Actions

Work Header

The Truth About Their Love

Chapter 5

Notes:

As the last chapter was getting a bit long, I decided to split it in two. So there will be one more chapter after this. I hope you enjoy :))

Chapter Text

Valinor, later that day

“Uncle Bilbo! Wait until you hear this!”

“What is it, Frodo?”

“I have big news! It’s about the dwarves from your book, the thirteen dwarves you journeyed with so many years ago. Apparently someone made three movies about your adventure!”

“Movies? What are those?”

“Like... pictures in motion? They’re a lot like plays, only recorded and shown on a screen. They were made in a place called Earth. Apparently they heard of us there; we’re actually quite popular! Even I appear in the first movie!”

“That’s fantastic! How did you learn of this?”

“It is the talk of all Valinor. Apparently the dwarves in the Halls of Mahal learned of it first. They have some sort of ability to peek into other worlds once a year. Now that the last movie is out, they are all in uproar. It had so much success in the Halls that even Mahal himself condescended to watch, and he said he’d never had so much fun in a long time.”

“Oh. That’s... wonderful. It’s too bad we don’t share the dwarves’ privilege. I should have liked to watch those movies!” said Bilbo with much longing in his voice.

“So anyway, Yavanna watched this third movie along with Mahal just a few hours ago, and afterwards immediately started spreading the word in other realms. She picked Valinor first because she knows you live here; she thought you’d be interested! As soon as they heard the news, some of the elves here found a way to get access to Earth in the last few hours and managed to watch it too. Now they’re searching Earth desperately, scrambling to find a theater where they’re playing the first two movies. The dwarves will have a laugh if they hear about this! Apparently some of them have already watched all three.”

“Ha! I can imagine the dwarves’ satisfaction at getting there first!” said Bilbo with great amusement.

“Uncle...” said Frodo hesitantly, “There is a bit of talk on a particular subject.”

“What subject might that be, my lad?”

“The dwarf king you journeyed with. They say that in this movie... he appears to develop strong feelings for you. Some say he goes so far as to offer you a courting gift; you can guess what they’re talking about. I would have never guessed that that mithril held so much meaning.”

“No, Frodo. You must not think such things.”

“To think that that shirt was so close to the evil of Sauron in Mordor... I almost feel bad that you gave it to me.”

“But it saved your life. Without its protection, the quest for destroying the Ring may have failed.”

“Right,” said Frodo, lost in deep thinking. “You see, the fact that it achieved so much almost shows that it was originally gifted out of love.”

“And why is that?”

“It’s something I’ve read in a book from the First Age. The only thing that love cannot do is fail.”

“If you’re saying that the mithril is THE reason why your quest didn’t fail, that’s a stretch,” said Bilbo, looking a bit troubled.

“Now, I have also heard that in the last movie you were really devastated over the dwarf king’s death. In the scene when he dies... it’s like your heart was ripped out of your chest. Yet you never gave that impression from your many retellings of your adventure.”

“Oh, Frodo. It’s up to the actors to play the characters how they see fit. I suppose all good stories deserve embellishment.”

“And is it? Embellishment?”

“That... is private,” said Bilbo.

“Oh. All right,” said Frodo. “I won’t pry any further. But I will say, Bilbo... I have also heard that the dwarf in question... Thorin...”

Bilbo lifted his sad eyes. “What about Thorin?” he asked.

“I have heard that Thorin is the only dwarf in Mahal’s halls who hasn’t watched any of these movies. And he’s got the most screen time in them!!”

“Really? What do you suppose he does instead?”

“He watches elsewhere,” said Frodo. “Only his Company know where. Neither he nor they will say.”

“It’s not hard to guess what place interests him,” said Bilbo. “Erebor, of course. He watches over the kingdom he so dearly loves.”

“Maybe,” said Frodo. “Or maybe there is a place that interests him more. Or a person.” He hugged Bilbo with much affection, and stepped out of the room.

Bilbo waited for him to depart. Then he stood from his chair and looked under his bed. There lay a small chest, and inside it there it was, the mithril coat that Thorin had given him, that Bilbo never learned the meaning of, whether it had been the first payment of his reward or something else entirely. As he beheld the precious garment, memories and pain came flooding in. He had always been too afraid to go there in his mind. All he knew was that, if he could have turned back time, he would have refused to put it on. You should have it, Thorin. It is you who should wear it in the battle, he would have said, if he had known how the adventure would end... Then things went to a bad place in a hurry: the falling-out on the ramparts, the dreadful battle, and the impossible sight of Thorin dying. It had all been too much, to experience the shock of those three events while at the same time registering the fact that he was still alive and still wearing the armor that could have saved Thorin and that Bilbo didn’t even need that day. So he had tried to part with those bitter memories, none of which would bring Thorin back, and had aimed to be plain Mr. Baggins of Bag-End, Under-Hill, again.

He took the mithril out of the chest and stared at it for a few moments, then pressed it tightly against his chest. “Thorin,” he whispered. “I miss you so much.”

He placed the coat of mail on his bed, then went out for a walk, alone.

 

Mahal’s halls, same day

The dwarves in Mahal’s halls were all at dinner. They had finished watching the last installment of the Hobbit trilogy, and were pumped to discuss it over food and beer. Mahal himself sat amongst them, all too happy to participate. His beloved Yavanna had left earlier, more than a little eager to teleport herself to other realms and share the news with her friends. As he carefully surveyed the tables filled with food and dwarves laid before him, Mahal frowned when he noticed that one of his children was absent.

“Where is Thorin, son of Thrain? Why is he not here?” he asked.

“He’s probably brooding somewhere,” said Dwalin. “This time of the year he gets really melancholic.”

“Oh, right... I remember now. I took pity on him for not enjoying The Battle of the Five Armies with us, and extended his allotted fun time. I let him watch whichever world he likes until midnight.” Mahal smiled generously. “Let him enjoy himself.”

“Lord Mahal,” said Balin gently, “may I ask... on the subject of him and the hobbit... do you have any knowledge of...”

“The love aspect? No clue. If that hobbit is Thorin’s One, it was not by my doing. I don’t always have control in determining who is whose soulmate. Certainly did not have a hand in this one, nope,” he shook his head with frustration. “Now I don’t know what really happened, but if you go by Hobbit 3 there totally was something between them. Obviously Thorin proposed to him in that mithril scene, and was accepted, though perhaps unknowingly...” At this, a loud “Oooo!” was heard from all the dwarves present. “At any rate, my poor child, oh sweet Eru, he was doomed to love from the moment he walked through the Halfling’s door. But again, this is the movie. Whether any of this is true, only Thorin knows.”

“Is there hope for them, Father?” asked Balin. “I mean, it’s a tad late for this, even if his love is returned...”

“There is always hope. If you asked my wife, she would say that The only thing love cannot do is fail,” replied Mahal. “But these are deep thoughts for this hour. Come, lads, let’s have more drinks. Let us toast to the dwarves who fought in the Battle of Five Armies! You all made me so proud. Especially you, Dain. The way you conducted yourself overall reminds me of why I got into the business of creating Dwarves in the first place!”

 

...Thorin watched as Bilbo returned from his walk, hung his coat and retreated to his bedroom without a thought for dinner or supper. It had been a long walk, and quite productive, for the hobbit ran into a beautiful elf with red hair, dressed in green, who was looking for his house, seeking to get acquainted with him. Thanks to Yavanna’s thoroughly informative scoop on The Hobbit 3, she knew that an elf very similar to herself had been paired with a legendary warrior named Kili. She hoped she wouldn’t be too forward if she expressed curiosity to hear more about the heroic dwarf from the main protagonist of the movie.

Bilbo walked with her at length, told her all he could remember about Kili, and invited her to come visit him in a week. Then he bid her goodbye and went home, while the elf maid remained lost in her thoughts, wondering if there was a way to contact any of the dwarves in Mahal’s Halls and longing to meet the dashing prince of Erebor...

Bilbo lay on his bed, the candles still lit in his bedroom, and once again reverently touched the coat of mail lying next to him. “Thorin,” he called, trying to keep his voice low for fear Frodo would hear him. “I don’t know how to reach you.”

He didn't know that in Mahal’s Halls, where the clock had not struck midnight yet, Thorin was still watching him. In that instant the mithril on Bilbo’s bed started glowing in places, revealing runes that spelled something in Khuzdul. And Thorin knew that the runes spelled his response, “I am here,” and that Bilbo likely couldn’t understand them...

“I hear you don’t want to watch those movies, Thorin,” Bilbo continued, unsure where the runes were coming from or of their meaning, yet determined to voice his thoughts. “I wonder why. Perhaps it’s a bit... embarrassing to you? That there seems to be love surrounding our story,” he rushed to clarify.

“No!” Thorin shouted. He stopped himself in time from saying more, as he realized that perhaps Bilbo would be able to translate just this one word.

As Bilbo saw the runes, an idea struck him. Perhaps he could both figure out if this word meant “yes” or “no” and identify if the word came from Thorin at all...

“Thorin, do you like elves?” he settled on, though he knew this would by no means narrow things down to one single dwarf.

“No,” came the answer again. Bilbo took notice of it, eyes wide in surprise at what this may mean. This conversation required a serious leap of faith, and fast, for he knew, based on what Frodo had shared, that he and Thorin did not have much time.

“So... the love part was not embarrassing to you?”

“No,” Thorin repeated.

As Bilbo took in the answer, the memory of that day when Thorin had visited his house with a Company of twelve dwarves came to him in a hurry. His fear of the unknown, his hesitation to leave the comfort of his home, his need to be led by someone else in a decision that he couldn’t make alone... Oh, how uneasy and afraid he had been that evening, and even more so at night, when he could still hear Thorin singing from the best bedroom next to his, the song that gave him very uncomfortable dreams... But this time, the decision was his alone to make, and there was no one who could help him make it; and to decide also meant to lead, for Thorin - if indeed it was Thorin on the other end - could do nothing but wait, wait for Bilbo to find the right words that could connect them further...

“Thorin, have you been watching me?” he asked, his eyes fixed on the mithril on his bed.

“Yes,” came the response, written in bright and clear Khuzdul letters.

Bilbo looked in wonder. “Hmm. I’ll take that as a yes. Year after year?”

“Yes.”

“Every year, since you arrived in...”

“Yes,” came the answer, and for all that Bilbo valued politeness he didn’t mind this interruption.

“Thorin...”

Bilbo did not know how to say this, and his shaky resolve felt threatened. Perhaps he was a coward, but... to ask Thorin point-blank if he loved him would be putting him on the spot! He needed to think of something less forward, while he knew the clock was ticking...

“Would you say that the way that we are in these movies is accurate? For your part?”

“Yes,” said Thorin again, and the mithril coat started vibrating, its links making a rattling noise. Bilbo seized it in a bit of fright, wondering if this meant that Thorin’s time watching another world was at an end.

“I wish I could see you,” he said. “So I could tell this to you in person. I love you.”

“I love you, too,” said Thorin, and this time Bilbo heard the words. At that same moment, the treasured map of the Lonely Mountain that hung on the wall above his bed began expanding up, down, left and right, until the Mountain in it reached the size of his bedroom wall. To Bilbo’s astonishment, a small door appeared at the base of the Mountain. It opened, and Bilbo stepped through it.

He felt himself carried into darkness, first onward, then down, then onward again, then up, and then repeating this pattern of paths a few times, until he arrived in front of a dark blue wall that looked like a dead end, with no door to break on through to the other side. And as he held the mithril mail close, he was about to ask where to now, when suddenly a bright light projected from the mithril onto the blue wall. And the wall broke into many pieces, not quite with the same fierceness as when Erebor’s wall had been torn down in The Battle of the Five Armies, but the spirit was there. And Bilbo tried to hang on to himself as a wave of light flowed from his being onto the space that opened in front of him.

In such manner did Thorin’s wall break at last as Bilbo entered Mahal’s Halls, and each found himself face to face with his love, bright light shining around them.