Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 21: Was Thorin's death redemptive?

Chapter Text

Anonymous asked: Sorry, I'm not even sure how to articulate my point lol. I don't think dragonsickness is exactly like a real mental illness (I can see Thorin having depression, he reads exactly like a victim of trauma since that's what happened) but I know some people like me could relate to the feeling. But since it's the wise characters like Gandalf or elves saying it, it's taken as him proving them right. And he dies anyway, so even if he believes he needs to die to redeem himself, it's not challenged.

1) Totally agree re: Thorin’s potential for depression. Thorin without dragon sickness has definite signs of being a victim of trauma, possible signs of depression, and clear examples of a low sense of self-worth. I tend to read this as “nurture” rather than “nature” based, as in a result of his experiences, but other very articulate fan writers ( like madamefaust) have speculated that he may have a family predisposition to depression, insomnia, etc. Either way, I’ve only ever seen this point respectfully treated by fans and, arguably, by the creators ie Richard Armitage’s character building. 

2) I agree that wise characters in LotR/Hobbit can often come across as “Word of God”, but I would point out that they are just as often proven wrong. Elrond claims “Men are weak” and skepticism about hobbits on the quest, and is proven wrong and admits to being wrong, he also claims that dwarves care nothing for the troubles of others and is directly contradicted by Gimli joining the Quest not a day later, and even in that face of that contradiction continues to be petty by barely acknowledging the Dwarves. These characters are not all-knowing, they have histories and opinions and prejudices just like any other character and as Gandalf also says, “Even the very wise cannot see all ends.” Elrond voices concerns about Thorin’s apparent hereditary illness but he does not state that Thorin will fall, he asks Gandalf’s opinion and Gandalf voices his support that Thorin has every right to pursue this quest, and will likely justifiably do so even without Gandalf’s help. By the time Gandalf voices his concerns about dragon sickness to Bilbo about Thorin’s health, it’s after Thorin is demonstrably ill, and after Bilbo has effectively betrayed Thorin’s trust. Gandalf is saying that after this act, it would be foolish for Bilbo to return to Thorin’s side and if anything, Bilbo pronounces unequivocal faith and trust in Thorin. What he wasn’t ready for was just how much the illness had changed Thorin’s natural behavior and it is presented as an aberration, not who Thorin really is. There’s constant evidence that this illness turns Thorin effectively inside-out. 

Tl;dr: wise characters are constantly shown to be wrong in the Middle Earth world, and Thorin’s case was no different.

3) I really, truly, do not believe Thorin’s death was his moment of redemption. This was: 

Thorin’s willingness to fight redeemed him, and it’s constantly reinforced that this is what Thorin would naturally do on his own, because he is noble and courageous. His kin like Dain and Kili vocally state their confusion when he doesn’t join the battle immediately. This is Thorin as he naturally is. Now, Thorin may believe himself unredeemable because of his bout of illness, much in the same way Boromir is ashamed for briefly succumbing to the Ring’s call. Their shame may jointly lead to a lack of self-preservation due to despair, but again, both set out to fight to redeem themselves, not die to redeem themselves or they could simply have fallen on their swords immediately. Joining a battle does not automatically mean going to one’s death, especially for such skilled warriors. 

I’d say Thorin’s belief in his need to die is directly challenged when Bilbo says, “Don’t you dare!” Bilbo is arguably the person who has suffered the most from Thorin’s illness, arguably the person who has the most right to wish Thorin ill, and he immediately rejoins Thorin side, is immediately joyful to see Thorin recover, and vehemently denies his death or the need for his death. He is clearly broken by Thorin’s death, and we also see Thorin’s despair let up immediately when he sees Bilbo, both when they reunite on Ravenhill (where Thorin immediately calls a retreat, saying they should live to fight another day) and by the joy on his face at Bilbo’s reassurance that it was all worth it. I see no evidence that Thorin’s death was anything but a tragedy and a senseless loss, except insofar as he fought nobly to defend his people from Azog and gave his life to that cause and that was not senseless. However he did not give his life to dragon sickness, or mental illness, but rather to something he believed was worth dying for, a shadow that had haunted his family and led to many deaths he needed to avenge. 

Part 2

Insofar as Thorin “needed” redemption, I think he got it the moment he came charging out the gate with the other dwarves behind him. I think that’s one reason Richard fixates so much on that moment: it’s the real moment where Thorin was comfortable in himself again. He made up for his failures towards his kin, he’s actively defending his home, and he’s proud in a way that doesn’t depend on the gold or the kingship. 

He had lingering doubts though, especially in his treatment of Bilbo. That’s why the relief is so palpable when Bilbo comes to warn him. With a glance they establish that all is forgiven and they are on the same side once again. Then Thorin gets slammed by his past again, and those wounds are ripped open all over again. From that point, I don’t think we’re dealing with the dragon sickness fallout anymore. Rather, we’re dealing with the very failures that made dragon sickness so seductive. 

Because what was Thorin’s weakness when it came to dragon sickness? Being a mere dwarf lord, “Thorin Oakenshield”. I will forever argue that the reason Thorin didn’t snap out of dragon sickness sooner is because it felt good. It gave him self confidence and a sense of power he’d never had before. His identity was now based on being king and possessing the gold, rather than on all the failures he’d suffered. Even if Thorin knew he was sick, it was hard to go from literally being high on self-confidence he’d never had before to the painful memories of being Thorin Oakenshield. It was wrenching to go back to that, and acknowledge that being king in this fashion was just another of his many mistakes, and one he’d have to make up for. 

What clarity and confidence Thorin had in pulling free of dragon sickness and regaining Bilbo was lost when the wound that made him who he was was reopened with Fili’s death. The name Thorin Oakenshield is clearly not an exalted one for him, it represents all the suffering he’s undergone. What’s worse, it now represents an even bigger failure, because he gained it for killing Azog and he was tricked into believing Azog was dead. Now he has to make up for that, but it’s already too late and he’s lost even more. It’s why he can’t look away from the body floating beneath the ice, he has to see Azog dead with his own eyes this time. 

So Thorin has three things he needs redemption for before he can feel peace. 

1) The death Azog, which was the basis of his fame and ultimately a lie. More importantly, he must see an end to this threat to his family, and make up for those he could not save. 

2) Reclaiming Erebor, which has become the driving purpose of his life. 

3) Apologizing to Bilbo and gaining his forgiveness as the person who suffered the most from Thorin’s bout of dragon sickness. 

Thorin accomplished these all before his death, but his peace does not come from his death nor was it a requirement of his redemption. He was already redeemed the minute he came out the doors of Erebor with the Company. I would argue, based on their willingness to charge out with him, that he did not need it even then except in his own mind.