Chapter Text
Ok, at this point I know I’m kinda well known as a Thorin junky and I spend 90% of my time agonizing over that big lump of dumb dwarf king, but I’d hate to think that Bilbo has fallen by the wayside.
So as I’ve said exhaustively in a couple posts, I see Thorin as someone who is externally grounded, as in his sense of stability and self-worth is based outwardly on the opinion of others. His pride is in the dwarves as a race, and the line of Durin, rather than his own accomplishments (since he does not recognize those, or does not count them as noteworthy in the absence of reclaiming Erebor). Love for others makes him shine,
isolation leaves him in shadows.
In contrast, though not to over-simplify either of them since they both have elements of each, Bilbo is fairly grounded in himself. He is, in his own words:
and he actually uses that to ground himself in moments of agitation (contrast with Thorin and “I am not my grandfather" in moments of extreme stress). Bilbo doesn’t fret about his identity or his responsibilities. He doesn’t need to prove himself to be worthy of anything. While he’d like to be thought fierce as far as adventure goes, he could take it or leave it and still be a whole person. You can leave him alone in his house and while he won’t be the best person he can be, he will not be lost in the way that I think Thorin would be.
By Richard’s own admission, Thorin was an ember burning low before the quest began and had he not gone on the quest the lack of activity probably would have had him suffer a spiritual death if not a physical one. Bilbo’s spiritual death was also threatening, but it would have been MUCH longer in coming by languishing at Bag End.
So Bilbo is good for Thorin because he grounds him in something solid that is based on who Thorin is rather than what Thorin represents, a rarity in Thorin’s life.
But since this is about Bilbo, not Thorin, let’s add this: While Bilbo plants Thorin, Thorin brings Bilbo out into the world.
On his own, the stability that keeps Bilbo healthy and stable would also see him atrophy. Gandalf was not wrong that Bilbo had to move before he started to grow moss. Thorin as a wanderer since his youth in exile, as a warrior, as a figure of legend and a questing hero, is the living embodiment of the figures in Bilbo’s books and maps. He is adventure. He is also stabilized by other people, and he shows Bilbo how to derive life and actualization from being around others. There wouldn’t be a Thorin without a Bilbo, but equally there would be no Bilbo (as we know him) without Thorin.
Ironically, Richard (paraphrased) said we saw Thorin at his happiest at Bag End (X). One could extrapolate that to: we see Thorin at his best at Bag End, on fire and ready to take on the world based on his ideals.
In general, we see Thorin at his best when he’s contemplating home.
By contrast, we see Bilbo at his best when he stops thinking about his own home, but when he begins to actively look towards adventure.
When he looks to Erebor, and stands up for the dwarves,
and stands up against the dwarves and Thorin in order to protect them
(because it’s harder to stand up to your friends than your enemies), and when he risks life and limb in battle to bring Thorin a warning,
we are seeing Bilbo become so much more than he was at Bag End, to becoming not just a whole person but a better person.
Thorin and Bilbo are looking past one another to different things that fulfill them. In essence, they are also looking into one another to find fulfillment of their dreams and desires, the things they need in addition to the things they want. And honestly, I don’t see how it gets much more romantic than that.
