is told accurately. If Bilbo hoodwinked poor old Bombur, took advantage of his exhaustion with a false act of kindness, then the tale is a simple one of utilitarian necessity. But if Bofur allowed Bilbo to go, knowing exactly what it meant, with full understanding of what Thorin’s words and deeds meant, what the king planned to do to the Hobbit should he stay? That would make it into a tale of deep, perhaps improper, friendship and love. Too many questions would be raised in the minds of the Hobbit children listening to the tale.
“I was just…“ Bilbo trails off. What’s the point? Whether he lies or tells the truth or remains silent, Bofur will know exactly what he’s planning to do.
Bofur moves to stand by Bilbo on the battlements, staring out at the long drop below. He pointedly refuses to look at Bilbo’s very obvious rope. “The Elves have been moving their archers into position. The battle will be over by tomorrow’s eve, though I doubt we will live to see it. You’ve been in the treasury with Thorin for a few hours now, haven’t you?”
“Yes.” Bilbo has, frankly, lost track of time. Lately he and Thorin have fallen into an odd rhythm wherein the king meanders through his hoard, searching in vain for the absent Arkenstone, and the Burglar paces in tight circles, trying to think of a way to get out of this mess.
“He’ll be looking for you soon, then.” Bofur does not qualify this statement with any further explanation. But that isn’t necessary. Bilbo knows full well what he’s talking about. “No one could blame a soul for wishing themselves elsewhere.”
Thorin will notice Bilbo’s absence in a matter of minutes, and he will hunt him down and bring him back to the treasury posthaste. Bilbo knows frightfully little about Dwarven Ones, and even less about how that sort of bond can be affected by dragon sickness. Clearly, since he accepted Thorin’s proposal, something significant has changed. While before Thorin seemed to crave Bilbo’s presence at all times, he now seems to become greatly unsettled by Bilbo’s absence, once he becomes aware of it. It’s all very confusing, but then, Bilbo can hardly expect somebody to think rationally when he isn’t in his right mind.
“He will be,” Bilbo agrees. He ignores the second half of Bofur’s utterance, just as he did the last time he heard it. Bilbo does not wish for his friends to think him a coward, to believe that he would abandon them, would abandon Thorin, in a moment of obvious need.
There is a long silence while he waits for Bofur to offer the same kind farewell that he gave him the last time, the same cryptic resolution to look the other way while Bilbo escaped. But Bofur clears his throat and says something altogether unexpected.
“I had a long talk with Fíli this morning,” Bofur announces.
“Did you?” For a moment, Bilbo doesn’t understand. He’s been so caught up in everything else that he’d nearly forgotten about the incident with Thorin and Fíli and the sword. Well, both incidents with Thorin and Fíli and the sword. “What did he say?”
“He says,” Bofur begins, clearly uncomfortable with this line of discussion. “That Thorin threatened you during the fight with the dragon.”
Bilbo bites his lip. Yes, technically, that happened. “Thorin isn’t in his right mind,” is all he can offer. He’s been saying it over and over ever since they got to Erebor, as though it might be news to any of the company. But Bilbo is truly at a loss for anything else. “We can’t— well, of course we can hold him accountable, but we can’t…” Bilbo huffs. “He wouldn’t have done that, if he were himself. I do not fear him.”
“The lad told me true, then.” Bofur looks down over the battlements at the desolation, as though contemplating an escape. Probably, he is contemplating Bilbo’s escape and wondering how it will go for the poor Hobbit alone in the wilderness, outside the protection of the Mountain. “I had hoped… I had hoped that perhaps he misunderstood what he was seeing. Jumped to conclusions, maybe.”
Bilbo does not mention the part of the story that Fíli left out, the very relevant detail where Thorin threatened the crown prince for no good reason. Maybe he should say something. After all, if Thorin discovers the two of them here together, he might be less forgiving with Bofur than he was with Fíli. “You should go back inside,” Bilbo advises, “And find Bombur. He’s next, isn’t he? Your watch is over, and you need your sleep.”
“Ah,” Bofur gives Bilbo an appraising look. “It’ll take a bit to wake him."
Bilbo swallows. “I’m not running away from Thorin.” He needs to make this clear. “I’m not giving up on him. I’m going to get him some help. I’ll be back. I’ll be right back! I’ll see you in the morning.”
Bofur may be very skilled at hiding his true emotions, but even he cannot conceal the doubt and grief in his bright eyes. Even if he does believe that Bilbo will be back, he very likely struggles with the idea that there is anything that can help Thorin now. But Gandalf was able to heal Thorin on the Carrock, when all hope seemed to be lost, and according to Merry Brandybuck, the Wizard once used a spell to shake King Theodin of Rohan from a similar madness to the one from which Thorin suffers. Where there’s life, there’s hope, Bilbo reminds himself, and where there’s a Wizard, there’s even more of it.
“Goodbye, Bilbo,” Bofur says with a gentle hand on the Hobbit’s shoulder. Strange. The last time, when he said that, he was already on his way back inside the mountain. But it does not take much pondering to figure out the reason for this change. It is obvious why Bofur would be more worried now that he was before.
“I’ll see you in the morning, Bofur.” Bilbo looks up into his friend’s eyes with steely determination. This is not a matter of debate. Bilbo will be back here with the Wizard in no time, and Gandalf will use his magic to put some sense into Thorin, and all will be resolved. Well, except for the two armies of Orcs presently plotting an ambush on Ravenhill, but that is a bridge that Bilbo will have to cross when he gets to it.
It takes much less time for Bilbo to be captured and taken to Bard and Thranduil than it did the on the first go. Obviously, since he can no longer become invisible, Bilbo’s only choice is to present himself to the guards with his arms raised. He considered leaving Sting on the battlements and coming unarmed to prove his peaceful intentions, but that seems ill-advised. What if something happens on the way to the camp and Bilbo must fight? He’d rather not be entirely unarmed.
So he raises his arms, throws down his sword, and allows the guard to take him and the blade to the tent where Bard and Thranduil await. Bilbo does not know precisely how to go about this conversation, but he has to try for Thorin’s sake and the sake of the company. “Good evening,” he addresses both kings with an awkward little bow.
“Mister Baggins,” Bard greets him, straight-faced as ever. “What brings you away from your king and his treasure hoard?”
“Ah, yes, well, about that.” Bilbo glances meaningfully at the guard who is currently gripping his arm with an unnecessary level of force. It is not as amusing as one might assume to know that the guard must stoop slightly to reach Bilbo at all. The Elf who’s holding him is about three times his size and heavily armed, while Bilbo has given up his sword and carries only a useless ring. He does still have his mithril mail on underneath his clothes, but it’s not as though anybody else is aware of that fact. “I thought we might talk in private. With the Wizard, too, if he’s here.”
“The Wizard?” Bard asks.
“He is here.” Thranduil waves his hand and dismisses the guard, presumably to fetch Gandalf. Bilbo is only pleased to have his arm released from that iron grip. He shudders to think of what Thorin would do to the Elf that dared to leave a bruise on Bilbo, because he doubtless will be bruised, even through the mithril. “Though I am more interested in why you have come, Halfling.”
Bilbo ignores the rude term. It’s not as though he expected Thranduil to be polite, especially considering that they are technically standing on opposing sides of a war at the moment. “Right, well, that has to do with Gandalf, and I’d really rather explain only once,” Bilbo explains. “So I’ll wait for him, if you don’t mind.”
Bilbo doesn’t really have the bargaining power here to be making such demands, but he doesn’t particularly care. He’s sick and tired of all this kingly nonsense. Yes, absolutely, Thorin is in the debt of the Men of the Lake and should repay them for their kindness, but he owes nothing to Thranduil, and no promise is worth the lives of so many worthy Men and Elves, not to mention how many of Dáin’s warriors will fall on the battlefield if things unfold the way Bilbo expects them to.
“Very well.” Thranduil studies Bilbo in a way he does not quite enjoy. “Though I suspect that you are responsible for the miraculous escape that Thorin and company managed from my dungeons.”
“I am,” Bilbo admits, stalling for time so he doesn’t have to sit in awkward silence waiting for the Wizard, “Though your friend Bard had a hand in it as well.”
Bard’s habitual grimace tightens. “At that time, Thorin, son of Thráin was in the habit of honoring his word and paying those who gave him aid.”
“I have received not a cent for the food I provided,” Thranduil drawls.
Oddly, the desire for vengeance which dogged Bilbo’s thoughts in the Elven dungeons has abandoned him now. He still seethes, of course, but he is less inclined to clobber Thranduil and more inclined to snipe at the Elf King with a biting remark, as any Hobbit worth his salt would do. “Perhaps you could consider the bruise your guard left on my king as your payment.”
Thranduil snorts. “You are an odd servant, Master Hobbit, and loyal beyond what Thorin Oakenshield deserves.”
“But Master Baggins is not a servant,” Bard points out. Both kings are studying Bilbo with far too much intensity for his tastes.
Thankfully, before Thranduil and Bard can get into a conversation about the nature of Bilbo’s relationship with Thorin, Gandalf barges into the tent. “Bilbo Baggins!” He bellows, embracing the Hobbit. If Gandalf is at all surprised to feel the mithril mail beneath Bilbo’s clothes, he does not betray this shock. “I’m glad to see that you are all in once piece after your meeting with the dragon!”
Bilbo hugs him back gratefully. “It’s good to see you, Gandalf,” he replies, “But now that you’re here, I think we should go ahead with it. We’re all very busy people, after all.” Bilbo knows that it is a risk to be gone from the Mountain for too long. Thorin will not take his absence well.
“Yes, I agree,” Thranduil drawls. “I am looking forward to hearing why Thorin Oakenshield has sent you in his stead. Why not one of his heirs?”
“Well, he hasn’t sent me exactly,” Bilbo explains.
“He has not sent you?” Bard repeats. “Please, tell us why you have come once more to speak with me against your king’s wishes.”
That reminds Bilbo of their earlier conversation. “Did you heed my advice before, King Bard? Did you wait for the dragon in the watchtower?”
“Aye, I did. Though that could not prevent the beast from wreaking havoc, especially considering the recent orc attack.” So Bilbo’s warning was marginally effective, but the company still led a party of orcs to Bard’s home.
“Are your children well?” Bilbo inquires. He knows he should get down to the business of his visit, but now that he’s been reminded, he needs to confirm that Bain, Tilda, and Sigrid are alright.
“All alive,” Bard reports. “Though none of the Men of the Lake are particularly well at the moment. We are sleeping in tents and preparing for battle, in case you had not noticed, Mister Baggins.”
“Right.” Bilbo swallows. That’s as good a segue as any. “Bard, Thranduil. You should know that there’s an army of orcs marching on the Mountain right now.”
“Yes, the Wizard told us,” Thranduil replies, sounding bored. “I did not believe it then, and I do not believe it now.”
Bilbo ignores him. “And there is another army coming from the North. They intend to stage a trap on Ravenhill.”
“A trap for whom?”
Well. Bilbo may as well say it. “For Thorin and his heirs. Azog the Pale Orc intends to wipe out the line of Durin once and for all.”
“I’m not quite sure I care.” At least Thranduil is honest. “They have refused us what we are owed. If they wish to die atop Ravenhill—“
“Thorin is not well,” Bilbo blurts out. He does not need to think about his friends dying right now. He cannot handle the flood of images, the bombardment of memories that will no doubt come of this. But he must. He must handle it, he must pull himself together, he must make use of his famous silver tongue and talk his friends out of this predicament. Bilbo has been strong for Thorin and Company before, too many times to count, and now he need only repeat that common feat. “He suffers from dragon sickness. There is a curse upon that treasure, as you well know, Your Majesty.” He directs a vague bow in Bard’s general direction. “And Thorin has succumbed to it, through no fault of his own.”
“He chose to enter the Mountain against all warnings,” Bard points out.
“Yes, yes, he did,” Bilbo concedes, “But the fact stands that he fully intended to give you what you were owed upon entry to the Mountain. He had no way of knowing that he’d fall ill. None of the rest of the company have succumbed.”
“Then why not remove him from the throne and have done with it?” Thranduil asks. “He has two heirs with him, does he not? Choose the sanest of them, if there is one that can be called sane, and name him the King Under the Mountain.”
“And if you fall sick, should Prince Legolas then claim your throne?” Bilbo snaps. “I’m sure he would rule fairly and justly. I doubt he would imprison starving travelers or allow orcs to pass unhindered through his lands.”
Thranduil’s eyes are icy. “Careful, little one. You should not speak of that which you do not understand.”
“And nor should you, Your Majesty.” Bilbo is not afraid of Thranduil, and he is angry, angrier than he has ever been in all his life. “I have come to request that Gandalf the Grey be allowed to speak with King Thorin.”
“Why should the Wizard succeed where we have not?” Bard asks. “I would have peace over war, Mister Baggins, but I doubt that there is any way around a battle if Thorin Oakenshield is truly as unwell as you claim.”
“I believe that Gandalf can cure him,” Bilbo reasons, “If he is only allowed inside the Mountain—“
“This is an obvious trick,” Thranduil declares, “Do not think we are so naive as to fall for it. Thorin Oakenshield is not ill but mad with power, and that cannot be cured. His greed poisoned him from the outset. You wish to send the Wizard into the Mountain merely to aid you in the battle to come.”
“Mister Baggins speaks true,” Gandalf protests, “Thorin has contracted dragon sickness, but it is likely I could find a cure if given enough time.”
“We do not have time,” Bard protests. “My people are starving now.”
“And my people will starve in a few days if no aid comes,” Bilbo replies evenly. “Surely Greenwood the Great has provisions enough for all of us on hand.” If he must appeal to Thranduil’s vanity to keep the company and the Lake-town refugees fed, then so be it.
“Your people?” Thranduil’s sharp eyes catch on the neckline of Bilbo’s tunic. Perhaps any but an elf would miss the hint of mithril peeking through, but Thranduil has keen eyes and the advantage made by deep suspicion. “He has laid claim upon you.” Clearly, the Elf king understands the significance of such a fine gift being bestowed upon a commoner by a Dwarven monarch.
“There is no food inside the Mountain,” Bilbo persists, “Or barely any, anyway. We don’t want a war any more than you do. There is a chance that Gandalf could talk to Thorin and make him see reason—“
“The Wizard has already tried to trick us with an army of imaginary orcs,” Thranduil alleges.
“No, he hasn’t! There really are two armies—“
“And how come you by this knowledge?”
It occurs to Bilbo that perhaps he should not have gone out of his way to provoke Thranduil as he has done. It would have been more prudent to play to the king’s impressive ego from the start. But what’s done is done. “Does that matter? Hundreds of your people will die.”
“I do not believe that Thorin Oakenshield suffers from any affliction which can be cured,” Thranduil replies, “Nor do I believe that the Wizard is without his own motives. No, we will not allow anyone to approach the Mountain until we are assured of our treasure, whether by the king’s consent or as we move to take what we are owed.”
“Gandalf.” Bilbo is desperate now. “Can you get past them?”
“They have two armies under their command, Bilbo,” Gandalf points out, “No, I cannot. And I am not convinced that Thorin would let me pass into the Mountain unhindered even if these good kings would allow it.”
Bilbo winces. That is wise enough counsel, but he isn’t pleased to hear it. “Please.” He is not above begging. “My plan is our best chance to avoid war.”
“But you claim that there will be war regardless,” Thranduil points out, “And I do not trust the word of Thorin Oakenshield’s intended.”
“You are to marry him?” Bard’s eyes narrow, “Even though you claim he is unwell?”
Bilbo swallows. He sees the situation through Bard’s eyes clear enough: if Thorin is mentally unstable, why would Bilbo agree to marry him? If Bilbo was held against his will in the Mountain, he would not be aching to get back to it. The logical conclusion is that Bilbo is either suffering from his own madness, in which case his word cannot be trusted, or he, Gandalf, and Thorin have concocted some sort of trap for Bard and Thranduil.
“I think it will be much more effective to offer a trade,” Thranduil decides, “Thorin Oakenshield has many things that we want, but we have that which he covets above all else, save the Arkenstone. You do not carry that along with the mithril mail, do you, Halfling?” The Elven king confirms Bilbo’s suspicions about his very good eyesight.
Bilbo tries to be sympathetic. He really does. Thranduil has every right to be suspicious, Bilbo supposes, but hitherto, the king’s behavior has been petty and childish. “That will not work,” he tries to explain, “Thorin will kill you. He nearly killed his own nephew for letting me hug him, and you think that you can prevent a war by holding me hostage?”
Gandalf looks deeply troubled by this news. “What?”
Perhaps Bilbo has shared too much. But the darkest aspects of Thorin’s madness will not stay secret much longer, and it is paramount that he impress upon these people the gravity of the mistake that they are making. Thorin will not take this well. He may lose what little sense the dragon sickness has left to him and act even more rashly than he did when it was the Arkenstone being kept away from him. After all, there was no threat of the stone being destroyed by Bard and Thranduil. If Thrór’s best craftspeople could not cut it, then surely no Man or Elf could do so.
“Yes, I do think that,” Thranduil declares, ignoring Bilbo’s panic. “What say you, Bard?”
Bard’s lips form a tight line. “I say,” he replies eventually, “That a trade is our safest option. Even if the Hobbit and the Wizard mean well, I do not trust that they will be safe upon return to the mountain. It is better to offer a deal and see how Thorin Oakenshield responds.”
“This is a terrible plan,” Bilbo moans as cold fear overtakes him. He can guess how Thorin will respond, and he can’t imagine that it will be very pretty.
Bilbo clings, as best as he is able, to Bard, his hands barely clasping as his arms strain around the Man’s middle. The Hobbit has spent the whole ride huffing and puffing, partly as a result of traveling on horseback for the first time in his life and partly in response to the utter indignity of being lifted onto the back of the beast. He can be thankful, at least, that he is not riding with Thranduil. The thought of Thorin’s reaction to that particular confrontation makes Bilbo shudder.
“It is not much father, Master Baggins,” Bard assures him, gazing forward with resolve. “You will be in the presence of your intended again very soon.”
Bilbo cannot determine whether he is being mocked or whether Bard is harboring some secret optimism hitherto concealed rather masterfully. “Thorin will kill you for this,” he tries to explain, for what must be the fiftieth time this morning. “That’s not a threat, you know. In fact, I really wish he wouldn’t, but when he sees that you’re holding me against my will…”
“Why do you chain yourself to one who would treat his friends that way?” Bard asks. It is not a demand but a gentle question, one that a teacher might pose for a student.
Bilbo swallows, considering dishonesty. But what dishonest answer would satisfy Bard? He is clearly already disappointed with Bilbo for even giving Thorin the time of day. “I am not chained,” Bilbo replies instead. “You saw how easily I left the Mountain. If I did not wish to be with Thorin, then I would leave him. I would never have accepted his proposal if I didn’t want to marry him.”
“And how do you think he would have taken that?”
Bilbo does not answer. He has long since learned that he doesn’t know what Thorin is capable of, but it is better not to underestimate his king. Bilbo’s arms and thighs ache from the uncomfortable position he’s been forced into. Drat this blasted horse! Could he not been given a pony of his own? One of Bard’s or Thranduil’s guards could have led it to prevent Bilbo’s escape, could they not? But nobody seems to have thought of that. Once Bard and Thranduil made their plan, it was a matter of waiting for the sun to rise so that they could approach the mountain and confront Thorin.
Bilbo releases another heavy sigh as he is brought before the slopes of Erebor. Having never before been on this side of a military parlay, he is somewhat taken aback by the moments of quiet waiting that take place upon the party’s arrival. He glances over at Gandalf in silent question. Can you get into the Mountain while we have the kings distracted? And the Wizard shakes his head. No, of course not.
Gandalf may be strong and powerful, but Bilbo doubts that his friend is impervious to arrows. It would be a suicide mission to try and sneak into the Mountain now; he would be fleeing a betrayed Thranduil to confront a gold sick and furious Thorin, and that is assuming that he would be able to break through the Mountain’s defenses at all. Besides, there is a chance that this might work.
Bilbo chews on his bottom lip. What if Thorin is willing to make a trade? It didn’t work with the Arkenstone, of course, but surely Thorin cares more about Bilbo than he does about some stupid rock. Ah, yes, that’s the lesson that Bilbo should take away from his initial adventure! When faced with a decision between a Hobbit and a gem, Thorin Oakenshield will always choose the Hobbit! That’s why he threatened to throw the Arkenstone over the battlements for Bilbo’s sake, left bruises on the Arkenstone’s neck because it threatened Bilbo, banished the Arkenstone from his Kingdom because he could not bear to be without Bilbo!
At the sound of Bilbo’s hysterical laughter, Bard turns around. “It will not be long now. They cannot see you from where they are looking.”
“Can’t they?” Bilbo feels shaky and vague, as though he were sketched upon Bard’s horse in light and frantic lines.
“I hate to do this, Mister Baggins,” Bard sighs.
“Nobody’s forcing you,” is Bilbo’s snippy retort. Honestly, Bard and Thranduil could have led their forces to meet the oncoming orc army twice over by now. They could draw the enemy away from the Mountain, away from Dale, and eliminate the orcs that have lately troubled the Woodland Realm. Bilbo and Gandalf could return to Erebor, where Gandalf would cure Thorin, and the King Under the Mountain would see the error of his ways and direct Dáin’s forces to join the ambush far away. Thorin and the lads would live, as would the people of Dale, and perhaps many fair Elves who would otherwise be caught off guard in the battle of the Five Armies.
But not so. Thranduil and Bard have made their decision. Holding Bilbo overnight against his will and forcing him to ride on the back of Bard’s horse is as good as torturing him, in Thorin’s eyes. The king will not see the matter clearly. There is no turning back now that they are here, and Bilbo expects to bear witness to some rather unpleasant things.
“Regardless of what I may say to your intended—“ the scoff in Bard’s tone is rather unnecessary, Bilbo thinks— “I have a great respect for you.”
“Well, thank you for that.” A great respect indeed, treating Bilbo the same way that he would have treated the Arkenstone, had it come into his possession.
Thorin makes an imposing figure, standing there in his crown overlooking the desolation and the small party gathered there. He is too far away for Bilbo to make out the expression on his face, especially since that would require leaning around Bard and, in all likelihood, falling off his horse. Bilbo is confident that if he fell to his death at the hands of the soon-to-be King of Dale, his friends would suddenly become very amenable to Thorin’s plan of outright war. Best to stay in place, then.
The Men and Elves all watch in silence as Thorin knocks an arrow and fires it at the hooves of Thranduil’s mount. “I will put the next one between your eyes,” the king declares. And he does not even know yet that Thranduil and Bard have kidnapped his intended. This isn’t going to end well at all, is it? And poor Bilbo is now trapped in the middle.
He adjusts his grip on Bard while his friends taunt the approaching host in half-hearted Khuzdul. They all look more anxious than intimidating, however. It is clear to Bilbo that most of them are participating only because they fear Thorin in his present state and will do nothing to displease him if they can help it. On the one hand, Bilbo is glad that his friends have the self-preservation instincts to get them through this ordeal despite their qualms. On the other hand, he worries that they may apply this same logic to Thorin’s less-savory ideas, which will only lead to disastrous results.
Naturally, the Mirkwood Elves raise their bows in unison, producing a mechanical sound as each and everyone one of them aims in Thorin’s direction. Thranduil urges his mount forward in an elegant movement that feels choreographed. Bilbo wonders absently how many hours the king has passed training the animal to respond to him so gracefully. “We have come to see if you will reconsider your refusal to offer payment for your debt.” The Elven king smirks, clearly very pleased with himself and his foolhardy plan.
Bilbo cannot see Thorin’s eyes at this distance, but he can imagine the blue fire that must be blazing there. “My mind does not change with the rising and setting of a few suns,” Thorin declares in an imperious snarl. “I will give you nothing. You will have nothing.”
Bilbo’s arms feel as though they are going to fall off, and he feels as if his legs are being tugged in opposite directions by the sturdy body of the horse beneath him. Bard rides without a saddle, which is all well and good for somebody of his size, somebody accustomed to long journeys on horseback, but for Bilbo, it is decidedly uncomfortable. He’ll have bruises on his thighs, for sure. For just one moment, he allows himself to focus more on that and less on the impending carnage.
“Give us the gold that you have promised us,” Bard cuts immediately to the chase. Unlike Thranduil, he does not seem to enjoy this in the slightest. “And we will give you back your Hobbit.” Bard moves aside slightly, allowing Bilbo to peer out from behind his broad back.
For a moment, nobody says a word. Thorin stares at Bilbo, and Bilbo stares at Thorin. The rest of the company looks from Bard to Thranduil to Bilbo to their leader as the pieces of the puzzle begin to fall into place. Doubtlessly, they were all aware that Bilbo was not with them. Probably, they thought he was hiding in the treasury from the impending battle, as Thorin would have directed him to do.
“They kidnapped Master Baggins!” Kíli announces, as if this was in any way unclear. “How? How did you get to him? You have made a grave mistake, setting your hands on the king’s intended!”
“The king may have him.” Bard moves again to obscure Bilbo from the company’s view. Bilbo shudders at the similarity to the words Bard used to offer a trade of the Arkenstone all those years ago. Is he really no different from any of the other baubles in Thorin’s collection? Clearly, Bard does not believe that Thorin will think so. “With our goodwill. But first, he must honor his word.”
“Bilbo!” Thorin calls, and despite himself, Bilbo feels his heart swell. Thorin is calling out for him, not going along with Thranduil’s plot to use Bilbo as a negotiating device the way Bard did so readily. “What harm have they done you?”
Bilbo ignores every instruction Thranduil and Bard have given him about keeping quiet. “I’m a little sore from riding here on horseback, but I don’t think any serious damage has been done!” Bilbo calls. “Please don’t kill anyone, Thorin! I’m unharmed!”
“You would lay your hands on such a kind and gentle creature,” Thorin snarls at Bard. “You would kidnap one who has already forgiven you when you still hold him against his will?”
“We did not wish to take a hostage,” Thranduil lies, “But you left us no choice.”
“I told them it was a stupid plan!” Bilbo hopes against hope that he will get through to Thorin somehow, though he doesn’t know why he thinks that will suddenly be an effective strategy when it has been so ineffective all this time. “They wouldn’t listen!”
“You have encroached upon my lands,” Thorin ignores Bilbo altogether, which is as bad a sign as Bilbo can imagine. “And stolen my One from me. And you expect me to parlay?” My One. It should not surprise Bilbo in the slightest to be referred to as such. After all, Thorin said it before, when he was fitting Bilbo with the mithril shirt. But it is one thing to say such things in private, during a fairly intimate moment, and quite another for Thorin to make such an announcement during a formal negotiation in his capacity as King Under the Mountain.
“I told you that this wouldn’t work,” Bilbo reiterates to Bard, who, like Thorin, seems content to ignore him.
“We will return Master Baggins to you unharmed in exchange for the promised gold,” Bard announces.
Bilbo leans around Bard to stare up at Thorin, ignoring the valiant protest made by the muscles in his thighs as he grips onto the horse. He has seen such rage only once before. This is exactly how Thorin looked when he learned that Bilbo had given away the Arkenstone. It is a struggle to push away the vibrant images of Thorin’s hands around Bilbo’s neck, the feeling of empty space below him as Bilbo prepared for his impending death. Gandalf saved him then, but where is the Wizard now?
Conspicuously missing all of a sudden. Bilbo knows not what to make of this development. Perhaps Gandalf has decided to try and sneak into the mountain after all, or perhaps he has formulated his own scheme for dispatching the orc and goblin hosts. Maybe Gandalf has realized that Thorin will not give in without bloodshed.
Bilbo looks around as best he can from his position behind Bard and catches sight of familiar grey robes. Gandalf is holed up in a corner, under the shelter of the Mountain, muttering. For a moment, Bilbo thinks that the Wizard is working some sort of magic, perhaps a spell that will help Thorin to come to his senses. Perhaps he can be healed after all, and at a distance, too! But then Gandalf opens his cupped palms, and an oversized moth flies out of them. He was speaking to the little creature, though for what reason, Bilbo does not know. It’s certainly a good thing that the Wizard has his priorities straight, making friends with local insects in the middle of Bilbo’s hostage negotiation. When Bilbo looks again, Gandalf and the moth have disappeared. Typical. Once again, it’s down the Bilbo to save himself and his friends from whatever awful fate they’re lurching toward.
“You will return my One to me unharmed in exchange for your lives,” Thorin roars. “Or I will come down and kill you myself.”
“By all means,” Thranduil drawls, “See how your company of fourteen… or, thirteen now, I suppose… fares against our armies.”
Bilbo stares at the Elven king in utter shock. “I’m sorry, are you trying for an arrow between your eyes?” Bilbo demands of the king.
Thorin laughs at that, though whether he finds Bilbo’s comment funny or whether he is fantasizing about doing exactly as the Hobbit suggests remains to be seen. Either way, he is not stable. Even from this great distance, Bilbo can see that Thorin is shaking with rage as he raises his bow. He knocks an arrow and aims at the Elven king.
Once more, the Elven army makes a great show of raising their own weapons all at once. Every single one of them is aiming for Thorin, but the King Under the Mountain does not seem deterred. Thankfully, others in the company have a bit more sense. Balin rushes to Thorin’s side and whispers something in his ear. Fíli, too, has a few emphatic words to say in Khuzdul. His hand hovers over Thorin’s for a moment, but, perhaps remembering the incident on the battlements, he does not dare place it there. Instead, his tone becomes conciliatory, and he makes no move to physically bar his uncle from committing an act that cannot be retracted.
“I will not stand by and allow these…” Thorin then makes use of his own choice words in Khuzdul. Bilbo has no idea what Thorin is saying, but it is enough to make Dori reach instinctively for Ori, as though he seriously intends to cover his brother’s ears in the middle of a rather nasty confrontation. “To put their hands on what is mine.”
Fíli says something else, and Dwalin seems to agree with him. Bilbo cannot make out the words from here, but he trusts his friends to make sound and reasonable arguments. Unfortunately, he does not trust his intended to heed any warnings that he is presently being given. This day will likely end with one of Thorin’s arrows stuck somewhere on Thranduil’s person, and about a million arrows fired upon Thorin and Company.
“Thorin!” Bilbo yells again. “Please don’t shoot! Even these—“ Here, he attempts to repeat the Khuzdul words he just heard, “— Will not be so stupid as to kill me while they still want something from you! I’m perfectly safe, I assure you. The Wizard is around here somewhere, and you can imagine how he might react should anyone attempt to murder me. If I am not worth my weight in gold to you, then that’s… perfectly understandable, just please, don’t start the battle this way!”
“You are worth everything to me,” Thorin declares. “They know this and have forced you from my side. They must pay in blood.” So much for reasoning with him, then. Bilbo really needs to stop thinking that will work.
“Your Hobbit is wiser than you are, Thorin Oakenshield.” Thranduil seems to believe that he’s being very helpful. He is, however, only making things worse.
“Oh, please shut up,” Bilbo snaps. “Your smug nonsense isn’t helping.”
Bard’s body shakes slightly in what Bilbo takes as a silent laugh. Bilbo feels as though all the bones and muscles in his body have turned to jelly. He has already failed once to prevent this battle, and now it seems that he has made the same mistake a second time. Not only is he unable to protect Thorin and the lads from Azog the Defiler, but he has somehow managed to bring a completely new threat to the company’s door. Just brilliant work, Master Burglar.
But Thranduil seems to take it in stride. Clearly, he is confident that Thorin will simply trade the gold for Bilbo. He does not truly believe in the curse or in dragon sickness and seems to be laboring under the misapprehension that Thorin is simply greedy. Why the Elven king believes this after taking counsel from Gandalf, Bilbo doesn’t know, but it hardly matters now, does it?
“As I said,” Thranduil smiles placidly, “He is very wise. Perhaps I should have him instruct me in the ingenious method that he used to smuggle you out of my realm.”
At the insinuation that Thranduil wishes to take Bilbo back to his own kingdom, there is a sound of snapping wood. Bilbo peers around Bard to see that Thorin has broken the arrow that he was about to shoot at Thranduil. Well, better than assassinating a foreign king, Bilbo supposes, but still not very pleasant.
“Uncle, please.” Fíli’s voice carries faintly down to the party gathered before Erebor’s gates. “Who knows what they will do to Master Baggins if you ignore their demands? We cannot allow them to keep Bilbo a moment longer. We must do whatever it takes to get him to safety.” These are brave words indeed. Perhaps Bilbo and Fíli are the only ones who know for sure how Thorin might react to them.
The king, thankfully, is too busy glaring at Thranduil to accuse his nephew of treason. “They will do nothing to him,” Thorin snarls, tossing his bow aside. Thank the Valar. “Because I will come and claim him.”
“Good,” Thranduil continues to look smug. Bilbo preferred it when Bard was doing the talking. “Please bring enough gold to satisfy your debts to the Men of the Lake and the Elves of the Woodland realm, and we will return your… Burglar to you in one piece.”
“You are still not helping,” Bilbo groans. It’s as though Thranduil really is trying to get himself shot.
“Kíli,” Thorin orders, loud enough to be overheard, “Aim for the Elven Lord. If he makes any move against me, or against Master Baggins, you are encouraged to shoot.”
“You are not really going down there,” Balin protests, “All you need to do is agree to their demands, and they’ll let Bilbo up to join us.” But before anyone can answer, speech is momentarily precluded by a sound like a herd of Oliphaunts marching through the waste.
Bilbo closes his eyes. “So much for negotiation,” he hums, “I hope you are prepared for war.” Dáin’s host has arrived.
“I will not parlay with you,” Thorin declares, just as Bilbo expected. He’s probably planning to rush down and liberate Bilbo himself, or, even worse, to try and divert Dáin’s entire army to the foolish goal of rescuing one Hobbit who is barely even in any danger. Though Bilbo doesn’t particularly trust or like Thranduil, he does not believe that the Elven King is hostile to him, and he knows for a fact that Bard has no interest in maiming or killing him. “If you will not give back what is mine—“ Bilbo winces at this phrasing, “Then you will face the wrath of Durin’s folk.”
“Please, can I just go back up there?” Bilbo asks. “It’d save us all a lot of trouble. If we can find the Wizard, there may yet be a chance—“
Bard opens his mouth as though to speak. Perhaps he intends to take pity on Bilbo and allow him back into the mountain, or to deliver a paternalistic edict about how it might be safer for Bilbo to stay by his side. In that case, Bilbo is perfectly prepared to sneak out of Dale just as he did the last time. But unfortunately, Thranduil beats him to the punch.
“Very well,” Thranduil replies, “If you and your Hobbit both survive, perhaps you will be reunited after the battle.”
“This is a waste of time,” Bilbo groans, “There are orcs approaching.”
But Thranduil has already turned his strange, antlered mount around, and Thorin has left the battlements to go do Yavanna-knows-what, and Bard is spurring his horse. There will be no parlay, there will be no alliance, and there will be no peace.
Notes:
Please feel free to keep commenting your guesses about the Arkenstone and the ring lol :)
Chapter 14: Sons of Durin
Notes:
Thanks as always for reading and for leaving kudos/comments! A lot of stuff happens in this chapter. Bilbo and Thorin both have battle flashbacks, and then, of course, there is an actual battle sequence. I tried to give them a little bit of banter, at least, to balance out the angst. Enjoy!
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Thorin’s first act after dismissing the Men and Elves is to summon a raven. He sends the bird off in Dáin’s direction with new instructions for the Lord of the Iron Hills: charge forward, show no mercy, recover my consort and return him to me. There was never any chance of negotiation before, but now? Now, Thorin will personally place the heads of his fellow kings on spikes outside the gates of Erebor. That is a Mannish tradition, not a Dwarven one, but in his present mood Thorin sees the appeal of it. To even touch the intended of the king is an unspeakable crime, but to kidnap him, to force him onto a horse and use him as a bargaining chip, is practically a declaration of war.
Since the Men and Elves want carnage, then, Thorin will give it to them gladly. Dáin will plow through their flimsy defenses and liberate Bilbo, who will be returned to Erebor in no time. Thorin does not put it past his Hobbit to start stabbing at his captors once war is properly declared. He would have liked to execute his enemies personally, but he is loath to leave the mountain.
The treasure calls to Thorin, even now. It sings to him with promises of peace and glory, rest and splendor if only he makes his way back down to the vaults. The Arkestone is down there, or if not, it is somewhere else inside the Mountain. Even if some traitor has taken it, Thorin will find it sooner rather than later. He will place it above his throne. No, he will carry it on his person forever more. Until his dying day, he will not be parted from it. Nor will he be parted from Bilbo.
Obviously, things will have to change once the Hobbit is returned to him. Bilbo will not be allowed out of his sight ever again. Thorin is no fool. He knows that the Men and Elves could not have gotten into Erebor without the king knowing, not even if his entire company betrayed him. Bilbo could not have been taken from the mountain against his will. He must have been lured down somehow, with false promises of peace. The Hobbit has spent several days pleading with Thorin to help the Men and Elves, apparently laboring under the naive misapprehension that their enemies will be satisfied with a single fair payment.
A fair payment would consist of nothing at all, because neither the Men nor the Elves did a thing to help Thorin reclaim his kingdom. And now they have manipulated his One with lies and false promises, taking advantage of a gentle soul who knows nothing of war and would not think to question the motives of his captors. More likely than not, the Wizard was involved. Perhaps he regrets giving Bilbo to Thorin in the first place and has elected now to take him back. Fair enough. Tharkûn’s head can join the others on the spikes for all that Thorin cares.
He finds himself at the door to the treasury with no memory of how he got here. Thorin knows that he should not be using his time in this way, that he has a battle to command, his One to rescue, and several executions to plan, assuming that Dáin does not take care of his enemies for him. There is plenty for the King Under the Mountain to do right now, but he seeks comfort from his hoard. He steps inside despite his misgivings and relishes the peace it brings him. Why brood in his throne room when he is so soothed by the sight of all that is his?
Gold. So much gold, and all of it only for Thorin. Enough jewels that he could use them as flooring for the entire mountain and still have plenty left over. Silver cups and fine musical instruments and crowns upon crowns. The wealth of a thousand kingdoms, and all of it reserved for one king. One great king, who will soon have all of his treasure in one place.
“What are you doing down here?” A voice destroys the soothing silence of the treasury.
Paying no attention to what he is doing, Thorin plays with a handful of perfectly shaped silver coins. He closes his eyes, trying to remember the feel of Bilbo’s hand in his. Not like the coins at all. Warmer, softer. But Thorin is beginning to forget what exactly it feels like. He is overcome by a pang of loss, sharp and heavy, a blade to his side. He will kill Bard of Lake-town, personally, slowly, painfully. And then he will do the same to the Woodland King, only more slowly and more painfully. That will teach them to take something of such import from the King Under the Mountain.
“What?” Thorin hisses reflexively, whirling around to face Dwalin. “It is mine and I can do with it what I choose.” Someone stole the Arkenstone from him. Someone stole his One from him. It is as though every being in Middle Earth is after Thorin’s treasure.
“Since when do we forsake our own people?” Dwalin stops in front of his king. “Thorin, they are dying out there. And your own One is with them.”
“Dáin will return what they have taken from me,” Throin growls. He does not wish to leave his hoard. It is the responsibility of his subjects to bring his missing gem back to him, and he does not appreciate the insinuation that Bilbo might die. No. That is not possible. That could not be possible. “There are halls beneath halls within this mountain. Places we can fortify. Shore up, make safe, yes. Yes. That is it. We must move the gold further underground to safety.”
And it will be easy enough to move Bilbo down with it, once he is returned. Yes, the Hobbit may struggle. He will not wish to leave Thorin’s side, and more than likely he will prattle on about food stores and the price of peace, as he has been doing for the past several days. But Thorin does not care what Bilbo thinks. He cares only that every last piece of his treasure is safe. Down to the coin.
“Did you not hear me?” Dwalin demands. “Dáin is surrounded. They’re being slaughtered, Thorin. And our Hobbit is among them, with no way to get back to the Mountain, even if he is alive.”
Thorin waves a hand. Three coins fly out and clatter against a pile of golden necklaces studded with rubies. “Is not this treasure worth a few lives? Is not my One worth a few more? Dáin will die before he fails in the mission I have given him. And Master Baggins will find his way back into the Mountain.”
But Thorin doubts his own words as he says them. After all, Bilbo is not like the coins. He will try his best to return, Thorin knows. The Hobbit has long since proven his desire to stay at Thorin’s side. But the field of battle is vast, and Bilbo is very small and rather fragile, at least compared to an armored orc. He would be much easier to destroy than a necklace or diadem. Can even Dáin be trusted to guarantee his safety? When the Hobbit is returned to Thorin, neither one of them will never leave the treasury.
“You sit here in these vast halls with a crown upon your head and yet you are lesser now than you have ever been,” Dwalin looks to be on the verge of tears. “You would have us stay here, then?”
“Aye.” Thorin is torn between the desire to charge into battle to rescue Bilbo, killing indiscriminately until he reaches his Hobbit, and the desire to stay in Erebor, to ensure that the rest of his treasure is safe. Is not it enough to give the orders? To have Dáin and his warriors rescue the Hobbit? Master Baggins can make himself invisible. He would not be seen by an enemy aiming to kill him. Or by an ally searching for a body.
“And what of Master Baggins?” Dwalin demands. “He followed you here. He faced a dragon for you. He wears your gift even still, and you would leave him to the orcs?”
“How dare you speak to me this way?” Thorin snarls.
Who is Dwalin to question him? Who is Dwalin to use his One to twist Thorin’s thinking, to force him away from his gold? This is what matters. This is most important. When he has his hands on his gold, Thorin can forget what Bilbo’s touch felt like. He can forget the warmth, the gentle care, every other carnal detail of being loved by Bilbo Baggins. The hurt and worry are dulled here.
For a moment, there is something unguarded in Dwalin’s eyes, something Thorin does not understand. “I’ve been speaking to you this way as long as I’ve known you, and you never had a problem with it. Was a time you were glad of it.”
“I am your king,” Thorin reminds him. There is no other option. He is beholden to his hoard. Dwalin has no right to accuse Thorin of mistreating Bilbo! The Hobbit will return. He must. And if he does not, Thorin has his jewels to comfort him. Surely soon the cold touch of the stones will replace the warm touch of his One in his affections. “No longer am I a mere blacksmith, with a cropped beard and not a penny to his name.” He is worthy now. He has his gold now. Is that not what Thorin has been fighting for all these years?
“You were always my king,” Dwalin replies, “You used to know that once. You cannot see what you have become.”
What he has become? What he has become? Thorin has become the King Under the Mountain, the true heir of Durin. Finally, now, he is worthy of the plucky little Hobbit who has steered him to his point.
“Go. Get out,” Thorin mutters. “Before I kill you.”
He does not wish to consider the possibility that Bilbo may be slain, that he may already be dead. Thorin does not wish to care as much as he does about the Hobbit. He does not appreciate Dwalin’s reminders. Why can he not be allowed to numb himself? Why must this be his lot in life, to suffer grief upon grief, loss after loss, as Mahal rips every good thing from Thorin’s grip? Not the gold. Thorin will not lose the gold. His mother, his grandfather, his brother, his father, his One. All of these can be taken from him, but the coins will not be. These Thorin will have until he dies.
Until he dies among them, alone and unloved. I am not my grandfather, he reminds himself, his voice more firm inside his head than it has been for days. No, he is not his grandfather. Thrór died with honor in battle at the hands of a formidable enemy, taking on a noble task. How will Thorin die? Here, in his hoard. What will become of the others? No. The mountain is safe. Erebor will protect Thorin and his gold.
Dwalin turns. It takes every ounce of Thorin’s self restraint to keep his word and stay his hand. How dare Dwalin come here, no better than the Men and Elves, holding Thorin’s One hostage in his mind? Master Baggins will make his way back to the Mountain. He is clever, he is crafty, and he will find his way back to Thorin. Even if Dáin is killed. Even if every last warrior on that battlefield is killed, every uppity Elf and foolish Man all the sturdy fighters from the Iron Hills.
The world constricts as the door slams shut behind Dwalin. Thorin is alone in the treasury. Thorin is alone in a dark void, in nothingness, and his hoard is far out of sight. He can feel a great longing, a great need for something that is absent. Hunger? Is this hunger? Is it thirst? Both of these things, yes, but something more. He is inundated with images: his sword, jabbing Bilbo’s chest, the Hobbit looking up at him with cautious eyes. Fíli with his hands raised, backing away from Thorin in terror. Dwalin, shaking his head in disgust, turning his back on the king to whom he has dedicated his life. Thrór’s headless body laying upon a pile of the fallen at Azanulbizar. Half of Frerin’s face frozen in a pained expression, the other half mangled beyond recognition. Gold in Thorin’s halls. Blood on Thorin’s hands.
He hears Fíli’s voice, frightened but unwavering. “You told me it would bring clarity of mind, so that I would always remember the sort of leader the Maker shaped me to be.”
Thorin has lost all honor, drawing his sword on his nephew. And before that, did he not hold his One at sword point? How far would Thorin have gone, had Fíli not interrupted them? Is this how Mahal made Thorin? Would the Great Smith be pleased, now, to see his child sunken so low?
He hears Dwalin’s voice, rough with disbelief and sorrow. “You were always my king. You used to know that once.”
Yes, once, Thorin did know that. Once, he had some idea of who he was. Once, he lived without gold or jewels. He labored in the towns of men, his beard shorn in shame but his honor intact. He risked his life and swallowed his pride for the good of his people. Where would they be, had Thorin not done that? Where would they be, had he been so selfish as this when first the dragon came?
Thorin is assaulted by Bilbo’s voice, a shifting kaleidoscope of love and pain and worry and rage. “Come back to yourself, as soon as possible, please, my love.”
These words made no sense to Thorin, when first they were spoken, but now he understands. Thorin has not been himself. He has been something else, a wicked shadow, contorted by greed. He has been hiding while his people, his kingdom, and his One are in danger. He has sought out comfort when he should seek the rush of battle.
The darkness around Thorin shatters, but still he is alone. All around him, piles of gold gleam in the torchlight, but he does not see them. The Arkenstone is in this Mountain, but he does not bother to search for it. He has no time for such things.
He has abandoned his honor and refused payment to those who have aided him. His cousin is fighting a battle that belongs to Thorin. His company is starving to death in this mountain. His One is out there on the battlefield, unarmed and held hostage by Men. These things he knows with a clarity that has been absent from his thinking since the moment he set foot inside his ancestral home. What has Thorin become, indeed? His have not been the actions of a great king but a great coward.
Thorin does not close the door behind him, let alone lock it, as he exits the treasury. He trips over his feet several times on his way to the front gate, but he only picks himself up and keeps running, ignoring the pain in his knees and the palms of his hands. He is winded when he arrives at the gate where his company have gathered. There is nothing majestic about His Majesty then, as he skids to a halt, panting, with his crown askew. But he does not care. He does not care how he appears, does not care what is proper. Cares only for the lives that are, by right, his to protect.
The members of his company are dressed for battle. But how could twelve defend a mad king and his treasure against three armies? Thorin has been a fool indeed.
“Uncle!” Kíli grabs him by the shoulders, a bold move, but one that Thorin cannot begrudge him. He is shocked that it has taken so long for anyone to try it. How long has he been in such a pitiful state? Days, weeks perhaps, and nobody has thought to grab him and shake him? Perhaps they did think to. Perhaps they decided against it, convinced that Thorin would kill them for it. What would he have done, had Kíli approached him an hour earlier? Would he have laid his hands on his sister-son? Thrown him off the side of the mountain? Forced him into a sword fight? “I will not hide behind a wall of stone while others fight our battles for us! It is not in my blood, Thorin. Erebor is ours, is it not? So we must defend it ourselves, with our own swords, with our own bows, with our own bodies if we must! Bilbo is down there, fighting orcs, though he is no warrior, and here we are, warriors, all, sons of Durin, doing nothing! I will not allow you to—“
“Kíli,” Thorin breathes. He has never been so proud of his sister-son.
“If you refuse to join the battle,” Kíli tells him evenly, apparently not noticing the tears welling in his uncle’s eyes. “Everyone here will support Fíli’s claim to the throne. I will drag you to the dungeons myself and lock you up in them if you continue this cowardice! We will not stand by and allow Dáin and Master Baggins to— oh!”
Thorin has enfolded his nephew in a crushing hug. “You are brave,” he announces, “And you are right.”
Kíli hugs him back, if a little reluctantly. “So you agree?”
“We are sons of Durin,” Thorin replies, “We do not leave our battles for others to fight, and we do not abandon our kin. Nor do we allow mindless despots to rule us. You and Fíli were plotting against me?”
“No,” Fíli speaks up, “Kíli had nothing to do with it. It was my idea from the beginning. I bear it upon my head.” He kneels then in a show of fealty, wholly unnecessary. But then, of course he would. He saw how Thorin reacted to his earlier transgression. Thorin cannot blame his sister-son for his fear, not in the slightest.
“You were right to do so,” Thorin informs his nephews. He hauls Fíli to his feet, wasting not a moment in doing so. “Both of you. I was not fit to rule.”
“And are you now?” Dwalin asks, arms crossed in front of his chest. He is clearly fed up with the king’s nonsense, and Thorin does not blame him.
Before Thorin can respond, there comes a familiar chattering noise from outside, and then a graceless sort of thud. Twenty-six practiced hands fly to weapons and shields. Dori steps in front of Ori, guarding him from whatever threat might be approaching. Kíli knocks an arrow and aims it at the entrance, lately barricaded.
“Thorin Oakenshield!” A voice booms from just outside the company’s makeshift fortification. “Let me in this instant!”
“Tharkûn,” Thorin grumbles. Dwalin’s hand relaxes upon his axe, which is nothing compared to the weapons taken from him by the Woodland Elves. That will be something to sort out later, Thorin decides. He longs for Orcrist.
Kíli does not drop his weapon. “Gandalf was down there with the Men and Elves. He let them kidnap Bilbo! How do we know he does not come here as a foe?”
“Because if he were a foe, he’d have magicked us all to death twice over by now,” Nori suggests. Thorin does not find himself comforted by this thought.
“Nori!” Dori scolds, but the damage is done.
“If you do not move this barricade, I will move it myself!” Tharkûn threatens. “You are not in your right mind, my friend. I will put things right whether you wish me to or not, if only for the sake of our dear Mister Baggins.”
Thorin finds himself rolling his eyes. “I am already well, Wizard,” he replies, “We were just about to move the barricade when you arrived.”
There is shuffling outside. Another chattering noise. “Is that so?”
“We would’ve moved the barricade even if Thorin wasn’t well,” Fíli admits. Good. Thorin is glad to hear that his heir was swayed neither by the treasure nor by sycophantic devotion to his mad uncle. “Bilbo’s worth committing treason over.”
“That is fair news,” Tharkûn decides, “But I fear it may have come too late. We must do what we can to find Bilbo and defend Erebor from the threat she faces.”
“Yes, that had occurred to me,” Thorin bites out. Who is this Wizard to order Thorin to rescue his own One? “Can you destroy the barricade by magic?”
“He’s a Wizard,” Glóin points out, “Of course he can.”
“Stand back, if you please,” Tharkûn orders, and suddenly, his transgressions are forgiven.
Dori grabs Ori now, and drags him as far away from the potential blast zone as is physically possible at such short notice. The rest of them merely treat this as a mining explosion, stepping back with practiced nonchalance.
We will find the Burglar, Bifur signs. His custom helmet, lately forged to accommodate the axe in his forehead, makes him look more polished than Thorin has ever thought of him before. He is not fooled. Bifur is formidable in battle. And we will defend our Mountain. We are strong. Death to all orcs!
There is a loud explosion, and then Tharkûn stands before them, a giant Eagle perched upon the battlements behind him. So that is how he got up here so quickly. In the distance, Thorin can see more of the great birds swooping down upon the oncoming orcs, though there are not enough of them to destroy the enemy’s ranks completely. “Quite right, Bifur,” the Wizard says.
“He can read Iglishmêk through solid rock,” Ori observes, dazed.
“I’d like to learn that trick,” Bofur muses, “Might come in handy in the mines.”
“You’re not a wizard,” Bombur points out. “And we have a Hobbit to save.”
Thorin does not even think about the heaps of gold which they will leave behind in the Mountain when he begins to shout orders to his company. “Your priority is finding Bilbo,” he declares, “Don’t bother trying to get him out of the action. He will make himself invisible and slip away to join the fight again.”
“It’s impossible to find him when you can’t see him,” Kíli speaks from experience.
“If you reach him, guard him,” Thorin continues, “And send word to me however you can. The ravens await our signal, and the thrushes understand the common tongue. Not to mention our friends the Eagles. This is our fight. Now, let us win it, or we shalldie trying!” Some deep-seated part of Thorin utters now the battle cry that he learned at his grandfather’s knee. It is echoed by his company as they charge through the whole where once their barricade stood. “Baruk Khazâd! Khazâd ai-mênu!”
Bard spirits Bilbo away, back in the direction of Dale. The Elven King went off to command his armies, shouting orders at the Lord of Men to keep the Hobbit close. No doubt he knows that the moment Bilbo is free to move at his leisure, he will run back to Erebor. To Thorin. To the Company.
Bilbo wonders how a Man from a town on a Lake learned to ride a horse so well, but he supposes that Bard has lived a scrappy and varied life, despite his noble lineage. And besides, if the Shire were in danger, Bilbo imagines that he, too, would suddenly become a very fast rider. “The Dwarves will march on Dale,” Bard alleges. He is wrong about his enemy, of course, but correct that Dale will soon be under attack. “We must make haste!”
“Oh, please wait, will you!” Bilbo tries to stop the horse somehow, though his efforts are ineffective. He doesn’t want to spur it on with the wrong sort of kick, and though he tries, he can reach neither its reins nor its mane.
“I cannot wait. I must—“
“Let me off here,” Bilbo commands.
“In the middle of a battle?” Bard does not seem to like this plan very much. “You will be killed.”
“Maybe,” Bilbo concedes. They aren’t really in the middle of a battle, per se. The orc host has not yet arrived, and Dáin is presently delivering some sort of speech to the Men and Elves, rather than fighting them. But they certainly will be in the thick of things soon. Within a few minutes, there will be carnage at this spot, beyond a doubt. “But there will be a battle soon in Dale, will there not? The danger will find us all, whether we run from it or toward it.”
“And you wish to run toward it?”
“I wish to run toward Thorin,” Bilbo replies evenly. “I cannot leave him to be killed.”
“Then you will die with him,” Bard argues, “Or perhaps before him. One Hobbit, running through a raging battle? And unarmed at that?”
“Then give me back my sword.” Bilbo will not be deterred. “Or I will leap off this horse and die that way.” He doesn’t think Bard will actually allow things to get to that point. The Man is reasonable, after all, and he was always reluctant to enact Thranduil’s harebrained hostage scheme. “The gold that Thorin owes you is no longer a priority. We must do what we can against the orcs. Please.”
“He does not deserve the faith you put in him,” Bard decrees, “Nor the love you give him.”
Bilbo bristles at this. “Well, you don’t know him, do you? And he may have been friendlier to you if you’d done anything other than doubt him and hinder him. Anyway, does any of that really matter if we’re all about to die?”
“I fear you will not reach him.”
“I must try,” Bilbo pleads, “Besides, I’ve done it before.” That was an extraordinarily stupid thing to say, but Bilbo is desperate. He will not allow Thorin to be killed again.
He knows exactly what will happen, of course: Dwalin will speak to the king and shatter the dragon sickness. Thorin will lead his company into battle and then he’ll take his nephews and his best soldier up to Ravenhill. Bilbo will be too late if is forced to accompany Bard to Dale and escape from his clutches. A head start is his only hope.
“Your king is a fool, let that be known.” But Bard has dismounted and is rummaging through the saddle bag in which he has stowed away Bilbo’s things. A sword, a handkerchief, and a pouch of useless pipeweed. Bilbo never did remember to pick out a replacement pipe in Erebor. At least Bard and Thranduil let him keep the mithril shirt. They clearly do not want him dead, whatever else they may desire. “I sincerely hope that, whatever happens this day, one of his nephews ends up on the throne.” He then helps Bilbo down from the horse and hands Sting back to the Hobbit.
“You shouldn’t speak ill of my intended when you’ve just put a sword in my hand,” Bilbo advises. “I’ll see you after the battle, and I’ll make sure you get what you are owed.”
“Go, then.” Bard does not sound optimistic about the issue of the treasure, but then, why would he? He knows nothing of dragon sickness and he has made it clear how little he thinks of Thorin. But he must have been telling the truth when he said that he harbored a great respect for Bilbo, or else he would not have allowed the Hobbit to enter the fray. If no one else does, Bard of Esgaroth and Dale trusts Bilbo to make his own decisions.
By the time Bilbo gets free of Bard and makes his way over to the fighting, the orcs have arrived. Naturally, getting through the battle is much more difficult now than it was the first time around. For one thing, the ring Bilbo carries is functionally useless and does not make him invisible. His enemies can see him, at least theoretically, though he is pleasantly surprised to discover that very few of them appear to be looking down, and therefore he escapes the notice of many an orc. It took an awfully long time to negotiate his escape from Bard, but Bilbo is not deterred. He must reach Thorin.
The main problem with that, of course, is that he has no idea where Thorin is. Last time, they met on Ravenhill, but Bilbo is now several hours ahead of that event. Thorin won’t attempt to climb Ravenhill until he knows that Azog and Bolg are there. He could be anywhere in the battle, as could every member of the company. There are only thirteen of them, after all, and Dáin, of course, who might have been given Bilbo’s description and be able to direct him to Thorin.
And then there is the horror of being here again, amidst the sounds and smells and sights of battle. Bilbo tries, he truly tries, to breathe only through his mouth, to plug his ears, to avoid focusing overmuch on anything that he might see. But of course, this is impossible. If he wishes to survive, and if he wishes to find Thorin, he must remain present. He was too late, the last time. He was too late, too distracted, too appalled by all that came to pass around him. He was disgusted, shocked, horrified, and Thorin died for it. Fíli and Kíli died for it. The sharp smell of blood hits Bilbo’s nostrils, and suddenly, he is there again, upon Ravenhill, holding Thorin in his arms and watching his only love bleed out upon the ice.
Bilbo is covered in blood again, running down the stairs again to tell Kíli the horrible news. He has pulled himself together again, forced himself away from Thorin in the name of his duty to the next king. The next king, who Bilbo might have called nephew, in a kinder world. Only to find him laying in a pool of his own blood, his body covered by Tauriel’s shaking, sobbing form. Yes. Bilbo remembers this moment well.
It was this very wind, whipping mercilessly against his wet face. It was this very stench that coated every inch of the battlefield, unwashed orc and blood and shit and other things more horrible. This stench which Bilbo has always associated with loss and horror and terror. This is the stench of Bilbo’s failure, his inability to protect the ones he loves.
He is nearly decapitated by the clumsy swing of an untrained man, wielding a rusted blade which looks to be as old as Dale itself. That brings Bilbo back to his senses. No, he is not upon Ravenhill. His face may be wet, and the world may smell just as it did when Bilbo pried his face off of Thorin’s bloody chest, but he has not yet failed. There is still time, and Bilbo must try. He cannot surrender to his memories, even ones so powerful and so horrific as these.
So he fights his way through, blindly, forcing himself to remember happier times. He is in Beorn’s garden with Thorin, sipping berry-water and talking about golden pipes. He is in Lake-town, the first time around, drinking with his friends. He is in Bag End, enjoying a proper Hobbit party with the least-proper and least-Hobbity folk he knows. He is wandering the Shire with Frodo on one of their long walks, deep in conversation, marveling at the lad’s bright wit and clever smile. He is watching Gandalf’s fireworks. Thorin is alive.
Are the Valar protecting Bilbo yet again? He still has yet to destroy the ring completely, weak though it may be, so he supposes that wouldn’t be too far-fetched an idea. Still, he has work to do. He is kicked once, distracted by the thought of his grandmother’s butterscotch biscuits, but he recovers quickly. He catches a stray arrow that leaves a hole in his tunic but cannot pierce his mithril armor. He is in Rivendell, and Frodo is there, alive after giving everybody such a shock. Beaming, despite his pallor, at the news that he is in the House of Elrond at long last. Eagles swoop and dive overhead, which fills Bilbo with true hope, none of this flimsy stuff that he’s been manufacturing thus far. The great birds have come early. Even if the worst happens, perhaps… perhaps there might still be some chance.
He presses on with renewed vigor. He must find Thorin. Bilbo’s arms are exhausted, after being stretched around Bard’s body and then from wielding Sting. He is panting from his long run and soaked in sweat, spattered once again with the blood of Elves and Men and orcs. But he is alive, and he can see Thorin now, and every fiber of his being is calling him toward his love.
Thorin is fighting with a heavy Dwarven broadsword. Of course, Orcrist is still in Legolas’s clutches, probably being put to great use in this very battle. Bilbo watches as the king dispatches orc after orc with his glorious weapon, narrowly dodging decapitation on several occasions over the course of only a few moments. Kíli is beside him, sword in hand and bow strapped across his back. They are both still alive, then. Bilbo has not failed. Not yet, at least.
Kíli spots Bilbo before Thorin does, but he knows better than to distract his uncle in the middle of a fight. His eyes widen in understanding and Bilbo nods a quick salute before making his way over to his love. Bilbo takes the liberty of sticking his sword into the latest orc’s back. That’ll teach him to threaten Thorin Oakenshield, Bilbo thinks.
As the orc falls, Thorin meets Bilbo’s eyes, and Bilbo is pleased to see no fire whatsoever. Thorin has come back to himself at long last, and not a moment too soon. “Ghivashel,” the king breathes.
“There’s no time to talk!” Bilbo pulls Thorin into what he means to be a very quick hug, not able to take his eyes off the battle around them. Kíli moves into a protective stance, apparently intent on covering the couple during their brief reunion. “You must listen to me, Thorin.”
“I am sorry.” Obviously, Thorin is not listening at all as he pulls the Hobbit close, so that he might mutter into Bilbo’s hair, “I am sorry.”
“I know,” Bilbo replies. Now is not the time for this conversation. They’re in the middle of a battlefield. “And you’re forgiven. Of course you’re forgiven.”
“Oh, thank Mahal.” Fíli has apparently joined them. Bilbo watches out of the corner of his eye as the prince, with swords drawn, establishes himself on the other side of Bilbo and Thorin. “I thought they’d taken him back to Dale.”
“Tell me you got a few hits in on that Elven King before you slipped away.” And Dwalin, too, is here, surrounding the third side of the embrace. Bilbo and Thorin are almost entirely defended, and it’s a good thing, too, because Thorin does not show any signs of releasing Bilbo. He may no longer be suffering from dragon sickness, but clearly, he’s being driven out of his mind by guilt and shame.
“So, this is the Hobbit.” Is that Dáin, as well? Oh, this won’t do at all! Two Ereborean princes, the greatest warrior among Durin’s folk, and the Lord of the Iron Hills, all defending Bilbo and Thorin so they can indulge in a simple hug? Bilbo loves Thorin, but this is a little excessive. They’ve got to put an end to this before somebody gets killed. No, not thinking about that. Bilbo’s got to keep his wits about him.“Not how I thought I’d meet my cousin’s intended, I have to say, but a happy meeting nevertheless.”
“I will never treat you so dishonorably again,” Thorin murmurs, “I will never restrain you in any capacity again. I will never—“
“That’s enough, Thorin.” Bilbo says firmly.
Immediately, Thorin releases Bilbo and steps back, as though the Hobbit were made of hot coals. “Have I hurt you?”
“I’m not so fragile that you could crush me with a single hug,” Bilbo protests, “But we’re in the middle of a battle, and I’ve already forgiven you, so there’s no need to keep apologizing and making promises and all that. Besides, if you say everything now, what will be left for the wedding?” He must force himself to keep his tone light. He does not wish to scare Thorin, to make him suffer when the king has already endured so much.
The dragon sickness has melted away. Bilbo knows neither how nor why, but he cares only for the fact that Thorin is well again. That is all. That is the only thing.
Dáin guffaws at this. “You’ve met your match, Thorin. Mahal be with you.”
“You are right, of course,” Thorin decides, though it’s unclear whether he is agreeing with Dáin or with Bilbo. “Our Maker has been merciful this day, helping you to find me amidst all this, returning you to me hale and hardy.”
Bilbo rolls his eyes. “And here I was thanking Yavanna for delivering you to me before you could get yourself chopped in half.”
“Chopped in half?”
“You should thank Kíli; he saved your life about three times that I just saw.” Don’t think about it. Don’t think about it. Don’t think about it. “Anyway, you’ve distracted me with your sweet nothings, and we are in the midst of battle, after all. You have to listen.”
“I am listening,” Thorin assures him. “Of course.” There’s a small scratch on his face, just below his eye, but he looks otherwise unharmed.
“There’s another orc army coming from the North,” Bilbo explains, “They’re going to set a trap for you on Ravenhill. Bolg and Azog are both there, and they expect that you’ll take your best warriors, Fíli, Kíli, and Dwalin, that is, and there you will be overwhelmed. They aim to separate you and kill you one by one.”
“How come you by this knowledge?” Thorin asks.
Bilbo tells as much of the truth as he can get away with without raising more questions than he is equipped to answer. “The Elven Prince and his Captain went to Gundabad and saw the hosts departing.” Hopefully, Tauriel will elect, as she did last time, to go up and help, and Legolas will follow her, just as he did before. “You need to have Dáin turn his army North and ambush our would-be ambushers. While they’re doing that, I say you and Dwalin and I take Ravenhill. Azog and Bolg will be caught off guard; they’ll be expecting to have an army at their backs and they won’t.”
“Tauriel is well, then?” Kíli asks.
Bilbo certainly hopes so. “Well enough,” he says vaguely. In truth, he hasn’t seen her since she saved his life in Lake-town. But he’s already committed to his story, and there’s no need to worry Kíli during such a vital moment. Tauriel will be fine. “We’ve got to get that army moving. It’ll take a while to extricate them, won’t it?”
“When did you become a general, men ghivashel?” Thorin asks, his eyes shining. Under any other circumstances, Bilbo would kiss him, but that would perhaps be inappropriate at the moment.
“Around the time I betrothed myself to a warrior king,” Bilbo replies. “Now, enough talk, and let’s get going. We must not waste time.”
“Very well,” Thorin acquiesces. Perhaps he’s still not thinking clearly, because it’s very unlike him to just go along with one of Bilbo’s plots without intervening. Perhaps because this plan involves killing Azog, Thorin is willing to do things that he would otherwise consider inadvisable and foolhardy. Or perhaps Bilbo’s plan just happens to be consistent with what Thorin would have done anyway.“Dáin, send your forces to the North and intercept the orc army there. The Men and Elves will have to hold this side of the Mountain along with my company. Dwalin, you will accompany us to Ravenhill. Defend Bilbo with your life.”
Bilbo glares at Dwalin. “Don’t you dare listen to him. Prioritize Thorin’s safety above mine.”
“I would have done anyway,” Dwalin promises. At least Bilbo isn’t the only one here with any sense.
“You are being ridiculous,” Thorin complains.
“No, you are,” is Bilbo’s clever retort. “I’m wearing mithril armor, Thorin. I’ll be fine. You, on the other hand—“
“Mithril?” Dáin seems to find this so amusing that he stops in the middle of killing an orc to laugh at it. Fíli has to finish the kill and keep Dáin from meeting his end mid-guffaw. “Mahal below, Thorin, you really are in love!”
“What are our orders, Uncle?” The situation must be dire indeed, if Kíli is the one to steer it back on track.
“Defend the mountain,” Thorin’s smile melts. “Return to it if necessary.”
“What?” Kíli doesn’t seem to like this very much. “You can’t be serious! You’re going to face Azog and Bolg alone?”
“Not alone,” Bilbo cuts in, “I’ll be with him, and Dwalin, too.”
“You would leave your two best warriors behind?” Fíli asks incredulously.
“He’s taking me with him,” Dwalin points out. “And we are the two best warriors in the company.”
“That’s preposterous,” Kíli protests, “Fíli and I are going with you.”
“Very—“
Before Thorin can finish allowing this, Bilbo puts his hairy foot down. “No. No, absolutely not. I’m not leading you two lads into a trap.”
Something tugs at his stomach. They would fare better with more warriors, and he is already taking Thorin back to Ravenhill against his better judgment. Besides, they will have the protection of Dáin’s entire army. Thorin must be there to kill Azog. Nobody else could do it, and Bilbo is dimly aware that it would be an insult to Thorin’s honor were anyone else to steal what he views as his kill. But there is no reason for Fíli and Kíli to risk themselves.
“We are sons of Durin,” Kíli points out, “And this is our battle to fight.”
“If the trap is intended for us, then we should be the ones to spring it,” Fíli reasons, “All three of us.”
“And Tauriel will be there, won’t she?” Kíli adds. “She’s been tracking those orcs. She won’t flee from them now. I would be honored to fight by her side.”
Bilbo rolls his eyes. “Does no one in this family have any self-preservation instincts to speak of?”
But he does, reluctantly, see the point. The lads would consider it dishonorable not to join the fight, and, now that Bilbo thinks about it, there’s no guarantee that the party will reach Ravenhill without the help of Fíli and Kíli. Besides, they will need an archer to cover them, and though the most logical move would be to protect the heir to the throne, even Bilbo is not naive enough to believe that the brothers would willingly be separated. Regardless, they are wasting time standing around and arguing. Bilbo can only hope that he has influenced things enough to keep the lads safe on Ravenhill. “Fine. Let’s get going, then. We don’t have time to lose.”
They set out for Ravenhill, the five of them, at a pace that Bilbo can barely match. “Dwalin will carry you,” Thorin decides, and it is difficult to determine who is most upset about this prospect.
“You can’t be serious!” Dwalin protests. “How am I supposed to swing an axe with a Hobbit on my back?”
“I hardly need to be carried,” Bilbo grumbles. “I can run perfectly fine. The lads have seen it.”
“He outran us once,” Kíli pipes in helpfully. “Which is practically unheard of.” He takes a moment to shoot his final arrow at a lunging goblin. He curses in Khuzdul. “Keep an eye out for arrows, will you?”
“Aye,” Fíli seems to understand what his brother is talking about, at least.
Bilbo may vomit. His legs are sore, but he can’t stop running, regardless of where he happens to be running to. His guts are swimming. They are running to Ravenhill, the very place where Thorin, Fíli, and Kíli were slain. Bilbo is leading them to their graves, but he sees no other choice. Bolg and Azog must be slain, and none of Bilbo’s stubborn friends would listen if he tries to persuade them to return to their Mountain and be safe.
“Thorin,” Bilbo pants, “Please tell me that your plan is not to run up Ravenhill on foot!”
“My plan was for Dwalin to carry you up Ravenhill,” Thorin grumbles. “Since I know you would not be parted from me even to save your own life.” It’s clear he disapproves of this, and would rather see Bilbo safe inside the Mountain, as well.
“You are not going to sulk at me in the middle of a battle, Thorin Oakenshield!” Bilbo scolds, watching with appreciation as Thorin takes out three orcs at once with that impressive sword of his.
“So you are allowed to be as contrary as you wish, but I must bend to your whims?”
“Contrary? Next time, perhaps I’ll keep my information to myself and see how you fare.” That’s a much lower blow than Thorin knows, but in Bilbo’s defense, he is near the point of losing consciousness from physical exertion and the cocktail of emotions brewing in his guts.
“Thank you for your input, General. When we have Erebor restored, I will be sure to make you my chief guard.” Thorin pauses to allow Bilbo to slash the legs of an oncoming orc before continuing. “Apologies to Dwalin; you are obviously better suited to the post.”
Before they can continue bickering, all further discussion is prevented by a loud whistle. Bilbo whips his head around and sees that Balin has commandeered some sort of goat-drawn cart from some of Dáin’s forces. Why they brought a cart into a battle, Bilbo has no idea, but he is glad of it now. “Oh, brilliant,” he breathes. He grabs Thorin’s hand and begins dragging the king in the direction of the cart.
Halfway there, he hears Thorin cry out, and when Bilbo looks back he sees that his beloved has an arrow sticking out of his arm. Despite the fact that all the blood in Bilbo’s veins has turned to jelly, he manages to keep running and help Thorin onto the cart. Dwalin joins them quickly, and the princes clamber up after him. Bilbo notes that Kíli’s quiver is mysteriously full of arrows again, though some of them appear to have seen better days. But Bilbo is too concerned about Thorin’s obvious injury to spend too long imagining the lads picking through the carnage for arrows to re-use.
“Right,” he says to Balin, “First things first, let’s find Óin. Second, we go to Ravenhill.”
Dwalin snorts. “We don’t need Óin for this, laddie. It barely broke the skin.”
“I am not injured,” Thorin declares, as if he does not have an arrow sticking out of his arm.
“I’ll be the judge of that,” says Bilbo, leaning over to examine the wound. “You’re bleeding.”
The cart begins to move, but Thorin pays it no mind. “That tends to happen when one is shot with an arrow.”
“So you admit that you are injured. Good. That’s progress. Let’s find somewhere safe for you to recover, and then the lads and Dwalin and I—“
“I will not sit this battle out,” Thorin growls. “You would have to saw off my legs, and even then, I would crawl forth trailing blood to challenge Azog.”
“There’s nowhere safe to put him, anyway,” Balin yells over the din of the battle.
Bilbo exhales heavily before taking his last remaining handkerchief out of his pocket. Thank Yavanna he had the sense to wash it when he was being held hostage. Thank Yavanna that Bard was generous enough to allow Bilbo to do so.
He does not bother asking Balin where the wounded are kept, because he has his own wounded to deal with. Thorin has already yanked the arrow out, and the fact that the blood is oozing rather than spurting is a promising sign that the wound is shallow. The cloth of Thorin’s tunic is torn, and it seems the arrow managed to pierce through a gap in his armor, but was stopped from puncturing the flesh any deeper by the hard metal.
“I wish I had something proper to clean it with,” Bilbo complains. Then he remembers the last of his handkerchiefs, which, thankfully, he had washed in Lake-town and then entirely forgotten about in all of the hubbub surrounding the Arkenstone and the hostage negotiation. Bilbo withdraws the little square of cloth from his pocket and uses it to bind Thorin’s wound.
“Your last handkerchief?” Thorin asks, incredulous for reasons which escape Bilbo entirely.
“Yes,” Bilbo confirms, “Now, hold still.”
Dwalin examines the arrow for a moment before tossing it aside and redirecting his focus to the weapon he has lately acquired. The cart they have stolen (perhaps not stolen; it is of Dwarven make, after all, and was likely handed over to Balin by its original drivers, assuming they’ve survived) is equipped to shoot bolts from two small canons mounted on either side.“Could be worse. Goblin make; no poison.”
“You see? I am not poisoned.” Thorin latches onto this news immediately. He tries to stand, as though he thinks that Bilbo will allow him to hang out the side of the cart, slashing at orcs with that ridiculous oversized sword. “I am fine and will continue fighting.”
Of course, things can never be simple for this company. They plow through rows of orcs. Dwalin and the boys fire bolts from either side of the cart while Bilbo tends to his king. It takes no small degree of glaring and muttering on all sides, but Thorin does eventually acquiesce to the gentle treatment.
Bilbo binds Thorin’s wound to his satisfaction and is pleased to see that there is little serious damage. Still, his heartbeat has yet to return to normal. He is uncomfortably aware that Thorin may very well die in a matter of minutes, that Bilbo’s intervention may not have been enough. At least this time, Bilbo will die with him. Rather than spend the next eight decades braving social isolation and ridicule in the Shire, for all his lonesome happiness, Bilbo will pass the time in the afterlife, atoning for his failure to resolve matters. Not that Thorin will expect much penance.
“Here, Uncle, you’ll make that worse,” Fíli uses one of his two swords to gesture at Thorin’s injury, “Trying to swing that great big sword around. Trade?” He removes the other sword from its scabbard and holds them both out to his uncle.
“Fine,” Thorin concedes. Bilbo does not know whether to be pleased that Thorin has acknowledged his injury or horrified that Thorin plans to rush into battle with a wound that is apparently so great as to necessitate a switch to a lighter weapon. “But do not damage the blade. That sword is a relic from Khazâd-dum and very precious to our family.”
Typical. Bilbo shakes his head. Before he can make some snide comment about the utter ridiculousness of worrying about the impressive history of one’s weapon in the midst of battle, a great troll lumbers into their path. Bilbo squeezes Thorin’s hand, more to stop his lover from attempting to challenge the beast one-handed than to comfort himself, and braces himself as Balin steers the cart roughly onto a frozen river. Yes, because the wisest course of action is to test the ice with the weight of a cave troll, adapted by some occult means to the daylight.
Kíli and Dwalin yell for a moment about how to kill the troll. Bilbo does not know if this happened before. He hopes that it did, and that his friends survived it the last time, but of course, he cannot very well ask them. He knows that his presence has thrown things off balance. Even if Thorin took an arrow to the shoulder before, Bilbo knows for certain that he is the only thing stopping His Majesty from hopping onto one of the goats and attempting to fight the blasted troll on his own.
“Hang on lads, I’m coming!” Is that Bofur’s voice?
Yes. It is. Bilbo does not know how Bofur has managed to commandeer the reigns of yet another troll, but he sits atop its head, pulling at the chains that apparently relate to the movement of the monster’s limbs. Bilbo watches as his friend manipulates his troll into attacking the other, knocking it out of play.
“Bofur, you beauty!” Fíli screams at the top of his lungs, before the cart turns a corner and their friend is out of sight. Bilbo must physically restrain Thorin from trying to help as Dwalin takes out another troll with his bolts and Balin steers the cart over the monster’s corpse.
“I think they have it well in hand,” Bilbo murmurs.
“I should be helping,” Thorin grumbles, “I will not sit here and do nothing while my kin fight my battles for me.”
“You are healing,” Bilbo protests, “And besides, you’re in no position to fight.”
“Let us guard you for a few moments more, uncle,” Fíli agrees, winking at Bilbo.
“Like Mister Boggins says, we have it well in hand.” Kíli is very good at feigning confidence, apparently, joking around in the midst of battle.
Their path is blocked by wargs. Bilbo winces as the beasts take out a few of their goats. He squeezes Thorin’s hand a little too tightly as the animals bleat in pain. Thorin mutters something in Khuzdul, though it is difficult to tell from his tone whether he is comforting Bilbo or cursing the Hobbit for keeping him from the fight.
“We’re pulling too much weight,” Dwalin says to his brother. Ah. Yet one more problem that is entirely Bilbo’s fault. Perhaps this happened the last time, but they were able to make it past this point because the Hobbit was absent. But now he has added weight to the cart, prevented Thorin from fighting, and mucked everything up, if only in a novel way.
“Cut the tracers,” Balin says. “Ride them to Ravenhill.”
“No, Balin.”
“My goat riding days are over,” Balin smiles. “Durin be with you, brother.”
“If only I could say my goat-riding days were over as well,” Bilbo grumbles, but he doesn’t have much say in the matter. His head spins trying to follow the swordplay taking place. In all honesty, Bilbo’s heart stops in his chest for a moment, watching Fíli walk across the ropes that bind the goats to the cart, swinging his sword as he goes. Bilbo knows that this is a battle, and that the lad is a trained warrior, but that does not make Bilbo any more comfortable with the sight.
Still, the prince eventually settles onto the back of a goat, and his brother follows suit. Dwalin joins them, and before Bilbo can protest, Thorin is tossing him onto the back of another goat (that can’t be good for his shoulder) before jumping on behind him and cutting the tracer that tethers the goat to the cart. Bilbo offers a sympathetic pat to the animal that must now carry their combined weight through a battle, but he knows better than to try and argue with Thorin about it at this juncture.
Once they get higher than the wargs can climb, things become much simpler. No orcs hinder them, because why would they? This is a trap deliberately set to give Azog the satisfaction of wiping out the line of Durin. Although, Dáin yet lives as he commands his troops below, but perhaps Azog expected him to come rushing forth as well. Or, perhaps the pale orc lives only for carnage and does not care who springs the trap that he has set.
Regardless, they make it up the hill without any further injury. Or, at least, nothing serious. They’re all a bit scratched-up, and Bilbo suspects that there are more than a few bruises lurking underneath all that terrible armor. “I need you to know that I love you,” Bilbo tells Thorin just as they reach the top. He doesn’t know why he says it now. “In case things go badly…”
“Things will not go badly,” Thorin assures him. For a moment, Bilbo thinks he’s lying to himself and everyone else yet again, but the king continues. “If we are killed, we will be reunited in the service of Mahal, where we will work together for eternity. Though, of course, I love you more than ever I had thought to love another being.”
“Are we certain that Mahal lets Hobbits in?” Bilbo asks as the goat bearing them slows to a stop. No orcs are yet visible.
“Perhaps not all Hobbits, but you were made as my companion, and I was made as yours,” Thorin explains in a low tone into Bilbo’s ear. “We will be together in the next life, as in this one. The Maker and his Lady would never be so cruel as to keep us apart.”
Nobody says anything about how Thorin appears to be making up lore as he goes along. It’s not as though there’s any precedent, and even if there were, Thorin would not know how the couple fared in the afterlife. He is alive now, and for that, Bilbo is infinitely grateful. “Well, I suppose it doesn’t matter.” For the second time today, Bilbo is lifted off of an animal’s back and set with ceremony on the ground. “We’re not going to find out.”
“I thought you said there would be orcs here.” Kíli looks around, apparently finding no threats.
“There are,” Bilbo gestures toward the large rock structure at the crest of the hill. “In that tower, no doubt, waiting for us. Didn’t you see them on our ride?” But of course he didn’t. Kíli was at bit busy defending Bilbo and Thorin while the Hobbit saw to the king’s wound. He would not have been paying attention to what was happening upon Ravenhill.
“Of course,” Thorin agrees, “They expect us to send one or two to check the structure over.”
“Mhm,” Fíli hums thoughtfully, “And if Dáin had not intercepted their army, they would send troops to distract those left outside. Then they would isolate whoever went inside the watchtower. Probably make a big show of the execution.”
“It doesn’t matter what they would do.” If Fíli knows all that, then why did he go into the tower in the first place? Oh. Because his king ordered him to do it. Because had he not gone, had he not been the one to forge ahead and spring the trap, it could just as easily have been Kíli. Bilbo keeps hearing the sound of Fíli’s bones breaking, over and over again, the lad’s pained scream echoing in his mind. That will not happen again. Bilbo will die before he lets it happen again. “Nobody is going in there. Agreed?”
“If they want us, they’ll have to fight us on our terms,” Kíli declares.
“And they will not win easily.” Dwalin is ready with his axe.
The five of them stand in a circle. Thorin, annoyingly, keeps trying to shove Bilbo behind him. “Please don’t be ridiculous,” Bilbo warns. “I’m armed and I’m fighting beside you. That’s that, so we’ll hear no more about it.”
“I will not allow you to be killed on my account.”
Bilbo rolls his eyes. “I’m wearing mithril armor, Thorin. If anything, I should be shielding you.” But he reaches out to squeeze the hand of his beloved. There is no point in arguing, but if it becomes necessary, then it goes without saying that Bilbo will put himself between Thorin and any approaching threat.
Everything will be fine. Bilbo’s head feels packed with cotton and his guts have turned to water and he keeps having to look beside him to make sure that Thorin is still alive, but other than that, everything is going to be perfectly alright. And if not, Bilbo will find Lady Galadriel and beg her to send him back again. He would fight the trolls a hundred times, riddle with Gollum over and over, and spend a thousand years imprisoned by Wood Elves if it means keeping his family safe.
A scraping sound behind Bilbo causes him to jump, but before he can react properly, Kíli exclaims, “Tauriel!” Oh. Good. The Elves are here, then.
“Thank the Valar we are not too late.” Bilbo turns to see Tauriel rushing to Kíli’s side. Fíli makes room in the circle for her to slide between the two princes. “Legolas and I came as fast as we could when we learned what the orcs were plotting.” As promised, the Elven prince climbs onto the hill after her.
“Why would you come?” Thorin demands, not even turning to look at her. “Why do you care? This is not your fight.”
“I would not see a friend slaughtered,” Tauriel cuts him off. “Nor would I allow any orc to triumph in battle if I could help it. We have been tracking this pack for weeks, Your Majesty. Did you really think we’d let up now, just because you got here first?”
“We’ll take the extra swords,” Dwalin decides. “You four can sort out the courtship later on.”
“I intend to save my sword for that, as well,” Legolas snipes. He has a bit more trouble shoving into the circle, but eventually finds his place between Bilbo and Kíli. It is probably for the best that Thorin cannot reach him, as Bilbo does not put it past the king to lash out. Especially considering that Legolas is currently wielding Orcrist, which glows the same faint blue as Sting.
“Less talking of courtship, and more killing of orcs, if you please!” Bilbo is perhaps the only one who understands the gravity of this situation.
“There are no orcs to kill,” Fíli reminds him. “Or none that I can see.”
“They’ll come,” Bilbo is certain of this.
In fact, they do come, after only a few moments of waiting. Apparently, Azog gets sick of waiting for Thorin to send scouts into the watchtower and sends a few of his own soldiers out. They are joined by stragglers from the orc host that Dáin’s forces have engaged. Their numbers are not as great as before, but they still occupy the seven fighters well enough. Their circle falls to pieces in no time, but Bilbo sticks close to Thorin. He knows that his absence would become a distraction, and anyway, Tauriel can defend the princes if it comes to that.
Bilbo is too distracted slashing at orcs to pay much attention to anybody else’s fighting. Flashes of auburn inform him of Tauriel’s quick movements, and he is dimly aware when Legolas leaves his side. The circle is broken quickly, which is likely what their enemies wish to happen. Still, aside from Bilbo, everyone here is a trained warrior, well accustomed to fighting in or out of a prescribed formation.
He is perpetually aware of Thorin’s position, and he watches his intended destroy orc after orc in quick succession, even with a wounded arm. Thorin fights with both of Fíli’s swords, but he favors his left arm slightly. Bilbo, then, establishes himself on Thorin’s left and does his best to compensate for any weakness there. This is how the battle passes until Bolg and Azog arrive.
“Oakenshield,” Azog greets Thorin, paying no mind to any of the rest of them. “Have you come to be slaughtered? Your filthy bloodline shall end today.”
Thorin laughs darkly at this. “A hundred years hence, my heirs will spit upon this ground as a place forever tainted by your blood, and that of your fell kin.”
Bilbo refuses to think about why this quick comment did not come to Thorin the last time. He refuses to remember the horror of watching Fíli fall. Of knowing that he was too late to prevent the trap from being sprung, that his young friend would never again laugh beside a campfire or stomp across anybody’s dinner table.
He finds himself glancing away, just for a moment, just to make certain that the princes still live. Kíli has climbed atop a boulder and takes advantage of the added height, firing arrow after arrow at their enemies. Tauriel flits around, engaging orcs with her twin knives. Fíli swings his massive sword around, and Bilbo hopes that the lad is not at a disadvantage for his lack of practice with the blade. Dwalin stands close by, making it clear that he has practice aplenty with that axe. Bilbo searches frantically for Legolas, but cannot find him.
“Your heirs will die first,” Azog decides, reclaiming Bilbo’s attention. “And then your…” he utters a word in his own tongue which Bilbo does not understand, but assumes is probably some slur against Hobbits, or else some rude reference to Bilbo in particular. Regardless, he is the intended target. “And then, once you have watched them all suffer, I will slay you slowly.”
He waves his sword arm, and Bolg steps toward Fíli. But Legolas is already there, leaping down from the side of the watch tower and moving in front of the prince to engage the great orc. It would, perhaps, be better if he did so with any weapon other than Orcrist, but that shall be a conversation to have after the battle.
“You’re not stealing our kill,” Kíli protests, knocking an arrow and aiming at Bolg. He is distracted by another orc approaching his boulder. He redirects the arrow and shoots the enemy at close range between the eyes.
Legolas mutters something that Bilbo does not catch. Fíli pivots, slashing at another approaching orc with his heirloom blade, and suddenly, it seems, the fight has begun anew. Bilbo catches sight of Tauriel leaping up to kick Bolg in the back of the head before he turns to focus on his own fight. The fight that has been brewing inside him for eighty years, the fight that has haunted his nightmares and dogged his every step since the first Battle of the Five Armies.
Azog advances toward Thorin, and Bilbo sees red once more. He is not aware of his own actions as he steps in front of the king. “Stay back,” he warns, as if Azog will be deterred by a single Hobbit wielding a short blade. “Do not touch him.”
This sentiment is not new, but all Bilbo can see is Thorin’s lifeless body on that stone slab, blood on the ice, the poor lads, Dwalin’s shaky hands, Tauriel’s tears, the Eagles’ descent a moment too late, blue eyes staring at nothing. This will not happen again. Bilbo will not allow it to happen again. He will drive Sting into Azog’s gut and watch with as the foul creature dies painfully. He will saw off the head and stomp on the face and spit on the corpse to avenge those he loves, those who have been murdered by this foul beast.
“What are you doing?” Thorin demands, trying to step around Bilbo. “Get behind me!”
But the Hobbit blocks him. Bilbo screams and charges at the orc, who only watches, in shock or amusement or some combination thereof. Bilbo gets one good stab in, but perhaps it’s in the wrong place, because Azog is still standing, and Bilbo cannot pull his sword out. The orc probably knew that there was no point in fighting off the little Hobbit. Or perhaps he did not believe that Bilbo would actually attack him. Perhaps the orc is simply too slow to process events, though he more than makes up for that shortcoming with his bulk.
There is a scream in the distance, one Bilbo has heard before, in Lake-town, on the first adventure. His blood chills. Kíli. Just for a moment, he glances away again, and sees the prince laying upon the ground, his sword tossed out of his reach and his empty quiver thrown even farther. His bow is broken, and an orc stands over him, curved blade raised. Kíli’s chest heaves with ragged breaths, which means that he is yet alive. From the looks of it, he was thrown from the boulder and is now too injured to flee or seek out his weapons.
Legolas bounds over and tackles the orc, saving Kíli. Good. Bilbo turns to face his opponent again, having lost any advantage he may have had in the element of surprise. Azog is aware of Bilbo’s weakness, his momentary distraction, and he has gathered himself. He is no longer shocked at the sight of a Hobbit charging toward him, and why would he be, when he has seen it once before? And Bilbo has given him long enough to ascertain that Sting will not kill him. Azog does not even bother to pluck the blade from his side.
Before Bilbo can scramble out of the way, Azog hits him across the stomach with the blade arm and enough force to send the Hobbit flying. He hits the stone wall of the watchtower and groans, but evidently, he is still alive. He may not be able to get up quite yet, but if he were dead, he would surely not be in so very much pain. His head, thank Yavanna, has not taken any impact. Bilbo is propped up against the wall, just enough to get a good look at the fighting behind him.
“Bilbo!” To hear the way that Thorin screams his name, though, Bilbo may as well have just been killed.
“Mithril,” he manages to say, “Wearing mithril.” Bilbo will not die today. He cannot. If this mithril shirt could protect Frodo from a similar attack by a cave troll twice Azog’s size, then it stands to reason, too, that Bilbo will recover in good time.
But Thorin does not seem to hear him, does not seem aware of the advancing orc at all. Azog walks slowly, apparently relishing in the sight of Thorin’s devastation. The other orcs do not touch him. Those not distracted by the fight with the rest of their company have clearly been ordered to leave Thorin to Azog, which is both a blessing and a curse in this terrible moment. The king rushes to Bilbo’s side, turning his back on his enemy.
“What are you thinking?” Bilbo demands. “Turn around. Turn around and fight.”
Disjointed footsteps sound, and he can see Kíli approaching over the king’s shoulder, ready to attack Azog. He must have heaved himself up somehow. No, he did not heave himself up; someone helped him. It is not hard to see who, based on the blade in his hand. Legolas has given him Orcrist.
Why would Legolas give up Orcrist? Something is wrong with Kíli’s run, his gait thrown askew, and his face is twisted in a grimace of pain. His injury is plainly slowing him down. He will not reach them in time. Tauriel and Dwalin are distracted fighting Bolg, though they appear to be winning. Fíli takes care of the other orc soldiers. Even if Kíli gets there before Azog kills Thorin, he will only be a momentary distraction. He is not as skilled with the sword as the orc is, and he is wounded already. There is nobody near enough to help him, save for Thorin.
“Thorin, please!” Bilbo begs. “You must fight. Turn around and fight!”
But Thorin is busy checking him over for injuries, pressing against Bilbo’s sides with trembling hands as though to staunch some imaginary bleeding. He is breathing heavily, as senseless as he was in Erebor. And he will die for it.
The orc that Fíli has been fighting collapses to the ground, and the lad meets Bilbo’s eyes across the battle. He cannot possibly get there quickly enough, cannot use his cumbersome blade to intercept the pale orc. Does he have throwing knives left? Bilbo doubts it. Plenty of these were used on the way to the Mountain, and anyway, he does not think that Fíli is in any position to rummage around in his boots for a spare blade.
This is a terrible predicament to be in. Thorin is entirely without sense, hovering over Bilbo. Azog is approaching. Kíli, one of the best archers among them, will be forced to fight the pale orc at close range, if he gets there in time. He lost a sword fight to Bolg the last time even with Tauriel’s help, and Azog is larger and more skilled, and Kíli is alone, or he will be, and Fíli is too far away to help, while the others cannot extricate themselves from their own fights. Azog raises his blade.
“Thorin,” Bilbo breathes, “Thorin, please. You must—“
Something comes flying through the air. For a moment, Bilbo thinks it is a burst of light, some magic, perhaps conjured by the Wizard. Yes, Gandalf should be here to clean up the mess that he made by sending them all on this adventure in the first place. He has seen this before, he remembers dimly, in the visions given to him by the Lady Galadriel. Not that this helps Bilbo any in determining what the sight before him means.
But then the ball of light hits Azog in the head, proving its own solidity with a resounding thud, like an uncuttable stone, like the heart of a mountain. The orc absorbs the force of the hit, the sort of force produced by a strong Dwarven arm. Bilbo is dimly aware of a harsh, determined battle cry, a wordless yell and the sound of disjointed footsteps pounding against the cold ground. Azog sways for a moment, apparently dizzy, and swoons, stumbling backwards right onto Kíli’s sword.
If the orc wasn’t dead when the stone hit him, the prince makes sure of it by releasing the weapon, stepping to the side and allowing Azog’s great weight to do the work of burying the blade. Even the pale orc cannot survive two swords boring into him, one in the side and one in the back. And all of this after what must have been a major head injury by what is probably the hardest stone to ever exist. Well. That’s step four out of the way, then. If Azog is dead, he won’t be bothering Thorin or the lads any time soon.
Kíli collapses with apparent exhaustion the moment his enemy is slain. His brother rushes to his side, sword raised. Bilbo can rest easy knowing that Fíli is there to protect them all from those few surviving orcs. Thorin still seems unaware of his surroundings, and Bilbo is not any more likely to rouse himself to rejoin the fighting than Kíli is, at this point.
“By the Valar,” Legolas cries. He is slumped against the boulder, clutching at his side where a knife has been lodged. Oh. That is why he gave up Orcrist, why he did not take on Azog himself. The run may very well have killed him. There are only five or six enemies left, of which Tauriel and Dwalin make quick work. It seems that Dáin has done his part, after all, because no more orcs appear to be forthcoming. “I would not have thought that possible. I would not believe it, had not I seen it with my own eyes.” He murmurs something else in shocked Sindarin, Westron apparently failing him in his pain and shock.
“What happened?” Thorin asks, eyes wide with confusion and awe. He brushes Bilbo’s face with a gentle hand, as though he cannot believe that the Hobbit is breathing. In his frantic, overprotective state, he must have forgotten all about the mithril. Silly. So silly.
Besides, it is obvious what just happened. All of the pieces have fallen into place for Bilbo, and he is beyond proud. Yes, Kíli just killed Azog the Defiler, which would be a cause for celebration under any circumstances. But this would not be possible had Fíli not made the greatest sacrifice that any Son of Durin could make. Legolas’s awe is perfectly explicable; Bilbo feels it too, and he knows that Thorin will be equally gobsmacked when he hears what has taken place.
Bilbo does not have the presence of mind to say anything very elaborate. He is tired, and he is bruised, and he has barely recovered from the knowledge that his beloved was about to die in his arms for the second time. He can be forgiven if he is not so eloquent as he would be on any other day. “Your heir just used the Arkenstone as a projectile weapon.”
Notes:
As many of you guessed, yes, Fíli had the Arkenstone the entire time, and apparently he was taking notes in chapter 5 when Bilbo tried to challenge Azog armed with nothing but a rock.
There's only a few more chapters left after this! The next update will be on Wednesday 22 July, as I'll be traveling again next week and won't have time to edit.
Chapter 15: Days of Conversation
Notes:
There's a lot of talking in this chapter, so buckle up. Thanks for all the comments and kudos, as always, and thanks for reading!
Chapter Text
Thorin’s body is trembling from head to foot, his thoughts racing and his breath coming quickly in erratic pants. He cannot believe that it is finally over. He has reclaimed Erebor. Azog the Defiler is dead, and his pack of fiends with him. Bilbo Baggins is alive, even after having been slashed across the gut by the orc and thrown several meters in the process. Not that this is a very big surprise, once Thorin is able to think about the matter logically. He knew, after all, that Bilbo was wearing mithril armor. But something at the very core of Thorin was unable to move past the sight of his One flying through the air, landing in a heavy heap upon the icy ground. The battle faded around Thorin and the Hobbit grew brighter, drawing him in with mumbled nonsense that Thorin could not parse.
Thorin would have died, in that moment, and he would not have cared in the slightest. There would have been no life for him without Bilbo, not anymore. No way for him to go on without his One, the only person who could draw him out of dragon sickness, the only person with the courage to contradict him openly in his most dangerous state. Perhaps the Hobbit simply did not understand the level of threat that Thorin posed. There must not be any similar affliction among his own people. What is there in the Shire to merit such disgusting greed?
“You’re alright,” Bilbo assures Thorin, reaching up to touch his face with one quaking hand. Bilbo’s fingers are so soft, with not a scar to speak of and only a few callouses in testament to a life spent reading, writing, cooking and gardening. “You’re alive.”
“Yes.” It takes Thorin a moment to register that Bilbo must have been mourning him already, must have seen Azog approaching while Thorin was senseless with worry. That odd mumbling must have been Bilbo’s attempt to get Thorin to take up his swords and battle the pale orc, but Thorin would not have been able to do so without knowing that Bilbo was safe. “You should not have jumped in front of me.” He grabs Bilbo’s hand and kisses it, pressing his lips to the knuckles one by one. “You should never risk yourself for my sake again.”
“We’ve had this conversation twice before, Thorin,” Bilbo breathes. Then his voice solidifies. “Don’t be ridiculous. If you’re in danger, of course I’m going to protect you. I’m as good as a shield with my mithril on.” To prove his point, the Hobbit tries to sit up. He winces with the effort, abandons the idea, and lays back down. “Though I don’t suppose it protects much against bruising.”
“There must be some way to re-engineer the design so that it does,” Thorin muses. If he were sensible, he would perhaps not be thinking of designing new armor for Bilbo with the corpse of his greatest enemy laying behind him, but if he were sensible, he would have killed the creature himself for harming his One.
“The one time you don’t charge into battle, I swear,” Bilbo grumbles, apparently thinking along the same lines. “By the Green Lady, Thorin, you scared me half to death! I don’t know what I would’ve done if… no, it doesn’t matter. We’re both alive. I suppose we have the lads to thank for that.”
And if there were any words to force Thorin back to his senses, Bilbo has just uttered them. It feels as though Thorin spent the past several minutes submerged underwater and has finally just come up for air. The world clarifies around him, and Bilbo is no longer the center of it. There are others here as well.
“My sister-sons.” They were the ones to slay Azog the Defiler, were they not? They were the ones to save Thorin’s life and, more importantly, Bilbo’s. Thorin has been so preoccupied with his One until now that little else has settled in his mind.
“You should speak to them,” Bilbo counsels. “I’ll be okay, but…” He trails off.
Thorin looks over his shoulder, attempting to see what has left his Hobbit at such a loss for words. There is Kíli, sitting upon the cold ground. He appears to be engaged in a rather intimate conversation with the Elf Maiden, who sits too close to him, her slender hand braced on his shoulder. It is clear to Thorin that his nephew is wounded, but judging by the grin on the lad’s face, he is less concerned with his injuries than he is with the chance to pass more time with the Woodland guard. Thorin swallows his instinctive distaste and decides that his sister-son is in good hands. At the very least, the Elf will prevent Kíli from straining whatever hurts he has managed to accrue.
“I’m fine, I swear,” Kíli is telling the Elf, “Just a twisted ankle, that’s all. You must see to Legolas first.”
“That is not a twisted ankle,” the Elven prince argues, still clutching at his side. His tunic is drenched in blood, and sitting up clearly requires great effort on his part. “You’ve broken something.”
“And you’ve been stabbed,” Kíli retorts rightfully.
Tauriel rolls her eyes. “Be still, both of you,” she orders, “And be quiet. You know I cannot work with all this chatter.”
Thorin watches in awe as his beloved nephew actually shuts up. Perhaps this Tauriel is not as bad as he originally thought. She is still an Elf, though, and still too old for Kíli, but Thorin can trouble himself with such things later.
Next, of course, Thorin sees Azog. The orc is dead. There is no malice left in those cruel eyes, and a large puddle of blood seeps from two rather impressive stab wounds: the first in the side and the second in the chest. It will take three warriors at least to move the pale orc off of Orcrist, upon which Azog fell with his complete weight, and when they do, Thorin thinks he will allow his sister-son to keep the blade. After all, it was Kíli, not Thorin, who used the ancient sword to slay the greatest foe their line has known since Durin’s Bane. Regardless, Thorin has no trouble ripping Bilbo’s little Sting out of the enemy’s corpse.
“Here you are, Ghivashel.” He hands Bilbo the weapon.
The Hobbit wrinkles his nose. Adorable, Thorin thinks, but knows better than to say. “Oh, the smell is even worse up close. Could you not have cleaned it first?”
Thorin can’t help but smile. If Bilbo has the energy to complain about cleanliness, he is probably going to be alright, after all. “Next time you kill an Orc Lord, I will be sure to clean your blade for you before I return it to you, yes.”
“I did not kill an Orc Lord,” Bilbo protests, “Fíli and Kíli did.” Which reminds Thorin once again of his initial task. This, apparently, was Bilbo’s intent, as he adds. “At least go and talk to Fíli. He looks terribly worried, and you might set his mind at ease.”
Worried? What does Fíli have to be worried about? Thorin owes him a life debt. Three life debts, actually: without Fíli’s intervention, Azog doubtlessly would have killed Thorin first, and then Kíli, and then Bilbo. Thorin takes responsibility for the lives of all his kin. But then his eyes fall to the Arkenstone, and he is distracted once again.
It is so bright. So beautiful. Sickened as he is at the way he behaved in pursuit of it, Thorin is shamefully drawn to the stone. He wishes the reclaim it, to hide it in his pocket and never allow it to be seen by any other soul. To hold it close forever more, proving once and for all his unequivocal right to rule over Durin’s folk. That is the dragon sickness speaking, or else the same curse from which his grandfather suffered, or both together, muddling his mind. Will it ever truly go away? Will Thorin ever be entirely without this burden, ever be free to trust his own instincts?
The same part of him that sought the Arkenstone sought also to possess Bilbo entirely. To lock him away deep within the vaults of Erebor, along with all the gold and jewels. Would the Hobbit have gone along with it, had Thorin tried it? Would he have gone to his prison willingly? Or would he have struggled? Would he have challenged Thorin, tried to fight him off? He would not have succeeded. Perhaps he might have run away. But fantasizing about imprisoning Bilbo is hardly the worst of Thorin’s crimes.
Understanding dawns on him, now that he has forced the clouds from his stormy mind. Of course Fíli would be worried. He stole the Arkenstone from the treasury of Erebor, kept it from Thorin for days on end, and ultimately used it recklessly as a weapon in battle. Had his plan failed, had his aim not been true, the stone could have wound up in the hands of the pale orc. But then, had Fíli’s plan failed, the lad would have become king in short order, and the stone would have been his to do with as he wished.
Had he wished to, in fact, he could have allowed Azog to kill Thorin, then attacked the orc from behind. It would have cleared up any disputes about the ownership of the stone. He could have saved Bilbo, too, and perhaps Kíli as well, if he’d managed to stop his brother from fighting. Had Kíli not said that he would support Fíli’s claim to the throne, if it came to that?
But Fíli chose to part with the Arkenstone and save his uncle’s life rather than ascend to the throne. Would Thorin have done the same, had their positions been reversed? He tries to tell himself that of course he would; he’d do anything for his sister-sons. But he nearly murdered his heir on the battlements, when Thorin walked in on Fíli embracing Bilbo. In his madness, Thorin could not see the innocent gesture as anything other than a threat to his authority, an attempt to steal from him, as though Bilbo were nothing more than a possession. Thorin was weak in the face of his own twisted desires, bending like a blade of grass to his worst impulses.
Thorin could never be so strong as his sister-son. Not in all his life. If he’d had the Arkenstone in his hands, he would have become his grandfather. He would have retreated into the treasury and probably starved to death there. Or he would have become a burden to all those close to him, leaving Bilbo to care for him and his sister-sons to rule his kingdom while he whiled away the days staring at a pretty rock.
Yet none of these things happened. Thorin did not lose himself to the dragon sickness, and he did not die in battle, all for the bravery of his sister-son. When he thinks of it like that, there is really only one possible course of action. Thorin takes a few quick, decisive strides in the direction of his heir.
Fíli holds up his hands in a gesture of peace, dropping his heavy heirloom blade upon the ground. “I am sorry, Uncle,” he blurts out before Thorin can reach him, “You should know that I acted alone. Kíli did not know that I had taken the stone. Do not blame him. What he said about my claim was—“
But he cuts himself off when Thorin falls to his knees. By Mahal, could there be one more suited to the throne of Erebor than Fíli, son of Dís? Even now, when he thinks he is going to face charges for treason, his first instinct is to defend his brother.
Something foul settles in Thorin’s stomach. For a moment, he is glad that Frerin is dead, that he could not have come on this terrible journey. That at least he never had to watch his beloved brother devolve into monstrosity. Is that why Mahal has reclaimed so many of Thorin’s loved ones, then? So that his father, his mother, his grandparents, his brother, and his brother-in-law would be spared the sight of his egregious behavior?
“What are you doing?” Fíli demands, dropping his outstretched hands in confusion. “Get up.”
“When we return to Erebor,” Thorin begins, “We will hold your coronation ceremony immediately. The King’s Chambers are yours if you want them. The Arkenstone, as well, to place upon your throne, if you think it wise.”
“I don’t understand.” The lad sounds genuinely perplexed.
“You have proven your worth a hundredfold this day, my sister-son,” says Thorin. He cannot look his nephew in the eyes, cannot bear the disgust that he knows he will find there. “None of our line have ever willingly parted with the Arkenstone before. You could have kept it for yourself and fled, but you chose instead to save my life at the cost of your own.” They both know what Fíli risked, after all, when he made it known that he took the Arkenstone. Legally, Thorin would be well within his rights to have the lad executed. But legally, Thorin was well within his rights to start a war with the Men and Elves, and see how that turned out! “I swear fealty to you, Fíli, son of Dís, true King of Erebor.”
“Uncle, please, get up,” Fíli urges once more, holding out his hand. “You don’t mean that.”
“I mean it well enough. You have acted as a true king would. Where I was a coward, you were—“
“I was protecting my king.” When Thorin does not get up on his own, Fíli hunches down and hauls his uncle to his feet. When did he grow strong enough to do that? “As I will continue to do as Crown Prince of Erebor. Crown Prince, and nothing more.”
“You are entitled—“
“I’m not letting you abdicate,” Fíli informs him flatly. “You know Mum would kill you.”
But Dís will kill him anyway. When Thorin tells her that he threatened her son, that he put the entire company at risk with his foolish, pointless war over nothing, against the better judgment of all of his advisors, she will charge at him with her axe raised. And she will be right to do so. “You have proven—“
“Do you think I planned to… to throw the Arkenstone?” Fíli gestures at the stone where it lays upon the ground. “I would have kept it. I would have challenged you for the throne. Had you not threatened me, and shown me that our treasure could cause madness, I would have acted rashly. I would have done what I could not take back, just as you would. I am not yet ready to be king, Thorin. I see the burden that you bear, and I would not yet take it from you. Durin’s folk look to you as their leader.” Fíli kneels before Thorin, a gesture which the king feels he does not deserve. “I swear fealty to you, Thorin, son of Thráin, son of Thrór, King Under the Mountain.”
“I—“ Thorin may cry. He does not deserve this level of loyalty. To have Bilbo forgive him is a miracle enough, but for Fíli to kneel when he is the one who just saved the kingdom would be far too much even had Thorin not spent the last moments of the battle sitting idle and without sense.
“Honestly,” Fíli continues, “If slaying Azog is what makes someone king, then we should be crowning Kíli. He wouldn’t do a bad job at it, either.” This must be some sort of joke, intended to relieve the tension or lighten Thorin’s mood.
“He owes you his life as well.” Thorin tries, truly, not to make the comparison that blooms so easily in his chest. Where he could not protect Frerin, Fíli was able to buy Kíli the time that he needed. Did he keep track of Kíli’s whereabouts through the fighting? Was he aware the entire time of his brother’s location?
Thorin never was. At Azanulbizar, he was distracted, first with his own opponents and then with avenging his grandfather. He could not keep track of Frerin, could not keep track of Thráin, could do nothing but charge forward and fight. He lost himself to it, and he earned himself a new name, but he was left bereft and grieving for his negligence.
“I’m not keeping score,” Fíli says firmly, “All of us are still alive. We have Erebor back, and you are… back to normal. Aren’t you?”
“Yes,” Thorin says roughly, because it is easier than explaining that he will never be back to normal again. That he may always be tempted by the gold, always pulled to lock himself away with it, to take his One with him and hide from the horrors of the world. He may always long to pluck the Arkenstone up off the ground and cradle it close to his chest.
“If we’re done swearing fealty,” Dwalin makes his eavesdropping apparent, “And figuring out that the fellow with the crown on his head is the king—“
“I’m not wearing a crown.” The words bubble to Thorin’s lips before he can stop them.
Dwalin rolls his eyes and flicks at the king’s braid in Thorin’s hair. It is the sort of gesture that a brother would make, something too intimate for any but the closest of kin. Dwalin will not say that he loves Thorin, will never put voice to the terror he must have felt during the battle, watching what he believed to be his king’s last moments. He will never speak of what transpired in the treasury, will never say that he forgives Thorin, will never ask the king to beg for absolution. No. With a single motion of his fingers, Dwalin makes it clear that everything is as it was.
And then he speaks. “If you’re finished taking a blunt axe to the line of succession—“
“Fíli will make a great king.” This much, Thorin knows for certain. “And he would have done today.”
“You are blind, still, Uncle,” Fíli laughs, having risen to his feet while Thorin was distracted. “If you truly believe that. Must I swear fealty again?”
“Please, no.” Thorin doesn’t think he can take that. He is suddenly very tired, and though he would never admit it, his wounded arm stings more now that there is no combat to distract him. The handkerchief tied around it has become sodden with blood, and Thorin would very much like to get Kíli and Bilbo to a serious healer. He still does not trust the Elves.
“Let’s collect our wounded and go home, then,” Fíli decides, “Though Kíli seems to have glued himself to his Elf maiden. And… the Elven prince? Mahal below, that’ll be a lot to sort out, won’t it?”
“Do not remind me.” That is a mess that Thorin is not prepared to start cleaning up. One Elf lingering around his sister-son was bad enough. It brings him no joy to see Kíli sandwiched between two of them.
“You’re courting a Hobbit,” Fíli points out.
“Bilbo is not an Elf.”
“He’s elf-adjacent,” Fíli teases, “Pointy ears. I do love him, but it’s true.”
Thorin growls. “If you call my intended Elf-adjacent ever again, I will make Dáin my heir and have done with it.”
“And I will help him plan your funeral when Mum murders you,” Fíli assures him with a pat on the shoulder. “You should go to Master Baggins now, before he tries to walk back to Erebor on his own. I’ll deal with Kíli.”
That, Thorin realizes, is a very good point. “If ever you would like to be King—“
“Oh, for the Maker’s sake,” Dwalin grumbles. “Our burglar’s getting up now, and if you don’t stop him from trying to make the trek on his own with all those bruises, I’ll go do it myself.”
That, as it happens, is enough to get Thorin moving in the right direction.
Unfortunately, Bilbo is not able to convince Thorin to let him walk back to Erebor. Fortunately, the poor Hobbit is so exhausted by the battle and the nerves and everything else that he somehow manages to fall asleep in the arms of his intended while crossing a battlefield. He wakes just as they reach Erebor’s gates. “Not a word,” Bilbo hisses.
“Of course not.” Thorin looks amused, but does not tease Bilbo.
“Where are you taking me?” This is the first serious question that occurs to Bilbo. Obviously, Thorin is bringing him somewhere specific, but Bilbo has no clue where that might be.
“The infirmary.” After a slight pause, the king adds, “Do not argue.”
“Argue? Why would I argue?” Bilbo asks sweetly, enjoying Thorin’s pleased expression. He’d like to make his king smile like that much more in the future. Every day, if possible. Because they have plenty of days left to them now, Bilbo realizes. The battle is over, and Thorin yet lives. And their nephews, too! What Bilbo set out to do has been done, and now he can enjoy a long and peaceful life with Thorin. “You need to have your arm seen to, after all.”
“My arm is not a concern,” Thorin alleges, “You have been bruised and battered by a foe six times your size.”
“Four times,” Bilbo argues, though Thorin is probably right. “Anyway, I expect we’ll all be spending a lot of our time in the infirmary from here on out. Tauriel says Kíli broke his foot.”
“How did he manage that?” Thorin asks. Probably, he would rub his temples, were he not carrying Bilbo in his arms.
“No idea,” Bilbo replies, “But you and he can keep one another company while you recover from your wounds. And it seems Legolas will be there, too, with that nasty stab wound. I don’t know how much Tauriel could do for him. I still don’t understand that Elven healing magic, to tell you the truth. Someday, I do expect you to tell me every detail of what it was like to watch the process.” Bilbo considers this for a moment. “And then after you’ve spouted your anti-Elven propaganda, I’ll consult with Fíli and Bifur and find out what it was actually like.”
“I am not wounded,” Thorin lies. He still very clearly does not want to address whatever situation is occurring between Kíli and Tauriel, especially not now that Legolas seems to have involved himself as well. Still, there are other matters to attend to. Bilbo can’t wait to see the look on Thorin’s face when Óin tells him that he is, in fact, injured. “You are.”
In the end, the healer makes it clear enough that Thorin and Bilbo are both wounded, although, annoyingly, Thorin is allowed to leave the infirmary after a salve is administered and a proper bandage is applied. Not that he does leave, however. Thorin spends the next two days in the infirmary, pacing between the bedside of his nephew and that of his intended.
Bilbo recovers quickly from the Battle of the Five Armies. Perhaps this is because he barely had anything to recover from in the first place. Yes, he was knocked around a bit, but it wasn’t half so bad as the blow to the head that he look the last time. Really, once Óin has verified that Bilbo’s bruising is limited to a few nasty purple patches on his back and belly and does not extend to any internal organs (nothing short of a miracle, that, but then again, he was wearing mithril armor), he is cleared to leave the infirmary as well.
But Óin had to know when he gave the order that this was never actually going to happen.Bilbo stays until Kíli is permitted to start hobbling around on crutches, which seems a very quick thing to Bilbo but is obviously an excruciating interval for the typically active lad. Fíli and Thorin are generally present in the infirmary as well, as anybody would expect, and the days pass quickly between the four of them and the other members of their company, who all visit regularly.
Tauriel is another constant fixture, and though she sometimes lingers by Legolas’s bedside, as soon as the Elven Prince’s safety is secured, the Captain seems to spend progressively more of her time with Kíli. Thorin, for his part, does not lash out physically, and he waits until his nephew is sleeping to throw the worst accusations at Tauriel. This shows great improvement, though it is clear that the Elf struggles to be patient with him.
There is a party in the throne room when Kíli is released. “Oh, how lovely,” Bilbo exclaims upon entry, marveling at the redecoration that has taken place since the battle.
There is no gold whatsoever in this room, and the Arkenstone is nowhere to be found. He does not ask Fíli what happened to the gem, though he suspects that the prince is responsible for its disposal. Thorin made it clear that the stone was Fíli’s to do with what he would, and Bilbo honestly wouldn’t be surprised to learn that the lad had taken it outside the Mountain and blasted it to bits with explosives used for clearing mines. If, indeed, that would have any impact on the Arkenstone, which is harder than diamonds and cursed with some sick magic. Honestly, though, Bilbo has no desire to know any more than he already does. He’d be perfectly content to put the Arkenstone out of his mind altogether.
There is wine and ale aplenty, and a fair amount of food, compared to what they have been eating. Legolas leans against a wall near that particular table, looking pleased with himself indeed. His battle wounds have healed up nicely, and though he has not yet been permitted to embark upon the journey back to Mirkwood, that announcement is almost certainly in the making. It’s not difficult to put two and two together and conclude that the Elves had a hand in this feast, though they could’ve sent over more meat and fewer greens. Thranduil is in attendance as well, unfortunately, as is Bard, who looks about as comfortable with the festivities as Bilbo feels.
It was not easy to avoid thinking of the ring in the infirmary. First, Bilbo was focused on Thorin’s injured arm, which healed at an impressive speed, but he also dwelt on the possibility that the ring might wake at any time and taunt him further. Then, he was concerned with his own recovery, which by all accounts went swimmingly, all the while pondering the route of his upcoming journey to Mount Doom. For the next several days, Bilbo busied himself with helping Kíli, which was an all-consuming task, particularly when the novelty of being waited on wore off and the lad started itching for something more stimulating than staring at a wall. Bilbo told him stories, read him poetry, and snapped at him when he attempted to sneak out of bed and put weight on his wounded foot. And he tried to convince himself that no harrowing journey would be necessary after all, that the ring may no longer be a danger in its present state, half-destroyed as it is.
But now? Now, with Thorin steering him around by the arm, and hundreds of pairs of eyes staring at them with varying degrees of curiosity and mirth, with people thrusting goblets of wine (no, thank you), legs of mutton (not right now, if you don’t mind) and lovely little cakes (oh, yes, please) into Bilbo’s hands, he can think of nothing else.
Bilbo’s quest is not over. He has only completed the first four steps of his initial plan. The ring is still very much intact, and though it seems much weaker than it was before its encounter with dragon fire, the fact remains that it is still a danger. From Sam’s description, when the ring was destroyed in Mount Doom, it disintegrated shortly after poor Gollum did, and then the fire mountain began to bubble, and Frodo needed to be dragged away, and they nearly didn’t make it, and… No. Not thinking about that now, because it isn’t going to happen. Because Bilbo is going to destroy the ring before Frodo is even born, to ensure that such a burden, even in a weakened form, never passes to his beloved nephew.
He will not see Frodo suffer. He will take that all away, he will fix it, he will make things better. He will reshape the world so that it is ready when Frodo comes into it, so that the lad never knows hardship. So that he never knows war. So that he never feels the need to leave Middle Earth before his time, so that he is happy in Bag End for all his life. Bilbo will give Frodo that simplicity, will take on the boy’s burden and bear it gladly, as he should have done the first time. If Bilbo’s life is the price for this, then so be it. He has saved Thorin and Fíli and Kíli, and now, he must do what he can for little Frodo, who is a son to him in all but blood.
“You do not look happy, ghivashel,” Thorin observes in a low tone that nearly sends Bilbo’s scattered thoughts careening in a more pleasant but much less seemly direction. Nearly.
Bilbo considers lying to him. It would be easy enough to let Thorin have this night, this first evening of the rest of his reign. To allow the king to visit with his subjects and celebrate his nephew’s fine recovery. There have been festivities every night since the battle ended, with Dáin’s folk filling the halls of Erebor and making merry over feasts of barley meal and enough ale to make the poor and scant food feel fair and plenty. Thorin has missed all of these fretting over Bilbo and Kíli. Would it not be kind to let him enjoy himself?
No, it wouldn’t. It would be very cruel indeed to keep something of such magnitude from Thorin. He could not have said anything on the journey, of course. Bilbo was resolved to keep Thorin safe, to get him to Erebor, at the very least, and begin changing things from there. If he’d explained it all at the start, nobody would have believed him. If he’d waited until he’d gained the company’s trust, if he actually managed to convince Thorin that he was telling the truth, then he would have changed things irreparably. Thorin may have found a novel and creative way to get himself killed. Better to let him act as Bilbo expected him to and to take advantage of his foreknowledge to set things right.
But Bilbo cannot explain about the ring without explaining about his time travel. The story would not make any sense without a description of Frodo’s actions at Mount Doom, the context of Sam’s devotion and the Fellowship’s meddling. His knowledge would seem too expansive, and Thorin would be able to tell that Bilbo was keeping something from him. And besides, hasn’t Bilbo been saying this whole time that he refuses to build a relationship upon a foundation of lies? He must tell Thorin the truth. Nothing else will suffice.
Thorin will not take this story well. He will stew in it and ruminate, even now that it is done with. He will obsess over how easily his madness could’ve induced him to harm Bilbo, if he is not doing so already. He will have to contend with his own mortality, how close he came to dying. And that is not to mention the betrayal of knowing that all this time, Bilbo has kept something so monumental from Thorin. Bilbo has had foreknowledge and used it to his own advantage, in terms of the quest, yes, but also in a personal context. He lied to Thorin, and not exclusively during the dragon sickness, either.
They have been given a second chance, and Bilbo will do everything in his power to protect it. It’s new for him, having someone he can confide in, can truly be himself around. After his last adventure, Bilbo returned to Hobbiton and endured years of isolation before Frodo came into his care. Then, he cherished his role as uncle and surrogate father. But that was not comparable to having a partner, an equal for whom he was not responsible, to whom he could show his heart of hearts.
At the moment, Bilbo’s heart is heavy, and Thorin deserves to know why. Some awful, selfish part of Bilbo would avoid this altogether, would sneak off to Mordor with the ring on his finger and pray to come back and talk things over later, if at all. He could take care of it himself or die trying, and he would never have to witness Thorin’s grief in the later case. But Bilbo is really not so terrible as all that.
“Can we talk?” He asks in a strangled voice.
Thorin seems alarmed by this. “Of course. We’ll go to our chambers.”
Our chambers, so easy, just like that. Something Bilbo never could have dreamed of, not in his wildest imaginings, not even when he and Thorin were together for the first time. Maybe they would have a warm friendship, maybe Bilbo would be able to admire the king from a very close distance, but to share chambers, to share a bed? He would not have allowed himself the fantasy. And now the reality is his.
Thorin leads him through the halls of Erebor to what is ostensibly the Royal Wing. Bilbo has never been here. He did not stay with Dáin and his family on his last visit to the Lonely Mountain, not wanting to impose. And of course, this time around, Bilbo and Thorin have spent the days since the battle staying in chambers close to the infirmary, much to Kíli’s horror. He made it perfectly clear that he did not need them hovering, but Thorin insisted upon chaperoning all of the lad’s interactions with Tauriel, and Bilbo insisted upon chaperoning Thorin’s chaperoning to ensure that no blood was spilled.
The room to which Thorin eventually brings Bilbo is modest, not what one would expect from the bedroom of a king. It is certainly large, but it’s clear that the bedclothes have been sitting in a cupboard somewhere for over a century, and the same can be said of the rug. It has been dusted and swept; the floors and walls have been washed, and the dresser and vanity look well-made. The bedside table has seen better days, however; it will need repainting. There are no adornments whatsoever.
Bilbo looks around, and Thorin shuts the door. “I thought we could bring in some of your things from the Shire, if you want to decorate,” the king explains.
“What about you?” Bilbo knows well enough that Thorin has not truly had a room to call his own since Erebor fell. Yes, he had his quarters in Ered Luin, and Bilbo is certain they were very nice, but he knows his intended well. Thorin would not have decorated, would not have indulged at all in the maintenance of a space that he’d have seen as temporary at best, for the same reason that he insisted on shearing his beard short and refusing the braids that would have been culturally appropriate for a king. “You are the king, and these are the king’s chambers. Surely we should decorate them to suit your tastes as much as mine.”
Thorin has spent more than a century depriving himself, and Bilbo intends to change that. The king sighs, sitting down on the edge of the great bed. “Perhaps you and Fíli might go down to the vaults later. You could surprise me with whatever you think I might like.” He doesn’t say that he is terrified to go down there himself, that he is terrified to let any set foot in the treasury but those who have proven already beyond a shadow of a doubt that they are not affected by the dragon’s curse. He doesn’t need to say it.
No matter how many times Bilbo and the lads reassure Thorin that they have no way to know what he’d have done if his and Fíli’s positions were reversed, Thorin maintains that he could never be as strong as his heir, could never relinquish the Arkenstone willingly, even to save the life of another. He has insisted since Ravenhill that Fíli is uniquely suited to the throne for this very reason, his ability to prioritize his family and the well-being of his kingdom over any treasure that said kingdom might contain.
This, in Bilbo’s opinion, is hogwash. According to Óin, many traits that run in families are not passed intuitively from parent to child, and it is difficult to trace the patterns of inheritance associated with mental instability. Fíli’s apparent resistance to dragon sickness may come from his father. Or, it may very well be something that he shares with Thorin. After all, the king was able to pull himself out of his illness eventually, unlike his grandfather. And there is no telling how Fíli might have reacted had he not seen Thorin’s madness before laying hands upon the Arkenstone. It is not a matter of strength or weakness but rather a combination of circumstances.
Bilbo wants to comfort Thorin, to assure him that the gold sickness will not come back. But in truth, he doesn’t know that. Perhaps the illness will return. Perhaps it will be an uphill battle for Thorin his entire life, and he will truly have to avoid the treasury for as long as he lives. At least he does live. That is better than Bilbo could have asked for a year ago, well and truly beyond his wildest dreams. And he knows that he is stalling, avoiding a conversation that he doesn’t know how to have. He grabs Thorin’s hand, seeking strength and comfort as much as he offers it.
“Will you not tell me what is the problem, ghivashel?”
“Thorin,” Bilbo begins. “I—“ Well, that won’t do. “Have you perhaps noticed…” Oh, bloody brilliant, Mister Baggins. Really great start to the story. The Old Took would be very proud indeed of his floundering grandson. You spent eighty years telling this tale, and yet you clam up now? “Well. Throughout the journey—“
“Do you not wish to marry me after all?” Thorin blurts out, stopping Bilbo short.
“What?”
“Is that what is so difficult for you to say? Because if it is, of course, I understand. When you accepted my gift, I was… I had already threatened you.” The words pour out of Thorin. It becomes painfully clear that he was just as distracted by these thoughts as Bilbo has been by his own. “I was not in my right mind. You would not have been misguided if you’d agreed only to… placate me. I did not even explain things to you. My behavior was shameful.”
“You already apologized for all that,” Bilbo waves him off. “And if I recall, I accepted your apology the first time.”
“I threatened you, and my own sister-son as well.”
“You didn’t hurt either of us. You can hardly blame yourself for things you didn’t do.”
“I would have.” Thorin seems very sure of this, indeed. “I would have.”
“But you did not,” Bilbo shakes his head. “You cannot hold yourself accountable for thoughts you never followed through on. I know you’re already torturing yourself about the things you actually did, Thorin. Please don’t add in made-up nonsense to feel guilty about as well. Fíli and I have both already forgiven you several times! Of course I want to be with you! If I didn’t, I never would have said yes, whether or not you were ill. You see, Thorin, I respect you a great deal, and I would never patronize you with a false acceptance of courtship, even if I thought that it would anger you. I accepted your gift because I love you, and that is that. If you’re going to doubt my feelings or accuse me of lying—“
“I would never,” Thorin breathes.
Bilbo shoots him an incredulous look. “And what, exactly, do you think you’re doing right now? Asking if I no longer wish to marry you! Do you really think me so fickle as that? I won’t hear it. If we’re to spend our lives together, then you must trust me when I tell you that I love you very much.”
“Alright.” Thorin does not sound entirely convinced, but he is clearly making an effort to trust Bilbo. This is a major feat, Bilbo knows, when Thorin cannot even trust himself. “But if that is true, then what is bothering you? Why can you not look me in the eyes?”
Bilbo sighs. He has to say this sooner or later. His relationship with Thorin cannot progress on a foundation of misapprehension, especially not after the speech Bilbo just delivered about the importance of trust. “Have you noticed,” he begins, “That over the course of our journey, I have always seemed to be a step ahead? To have a plan, to know what was coming? As though I had foreknowledge.”
“Yes.” Thorin does not hesitate, nor does he elaborate.
“Right, then.” This may be easier than Bilbo thought. At least he will not have to give examples or provide proof. “That’s because I’ve done this all before.”
“I do not understand.” Thorin studies Bilbo with narrowed eyes, as though he is a complicated piece of metalwork. “What have you done before?”
“This entire adventure.” Bilbo swallows. “From the very beginning to the very end. I lived it one time already. This is my second go.”
“And that is how you knew who I was when I arrived at your home,” Thorin breathes. “That is how you knew the bowman’s name before we spoke to him. How you seemed prepared each time it rained. That is why you treated my sister-sons as kin, even at the start.”
“It is.” At least Thorin understands.
“I still do not understand.” Never mind. “Why would endure so much suffering a second time? We have our Mountain back. You are here, and you are safe. Why would you feel the need to do it again?”
Naturally, there is one clear explanation, the only true one, and probably one that Thorin does not want to hear. He must know, of course. He is not stupid. He must be hoping that Bilbo will tell him that he does not know why he had to do his adventure over, that it was just some magical accident, that he had no choice and no reason but necessity to embark upon such a massive undertaking.
But Bilbo cannot give him the comfort of that story. He is sick and tired of making up lies, of telling tales much smaller and simpler and sweeter than the ones he’s carried coiled up inside his guts for eighty years. So he tells the truth.
“The first time,” Bilbo grips Thorin’s hand tightly, “The battle did not end so well.”
“What happened?”
There is no other way to say this. “You died.” Once those words come, the others fly out unbridled. “You died in my arms, Thorin. I… well, after you killed Azog, that is, I found you, and we spoke a little, we forgave each other, but then y—“
“Forgave each other,” Thorin echoes slowly, cutting Bilbo off mid-word, “What did we have to forgive each other for, ghivashel?”
Bilbo bites his lip. He doesn’t want to get into this whole Arkenstone business. “The first time, I stole the Arkenstone and gave it to the Lake-Men. I thought that if they had it, you would give them the gold they wanted and just… I thought that I could prevent a war, if only… if only you would have seen reason.”
“But I would not have seen reason.” This, Thorin knows to the core of his being. It is all over his face.
“You were furious.” That’s an understatement.
“I can imagine.” Thorin does not elaborate, does not tell Bilbo what he is imagining. Does not compare it to whatever thoughts must have raced through his head during the worst of the dragon sickness. It must be as painful for him to have this discussion as it is for Bilbo, and he does not even know what is coming. “Did I hurt you?”
Bilbo sucks in a breath and settles on the best answer he can muster. “You did not hurt me, no. This was a completely different world, as far as I’m concerned, and I refuse to allow you to hold yourself accountable for actions that you would have taken under different circumstances. We just had this conversation, Thorin, I—“
“How?”
Bilbo closes his eyes. “Does it matter?”
“Yes. How did I hurt you, in this other world of yours?”
Thorin wants to know. He is asking, and it would be unfair of Bilbo to withhold the information, wouldn’t it? Even though he knows that Thorin will only use the knowledge to torture himself, Bilbo cannot carry this secret around for the rest of his life. Someone has to know, and it would be far worse to tell somebody other than Thorin and guard the knowledge from the king.
“You first commanded the company to kill me, but they all refused.”
“As they should have.”
“Then, you tried to force Fíli in particular to do it, but he would not.” This is the easy part. Let Thorin be proud of his sister-son.
Bilbo cannot see Thorin with his eyes closed as they are, but he can hear the king’s slow, steadying inhale. “Of course he wouldn’t.”
“Then,” Bilbo pauses for a moment, trying to find the best way to describe this. “You attempted to… take matters into your own hands.”
“I tried to murder you?” Thorin’s voice sounds gutted, hollow. “My own intended?”
“No, Thorin, no,” Bilbo has to put a stop to this. “We were not… listen. Please listen. I was rude to you for most of the trip. I constantly pushed you away, and every time you were a little cold to me, I took it as evidence that… that you hated me, I don’t know. And I didn’t try to… to push through or anything, I just went along with it, and… and even on the Carrock, I thought… I thought that we would never be anything more than friends, so…” Bilbo trails off. He does not know why he is making excuses for Thorin’s behavior on the first adventure.
Perhaps because it does not seem fair that the matter should be drudged up again when it was already put to rest. Bilbo would not be pursuing a romantic relationship with Thorin now if he truly believed that the king would harm him when in his right mind, or if he truly believed that Thorin would fall once more to dragon sickness. In another world, the version of Thorin who threatened Bilbo’s life apologized for it, and Bilbo forgave him. Now, the present version of Thorin, who did nothing so horrible as all that, has taken it upon himself to feel guilty for things never even had a hand in.
“But that does not matter,” Thorin reasons, “I put my hands on the one that I love. You would be entitled to cast me out of Erebor, to cut off my braids and send me away in shame. How could you have forgiven me for something like that?”
“Once again,” Bilbo says sharply, “It wasn’t you. You were not there. And even… the other Thorin, I suppose, the one on my first timeline, he… the dragon sickness. I gave away the Arkenstone. I betrayed the person I loved. We were both at fault.”
“No. Nothing could justify that.” Thorin is silent for a moment before he asks. “Surely the company would have acted. I was not fit to rule. The throne should have passed to Fíli.”
“That’s not what happened, I’m afraid.” Bilbo will have to give more details than he already has, more details than he has any interest in giving. “They were shocked, I think. You must remember that I had stolen the Arkenstone and given it to an Elf. Perhaps they didn’t want me thrown over the battlements, but I’m sure some of them were perfectly comfortable with my being exiled. Gandalf put a stop to things, of course, but naturally, I was banished. He took me to Dale. The Elves, Legolas and Tauriel, that is, came and told us about the Gundabad orcs, and I’d seen you climbing Ravenhill, so… of course, I went to you. And I found you, I spoke to you, but you charged off to…” Bilbo decides to omit the relevant details in the middle. He will not make Thorin carry the weight of his sister-sons’ lives, not when all of it happened in another world. “You charged off to challenge Azog, and Dwalin and I were left with… well, with hundreds of orcs, really, and one of them knocked me out, and when I woke up, I followed you, and I found you, and as I said, we forgave each other, and then…”
“Ah.” Thorin is silent for another long moment. “What was Fíli like as king, then?”
Bilbo squeezes his eyes as tight as they will go. Of course Thorin would ask that. Of course he would want to know. Of course he would not conceive of the horrors that Bilbo witnessed, the awful memories that he and Dwalin would carry in silence for decades on end. But all that Bilbo can manage by way of explanation is a single word. “Dáin,” he says, choked and awful.
Thorin seems to understand because he sobs aloud, then, and Bilbo cannot bear this any longer. He opens his eyes and throws his arms around his king, his love, his intended. They both weep, and neither seems very much for words at the moment. For so long, Bilbo has been alone in his grief. His horrible, terrible grief. He was alone in the loss of his family, the only Hobbit in the Lonely Mountain until he went back to the Shire. And there he wrote a silly little story, told the tale wrong so many times that he could nearly convince himself of the plot that he constructed.
In Bilbo’s book, Thorin did not die upon Ravenhill. He was seen to by healers, laid upon furs in the most comfortable tent that could be had, as he would have deserved. He was surrounded by loved ones, and he was at peace. In Bilbo’s book, Fíli and Kíli were killed as an afterthought, painlessly, with no detail. He pretended not to know, when faunts asked him how their favorite characters were slain. He pretended to have been unconscious for it all, and that became his truth.
He has never told a soul. Never mentioned it, not even to the other members of the company. He has never talked it through, not even with Dwalin, who was there for all of it. Bilbo never said a word to Tauriel, only left her sobbing over Kíli. He does not know what happened to her after, does not know whether she lived on in her grief, sailed to the Undying Lands, or perished of sorrow, as some Elves do.
Now, Thorin joins him in his grief. It is not the cool state funeral, with organized chanting and weaving around the stone slabs where the bodies have been placed. Thorin is warm, so warm, so vital, so alive. He is here, and he is breathing, and if Bilbo lets his focus drift a little, he can hear the faint sounds of Kíli’s laughter from the party downstairs. There is a loud clomping sound, and Bilbo imagines that Fíli is marching across yet another table. They have changed, both of them, but some things will remain forever the same.
All three of them live. The knife that has been twisting in Bilbo’s gut for several months now comes free and clatters to the floor, leaving him to bleed out his sorrow in Thorin’s strong arms. It takes a while, but eventually, Thorin is the first to speak again.
“You came back to save my sister-sons,” he concludes, voice quivering. “Somehow, through some Hobbit magic, you returned. You risked everything for my boys. I thank you.“
“For all three of you,” Bilbo nips that in the bud as quickly as he can. “But it was not Hobbit magic.”
“Tell me.”
This is the easy part. “Well, I lived a very long life, and at the end of it, Lady Arwen of Rivendell offered me her place on an Elven ship sailing West, to the Undying lands.”
“What?” That, clearly, was not what Thorin expected at all.
“She was to marry the King of Gondor, a lovely lad called Aragon, a friend of mine, actually,” Bilbo explains. “But, of course, when I arrived to board the ship with my nephew and Gandalf, there was Lady Galadriel. She really cornered me, now that I think about it. She showed me a vision, I suppose, of you and the lads looking healthy, and I… well, you see, I may have misunderstood. I thought I was being sent to join you in Mahal’s realm, which seemed… odd, I have to admit, especially considering that I wasn’t exactly dead yet, mind you, but it made much more sense than what actually did happen, so I don’t suppose anyone with sense could hold it against me for jumping to conclusions.”
Thorin clenches his fists. “The Elf lied to you and tricked you into putting your own life in danger.” Of course that is what he would make of Bilbo’s story.
“No, she didn’t lie!” Bilbo protests, “There was no trickery. I misunderstood. But even had I known the truth, of course I would have come.”
“I do not understand why an Elf would care for the lives of three sons of Durin,” Thorin replies after some consideration. “Though I can easily believe that one would send you back through time for sport.”
“Yes, well,” Bilbo heaves yet another sigh. “I may have come here for another purpose. But that is a very long tale, and a complicated one, and a rather sad one, I’m afraid.”
“I will hear it.” Thorin sets his jaw the way he always does when he looks forward to getting his way. And he is right, of course. Thorin needs to know. He asked what was bothering Bilbo, and he will hear of it soon.
“You remember the tale of the Rings of Power,” Bilbo begins. Thorin merely nods, entreating him to continue.
And continue Bilbo does. He recounts the entire tale of the War of the Ring, beginning to end, adding Gollum in for context, and concluding with the damage that was done to Frodo even after the ring was destroyed. For another long moment, Thorin is silent.
Then, he brings his free hand, the one not locked in Bilbo’s iron grip, to his temple. “You knew that you carried the One Ring,” Thorin recounts, “And yet you put it on your finger multiple times. You wore it for several days in the Elven prisons. You understood, and yet you put yourself at risk.”
“I had no other choice!” Bilbo protests, “I didn’t want to change anything too much, and I knew it wouldn’t hurt me, because it didn’t the first time. I had to get the company to Erebor, and frankly, I don’t think I could’ve done it at all without ever going invisible!” But does Bilbo truly not think this? Or has the ring convinced him of it over the years, warped his mind into believing that he is incapable of acting on his own, powerless unless that awful little bauble deigns to grant him some of its power?
“It sounds as though it hurt you very much the first time.”
“Alright, yes, fine, but not during the adventure. And if I’d done anything differently, we may not have gotten to Erebor, and then what would have happened?” Bilbo asks. “If I hadn’t worn the ring, we would both be in Thranduil’s dungeons right now.”
“You should have stayed in Bag End and left me to my fate,” Thorin resolves, stubborn as usual.
“And the boys as well?” Bilbo clinches the argument tightly and neatly. “No. I should not have. None but a Hobbit can carry the ring, as I just explained. And anyway, it’s weakened now. I had Smaug blow on it, to knock it out, you know. I’d hoped it would destroy the thing, but it still seems intact, even if it doesn’t work anymore.”
Thorin exhales heavily. “Yes. It would be. The One Ring can only be destroyed in the fires that forged it. Is this not common knowledge?”
“Perhaps for Dwarven princes it may be,” Bilbo retorts testily. “In case you had forgotten, I was very old when I learned the true nature of the ring, and my mind was not what it once had been. But either way, I have it now, and it must be destroyed. I’m going to speak to Gandalf, and then I’m leaving for Mordor.”
Unsurprisingly, Thorin is not at all pleasedwith Bilbo’s plan. After several hours of emotional argumentation, they eventually arrive at three important conclusions. First, the ring must be destroyed, and the only way to destroy the ring is to return it to the fires whence it was forged, which necessitates lugging the thing to Mordor and tossing it into Mount Doom. Only a Hobbit can be trusted to carry the ring without being irreparably corrupted (though Bilbo doesn’t like to use Thorin’s battle with dragon sickness against him, he does here, at length), and it would be stupid and irresponsible to turn around, march back to the Shire or Bree, and find some other Hobbit to take on the task when Bilbo is already right here. Therefore, Bilbo must be the one to carry the ring to Mordor.
Second, Thorin will accompany Bilbo on his journey, through whatever peril it may lead. That is only fair, considering their bond and the pain that the separation will cause for Thorin. Bilbo, too, dislikes the idea of spending any meaningful amount of time away from Thorin, if only because he truly struggles to believe that his intervention at the battle was successful and the King Under the Mountain is, in fact, alive. Also, Bilbo followed Thorin on his quest, so it’s only fair that Thorin plays a part in Bilbo’s greatest errand. Though Bilbo does not want to put Thorin in danger, the king is stubborn, and he makes sound points. Since neither of them wishes to send the other to Mordor, the best compromise seems to be for both of them to go together.
Third, they must inform the rest of the company. Not about Bilbo’s time travel, not about his decades of grief, and not about the fact that the Lady Galadriel can apparently manipulate the strands of the universe to send Hobbits eighty years into the past. But at the very least, as Thorin’s heir, Fíli will need to be told why he’s being appointed as the regent of Erebor, and he will tell Kíli everything, anyway, so the other prince may as well be included in the discussion.
Of course, the lads will need Balin to guide them and Dwalin to protect them, and as their resident scribe, Ori, too, should be kept in the loop. It would be a shame to let him start writing about their adventures without knowing about the ring and its integral role in the whole business. And Óin should know in advance in case somebody gets hurt and must return to Erebor for emergency medical treatment, though Bilbo can’t help but worry that there will not be an opportunity, where they’re going, for such hasty transportation. That’s half the company already, so they may as well just tell everybody. And obviously, Gandalf must be kept informed.
They elect to tell the Wizard everything first. Thankfully, despite the fact that it is now the middle of the night, Gandalf is wide awake and receiving visitors. At the very least, the opens his chamber doors for them, and does not inquire about their presence here at such a late hour. He says very little as he listens to Bilbo’s tale, though his eyes twinkle with characteristic menace each time Bilbo brings up Aragorn. Probably, Gandalf is already plotting the restoration of the monarchy in Gondor.
“May I see it?” Gandalf asks, once everything is out in the open.
“No,” says Thorin. “Bilbo does not have it with him. Of course it is somewhere safe.”
Bilbo bites his lip. “I think you overestimate me, my love,” he admits, pulling the ring out of his waistcoat pocket and setting it on Gandalf’s desk. Somehow, the surface is already cluttered with paper, though where the Wizard procured all of this, Bilbo does not know. “But I could not leave it be stolen. Even in its weakened state.”
Thorin turns away. “I will not look upon it.”
“That is wise,” Gandalf observes. His fingers hover above the ring, but he does not dare to pick it up. “Does it call to you?”
“Not more than any other piece of gold,” Thorin replies. His voice sounds ragged, but the news makes Bilbo smile.
“That’s good to hear,” the Hobbit reports, “I think it would have done, the way it was before. Most of the journey, it was speaking to me, I suppose, telling me things I knew weren’t true. It tried to convince me that you were going to take it from me, though of course, I knew that was rubbish. You didn’t the first time, after all.”
“It is weakened,” Gandalf confirms, “Greatly weakened. Dragon fire may not be enough to destroy the One, but in conjunction with the blows that we of the White Council have just dealt to its master, I believe its battle with Smaug was enough to dilute the power of the ring, as you say. Though I do not know how you will fare, bringing it to Mordor.”
“That’s to be expected,” Bilbo concedes, reaching out and squeezing Thorin’s hand. True to his word, the king is very pointedly looking away from the apparently harmless bauble on the table. He seems to think himself very weak indeed, very heavily affected by the magic of the ring. He doesn’t know half of what the ring is capable of, or would once have been capable of, or will be capable of should Bilbo fail to destroy it. “We both know the risks. But we must go, Gandalf.”
“Both of you?” The Wizard smiles, though it doesn’t reach his eyes.
“I will not abandon Bilbo to carry such a burden alone,” Thorin replies decisively. “Even if I cannot look upon the ring, I will not leave him to its mercy.”
“I do not like this,” Gandalf admits, “I would rather send another of the company as Bilbo’s escort.”
“I’m sorry, but that’s not your decision.” Bilbo puts the ring back into his pocket. There’s no point leaving it on the table, now that Gandalf has seen it. Its presence is only torturing poor Thorin. “It took enough arguing to get us to this point, and I don’t particularly fancy starting again. Thorin and I are going to Mordor, and that’s final. We wanted to let you know before we met with the rest of the company about it, but we’ve made up our minds.”
“Very well,” Gandalf says gravely. “Assemble the company, then. In the meantime, I will arrange for your transportation.”
Bilbo doesn’t even bother to ask what he is talking about. He has learned enough, over the course of his long life, about dealing with Wizards to understand that such a gesture would be perfectly pointless.
The next evening, the company assembles in the Second Royal Meeting Hall. It’s a very nice room, all things considered. The walls are plated with silver, and there are some lovely stone statues standing in all four corners, depicting famous kings of the Line of Durin, none of whom Bilbo is able to identify on sight. They cannot use the First Royal Meeting Hall because the walls are covered in gold leaf and the throne at the head of the gold-plated table is made of solid gold. Quite gaudy, in Bilbo’s opinion, but he supposes that Thrór might have thought the same of Bilbo’s own home, had he ever gotten the chance to visit Bag End. When Bilbo and Thorin enter the room (hand in hand, as they always are, nowadays), they walk into a heated discussion about battle names.
It makes sense. After all, Fíli and Kíli both fought valiantly during the Battle of the Five Armies, and they did take down Azog the Defiler. They have more than earned the traditional privilege. It simply has never occurred to Bilbo before that perhaps not every act of heroism lends itself to name so intuitive and powerful as Oakenshield.
“Hush and listen to what I’ve got so far,” Ori orders, consulting a leaf of paper on the table in front of him. “Fíli of the Arkenstone.”
“No,” Fíli shakes his head, “Absolutely not.”
“Fíli Gem-wielder,” Ori suggests.
The crown prince cringes. “That’s not much better. Can’t I just be… Stone-thrower?”
Kíli laughs at that. “That does have a nice ring to it, brother. Imagine this: King Fíli the First, Rock-hurler.”
Fíli shoves his brother in the side. Apparently, Kíli has now recovered enough for roughhousing, which must be wonderful news indeed for the young prince. “I’m not taking suggestions from you, Kíli Dropped-sword.”
It seems that the brothers have recovered from the horror of battle enough to mock one another for their admittedly unconventional orc-slaying methods. Bilbo supposes that this is a positive development, all things considered.
Thorin seems to disagree. He pinches the bridge of his nose and closes his eyes. “I patiently await the day that Dís arrives to deal with her sons.”
Bilbo is so fond of his new family that he can hardly contain himself. How the Valar have blessed him, allowing him a chance to keep everyone alive. Even if their quest is unsuccessful, at least Bilbo can take comfort in the knowledge that the lads are safe. He may not be able to shake Thorin as he undertakes his perilous mission, but Fíli and Kíli will stay in Erebor, where they will live long and happy lives.
“Alright, enough of this!” Bilbo takes the list from Ori and searches for appellations which are to his liking and suitable for the boys. He knows that this discussion could go on forever if the princes are expected to select their own titles. “Fíli Mountainheart and…Kíli Elfblade. We called this meeting for a reason, you know, and it’s very rude to ignore your hosts. Not to mention your king.”
Bofur elbows Dwalin in the ribs. “You’re going to be out of a job soon, now that Thorin’s using Bilbo for an enforcer.”
Dwalin grunts. “I don’t mind the thought of retiring.” Balin snorts at this, aware as everyone else is of the blatant untruth in his brother’s words, but does not intervene.
“I like those,” Kíli gives his verdict on the titles. “Although I still think Rock-hurler is better.”
“Did Bilbo not just say ‘enough?’” Thorin demands. He does not dispute the Elfblade title for Kíli, which feels like a significant win. “You will heed him or you will be sent from this room and back to the infirmary.”
“Now, that hardly seems fair,” Óin grumbles. The poor healer has been dealing with Kíli’s restlessness for some time and has just gotten free of the incessant pestering. “Can’t you send him somewhere else?”
“I’d be happy to go on a diplomatic expedition to the Woodland Realm,” Kíli suggests, grinning broadly.
“Yeah, you would be,” Nori grins and shoves Kíli so hard that the lad nearly falls out of his chair.
“You be careful with the prince,” Bilbo orders, “He has a broken foot, in case you had forgotten.”
Kíli rolls his eyes. “Óin said it wasn’t broken anymore.”
“I did not,” Óin counters. Wisely, he’s had his trumpet close to his ear this entire time. “I said you could put a little weight on it without making the damage any worse. But if I catch you trying to run again before I give the word, Mahal help me, you won’t see a thing outside of my infirmary until your beard reaches your knees!”
“You’re not helping,” Kíli grumbles.
“Please let Bilbo speak,” Dori orders, having taken notice of the conversation between the Burglar and the king. “I wonder if this isn’t very important.”
“It is.” Bilbo offers him a grateful nod. “I don’t exactly know where to begin, so I guess I should just come out and say it. The Wizard should be here any minute, and he knows the story better than I do, mind, but…” Bilbo exhales heavily. “You may recall that I was briefly separated from the group in the goblin tunnels during our adventure.”
“Yes, but you turned invisible and got away,” Nori recounts.
“And then you sneaked past my lookout,” Balin smiles at Bilbo, “The first creature ever to do it, too.”
“Yes, well.” Bilbo can’t return the smile. “As it happens, I can’t turn invisible on my own, which you would’ve known already, if you knew anything about Hobbits. In fact, I’m gobsmacked that any of you believed that in the first place. But, regardless. In the goblin tunnels, I picked up a magic ring, which at the time I believed to be nothing more than a helpful, shiny bauble. But I’ve come to understand that it’s a bit more than that.”
“Bilbo has a Ring of Power in his possession,” Thorin explains. “He has carried it this far and tricked Smaug into breathing fire onto it.”
“As he should’ve done!” Glóin cheers. “That’d be the only way to destroy it.”
“But Thorin says Bilbo still has it,” Ori points out.
The color drains from Bofur’s face. “You can’t mean…”
“No.” Bombur shakes his head in utter disbelief. “Bilbo doesn’t have… he couldn’t have The One. That thing tears people up inside, doesn’t it? Makes them go insane. But Bilbo’s as stable as they come.”
“True,” Balin agrees, “He was the only one of us quick enough to think of any kind of plan when….” But he trails off, not wanting to refer to Thorin’s dragon sickness. Out of politeness, Bilbo neglects to mention that Fíli, Kíli, and Nori each came up with plans as well, though admittedly, enacting any of them would have resulted in an unprecedented disaster.
“Bofur is right,” Thorin explains, grabbing Bilbo’s hand under the table. “Bilbo has the One Ring in his possession.”
“It was not destroyed by Smaug,” Bilbo explains, “Though Gandalf and I can agree that it was weakened. It no longer grants me any invisibility, even when I put it on, and it no longer speaks to me as it once did. Thorin says that it calls to him no more than any other piece of gold. I trust that none of you can hear its voice now?”
“I wasn’t aware that a ring could have a voice,” Bofur is gripping the edge of the table with white knuckles. “But then, all the things that ring can do, why wouldn’t it be able to talk as well?”
Bifur says something in Khuzdul, and Bombur nods. “Amad told that story often, and she never mentioned the ring having a voice. But then, how would she know?”
“So, you have the One Ring in your waistcoat pocket,” Dwalin summarizes the situation with his typical bluntness. “What next?”
“Right.” Bilbo is truly grateful for the assistance with staying on track. “Well. Thorin and I are going to take the ring to Mordor, where we will destroy it in the fires of Mount Doom.”
“Have you lost your minds?” Glóin demands. “The King Under the Mountain can’t just march into Mordor!”
“It’s the only way,” Bilbo retorts smoothly. “I wanted to go alone, but you can imagine how well that went over.”
“Aye,” Óin nods. “I suppose Thorin threatened to lock you in his chambers while he went in your stead.”
“Yes, that’s exactly what happened,” Bilbo agrees, “Though he apologized after.”
“I still do not wish you to go,” Thorin admits, “I would find another Hobbit, if it is indeed true that none but a Hobbit can bear the ring.”
“None but a Hobbit?” Ori echoes, flipping the list of names over and taking up his pen.
“That is what the Wizard says,” Thorin explains, “Any other creature would easily become corrupted by its influence.”
“But that was before Bilbo weakened it,” Kíli points out, “He threw it into dragon fire, didn’t he? How are we to know whether the rule about Hobbits is still true?”
“It’s certainly weaker now than it was when I picked it up,” Bilbo confirms, “And it might be that the ring is no longer strong enough to have that sort of pull on any creature. But I’d rather not take the risk. It’s not nice to think about, but Thorin is very powerful indeed even when… well, even when he’s in his right mind. I don’t need to tell any of you about what happened with the dragon sickness, and forgive me, but I’d rather not let my intended take that kind of risk, simply for his own sake, if not for the sake of Middle Earth.”
“But if that’s the case, does anyone need to go at all?” Fíli asks. “The ring is already weak, and the one who made it isn’t a serious threat. Why risk a journey into Mordor?”
“Because it may yet grow stronger over time,” Bilbo points out, “In fact, I don’t see any way around that. We’re lucky right now. The enemy has been driven back a bit, and we’ve taken care of a good chunk of his forces. This is the best time to mount an attack, with the ring in its current state. I’d hate to wait for it to get worse and try to deal with it then.”
“You know more than you’re letting on,” Nori observes. “Last I heard, Sauron was destroyed centuries ago.”
“Yes,” Thorin admits, “But we will not tell you any more. It is dangerous enough sharing as much as we have.”
“We trust all of you,” Bilbo explains. “But we would not put any of you in unnecessary peril by telling you more than you need to know.”
The door to the meeting room opens, admitting Gandalf. The Wizard does not sit down but lingers in the doorway.
“Then you should let someone go with you,” Ori suggests. “Thorin is a great warrior, but only two of you against all the orcs of Mordor?”
“Fíli and I killed Azog the Defiler,” Kíli recounts, “We could be of some help to you, I’m sure.”
“You are still wounded, brother,” Fíli points out gently, “But I will go.”
“You most certainly will not!” Bilbo yelps. “There’s a fair chance we may all die on this journey, you know, even with the ring as weak as it is. As I’m sure you know, there are still the orcs to deal with. If I could talk Thorin out of it, I would.”
“But you cannot, ghivashel, any more than I can talk you out of it,” Thorin assures Bilbo.
“Yes, well, be that as it may,” Bilbo tries not to be affected by the pet name at this juncture. “The fact stands that we’re going, and you are all staying, and now you all know.”
“But you really shouldn’t go alone,” Kíli protests.
“They won’t take your brother when he’s hale enough,” Glóin reminds him, “They’re not going to bring you and your broken foot. You’ll hinder more than you’ll help, I’d say.”
“No, I’m not talking about me,” Kíli shakes his head. “I just don’t think Bilbo and Thorin should try to do this alone. They should bring an Elf—“
“You would think that,” Nori mutters teasingly.
“Come on, Nori, think of another joke,” Fíli quips, flying to his brother’s defense. “We’ve heard that one before.”
Nori only shrugs. “It’ll stay funny as long as he’s mooning over one of Thranduil’s guards.”
“No, listen, I’m serious!” Kíli continues, “They should bring an Elf and a Man as well. Isn’t it better to have the whole set? We’ve just learned there’s a lot that Hobbits can do but we can’t. Bilbo has to be the one to bear the ring, and Thorin can protect him better than anyone. But Elves have good eyes and better aim, and Men must have good qualities, too. Do you know if Beorn is available?”
“I am not dragging Beorn to Mordor,” Bilbo puts his foot down. “He has too many responsibilities to the animals under his care, and he’s a good ally to have on the Borders of Mirkwood. Besides, he’s a peaceful sort. It was bad enough we led him into one battle; I’ll not bring him to another one.”
“Ah. More wisdom from General Baggins,” Balin observes. Bilbo truly hopes that nickname doesn’t stick.
“Fine, not Beorn, then. What about Bard?” Kíli suggests. “I just don’t think it would hurt to have an even mix.”
“That is well spoken, Kíli Elfblade,” Gandalf agrees. Bilbo had quite forgotten about him, but apparently, the Wizard has been eavesdropping for longer than anyone would suspect, if he’s aware of Kíli’s new title. “I, of course, will be coming along, but it would be wise to reach out to Bard and Thranduil and ask them each to send a warrior.”
“I’ll head for Dale in the morning,” Dori offers, “And speak to Princess Sigrid. We’ve been working on a trade deal since she returned from the Woodland realm.”
“I like the lass,” Glóin decides, “She’s got a good head on her shoulders. She’ll be able to help her father pick a worthy warrior.”
“Did you not see the Men of Dale in battle?” Bofur asks. “I’m not sure they’ve got many warriors, excepting Bard.”
Dwalin snorts. “I’d not trust my king’s safety to any of them.”
“We should still extend the offer,” Bilbo concedes. He can’t really argue with Kíli’s logic. After all, that was what Frodo did, and having Men and Elves around saved his nephew’s life on more than one occasion. Though in the end, it was only Sam who followed the lad to Mordor.
“I’ll send a Raven to Tauriel,” Kíli resolves, “Most of them already know where to find her. Shouldn’t be too much trouble.”
“We will speak about this when Bilbo and I return,” Thorin warns, clearly allowing himself to be distracted by the matter of Kíli and Tauriel.
This, too, is progress. If Thorin finds sport in courtship negotiations, clearly he is coming around on the idea of his nephew loving an Elf. Perhaps after their journey, Bilbo can advocate for the young couple and help his intended see reason.
“And if you do not return?” Balin asks. Of course he would be the one to think of that.
“Then we will speak of it in the Maker’s halls,” Thorin says gravely. At least he understands the level of danger inherent to their present quest.
Chapter 16: Another Journey
Notes:
Finally, they're going to Mordor. Be prepared for plenty of angst, though I promise there's a little fluff in there as well. As always, thank you all for reading/commenting/leaving kudos, and please enjoy the chapter.
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Thorin still dislikes the plan. If he had his way, Bilbo would stay safely in Erebor, and some other Hobbit would be hired to carry the ring to Mordor. But Thorin understands by now that there is no talking Bilbo out of this. The two of them have arrived at a stalemate: neither of them wishes for the other to go, so neither of them will stop the other from going. The Wizard has made arrangements, calling on the Great Eagles to give them passage to Mount Doom. Legolas, who has proven himself to be much less infuriating than his father, has offered to lead an army of Elves to the gates of Mordor to draw the enemy off and has promised to send an archer on the quest with the ring. What is more, both Óin and Tauriel have agreed that this is medically permissible and that the foolish Elf will not succumb to his wounds in the process. A Mannish warrior has been brought in from Dale, and though the Man’s armor is too large for him and he does not seem to possess the power of speech, Thorin does not suppose that they’ll get anyone better from Bard’s folk at this juncture. At the very least, their alliance with Dale is secure, and the Men of Arda can claim they had a hand in the destruction of their greatest enemy.
“What is this, ghivashel?” Thorin inquires of Bilbo, who has managed to smuggle a tray of food into their chambers.
Not that this isn’t allowed, of course. The king can have whatever he’d like in his own rooms. But he’s still surprised that Bilbo managed to sneak out of bed while he was sleeping, pad down to the kitchen, procure this feast, and slip back into the King’s Chambers, all while Thorin was none the wiser. How safe does he feel beside Bilbo that he can sleep so deeply, even with a new and dangerous quest looming above his head?
“Breakfast,” Bilbo reports, “I’m not going without it, and neither are you, my heart. Eat up.”
“How did you manage this?” Thorin asks, sitting up in bed and accepting the tray. He does not understand why Bilbo would wish to care for him so, after everything that has happened.
After the battle, Bilbo stripped away the layers of secrets in which he has been cloaked for the duration of their acquaintance. He showed Thorin his truest heart, which was damaged long ago, apparently by Thorin’s own hands. Though the king has no memory of this, though his One has assured him on multiple occasions that he bears no responsibility for it, guilt continues to tug at him from all sides. He does not understand why Bilbo would wish to be with him at all, let alone why the Hobbit would bother to spend such time cultivating a relationship with him, being kind and gentle with him, knowing all the while that Thorin would turn cruel and selfish in the end. Bilbo put his own life at risk to save Thorin when he did not have to. He could have protected Fíli and Kíli alone, but he made the active choice to defend Thorin as well.
Bilbo looks at him with warm eyes. “It’s not so difficult to sneak past you when you’re sleeping, and it’s even easer to get into the kitchens without anybody knowing.”
“I’m surprised the kitchens are in any condition for cooking,” Thorin muses, moving over to allow Bilbo space beside him on the bed. “But perhaps Mahal preserved them all these years, knowing you would come and use them some day.”
“Nothing so dramatic as that, I’m sure,” Bilbo laughs. Only one who knows him very well would be able to tell that his mirth is forced. “More that Smaug wouldn’t have known what to do with them, and once the ice chest is full of ice and the oven is hot, it’s easy enough to keep food and put together a good meal. Bombur says the plumbing took a while to sort out, but it’s all working perfectly at the moment. Durin’s folk do not waste time, it seems.”
The meal on the tray before Thorin is simple enough: only a few slices of buttered toast, some fish from the Long Lake, two fried eggs in a porcelain dish, and a few withered brown strips of dried apple. But considering that they are recovering from a nasty battle, in an area where little will grow, on the eve of winter, Bilbo may as well have produced a table laden with fine fare. He has certainly taken care in cutting perfect triangles of toast and artfully arranging the fish and the apples on the plate they’ll both eat from.
“You flatter me,” Thorin informs his beloved between bites of toast. “And you spoil me. How did you get butter?”
Theoretically, the king should be the one making the trade deals that will lead to such unimaginable luxuries. “I told Thranduil where we were going,” Bilbo replies.
“Ah. That explains it, then.” Thorin bites back a dry remark about Thranduil’s evident glee in providing what may turn out to be Thorin’s last meal.
He will defend Bilbo with his life, and he expects the others in their small fellowship to do the same. Surely Gandalf will have imparted this upon the Elven guard and the Mannish warrior. “We really should all be having breakfast together,” Bilbo decides.
“Bard’s Man will not leave his chambers,” Thorin points out flatly. As a general rule, he does not trust Men. He has had far too many bad experiences with them to to believe that they mean him anything but harm, and Bard’s conduct prior to the battle of Five Armies has not disabused him of this notion.
Yes, it is true that Thorin was gold-sick and not in his right mind. Yes, it is true that he succumbed to the poison left by the dragon upon the hoard in conjunction with the curse on Durin’s line. It is also true, however, that Bard held Bilbo against his will overnight, and used the Hobbit as a bargaining chip, as though he were merely a possession of Thorin’s to be ransomed out in exchange for a few gold coins. Thorin will spend the rest of his life repenting for the harm that he did his Hobbit during his days of madness, but what is Bard’s excuse?
“How do you know Bard’s warrior is a fellow?” Bilbo asks, shocking Thorin out of his rumination. “It’s not as though we’ve seen their face. We don’t even know their name.”
Thorin snorts. “Men do not allow their ladies to fight.”
Bilbo looks taken aback. “What?” He comes, after all, from a culture where nobody fights at all. Hobbit lasses probably do not wield weapons any more than do the daughters of Men, but Hobbit lads are no better trained. “But the women of Lake-town have grown up in Smaug’s shadow just the same as their fathers and brothers!”
“Their culture is twisted and backwards,” Thorin announces. “They pick and choose at random who deserves rights and who does not.” He remembers how he was treated in the towns of Men, how plain it was that many of the smiths who talked down to their Dwarven workmates were equally dishonorable in dealing with their wives and daughters.
“I can’t imagine that’s the case with all Men. The Rangers of the North surely do not… Although…” But he trails off, apparently remembering something that contradicts his own argument or else proves Thorin’s point. “Well. I suppose I should’ve known. I’d forgotten all about the White Lady of Rohan, I must say.”
“Rohan?” Thorin is intrigued by this. “I do not know much about the Horse Lords. Have you spent much time in their lands?” He still has much to learn about Bilbo’s other life.
“I haven’t, but a few of my young cousins have,” Bilbo explains, “Or, they will spend time there, I suppose. Or, they would have spent time there, had we not intervened. Goodness, Thorin, I can’t tell you how confusing this whole mess is! Someday, I swear, I’m going to sit down and write it all out, and then you’ll see what a mess I’ve had inside my head all this time!”
“I would read it, if you did,” Thorin purrs.
“I wish I’d been able to bring my book with me,” Bilbo grumbles. For just a moment, Thorin is willing to believe that his Hobbit is very old indeed. “I worked so long and hard on it, too, only for the plot to change and everything else! I suppose it’s for the better, but you know, I was quite proud of how it turned out. And Frodo’s bit at the end was very well done. I think young Sam was hoping to finish it, too, though of course I don’t know how that turned out.”
It is strange, very strange, looking at the lovely young face of his love and knowing that Bilbo is ancient at heart. Bilbo has lived through the painful stretching of his mind on top of the deterioration of his body. From what Thorin understands, that took place rapidly toward the end of Bilbo’s first life. Oh, how he wishes he could have been there to provide comfort for Bilbo in his old age. Thorin, too, would be old by then. But he failed his Hobbit, in the other world. He failed to survive, leaving Bilbo bereft and alone to face untold hardships.
“You can tell me the stories later, if you remember them,” Thorin offers, because he does not know what else to say.
“I do wonder,” Bilbo barrels on as though his king had not spoken, and Thorin is hopelessly endeared. “What happened to my body. Did I just drop dead on the shores of the Grey Havens? I should hope not. Poor Frodo has been through far too much to have to deal with that on top of everything else. But perhaps the world simply dissolved around me, I don’t know. I suppose it depends.”
“Depends?” Thorin echoes, rapt. He loves to watch the working of Bilbo’s mind.
“Have I been sent back in time, or to another world entirely?” Bilbo muses. “Because if I’ve only traveled through time, then I suppose that everything must have.. gone away. Obviously, my being here has changed the future. But if I’ve been taken to another world, then I suppose dear Frodo would be mourning me right now in the undying lands.”
“Poor lad,” Thorin says, entertaining this idea. He would like to know this Frodo someday, though of course, he’ll have to wait for the boy to be born.
“Anyway,” says Bilbo, collecting himself, “I do wish we could all have breakfast together. I suppose we should have invited Gandalf, at least. And Tauriel.”
Thorin does not understand why the Captain of Mirkwood was chosen for this task. Were he in Legolas’s position, he would not send one of his own kin on such an errand. But perhaps it will be good for Thorin to spend more time with Tauriel. She may soon be joining his family, after all, or trying to.
“I believe she is with Kíli now,” Thorin growls. He still does not understand why his nephew is courting an Elf. Especially now that Kíli has proven his valor in battle, he could have his choice among any dam or fellow from any of the great Dwarven kingdoms. But he seems devoted to Tauriel, which makes Thorin wonder. If he himself was forged to love a Hobbit, could not Mahal have crafted Kíli to love an Elf?
“You can’t have expected anything else to happen, seeing them on Ravenhill,” Bilbo points out, “And in the infirmary! I imagine we’ll have a wedding to look forward to in no time.”
“I hope not.” Thorin is aware of how petulant he sounds.
“You still dislike her?”
“What was the Captain of the Guard of Mirkwood doing when the dragon took our home from us?”
“I imagine she was following the orders of her king, who could have her executed for disobedience,” Bilbo retorts. He is always in the mood to argue, for which Thorin is very grateful. He enjoys their verbal sparring matches, though he’d prefer it if his own rhetorical sword were a bit sharper in this instance. “Unlike at the last battle, when she and Legolas risked exile to help us on Ravenhill. There’s a fair chance Kíli wouldn’t be here to get married to anyone if she hadn’t intervened, and I won’t have you dragging her good name through the mud because you don’t like her employer. I expect you to be civil to her on the journey, and I expect you to behave yourself and dance with her at the engagement party.”
“Dance with her?” Thorin is pleased to discover that Bilbo has remembered how he likes his eggs. The yolks have not been broken, and they collect in golden splendor at the bottom of the little bowl. Thorin gladly uses the toast (of which there seems to be no shortage) to mop them up. “You are not familiar with the customs of Dwarven courtship.”
“I am not throwing an engagement party where the two families don’t dance together! And I’ll tell Kíli the same thing if he tries to kick up a fuss about dancing with Thranduil.”
That gets Thorin to laugh out loud, though he does not believe for a moment that Bilbo is anything but serious. In all likelihood, he really will expect poor Kíli to participate in some sort of traditional Hobbit line dance involving the Elven King as the adoptive father of his intended. “Yes, you should tell him about that. He may decide the courtship isn’t worth it after all.” Not that Thorin believes for a moment that Thranduil would indulge Bilbo by agreeing to participate.
He is more concerned with what this means for their own future. Will Bilbo refuse to marry Thorin until the entire Line of Durin has shared a dance with the entire Baggins clan? If that’s the case, then arrangements should be made to get them all to the Shire. Best to do that soon, so that Dís and the first caravan from the Blue Mountains can join them on the journey home.
Bilbo huffs. “If the courtship isn’t worth a few moments arm-in-arm with the Woodland King, it’s just infatuation, not love, anyway. I did let Thranduil kidnap me twice for your sake, you know. That never happened on my first adventure.”
“I wasn’t aware that you had any say in the matter of being kidnapped,” Thorin snarls. He still is not pleased with Thranduil and Bard for holding Bilbo against his will.
“I didn’t have to go into the throne room with you in Mirkwood, and I certainly didn’t have to leave the Mountain just before the battle,” Bilbo reasons, “And I’d do both of those things again if I got another chance. Which, Yavanna willing, I will not. Twice is quite enough, I think.”
“It is an honor to be chosen twice by you,” Thorin says. “Were our places reversed, I would choose you a hundredfold.”
“You’re being dramatic again,” Bilbo protests, “Who else would I choose? I keep telling you, you’re the only one for me, Thorin Oakenshield. I decided that a long time ago, and I don’t intend to change my mind now.”
“And how very glad I am of that.” For a moment, Thorin considers leaving it there. He certainly has no right to ask Bilbo for anything more. He would let his One determine the course of their courtship. That is only right, considering all that he has put Bilbo through. But Thorin is greedy, and he has spent the past several months pushing down the desperate wanting that has been clawing at his guts. Deeper-rooted than the fleeting desire to possess a shiny stone, though the need is much less heavy, much less painful. “May I kiss you?”
Bilbo gapes at him. “Of course!” He blurts out. Thorin begins to lean in, clenching his fists in the sheets to hide his trembling fingers, but then Bilbo stops him. “Wait!”
Thorin pauses and watches in wonder as Bilbo transfers the breakfast tray to the bedside table. “Okay, alright. I’m ready now. Go ahead.”
And Thorin cannot help but smile. Yes, this is what he wants. This is better than any treasure hoard, better than any crown, better than anything in the world. “Are you sure you wouldn’t rather wait until after breakfast?”
“You’d better not tease me,” Bilbo scolds, though the fond smile upon his lips rather betrays him.
Thorin knows that he does not deserve such fondness. He certainly does not deserve the second chance that he has apparently been given, unbeknownst to him. No matter what he might do, Thorin is certain that he will never for a moment deserve Bilbo’s love. But it’s plain that he has it, whether he deserves it or not, and he will do everything in his power to become worthy.
“Of course not,” Thorin breathes, cupping Bilbo’s face in his hands.
These hands, which have done so much damage. These hands, which pointed a sword at Bilbo, which clutched at the ghost of the Arkenstone. Which, in another world, were laid upon the Hobbit in anger. These hands which failed to slay Azog the Defiler, leaving the task to Thorin’s sister-sons. These hands which are capable of bringing pain and disappointment can also bring pleasure and comfort. Bilbo leans into the touch, despite what he said about teasing, and meets Thorin’s gaze, unwavering.
Thorin leans in and kisses him softly, gently, sweetly. He kisses Bilbo with reverence, worshipfully. He knows he will never deserve this. But he also knows that this is what Bilbo wants, that this is what makes him happy, that for whatever reason, he continues to return Thorin’s feelings. Perhaps, Thorin thinks, in an unavoidable moment of darkness, it is only the ring that makes Bilbo love Thorin. It is only the foul magic that makes him wish to stay with one who hurt him so? What if the enemy wants Bilbo in Erebor for his own nebulous, but surely nefarious, purposes?
Bilbo deepens the kiss, pulling Thorin impossibly closer, getting his tongue involved. They are both clumsy at this, lacking in practice, and Thorin knows that he was wrong to doubt his Burglar. He would not have minded, knowing that there were others, after him. He would not have understood the impulse, being of a race that loves only once, but he would have understood the principle. He would rather see Bilbo happy than anything else, and after how Thorin apparently treated him in this other world, he knows he would have forfeited any claim he could once have made to the Hobbit’s heart.
But it is plain to Thorin as Bilbo kisses him that the Hobbit never took another lover. When Bilbo finally pulls away, breathless and panting, Thorin finds himself babbling in Khuzdul, saying things he’d never thought to voice. Telling Bilbo that he loves him over and over again, that he is sorry, that he is afraid. That he would not choose this, if given the chance to decide. That he wishes there were anything to do but take his love to Mordor.
Bilbo only sighs, cuddling Thorin close. “It’s alright, darling,” he says, as though he understands the words.
Perhaps he does. He had eighty years to learn Khuzdul, after all, though it seems he spent those years in the Shire, locked away in silent grief. And Thorin cannot blame him. He cannot imagine what it would be like, to watch his boys fall in battle. Though Thorin does not believe himself to be worthy of the same level of grief, he knows what the bond between Ones is like. He does not believe that he could live on without Bilbo. He does not believe that he could do it for eight decades. How strong his Hobbit is, how brave.
“It is alright,” Thorin agrees. He will not err again, not with Bilbo to guide him. He can be vigilant, attentive. He can do everything that must be done.
He cannot take the ring to Mordor. He cannot even look upon it, does not trust himself in the face of the temptation. But Thorin must help Bilbo. That is not even a question.
Bilbo and Thorin spend a lovely morning together, not taking about the quest. They’ve gotten very good at not talking about things over the course of their journey together, after all. They spent several months ignoring their feelings for one another, or refusing to express them, at least. Bilbo does not think that he ever told anybody aloud that he loved Thorin until they were in Mirkwood for the second time, and that probably doesn’t count, because he was far from his right mind. They say it a few times, laying side-by-side in the king’s bed. They share a few chaste kisses, and a few kisses that could not be called chaste by any stretch of the imagination.
And then it is time to set out again. Four Eagles await to bear them to Mount Doom. “I wish I’d remembered how Frodo described it,” Bilbo mutters. “He didn’t give much detail in his account. I think he was half-senseless by the time they got there.”
“But that was a different time,” Thorin murmurs in response. They have not told Tauriel or the unnamed Mannish warrior about Bilbo’s other life or his foreknowledge, which has become admittedly limited in recent days. After all, nothing that he remembers about those weeks of grief following the battle applies very well to the inception of this new quest. “And the ring was stronger than it is now. Has the weight of it changed?”
“No.” This much Bilbo can be sure of.
When he sneaked out of Thorin’s chambers this morning, he did not merely set about preparing breakfast. He also practiced casting the ring into the stove, over and over again, burning his fingers more than once as he picked it out. When Thorin called attention to this, because Bilbo could only distract him for so long with kisses and food, Bilbo only shrugged, reporting that the wounds were superficial, anyway, and therefore it did not really matter how he acquired them. This had not dissuaded Thorin from having him seen to by Óin, who was annoyed, to say the least, at having to take time away from the battle-wounded to look at a ‘wee mark on the sodding consort,’ as the healer put it whilst muttering to himself.
A normal ring would come away burning hot from the embers of a stove. The One Ring should be plenty cold after spending time in any fire. As it happens, the ring is somewhere in the middle, warm to the touch, but not as hot as it should be. Bilbo does not know whether the damage done by the dragon fire is permanent, but it seems to be holding at this juncture. Of course, that could all be a clever trick. Wouldn’t it be just perfect to lure Bilbo to Mount Doom, to put him and his fellows in grave danger, and then snatch the rug out from under him? He wouldn’t put it past this tricky little ring. Maybe it’s only taken away the invisibility to punish Bilbo for trying to destroy it. Maybe it’s not calling out to Thorin because it wishes to lull Bilbo into a false sense of security, and in the hour of their greatest need, the ring will awaken and poison Thorin’s mind.
If he tried to kill Bilbo, the Hobbit would not fight back. He would let it happen. He could not harm Thorin, not even for the good of Middle Earth. Anyone else, he thinks he could bring himself to stab, if the fate of the world depended on it. But not Thorin.
Is that Bilbo’s own thinking, or is it the influence of the ring? “It does not call to me,” Thorin assures him. “When I cannot see it, I feel nothing at all.”
“And when you can see it?” Bilbo is not so foolish as to believe that the ring has been completely disarmed. Probably, it knows his plan, and it is saving its depleted energy for the very last moment.
“Then it is like any other piece of gold.” This is a familiar refrain. But Thorin has not explained to Bilbo the depth of feeling gold evokes from him, so the Hobbit cannot possibly understand. All he has to compare it to is his former longing for the ring, which is significantly diminished now that the wretched thing and its wicked master have both been weakened by time and magic.
Significantly, but not entirely. He still feels odd about parting with it, and he cannot help but wonder whether this is truly necessary. After all, it’s not as though the ring is going to trouble anybody any time soon. It was stronger before, and Bilbo lived with it for years before it started to show an effect! And even still, he was able to part with it. Why destroy it now? Why jeopardize the happy life he’s begun to build with Thorin?
But that’s a simple question with a simple answer. For Frodo. Bilbo will do this all, and gladly, for his nephew’s sake.
“We should go,” Tauriel advises, “While we have the daylight.” In truth, Bilbo was so distracted by his worry for Thorin’s ability to truly overcome the dragon sickness (not to mention his own ability to stand up to the influence of the ring) that he altogether forgot about their other three traveling companions. Some ring-bearer he is. Frodo would never have made such an oversight.
“Yes,” Gandalf agrees, “We must make haste, and enjoy the daylight while we have it.”
“It will be dark in Mordor,” Bilbo agrees, suddenly remembering Frodo’s stories of that horrid place. He drifted in and out, when they were told to him, falling asleep or into a daze so many times that his poor nephew had to recite the same harrowing details over and over again.
How much did he leave out, for Bilbo’s sake? How much did he hide, so that his beloved uncle would never know of Frodo’s pain? And how much did he omit for his own wellbeing, so that he did not have to tell the same awful, aching story so many times to a sleeping, aged Hobbit who could barely remember where or when he was, who kept asking for his missing ring?
“Will the Eagles still be able to fly without light?” Tauriel asks. “How will they navigate?”
“These are not the sparrows of the Greenwood,” Gandalf informs her brusquely, “But the Eagles of Manwë, They need no light to navigate, though of course they prefer it.”
The members of the company will not be pleased when they discover that Bilbo and Thorin left without saying goodbye. Kíli will likely be equally upset with Tauriel. But they could not afford delays or further requests to accompany their fellowship, and Bilbo is eager to have this errand done. So he and Thorin climb onto the back of the same Eagle. The others find an Eagle each. Bilbo tries to ask for the bird’s name, more out of politeness than anything else, but he is snubbed. Or, perhaps only the King of the Eagles speaks Westron. That, too, is a possibility. Bilbo allows himself, for just a moment, to be distracted from his terror and guilt by musing about the language of Eagles, of all birds, actually, and whether it might be possible to learn such speech.
The decision to mount the same Eagle was one on which Thorin refused to compromise.He and Bilbo will ride into Mordor together, and they will not be parted, even when logic and reason would dictate that they should be. Besides, as Tauriel pointed out to Bilbo, with steely-eyed practicality, they would be easiest to defend if they were both in the same place. The forces of Mordor would likely aim to attack the King who just defeated their armies in battle just as much as the Ring-bearer. Which, as the Hobbit cannot stop reminding himself, is Frodo’s title, not Bilbo’s.
Still, it grounds Bilbo to be held about the waist, to have Thorin clinging to his back as they sail over unfamiliar lands. Could it really be as easy as all this? “You are distracted,” Thorin observes.
“Yes,” Bilbo admits.
“Will you not tell me what you are thinking about?” In this position, it is ever-so-easy for the king to simply lean over and murmur into Bilbo’s ear. Whether he knows what he is doing or is completely oblivious to the effect that he has on his Hobbit, Bilbo is not certain. That is, perhaps, a conversation to have at a later date, when they are not sailing into mortal peril.
Bilbo considers lying. It would certainly set Thorin’s mind at ease to do so. But he cannot bring himself to that point. If Bilbo is to die, which he may very well be, he will do it with a clean conscious. “What if the ring is only tricking me, only pretending to be weak to force my guard down? What if it tries to make me hurt you, like it did with Frodo? I nearly killed him, Thorin. I would have killed him, if I’d been able to, and I had not carried the ring or even seen it for nearly two decades by then.”
“Tell me about him,” Thorin orders, rather than trying to assure Bilbo that the ring will do no such thing. He must understand that there are no guarantees in that arena. By riding on the back of this Eagle with Bilbo, Thorin is risking being thrown to his death, should his lover turn on him by the malice of the ring. But then, Thorin is strong. His arms are a prison from which Bilbo cannot escape, which feels more comforting than smothering when it means that Bilbo cannot be used as a weapon of the enemy to harm the one he loves. Of course, if the ring gets ahold of Thorin, then he could easily throw Bilbo to his death, but surely one of the others would intervene in that case. “Your nephew.”
Bilbo sighs. “Frodo is a right menace,” he decides, not worrying at all about the proper tense to use when discussing someone yet to be born who manages, despite this, to be an intimate of nearly half a century. “Not… well, not like your boys. He’s much quieter than they are, at least. But he has a way of looking very contrite, especially when he knows he’s done something wrong. I’ll tell you, once, he broke my favorite cookie jar trying to get it off the high shelf in the larder. This was before he came to stay with me, mind, so I didn’t know how easily he could make that face. I thought he was terribly sorry! I ended up baking more cookies just to calm him down, which, of course, is exactly what he wanted. And his mother was no help at all! Primula found it very funny, how easily her lad could manipulate me. Which is hardly fair at all! I did make him sweep up the mess he made, at least. It’s not as though he had me bending to his every whim.”
“He sounds exactly like my boys,” Thorin breathes. “I can imagine the trouble he made for you when he was small. What was he like when he grew up?”
“He’s very skilled with maps, making them and reading them,” Bilbo continues, “Better than I ever was, that’s for certain. Though he’s lucky he’s got Sam, or else I don’t know what he’d do out in the garden. Frodo nearly killed my hydrangeas, the last time I let him do the weeding, but thankfully, Sam stopped him just in time. The lad always meant well, of course, but his eye is better for foraging than for gardening, if you know what I mean.”
“I do not.”
“Oh, he’s just much better at remembering different types of wild plants and mushrooms than he is at fussy work in the garden,” Bilbo elaborates, “Just a little quirk, nothing too terrible. Most Hobbits have a little of some, a bit of the other, though I’m not much for foraging. I’d say he got it from the other side of the family, but he’s my cousin on both sides, so it can’t be that. Though those Brandybuck cousins of his were always taking him with them to steal from poor Farmer Maggot, so maybe he just had more practice with the harvesting than the cultivating, I don’t know. It’s formative, what you learn in the garden at a young age.”
“And what did you learn, when you were a pebble?” Thorin’s voice is low and soft, enticing despite the horror of their situation.
It’s obvious what Thorin is doing. He’s trying to draw Bilbo out, to induce the Hobbit to talk and to think about things other than the ring. To prove to him that the ring does not have the power to control Bilbo’s mind. Perhaps, also, to distract him from the changes they are seeing in the landscape below them and the peril toward which they fly.
It’s surprisingly effective. Bilbo talks at length about raised plots and stepping stones, about cleaning up the edges of the walkway and different types of grass. He speaks about perennials and annuals and the nuisance made by rabbits.
The days pass; the Eagles stop on high rocks to rest themselves, and the company eats and sleeps. Tauriel and Gandalf talk amongst themselves, though both seem content to be quiet, and the Mannish warrior retreats, apparently disinterested in making conversation with any other member of the fellowship. Bilbo has his theories about the Man, ranging from muteness to bigotry. But Bilbo and Thorin huddle together, wrapped in conversation, making up for lost time.
Bilbo makes certain to inform Thorin about every detail of the eighty years he spent alone. He talks at length about the Shire fairs, the young Hobbits who hailed him as a great storyteller until they grew up and decided that Bilbo was rather odd, actually, and perhaps no longer worth their time. He speaks of Erebor, his late journey there and all that he learned, of the years he spent in Rivendell amongst the Elves. And Thorin speaks in return, divulging secret years of his life to Bilbo.
Bilbo never hoped to know so much about the exile of the Ereborean. Thorin tells stories of his brother, Frerin, who was killed in battle, and of his father and grandfather when both were sane. He speaks of smithing, of his nephews’ youth, of his own desperate attempts to provide for his people and his family. At night, they push their bedrolls together and hold one another close. Though they do not make a point of ignoring the other members of their party, all seem content to allow Bilbo and Thorin a bit of time and space to themselves.
A heavy feeling of dread begins to surround Bilbo. He worries that it may be caused by the ring itself, and not by the gravity of his task. But then, they have entered Mordor, and to camp here is not safe for anyone. Not even Eagles, not even Elves or Wizards. The Mannish warrior, still quiet, huddles in on himself and trembles in the evenings. Tauriel and Gandalf both sleep with their eyes open. When Bilbo is on watch, he observes Thorin pretending to sleep for the sake of his Hobbit. When Thorin is on watch, Bilbo feigns slumber in turn. That is only polite.
Near the end of their journey, Bilbo tells Thorin about the acorn that he took from Beorn’s garden the first time around, and about how he didn’t bother with that on this trip because he has no intention of returning to the Shire.
“You will stay with me, then, when this is over?” Thorin inquires, pressing his forehead to Bilbo’s shoulder.
“Of course!” Bilbo can’t believe that’s even a question in Thorin’s mind. “Now that I have you, I’m not leaving unless you ask me to.”
“I would never ask that,” Thorin assures him, “But what about Frodo?”
That’s not something Bilbo had considered, truth be told. He’s been so wrapped up in protecting Frodo from the ring that he hadn’t even considered the lad’s more immediate future. “Well, obviously, I’ll warn Drogo and Primula about boating on the Brandywine, though I doubt either of them will listen to me. And if they don’t heed my warning, and things turn out exactly the same, though I ask Yavanna to protect my cousins, of course, then I suppose it will be Frodo’s choice whether to stay in Brandy Hall or come join us in Erebor.”
“He is welcome, if he does choose to join us,” Thorin assures Bilbo, “And of course we can maintain a correspondence if he does not.”
In all honesty, Bilbo has been so preoccupied with repeating his adventure exactly the same way, and then with fixing the battle and destroying the ring, that he hasn’t bothered to think much about what will come after. He can imagine, of course, that he will stay in Erebor with Thorin and become consort, but he has no clue what that might entail. Dáin had no queen when Bilbo visited him before the council of Elrond, and even if he had, it would have been a bit strange to ask her about her daily duties. That would not have occurred to Bilbo, for he would not have thought that he’d ever wind up in this situation.
“I’m sure he’ll get all sorts of odd looks in the Shire,” Bilbo mutters. “Receiving ravens from the Consort of Erebor? The poor lad will be badgered by relatives, day in and day out.”
“Not to mention the letters he’ll be getting from the King of Erebor,” Thorin replies smoothly, pulling Bilbo impossibly closer. As they get closer to their destination, the ring becomes undeniably heavier on the chain around Bilbo’s neck. It’s by no means excruciating, and it’s not as though the ring is speaking to him, but Bilbo wouldn’t describe the sensation as particularly comfortable. For now, however, Thorin’s presence at his back feels grounding, a firm resistance against the other pull he feels. “It is as you said, ghivashel. Frodo is your kin, which makes him mine as well.”
“We’ll have to go to back to the Shire for his birth,” Bilbo muses. “Drogo and Primula will be over the moon! Well, Prim will be over the moon, and Drogo will probably grow a few grey hairs, having you lot all in the dining room, and I don’t blame him, but I already know the lads will want to come, too.”
“Oh, yes,” Thorin agrees. “Are you going to tell them about—“
“Absolutely not.” Bilbo nips that idea in the bud right away. “I’ll not make them mourn when neither of them has any cause to. As far as I’m concerned, it never happened.”
There is a palpable shift in the air as they cross into Mordor. The enemy’s eye may not be capable of watching them or commanding the Nazgul at present, thanks to the ministrations of Lady Galadriel, but that does not mean that their party is safe. Legolas is still running a diversionary campaign to draw off the orcs, and even so, Tauriel takes out a few archers on the cliffs. Not that she needs to, with the Eagles maneuvering so well. The Mannish warrior still has yet to say a word to any of their fellowship and does not seem particularly skilled with the bow, but Gandalf has been very liberal with his use of his staff.
Thorin hums. “Then we won’t tell them,” he says. “We will bring them to the Shire and pretend we don’t know the exact date of your nephew’s birth.”
Bilbo purses his lips. “That’s a difficult secret for me to keep, Your Majesty.” He can only really bring himself to use Thorin’s proper title in jest. “Since Frodo’s birthday is the same as mine.”
“Mahal below, I do not even know when that is.” Thorin sounds so very taken aback that Bilbo cannot help but giggle. He hopes they aren’t bothering their Eagle too much with all this stilted flirtation, but then, the great bird did agree to carry Bilbo and Thorin together. He had to have had some idea of what he was in for.
Bilbo decides to play coy. “I’m sure you’ll figure it out when you wake up to cake and fireworks and me giving you a present.”
“Why would you give me a present on your own birthday?”
“And I’d forgotten about your silly Dwarven birthday customs, too!” Bilbo can’t help but exclaim. “To receive presents on one’s birthday, at one’s very birthday party! I can’t believe that slipped my mind.”
“We will have to have a long discussion when we return to Erebor,” Thorin decides, “About our cultures. To avoid a misunderstanding.”
Bilbo blinks. “You know, the last time, when you gave me the mithril armor, I didn’t know what you were doing.”
“What?”
“I didn’t know it was a courtship gift,” Bilbo explains. “I thought it was just a pretty shirt. I had no idea it was worth so much money, either, or I probably never would’ve worn it. And I guess it just seemed so obvious to everyone else that they never bothered to explain it to me. All those years, it was sitting in the Mathom House down in Michel-Delving when it could easily have purchased the whole Shire. Apparently, Gimli was absolutely beside himself when Frodo showed it to him in Moria, and no wonder, finding out his king had proposed marriage to a Hobbit and nobody had ever bothered to tell the lad.”
Thorin breathes out a laugh, and it is the most beautiful sound that has ever reached Bilbo’s ears. This moment is worth the trip to Mordor, worth all the hardships of both of Bilbo’s journeys and maybe even worth the time he spent stretched thin by the influence of the Ring. Bilbo decides that he’d endure all those trials over again, harrowing as they may be, just to listen to that lovely laugh. Which is very stupid of him, but he’s besotted, so he’s got to cut himself some slack.
They spend one night camped in Mordor. Bilbo thought, before the journey began, that it would be the worst evening of his life. He believed, naively, that nothing could be worse than bedding down in the shadow of Mount Doom, with orcs on all sides. “The Eagles grow weary,” Gandalf explains simply, confirming Bilbo’s suspicion that he can communicate somehow with the great birds.
“This is dangerous,” Thorin complains, as though it had just now occurred to him.
“Of course it’s dangerous,” Bilbo snaps, “We’re in Mordor. But we’d better not tire out our birds before we get to the main event. They may need to make a quick extraction.”
The Mannish warrior, in his ill-fitting armor, curls in on himself as always, trembling from head to toe. Tauriel strokes the feathers on her Eagle’s neck and murmurs to the bird in quiet Sindarin, too low for any of the others to hear. Gandalf takes out his pipe and chews on the end of it, not bothering to pack or light it. They do not dare to make a fire.
“The enemy’s forces are few, surely,” Bilbo says, leaning back against the warmth of Thorin, all around him. “Lady Galadriel has driven him back, and Dáin’s people took out most of the Gundabad orcs.”
“There have been archers on the cliffs,” Tauriel points out, “Legolas will do what he can to draw out those forces which remain, but we must remain vigilant.”
Bilbo does not think that he has ever seen an Elf in such distress. Tauriel does not require proper sleep, yet her cloudy eyes suggest a lack of it. Her hands do not tremble, but they twitch periodically. Her brilliant red hair is uncombed, and she looks somewhat disheveled. Bilbo never learned what happened to her, at the end of his first adventure. He was not close with her, then, and he was selfish in his grief, retreating into himself rather than offering comfort to anyone else.
“You’re right,” Bilbo tells her.
They are tired, all of them, and haggard. Bilbo feels Thorin’s shuddering breath against his back as the king manages his terror. He does not like to see Bilbo in danger, and this is the greatest danger of all. This entire trip, Thorin has offered security to Bilbo. Now, he falters. Because he is not the great king of legend, after all, not one of the Dwarven monarchs carved from Erebor’s green marble, but a living, breathing being, vital, inhaling the smog of Mordor and the glory of a second chance. Bilbo squeezes his hand.
There is no merry-making, no song and little talk. They eat rations, and they sip their water sparingly. At their last camp, there was a little stream from which drinking water could be taken, and Bilbo drank greedily. Here, though, there is nothing. No drinking water, no game for Tauriel to hunt, and no sound but the menacing wind.
And yet this is not the worst night of Bilbo’s life, not by a long shot. The worst nights of Bilbo’s life came in Rivendell, when he was foggy and hazy and exhausted yet unable to sleep. The worst nights of Bilbo’s life came in quick succession, one after another, each day blending into the next as Frodo walked across Arda with Bilbo’s burden strung around his neck. Poor lad. Poor, poor, lad. Being here is not half as bad as knowing that Frodo was here, thin and wan and pained. Not knowing whether his nephew even lived, or his cousins, or dear Sam.
Nothing could be worse than that. Death, Bilbo thinks, is better than uncertainty. He knows how to mourn his dead, and he has done it before. He knows how to push those feelings away, to soothe himself with poetry and maps and food. He knows how to turn his grief into fine stories, fine songs. But he has never known what to do with uncertainty.
“Mister Baggins,” Tauriel says, “You are not well.”
And Bilbo wishes to scream at her, to tell her that of course he isn’t well! How could he ever be well, knowing that this dreadful, harrowing journey is not half as terrible as the one that Frodo went on? How could he ever be well, leaning against the warm, healthy body of his lover, knowing that Frodo and Sam each had to watch while the other slowly starved? Knowing that they drank dirty water and evaded orcs at every turn and battled an arachnid far worse than any Mirkwood spider? Knowing that they were pursued by Gollum all the while, because Bilbo was so stupid, so trusting, so arrogant as to give the fiend his name?
How could Bilbo ever be well, knowing that he was personally responsible for every moment of Frodo’s suffering? He returned to Rivendell thin and frail. So thin and so frail, in fact, that Bilbo was not told of his arrival, was not allowed to see him for days in case the lad should die, for fear that the shock would do Bilbo in as well.
“I’m alright, lass,” he says, instead of all that. “Or, I will be, once this business with the ring is taken care of.”
Nobody sleeps. They stay awake, all five of them, and the ring makes Bilbo’s back hurt. They do not even put out bedrolls. Bilbo and Thorin lean against one another, aware that this might be their last night together in this life but aware just as keenly that their surroundings prevent them from doing anything about it. Still, Bilbo reasons, they both knew what they were signing up for.
The next day, they approach Mount Doom. It is horrible, imposing even against the perpetual dark of Mordor. “The Eagles will leave us here,” Gandalf reports as they swoop down to land. “They will circle above to retrieve us, of course, but they cannot go inside.”
“Of course not,” Bilbo grumbles. “That would be too easy.”
Perhaps he’s not entitled to his complaints. After all, this entire journey has been remarkably easy, and Bilbo knows precisely why: his trademark luck is not luck after all but the deliberate hand of the Valar. He was sent here on purpose, and here specifically, as well. There is something unique about this precise time, just after the Battle of the Five Armies, just after Lady Galadriel has driven the enemy out of Dol Goldur, just after Bilbo has doused the One Ring with dragon fire. It will not be a stroll in the garden, by any means, but it will be easier for Bilbo than it was for Frodo. Or so he tells himself, at least.
The Eagles set them down at the entrance to the mountain. “It would’ve been much more convenient if he’d built an opening at the top,” Bilbo complains. He’s decided that he is, actually, entitled to do so by virtue of the fact that he’s presently in the process of saving the world.
“And make his forge vulnerable to the weather?” Thorin asks dryly. “Any smith could tell you what a bad idea that would be.”
“It’s all just very inconvenient,” Bilbo protests, but he sees Thorin’s wisdom.
Gandalf is delivered to the mountain next, and then Tauriel. However, a gust of wind overtakes the Eagle carrying the Mannish warrior, who is deposited shakily, falling sideways onto the ground with a rather loud curse.
That does not sound like the voice of a great warrior. In fact, it is almost certainly the voice of a very young person, and what’s worse, it sounds familiar. Bilbo is amazed, in fact, that this voice has been hitherto unheard. But then, it isn’t so surprising. Bilbo and Thorin have spent the entire journey wrapped up in one another, and Gandalf and Tauriel have been muttering amongst themselves, when not sleeping or on watch. What time they do not spend resting, they spend flying into the wind. It would be easy to miss the sound of a voice in all of that.
“You are full of surprises indeed, Princess Sigrid of Dale,” Gandalf proclaims, as if he is not disturbed in the slightest by the fact that Bard’s eldest daughter managed to slip unnoticed into their fellowship and thereby into Mordor.
Thorin and Tauriel, thankfully, seem to have more sense. “This is no place for a child,” Thorin proclaims. “You should not have come.”
He is clenching his fists so tightly that his nails will surely leave marks on his palms. No doubt he is reliving the harrowing ordeal of talking his nephews out of accompanying him on this particular quest. Bilbo is in a similar position, forcibly reminding himself that this is worse than Frodo’s situation, because although the Ring-Bearer will always be Bilbo’s baby, he was, in fact, a fully grown Hobbit of a very respectable age when he undertook this quest.
“You must return to Dale at once,” Tauriel agrees, “Your father will be worried about you.”
“I am no child!” Sigrid protests, springing to her feet as only the young can do after such a tumble and removing her helmet. She certainly looks like a child, with her cheeks flushed and her eyes round.
“How many winters have you seen?” Thorin inquires gently.
“Sixteen, Your Majesty,” Sigrid holds her ground.
“Then you are a child,” Tauriel informs her, tight and clipped as every Woodland Guard should be. “You have no training that would help us here. You are only putting yourself in danger. I would not have you guard the gate as planned when you cannot have spent more than a fortnight with that sword.”
“But none of my people have spent more than a fortnight with their swords,” Sigrid protests, “I am just as good as any other fighter from Lake-town.” This implies that she fought in the Battle, which Bilbo hopes is untrue. He does not like the thought of one so young taking up a blade.
“The Elf speaks true.” The fact that these words have left Thorin’s lips is a testament to the dire situation. He whirls on Gandalf next. “Did you know about this?”
“I did not,” Gandalf replies, though who knows whether he’s telling the truth?
Bilbo closes his eyes and opens them again. “How did we not figure this out sooner?”
Sigrid shrugs. “I don’t know, but here I am.”
“Were you not asked to find a warrior from among your people to accompany us on our quest?” Thorin demands. That had all sounded like a very good idea when Kíli proposed it, but at the moment, Bilbo can’t see the point. Better to have only the four of them and leave this child safe at home.
“There are no warriors among my people,” Sigrid replies, “And my father would not have risked any if there were. If I’d told my brother, he’d have felt it was his duty to come as the future King of Dale, and he has yet to see his fourteenth birthday. I had no choice.”
“You mean to say that your father does not even know where you are?” Bilbo demands, hands on hips. “He must be worried sick! Gandalf, we can’t have this!” He does not bother to mention that the fire mountain is probably going to erupt when he throws the ring inside. After all, the Wizard knows this.
But perhaps the Valar have smiled upon Bilbo again this day. It does give him an opening for a rather ingenious plan. “You may yet need me,” Gandalf informs the Hobbit. Clearly he has made the same calculations. “I cannot leave, not even to deliver Sigrid safe to her father.”
“It’s not as though he thinks I’m missing,” Sigrid replies. Her voice does not waver. Of course, it wouldn’t. She has spent her entire life under the threat of Smaug, under the oppressive regime of the Master of Lake-town. She has battled orcs, apparently, and seen her home destroyed by dragon fire, just as Thorin has. She does not fear kings or Wizards or any other source of authority. Bard, Bilbo thinks, will be proud, once the steam stops coming out of his ears. “I’m supposed to be getting lessons in diplomacy from Prince Kíli.”
“Lessons in—“ Bilbo stammers, “From— oh, by the Lady, lass, that’s preposterous! And your father believed that?”
“She could find a worse teacher,” Tauriel muses.
“Yes, I suppose that’s true,” Bilbo concedes. Though, truly, if Sigrid wants lessons in diplomacy, she’d be better off asking her own father. “But if she was going to lie to Bard, she may as well have made up something believable!”
“All sound ideas that I’m sure young Sigrid will consider for next time,” Gandalf muses. He may be trying to sound lighthearted, but he has subtly positioned himself behind Sigrid, as though to be certain that nothing will attack her from the back.
She is brave, yes, and clever, and in her time, Bilbo has no doubt that she will be great at this sort of thing. Perhaps she’ll serve as general and advisor to her brother the king. Truthfully, Bilbo doesn’t understand why Sigrid herself won’t ascend to the throne, but then, he won’t pretend to have spent much time studying Mannish lines of succession. Either way, Sigrid is yet a child, and this is no place for her now.
“Tauriel should take the Princess home,” Thorin decides.
“No.” The ring is the heaviest burden Bilbo has ever carried. It was not so bad on the journey. His trials have not been half of what Frodo had to go through. But now, just as he suspected, the ring is pulling out all the stops. It is making one last ditch effort, from what little power remains to it, to keep itself safe. Who knows what will happen when Bilbo tries to throw it into the fire? Well, aside from the eruption that he knows is coming. “You should go, Thorin.”
“What?” Thorin demands. “No. I should not. My place is by your side, and—“
Bilbo cuts him off with a shaky exhale. “If Bard finds out what has happened, he’ll already be in Erebor, harassing poor Fíli.”
“My nephew can handle himself,” Thorin protests, “I would not have made him my regent if he couldn’t.”
“We’ve just had a war, and I don’t want another,” Bilbo reasons, “And there’s more to it than that.” He doesn’t want to use this argument, but he will if it means getting Thorin away from the Mountain. Away from the ring, and what it might turn Bilbo into. In truth, Bilbo cannot forget the moment when he lashed out at Frodo, the feeling of utter rage engendered by the ring. He would have killed his own nephew. What will he do if Thorin tries to prod him into casting off the ring?
Bilbo is prepared for the possibility that he will need to be pushed into the fire. He is prepared for the possibility that he will fall to the faint influence of the ring, that he will not be able to part with it. But he is not prepared to take Thorin down with him. Oh, yes, he knows that his king would rather die by Bilbo’s side, and that he is being entirely selfish by sending him away. But then, Bilbo also knows that Thorin would not push him into the fire, even for the good of Middle Earth. He would not allow Tauriel or Gandalf to do so either.
“What more is there?” Thorin asks. “When my only place is by your side, what more is there?”
“Thorin,” Bilbo breathes, “You are only just recovered from Dragon sickness. You say that the ring calls to you no more than any other piece of gold, but you will know as well as I do that it has gotten stronger in its native land. It is tugging on me like a weight, even now. It does not want to be destroyed, and it will fight. Can you resist its pull? Could you resist a thousand Arkenstones?”
Bilbo is being deeply unfair. “You are stronger than I am, ghivashel.” Thorin brushes his thumb over Bilbo’s cheek, tender and soft. They will not call this goodbye. Perhaps Thorin does not know that it may be. Bilbo doubts that he’d be able to get his love to leave him here if he thought that Bilbo’s death was a legitimate possibility. After all, Bilbo has neglected to mention the bit about the eruption and the bit where he may need to be pushed into the fire.
It might be easier to return to Erebor with Thorin now. They could rule together and be happy and the ring would not be a problem for eighty years. And after eighty years together with Thorin, Bilbo would have lived a better life than he could ever have imagined. Would it really be so bad to just give the ring over to its master, then, after such a long and comfortable peace? It could prolong Bilbo’s life, so that Thorin would not have to watch him die. They could go together into the afterlife, as Bilbo had wanted to do all along. Middle Earth would be no concern of theirs, after they had left it.
“It is trying to manipulate me even now,” Bilbo admits. “It would use you against me. It would bend both of us to its will and we would each be weaker for the threat to the other. The ring knows how painful it is for us to be parted, and it will take advantage of that if it can. You must return to Erebor with Princess Sigrid and ease her father’s fears.”
“How can I leave you in this place?” Thorin asks softly.
Bilbo is fighting tears. Every fibre of his being wants so desperately to go with Thorin now. The bond between them is so great. Could they not share the power of the ring? And it is so weak now, anyway. So very harmless. Why risk himself? Why die, why devastate Thorin, when they could just as easily go home? The home that Bilbo has fought for all this time. The life that Bilbo was promised by the meddling Lady of Lorien.
“I came back to you once,” Bilbo points out, “Across time and against all odds.”
“More than once,” Thorin reminds him. “Did you forget about the battle?”
Bilbo’s laugh is soggy and tearful. “I will come back to you again.” Even if only in the afterlife. Middle Earth must be saved. Frodo must be saved. That is more important than a lifetime of joy for Bilbo and Thorin. These few days together were enough, and even if his mind slips away from him when he walks through that door, Bilbo will take comfort now in the knowledge that Thorin will be safe.
Bilbo leans up and plants a gentle kiss on Thorin’s lips. If it is to be their last kiss, then it will be a sweet one. Soft and loving. A promise of more to come, whether anything is forthcoming or not. “For the road,” Bilbo explains, in response to Thorin’s stunned expression when he pulls away. “I love you.”
“And I love you,” Thorin replies, pressing his forehead to Bilbo’s. They stay like that for an eternity that lasts only a few seconds. At least if Bilbo dies, Thorin will know that he is loved. “Which is why I cannot leave you.”
“Thorin—“
“Did you not follow me on my quest?” Thorin inquires, ignoring Bilbo’s protests and smoothing a hand over the back of his messy hair. Bilbo has been resting on the ground for days now, and he did not exactly bring a comb along. “When all hope was lost, did you not stay by my side? When I became a monster—“
“You were never a monster,” Bilbo argues. “But that is different. This—“
“I will not leave you.” Thorin speaks firmly. “Let the Wizard go with the princess. He will see her safe to Dale and handle the fallout with her father.”
“No,” Bilbo argues in vain. “Absolutely not. I won’t let you do this.” He is aware that he is throwing a tantrum, and aware, despite the painful tugging of the ring, that they have an audience for this conversation. No doubt the others are studiously looking away, ignoring Bilbo’s ridiculous display at the gates of Mount Doom. “I just saved your life, Thorin. I’m not letting you die.”
“There is no life for me without you, ghivashel.”
“That’s a very silly thing to say! You have your Kingdom, your nephews, the rest of the company—“
“I will not abandon you to this fate. If you wanted a quiet, gentle lover who would roll over and allow this madness, you should not have chosen to wed a Son of Durin.” That, Bilbo cannot argue with. He did know that Thorin was very stubborn when agreeing to court him.
“Thorin,” Bilbo tries one last argument. “I may not be able to cast the ring off. I may die. I may need— I may need to be pushed.”
“No.” Thorin grits his teeth. “It will not come to that.”
Bilbo glances in Tauriel’s direction. Of course she is listening to their conversation. Even if Elves did not have some of the keenest ears in Middle Earth, Bilbo and Thorin are yelling so loudly that they have probably woken every fell beast in Mordor. No doubt the Nazgul will not need their master to command them when they have only to follow the sound of shouting to find their quarry. Which is precisely what the ring wants.
The Elf nods, and they arrive at a silent agreement. Thorin will not push Bilbo into the fires of Mount Doom. Not unless his mind is so twisted that he seeks to take the ring for himself, in which case they will have other problems on their hands. But Tauriel will act as needed. She will push Bilbo if it is the only way to see the ring destroyed. Bilbo raises his eyebrows, in what he hopes is an instruction to protect Thorin at all costs. Though he is not sure if the Captain understands.
“The mountain will erupt when the ring meets the fires,” Bilbo warns, “It will be dangerous.”
“My body was made to withstand heat,” Thorin points out, “I might shield you. And then the Eagles will bear us away.”
It occurs to Bilbo that he has no choice but to allow this. He has to let Thorin come with him, or they will die of exposure, arguing on the face of this mountain. He should have known better than to believe that Thorin would ever leave him to his fate. “I love you,” he says again, “Even if I tell you otherwise in there.”
“I am the other half of your soul,” the king reminds him. “I would know your true heart no matter how the enemy spoke through you. But it will not come to that. You are stronger than this ring.”
Bilbo cannot help but laugh. “Oh, don’t tell me that you actually believe that! Stronger than the ring? No wonder you want to put a throne under me, if that’s what you think!”
Gandalf clears his throat. “I think it best if Princess Sigrid and I be going now,” the Wizard decides. Apparently, the decision was never in Bilbo’s hands to begin with.
“Farewell,” Thorin murmurs. But he does not even look at the Wizard as he reaches for Bilbo’s hand. “Let us get this over with.”
“Ah, easy for you to say,” Bilbo grumbles. “Goodbye Gandalf. Goodbye Sigrid.”
The Princess shakes her head at Bilbo. “Do not say it like that, Mister Baggins. You will be back in Erebor soon.”
“And I imagine you will be stuck in Dale for the foreseeable future,” Bilbo replies. He can imagine how he would have reacted if Frodo had attempted to sneak out on a dangerous quest while still a tween, and it does not bode well for the Princess. Bard will be furious.
“Probably,” Sigrid admits, head held high. “I will bring my father news of your safe arrival. And I will speak to your nephew as well, Your Majesty.”
“Very well,” Thorin says, though Bilbo can hear a note of wry amusement in his voice. Even in this moment of terror, knowing what he’s about to walk into, Thorin is clearly not sure how to feel about the idea of Sigrid conspiring in any way with such seasoned schemers as Fíli and Kíli. The three of them will get on like a smial on fire.
“Farewell,” Gandalf says, placing a heavy, meaningful hand on Bilbo’s shoulder. This is much better than the alternative, and Bilbo can see that in the Wizard’s eyes. He looks troubled, yes, but not terrified.
Perhaps Bilbo may die. But unlike Frodo, he understood the magnitude of the risk from the beginning, and it was his decision to make. Frodo was forced to bear the ring by circumstances beyond his control. Someone had to do it, and Frodo was the one who had inherited that burden. But Bilbo could have chosen not to do this. He and Thorin and Tauriel and even young Sigrid knew what peril awaited them when they left Erebor. And still they chose to come, for the sake of Middle Earth. Even if the very worst happens, it will not be for nothing. Bilbo will die sooner than fail, and his death, he knows, will almost certainly result in his success.
Tauriel moves to stand beside Bilbo and Thorin. The three of them watch as the Princess and the Wizard depart. “Let us go,” she decides. “We must make haste. I do not like this place.”
“Oh, don’t you?” Bilbo snaps, but he sees her point. The ring is heavy around his neck indeed, and Thorin’s grip on his hand does not do much to ease the burden. Bilbo is not confident in his ability to do this, and he would really prefer it if at least he could be certain in the knowledge that Thorin was safe. But that, it seems, is not to be.
“Whatever happens,” Thorin mutters, “We will be together in the Maker’s Halls.”
“The Valar will not begrudge us that for saving Middle Earth, I suppose,” says Bilbo. “I hope they let Tauriel in as well.”
The Elf snorts. “I do not think even Lord Aulë would allow such a thing.”
Bilbo takes a decisive step toward the entrance to the mountain. “We will not be finding out,” he lies. Thorin, at least, has the decency not to argue with this.
Bilbo and Thorin walk into the mountain on the narrow path, with Tauriel following behind. It is every bit as horrible as Sam and Frodo told him it would be, a thin strip of stone over a rushing river of fire. The ring is like an oliphaunt around his neck. He should have stayed in Erebor. He should have taken his crown. He should go back and do that now. He could use the ring. He could— no. The ring is useless. Bilbo made it useless. He took away its power when he cast it off before.
The ring is weak. The ring is nothing. The ring is just a shiny bauble. No more than any other piece of gold, as Thorin said, and he was absolutely correct. The ring is nothing.
The ring is everything. Its power will return, if Bilbo only gives it time. Bilbo will be forgiven for his mistake. See, it is already getting stronger. It could not have spoken to him this way a week ago. If he only waits, he can use the ring to his advantage. He can make the entire world bow to him. Nobody will be locking Bilbo in any treasury now, that’s for sure. Nobody will be calling him Mad Baggins now, not if he’s got the ring on. Nobody will be hurting Frodo now.
But nobody ever hurt young Frodo worse than the ring did. This ridiculous, evil piece of metal did irreparable damage to Bilbo’s beloved nephew. It twisted his mind and took advantage of his every fear, his every thought. It tortured him for months on end and made him want to end his life. Bilbo is overcome with rage. How dare the ring try to sweet-talk him, try to use Frodo for its own salvation once again?
Bilbo Baggins has cast off this ring twice before, and both times it was much stronger than it is now. He was able to give it up, to give it to another, and to let the other live. He lashed out at Frodo, yes, but that was only once, and afterwards, Bilbo was able to keep himself in check. Oh, he longed for the precious, yes, how he longed for the precious, but his love for his nephew was greater than his longing. Drogo and Primula died when Frodo was very young. Bilbo was his father from that point forward. Nobody ever used that word, of course, but Frodo was Bilbo’s adopted heir. Even before Frodo came to live in Bag End, Bilbo was at Brandy Hall at least two nights a week while the lad was recovering. Bilbo was the one who bandaged Frodo’s bruises and scrapes, the one who sang to him when he woke up screaming in the middle of the night. Bilbo was the one who told Frodo stories of loss, who proved to him that a person could recover from having one’s entire world torn away.
Bilbo has a responsibility. Not just to Middle Earth, but to Frodo. To his child. That’s what this is, isn’t it? The last time, Bilbo failed.
He failed as a friend, and Fíli and Kíli were killed upon Ravenhill. He failed as a partner, and Thorin died not knowing how loved he was. Bilbo failed as a resident of the Shire, and his homeland was invaded because of his carelessness in dealing with Gollum. But most of all, Bilbo failed as a parent. He failed to protect Frodo. He allowed his child to travel to Mordor with the One Ring around his neck, to be traumatized, to nearly die, because Bilbo himself was too foolish to realize what he had in his possession. He trusted others too much to make his decisions for him, to know better than he did, to have a plan better than his own. And it cost Frodo his happiness, and nearly his life.
Before, Bilbo could be forgiven. He had not understood, had not known. He could not have gotten to Ravenhill five minutes faster. He was running as fast as he could, pushing his body beyond its limits. Fíli and Kíli should never have split up inside the watchtower, and they should both have known that. Indeed, Fíli chose to forge on alone, likely aware that he would die but hoping that perhaps his brother might live. His miscalculation and Kíli’s decision to avenge him do not truly rest on Bilbo’s shoulders. They were not children, after all, but trained warriors defending their reclaimed home.
Thorin never should have sent his nephews to scout alone, and he never should have rushed off to challenge Azog with no support. He was careless, angry, grieving. His thoughts were scattered, his mind still recovering from the weight of dragon sickness and his body much depleted from weeks of scant food and little sleep. He was overcome with battle rage, and Bilbo knows now that had he been awake and present, he could not have prevented Thorin from fighting Azog.
Frodo could have been selfish and refused the Ring. It could have been any of them, Sam or Merry or Pippin, and the story would have been the same. But it was Frodo, brave Frodo, who would never have turned down his duty, would never have allowed another to suffer on his behalf. Brave, kind, selfless Frodo, who tried to go to Mordor alone, and would have done, if not for Sam.
All these people Bilbo loves made their own choices, and all of them suffered for it while Bilbo watched, helpless. But now, he is not helpless. Bilbo has cast the ring off twice before. He can do it again.
Weak, the ring hisses. But it may as well be taking about itself. It has not managed a single word until now. Oh, certainly, it may get stronger, but now? Right now, the ring is barely more than a bauble. A bauble that harmed little Frodo. Sweet, funny, adventurous little Frodo, who once stared up at Bilbo with shining eyes, seeking comfort and protection. Who will one day look again to Bilbo the same way.
“You will not harm my nephew,” Bilbo informs the ring as he throws it into the fire.
Thorin has to stop him from jumping in after it, though Bilbo doesn’t know why. He doesn’t want the ring. How could he want such a thing, with strong Dwarven arms wrapped around him and a scratchy beard pressed into his neck? The contact is steadying. Bilbo wonders if Frodo would have experienced something similar, if perhaps Sam would have been the one to drag him back from the precipice. “You have done it, ghivashel,” Thorin murmurs, “You have done it.”
But Bilbo cannot take credit for this. After all, even in his first life, Bilbo Baggins was the only creature ever to cast off the One Ring. It was no great feat for him, not so much to withstand. If he could get rid of it at its full power, even in the Shire, it does make a certain level of sense that he could toss it away here in Mordor when it is so weak. He had good friends at his back to help him, anyway.
The only reason Bilbo couldn’t have done this before was his own ignorance, his own cowardice, his own refusal to trust others with such sensitive information. It occurs to him, belatedly, that never, in all his life, has he been as plainly truthful with anyone as he was with Thorin when he opened up about his other life. That was all it took for Bilbo. But Thorin has only just recovered from dragon sickness. Who knows what he’d have done a week ago, in the presence of the ring?
“You have done it,” Bilbo breathes, “You have withstood—“
“We have withstood,” Thorin takes Bilbo’s correction one step further. “We have withstood the ultimate temptation.Nothing could be worse, but we have done it. We are… we are worthy now of Erebor’s throne.”
He may be saying we, but Bilbo knows what Thorin means. Ever since he watched Fíli cast off the Arkenstone, Thorin has questioned his own right to rule. He has not believed himself deserving of the crown. Now that he has watched the One Ring fall, has stopped Bilbo from falling along with it, Thorin is finally confident that he can rule Erebor as well as his nephew could.
“We do not have time for this,” Tauriel announces, ushering the couple out of the mountain as the first spurts of fire begin to come up.
They run, then, the three of them, until they are outside and there is nowhere left to go to and the fire of the mountain is lapping at their heels.The weight that is lifted from Bilbo feels significantly lighter than the one that he remembers losing the last time the ring was destroyed. But Bilbo was so much older then, and more frail by any estimation. Now he is young and healthy and he registers it very little before the events of the day catch up to him and all he can do is lay there on the Eagle’s back. That’s step five taken care of, then. Bilbo has done everything that he set out to do.
Notes:
Just one short chapter left after this one, folks!
Chapter 17: Epilogue
Notes:
As always, thanks to everyone who read the last chapter and left comments, kudos! This is just a short little epilogue to tie up a few loose ends, with only a teeny-tiny bit of angst. Enjoy!
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
60 years later
Thorin shakes his head fondly at the pile of boxes in front of him. The lad certainly wasn’t shy about clearing out the study in Bag End, then. Good. Bilbo has been talking Thorin’s ear off for the past six decades about a specific book that he left behind when they embarked upon their journey. Granted, they’ve been back to the Shire more than once since then, but Bilbo always insisted that it would be very rude to rifle through Bag End while the Gamgees were still living there, and even worse to trouble poor Hamfast with the request.
It’s only a book, my love, Bilbo always says, usually after several sustained minutes of carping about the absence of said book. Not worth so much fuss.
Apparently, few of his former possessions were worth very much fuss. When they returned to the Shire for Frodo’s birth, Bilbo took nothing more than his mother’s so-called “glory box.” Kíli helpfully explained that at the time of his first visit, he had believed that the little treasure chest was intended for the scraping of boots, which earned him a fond sigh from Bilbo, some laughter from Fíli, and a hard look from Thorin. Thankfully, Master Gamgee set him straight with a comment about how he’d been the one to clean the box after the party.
At which point, of course, Bilbo apologized profusely, and Kíli joined in with equal fervor. Master Gamgee then reminded Bilbo that this was, in fact, his house. To which Bilbo said, nonsense, and presented Master Gamgee with a deed declaring their joint ownership of the property. Privately, Mistress Gamgee asked Thorin if he thought it was such a good idea for their husbands to co-own, and wouldn’t that get a little bit complicated with all of their many heirs added to the mix? Thorin assured her that the property would pass to her son Samwise, though he was somewhat concerned about what this meant for poor Frodo.
On subsequent visits, such questions have gone unasked, and thankfully, Master and Mistress Gamgee never questioned why Bilbo and Thorin intended for them to give the property to little Sam, who was barely more than an infant when the decision was made. Though this question, too, is already beginning to answer itself, as young Samwise has apparently proven himself to be quite a deft hand with things that grow; of all the Gamgee children, he seems the best able to care for the sprawling gardens, and the most interested to boot.
Besides, Frodo is Drogo’s heir already. He’s going to inherit the sturdy smial that Primula insisted upon building with the small fortune in gold that served as Bilbo’s wedding gift. He desperately wanted to give his cousins more, claiming that, as Prince Consort of Erebor, Bilbo himself had no use for such treasure. Thorin talked him out of this, arguing that to lavish Drogo and Primula with too much coin could have disastrous consequences for the Shire’s economy, assuming that the couple actually spent the money. The idea that they might do so had apparently never occurred to Bilbo, who sat on a chest of gold for sixty years and never bought a thing but buttons with it.
Frodo has a very nice home to look forward to, and Bilbo insists that it is “only right” for Bag End to go to young Samwise. Though the consort claims that he is certainly not trying to push his nephew and Samwise together, at least not yet, he does not seem to have foreclosed on the notion of the pair of them living in Bag End together. He has made baffling allusions to a Hobbit lass named Rosie, as well. Bilbo can be cryptic about his other life when he wants to be, even with Thorin, and he seems to take pleasure in withholding information.
Thorin does not know what Bilbo said to Primula after Frodo’s birth, but it was enough to prevent the accident that had killed the boy’s parents in Bilbo’s first life. A noble sacrifice on his husband’s part, Thorin thinks. With Frodo’s parents whole and hale, the lad is not such a big part of Bilbo’s life as he might once have been. But Bilbo would never allow his cousins to suffer or die when he could prevent it, and so, of course, he intervened. Besides, he and Frodo have kept up a lively correspondence over the past several decades. Now that Frodo is 33 and fully grown in the eyes of Hobbits, he has been permitted to venture as far as Erebor. Thorin suspects that actually, nobody has given Frodo permission to do anything, and he has simply taken advantage of his majority to slip out of the Shire, social consequences be damned.
Frodo, like his uncle before him, is eager to see the world. He is clever, playful, and adventurous, just as Bilbo promised. And Gandalf has conveyed him here, taking great delight in Bilbo’s tale of the one-time end of the Third Age and the role that young Frodo played in it.
Yesterday, Frodo arrived, beaming, with no shortage of questions about the layout of Erebor, how the different levels of the Mountain can be depicted on the same map, and whether Thorin has ever considered commissioning an artist to produce a scale-model of his entire kingdom. Once Thorin answered these inquiries, Bilbo asked Frodo about himself, and the lad prattled on for some time, not about his own life, but about various neighbors and their doings. Bilbo’s jaw was practically on the floor by the end of it, and both Hobbits were laughing merrily.
Thorin could only grin at his husband and adopted nephew. He worried at first that Bilbo might adapt too much to the court at Erebor and eschew some of the Shire customs which once meant so much to him. Now, however, it is plain that these fears were unfounded. Even being dragged across Arda to reside in a mountain kingdom with a Dwarven King for a husband could not stop Bilbo Baggins from being a Hobbit. Thorin is glad of that.
He is less glad about the amount of sorting that has fallen to him, however. Bilbo saves just about every piece of paper he’s ever written on, which is endearing enough, when those papers have not colonized Thorin’s living area. And Frodo, in collaboration with Mrs. Gamgee and with Bilbo’s blessing, has packed up the contents of Bilbo’s study in their entirety and shipped them to Erebor for the consort’s consideration.
Naturally, Thorin would never dream of interrupting Bilbo’s time with his nephew to ask the Hobbits to comb through the clutter, but he did request his husband’s permission to sort through what was there before Bilbo left for the market with a young Hobbit in tow. Thorin has no doubt that Frodo will return with even more cartographical questions than he had when he first arrived. These, Thorin will answer to the best of his ability, though he plans to orchestrate a meeting for Frodo with the guild of scribes, as well. They have some ancient maps within their library which Thorin thinks will be of great interest to the lad.
Oh, whatever you want, darling, though of course I can look at it when I get back, Bilbo assured Thorin with a kiss to his cheek. Just don’t throw anything away, but read whatever you want. There’s nothing very secret in my papers from Bag End, and all of my relations have read through all of it fifty times, I’m sure.
The expression on Frodo’s face made it very plain that he’d never taken the liberty of perusing Bilbo’s tax documents from seventy years ago, and Thorin made a very valiant effort to contain his laughter until his husband and their young guest vacated the royal quarters.
Now that they are gone, the sorting has consumed Thorin’s full attention. He’s enlisted his nephews, as well, though Kíli seems more interested in eating the foodstuffs imported from Hobbiton (“Look, Uncle, they sent Marshmallows!”) and poor Fíli has gotten stuck with a box that truly is just full of tax documents (“Does Bilbo actually need all of this? He’s saved it long enough, I’d feel bad throwing it away, but…”). Thorin, happily, has spent most of the morning unpacking boxes of books, of which there are no shortage.
This box is like all the others, with books grouped together by size rather than subject as a Dwarven librarian would arrange them. There is a piece of paper sitting in the bottom of the box, yellowed with age and marked with Bilbo’s spidery handwriting. Thorin picks it up to get a closer look, expecting an old shopping or reading list, like many of the others he has found in different boxes. However, that is not what he finds at all.
#1: Party
#2: Adventure
#3: Face Dragon
#4: Save Thorin & Lads
#5: Destroy Ring
Thorin cannot help himself. He laughs aloud at the list, endeared by his husband’s determination and uncharacteristic brevity. This is a to-do list, plainly, and Bilbo no doubt wrote it when he woke up eighty years in the past, confused and alarmed but dead set on saving his friends’ lives and then Middle Earth. It’s so like Bilbo to come up with such a straightforward plan, to distill a year of horrors into five deceptively plain stages. To equate destroying the One Ring to hosting a party on short notice, as though both were equally bothersome but also equally possible. Then again, Bilbo did destroy the One Ring, with as much grace and poise as he brought to the task of hosting.
“What is it?” Fíli asks, clearly desperate for an excuse to take a break from the tax documents. As heir to the throne, he spends much of his time being briefed on the economic situations of Erebor and other kingdoms, going over paperwork for trade deals, and, occasionally, overseeing tax collection. His experience with the subject matter does not seem to have granted him any immunity to the resultant boredom.
“Nothing,” Thorin says.
“I don’t think we want to know,” Kíli decides, holding up a paperweight with a preserved dandelion head inside. “This is nice. I’m sure Uncle Bilbo will want it on his desk.”
“He really said not to throw anything away?” Fíli asks. “Even if he needed these records in the Shire, he hasn’t looked at them for sixty years, and I don’t think they’re ever going to be relevant in Erebor, anyway.” Then, he considers it. “Well. Ori might want them for the archives, I suppose. Bilbo is enough of a legend already. I’m sure there’ll be statues of him everywhere, and stories chanted in song and everything else a hundred years from now. Maybe then people might like to read about his charitable donations.”
“Mhm,” Kíli hums, “Besides, the scribes save everything. Remember when Lady Galadriel brought over that boring thank-you note from Durin IV? I thought Ori was going to cry. And I think Dori did cry, for how proud he was of his brother, to be the one to catalogue such a thing.”
“All I remember from that visit was Glóin growling in the corner about how his little Gimli was too friendly with the ‘Witch Queen,’” Fíli recounts. “Which set Balin off about diplomacy and history and everything else, if I recall.”
“Glóin should know better than to bait our dear Lord Seneschal,” Kíli muses. “Anyway, why don’t we just bring all this paperwork to the library now?”
Thorin shrugs. “Bilbo wishes to go through it all himself when he and Frodo are finished for the day.”
“Then why are we looking at it at all?” A wise question from Kíli, who, despite the longer beard, is just as restless as he was on their quest for Erebor. He may never grow out of his boyish charm. Thorin wonders absently if Frerin would have been similar, had he lived.
“Because I want it out of my sitting room,” Thorin snaps.
Fíli snorts. “Your sitting room? And I suppose those are your doilies on the end tables, then?”
Thorin squeezes his eyes shut. Apparently, being an uncle is a lifelong job. Both of his nephews have grown up nicely and are very successful adults with a litany of useful skills and plenty of experience in government and battle both. This does not seem to deter them from pestering Thorin at every opportunity, just as they did when they were small. Probably, they will pester him on his deathbed. “As you know, Bilbo and I share everything.”
This includes the throne of Erebor, for all intents and purposes. Thorin’s reign has been prosperous; Bombur’s kitchens have fed the people well, and Bofur’s mines have kept the kingdom wealthy. Dwalin’s guards have kept the people safe, and Dori’s weavers have clothed them. Bifur has single-handedly re-established the once-famous toy markets of Erebor and Dale, and Óin has ensured that the infirmary is staffed with well-trained healers and employs the safest and most effective treatment methods.
Glóin, as Thorin’s treasurer, and Balin, as his Seneschal, have provided indispensable advice, and Nori’s spywork and political maneuvering continue to keep everything functional behind the scenes. Fíli Mountainheart and Kíli Elfblade have come into their roles as heirs nicely, and even Tauriel has proved an important diplomatic connection as the ambassador from the woodland realm, though there have always been whisperings amongst the Elves that her integrity became compromised upon her marriage to Kíli.
Dís, when she finally arrived, declared herself exhausted with ruling and grateful to no longer have the Blue Mountains under her care. This lasted for roughly three days before she began arranging to travel back to Ered Luin to “sort some things out.” Now, the Princess splits her time between her ancestral home and the home she has built, and Thorin is pleased to see that the line of Durin has two kingdoms to their name. Neither is Khazad-dûm, but none of Thorin’s people have lost their lives to Durin’s Bane, which, he knows, is a blessing he may not have been afforded in a different life.
And through it all, Bilbo has been there for Thorin, by his side. His foreknowledge has proved almost entirely useless, as the destruction of the ring changed nearly everything about the politics of Middle Earth. But his first life granted him important insights and experience which Thorin cannot do without. And even had Bilbo no knowledge of policy and no interest in seriously serving as consort, Thorin would love him with every fiber of his being.
Thorin cannot discount his own role in the prosperity of his kingdom. He was the one to lead his people to this point, as Bilbo so often reminds him. He was the one to overcome the dragon sickness, and every day, he resists any temptation to set foot in the treasury. Through discipline, for the love of his people, Thorin has remained sane and guided those former refugees home. Erebor has been restored and renewed by a worthy king who once did not believe himself deserving of that name.
“Go through your own accounting records, then,” Kíli suggests, tossing the paperweight in the air and catching it.
He’s not going to break it. He’s got a very steady hand, though perhaps not as steady as his brother’s. Still, Thorin shoves the paper in his pocket, crosses the room, and snatches the paperweight away. “Perhaps I will, after lunch.” Another thing about being an uncle: from Thorin’s experience, one’s nephews will have seemingly bottomless appetites for all time.
Bilbo stands beside Frodo in the throne room, where he and Thorin are to meet after an afternoon spent in the marketplace with their respective nephews. The whole family will dine together, and perhaps play a few games in the Royal sitting room before Thorin must return to running his kingdom and the lads will, inevitably, sweep Frodo up into their orbit, where all three will make mischief to their hearts’ content.
“Green Lady,” Frodo breathes, “This is almost as nice as Elrond’s audience chamber in Rivendell.”
“Don’t let Thorin catch you saying that; he’ll have you locked up.” He probably won’t, but he might grumble a bit and interrogate Frodo about his interior design opinions.
“I do like the green stone better than the white,” Frodo concedes. His knowledge of stone-carving is limited, and, like most Hobbits, he cannot identify many different types of stone by sight. Bilbo, too, still struggles with this, even after so many years in Erebor. “But there’s a bit of a draft in here.”
“Ah, yes, well,” Bilbo throws up his hands. “The last time I complained about this room, Thorin tried to have a fireplace installed, but his council voted him down.”
“They’re allowed to do that?” Frodo asks, amused, “I thought he was the king.”
“And he is, but apparently the throne room of Erebor is a protected Dwarven cultural institution, put in place by their great fathers under the eye of Mahal, and not even a king can make changes to it without formal permission.” Bilbo rolls his eyes, because, really, a fireplace would’ve done wonders for the temperature in this room. “That’s Thorin’s own fault, though, since he insisted upon adding safeguards after all that time we spent dealing with the guady gold. His grandfather certainly made more than his fair share of changes, that’s for sure, and I suppose it’s only natural to pass a few laws making sure another king a thousand years from now can’t wreak the same havoc. He could’ve made a few provisions about fireplaces in that law, if you ask me. But Thorin is allowed to put as many fireplaces as he’d like in our chambers, for which I find myself very, very grateful.”
“How does that work inside a mountain?” Frodo inquires. The lad may have reached his majority, but he’s just as curious as always.
It is Bilbo’s greatest blessing to see his boy so healthy and carefree. When he left Frodo so many years ago, the poor lad took no pleasure in food and little joy in literature or the company of his friends. The ring did a number on him, strong as it was, and all those months he carried it. But thanks to Bilbo, Frodo will never have to worry about such things. He’ll live a long and happy life as a cartographer, and he and Sam will someday be co-owners of Bag End. This will give them a nice excuse to live together without turning very many heads, if, as Bilbo suspects, that turns out to be something they’d both like. Though they have plenty of time ahead of them before either needs to consider settlings down. Who knows what Frodo will get up to now, what sorts of joys and dangers he will find upon the road?
He’s got his parents in his life, blessedly, even if it means that he is not half as close as he would have been with Bilbo. It’s strange, having him here and loving him so much, when, as far as Frodo is concerned, Bilbo is nothing more than a pleasant but eccentric relation. Still, Bilbo would rather have Drogo and Primula alive, and Frodo not terribly traumatized from a young age, than have the lad all to himself. Bilbo has Thorin, after all, and the company, and two lovely step-nephews who would positively clobber him if they heard him calling them step-anything.
Bilbo is old now, and perhaps not very long for this world. He has missed Frodo a great deal for many years, truth be told. He has longed, occasionally, for their time together in Bag End, their daily walks, all the hours spent silently reading in the same room.To Bilbo’s mind, this particular sacrifice has been greater than the loss of the ring. But it matters very little. After all, Bilbo already has those memories with Frodo. It would be very greedy of him indeed to try and make them all again just to say he did it.
Bilbo cannot save Frodo from all suffering. He knows this very well. Frodo is still associated with Mad Baggins, who ran off to live with strange folk in strange places rather than stay in the Shire. He has fought with his parents and been picked on by some of his nastier cousins. Lobelia and Otho have been downright rude to him, though that is nothing compared to the way they’ve treated Drogo.
The Shire has had bad harvests, and Frodo’s neighbors have lost animals that he rather loved. The Brandywine has not taken Frodo’s parents, but his dear cousin Marigold lost her life in a boating accident several years ago. And of course, there is the matter of Frodo’s future. If he grows to love Sam, as he did in Bilbo’s other life, or even another Hobbit lad, the two of them will face an uphill battle in the Shire. If, on Frodo’s travels, he falls in love with someone from another culture, he will face just as much judgment in the Shire.
There is still the throne of Gondor to be sorted out, and Bilbo knows that Gandalf has his eye on a group of four Hobbits who he feels will be able to help him on this venture, when the time is right and young Aragorn is prepared to claim his birthright. Remarkably, Bilbo has told the Wizard nothing about Merry’s connection to Rohan or Pippin’s knighthood in Gondor, and yet, Gandalf seems to have selected them, along with Frodo and Sam, to travel to these places all the same. They are, as the Wizard has pointed out, the most adventurous Hobbits in the Shire by far, and all very clever and well-suited to such a journey.
Besides, Aragorn will not be ready to take his throne for some years yet, giving Merry, Pippin, and Sam the time they need to grow up before setting out, or so Gandalf assures Bilbo. There will be some degree of peril ahead for all of them, but at the very least, Frodo has not been left to torture himself cleaning up a mess that Bilbo made.
Life is hard for everyone, no matter what sacrifices have been made on their behalf, knowingly or otherwise. Bilbo cannot give Frodo a life free from pain, though he has wished, sincerely, to do so. He feels a bit like a parent who has given their child up to another family, unable to feed another babe but so, so dedicated to his little darling nonetheless. Frodo has grown up well, and Bilbo is just as proud of him now as he was when he had a hand in the lad’s upbringing.
Ah, yes. Right. Frodo wants to know about how fireplaces work inside the Mountain, as though that is something with which Bilbo has any experience. He feels a bit bad for not foreseeing all the lad’s questions, and he can’t even use the excuse of never having been Frodo’s guardian on this timeline. After all, this is just the sort of question that Frodo would ask, in any universe, no matter his upbringing.
“You’ll have to ask Bofur,” Bilbo decides, when his silence has gone on a mote too long. “Bifur might know, too.”
Frodo laughs. “It seems strange to be meeting all the people from your stories after all these years.”
“I’m glad,” Bilbo offers him a grin. “I think it’s a bit strange for them to be meeting you as well, given all the stories I’ve told about your antics.”
“Antics?” Frodo echoes glibly, “What antics? I’ll have you know that I’m a perfectly respectable Baggins.” He makes a truly valiant effort to restrain his laughter, and only fails a little at the end.
“Mhm,” Bilbo hums, “Yes, well, tell that to Farmer Maggot.”
“I haven’t stolen even a single mushroom in well over a decade!”
“And yet when you were only a little lad, you braved those great dogs all the same, just to get yourself a snack to gobble up between tea and dinner.”
“I can’t believe my mother told you about that,” Frodo grumbles playfully.
“She’s not the only one,” Bilbo admits, “You know, I had a letter from Mrs. Maggot herself when that happened, asking if I might let you know that the heir to the throne of a Dwarven kingdom shouldn’t be going about stealing mushrooms. I have no idea where she picked up the notion that you’re Thorin’s heir, but it’s terrible news for Fíli if it’s true.”
Frodo laughs. “Oh, I hope not. Mrs. Maggot is probably right that kings and princes don’t get half as many mushrooms as impetuous Hobbit lads do.”
“The nerve of you, Frodo Baggins!” But Bilbo is laughing as well. “Now. I’ve heard all your Shire gossip, and you’ve heard everything I’ve got to say about Erebor. I want to know about your work. Are you still busy with that model?”
Drogo was beside himself a year ago when he reported that Frodo had claimed an unused guest room in their smial and devoted the entire floor to some sort of living map project. Apparently, he’s making a scale model of the entire Shire, honing his whittling skills and hoping to move into clay-crafting as well. It took a lot of persuasion on Primula’s part, as well as Bilbo’s, to convince the dear old fuddy-duddy that there was nothing so strange about Frodo’s creative inclinations. It took even more persuasion from both of them, Frodo, and even Gandalf to win Drogo over to the idea of removing the bed, the dresser, and the rug from the guest room so that Frodo might have space enough to truly capture the scope of their homeland.
Bilbo has already spoken with the head of the potter’s guild in Erebor, as well as with Bifur, who is the best whittler Bilbo knows. There are meetings lined up for tomorrow, and Bilbo expects that a certain Hobbit will be returning to the Shire with skills he can put to use in the continued construction of his model. Frodo will not be able to escape from learning on this journey, not that he seems to have any desire to.
“Oh yes,” Frodo grins, and then he launches into a discussion of the trials and tribulations that his model has caused him as of late. Bilbo listens actively, though Frodo’s technical jargon quickly surpasses his uncle’s level of expertise.
When the door to the throne room opens, some instinct turns Bilbo around. He knows, in his heart and in his stomach, that he has lived this scene before. He is reliving a moment show to him by Lady Galadriel, all those years ago, by the shores of the sea.
This is not the first time that such a thing has happened. In fact, far from it. On his first morning back in Erebor after he cast off the ring, following several hours of prolonged sleep, Bilbo woke up beside Thorin and was struck by an overwhelming sense of deja-vu. It took him a moment, a little bit of sleepy blinking and wracking his muggy brain, to understand that this was one of the scenes from the vision he was granted at the start of his quest. The second clear image in the sequence: waking up to the sight of Thorin’s dark hair and broad back. When Bilbo was there in spirit, he tried and failed to reach out. But when he was present in the flesh, he happily traced the lovely, strong spine of his intended before settling back into their warm bed to hold Thorin close.
The second time, Bilbo walked into the library and found the entire company there, just as he saw them from the Greyhavens. It was only a routine meeting, of course, nothing particularly special. Something to do with the chronicle Ori was writing about their journey and the battle that followed, a formal interview which quickly devolved into the same sort of chaos that always abounds whenever the company gets together. Bilbo was glad of the callback to his encounter with Galadriel. He was reminded to be grateful that all of his friends were still alive.
Naturally, as soon as they were home from Mordor, Bilbo and Thorin sat down and talked for several hours. Among many, many other things, it was Bilbo’s task to tell the king the fate of the Moria expedition on his original timeline. Bilbo considered leaving out a few details, but, as always, decided that honesty was a better policy and recounted everything he could recall of Frodo’s description of the mines and the horrors the Fellowship faced there.
Thorin, naturally, took this information to heart, and forbade Balin in no uncertain terms from making any attempt upon Moria. There was a bit of bad blood between them for about a fortnight, but after two weeks of Thorin’s insistence that the halls of Moria were overrun with goblins and worse (Bilbo has no idea how Thorin managed to convince his cousin about the Balrog without revealing the source of this knowledge), Balin decided that it was not worth the argument and devoted himself entirely to Erebor. Though rumor has it that the old Seneschal, who is very old, indeed, these days, has spent many hours of his life studying Balrogs and the slaying of them, so that his people might someday reclaim the ancient halls of Khazad-dûm,
Bilbo might have felt bad, had he and Thorin not saved the lives of three of their closest friends and all the other members of the would-be colony. Not that they’ve ever told anyone about Bilbo’s time travel. It would be too much of a burden for the lads to know about their original fates, and the same, perhaps, is true of Balin, Ori, and Óin. Besides, Bilbo and Thorin have long since decided that it is not good practice to keep secrets from some of the company but share them with others, though of course, a married couple can be excused for having secrets between themselves.
All told, Bilbo is no stranger to reliving moments from that awful, jolting vision which induced him to embark upon his second adventure. But this was the first thing he saw when Lady Galadriel told him to close his eyes: Thorin, walking through the throne room, flanked by his nephews. All three of them are smiling, wearing fine clothes, per usual, with their beards long and healthy.
Bilbo cannot help but grin back. He is reminded, once again, of the wonderful boon that the Valar have granted him. Bilbo knows perfectly well, of course, that it isn’t as simple as all that. Galadriel sent him back in time to destroy the One Ring; getting to repeat his greatest adventure and set things right in the the Battle of the Five Armies was really only incidental to her purposes and those of greater powers. But regardless, Bilbo is overcome with gratitude.
Thorin embraces him, as though it had been weeks since they parted, rather than mere hours. “How has your day been, ghivashel?” The king murmurs.
“Fine,” Bilbo replies, “Lots of walking around the market, though, and of course, we were so busy that we skipped luncheon altogether. I’m starved.”
“We’ll have to remedy that, then,” Thorin declares. Bilbo is vaguely aware of their nephews mingling in the periphery, no doubt trading tales and jokes. “But first, I’d like to show you something I found in the boxes from Bag End.”
“Is it my book on flower language in the first age?” Bilbo perks up, hunger forgotten. “I’ve been looking for that.”
“I know you have, ghivashel,” Thorin replies, sounding fond. “But I haven’t seen that one yet. Are you certain that it truly exists?”
“I’m very sure,” says Bilbo. Then, he considers the question more seriously. “Well, unless I bought it after my first adventure.” That has been the biggest problem by far with being dropped in the middle of his life by Elven magic. Some of Bilbo’s memories have been filed incorrectly, now that he’s lived a grand total of 191 years, which is practically unheard of for a Hobbit.
“We can look for it later,” Thorin assures him, “And if it turns out not to be among your things, I will hunt it down and buy it for you. For now, however…”
Bilbo accepts the yellowed piece of paper, wondering what it could be. When he reads his little to-do list, he cannot help but laugh aloud. Yes, he’s certainly done all of those things, hasn’t he? How lucky he was to get a second chance at everything. The Valar have blessed Bilbo, and he won’t forget their kindness. He is old now, fast approaching the end of his life. Bilbo knows that he is unlikely to get another two decades. The ring, after all, was responsible for the impressive length of his first life. Though, truly, Bilbo could go without that awful stretched feeling that plagued him in his final years, and he won’t be greedy for more life after the great gift of life that he’s already been given.
Bilbo is happier than he’s ever been, happy to grow old alongside his friends in Erebor, happy to know that the Gamgee family is thriving in Bag End. Truly, it has been a delight to watch Thorin rule, to see the joy that has blossomed within him, too, as he has reclaimed and grown accustomed to his beloved home. Bilbo has enjoyed watching Fíli and Kíli grow from young troublemakers into middle-aged troublemakers with passable diplomatic skills, and he is over the moon to see Frodo so well-adjusted and mirthful. Bilbo would give up a thousand years of his own life and a million rings of power to see that happen; twenty years and the one ring seem a fair compromise in the scheme of things.
“For now,” Bilbo picks up the thread of the conversation. His mind wanders so often these days, but that is only to be expected, at his age. “We’d better have something to eat.” Because no matter how many lifetimes he may live, and no matter what may happen to him, he is still, in many ways, the same person who once ran from Bag End without bothering to lock the door or pick up a pocket handkerchief.
“Very well, my Hobbit,” Thorin says, wrapping one strong arm around Bilbo’s aged shoulders.
Notes:
…. and that’s the end! Thank you very much to everyone who has stuck with this story from the beginning (and to everyone who is binging it all in one go). It was a joy to write and I’m so glad to have been able to share it with you all. I have a few other projects in the works at the moment and I’m looking forward to posting those, as well. Bye for now!
