Chapter Text
experimentalpotion asked: I have a feeling that when Thorin was telling Bilbo "Go back to your books and armchair. Plant a tree…” Well I guess these were the last things Bilbo wanted at all in that moment, and maybe his thoughts were: to the hell with books and armchair! I want you to live! I want you to stay! Like Thorin was sending him home with these words, but maybe Bilbo on the contrary wanted to STAY. Cause when he returns to the shire, there are no books and cosy armchair, he finds an empty hole in the ground(
Yeah, I think that’s absolutely true. There’s a LOT going on in that short conversation (which I’m still too emotionally devastated to re-watch outside of gif form).
Bilbo was absolutely saying to hell with the books and armchair if it meant Thorin living. He saw a whole world open up and then crumble in the space of a few (final) breaths with the realization of how much Thorin loved him and how much he loved Thorin in return.
Thorin in return knew what was coming and wanted to part knowing that Bilbo was happy. He remembered Bilbo’s speech *very* clearly, word for word, and wanted happiness for Bilbo. However, I almost found his particular choices very telling. Because he could have also told Bilbo to take his share of the treasure and go home, or some other parting words that indicated what he wanted for Bilbo, and what ‘happiness’ meant to him. It also modified the books for “food and cheer”, so it’s deliberate. I truly believe Thorin named all the things that represented happiness to him at that moment of realization: Bilbo’s home, the things Bilbo treasures, and the acorn that will grow into the tree representing Bilbo’s memories of him. I really think in his final moments, having accomplished his quest, Thorin and Bilbo had undergone a reversal. Bilbo wanted something heroic and larger than life - he wanted Thorin in his life, and Erebor, and to hell with the Shire. And for Thorin, Erebor had become a dark and blood-soaked place. What he longed for was home, and peace, and Bilbo in his life. Failing that, he wanted to die knowing that Bilbo was happy, not truly understanding how impossible that would be for Bilbo without him in it.
I think Thorin’s encouragement for Bilbo to go home is what really drives him there, rather than any desire on his own part. That, and with the terrible weight of that grief I think he went home to see if his books and armchair and garden would truly cure it. I don’t think they did, but he had to try for Thorin’s sake and because that was the last thing Thorin asked. In that regard too, Bilbo became far more like Thorin over the course of his quest: noble, brave, a fighter, someone seeking home, on a superficial level clad in blue, and most importantly, someone who lives by the dying words of others. Thorin lived to reclaim Erebor on behalf of Thror and Thrain, people who could never take back the request and who could not see how that goal was tearing Thorin apart. Had they known, I think Thror would have taken it back, we *know* Thrain did, they both would have told Thorin to give up on Erebor (in a way that Balin can’t, because Thorin is responding to the final words of his forefathers, words that can never be taken back).
Likewise, Bilbo in his final moments on screen is like Thorin at his darkest ones. He’s regained a home that has become a place of loss and madness, with only a golden object for company that is slowly driving him insane, and the reason he even “wants” this home is because of the dying words of another person. If Thorin had known how miserable Bag End would make Bilbo, I don’t think for a second he would have sent Bilbo back there. Like Erebor for Thorin, Bilbo is encouraged to return to Bag End because dead loved ones believe it’s what’s best for them, not able to take those words back when confronted by the reality of the misery those “homes” now embody.
… This just became a really long rambling parallel on Bilbo and Thorin, but long story short, YES I completely agree Bilbo wanted to stay during the death scene, and to hell with Bag End.
