Actions

Work Header

Love Is A Shield

Chapter 12: And The Forest is So Black and Empty

Summary:

Bilbo and Thorin talk about the latest developments and continue to deepen their special bond. Thranduil opens up to Bilbo about his wife’s death and asks for advice on how to deal with his pain. Then he reveals a surprise that renders Bilbo speechless.

While this chapter is written from Bilbo’s POV, I also wanted to show some love to Thranduil with one rare and beautiful song that has the power to express the depth of his sorrow: a unique song for a unique character :) ("Ohne Dich" by Rammstein) The lyrics are included in both German and English.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

“Ich werde in die Tannen gehen

Dahin wo ich sie zuletzt gesehn

Doch der Abend werft ein Tuch aufs Land

Und auf die Wege hinterm Waldersrand

Und der Wald er steht so schwarz und leer

Weh mir oh weh, und die Vögel singen nicht mehr

 

Ohne dich kann ich nicht sein, ohne dich

Mit dir bin ich auch allein, ohne dich

Ohne dich zähl ich die Stunden, ohne dich

Mit dir stehen die Sekunden, Lohnen nicht

 

Auf den Ästen in den Gräben

Ist es nun still und ohne Leben

Und das Atmen fällt mich ach so schwer

Weh mir oh weh, und die Vögel singen nicht mehr”

 

Bilbo walked slowly, unsure if he could hold himself steady. He reached the healing chamber and entered, his vision blurred as his eyes searched for the one person he needed to see. Thorin was sitting beside a sleeping Fili, Tauriel and Legolas administering to both his nephews. As Bilbo approached them, Thorin stood and rushed towards him.

“He was awake for a few minutes,” said Thorin, pointing to Fili. “We talked to him for a bit. He knows we all survived and saw his brother by his side. He gave us a smile and said he needed sleep. Bilbo, you’re shaking…”

“Oh, Thorin,” Bilbo said, letting out a sigh of relief, yet the effort was palpable in his voice. “This is great progress. I am so glad to hear of it.”

“Bilbo, are you cold? What is the matter?”

“Nothing. It’s… Can we talk somewhere private?”

Thorin reached for a nearby bed and picked up a blanket. Then he led Bilbo out of the room and outside the halls. They crossed the bridge and stopped at the entrance to the forest. Thorin wrapped the blanket around Bilbo’s back and placed his hands on his shoulders to hold it in place, and Bilbo felt his presence steady him. They sat down at the bottom of a tree, facing each other. Then Thorin asked, “What is the matter?”

“Thranduil wants me to stay here, in his kingdom. He said he’d give you back the Arkenstone in exchange for me.”

Thorin’s hands trembled, yet his posture didn’t change, and the look on his face grew fierce. “Never,” he said. Then he looked a bit taken off guard. “Unless... you wish to stay here.”

Bilbo shook his head. “I don’t!”

“Bilbo, you don’t look well. What did this weed-eater do to you?”

“It’s too much. All of this is too much. I hate how he’s blackmailing you. And we never have time to talk about anything. Like how this is all my fault.” He looked down in defeat. “I shouldn’t be burdening you with this; there’s Fili and Kili to worry about. I’m sorry, I just…”

“There will be time to talk. Actually…” Thorin paused as if mind-blown by his own thoughts. “Anything. We can talk now. Tell me what’s on your mind.”

“I’m scared,” Bilbo said. “I don’t know what’s going to happen. And I haven’t been feeling well since we got here. I’m still glad I came to Mirkwood with you, but I did not expect to feel so… worn out. Perhaps it’s the effect of this accursed forest, or its strange owner. He’s so unpredictable! I was walking with him earlier, my head was spinning like something unnatural. Something just doesn’t feel right.”

“You seem troubled by this Arkenstone business,” said Thorin tentatively, his voice lowering as he pronounced a certain word.

“How can I not be? I gave it to them. I had no idea it would wind up with Thranduil. How am I going to sort out this mess? The Arkenstone belongs with you.” Yet I worry about that too. “If I stay here, he’ll give it back to you. So maybe I should, shouldn’t I? It would... fix things,” he said hesitantly.

“Bilbo, look at me,” Thorin said, cupping Bilbo’s cheek with one hand and gently lifting his head up. “You do not need to fix anything. You are not responsible for this. You did what you thought to be right at the time. Don’t carry the burden of this wretched elf’s misdeeds.”

“But I would help you!” said Bilbo passionately, his body still shaking. "Me staying here would lead the Arkenstone back to you.” Thorin looked unmoved. Then Bilbo pondered thoughtfully, “You know, I don’t even understand why he wants me here.”

“I could think of a few reasons,” said Thorin with an all-knowing smirk. “Despite my efforts to hide my thoughts from him, he saw how highly I value you. He wants to one-up me, to prove that he is better than me... It wouldn’t be the first time,” he scoffed. “Or...”

Bilbo eyed him with curiosity. It looked like now Thorin was hiding something from him. “Or he’s just messing with both of our minds,” Thorin continued hastily. “Maybe he’s not serious. Maybe seeing our reactions amuses him, or he simply switches from one thing to another randomly. This is not the first time he appears to be bending one way or another on a whim.”

Bilbo frowned. That’s what Thranduil said to me about you! Wow, I can’t believe these guys.

“But Thorin…” he struggled, hating that he had to ask this, but it meant doing the right thing, did it not? “Don’t you want to get the Arkenstone back? This would be a chance for me to redeem myself.”

Thorin laughed softly. “Ideally, yes, I would have it back. But not like this.”

Bilbo’s frown intensified before it gave way to a playful smile. “Perhaps I should have stayed in Dale as you asked me to. It serves me right to disobey you, King Under the Mountain. I’ll have you know I don’t like this situation at all!”

“I don’t terribly mind it,” Thorin said calmly.

“You don’t mind... what? This Thranduil situation, or that I disobeyed you?”

“I don’t mind this situation. It is a chance for me to redeem myself,” Thorin echoed. “As for you disobeying me...” he sighed. “You are here with me and I’m grateful for it. Though I don’t know what tomorrow will bring.” He brought Bilbo’s head to his chest, and started tracing a pattern on Bilbo’s back with his hand, up and down, pressing gently. And Bilbo’s shaking ceased.

“I don’t know what you mean. You don’t need to redeem yourself for anything. You never did,” Bilbo said, and felt his eyes closing, this time not with heaviness, but with true comfort and peace.

“A chance for me to show you,” Thorin tried, his voice that was previously steady and confident now shaking. “That you mean far more to me… and I should have never let it endanger our…” and he looked like he was out of words, just say it, Thorin, tell me what we are to each other, “…our bond,” he finished with uncertainty.

“So you... would leave without the Arkenstone?” Bilbo asked in disbelief.

“I would rather be without the Arkenstone than be without you,” Thorin said, and at that moment Bilbo realized his head was pressed against Thorin’s heart. He could feel all the turmoil there in his heartbeat, and could tell that despite wanting to be reassuring, Thorin was scared of something. Perhaps I transferred my shakiness to him, Bilbo thought with concern. He lifted his head and placed his hands on Thorin’s heart. “Thorin...” he said urgently. “I would not want to part with you. If this is how it is... if this is how you feel... then I’m feeling much better already.”

He could feel Thorin’s heart calming, and some euphoria came over him, a feeling that he had not quite known before, though touches of it had been present at times during their adventure. He felt that this was the peace and happiness he had longed for, and wished he could stay here and feel safe forever. But he holds me like this only because I’m not feeling well. Perhaps now that I told him I feel better this moment will be over. Yet I wish he would never let me go.

I could just ask him, he continued his thoughts, I could ask him to hold me like this more often. But I can’t, can I? I’d sound desperate! And this was what Bilbo didn’t like about the possibility of falling in love. It would turn into exactly this kind of mess, even more impossible to sort out than...

“It is,” he heard Thorin say. “Always.” And a smile enveloped him, there was so much in this moment, trust, he wanted to name it, I trust that things will stay like this, that Thorin will never succumb to gold madness again, that he values me as he says he does. I want to trust in this moment. Ikrid, hikhthuzul, Bilbo heard in his mind, words unspoken that he was used to finding there, but this time they sounded as if they were being formed in Thorin’s... no, not in his mind, but in his heart. Ikrid, ana id-anat. And Bilbo understood this and looked at him in complete astonishment, and it felt like the sun and the moon were shining on the Hidden Door all over again, and that it was going to open once more...

...And Thorin didn’t let go of him for a long time, and began stroking Bilbo’s hair and singing something slow and peaceful. The last obstacle was removed, and for the first time, Bilbo thought of saying the words he had wanted to say and wondered how it would feel if Thorin said them back. Yet the moment was perfect as it was; it felt enough for now. I will tell him, he resolved. I promise myself, right here and now, that before we leave this place he will know how I feel about him. I won’t let him enter the Mountain without telling him.

“We’ll leave as soon as Fili and Kili are fit to travel,” he heard Thorin speak after a while. “Soon, my kurdu azmâr...”

* * *

Fili woke up again, and both he and Kili continued to improve as they passed their first week in the Woodland Realm. Thorin and Bilbo attended to them often, sometimes accompanied by Balin and Dwalin, who also spent their time exchanging fighting tips with Legolas and Tauriel in the forest. Balin maintained correspondence with Dain and Bard, which he reported to Thorin regularly. This is how they found out that Dain’s dwarves had moved into the Mountain and, along with the rest of Thorin’s company, were slowly making it into a proper home. Thorin himself corresponded with Nori and Bofur, who informed him that Gandalf too had entered the Mountain and attempted to remove any curses. However, the two dwarves expressed their uncertainty as to the success of this endeavor.

This last piece of news weighed heavily on Bilbo’s mind, along with his apprehension toward being in the Woodland Realm under the piercing gaze of its ruler. Bilbo found himself needing Thorin’s presence more and more. They did continue to share moments of comfort, though only briefly here and there, as Thorin was still preoccupied with his nephews’ recovery and with the state of his kingdom, often seeking Balin’s counsel. He did, however, bring Bilbo breakfast every morning, played harp for him on occasion (as Tauriel had provided him with one upon request), and walked with him around the palace. Bilbo was uneasy about going anywhere alone, for fear of the Elvenking shadowing his footsteps. He did not trust Thranduil would not try to persuade him to stay again, and did not trust himself to fully resist that attempt. After voicing some of his concerns to Thorin, Dwalin was promptly enlisted as Bilbo’s on-demand bodyguard for anytime the hobbit wanted to take a walk.

For his part, Thranduil did not look eager to talk with him alone again. Bilbo only saw him at dinner every now and then. Yet Thranduil did gaze at him often, with a look so sorrowful and full of longing that Bilbo felt there was more to the Elvenking than met the eye, and eventually grew curious to know more about him. As he felt his strength return more and more, and with it his confidence that he could hold his own against Thranduil, one day he ventured outside unaccompanied.

Right on cue, Thranduil made an appearance, looking most eager to converse with Bilbo again.

“I haven’t given up hope I might prevail upon you to change your mind,” he began instantly. “I know what you need in order to heal; and your healing, Bilbo Baggins, is of great importance to me.”

Bilbo smiled politely. “I am humbled by your generosity, King Thranduil. But I cannot stay here.”

“Ah, so things have changed between you and the dwarf king? He has caught on, hasn’t he?”

“I don’t know what you’re talking about,” said Bilbo, and for some reason the conversation he had had with Smaug not a month before stirred vividly in his mind.

“Oh, I think you do. One question, Halfling, and I will let you go. Tell me: Are you happy? Are you content? Are you healed?”

That’s three questions, Bilbo thought, rolling his eyes. Yet he could not entirely dismiss that Thranduil had the ability to cut through the fog and get to the heart of the matter. Regardless of his delivery, the Elvenking had a point in everything he said. This helped Bilbo reflect, in a place where everyone was too busy to think about their own happiness.

He thought of Thorin, who possessed the ability to make him all of these things: happy, healthy, and content. If he only spent more time with Bilbo, if he only showed him more affection. But Thorin was not often available. And Thorin did not know all of Bilbo’s needs. So, in the absence of that… could he say that he was happy? Or healed, or content?

“I am close to being all of these things,” he answered.

“And are you confident that you will get them?”

“Y… yes.”

As they walked through the forest, Bilbo’s shields began to drop, and he felt relaxed again. “King Thranduil,” he asked, “what would you need me here for? Please, let me know now. I might be able to be of some assistance before I leave.” And you can still keep the Arkenstone, he added privately.

So Thranduil got to tell him about his wife. How she was slain by the Gundabad orcs, and he never found her. Instead he just received word from his Elven army that she was gone, that they couldn’t save her. How he had no memory of her death, and no possibility of holding a funeral. How he had to live for hundreds of years without her, protecting his kingdom as darkness and malice were slowly creeping within. How he found comfort in his son, Legolas, but never for long. How he could never heal from the pain of being without his love. And as Thranduil was sharing all of this, Bilbo felt the king’s sorrow, and was saddened beyond belief. Strangely, he felt he could relate to his grief, even though he’d never experienced anything similar. But he had almost experienced it, had he not? The thought sent shivers down his spine.

“All I want is to bring her back, if only for an hour. To see her beautiful eyes, to tell her I love her and I miss her every moment. And to say goodbye, for now, since I’ve never had that chance.”

“I’m sorry,” said Bilbo fidgeting, “I just can’t see how a simple hobbit like me would be able to help. I can’t bring people back from the dead.”

“Well… that is not entirely true, I think,” said Thranduil with a strange twinkle in his eye, and now Bilbo could perceive one very, very strange reason why the Elvenking would want him there. “Nevertheless… even if you could not, I’d like to hear what you would do if you were me. If you were faced with this sorrow, and the impossibility of bringing your love back?”

Bilbo gave a deep sigh. Yes, he had wondered. In the minutes when he was close to despair, clutching Thorin’s hand and wondering if he would live, he had wondered how he’d manage if Thorin died.

He did not have an answer. “I think… I would try to do the things that I know that person liked. If they asked something of me… I’d try to make that happen, in their memory.” He thought of plant your trees, watch them grow... But truthfully he wasn’t even sure he would have planted his acorn if Thorin had died. “What would your wife have wanted you to do?” he asked finally.

“She was undoubtedly broken beyond repair that she had to part with Legolas and me. She still is, I am certain, just as I am to be parted from her. For us Elves... such feelings never go away. The more time passes, the deeper the grief. With every season, it makes its way into the world around us, into the trees, the grass, the soil itself. The pain of separation weaves itself into the fabric of space and time, growing stronger and harder to bear with every moment.”

“What about the jewels Thorin returned to you? Do those not help at all?”

“I sleep with them,” said Thranduil. “I cherish them night and day. I look at them and hope to see her in them. But she is not in them. They were not meant to capture her essence, but just as an ornament to complement her beauty... not that any such thing was ever needed.”

“How about drawing her? From memory?”

“I have tried. I am not good at it, though. And others, who have tried at my request, have not managed to capture her either.”

“But there’s a stone statue in the forest. Is that…”

“Yes, that is a sculpture of my wife. That was done while she was alive. It’s a very faithful representation.”

“It’s beautiful,” Bilbo murmured dreamily. “I’ve never seen a more beautiful sculpture.” And he smiled in amusement as he thought of how Thorin would fiercely disapprove of this statement.

“It is. But it doesn’t help. To answer your question, I can’t think of what she would have wanted me to do. She left me no message. There was no time.”

As he said this, Bilbo realized they had been walking back toward the palace, and had now reached the area of the former garden the Elvenking had shown him a week before. Thranduil stopped and gave him an enigmatic look. “However, I’m inclined to think that she would have wanted me to restore this,” he said. “This is the place where I last saw her.”

They entered the area of the dead garden, and Bilbo gasped, at a loss for words, breath caught in his throat. In place of the withered leaves and barren soil, he beheld a spectacle of flowers in red, purple and violet, and a tree with beautiful pink and white flowers against a background of green grass and leaves. The colors were not too bright; it was as if they were meant to fit the rest of the environment. He briefly wondered why yellow and blue were completely absent from the garden. There was something quiet and humble about the flowers, and he remembered the statue at the edge of the forest, her face peaceful and equally humble, looking as if she held the sadness of her realm in her heart. I can see what Thranduil loved in her. Loves... he corrected himself. Goodness, is what I see. She was good for him. He is lost without her.

“You grew a garden overnight?” he found himself talking before he could gain control of himself. “How did this happen??”

“Well, it wasn’t me,” Thranduil said, as if this was but a simple matter. “It turns out I was right after all.” As they walked toward the center of the garden, Bilbo noticed the circular stone structure again. This time, it held a shiny object on top. As Bilbo drew closer, he recognized the object. It was the Arkenstone!

“The stone is magical after all,” said Thranduil. “It brought some of the plants back to life. All I had to do was bring it here.”

Bilbo was astonished. “How...?”

“That’s right, little Halfling. It has tremendous power, just as I suspected. Now all I need is time. To find out what else it can do.”

Then Thranduil gave him a smile of great satisfaction. “This garden is but a small token of what I could offer you if you stayed here. Now... as dear as your king is to you, I trust you won’t share this piece of information with him?”

“Oh. Well... I would expect you would share this news with him, to be honest. The Arkenstone is his. If anyone should know about its powers, it is him.”

“Undoubtedly. Then why don’t I do that,” said Thranduil casually. Then his face changed into a sudden frown. “But if I do, he most certainly will want it back. Do you see the problem, Halfling?”

I see. Better that Thorin should think it’s just a pretty stone with some symbolism for his line. But... if it does hold such power – a good power –... maybe it won’t drive him mad after all. Maybe Smaug lied. And when I spoke to him, Balin wasn’t sure anymore that the Arkenstone is bad news...

Yet Thranduil’s sorrow... surely he deserves a chance to... anyone would, no matter how big of a jerk... now he felt an unmistakable twinge on his forehead, and remembered Thorin saying the Elvenking had attempted to read his thoughts earlier. Too late, for Bilbo had been an open book all this time! I. Must. Stop. Then he conjured a serene face and tried to insert a thought, If any average jerk deserves a chance, all the more so Thranduil, the great King...

“Flattery will not save you, Halfling,” said Thranduil. Bilbo was startled, though strangely, the king only appeared to be amused.

This is messed up. I need you, Thorin. I can’t face this without you.

“I request some time to think more,” he tried to fight his panic, “of what I would do if I were in your position. In the meantime... I wish you good luck with your... experiments.” He smiled generously at Thranduil. “Your garden is beautiful, dear King. Like your wife.” And after a small bow, he turned and went back inside the palace.

 

“I’m going to go into the fir trees

There where I last saw her

But the evening is throwing a cloth upon the land

And upon the ways behind the edge of the forest

And the forest, it is so black and empty

Woe is me, oh woe, and the birds sing no more

 

Without you I cannot be, without you

With you I am alone too, without you

Without you I count the hours, without you

With you the seconds stand still

They aren’t worth it (without you)

 

On the branches in the ditches

It’s now silent and without life

And breathing becomes oh so hard for me

Woe is me, oh woe, and the birds sing no more”

 

Notes:

Khuzdul:

ikrid: trust
hikhthuzul: always
ana id-anat: to the end
kurdu: heart
azmâr: sound

In Khuzdul, the words "trust" and "heart" have the same root.

www.dwarrowscholar.com