Chapter Text
The mountain seemed darker as Thorin stalked through its airy chambers. “Thorin! Thorin, wait!” Dáin's cries echoed from behind him but Thorin did not slow a single step. Dwalin was at his side, had been from the moment Thorin stepped out of the tent, with Glóin on his other side. The men and elves trailing behind him were stretched out in a line, since the path through Erebor was a tricky thing. Smaug had done so much damage to the front part of the mountain that the areas immediately in front of the gates had to be reinforced right after the battle had ended. The ugly wood and rusted metal frames on the columns were a necessary evil for the time being, though from the way Bofur was talking these last few days, the damage may have been overestimated. They still kept those braces in place for the time being and Thorin was well aware how they gave the mountain an ominous look to those unfamiliar with such spaces.
Once, when Thorin was young, the great gates stood open to let in the light and illuminate the grand chamber that had been hollowed out of the mountain. The airy staircases and ramps that soared over the depths had been carved with runes and sigils of their people, sometimes inlaid with metals and gems so that they would catch the light of the sun. The great chamber used to be the fastest way to the throne room, where a special ramp had been installed, large enough for every race to be able to use it. That ramp had been cracked in several places, leaving Bofur leery of having even his own people look at it any closer, at least until the proper artisans could come and see what repairs could be made. That meant that Thorin had to take the crowd of beings behind him through a side passage, where at least Maedhros would have to duck his head more often than not to avoid hitting his head on some of the lower doorways.
The path Thorin took was the quickest to the throne room, up a right-hand set of stairs that were once used by the royal servants. As they twisted their way up the steps, the crystals set into the side of the stone walls began to glow. Thorin paused at one of the landings, staring at them. In all their time in the mountain these particular crystals had not once sparked to life. They did now, though, glowing brighter and brighter as Thorin passed each small lamp.
“Thorin,” Nori's voice was a bare whisper.
“Yes,” Thorin said, just as soft. They could investigate why the crystals were glowing later. Thorin shook his head and started up the stairs once more, winding around and around until they came out on the floor above the royal wing, where many of the more formal council rooms had been carved out of the mountain, and where the throne room held pride of place. The hallway that led to the throne room was clean, the polished floors glittering under the sparking lights of the crystals that were lighting along the walls. The throne room itself sat in a great chamber that had been smoothed out by countless hands over the long years of their residence. The long, narrow bridge that led to the throne was a natural feature, where the small island that held the throne had been formed by some stroke of luck or divine hand. The windows had been cut into the sides of the mountain, positioned so they were invisible to any outside eye, and numerous enough to fill the entire chamber with light when the sun was out.
Thorin nodded to Nori's guards as he stepped through the great doors that were open to the throne room beyond. The morning light streamed in through the eastern portion of the windows, leaving the western half in pools of shadow. There should have been no reason for any dwarf to be in this part of the mountain, much less this level of Erebor this early in the morning. Thorin did not hold his councils in these chambers, preferring the smaller rooms in the lower levels, so that his older councilors did not have to puff their way up so many stairs in their advanced age. Ever since Thorin's return to this very same chamber their holy people had been gathering in the chamber below the island that held the throne, where once musicians played and their holy people held rites during the longest day of the year. Now that area was dark, with many shadowed doorways that led in and out of the lower levels, all of which should have had a guard on them to stop any curious – and not so curious – beings from going where they were not meant to be.
Even from the doorway Thorin could spot the damage to the throne. He felt a growl rumble through his chest as he stalked forward, his boots coming down hard on the solid stone of the walkway. The gold on the arms of the throne had been cut, the sigils of his forefathers slashed through, disgraced. The gold filigree around the Arkenstone itself had been pried up, as if this would-be thief had taken a knife to it in his haste, trying his best to pry the gem from the mount with sheer brute force alone. There was a smear of what looked like blood along one side of the Arkenstone's mounting, where perhaps the thief had slashed his hand open on the jagged metal there. The blood had darkened to the color of rust and something about it made Thorin's chest go cold.
He stopped in front of the throne and took in the damage, seeing where this thief had scraped away the names of Thorin's grandfather and great grandfather, where even the carved stone itself looked damaged from a careless hand.
“Bofur,” Thorin called.
“Here I am,” Bofur said, pushing through the crowd to come to Thorin's side. A low whistle left his lips. “Well, that's a mess, now ain't it?”
Thorin turned his head to look at Nori. “How did you find him?”
“The guards did,” Nori shook his head. “They heard a ruckus coming from inside and when they opened the doors he was striking the Arkenstone with a knife, trying to free it from its mounting.”
“It's mine,” the dwarf hanging from between Nori's minions snarled, his legs kicking out as he thrashed in their hold. “It be mine! Let me go!”
“Bofur, check the throne please,” Thorin said. Bofur bobbed his head and scrambled up on the steps, going to his knees before the ruins of the inlaid gold on the arm rests. “Hragr,” he turned to look through the crowd. His head of the jeweler's guild slipped through the press, coming to his side. “Please check the Arkenstone to make sure that it has not been damaged.”
“Yes, my lord,” Hragr gave him the briefest of bows before scrambling on top of the throne with Bofur.
“This is how you would honor our forefathers, Thorin?”
Thorin closed his eyes at the sound of Dáin's voice. Then he turned to look out over the crowd of beings that had followed him to the throne room. Dáin pushed his way to the front, his brows drawn tight together in a ferocious scowl. His guards had forced their way in with him, flanking him on either side. Thorin saw Dwalin move to stand between them and reached out to stop him, one hand light on his arm. “Dáin,” Thorin said when he looked back to his cousin. “What I do in my own mountain is no business of yours.”
“Not my business? Do you forget, cousin,” Dáin spat the word, “that it was I who came to your aid to defend this mountain? That had it not been for myself and my army your mountain would have been overrun, if not by orcs and goblins, then by men and elves? Did you forget that part?”
An angry rush of whispers broke out through the gathered crowd. Thorin squared his shoulders to face Dáin, planting his feet in front of his throne, not about to back down now. “I will always be grateful for your aid,” he said, lifting his chin. “You and I have spoken more than once about what I will give to you for that aid as well, or did you forget that in your strange madness, cousin?”
“Mad? You think I am mad?” Dáin cried out. “You, who holds the blood of the traitor on the holy silks of our people, you say I am the one sick? You, who would not lock the gem of your people away where it belongs? You, who mourns a thief who got what he deserves? You think I am sick? No! It is you who are sick!” Dáin pointed at Thorin's nose, his hand trembling. “Look to yourself for the one who is mad, Thorin Oakenshield! You do not deserve to be King Under the Mountain!”
Hisses rose up from the crowd. The men and elves drew back as Erebor's holy people pushed forward, surrounding Dáin and his guards before they could draw arms. “Bilbo's life blood was given to us after his death, a blessing that even our holy people have proclaimed.” Thorin stepped towards Dáin, forcing his hand to drop. “Bilbo is a hero. He killed the dragon. He saved us all. I will not have you disparage him thus. Alviss,” he looked to the head of their holy people, who gave him a grave nod. “I believe my cousin Dáin is unwell. See to him. Please.”
“My lord,” Alviss bowed low to him before turning to Dáin. “Come, King of the Iron Hills. You have heard the word of the King Under the Mountain, the heir of Durin. You are unwell.”
“I am not! It is he who is unwell! He fell! He is some foul spirit brought back from the dark! Some trick of the traitor! Unhand me!” Dáin's shouts, as well as the shouts of his guards, faded as their holy people pulled them through the crowd and out the door. Nori and what seemed to be a few of his minions had the guards on the ground and disarmed before Dáin's dwarves could pull their axes from their belts. Nori's boys hauled those dwarves up and marched them out of the room as Nori returned to his side. Thorin watched them go with a long sigh, knowing that it would be chaos in the Iron Hills tents soon if something was not done. They could not keep Dáin against his will, not with his people in their camps, but if Thorin had their holy people contain his cousin for now, under the guise of Dáin being unwell it might buy them at least a little time to get in front of any problems from that quarter.
Added to that was the entire crowd of spectators who had just watched this farce of a scene. Thorin turned to Eönwë and the other lords who had come to the throne room and bowed low. “My apologies,” he said to the floor. “Things have been...fraught between myself and my cousin. He is...”
“Unwell,” Eönwë's voice said, far closer than Thorin expected. When he rose it was to see the herald of Manwë before him, his entire being glowing just a bit in the shadows of the room. “How is he unwell, King Thorin? Can you explain it?”
Thorin paused, glancing at Dwalin, who shrugged back at him. Thorin looked back at Eönwë. “It is true that I and my Company experienced gold-madness in this place, yes, but Dáin is not acting as we did, then. He is...paranoid. Suspicious in a way that...makes no sense. He keeps calling Bilbo a thief,” he shook his head. “I do not understand it.”
There was a clatter from behind Thorin before Eönwë could respond. Thorin turned to see both Bofur and Hragr stepping down off the steps that led to the throne. Bofur had a rag in his hand and a pensive look on his face. “Bofur? Hragr?” Thorin looked between them. “How is it?”
“Well the throne has been defaced but good,” Bofur said with a shake of his head. “We'll need a clan of artisans to repair it. It almost looks like he took a mace to the back of the chair, trying to break it in half. I can not tell if there are any fractures in the stone just yet. I'll need the rest of my gear to do that.”
Thorin pinched the bridge of his nose and then let his hand drop. “Very well. Hragr?”
“The Arkenstone is not damaged, my lord,” Hragr said when he came to Thorin's side. “Not a scratch on it.”
“No, there wouldn't be,” a voice said from the crowd. Thorin turned to see Maedhros step forward, his eyes not on Thorin but on the throne...on the Arkenstone.
“Lord Maedhros?” Thorin looked from the elf, to the stone, and back again.
Maedhros' lips moved for a moment, but no sound came out. Then he cleared his throat, giving himself a short shake of the head and then his gaze was on Thorin. “A Silmaril does not chip. Not even Morgoth's evil powers could scratch the surface of them, when that enemy of ours put the gems into his vile iron crown.”
Gasps and murmurs arose from the gathered crowd. Thorin looked to Dwalin, who looked as shocked as Thorin felt. “A Silmaril?” Thorin looked back to Maedhros. The elf had not moved, though his gaze was back onto the Arkenstone. “But that cannot be. The Arkenstone was found beneath the roots of Erebor, when King Thráin I founded our kingdom here. How could this be a Silmaril?”
Maedhros' hands curled and relaxed at his sides, his eyes strangely shiny in the morning light. “After the War of Wrath, after we...I stole the remaining Silmarils, I could not hold the gem in my bare hand. It would burn and torment me, as I have said.” Maedhros shook his head. “Afterwards...after, I wandered long and far during those wild years, blind with madness and perhaps more. The pain became so much that I cast myself into a fiery chasm, though where I cannot tell you.” His gaze lifted from the Arkenstone to gaze about the chamber, then up towards the vaulted ceiling high above. “Perhaps it was here that I met my demise. I do not know. But of this I am sure,” his gaze went back to Thorin and he felt in that moment struck breathless by the intensity of Maedhros' gaze. “The gem you call the Arkenstone, the gem that your people have held holy for all these long years, is one of the three Silmaril that were made by my father's hands.” He swallowed, his throat bobbing, gaze flicking past Thorin and then back again. “I would know it anywhere.”
More murmurs arose from the crowd. Thorin drew in a long breath, studying the elf's face. “And do you feel...compelled to take it, now?”
There was a long stretch of silence. Thorin saw how Elrond moved through the crowd to Maedhros' side, staring up at the elf with a mix of emotions too tangled for Thorin to read. Then Maedhros drew in a stuttering breath, blinking away the shine of tears in his eyes. “No,” he finally said, shaking his head. “I do not.” There was a strange note of wonder and...perhaps relief in his voice. “But,” he continued and Thorin felt a chill touch the back of his neck. Maedhros stepped forward, a frown drawing his brows together as he peered at the Arkenstone. “There is something...wrong with the Silmaril.”
“Wrong?” More than one voice echoed the question, Thorin among them. He turned to look at the throne, at the Arkenstone, trying to see what the elf saw. The Arkenstone looked as it ever did, shining in the room that was slowly filling with morning light. But, just as he had seen on the day of his return, there seemed to be a strange film over the shining gem, almost like a... “A shadow,” he said, turning back to Maedhros. The elf blinked and looked at him, dipping his head in a short nod. “There is a shadow that lies upon the stone.”
“Yes,” Maedhros said. “You see it as well?”
“I do,” said Thorin. “I saw it for the first time when I returned from the depths of the mountain.” He felt Dwalin take his hand. He looked to Gandalf and Eönwë, who were next to him. “Do you not see it?”
The herald of Manwë stepped forward, his eyes narrowed as he looked at the Arkenstone. “I do not,” he murmured. “Olórin?”
Gandalf was slower to move, his eyes dark as he looked at the Arkenstone and then at Eönwë and back again. “I have never seen the Arkenstone before,” he said after a moment of study. “The kings of Erebor never displayed it upon their throne as it is now before any visitors to their realm, or so I was told.”
Thorin glanced back at the gem, his chest going tight at the memories it evoked. “I had it placed there after Bofur chipped it from the melted gold in the treasury,” he told them. “I would have sat curled about it like a dragon had Bilbo not shocked us out of such madness. The only time I have come back to this room is when I...returned from the dark.”
“Returned from the dark you say,” Saruman was the one to speak. The wizard stepped forward until he was almost abreast with Thorin, though his gaze never left the gem set into the throne. The two blue wizards were close on his heels, though Thorin did not see Radagast anywhere. “What does that mean, exactly?”
Thorin felt the way Dwalin's hold on his hand went tight for a moment. Thorin squeezed back, also put off by the lack of courtesy in the wizard's tone but what could he do about it? Now was not the time nor the place to fuss about such niceties. “On the night of the new moon, the day before the emissaries from Valinor were set to arrive, our people held a holy rite in the depths of the mountain.” Thorin looked at Dwalin, whose jaw was set and a muscle was flexing in his cheek. “During that rite a dwarf from the Iron Hills pushed me from the ledge and into the heart of the mountain.” Whispers arose from the crowd. “I...fell, but I was caught.” He couldn't help his smile. “Bilbo came for me,” he said, looking at Gandalf. The wizard twisted to look at him, his bushy brows raised high. “He caught my hand and took me some place...else. I cannot explain it more than that. When I woke I was here,” he swept out his free hand to the space before the throne. “I was found the very same morning that you arrived.” This he said to Eönwë, who had also turned to look at him.
“I see,” Eönwë said with a thoughtful frown. “And you did not see such a shadow on the gem before now?”
“No,” Thorin shook his head.
“How strange. And do you, master dwarf,” Eönwë then looked at Dwalin, who stood up straighter at Thorin's side. “Do you see a shadow upon this gem?”
Dwalin looked over his shoulder at the throne and then back at Eönwë. “I do not,” he said. “It looks as it ever has, but...”
“But?”
Dwalin's mouth twisted to one side for a moment. “It does not seem as...bright as it was in my memories.”
That was news to Thorin. He canted a look at Dwalin, who just shrugged back at him.
“Would it be possible,” a voice said from the crowd, which parted to reveal Master Erestor. He glanced around at the sudden attention, but continued. “Would it be possible that the attempted destruction of the Arkenstone...of the Silmaril is what caused the darkness you see upon it now?”
Maedhros frowned, turning to look at the smaller elf. Thorin did not miss the way the lords Glorfindel and Ecthelion slid to stand behind Master Erestor, with each of them crossing their arms over their chests as they stared back at Maedhros. A humorless smile pulled Maedhros' mouth to one side. “Which attempted destruction do you mean, good sir? The one in which I cast it and myself into a fiery chasm or...” His frown deepened and then Thorin found himself on the end of that same look. “You said you had to...chip the Silmaril out of solid gold?”
“Yes,” Thorin said after a moment. “When Smaug attacked Bilbo in the treasury.” His throat closed for a moment, the memory of his terror rendering him mute. He shook his head, trying to get the smell of dragonfire out of his nose. He cleared his throat and continued. “When we came in, afterwards, to see if we could...help in any way, we found the dragon dead and the floor still boiling hot, and all of it gold.”
Maedhros tipped his head down, his frown still in place. Thorin saw the way Master Erestor was chewing on his lower lip, one arm wrapped tight about his waist. Lord Elrond moved to his side, the two of them sharing a look Thorin could not read.
“You think the attempted destruction of the Silmaril is what is causing the protections about Valinor to fail as well, Erestor?” Lord Elrond's question caused a stir in the crowd.
Master Erestor looked at Elrond and then back at Maedhros. “I do not know if that is the case or not,” he said as Eönwë stepped up to Maedhros' side. “But you have said that you fear that this strange shift in the Song is some ploy of Morgoth's. And if Morgoth cursed the Silmarils...”
“Then perhaps they are connected,” Eönwë nodded slowly. “Yes, I could see how that may be a reason. But,” he turned to look at the Arkenstone and then back at Thorin. “We do not know this for certain and I will not take such a symbol of your people from you, King Thorin, no matter its origins.”
Thorin bowed to the Maia. “I thank you, Lord Eönwë,” he said as he rose. He knew what he would say next might cause a rather large stir. “But I would hand it over to you this moment if you felt it proper. I will not be the reason why Arda is torn apart by Morgoth's evil plans, even if it means to hand over the gem that has signified the kingship of our people here in Erebor.”
Thorin was right. It did cause a stir. A very large stir. Even the wizards exchanged words together, with Saruman stepping forward after a hushed conversation with one of the blue wizards. “Perhaps taking the Silmaril would be the most wise move,” he began.
“No,” Eönwë held up a hand, silencing the entire crowd. His gaze had not moved from Thorin for a moment. “I do not believe it is necessary to take this item from King Thorin.” Eönwë glanced at Saruman who bowed his head at the Maia, his hands folding into his sleeves. “I do appreciate the gesture,” Eönwë's tone warmed when he looked back at Thorin. “But let us not get ahead of ourselves. We do not know for sure if the Silmarils have any part to play in this, though my heart tells me that they do. As such the Silmaril, your Arkenstone, King Thorin, should remain in your possession until such a time as it may be needed.”
“In such an open spot? In a place where it has already been attempted to be stolen?” Saruman's nose went up in the air. “Perhaps it should be moved to a...safer place.”
“The treasury is gone,” Thorin couldn't help his dry tone. “Lost in the destruction of Smaug's fury and his own death.”
“About that,” Gandalf spoke at last, stepping forward to stand shoulder to shoulder with Eönwë and Maedhros. “Would you allow us to see this place, where the dragon died and the...Arkenstone was found?”
Thorin frowned and looked at the crowd. “Bofur?” His friend stepped out from behind Lord Glorfindel. “Is the area safe to bring them into?”
Bofur pulled at one of his braids, his mustache twitching back and forth before he gave a slow nod. “Should be. As long as you don't go up onto any of the balconies and maybe stay away from the eastern halls. The columns looked a bit dodgy there.”
“But they will hold?”
“Oh, they'll hold unless another dragon comes along or we have an earth shaker pop off.” Bofur's hand curled into a warding sign, as did several other dwarves' in the crowd. “Other than that, yeah, I'd say it would be safe enough.”
Thorin looked back to Gandalf. “Then I will show you,” he said. Thorin led the crowd back the way they came, leaving a pair of guards to stand watch over the throne itself when they left. Nori, he knew, would have more than a few of his minions hiding in the shadows of the throne room from here on out. None of them would be comfortable leaving the Arkenstone alone now that they knew of its true origins.
The treasury was a level below the main floor of the mountain. Bofur had shown them all how Smaug had used the central cavern to snake his way down to that area, forcing the halls and doors open with his great armored bulk. Thorin again led the crowd down a circuitous route to the treasury, bypassing the cracked stairs in the central area. It was a bit amusing to see even the elves leery of the deep chasm that opened up on one side of the stairs that Thorin led them down, though he had been told by Bard that most beings other than dwarves were a touch nervous when there were no handrails to be seen on such structures.
The doors to the treasury had long been broken off. As Thorin stepped down from the final stair and onto the hall that would lead to the treasury the floor began to be uneven, as the entire hall had been covered in that river of molten gold. Small lumps still existed in that now cooled metal lake, remains of gems or weapons, perhaps. Thorin had not allowed any of his people here since the battle had ended and they had handed over Bilbo's portion of the gold to the men and elves for their payment. Thorin glanced over his shoulder to see most of the gathered men and elves staring up at the cracked stone and the dark smudges of soot that still blackened the walls and ceiling of the area.
Thorin pointed to the eastern half of the long hall, when they came to a crossroads. “I would have you all stay out of that area.” He lifted his gaze and saw many others look up as well. Above them were the hasty structures Bofur and his crew of miners had managed to put into place to help stabilize the area. “The Arkenstone was found through here.”
Thorin led the way into the melted ruin of the treasury, his boots steady on the slippery gold, but others were not so lucky. Saruman slipped more than once, almost falling on his rear a number of times. Thorin forced himself to look away from the flailing wizard before he let out the laughter that was stuck in his throat. His mirth dimmed the further into the treasury they went, as memories of the time during their gold-madness began to slip back in. He felt Dwalin take his hand and knew his partner felt the same.
Thorin rounded one of the large melted mounds of gold and stopped, his nose wrinkling. The dragon's carcass lay where Bilbo had killed it, spread out over a mess of melted gold and shattered gems, pressed against the back wall of the treasury as if it had been flung backwards, hard enough that thin, spiderweb cracks had formed in the stone above Smaug's body. Gasps rose from behind him and it was only a brave few that came to Thorin's side to stare at the corpse of his people's great calamity.
“You have left it here,” Gandalf said as he came to a stop next to Thorin.
“Yes,” Thorin looked up at the corpse. “When we were gold-mad it did not seem...necessary to remove the gems that still adorned the dragon's body.” Thorin made a face at those hazy memories. “Now that we are of sound mind once more it has become more of a concern about logistics on how best to remove it.”
“Indeed,” Gandalf said, placing his staff in front of him and leaning on it. “It is a very good thing that you have not touched the corpse, King Thorin Oakenshield.”
Thorin gave the wizard a sharp look at that. “Why?”
Instead of answering Gandalf tapped the butt of his staff against the ground once, twice, and then a series of three sharp beats. It seemed to...echo oddly in the cavernous room. “What can you tell us of how Bilbo killed this dragon? Did he say anything at all about it?”
Thorin opened his mouth, paused, and then looked at Dwalin. He slowly shut his mouth as he thought back, trying to remember just what Bilbo had said about that harrowing moment. “Bilbo said that Smaug could sense him, somehow,” Thorin began after a long moment. Dwalin nodded at him. “At the time...I think Bilbo said he thought Smaug could smell him?” Thorin turned to look at the crowd, where the rest of his Company had gathered. “Do you remember anything else?”
Nori was the one to step forward. “We were outside the mountain,” he began. “We heard a roar and it sounded like a great voice speaking. It was not Bilbo,” he shook his head. “It must have been the dragon.”
“Long it has been since the dragons of Morgoth have spoken. They lost that ability Ages ago,” Saruman said as he stepped forward from the crowd, with one of the blue wizards holding his elbow.
Nori glanced at the wizard and Thorin watched his Spymaster narrow his eyes at the tall figure. “I'm telling you what we saw and heard. A voice spoke. It was not Bilbo, that's for sure. So it had to be the dragon.”
“Or you were already mad,” Saruman looked down his nose at Nori. “Is that not also a possibility?”
“Maybe,” Nori did not back down from the wizard's look. “But I know what I heard.” Nori then turned to where Eönwë had moved to stand next to Gandalf. “The mountain trembled, like an earth shaker had gone off right under our feet. It caused land slides to come down around the door we had used to get into the mountain.” His mouth pulled to one side. “We had to dig out the entrance and when we did we found Bilbo on the other side, shaky and pale and crispy in places. He said that the dragon was dead, that it had melted the treasury and that he had not been able to find the Arkenstone in the chaos of killing the dragon. We did not believe him.” Nori looked down at that. Thorin had to look away. “We dragged him back into the treasury but even for us it was too hot to stand. Bilbo fainted from the heat and Óin took him out of the tunnel.”
“Bilbo told me later that he had found a bow in the treasury,” Thorin finished the tale as he looked back up. Dwalin pressed their shoulders together. “He said that he had found an arrow in the piles of gold and gems and while he was running from the fires and the melting gold he fired at the dragon and somehow hit Smaug in the only empty spot on his chest.”
“Did he now,” Gandalf said, soft, leaning heavily on his staff.
“Yes,” Thorin said. “That is what he told us.”
There was a long moment of silence and then Gandalf let out a long sigh. “Do you believe he spoke the truth, King Thorin?”
Thorin looked at Gandalf, at the set of the wizard's shoulders, at the way his mouth was drawn down into a tense line, and then looked out over the treasury. It looked nothing like it had when he was young, when the heaps of gold stood twice his height, when his grandfather would wander through the piles, running his fingers over the gleaming metal, the gold-madness shining in his eyes. Thorin closed his eyes for a moment and let out a long breath before he opened his eyes and looked to Gandalf once more. “You know as well as I do that there are no bows kept in dwarven treasuries. Not even for princes who hunt, who would like to use it as their main weapon of choice.” He saw Kíli duck his head from the corner of his eye. “I do not know where Bilbo got a bow or an arrow to strike down a dragon. What I do know is that the arrow that did kill the dragon is unlike any that I have seen before.”
Gandalf's head came up at that. He sent Thorin a sharp look Thorin could not quite read and then was off, picking his way across the uneven surface of the solidified gold, trailing the rest of them in his wake. Halfway there he came upon the spot where Bofur had chipped out the Arkenstone, the gold peeled back like the rind of a fruit in places from his haste. There was a strange cast to the gold there, almost green, like the scum that would form on the top of still ponds.
“What happened here,” Gandalf murmured as he stopped to stare down at the discolored metal.
Thorin joined him, his boots well away from the greenish metal. “We do not know,” he shook his head. “Bofur?” He turned to look at the miner. To his shock Bofur was backing away from that spot, face pale and sweating. “Bofur!”
“I don't like it,” Bofur's voice shook. Óin was on him in a flash, turning the other dwarf away so Óin could check him over. “I didn't remember until now. It felt...it felt wrong when I was chippin' it out. Like...like I was half dunked under the coldest water or – or being pulled apart by two teams of carts. I almost put the chisel through me own hand twice. It felt like something...something bad was tellin' me I had to.”
“Take him from here,” Gandalf's voice rang through the room. It made Thorin's ears ache. Eönwë was shining at his side. The two of them stood on either side of that discolored metal, their hands held out over it.
“What is it?” Thorin refused to back away, to retreat.
“I believe,” Gandalf's tone was grave, his eyes dark as he focused on the spot before him. “We have found where the One Ring was destroyed.”
“On top of the Arkenstone?” Thorin couldn't help but say.
“Indeed,” Gandalf said.
“If that is the case,” Saruman somehow appeared at Thorin's elbow. He had not heard the wizard move. “If the One Ring really was destroyed here and it somehow interacted with the Silmaril...then yes, yes, I see.”
“What can you tell us, Saruman?” Gandalf did not look up from the discolored metal.
Saruman was silent for a long, long moment. He knelt down despite the way whispers erupted from behind him. His robes almost brushed the edges of that large patch. Thorin wanted to draw him away for a reason he could not name. He did not want anyone to go any closer to it. “Sauron's Ring was a physical manifestation of much of his own power,” the wizard said at last. His hand was curled tight about his staff, the veins on the back of his hands standing out in stark relief. “Sauron himself was tied to Morgoth in many unnatural ways. It is...speculated that Sauron's own power was borrowed from his Master.”
“That is not something I have ever heard,” Gandalf said.
One of Saruman's shoulders tipped up and dropped. “Many things have been written in the long Ages of our world.” He bent closer to the metal, his dark eyes sharp and intent on the gaping hole where the Arkenstone had been lodged. “It looks as though the Ring was destroyed right on top of the Silmaril. If that is true, and if there is some bit of truth to the...rumors that Sauron's own powers were tied to his Master's, then such a meeting of magics would have strange and unknown repercussions to the world about us...and beyond.”
That earned Saruman a sharp glance from Gandalf. Eönwë was still focused on the discolored metal, a deep frown etched between his brows. Then Gandalf rocked back on his heels, his hand dropping at last. “The protections about Aman,” he said.
“Indeed,” Saruman agreed with a slow nod.
“How would this affect such a distant place?” Thorin looked between them.
It was Eönwë who answered him. “The protections about Aman, that have separated Valinor from the realm of Arda, was done much by the Maiar. The legends that it was done by Eru Ilúvatar Himself are wrong, for He has not touched this realm or ours by His own hand since the creation of Eä. When the Valar decreed that Aman would be separated from Arda the Maiar were the ones tasked with the shaping of the protections that kept the two realms apart. The Lady Varda and Lord Ulmo were the only two Valar that put their powers forth into the separation. So far it is only their two spells and magics that are holding. The rest are failing.”
Saruman nodded again at this, his head dipping for a long moment. “Yes. Yes, that would make sense,” he said. “If the Ring, which was the physical form of a Maia's might, met the power of the Silmaril that was cursed by Morgoth's own hand, then yes, I could see how the protections about Aman are now failing.”
“How so?” Thorin frowned down at him.
“The Silmarils contain what remains of the Light of the Two Trees. They were formed in the youth of the world, in Aman, which is their home, which is where the remains of the Trees still stand.” Saruman stood in fits and starts. Pallando the blue wizard was at his side, sliding a hand under his elbow to help him up. “If they were cursed by Morgoth, then they remain connected to him in some way, drawing them from this realm to the utmost West, to where Morgoth has been banished. If Sauron's Ring was destroyed, unleashing the contained might of his power to sweep over this place, to combine with the power of the Silmaril, then it would also touch the very spells that have shaped this world...and disrupt them.” His gaze went to where Smaug lay, curled against the far wall of the treasury. “Perhaps it was not even this Bilbo's arrow that killed the dragon, then.”
“But we've seen the arrow,” Thorin said. “It pierced the dragon's heart.”
Saruman sniffed, his lip curling for a moment. “I do not belief such a little thing could kill a dragon of such power that it could speak.” He shook his head. “No, the release of Sauron's power, combined with the Silmaril must have been what killed the dragon in the end.”
“But Bilbo –”
“Is a halfling,” Saruman flicked his hand and Thorin set his jaw and his feet, trying to keep a hold of his temper. “He must have lied to you about his actions here. It would take something far larger than even an average arrow to kill a dragon.”
“But the arrow –”
“I said –”
“Saruman,” Gandalf stepped between them, his bushy brows drawn down. “You are being unkind. Again.”
The other wizard huffed out a breath through his nose and looked away, tipping his chin up. “You and I both know that killing a dragon is something that few have ever managed, Gandalf. Do you really believe your little pets could achieve such a feat?”
“They are not my pets, Saruman,” Gandalf's voice rang with something that made a shiver work its way down Thorin's spine. “And,” he turned to look at Thorin. “I would see this arrow, King Thorin, if you would allow.”
Thorin frowned at the phrasing of the question but nodded. “We have not touched the dragon's corpse,” he gestured at the still form laying along the wall. “It is not rotting, which surprised us. We do not know why.”
“Dragons were the creation of Morgoth,” Gandalf said as he stepped away from the discolored metal. Eönwë stayed for a long moment before looking up and moving with him. “No one knows how they were created, nor what they were created from. The wurms that have ravaged the northern parts of Arda now are bare echoes of the scourges that used to burst forth from Angband. Smaug the Golden was perhaps of an older line that even I had guessed.” Gandalf's voice began to echo oddly the closer to the dragon he went. “There was much thought about dragons and their creations in the Ages before I came to Arda. Some claimed that Morgoth formed them out of stone. Some claimed that they were formed out of Morgoth's own magic.”
“And what do you believe?” Thorin stayed close to Gandalf's side, with Dwalin right behind him. They had lost much of the crowd behind them as they stayed to study the strange colored metal and where the Arkenstone had been found. Only a handful of the lords that had come to Erebor went with them, along with the gathered wizards.
Gandalf came to a stop before the corpse of Smaug. Thorin stepped to his side, staring up at that terrifying creature that had caused so much pain and suffering for his people and more. It almost looked as though the dragon was sleeping. Thorin felt his fingers curl into a warding gesture. His gaze tracked down to the dragon's chest, where a large, golden colored arrow protruded from the dragon's belly, right where a missing scale left him open for attack.
“Once I would have agreed with my brethren about the origins of dragons but no more.” Gandalf shook his head, his fingers curling and uncurling at his sides. “Morgoth has never been able to create anything on his own, therefore he must have taken something that already existed and twisted it to his own uses.”
“What could he have used, though?” Thorin looked up at him.
Gandalf stood for a long moment, his gaze distant. “The first time Morgoth was contained by the Valar it was at his first fortress, Utumno, which still exists in the far northern reaches of this world, buried under thick layers of ice and debris. It was where Morgoth's powers were strongest, where he set to corrupting many of the Maiar and other spirits that had come to this world, and...” Gandalf tilted his head to one side, eyes narrowing. “Where the magics of the Valar came together in a great battle, ripping that fortress to pieces to expose Morgoth who was hiding in the very depths of his dungeons. It was not thought of at the time, but when the Valar left, Utumno was not cleared out completely, not of Morgoth's own foul projects, but also of the Valar's own magic which lingered in that place.”
Thorin frowned up at the wizard. “The magic of the Valar is such a physical thing?”
Gandalf gave a slow nod. “It can be, when used with such force and in such volume. I believe that Morgoth did not create his dragons from nothing, but rather returned to the ruins of Utumno to gather what was left of the Valar's own magic to form his own foul creatures instead.”
Thorin felt his eyebrows rise and shared a look with Dwalin, who looked as surprised as Thorin felt. “Would the Valar's magic have stayed in one place so long?”
Again Gandalf paused, his brows drawn together. “The magic of the Valar is unlike anything you can imagine, King Thorin Oakenshield. If it lingered there it could have done many things, things not even we can imagine.” Then he took in a sharp breath and shook his head, as if clearing it. “But all that is conjecture. We will never know for sure. But what I do know for sure is this – that arrow is unlike anything I have ever seen before.”
“Indeed,” Bard said from behind Thorin. He turned to see the man approach with Thranduil, the two of them stopping not far from the dragon's corpse. “I have never seen its like.” He nodded to Maedhros when the elf held out his hand when Bard almost slipped on the gold. It was Thranduil, instead, who took Bard's arm to help him the rest of the way to their side. “I do not know how Bilbo Baggins could have shot that arrow,” he said as he came to a stop in front of the dragon's chest. “It is almost larger than he is...was.” Bard ducked his head for a moment.
“Indeed,” Gandalf said with a frown. “I did not expect its size. Is it...made of gold?” He leaned forward, peering at it.
“No,” Bard was the one to say as he raised his head to study the arrow once more. “It is...if I did not know better I would have said it was made of...”
“Made of what?” Thorin took a step closer to the man.
“Wheat,” Bard said, his head tilting back. “It looks almost as if it was made from woven wheat.”
“Wheat?” Thorin echoed, shaking his head. “That is impossible, surely. How could –,” Thorin stopped when Maedhros moved, spinning in place with his hand falling to his sword. Thorin set his feet and looked up, trying to find what Maedhros was staring at. All he could see was the shadowy hallways that ran above the treasury, where the very floors were too fragile to walk on and no stairways existed to reach them anymore. “What is it?”
The silence stretched as Maedhros studied that dark area. He slowly stood, his hand still lingering near his sword. “I do not know,” he said, still frowning at the balcony. “I thought...”
“More jumping at shadows?” Saruman said as he came to a stop by Gandalf's side.
“Saruman,” Gandalf sighed.
“I do not think they were shadows,” Maedhros said, still staring.
Thorin shared a look with Dwalin and then turned to find Nori but his Spymaster was gone from the crowd. “Perhaps it was one of Nori's boys.”
“Perhaps,” Maedhros said, though his frown did not ease. “Perhaps.” At last he turned away.
Thorin glanced back up at the balcony, trying to see what might have caught the elf's eye. From his vantage point he thought...he thought for a moment there were two small shapes, almost like hobbits, perched near the edge of the wall, but when he focused on them the shadows seemed to...shift, in a way, as if someone had opened a door beyond them and caused the darkness there to recede for just a moment. Then he blinked and he could make out the forms of broken pillars in the resettled darkness. Surely that was what he had seen, his mind making shapes of out shadows and letting Thorin see what he wanted to in that formless space. For that was all it could have been. Bilbo was gone. His people were gone. All Thorin was left with was staring at shadows and wishing they were Bilbo instead.
Thorin turned away from the balcony, blinking away the burning in his eyes. He felt Dwalin take his hand again. Bilbo was gone, yes, but his memory would always remain. They would hold onto that for the rest of their lives. And if...perhaps...Thorin imagined Bilbo in the shadows, smiling at him? Well. No one else needed to know. That was for Thorin and Dwalin alone. No one else.
No one else.
