Actions

Work Header

The Truth About Their Love

Chapter 6

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

“Is it really you?” Bilbo murmured, out of breath, as he reached for Thorin and placed a hand on his shoulder.

Thorin did not answer. He just held him close, and Bilbo wrapped his arms around him and let go of the mithril, which now lay between them, pressed against both their bodies. And they stayed like that for a time, while neither could speak or even truly believe, until Thorin slowly released them.

“Tell me that one more time.”

“I love you,” said Bilbo achingly. “I’ve missed you so much, all these years. Yet I never thought I had the right to even wish to see you again. Or to be loved by you.”

“You have the only right,” said Thorin. He took Bilbo’s hands in his, regarding them with silent awe and marveling at the feeling of touching them.

“You weren’t supposed to die,” said Bilbo, his eyes full of tears. “I couldn’t bear it.”

“I am so sorry. I had no notion it would affect you so.”

“It was not your fault. If I had known... well, I still don’t know what the mithril means. But... it should not have been me wearing it that day. It should have been you. It is I who am sorry.”

“No,” said Thorin. “It was meant only for you. This was the only thing I had that could show you what I felt for you. What I still feel for you. I hoped you would keep it, and see that it would endure.”

“Can it be true? After all this time?”

“I have always loved you. But it feels like I’m always beginning. There is so much love, and I have not known what to do with it. But now that you’re here...”

“First thing, we’ll have to watch those movies,” said Bilbo with a smile. “It seems to me they offered us a lot to be grateful for. But how is this possible, Thorin? How did I get here?”

In that moment they heard the clock strike midnight. “It was my doing,” a voice interrupted ungraciously. “I am Mahal, the Father of Dwarves. I was touched by your conversation.”

Thorin hadn’t realized this, but Mahal had left before the dinner party was over and had been watching him from a small distance, very curious to see, and willing to help with the outcome of his child’s effort at connecting with his world of choice.

“Oh, goodness. Lord Mahal,” said Bilbo, looking positively bewildered. “I don’t know how to thank you.”

“It also helps that I really liked that third Hobbit movie,” Mahal grinned. “So. Question for you two. Thorin, the sappiest dwarf I’ve ever created, your love for the hobbit is clear. You, on the other hand, Master Baggins of the Shire, are you really in love with my son here? And if so, for how long? There are quite a few people who need to know.”

“I’ve loved him since he...” Bilbo glanced at Thorin shyly. “Since he played the harp and sang that song in my home. And I will say, Thorin... I have travelled and seen a lot in my life, and heard lots of high quality music played by wonderfully skilled creatures, but never have I heard anything more beautiful than that song.”

“I have. The way Dain talks to Thranduil in Hobbit 3, that is music to my ears,” said Mahal with a twinge of jealousy in his voice. “But I digress. Oh, you guys, this is very sweet and warms my heart,” he laughed. “I’ll have to find a way to reach Earth and inform that Mulder fellow about this. We owe him a lot; after all, he and Agent Scully are how we got to hear of these movies, thanks to your two mischievous nephews, Thorin. And then Mulder can feel free to tell everyone else that this is how it went: you guys were in love all along.”

“NO!” they heard a shout, accompanied by the sound of footsteps approaching. Fili and Kili came in, together with Balin and Dwalin, at once anxious to protest Mahal’s idea.

“No, not Mulder! Anyone but him! He has... a bit of a reputation on Earth. No one will believe him!” said Fili.

“That’s not my problem,” said Mahal. “If they don’t like him over there, that’s their loss. I like the dude, at least the account of him that you two have graced me with all evening.”

“By my beard, is that our hobbit?” asked Balin and Dwalin in unison, as they could finally see Bilbo’s figure, now distinguishable in the light that surrounded him and Thorin.

Mahal signalled them to be silent. He was not finished talking for one thing, but was also starting to realize he may have interrupted Thorin and Bilbo’s moment prematurely.

Thorin brushed Bilbo’s curls with his fingers, gazing at him in perfect adoration, happy that for a second their eyes were turned from Mahal back to each other. “My love,” he whispered, “I never thought this could ever be real.”

Mahal cleared his throat with some impatience. “Master Baggins, one more question for you. Do you wish to stay here on a more permanent basis?”

“I... wish to be wherever Thorin chooses to be.”

“And you, son of Thrain? Where might you wish to be?”

“Wherever my One is happy,” said Thorin. “I will follow him.”

“Ah. So then I can decide where to put you two, perhaps.” They nodded. “All right. I have an idea. I hear that on Earth a lot of Hobbit movie fans are popping out fan-fiction about you two like there’s no tomorrow. What do you know, some of those stories focus on the two of you meeting in the afterlife. After watching this epic movie I’m eager to get my hands on them and read where those authors imagine you’ll spend your time together. I’ll leave the decision of your residence to the author of the story I like best. But first, I’m going to binge watch Hobbit 1 and 2. Got to get a head start on those elves.”

“That sounds good, Lord Mahal,” said Bilbo. “One word, if I may... I left my nephew, Frodo, back in Valinor. He’s probably worried about me. Is there a way for me to...?”

“Yeah, that’s all arranged. I left him a note in your bed. He knows where you are and will come to visit you in a day or two. Or... how about we make it a little later than that. It’s obvious you two need some alone time.”

“Oh, Father, that reminds me,” said Thorin. “My nephew, Kili, asked me to find out if there is an elf maid named Tauriel in Valinor. I did find out that there is someone who matched the lady in the movie: red hair, dressed in green, great warrior... Though Kili says that the movie Tauriel has really long hair, while the Valinor elf’s hair is considerably shorter; actually... she is shorter altogether. And I didn’t catch the Valinor person’s name.”

“Oh,” Bilbo jumped in. “Then we have a small problem. I met the person, and...”

“It’s not an elf maid?” asked Dwalin.

“It’s a maid, but her name is Danielle.”

Kili gave a whistle of surprise. “Wow! Does she have superpowerful reasoning skills? Beauty and brains?”

“Ah, yes, Kili,” said Mahal with a grin of satisfaction. “I definitely had a hand in this one. It’s no coincidence you’ve had a crush on that Scully agent for years; she resembles your One in more than one way, and a bit of a warrior herself, by Earth standards. Nice work, my boy. Very, very creative. You’ve done the best you could despite the restrictions placed around you. We’ll figure out a way to make you and Danielle meet. One couple at a time, all right?”

“Thank you, Father,” said Thorin with great hope that his part of the conversation was over. He couldn’t wait anymore. He turned back to Bilbo and they kissed for the first time, and the love between them was a wave that came floating like a gleam, reflecting in the myriads of intricate patterns of glass and gems that adorned Thorin’s room. And they stayed in that kiss for countless seconds, tasting each other again and again in numberless ways, and in it they poured the heartbreak of how much they had lost, and how much they’d missed each other during their endless waiting; and when the kiss was consumed, their hopelessness and sorrow were dissolved. Not much more is known about that moment, for when it was over, Bilbo took a second to look towards Mahal, who was still standing there open-mouthed in amazement at their display, and spoke.

“Excuse me, but... can you please not mention how this bit went, to anyone on Earth, or here in your Halls? Or even to your wife? Some things are meant to be private.”

“Indeed they are,” said Mahal with a wicked smirk. And he left Thorin’s room to attend to watching the movies and reading the stories he was so eager for.

 

Earth, six hours later that night

...Mulder had fallen asleep at his desk, Hobbit book and DVD’s also present, and papers filled with notes, arrows and diagrams. The coffee had gone cold and Scully had gone home, when his computer, with The Hug wallpaper on the desktop, suddenly flickered, and a message wrote itself in big rune-like letters.

 

To: Agents Fox Mulder and Dana Scully, FBI

From: Mahal, Mahal’s Halls

Bagginshield is real.

 

As if led by a supernatural force, Mulder jolted out of his chair and read the message, blinking in astonished surprise.

“Mahal?! Wow!! THE Mahal?”

After a few moments he remembered himself, adjusted his hair and tie, bowed and said: “Mulder. At your service.”

Mahal. At yours, came the answer on the screen.

After a much longer while, Mulder remembered he could use other words.

“This is a great honor. May I ask if they were both in love?”

I’m pretty honored myself. Yes. They loved each other from the beginning, but kept it secret like the idiots that they are.

“And the thing I felt surrounding them in The Hug, that inexpressible quality... Here,” Mulder said, pointing at his wallpaper, “do you know anything about that?”

What you felt was Thorin’s hope. He learned early on that the movies were being made, and unknowingly influenced part of their making. His hope, that someone would manage to create a connection where he could not, manifested on the screen. You did not discern love coming from him because at that time he did not dare show his love to anyone, even himself. But his hope was there, the only thing he allowed.

“So he wanted to believe. That one day...”

That one day all he wished for would come true. Something like that.

“And Bilbo? Did he really interrupt his process of falling in love at some point, or did I read that wrong?”

He was in love from the beginning. But I think he was also very cautious. Love takes a leap of faith. He was in it, but I think he was also very afraid of it, at times.

“Huh,” said Mulder, a bit confused. “Do you think you can maybe expand on that? Scully is going to find all kinds of loopholes in this account.”

I don’t know all the details on that. I make Dwarves, not Hobbits. My wife might know. But I’ll say, I thought Dwarves were secretive; that Hobbit takes the cake.

“Lord Mahal...” said Mulder, eyeing his computer screen with utmost hope, “by any chance do you happen to know if they got together in the end? Does anyone know?...”

The screen did not display any more messages. Mulder was neither entirely surprised, nor entirely displeased. He remained there, staring at the screen, taking numerous pictures of Mahal’s words, pondering over their mysterious font, and thinking of the most effective way of breaking the news to Scully later.

 

Mahal’s Halls, present

...Mahal has not revealed to Mulder that Bilbo and Thorin did get together in the end. He has said he would reveal the truth when he has read all the Bagginshield stories written in all the worlds. As their number on Earth keeps growing, to this day he is still reading, and quite possessively guarding the secret of the real ending, while Thorin and Bilbo are ever learning, first-hand and unhindered, in a place undisclosed and subject to change, the truth about their love.

 

- The End -

 

Notes:

The italicized quotes in this story are from J. R. R. Tolkien’s The Hobbit or from Peter Jackson’s Hobbit Trilogy, with one exception. The quote Frodo and Mahal mention in Chapter 5 is from a commentary to Corinthians 13, the beautiful Bible passage that ends with “And now abide faith, hope, love, these three; but the greatest of these is love.”

Thank you for reading, and thank you to all those who left kudos and comments! They mean the world to me ❤️