Chapter Text
With regards to Thorin's quote in Desolation of Smaug "I have the only right," and how it contrasts with his later statement in Erebor, "I have no right to ask this of any of you." Seen here: http://avelera.tumblr.com/post/108049236755/boromirs-thorin-in-dos-v-thorin-in-botfa
I’ve seen a posts that regard this transition as character development, but to me it’s not that at all, it’s actually very consistent characterization throughout.
In the first gif, Thorin is being questioned on his right to enter the mountain. As the heir to the kingdom, and an extension of the line of Durin, Thorin is speaking what he believes to be the truth. (Never mind what Bard is saying, essentially barring Thorin from returning to his own ancestral home in much the same way the hobbits tried to bar Bilbo from Bag End.) Thorin’s self-doubt has never manifested itself in any doubt towards the rights of his lineage and the pride of his people.
Where Thorin’s self-doubt manifests is his right to ask anything of anyone as a person, as Thorin Oakenshield. That’s what’s happening in the second gif. Thorin has cast off the kingship at this point, he’s thrown away his crown and come before the Company as only himself, not as an extension of the line of Durin or as the heir of Thror. He’s asking them to help him redeem his own person by coming with him into battle. He's not commanding them as their king to do so. Thorin truly believes he has no right to ask people who have followed him across the world to follow him now into battle, because he truly believes no one would ever follow him if not for his right and ancestry.
This is a huge part of the tragedy of his character. When Dain cries for the dwarves to rally around their king, when the Company follows Thorin into battle, when the tide turns because Thorin has joined it, it’s because he is king. Not because of lineage or right, but because he is everything a king should be. Except Thorin cannot see that, cannot understand it. He does not see himself as worthy of kingship, only an extension of a far greater person, his grandfather, against whom he is only a pale shadow by comparison, at least in his own mind.
This is what makes Bilbo’s, “To me he was never that,” so poignant, and why the dwarves are elevating Thorin into legend. To them, they are showing in death that he was their king in his own right, a legend in his own right, even if he could not see it. But to Bilbo, he was always a person of his own, and a friend, and I think in some ways that was the greatest gift he could ever give Thorin, who in all his life was never able to separate himself from all the expectations upon him, except in Bilbo’s eyes.
