Chapter Text
Earth, Dec. 2013
Mulder and Scully watched The Hobbit 2 twice in one day, first in the morning with fresh coffee in their system, then again after lunch, during which they purposely kept quiet about the movie lest they’d influence each other’s judgment prematurely. Now they were back in Mulder’s office, eyeing each other as if ready for a duel.
“All right, Scully, where do we start?” asked Mulder, looking down at a sizable set of notes he had taken during their second viewing. “The first thing that comes to my mind is that Bilbo and Thorin are much closer in this movie.”
“If by that you mean they’re in the same screenshot more often, then you’re right,” said Scully, reaching in her purse for her own notes. “I myself saw a nice friendship developing on screen. Admiration and respect, concern for one another, and a dose of protectiveness. But I’m all aflutter to hear what you saw instead.”
“I noticed some clues in their body language in Beorn’s house. For example, during that scene where Bilbo is checking out his Ring while the dwarves are sleeping. At some point he looks around and his gaze runs into Thorin, and he averts his eyes as if he’s startled.”
“That’s probably because Bilbo is still intimidated by him,” said Scully.
“I first saw him do this in Hobbit 1, when Thorin walked into his home and Gandalf introduced them. When he did it then I too thought he was just intimidated. But here, this explanation doesn’t hold; they’ve been around each other long enough. Then he does it again in the morning, when Thorin motions him to go with Gandalf to meet Beorn. In that scene Thorin smiles fondly at him, so there’s no reason for Bilbo to feel intimidated. Yet he once again averts his eyes quickly, in a subconscious gesture, as if making contact with a much-too-close-majestic-dwarf is more than he can handle. Speaking of whom, Thorin does keep a commanding demeanor, but he’s more relaxed and...”
“Oh, Mulder. I don’t think I’m ready for this,” sighed Scully. “But fine. Their body language has a simple explanation. Thorin likes Bilbo now, because Bilbo saved his life and because of his heartfelt words about home. Otherwise Thorin is still an all-business leader, his mind still set only on seeing the quest fulfilled. Bilbo, while definitely more comfortable around him, is still a bit overwhelmed with his imposing personality and hasn’t had time to process Thorin’s sudden change of attitude towards him, which means he’s still surprised by it.”
“Oh well, he’ll have plenty of time to process Thorin’s ”change of attitude“, and catch up with him,” said Mulder with a pleased grin.
“What does that mean?” asked Scully with a raised eyebrow.
“I think that Bilbo was encouraged by Thorin’s behavior on the Carrock. Whatever he sensed coming from Thorin, he is now happy to reciprocate.”
“Really? Expand the statement.”
“Did you see how he looks at Thorin when he frees him from Thranduil’s dungeons? Like he’s almost blushing?”
“That’s because Bilbo is a bit unsure there. Or even embarrassed. It’s awkward, him rescuing the leader of the Company, a king no less. He feels for Thorin being in this position.”
“Then when they stop at the overlook on their way to the Mountain, Thorin holds his hand and Bilbo looks at him in a certain way, smiling just barely. It’s like his face lights up at the slightest attention he gets from Thorin. He does that multiple times. You can see it best when Bilbo identifies the staircase and Thorin runs towards him and says, You have keen eyes, Master Baggins. Bilbo is with his back to him so he can’t see him, but just having Thorin that close to him and, if I’m not mistaken, touching his back, is enough to...”
“You have some keen eyes yourself, Master Mulder,” said Scully with great amusement. “How in the world did you see all this? Why can’t Bilbo just be excited that he managed to find the staircase at the opportune time for them to reach the Hidden Door before sunset? Getting approval from a person he looks up to is no small thing!”
“Sure, Scully. Bilbo is just a big sweetie who felt bad for Thorin for being imprisoned, and now is all animated because Thorin gave him his approval. If you don’t want to see it, that’s fine. It is not obvious yet, but it will be soon. There is also the moment when they’re running from Smaug and Balin pulls Bilbo in a new direction, and Bilbo calls for Thorin...”
“Yeah, yeah. I thought you might bring up that one. Bilbo is concerned there, as a good friend, who knows Thorin’s recklessness, would be; he is looking out for him. Mulder, it’s a nice try, and I am sincerely touched by their bond of friendship, but that is all that it is: friendship. And by the way, you haven’t said anything about Thorin. If he’s so in love with Bilbo as you made him out to be after that hug, I would think he’d express some of that love in this movie. But no. His sole interest is in taking back Erebor. Sure, he gives Bilbo a look of acknowledgment after Bilbo solves the Hidden Door puzzle, but alas, it’s much too brief, because he’s eager to enter the Mountain. Other than that I haven’t seen anything from him. Compared to his efforts, I can’t blame a naive fellow like yourself for attributing to Bilbo all those butterflies in the stomach.”
“If I had to guess what’s on Thorin’s mind...” Mulder pondered carefully, “yes, taking back Erebor is his priority. He can’t afford to think of love. He still has the Company to watch over, his nephews included, one of whom is injured... and he’s on a really tight schedule. One minute delay could cost the whole quest. He’s probably making mental notes or something, When this is all over I’ll ask him to stay.”
“But this is all speculation. How do we know that he’s thinking of Bilbo like that? And don’t give me that hug again; that is old news.”
“The fact that he briefly takes Bilbo’s hand in his at the overlook. The way he looks at him at the Hidden Door, as you’ve mentioned. And when they get inside the Mountain, and he waits for Bilbo and Balin to finish talking so he can give Bilbo his final task... did you not see the nervousness and pain in his face? He knows that this needs to be done. He needs to send Bilbo down to face the dragon; that is what he hired him for. But he also knows how much Bilbo means to him now, hence the pain which we can also hear in his voice. It’s a very vulnerable moment for him.”
“And he can’t have the same pained expression if this were just someone he viewed as a dear friend?”
“You got me there, Scully,” said Mulder, much to her surprise.
“Wow,” she said, “you’re giving up that easily? You know, it’s not like I don’t want them to be in love. After hearing from you for the last year, how I need to keep an open mind, I did try and look for evidence of love. But the evidence is inconclusive. Speaking of how they look at each other, let me tell you, none of those is a look of love.”
“Hmm?” said Mulder. “A look of love?”
“The look of love, Mulder. The look you’d expect between two people who are, or are falling, in love. The look that Thorin gives the Mountain when he beholds that door and knows he can insert the key and open it. If he looked at Bilbo like that once in this movie, I’d come to your side. But he does not. The Mountain gets a look of love, and the gold, one of a different kind. Oh yeah,” she smiled insinuatingly, “perhaps Bilbo would settle for at least the look Thorin gives that gold, but no such luck.”
Mulder sighed. “Well, they’re not there yet. To look at each other like that. And Thorin is trying to focus on the quest.”
“But when you’re in love you give the look, quest or not! You can’t help yourself!” Scully was on a roll. “Also, Bilbo is no better. Remember in Hobbit 1, when they get to Rivendell? The way he looks at that place when he first lays eyes on it? And then when they’re leaving Rivendell and Bilbo stays behind to behold it one more time, with so much longing and regret that he can't stay there, and Thorin says, Master Baggins, I suggest you keep up! If Bilbo looked at Thorin like that just once, we’d be toasting to their love right now and putting the matter to rest.”
“You have missed one moment, Scully,” said Mulder with great patience. “The look he gives Thorin in the Hidden Door scene, after he almost knocked the key down the Mountain.”
“What’s so special about it? All I see is a guy who is terrified that he almost made a very costly mistake.”
“No, Scully. That is not all you see. Try again. I know you can do it,” he said sweetly, with a smile of encouragement. “Let’s go over this slowly. Fear not. I’m with you, every step of the way.”
“O... K? So Bilbo is at the Hidden Door. He has just found the key-hole, but as he’s fumbling around looking for the key he almost kicks it over the cliff. Thorin rescues it. Bilbo knows he messed up really badly. If the key had fallen, the quest would fail. So he is afraid of Thorin’s reaction. But at the same time, he didn’t mess up. He solved the puzzle for him. Therefore he knows that Thorin can’t be too upset. So this is all very bewildering to him. As for Thorin, he is really blown away in this scene. The clever Master Baggins has done it again.” She stopped and examined Mulder carefully. “How am I doing?”
“I could kiss you right now, Scully,” said Mulder lovingly. “You have done a brilliant job walking me through the complexity of Bilbo’s emotions. But there is one more layer to them. He is afraid as you said, and also thinking, If this won’t impress him then I don’t know what will. But there is also the awareness that Thorin must be blown away, that makes him...”
“What? In love?”
“Not quite. It’s another high, like in the hug scene. He knows how Thorin reacted there. This is bigger. What this Mountain means to Thorin... is more than Thorin's life, which was at stake before the hug. Bilbo here is... another level of afraid, maybe.”
“He is afraid that this means love?”
“He... He didn’t expect things would go this far. That he, a hobbit from the Shire, could make such a difference in this person’s life, a person he greatly respects and admires. That he’d open the door to his home for him, essentially. So he feels that this could very well spell love.”
“So, he feels that thing in the air, again? Like in the hug?” said Scully, with no small amount of irony.
“He feels it as a possibility. Which he caused, because he’s really good at what he does. Oh, Scully. I’ve always told myself that if the love is meant to exist between them, it would manifest one day, and I would see it. That day has come. It’s Durin’s Day, according to this movie. That’s when at least one of them felt it around them.”
“Just to be clear, because last time you said the love was something Tolkien placed around the characters...”
“I don’t think it’s Tolkien anymore, not after this,” said Mulder. “Here, the love is not over and above what the characters are feeling, but stems directly from Bilbo’s emotions. It’s not yet complete, Bilbo is not fully in love yet. It’s a possibility that Bilbo catches a glimpse of. Tolkien is not needed for this. The love would be there with or without his intention, and I’m inclined to think this is happening without his intention.”
“But if Tolkien didn't plan for this love, then who did?”
“Think of it this way, Scully: Bilbo and Thorin are like two machines that the author programmed to act in a certain way. He programmed them to go on this adventure, to follow a certain path to get there, and find creative ways to solve problems along the way. You know how sometimes, due to an oversight by the programmer, the machine doesn’t quite act as intended? I think that’s what’s happening with Thorin and Bilbo.”
“So Tolkien’s “code” entailed something that he could not foresee? A side effect of his writing?”
“Exactly. Tolkien did not foresee or intend for them to fall in love. But they did. Or rather, Thorin did, as I believe based on Hobbit 1. And Bilbo here is on his way. He’s still catching up with Thorin, but he sees what’s going on by now.”
“Mulder, if this were true, surely Tolkien would have become aware at some point that his own characters came close to falling in love? He lived and wrote extensively after The Hobbit. Yet he doesn’t indicate anywhere that he saw any love between them.”
“He was more interested in other things, like the Ring, the Elves... Thorin was dead, so it was kind of a dead end.”
“But what about the mithril? And Thorin’s heart which Bilbo stole, according to you? That’s Tolkien!”
“I think he didn’t know what he was doing. Scully...” said Mulder in a voice filled with emotion, “do you think he would have let Thorin die if he had known...”
At this, Scully could not contain her sadness. “It was a terrible thing when Thorin died,” she said as she put her arms around him, eyes full of worry in ominous anticipation. “That will be hard to watch, Mulder. I don’t often get emotional, but... I’m really not looking forward to watching that part.”
“We’ll have to, Scully,” said Mulder with quiet resignation. “We’ll have to watch it if we’re to really understand it all.”
Mahal’s Halls, same day
“Hey Uncle,” Kili whispered busily as he let himself in Thorin’s room. He was painfully aware he was interrupting his uncle’s special time watching Bilbo in Valinor, but this could not wait. “I’m watching The Desolation of Smaug right now. I’m sorry to bother you. I’m assuming you’re watching your... stuff of interest in Valinor again?”
“What do you want?” answered Thorin without turning, his gaze fixed on the spot in his wall that was open once more.
“If I may ask for a favor, can you please find out if there’s an elf maid there, in Valinor, by the name of Tauriel? She’s supposed to be a great archer, all-in-all an amazing warrior. She’s got auburn hair, is tall and likes to dress in green. Oh, and she... umm...” Kili cleared his throat, “she hails from Mirkwood.”
“Your description is not much help. They all look like that,” Thorin scoffed. “Why the sudden interest?”
“They paired me with her in this movie. I’ve just watched the scene where I meet her. I really need to go back; I’m missing important plot points.”
“I don’t get to see many people in Valinor, Kili. Right now Bilbo is in his house, so that is where I’m watching. If he goes out later I’ll follow him, but I can’t promise he’ll run into anyone.”
“Uncle,” Kili took a chance, “is there a reason why that’s all you do with your special time every year? A few people are wondering, you know.”
“I miss him,” said Thorin, who found it was difficult to dissemble when Bilbo was in his view. Then he quickly changed the subject. “Try asking your mother. She’ll be glad to help you, even to find an elf.”
“Oh, no. Mom is also watching The Desolation of Smaug. Quite a few of us are, in fact. It’s not too late for you to join.”
Thorin shook his head. “Enjoy,” he said dryly.
“So, did you have any memorable lines in the movie?” Thorin asked Dwalin when all dwarves were finished watching their favorite worlds for the day.
“Aye,” said Dwalin. “We have a key. Which means that somewhere, there must be a key-hole.”
“No, seriously, did you have any memorable lines?”
“No. But your nephews tell me that in the first movie I refer to the hobbit quite a bit. I say stuff like, I thought we’d lost our burglar! and, Curse the Halfling! Now he’s lost?”
Thorin was violently startled at that, and his eyes shone like daggers. Dwalin took the opportunity to make his inquiry.
“How is he?” he asked.
“Fine. He carries on with his nephew. He seems happy.”
“Thorin... Did something happen between the two of you during our quest for Erebor?”
“Nothing happened,” said Thorin.
“How did you feel when he solved the Hidden Door puzzle? When thanks to him you could reclaim your kingdom, your throne, your crown?”
“Grateful. And eager for the reclaiming part.”
“Nothing more? Pardon my bluntness, but the way you look at him in this movie at said Hidden Door... if it weren’t for the horrendous task awaiting him I’d wager you’d rip his pants off right then and there.”
Thorin gave him a scandalized look. Then he took a patient, deep breath. “Dwalin... I asked you to do something for me a year ago. Do you remember?”
“To reach out to my fellow Lord of the Rings subscribers and find out what happened to the mithril you gave the hobbit.”
“Right. Did you?”
“Well... Nobody knows for sure, because nobody is watching the Shire right now. It’s not clear if it stayed there. And it has not been spotted in Valinor by Gloin or his wife, the only dwarves who watch there every year to see their son. But a lot of dwarves believe the mithril is in Valinor. Master Baggins gave it to his nephew, and Frodo either kept it or gave it to his friend Sam Gamgee. Since both are in Valinor now...”
“Could Master Gamgee have left it in the Shire?”
“I don’t think so. The mithril held too much meaning for those involved in the quest for Mount Doom. It must be with Frodo or Sam, a precious reminder of their adventures.”
“Then why do I never see it in Master Baggins’ house? I have noticed he keeps the map I gave him hanging on the wall by his bed. I’ve also seen Sting, but no sign of the mithril.”
“The map is a good sign, I’d say. Maybe the mithril is kept in Frodo’s rooms. Do you ever look there?”
“No. It’s bad enough that I’m watching Master Baggins without his knowledge or permission. I’m not going to pry into his nephew’s things.”
“Uh-huh. If you say so. Would it make a difference if he kept that shirt, Thorin?”
“I hope... I hope it would,” said Thorin longingly.
Dwalin met his eyes. He had to ask, even if it was already plain to him.
“You loved him, didn’t you?”
“Don’t...” Thorin tried with a faint voice.
“I won’t. Don’t worry. I won’t tell anyone.”
“I loved him then and I love him now,” said Thorin. “It never ends.”
Dwalin spit on the floor in disgust, and only someone like Thorin would know it was a well-meant gesture of empathy.
