Actions

Work Header

Growing Pains

Chapter 6: Donuts

Summary:

Billy collects on a bet, catches weird vibes from a suburban house-wife, and goes to a party.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Billy yanked open the front passenger side door of Steve’s BMW, resting his forearm against the roof and meeting Steve’s welcoming smile with a razor-sharp grin that immediately had the senior’s defences going right the fuck up. “Move your ass, Stevie.”

 

“What?” He questioned dumbly, frowning as he adjusted his hold on the steering wheel and shifted his upper body towards him. Steve looked good – which incited a slightly tense feeling within the junior’s stomach he was quick to dismiss as annoyance – and Billy had to resist the urge to self-consciously run a hand through his short curls. The older boy’s ridiculous hair was styled with artfully purposeful carelessness, and while his outfit was relatively simple – consisting of a stylish black jacket, forest green Henley, tight navy jeans and probably some Nike shoes, if Billy knew at all – it screamed I look good and I know it. “I thought the plan was for me to drive us out, and you-“

 

“Plans change.” Billy interrupted, rapping his knuckles in a staccato rhythm against the roof of the BMW. “You’re navigator. C’mon.”

 

Steve hesitated for a second – wisely suspecting that Billy had ulterior motives – before arching an expressive eyebrow and giving him an unimpressed look. “Dude, you can’t just kick me out of my own car-"

 

Rolling his eyes, Billy turned his head and blew out a plume of smoke before dropping his cigarette into the gutter. “I’m collecting on our bet, not kicking you out of the damn car.”

 

“I don’t even know why I’m honouring that stupid bet, you clearly cheated.”

 

Billy didn’t snicker at Steve’s beleaguered tone, but it was a very near thing. Riling the senior up was fun, and Steve made it way too easy. “Not my fault the joystick jammed-"

 

Steve threw up his hands before burying his face in them. Voice muffled, he groaned, “You’re so full of shit oh my god-"

 

“What’s the holdup?” Maxine asked peevishly, jogging down their narrow footpath and then over their patchy, mostly dead front lawn. “Come on, guys! I’m already late-"

 

“Hey, we’d be gone already if Bil-"

 

“Patience, shitbird. You’ll get to your-“ Billy cut himself off once he registered exactly what Steve was saying as they both tried to speak up over the other. He shot the senior a dirty look, to which Steve responded with a challenging lift of his eyebrows. “Oh, that’s how you wanna play it, Stevie?” Billy turned his head towards his sister, who was shifting restlessly beside him, her hand clenched impatiently around the BMW’s back door handle. She looked like she was seriously considering rushing back into their currently empty house, grabbing her skateboard, and skating to the Wheeler’s, but Billy ignored her obvious irritation with long practiced ease. Instead – because he knew that it would annoy both of them – he jerked his thumb towards Steve. “This dickhead’s trying to worm his way out of a bet he was dumb enough to make-"

 

“I am not!” The taller boy sputtered indignantly. “I agreed to letting you drive us home, didn’t I?”

 

“Oh yeah, like carting your drunk ass home after Tina’s party isn’t me doing you a huge fucking favour. A favour that you’ll sure as shit be owing me for, pretty boy.”

 

“Look, Steve.” Maxine began, reigning in her exasperation and aiming for a more cajoling tone. “It’ll be easier for everyone if you just let Billy drive.”

 

Mildly surprised by the back-up but refusing to show it, Billy didn’t bother trying to tamp down his widening smirk, sensing that Steve’s resistance was crumbling at a rapid pace. “That’s cold, Max. This is my car-"

 

She rolled her eyes and leaned slightly to the left in order to peer more clearly at Steve through the open front passenger door, her face the textbook definition of unsympathetic. Billy’s smirk shifted into a thoroughly entertained grin when the senior visibly winced at the sight of it. “You should know better than to make bets with Billy. Hurry up, Steve.”

 

“I- this is ridiculous. Fine, you guys win.” He put the BMW in park and unbuckled his seatbelt before throwing open the door, muttering beneath his breath something about damn Hargrove’s not playing fair as he stepped out in a petulant huff. The pair of siblings shared a look – one smugly victorious, the other reluctantly amused – and Billy lightly brushed his knuckles against Maxine’s shoulder in wordless appreciation. He turned and rounded the front of the BMW with an eager spring in his steps, swatting Steve on the back as they passed each other and cackling at the senior’s disgruntled curse.

 

Billy slid behind the wheel with a wicked grin, making some minor adjustments to the seat and rear-view mirror before reaching for the volume dial and spinning it anti-clockwise, huffing derisively at Bonnie Tyler’s impassioned Holding Out for a Hero. The BMW was a nice car – nowhere near as gorgeously sleek as the Camaro, but impressive quality all the same – and Billy was eager to see just what its engine was capable of.

 

He was kind enough to allow his passengers time to buckle themselves in before wrenching the steering wheel and pulling away from the gutter with a loud screech of rubber against asphalt, his purposefully obnoxious whoop drowning out Steve’s anxiety riddled cursing and Maxine’s excited laugh.

 

So long as Billy wasn’t speeding towards a trio of nerds on bicycles, his little sister was almost as much of a speed demon as he was.

 

Billy took the next corner fast enough that the inside wheels threatened to lift, which had Steve slapping one hand down on the dash while reaching out his other to clutch desperately at the junior’s arm. Billy glanced over – only mildly annoyed by the pinching tightness of Steve’s thoughtless hold – and had to bite back the urge to snort at the comical wideness of his whiskey brown eyes. “Jesus, Billy! Slow down!”

 

“Don’t be a pussy, Steve.” He slid his tongue between his teeth, grinning as he pressed his foot down harder on the accelerator. The BMW rumbled eagerly beneath him, meeting Billy’s harsh demands with only a slight delay. Considering the fact that Steve drove like he was nineteen going on seventy-five – and probably didn’t know how to change his own oil, let alone do regular maintenance – he was surprised that the engine didn’t struggle more noticeably beneath his lead foot. “Just sit back and enjoy the ride.”

 

Steve whipped his head towards Billy, looking like he couldn’t decide whether he wanted to smack him or start cursing him out, or both. “Enjoy the- you’re gonna give me a heart attack!”

 

Billy scoffed, approaching an intersection – slowing down just enough to gauge whether or not there were any approaching cars – and casually blowing through it. The unintelligibly stressed sound that Steve made in response was quiet but high pitched, and he felt some of his amusement swiftly tank into annoyance. Just how fucking stupid did the senior think he was? Billy might drive fast, but he never drove with genuine recklessness when his sister was in the car. “So fucking dramatic. Chill the hell out and trust me, Harrington.”

 

“I don’t trust you,” Steve lied vehemently, sitting rigidly in his seat and clenching his jaw hard enough to make the muscles in his cheek jump as Billy roared down a straight section of road.

 

Thoroughly pleased by the senior’s unintentional confession, Billy merely threw him an unrepentant grin before turning his focus towards getting them where they needed to go as fast as possible. It felt… nice – not to mention surreal, even if rationally it made sense after all the fucked-up shit they’d been through together – to know that despite all the sensible reasons that he really shouldn’t, Steve honestly did trust him.

 

Nobody who’d ever met him would make the mistake of describing Billy as trustworthy, or anything even tenuously resembling reliable. He’d never wanted to be, uninterested in shouldering anyone else’s expectations, along with their  inevitable disappointment. Yet, against all odds and his own better judgement, here he was, sitting in a car with two people – maybe the only two people – who believed that he was someone worth putting their faith in.

 

That kind of trust was daunting as all hell, but while Billy was undoubtedly a selfish piece of shit, he wasn’t a fucking coward. Their trust was important to him – so fucking important – and he’d sooner drive the Camaro off a cliff than do anything to deliberately break it.

 

~

 

Billy pulled the BMW into the Wheeler’s smoothly paved driveway hardly three minutes after leaving Cherry Lane, which got him a relieved sigh from Steve and a rushed thank-you-bye from Maxine as she scrambled to get out.

 

The Wheeler’s house was firmly upper-middle class – first floor exterior covered by crisp red brick, while the upper floor was cased in neat white panels – and their front yard was pristinely maintained, with a narrow garden lining the footpath and lawn that was somehow still richly green despite the punishingly cold temperatures of the past few days.

 

Exhaling a sharp sigh at the sight of his sister scampering like a miscreant towards the Wheeler’s front door, Billy unbuckled his seatbelt, put the car in park, and moved to follow her. “Any tips on handling your ex’s parents?”

 

Steve blinked at him like he’d just started spouting astrophysics. “Huh?”

 

“Nancy’s parents, what’re they like?”

 

“Uh, fine? Normal?”

 

Billy rolled his eyes, unsure why he’d even bothered asking. “Useless, Stevie. Be back in a second.” He slammed the door shut and rounded the front of the BMW, jogging slightly to catch up with his overeager little sister, who’d already pressed the Wheeler’s unpleasantly high-pitched doorbell. Twice.

 

“Whoa, hang on.” Steve called after him, deciding – for some fucking reason – to also get out of the car. Billy watched with an incredulous sneer as the senior hurried after him, wondering uncharitably if he was just that much of an idiot, or if the guy was secretly some kind of masochist. No way was Steve about to voluntarily place himself into a situation where he’d be forced to interact with his ex-girlfriend’s goddamned parents, especially when Billy had given him the opportunity to just sit his ass in the car and wait, right?

 

Steve came to stand slightly behind Billy’s right shoulder, face twitching like he was trying to appear calm but couldn’t quite pull it off. “Nancy’s parents are nice, okay? I’m not gonna let you be a dick to them just ‘cause you don’t like her.”

 

Irritation surging through him, Billy fought down the urge to get right back in Steve’s fancy car and leave his dumbass standing like a desperate moron at his ex’s doorstep. First, Billy wasn’t stupid enough to piss off the people who were about to be responsible for Maxine’s safety over the next however many hours. Second, fuck Steve for assuming he was petty enough to allow his dislike of Wheeler to transfer over to her parents. It definitely had – to produce a conceited goody-goody like Nancy he knew they had to have serious dysfunctions – but that wasn’t the goddamned point, and third… Billy unceremoniously stomped his boot-heel into Steve’s closest foot. “It’s funny you think you could fucking stop me, asshole.”

 

Maxine turned her head and threw Steve a pointed look over her shoulder. “Billy’s actually weirdly good at being polite to adults.” Her lips twisted into the beginnings of a concerned frown when she noticed his silently pained grimace. “Are you okay?”

 

“Fine,” Steve replied – tone almost impressively nonchalant – shaking out his aching foot and jabbing a light elbow into Billy’s side. Under his breath, he muttered a very pointed, “Ow.”

 

Billy smirked unapologetically. “That’s what you get for being such a condescending motherfu-“

 

The Wheeler’s front door swung inwards, and the trio was greeted by the sight of an older and far softer-looking version of Nancy Wheeler. The woman was clearly her mom, looking to be well into her forties if Billy were to guess, though her thick foundation, dark lipstick, and subtly eye shadow was enough to make her appear superficially younger. The scent of hairspray coming from her tousled brown locks was stronger than the floral perfume she’d attempted to douse herself in – he barely resisted the urge to start coughing in her face – and the neckline of her long-sleeved red dress was deep. Deep enough to have Billy arching a bemused eyebrow and casting a quick sideways glance at Steve, who was very clearly doing his best not to stare at the woman’s partially revealed breasts.

 

Billy had been under the impression that Wheeler’s parents were going to be supervising the kid’s sleepover, but for Mrs Wheeler to be answering the door dressed and primped like that? No way in hell was he about to let Maxine spend the night alone with a trio of hormonal little shitheels. Nerds they might be, but they were also boys. So was Will, Billy belatedly acknowledged, though he at least trusted baby Byers to think and act with his brain, rather than anything else.

 

Mrs Wheeler had initially opened her door with a broad smile – rosy cheeks bunching as she showed off her near perfect teeth – though once her dark eyes had time to dart over their faces her expression… shifted. Disappointment furrowed her perfectly plucked eyebrows before she seemed to consciously snap herself out of it, forcing her pursed mouth back up into a smile, though this time it was close-lipped and mild.

 

Billy couldn’t help but wonder who she’d assumed was at her door.

 

“Oh, hello.” Mrs Wheeler greeted, her made-up face smoothing out into something more genuinely welcoming. She directed most of her focus towards the Hargrove’s, granting Steve little more than a brief once over and a very unsubtle frown. If Billy had to guess, the woman still harboured some resentment towards Hawkins High’s former King for daring to put his hands on her perfect little daughter. “You must be Billy, and Maxine.”

 

Maxine smiled, and only someone who knew her well would pick up on how bland it was. “Just Max, actually.”

 

To her credit Mrs Wheeler hardly blinked, merely nodded her head in acceptance.  “Max, of course. Please come in, the boys are already downstairs.” She stepped to the side to give Maxine room to pass by her, revealing a slightly messy and clearly well used entryway. Similar to Steve’s house, the stairs leading to the second floor were directly across from the front door, though the Wheeler’s were covered in dull, sporadically stained carpet. Billy didn’t bother craning his neck trying to see any more, the floral wallpaper telling him all he needed to know about the interior design of the house.

 

Maxine moved to take a step across the threshold, though Billy stopped her with a light tug on the ends of her long red hair. She spun to glower up at him – shifting her weight like she was about to aim a kick at his shins – which prompted him to arch an expectant eyebrow. “What do you say, Maxine?”

 

Freckled face reddening with a mixture of annoyance and embarrassment, his sister turned back to Mrs Wheeler – who was watching their interaction with interest – and dutifully said, “Thank you for letting me stay over tonight, Mrs Wheeler.”

 

The woman’s polite smile brightened, though Billy couldn’t tell whether she was charmed by Maxine’s belated manners, or the fact that he’d had to remind her to use them. “You’re very welcome, Max. Just head straight down this hallway past the stairs. The door’s on your left.”

 

His sister gave him a look that very clearly – and fucking sarcastically, the little shit – asked, can I go now? Billy clicked his tongue at her silent attitude, giving her a gentle shove between her shoulder blades. “Be good, shitbird. If I hear any complaints about you you’re never coming back here, capiche?”

 

“Yes, mom.” She griped dramatically, darting past Mrs Wheeler before Billy could give her a solid flick to the centre of her forehead for her cheek. He watched her go with an annoyed glare, his pride prickling at being referred to so mockingly. Billy wasn’t a fucking woman, for one thing, not that it would have been any better if Maxine had decided to call him dad. Neil had spent the last seventeen years turning that title into a curse, and the thought of sharing it with him – even in a sarcastic manner – was enough to make Billy want to claw out of his own skin in a rush of visceral disgust. No matter how much of both Neil and Susan’s slack he’d grudgingly picked up over the years, he was nobody’s goddamned parent.

 

As far as Billy was concerned, he never would be. 

 

“I wish my kids got along even half as well as you two do.” Mrs Wheeler said wistfully, pulling Billy from his bout of pathetically bitter introspection. He blinked at the dolled-up woman – her words taking a moment to fully register – and she gave him a slightly coy smile, like she was sharing some kind of secret. “My eldest fight like cats and dogs.”

 

Billy’s eyebrows rose slightly. He hadn’t known that there were three Wheeler brats running around town. Deciding that some flattery never hurt, he tilted his head to the side and narrowed his eyes just slightly as he looked over Mrs Wheeler’s caked face, like he was studying something particularly confusing. “You don’t look old enough to have three kids under your belt.”

 

Steve made a quiet noise – whether the senior was confused or disturbed he didn’t care to figure out – but Billy ignored him entirely, instead flashing Mrs Wheeler a charming smile.

 

More often than not, compliments served to butter up whoever he was speaking to, which in turn gave Billy a lot more room to manoeuvre the conversation into whatever direction he wanted it to go. Usually that meant shutting down a topic he found either uncomfortable or mind-numbingly boring, though sometimes he simply ended the conversation altogether, using a blunt kind of finality that nobody – not even the most flirtatious high-school girl – could fight against.

 

Mrs Wheeler fluttered her eyelashes and smiled, buying into Billy’s empty flattery hook, line, and fucking sinker. She waved her hand like she was attempting to dismiss his words, oozing delight and so much false modesty Billy had to bite down hard on his tongue to stop himself from outright laughing in her face. “Oh, stop it.”

 

Billy kept smiling – ignoring the sting that was starting up in the underused muscles of his cheeks – and asked, “What time do you want Maxine out of your hair tomorrow?”

 

“With a responsible older brother like you, I’m sure she won’t be in my hair at all.” She replied sweetly, briefly lifting a hand to trace her fingertips – with an absentmindedness that couldn’t be anything other than perfectly deliberate – over one of her partially exposed collarbones. “The boys, however… Well, their parents will be collecting them at ten o’clock.”

 

He nodded along, not even having to fake a grimace at the thought of enduring the pubescent screeching of Little Wheeler, Henderson, and Sinclair for such an extended period of time. If Billy was in charge of their little sleepover? He doubted those loudmouthed dweebs would make it to sunrise. “I’ll swing by at nine forty-five.”

 

“Not your father?” Mrs Wheeler asked. She went rigid for a moment after the question escaped her – dark eyes widening like she hadn’t intended to ask it aloud – before forcing herself to relax once more, playing it off like she’d merely been curious, rather than strangely intent.

 

“He tends to sleep in whenever he’s not working.” Billy excused politely, maintaining his blandly interested expression through sheer force of fucking will as his mind began racing and his stomach performed a sickening roll. Mrs Wheeler had opened her front door – smiling that million dollar smile and dressed to make a show of her decently sized tits – expecting to see his dad. His dad. Jesus fucking Christ. Billy wasn’t sure whether the sudden lump in his throat was vomit or hysterical laughter, and it took all of his self-control not to turn towards Steve, desperately wanting to know if he was alone in this goddamned shitshow of a realisation.

 

The fact that his dad was potentially cheating on Susan didn’t surprise Billy. Neil had been doing it for years, so often and so unsubtly that Maxine’s mom hardly even blinked at his late night outings anymore, nor did she flinch from the unfamiliar perfumes that sometimes followed him home. Hell, Billy wasn’t even really surprised by the fact that he’d apparently set his sights on Mrs Wheeler. The women seemed like your run-of-the-mill, cliched suburban housewife – repressed and eager for any kind of illicit excitement – and clearly she wasn’t smart enough to see through Neil’s genial exterior. She was the perfect target, and Billy felt pity briefly overwhelm the contemptuous disgust writhing sharply in his guts. The woman had absolutely no fucking ideajust who the hell she was dealing with. Who she was so clearly trying to have sex with.

 

Which- fucking gross. Billy gave his head a hard shake, feeling like he needed to douse himself in bleach, and maybe drink a gallon or so for good measure. If he never again thought about Neil and sex at the same time it’d still be too fucking soon.

 

Curiosity was quick to overrule his brief rush of shock, his mind whirling with exactly three questions that he felt he needed answered immediately. First, how and fucking when had Neil and Mrs Wheeler met? Second, did Nancy know that she’d inherited her penchant for cheating from her hussy of a mother? And third, if Bitch Wheeler didn’t know, what was the best way to inform her if his goal was to inflict the highest amount of psychological damage possible?

 

The possibilities were endless, and Billy looked forward to watching horrified, furious revulsion grace Wheeler’s pointy face at some point in the near future.

 

“Do you two know each other?” Billy asked casually, cocking his head to the side. He watched with a wicked sense of amusement as unease flickered imperceptibly over Mrs Wheeler’s features, guilt thickening the air around her before she inhaled a deep breath and composed herself. She wanted to fuck around with his piece of shit father? Whatever, but Billy was going to enjoy making the experience as uncomfortable for her as he possibly could. “He hasn’t mentioned you.”

 

Mrs Wheeler waved a dismissive hand, pulling on another smile that didn’t even come close to reaching her eyes. “Oh, I doubt he would. We’ve only spoken a few times now.”

 

“How did you meet?”

 

“He showed up on my doorstep looking for you and Max. It was the night you were hurt by that awful stray.” She answered truthfully, taut smile softening slightly around its lipstick darkened edges. “Neil was so concerned. You’re lucky to have a man like him for a father.”

 

Steve sucked in a sharp breath, radiating a sudden and sharp tension against Billy’s back. The junior merely smiled – pretty and wide, just like he’d always done whenever someone mentioned Neil, or questioned whatever new bruise was decorating his face – the swell of his useless, bitter anger familiar but distant enough to ignore. “Don’t I know it, Mrs Wheeler.”

 

“Call me Karen.” She insisted, with none of Ms Byers’ friendly humility and far too much teasing confidence. The woman’s dark eyes moved almost consideringly over his face, mascara laden eyelashes fluttering. “If I didn’t already know, I never would have guessed that you’re Neil’s son, Billy. You two look nothing alike.”

 

Billy’s fake smile gained an edge of genuine pleasure. In a bout of uncharacteristic honesty, he said. “I take after my mom.”

 

“Well, she must be a very beautiful woman.”

 

Unsure whether Mrs Wheeler was simply giving him a compliment, or if she was edging more firmly into creepy cougar territory – this entire interaction had felt undeniably weird from the moment it began – Billy decided that it was high time for he and Steve to get the fuck out of dodge. “Nice meeting you, Karen. I’ll be back to pick Maxine up tomorrow morning.”

 

Billy took a very deliberate step back from the open door – Steve wordlessly moving in sync with him, even more eager than he was to leave the Wheeler’s house behind them – but Mrs Wheeler wasn’t quite ready to let the conversation die. “Where are you two off to?”

 

The woman gave the senior a brief but thoroughly disapproving look before turning her gaze back to Billy, as if Steve was the bad influence between them. Bemused more than anything else – her dislike for Steve seemed disproportionate, especially considering the fact that her daughter had cheated on him, and not the other way around – Billy gave an ambiguous smile before reaching a hand back and snagging his fingers in Steve’s jacket, giving a single, sharp tug. “Oh, you know, wherever the free booze takes us.”

 

Mrs Wheeler looked like she wasn’t sure whether she should laugh or attempt to scold him for his casual reference to underage drinking. She opened her mouth, but for the first time since she’d opened her front door Steve spoke up. “Thanks for having Max over, Mrs Wheeler. We’re already late, so we’ve really gotta go now.”

 

“I see.” She replied, voice and expression both flattening just slightly. Steve picked up on her subtle shift in demeanour immediately, but when Billy snuck a glance back at him his handsome features were composed into a mask of near perfect politeness. Mrs Wheeler eyed him for a moment before pasting on a tight smile. “I won’t keep you, then. You two have fun, and I’ll see you tomorrow, Billy.”

 

“Looking forward to it.” Billy lied easily, watching with a mixture of morbid fascination and mild disgust as a light blush managed to peak through the heavy layer of foundation covering her cheeks. “You heading out on the town?”

 

Mrs Wheeler glanced back into her house – towards what Billy assumed was the living room – something like resentment flashing across her face before she reigned it in behind another insincere smile. She carelessly shrugged her tense shoulders,  “No, not tonight.”

 

Billy arched a disbelieving eyebrow despite sensing the truth in her answer, which prompted her to adjust the deep neckline of her dress and touch her fingertips to her thick brown perm with an overabundance of faux bashfulness, clearly aware that she was far too dressed up to be staying at home. On one hand, Billy was glad to know that she wasn’t planning on leaving a bunch of dumbass middle-schoolers unsupervised, but on the other…

 

Well, Billy did not enjoy having further proof that Nancy Wheeler’s mom was desperate enough for some dick – or at least, some dick that wasn’t attached to her husband – to slut herself up for a good for nothing scumbag like Neil fucking Hargrove.

 

It was Steve’s turn to yank insistently at Billy’s denim jacket, clearly impatient to leave the awkward atmosphere that his silent but pointed incredulity had created. “Bye, Mrs Wheeler!”

 

Billy gave the woman a lazy wave before allowing Steve to pull him down the footpath back towards the BMW. He shoved the senior off him with a light-hearted fuck off, not truly minding Steve’s fingers curled around his arm but also not wanting to be herded down the narrow footpath like a goddamned sheep.

 

They collapsed into their respective seats with nearly identical sighs of relief, turning their heads in sync to look at each other.

 

“What the hell was that?” Steve demanded, his blank expression quickly morphing into something highly fucking disturbed, eyebrows arched and frown pinched.

 

Billy shrugged a shoulder – locking down both his disgust and inappropriate amusement – twisting the key in the ignition and feeling slightly let down by the BMW’s answering hum. Purposefully blasé, he said, “Your ex’s mom wants to fuck my dad.”

 

“She what?”

 

~

 

The drive out to Lover’s Lake – once Steve had gotten over most of his horrified disbelief – was filled with idle gossip interspersed with the occasional direction, both of which the senior readily supplied.  Journey's Chain Reaction played quietly in the background, which Billy allowed with only a very mild sneer.

 

He should have guessed it already, but it turned out that Steve was a veritable fucking treasure trove of blackmail material. As the former King of Hawkins High, he knew who’d fucked who, who’d wanted to fuck who, and who’d fucked the old Biology teacher before he was caught, summarily fired, and probably put on some kind of sex-offender watchlist. Steve knew who’d done the wildest shit at parties – had been the one to do some of that wild shit – and eagerly launched into the story of a senior a couple of years back who’d streaked through Loch Nora hollering the national anthem as loud as he could on a dare. The same nudist dipshit swam a lap of Lover’s Lake buck-ass naked at the last New Year’s bonfire, though apparently that had been driven by drunken stupidity and a severe lack of shame, rather than a dare.

 

Steve was pretty much a human encyclopedia when it came to the popular – or wannabe popular – assholes infesting their school. He even knew who most of their goddamned parents were, his own having a penchant for lavish dinners whenever they were in town long enough to actually host them. Billy didn’t waste the opportunity to dig for useful information and inflammatory gossip, eager to equip himself with enough ammunition to fucking destroy any moron dumb enough to try and start shit with him.

 

The ruthlessly abrasive, devil-may-care persona he’d cultivated in his first few weeks at Hawkins High may have kept him firmly within the ranks of the popular assholes – even after those lab fuckers had buzzed his hair while he was unconscious in the hospital – but it didn’t spare Billy from the pathetically predictable shit talking that a few braver students aimed at him. Ditching the main crowd in favour of spending most of his lunch breaks with Steve hadn’t exactly helped the situation, but their petty displeasure wasn’t something Billy gave a fuck about.

 

Hagan and Perkins had hardly dared to even look at Billy since the carpark incident, but that little blonde bitch of a sophomore Jason Carver was seriously beginning to grate on his nerves – his passive aggressive comments and snide remarks making Billy’s scarred knuckles ache to hit something – as were a few of the rowdier seniors.

 

Blackmail wasn’t typically his style – punching was a simple and far more immediate solution – but Hawkins wasn’t California, and despite having an in with the Chief, Billy doubted he’d get away with beating the hell out of whatever condescending dickhead was taking their turn at testing his very limited patience.

 

“-so to get back at him, she started sticking her tongue down- oh, take a left here. Holland Road’s pretty much a straight shot to the lake.” Steve said, pointing towards the poorly maintained road quickly coming up on their left. By now the sun was well on its way to setting – the sky shifting rapidly between reds and yellows and pinks before beginning to darken with night – and it was likely that Billy would have missed the turn if he hadn’t had a Hawkins native riding shotgun. “Reefer Rick’s place is the… third house, I think. It looks kinda run down; you won’t miss it.”

 

“Who the fuck is Reefer Rick?” Billy asked, sneering at the name.

 

“He’s the local drug dealer.” Steve shrugged, grimacing and slapping a hand down on the dash as Billy took the turn fast enough to send the back wheels skidding.

 

“I thought that was Munson?”

 

“Munson just sells weed. Rick sells the hard shit.”

 

Billy arched an eyebrow, shooting the senior a curious side-glance. “Know that from experience, Stevie?”

 

“I mean, no, but I went with Tommy and Carol a few times when they wanted to get some special K.” Steve shifted slightly in his seat, eyeing Billy like he wasn’t sure whether his admission would invite ridicule or approval. “I was never really interested in getting that messed up. Beer and weed’s always been good enough for me.”

 

“Self-control, from the infamous King Steve? Colour me impressed.” Billy snarked meanly, grinning when Steve rolled his eyes hard enough to send his head rocking to the side. “Bet Hagan and Perkins didn’t like that.”

 

“They didn’t, but it was one of the few things I never changed my mind about. Seeing them on that shit- even back then, I didn’t want to be like that.”

 

Billy’s grin softened just slightly, and he didn’t hesitate to reach over and give the older boy a hearty pat on his closest thigh. From the stories he’d heard, King Steve hadn’t exactly been a role model when it came to resisting peer pressure, so despite his vaguely sarcastic tone Billy genuinely was impressed by his restraint. Seeing his mom slowly become dependent on whatever shit she took to numb herself, and enduring Neil’s rages whenever he decided that alcohol wasn’t enough… Billy was more than impressed, he was fucking relieved that he wouldn’t have to find out what kind of person Steve turned into when he was cooked out of his goddamned mind.

 

Seeing how the taller boy handled – or didn’t handle – his alcohol was going to be bad enough, though Billy was tentatively hopeful that drunk Steve would behave similarly to the laid-back, giggly idiot he became after smoking a bit of weed. “Good for you, pretty boy.”

 

Steve turned his head to look at him, expressive eyebrows climbing up his forehead. “You’re not gonna call me a pussy?”

 

“For not doing hard drugs? Why the fuck would I?” Billy scoffed, fingers drumming restlessly against the steering wheel. “I hate that shit.”

 

“Really? I would’ve thought-"

 

“Yeah, well, don’t hurt yourself. We both know thinking’s not your strong suit.”

 

“Hey.” Steve scowled, offended.

 

Billy flashed him an unconcerned grin, running his tongue along his bared teeth.

 

~

 

Because he knew that Steve would hate it – and because he was itching to test the BMW’s limits – Billy turned onto Reefer Rick’s long driveway with a wrench of the wheel, pressing the clutch and engaging the handbrake. His sadistically gleeful cackle was drowned out by the loud rush of the BMW’s tyres displacing loose gravel and dirt, and Steve’s curse-riddled stream of exclamations – holy shit Billy stop what the fuck are you doing this isn’t funny stop drifting my car you complete lunatic – only made him laugh harder. Throwing an exaggerated wink the senior’s way, Billy floored the accelerator, releasing the clutch and hand break.

 

The BMW continued into a donut – the loose quality of the driveway making it a little less controlled than Billy preferred, though he didn’t have too much difficulty reigning the car’s circling movements in tighter – which had Steve’s barely intelligible protests rising in both pitch and volume. Billy’s cheeks stung from the width and duration of his wicked grin, but as much as he liked hearing the taller boy beg for mercy and bitch about his paintjob, he eventually relented, taking his foot off the accelerator and deftly straightening the BMW back out.

 

“How was that, pretty boy?” Billy asked rhetorically, still grinning as he tilted his head towards Steve. That had been fucking fun. Doubtlessly the BMW’s engine wasn’t as powerful as the Camaro’s and its reaction times left something to be desired, but it was a solid car, and he was looking forward to bullying his way back behind the steering wheel in the future.

 

He'd expected the senior to be glaring at him – or maybe sticking his head out the open window and throwing his guts up – incensed by Billy’s supposedly reckless endangerment of both his car and his life, but instead Steve was just kind of… staring, whiskey brown eyes wide and lips slightly parted, like he was surprised by something. Billy blinked, his lingering smile instinctively twisting into a faint sneer as he resisted the urge to drag a hand through his hair and over his face. “The fuck’re you looking at?”

 

It was Steve’s turn to blink, quickly snapping his gaze away and flapping a dismissive hand, laughing a little bit breathlessly. Gone was the stressed irritation that had been permeating the air for the past minute, replaced by something oddly warm, though embarrassment was quick to overwhelm whatever it was. “Nothing! Nothing, uh- where’d you even learn to do that, anyway?”

 

Taking a moment to concentrate on bolstering his mental shields – Maxine’s impassioned rant about privacy making him feel irritatingly guilty whenever his recently awakened telepathy acted without his conscious intent – Billy shot the senior a dubious look before magnanimously deciding not to press him about his weird as fuck behaviour. “Used to hang around a bunch of rev-head mechanics back in Cali.” He answered with a shrug, feeling a rush of surprisingly painless nostalgia as he thought back to Mrs Holly and her crew of eccentric grease-monkeys. Lips curving up into the beginnings of a smirk, Billy flicked his eyes away from Reefer Rick’s rapidly approaching house – which he could already tell was packed to the brim with drunken teenagers – and met Steve’s attentive gaze. “I’ll let you join in on Maxine’s lessons, if you’re bored of driving like someone’s half-blind grandma.”

 

Steve sputtered, immediately launching into a vehement defence of his perfectly reasonable cautiousness when it came to driving over poorly maintained small-town roads in winter. Billy listened with half an ear as he found a park – that they wouldn’t get penned into – amongst the disorganised mess of other cars sitting in front of Reefer Rick’s brightly lit one-storey house, rolling his eyes as Steve’s righteous speech about safety lost steam and swiftly devolved into nearly nonsensical rambling.

 

How the guy had gone from King Steve to I Have A Massive Stick Stuck Up My Ass Steve was something that Billy found himself ruminating on with surprising frequency, leaving him to wonder who Steve would be now if Nancy Wheeler hadn’t turned his head, and monsters from another dimension hadn’t invaded Hawkins.

 

Hell, who the fuck would Billy be, if Steve were still that shallow, rich asshole everyone had been so eager to tell him about when he’d first arrived in town?

 

Friendless, probably, just like he’d always kept himself back in California. Lonelier too, though he could hardly stand to admit that to himself, let alone anyone else.

 

He supposed he’d be less… happy, which was a realisation that made Billy grimace in honest confusion, feeling suddenly jittery and off balance. Jesus, since fucking when was happiness something that he knew anything about, let alone something he actually felt with any kind of reliable frequency?

 

Billy cast a subtle glance towards Steve’s oblivious, handsome face, a privately disbelieving smile ghosting over his lips.

 

~

 

The roaring of the BMW’s tyres tearing up Reefer Rick’s long driveway had drawn most of the partygoers back from Lover’s Lake and out of the drug dealer’s small house, which was just fine by Billy. He stepped out of the car with an arrogant grin – completely ignoring Steve, who looked like he wanted nothing more than to sink into his seat – spreading his arms wide and bowing shallowly when a wave of drunken hollering, piercing whistles, and raucous laughter threatened to deafen him.

 

Billy was good at being the reckless party-boy, but he was also well aware that he hadn’t been putting much effort into maintaining his façade recently, too distracted by the pleasant novelty of having someone that he actually wanted to be around. Someone who he didn’t have to play a part for.

 

Fucking hell, how pathetically sad was that?

 

A few too many assholes had mistaken his withdrawal from the popular clique as weakness, which was something he planned to rectify tonight, arrogant mask firmly in place and tenuous sense of patience as heavily fortified as he could possibly make it.

 

Billy endured the heavy slaps being pressed carelessly across his back and shoulders – locking his instinctual flinches down hard – as he waded into the awaiting crowd, flashing smiles and snark and refusing to show his disgust as alcohol laced breath was blasted into his face. He might be slightly out of practice, but not for a moment did Billy doubt his ability to convince the small-town hicks surrounding him that he was just as eager for some drunken revelry as they were, if not more so.

 

Tina appeared far too fucking closely in front of him, cheeks flushed and eyes lined with smoky makeup that looked more smudged than deliberate. Billy cast a brief glance back over his shoulder towards Steve – ensuring that the senior had grown a pair and actually gotten out of the BMW – before turning back to the senior and offering her a sly grin. The two girls flanking her fluttered their lashes and sipped at their cheap beers, though Billy didn’t spare them more than a cursory once-over.

 

He probably knew their names – no doubt they’d been introduced before – but for the life of him he couldn’t be bothered even trying to remember.

 

“Billy Hargrove.” Tina greeted; speech only very slightly slurred by the alcohol no doubt already rushing through her veins. She reached forward with a flirtatious smile and patted his chest, which he allowed with a subtle twitch of his eyebrows. “What an entrance! I wasn’t sure if you were going to come.”

 

“And miss one of your infamous parties?” Billy pulled on a faux expression of hurt, lifting an arm and curling his fingers over the back of her hand – which she still had pressed to the centre of his chest – giving it a faint squeeze before dropping it between them. “You underestimate me, Tina.”

 

The senior pouted in a way that she probably thought was cute, though to Billy the infantile expression only made her look really fucking stupid. “You didn’t come to my Halloween party.”

 

This again. Jesus Christ could this spoilt bitch hold a grudge. Smiling benignly – the expression not even coming close to reaching his eyes – Billy cocked his head to the side and said, “And I’ve already apologised for that.”

 

Perhaps sensing that she was testing Billy’s patience, Tina offered up a slightly tense grin before darting his gaze over his shoulder, clearly eager to change the subject. “I see you brought Steve with you.”

 

“That I did.” Billy replied, biting back a sarcastic comment as he followed the direction of her stare. Billy had assumed that he’d see Steve drowning in awkwardness as the drunk teenagers gathered around them poked and prodded and gave him shit for his messy fall from the top of the social hierarchy, so to say that he was surprised by the sight that did greet him would have been a severe understatement.

 

King Steve was fucking back, smirking and bantering and playing the crowd like they were his own personal instruments. Some nameless asshole dared to call him old news to his face, and the senior arched his expressive eyebrows in a look that was so goddamned condescending Billy couldn’t help but flash his teeth in a vicious grin, feeling something that was almost like pride writhe to life in his chest. All of the nervousness Steve had been trying and failing to hide on the drive over was long gone, replaced by an unshakable kind of confidence that suited him really fucking well.

 

It was almost uncanny, how the senior could look exactly the same yet almost completely unrecognisable simultaneously. Gone was the slightly high-strung, affable idiot he’d come to know and tolerate – more than tolerate, not that he’d ever admit to harbouring any warmer feelings towards the older boy – replaced by somebody… effortlessly goddamned suave, and completely unintimidated by the opinions of his peers. His confidence was a lot less aggressive than Billy had learned to make his own, but it was clearly working for him nonetheless.

 

Jesus, with an act like that it was no wonder that a decent chunk of the female population of Hawkins High wanted to fuck him. Or had already, easy as Steve apparently used to be.

 

Steve brushed a hand through his artfully arranged hair, shooting some brunette a downright devious smile, and Billy found that he could quite easily see the appeal.

 

In a strange way, watching Steve almost felt like he was peering into a mirror. A part of him was selfishly relieved to know that he wasn’t the only one who put on a mask in order to satisfy the people around him, but a larger part felt uncomfortably sympathetic. Billy knew how exhausting it was to keep up appearances – enduring the obnoxious loudness of other people when all he wanted was some goddamned quiet – but fitting in had always made the effort worth it, and he knew that Steve felt similarly.

 

At least his friend seemed to genuinely enjoy hanging out with other people – soaking up the attention like a sun deprived daisy – an extrovert through and through despite the extremely limited social circle he’d been surviving in since being condemned for daring to fancy a stick in the mud like Wheeler.

 

Regardless of all that, seeing Steve now… if Billy had met the senior when he was nothing more than this arrogant, entitled playboy? He would have hated his fucking guts, which was somehow both a hilarious and weirdly off-putting thought.

 

It was strange, to think that under slightly different circumstances – with both of their masks firmly in place – he and Steve might have despised each other, measuring dicks and trading blows, be them verbal or physical.

 

Steve met Billy’s gaze through the throng of overenthusiastic drunks separating them, and for a fraction of a second his arrogant façade broke, whiskey brown eyes brightening as his grin lost most of its manufactured sharpness. The junior felt a thrill of smug satisfaction rush through him at the subtle difference in the way Steve looked at him compared to everyone else, knowing with a deep certainty that he was the only asshole at this party who had the dubious honour of being allowed to see what an excitable dork he actually was.

 

“Stevie here tells me your parties are the best in town.” Billy said, turning his most persuasive smile on Tina. If the organiser of this shindig got behind Steve’s uninvited presence, then that would take care of a lot of potential problems before they even had the chance to arise. He’d already pegged the dark-haired senior as an attention seeking busybody, so empty flattery seemed the most obvious route to take in order to soften her up. “And I know you won’t hold that shit with Bitch Wheeler against him, right Tina?”

 

Tina hesitated for only a fraction of a moment before scoffing, waving one of her manicured hands in a broad, dismissive wave before settling it heavily on Billy’s bicep. “Of course not! It’ll be just like old times! We’ve all missed him, you know.”

 

“Hear that, Steve?” He asked with a smirk, sensing that the taller boy’s rapid approach had placed him almost directly behind Billy. “You’re off the hook.”

 

Steve dared to sling a casual arm over his shoulders, and Billy withheld the instinctual urge to drive a sharp elbow into his friend’s ribs only because he was grateful for the fact that his familiar gesture had managed to dislodge Tina’s grasping fingers. “Huh, didn’t know I was on one.” The senior commented idly, tone utterly unphased and gaze even more so. Steve allowed Tina a brief moment to squirm in her discomfort before directing a winning grin at her, that stray lock of hair falling over his forehead as he cocked his head to the side. “You don’t still believe the rumours that Tommy and Carol were spreading about me, right Tina?”

 

Looking increasingly overwhelmed as Billy and Steve continued to stare her down – both with perfectly pleasant expressions on their faces – Tina offered up a slightly stressed smile and a quickly muttered of course not before linking arms with her nameless friends. Eager to escape from the tension they were all pretending not to feel, she promptly spun away, stumbling slightly as her ridiculous heels sunk into the uneven gravel path leading up to Reefer Rick’s house.

Notes:

Did anyone else hate with a burning passion that whole Billy/Karen *thing* the show put us through? Maybe it was just me, but I couldn't help but add in a scene to fix it lol.

Anyway, this and the next update were originally meant to be posted as a single chapter, but it was getting pretty long and it's been ages, plus I've been itching to post something for a while.

Hope you enjoyed!