Actions

Work Header

Growing Pains

Chapter 5: Merry Fucking Christmas - Part 2

Summary:

Christmas: 1984.

Notes:

For your patience, I hope you're able to enjoy what's probably the longest chapter I've ever written.

As always, thank you very much for reading!!

Chapter Text

Billy’s memories of the first seven years of his life were blurred – whether that was due to his youth or the frankly ludicrous number of hard knocks he’d taken to the skull was anyone’s fucking guess – but he remembered the last Christmas he’d spent with his mom with perfect clarity. It was the day he’d realised that she didn’t plan on sticking around – that she planned to leave him behind – and ever since, Christmas was nothing more to Billy than another shitty thing he had to endure, memories sour and heart sore.

 

In the years following his mom’s departure there’d been no such thing as celebrating holidays – no Thanksgiving turkey, or Christmas lights, or chocolate on Easter – and though that had changed when the Mayfield’s joined the fucked-up picture, to say that holiday season in the Hargrove household was happy or cheerful would be an overly ambitious lie.

 

Susan – with very little help from Neil, who believed waiting until lunch time to start drinking was some kind of great contribution – did her best to make Christmas anything other than completely miserable, going through the trouble of putting up their cheap tree, labelling presents that she’d bought alone with from Dad, and cooking a decent spread of food for breakfast.

 

Usually Billy helped with cooking – mostly because he enjoyed the mindlessness of flipping pancakes and scrambling eggs, rather than any real desire to assist her – but this year Susan insisted that Maxine be the one to join her in the kitchen. Whether that was because she wanted to instil in her daughter at least some culinary skills, or because it was a good opportunity to actually spend some one-on-one time with her, Billy didn’t know. Hell, maybe it was a mix of both. The downtrodden woman had seemed more attentive since Maxine’s shitshow of a nightmare, to the both of them, which was weird and confusing and vaguely irritating. Regardless of Susan’s reasoning for enlisting Maxine’s dubious help, Billy took great pleasure in waking his sister up and breaking the news to her, grinning unsympathetically in response to her disgruntled, sleepy cursing. He then ordered her into the bathroom to brush her teeth and try to tame her ridiculous bed-head, uninterested in finding long strands of red hair in his food.

 

Neil always slept in whenever work didn’t demand he be up early, which meant that Billy got to plant his ass down at the dining table and do nothing but watch the clusterfuck that was Maxine – who had a bad habit of dismissing small details and couldn’t follow directions to save her fucking life – attempting to be a functional participant in their modest kitchen.

 

The poisonous glower his little sister sent him when he gave her shit for burning the bacon was goddamned lethal, though it only made Billy double down on his cackling insults. Susan did a decent enough job at hiding her own amusement, calmly binning the burnt strips of meat before lowering the heat of the stovetop and placing another raw strip in the pan, telling her daughter to ignore Billy’s heckling and pay attention.

 

Once she was distracted Susan scrunched up a few tissues and carefully placed those in the bin, hiding the proof of Maxine’s ineptitude so that Neil didn’t see and start ranting about wasted food.

 

Maxine managed not to burn the new bacon strip, or the next few, but then Susan had her cracking eggs into a mixing bowl, and that was a whole new and fucking hilarious comedy of errors. Watching his sister fish for eggshells – face scrunched up in abject disgust at the cold, sticky sensation of raw egg against her fingertips – was probably the highlight of Billy’s entire year.

 

It was an… unexpectedly tolerable way to spend the first hour of Christmas morning, though of course the almost light-hearted atmosphere evaporated like smoke once Neil showed his perpetually stern face and rudely ordered his wife to make him some coffee.

 

Billy stood up before his dad had the chance to have a go at him for lazing around – amused smile long gone from his suddenly blank face – deftly manoeuvring between both Maxine and Susan as he set out plates, pored orange juice into a pitcher, and collected the necessary cutlery. Neil sat down at the head of their small dining table – staining his moustache as he slurped disgustingly at his freshly brewed mug of coffee – and waited impatiently to be served, sickly green eyes flicking critically over every new dish as it was placed on the table.

 

Breakfast was as uncomfortably tense as any family meal in the Hargrove household ever was. More so, even, considering the fact that Maxine could hardly bring herself to look at Neil, let alone actually speak to him. Billy and Susan – eyes meeting in an incredibly rare silent exchange of anxious understanding – did their best to direct Neil’s attention away from Maxine’s surly attitude, Susan by plying her husband with more and more food, and Billy by gritting his teeth and forcing himself to talk sports with him.

 

Billy kicked out at his sister’s foot beneath the table – solidly enough to ensure that he had her full and goddamned immediate attention – shooting her a pointed glare when she stopped playing with her food and scowled up at him. Double checking that Neil was currently preoccupied by Susan, Billy hissed out an impatient. “Quit with the sulking, Maxine.”

 

Her scowl deepened, but she finally made a more genuine effort to mask the way she was feeling – hatred and anger falling behind a rudimentary mask of unbothered calm – understanding that she was making things more difficult than they had to be by acting like a bitchy little shit.

 

Once breakfast was mostly gone – Neil having scarfed down at least three servings, while the rest of them struggled to finish their first – Susan automatically began cleaning up, waving Billy away when he moved to help her. 

 

“C’mon, Max.” Neil grunted, pushing himself up from the table and gesturing for her to follow him into the adjoining lounge area. Their slightly ratty Christmas tree stood to the right of the television cabinet, sheltering a few gifts of various sizes beneath it. Two of which were particularly small – obviously from Maxine – and covered in more tape than actual wrapping paper. “I’ll let you open the first present.”

 

Once upon a time such a statement would have had his sister all but sprinting towards the Christmas tree, vibrating with eagerness as she sat down and reached for the largest gift with her name on it. Now, her only response was to repress a grimace and look back at Billy, sending him a pinched look that very clearly pleaded come with me. Billy – who would never feel comfortable leaving Maxine alone with Neil, no matter how much psychic fuckery he’d subjected the man’s brain to – made a show of rolling his eyes, giving her hair a light ruffle before striding past her into the lounge room. Neil shot him a derisive scowl from his reclined position in his favourite armchair, but Billy ignored him with practiced ease and sat himself down on the floor – as far from his dad as he could casually be – legs crossed at his ankles and back pressed against their leather couch. Maxine perched herself above him, close enough that Billy’s elbow brushed her calf whenever he shifted his arm.

 

Neil’s dull green eyes narrowed at them but refrained from making a scathing comment – for all that he liked to pretend they were a normal, happy family, he was never pleased when Billy and Maxine actually appeared to be getting along – instead pointing a thick finger towards the small pile of presents beneath the tree. “Go on, Max.”

 

“Um, I’ll wait for mom-"

 

“Don’t worry about her,” Neil interrupted, his sharp tone edged with irritation. Billy tensed up, but his dad was quick to cover his brief lapse in patience with a reassuring smile. “She’ll be finished cleaning up soon enough.”

 

Figuring that his sister was hesitant to open a gift that Susan had bought her while the woman wasn’t even in the room – the label might say from Mom and Dad, but they both knew that was complete bullshit – Billy nudged her knee with his shoulder and tipped his chin towards the tree. “Mine’s the red box on the left.”

 

Surprised anticipation quickly overriding her unease – their gifts to each other were usually just small, cheap things that they hardly bothered wrapping, let alone boxing up – Maxine rocketed up onto her feet, dashing over to their sparse plastic tree and snatching up the plainly wrapped box sitting on the outskirts of the pile. “To shitbird…” His sister huffed, failing to tamp down a grin as she moved to retake her seat on the couch. “You’re a jerk.”

 

“Yeah? Guess you won’t be wanting that, then.” Billy said nonchalantly, darting a hand out towards the red-wrapped box sitting on her lap.

 

Maxine lifted it up above her head and dramatically leaned away from him, well out of his reach. “No! I take it back.”

 

He smirked faintly, lowering his arm. “That’s what I thought.”

 

“Quit messing around and let her open the damn thing, boy.” Neil barked, harsh voice immediately shattering the playful moment. Clenching his jaw – ruthlessly fighting down the instinctual surge of fear that sent his heart racing – Billy forced himself to meet his dad’s piercing glare before nodding his head in acknowledgement and lowering his eyes. He shouldn’t be fucking scared of Neil anymore. He was nearly eighteen, and that was waytoo goddamned old to be afraid of his good for nothing drunk of a father. Yet, even knowing that Neil’s more violent tendencies were thoroughly trapped beneath layers upon layers of psychic dampeners, Billy couldn’t fully shake the frustrating, shameful fear that only his dad could inspire in him.

 

He was such a weak little bitch. Fucking hell. He hated being so goddamned pathetic.

 

Maxine’s hands clenched around her present, short nails ripping into the red wrapping paper as she struggled to keep her indignant ire in check. She was biting at her lower lip hard enough to bleach the colour from it, which prompted Billy to subtly shift his arm and curl his fingers around her closest ankle, giving it a warning squeeze. “Open it.” He murmured pointedly, wanting to redirect his sister’s focus away from Neil’s dickish behaviour before she did something incredibly fucking stupid. Like mouth off, or try to hit him again.

 

Sucking in a deep breath before exhaling it in a carefully controlled rush, Maxine relaxed her claw-like fingers and started unwrapping her present like a normal, perfectly calm person.

 

Billy watched her with a placid expression, keeping his sudden and completely ridiculous rush of nerves locked down tight. He knew his sister would appreciate what he’d bought for her – he’d learned that practical gifts were always a safe and easy bet – but as he took notice of the rapidly brightening spark of excitement in her pale eyes, not to mention the subconscious little grin currently playing on her lips, he couldn’t help but dread the possibility of disappointing her.

 

Billy had put more thought and effort – and fucking money – into this present than he ever had in the past, but that didn’t guarantee Maxine’s stamp of approval.

 

Not that he gave a shit. The little brat better be grateful that he’d bothered to get her anything at all.

 

Maxine shredded up the last of the wrapping and hooked her fingertips into the unsealed seams of the decently sized cardboard box he’d stashed her gift inside, pulling out a brand new set of obnoxiously bright turquoise skateboard wheels, a packet of pristine bearings, two sets of bushings, two sets of pivot cups, and some shiny new trucks.

 

His sister fucking beamed – freckled cheeks bunching and eyes crinkling around the size of her ecstatic grin – barely sparing Billy more than a glance and a rushed thank you so much before she was running down the hallway and disappearing into her bedroom.

 

Billy snorted to himself at the childish display of eagerness, relaxing back against the couch with a deep sense of satisfaction. There wasn’t any doubt in his mind that Maxine was currently rushing around searching for the few tools she’d acquired over the years, wanting to replace all of the old, dangerously worn-down parts on her second-hand skateboard immediately. She’d been complaining about the slowness of her board for a couple of months now, as well as the unsteady looseness she felt in its joints while riding.

 

He was glad – and relieved – that she was so happy with his present, knowing himself well enough to realise that he wouldn’t have had the grace to handle a negative reaction well. Hell, he probably would have thrown the whole thing into the quarry in a fit of mortified anger, damn the ungrateful little shit and the money he’d spent trying to make her happy.

 

It was just… Billy had never tried so hard – or been so invested – when it came to a Christmas gift before. After the Mayfield’s entered his life and Christmas once again became something that he was expected to celebrate, Billy had gone out and bought thoughtless, impersonal, offensively cheap gifts, because why the fuck should he do anything more than that? Because Neil’s perpetually cynical attitude towards the good for nothing, money wasting holiday had suddenly changed? Because he finally had a wife and a kid that he actually liked, and wanted to play happy family with? Screw that. No matter how many times Neil beat him for his malicious compliance, Billy had been seething with too much furious grief and overwhelming bitterness to do anything other than grit his teeth and silently bear it.

 

The last Christmas he’d spent with his mom – which was both the happiest he could remember, and the most excruciating to recall – had been the last to actually mean anything to Billy, so for Neil to expect him to just… start acting like everything was fine and fucking dandy? To smile, and hide his resentment, and pretend to give a single fuck about any of it?

 

For years Billy had refused – he hadn’t liked Susan and Maxine had been more of an annoyance than anything else – but now… Well, he liked Susan even less these days, but for Maxine he was willing to try and hate the overly festive holiday a little less aggressively.

 

“Where’d you get the money for all that?” Neil demanded to know, frowning suspiciously. His dad had always kept him on a tight leash – setting curfews and routines that he was always thoroughly punished for daring to break – yet he’d managed to completely miss the fact that his son had worked multiple part-time jobs throughout his childhood, and mowed a veritable fuck tonne of rich people’s lawns.

 

Billy was saved from having to answer by Susan and Maxine, the pair of red-heads – one preoccupied with juggling her tools and skateboard, while the other balanced a bottle of beer and a near full coffee mug in her hands – nearly running into each other on their way into the lounge area. Thankfully Susan had far better spatial awareness than her daughter, managing to avoid a collision and the infuriated tirade that Neil would have launched in response to the mess. She sidestepped Maxine and approached her husband with a taut smile, holding out the beer in offering. “Here you go, dear.”

 

Neil took it without so much as a thank you, patting his left thigh invitingly. “Take a seat.”

 

Susan didn’t hesitate to sit herself down on his lap – early on in their marriage she would have, but her sense of propriety had long since been whittled away, right alongside her pride and willpower – masking her vague reluctance by bringing her mug of coffee up to her lips and taking a few long sips.

 

Maxine retook her seat on the couch above Billy’s left shoulder, and he didn’t need to look up to know that she was sporting a disgusted grimace. “Yuck.”

 

Billy snorted at the pure revulsion in her quiet tone, agreeing wholeheartedly. Watching their respective parents be affectionate – and Billy used that term very loosely, knowing that his dad’s brand of care was merely possession, and Susan’s lack of resistance was weakness, rather than consent – was always a stomach churning sight, though their shared disdain did make it easier to endure.

 

Neil sternly ordered Maxine to set aside her skateboard gear in favour of paying attention – which instantly and thoroughly pissed her off – but Billy was able to avert a flare of temper by promising to help her fix up her board, later.

 

The next ten minutes passed relatively quickly, with only the sounds of ripping paper and words of gratitude – that varied wildly in sincerity – breaking the slightly awkward quiet that had descended upon the house. Christmas to Billy had almost always felt like this – filled with false happiness and forced appreciation – but now that Maxine knew what Neil was really like, and Susan knew that she knew, the tension thickening the air was at an all-time high.

 

A part of Billy revelled in it – he’d spent most of his shitty life being miserable on Christmas, so it was about fucking time that he had some similarly miserable company – but another part detested it, knowing that Maxine didn’t deserve to go through even a fraction of the discomfort he’d learned to tolerate. Christmas in their house had never been particularly merry, but this was just straight up fucking uncomfortable.

 

Neil either didn’t notice or didn’t care that nobody was enjoying themselves, taking long swallows of his beer and intermittently squeezing Susan’s bony hip.

 

Maxine received a Walkman and a set of headphones to go with it, as well as a cassette of Kate Bush’s Never For Ever album. Because of course she fucking did. Billy eyed her present with a quiet sense of jealousy, hardly remembering a time when he actually got something he wanted for Christmas. His sister was obviously excited by the gift – pale blue eyes widening with delight as she ripped away the last of the wrapping paper – but a moment later she was doing her best to hide her elation, flattening the grin that had been rapidly forming on her mouth. Billy arched an eyebrow at her deliberately lacklustre thank you, wondering if it was pride that held her back, or if it was simple pettiness. It would be just like his obstinate little sister, to refuse to show either Neil or her mom that she liked the present because she was still royally pissed at the pair of them.

 

Susan was clearly disheartened by Maxine’s lack of reaction, while Neil hardly seemed to notice, too busy reaching for the television remote and flicking over to the sports channel.

 

Susan’s first gift was a fucking cook book – it didn’t even have a hardback cover, the flimsy thing looking more like a magazine than a real, quality book – and even though Billy wasn’t exactly her biggest fan at the moment, he couldn’t help but wince at the clear lack of fucks given by Neil when it came to his wife.

 

Her placidly smiling expression not faltering for even a moment – when it came to Neil she’d developed a goddamned superb poker-face – Susan placed a brief peck on his cheek before moving onto her next gift, which was a small set of brightly coloured nail polishes from Maxine. She tore open Billy’s present last, stilling when her hands fell against the soft material of the simple but warm winter pyjama set he’d bought for her.

 

After Maxine’s nightmare he’d considered fetching his gift back from beneath the tree and fucking burning it, but in the end he’d decided not to, figuring that the money was already spent. That, plus the knowledge that Susan’s life was almost as shit as his own. They might suffer in different ways – Neil didn’t hit her like he hit Billy – but ultimately suffering was suffering, and his desire to be pettily cruel hadn’t been strong enough to overwhelm his pity.

 

Billy was all for kicking someone when they were already down – sometimes an extra hit or two was necessary in order to properly get your point across – but he didn’t enjoy the thought of doing that to Maxine’s downtrodden mom, no matter how frustratingly pathetic she was. Besides, Susan really fucking needed some new pyjamas. Some mornings just looking at her was enough to make Billy shiver, not that he wasn’t already. His own pyjamas were probably in even worse shape – Neil didn’t give a shit when he outgrew or wore out his clothes, and Susan didn’t pay enough attention to notice – but he was determined to get through winter without spending what little money he had left on shit he’d use just for sleeping.

 

Neil planted a solid and nausea inducingly wet kiss on Susan’s mouth when he ripped into his new tool kit, and waved a dismissive thanks to Billy and Maxine for his carton of beer – which Susan had bought for him in their names – shoving his wife from his lap with little care before lumbering out of the room, intent on stashing his gifts in the garage.

 

Susan perched herself on the edge of her husband’s freshly vacated armchair, something like shame flickering over her freckled features when she observed the way both Billy and Maxine’s posture relaxed in the wake of Neil’s abrupt departure. She cleared her throat and tried for a smile, lifting a hand towards the final two gifts sitting beneath their ratty Christmas tree. “Your turn, Billy.”

 

Expectations non-existent – knowing that Maxine’s gift was likely a trinket she’d won at the arcade, and Susan’s some generic bullshit advertised for teenage boys – Billy pushed himself up off his ass and moved to collect his presents. One was tiny and coiled in a truly ridiculous amount of sticky-tape, while the other was a decently sized box with a surprising amount of heft to it. He returned to his seat on the floor with a dubious frown, giving the box a light shake and wondering at the faint but solid thuds emanating from inside.

 

Curious despite his instinctual misgivings, Billy set Maxine’s sad little packet aside and ripped into the box labelled From Dad & Susan, bracing himself for something stupid, or just straight up fucking embarrassing. Two years ago Susan had gotten him a pack of socks and a can of deodorant for Christmas, and to say that Billy had struggled to hold back his bark of incredulously bitter laughter was a huge understatement.

 

He'd managed to maintain his faux gratitude for about five seconds before a mean, sarcastic grin had split his mouth and bared his teeth. Billy had thanked her with such a cuttingly vicious tone that Susan had actually flinched, and he’d felt nothing but vindicated at the sight of her useless shame.

 

Jesus, Neil had left his back a bloody mess as punishment for the disrespectful way he’d spoken to her, but all Billy could remember thinking through the dizzying pain was that it had been worth it.

 

Setting aside the torn wrapping paper, Billy stared down at the instantly recognisable logo stamped onto the shoebox in his lap, disbelief and then confused suspicion coiling in his gut. There was no goddamned way, right? Doc Martens at their cheapest were still nearly one-hundred dollars a pair, and nobody had ever spent that much money on him before.

 

Maybe she’d just had the box lying around and decided to put it to use housing something that wasn’t a pair of kickass boots, though Billy had never seen her wear anything other than plain sneakers or sandals.

 

Even if for some unfathomable reason Susan had decided to get him something expensive after years of only gifting cheap necessities, Neil wouldn’t have ever allowed it. Spending that much on his good for nothing son? As fucking if.  

 

Hands stalled on the lid of the box – fingers clenching against the cardboard as his deeply ingrained cynicism fought against the stupid hope welling within his chest – Billy flicked his narrowed gaze over to Susan, trying to gauge her expression. She looked strangely nervous, and he couldn’t help but throw a glance back in the direction of the garage, stretching out his sixth sense and relaxing marginally when he felt Neil’s preoccupation with his new set of tools.

 

“Billy?” Maxine asked tentatively, drawing his focus back into the living room. “Is something wrong?”

 

Billy ignored her, looking towards Susan once more before glaring back down at the box on his lap. Rolling out his shoulders and ordering himself to get a goddamned grip – clenching his jaw and steeling himself for yet another bitter disappointment – he flipped up the lid.

 

Inside the box was a pristine and attractively sleek pair of sturdy boots, made of dark brown leather – realleather – with heavy-duty black soles and thick black laces. Feeling like his eyes were going to bug out of their sockets at the sight, Billy traced a fingertip feather lightly over a neatly sewed seam, hardly able to fathom the fact that Susan had actually bought them. For him. These shoes were fucking nice – not to mention goddamned expensive – and almost exactly what he would have chosen for himself if he’d had the money.

 

Still, his paranoia didn’t let him enjoy the moment for longer than a few seconds, calling forth a sharp sense of rising unease as thoughts began racing through his head. Billy shut the lid and shot an incredulous look at Susan, climbing hastily to his feet. He shoved the shoebox under his arm, feeling jittery and grateful and so goddamned confused. Was Susan trying to get him in trouble? Bribe him? If so, what for? There was no goddamned way Neil had agreed to pay for a pair of Doc Martens. Especially if they were for Billy. Shit, if his dad saw them he’d be fucking furious.  “Are you trying to screw me over?”

 

Maxine made an inarticulately bewildered noise, no doubt wondering how the hell a Christmas present could possibly screw him over. “Wha-“

 

“No, no, I promise, Billy, Listen.” Susan said quietly, spreading her hands out in what was probably supposed to be a placating gesture. Her sea-blue eyes were wide and vaguely pleading, and despite himself – despite wanting nothing more than to run to his bedroom and hide his new pair of boots somewhere Neil wouldn’t find them – Billy stilled, reluctantly willing to hear her out. She sighed with relief, offering him a shaky smile. “I’ve spoken with your father, and he knows I bought those for you. He won’t cause any trouble over them.”

 

He could sense that Maxine’s mom was telling the truth – or at least, thought she was – which had him cautiously lowering his guard. Billy’s expression slowly softened from a sneer into a far milder frown as he considered a new, far more pressing question. “Why?”

 

Why had she bothered, when she’d never cared to before? Why wasn’t Neil spitting mad, when he’d always despised anything that made Billy even remotely happy? He didn’t understand.

 

Susan’s gaze lowered – her shame and regret strong enough to grate irritatingly against his senses – and Maxine cleared her throat into the awkward, heavy silence that followed. “Um,” She murmured, pale eyes darting between them as she fidgeted anxiously. His sister was smart enough to have realised by now that Neil was the issue – the helplessly frustrated furrow between her brows made that pretty fucking obvious – but she was doing a decent enough job of holding back her sudden surge of anger. “Because it’s Christmas?”

 

Her attempt at upholding the tentatively civil atmosphere was sweet, but naïve and ultimately useless.

 

Billy scoffed, highly doubting that the holiday spirit was the reason for Susan’s sudden and uncharacteristic kindness. It was far more likely that she was simply attempting to soothe her own conscience, still feeling guilty after watching Billy try to calm the emotional shitstorm left by her spectacularly awful parenting in the wake of Maxine’s nightmare. Or maybe she was wasting her money trying to buy his… what? Compliance? Forgiveness? Affection? If it was the latter than her efforts were in vain – he wasn’t some kind of gullible moron – but either way, and no matter how temporary her shift in attitude turned out to be, Billy wasn’t about to stop her from treating him like he was more than some stranger she was forced to share a house with. It’d be a nice change of pace. So long as she didn’t try to push it.

 

Don’t look a gift horse in the mouth, and all that bullshit. A present was a present, regardless of the intentions behind it, and Billy planned on wearing the fuck out of his new boots.

 

“Do you not like them?” Maxine asked, trying and failing to hide how disheartened she was. He turned his head to glance down at her, arching an eyebrow at her slumped sounders and troubled frown. “We’ve still got the receipt, if you want to-“

 

It occurred to Billy then that his little sister had probably been the one to pick which pair of boots her mom should buy – after all, Susan would have absolutely no fucking idea when it came to his preferences on pretty much anything – and in an instant any conflict he felt regarding the gift completely vanished. Susan might have ulterior motives, but Maxine wasn’t capable of that kind of manipulation, and that was enough for him. “Screw that, these are cool.” He dismissed easily, knocking his knuckles against the box and offering her a fond look before redirecting his gaze towards Susan. His faint smile fell flat the instant their eyes met, but his tone was genuine when he said, “Thanks, Susan.”

 

Susan smiled, inclining her head and clasping her hands together in her lap, looking absurdly pleased. “You’re very welcome, Billy. I’m glad you like them.”

 

“I picked them out.” Maxine couldn’t help but chime in, smug as shit.

 

Billy snorted, ruffling her hair as he moved around the couch and towards the hallway. Susan might have spoken with Neil already, managing – and he seriously did not want to know how – to assuage his notoriously unstable temper, but Billy wasn’t about to risk Neil seeing his new boots and deciding to blow a fuse anyway, whatever promises he’d made to his wife be damned.

 

“Hey, where’re you going?” Maxine complained, sitting up and twisting her torso to peer accusingly at him from over the back of the couch. “You haven’t opened my present yet!”

 

“Chill the hell out, shitbird. I’ll be back in a second.”

 

He ducked into his bedroom and yanked open his small cupboard, jamming the Dr Martens box as far as he could behind his dodgy old shoe rack. Billy didn’t care what promises Susan had made, he wasn’t stupid enough to trust that his dad would hold up his end of them. The man had a vindictive streak that stretched on for fucking miles, so as far as Billy was concerned, keeping his new boots out of Neil’s direct line of sight was an absolute necessity.

 

If anything could enrage Neil enough to break apart the psychic barriers Billy had inelegantly placed around his most aggressive impulses, it’d be seeing his disappointment of a son enjoying something he didn’t deserve.

 

Maxine’s present was a small but nice quality Aerosmith keychain, which Billy thanked her for with a brief grin and a light flick to her nose.

 

~

 

“Alright, you lazy shit.” Billy muttered distractedly, setting aside the socket wrench and deftly flipping her newly outfitted skateboard upright, giving it a thorough once over before holding it out to her. While Maxine was perfectly capable of replacing the worn parts on the board herself, she didn’t particularly like doing it, lacking in patience despite the countless times he’d tried to drill it into her stubbornly thick skull. Luckily for her, Billy genuinely enjoyed working with his hands, finding a deep sense of calm satisfaction in his ability to maintain and fix things. Be it his old guitar – before Neil smashed it to pieces – his Camaro, or his stubborn little sister’s skateboard. “Here.”

 

Apparently too excited to register the insult, Maxine dropped her Walkman onto the crumpled sheets of her unmade bed and eagerly scooted forward, taking her new skateboard with wide ice-blue eyes. Billy watched her study the shiny new trucks and spotless turquoise wheels, feeling a pleased warmth settle in his chest at the sight of her happy grin. “Thank you, Billy.”

 

He dismissed her gratitude with a vague wave of his hand, resting his forearm against the edge of her mattress before smoothly pushing himself up from his seat on the floor. For now Maxine was thoroughly preoccupied with her new and improved skateboard, but Billy didn’t doubt that her attention would shift back to her fancy little Walkman before long. “Hey,” He said, waiting until he had her full focus before pointing a finger towards her Walkman. Regardless of the fact that Neil hadn’t ever given Maxine grief over the volume of her music – whereas Billy copped shit for playing anything louder than a goddamned whisper – he didn’t trust the man to continue being so lenient. Especially when he was already more than halfway to drunk and one of his favourite teams was playing. “The Knicks and Nets game will be starting soon, so keep it down in here. Got it?”

 

His sister scowled darkly, but hesitated for only one ire filled moment before grudgingly nodding her head. Only an idiot would get between Neil and his precious fucking basketball, and as much as Billy made fun of her for being stupid, Maxine wasn’t an idiot. “Yeah, I know. I wanted to test out my headphones, anyway.”

 

Billy narrowed his eyes at her aggravated tone but didn’t press, instead turning on his heel and moving towards her ajar bedroom door. He was confident that it’d be at least a couple of hours before boredom drove her to try her luck bothering him, and Billy planned to make the most of that time putting the finishing touches on Steve’s present.

 

“Wait!” Maxine called suddenly, halting Billy just as he’d been about to step out into the hall. Biting back an annoyed huff, he cast a narrow-eyed glance back over his shoulder. He watched with a growing sense of exasperation as she all but threw aside her skateboard – for fucks sake, his sister was absolutely shit at taking care of her things – in favour of jumping up off her bed and pulling open her bedside table drawer. “I’ve got something for you.”

 

“The hell are you talking about?” He asked somewhat snippily, wariness quickly overriding his sense of natural curiosity. Maxine had already given him her gift, and she was too broke to afford giving him another one.

 

She had the gall to glance up and roll her fucking eyes at him, which made Billy seriously consider dismantling all the precise work he’d just put into updating her skateboard. “Just- wait a second.” Maxine rifled almost aggressively through all the random junk collected in her top drawer, muttering where is it beneath her breath before finally pulling out a small rectangular package wrapped in candy-cane themed paper. She held it out to him with a ridiculously accomplished grin, though Billy didn’t have time to even contemplate taking it before she was retracting her arm and hugging the thing to her chest. Expression suddenly uneasy, Maxine swallowed thickly before speaking. “Um, before I give it to you, you have to promise not to be mad at me.”

 

Immediately suspicious as fuck – and preparing to be mad as hell for whatever shit she was attempting to pull – Billy levelled his sister with a deadpan stare. “Maxine.”

 

“Promise.” She repeated staunchly, planting her feet and adjusting her tight hold on the colourfully wrapped package.

 

Billy turned to properly face her, arching an unimpressed brow and eyeing the seemingly innocuous present in her hands. It wasn’t from Maxine – her pocket money didn’t stretch far enough for her to afford more than the keychain she’d already given him – but who the hell else could it possibly be from? And why did she think its contents was going to piss him off? Not knowing was making him feel antsy, and fucking impatient. “I’m not promising you shit, now hand it over.”

 

“Billy, don’t be an asshole.”  

 

“Don’t annoy me, then.” Billy responded bluntly, coming to stand in front of her before holding out his hand expectantly. “Give it here.”

 

Maxine hesitated for a long moment, her flushed face shifting through a range of emotions – frustration, mild guilt, anxiety, and finally resigned acceptance – before she exhaled a forceful breath and all but slapped the gift into his waiting palm. “Urgh, fine, but you really can’t be mad! It’s from Will.”

 

Eyebrows lifting in surprise before once again lowering into a confused furrow, Billy gently turned over the small present in his hands. Sure, the thought of Baby Byers wasting his time and effort – and probably his mom’s hard earned fucking money – getting him something for Christmas made him feel awkward and so ridiculously undeserving he almost wanted to rip his freshly regrown hair out, but he couldn’t fathom why Maxine thought Will’s generosity would make him angry, let alone angry at her. Jesus Christ, how much of an irredeemable dick did his sister think he was? No matter what Byers had gotten him – be it weird or dirt cheap or goddamned broken for all he gave a shit – it was the thought that counted, as disgustingly cliché as that was.

 

Honestly, it shouldn’t have surprised him, that Byers had gotten him something. The kid was too thoughtful – too generous – for his own good, and now Billy had to get him something in return. Shit.

 

Done with Maxine’s cagy vagueness and his own apprehensive wondering, Billy tore into the wrapping without any further hesitation. A bundle of richly coloured pencils looped together with a rubber band was the first thing he saw – their varying lengths and bluntness indicating that they’d been very well used – and folded neatly behind them was a piece of seemingly plain white paper. Intrigued, Billy set the pencils down on Maxine’s desk and carefully unfolded the creased A4 page. He should have guessed that it would be another of the creative nerd’s drawings, and he stared down at it for a long moment before cracking a bemused grin. Like the card he’d made for him when he was still in hospital, Will had once again drawn Billy, only this time instead of being depicted as covered in blood and absolutely batshit insane, he looked like some overdramatic fucker straight out of a comic book.

 

In the drawing – which was impressively detailed for such a young kid – Billy was wearing an old-fashioned ankle length coat cinched tightly at the waist and flaring theatrically around his legs, coloured such a dark blue it almost looked black. It’s drawn up hood cast his entire face in shadow, leaving only the impossibly bright blue-white glow of his eyes visible. A similarly coloured orb of something – energy? – was centred in front of his chest, held there between the palms of his rigidly posed hands. The background was almost entirely empty, shaded with darkness that was occasionally broken by more of those glowing orbs as they circled his lone figure on the page. The Party’s Sorcerer was written along the bottom edge in electric blue, which he cocked a perplexed eyebrow at.

 

Will’s fantastical version of Billy looked like some kind of overpowered madman, and he honestly wasn’t sure whether he should feel flattered or mildly insulted by the interpretation.

 

Billy lifted his gaze to Maxine, studying her nervous grin as he considered why Byers had chosen to gift him with pencils he’d clearly enjoyed using.

 

“It’s cool, right?” She was quick to ask – clearly eager to distract him – yanking open her second bedside drawer and pulling out a similarly creased piece of paper. Baby Byers had drawn her in some fancy skate-gear styled to look like medieval armour, with her wild red hair whipping behind her and her arms held out for balance as she rode her skateboard down a cobbled street. The Party’s Zoomer was the description that Will had chosen for her, which was somehow even weirder than Billy’s.

 

“The fuck is a zoomer?”

 

“I made it up,” Maxine shrugged, smoothing a fingertip over the words and looking incredibly pleased with herself.

 

“Right.” Billy muttered, absently wondering at Byers decision to label him a sorcerer before soundly dismissing his curiosity, figuring that the answer was probably drenched in some nerdy Dungeons and Dragons bullshit that he was really not interested in. He turned his thoughts once more to Maxine’s shady behaviour, quickly coming to the conclusion that his sister must have done or said something to influence Byers gift, something that she knew Billy wouldn’t like. But how could she? It wasn’t as if Billy had ever told her he sometimes drew random shit, and he always took care to keep whatever sketches he didn’t immediately tear up well hidden, crammed at the back of his desk drawer...

 

Which she’d recently had unsupervised access to. Fucking hell, that snooping little shit.  

 

His eyes narrowed into a flinty glare, and Maxine cringed guiltily before throwing her hands up in surrender, not even bothering to try and deny his silent accusation. “I’m sorry! That night- I needed a distraction from- from everything, and you weren’t there-“

 

“Oh, so all this is my fucking fault?”

 

“No! I just- I didn’t mean to go through your stuff, but I wasn’t thinking-“

 

“Clearly.”

 

His sister glared at him, remorse shifting quickly into frustrated ire. Maxine opened her mouth – probably to say something bitchy, judging by the scowl darkening her expression – but after a moment she snapped her jaw closed and squeezed her eyes shut, exhaling a deliberately slow breath. Billy’s angry sneer lost its mean edge as he watched her try to calm herself down, surprised by the atypical display of restraint.

 

Like his own – though only a fraction as vicious – his sister’s temper was easily triggered, and not half as easily soothed.

 

“Look, I really am sorry, alright? I shouldn’t have gone through your things. I won’t do it again.” Maxine assured truthfully, meeting his glowering stare before shrugging her shoulders in an almost helpless gesture. “Um, would it make you less pissed if I said your drawings were actually really good?”

 

“No.” Billy lied, sending her one last half-hearted glare before looking back down at the coloured drawing in his hands. More annoyed than truly angry now – because really, this was his fault for being stupid enough to leave his doggedly meddlesome sister alone in his room – he huffed out a short sigh. “You told Byers?”

 

She winced slightly, nodding. “He wanted to get you something for Christmas, and when he asked me what he should get I kind of just… blurted it out. Sorry.”

 

“You’re fucking hopeless, shitbird. Jesus.” He shook his head, carefully refolding Byers’ drawing and picking up his bundle of used pencils. A large part of him wanted to return them – because imagining the kind-hearted dweeb drawing without his full range of colours made him feel deeply uncomfortable – but he knew that doing so would probably only hurt Will’s feelings. Despite being a mostly unrepentant jerk to pretty much everyone he’d ever met, the last thing he wanted was to be the reason Byers’ sad little face became even sadder. It’d be like kicking a sick puppy. Just… really fucking depressing, and way crueller than even Billy was capable of being.

 

Maxine cleared her throat, ice-blue eyes glinting with cautious curiosity. “I didn’t know you could draw.”

 

Billy sneered more out of reflex than any real malice, shrugging uncomfortably. Whenever his mom hadn’t been busy with work – constantly trying to make up for Neil’s frequent lapses in employment – she’d be standing at her easel and painting, or sitting by a window and sketching whatever new thing had caught her interest. Some of her finished pieces had even sold, and Billy remembered with a rush of painful nostalgia the secret trips they’d take to the local ice-cream parlour whenever she had some money to spare.

 

His mom had been – maybe still was – an artist, always encouraging Billy’s creativity and sharing with him her love of making things, though only when Neil wasn’t around to catch her corrupting his son with useless, pussy bullshit.

 

As a kid he’d thought drawing was fun, but paint had been his mom’s favourite medium, and so it quickly became Billy’s too.

 

When she left, anything even remotely artistic had been promptly and violently eradicated from the Hargrove household. Neil had taken sadistic pleasure in throwing all of her canvases, books, and supplies into the small bonfire he’d made in the backyard. When Billy tried to intervene, screaming profanity he barely understood while furious, grief-stricken tears streaked down his face, his dad had picked him up and threatened to throw him into the fire.

 

The blistering heat had been enough to shut Billy up and send him cowering back to his small room, sobbing into his pillows until he passed out.

 

Billy hadn’t ever dared to touch a paintbrush again – truthfully hadn’t wanted to, the peace he’d once found painting having been turned thoroughly sour by his mom’s abandonment – but drawing… sometimes the compulsion to press lead to paper was just too overwhelming, the chaos in his head begging for an outlet. Even so, it was a bad habit he allowed himself only very rarely to give in to.

 

A lashing was one thing, but the hateful, demeaning vitriol that Neil would spew at him if he ever found out that his only son – who he’d raised to be a merciless, hard-hearted man – liked to fucking draw? Billy smirked emptily at the thought, the raised scars criss-crossing his back burning with remembered agony.

 

It was probably fucking deranged, but most of the time Billy preferred the physical beatings to the verbal ones. The kind of pain that Neil’s razor sharp words could inflict was different, deeper, and those wounds never healed right, if they healed at all.

 

“I don’t draw.” Billy responded after a too long pause, tugging at his short hair and using the brief sting to pull himself out of his morbid thoughts and refocus on the present. He cast his sister a sharp look, pointedly ignoring the concern he could read on her face. “And you didn’t see jack shit in my desk. Got it?”

 

Maxine frowned discontentedly but didn’t argue, instead sighing like he’d somehow managed to disappoint her. “Fine, jeez.” She narrowed her ice-blue eyes at him, head cocking to the left just slightly. “I know you know I was telling the truth, before. Your drawings are… creepy, but good. I don’t understand why you’re being so weird about this.”

 

Creepy, really. It wasn’t his goddamn fault that most of his sleep-deprived, anxiety driven sketches consisted of shit he’d seen in his nightmares, or from the Upside-Down. He’d stuffed them in the back of his drawer as if they were pages out of a porn magazine for a reason. “Maybe because it’s fucking private, Maxine. Jesus.”

 

“Okay! Okay- but if Will says anything, can you please not be mean about it? He was really excited when he found out you like drawing too.”

 

Locking a few choice words behind clenched teeth, Billy turned and left her bedroom, knowing that if he stuck around a second longer he really would lose his fucking temper. Out of all her annoying little nerd friends, Byers was the only one he’d never given any shit to. He wasn’t about to start being a dick to the kid now – why the hell would he, when this whole awkward mess was Maxine’s fault – and screw her for thinking he would.

 

~

 

Max stared down at her restlessly bouncing knee, pressing her palm against it and willing the stupid thing to be still.

 

The day had started unexpectedly well – attempting to help her mom make breakfast hadn’t been too awful, even with Billy running his mouth the whole time – and though Neil’s shitty attitude had swiftly put a damper on the relaxed mood, sitting in the living room and opening Christmas presents had brought it right back up. Or, it had for Max, at least. Her mom just pretended to be happy with whatever she was given, Neil received his presents with barely a thanks before either sitting and drinking, or leaving the room entirely, and Billy…

 

It made Max feel like absolute crap to think about, but before she’d discovered Neil was an abusive piece of trash, she’d never really thought twice about the fact that her brother’s Christmas presents were always really cheap, or impersonal, or just straight up terrible. Like, come on, who in their right mind actually believed that a pack of socks was a good gift idea? At the time she’d thought it was funny – she cringed with shame to recall it now – though her amusement had fled when Billy smiled that cutting smile and Neil started yelling.

 

Christmas that year had been ruined, and she’d blamed Billy entirely for it.

 

The clear lack of effort from both Neil and her mom had made perfect sense to her, and she’d been too childishly spiteful to look past her own shallow assumptions. After all, not only was Billy a giant asshole, he was also constantly getting into fights – that he never seemed to win, judging by the cuts and bruises that were so often marring his face – and he made absolutely no secret of his intense loathing for Christmas. Why would their parents bother getting him anything good, when he obviously wouldn’t appreciate it? Didn’t deserve it? Max had always thought that if Billy could just pull his head out of his ass and stop acting like the world’s biggest jerk for longer than five minutes, then Neil would stop being so hard on him, and her mom might even be less distant. She’d thought he was arrogant and reckless and mean – she still did sometimes, only with none of her previous resentment – and that their parents favouritism towards her was perfectly justified.

 

Max had actually fooled herself into believing that there was nothing wrong with the sheer unfairness of the whole messed-up situation. How could she have been so unforgivably blind? And so completely, mortifyingly stupid? For four years Billy had suffered his dad’s abuse and her mom’s indifference – all while thanklessly protecting her from both – and Max had… God, she’d thought it was Billy’s fault that their parents treated him so differently. So coldly.

 

Even now that she knew exactly what kind of monster Neil was, the awful truth of it hadn’t clicked until she’d witnessed Billy’s strange reaction to his new Doc Martens, and heard her mom’s oddly worded reassurance.

 

All this time, Billy’s Christmas gifts had been so awful not because of anything he did or didn’t do, but because Neil was just that much of an evil piece of shit. It’d never been about punishment, or teaching him anything. It was just… cruel, and neglectful, and Max felt so furiously sick with guilt – the sensation knotting her stomach and lodging in her throat – because what kind of sister was she, if she’d thought for even a second, that Billy had deserved it? Deserved any of it?

 

To make things worse – it was becoming increasingly clear to Max that making things worse might be all she was good for – she’d been stupid enough to ask Billy not to be mean to Will after giving him her friend’s present. As if he would. Billy liked Will, Max was completely certain of that. She just- she’d been panicking a little bit – cursing herself for snooping through Billy’s things – and the words had spewed out of her before she could think better of them.

 

Her brother was a good person. Loud and crude and more than a little bit rough around the edges, but good all the same. On some level she’d always known that, because for all the many instances where Billy was a dick to her, there were also plenty of moments wherein he was protective, or teasing, or even nice, in his own way. Max didn’t think she could forgive herself for being too preoccupied with her own bullshit to see all the blaring neon signs that pointed to Neil’s treatment of Billy being wrong. Even if she’d never seen him hit her brother, abuse wasn’t always just physical stuff, and she should have been smart enough to recognise that.

 

Not for the first time – and certainly not the last – Max wished that a monster from the Upside-Down had managed to sink its claws into Neil before El shut the gate and killed them all. She didn’t care if it made her a terrible person, she just wanted that piece of shit bastard gone.  

 

She startled when Billy poked at her shoulder, blinking her wet eyes and hoping they didn’t give away the fact that she’d felt on the verge of crying for the past five minutes. Max turned her head and tried for an annoyed glare, but it was half-hearted at best and Billy saw through it immediately. He frowned at her before returning his gaze to the road ahead, the tilt of his jaw revealing the mostly faded, finger shaped bruising on his skin. “What’s wrong with you?”

 

Max just shook her head, thinking back to the daunting revelation that Billy could quite literally feel what she was feeling, and then feeling mortified on top of her guilt-riddled distress. “Don’t you already know?”

 

“I’m not reading your damn mind, shitbird. Fucks sake.” He answered; tone caught somewhere between impatient and bemused. “I told you; I don’t want anything to do with your teen angst.”

 

“Well- good, then.”

 

“So?”

 

“So what?”

 

“You gonna tell me what’s got you in such a shitty mood?”

 

“No.” Max grimaced, wondering how Billy would react if she did tell him about the depressing thoughts swirling around inside her head. Maybe he’d scoff and call her a naïve idiot – thinking she deserved to feel like shit after all the pain she’d inadvertently caused him over the years – or maybe he’d tell her not to worry about it, insisting that he didn’t care. If there was one thing Billy hated above all else, it was being caught giving a shit. About quite literally anything.

 

She glanced back over at him, pale eyes widening slightly when she caught sight of the Aerosmith keychain dangling down from the Camaro’s ignition.

 

It felt nice, to see that he was actually using her small gift. Max was pretty sure Billy had thrown away all of her previous Christmas presents, which was kind of disheartening to think about, though she didn’t blame him. They’d all been stupid little gift-shop trinkets that she’d never bothered to put much thought into, and she felt an uncomfortable stab of regret when she remembered her complete lack of effort.

 

Sure, Billy might not have put in much effort either when it came to Christmas – or any other holiday, birthdays included – but she’d never wanted to throw his gifts away, as small as they might have been. Their first Christmas together he’d bought her a dark red cap with a seagull embroidered onto the front, and despite the fact that she’d never be caught dead wearing it, that ugly, ridiculous hat was still sitting in the back of her wardrobe. Even if his gifts were small or cheap or both, they’d at least had some kind of personal significance. Like the seagull cap, sometimes they were even grudgingly funny.

 

Her new and improved skateboard was the best present to date, yet Max felt so wretchedly unworthy of it that she almost wanted to cry, or rip her own hair out.

 

Max frowned to herself and drew her eyes away from the dully glinting Aerosmith keychain, determined to be a better sibling from now on. “I’ll buy you nicer presents.” She vowed seriously, folding her arms tightly across her chest and steadfastly avoiding the confused look he shot at her. “When I’m older, and I’ve got a job.”

 

The way he’d frozen up after unwrapping his new boots, not a single trace of joy on his face or in his eyes… Never again did Max want to watch her brother stare down at a gift like he couldn’t believe it was real, like he couldn’t bring himself to even consider the possibility that it was for him, no strings attached.

 

Max hated Neil for being so disgustingly cruel. She hated her mom for silently going along with it. And she hated herself, for being so blind and selfish.

 

“Knock yourself out, I guess.” Billy eventually responded, shrugging a shoulder before lifting a hand from the steering wheel and giving his new Aerosmith keychain a light flick. “But this is fine, Maxine.” He briefly met her apprehensive stare – eyes lacking their usual sharpness – before once again looking forward, relaxing back in his seat.

 

Max fervently hoped she hadn’t imagined the rare warmth in his electric blue gaze. “Really?”

 

“What d’you think I am, some kind of spoiled bitch?” Billy scoffed, expression twisting into a mild sneer as he shook his head. “I don’t need fancy shit.”

 

“You like your boots though, right?” Max asked, firstly because she didn’t want Billy to be disappointed by what was probably the first real Christmas present he’d received since Daniella left – a fact that made her almost as furious as it made her really freaking sad – and secondly because she’d endured almost two hours of awkward gift shopping with her mom in order to pick them out.

 

He gestured towards his feet, rolling his eyes. “I’m wearing them, aren’t I?”

 

Max leaned over the centre console and craned her neck, feeling something within her chest unclench when she saw that he really was wearing his new Doc Martens. She felt a rush of smug satisfaction at how well they suited him, silently congratulating herself on a job well done. “Do they fit properly?”

 

“Yes, shitbird. Quit stressing yourself out.”

 

Grinning mostly to herself – incredibly pleased that he liked them, and that they fit – Max slumped back into her seat and did her best to stop focusing on the mess of negative emotions trying to consume her. It was Christmas, and if Billy had forgiven her for telling Will about his creepy drawings – she wasn’t sure if he really had, but he at least didn’t seem too angry with her anymore – then she wasn’t about to let her own bad mood ruin the rest of the day.

 

~

 

No matter how many times Max visited Steve’s house, she didn’t think she’d ever get over just how absolutely massive it was, or how depressingly empty.

 

Billy drove up the long driveway with a quiet growl of the Camaro’s engine, parking and getting out without a word. Max rushed to follow, tucking Steve’s present into the front pocket of her hoodie. She circled towards the back of her brother’s car, watching with a slowly widening smile as he popped open the trunk. Billy stared down pensively, hesitating to actually reach in and pull out the gift he’d made for his – only? – friend.

 

It was rare that she ever got to see Billy as anything other than immovably confident – because even when he wasn’t, he was really good at pretending to be – and though she knew she shouldn’t, Max couldn’t help but tease him. “Worried he won’t like it?”

 

“Fuck off.” Billy snapped, sending her an irritated glance before pointedly snatching up the wickedly redecorated baseball bat he’d been working on for the past week. He gave it a harsh swing – fast enough that she could hear it swooshing through the air – and Max took a swift step backwards, eager to remain far away from the ridiculously long and sharp nails poking out from the top. Her brother smirked at her hasty retreat, twisting his wrist in a smooth arch as he gave the bat a flashy spin. “I don’t give a shit if he likes it.”

 

Max stuck her tongue out at him, refusing to be impressed. “You do realise the whole point of Christmas presents is to get people things they’ll actually like, right?”

 

“Not this time.” Billy answered flatly, eyes going distant for a moment before he gave his head a firm shake and slammed the trunk shut.

 

Left wondering what the hell that meant – deeply unnerved by all of the decidedly ominous possibilities – it took a moment for Max to realise that Billy was already halfway up the footpath leading to Steve’s fancy patio and huge front door. Cursing creatively under her breath as she glared at her brother’s denim-clad back, she once again hurried after him.

 

Billy rang the doorbell, though Max wasn’t sure why he bothered when he was too impatient to wait for the high-pitched chime to finish. Instead, he raised an arm and thumped the side of his fist against the darkly polished wood in a serious of door-rattling knocks. “Hey Steve, open up! It’s cold as shit out here!”

 

Max winced at her brother’s unapologetic loudness, reflexively glancing around the quiet, perfectly maintained street for sign of any disgruntled neighbours. Luckily there weren’t any, but she jabbed her elbow into Billy’s side anyway, fending off his retaliatory poke with a wild flail of her arm. “Can you not yell at the top of your lungs? You’re gonna piss someone off.”

 

“Like I give a shit about any of the rich fucks in this neighbourhood.” He dismissed easily, slipping a hand under her guard and digging his fingers mercilessly into her ribs. Stifling a snort of unwilling laughter – she hated being ticklish – Max whacked his arm away and did her best to maintain her wobbling scowl, to which he responded with an unapologetic, shit-eating grin.

 

It took Steve another thirty seconds to finally answer his door, swinging it open before proceeding to stand in the threshold and stare, his wide brown eyes darting rapidly between the Hargrove siblings’ faces before settling on Billy’s and narrowing. Max tensed slightly – dreading a comment on the healing split in her brother’s lower lip, or the faint bruising marring his jaw – but Steve only asked, “What the hell are you guys doing here?”

 

The senior’s rumpled pyjamas, pillow creased face, and ridiculously wild bed hair made it obvious that he’d only just woken up, which made Max feel kind of bad. In stark contrast, Billy gave no indication that he’d even noticed Steve’s bedraggled appearance, though she thought she spied her brother give him a brief once over before smirking very subtly. “Funny way of greeting guests, Stevie. You gonna invite us inside, or what?”

 

Rubbing sleep from his eyes and smiling like he didn’t want to but couldn’t stop himself – broad shoulders relaxing as tension all but fled from his tall frame – Steve shook his head and stepped aside. “Get in here, asshole. Hi, Max.”

 

“Dick.” Billy tutted amusedly, knocking his shoulder into Steve’s as he moved past him, deftly keeping the nail-tipped bat out of his line of sight.

 

“Hi, Steve.” Max smiled, relieved that the senior wasn’t annoyed by their unexpected visit. “Merry Christmas.”

 

Steve blinked down at her, his reluctantly pleased expression softening into something a lot less reluctant. Max couldn’t imagine spending Christmas alone – as shitty as her mom was, at least she was there – and thought she might understand why Steve would prefer to sleep the day away. Like Billy, the senior tried to hide it when things bothered him. Unlike Billy, he was kind of terrible at it. Everyone had noticed that while he might grumble and complain, Steve never actually said no whenever Dustin demanded he grant the party access to his spacious living room.

 

His house – mansion, really – was too big to live in all by himself, and though Max knew her brother would never admit to being motivated by something so undeniably sentimental, she suspected that Steve’s loneliness was the entire reason they were here. Despite Neil’s drunken protests and her mom’s quiet disappointment, Billy had been adamant about visiting the senior today. On Christmas.

 

Max had never seen Billy act like a real friend before, and she wondered if- no, when she’d stop being surprised by her brother’s severely underused ability to not be a complete douchebag. His antagonistic personality and general aversion to any feeling that wasn’t connected in some way to anger or disdain didn’t exactly scream friendship material – Billy was always popular, but that didn’t necessarily mean he was liked – yet instead of just tolerating him, Steve seemed to genuinely enjoy having Billy around.

 

Max didn’t want to say that it was a miracle her brother had found someone patient enough to deal with all of his heaping piles of bullshit, but… Anyway, it was a relief, to know that she wasn’t the only one who really cared about Billy. Moving to Hawkins might have sucked – the freaky, blood-thirsty monsters certainly hadn’t helped them settle in – but at least they’d both finally gotten some decent friends out of it.

 

“Merry Christmas,” Steve said sincerely, closing the door behind Max as she hopped into the tastefully furnished – and tinsel free – foyer. He turned to face Billy, who’d perched himself on the back of the senior’s cream coloured sofa. “Uh, not that I’m not happy to have you guys over, but what are you doing here? Did something happen? What-“

 

“Untwist your panties, Steven.” Billy cut in, flashing a mean smirk when the senior huffed in annoyance, worry forgotten. “It’s your lucky day. Maxine wanted to spread some Christmas cheer.”

 

Max shot her brother an incredulous look – she’d had to bargain and plead for Billy to let her come with him – but managed to fix her face in time to meet Steve’s confused stare with a quirked grin and a shrug. Just this once, she wouldn’t call her brother out for such a blatant lie. It was the least she could do after blabbing to Will about something that she’d known Billy would have wanted to keep to himself.

 

Max pulled Steve’s present from her hoodie’s front pocket and held it out, giving it a slight wave when all the senior did was blink down at the small, mostly tape wrapped packet. “It’s not much, but… here.” The absence of Christmas decorations in the senior’s house painted a pretty depressing picture – making it obvious that Steve hadn’t expected to celebrate the holiday at all – so even if her gift was just silly and inexpensive, Max found herself glad that she at least had something to give him.

 

“I- thanks, Max.” Steve murmured as he finally took the gift, a slowly widening smile spreading across his mouth as he attempted to tear away the ample amounts of tape she’d used. “Jesus, you really sealed this thing tight, huh?”

 

Billy snorted, watching Steve struggle with a small, amused quirk of his lips. “It’s one of Maxine’s few talents.”

 

“Jerk.” She scowled, flipping him off.

 

Eventually, the senior managed to open his present, and Max felt a surge of relief flow through her when he grinned at the tiny pair of neon orange sunglasses dangling from the keychain pinched between his fingers. He seemed genuinely pleased by the small gift – if also slightly baffled – eyes warm as he studied it from a few different angles. “Wow- uh, this is great, Max. Thank you.”

 

Max beamed, happy that he liked it. “You’re welcome.”

 

“Matches her hair.” Billy commented, tone too casual to be anything other than teasing.

 

“It does not.” She snapped, flipping him off with both of her middle fingers this time.

 

Completely unconcerned by their harmless bickering, Steve stepped around Max and approached the dark-wood cabinet standing by the front door, plucking his car keys from the pretty blue-green bowl sitting atop it with a clink of metal against ceramic. With her hands and middle fingers still raised distractedly towards Billy, Max watched with a mixture of satisfaction and uncertainty as Steve attached his new keychain. It was nice of him to do, but she doubted a high-school senior really wanted to show off such a childish decoration. “You don’t have to put it on your keys, I-“

 

“No way.” Steve interrupted, the concentrated furrow between his brows relaxing slightly as he glanced up and sent her a reassuring smile. He held up his BMW’s keys, jangling the newly attached miniature sunglasses. “These bad boys are coming with me everywhere I go.”

 

Billy huffed out what might have been a laugh, which drew Max’s attention back towards him just in time to see him lean back and pick Steve’s new spiked bat up from where he’d hidden it out of view on the couch. Her brother hefted it carefully in both hands, expression serious as he gave it one last scrutinising examination. It must have met his lofty expectations – it would come as a surprise to most, but her brother could be a bit of a perfectionist – because Billy straightened up from his comfortable slouch against the back of the sofa and rolled out his shoulders a couple of times. He looked oddly tense, as if he was bracing to fight Steve, rather than give him a gift.

 

After double checking that his neon orange accessory was firmly secured, Steve dropped his keys back into the ceramic bowl with a quiet plink and turned towards the stairs, movements becoming almost jittery. He glanced quickly between them – somehow completely missing the baseball bat held by Billy’s side – before holding up his hands in a wordless request for patience. “You guys wait here. I’ve got- just hold on a minute.”

 

With that, he dashed up the stairs three at a time, his fuzzy-socked feet somehow not slipping against the carpeted steps. Max stared after him – feeling slightly mystified by the sudden departure – before turning to stare at Billy, who was shaking his head and… smiling, electric blue eyes uncharacteristically warm. “He’s so fucking stupid.”

 

Max couldn’t hold back an undignified giggle, pointing incredulously at the bat. “How did he not notice?”

 

“Guy’s oblivious as shit.” Billy answered with a shrug, his quiet tone almost landing in the realm of fond, as unlikely as that seemed.

 

Before Max had the chance to ask any questions – or tease him for no longer being above having a best friend – Steve came racing back down the stairs, holding what looked like a small black drawstring bag in each of his gently curled fists. She perked up eagerly at the sight of two presents, not having expected the senior to get her anything. As much as she liked Steve, he was Billy’s friend, and when he’d asked Max for present ideas his questions had been centred solely around her brother, not her. It’d felt too presumptuous to assume he’d buy her a gift – people didn’t typically buy presents for their friend’s siblings, did they? – but she should have known that Steve was too nice not to have gotten her something.

 

“I was gonna give these to you guys whenever I saw you next, but since-“ Steve’s socked feet skidded slightly as he came to a sudden stop at the bottom of the stairs, staring with wide brown eyes at the spiked baseball bat that he was only just now noticing. “Jesus, that’s- Billy, what the hell?”

 

Billy rolled his eyes, shifting slightly in place before giving the bat a small, restless swing. He smoothly adjusted his grip and offered the weapon to Steve handle first, shrugging carelessly. “Byers’ hand-me-down was looking pretty beat up the last time I saw it, so I figured you could use a new one.”

 

“You- I-" Steve looked utterly stupefied, absentmindedly handing both drawstring bags to Max before stepping into the living room. He came to a stop directly in front of Billy, gaze darting rapidly between his face and the spiked bat still in his hand. “Did you make this?”

 

“No, I bought it like that.” Her brother deadpanned, maintaining his flat expression for a second before he gave Steve a mild sneer. “Yes, jackass, and fuck you if you don’t like it.”

 

The senior quickly shook his head, snatching the bat up like he expected Billy to suddenly change his mind and refuse let him have it. “Like it? Dude, this thing looks like it could take someone’s damn head off.”

 

“Kinda the idea, Stevie.”

 

Max darted around Steve and joined Billy in leaning against the back of the couch, watching intently as the senior studied his unusual present. From what she could remember, the baseball bat her brother had chosen to remodel was both longer and wider than the one Steve had been swinging around during the demo-dog invasion. The wood it was made from was also darker – knowing Billy it was probably stronger too – and there was a lot of dark blue tape wrapped in firm, criss-crossing lines around the handle. Her brother had sharpened each and every single one of the ridiculously long nails he’d used until they could draw blood at even the barest touch, hammering them into the bat in neat, deadly rows.

 

Compared to the spiked baseball bat that Jonathan had made, Billy’s looked professional. Or, as professional as a homemade weapon could possibly be.

 

Steve took a wide step backwards and gave it an experimental swing, letting loose a breathless laugh before adjusting his grip and doing it again, this time with more intent behind the movement. It was blatantly obvious that he was impressed with Billy’s craftmanship, and a brief glance up at the side of her brother’s smugly satisfied face told Max that he knew it too.

 

“This is…” Steve’s wide smile faded somewhat as he brought the tip of the bat up towards his face, narrowing his eyes at the razor sharp nails embedded within it before turning his gaze to Billy. “It’s- thank you, Billy, this is awesome, but, uh…” He ran a hand through his messy hair, wincing slightly when his fingers snagged on a tangle. “I guess I just wanna know, is there a reason why you think I need a new one? Like-“ Steve tapped a knuckle against his own temple. “Any more bad feelings?”

 

Max’s head snapped towards Billy, questions already piling up on her tongue. What bad feeling? When had Billy felt it? Why hadn’t he told her? He silenced her with a warning glare – as much as she wanted to know what the hell Steve was talking about, pissing Billy off wasn’t going to get her any answers – which he turned on Steve when Max subsided with an annoyed pout. “Your old bat’s shit, so I made you a new one. Don’t overthink it, Steve.”

 

Dubious but just as unwilling to test Billy’s good mood as Max was, the senior slowly nodded his head. “Yeah, okay- but you’d tell me, if that changed?”

 

“Me too.” Max said firmly, more of a demand than a question.

 

Billy glanced between them; expression inscrutable for a long moment before he waved a dismissive hand and jerked his chin towards the small drawstring bags that Max had almost forgotten she was holding. She hadn’t noticed it before, but each bag had a different coloured string. One grey, and one white. “Those for us?”

 

Steve and Max shared an incredulous but unsurprised look, neither fooled by the abrupt change in topic for even a second. It was clear that Billy didn’t want to talk about whatever bad feelings the senior was referring to – nor was he willing to agree to talk about them in the future – and while neither of them wanted to let it go, they both recognised the futility in pushing. Billy would either talk about it or he wouldn’t, and pressuring him would only serve to seal his lips even tighter than they already were.

 

“Yeah.” Steve answered belatedly, looking suddenly incredibly nervous, holding his spiked bat in front of himself like a shield. “Let’s- c’mon, let’s sit down.”

 

Max rounded the couch and sat down – like a normal person – while Billy simply bent his legs up, did a one-eighty, and then slid down onto the middle cushion, somehow managing to make the move look well-practiced rather than idiotic. Steve gently placed his baseball bat down on the glass coffee table before sinking into one of the plush armchairs, leaning forward with his elbows on his knees. “Uh, the one with the white string is yours, Max.”

 

Billy snatched the other drawstring bag from her palm, tossing it up into the air a couple of times as he judged its negligible weight and lack of firm shape. Max watched him intently, her own present held unopened in her hands. She was mostly sure that Billy would like it – Max might not have seen what Steve ended up choosing, but she still knew what it was – and she wasn’t about to miss even a moment of her brother’s reaction.

 

Annoyingly perceptive, Billy clocked their nervous anticipation pretty much immediately, frowning at the pair of them before deftly retightening the grey drawstring. “What?”

 

“Nothing-"

 

“Just open it already!”

 

“Don’t fucking rush me, shitbird.” He snapped, reaching out and flicking her in the centre of her forehead. Max reeled back with a muttered curse, though she resisted the strong urge to retaliate when she noticed that Billy was finally opening the bag.

 

He tipped the contents out onto his awaiting palm, stilling when a simple gold chain coiled in the centre of his hand. Max made note of the way Billy’s electric blue eyes widened, and felt a thrill of hopeful excitement when his jaw actually dropped, lips parting in mute surprise. Her brother discarded the drawstring bag and gently lifted the necklace, blinking at the subtly glinting gold hanging from his fingertips. In Max’s opinion it was perfect – not delicate enough to be feminine, but nowhere near bulky either – yet she still held her breath, waiting for Billy’s verdict.

 

Billy turned his head to stare at Steve, who mustered up an anxious smile. “Do you like it?”

 

Her brother’s expression twisted from open astonishment to something edged with tension – conflict arising in the clench of his jaw and the slight furrow of his brow – which was never a good sign. “How much-"

 

“No, nope, you don’t get to complain because you think it was expensive.” Steve cut him off, waving his hands and pinning her brother beneath a deeply knowing look. “I didn’t pay a single cent for it, and I know you can tell that’s the truth.”

 

Billy narrowed his eyes, “How’d you get it, then?”

 

“Um.” The senior hummed reluctantly, warm brown eyes flickering away as he ran a hand through his thick hair. “Funny story… I stole it. From my mom.”

 

There was silence in the wake of Steve’s confession, both Hargrove siblings simply staring as he began to fidget in his seat, cheeks flushing with embarrassment.

 

Billy was the first to break it, barking out a rough but genuine laugh as he shook his head and clutched the necklace against his chest. “Let me get this straight, you’re giving me fucking jewellery, from your mom.”

 

“…Yes?”

 

“Why?”

 

Steve looked almost desperately to Max for some assistance, which she gave once she’d gotten her entertained grin under control. “You always used to wear a necklace. I dunno if the old one broke, or if you got sick of it, but..." She shrugged, hoping that Billy wasn’t about to admit to hating it. “Me and Steve thought you might like a new one.”

 

“You were in on this.” Billy accused quietly, rubbing his thumb in a slow back and forth motion over the gold chain. He seemed stuck somewhere between being upset and being pleased, his expression twitching subtly as he tried to process what was happening.

 

Despite the fact that it wasn’t a question, Max had absolutely no intentions of admitting to anything until she knew whether her brother loved or hated the gift. If he ended up hating it, well, she was shamelessly going to do everything within her power to make that Steve’s problem to deal with.

 

Billy rolled his eyes at her lack of response, once again shifting his focus to Steve. “Your mom won’t miss it?” The stare he pinned Steve beneath was slightly menacing, which Max thought was unnecessary. The senior knew her brother pretty well by now, which meant that he knew far better than to try and lie to him.

 

“No, definitely not.” Steve was quick to reassure, looking thankful to be able to give an answer that was both true and what Billy wanted to hear. Probably. It was hard to know what was going on in her brother’s head at any given moment. “She’s got like- a million necklaces, and that’s just counting the stuff that she didn’t take on the cruise with her. Trust me, she’ll never notice it’s gone, so… if you want it, it’s yours.”

 

“Alright.” Billy said flatly, lifting the golden chain and giving it a considering look. “How many karats?”

 

“Uh…” Steve stuttered uncertainly, expressive eyebrows drawing down in what could have been worry, or disbelief.

 

Max smacked her brother’s closest arm, shooting him a glare as she felt her cheeks flush from second-hand embarrassment. “You can’t just ask that, you assho-“

 

“I’m fucking joking, Maxine. Calm the hell down.” He knocked his elbow into her side, cracking a mean grin when he saw Steve slump back in his seat with undisguised relief. “Want to take it back yet?”

 

Steve just rolled his eyes, rubbing a hand over his face in an effort to hide his quirked smile. “I should. You’re such a dick.”

 

“Just curious, do you know how many karats it is?”

 

“Even if I did, I wouldn’t tell you.”

 

Snorting in amusement – utterly unbothered by the senior’s refusal – Billy threaded the necklace through his fingers until he came upon the small clasp. He used his blunt thumbnail to undo it before lifting the chain up and circling it around his neck, hands fumbling as he tried and failed to re-connect the clasp. It took about five seconds for her brother to become frustrated, shoulders tensing as an irritated frown creased his features. “Motherfucker…”

 

Max opened her mouth and started to raise her hands – intent on offering to do it up for him – but Steve beat her to it, all but jumping up out of his seat. “Here. I got it.”

 

Billy dropped his hands back down into his lap, scowling up into Steve’s guileless eyes like he couldn’t decide whether he wanted to strangle him with the chain, or just take the path of least resistance – for once in his life – and hand it over to him. “Goddamn- fine. Stupid fucking thing.”

 

Steve took the necklace with a grin that only deepened her brother’s scowl, dropping himself down on Billy’s other side hard enough to jostle the entire couch. Max grinned at her brother’s muttered fatass, and laughed outright when Steve quipped back with an impressively fast shorty.

 

“Screw you, Harrington.” Billy snapped, though his faint smirk belied his irate tone. “A couple of inches hardly counts.”

 

The senior waggled his eyebrows, and it took only a fraction of a moment for Billy to catch onto his silent innuendo, punching Steve’s closest shoulder and cackling. It took Max a couple of seconds longer, and when she got it her disgusted grimace sent both high-schoolers into a fit of nearly hysterical laughter.

 

“You’re both so gross.” She complained, struggling to maintain her horrified expression through the cheerfulness and very reluctant amusement warming her chest. It was nice to hear Billy laughing so freely, even if the cause of his laughter was a terrible dick joke.

 

“Hey,” Steve said, voice shaky with lingering mirth. “I didn’t say anything.”

 

Max huffed, shaking her head and folding her arms. “You didn’t have to. Do boys ever grow up?”

 

“Steve’s brain isn’t developed enough for that.”

 

“Dude, you laughed!”

 

“No idea what you’re talking about.”

 

“You- whatever, Billy. Hurry up and bow your head forward a bit.”

 

“Don’t tell me what to do.” Billy grumbled even as he did as Steve asked, tipping his chin down as he leant forward just slightly.

 

Steve adjusted the unlinked necklace in his hands and carefully looped it around the front of Billy’s neck, his movements smooth and efficient. He was careful not to touch him unnecessarily – no doubt having noticed over the past couple of months that Billy wasn’t exactly a big fan of casual contact – but Max could tell from her brother’s relaxed posture and slowly blinking eyes that he wasn’t bothered by the close proximity. Which was… good, but surprising.

 

She wondered idly if Steve realised what it meant, that he was allowed such relatively easy access to Billy’s highly prized personal space. How much Billy must trust him, and how exceedingly rare that was.

 

Her brother’s shorter hair and bowed head revealed a faint scar that trailed down from beneath his hairline, a few centimetres long and located near the middle of his nape. Max watched Steve stare at it with a rising feeling of apprehension – his face doing something… complicated, only to flatten into a disturbingly unreadable mask barely seconds later – fervently hoping that he wasn’t stupid enough to say anything about the pale mark. Billy didn’t talk about his scars. Ever.

 

The senior clasped the necklace without uttering a word – thank god – releasing the chain and allowing it to settle flush against Billy’s skin. Believing that the threat of Steve shoving his foot into his mouth had passed, Max gladly released the breath she hadn’t even realised she was holding.

 

A breath that she promptly choked on, because instead of moving away Steve leaned fractionally closer, brown eyes dark with something like fury as he proceeded to purposefully brush the tips of his fingers over Billy’s small scar. Like he was studying it, or like he was confirming to himself that it was real.

 

Fully expecting Billy to jerk away and curse the senior out for his sheer audacity, Max prepared to make a quick getaway back to the Camaro, allowing herself only a fraction of a second to mourn the friendly atmosphere. A large part of her wanted to be mad at Steve, but she just couldn’t summon the anger, not when she could guess exactly how seeing that mark on Billy’s skin had made him feel.

 

Back in Hawkins General, seeing what had to be at least five different cigarette burns dotting her brother’s left forearm… Max had felt so indescribably livid. Then she’d cried until she ran out of tears. Then she’d felt so sick she’d been sure she was going to throw up.

 

In short, Max perfectly understood Steve’s actions, even as she wished he would have- not ignored, but at least not reacted to the small sign of Neil’s longstanding abuse.

 

Like she’d expected him to, Billy did shift away from Steve’s touch, though it was less the violent flinch she’d expected and more like a startled shiver. Her brother reached up and waved aside the senior’s hand – though even that movement was far less aggressive than Max had anticipated – covering his nape with his palm before shooting Steve a look that very clearly communicated the question; what the fuck is wrong with you?

 

Cheeks flushing a pale red as he winced – looking guiltily apologetic but not necessarily like he regretted what he’d done – Steve dropped his arm back down to his side and shuffled over until there was at least a foot of empty couch between them, giving Billy back his space. “Sorry, that was weird- I just…” He exhaled a sharp sigh, hands clenching into fists in his lap. “I just really fucking hate your dad, you know? I don’t think I’ve ever hated somebody so much.”

 

Max fought back the instinctive urge to loudly and vehemently agree, biting down on her lower lip in an effort to keep herself quiet as Billy continued to stare at Steve like he’d grown a second head. “The hell’s my dad got to do with-“

 

“You’ve got a scar, on the back of your neck.”

 

Blinking in sudden comprehension, Billy’s hand grew tense against the back of his neck, fingers curling into his skin hard enough for his nails to leave shallow divots. He sneered, all of his previous levity well and truly gone. “That’s nothing, alright? Just some scrape I got as a kid.”  

 

“Okay.” Steve agreed, soft tone free of any kind of judgement or condescension as he met and fearlessly held Billy’s glare. “I… Sorry, Billy.”

 

“You should be fucking sorry.” He groused, maintaining his heated glare for another few seconds before picking up the discarded drawstring bag sitting in his lap and throwing it directly at Steve’s unhappy face. It connected with a solid but quiet slap, staying in place against the senior’s nose for a second before being displaced by his long but accepting sigh. The comedic sight seemed to help soothe Billy’s remaining ire – his scowl becoming marginally less severe – and he sunk back into the comfortable couch cushions with a huff, directing a pointed look at the unopened drawstring bag still held in Max’s hands. “C’mon, let’s see what this loser got you.”

 

“Loser? I steal a necklace for you, from my mom, and this is the thanks I get?”

 

“You just wanted an excuse to grope my neck, you freak.”

 

Steve’s face went red, the violent shade managing to rival Max at her most mortified. “I- what- I did not!”

 

Cautiously amused by their bickering – comparing them to an old married couple within the safety of her own head – Max dug her fingers into her drawstring bag and excitedly pried it apart.

 

~

 

Steve gave his slowly melting McDonalds soft serve a broad lick – Billy had forced both of his passengers to swear on pain of death that they wouldn’t spill so much as a single drop on his leather seats – somehow managing to get a small dollop of ice-cream on the tip of his nose while he was at it. Billy caught himself smiling at the idiot and nearly swore aloud, flattening his expression and forcing his gaze firmly back to the empty road ahead.

 

He was still annoyed at him, for fucks sake.

 

Never one to let quiet sit for long, Max took another bite out of her own ice-cream before saying, “I can’t believe you didn’t notice my ears aren’t pierced.”

 

“I’m sorry, Max.” Steve groaned long sufferingly, not for the first time and likely not the last, knowing how much Maxine liked to complain. The senior’s present to his sister had been a really nice pair of earrings – small gold hoops with sharp, almost dagger-shaped rubies dangling from them – but of course Maxine didn’t wear jewellery. Steve’s face when he’d realised his mistake had been fucking hilarious. “Instead of giving them to Billy, you could always just get your ears pierced?”

 

“Your solution is for me to get stabbed?”

 

Billy tuned out the rest of their light-hearted squabbling with ease, one hand resting casually on the steering wheel while the other fidgeted with the gold chain around his neck. Back when he’d worn his mom’s necklace every minute of every day, he’d had a bad habit of pulling on it – especially when he was stressed or preoccupied – and despite all the years he’d gone without wearing one, it was a bad habit that Billy was already slipping back into.

 

Knowing how much Neil hated any and all reminders of Daniella, Billy had always been careful to keep her Saint Christopher necklace tucked safely beneath his clothing, out of sight and out of mind.

 

He should have known better than to think that would be enough.

 

About three years ago Neil had been smacking him around a bit – Billy couldn’t even remember what he’d done to deserve it – and a particularly rough shove to the ground had dislodged his mom’s necklace from its place beneath his shirt. Neil’s face had turned almost purple with rage at the sight of it, and he’d knelt over Billy’s prone form with petrifying speed, breath stinking of rum as he screamed in his face about that fucking good for nothing bitch and her useless saints. His dad had ripped the chain from around his neck and tossed it aside like it was nothing, meaty hands reaching next for Billy’s throat.

 

Billy didn't know how he’d managed to escape, only that doing so had saved him from being strangled to death. He did remember snatching up his mom’s pendant from the floor before fucking booking it, ignoring Neil’s slurred roars demanding that he come back and face his punishment like a man.

 

He’d hidden the pendant in a small plastic container beneath their house after that, unwilling to lose it to Neil’s hatred.

 

Billy had always wanted to wear it again – sick at the thought of his mom ever finding out that he’d stashed her precious Saint Christopher pendant away in the dark – but a lack of funds and an overabundance of fear had always been enough to stop him from getting himself another chain to attach it to.

 

Of course Maxine and Steve had absolutely no idea about the history behind his old necklace, but that didn’t matter. What mattered was the fact that Maxine had even remembered it in the first place, and that Steve had apparently thought nothing of taking something he’d believed Billy would like from his mom’s things.

 

Mrs Harrington might be a neglectful bitch, but the woman had good taste in jewellery, if nothing else.

 

He gently twisted the gold chain between his fingers, already itching to thread his mom’s Saint Christopher pendant onto it. This necklace… it was the most meaningful thing anyone had ever given him, and the warm, disgustingly squirmy feeling coiling in his guts whenever he looked over at Steve’s stupidly handsome face was seriously starting to piss him off. The ghostly sensation of the older boy’s fingers on the back of his neck was still fresh in his mind, and Billy wondered at the shivery feeling of not fear that had wracked down his spine at the barely there touch. If anyone else had dared to put their fucking hand on his neck he would have been liable to start swinging – or at the very least hurling aggressively descriptive threats – but apparently Steve was exempt from his more violent instincts.

 

Billy couldn’t decide whether that was a good thing or not, and he hated feeling so uncertain. He gnawed at the healing split in his lower lip and frowned at nothing in particular, wondering why this whole friendship thing had to be so fucking mushy, and weird, and complicated.

 

Having scarfed down his soft serve while Billy wasn’t paying attention, Steve popped open and glove compartment and began to rifle around inside with hands that he was lucky weren’t covered in ice-cream residue. The junior arched an eyebrow at the blatant invasion of privacy, his overly sentimental and goddamned confusing thoughts falling to the wayside. “The fuck are you doing?”

 

“Have you got anything other than rock in here?” Steve asked plaintively, picking up an ACDC tape and frowning at it before turning expectant eyes towards Billy. “Springsteen, or The Beatles? What about Queen?”

 

He scoffed derisively, “Should I get out some ABBA?”

 

“You have ABBA? Where is it?”

 

Maxine giggled quietly in the backseat while Billy rolled his eyes so hard it gave him a spontaneous headache, reaching over and jabbing his fingers into the senior’s ribs. Steve jerked away with a startled – and ticklish,Billy noted slyly – cry, dropping the Scorpions cassette he’d been looking at. Shielding his ribs by holding his arm tightly to his side, the senior lent forward to pick up the cassette from the footwell while giving Billy an annoyed side-eye. “Dude, what the hell?”

 

Billy just shook his head, biting back the urge to grin. “I’m gonna make you a mixtape, pretty boy.” He decided spontaneously, first because Steve’s current taste in music was a goddamned travesty, and second because after what the senior had given him, a nail studded baseball bat didn’t feel like enough. “You’ll thank me later.”

 

“Okay?” Steve answered, sounding mildly confused but not against the idea. He winced as a particularly loud scream from Robert Plant rang out through the Camaro’s speakers, and Billy made a mental note not to add Kashmir to the mixtape. “So… Beatles?”

 

“I’m never letting you in my goddamned car again.”

 

Maxine snorted, leaning forward and sticking her arm between the front seats to point at the glove compartment. “Queen should be in there somewhere.”

 

“Change my music and I’ll drive us into a fucking ditch, Harrington.”

 

Grinning cheekily – ridiculous hair falling charmingly over his forehead and whiskey brown eyes bright – Steve ignored his empty threat and happily renewed his search through Billy’s collection of tapes.

 

~

 

Billy pulled the Camaro into The Palace Arcade’s mostly empty parking lot, absently drumming his fingers to the beat of Dragon Attack on the steering wheel. He’d spied a sign while driving past earlier stating that they were open despite the holiday, and he figured that while a body-odour infused cesspit wasn’t exactly the most ideal hangout location, it at least wouldn’t be boring.

 

“Hey, what’re we doing here?” Steve asked curiously, straightening up and peering out at their surroundings.

 

Maxine stuck her upper body into the space between the two front seats, frowning doubtfully at the arcade’s purple and orange front doors. “Is this place even open on Christmas?”

 

Wordlessly pointing out the large red sign that stated OPEN FOR CHRISTMAS hanging in the arcade’s window, Billy deigned to answer Steve’s – only marginally less stupid – question. “Like hell are we going back to your depressing as fuck mansion, and our house isn’t even an option, so. Arcade it is.”

 

Maxine shrugged, agreeing easily. “Okay.”

 

Steve held up his hands in the universal sign for time out, his face the picture of confused offense. “For the millionth time, I don’t live in a damn mansion-"

 

“Uh-huh. Tell that to the nerds-"

 

“-and why’s my house depressing as fuck?” The senior continued doggedly, more than used to Billy’s penchant for interrupting.

 

“Maybe depressing isn’t the right word?” Maxine interjected, though her subtle wince and tentative tone made it clear that it very much fucking was.

 

Billy arched an eyebrow, “Can you think of a better one?”

 

“Guys, seriously, my house is fine.”

 

“Um.” His sister hummed, eyes narrowing in concentration as she tried to come up with a better suited description for Steve’s massive, empty house. “Lonely?”

 

Steve flinched like Maxine had hit him, eyes falling to his lap and lips pressing into a tense line. Within the safety of his own head the senior might have agreed with her – as much as Billy hated other people, even hecouldn’t imagine not being affected by such prolonged bouts of isolation – but it was obvious that nobody had ever told Steve to his face that they thought his house was anything other than great for parties. His so called friends had probably simpered about how lucky he was to have it all to himself, wishing that their own parents were even half as uninvolved in their vapid little lives.

 

Hell, Billy highly doubted that anyone had bothered to recognise how completely fucked it was that Steve’s parents routinely abandoned him to occupy those empty rooms and hallways alone, too distracted by the image of the perfect suburban dream to see it for what it really was.

 

Wary of genuinely upsetting Steve – Maxine had a gift for pressing on hidden wounds, and Billy was intimately familiar with the sting of her obliviousness – he shot his sister a quelling look. She clocked it immediately, flicking her ice-blue eyes over Steve’s pale face and grimacing with regret. Leaning back and grasping the closest door handle, she muttered a quiet meet you guys inside before making a quick escape from the awkward atmosphere she’d inadvertently created.

 

The slam of the Camaro’s back door sounded almost deafeningly loud in the ensuing silence. Billy scratched at his jaw, keeping an uncomfortable grimace off his face through sheer force of will. He wasn’t good at this – wasn’t good at comfort – but he wasn’t about to let Steve drown in his misery without at least trying to pull him out of it.

 

Steve was patient enough to forgive his fumbling attempts, anyway.

 

“You alright?” Billy asked bluntly.

 

The older boy cleared his throat, pulling on a smile and quickly reaching towards the door. Billy would have been offended by Steve’s obvious eagerness to get away from him, except he really didn’t want to be here either, which was why Billy very graciously decided not to hold it against him. “Yeah, ‘course.” Steve lied, shoving open the door.

 

Billy pulled it shut again with a brief curl of his fingers – since the giant clusterfuck at Hopper’s cabin he’d been practicing his control a lot – and continued to silently foil Steve’s increasingly frustrated attempts to get out of the Camaro. Eventually the senior realised that something not quite right was happening, turning his head and cursing angrily when he was met with the sight of Billy’s wicked grin and lightly bleeding nose. “Not cool, man. Let me out, now.”

 

“Nah, I don’t think I will.”

 

Steve gave the door one last shove before letting out an infuriated grunt and throwing up his hands, directing an almost startlingly severe glare Billy’s way. “Why the fuck not?”

 

Smirk falling flat as he wiped the back of his hand under his nose – swallowing blood and the smidgeon of unease that Steve’s rare anger inspired in him – Billy answered using a deceptively casual tone. “You lied to me, Steve.”

 

The taller boy blinked, thrown off guard. “What?”

 

“What Maxine said, it bothered you.” Billy stated flatly, cocking his head to the side and watching as Steve’s eyes darted away, the sharp set of his facial features twitching into something almost ashamed. The sight inspired none of the cruel amusement that it once might have, and Billy was surprised by the intensity of his desire for the return of Steve’s typically easy-going, affable expressions. What the fuck was he even ashamed of, anyway? It wasn’t his fault that his parents were neglectful assholes, and it sure as shit wasn’t his fault that everyone he’d grown up surrounded by were a bunch of small-town, closed-minded dicks.

 

Steve shook his head, rubbing a hand over his face before running it agitatedly through his mussed hair. “No it didn’t-“

 

“You’re still lying-”

 

“Get out of my head, Billy!”

 

“I’m not in your head! Just- Christ, I’m not trying to piss you off, alright?” Billy held up his hands in a gesture of peace, hoping that he looked at least half as sincere as he felt. He understood perfectly well why Steve believed him capable of violating his mind like that – he was an irreverent asshole with a bad temper and a cruel sense of humour – but the accusation hurt anyway, like a too tight clench in his heart.

 

When Steve did nothing but glower at him – restless and unhappy but also resigned – Billy said, “Maxine… she didn’t mean it as a dig, or anything. She just- doesn’t really think shit through before she says it.”

 

The senior relaxed somewhat, slumping back into his seat with a long sigh. Still, he refused to meet Billy’s gaze. “I’m not offended.” He muttered truthfully, staring out through the windscreen. “I just- is that what all the kids think? That my house is lonely? That I’m…”

 

Billy scoffed, shaking his head. “Those kids fucking love your house, and they think the sun shines out of your ass.” He hummed a short note, imagining Wheeler’s pointy face and reconsidering. “Except maybe Wheeler, but that kid’s a bitch.”

 

Steve finally cracked a smile – small as it might have been – and Billy felt a thrill of satisfaction at the sight of his subtly upturned lips. “You really don’t like the Wheeler’s, huh?”

 

“What’s there to like? All they do is judge and whinge and think they’re better than everyone else.”

 

“Oh, really?” The taller boy asked sarcastically, throwing him an incredulously amused glance. “That totally doesn’t describe anyone else I know.”

 

“Hey, fuck you.” He snapped, resenting the implication that he was anything like Nancy ‘The Priss’ Wheeler. Billy reached over – smacking at Steve’s knees until he got the hint and shifted his ridiculously long legs aside – and punched open the glove compartment, clicking his tongue at the disorganised mess the senior had left it in. He rooted around for a few moments before making a victorious noise, pulling out a pack of cigarettes and his spare lighter. Steve declined when he held it out in offering, moving his hand towards the centre console and lowering the windows while Billy clamped a smoke between his teeth and lit it up.

 

For a while neither said anything, and despite the previous tension the quiet was comfortable, broken only by the music still coming through the speakers. Billy smoked – savouring the soothing rush of chemicals as they sank into his system – and if it weren’t for the lingering unease leaking into the slightly smoggy air surrounding Steve, the atmosphere could almost have been labelled peaceful.

 

Fiddling with the skin warmed chain of his new necklace, Billy realised that he hadn’t even thanked Steve for it. He didn’t particularly want to – awkward tension already collecting in his shoulders at the mere thought of having to express genuine gratitude – but he knew that the older boy deserved to hear it. Steve might not have paid any money for the chain, but he had stolen it from his mom, which wasn’t nothing.

 

He liked the thought of Steve rifling through his mom’s apparently extensive collection of jewellery and picking something out with only Billy in mind. He also liked that the senior knew him well enough to make a damn near perfect choice.

 

Billy had always shied away from even just the possibility of being known so well – the closer someone was, the more power they had to hurt you – but when it came to Steve, he was becoming increasingly confident that the kind-hearted, lonely idiot wasn’t someone he needed to protect himself from.

 

“Thanks,” Billy said, the word coming easier than he’d expected it to. When Steve tilted his head in confusion Billy hooked a finger beneath his necklace and gently tugged it forward. “For this. It’s cool.”

 

“Oh, yeah. You’re welcome, Billy.” Steve was quick to answer, completely failing to tamp down his absurdly pleased little grin. “I’m glad you like it, and… thank you, too.”

 

Now it was Billy’s turn to be confused. “What for?”

 

“You know, for coming over today.” He explained with a deliberately casual shrug, grin turning slightly pained. “And for getting me out of my depressing house. I appreciate it. Really.”

 

The senior’s tone didn’t sound bitter or sarcastic – more plaintive than anything else – and Billy could sense that he was being completely sincere, yet he still winced at hearing his own thoughtless words come out of Steve’s mouth.

 

The senior didn’t have anything to thank him for, anyway. Billy had just- he’d just wanted to get out of his own house – to get away from Neil’s irate shouting at the television, as well as Susan’s weird attentiveness – and he’d known that Steve wouldn’t turn him away if he showed up at his. That was all. He’d been motivated by selfishness, not care, or worry, or any other sappy bullshit like that.

 

“Maxine was the one who wanted to swing by.” Billy lied, taking another drag of his smoke before sticking it out the window and tapping away the ashes, all while shoving down the unexpectedly sharp feeling of guiltstabbing into his gut. Lying was second nature to Billy – so much of what everyone knew about him was almost entirely built upon lies – and he’d never felt particularly bad about it before. Hell, he lied to Maxine all the damn time without so much as a second thought, so why would lying to Steve goddamned Harrington be any different? “I was just playing taxi.”

 

“Uh-huh.” Steve nodded, Bambi eyes warm and lips still faintly upturned.

 

Billy narrowed his eyes, suspicious. “What?”

 

“Nothing.” Steve said, though his widening smile – which he tried to hide by turning his face away – told Billy that it very much was something. Before he could demand to know just what the fuck had the older boy looking so chipper, Steve continued. “As much as I like breathing in second-hand smoke, we should probably head inside before Max comes looking for us.”

 

Though he very much doubted that his sister cared about anything apart from whatever arcade machine she’d stationed herself at – if she’d managed to pilfer a quarter from somewhere – Billy hummed a vaguely agreeing note and flicked away his half-finished cigarette. He wound up the windows and cut the Camaro’s quietly rumbling engine, smoothly stepping out onto the cracked asphalt.

 

Billy had never actually been inside Hawkins’ only arcade before, and he sneered at the tacky decor that immediately assaulted his eyes upon entering. The walls and ceiling were painted a dark purple with blue and orange accents, and the carpeted floors – who in their right mind carpeted a place that they knew a bunch of rowdy, disgusting kids were going to be stomping through? – were patterned with a mess of multicoloured stars. The front kiosk was to the left of the entrance, lined with prizes and signs advertising all the sugary shit they sold, while flashy arcade machines were lined up in rows to the right.

 

It didn’t smell as bad as he’d assumed it would – more stale than anything else – but that probably had less to do with cleanliness and more to do with the fact that there were only a few kids currently milling around. Flicking his gaze over their pimply faces, Billy wondered for a moment whether they’d chosen to spend Christmas at the arcade, or been forced to by extenuating circumstances.

 

Deciding that he didn’t really give a shit either way, he shifted his focus towards spying a head of red hair amongst the arcade machines.

 

“Ugh, it’s Keith.”

 

Billy followed Steve’s wincing stare, arching an eyebrow when he caught sight of the ugly dude sitting in the kiosk. The guy was digging his hand into a huge bag of Cheetos, and judging by the dark orange stains surrounding his mouth he’d already eaten way too many of them. “Who the fuck is that?”

 

“He’s a senior.” Steve murmured, resolutely looking up at the ceiling when Keith slowly shifted his dull gaze towards him. “Like- he’s fine, I guess. Just- super weird, and kind of creepy.”

 

“My bad, I thought you were about to introduce me to your best friend.” Billy taunted, grinning meanly in the face of Steve’s annoyed glare before looking back towards the Cheeto muncher. When Keith met his piercing stare Billy let his expression fall into an ominously blank mask, finding cruel satisfaction in watching the weird motherfucker nearly snap his own neck in his rush to look away.

 

They moved through the rows of arcade machines without a real destination in mind – though Steve kept hinting unsubtly at his preference towards Pac Man – and found Maxine with ease. His sister was enthralled in what looked like an intense game of Asteroids, utterly oblivious to everything that wasn’t pixilated on the screen in front of her. “Fuckin’ nerd.”

 

“Damn, level ten already? Dustin wasn’t kidding about how good she is.”

 

“Don’t let her hear you say that. She’s got a big enough head about it already.”

 

Continuing on – Steve’s departing good luck going entirely ignored – they made their way to the final row of arcade machines, and Billy narrowed his eyes at the blonde kid that was currently playing Pac Man. He stepped forward – fully intending to intimidate the scrawny teen into migrating to a different machine – but paused when Steve placed a lightly restraining hand on his shoulder. Billy shot the taller boy a questioning look, to which he responded with a shake of his head. “Let’s not traumatise some random kid, alright?”

 

Billy rolled his eyes. “Why not? You’re the one who wanted to play that stupid game.”

 

“First of all, Pac Man isn’t stupid, and second, we can just wait, Billy.” Steve wheedled, using the hand he still had clasped on the junior’s shoulder to turn him away from his would be victim. Billy allowed the manhandling with only a mild scowl, wondering why the fuck he’d let himself become friends with such a frustratingly decentguy. Steve smiled tentatively, gently squeezing his shoulder before dropping his arm back to his side. “I’m sure it’ll be game over soon.”

 

Rolling out his faintly tingling shoulder, Billy leant back against an unoccupied Missile Command machine with a reluctantly accepting, “Fine.”

 

Steve politely informed the kid that he had the next game, flashing a quarter and a charming smile. The boy sent him a brief glance – the thick lenses of his hilariously overlarge glasses making his green eyes look fucking bulging – before returning his focus to the screen without so much as an acknowledging nod.

 

Billy grinned unsympathetically at Steve’s flabbergasted expression, and snorted when he turned around and pulled a face. The senior came to stand beside him, cocking a hip and folding his arms like he was someone’s disapproving parent. “Can you believe that? Kids these days, man.”

 

“What are you, fucking fifty? Kids these days.”

 

“Hey, you can’t tell me that little shit wasn’t rude.”

 

“Still against traumatising him?” Billy asked mockingly.

 

Steve huffed, shaking his head. “Yeah. I mean, if he’s hanging out here on Christmas?” He winced sympathetically, whiskey brown eyes going all soft as he glanced back over at the blonde kid. “His day’s probably bad enough already.”

 

“Doesn’t make him special.” Billy scoffed, thinking back to all the Christmases he’d never celebrated – December twenty-fifth passing with only silence or pain to mark the occasion – and then all the Christmases where he’d been shoved to the side, an outsider within his own fucked-up family.

 

Sometimes Christmas wasn’t a happy occasion. Tough shit.

 

“I guess not.” Steve agreed quietly, kicking his red Converse against the starry carpet with a sigh. He didn’t speak again for a few long moments, but Billy knew better than to think the lull in conversation would last. The senior was radiating a sudden, sort of melancholy agitation against his sixth sense, and while Steve was many things – dyslexic, tall, and prone to worrying, just to name a few – he typically wasn’t someone who remained silent when something was bothering him.

 

Or at least, he wasn’t whenever Billy was around.

 

Eventually Steve lifted his eyes from the colourful carpet and met Billy’s uncharacteristically patient stare, anxiety held in the tense set of his shoulders and determination etched in the serious line of his brow. “This is going to piss you off, but-"

 

“Really shitty way to start a sentence, Stevie.”

 

“But, I’m going to ask anyway.” He persisted, completely ignoring the somewhat curt interruption. Steve’s gaze lowered for a moment before darting back up. “Did your dad, no- are you safe, Billy?”

 

Billy blinked, mind stalling as his hands twitched with the repressed urge to cover up the split in his lower lip. Of all the things Steve could have said – considering his easily riled temper, the senior’s warning hadn’t helped to narrow his expectations – are you safe hadn’t even registered as a goddamned possibility. What the fuck kind of vague question was that, anyway? Was anyone safe in this hellhole of a small town? Just because Steve knew that Neil knocked him around didn’t give him the right to go poking his nose where it didn’t belong, and them being friends didn’t fucking change that.

 

Are you safe? Steve had been right, and Billy was pissed. He also felt oddly betrayed – a painful sensation that he furiously ignored – because he’d thought they’d come to a silent agreement not to fucking talk about this shit.

 

There was absolutely no point in talking about Neil. No amount of pity or condolences or empty platitudes would help him, and besides, Billy was more than capable of taking care of himself. He’d been doing it since he was seven-years-old, for fucks sake. He didn’t need a knight in shining armour barging into his pathetic life and deciding to give a shit about him now, when it was already far too late to matter.

 

Billy pulled on his nastiest sneer – heart thundering uncomfortably against his ribs – and asked with a truly scathing amount of sarcasm, “Aw, worried about lil’ old me, pretty boy?”

 

Steve didn’t flinch from his rancour, maintaining his concernedly beseeching expression as he shamelessly nodded his head. “Yes, Billy. I’m worried about you. I won’t ask any other questions, ‘cause I know you don’t like talking about it, but…” He ran his hands through his hair before roughly shoving them into his jean pockets, fists clenched. “It makes me feel kind of sick, and just really angry, to know what a piece of shit he is. And I guess I just wanted you to know that I’m here, if you ever need anything- not that you will, just. Um, my house is always open to you and Max, is what I mean.”

 

The senior’s words rang with nothing but sincerity, and all at once Billy felt his defensive anger just… fizzle out, leaving behind a nearly overwhelming mixture of guilt and exhaustion and begrudging gratitude. Goddamnit, hadn’t he just had this fucking conversation with Maxine? Albeit with a lot more tears and shouting.

 

Billy rubbed a tired hand over his face, looking down at his shiny new Doc Martens rather than Steve’s big brown eyes. The idiot really was worried – angry, too – and the fact that he’d so readily offered not just Billy refuge in his big-ass house, but Maxine too? Any lingering annoyance he felt towards Steve for daring to pry into his fucked-up life died a swift death.

 

He risked a sideways glance at the senior’s face, and nearly groaned aloud when he was hit with the full force of Steve’s apprehensive, almost puppyish expression, all wide eyes and pouty lips. “I’m fine.” Billy snapped flatly; previous animosity gone from his voice. He lifted a hand towards his own temple, wriggling his fingers before waving dismissively. “Everything’s- handled.” 

 

Steve released a heavy breath, nodding. “Good. That’s good. Uh- when you say handled-"

 

“No questions, Steve.”

 

“Sorry, sorry. You’re right, I just-"

 

“What do you want me to say, huh? That I-" He cut himself off with a frustrated curse, flicking his eyes towards the kid still playing Pac Man before squeezing them shut and tightly folding his arms across his chest. If Steve knew exactly what he’d had to do in order to handle it – that he’d ruthlessly forced his way inside Neil’s head and felt nothing but grim determination as he manipulated feelings, intentions, and fucking memories – would he still offer to let Billy inside his home so freely?

 

Steve had witnessed firsthand the mess Billy had made of Hawkins Lab, seen the way he’d mind-tricked his dad into leaving the Byers house, and he was the only one who’d had an unobstructed view of the excessively gruesome way Billy had killed those demo-dogs in the tunnels. Somehow none of that supernatural bullshit had been enough to drive the senior away, but everyone had a limit.

 

Billy was surprised by how badly he didn’t want to find Steve’s.

 

He drew in a deliberately slow breath and let it out with strict evenness, mentally ordering himself to stop being such a dramatic little fucking bitch. Steve didn’t need to know what he’d done – didn’t need to know the extent of his increasingly disturbing psychic abilities – and Billy wasn’t about to risk telling him. “Look.” He said, clearing his dry throat before forcing himself to tip his head back and meet Steve’s steady gaze. “Thanks, but me and Maxine are good.”

 

Nodding slowly – expressive features visibly smoothing out as most of his concern began to dissipate – Steve flashed a somewhat weak smile. “Great! But... if there’s ever a time when you guys aren’t great, my door’s always open, okay? Even if my parents are home.”

 

Billy smiled for a moment – something fond and teasing settling timidly in his chest – though he was quick to sharpen it into a smirk. “Aren’t you sweet.”

 

“Wha- stop.” The senior complained, scowling even as his cheeks tinged with a flustered pink. “I’m trying to be supportive here, man!”

 

“And you’re doing a real a fantastic job-"

 

Steve laughed, flashing his pearly whites in a broad grin as he exasperatedly shook his head. “I seriously hate you, Billy.”

 

“You seriously don’t, Steve.”

 

“If you guys are just gonna keep yapping, I’m playing another game.”

 

Levity evaporating like smoke, both high-schoolers turned their heads to frown – or in Billy’s case, sneer menacingly – at the little blonde twirp standing by the Mac Man machine. “Scram, four-eyes.”

 

Only mildly intimidated, the kid adjusted his thick glasses and wandered away.

 

Billy and Steve exchanged bemused looks before approaching the now vacant arcade machine. The senior tapped his fingers over the white start button, lips twitching up into a mischievous grin. “Wanna make a bet?”

 

Interested despite himself, Billy took the bait. “What’re you thinking?”

 

“Whoever gets a higher score gets to drive the other’s car.”

 

Billy immediately held out his hand, already planning to send Steve’s maroon BMW spinning into enough tightly controlled donuts to have the senior turning green in the front passenger seat. “You’ve got yourself a deal.”

 

Steve narrowed his brown eyes at Billy’s quick agreement but didn’t hesitate to shake his hand, grip firm and palm surprisingly calloused. “Wanna go first?”

 

Hip checking the senior out of the way – biting back a smirk at his dramatic huff – he dug a quarter out of his back pocket and inserted it into the slot.

 

Billy had never cared much for video games, but his quick reflexes and sharp eyes meant that he was able to snag himself a pretty decent score before those annoying as fuck ghosts managed to corner and kill him. He stepped away from the arcade machine with a curse, glaring at the bold GAME OVER written across the screen.

 

Steve cracked his knuckles and rolled his head from side to side, sending Billy a confident smirk. “Get ready to listen to Super Freak on repeat, with all the windows down.”

 

“Just play the damn game already, idiot.” Billy demanded, unimpressed by his peacocking and determined that no matter what, Rick James would never play through his precious Camaro’s speakers.

 

It turned out that Steve had a videogame nerd tucked away somewhere inside that athletic build of his, and it became apparent very quickly that he was going to fucking win. Not about to let that happen – able to perfectly picture the infuriatingly smug smirk the asshole would give him – Billy cast a quick glance around before narrowing his eyes at the joystick in Steve’s hand and concentrating.

 

It jammed to the left and refused to move no matter how aggressively Steve tugged at it, leaving him to watch with increasing franticness as the pink ghost rapidly closed in on his stagnant location. He cursed like a sailor – even going so far as to smack his palm against the side of the machine – but could do nothing as his game ended, point score about one-hundred and fifty less than Billy’s had been.

 

“Looks like I win.” Billy hummed, smiling with a tooth-rotting amount of sweetness when Steve turned his disbelieving stare on him. “Make sure the BMW’s got a full tank for me when I come to collect my winnings.”

 

Realisation dawned suddenly on Steve’s face, his features going slack with it. “You did that, didn’t you?”

 

Billy sniffled – masterfully withholding a grimace at the foul taste of blood in the back of his throat – pulling on his most innocently bewildered façade. “I have no idea what you’re talking about.”

 

The senior wasn’t buying it for a second, eyebrows climbing up his forehead at Billy’s bald-faced lie. “Yes you do. I should’ve known you’d be a sore loser.” He glanced back at the game over screen, clicking his tongue and resolutely shaking his head. “That- that doesn’t count. I’ve seen the way you drive!”

 

“A bets a bet, pretty boy. Can’t back out now.”

 

“You’re such an asshole.” Steve bitched half-heartedly, lips twitching up into the beginnings of an amused smile. “Fine, but I’m banning the use of superpowers from all future bets. That’s cheating, man.”

 

Tongue sliding between his teeth as his mouth split into a shit eating grin, Billy leaned closer and murmured a very self-satisfied, “Merry fucking Christmas, Stevie.”

 

Steve laughed, lightly shoving him away. “Merry Christmas, Billy.”