Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 15: Did Dragon Sickness Directly Invert Thorin's Personality?

Chapter Text

But man, baggvinshield‘s post about Thorin being overt about his romantic feelings for Bilbo under the influence of dragon sickness really has me thinking (such a good post btw). Because I did a post not long ago that postulates that dragon sickness doesn’t just change one aspect of dwarves it infects, but it actually turns them inside-out as far as their personalities go. Like, every trait they had before is essentially reversed. I did a post about what we can deduce about Thror’s personality if we assume this to be the case (so like, he’s greedy now, which means that once he was generous).

But what does this say about Thorin in regards to Bilbo?

- Quickly gonna say, I don’t think dragon sickness made feelings for Bilbo where there were none, it’s not that kind of reversal. Rather, it’s changing his behavior in revealing it, and that behavior says a lot. 

- I think the dragon sickness attacks Thorin’s ego primarily, basically giving him one where there wasn’t any before. So Thorin having delusions of grandeur, seeing the kingship as something that makes him untouchable in his authority, something that he flaunts with rich clothing meanwhile ignoring the plight of his people, those are all things Thorin on his own would never do. We have a lot of evidence to back that up: the fact that once he breaks free he switches to fairly simple clothes, the fact that he’s primarily concerned with the feelings of the Comany in regards to him as his first priority once he snaps out of it, the fact that all his arrogance about being king (”I am your king!”) is basically snuffed out immediately and that he throws away the crown. My point is - we have other actions he took under dragon sickness as examples of just how much the illness didn’t just change his behavior, but actually inverted it to the polar opposite. 

So how does he behave towards Bilbo under dragon sickness?

- Not making him look for the Arkenstone or be an active member of the Quest.  - “Sober” Thorin did not single out Bilbo for special treatment or remove his responsibilities (”We send the lightest first” “I will not risk this Quest for the life of one burglar.”) That may seem harsh and un-romantic, but witness too that Thorin turned Kili, his own kin, away from the Quest when he presented a risk to it. Thorin doesn’t put his loved ones before Erebor. Not until Erebor is reclaimed does he apologize profusely for all all the actions he had to take to get it back, heavily implying that he wishes he didn’t have to take them but too bound up in honor to do otherwise (”I am sorry I led you into such peril” is not spoken until after he is certain he succeeded). So essentially, dragon sickness stops Thorin’s natural instinct not to give his loved ones special treatment which is a good quality for a leader to have, and one the dragon sickness undermined. 

- Assuming that Bilbo will stay in Erebor - “This gold is ours and ours alone,”, having Bilbo with him on the dais, and my own belief that parting with the mithril shirt did not represent “parting with a single coin” because he didn’t see giving it to Bilbo as giving it away. This leads me to believe that “sober”, Thorin would be very cautious about making such an assumption. And we have evidence of this with “Go back to your books, your armchair and your garden.” On his own, with a clear mind, Thorin assumes that Bilbo will want to go home after all this is over and encourages him to do so. Only under the sickness is it revealed that he may wish it to be otherwise, only the sickness I think gives him the confidence to make this assumption. I would say that in his heart of hearts, Thorin may wish Bilbo would stay, but he would never presume to force him and only under the sickness would he assume that what he wants will happen. Because on his own Thorin almost never assumes what he wants will happen (without costing him his life see: Erebor and Azog’s death).

- Thorin is unable to see his own flaws under dragon sickness - witness his confusion whenever someone brings up that “he is changed.” This leads me to believe that he has a very heightened awareness of his own flaws naturally, and tragically this is one reason that dragon sickness probably feels good, and therefore is more difficult to escape. It’s like a drug in that respect. Normally, Thorin would hear others pointing out his flaws and listen - see his expression when Elrond talks about the dragon sickness. See the way he evades praise when Balin gives his speech about Azanulbizar, or Dwalin in Lake-town where he looks reluctant to step forward. We can assume that normally he would take criticism from Bilbo very seriously (see his expression in the Misty Mountains when Bilbo said he was right to say Bilbo didn’t belong there), and actually under the sickness he wavers and begins to consider Bilbo’s words and looks like he might snap free.

- Ignoring Bilbo’s advice under dragon sickness - see “Do as he says” in the Mirkwood Dungeons, or even his look of realization with the trolls when Thorin understands Bilbo’s plan. Yet at the gate when Bilbo says they can’t possibly fight because they’re outnumbered, Thorin brushes his concerns aside and acts as if he knows better. So right there we see that on his own Thorin would take Bilbo’s advice extremely seriously, and had he been sober in that instance he most likely would have appealed to Bilbo for a plan on how to deal with the army at their doorstep. 

- Being super flirty with Bilbo under dragon sickness - just going back, but that look he gives Bilbo at “never underestimate dwarves” is SO flirtatious, I cannot believe. Also the mithril shirt itself could be seen as a blazing gesture of his regard. Whereas, on his own Thorin would probably be much more quiet about his love, saying it with looks rather than speeches or gestures, as he does in the acorn scene and at their farewell. His love is usually in his eyes in soft looks, rather than open flirtation. (I’d like to imagine Thorin as basically drunk in that instance and ifwhen he got better he definitely had a moment of Oh Mahal please tell me I didn’t do that last night help I’m so embarrassed why)

- Controlling Bilbo’s movements/manhandling Bilbo at all - Thorin once cured is very open with how much he wants Bilbo to be free to return to his own life. Only under the sickness does he try to control his movements, or manhandle him, or lay hands upon him. Again, I think that means we can safely assume that no matter how far Thorin could be “pushed” while sober and sane he would never lay hands on Bilbo or presume to drag him away from the Company or otherwise do more than verbally request he do something (”Master Baggins, I suggest you keep up” after Rivendell). Caveat to this being Thorin’s responsibilities as leader of the Company, where he will give orders but only in that capacity and out of necessity for their to be a central leader. He never presumes to ask others to do things just for himself, not even when he kept Kili away (where I got the sense that on his own he understood and wanted Kili to come, but he even frames it to Fili as “when you are king, you will understand” which clearly shows that this was an order he gave as a leader, and not as a family member. See point 1). 

I can’t think of any other particular examples off the top of my head, and obviously this is only my own take, but it does have me thinking a lot about how Thorin and Bilbo would advance their relationship after, and who Thorin would be now with his awareness of himself under dragon sickness, and knowing that oh god he blew it he was way more obvious than he meant to be, oh Mahal please let the ground rise up and swallow him whole, but only after he’s done looking softly at Bilbo with his heart in his eyes