Chapter Text
“There’s no time for us
There’s no place for us
What is this thing that builds our dreams
Yet slips away from us?
There’s no chance for us
It’s all decided for us
This world has only one sweet moment
Set aside for us
Who wants to live forever?
Who dares to love forever
Oh, when love must die?
But touch my tears with your lips
Touch my world with your fingertips
And we can have forever
And we can love forever
Forever is our today
...Who waits forever anyway?”
“I can’t decide alone,” Thorin resigned himself defeatedly. The next moment, he heard Fili and Kili’s voices from the garden’s entrance, asking if they were still scheduled to leave that day. No, he answered, there had been a change of plans and they were going to wait one more day. Then he asked his nephews to accompany Bilbo back inside and ensure that he got breakfast. As he watched Bilbo stand up, he heard Kili nervously trying to articulate a sentence about Tauriel. “Yes, Kili. She can come to Erebor with us,” Thorin anticipated him. The two brothers regarded him with a mix of surprise and pride, I guess I’m a decent uncle after all, and Thorin watched an apprehensive Bilbo leave, no words between them.
“It might be that I can’t decide at all,” he said as he faced the difficulty laid at him. He saw what he had done. This was what doing the right thing amounted to: sharing Bilbo’s secrets, that Thorin had had access to through Mahal’s mercy, secrets from another world, with the Elvenking, who would only use them to further his self-absorbed purpose. And take him away from me, Thorin’s heart wept. I am such a fool. They may as well say goodbye forever; the elf king was powerful and persuasive, and would clearly stop at nothing to split them apart. And now Thorin really didn’t have anything to offer Bilbo. If Bilbo went to Erebor and kept the ring, he wouldn’t be able to fight its power. He should be in the Shire, a place immune, or at any rate safer from the ring’s evil, if Thrain’s words were correct.
Bilbo would go to the Shire. It was inevitable. A temporary parting, perhaps; Thorin could always try to find Bilbo there later, much later, but at a time nevertheless, a time that was available in this world... the world in which he hadn’t died. And yet it felt like parting forever.
What Thrain had said... This wasn’t just about Erebor; it sounded like the fate of the world was at stake. I want to obey you, father. Yet I wish I had had the chance to tell you... I’m in love with him. Does that change anything?
Is one person worth more than the whole world?
Thorin stood and moved towards the stone altar that had previously held the Arkenstone, now in a further location of the garden. The altar seemed so familiar to him now, and Thorin felt a measure of comfort in its presence. He stood before it and touched its surface with his right hand. He began tracing its circular shape close to its edges, slowly. After doing so a few times, his hand began to stop in places, briefly, before resuming its motion. It moved like the hand that counts the seconds on a clock, a clock that is ticking, only his hand’s motion was a lot slower, as if it hoped to stop the passing of time. And his hand stopped at 1 o’clock, then at 2 o’clock, then at 3... and despite the calmness of this movement, so precise and controlled, his mind began to race in a wild panic, with scenes unfolding in rapid succession before his eyes, while he could hear the fast ticking of the clock...
* * *
One
A raven is perched on the altar, while Thorin is writing a hasty note. Dear Dain, I need you to stay in Erebor a while longer. I can’t be there right now. There are decisions I have to make that require time. I’ll relieve you of your burden as soon as I can. Thorin. P. S. Kili is bringing an Elf lady. Be kind.
Two
He sends Fili and Kili home with Balin, Dwalin, and the aforementioned Elf. He then seeks audience with Thranduil, and asks him for permission to stay longer in his kingdom. How long? Thranduil demands with a raised eyebrow, and Thorin tries for a week...
Three
Thorin is in Mirkwood’s library, searching for books on flowers. He grabs a few and returns to his room, where Tauriel has left him some painting materials, at his request.
I would try to forge a connection... though I don’t know what materials could be used... he remembers hastily.
Four
He studies the books meticulously, looking for pictures of the flowers he remembers Bilbo prefers. Thorin only knows their names; now it’s time to actually see what they look like.
Five
He begins painting. It’s all just experiments; he will probably not be able to grow such flowers in the Mountain, but he can try to create them in some other way. So he paints his ideas, some carefully informed by the pictures he’s seen in Thranduil’s books, others flowing directly from his subconscious. Some of his resulting “flowers” are lights projected on a wall of different shapes and colors; others are painted on walls, on glass, on rocks... and Thorin doesn’t know which ones are him.
Six
“Bilbo, I have something to ask of you,” he says as he stands at the entrance to Bilbo’s room. Next, Bilbo is sitting in an armchair in Thorin’s room, staring at the lit fireplace, and Thorin is trying to draw him.
Seven
...They are in the garden. The sun is shining. It’s such a beautiful day! Bilbo is sitting on the grass, leaning against a tree, and Thorin is lying at some distance, watching him.
“So, we’re just going to sit like this?”
“Just a little longer.” Thorin hasn’t had enough. He wants to memorize each element, every shape and color. How the light changes Bilbo’s features when the sun illumines him; how happy and carefree Bilbo is when surrounded by nature.
Eight
Thorin has not said much. Now, before time is running out, he is determined to say something. Not I love you. No, now he really can’t say that. That would only make Bilbo’s decision more difficult. So he is thinking, and it’s not easy with the clock that keeps ticking.
Nine
“Can I see it again?”
Bilbo holds the acorn for him, and Thorin takes it in his hand, mistakenly letting a tear drip down. The fruit darkens slightly at the tear’s touch, as if it can feel Thorin’s sadness. “That’s not the way to make it grow, Thorin,” Bilbo scolds lightly. “That’s... not what it needs.”
“What does it need?” Thorin asks in frustration.
“If you have to ask, you’re never going to know,” Bilbo says with a secretive smile.
Ten
Thorin spends time in his room, painting, thinking, and something more. He writes Khuzdul notes in a small blue notebook. He fills every page, until the end, writing about Bilbo’s favorite things, and about some of his own as well. Swordfighting. His brother. Fili and Kili. His sister. And Erebor. Always, Erebor.
Eleven
It is now close to the end of the week Thranduil granted him. Bilbo comes in and sees paintings spread everywhere, some taped to the walls, some lying on the floor; Thorin has run out of space. “Which ones do you like?” he asks Bilbo. Bilbo picks a few, and Thorin is ecstatic to see among those favorites are the small blue flowers whose persistence in his mind may have helped delay his passing not two months ago. He gives Bilbo some of the chosen paintings and keeps some for himself.
“What is this for?”
“For me. To remind me of you,” Thorin says. It’s not the whole truth. He hopes that Bilbo will come to Erebor one day; knowing what designs he prefers is of utmost importance.
Twelve
They spend the last evening together in Bilbo’s room, Thorin playing the harp, Bilbo singing and Thorin writing down the words. Then just sitting in deep silence, enjoying each other’s company. “This is for you,” Thorin says at one point, handing Bilbo the notebook. “So you can remember...” what we never had, he finishes to himself.
“A notebook of written Khuzdul?” Bilbo asks, wide-eyed and hopeful.
“There is more to it than meets the eye,” Thorin says gently. It is a part of him. Everything, everything he could offer as a friend is in this notebook; and there is more to it, that only Thorin knows. The only thing that makes this a “just friends” gift is that he has not written I love you.
Bilbo prepares for bed, while Thorin is examining the acorn which is placed on the nightstand. Then Bilbo is lying in bed, ready for sleep, and Thorin sitting by his side, not yet ready to leave. “You’re the most beautiful person I’ve met.” Thorin’s eyes mirror his words. Perhaps this doesn’t make the two of them more than just friends either; it will have to do for now, though.
Bilbo gives him a sweet, encouraging smile. Then Thorin looks at the acorn again; it looks brighter, more vivid now...
* * *
“You’re doing it again.”
Thorin felt a hand on his shoulder. “Losing track of time in this place.” His hand was still placed on the altar, cold and unmoving. “I trust you’re doing something productive?”
He turned to face Bilbo. “I was examining... possibilities. I didn’t get very far.” He looked into Bilbo’s eyes with fierce determination. “Bilbo... I’m going to ask you this once, and I want you to answer me honestly. I see three options for you: you can go back to the Shire, stay here in Mirkwood, or come to Erebor with me. I need you to tell me which one you want for yourself, regardless of what I owe Thranduil. Which one would make you the happiest. Do you understand?” Bilbo only needed to answer Shire or Mirkwood, and the discussion would be at an end, the plan set firmly in stone.
“Just so you know...” Thorin continued, “I’m going to leave the Arkenstone here, no matter what. So that should not influence your decision.”
“Leave it here? But why, when I could stay here or offer him the ring?”
“Because the ring won’t bring his wife back, you said it yourself. And neither you nor the ring are mine to offer. I owe him something for helping Fili and Kili, and the Arkenstone can help him. This feels right to me.”
“Erebor, Thorin,” Bilbo said, appearing blissfully ready to oblige him with an answer. “I thought you knew already. I do want to go back home sometime, of course, but for now going to the Mountain with you is what would make me the happiest. And I’m sure I’d rather not stay in the Woodland Realm. I’ve had enough creepy moments with Thranduil, thank you very much!”
“I would choose the same as you,” said Thorin. “Unfortunately...” It was now time to tell Bilbo of his father’s warnings about the ring coming to Erebor, and that the Arkenstone echoed his reservations. Thorin spoke trying to stay neutral and dispassionate; to his surprise, though, Bilbo was unmoved. “Then I will give the ring to Thranduil. I want to go with you. And I don’t want any harm to come to Erebor.”
“You would part with the ring?!” asked Thorin, completely astounded. He could detect no trace of I owe you, no obligation in Bilbo’s words; only a sincere wish.
“So I could join you in Erebor, if there is no other way, yes, I would.”
I didn’t think it was possible to love you more, Thorin thought wildly. But with you... it will probably always be more. Yet this, like so many other moments, was not a good time to bring such thoughts to light.
“Bilbo... my father also warned me against giving the ring to Thranduil. He said that the ring could cause much evil in his hands. Being in your keeping is what would hold the ring’s power at bay. Also... my father seemed to think the Shire is the best place for you... and the ring. You will be protected from its evil there, and the world would be protected from the ring.”
“Is that what you would have me do?” asked Bilbo, all confidence lost in his voice.
Thorin sighed heavily. “Yes, for now. I think that would be for the best. I would have you leave tomorrow, at the same time that I’d be leaving with Fili and Kili. And... Tauriel,” he added, amused if not somewhat embarrassed. “I’d have Balin and Dwalin accompany you to Beorn’s house, and you could stay there until Spring comes. I’d trust him to offer you good accommodations, and some comfort, and perhaps he can make some of the journey with you.”
“I can’t believe this is happening,” said Bilbo. “This is a very strange situation. What can I say? I suppose this is a good plan, although I can’t say it will work for me personally. Anyway, Thorin... how about we don’t decide today? How about we just have a nice time, and I’ll decide in the morning?”
Thorin smiled. “What do you have in mind?”
“Well... this acorn. It needs to be planted soon. It doesn’t look like I’m going to reach the Shire anytime soon, and Erebor sounds out of the question right now. I don’t want to plant it without you, and... since it may be a while until I see you again, it seems today is all I have.”
You’d be planting it without me in the Shire, Thorin observed silently. Bilbo’s words certainly had an air of mystery. “What are you saying?”
“That we plant it here, today. And maybe watch it grow, if the Arkenstone really is that powerful. Maybe it will grow overnight.” Bilbo gave Thorin an inquisitive look. “How would you feel if I planted it here?”
“It’s your acorn, Bilbo. You can do with it as you wish. But... you would give this wretched elf the satisfaction of having such a precious gift - the tree that would remind you of our adventure?”
“No. Not satisfaction. It’s something else I’d be giving him, Thorin.”
“And what’s that?”
“My way of responding to him. Responding with love to the stupid childish tricks he pulled. My way of telling him that I feel sorry for his loss and I hope my tree will make it better, though I know nothing will. He has lost his everything. He said it himself, nothing really could heal him. He is stuck with living forever; what good is it to live forever, when your love is gone? And yet he persists in sorrow and grief, and a great deal of instability. I pray to Yavanna that I’ll never know what it is like to be him.”
Thorin did not say anything, so Bilbo continued. “It would be a token of gratitude, also. Because, Thorin... wretched as he is, he makes me... he makes me appreciate what I have even more. I have hope. Hope that my love story will turn out well. End well. Or better... that it will never end. And that one day I will be whole. ”
Thorin stared at him with newfound awe. I never thought I’d meet someone like you. And then I didn’t think it would be possible for your soul to shine even more beautifully than I’d already seen it, when you stood between Azog and me. But right now... and he was ready to let the words burst out of him, when something else caught his sight. Bilbo was looking towards the statue, and Thorin perceived the source of his alarm as he noticed tears on her face.
“Oh. No, no, no,” Bilbo said gesturing hurriedly. “I didn’t mean to make you cry. Please. If this is not a good idea, I don’t have to do it. I don’t have to plant the acorn here.”
The Arkenstone immediately emitted a sound and shone its rays, spelling words. “It’s saying it’s a very good idea,” said Thorin.
“Oh. All right then.” Bilbo gave the same secretive, mischevious smile Thorin had seen in his mind earlier. “And it may be that we won’t lose anything at all. So, Thorin... is this all right?”
“I like it.”
So they planted the acorn while the sun was still out, then Bilbo went back inside, while Thorin remained in the garden for a little while. He drew closer to the statue and spoke to her for the first time, with respect and also sorrow, and gratitude for the kindness and compassion he felt she bestowed upon that place and all the living things in it. “I wish you would just come back to life. Then Thranduil would probably feel better. And I’d have the Arkenstone back. And I would not have to part with him.” As he voiced his thoughts in reverse order, he took in all the statue’s features, trying to understand what it was that made her look so real, half as if she was already brought back to life. “This is not enough,” Thorin continued, fully absorbed in the statue’s appearance, “for him to truly feel your presence. He needs you. Nothing will replicate that. Nothing.”
Then he went inside too, packed his things, advised Balin and Dwalin of the change in plan, and thanked Tauriel for the harp and the painting materials. And as the evening set in, he and Bilbo returned to the garden with lots of blankets in their hands and with hope in their hearts that they would watch the tree grow. Yet nothing was happening for the time being, and they were content to stay like that, admiring the nature around them one last time.
As night came, they picked a sleeping spot in the garden, very close to the place where they had planted the acorn. They used some of the blankets to make a bed and some to cover themselves, and agreed they should get some sleep, as they had a long day with journeys ahead of them. If the tree was going to grow overnight, they surely would hear or feel something that would wake them up, and thus wouldn’t miss it. Thorin fell asleep first, and Bilbo was left to wonder where his adventure would take him next...
* * *
Once again, Bilbo could not sleep. How could he? This may be the last night he had with Thorin! The strange conversation with Thranduil, Thorin having a One or not, the ring, decisions, decisions... No, he couldn’t think of any of that. There was one thing staring him in the face, blocking everything else from his sight. This could be the last night. Thorin could have twenty Ones for all Bilbo cared. He was not going to waste this chance, and that was final!
Yet there was Thorin sleeping, a discouraging sight. Bilbo didn’t know that Thorin’s earlier attempt to slow down time had rendered him quite exhausted. He stood up, took one look at Thorin, removed the blanket that covered his back, exposing his blue coat, and walked towards the statue. He had to come up with something, and the first idea he had was to talk with the Arkenstone. Make it short, he told himself. You don’t have much time. If this doesn’t work, you need a backup plan.
“So. It looks like I’m leaving tomorrow,” he spoke as he beheld the precious jewel. “There is not much time left until we will probably part, and with all the commotion surrounding our departure I really don’t think I’m going to have a chance to tell him. I love him. Just so there’s no confusion, I’m talking about...” - he pointed to the sleeping Thorin - “that dude over there. Thorin II, son of Thrain, King Under the Mountain. I will always love him. And I want to be with him. But I don’t want it to be rushed... when I tell him. Or for either of us to be conflicted.”
He paused to take a breath, then resumed. “Here’s the thing. That talk with Thranduil earlier was really weird. It sounded like if I lost Thorin I’d write a book, and that I’d write this book as a way of declaring my love. That’s all well and good, except... well, when we were taking to Thranduil, I felt like I wrote this book already. And I knew that and what the book contained. So maybe that’s a big deal, me, writing a book. Maybe that needs to happen even if he’s not dead. Not to mention I may want to write it.”
Bilbo Baggins, you’re talking too much. Get to the point.
Yet Bilbo liked to be thorough. “And Thorin is going back to the Mountain. With or without the presence of the ring, I know he is vulnerable. I know the madness may come back. So what I’m going to do now... I hope it will help him. This was one thing I really wanted to do, if nothing else: to be there to protect him from that evil. And now it seems that my presence - because of that blasted ring - would only make him worse. So... I want to be there for him, in another way. I want to do something special, and you are... pretty special.”
The Arkenstone gave no reaction, so he continued. “I want you to write. On him, that is. I’m going to try to say some words - everything good that I can think of - and I’d like you to translate them into Khuzdul and write them on him with your light. I have hope that your light will protect him, at least for a while. Not to mention...” he chuckled nervously here, “I hope my words can wake him up. Will you help me?”
ALL RIGHT, the Arkenstone spelled. HE’S FAR FROM US, THOUGH.
“Oh. Yes. I guess your rays can’t reach that far?”
The Arkenstone shone its rays as a test; they reached Thorin, but their light was dim, and Bilbo was not satisfied. He touched the Arkenstone and tried to take it out of the statue’s hand; but the jewel was firmly enclosed in, the hand slightly forming a fist. “I need more light,” Bilbo said, not sure whom he was addressing this time. “By any chance... have the two of you become friends in the meantime?” He shifted his gaze from the statue’s face back to the Arkenstone. “Can you tell her to help?”
The Arkenstone made no answer, so Bilbo touched the statue’s hand instead and asked, “Can you please help?”
The Arkenstone waited a moment, then answered. THE WORDS, FIRST.
“Oh. All right. Here’s what I want to say.” He took a deep breath, with a serious and solemn air as if he was taking a marriage vow, and began.
“Thorin... I feel you.
You’re in everything I see. In the air that I breathe; in every stone, in every river and in every leaf. In this garden and in this light that is now shining on you; and in the Mountain itself that is so dear to you. And in this tree that has not yet grown, and in the stars above it. And if I am to return to the Shire, you’ll be there too, in the sun and the grass and the flowers. When I breathe, you breathe with me. And when I don’t... you will continue to breathe. You will always be.
And if you’ve really known me across multiple worlds, as I have a feeling you have after that really trippy stuff earlier... then know this: that book I wrote... I’m sure it was nice and good, and it spoke of Orcs and Goblins and spiders and what-not; but it’s not the book I’ll be writing in this world. In this world, my book will be blended with life; with you. But even that book... it was all for you. It was my way of telling you I love you.”
Then he touched the Arkenstone again, affectionately, and said: “Please shine your rays on him and infuse him with your light, and let these words penetrate him deeply. Create a shield to protect him against all evil. Let them enter, and with them, please, let my love in. Ifil amralime ni,” he spoke hopefully.
The Arkenstone made a sound like a clink, clink, clink, perhaps approving of his impeccable use of Khuzdul. The statue opened her fist a little, allowing the Arkenstone to shine brighter, fuller rays, and glowing blue runes started pouring onto Thorin’s hair and back, and Bilbo watched in fascination how the words were being written. You’re the most beautiful book I’ve seen, Thorin, he thought with great joy, and then he said those words out loud. “Or read... or wrote. I love you, Thorin Oakenshield. In this and every world. Always and forever.”
The Arkenstone wrote everything, and then the statue’s fist closed again slightly, and Bilbo stood there, perfectly bewildered. “Thank you,” he said to them, shaking with reverence. “I will never forget this. At least I had a witness; two witnesses, actually. Now someone knows I love him. That is no small thing.” Then he looked towards Thorin, who still exhibited no sign of waking upon him. “He’s a really heavy sleeper, isn’t he?” he said with a resigned sigh. He bowed to his two witnesses and returned to his love, lying next to him.
Bilbo positioned himself slightly above Thorin, facing him, and began caressing his hair. “The tree is not growing, Thorin,” he whispered. “Nothing is happening. I think the Arkenstone wants to help, but the acorn needs something more, and there is only one person in this world that can offer it. And I don’t know how to ask for this thing.”
Bilbo didn’t know this, but if Thorin wasn’t worried night and day about his kin’s health, or on a stressful quest trying to keep a low profile from warg scouts and orcs, he slept like a log. Yet Bilbo continued fearlessly, determined to try everything he could; and the following was certainly not something he could have shared with the Arkenstone or with Thranduil's wife! “You know what else? I really liked it when you kissed me the other night. And I wouldn’t mind it if you did it again. I wish that so much. Mahazrul... ma... haz... rul...”
...At the sound of Khuzdul on Bilbo’s lips Thorin opens his eyes wide, and now it seems like he never slept at all. “What do you wish?” he asks, his voice soft and calm. “Name it. Anything.”
”I wish...”
Where is Thorin? Suddenly Bilbo realizes how close they are, and how little matters now. I want it to be me. I want to be the one to start this. It’s the last night, most likely. The plan seems to be set. What’s the harm in living for one night as if it were forever? His eyes are closed, and he is kissing Thorin with passion, as if he wants to transfer it to him, that love that started out as admiration and grew into respect, and friendship, and comfort and peace, but that is now love and cruel wanting. I am not afraid of Thorin, and he feels Thorin’s hands push his slightly towards his back, just like last time. Thorin is letting him kiss him while seeming careful and composed, pleasantly surprised at Bilbo’s initiative and hesitant at the same time. He feels Thorin’s hands on his hair, on his ears, as if framing his head, and next Thorin is touching every inch of him...
Thorin rolls on his back, laying Bilbo on top of him, and his fingers are touching Bilbo’s hair very slowly, as if he wants to immortalize every strand, while Bilbo continues to kiss him. ”Come with me,” Bilbo hears, and perhaps now he can see that Thorin has willed himself to sleep precisely so it wouldn’t get to this point, for he knew that if they got close again all his resolve would fade, “I can’t let you go, I can’t...” “And the ring?” Bilbo asks in disbelief. “I’ll find a way. There has to be a way,” Thorin says, and that is the end of their discussion...
Then Thorin rolls them again on the side, and is now kissing him, and it’s violently passionate, that part of him that Bilbo has seen plenty of in other circumstances is finally manifesting, so intense that it feels like the ground is shaking, an earthquake in Thorin’s whirl of emotions. And it turns out some of this shaking is real, for they hear a rumble and feel the ground move beneath them. As they lift their eyes and turn their gaze toward the planting spot just a few inches away, they see a stem emerging out of the ground and becoming taller and taller, and now it’s getting wider and it’s no longer a stem but a trunk, and branches start emerging, spreading like arms upwards and to the sides. They take a few steps back to behold the miraculous sight, and Thorin now stands behind Bilbo, holding him and speaking in his ear, “Remember this, Bilbo,” his words betray a sense of urgency, “You see this... The Arkenstone has given life. And it can do so again. It can give life again. Please, remember this,” and he leans forward to kiss him, “’ala zann ikhthuzul,” Thorin says in a chanting tone, “this night will endure,” and they forget about the tree for a few seconds, then Thorin retakes his position behind Bilbo and turns him towards the tree again. Now they see the first fruit appear on one of the tree’s branches, along with leaves, and Bilbo turns to him for a second. “You still think the Arkenstone did it?” and touches Thorin’s face in amazement...
...Thorin and Bilbo slept under the tree, in each other’s arms, for the rest of the night, tears of happiness dried on their faces and heavenly bliss, finally, warming the air around them. In the morning they beheld the tree once again, and saw it had grown more fruit, and Bilbo, who had thought of this all along, remarked immediately, “You see, Thorin? Nothing was lost. One for you, one for me.”
Thorin stood and collected two acorns from the tree, and gave one to Bilbo. “I’ve got it,” he said with much excitement as he pushed a strand of hair from Bilbo’s forehead, only to see it stubbornly come back. “I know what to do with the ring. Come with me. When we get to Erebor I’ll tell you what we’ll do.”
Bilbo eyed him with caution. What if I don’t like your idea? his eyes seemed to say.
“Trust me,” Thorin spoke, simple yet powerful words, with no trace of uncertainty.
“I trust you,” said Bilbo, feeling Thorin’s determination. Nothing, ever, could stand in its way. And they went and retrieved the ring from where Thorin had buried it, under the red-flowered bush, and placed it in Bilbo’s pocket. They made a brief stop at the site of the statue, bowed twice reverently, and walked out of the garden, hand in hand.
