Actions

Work Header

Fili on the Lake

Chapter Text

 

The journey was a far cry from the holiday walk that they had taken to and from Dale under the summer sun a few months before. The autumn wind was already sharp and cold against their ears, and on the ridges the gusts even threatened to overturn the litter. The fear of the dragon was in all of them, and Tilda walked at the front with her eyes constantly searching the ground. Fili guessed that she was looking for signs the beast had been through this way, and he was glad to have her as their scout. But the land revealed no drag marks of a great tail nor the smell of that oily, black poison.

The sky was pink when they passed below Dale, whose gates were all shut. They looked up to see guards and civilians watching them from the windows and balconies of the city’s towers. Tilda waved to them and got a few waves back, but they did not turn up the road to the city or go close enough to hail any of the watchmen.

The huge doors of Erebor were shut tight. Dale would have sent them Tauriel’s warning as soon as they received it, and even if they did not believe it possible, Erebor was the last place in Middle Earth that would underestimate the rumour of a dragon. But there were eyes in the arrow-slots and windows above the gates, and soon someone opened a small door at the bottom and ushered them in.

As they walked into the mountain, carrying Sigrid like pallbearers, Fili thought of his father’s wake.

Fili felt only anger at his father in those first few days. For dying, for dying suddenly, for dying too soon. Right when Fili thought he was going to go out alone for the first time in his life, have the freedom to make mistakes and not worry about everyone else.

On the third day after his father died, the wake was begun in a stone cold-room in the nearby temple. Khagr had already arrived from who knows where; Fili certainly hadn’t invited him. Khagr had taken charge, or at least, he said he was taking charge. Yet somehow it was Fili who had sent out the death-notices sealed with black wax, found rooms or inns for all the out-of-town mourners, arranged the food, and paid the tomb-cutter and the death-singers from his own money, money that Father had given him for a trip to the Orocarni’s to visit the guild schools.

And Fili had to look after Kili on top of that. Kili was inconsolable. He wanted to lie in his bed all day staring at the wall. He had no memories of their mother’s death. Their grandparents on Father’s side had died before they were born. Khagr had visited rarely in their childhood and Kibil, the older uncle from their grandfather’s earlier marriage, did not even come to the funeral. Father had been everything to Kili; parents, grandparents, aunts and uncles and cousins. Kili behaved like he’d lost his entire family in one terrible blow. He didn’t seem to notice that his brother was still right there.

He certainly didn’t help arrange the funeral or sort out all the estate’s paperwork or go through Father’s belongings or try to keep the stables running as normal, which was partly why Fili (stupid, idiot!) let Khagr help manage it.

Their father had been a good father. He had taught them to ride and to hunt with the bow. He had sent them to good tutors, practiced Khuzdul with them himself, and discussed the histories of the first fathers and first mothers over dinner with them. He gave them the best ponies in the herd and the best rooms in his house.

His delight in his sons was plain to anyone with eyes to see it. When they were young he brought them with him wherever he went, and made them stay up past bedtime to meet important visitors, to boast about them with the sincerity of every parent who thinks their child is better than all other children in this or that way. He had never shown an ounce of disappointment that Fili could not tame the most difficult ponies, or that Kili neglected his bookkeeping lessons to read stories about great heroes winning wars and fighting monsters.

He was a good father; but he did not remarry, and it did not seem to occur to him to hire a governess or a nanny along with the tutors. So from the earliest age, Fili had to be mother to Kili’s scrapes and bruises, and later, to his adolescent griefs and dramas. Fili noticed first when the two of them grew out of their shoes, out of their clothes, out of their beds, and had to ask Father for money and buy everything himself. When Fili had a toothache while their father was away, he had to ride into town and find a reputable barber-surgeon himself. Their father was always busy running the stables, and he let them roam where they liked. It felt like freedom somedays, and other days it just meant Fili was the one who had to cajole and bully his brother into staying home for lessons, or coming home before dark.

When Kili got caught in bed with the daughter of a Blacklock noble, Father of course did the diplomacy and a little bit of apology-money, and it was all smoothed over with no long-term harm. But none of it would have happened if Father had listened to Fili and given Kili a proper talking-to beforehand, when the two youngsters had started their surreptitious courting. Kili’s would-be paramour was promised to the Prince of a distant royal alliance, and it had been clear to apparently nobody except Fili that the poor girl was desperate to escape her engagement by any means, including by getting herself in an unmarriageable condition with the pony-trader’s son. But Father was indulgent, and thought his children could do no wrong, and thought Kili sneaking around with girls far above his station was cheeky instead of nearly life-ruining.

Fili had planned to go to the Orocarni mountains the day he turned seventy-five to find himself a school, and from there a trade or a craft. He was a wealthy and well-educated young dwarf with a good head for business, but he knew he didn’t have an artisan’s hands or a gem-cutter’s rock-sense. He would take up something with changing fashions, where brains and good taste were required to sell it, and from there he’d get a position in a court - there were minor royal houses and noble dukedoms everywhere, in the East - and build a life. His own life.

If Father had died ten months and a day later, everything would have been so different.

—

Fili awoke with a jolt, nearly falling out of his chair.

It took him a moment to remember where he was. A room at least twice as big as their living room in their Laketown house, with walls of polished stone. Bright lamps hung from the ceiling, and the huge, geometric hearth had a fire burning merrily behind some kind of glass or rock-crystal shield, cleverly pulling in fresh air through unseen grates but letting almost no smell of smoke into the enclosed room.

They were in the great halls of Erebor, cut into the living rock like the homes of the forefathers who built Moria and the kingdoms of the Orocarnis. It was like walking through an epic ballad, but he’d had little time to marvel as they were hurried upstairs. Once the dwarves at the gate understood the nature of their errand, a makeshift sickbay had been arranged for Sigrid in one of the guest rooms where non-dwarvish visitors were usually hosted, as these were the only rooms that had beds large enough for her. Fili had dozed off while sitting upright beside Sigrid’s bedside.

Now a dwarf named Oin and two other physicians were examining Sigrid for any sign of injury or ailment, perhaps not trusting that the simple Lake-folk knew what they were doing.

Tilda sat on a stool in the centre of the room and was explaining everything she had seen the night the dragon came, while another dwarf in red velvet, named Balin, listened with a silent, grim expression. Balin had a large, neat, white beard and seemed to be the oldest and presumably most important fellow in the room. Another, younger dwarf named Ori was taking notes. Tilda’s elocution had improved markedly over the course of her schooling. She was precise and illustrative in her description of Smaug and his diminished condition compared to the fire-breathing drake she had witnessed the last time he attacked the town, right down to details of the iron collar he was wearing.

When Tilda got to the part of the story where Sigrid was stupefied by the dragon’s gaze and rescued in the nick of time by Fili, Tilda pointed across at him and every face in the room looked at him. Fili felt himself go slightly pink and folded his arms defensively. He heard a snigger from Kili, who had been roaming about inspecting the stone bas-relief carvings in the wainscoting.

Kili said in a mock-serious voice. “Tilda, don’t forget the part where he swam fifty feet carrying Sigrid and came up between the piles right under Smaug’s front claws.”

“Kili, this is not funny, let me talk,” Tilda snapped at him. “As I was going to say, since then, Sigrid cannot be roused from her trance. That’s why we came here,” she finished. “My father thought your famous hobbit might have some idea of how to cure her, since he has faced the dragon before.”

“This is a strange story indeed,” Balin took a few steps around Tilda’s seat. “So the dragon did not speak, not a word?”

“No,” Tilda shook her head and looked at Kili. “Nor when he attacked the militia, as I understand it.”

“Could he have been rendered mute by his injuries?” Oin rumbled from Sigrid’s bedside. “Did the arrow pass through his throat?”

Tilda shook her head. “I’ll show you where it is,” she held out her hands for the lap desk that the scribe was using, and when Ori meekly handed it over she took his quill and held it with a practiced hand. Without a blotch in the ink, she sketched Smaug’s head and the location of the arrow in bold lines across the parchment before handing the writing board back to Ori.

“Perhaps he is in the thrall of something greater and more terrible,” Balin mused, stroking his beard. “Who placed the collar there?”

Oin clicked his tongue and looked at his fellow physicians. “The girl is right about one thing, her sister seems to have no physical injury. Her condition is consistent with some kind of enchantment, though I’ve never seen the like.”

Balin nodded. “Then he has enchanted this maiden, but himself is enchanted by some other power. And yet the attack on Laketown seems such poor planning, so their mastery of him may not be complete, and was his attempt at revenge despite his master’s will. A strange riddle to unpick.”

There was an alarmed clamour of questions from Ori about what to put in the notes, but Balin raised his hand and the young dwarf fell quiet. “Where is Bilbo?”

As he asked this, Balin looked to the corner by the fire. Fili realised there was someone else sitting there, on the far side of the mantelpiece. The dwarf in the corner seemed to have found the only part of the room somewhat in shadow, so his face was hard to see. He wore a plainer set of clothes than the others, with his dark, curly hair flowing unbound over his shoulders. He answered Balin, “At this time of night? Asleep with a book on his lap.”

“Ori, go fetch him,” Balin commanded. He smiled at Tilda. “You have done a brave thing coming here, my lass. I cannot promise you anything more than our gratitude for your story, but we’ll do what we can.”

Ori left at a dash, and Balin came to stand in front of Fili with a diplomatic smile. He waited a moment for Kili to come and join them. Fili wondered if he was supposed to stand up or bow, but he thought about it so long it felt like he missed his chance, so he stayed in his seat.

“I believe you already heard that my name is Balin, at your service,” the old dwarf said, hands still clasped behind his back. “I chair the king’s inner council. If there is anything you require of the king, you may petition me for it.”

Fili glanced at Sigrid in the bed. “Perhaps ask Tilda, but I think she has everything she needs, thank you.”

Balin looked between their faces. “I mean for yourselves.”

Fili looked at his brother. Kili looked much more offended by Balin’s question than seemed fair, so Fili decided to take the lead. “We only came to help our friend, and anyway, it’s Bard who would owe us payment for the favour - which we wouldn’t accept,” he hastened to add. “Bard and his family have been good neighbours to us since we arrived in Laketown.”

“I’m heartened to hear it,” Balin smiled warmly at him and paused, as if to say something else, but then simply nodded and turned away. Fili could see that the dwarf in the corner was watching this conversation, no doubt able to hear them clearly in the quiet room. He wore a very serious expression, but his face had looked serious since Fili first noticed him.

Fili reached over and tugged Kili’s sleeve. “What was that? Why is he offering us… money? What did I miss while I was asleep?”

“Not much. That’s the first one who’s bothered to formally introduce himself,” Kili mumbled back.

“I assume they think any dwarf from Laketown is a vagabond who needs to be paid to leave their palace,” Fili rolled his eyes at Kili, but Kili didn’t respond with a laugh or a wink; he still appeared furious about what Balin had said.

Before they could discuss it further, Ori returned trailing Bilbo, who was tying a thick dressing gown over his nightwear. He looked around the room and focused on Sigrid’s vacant face. There was no mistaking the pity in his eyes, though Fili knew he’d met only Sigrid twice in six years.

Oin explained the shape of the illness to Bilbo, while Tilda lingered just over his shoulder. Bilbo took the stool over to Sigrid and perched himself on it, settling on the other side of the bed from Fili. He scratched his nose and twisted his fingers on his lap.

“I’m sorry,” he said, looking up at Tilda at last. “I really don’t know what you want me to do.”

Tilda, so confident with the dwarves a moment before, immediately looked at her feet and began to cry, raising her hand to try and hide it. Kili went over and made her sit down on the end of the bed by Sigrid’s feet, saying something soothing to her as she folded herself over her lap, covering her face.

Fili leaned over the bed towards Bilbo. Between them, Sigrid mouthed some nothingness silently into the air. He asked, “But how did you repel the dragon? All those years ago?”

“Riddles. Luck. Hiding,” Bilbo said softly. “Avoiding eye contact,” he winced. “Not that I’m saying there was anything she could have done. Has she gotten any better, since it happened?”

Fili rested his elbow on the mattress beside Sigrid’s head. “We don’t think so. She talks sometimes, but it doesn’t make sense. It’s like she’s in another world, a world of nightmares and shadows.”

Bilbo said nothing for a few moments, and then Fili heard him mutter to himself, “A world of shadows, hmm,” he looked up. “There is… there is something I could try. Something small… like a little spell. It’s a long shot, but it might help me see things from her perspective.”

There was the scraping of a chair and they both looked over. The dwarf in the corner had stood up, shaking his head. “No. Not within the walls of Erebor.”

Bilbo raised a hand to him as if warding off his words. “Only for a few minutes.”

“I forbid it.”

“Oh, well, that’s me told, we’ll just let her waste away, then?” Bilbo said with a grimace. Tilda began to cry harder, burying her face in Kili’s shoulder. Balin ‘tsk’ed at Bilbo, but also looked as lost as the rest of them at this exchange.

The dwarf in the corner let out a long breath. “A few minutes, then.” He nodded at Oin and his assistants. “Put out the lamps, screen the light of the fire.”

“Why? What is the danger?” Balin took a step towards him, but stopped at a glance from the other dwarf. He threw his hands up with a sigh. “Very well, I’ve long given up questioning the wisdom of hobbits.”

In moments, the room was darkened to obsidian, darker than a moonless night on the lake. Fili heard Tilda give a little gasp and then stifle her breath, like a rabbit under the shadow of a hawk. Although he’d never been so deep beneath stone, he found he didn’t feel any fear. He might have been raised in the open grasslands of the East, but he was still a dwarf.

Ori had unfolded a solid, iron shield over the hearth, but it did not entirely cover the back-reflections, and a little light still came from the fire like the corona around an eclipse. As his eyes adjusted, Fili found he could still see the pale profile of Sigrid’s face on the pillow, glowing red like the last embers of a campfire. But it was so dark he found he could not see Bilbo’s face across the bed, even though he must be only a few feet away.

Nobody spoke for a few moments, and then Bilbo said. “Ah, you poor thing, what an awful racket. You’ve been putting up with this for two days?”

And in the bare glow, Sigrid’s face turned towards the sound of his voice. Bilbo said, “Aha! Hello! Can you see me, Sigrid? It’s Bilbo Baggins, do you know me? We bumped into each other a few months ago,” there seemed to be no response from Sigrid. “Do you know who you are?”

Sigrid’s jaw moved, forming around a slow, forced word that seemed to cause her great pain. “Sigrid.”

It was not even a whisper, but the entire room was holding its breath, and the rasp of the name seemed to fill the space.

“Yes! Yes, you are,” Bilbo’s voice rose a little in excitement. “I know it doesn’t seem like it, but you’re safe, Sigrid.” A note of urgency entered his voice. “No– don’t listen to him, don’t listen to any of them, they are mere artifice of the beast echoing in your head. None of them are real. Sigrid, stop looking at them!”

Sigrid hadn’t moved, her face was still turned to Bilbo’s voice, but her eyes were glancing frantically around the room. There was nothing there.

Fili could not stand it any longer. He seized Sigrid’s hand and squeezed it tight, tighter than would be comfortable, forgetting his strength and her frailty. Sigrid’s head whipped around and for a moment he thought he had ruined everything by breaking whatever magic Bilbo was performing.

“Fili?” she said, in a clear, low voice. Her other hand reached across her prone body and touched his wrist, her fingers mapping up his arm to the rolled hem of his shirt. “I can feel your hand.”

“Yes. I’m here, Sigrid,” and for a moment, on the tip of his tongue, he nearly spoke some endearment - darling, sweetheart, ibinê - and just stopped short.

There was movement in the corner of his eye. He saw Bilbo, suddenly visible in the smidge of light, standing up to strike a match and put it to one of the lamps above the bed. Somebody uncovered the fire and the physicians came crowding in. Tilda was leaning over the foot of the bed, her hand on Sigrid’s knee through the blankets.

“Tilda?” Sigrid croaked. “Bilbo? Where are we?”

Her face looked drained, her eyes bloodshot and hollowed, her skin pale and clammy. It was as if fighting her way out of the nightmare had been the peak of a vile fever and she had only just broken through it. She smiled at her sister. “Have you been crying? For me?”

“Yes, you stupid—“ Tilda sobbed and hid her face again. “Stop looking at me like that, I’ll start all over again!”

“I’ll never stop trying to embarrass you, little sister,” Sigrid mumbled. “Can someone bring me water, please?”

—-

Sigrid was groggy and clearly hungry, explaining to the physicians that her throat and eyes were dry and painful. Tilda would not leave her sister’s side while the healers went about their care, chattering to Sigrid about everything that had happened, reassuring her that the town had been saved and Bain would probably recover. Sigrid wanted to send a letter to Bard at first light, and Ori said they didn’t have to wait that long, they could send a raven tonight if there was enough of a moon. He stayed so Sigrid could dictate to him, as her hand was still too shaky to write.

The rest of them left, Balin and the long-haired dwarf going ahead with their heads bent in some quiet conversation. Bilbo stayed for a moment to say goodbye and then trotted out, yawning and pulling his dressing gown tighter over his round belly. Fili gave Sigrid’s shoulder a last squeeze, and she glanced at him, met his eyes, and then was distracted by Tilda again. He left with Kili, and only realised as they got out into the echoing, shining halls how exhausted he was.

Balin and the unnamed dwarf were still in the corridor, at the edge of the landing where the stairs opened up into a greater hall with paths deeper into the mountain. Balin saw Fili yawn and came back to them. He gave them a small bow.

“I’m glad we could be of service to Bard’s family, and that he has such friends as you. There’s rooms made up for you, if you’ll follow me. In the morning, King Thorin would like to speak to you, if you’ll be kind enough to join him for breakfast.”

“We’ll be leaving first thing,” Kili said at once, with a snap in his tone. “I’ve got repairs due in Laketown.”

Fili elbowed him, “Oh, we could stay a day, surely? For the king,” he smiled at his brother and waved his hand at the grand hall just beyond. “Did you ever imagine we’d see the inside of a palace like this, brother?”

Kili was watching the dark-haired, unnamed dwarf. Fili had been craning his neck to stare up at the distant ceiling of the mountain halls and took a moment to realise that the dark-haired dwarf was in turn staring at him, at Fili.

Kili didn’t reply to his brother’s question; he just continued to glare at their nameless companion while Balin hovered at the edge, waiting for them to follow him. At last, the unnamed dwarf came over to join the tense gathering. “Surely you are not in such a rush to return to that chilly town on the lake. Bilbo mentioned you came from the East a few winters back, you must prefer milder seasons.”

Fili nodded, “We’re Stonefoot, born and bred.”

“On your father’s side?”

Fili didn’t really understand the emphasis, but he nodded. “That’s right. Father bred and traded ponies, but neither of us had the gift of talking to them. Our uncle sold the herd for coppers after he died.”

The dark-haired dwarf cut in, almost as if he had been waiting to snatch an opening in the conversation. “I knew a Stonefoot pony trader when I was young. He used to take his flock from Rhûn to the Western shore to cover the best breeds. I never met a dwarf better travelled. He had gold hair, like yours. Very unusual in these parts of the world.”

“Ay, there’s scores of stables in the east,” Fili grinned. “And plenty of yellow-haired dwarves, too. Your friend was probably not one of our kin.”

“No? What was your Da’s name, then?”

“Vili, son of Vim.”

The dwarf raised one eyebrow. Fili laughed and drew back, “Not the same?”

“The same. I knew him well. I went to his wedding.”

“You didn’t—! You were at our father’s wedding?”

There was a sharp, furious grunt from Kili; Fili flinched with the shock of it, but Kili’s voice shoved into the conversation. “Oh come off it. Just ask us what you really want to ask. Your king already sent Bilbo to spy on us and Balin to bribe us, I’m sorry their answers haven’t assuaged his curiosity. Can you just tell us what he wants? Because if the king is willing to pay us a ransom to sod off back to the east and never threaten his reign again I can completely, utterly guarantee we’d take the money and get as far away from that rat-infested swamp of a town on the lake—“

“Laddie, let’s take breath—“ Balin tried to intervene, physically stepping between Kili and the dark-haired dwarf.

“Kili! What has gotten into you?” Fili grabbed his arm and laughed nervously. “Mama didn’t teach you those manners.”

“There, someone finally mentioned her. That’s what you are so desperate to know, isn’t it?” Kili almost spat. “Our mother’s name? That’s what the great King Thorin really needs to know?”

The strange dwarf held his gaze and let the hall fall quiet. His arms were loosely folded across his chest, but it looked more like self-preservation than a challenge. And then the faintest smile crossed his face. “I don’t have to ask, Kili,” he said, and his voice creaked with the weight of it. “You sound just like her.”

Kili’s anger faltered into a wordless confusion. Fili, ever the diplomat, spoke to patch up his brother’s offense. “You knew Ma? From way back in Ered Luin?”

The dwarf smiled wider, but with such grief in his face that even these two strangers could see it. “Yes. And I knew you both. I met you moments after you were born. I remember the days you crawled, ran, spoke for the first time; I taught Fili his first letters. Memories more precious than any treasure in this mountain.”

Fili’s heart was pounding in his chest. His memories of a childhood before his mother died were far away in a mist, with flashes showing through like lightning. He remembered sleeping in a tent between his parents, on a warm summer night. He remembered Kili, too small to walk the trade roads yet, riding on his mother’s back in a sling. And there was a memory of a dwarf so tall he might have been a mountain, a dwarf who carried a real sword and sung to him as they walked side by side. In the broken, distant memory, he showed Fili the delicate filigree on the handle, explaining the meaning behind each rune and image, then gave him a stick and sparred with the sheathed sword until, defeated by the tiny child’s blows, he fell to the ground and cried for mercy as Fili climbed on his chest with a war holler.

Fili swallowed. “Uncle,” he felt the blood flush up his neck, beneath his beard. “I… don’t remember your name, I am sorry. Our father never told us we still had family alive in the West.”

“My name is Thorin,” the dwarf said, beginning to smile.

“Oh. Like the king?”

“Yes, Fili, like the king.” Thorin began to laugh, a deep, rolling chuckle like stones in a mine shaft. “Your father told you nothing of your mother’s family?”

Fili looked at his brother. Kili’s face was ashen and clammy, his eyes wide. He looked like he was going to throw up. His mouth opened, gaped like a gull as he tried to speak. Fili finally answered for him, “Nothing of substance.”

“I think he planned to, when we were grown,” Kili croaked, and fumbled at the inside pockets of his coat. He withdrew a black fold of old, stained leather that Fili had never seen before and thrust it at Thorin, almost like a defensive parry, and Thorin took it and opened it. Kili said in a rush, “He died before giving us this. Father must have kept it hidden, and our uncle - his brother - found it when he inherited the estate. I’ll wager it was at the bottom of a trunk somewhere after everything was sold, when Khagr was scrabbling for any trinket to pay his debts. He said he’d uncovered an heirloom of our house that would fetch a high price in Erebor, he insisted we pack up everything and leave in the middle of the night. He had all sorts of villains chasing him for money and we didn’t think it was worth staying behind to meet them. But he never told us what he’d found, he just brought us to Esgaroth and then he drowned, and this ended up in the canal. I found out about it and pulled it out of the mud the day before yesterday. That’s the first that I knew of the truth - yesterday, I swear, I’m so sorry, I didn’t know anything until a day or two ago. Thorin, I’m sorry,” and he stepped back and attempted a stiff bow.

“Didn’t know what?” Fili frowned, leaning over to try and read the ruined parchment in Thorin’s hands. His gaze followed the spindly lines that spread across the page, a long trunk growing down from the top, widening into branches and then narrowing, down to a single point with two names. It was obviously a pedigree, hand-drawn from someone’s memory rather than a precious artifact illuminated by a professional scribe. It didn’t look expensive.

Fili could see the shape of the names at the top of the tree. He couldn’t guess at anything else as he went down the tree, as the names multiplied and the writing got too small to read upside-down.

“It’s your mother’s hand,” Thorin said quietly. “She made this for you, to teach you who you are,” and he handed it to Fili.

Fili looked at the parchment, rotting at the edges, the ink faded and patchy. He looked at the names at the top.

He looked at the names at the bottom.

Fili raised his head so fast he had a moment of vertigo. Thorin smiled at him, and Kili put his hand on his shoulder.

“I think I should sit down,” said Fili.