Chapter Text
“You know you’re not supposed to venture outside all alone,” Dwalin scolded, he and Balin eyeing Bilbo with concern as they stood near the entrance to Thranduil’s palace. “Thorin is worried sick about you. Come! Let’s take you to him.”
“We were just about to go outside in search for you,” said Balin. “Are you all right, Bilbo?”
Bilbo took a moment to think, an idea striking him.
“Balin, Dwalin... Would it be a terrible inconvenience if I had a word with you both?”
“Spit it out,” said Dwalin, “but be quick. Thorin is waiting.”
“It’s Thranduil. He... he just showed me something out of a fairy tale. A garden. A garden that was dead a week ago, now has flowers and trees in full bloom. He managed to resurrect it in a matter of days. Do you want to guess how he did it?”
“Can’t imagine he worked his noble fingers to the bone,” scoffed Balin.
“He used crap from his majestic Elk as fertilizer?” said Dwalin.
“He used the Arkenstone! All right?” Bilbo shouted, exasperated. “So now it really does seem that it is magical, just as he thought!” The two brothers continued to stare at him, unfazed. “And now he feels encouraged to continue experimenting with it. In the meantime... well, he says he offers me this garden if I decide to stay here. Which is really confusing, you know? If I decide to stay here, the Arkenstone goes with Thorin. I’m not sure how Thranduil plans to maintain this garden without the Arkenstone.”
Dwalin and Balin gasped in horror, and Bilbo stopped for a moment, unsure.
“So... the question is whether I should tell Thorin. You know, I wouldn’t want to keep anything from him. I want to show him that he can trust me. On the other hand... this magic business... may severely mess with him. Who’s to say that the Arkenstone won’t destroy his mind if he finds out...?”
He paused to catch his breath. “And yet, it may not. He might know how to handle its magical powers. Balin... do you see what I’m saying?”
Balin gripped his shoulder reassuringly. “Don’t worry, Bilbo. For all we know the Elvenking is just bragging. He could have brought in some fake plants, placed a powerful magic on them to make them look somewhat real, and poof. Have you looked closely at that garden?”
“But why would he do that? Why would he want to brag to me?”
“To dazzle you,” said Balin resolutely. “A cheap trick from a simple elf. He wants you to stay here, remember? And he sure wants to mess with Thorin. Which brings me to my next point. Bilbo, I strongly feel... are you with me on this, brother?” - Dwalin gave him a firm nod - “if you must keep something from Thorin, it’s the Thranduil-gifting-the-garden-to-you part. If I understood that correctly.”
“You understood correctly, brother,” Dwalin interjected angrily. “I wouldn’t put anything past that faithless woodland sprite.”
“I would spare Thorin this part of the news if I were you,” Balin finished.
“By Mahal,” Dwalin groaned, and it sounded like the axe in his hand groaned with him, “that’s the last thing Thorin needs to know! He’s been through enough!”
“Huh.” Bilbo paused in confusion. “Guys, I don’t think you truly see the problem here, and I mean no disrespect. If Thorin... if he should know about the Arkenstone’s powers... his mind... the madness could return. I’m sorry to be so blunt, but I’m concerned about that!” he yelled, all worked up in alarm.
“No, laddie. Don’t you worry about that,” Balin repeated. “Thorin is stronger than that. He conquered the dragon sickness and recovered from his wounds after almost dying. That’s gotta mean something. He learned his lesson. Now if you learned yours... you should probably tell him about the stone’s...” - he cleared his throat - “...powers.”
“Balin,” Bilbo insisted gently. “Do you mind telling me... how can you be sure that he learned his lesson?”
“If you still can’t figure that out, why don’t you ask him yourself. In the meantime, I would encourage you to be honest and let him decide if he wants the Arkenstone back or not. And trust in him to make a good decision.”
“And if I don’t tell him, are you two going to?” Bilbo asked.
Balin and Dwalin did not answer. Instead they just eyed each other with uncertainty, brows raised.
“Hmm. That’s what I thought. All right, let’s go back.”
“Bilbo,” Balin said as they walked, “about the garden bit... I’m all for you and Thorin working on trust, but I really wouldn’t mention that Thranduil did this for you. What Thorin doesn’t know cannot hurt him.”
“I fail to see how that bit is relevant,” said Bilbo. “But fine. It’s not like I wanted to stay here and enjoy it in the first place!”
“Good,” Dwalin gave a tired grunt. “That’s good!”
* * *
Thorin walked towards the garden with his head down, his right hand touching his sword as if to reassure himself it was still with him. The anger that had consumed him through the day – his worst enemy – was now beginning to subside.
Bilbo had come to see him. Bilbo had told him about the Arkenstone’s newly-found powers.
He had held Bilbo’s head in his hands, pressing his temples a little too hard, as if he wanted to get the point inside Bilbo’s head with no trace of uncertainty, and only by sheer will power kept himself from saying or doing anything he feared would be deemed inappropriate. You are still more important to me, and I would leave it here if you returned to my home with me, he said instead, and wished the glitter of happiness he saw in Bilbo’s eyes would be enough to keep him calm for the hours to come. Please don’t go anywhere alone, that is all I ask, he pleaded, reminding Bilbo of his distrust of the Elvenking. Bilbo nodded, and they left it at that...
Then his anger had stirred, and he let go of Bilbo and blindly made his way to the Elvenking’s throne, and saw him sitting there, looking greatly pleased. Words were exchanged, fruitless and meaningless, as Thorin only wanted to fire a piece of his mind at him, to tell him none of this was right, without any practical purpose. The Arkenstone is not yours, you will pay for this, how dare you, if your wife does come back I hope she restores you back to sanity, but fine, for now you can keep it, as Master Baggins will not stay in your kingdom no matter how many magical objects you have that are not yours to begin with, and Thranduil gave him a candid stare and said, perfectly unperturbed, “Master Baggins” might reconsider, as the beauty of the garden I gifted him is no doubt going to be a determining factor in his choice to leave or to... stay
and Thorin’s mind darkened beyond belief.
He had turned around and left without words, returned to his room to pick up his sword, and stormed out, running into Bilbo who had been looking for him with concern. I wish to be alone, he said and walked on. Balin and Dwalin emerged instantly and insisted on escorting him wherever he’d go, I don’t need anyone escorting me! he roared, Just make sure he is safe and don’t lose sight of him again!
He blindly wandered the halls of the Woodland Realm, losing his way once or twice, ending up at the dungeons level, and in the blink of an eye saw himself caught in the darkness of that prison and wished he could turn back time and be trapped there one more time... but what could he have done differently? It was pointless to revisit memories from what seemed like another life. Then he managed to find the exit, wandered through the forest, glad to run into some dead trees and swing his sword at them, smashing and smashing until they were reduced to splinters. He continued walking aimlessly, wishing he would run into spiders so he had something more rewarding to do, and he eventually reached the edge of the forest where he and his Company had entered the first time around. As he beheld the statue of Thranduil’s wife, he felt the kindness in her gaze, and his mind started to calm. He turned around and went back...
...And here he was, in pieces, entering Thranduil’s garden to see for himself, to see if this was something that Bilbo could ever like, that he could have ever made, that could ever match his dream...
Yet he didn’t look at the garden right away. Instead, his eyes were drawn to the Arkenstone lying on top of what looked like a stone altar. He kneeled before the altar and laid his head on its top, his hair spread out, lightly touching the Arkenstone. And he wrapped his arms around the altar. How is this working out for you, my child? he thought he heard Mahal’s voice from deep within the stone. The hours passed unceasingly into the evening, and he wept bitterly.
While he rested so, Thorin had a dream. In his dream the stone altar was a deep well, and instead of resting on its top, his head was falling into its empty pool. And the pool was slowly filling with his tears. The Arkenstone lay at the bottom of the well, its bright rays showing through the water. Thorin reached down for it, but the well was too deep and his hand couldn’t touch the bottom. He stubbornly tried again, and it felt like he was drowning. The only way to save himself was to leave the Arkenstone at the bottom, or he would take its place. He brought his arm back up and got his head out of the water. Yet he couldn’t stop the tears from flowing, and they soon filled the well to the top. And now the Arkenstone lay on top, floating on the water, and it was easy to reach for it. As he hesitantly extended his hand towards it, Thorin beheld the deepness of the water once more, and this time Bilbo’s tiny acorn lay at the bottom. As Thorin’s hand was getting closer and closer to the Arkenstone, the acorn was getting smaller and smaller. He gasped and withdrew his hand. And he threw himself into the water, trying to reach for the acorn instead, and did not fight the sensation of drowning. And he woke up, his head jolting violently and hitting the top of the altar, where the Arkenstone still stood, unmoved.
...It was completely dark now, when Thorin lifted his head and beheld the Arkenstone through the tracks of his tears. Oh, how beautifully it shone, its blue and yellow light piercing through the shadows of the evening, lighting the branches and flowers on the trees and warming their colors with its light. He reached to touch it, and marveled that it seemed to be there for anyone to take. The elf must have cast a powerful magic on it. It won’t be easily moved, he thought. And he felt a measure of comfort in the touch.
He looked around, taking in the sight of the garden for the first time, and it felt somewhat wrong. This was not the garden that he would have wanted to create for Bilbo. Yet Bilbo may enjoy it. Thranduil had got to him first, had been able to offer him a thing of beauty when Thorin could not.
Then he thought he heard the Arkenstone make a sound. As he beheld its light again, he noticed the rays emanating from it getting brighter, and followed their path. The light reflected on the trees, and Thorin could make out that it formed six Dwarvish runes. EREBOR, they spelled. Then the light changed and the runes with it, and now they spelled HOME.
I know, he whispered tenderly. You don’t belong here. And yet I can’t take you home. The Arkenstone emitted another sound, and focused its light downward, towards the flowers that covered the ground.
He looked in the direction of the rays. Flowers. Pink, violet, red, white. Thorin was not impressed with those colors. But he... he may very well be. And only now did he notice the absence of yellow and blue.
Yellow is for sunshine, he thought absently. Yellow is... how I see him. What he means to me.
And blue... is the color that ties him to me. The color of the flowers I wanted to give him. So that he would stay with me.
Would Bilbo have liked that?
It doesn’t matter anymore. If this can make him happy...
“Thorin!”
He turned to see Dwalin standing at the entrance to the garden, looking fed up with life.
“In case you haven’t noticed, it’s night time. Everybody’s getting ready for bed. Fili and Kili said if you don’t cease your brooding at once they would come get you themselves. And they’re not allowed to walk yet, so the wretched task falls on me. Oh, and Balin is already sleeping. Which means that your hobbit lies sort of... unattended.”
“I’ll be there, Dwalin,” said Thorin, and there he stood dizzily, resting his hand on his forehead and taking in the evening breeze.
They walked together, Dwalin taking immediate note of Thorin’s disheveled appearance. “Is this about that stupid garden?” he asked.
“Of course it is about that stupid garden. The elf says he grew it for him. Do you see what he’s doing, Dwalin?”
“Ah. If you want to know my opinion, it’s nothing special. I think you could do better.”
“Do better,” Thorin echoed full of sarcasm, “or do nothing. Have you been keeping track of the elf’s latest achievements? First he gracefully accepts to shelter my nephews and help with their treatment, despite our recent... argument. Then the Arkenstone – my Arkenstone – ends up in his realm, with no effort on his part. And now he brings back a garden lost long ago, with the help of my Arkenstone, and offers it to my... my...”
“Thorin, enough. It’s not like he’s interested in Bilbo in that way, is he? Who cares about his blasted achievements?”
“I don’t know, Dwalin. I wouldn’t be surprised if he were. But I don’t think you see the problem. I wanted to offer Bilbo a home. To him, home is his books, his armchair, his garden... These things are important to him; they mean happiness. Thranduil has already got there in one week. For all I know, when he showed him that garden he already saw that smile of joy on Bilbo’s face, that should never be meant for him. Forget it,” he closed abruptly with a heavy frown. “I can see that I’m not cut out for this.”
“I don’t even know if Bilbo would want a garden from you,” Dwalin remarked. "He seems happy enough just being around you. Maybe you don’t need to do anything.”
“You’re wrong. I need to do everything. I know him. I have seen the things he likes, and providing them for him is the key.”
“Fine,” Dwalin sighed. “By that logic it does seem you have failed so far.”
“Even as a king I’d probably fail, Dwalin,” Thorin continued, his head sinking deeper towards the ground. “I am telling you right now, and if you want to announce it out loud to our kingdom when we get back, go right ahead. I would readily give up the Arkenstone, without a second thought, no matter how much power it has, just so he would stay in Erebor. Do you understand? Even if all I get is to see him once a day at dinner and nothing more.”
“Speaking of that...” Dwalin said gravely, “the hobbit was looking for you earlier and asked me to go outside with him. So we went, and he saw you kneeling in the garden and weeping over the Arkenstone. He was appalled, Thorin. Now, it’s not my business, and I’m certainly no genius in matters of the heart, but if I were him I’d think you’re in love with the Arkenstone!”
“Undeserving,” Thorin went on as if he hadn’t heard a thing. “Undeserving of his love, I am. But that’s all right, because I’ll never have it. And equally undeserving of ruling my beloved kingdom. I’m a warrior, nothing more. I should just accept it; I don’t know how to do any of this.”
Despite his annoyance, Dwalin proclaimed in agreement that truly, both he and Thorin belonged in battle, where things were simple and clear-cut, and on that note they entered the healing chamber. Fili and Kili cheered with gladness at their uncle’s return, and Thorin spoke to them affectionately. “I’m sorry I was gone for so long. I’m going to sleep in my room this time. I need to get some thinking done.” Next he spoke to Tauriel, who was there once more, holding hands with Kili, the sweetest look of love between them. “If you could spend the night here I would be most grateful.” She nodded happily while Kili couldn’t resist, “Are you really going to give us some alone time, Uncle?” he said hopefully, in a teasing tone. “You won’t be alone,” Thorin retorted menacingly, his words equally targeted to Fili, who responded with a yawn.
Then he moved towards Bilbo, who sat on a nearby bed, looking lost. With uncertainty, he asked him if he had everything he needed. Yes, Bilbo said in a miserable tone, and Thorin hastily bid everyone good night and went to his room.
This was the first time he actually had a use for it other than to store things.
He needed to think, yet he didn’t know the first thing about thinking. Thorin was a person of raw instinct and a person of action.
His eyes were drawn to the harp that was sitting in a corner. He removed Orcrist and laid it against the table, then took the harp in his arms, sat on a chair and began to play, the first time he’d do so only for himself in the Elven realm. And he played and sang of falling in love like a fool and not knowing how to deal with it, and uselessly vowed to never have such feelings again...
After about half an hour of lamenting through music he heard a knock on the door, and didn’t stop playing to answer. He’d answer the door after finishing the song, if there was still anyone there...
But the person at the door did not wait for an answer, and Thorin saw Bilbo approach slowly, hesitantly, holding something in his hands, which he placed on the table. Thorin couldn’t see what it was. His eyes were small, almost closed all the way, red from the tears of earlier, and his vision was a blur. He put the harp aside, and saw Bilbo move towards him.
“You missed dinner, Thorin,” Bilbo spoke softly and solemnly, his voice surrounding the space with calm. And now Thorin could see two plates filled with food lying on the table. Then Bilbo brought his hands to Thorin’s eyes. “And these have seen better days. You know, it’s a crime to cry with these eyes.” And he covered Thorin’s eyes gently with his hands.
“Now, I don’t mean to intrude upon your privacy, but I would like to stay here while you have dinner. And... have dinner with you. Just to... make sure that you actually eat.”
Thorin’s eyes closed under the touch of Bilbo’s hands, and yet he felt like something inside him was opening and he could see with it, could gaze far away and so close at the same time. In the distance all he saw was blackness and darkness – or was it the blindness in him -, while if he gazed close he could see two stars shining a dim light. His mind struggled frantically to put the puzzle together, that this was dinner, an important meal of the day, that Bilbo wanted to eat with him, which meant that perhaps Bilbo had not wanted to eat without him, perhaps he had waited for him...
“I would like that,” he broke his silence, and covered Bilbo’s hands with his own, moving them slowly to the sides. Bilbo’s hands touched his temples, calming the last bit of tension in them, and Thorin opened his eyes, their blue light returned in them.
* * *
“Thorin... is there anything you want to talk about?” Bilbo asked after they finished eating, as he stood from his chair, switching uncertain looks between Thorin and the door.
“Yes,” said Thorin. “I would ask you one thing.” Then he paused, looking down and not knowing how to begin.
“Ask me.”
“Bilbo, do you like what Thranduil did with that garden?”
Bilbo was silent for a while. Then he spoke. “I do like it. I think the garden fits perfectly here in the Woodland Realm. And it made me think of Thranduil’s wife. I could almost feel her spirit there. Why do you ask?”
“And if you were to...” Thorin continued, “if let’s say at some point you decided to live somewhere else, somewhere other than the Shire... is this the kind of garden you would want for yourself?”
“Hmm. I haven’t thought about that. I honestly don’t even know if I would grow a garden at all if I were to live away from the Shire.” Bilbo paused to think for a moment. “I don’t know. It seems to me that Thranduil’s garden is missing something.”
“I thought that too.”
“When he showed it to me, I noticed it missed certain... colors. And I wondered, because his wife- well, I’m sure she was a woman of taste. I don’t think she would have limited herself to pink and red and the like.”
“Probably not,” Thorin said, not feeling like he grasped exactly what Bilbo was saying, but definitely willing to agree.
“If I were to guess – and Thorin, this is really just a wild guess – I would say that the Arkenstone may have not resurrected all of the garden. Maybe it left some things out.”
“Mmm. Do you think so?”
“Maybe. But what do I know, I’m just a simple hobbit. I do have some knowledge of gardening, though,” he mused with a smirk. Then he looked at the door again nervously.
* * *
“Bilbo, is there anything you wanted to talk about?”
“One thing. Though I don’t know how to say it.”
“Tell me. Anything.”
“I saw you earlier. In the garden. It felt like this Arkenstone thing broke your heart. So I want to know, because earlier you told me you’d still leave it here, and everything seemed fine. But then you left and were gone for hours. And you didn’t eat, and I worry that you don’t intend to sleep. Yet you said I’d never see you like that again.”
“Everything I said still stands,” said Thorin, trying to hide his disappointment that perhaps Bilbo had brought him dinner only out of concern and nothing more. “Never doubt that.”
“Then why... I understand you being upset with Thranduil, but you also seemed sad and lost and... unwell, and I don’t know why. I can’t bear to see you like this.”
“Because I’m a fool,” said Thorin. “There are things... some things I cannot share with you. Things I have to face alone. And when I’m alone, I don’t always act right.”
“But why wouldn’t you share them with me? Why wouldn’t you let me try to help you?”
“Because they concern you.”
“Oh.” They sat in silence for some time, while Bilbo pondered with a frown. “And if I asked you to share them with me anyway?”
“Then I would tell you that I need more time.”
“Huh. Time. A tricky thing, time, considering I almost lost you. Well... I think I should go back now. Fili was getting ready to sleep when I came to see you. I should probably check on those lovebirds.” Bilbo walked towards Thorin, who was still sitting on his chair. He raised his arms and enclosed Thorin’s head in them, running his fingers through his hair.
“I have been pushed over the edge,” said Thorin dreamily. “You should not have had to witness that. But it’s all right now. Now I’m slowly coming back...”
“I’m glad to hear it,” said Bilbo, and placed a kiss on Thorin’s forehead. “Sleep well, Thorin.”
“...to the center,” Thorin murmured as he watched his love release him and walk out of the room.
* * *
I love you. But I have nothing to offer you. And I’m still not sure you could ever forgive me, he whispered to the air that filled the emptiness of the room.
“If blood will flow when flesh and steel are one
Drying in the color of the evening sun
Tomorrow’s rain will wash the stains away
But something in our minds will always stay
Perhaps this final act was meant
To clinch a lifetime’s argument
That nothing comes from violence
And nothing ever could
For all those born beneath an angry star
Lest we forget how fragile we are
On and on the rain will fall
Like tears from a star
Like tears from a star
On and on the rain will say
How fragile we are
How fragile we are”
