Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 19: Did Thorin abdicate the throne?

Chapter Text

experimentalpotion asked: "He had thrown away the crown, Dwalin had said, why would you put it back?" This made me think of "Will you follow me one last time?" So if Thorin threw away the crown, that meant he really was abdicating the throne? And his words with following him one last time support that? Cause once he is not a king, he will really have no right to ask them to follow him once more, cause he will be just a simple mortal. BTW, thanks for the snippet and effective breaking of my heart! Well done!

Sorry for the heartbreak >.< (This is the fic they’re referring to)

I truly believe Thorin abdicated the throne in his own mind when he threw away the crown. It makes the most sense when you consider the words, “I have no right to ask this of you,” because he has effectively thrown away that right. Thorin has never had an issue commanding the dwarves as king and heir of Thrór, his difficulty extends when he’s acting as only Thorin and when he has nothing to offer them in return. Or so he believes, now that the mountain is claimed I don’t think he believes the dwarves of the company have any further reason to follow him.

Dwalin is the only one who would have possibly seen Thorin before and after, and put together that Thorin threw away his crown. He’s the only one who might connect that Thorin didn’t want to be king anymore, especially when you consider he went up to Ravenhill by himself, or just with Fíli, Kíli, and Dwalin, and then took steps to make sure Fíli and Kíli got out of there (*sob*). That is not the action of a king with a kingdom to rule, but of an individual trying to make up for his past mistakes of letting Azog live. He could very well have sent Fíli and Kíli away when it got dangerous because he intended them to follow as kings. 

However, Dain does not know of this, and Thorin never said with words that he no longer saw himself as King under the Mountain, so I feel it would be natural considering the whole, “To the king!” and the fact that even Gandalf says, “They’re rallying to their king,” for outsiders to still see Thorin as a king, and style him as one after his death. It would be an intensely personal and not widely advertised matter that he did not think of himself as one in his final hours, and may have even resisted the crown and the title had he been able to. That styling him as a king would be against his wishes, and perhaps bordering on an insult because of the great battle he fought to throw off the sickness. I feel like only those who knew Thorin very well in those final hours would make this connection, but of course they would only be small voices amongst all those who wished to honor Thorin Oakenshield, and likely drowned out. Hence too why I believe Bilbo’s words about, “That’s how you choose to honor him,” is his very polite way of not interfering with dwarven matters, but ultimately choosing not to partake in a ceremony that honor Thorin as a king, because that’s not what he would have wanted. He’s going off to mourn Thorin alone as an individual, as his friend or maybe more, because that’s how Bilbo chooses to honor him.