Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 20: Did Thorin deserve to die?

Chapter Text

Anonymous asked: Your post was interesting and I'm nervous weighing in so let me know if you want me to send a private message, but I did want to add it's commonly accepted that Thorin can be dick, sometimes it becomes all he ever is, and maybe parts of the narrative contributes? Ppl see Elrond as the smart one nobody listens to, so his comments about Thorin aren't seen as wrong. Thorin dies so the common opinion is that it was narrative punishment. Bilbo's flaws are ignored bc he's seen as just innocent.

Yeah no those opinions are definitely around! But I’d say this:

- Thorin can be dickish, and Thorin also dies, but it seems bluntly ignorant to say that those two things are directly related. A character can die without it being a result of their flaws, unless this is a hyper-simplistic morality tale (and therefore boring as fuck). Thorin had a richly complex life and died facing a shadow of his past, but if people see A led to B led to C led to D and assume that means A = D then that’s their loss. Not to mention, Azog had nothing to do with dragon sickness??

- Elrond says “Men are weak” “Dwarves care nothing for the troubles of others” voices outright skepticism of the hobbits succeeding in the Quest. He was right about Isildur and jaded as a result, but wrong about Aragorn (and admits it), right to be careful of the dragon and to be concerned Thorin would fall to dragon sickness, but voiced no belief at all that they could overcome these threats (so again, he was wrong). There’s a difference between a character being wise vs. all-knowing, and the latter is frankly boring. Elrond can be an overall good person and still dislike or be uncertain about other good people that he’s never met before. 

- Bilbo being innocent - I’m going to laugh for a thousand more years at this. Bilbo is grouchy, snarky, brave, caring, clever and also a thief and a liar. He was as much a part of the narrative as Thorin and the two are well matched in their mix of bad and good qualities. Why he gets polarized to this perfect little angel is so baffling to me on so many levels, but if people choose to ignore them there’s not much I can or should do about that *shrugs*