Actions

Work Header

the passing of mysteries

Chapter 18: a certain shift of shadows

Chapter Text

 

        Thorin pressed at the spot between his brows, trying to will the dull headache away. He could hear the stomp of Dáin's boots as he stormed off, the growl of his voice loud as it echoed in the hallway outside of Thorin's state room.

        “I take it the talk did not go well.”

        Thorin let his hand drop to pin Balin with the look he deserved. Thorin sat back in his chair as Balin slid into the seat that Dáin had occupied, a stack of papers thick in his hands. “It did not,” Thorin said as Balin flipped open the first leather-bound folder. “Is that...”

        “The register of the artisan families currently residing in the Iron Hills territories, yes.”

        Thorin let out a long sigh and let his head thump back against his chair. “I see.”

        “Do you have a list of which ones will be returning?”

        Thorin swallowed then, shifting his jaw as the urge to growl swept over him for what felt like the hundredth time that evening. “All of them,” he finally said. Balin's head snapped up, his pen dripping ink onto the white paper. “I got all of them back.”

        Balin blinked at him and then looked down at the paper, swearing at the smear of black across the neatly printed page. “All of them?” Balin said as he set his quill aside. “How did you manage that?”

        “Well, his attempt at trying to kill Fíli was a rather large bartering piece.” Thorin ran a hand down his face as Balin scowled at the memory. It had been a day since the push, the fall, and Thorin's return in the throne room. It had been filled with far too many meetings, far too many conversations full of pit holes Thorin had to maneuver, and not enough sleep. But sleep was something he did not have the time to indulge in, since Eönwë had told them all that evening that the rest of the wizards in Arda would be arriving the next day. How, exactly, the herald of Manwë knew such information Thorin did not know but he trusted that such a powerful spirit had his own ways of knowing things. Eönwë had been reluctant to speak more to any of the leaders gathered at Erebor until the rest of the wizards had arrived, for reasons he would not say. “Dáin tried to deny any knowledge or connection to the...” He couldn't say it, not even now. “But we both know he had to have known something was going to happen.”

        Balin's scowl deepened at that. “We still have not found the one who pushed you,” he said.

        “I know. Nori is furious about it. But it did help.”

        “Help?” Balin frowned at him.

        Thorin tipped up one shoulder. “I pointed out to Dáin that his immediate loss of the dwarf who would have murdered the rightful king of Erebor would be an...unfortunate piece of news to be spread among his allies and trade partners.” Thorin slid down in his seat, just a little. He was so tired. He hated to be at odds with his cousin, even now, when Dáin was so full of fury and a strange madness that Dwalin had been quick to point out once their Company was alone and behind closed doors.

        “Ah, lad,” Balin said on a sigh as he sat back in his own chair. “I know you are worried for Dáin. We all are.” He made a face. “In our own way.”

        “I'm rather sure Nori is going to try to push him off one of the ledges,” Thorin said with a laugh he did not feel. Balin snorted. “Did the holy ones agree to the rite?” Thorin forced himself to sit up and put his arms on the table. He could rest later. There was work yet to do, now.

        Balin's faint smile faded. “They have,” he said as he stayed in place, his sharp eyes studying Thorin. “They will do the cleansing ritual on the full moon.”

        “Less than a fortnight away, now,” Thorin murmured, tapping his fingers on the table. “That is still too long for my taste.”

        “Mine as well,” Balin said as he sat forward once again. “And with Dáin agreeing to give back all the artisans...that concerns me.”

        “Yes,” Thorin agreed, hating to voice the thought aloud. “He should have fought me more on it. Even with the threat of exposing his lack of action against the dwarf that would have killed me...” Thorin shook his head. “He gave in too easily. He is planning something. I can feel it.”

        “Do you think he will try to have you murdered again?”

        Thorin felt his shoulders go tight at the question. “I do not think Dáin ordered such an action.” He held up a hand when it looked as though Balin would disagree. “He seemed truly happy for a moment, when we first sat down. That I was alive. But it...there was something...” Thorin curled his right hand into a fist. It was the one he had held Bilbo's hand with, the one that still tingled from time to time in memory. “He seems...shadowed. Unlike himself, yes, but not quite gold-mad. Does that make any sense?”

        Balin's quill ticked back and forth as he made a note on a clean sheet of paper but after a moment he set it aside again. “Yes,” Balin said as he met Thorin's gaze. “While I agreed with Dwalin at first about the gold-sickness after your...” He looked away for a moment and then back before Thorin could say a word. “Dáin is not acting like...like we did, when we went...mad. He is not hording anything to my knowledge in his part of the camp, nor is he attempting to access the treasury at all. I do not know what to call what he is doing but it is not madness, not in the sense that we can understand at least.”

        Thorin let out a breath at that. “Yes,” he said. “Exactly.” He rubbed a hand over his mouth. “Nori has watchers on Dáin's part of the camps for now. What of the elves and men? I know you have had meetings with them both.”

        “With Thranduil, yes, but Lord Elrond and Lady Galadriel have declined any meetings so far. I believe they are not leaving Lord Maedhros' side at the moment. As for the men, they seem wary at best at the news that has been given to us by the emissaries from Valinor. I have seen Lord Ecthelion – the elven one – and Lord Glorfindel walking together when I go out to the tents but I have heard little of what Lord Ecthelion's business is here in Arda.”

        “And of the wizards? Has Gandalf said anything?”

        “That he has not,” Balin sighed. “He is most often with Lord Elrond and Lady Galadriel these days. Even Thranduil has joined them a handful of times, or so I have been told. Whatever is going on there we will find out when everyone else does.”

        “Wonderful,” Thorin muttered as he leaned further onto his elbows. “What other problems do we need to solve tonight?”

        Balin paused a moment too long, causing Thorin to look up at his old friend. “I think that is enough for tonight,” Balin said as he closed the folder he had been writing in.

        “But...”

        “Thorin, you have barely slept. You look worn through, even I can tell as much, and I know Óin is about half a moment from pouring one of his concoctions down your throat to get you to sleep.”

        Thorin made a face at that. “I would sleep if I could, but there are things to do before winter comes. The Long Night is less than a month away and the mountain is not yet inhabitable. If we do not sort out Dáin and the necessary goods that will get us through winter...” He trailed off as Balin held up a hand.

        “I know, lad,” Balin said. “I know. But none of that will be solved tonight. What's best right now is if you go and get a good night's sleep and start fresh tomorrow. We need you at your best, Thorin. Too much depends on it.”

        Thorin looked away at that but he could not argue the point. “I will sleep,” he said instead.

        “Soon.”

        Thorin huffed out a laugh. “Soon,” he promised. “Go on, then. I am sure Dwalin will be on his way back soon.”

        “I will send word to him that you've seen sense,” Balin said as he plucked his folders up from the table. Thorin rolled his eyes at him. “Get some rest, Thorin. I will see you in the morning.”

        “Good night,” Thorin called after Balin's retreating form. He knew the entire Company had been fretting over him since he had returned in the throne room. He was not sure if they believed what Thorin had heard in that strange place or whether they thought that it was something Thorin's mind had made up. None of them could deny, though, that Bilbo had saved him, that their Burglar had fallen with Thorin into the heart of the mountain and somehow pulled him out alive. But whether Bilbo's spirit had lingered with Thorin, had taken him somewhere else...that was not something Thorin could prove.

        Restless, Thorin pushed himself out of his seat and paced through to the bedroom. The fire had been banked but the air was still full of warmth. He crossed the room to where the stand for his crown now sat, slipping the crown of Durin I from his head and setting it aside. He stared at it for a moment, lips pressed together, and then turned away.

        As he made his way deeper into his rooms he tried to set his worries aside and focus on the present. The bedroom was warm as he shed his outer layers and laid them over the back of one of the chairs. Thorin had never remembered the royal wing being this warm before, but perhaps that was just his memory being faulty. The scattered memories of this room he did have was full of studying at the desk or running through drills in the front room, long after he should have stopped for the night.

        Since their return Thorin's childhood suite had been reconfigured so that it could become the main residence of the king of Erebor. The rooms on either side of his old chambers had been converted into an audience chamber and a more informal sitting room, with his and Dwalin's bedchamber at the very back. A more defensible position, both Nori and Dwalin had agreed. Thorin had remembered this area as rather cold and drafty but now it was snug, warm and inviting, like Bilbo's –

        Thorin had to stop and close his eyes, one hand pressed against the wall. No, he should not think of such things, not compare it to Bilbo's warm home in the Shire that was now ashes and crumbling away.

        “Thorin?”

        Thorin opened his eyes at the sound of Dwalin's voice. He turned to see his partner step into the room, his sword held in one hand but off of his belt, ready to be set aside. “Here,” he said, voice a touch rougher than he meant it to be. Dwalin was quick to strip his off his armor and weapons and set them on their stand before he crossed the room to Thorin's side. Thorin had not realized his feet had taken him to the small altar that sat on the east side of the room, set with candles that burned night and day.

        Thorin let out a long breath when Dwalin's warm palm settled at his nape. They leaned into each other as they stood before the altar and the small box where the holy silk that contained Bilbo's blood and a handful of other little objects of their One was kept. “I passed Balin on my way here,” Dwalin said into the quiet that had settled between them.

        Thorin just let out a long, tired sigh.

        “Are you still going to go through with the rite?”

        Thorin blinked at Dwalin's question, glancing at him and then looking back at the altar. “Yes. Why?”

        Dwalin's mouth flattened into an unhappy line. “Dáin does not deserve it.”

        Thorin swallowed down his first and second responses to that, knowing full well how Dwalin still shook at night sometimes when he held Thorin. Thorin could not imagine how Dwalin had felt on that ledge, seeing Thorin fall into the dark with Bilbo. It was a wonder that Dwalin had not thrown himself off after them. “He is still our kinsman,” Thorin said after a tense moment. “We have to try. If this is indeed some other force working upon him, then we have to try.”

        “I know that.”

        “Dwalin.”

        “I don't like you down there alone with him,” Dwalin shook his head. “I know the holy ones will have a few of themselves down there, but...”

        “I know,” Thorin said. “There will be no ledge for Dáin to push me from and we both know Dáin will not go into water deeper than his knees. I will be safe from him there.”

        “If the waters do not take you.”

        Thorin drew in a slow breath and let it out just as slow. “They will not take me,” he said, feeling the truth of it down to his bones. “I am meant to go into the waters beneath the mountain. There is something for me there. I can feel it.”

        Dwalin's hold tightened for a moment and then eased. “We will get through this,” Dwalin slid his hand down so that he could curl his arm about Thorin's shoulders. Thorin leaned into his warmth as they returned to contemplating the altar in front of them. He took the statement as the peace offering it was. They both knew that Thorin had to go through with the rite that he had asked of their holy people, both for their sake and for their people...and for Dáin.

        The candles on the altar were getting low. Thorin knew they would have to change them out soon but they would last through the night at least. The flickers of the candle flames did strange things to the shadows on the wall. For a moment Thorin thought there might have been a third body next to him, smaller than both he and Dwalin, just like...“Do you think Bilbo would have liked our rooms?” Thorin did not know where the question came from. He blinked and that shadow was gone.

        He felt Dwalin's pause, the slight tensing of his body. They rarely spoke of Bilbo, though they always spent time each night before what little they had left of him. “Maybe,” Dwalin said after a moment, his voice gone rough as well. “Might have wanted a balcony though.” His tone turned dour at that.

        Thorin couldn't help his laugh, a mere breath of a thing. “He would,” he agreed. “Full of flowers.”

        “And vegetables.”

        “And vegetables,” Thorin nodded. “You would complain endlessly about it.”

        “Oh like you wouldn't.”

        Thorin tipped his hand back and forth, laughing as Dwalin pushed at his shoulder. They came back together after a moment, pressed shoulder to knee against one another before the altar. He drew in another breath, to say what he did not know, but then a scent hit his nose. It was...strange. Odd. Out of place. It smelled like...it smelled like...

        Thorin twisted out of Dwalin's hold, turning to scan the room. “Bilbo?” His voice was little more than a whisper.

        “Thorin?” Dwalin's brows were drawn down into a deep frown but Thorin held up a hand, still scanning the room. It was by pure chance that he saw Dwalin pale and stagger back a step, one hand coming to cup his mouth and nose.

        “Do you smell that?” Thorin still could not speak above a whisper.

        “...Yes,” Dwalin croaked. “I do.”

        Thorin turned in a slow circle but the scent of Old Toby pipeweed was fading with each breath he took. They had all long ago run out of Shire pipeweed, something Bilbo had complained about when they had stayed in Lake-town. Dwalin had managed to find a pouch of something that might have once been the dregs of a pipeweed barrel long ago, just enough to get them through to the mountain and inside. After that...

        Well. The Shire was gone and the fields of pipeweed they were so known for along with it.

        “Perhaps it is coming from Bilbo's pouch?” Dwalin said after a long, strained moment. His hand dropped back down to his side.

        “Perhaps,” Thorin said, still scanning the room. The hairs on the back of his neck were standing on end. It felt like...it felt like...He reached out, not sure why, as if he could almost feel Bilbo near them. As if he tried hard enough he could touch Bilbo once more.

        “Thorin?”

        His fingers hit nothing but air and Thorin felt all the breath leave his lungs in one rush. “I thought...it felt like...” He had to stop and shake his head. He ran a hand over his eyes. “Perhaps I am just overtired.”

        “Perhaps,” Dwalin said. “Come. It has to be a scent from the pouch. We know he used to keep his pipeweed there.”

        “...Yes. Yes, of course.” Thorin let Dwalin draw him from the altar. They settled into bed and despite his exhaustion Thorin found that sleep did not come quick. He lay there as Dwalin drifted off, breathing deep every now and then, but not even Thorin knew if he was still hoping for a fresh scent of that familiar smell or not. Sleep, when it did take him, found him on a bench outside a round, green door, sitting in the sun in a place that no longer existed.

        What neither of them would realize, until days later, was that a full pouch of Old Toby would be found inside Dwalin's coat where it was hung up on the armor stand in the front room. Neither of them would know where it came from. It was at the very bottom of one of the deepest pockets. Perhaps Dwalin had forgotten about it. Perhaps it was some strange stroke of luck that had made Dwalin forgetful of its existence. Either way they put it on the altar along with Bilbo's other possessions they still had and did not touch it.

        (They did not look inside, for if they had, they would have realized that that particular pouch of Old Toby was fresher than any they had ever had. As if it had just been harvested that fall, while they were on their long journey to Erebor. But that was a mystery they would unravel much, much later.)

 

 

~*~

 

 

        Morning found Thorin marginally more rested, though sad in a way he could not name. He had a vague recollection of being somewhere that made him happy, happy in a way that also made grief tighten his throat, but he could not hang on to just where that place was. Still, he must have looked a good deal better if the way Balin nodded and hustled them off to breakfast was any measure.

        Thorin had just finished eating when a runner came to tell him that riders had appeared on the horizon. Thorin nodded at Dwalin and stood, trailing much of his council behind him as he made his way to the gates and out into the chilly morning air. The elves and men were stirring from their tents, many looking as though they, too, had just finished their morning meal, as they gathered on the far side of the strange encampment that had taken shape on Thorin's front lawn.

        Thorin caught sight of Dáin in the crowd but his cousin did not look at him. Instead he was surrounded by his own council members who had arrived in the weeks following the battle. Thorin cursed himself as a fool to have not seen the problem building earlier. Perhaps he had been too focused on clearing the area before the gates, trying to find what was left of Bilbo, to see what was in front of his nose. Perhaps Dáin had been hiding it better. Thorin did not know but now that he had seen it he could not ignore the way the Iron Hills dwarves were clustered together under the shadow of the mountain, all scowling and surly to any who came close.

        Thorin did not know what to expect when it came to the arrival of the missing wizards. Radagast they had met before, though Thorin was still not quite sure that the wild being they had met really was a wizard. He seemed too strange and odd to be considered the same as Gandalf or even Saruman, who Thorin had only heard of in passing from his father and grandfather. That there were even more of these beings had been a bit of a shock to hear. That they even had an Order was news to Thorin and his council. So when they came out of the gates to see four riders approaching it was a shock not only to Thorin but to many in the crowd as well it seemed.

        Thorin saw how Gandalf's head went back and the way his hands tightened on his staff. Galadriel and Elrond shared a look Thorin could not read. The four beings were quick to cross the distance, coming close enough that Thorin could see them clearly. The lead rider was a stern-faced older man, with dark hair that was graying at the temples. There was something...strange about his face that Thorin could not place. Almost as if only his eyes were set into shadow while the rest of him seemed to shine a bit too bright. On either side of him were two men in blue, one was smiling and nodding to the people they passed, his robes a robin's egg blue, while the other was dressed in dark navy robes that made his own dour expression that more severe. They were both blond, though the one on the left wore his short, falling just about his shoulders. The other wizard in blue had his hair pulled back in a low tail that made his narrow face look hawkish. Behind those three came Radagast, his own horse lagging well behind them, and the strange fellow looked as wild as Thorin remembered him. His hat was tilted to one side and there were leaves and sticks poking out of the nest of his hair.

        The wizards came to a halt before Eönwë, with the one in the front swinging off his horse first. Thorin saw the way Gandalf stood up straighter, his shoulders going back and the hold on his staff going tight. The others followed suit, with Radagast the only one to stay seated on his mount, looking as if he was half a second from running off into the wilds.

        “Curumo,” Eönwë said as he stepped forward, hands outstretched. But instead of taking them this Curumo bowed instead, deep enough that the tips of his hair swept the ground. It brought Eönwë up short.

        “Pray forgive our tardiness, Lord Eönwë,” this Curumo said as he straightened. “For just as your summons reached me, I received another message from our long-lost brethren. Alatar and Pallando have long been lost to the furthest reaches of the East and have only now returned to our western lands. I do not think this is something that has come about by chance.” The wizard tucked his hands into his long sleeves as the two wizards in blue bowed low to Eönwë on either side of him. “And of course you know Aiwendil.”

        Radagast blew a raspberry at them all, which caused a wave of whispers to rise from the gathering crowd.

        “Saruman,” Gandalf said before Eönwë could speak. “Do not be rude.”

        “I am not the rude one here,” Curumo – or Saruman said with a sniff. “You know better than to speak out of turn before such powers, Olórin. Lord Eönwë is the one who has summoned us here and it is to him that we answer and none other.”

        “Saruman!”

        “Peace,” Eönwë held up a hand, calming them all. “Glad I am to see you again Curumo...or do you prefer Saruman now?”

        Saruman bowed to Eönwë again, his dark hair hiding his face for a long moment. “I am comfortable with either name. Call me what you wish.”

        “I see,” Eönwë said, a faint frown marking a line between his brows. Then he turned to Thorin and made his own bow. “King Thorin, the wizards have come. I believe it is time for a longer conversation of the things that have happened in this place to be had between all the leaders that have gathered here.”

        “Yes,” Thorin said and gestured to the tent to his right. “I believe this will fit us all, though we may have to find a few more seats.” He glanced at the other wizards. “We did not expect so many, gentlemen, my apologies.”

        The two wizards in blue nodded to him, which made Balin bristle a bit at Thorin's side. He nudged his old friend but did not look at him. “I'm sure there are some of us who are willing to stand for this meeting,” the wizard with the hawkish features said, exchanging a glance with the other wizard in blue. “Aiwendil has not stopped complaining since we found him on the road.”

        “I am not made to ride such an animal,” Radagast said as he slid from his horse's back at last. He patted down his robes, causing tiny puffs of dust and dirt to escape his clothes. “Gandalf, why did you send me to Saruman's old tower if you wanted me here in the first place? I was visiting with Beorn and his people, I could have come straight away and not backtracked so far.”

        That caused a stir. Thorin saw Gandalf share a look with Galadriel, both of them frowning. “It was not I who sent you there, Radagast,” Gandalf said. “It was Eönwë who called us all here.”

        “Indeed,” Saruman said, his hands still hidden in his sleeves. “As I have told him multiple times. I fear he has been indulging in those mushrooms he likes too much. Again.”

        “But that is not so,” Radagast said as he looked between them. “I got a moth from you, Gandalf. You said to go to Isengard, to Saruman.”

        All eyes turned to Gandalf. “I did not send such a messenger,” he said. His bushy brows had come together in a deep frown. “I will swear upon it, if needed.”

        Eönwë held up his hand before anyone else could speak. “Strange it is that my own summons have found but one of your Order and not all of you. I worry that it is a consequence of the changes that have been made to this world. But let us speak now, for there is much to tell you all of what changes are happening in the far West.”

        Thorin glanced at Balin before he made his way inside the tent, making sure he was the one to lead the way. Dáin, he had noted, had come out of the crowd to join this meeting, though he was forced to keep his guards outside. Thorin settled into his chair and to his surprise it was Lord Elrond who sat at his right, while the Lady Galadriel sat on his left. Thranduil, thankfully, was on the other side of the Lady, with Bard to his left. The rest of the men settled about the table, with Dáin between Bard and Prince Thengel of Rohan. Lord Glorfindel and Lord Ecthelion sat on Lord Elrond's other side. Eönwë sat on the opposite side of the round table from Thorin, with Saruman and Alatar taking the seats on either side of him. Gandalf managed to slide into the chair next to Alatar while Pallando took the last seat, leaving Radagast standing behind them. Thorin glanced back at Balin, who gave him a shallow nod. It was the work of moments to get a stool brought in for Radagast to perch on, which the wizard seemed to appreciate more than an actual chair.

        As they settled at the table wine was brought in. It was from one of the deep caves under the mountain, where Smaug seemed to have never gone. Thorin did not know how the bottles were still intact or how the wine was still sweet, but Bombur had been careful with all of the provisions found inside Erebor, testing them all to make sure it would not make any sick from consuming it. It was a sweet blend, one Thorin did not remember their people bottling, though they must have since the racks were full when Bombur had shown Thorin the chamber. Thorin noted the way many of the elves seemed to savor the wine as they sipped at it. Even Eönwë seemed surprised by it. Thorin made a mental note to try and find the old vineyards on the mountainside. Perhaps they would be able to use such a wine as an export as Erebor got her feet under herself once more.

        There were a number of other stools brought in for those who did not have a seat at the table. Lord Elrond's councilor, Erestor, was perched on his own seat, with a lap desk set up so he could take notes. Thorin saw how Balin set up his own seat next to the elf, the two of them bent together and talking quietly as Bombur had his runners bring in platters of finger foods. Thorin also noted the way both Lord Glorfindel and Lord Ecthelion sat together, their chairs pressed as close as they could get to one another...and the way both elves were glancing at Erestor as they whispered to each other.

        Interesting.

        Thorin waited until everyone was settled and looked to Eönwë, a bit startled to find the herald of Manwë already looking his way. He had thought that Eönwë would have wished to speak first, but...Thorin glanced at Gandalf, who was also looking to him with dark eyes. Yes, there were things that still needed to be said about what happened inside Erebor that Thorin had not spoken of. Thorin set his hands on the table and glanced around at the faces, seeing everyone turn their attention his way. “I have told you all of what happened here, briefly, the day before. What I did not say then was that it is believed that during our Quest to retake Erebor it is believed that Bilbo Baggins somehow gained possession of the One Ring created by Sauron in the Second Age.”

        There was a stir from about the table.

        “I did not speak of it before, since we are not completely sure of this fact. But what we do know is this; that at some point Bilbo found an object that allowed him to turn invisible, a ring that he became reluctant to show any of us as the weeks wore on. We know that Bilbo wore the ring to investigate the mountain. We know that he wore it while Smaug hunted him through the treasury and turned it all into a river of molten gold. We know that at some point during that event that Bilbo lost his ring.” Thorin had to stop for a moment, his throat gone tight. “It was explained to us later, by Gandalf, that sometime during these events that Mordor was destroyed by the eruption of Mount Doom and that the whole of that black land was wiped out, and Sauron along with it.”

        “Strange it is that such a creature as a halfling would find such a valuable item by chance,” Saruman was the one to say. His hands were still hidden in his sleeves as he sat back in his chair. His dark eyes were fixed on Thorin. He fought down a shiver at that intent stare. He did not know why the hairs on the back of his neck were prickling. “There were many rings made during the Second Age. Assigning such a find to be the One Ring is irresponsible, Gandalf. You should have come to me with your concerns over it.”

        “Perhaps,” Gandalf said, leaning forward in his chair. “But the facts fit the timeline. No other object would have that kind of power to destroy both Mordor and Sauron. And I did not know what kind of ring Bilbo had at the time, for he became secretive of it, very quickly. It...concerned me, but we had other problems at the time.” Gandalf's bushy brows twitched as he pulled out his pipe but did not light it. “Or did you forget the issue with the shadows we fought at Dol Guldur?”

        “I did not forget,” Saruman's nose went up at that. “We fought those shadows and defeated them, as you remember Gandalf. To say that this halfling then found a way to completely destroy the powers that we of the White Council had problems merely banishing back to shadow is laughable. You know as well as I do that there is only one place where such a ring of power could have been destroyed and that was inside of Orodruin. I cannot see how this halfling could have had the One Ring.”

        A stir swept over the table at that. Thorin had not known that it would take such a fire to destroy Sauron's ring of power. There had been whispers about the dwarven rings for centuries, how they could pass through the hottest of forges and come out clean, without a dent or scratch on them.

        “I know what has been said about the One Ring,” Gandalf began after the stir quieted. His hands were laid out on the table, spread wide, pipe forgotten. “And I know that there are things that not even we, servants of that secret fire though we are, know about hobbits and their abilities. I, perhaps, have known them longest and even I have not been privy to the most secret parts of their society.”

        “Society,” Saruman scoffed, his lips twisting to one side. “Do not give it more airs than what it is. They are a simple folk, who lived simple lives, turning the soil and feeding the nations about them with their produce. What is so secret about that?”

        “Do you not find it strange that in all the years that the hobbits have worked the land of the Shire, they alone have had the largest harvests in all of Arda? That from them came more than half the herbs that fill the boxes of the healers across the lands? That – aside from the elves – in all the peoples in Arda the hobbits are – were,” Gandalf's expression twisted with grief for a moment, “better at fixing the ills that plagued both body and land?”

        “Surely you exaggerate, Gandalf. Your fondness for these little creatures is well known.”

        “Bilbo was no creature,” Thorin bit out, cutting off Saruman's words. All eyes turned to him. “He is – was – a hobbit. Not a halfling, not a creature, not an animal. A hobbit.” Thorin curled a hand into a fist in his lap. “I would not have him disrespected, not here, where he has saved us all.”

        “If he has done such a thing,” Saruman said. His dark eyes were glittering like fractured obsidian. “You say this Bilbo killed a dragon. How on earth could such a little creature do such a thing as that?” Saruman leaned forward in his chair. “No, something is amiss in this, I fear. Something that we are not seeing. There is some greater plot afoot that is moving right under our noses. Are you a party to this, Thorin Oakenshield? Are the dwarves of Erebor hiding something from us even now?”

        “What? No, of course not!” Thorin surged up out of his chair. “We have been truthful to you all, to our own fault, laying bare our sins that we committed while mad when we could have kept such dishonor secret to save our pride. Bilbo is the one who killed the dragon Smaug. Bilbo is the one who somehow destroyed the One Ring of Sauron. Bilbo is the hero that all should know his name!”

        “All we have is your word, Thorin Oakenshield! Even I have heard of the madness that took your Company all the way in Isengard. How can we trust your word?”

        “Peace, Saruman,” Eönwë said before Thorin could try and launch himself across the table and punch that wizard right in the nose. “That was unkind and unhelpful. I – we – came to this far land to find out what has changed the Song of Eru in Arda and bickering between ourselves does not solve this pressing problem. If Gandalf says that these hobbits have gifts that even members of your Order do not know of, then I believe him. It still remains that we must try to figure out what these powers are – or were,” he amended, “and if they were in any way under the command of Morgoth or his servant Sauron. The world is changing,” Eönwë looked about the table, meeting each gaze, “in ways that not even the Valar can now predict. It is vital that we understand what is happening so that should this be a plot of the Great Enemy's then we are able to move in time to counter it.”

        “Then what would you have us do?” Ecthelion II of Gondor asked. He and Prince Thengel had been leaning together for much of the meeting, speaking in soft voices with one another.

        Thorin met Eönwë's gaze when that spirit looked to him. “I would ask of you, King Thorin, that you allow myself and the Istari entrance to your mountain, so that we might see where these events took place, and,” Eönwë tilted his head to one side. “That we might better ascertain if what was destroyed in your mountain really was the One Ring.”

        Thorin swallowed down a biting reply, breathing through his anger at Bilbo's accomplishments being so openly questioned. He understood their confusion. He had felt the same when he had first heard Gandalf's claim. But to allow so many strangers into the mountain was a tricky thing, especially with Dáin's challenge so fresh in the memories of his people. Their mountain was theirs, the sacred space given to them by their Maker, to live in, work in, the create in, like Mahal before them. But if they did not allow them entry then it would seem as though they had something to hide when they did not. “I...”

        A cry and the sounds of a commotion came from the entrance of the tent. Thorin turned with the others to see Nori burst inside with two of his dwarves holding another between them. “My king,” Nori said, going to one knee in front of him. “Forgive my intrusion but this could not wait. We found this one, a dwarf of the Iron Hills, trying to steal the Arkenstone from your throne.”

        “What?” Thorin couldn't help but sputter.

        “You dare!” Dáin was on his feet, red faced and furious. “My people would not do such a thing!”

        “He was trying to pry the Arkenstone from its mounting,” Nori said, his gaze never leaving Thorin's. “The throne has been marred by this dwarf's hands.”

        “That is preposterous!” Dáin cried.

        “Show me,” Thorin said, uncaring of the eyes on him. He cut a look at his cousin, who was already shaking his head. “I would see the damage that has been done to my mountain by hands that are not ours.”

        “This is a clear lie, Thorin, my people would never –”

        “Just as none of your people would dare push me from a ledge?” Thorin turned on him. “Truly?”

        Dáin shut his mouth and looked away.

        Thorin looked back to Nori. “Keep that dwarf with us at all times,” he said. Then, “Show me.”

        Nori bowed over his bent knee and stood, snapping his fingers at the two dwarves holding the one struggling between them. “Tie him up,” Nori said as he stalked from the tent, Thorin hot on his heels. Thorin could hear the rest of the table rise as one, with most of them following in his wake. This Thorin did not dispute, since Nori had made the matter so public. Thorin could well guess why Nori had dragged out their dirty laundry to air it in front of their allies and trade partners. They were all worried about Dáin's next move. Perhaps this would place a crack in whatever plan Dáin had in the works. Thorin hoped it would derail his cousin altogether but he had little hope of that happening.

        And so, as one, the party of elves, men, and dwarves stepped into the shadow of the mountain, heading for Erebor's throne room and what might lie within.