Chapter Text
In the morning, no one woke them in their palatial bedroom. Fili stirred under the growing glow of what seemed to be real sunlight, captured and reflected through who knew how many twists and tunnels before it trickled in through a shaft in the ceiling of the guest room. Some servant must have come in early, because there was a little breakfast waiting on a table beside the wide, recessed entrance.
There were clothes laid out on another table, on the other side of the entrance. Fili shoved a piece of thick-buttered bread in his mouth and then wiped his hands on the tablecloth and went to inspect the clothes. There were two outfits, similar but for the details of the cut and the colour. Both were elaborately decorated, Dale-made brocade with leather belts and fine-spun, wool doublets. One was of soft grey, with blue embroidery on the doublet, and was long in the chest and leg; clearly meant for Kili. It was far too broad across the shoulders and thighs for him though, so Fili was heartened to think it had probably been borrowed from the wardrobe of some tall dwarf on short notice, and not miraculously cut and stitched in a few hours.
The other outfit was a near-uniform, dark blue. Fili held the tunic up against his chest. He recognised the colour as he glanced in the mirror. It was the deep blue of the King’s cloak, which they had all seen that day - it felt like years ago - when Tilda had pointed Thorin out from the promenade in Dale.
Fili stepped back from the mirror. The toast seemed to squirm in his stomach.
He found a basin of clean water and towels in a side room, and a comb that appeared to be made of silver, inset with tiny images of dwarves smithing. He cleaned himself up, tamed his hair and put on his old clothes, his own familiar Laketown-made linen, the threads failing at the seams, and his brown, wool trousers with varnish stains.
He had to ask a passing dam for directions back to the makeshift sick bay, though it was only a couple of corridors away. Sigrid was sitting up in bed, holding a steaming cup of dark, creamy tea. Her eyes were lucid and as he sat down beside her she smiled that familiar, wry twist.
“How do you feel?” Fili asked.
She reached out and took his hand. “Like I’ve walked miles uphill in a thunderstorm, but alive. Thank you,” she shook her head. “You can’t imagine how it was to feel a hand, hear your voice in that horrible, loud place. I’m sure I should be worried about nightmares for the rest of my life, but all I can think about right now is the joy of being out of there.”
“You can thank Bilbo for the cure.”
“I’m thanking you,” she said, and squeezed his hand.
Fili swallowed. “Sigrid, would you marry me if I was the crown prince of the greatest dwarf kingdom west of Rhûn?”
She considered his face for a long time before she said, “No.” Like a candle-flame in a breath, Fili felt the flickering out of a life, a future, a world where he could have been mostly happy and lived a mostly quiet life; yet the loss of it was not as painful as he expected.
Then Sigrid asked with a frown and a soft laugh, “Are you the crown prince of the greatest dwarf kingdom west of Rhûn?”
Fili echoed her laugh. “Yes. I think I am.”
“Well,” she relaxed back against the pillow again. “Throw me in the lake and call me a fish, that’s not what I expected to wake up to.”
—-
They were able to spend most of that day in anonymity. Erebor was full of activity, much of it apparently armoured and armed. When Fili returned from visiting Sigrid, he found a very friendly fellow named Bofur had been sent to meet them at their room and guide them on a tour of the main districts of the mountain.
Bofur walked fast and talked even faster, but his guests were a difficult audience and even he ran out of jokes once or twice. During one long silence, while they were heading down from the mirror-gardens that ringed the upper levels, Fili tried to fill the gap and asked him his trade.
Bofur laughed. “Nothing. I do absolutely nothing. I live pleasurably on the profits of our quest and occasionally act as nanny for poncy diplomats from the Eastern kingdoms," he looked back at them with a frown. “Wait, are you poncy diplomats from the Eastern kingdoms?”
“No. We’re from Laketown,” Kili said quickly.
“Ah! Yes, you must be part of that local militia that drove off the dragon. It’s supposed to be hush-hush, they’re trying not to panic anyone, but the rumours are spreading like fire in a coal seam and my lads, I tell you, so is the panic. I can’t imagine why, when’s the last time a dragon bothered Erebor? Not in your lifetimes, I’m certain,” he gave them a wicked grin. “Do you think he’s coming here, then?”
“Who?”
“Smaug,” Bofur turned and stopped. They had reached a quiet intersection with stairs dropping away in two directions. For the first time, Bofur’s mirth showed a little thin on his face. “The one who’s supposed to be dead.”
Fili shook his head. “I wish I could tell you. But he’s had almost three days, and it’s not a long walk.”
Bofur laughed. “True enough. So either you scared him off, or he’s bringing friends.”
Back in the luxurious guest room, someone brought them tea and a kind of honey-soaked spice cake that was inedibly sweet. They sat at the wrought table under the sun shaft and stared at a mosaic of Durin the Deathless discovering Mirrormere. Neither of them spoke for a long time.
“Are you angry that I didn’t tell you straight away?” Kili asked at last.
“Yes,” Fili said, angrily.
“You were so worried about Sigrid, and we all thought the dragon would come back any minute,” Kili leaned across the table. “There just wasn’t a good time.”
“Stars above, Kili, this was kind of important to mention,” Fili couldn’t think what else to say. He couldn’t really think, to be honest.
“What are you going to do?” Kili asked.
Fili looked at him. “Me? Don’t you mean ‘we’?”
“I could still leave and go back home. Really home, I mean, back to Rhûn, open a workshop there. I don’t know if I can stay here and ‘do absolutely nothing’ like Bofur, living the life of a pampered prince. And I’m not going back to finish my sodding apprenticeship with Kibil. He can’t threaten us once he finds out we’re royalty. I’ll go back to the house, pick up my stuff and find a lodging house in Laketown until Bard says it’s safe to travel the roads again.”
“Don’t you think he’d be angry?” Fili winced. They both understood who ‘he’ was, and it was not Uncle Kibil.
“I think he would be a bit sad, but he doesn’t even know me,” Kili swallowed. “When Mama and Father took us away, I must have been barely stringing two words together. Last night in the sick room, it was you he was staring at the whole time. Assessing you, I think, but also yearning. Whatever is really going on here, if there really is some succession crisis brewing or if he just remembers you more fondly, he… I mean this as a warning because you’re my brother… I’m scared of what Thorin will do if you try to leave,” Kili put his hand on Fili’s arm and shook his head.
Fili put his hand on top of Kili’s. “Do you want to go home to Rhûn?”
Kili shrugged. He pulled his hand back and slumped into the chair, staring into his half-drunk teacup. “I’m a grown dwarf now, I’m trained, I can take care of myself. It might be better if I left.”
“Better for the king?” Fili frowned.
“For you. You wouldn’t have to look after me anymore. Finally.”
Fili felt a cold shiver run through him. “Kili, I don’t…” could he really deny it? He’d wanted to get away from Kili, and Father, and the stables. But that had been a different world, lifetimes ago. They were staring into another turn of fortune again, at least as dramatic as the last one. “I want you to be whoever you want to be,” he said slowly. “But if you want to stay and be my brother, I’d like that a lot.”
Kili’s mouth wobbled in the beginning of a smile, but before he could reply, there was a knock on the door. Fili swore under his breath and turned to call them in. It was a retainer in royal livery, asking them if they would join the King in an early supper. Fili had lost track of what time it was. Everything in this place was so precise and yet so indecipherable.
They asked for a few minutes and the retainer withdrew. Kili looked at him. “Do you think we should wear the outfits?”
“I’m not wearing that getup,” said Fili. “And it’s going to look blazing rude if you wear it and I don’t.”
“Ah, Mahal take you, I wanted to wear it,” Kili said with a warm smile. “If they’d given us a bit more time we could have at least visited the laundry room!”
The retainer returned soon and led them along passages and up and down stairways and across the span of a great, busy highway trafficked not just by dwarves but full carts and ponies, lit by enormous spheres of burning light that Fili was aching to understand the engineering of. Fili was fairly sure he’d mapped out the vague shape of the Erebor that Bofur had shown them around, and this was not in any of those public places. They must have entered the private manors of the royal family and their court.
At last they were waved into what, for Erebor, was probably quite a small dining room deep in the mountain. It was still large enough that it would fit the entire of Bard and the dwarves’ houses together in Laketown. The walls were a pale, greenish marble unlike the dark-grey granite of Erebor’s raw-cut halls or the deep shades of reddish-black and brown stone that sheathed the walls of the guest rooms. Combined with the strange lamps flickering in their glass braziers, it almost felt like they were underwater.
For some reason, Fili had assumed this would be a private dinner, just the two of them and the King. However, the large table in the centre of the room had eight chairs around it.
Thorin sat at the far end of the table, his eyes flicking to meet theirs as they entered. There were two empty chairs on his left hand, while the two on his right were filled by Balin and an enormous, bald-topped dwarf. Tilda was next to the two empty chairs and Sigrid sat opposite her, next to the bald dwarf. Peering around the last chair because he was considerably shorter than the high back, at the end of the table facing the king, was Bilbo.
The bald dwarf got up at once and came towards them in what was frankly quite a threatening manner. When he arrived in front of them he bowed low. “Dwalin, son of Fundin, at your service,” he straightened up. He clapped his meaty hands on each of their shoulders, so hard Fili had to brace his knees. “It is good to see you both again, my princes. Your mother was,” and Fili could almost swear there was a sheen in his eyes, “very dear to me.”
As they sat down, Fili realised what a mistake his stubbornness about the clothes had been. Although the other dwarves had dressed in relatively plain robes, they were still of the finest weaves he’d seen before he came to the mountain, and perfectly clean and crisp at every angle. And both Sigrid and Tilda had been given dresses that shone like rippling blue and amber pastures, and sparkled with gems around the collar and chest. Fili couldn’t really blame them for accepting the outfits; Sigrid’s clothes would have been wretched after two days of sickness, and it would have been cruel to ask Tilda to pass up the chance to dress in finery. But it did make Fili and Kili look absolutely ridiculous. They hadn’t even polished their boots.
Without really thinking, Fili started to take the chair next to Tilda, but Kili came up close and gave him a sharp kick to the side of his leg. Fili quickly pretended he was just saying hello to her. It was clear he was supposed to have the chair at the end, beside Thorin and opposite Balin. Kili got to sit down in the much more comfortable spot next to Tilda and within conversational distance of Sigrid and Bilbo.
This is going to be the longest dinner of my life, Fili thought.
Food was brought in by servers as if by clockwork. For the first course, Fili’s end of the table was almost silent, except for pleasantries. Fili couldn’t even discuss the weather, since there was none in the mountain. At the other end of the table, he could hear Tilda regaling Bilbo and Dwalin with the story about the dragon attack, except with even more drama and embellishment than when she’d told it last night to Balin. She must have had a conversation with Kili about his version of events, because she even added in everything that had happened to the militia when they’d stumbled upon the dragon on the shore.
Fili remembered that night in his own mind as moments of utter terror - the long hours of waiting for the militia, the moment he’d seen Kili and the others running for their lives, the sight of the beast - crushed together with the moments that had no feeling at all, only the memory of doing, of running onto the bridge towards Sigrid, towards Smaug, and swimming until his lungs burned. The hours of clinging to the bridge pile, freezing, calling for help until his throat ached. The slow surety creeping over him that Sigrid’s mind was no longer in her body. It was so cold in the water he thought he would die clinging to that pile, and for nothing, because Sigrid was gone anyway. Flashes of it were so clear that his body twitched like it was trying to mimic the movements even while he sat here safe and warm in the mountain hall.
He remembered that when it all happened, Tilda had looked as scared as he’d felt, but now she had already found the courage to tell the story like it was an adventure, as if she was an old-fashioned lore-speaker who’d gone by choice to record the deeds of these great heroes. And Dwalin was crying, “No! The beast’s breath did what?” and other such comments in suitably impressed tones.
Fili looked over and made eye contact with Sigrid. She looked a little green - but maybe it was just the light. She smiled at him and gave an indulgent nod at her little sister. She mouthed something at him. He cupped his hand around his ear and she mouthed again - Thank you.
He shrugged and waved his hand. For what?
She brought her hands together in a cupping motion and then pointed at herself. For saving me.
He flattened his hand on his chest and inclined his head. You’re welcome.
There was a clink as a server retrieved his empty plate and he looked back to his end of the table. He realised Thorin was, once again, watching him with a sharp and inscrutable expression and had seen the silent exchange with Sigrid. Another course was placed in front of him but his stomach had no hunger left for it.
Thorin seemed to be trying to find the words to speak, and then cutting himself off before he could say them. Fili decided that he had to follow Tilda’s lead and at least fake courage. He asked Thorin, “Did you know we were still alive, this whole time?”
Thorin shook his head, picking up his fork and turning to the latest course, which consisted of tiny slices of salted meat each topped with a small lump of some kind of fruit relish. “I had no reason to think you were dead, but you were as seeds in the wind.”
He paused, and Balin stepped in to explain. “After we reclaimed Erebor, Thorin sent many dwarves east to bring you home to your birthright. They returned with the news that your father was dead and his children made destitute and vanished, no one knew where. We could not have imagined you were under our noses this entire time.”
“So it was no secret that we existed,” Fili was starting to put things together from Thorin’s perspective. “And I imagine when Bilbo told you who he’d met in Dale, the risk of imposters was not far from your mind. Come to steal a share of Erebor’s wealth.”
“Yes,” Thorin agreed heavily. “It was a risk I had to guard against. I had to see you for myself before I made any move to acknowledge you. In truth, I thought it so unlikely that Bilbo was right, that I was not willing to entertain even a hope.”
Fili poked at the appetiser on his plate. The fork looked like pure silver; the plate was a fine, white porcelain so delicate it seemed to glow from beneath. “And are you sure?” he said carefully. “Our uncle Khagr was a master of the swindle. I’ve seen him talk clever, well-learned dwarves into practically selling their mothers. Mama’s handwriting on that pedigree proves only that someone found her papers, not that we are really her sons. And the last time you met me, I was - what? Eight? Nine? Am I that same dwarf?”
Thorin glanced at Fili’s worn, faded clothes and the simple, wooden beads in his hair. “From what I have gathered,” and here, Fili was sure he meant, ‘what my spies and agents have gathered’ because he obviously had not been knocking on doors in Laketown in person, “since you arrived in Esgaroth many years ago, you’ve made no grand claims to royalty and asked for nothing from Erebor, except the life of your friend,” he indicated Sigrid at the other end of the table with a twitch of his hand without looking away from Fili. “If this is a play, it is a long and strange one.”
Fili swallowed. He still felt like a cheat. He kept trying to think of ways it could be a mistake. Could it all be happenstance? Could Khagr have learned about the missing princes, noticed the coincidence of their names and ages, forged the pedigree and dragged them here with a plan to sell them to Erebor and then sod off with the profits before anyone figured out the racket? But then their parents’ names must be a coincidence too, and he and Kili were born in Ered Luin, Father had never lied about that.
And he remembered the way Bilbo had stared at him that very first day in Dale. Bilbo had heard his name shouted in the crowd and recognised his face, though they’d never met before. He had seen a family resemblance that had been convincing enough for him to follow them to Laketown to try and engineer a ‘chance’ meeting with Thorin that very night, in the middle of the war council. Fili looked at Thorin’s sharp profile across the table and touched his own nose, and then pretended he was just scratching it.
It had to be true. A part of him was furious that Khagr had kept this hidden from him. But then he’d also have to be furious at his father for doing the same. He had the faintest memories of saying to his father, when he was very young, things like, “I don’t have to do what you say. Mama said we were descended from kings.” And his father would ruffle his hair and reply, “Oh yes, of course she did, all mothers think their sons are little princes." Father must have been so afraid that if they found out their heritage, they would run away to Ered Luin to reclaim it, that after their mother died Father never breathed a word of her family name or homeland. Father was not really denying them anything of material value, since Erebor was still occupied by the dragon at that time. Fili couldn’t bring himself to be angry, not at Father, not even at Khagr. What a waste of feeling it would be, against two dead dwarves.
“Why didn’t you try to find us until you had Erebor?” Fili tried to put a forkfull of food in his mouth but had to force himself to swallow it.
Thorin raised an eyebrow at him.
Fili knew he was dancing around the questions he really wanted to ask. What do you want from me? What use am I to you? So he just came out and said it. “It seems like you didn’t need us until you had a legacy that you wanted to turn into a dynasty.”
He realised too late that the entire table had gone quiet.
Thorin sighed and leaned his elbow on the table. “I would have claimed you as my heirs years before the quest for Erebor, but I had to respect your father’s wishes. What was I to do, steal his children?”
“What do you mean?”
Thorin shook his head. “When your father took the family back east, we thought it would be for two summers, maybe three. But he wrote that your mother had died and he couldn’t risk the journey alone with Kili so young. I sent messengers in person, begged him to give you back to us. He was angry, offended that I would take his children from him. Like I was punishing him for the death of his beloved wife. No more letters came.”
For a moment it seemed he couldn’t find the words to continue. Balin spoke up, “It was a misunderstanding. Among Longbeards, with the death of either parent, the maternal side of the family is expected to be as both mother and father. They often pay for the raising and educating of children, or even take them into their households, to give the surviving parent time to grieve and go where they must. A dwarf who loses a wife or husband needs to be alone, to find understanding for themselves, to accept the will of Mahal, even if such a thing takes years. Caring for their children is supposed to be a kindness. But these are not the traditions of the Stonefoots, so your father took it as an insult.”
“Or he understood,” Fili’s jaw tensed. “You didn’t mean it as a kindness.”
Thorin met his eyes. “No. I would never have let you slip out of my hands again. The last of my kin, the last of the elder line of Durin, two precious reminders of my sister. Your father must have known that, despite my silvered words and pretty platitudes.” His eyes grew dark. “He was a common horse-breaker and I cared nothing for him beyond the good he’d done for Dis. And for my arrogance, I lost you.” And then his face softened. “But here… by the will of the gods, you are home at last.”
Fili tried to smile back. But he thought of Kili’s hand on his arm. I’m scared of what Thorin will do if you try to leave.
—-
Although time was hard to measure, he was sure the dinner had started early in the evening and it seemed it would go on all night, but shortly after the fifth course a messenger arrived with something urgent for Thorin. He, Balin and Dwalin made their apologies and left at a swift pace, while Bilbo walked them back to their rooms.
“I’ll head off to meet some friends. Some of them were in Thorin’s company, when he reclaimed the mountain,” Bilbo explained as they were drawing closer to the guest quarters. “I don’t suppose you’d like to come? It’ll be a bit more,” Bilbo gave an exaggerated wince, “relaxed than tonight’s dinner.”
“Oh, normal dwarves, not important ones? Yes please,” Kili said, practically jumping forward. “Fili?”
“I think I just need to sleep,” Fili said, though his thoughts were screaming in circles around the inside of his skull. “Thank you, Bilbo.”
“I’ll come,” Tilda bounced after them. “Since I’m all dressed up anyway. But Kili, if you tell Da, I shall never speak to you again.”
They stopped outside Fili’s room, and Sigrid came in to try the horrible spice cake, which she agreed was on the rich side but which she ate anyway. Someone knocked and walked in without warning, to offer them tea. Fili jumped as if they’d yelled in his ear. Sigrid asked for tea for two as if it was the most natural thing in the world to have servants, but now Fili was paranoid that Thorin would find out he’d been alone in his room with Sigrid. Were they conservative about that sort of thing, here in Erebor? And why was he even worrying about it? He was just visiting. He didn’t have to follow their rules and proprieties. The tea arrived, and the servant didn’t seem to blink at the two of them sitting alone together, so he tried to relax.
Sigrid drank deeply; since she woke up from the dragon’s spell she seemed to struggle to stay warm. Fili tried to sip his cup. It tasted bitter at first and then clogged his throat when he added cream from the jug. He wished he’d gone out with Tilda and Kili and gotten drunk instead of staying in with his thoughts.
“I did a bad job of my first day as a prince,” Fili muttered, picking the dried fruit out of the spice cake with a tiny fork that he was pretty sure was designed for eating baked snails.
“I’m sure the king doesn’t think that.” Sigrid soothed. “What are you going to do next?”
“I don’t know,” Fili said quietly, leaning in as if Thorin had spies in the walls. “We don’t know anything about these dwarves, about this mountain. Getting involved in the politics of a monarchy like this… what if we’re just pawns in some battle for the succession of Erebor? Your father said Thorin and his people are desperate to produce an heir to keep power out of the hands of the Iron Hills. And worse—“
“Fili—“
“—-and there’s going to be a war with the Grey Mountains, everyone thinks so, and the orcs have a dragon—-“
“Fili.”
“—and I’ve never held a sword in my life, I’m the son of a pony trader, and I don’t even have a pony, I can’t fight a dragon—!”
Sigrid put her hand on his mouth. Her skin was over-warm from holding the teacup, and smelled of the slightly sulfurous water that came from the mountain’s washbasins. He shut up immediately, and she let it fall back onto the table. She said, “Let me talk. My throat still hurts and I can’t shout you down.”
There was a pause, and Fili said, “Well?”
“I’m thinking,” she said, holding his eye. “I think I’d be as panicked as you. I don’t think it’s the dragon that you’re really scared of, or even Thorin. I think it’s because you have been let down by all the others before him. Everyone else died one after another, or turned out to be monsters, or both, and left you with more on your plate to carry. You’ve been completely focused on just keeping you and Kili alive, and now somebody is telling you about this new obligation, this new duty. I understand that feeling of wanting to scream at everyone to just go away and stop giving you things to do,” she shook her head. “But I can tell you from experience, it won’t go away with hiding.”
Fili scrubbed his hand down his face. “I wish we’d left in the summer when we could have made the trip East in good weather. We still could leave, without taking anything from Thorin. If we were nobodies scrabbling for a living back home, at least there would be nothing left for us to lose.”
“And what if Thorin really does want what’s best for you?”
“Then he’ll wait for us to come back when we’re ready,” Fili growled. “Or if not, it will force him to show his real purpose.”
Sigrid tipped her head, her brows furrowed. “Fili, were you not listening to him at dinner? You’re the only family he has left. Make a decision, but don’t make him wait for you any longer.”
“What is my choice? To stay and pretend to be a prince, or go and be a pauper in my father’s land?” Fili dug his hands into his hair. “Anyone would say I was an idiot for thinking twice about it.”
“You could stay and still be a pauper, if you'd prefer that,” Sigrid said quietly. She had taken a small, decorative blanket from the bedside and wrapped it around her shoulders, though the air felt warm and dry to Fili. He waited for her to explain and she said, “If Thorin is just looking for a successor, he won’t want anything but true, dwarvish stock. If you… well, if you were married to me, you’d not be much good to carry on the dynasty, would you? I know how seriously dwarves take marriage. I’m sure he’d accept your abdication.”
Fili stared at her. “Are you really reconsidering?”
“We don’t have to live on the lake. I know you hate it there. We’ll help build Da’s new town in the South, like you wanted all along. If it prospers, and I know it will, it will be a steady, honest life. Thorin could invite us to dinner whenever he likes but he couldn’t force you to be a prince.”
Fili let out a long breath. “It’s not what you wanted. You don’t want to be a mother.”
“I didn’t say that was on the table. But I could do worse for a husband,” she smiled. “Think about it. So that at least you don’t feel Erebor is your only choice.”
—
When Kili and Tilda got back, they were merry but full of news. They had spent the evening with a group of young dwarves, including Ori, the scribe from their first night in the mountain. It had not taken the gathering long before the dwarves were all trying to outdo each other spreading rumours and secrets. Ravens had been back and forth between Erebor and all their allies, even the elves, and although nobody could pin down exactly what the threat was and where it was coming from, it was clear that it was coming.
Sigrid and Fili decided for the four of them; they had to leave the mountain tomorrow, if the threat was not already on the doorstep. If the roads became blocked or shut to forestall an enemy, they could end up trapped in Erebor for who knew how long? If Dale and the mountain were besieged, it could be years.
They decided to leave in the morning, walk the short distance to Dale and stay there overnight, to be sure that Sigrid was properly recovered and to gather any further news. Then they would head straight for the lake the next day. Fili took the responsibility of writing a short goodbye to the king and asking one of the ubiquitous retainers to take it to him, requesting also that a raven be sent to Bard so there would be a boat waiting for them on the north shore.
Balin caught them as they tried to slip out early the next morning, after storing every bit of the extravagant breakfast in their packs and filling their water-skins from Erebor’s fountains. It did not help that they had to ask directions to the front door twice, so they were easy to find.
Balin was panting slightly as he reached them just on the threshold. “Will you wait an hour, at least?” he begged. “The King would like to arrange an armed escort back to the lake.”
“Have there been sightings of danger on the road?” Sigrid pushed.
“No, but he wishes you to be protected.” Balin clasped his hands together. “Things may be moving very quickly, very soon.”
“All the more reason we can’t wait,” Fili said, rearranging the straps of his pack. “I have to get the ladies back to Esgaroth. I promised their father I’d bring them both home safe. Besides, a clumsy armed escort is more likely to attract attention than four walkers dressed like common labourers.”
“Thorin will not be best pleased,” Balin warned. “He would be here himself if he could.”
“Well, let him be as he likes. He’s my uncle, not my king,” Fili replied.
Balin huffed, forming a retort, but Fili turned and waved the others through the small door at the foot of Erebor’s great gate.
The sunshine on his face washed some of the knots from his muscles as they made their way between the arms of the mountain. They were in Dale before the sun marked the eleventh hour. The gates were all shut, but the watchmen had seen them approach from Erebor and ushered them inside.
The watchmen assumed they were envoys from Erebor. When they insisted otherwise and explained they were Bard’s daughters and bodyguards, which seemed the simplest story to stick with, the Dale watchmen decided they must be Esgaroth ambassadors, and brought them straight to the great city hall of Dale. By the time they sorted out the confusion, food and a room had already been arranged for them, which they accepted to avoid any further offense. Kili was delighted to run into Tauriel, who was safe and well in the city hall; she was advising the council of Dale on Thranduil’s intentions and helping them prepare for a possible siege if it came to it.
Kili pulled Tauriel into the room where they’d settled themselves and shut the door. “Do you think it will come to a siege?” he asked her.
“We will try and turn them away first,” Tauriel murmured. “But our scouts and spies bring more confusion than guidance. Three days ago, there were signs of a great force mustering in the North-West mountains, and something coming up from the south. But yesterday, news came that the armies have begun retreating, retraced their own steps, and the smaller forces on the move from clans farther away have now vanished altogether.”
“That’s good news!” Kili looked around at the others all listening in. “Isn’t that good news?”
“Maybe when the dragon failed to breach Laketown, they had to change their plans,” Tilda said hesitantly. “Or they’ve just given up and gone home.”
Tauriel seemed to be gathering her thoughts, perhaps considering what was safe to discuss and what was confidential military judgement. “It is a very great shift in their direction for what seemed like a failed gamble, or possibly even a mistake, if the dragon’s strike was a rogue one. And these retreats were first observed yesterday, not right after the attack at the bridge.”
“Something changed two nights ago,” Fili guessed. He glanced at his brother. “Did your drinking companions say anything about what might have happened?”
Kili shrugged. Tilda said, “That was the first night we were in Erebor. The night Sigrid woke up.”
Without meaning to, Fili thought of the sickbay, and Thorin - before Fili knew he was Thorin - saying to Bilbo, ‘Not within the walls of Erebor. I forbid it.’ Whatever he’d meant, whatever ‘little spell’ Bilbo seemed to have wrought to enter Sigrid’s dreams, even Balin had not been privy to the details. Only the king and the hobbit. But it was just another mystery upon mysteries.
They settled down that night on comfortable, human-sized Dale beds. Kili slipped away when he thought everyone was asleep, no doubt to Tauriel’s room. Fili lay still and let him go without comment. He had been awake since the last bells marked the night-watch, but his eyes didn’t feel the slightest bit heavy.
He could see the clouds through the unshuttered window moving across the stars. He kept expecting to hear a crack as the door was kicked open, or see steel-clad agents climbing in the window. Dale would not protect him against the will of Erebor, and he was sure the king’s army was coming to carry him back to the mountain.
In the thin starlight he could see Sigrid twitching in the next bed, and then with a sharp gasp she awoke. He heard her sit up and swing her legs over the bed.
“New nightmares or old?” he asked. She raised her head, pushing her hair back from her face.
“Hard to say. It’s like memories, but not my memories. Since the dragon came, I feel like everything I dream is real, but not…” she shook her head. “Not our real. It’s hard to explain.”
He was still on top of the bedclothes, and he sat himself up against the wall. He patted the bed beside him and she crossed the gap in bare feet and stretched out along the mattress, pulling his blankets over herself, shivering and shuffling closer to his warmth.
“I’m sure the nightmares will pass with time,” Fili said. “I can’t sleep, do you mind if I smoke?”
“Go ahead,” she was lying on her back, staring into the shadows of the roof beams.
Fili packed his pipe and lit it. The match-flame shone red on their faces and then went out. He nudged her ribs through the blankets. “When you were in the dragon-spell, you said my name.”
Sigrid elbowed him back. “I saw a lot of strange things in the dragon-spell. It wasn’t romantic.”
“The real-but-not things?”
She nodded. “I know now that it was an enchantment, but his voice in my head was so persuasive. My home burned to ashes. The Greenwood poisoned and cut down, the stumps rotting. Erebor enslaved, its people forced to mine down to its crumbling roots by orcs with whips. Iron-shod armies covering the whole world. Some of it felt like omens, but some of it was things that I know never happened. Visions of the past: I saw the night Smaug first came, but it was different, in the dream Da wasn’t there to man the windlance when the mountain started rumbling. He was trapped in a cage and none of us could help him. So Smaug flew over and burned the town to nothing and then fell on it and crushed the ashes, and died for certain. The fire was everywhere, so many dead, and the dragon dead. And you were dead, too.”
“But I wasn’t even in Laketown when the dragon came out of the mountain,” Fili pointed out, waving his pipe. “So it’s just a dream.”
“Yes, that’s true,” Sigrid’s face was tense in the darkness, her gaze moving over the planes of the ceiling, trying to focus on shapes and figures that didn’t exist. “But everything was different. You looked different. You had a sword and armour and your voice sounded different, your accent, your… bearing. You looked like a storybook hero. And it all ended badly.”
Fili let her trail off, drawing on his pipe. He said at last, “I think I’ll stick with being a bookkeeper, then. If that’s my fate as a hero.”
“I don’t think it was the future. The dragon just showed me what was already there,” she said. “That I had all these silly worries about Da, and the town, and you dying.”
He took a long draw on his pipe, and asked softly, “Is that really why you’re rethinking my proposal? Because if I come and live a simple life with you, all those nightmares can’t come true?”
She wouldn’t meet his eye.
He pushed the guess further. “Because if I marry you, you think bad things won’t happen to me? It’s me in particular you’re worried about, isn’t it?”
She shivered. “I suppose it’s ironic. Chances are you’ll still be young and hale when they put me in the ground.” She looked at him and raised her hand, brushed the back of her knuckles against his leg. “Does that make it easier to decide? Because we won’t be forever, you’ll just be buying yourself time to grow up, really.”
He groaned. “That’s not a cheerful reason to get married, Sigrid.”
“I’m not cheerful. I’m Bard’s daughter,” she laughed. They sat without speaking for a while, and Fili realised soon that she was asleep again. He lay down on top of the blankets, facing the window to keep watch. At last he slept fitfully and awoke still safe in the Dale.
So Thorin had not tried to stop them after all.
—
The watchmen let them out the gate again without a fuss. They seemed bored, sitting on the wall staring at the empty valleys and the distant glimmer of the peaceful lake. It felt increasingly hard to believe there really was a war about to break upon their homes. Perhaps Tilda was right. Perhaps the armies had all given up and gone home.
The cart-rutted path from the Dale gate soon joined the wide, smooth road that led from the door of Erebor towards the lake, where it would turn away southwards to the countries beyond. They paused for a moment to drink and eat the last of their pilfered food from yesterday morning, since Dale had given them plenty for the trip, along with letters from the council to take to Bard. The sky was cloudless as it turned slowly towards the coming winter, the air cold but clear, with no smell of smoke or dragon-poison.
Kili and Tilda were already walking on; they had their heads together playing some kind of game, taking turns to pull gloomy faces at each other until the other person crowed with laughter.
Sigrid held out her hand to pull Fili to his feet. “They’re making fun of us.”
“They’ll be younger siblings forever,” Fili said mournfully. “There’s no cure.”
They hefted their packs, but as the others started down the road, Fili found his feet didn’t take a step. Sigrid waited, and then the others noticed and stopped.
“Are you alright?” Kili hollered from up ahead.
Sigrid took a couple of steps closer, slightly downhill from him. Fili reached out and took both her hands, pulling her in. She bent towards him and he kissed her. He didn’t know he was going to do it until he did it, and the shock of it ran through his body like a plunge into the freezing lake. This wasn’t where he’d ever have chosen, out here on the open road with the two shining cities at his back. They had always both kept their secrets so close, so private they had smothered them, but he knew it was his last chance. Maybe his only chance. Sigrid leaned into it and at last, in the same moment, they pulled apart.
Fili said in a rush, “After this war has passed, go build Bard’s new town. When you’re the new Master of two Esgaroths and I am the crown prince, we’ll make an alliance stronger than its parts. I have to go back.”
“I know,” she said, smiling, and added, “We both have to go back.”
She squeezed his hands one last time and stepped away.
Kili had guessed what Fili was about to do and was running back up the path. He reached Fili in a rush and threw himself at him, pressing his face into the rough wool of Fili’s ill-fitting jumper. Fili wrapped him up in his arms and stood with him for a moment.
“I changed my mind,” Kili croaked. “I don’t want to go back to the East. I belong with you. I want to help you. We can face the king together.”
“Good. I will need you,” Fili tightened his grip and mumbled into Kili’s uncombed hair, “You’ll be safe on the lake. Come join me when you’re ready.” He let his brother go slowly.
He stepped away, gave them a last glance, and walked back up the road towards the mountain.
—
Kili found the house and shop empty. The ashes in the belly of the stove were cold. The pantry was bare except for a jar of dried rosemary, one of salt, and a handful of apples, one of them beginning to grow an ugly, brown rot on its skin. The beds were unmade as they’d been the morning they left three nights ago. Kibil’s books were still on the shelf, but his clothes and boots were gone. His uncle had also taken their stock of silver and copper from the workshop lockroom, anything of value that could be carried.
Kili spent several days helping with the bridge and trying to catch up with promised work around the town. In that time, the Laketown workers put together a temporary structure across the gap, with ramps down to planks over clusters of low-set, splayed piles. The temporary structure did not have the grandeur of the ancient, oak columns of the old bridge but was solid enough. It would take people and goods by foot, and maybe small carts and ponies. Probably not the weight of a dragon.
The work kept his hands busy, and his mind turning over. He ate with Bard and the family every night, but slept in the house alone. Sleep came easy after a day’s labour, but he didn’t feel like he woke up refreshed. The cold and damp was rising off the lake as the autumn grew colder and deeper. Everything smelled of mould.
In a few days, messengers from the Greenwood and Erebor-Over-Dale came over the new bridge on horses, which pleased everyone who had built it. Bard looked as grim as he ever was that night, but wouldn’t talk to Kili and Tilda about what the messengers had said. After he went home, Kili heard the faint voices of him and Sigrid through the wall.
That night, Kili went down to the shop and packed up his woodworking tools. Kibil had taken a lot of the best pieces, especially the light ones, but Kili had his own favourites. He wrapped everything in spare cloth and stacked it carefully in a padded bag that was comfortable to sling over his shoulder. He made a quick repair of one boot and folded his oilskin coat on top of the bag, as it smelled like rain in the air.
He looked for anything Fili might want. A couple of sentimental hair-clasps, a watercolour of their father, a little folding knife from Rhûn that Fili always forgot when they went out and then complained about leaving behind. It was so little he could fit it all in a small bag hung on his belt. Their whole lives to this point, tucked away in one little bag.
In the morning he said goodbye to Bard and the rest of the family, handing Bard the keys to the house.
“You can sell anything that’s left,” he said. “Give the money to the militia’s armoury fund.”
Only Tilda laughed. Kili gave her a particularly warm smile and turned to go.
“Be careful,” Bard said, as he went down the steps. “The road to Erebor may not be open long.”
As he crossed the bridge, Kili paused for a moment and looked back at the town on the lake. Smoke columns rose and sat in the air above it, blending into a haze that drifted away down the lake. The swallows were gone now, as were the swifts and the martins, off to some far-southern home where it was warmer and richer, some to Rhûn and some to the farther sea. He felt a few drops of rain, and unhitched the bag so he could put on his coat.
The toolbag was heavy as he tried to lift it back onto his shoulders. He thought, what am I doing? There’s no wood in Erebor.
He slid the bag off his shoulder, reached out his arm, and dropped it off the bridge into the lake. It gave a satisfying smack as it hit the surface and the water closed over it in a moment, the lake pulling it down to join all the other secrets. Kili walked on towards the distant mountain.
