Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 18: Does Thorin view his epithet Oakenshield as shameful?

Chapter Text

castellan-garak asked: i totally dig the 'thorin takes bilbo's last name' headcanon, but i was wondering why you said he thinks oakenshield is shameful? that was in botfa when he was dragon sick & talking to dwalin, right? he said his epithet like it was something dirty, but i didn't understand why

I may be over-extrapolating on it, which is always possible, but the fact is that his voice is broken and he’s clearly sobbing or on the edge of tears when he says, 

“Do not speak to me as if I were some lowly dwarf lord… as if I were still Thorin Oakenshield… I am your king!”

Even if you don’t read self-loathing into that line there’s definitely some disassociation going on just from the wording and use of the third person. That’s the most mild interpretation. I personally think it’s something much deeper, the fault line of something that’s been eating at Thorin since Azanulbizar that has only been given voice in the desperation and confusion of dragon sickness. Any way you read it, his identity as Oakenshield is associated with “lowly”. Not a king, but just one of many dwarven nobility carrying no greater significance.

I’ve expounded on it exhaustively elsewhere in other meta - but in an attempt to make a long story short: 

1) Being a king is clearly better than being Thorin Oakenshield 2) Thorin Oakenshield was an identity he had since the day his grandfather and brother died and his father went missing (not to mention various uncles and cousins died if one considers Fundin at the very least). 3) He gained that name avenging the brutal murder of his grandfather, presumably by killing Azog 4) In Richard’s own words, that’s the moment where he became the Thorin we know. His fighting style before that is skilled by a bit juvenile and all over the place. He becomes a driven and contained fighter from that point on as part of his physical identity (so it’s a significant moment) 5) In AUJ he discovers that Azog is still alive, his grandfather is therefore unavenged, his family is once again at risk from a driven psychopath AND, if he understands any Black Speech, that Azog had a hand in personally torturing Thrain while Thorin was unawares. 6) He loses the oak shield in the battle, both literally and figuratively losing his right to that name. 7) Presumably, that name was the basis of most of Thorin’s positive image of himself. Even if he counted Ered Luin as a poor replacement for Erebor, even if he was a failure in other ways, at least he had avenged his grandfather and gained a warrior’s title. Not so much anymore.  

I think Thorin associates the name Oakenshield with all of the suffering in his life. It recalls a dark day in his past, a day where he lost everything even if he earned some respect. But clearly I think he would rather have the throne of Erebor as he was intended to have it rather than lose his grandfather and undergo all that suffering. In a way, becoming King represents a break from the suffering in his life, the accomplishment of his goal. Under any other circumstances it would be a joyous and quite possibly healthy move to make that distinction. IE, I don’t think under healthy circumstances like picking up a new epithet (for example, seeing marrying Bilbo and gaining the name Baggins with it as a proud moment and a turning point in his life) would necessarily be unhealthy for him to cast off Oakenshield and pick up a new name. Especially if he sees “Oakenshield” as “lowly”. The problem is that he puts all his pride in being king and keeps none for the person he used to be which is clearly not healthy. 

Ugh, man I could go on with this forever but tl;dr - I think there’s a lot of trauma attached to the name Oakenshield, bad memories and good things too with the respect he earned (but didn’t earn because it was a lie until he finally killed Azog for good). I think even when Thorin comes back to himself and feels secure once more in his identity as Thorin Oakenshield and not the king (and perhaps even abdicates the throne, which I believe he did when he threw away the crown) - I think it would not necessarily be unhealthy for Thorin to take on a new epithet and a new identity as he embarks on a new and healthier life. I don’t think Oakenshield should be cast away, but if Silmarillion has taught us anything it’s that people can have an absolutely endless list of nicknames for all their accomplishments.

But, as a side note, Bilbo couldn’t take Oakenshield anyway because it’s not a last name it’s a title. Thorin does not have a last name.