Actions

Work Header

Love Is A Shield

Chapter 4: To Wish Impossible Things

Summary:

Bilbo has a talk with Balin and a debate with himself. Thorin has a second vision of what the future would look like for both Bilbo and himself if he died.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Dawn was breaking as Bilbo walked to Balin and Dwalin’s tent, not knowing what he could hope for. Thankfully, Balin was outside the tent, stretching and humming a melodious tune. Upon seeing Bilbo, his face relaxed into a smile. “Bilbo, my friend! What brings you here? I trust Thorin is still doing all right?”

“I… think so,” said Bilbo.

“It will be all right, laddie, you’ll see. He’ll wake up soon. He is made of sturdy stuff, that one, and he has much to live for.” Balin looked so hopeful and optimistic that Bilbo wanted to give him a huge hug.

Instead, he looked at Balin doubtfully. “Balin. I need to ask you for some advice… again.”

“Of course, Bilbo. Before you do, though, remember that I’m the one who counseled you on the Arkenstone matter. Now I’m not sure what to think, seeing as how Thorin ended up defeating the gold sickness by himself. Perhaps he would have managed just the same if he had obtained the Arkenstone. We’ll never know.”

“Oh, Balin. Your counsel was very valuable. You know Thorin best.”

“As you say, Bilbo. I trust that Thorin will soon be returned to us in body, as I already know he is returned in mind. And you? You had a chance to speak to him on Ravenhill, Dwalin informs me.” Balin had not had a chance to discuss this with Bilbo, and wanted to make sure his king would have approved of him treating Bilbo as a friend again.

“Yes, I did.” Bilbo suddenly wanted to sit down, and felt immediately cold.

“And you two were… on good terms?”

Yes. Well, Thorin… he… wanted to say goodbye to me. He was not upset with me anymore. He called me a friend. And he… Instead of these words, though, Bilbo said:

“Yes. We were. He wanted to lead me out of Ravenhill, but before we could do so we saw Azog with Fili… and then we were attacked. And then I saw him after… after Azog. I believe that he forgave me, Balin. Even though…” Bilbo stopped to collect his breath, and it was clear that he couldn’t talk about this anymore.

Balin gave him a pat on the shoulder and a sympathetic look.

“Anyway… Balin, I need to ask you about… about Ones. You mentioned to me that some Dwarves have Ones, and that Thorin does not know who his One is. So I was wondering, because, you see, I really hope that Thorin will live. I’ve been trying to speak to him, in the hope that he can hear me and come back. But, part of me wonders if maybe Thorin would be better off going to Lord Mahal’s halls, just in case…”, Bilbo hesitated, “…just in case his One is already there. I mean, would Thorin really want to come back to us? Or perhaps he’s tired of living and hopes to be released from here and meet his One?”

Balin took a long, puzzled look at Bilbo. He seemed to be searching for the right words.

“I highly doubt that Thorin’s One is in Mahal’s halls, and I’m just going to leave it at that. As for him coming back, we’re all with you, laddie. We hope to see Thorin back with us. Don’t worry. You’ve done well in trying to get him to come back, and I trust he is in good hands with you.”

“Thank you, Balin. This was most helpful.”

Then Bilbo went back to Thorin’s tent, checked on him, and pondered. That luminous entity may have been wrong about Thorin’s One being dead– well, unless his One is a non-Dwarf, I suppose! Bilbo laughed at the irony of this. Then the One could be dead, just not in Mahal’s halls. Bother and confusticate it all! Yet the entity may have been right in implying that Bilbo was not that One. So Bilbo decided to half-trust the being from his dream. It was the sensible thing to do. After all, it seemed to know some things about him and Thorin, and maybe it cared for Thorin, despite sounding cunning and not exactly loving. I may not be Thorin’s One (how could I be?), so I should really stop with those love declarations. I’ll talk of friendship instead. I’ll still try to bring him back. Balin supports this endeavor. I will trust Balin on this.

Friendship? a voice in his head laughed sarcastically. Wow, you can make so quick a switch!

Well, he answered trying to stay calm.Thorin is my friend. And that may be all he will ever be. It is not a small thing, and I will certainly cherish his friendship. Perhaps it’s not as good as love, but it’s the next best thing! Or maybe better, seeing as how love can make things very complicated sometimes!

Sure, but… how will you feel, Bilbo Baggins, at the sight of Thorin getting crowned, with a beautiful queen by his side? After all, if his One is not in Mahal’s halls then where can they be? Surely close by, don’t you think? Maybe one of the beautiful Elves of Mirkwood? His nephew Kili clearly fell for one…

Bilbo hung his head down. Thorin falling for an Elf was not a high probability, but… Yes, it will be hard. But we’re not there now, he said resolutely. Now, all there is is Thorin lying in a tent, unconscious. I’m going to do all I can to help him, and that is final!

With that, he managed to silence the voice in his head, and he resumed talking to the sleeping dwarf in front of him. He shared Balin’s words, that everyone wanted to see Thorin come back and thrive as King Under the Mountain. Bilbo continued talking softly throughout the morning, pausing only when Elrond came to check on Thorin.

“Hmm… It seems Thorin Oakenshield is still doing well, but his progress is a bit slower now. Mister Baggins, no doubt you must be very tired after all your efforts to help your friend.”

“Oh, no. Not at all,” Bilbo protested. “I… Did you say his progress is slow now?”

“Yes, compared to the last times I checked. He is still within our reach; he has not left our world. But I sense that he is now slower to come back. You’ve been talking to him, correct? Did you… change something?”

“N- no.”

“Very well. I’ll return later. By all means, Mister Baggins, continue to care for him, but I suggest you eat and rest too.” And Elrond left again.

Bilbo sat at Thorin’s side, his head dizzy with thoughts. He was tired, but he wasn’t going to rest yet, not when there was still much to do, or rather, to say. He found himself debating in his head again, asking himself what he would prefer, to be Thorin’s One but to have Thorin die, or to have Thorin live but no love between them? He tried to picture living in a world without Thorin, and that seemed to be worse than sharing the same world as just friends. This subject matter is way over my head, he thought. In truth I would very much prefer to be his One and have him live. But the way things are looking, that is probably impossible. I really ought to know my place. I don’t know what I was thinking, telling him I love him. I should be grateful if he didn’t hear me. Yet he couldn’t resist whispering “I love you” to Thorin one last time, before saying goodbye to those words, for now.

He spent the rest of the day at Thorin’s side. Elrond came again, declared himself pleased with the king’s condition, and left. After a while Bilbo picked up the Khuzdul notebook again, looking for friendship terms. He felt a bit more at ease now that love was out of the way; a little less selfish. The Took in him had had his moment, going for more, trying for love rather than the safe space of friendship. Yet the being in his dream had managed to silence the Took. So the Baggins happily took over, and spoke to Thorin about valleys and waterfalls, about spring in Bag End, about trees and flowers and the color of sunshine, and continued to talk fondly about their adventure.

Thorin continued to sleep, and at one point Bilbo couldn’t resist and wanted to say amrâlime hikhthuzul again. He thought about disguising it as a non-endearment, and ended up saying akdâm hikhthuzul – he wasn’t even sure he used the words properly but the spirit was there – and as he looked at Thorin he saw him move his lips and heard him rumble something, as if he wanted to give a reply. And Bilbo was so startled, he wondered if he should just go back to straight-up love terms. “Thorin?” he said, taking both Thorin’s hands in his, “Thorin, I am here.” But Thorin was silent. The magic moment had passed.

Still, this was progress, and as the evening settled Bilbo began to think of rest. He sat on blankets on the ground, next to Thorin’s bed. Bofur brought him some bread and water, which he gratefully accepted, and after consuming them ravenously he went to sleep. “Good night, Thorin,” he said. “My one and only adventure. I am always here for you. I am not going anywhere.”

* * *

The harp-like voice that had accompanied Thorin for a few moments during his journey through an endless night seemed to slowly change its song now. The voice sounded more detached, and was not begging him to stay anymore. It seemed that things would be all right either way. And then Thorin had a vision of a world forming again, in the shape of the same round green door, and the bench in front. The same creature was there, only now he was moving around more, greeting different guests, having parties, serving dinners, being busy with books and telling stories to children, traveling and spending time with Elves. This person seemed to have a fulfilled life, if not exactly happy, and long it was indeed, for in the blink of an eye, Thorin could see this person through time…

Thorin did recognize him, the same hobbit he had looked upon in his previous vision, and understood that he fared better in this second world. And this time Thorin found himself begging for the creature to see him, to let him enter his house. Yet the Halfling would not let him in, and even protested that he would not be pushed, that some things were better left at a distance, and that includes you and your Mountain! I will never set foot there again! I’ve had enough trouble! he shouted. To his surprise though, Thorin saw himself enter the hobbit’s home through the closed door and follow him around.

Before he could think more on the strangeness of it all, something caught his attention. As he proceeded down the hobbit hole into an endless maze of hallways and rooms, he stopped in front of a chest that was gathering dust on the floor. Thorin found that despite the chest being locked he could see inside it. What he saw was a red book, and he found that he could see inside it too. So he willed it to open and realized it was a book about their adventure, and as he looked on the last pages he read, They buried Thorin deep beneath the Mountain, and now Thorin knew that he himself was dead in this world too.

He continued moving, and saw the Halfling draw towards his desk and stare at a ring placed on it, his eyes glimmering in a way that reminded Thorin of his own former passion for gold. Yet the way this creature was bound to the ring was different from Thorin’s experience with the gold. The ring was turning him into someone secretive and deceitful. Thorin saw, then, in a brief moment, the same creature take an object from Thorin’s inherited treasure hoard, and keep it from him, and then give it to others, and out of the many things that were wrong with this what had angered Thorin beyond belief was that Bilbo had lied to him-

And now he knew, oh, he knew who this creature was, and just how he held his heart…

Why is this important now? he wondered with sadness. Why do I have to remember the bad in order to finally remember him?

Then he glanced at the ring again. Bilbo seemed to be having a dialogue with it, and the ring was whispering something to him. But Thorin could not make out more than this.

Then the vision changed, and Thorin saw himself in his Maker’s halls, surrounded by stone, and there was no more green door at Bag End, only a life of loneliness and misery for him, because he now knew that Bilbo was his love and that Bilbo probably did not love him back, or if he did he got over it comfortably, and lived a long and satisfying life, in which Thorin was not mentioned hardly at all.

He saw himself implore Mahal to let him leave, and appear to Bilbo as a ghost, or in a dream, or vision, or something, anything, and attempt to talk to him, at least to see if Bilbo could possibly feel the same. But Mahal was unmoved. Son of Thrain, you came here of your own choosing. You decided to fight in battle and went after a formidable enemy on ice of all things, a territory unfamiliar to you, when you could have walked away. My child, do not think it doesn’t pain me. I hoped you’d turn around and run so that you might be spared, but there you were, you didn’t learn after your previous confrontation with Azog… You will stay where you are, there may come a time for love, but you left all that behind when you decided to mount on Ravenhill…

Thorin tried to tell him of his love for the hobbit. Mahal did not have any of it. Ah, yes, this very special hobbit. I am touched, but if you loved him so much, why didn’t you cherish him when you were alive? Make a confession to him, try to secure his love? Why pine for him now, a bit too late?

Thorin was dismayed. I… But the words would not come. Instead, shame, hopelessness and grief, impossible to express. Yet the music of the harp-like voice was still there with him.

Go to the forge, my son. That’s where many like you cleanse their sorrows. It will end in fire, that was something of your tune, right?

Then Father, let me sleep until the world is remade. I will be of use then. And maybe I’ll be able to find my One again. Please, Lord Mahal, please grant me rest from this misery. There is no comfort for me here.

No, my son. I cannot grant you that either. I made you out of stone, so you will endure. You are stronger than you think. You’ll find things to do here. I know that your love will never fade, but you can put it to use, you can craft, you can make music, write books, create beautiful things with your hands. Take a page out of your hobbit’s book. He’s not wasting his time. He has more faith than you do.

Faith? He has forgotten about me! Thorin released an anguished cry that echoed loudly in his mind. And then there was silence. It didn’t look like anybody heard him.

Notes:

Khuzdul:

amrâlime: my love
hikhthuzul: always
akdâm: adventure

www.dwarrowscholar.com

"They buried Thorin deep beneath the Mountain" is a quote taken directly from Tolkien.