Chapter Text
There were people fucking everywhere, loud and drunk and constantly shoving themselves right up into Billy’s highly valued personal space. He’d expected it, but expecting and actually enduring were two very different things. Billy was somewhat out of practice when it came to slipping into his well-crafted douchebag party-boy persona – spending so much time with Steve certainly hadn’t helped – which rendered him far less patient when dealing with people he didn’t like.
Which was pretty much everyone who was currently screaming the simplistic lyrics of Whip It loud enough to threaten the integrity of his eardrums, as well as his easily triggered temper. Taking slow, deep breaths only worsened his rapidly plummeting mood – drunken, sweaty teenagers fucking reeked – and it was all he could do to refrain from turning on his heel and driving the hell away from this shithole.
Billy forced himself to enter Reefer Rick’s shitty one-storey lake house despite wanting nothing more than to remain outside – much preferring the icy night air to the disgustingly humid, alcohol infused smog leaking from the ajar front door – smiling and flirting and saying all the right things at all the right times. He lost track of Steve almost immediately, the senior allowing himself to be herded towards the outdated kitchen and the ludicrous amount of alcohol that was no doubt stored inside it. Refusing to trail after him despite the strong urge he felt to keep the older boy in sight, Billy preoccupied himself making small talk and surveying the interior of the cramped house.
The furniture was sparse and very obviously cheap as fuck, chairs looking moments away from collapsing and a sunken couch that looked so threadbare Billy was surprised nobody’s ass had been stabbed by a wayward spring poking through the ratty material. A large crack ran through the screen of a small television set up on what looked like a footrest in the living area, one of its legs propped up by a small stack of playboy magazines. The walls might have been coloured a pale cream once upon a time – and the large paned windows might have been transparent – but they’d been yellowed with what was probably years’ worth of cigarette smoke, a theory that was supported by the many overfilled ashtrays scattered wherever there was space amongst the general clutter. Dust settled thickly over any surface was wasn’t regularly disturbed, and Billy wondered with an internal grimace of disgust when the last time anyone had cleaned anything on this property. Nobody else seemed to give a shit – dancing and making out and playing beer pong without a care in the world – but the low standards of Hawkins natives wasn’t anything new.
One of the younger, less dickish basketballers – Patrick, if he was remembering correctly – offered Billy a plastic cup filled with questionable purple liquid that he hazily insisted was the best punch ever. He took it with a quick pat to the dark-skinned boy’s shoulder, taking a sip and masterfully hiding his distaste behind a lopsided grin. Whoever the wannabe bartender was in this shithole, they fucking sucked at their job. Or were really good at it, depending on how shitfaced you planned on getting. The punch had been spiked with way too much vodka, and the sugary burn of it sliding down Billy’s throat was incredibly unpleasant.
Patrick wandered away with a sloppy grin, teetering from side to side as he made his way out of the grimy kitchen.
Tipping his full cup of punch straight back into the gaudy bowl the rest of it was stagnating in, Billy yanked open the old, dented fridge – which was almost vibrating with the effort of continuing to function – and pulled out the first bottle of beer he saw, intent on nursing it for the rest of the night.
He sedately made his way back towards the beer pong table, smirking as he watched a kid hurl his guts up into a long dead pot plant before deftly sidestepping the overspill.
Natural curiosity and a rising sense of competitiveness drew Billy into the intense game being played between a pair of senior cheerleaders and a couple of guys that he thought might be on the swim team, not that he cared. The girls – displaying impressive accuracy and an incredibly high tolerance for cheap beer – pulled off the win, and Billy jeered along with everyone else as the sore losers were forced to skull the alcohol in the girl’s remaining cups.
Despite his refusal to get drunk – mind flashing with countless memories of intoxicated rages and merciless fists – Billy allowed himself to be coerced into a one on one game with Carver, wanting badly to wipe that infuriatingly smug look off his extremely punchable face. The sophomore had some fucking nerve challenging Billy so openly, and he planned to make the overconfident asshole regret it. Deeply.
Using his telekinesis – which El had recently assured he was getting better at – to subtly shift the trajectory of each ping pong ball as it was thrown led to a decisive and merciless victory. For each miss Billy taunted the sophomore for his below average shooting percentage, gleefully bringing attention to all of his mistakes – both on and off the basketball court – as the crowd howled with heckling laughter. Watching Carver’s entire body grow tense with the seething humiliation rapidly building within him sent a sadistic thrill through Billy. He enjoyed every moment of Carver’s struggle to drink all of the generously filled cups on the table, meeting the younger boy’s burning glare with a cruel smile as the onlookers chanted chug, chug, chug with increasing fervour.
He’d almost forgotten how fucking fun it was to be a ruthless, bullying piece of shit.
In the end Carver couldn’t stomach it, sprinting out of the house with a red face and glazed eyes before promptly vomiting a truly impressive amount all over the dead lawn outside. A chorus of laughter and enthusiastic boos filled the cold night air, and a few seniors – who clearly appreciated Carver’s condescending personality about as much as Billy did – threw their nearly empty beer cans at his hunched over back. The sophomore’s girlfriend approached him tentatively, aiming a strained, somewhat pleading smile at the gathered onlookers.
According to the vast majority of Hawkins High students, Chrissy Cunningham was a sweet, gorgeous, and impressively flexible cheerleader, well on her way to becoming one of the most popular girls in school. She wasn’t particularly gifted in the areas that teenage boys typically appreciated – possessing a mostly flat chest and an even flatter ass – but she had big green eyes and kindness enough for everyone, spending most of her time with her fellow cheerleaders, or hanging off of Carver’s arm.
In short, everyone liked her, and her silent plea for them to please stop immediately put an end to most of the lingering jeers. The crowd began to disperse, short attention spans already searching for something new to entertain them.
Billy watched the scene unfold for only a moment longer – sharp eyes cataloguing Cunningham’s tense posture and wary expression as she placed a feather-light hand on Carver’s shoulder – before turning away with a loud scoff, something like disappointment stirring in his chest despite the fact that he’d never even spoken to the girl before. Unlike most cheerleaders, the auburn-haired girl was surprisingly quiet. Not quite reserved, but definitely shyer than was typical of a girl who made a habit of vaulting through the air wearing a pleated mini-skirt in front of large audiences.
Beautiful and kind Cunningham might be, but she was also fucking stupid, and weak. There was no way she didn’t know that her precious little boyfriend had been cheating on her with Perkins, yet here she was, trying to take care of his ungrateful ass despite so clearly fearing some kind of negative reaction.
Carver was good at pretending to be the upstanding, god-fearing young man that his friends and teachers believed him to be, but even if he hadn’t taken an instant disliking to Billy, the junior had lived almost eighteen years beneath the thumb of an abuser. He knew what a wolf in sheep’s clothing looked like, and he didn’t need his psychic bullshit to sense the potential for cruelty in Carver’s friendly smiles and glinting storm blue eyes.
Seeing Cunningham interact with Carver… it was too much like watching his mom walk on eggshells around Neil, and Billy couldn’t stand the fucking sight of it.
Feeling jittery and irritated – the mean-spirited delight he’d felt while reducing Carver to an incoherent mess well and truly gone – Billy stalked back through the musty house, making a beeline for the backdoor. He waved away the few people imploring him to stick around and play another round of beer pong, desperate for a distraction.
The edge of Lover’s Lake was a lot closer to the back of Reefer Rick’s place than Billy had expected it to be, leaving only a few metres of land between the rickety back steps and the eerily still water. It wasn’t any quieter than inside, and he found his attention quickly drawn away from the vast blackness of the lake stretched out before him. Billy turned his face towards the goddamned huge bonfire that was merrily burning away between the lake house and another, smaller building that could have been either a shed or a boathouse. The blaze was surrounded by drunken high schoolers, some resting comfortably on the logs that served as seating, some dancing around like crazed gypsies belting out the lyrics to Call Me, and some binge drinking by the kegs of beer that someone had so generously provided.
Billy did a double take of the tall asshole currently in the middle of doing a keg-stand, a wry grin twisting his lips even as a sliver of unease worked its way down his spine when he recognised said tall asshole as Steve. Some of the obnoxious seniors surrounding him were chanting his name, while others were eagerly keeping count of the seconds Steve drank without pause, each subsequent number gaining volume and fervour. They were clapping their hands in something that only vaguely resembled a steady rhythm, and Billy flicked his eyes away before his dumbass friend had the chance to come up for air, uninterested in watching Steve as he barfed away his newly returned popularity. Or, in the unlikely event that he managed to keep the alcohol down, beat his chest like a victorious, demented gorilla. Billy honestly couldn’t decide which possibility he detested more.
He looked to his right instead, immediately spying a far smaller fire tucked further back from the lake, half hidden by both Rick’s house and the layer of trees standing between it and Billy. The people surrounding it were decidedly shadier than the main crowd – druggies, loners, and freaks – but the only one that Billy immediately recognised was Eddie Munson, his signature leather jacket and patched denim vest combo making his identity obvious.
Making a mental note of the drug dealer’s location – lifting cash from a few drunk teens for some weed should be child’s play – Billy made his way towards the bonfire, absentmindedly twisting the cold bottle of beer in his hands. Hanging out with the shitfaced morons by the kegs was a giant fuck no, one because he didn’t want to deal with all the whiny bitching that would no doubt start up when he refused to join their sickening drinking game, and two because he had absolutely no intentions of being anywhere near Steve until he’d gauged exactly what kind of guy the senior became after drinking that much cheap beer.
Steve had initially expected them to stay out all night, either partying until the sun rose or crashing out wherever there was sufficient space and warmth. Billy had outright refused to entertain either shitty option, using Maxine’s sleepover as a convenient excuse to both remain sober and avoid freezing his balls off trying to sleep in some overcrowded dump of a lake house, surrounded on all sides by a bunch of inebriated near-strangers.
Yeah, fuck that.
The older boy hadn’t questioned him, offering only an unconcerned shrug and a complete lack of judgement that Billy probably shouldn’t have been so surprised by. Steve’s easy acceptance had nearly tempted Billy to offer him something more honest – trust and shame and a deeply ingrained sense of wariness fighting for control within his too tight ribcage – but in the end he’d kept his mouth shut, effortlessly steering the conversation towards a topic that didn’t make him feel like a cowardly liar.
Steve might not judge him for prioritising his little sister, but if Billy told him that he didn’t drink because he was scared of losing control, of becoming just like his dad? Christ, even just the thought of the senior knowing something so deeply, mortifyingly fucking personal was enough to make him want to take a flying leap off Sattler’s Quarry. Steve wouldn’t be cruel about it – he was too good for that – but the pity Billy could imagine dimming his whiskey brown eyes was almost worse.
Steve already knew way too goddamned much about all the shameful bullshit Billy had successfully hidden for most of his pathetic life, not to mention the guy having seen irrefutable proof that he was a legitimate freak of nature. He didn’t need to know any more. Billy wouldn’t let him know more.
If Steve ever realised how irreparably fucked-up Billy really was? He’d finally come to his senses and leave him where he belonged, a speck of nothing far in the rear-view mirror. Cutting him loose would be better for the senior in the long run – he couldn’t imagine a future where he was worth anything, let alone worth keeping around – but Billy had always been selfish right down to his core.
He’d take his worst fears and weaknesses with him to his fucking grave, and nothing would ever convince him not to.
Anyway, the giggly cheerleaders warming themselves by the bonfire would be more than happy to have him, and Billy could force himself to tolerate their tactile flirting if it meant avoiding the morons trying to measure dick sizes by drinking themselves blind.
He spent the next couple of hours on one of the old logs serving as seats – his ass having gone numb by about the half-hour mark – jammed between Heather and an irritatingly pushy senior named Stella. His fellow junior was far too tipsy to hide the fact that she very clearly didn’t like Stella, and made a point of speaking over the blonde’s slightly nasally voice whenever she opened her mouth. Billy appreciated Heather’s bitchiness more than he would ever tell her, deeply glad when Stella shifted her focus away from trying to get into his pants and instead began trading increasingly catty quips with the younger cheerleader.
Billy listened with a steadily sharpening grin, highly entertained.
“At least I’m not chronically single, unlike someone.”
Heather scoffed, leaning forward to peer around Billy before meeting Stella’s hazy eyes with a smirk. “At least I’m not throwing myself at a guy who clearly isn’t interested.”
“You bitch.” Stella hissed, shooting Billy a desperate look that he pretended not to notice. Instead, he took a small sip of his beer – withholding a grimace at the bitter taste through sheer willpower – and tipped his head back to look up at the smoke obscured night sky. When it became clear that Billy wasn’t about to offer her any support, Stella glared back at Heather. “At least I don’t wear my hair in a side-pony, like a five-year-old.”
“Like your rats nest is any better.”
“It’s a perm.”
“Oh, is that what we’re calling it these days?”
Billy snorted, but before Stella could dramatically gasp her offense or Heather could crow her supposed victory, Amy wobbled to her feet and drunkenly started diffusing the tension between the two cheerleaders, clearly well practiced at it. He watched on with a deeply amused grin, waiting until everyone was once again settled – with the exception of Stella, who’d angrily stalked away with the flimsy excuse of getting another drink – before playfully asking Amy, “Crashed your car yet, Rivers?”
She rolled her eyes as laughter erupted around them, folding her arms and pretending to be offended as everyone who’d had the dubious pleasure of experiencing her driving first-hand started sharing their near-death experiences with the group.
~
Drunk enough that apparently the cold was no longer a concern – they must be fucking smashed, because it was goddamned freezing – a few dickheads on the swim team decided that it’d be a great idea to strip down to their boxers and race each other out to the floating dock near the middle of Lover’s Lake. Word got around quickly, and everyone stopped what they were doing in favour of rushing towards the edge of the lake, eager to watch the clusterfuck unfold. The conclusion seemed forgone – either they were going to drown, or they were going to survive long enough to suffer from hypothermia – but all the same Billy gleefully stood up from his ass-numbing seat, wanting to witness for himself the swimmers faces when their balls touched the ice-cold water.
After saving a couple of drunkenly waltzing band dweebs from being shoved into the bonfire by an oblivious group of high-as-fuck seniors – dismissing the short-haired girl’s breathless gratitude with a sharp order to stay the fuck away from the fire, nerd – Billy followed the direction of the surging partygoers, fully intending to shove himself to the front of the crowd for the best view possible.
A sharp burst of muddled rage cut through the general feelings of blurry cheerfulness brushing against Billy’s sixth sense, ensnaring his attention so completely that he became deaf to the enthusiastic chattering surrounding him, and numb to the bodies pushing uncomfortably close. Thoughtlessly abandoning the no doubt hilarious spectacle taking place in the water, Billy spun on his heel and glared towards the ominously dark woods beyond the ratty boathouse, ignoring the vague ache that sprang to life his skull as he determinedly narrowed his focus.
He couldn’t see them through the shadows, but Billy immediately recognised Carver’s grating presence, and after another few moments of concentration he could feel brief flickers of somebody else’s sorrow-fear-desperation-guilt breaking through the basketballer’s distant yet still oppressive fury.
Deaf to the confused and irritated exclamations coming from the people nearest to him, Billy roughly freed himself from the crowd and stalked into the darkness lining the bonfire’s healthy glow, trusting both his new boots and his hard-won instincts to save him from twisting an ankle in a ditch or running face-first into a goddamned tree. Like all the numerous times he’d hunted Maxine’s flighty ass down over the last four years, Billy didn’t overthink where he was going, knowing with a bone deep certainty that he was moving in the right direction.
He passed within a few metres of the boathouse’s uninviting front door and singular grimy window, hardly paying any attention to the faint light and murmuring voices coming from within. According to pretty much everyone – the drug dealer wasn’t exactly subtle – Reefer Rick and some of the more hardcore addicts in Hawkins used the building as more of a smokehouse than a boathouse, and judging by the sharp, slightly acidic scent muddying the crisp night air, everyone was right. Not that Billy gave a fuck. So long as they didn’t bother him, they could fry their brains all they liked.
Moving on quickly – leaving the light and quickly fading music even further behind him – Billy headed deeper into the steadily thickening woods, suspicion and dread churning agitatedly in his stomach. There was no good reason for Carver to drag his fearful girlfriend away from the party and into the dark, and Billy wasn’t about to allow the haughty douchebag the privacy needed for whatever foul bullshit he was trying to pull. His imagination readily supplied him with a long list of fucked-up shit that a guy – especially a guy as drunk as Carver no doubt was – could do to a vulnerable girl far away from prying eyes, filling his mind with images and scenarios that he vainly tried to shake loose, teeth gritted hard enough to make his jaw ache.
Billy restlessly flexed his scarred knuckles, aching to break Carver’s nose, or bust in his teeth, or both. Hell, maybe he’d take a page out of Maxine’s playbook and kick the sophomore in the dick. He might not think much of Cunningham beyond occasionally being impressed by the falseness of her beaming smiles, but that didn’t matter. If Carver dared to lay so much as a single fucking finger on the naïve girl… well, Billy’s hair-trigger was never more sensitive than when an asshole was treating a woman like shit.
A hollow rattling sound pulled Billy from the viciously swirling thoughts in his head, the noise growing louder while seeming to come from every direction at once. He glanced around the moon-lit woods with a grimace, exhaling a harsh breath and agitatedly rolling out his shoulders when he noticed that the mostly bare tree branches above him were trembling unnaturally. His cruel fantasies of beating Carver senseless were swiftly replaced by memories of the destruction he’d wrought near Hopper’s secluded cabin, and as much as Billy might like to hurt Carver for being such a douchebag, he didn’t want to accidently fucking kill him. It took some effort, but he managed to reign in his temper – which in turn soothed his fickle, emotion-driven telekinesis – relaxing somewhat when that haunting rattle faded back into the natural silence of the woods.
Which was broken again when Billy got close enough to the pair of arguing sophomores to hear them. He quickened his pace but made sure to quiet his footfalls, knowing how erratically drunks could behave when they felt startled or threatened.
“…ust stop, Chris. You’re embarrassing me, and- and yourself. I’m fine!”
“You’re not fine, Jason. You’re dru-“ Cunningham was quick to cut herself off, voice shifting from indignant to pacifying in an instant. Just like Billy, the cheerleader had obviously learned that arguing never did anything other than make an already tense situation that much fucking worse. “Let’s just go back-“
“No, you said you wanted to talk. Privately. So- here we are, babe.”
Billy skirted closer until he could see the couple more clearly, biting back a derisive scoff at the way Carver dramatically threw out his arms and spun unsteadily on his heel, clearly trying to indicate their supposed privacy. At least for now, the basketballer’s anger had shifted into a bemused kind of scorn, and a shallow dip into the disgusting swirl of his drunken mind reassured Billy that he wasn’t about to start swinging at his girlfriend. Yet.
Cunningham’s fear had faded almost into non-existence, though her nerves and supressed eagerness to return to the party were still pulsing strongly.
Now more curious than concerned, Billy leant a shoulder against the closest tree trunk – well within sight of both Carver and Cunningham, not that either of them noticed – and settled in to watch the domestic dispute unfold, wondering what had started it, as well as how it would end. He’d put his money on pretty goddamned badly, but he also didn’t want to underestimate Cunningham’s ability to handle her shitty boyfriend’s bitch-fits. Apparently they’d been dating since early middle school, so Billy seriously doubted that she’d endured Carver for that long without learning how to navigate – manipulate – his obviously fragile ego.
Cunningham shifted uneasily on her feet, shivering despite the fact that she was currently wrapped up in Carver’s too-big letterman jacket. In the faint light provided by the nearly full moon above, Billy spied the cheerleader’s delicately pretty features settle into something simultaneously uncomfortable and determined. “I- Jason, please listen. I wasn’t trying to- to control you, or anything like that. You were just being really mean to Patrick and I-“
“Oh, fuck Patrick. What, you like him better than me now?” Carver snapped bitterly – practically fucking broadcasting his pathetic insecurities – taking a sharp but wobbling step closer to his girlfriend.
She cringed, backing up a step. “Of course not. But-"
Carver scoffed, rolling his eyes and releasing a heavy sigh, as if Cunningham was acting like some kind of spoilt child he didn’t have the patience for. “You know I love you, Chris. But right now you’re really-“ He hiccoughed, swaying slightly to the left before consciously straightening his posture. “- testing my patience. I-"
“No.” Cunningham interrupted, fingers twisting together anxiously before she tucked them out of sight behind her back. Her chest rose steadily as she pulled in a deep breath, and her spine straightened in a way that had Billy’s own tensing up. He’d expected her to play the meek, agreeable little girlfriend in order to appease Carver’s growing temper, but looking at the cheerleader now… This was not a girl who was about to let herself be cowed. Not anymore.
It was a risky move on Cunningham’s part. As far as she knew there was nobody around to help her if Carver reacted badly to her uncharacteristic display of defiance – which was pretty much fucking guaranteed, especially considering how drunk he was – and Billy couldn’t decide whether he wanted to give her shit for her ill-timed recklessness, or congratulate her for standing up to the self-important dickhead.
Billy slowly – silently – straightened up from his casual lean, eyes sharp and hands curled into fists by his sides. The millisecond that Carver decided to do something stupid, he was going to make the snobby shit eat the fucking ground.
“What?” Carver blinked, clearly thrown off guard by the unexpected denial.
The cheerleader swallowed thickly; voice quiet but tone unwavering when she answered. “I don’t think you do. Love me. If you did, you wouldn’t have slept with Carol.”
Carver groaned loudly, running a hand roughly through his hair before rubbing it over his face. “Babe, I’ve already told you this a thousand times. It was a mistake, alright? And- it only happened the one time! You’re being way too sensitive, Chris. It’s really not a big deal.” After a moment the tension eased from his twisted face, giving way to a sloppy smile as he took another step closer to Cunningham. She watched him suspiciously, but didn’t back away this time, not even when Carver reached out and clumsily cupped her cheek in his palm. “Hey, let’s forget about that, yeah? All this privacy… I can make you forget everything if you actually let me touch you…”
The sad grimace on Cunningham’s face made it very clear that she was uncomfortable, and the pitiful sight had Billy’s protective instincts flaring to life inside his chest. He might not know the cheerleader – having absolutely no idea if she’d thank him or politely tell him to fuck off for daring to inject himself into her very personal business – but like hell was Billy about to watch Carver lay his drunken hands on her when he couldfeel how much she wasn’t into it.
What kind of unappealing as shit proposition even was that, anyway? Jesus Christ, it was no fucking wonder the sophomore had resorted to getting his dick wet with a known floozy like Perkins.
Having heard more than enough out of Carver’s disgusting mouth, Billy legs tensed in preparation to propel him forward, fully intending to snag a fistful of Carver’s neatly coiffed hair and throwing his ass down hard into the dirt.
Cunningham moved before Billy had the chance, her sadness sharpening into a fierce kind of indignance as she shoved aside her boyfriend’s caressing hand, drew back her arm, and landed a goddamned solid slap against his hilariously shocked face. Carver’s head whipped to the left beneath the force of the blow, and he slowly brought up a hand to touch his stinging cheek. A momentarily debilitating mixture of alcohol and sheer, mind-numbing disbelief left him frozen with indecision, struggling to come to terms with the fact that goody-goody, kind-to-everyone Chrissy Cunningham had just struck him. On purpose, and with a surprising amount of strength for someone with such skinny arms.
The cheerleader gasped as her own disbelief slammed into her, staggering a few steps away from Carver as she cradled her no doubt smarting hand tightly against her chest. If the situation weren’t so tense – if it didn’t evoke so many fucking godawful memories – Billy might have laughed, morbidly amused by Cunningham’s horrified expression. As it was, he simply rolled his eyes at the discombobulated mixture of surprise-guilt-satisfaction-anger-sorrow-guilt radiating from the distressed girl, psychically shoving her loudly clamouring emotions away before they had a chance to worsen his headache.
Cunningham felt guilty? What the fuck for? As far as Billy was concerned, Carver deserved far worse than a measly slap to the face for all the despicable shit he’d said and done over the last few minutes. Hell, considering how long they’d been dating and how much of a piece of shit Carver was? A part of Billy was surprised that Cunningham hadn’t smacked the shit out of him a lot sooner, though a larger – and far more realistically cynical – part knew exactly why she hadn’t.
Most of the time Carver put on one hell of a convincing show, playing the innocently charming boy next door with almost clinical precision. Billy might have clocked the sophomore’s bullshit pretty much immediately, but he highly doubted that a nice girl like Cunningham – who didn’t seem all that clever, if he was being honest – would have realised what a two-faced scumbag she was dealing with until the truth of it was all but shoved in her face. Maybe tonight was the first time she was seeing who her boyfriend really was, maybe it wasn’t. Either way, it seemed like her impressively deep well of patience had run dry.
Carver huffed out a breathy, disturbingly flat chuckle, slowly rotating his head back to glare into Cunningham’s wide, anxious eyes. He rubbed aggressively at his cheek, his sense of mystified amusement quickly devolving into an intense, furious desire to teach her a lesson. “You think you can just- just hit me when we disagree on something?” Carver shook his head, smiling in a way that was anything but friendly. “That’s just not on, babe. Now, I’m gonna hit you, and we’ll see how-"
Billy moved, Cunningham’s hyperventilating breaths and tear streaked cheeks breaking through the harsh ringing in his ears and giving way to the near blinding rage pounding against his ribcage. He didn’t bother quieting his footfalls as he lunged across the space between himself and Carver, briefly meeting Cunningham’s tear-bright eyes over the shorter boy’s shoulder but completely ignoring her near silent gasp of his name. Before Carver had the chance to fully register the danger he was in – turning far too slowly as he belatedly noticed the ominous shift in the previously still night air behind him – Billy grabbed a merciless handful of his blonde hair and yanked.
The sophomore let out a choked gurgle as his head was cruelly forced backwards, the dulling effect of alcohol and a deeply pleasing surge of fear extinguishing any kind of fight he might have otherwise put up as Billy ruthlessly kicked his legs out from beneath him. Carver fell hard onto his back, his head bouncing off the ground with a satisfying thud and his lungs emitting a desperate wheeze as the air was knocked out of them. Billy was incredibly familiar with the overwhelming breathlessness that came with such an unforgiving blow to the diaphragm – Neil had left him helplessly curled up on the floor more times than he could fucking count,lungs seizing and vision spotting with black – but he had no pity to offer, viciously glad that the pathetic asshole was suffering.
He deserved it. He deserved worse.
Feeling disinclined towards making breathing any easier for the douchebag, Billy was quick to plant a booted foot onto his sternum, grinning widely as Carver’s eyes bulged and his mouth gaped open like a land-bound fish beneath the pressure. “You weren’t stupid enough to think you were alone out here, did you?” Billy asked rhetorically, cocking his head to the side and smirking when the younger boy grasped at his ankle and vainly began trying to pry his foot off.
Smirk flattening into a tight line when one of Carver’s fingers pressed just a little bit too hard into some of his demo-dog scars, Billy leaned more of his weight onto his shuddering chest.
Coughing weakly between gasps – body twitching uselessly as he tried to force his alcohol leaden limbs to do something that was actually conducive towards escape – Carver scowled mutinously, eyes glittering with malice. “F- Fuck you, Hargrove. I’ll fucking e-end you!”
“Aw, trying to threaten me, little boy?” Billy taunted snidely; shifting his foot closer to the sophomore’s frantically bobbing Adams apple before applying more pressure. Carver renewed his struggling with a string of increasingly incoherent curses, hands clawing violently at Billy’s boot as his hips bucked and his legs kicked out at nothing. He was squirming like a rat caught in a trap – eyes wild, hair littered with debris, and a disgusting amount of spittle staining his cheeks – and Billy revelled in the truly pathetic picture he made. Flashing his teeth in yet another nasty smile, Billy inched his foot even closer to the drunken asshole’s vulnerable throat, smiling wider still at the distressed squeak Carver involuntarily emitted. “You’re being way too sensitive, Jason. This isn’t a big deal.”
It took him a second – Carver successfully portrayed himself as a lot of things, yet smart hadn’t ever been one of them – but once he recognised his own words being crooned back at him he grimaced, pale face colouring slightly in the dim light of the moon. “Let me u-up!”
Billy bent his upper body forward, resting his crossed forearms against his raised knee and sliding his tongue between his teeth as he stared down into the sophomore’s livid expression. “Fuck no, dipshit. Not until you’ve learned your lesson.” He straightened back up and shot Cunningham a quick look over his shoulder, momentarily distracted by the chaotic whirlwind of conflicted emotions that were currently grating against his sixth sense.
The cheerleader was watching him bully her boyfriend with a surprisingly neutral expression, though her painfully rigid posture and red-rimmed eyes would have immediately clued Billy in to how not fine she was if his psychic fuckery hadn’t already made that perfectly clear. He almost opened his mouth and ordered her to go back to the party – to free herself of the emotional upheaval this fucked-up situation was causing her and leave dealing with Carver to him – but silenced himself before he could put his foot in his mouth.
Billy didn’t know exactly how she was feeling and he wasn’t about to go digging through her head trying to find out, but if even a small part of her was glad to see her shitty boyfriend be put in his place… Well, he wasn’t about to deprive her of witnessing some good old fashioned payback. So long as Cunningham didn’t descend into a panicked spiral or ask him to stop, Billy figured that she was fine with him roughing the cocky asshole up. Probably.
Regardless, he was enjoying himself far too fucking much to bother overanalysing the cheerleader’s anxious silence. She’d either grow a spine and speak up, or she wouldn’t. Her indecision – or lack thereof – wasn’t his problem.
Cunningham flinched when Carver followed the direction of Billy’s brief glance, swallowing thickly and jerking her teary eyes away when he proceeded to glower at her in a way that all but promised cruel retribution. Witnessing the entire sickening interaction, Billy had to fight down the urge to stomp on Carver’s fucking throat, heart hammering with the fierce desire to hurt as his hands curled into tight fists. Instead of giving into his more violent impulses – because no matter how furious Cunningham’s instinctual fear made him, he wasn’t about to actually kill the dumb fuck lying at his feet – he leaned down once more and delivered a harsh slap to the sophomore’s face, directly over the subtly reddened skin left behind by Cunningham’s own strike. “Hey, eyes up here, you piece of shit.”
Grudgingly – fear singing beautifully through the air around him – Carver turned his hateful glare on Billy, who met it with an unconcerned sneer.
“Now, here’s what’s gonna happen.” Billy began, his friendly tone at odds with the cruel glint in his narrowed eyes. “You’re gonna apologise- nicely, to your girlfriend-"
“I’m not- we’re not…” Cunningham trailed off uncertainly, shivering. Billy prompted her to continue with a pointedly arched eyebrow – his curiosity warring with his impatience – watching closely as she clumsily set her shoulders and pursed her lips, resolve in every line of her tense frown. “I’m not his girlfriend. Not anymore.”
Carver blinked in mute shock for about half a second before renewing his pointless thrashing, quieting down only when Billy finally slid his foot up to rest threateningly against the base of his throat. The sophomore’s hands slowly unclenched from the leather of his boot before he held them up in begrudging surrender, each of his inhales and exhales made slightly thready by the weight Billy was mercilessly applying to his trachea. “Okay, okay.” Carver capitulated angrily, refusing to meet Billy’s eyes – staring instead at the dully glinting Saint Christopher pendant hanging from his necklace – while also very obviously fighting down his desire to look over at his girl- ex-girlfriend. “Chris- babe. You don’t mean that. I love you, and- we can work this out!”
“I don’t want to- to work things out with you anymore!” Cunningham exploded tearfully, sniffling wetly as she stared down at Carver’s incredulous expression. “I- I’m not happy. You don’t make me-“ Her voice trembled on the edge of breaking – an emotion disturbingly like grief shadowing her mind – but she continued with a doggedness that Billy wouldn’t have ever expected from her. “You don’t make me happy anymore, Jason. We’re not good for each other, and- I just think it’d be best if we broke up. Please, don’t be angry.”
Carver’s face twisted into something truly ugly, jaw working as he ground his teeth together. “Don’t be angry? I-“ He cut himself off before Billy had the pleasure of smacking some more sense into him, sucking in as deep a breath as he was currently able before shoving his outrage behind a disgustingly fake mask of contrition. “I’m sorry, alright? I’ll make it up to you, I swear. All that with Carol, it didn’t mean anything! What else was I supposed to do?” The drunken haze in his eyes seemed to deepen as he slipped into memory, a darkly amused, lecherous smirk slowly curving his lips up. Carver gathered up the courage – or maybe the stupidity – to meet Billy’s unimpressed stare, no doubt hoping to appeal to the Californian party-boy he supposedly was. “It’s not my fault. She just wouldn’t stop begging for it, you know? The slut was practically on her knees, and I thought- hey, it’s not like I’m getting any from my frigid girlfr-argh-"
“Shut the fuck up.” Billy ordered flatly, watching intently as the veins and arteries in the sophomore’s neck began bulging beneath the pressure of his boot. It was so goddamned tempting to just cut off the good for nothing cheater’s airway entirely, and with each of Cunningham’s badly muffled sobs the violent urge became more difficult to ignore. Billy wanted Carver to know what it was like, to suffer beneath the words and hands of someone stronger, someone fucking meaner. He wanted him to know exactly the kind of bitter, hopelessly painful dread he’d so callously enjoyed drawing out of his ex-girlfriend, and what it felt like to be controlled by it.
Rage tunnelled Billy’s vision – his mind eagerly supplying him with echoes of his mom’s miserable cries, accompanied by crystal fucking clear images of her beautiful, bruised face – and it took every iota of hard-won restraint he possessed not to give into it.
Carver might deserve to have the absolute shit kicked out of him, but Billy wasn’t the one he’d wronged, no matter what fucked-up connections his damaged psyche was drawing. Yes, there were some surface-level similarities between the pair of high-schoolers and his parents, but while Billy was undoubtedly taking Carver’s disgusting, vile bullshit personally – probably too goddamned personally – he wasn’t an idiot. Despite the sophomore’s blatant disrespect for Cunningham’s… everything, and the drunken ease with which he’d decided that he was perfectly within his rights to lay a violent hand on her, he was nowhere near vicious enough to be compared to Neil… Or at least, he wasn’t yet. In the same vein, Cunningham wasn’t anything like Daniella.
He very pointedly didn’t let himself consider what his mom might have been like before Neil systematically broke her down, tugging sharply at his short hair and forcing himself to refocus on Cunningham’s deathly pale face. Billy watched her for a moment – taking in the sharp rise and fall of her chest, as well as the fine trembling of her narrow shoulders – before blowing out a long breath, taking his deeply seated desire to hurt,and forcibly putting it on the backburner. The last thing she needed right now was to deal with another angry asshole. “Want me to fuck him up?” Billy asked, waving his hand down at Carver’s pathetic form.
“No! Let me-"
“I wasn’t fucking talking to you, shitheel.” Billy interrupted sharply, applying enough pressure to Carver’s throat to turn his voice into a weak, strangled croak. He didn’t let up until he felt the sophomore’s defiance crumple into frightened resignation, and the sounds of his gasping breaths brought a small, sadistic smile to his lips. “I’d rather not get blood on my new boots, so why don’t you quit squirming around like a bitch and keep your useless mouth shut?”
Carver bared his teeth in a silently furious snarl, though he very wisely kept whatever empty, macho-bullshit comeback he wanted to make to himself.
Satisfied that the sophomore was sufficiently cowed, Billy once again turned his gaze to Cunningham. Despite his foolish hope that the cheerleader would be vindictive enough to let him bloody up her ex at least a little, he knew what her answer would be even before she tentatively began to shake her head. He’d learned over the past few minutes that Cunningham really was too kind – too goddamned forgiving – for her own good, which was about as respectable as it was irritating as fuck.
In Billy’s experience, kindness was rarely worth the pain it invited.
“Um, Billy…” Cunningham whispered shakily, wiping away tears that were almost immediately replaced by more. “Could you please let him go? He’s too drunk for any of this to really matter…”
Billy shook his head and clenched his jaw, her despondent tone making him feel disproportionately angry. How many times had his mom adopted that exact tone after being forced to endure Neil’s latest cruelty? Too many to fucking count. “Screw that.” Billy refuted firmly, holding back the urge to sneer and snap through sheer force of will. “What, he’s gonna come crying at you tomorrow, hungover and pathetic, and you’re gonna forgive him just because he was fucking drunk?”
The cheerleader blinked, quickly shaking her head. “N-No…”
“He’ll keep cheating on you.” Billy continued ruthlessly, determined to make Cunningham see the reality of her shitty situation before doubt convinced her to backslide into the quiet, hollowly cheerful girl he’d originally had her pegged as. She’d demonstrated a stronger spine than Billy had given her credit for, and he’d be damned if he watched it bend now. “He’ll keep treating you like shit. I mean- come on, Ponytail. You’re not stupid enough to believe this is the last time he’s gonna try and hit you, right?” He barked out a bitter laugh, swallowing the guilt trying to clog his throat when she flinched back from the harsh sound. She needed to fucking hear this, no matter how much the brutal truth of it stung. “Newsflash, Cunningham. Guys like him don’t get better. They only get meaner, drunker-"
No doubt remembering the relentless gossip surrounding Billy’s two week absence back in November – he’d lost count of how many nosy shits had demanded to see the ugly wounds left behind by the stray that had supposedly torn into him – Carver reached up and dug his fingers as deeply into the scarred meat of Billy’s calf as the thick denim of his jeans allowed. Grunting at the unexpectedly sharp ache that erupted in his leg, Billy jerked his boot off Carver’s throat and shook off his clawing fingers with a vehement curse. The sophomore gave a smugly triumphant little smirk in response to his pained reaction, but Billy only allowed him half a moment to revel in his meaningless victory before bringing his boot back down, hard.
Cunningham’s alarmed cry overshadowed Carver’s frightened yelp, the cheerleader darting forward as her ex-boyfriend turned his head away – fast enough that Billy was surprised he didn’t snap his own worthless neck – and squeezed his stormy blue eyes shut as he braced to have his face caved in.
Billy’s Doc Marten hit the ground directly beside Carver’s head with enough force to kick up a decent amount of dirt, and he found a deep sense of spiteful satisfaction in watching the asshole choke on it. Voice coming out perfectly flat – he’d learned young that most of the time a whisper was far more unnerving than a shout – Billy warned, “Try some dumb shit like that again and I’ll crush your fucking trachea. Understood?”
Looking like he was moments away from either hurling or pissing himself, Carver frantically nodded his head. “U-Understood! Jesus.”
Humming a vague note, Billy pointedly returned his boot to the base of the sophomore’s throat, pressing down almost teasingly. Without looking back at Cunningham – uninterested in seeing evidence of the spike of nervousness he could sense jittering through her – he asked, “What’ll it be, Ponytail? You gonna be his pretty little punching bag, or are you gonna leave him in the dirt where he belongs?”
“I… I’m sorry, Jason. We’re done.” Cunningham said softly, voice taut with emotion she was trying to hold back.
Carver had the fucking nerve to look heartbroken, eyes round and glossy with tears as he gathered the courage to stare over at his now ex-girlfriend. “Chris…”
“Please don’t hurt him.” She continued, ignoring Carver’s wobbling plea and instead choosing to address Billy. “He- he usually isn’t like this, really. Jason’s not a bad person. Tonight was just… it was just- he can be a little bit too sensitive, when he’s drinking.”
Billy scoffed derisively, sneering down at Carver but seeing Neil. Was this what his dad had been like as a teenager? Manipulative, prone to violence, but still somewhat clumsy in his execution? Still a little bit sensitive when it came to the pain he caused others? A juvenile monster, still learning its craft? Had he drawn Daniella in using whatever sliver of goodness he hadn’t yet carved out of himself, luring her to his side with false decency before trapping her there with his belittling mouth and bruising hands?
Would Carver have done the same to Cunningham, if Billy hadn’t intervened?
A feather light pressure to his left elbow pulled Billy abruptly from his morbid musings, and he instinctively jerked his arm out of Cunningham’s lax hold. She took a quick step backwards, green eyes wide with apology. “Sorry! I didn’t mean to-"
“It’s fine.” Billy grumbled, berating himself for flinching away from a girl who looked thin enough to snap beneath a light breeze. Fucking hell, he needed to get a grip.
Cunningham nodded slowly, unwilling to question him despite the faintly doubtful furrow in her perfectly plucked eyebrows. “Of course, um… I was just going to say, I think Jason’s learnt his lesson. You can let him up.”
“Oh, can I?” He drawled sarcastically, rolling his eyes at Cunningham’s wincing attempt at a flustered smile before reaching down and pinching Carver’s chin between his thumb and index finger. The younger boy didn’t put up any kind of fight – a mixture of lingering fear, mounting exhaustion, and bitter dejection clouding his drunken mind – and the glare he tried to pierce Billy with was weakened by the tear tracks leaking from the corners of his eyes, as well as the snot congealing above his upper lip. He made for a disgusting, pitiful sight, and Billy felt some of the anger that had been coiling tighter and tighter around his jackrabbiting heart begin to settle.
Carver was no longer a threat – not that he’d posed one to Billy in the first place – and he’d make damn sure the sophomore never threatened Cunningham again.
Billy tightened his hold on the younger boy’s chin, digging his thumbnail into sweat-slick skin hard enough to threaten blood. Carver blinked up at him uneasily, starkly uncomfortable beneath the intensity of his venomous stare. “Listen up, ‘cause I’m only gonna say this once.” Billy murmured, carefully stretching out his telepathy and digging shallowly into Carver’s wide-open mind. He’d wanted to ensure that the sophomore didn’t have any choice but to pay attention – to obey – but his mental trespass was immediately derailed by the whining asshole’s blaring internal monologue.
How could she break up with me? Doesn’t she know I love her? This isn’t happening. Billy’s terrifying- his eyes. I’ll get him back for this. I’ll get Chrissy back too. Once Billy not around to feed her any of that bullshit about me, she’ll take me back. She’s nothing without me and I’ll make sure she remembers that. None of this is my fault. I didn’t do anything wro-
Sickened and pissed right the fuck off – anger ratcheting back up into a teeth grinding haze that made him want so goddamned badly to split his scarred knuckles open against Carver’s face – Billy shoved aside his own reluctance and dug deeper into the sophomore’s insipid little brain, curling metaphorical fingers around his whining, circular thoughts before crushing them into silence.
Carver’s eyes lost what little lucidity an overabundance of cheap beer hadn’t already taken, and Billy wasted no time pressing his own will onto the newly blank canvas of the younger boy’s thoughts. Taking what he’d learned from his previous forays into Neil’s hellscape of a mind, Billy did his best to instil in Carver a deep sense of respect for Cunningham – something that was notably absent – as well as a heaping pile of guilt for the way he’d treated her tonight. His headache bloomed quickly into the beginnings of a migraine and his stomach began to roil from the mental strain, but Billy didn’t let himself falter. Cunningham’s continued safety might depend entirely upon the cognitive rewiring he was putting her ex’s empty brain through, so he wasn’t about to stop until he was certain that Carver wouldn’t try to manipulate – or just outright force – the naively kind-hearted girl into taking him back.
Fucking with other people’s heads might leave Billy feeling like some kind of filthy, monstrous voyeur, but he couldn’t just do nothing. If his psychic tampering protected Cunningham, then the toll it took on his already fucked-up psyche was well worth it.
“From now on, unless Cunningham approaches you first, you’re going to leave her alone. If you don’t, I’ll do worse than just make you regret it.” Billy murmured softly, staring unblinkingly into Carver’s vacant eyes as his words sunk in and stuck. “Now, get the hell up, go back to the party, and tell anyone who asks that it’s yourfault she broke up with you. If they demand details, you tell them to piss off.”
After a few moments Carver sluggishly nodded his head, blinking back into awareness and shoving weakly at the boot that Billy still had pressed to the base of his neck. “Wha-whatever. Get off’a me…”
Though it was the last thing he wanted to do, Billy lifted his foot and took a wide step backwards, watching closely as Carver clumsily climbed up onto his feet. The younger boy cast a brief glance towards both of them – eyeing Billy resentfully and pouting at Cunningham like she’d just given him a terminal cancer diagnosis – before proceeding to stagger away, moving in the general direction of Tina’s shitty New Year’s party.
Billy and Cunningham stared at his back until the darkness of the woods swallowed him up, and continued to stand side by side without speaking until they could no longer hear his uneven footfalls crunching against the dead leaf litter layered over the ground. Once Carver was well and truly gone the cheerleader buried her face into her hands and blindly fell back against the tree standing behind her – either oblivious to or uncaring of the dust and bark she was getting all over Carver’s precious letterman jacket – knees threatening to give out as her adrenaline began crashing. Billy took a quick step towards her but didn’t dare to actually reach out, wary of frightening her any more than he already had.
The fuck could he even do, anyway? Or say? Shitty circumstances and terrible timing might have necessitated that Billy become more open to at least attempting to comfort people over the past few weeks – giving a damn about a bunch of traumatised, overly emotional children, plus Steve, was goddamned exhausting – but that didn’t mean he’d gotten any better at it.
Still, Billy wasn’t about to just stand there and stare like a brain-dead moron while the distraught cheerleader failed to quiet her crying. He ran a stressed hand through his hair before clearing his throat, wanting to get rid of the oppressively awkward atmosphere that was descending upon them. “This is a stupid question, and feel free to tell me to eat shit, but- you alright, Ponytail?”
Cunningham nodded her head rapidly, lifting her tear-stained face from her hands to look at him. Whatever she saw in Billy’s expression had her just as quickly shaking her head, narrow shoulders lifting in a helpless, tired shrug. She sniffled, lowering her arms and instead wrapping them around her middle. “Not- not really. I’m…” The girl laughed, the sound edged with self-depreciation and slight hysteria. “I feel really dumb. I feel- I’ve always known that Jason had a temper, even back when we were kids, but- I’ve never been scared of him before. Not truly. Not- until tonight.”
“You’re not dumb.” Billy said, though he wasn’t sure if he believed his own statement. “Carver’s just a prick.”
“I- this is my fault. I shouldn’t have slapped-"
“Hey, don’t start with that bullshit, Cunningham.” Billy couldn’t help but snap, incensed that Carver had managed to twist her up so badly that she actually believed that any part of this was on her. He met and held the cheerleader’s surprised gaze, trying not to scowl too harshly. “If some asshole acted like Carver did just then to one of your friends, would you tell her to stand there and take it?”
Cunningham frowned, offense – and another spark of that unexpected fire – breaking through her guilt-ridden melancholy. “Of course not!”
“So what, she gets to fight back but you don’t? Wanna try and explain that logic to me, Ponytail?”
“I-“ Her mouth opened and closed a few times as she failed to think up a timely excuse, shame and incredulity and realisation rendering the cheerleader temporarily mute. Cunningham’s indignation sputtered out into a fragile, uneasy kind of acceptance, and she let out a long but thankfully steady sigh in the wake of it. After a few moments of quiet introspection she managed to actually smile at Billy – the green in her eyes briefly shining more with amusement than pain – wiping absently at her wet cheeks as her tears finally slowed to a stop. “That was sneaky of you, Billy. You’re clever.”
Billy huffed out a bemused breath – he’d been called a lot of shit in his life, but clever hadn’t ever made the cut before – relieved that the threat of a hysterically sobbing high-school girl seemed to have passed. Even after surviving the awkwardly emotional messes that Maxine, Byers, and El had a bad habit of becoming whenever Billy was unlucky enough to be nearby, he still had no real idea how to handle someone else’s tears without coming across as an uncaring, blunt douchebag. Or, he didn’t know how to handle tears in situations where he didn’t want to come across as an uncaring, blunt douchebag. There was a definite difference.
“Don’t sound so surprised, Cunningham.” Billy eventually responded, rolling his shoulders and aiming a somewhat lacklustre smirk her way. He didn’t want to linger out in these creepy as fuck woods any longer than he had to, but he also wouldn’t be leaving them until Cunningham did. “You good, or do you need another minute before heading back?”
Cunningham proceeded to sit down, leaning her back against the tree and curling her arms tightly around her drawn up legs. “I’m- I just want to stay here for a bit.” She gave him a brittle, insincere smile that didn’t look much like a smile at all, fiddling with the striped cuffs of Carver’s jacket. “You don’t need to, though! I mean, you probably want to get back to the party. I’ll be fine.”
Unsure whether the cheerleader was just naturally a terrible liar – like, Steve levels of terrible – or if she just assumed that he wouldn’t notice how not fine she’d be if he left her alone, Billy cocked his head to the side and stared down at her small, defensively hunched form for a long moment.
After his mom left, Billy had still been young and naïve enough to hate being alone. He’d learned quickly, though. Being alone was the safest thing you could possibly be, and safety was always more important than childish notions of unfairness, and comfort.
Somehow, he doubted that Cunningham would agree.
Locking a long-suffering groan behind his clenched teeth – this was going to be so goddamned awkward – Billy lowered himself to the ground a few metres opposite her, making a show of casually stretching out his legs and leaning back on his hands. A pointy rock immediately started jabbed into his right thigh and the cold dirt felt gritty against his palms, but he kept his posture loose and his irritated shifting to a minimum. He wasn’t about to risk making Cunningham even more uncomfortable by looming over her like an asshole, not even to avoid annoying rocks and dirt stains on the ass of his jeans.
Cunningham stared at him with wide eyes over the bony rises of her bare knees – Billy honestly had no idea how she wasn’t visibly shivering in that ridiculously short dress of hers – no doubt surprised by the fact that he hadn’t immediately taken the out she’d offered and run with it. Her reaction was perfectly understandable considering the obnoxiously uncaring persona he made sure to flaunt at school, but it still prickled at his nerves to know that she’d fully expected him to leave her out in the woods by herself.
He wouldn’t admit to being worried – he didn’t know this girl – but… well, it was pretty fucking cold, and dark, and they were a decent distance from Reefer Rick’s property. Sue him for being pessimistic enough to imagine all the ways that Cunningham might fuck herself up – either on accident or on purpose – if left to her own questionable devices.
Billy didn’t typically consider there to be any cons to being known as a sharp-tongued Californian with a bad attitude – being a raging dick was effective protection against other, potentially worse raging dicks – but this? The wariness in Cunningham’s flickering stare? That was a big fucking con, and it made Billy feel like shit, chest tight and skin fitting wrong over his restless muscles.
“Um.” Cunningham murmured, clearly thrown off both by Billy’s quietness and his continued presence. He arched an eyebrow at her nervous stuttering – shunting aside the sick feeling her well-founded caution had inspired in him – and in the moonlight he just managed to catch the way her cheeks flushed with embarrassment. “Uh- what- what were you doing out here, before…”
“Taking a piss.” Billy lied with a smooth shrug, smirking at her startled blink. “I heard Carver start throwing his bitch fit, so I came to see what all the fuss was about.”
The cheerleader grimaced, tightening her arms around her legs and looking away. “Right…”
It went quiet – Cunningham’s shame and awkwardness all but vibrating the air around her – and Billy had to bite back a sigh, cursing his stupid mouth and searching his stalling brain for something to say that wouldn’tupset her. Billy despised small-talk, but considering the vaguely traumatic shitshow that Cunningham had just gone through? He figured the least he could do was suffer through some empty pleasantries and shallow questions for her peace of mind. “So, how long have you been waving pom-pom’s around?”
The smile her lips curled up into was short-lived but genuine – as was her flash of unspoken gratitude – and Billy begrudgingly settled himself into his uncomfortable sprawl on the ground, preparing to get to know Chrissy Cunningham better than he’d ever expected to.
~
“Your mom sounds like a bitch.”
Chrissy snorted, quickly bringing up a hand to cover her flustered, guiltily pleased grin. Clearly the cheerleader was glad that he thought so – soothed by his roundabout acknowledgement of Laura Cunningham’s casually dismissive behaviour – but she also seemed intent on being as close to her mother’s version of the perfect daughter as she could possibly be. “Billy. She’s really not that bad, she just… cares, a lot.”
“Whatever you say, Ponytail.” Billy replied, doubtful but unwilling to ruin her tentatively uplifted mood by pressing for information about her mom, who sounded like a controlling bitch desperate to vicariously relive her high-school days through her push-over of a daughter. He’d learned over the past fifteen minutes that Chrissy loved both her father and younger brother with an openness that Billy wouldn’t let himself envy, while her feelings towards her mom were a lot more complicated, which made perfect sense after hearing a few childhood cheerleading stories.
He'd also learned that he actually liked the surprisingly resilient girl, which had come as a far larger surprise than the revelation of her shitty, neurotic mother.
Fucking hell, sometimes Billy wondered if the only genuinely good parent in the entirety of this shithole town was Ms Byers.
Chrissy huffed at his noncommittal response, gracefully climbing to her feet before shaking off the loose dirt and tree bark decorating her clothing. She took a couple of confident steps towards Billy – having grown far more comfortable in his presence after he allowed her to ramble without judgement – offering him her hand with a soft smile. “Ready to head back?”
“Are you?” He asked curiously, eyeing her dainty little hand for a long moment before clasping it within his own, frowning at how cold her bony fingers were. The friendly gesture was unnecessary – Billy highly doubted that Chrissy could lift fifty pounds without straining herself, let alone one-hundred and seventy – but he entertained her all the same, biting back an amused smirk as he watched the cheerleader brace her feet and start pulling. He stood entirely under his own power, but Chrissy’s satisfied little grin told him that she was pleased with her supposed contribution to his vertical state.
“I think so.” She answered a little belatedly, nervously adjusting Carver’s letterman jacket before grimacing, apparently only now realising that she was wearing her ex’s clothes. “Oh…”
Unable to stop himself from rolling his eyes, Billy didn’t hesitate to begin shrugging off his outermost layer, leaving himself in only a long-sleeved maroon button down that did fuck all to ward off the cold. His denim jacket wasn’t the warmest piece of fabric, but he figured that Chrissy would rather risk some shivering than deal with all the judgemental assholes who’d fucking jump on the chance to give her grief for daring to wear Carver’s clothes after breaking up with him.
Billy held it out to her by the collar, giving it a shake when she didn’t immediately take it. “Here.”
“No- no. I couldn’t-"
Supressing a shudder as a particularly strong breeze rushed past them – fucking hell he hated midwestern winters – Billy continued holding out the jacket. “C’mon, do you really want to deal with all the gossip hungry cows back there?”
“They’re not cows…” Chrissy tried to reprimand, though she was quick to crumble in the face of Billy’s unimpressed stare. “Okay, fine, but they’re not all cows.”
“Just take the fucking jacket, Christina.”
She startled slightly at his use of her full name – which she’d confessed only her dad ever called her – scowling in a way that reminded Billy vividly of the pissy face that Maxine always pulled when she was annoyed at him. Deliberating for another few moments, Chrissy released a gusty sigh and quickly pulled off Carver’s jacket, clamping it between her knees in order to free up her hands before reaching for the proffered denim.
Billy’s jacket was comically big on her – even more so than Carver’s had been – and she tugged it tightly around herself, offering him a bashful smile. “Thanks, Billy.”
He dismissed her gratitude with a wave of his hand, flicking his fingers towards the white and green letterman jacket that she was now anxiously twisting between her hands. In her place Billy wouldn’t have hesitated to let the pretentious thing fall to the ground, but even after all the mean shit that had spewed out of Carver’s mouth, Chrissy was still too nice to consider dirtying his property. “Give me that.”
“What’re you going to do with it?” She asked, tone only slightly suspicious as she handed it to him.
Billy bared his teeth in a slightly feral grin. “You’ll see.”
Chrissy looked like she was sorely tempted to push for more information – green eyes narrowing as her perfectly sculpted eyebrows drew together in a frown – but ultimately she let his ominous statement go, shaking her head and smiling in slight exasperation. “You’re… different than I thought you’d be, but… the same, too.”
“A massive dick?” He asked unconcernedly, turning on his heel and starting back towards the party.
The cheerleader rushed to keep up with his longer strides, surprisingly eager to stick close by him. “Um, kind of?” She aimed an uncertain glance up at the side of his face – clearly worried about offending him – but relaxed with a shaky laugh when Billy merely flashed another sharp grin her way. “But in a nice way. You- you really helped me back there, Billy. I’m grateful.”
“Don’t thank me, Ponytail.” Billy said, turning his face away from her painfully earnest expression. He rolled his shoulders uncomfortably, pulling on a faint sneer. “I’ve wanted to put that smug shit on his ass for months.”
He hadn’t intervened for a thank you, or because he’d harboured any kind of selfless, heroic intentions. Billy had stepped in because he loathed Carver and he’d wanted an excuse to hurt him, while Chrissy… she’d been an afterthought, nothing more than the girl stupid enough to date the condescending asshole. Sure, Billy wouldn’t have let Carver hurt her, but that wasn’t anything worth acknowledging.
Defending Chrissy from that shitbag was the bare fucking minimum, and Billy didn’t want the cheerleader to mistake his actions for anything more than that.
“Still.” Chrissy continued quietly, brushing aside her bangs as she looked up at him. Apparently the past twenty minutes of mostly one-sided conversation had quelled the uncertainty she’d felt regarding him, because the cheerleader seemed completely undaunted by his menacing confession. “Nobody’s ever… just- let me thank you, please.”
“Whatever.” Billy muttered in a purposefully bored tone, keeping his gaze focused forward in order to avoid looking at her pretty, sincere face. He didn’t need or want – or deserve – her thanks, but he recognised her stubborn need to give it anyway, and he wasn’t feeling cruel enough to deny her that.
He could feel Chrissy studying him, mind awash with a combination of bemusement, intrigue, and gentle confusion. “You’re not very good at accepting gratitude, are you?”
Billy scowled at her blunt observation, shaking his head. “You’re fucking welcome. Is that what you wanted to hear?”
“Yep.” Chrissy all but chirped, a disgustingly pleased smile in her voice.
Locking an annoyed groan in his throat, Billy couldn’t help but wonder where in the ever-loving fuck all this confidence had sprung from. Just twenty minutes ago Chrissy had been scared of him, but now? Now it was like she thought they were goddamned friends or something, which was ridiculous.
He didn’t do friends; having learnt through painful experience that they were worth neither the effort spent making them or the risk inherent in keeping them. The only person who’d ever proved to be worth both the effort and the risk was a moronic, big-hearted Hawkins High senior by the name of Steve.
Billy picked up his pace, wanting to drop Chrissy and her absurdly friendly attitude off with all of her cheerleader friends as soon as he possibly could.
~
The moment he and Chrissy stepped out of the quiet woods and back into the loud, overcrowded clearing by Reefer Rick’s shitty house, almost all eyes turned towards them, unsubtle whispers and pointed fingers making it obvious that everyone knew that something had happened. Carver was nowhere to be seen – probably hiding away somewhere like a bitch – but his psychically altered description of their breakup had clearly already made the rounds.
Billy weathered the overwhelming rush of attention with ease – eyes sharp and lips curved into a self-possessed smile as he swung Carver’s jacket by his side like a woolly trophy – but Chrissy wilted beneath it, insecurity and shame forcing her head to bow, shoulders to hunch, and shaking hands to cling tighter to the denim of her borrowed jacket. Protective instincts once again flaring to life at the sight of her deathly pale face and anxiously wide, red-rimmed eyes, Billy lightly clasped a hand over her shoulder, allowing his hold to become fractionally heavier when she relaxed beneath it.
“Nothing to see here, folks!” Billy called loudly, his voice cutting through the music and whispers with the unexpected suddenness of a gunshot. Most of the drunken partygoers jolted in place before quickly looking away – going back to whatever questionable activities were capable of holding their greatly reduced attention spans – but a few continued with their narrow-eyed staring, either too stupid or too drunk to recognise the implied threat in his words.
His forbidding expression stopped anyone from outright approaching them, but that barely eased the riot of headache inducing apprehension that Chrissy was unknowingly projecting straight into his poorly shielded brain.
Muttering a variety of irate curses and insults beneath his breath – mostly because the continued gawking was pissing him off, though his quietly vicious tirade also had the added benefit of amusing the impossibly tense cheerleader next to him – Billy led Chrissy towards the bonfire, intent on leaving her with the congregation of cheerleaders still warming themselves by its burning light.
A large, sadistic part of him wanted to just toss Carver’s obnoxious jacket straight into the fire and watch it turn to ash – wanted to make a spectacle of how much he didn’t give a single fuck about the sophomore – but instead Billy exercised his rarely used self-restraint, knuckles whitening around the thick fabric bunched in his right hand.
As eager as he was to sow chaos amongst the small-minded idiots infesting Hawkins High, doing so now would undoubtedly make Chrissy’s life more difficult, which for once wasn’t Billy’s intention. The girl was already uncomfortable as hell, and burning her now ex’s jacket in front of dozens of people would only add even more drama to the clusterfuck that was her freshly terminated relationship with Carver.
Despite Billy’s shitty personality and general inability to be a decent human being, he could recognise that his desire for some minor arson wasn’t more important than Chrissy’s currently fragile mental state.
Once they got within a few metres almost all of the cheerleaders jumped up from their seats, rushing forward and surrounding them with hardly any drunken stumbling and a surprising amount of speed. A few eyed Carver’s letterman jacket greedily – either desperately curious as to why Billy had it, or wanting to impress the sophomore by returning it to him – but none of them were brave enough to outright question him about it, and the flat stare he sent those looking had their eyes averting quickly.
Chrissy didn’t even get the chance to open her mouth before the ruthless barrage of questions started, and Billy grimaced at the sudden surge of high-pitched squealing assaulting his ears.
“What happened?”
“I can’t believe it! You didn’t break up with him, right?”
“Hey, give her some space-"
“You and Jason are the perfect couple!”
“You little slut! How’d you manage to bag Billy?”
“Yeah, that’s his denim jacket!”
“Guys, take it easy-"
“Go and talk to Jason, honey. He looked absolutely miserable.”
“What did you do? He said it was his fault, but-"
Chrissy’s wide green eyes darted from face to face with rapidly increasing panic, breaths coming in erratic bursts and knuckles whitening as she tugged the denim of Billy’s jacket tighter around herself. The girl looked to be on the verge of an anxiety attack – she felt like it too, her emotions a veritable hurricane of incomprehensible noise battering against his sixth sense – and Billy barely held back the urge to start hurling obscenities at these rude, tactless bitches who were supposed to be Chrissy’s fucking friends. Couldn’t they see that their assumptions and demands and thinly veiled accusations were freaking her the hell out? If they did, none of the heavily primped girls gave a shit – with the exception of Heather and a black-haired sophomore that Billy thought might have been named Val – crowding closer and continuing to run their mouths without any sign of shutting the fuck up.
Chrissy let out a barely audible, heart-wrenchingly miserable whimper, and Billy felt his tenuous sense of patience snap.
“Ladies!” He cut in over their clamouring voices, silencing them immediately and gaining their full attention. Billy took a firm step in front of the sophomore, making himself a barrier between Chrissy and the harpies trying to sink their neon-coloured nails into her. “Ever heard of a little thing called personal space? Make some room.”
They did so grudgingly, most having the decency to at least pretend to be shamefaced. Heather offered up a helpless shrug when Billy caught her brown eyes, leaning slightly to the side and peering concernedly at Chrissy. The girl who was probably named Val was watching him with wary hopefulness, which made him wonder if she was one of the apparent few who actually gave a damn about the anxiety ridden auburn-haired girl currently hiding behind him.
“We just want to make sure Chrissy’s alright.” Stella simpered, batting her mascara thickened eyelashes and swaying drunkenly in her impractically high-heels. Even standing a good few feet away, the potent scent of alcohol on her breath was repulsive.
Billy reigned in a disbelieving scoff, instead pulling on a lazy smirk that made the older girl’s eyes widen and her cheeks flush. “Nothing a little beer won’t fix.” He glanced back at Chrissy over his shoulder, meeting her tear-bright stare and arching a questioning eyebrow. “Sound good to you, Ponytail?”
Chrissy nodded vehemently – clearly eager to escape from the judgemental eyes tracking her every move – clearing her throat when her voice came out hoarse. “Y- Yeah. Sounds good.”
“Fan-fucking-tastic.” Billy drawled, smiling charmingly at the gathering of nosy cheerleaders before him. “We’ll see you girls later.”
“Wait! Chrissy, please stay. We just want to hear your side of the story.” Stella implored, arranging her made-up face into something that she probably thought resembled compassionate. When Chrissy failed to answer the senior turned her gaze to Billy, faux kindness almost immediately shifting into something flirtatious, as well as vaguely threatening. “Take a seat, Billy. I’ll get you that beer, and then you can tell us what you were doing with Chrissy out in the woods. Alone.”
Billy huffed out a sharp breath of unconcerned laughter at her bad attempt at manipulation, cocking his head to the side and giving the busty blonde a leering once over. Her bad attitude reeked of desperation – not to mention an easily bruised, overlarge ego – and Billy was getting really fucking tired of pretending like it didn’t get on his goddamned nerves. “Jealousy doesn’t look good on you, Stacy.”
Stella’s eyes bugged out as she registered his casual statement, her darkly painted mouth falling open in an unattractive impression of a beached fish as she struggled to think up a timely comeback. The girl was obviously and deeply offended, and Billy amused himself wondering which had offended her more, him calling her out for being a jealous bitch in front of so many witnesses, or the fact that he’d supposedly forgotten her name.
Probably the name thing, if he had to guess. Girls tended to be sensitive about shit like that.
Muffled giggles and snorts badly disguised as coughs erupted from her fellow cheerleaders, though when Stella whipped her head around to glare daggers they were all quick to hide their amusement behind eye rolls and commiserating head shakes. Except Heather – who Billy was liking more by the minute – who grinned unabashedly, utterly unintimidated by the older girl’s ire.
Stella faced Billy once more, and the anger in her reddening face was nothing short of intensely satisfying. “I- you-“ She stuttered, looking like she was moments away from either crying out of sheer mortification, or stomping her feet and descending into a full-blown tantrum. “My name’s Stella!”
“Really? Huh.” Billy hummed a falsely surprised note, offering an unconcerned shrug in the face of her comically furious expression. “My bad, Sarah.”
Thankfully Stella’s near apoplectic surge of rage rendered her mute – and frozen, her tear bright eyes staring unblinkingly – which gave Billy the perfect opportunity to turn his back on her and start walking towards Reefer Rick’s house. Chrissy stuck closely to his side, glancing back at the gaggle of dumbstruck cheerleaders with a hand clasped tightly over her twitching mouth, clearly uncertain whether she wanted to grimace or grin. “I can’t believe you did that.”
“Bitch’s lucky I didn’t do worse.”
“Aren’t you worried?” Chrissy asked tentatively. “Stella’s so… mean, and intimidating.”
Billy looked down at her with a pointedly arched eyebrow, and to the cheerleader’s credit she was quick to realise that her concern was entirely unwarranted. No matter how catty Stella tried to be, Billy had the capacity to be far worse, which Chrissy had just had the pleasure of witnessing firsthand. “Right, dumb question. Um.” She fiddled briefly with her bangs, eyeing Reefer Rick’s house uneasily. “Sorry, but I don’t really like beer.”
“Shit’s fucking nasty, isn’t it? We’re not getting beer.” Billy reassured, an impulsive, probably terrible idea rapidly forming in his head as he looked down into the cheerleader’s curious expression. “Say, Chrissy. You ever smoked weed before?”
Chrissy narrowed her green eyes at him, something like cautious anticipation lighting them up from the inside. “No.”
“Wanna try it?”
There was a long pause before she gave a rebellious nod of her head, ponytail bobbing along with the abrupt, definitive movement. “Yeah, actually. I do.”
Billy flashed a sharply approving grin, pointedly ignoring all of the many ways that introducing Chrissy to drugs could go horribly wrong. “That’s the spirit, Ponytail. C’mon.”
