Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 14: Who was Thror before he came down with dragon sickness?

Chapter Text

Interesting point, but if you run with the idea that dragon sickness literally turns Thorin into the opposite of himself, in how it makes him abandon Dain and his armies, suspect his own family, and value hoarded gold over the lives of his people or other refugees, I wonder what we can construct of Thror? 

Because we see very little of Thror except when he’s under the dragon sickness, but perhaps we can reconstruct a glimpse of who he used to be if we assume the sickness essentially turns dwarves into dark mirrors of themselves.

- Hoarding gold —-> Generous? There was much talk of gold flowing out from Erebor, making Dale prosperous amongst others. So we may be able to assume that before he got sick, Thror was extremely generous with his vast wealth. 

- Refusing the gems/Breaking contracts —–> Extremely devoted to keeping his word? We may be able to assume that if Thranduil gave the gems to be set in a necklace, and Thror refused to give them back or raised the price before returning them, that Thranduil assumed at one point that Thror was trustworthy enough to give the gems to in the first place. For example, if Thror was particularly noted for keeping his word, which makes sense for the great king of a great kingdom. 

- A hatred of elves —–> open to dealing with other races? We can also assume he refused to give Thranduil the gems out of a hatred for elves. This could be a transformation from being a person who overlooked race, which is also in evidence from the alliances Thror forged with Mirkwood and Dale in the first place. 

- Putting his family in danger at Azanulbizar —-> overly protective of family? If we assume that losing the mountain did NOT cure Thror of dragon sickness, then the bid to reclaim Moria could have been part of his greed. The deleted scene of Thorin talking about fireflies refers to a very isolated and insular life, where the heirs were fiercely protected by Thror, perhaps even forbidden to leave the mountain. That may have changed over time, with dragon sickness making Thror willing to throw away the lives even of his closest kin, who once he would not even allow into any kind of danger. After all, his line being secure in his son and grandson was a huge point of pride for him, especially since we know Thror lost his brother and father in the Grey Mountains to dragons. This also jives well with what we see of Thorin’s illness and “life is cheap” if we assume dragon sickness imposes some similar changes on similar people. 

- Conclusion? So what does that leave us with - the transformation of a generous, gregarious person who did not see race and freely traded with them, who was obsessed with the safety of his family, dedicated and driven, capable of founding one of the wealthiest kingdoms in Middle Earth and sharing the wealth to promote their neighbors in the region. A person that dwarves like Thorin and Balin would look up to unquestioningly and idolize, someone even Elrond could admire, and Thranduil do business with. Someone who built up Dale as well as Erebor. So when things began to sour, there was such a buildup of admiration but also of faith, that no one could believe that the person they’d known to be so wise for centuries could ever break and become the opposite. If we look at Thorin under the dragon sickness though, and who he became, essentially the opposite of who he once was, then perhaps we can see who Thror was too.