Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 16: What if Thrain had Lived?

Chapter Text

I think Thrain would go into sensory overload if he was dropped into the middle of the Arkenstone Debacle/Battle of Five Armies issues. He may no longer be mad from Sauron’s torture but he is deeply traumatized and probably still has issues telling reality from illusion. 

I think one on one he could do some good. I think he could remind Thranduil of his obligations, but honestly I doubt Thorin was the only one with that strong a reaction to Thranduil’s betrayal of their alliance, and I doubt that Thrain could get results now if he couldn’t before.

Thrain would be most useful in helping Thorin. If Thorin could be convinced that Thrain is really there, it may even help break him out of the dragon sickness. For one thing, he may not even technically be king at that point, but more importantly I think Thrain could give Thorin forgiveness he desperately needs - assurance that he has done well, that he doesn’t need to throw his life away on Erebor, that he did not fail his father (Thrain I think would have been horrified if Thorin showed up at Dol Guldur looking for him). 

I don’t think Thrain could be an effective leader or politician at this point, nor that he should be forced to take on that role. I think he’s seen too much. But as a support and pillar of trust and love for Thorin I think he could quite literally have single-handedly resolved a lot of the issues Thorin had under dragon sickness (with having no one he could trust) and help dispel a lot of Thorin’s traumas as well for the better. I don’t think it’s a stretch, for example, that Thrain would caution Thorin yet again against taking on Azog alone, and even if Bilbo was absent he’d have a voice of reason encouraging him to, for example, take a larger force to challenge the Pale Orc and perhaps even, for example, leave Fili and Kili behind (as Thrain tried to do with Thorin all those years ago).

Part 2

madametortilla asked: I'm really curious to read about your meta regarding an AU where Gandalf saves Thráin and brings him back to Thorin (in Erebor) during the the siege of Erebor. Thorin would be flabbergasted, to say the least.

OH MAN OH MAN

Sometimes I can’t even think about what would have happened if Thorin saw Thrain again because I get SO. EMOTIONAL. 

Quite honestly, I think it would have been enough to snap Thorin out of dragon sickness. Forget the Arkenstone, which he tried to pretend was a trick, this would mess him up but in a positive way. If it’s during the wall scene he would definitely pull the whole, “This is a trick!” thing but he would definitely waver too. Thrain would look very different after all.

However, there is no way in hell that Thrain would allow himself to be used as a hostage against Thorin, and it would speak poorly of Thranduil, Bard, and Gandalf if they allowed that to happen. Thrain would do everything in his power to get to his son’s side, especially if he saw the marks of dragon sickness on him. 

But let’s examine this for a moment! Because a lot of what dragon sickness targets would be resolved by having Thrain around.

- Thorin’s position as king. Perhaps the dodgiest as far as him possibly reacting badly, but having Thrain around does somewhat throw Thorin’s claim to the throne into question, since Thrain was the Crown Prince and not him. One thing I get really emotional about is the fact that Thorin crowning himself indicates that, one way or the other, he has given up on his father being alive. 

- Thorin’s belief that he must reclaim Erebor is, in my opinion, based on what he sees as the “final words” of his father and grandfather. I truly believe that a huge part of his obsession is his belief he’s carrying out their legacy. After all, the battle at Moria was meant to gain a new homeland for the exiled dwarves of Erebor, that both fell in the taking of it means that the last thing Thorin knew of them was that they wanted to get a home back. We learn later that Thrain under no circumstances wants Thorin to go back to Erebor. Thrain being able to clarify this would have a profound impact on Thorin. He may still wish to reclaim Erebor for his own reasons, but it would no longer be relying on the belief that he’s doing it in Thrain’s name. 

- Thorin’s isolation. One problem that the dragon sickness is clearly causing is isolating Thorin from the others on the belief they stole they Arkenstone. Thrain clearly could not have taken it, so immediately Thorin gains an ally and confidante that he can trust, which can only do good things for him. 

- Thorin as an orphan. Thorin is clearly profoundly hurt by the loss of his family members. This causes its own isolation, where all the other members of the Company have a brother on their status level to relate to. Yes he has his nephews, but he’s in charge of them. Having his father around gives Thorin someone he can lean on, which will do wonders for his health in my opinion. 

- Thorin as the bearer of every responsibility. There is no one who can tell Thorin he’s working too hard, or that he’s not well, without breaking the status hierarchy. As his father, even if he’s not king, Thrain can bypass all of that in private and give Thorin orders on self-care that no one else has the authority to give. 

- Thorin’s insecurities. A huge part of Thorin’s sense of inadequacy before the Quest began was his inability to find his father. Having Thrain back, even if he didn’t save him, would soothe a part of him that has been suffering since Azanulbizar. In this one thing, at least, he was not wrong. Thrain is alive, and has returned. He’ll get a new sense of inadequacy that he wasn’t the one to save Thrain, but this can be mitigated by Thrain’s living presence. 

- Thorin’s dragon sickness. Something of a reiteration of all the previous points, but I truly do believe Thrain could snap Thorin out of dragon sickness. If the sickness feeds on isolation and a sense of inadequacy made up for by his kingship and worldly possessions, Thrain can serve as an antidote and voice of reason for all of those, soothing Thorin’s sense of self-worth, helping to get him away from the gold, and also being a trustworthy voice because he cannot have stolen the Arkenstone, or even if he had it would be because Thrain has a greater right to it than even Thorin does. I can see the dragon sickness trying to convince Thorin that Thrain is a threat with his greater right to kingship, but Thorin being far too overjoyed at the return of his father to pay any attention to that impulse. 

I just… there needs to be more Everyone Lives AU where Thrain is alive, but I almost can’t do it myself because of how painfully joyful it would be for Thorin, especially at his lowest moment under dragon sickness. Thrain could, in my opinion, have saved the day had he been there.