Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 13: Did isolation exacerbate Thorin's dragon sickness?

Chapter Text

murmuredlullabye asked: See this is fascinating because now I'm wondering if Thorin's goldsickness might have actually been more MANAGEABLE if they had given him the Arkenstone, reaffirming his trust in them and the fact that the Company supports him. One of the things therapists repeat over and over again when dealing with mental illness is the need for a string support network, which is exactly what Thorin couldn't believe he had.

THIS EXACTLY!

I can understand Balin’s fears. Perhaps he thought that with the Arkenstone in hand there’d be nothing to distract Thorin and he’d go into free-fall. Or perhaps he thought it would bring out a twisted and megalomaniacal streak that we see a glimpse of when Thorin denies aid to Bard. 

But then we get that line, “As if I were a mere dwarf lord, as if I were Thorin Oakenshield,” and my heart stops. Because there it is, this thing we’ve only been getting glimpses of since AUJ when Thorin cannot meet the eyes of those who show faith in him. Thorin is so touched by the loyalty of those who agree to follow him, even though you know he thinks they’re only there for their own wealth and self-interest. The thought they’d follow him at all with “loyalty, honor, and a willing heart” is clearly extremely meaningful to him and heavily implies it’s a rare thing, given the fact that he did not gain a single volunteer from the meeting of his kin and all but four members  (excluding Gandalf) of the Company are direct relatives of his. Bofur, Bifur, Bombur, and Bilbo are the only ones who are not members of the direct Line of Durin who agree to help. Balin is the only one making jokes about “Not the best, or brightest.” Thorin, for all that he is a legendary warrior from an exalted lineage, never makes a joke at the expense of the dwarves in the Company.

The problem of course is, since Thorin can’t believe that anyone would follow him on the quest for himself, but all rather out of self-interest in reclaiming Erebor, there’s going to be that whispering voice that says they all have an interest in the Arkenstone. To Balin and Dwalin it is absurdly obvious that no one would withhold the Arkenstone from Thorin, because to them Thorin has always been their king, and that’s a line they would never cross. But Thorin doesn’t intrinsically know that, he is actually shocked when Dwalin says “You have always been my king,” though to Dwalin the statement seems obvious. There’s a huge failure to communicate going on here, and it’s aggravated by the loss of the stone, and the dragon sickness, and the fact that Thorin has put so much off until he reclaims Erebor, only to have his judgement clouded once he’s there. 

Thorin desperately needed his support network once the dragon sickness descended. And lest we forget, it was Smaug who planted the idea in Bilbo’s head that giving the Arkenstone to Thorin would have a negative effect, and throughout Tolkien dragons are noted as using poisonous words to twist the minds of their victims and that was clearly happening there, as Smaug obviously does not have Thorin’s best interest in mind but is actually sowing conflict deliberately.