Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 24: On Bilbo and Marriage (headcanon)

Chapter Text

Headcanon that Bilbo is all repressed and proper and terrible at revealing genuine emotion when not under pressure, at least until he gets married

Suddenly, all bets are off. In the privacy of their home, Bilbo cannot keep his hands off Thorin. He showers him with compliments, laughs openly, and is constantly kissing, touching, and generally making no secret of how utterly besotted he is

Thorin is definitely not complaining (dwarves after all, are very demonstrative with their affections), but he is a little surprised at this abrupt turn-around from the fussy hobbit he first met

He shouldn’t be, at least not if he better understood Bilbo’s upbringing. The Shire may be hung up on propriety, but if you look around there’s a lot of public displays of affection within families. Sure, Sam could barely look at Rosie while she was dancing, but husbands and wives kiss and hug in public all the time. Bungo and Belladonna were by all accounts smitten with one another, and Bilbo’s home life was full of displays of affection that he took for granted as what love looks like. That he’s been alone all these years, living by himself and without family around, is entirely to blame for his reserve. 

But once it’s declared, once the world knows that he and Thorin are married and have done everything properly and just so, there’s no more shame attached to showing affection (at least, for this person and his extended family, of course) and Bilbo has very little trouble (and needs very little encouragement) to be a complete nuisance about his love for Thorin.

Part 2

Bilbo and marriage, further ramblings

Going back slightly to “Bilbo will show affection once he’s married” meta tidbit, it felt kinda weird to write because we do, many of us, live in a day and age where marriage is less important and so fraught with different views and lots of baggage, such that many see it as secondary to a healthy relationship, hence why I think you see a lot of fics (myself very much included) where marriage doesn’t really come up between Thorin and Bilbo, or it’s more of an afterthought

But Bilbo is old fashioned. He is quintessentially old fashioned, integrally so when you consider when the character was created. He comes from a (based on our world) time when marriage was central to any life (social, reproductive, economic, etc.) and given that the Shire is a pocket of Tolkien’s Oxford (more or less) in the middle of a medieval fantasy world, he comes from a place where marriage maketh the man, or woman, as far as establishing you place in society. For Tolkien, it would be unthinkable to be otherwise. Bilbo is odd in large part because he never marries. 

However, he is the product of a happy marriage, by all accounts. I don’t think it’s too much to say that Bilbo would actually have fairly romantic views of marriage given his parents, given the fact he places such importance on remaining in the house that his father built for his mother out of love. He states openly that he belongs there, in this physical manifestation of his parents’ love. Yet he remains isolated within it, does he not? 

 As much as I hate the dominance of coming of age stories, and appreciate that Bilbo is more of a midlife crisis story than coming of age, there is something to be said for the fact that he finally lets go of his parents love for one another in order to pursue a love of his very own - adventure, and by extension Thorin if you’re a Bagginshield shipper. 

So I actually really can see Bilbo placing enormous importance on a formal declaration of love and a formalization of that relationship via an official marriage. That’s how it’s done. There’s a threshold there, something that often fades in and out of importance for the modern western world.

(Aside: just look at the fact we have multiple “coming of age” ages, which dilutes the threshold down so we’re never “really” adults and many scholars believe that’s why we have the persistence of “I don’t feel like an adult” because we’ve lost those ceremonies that surround coming of age, with marriage or rites of passage associated with a particular time in someone’s life. It’s no longer menstruation/puberty, or 16, or even 18 because you can’t necessarily drink, or 25 because you may not have your own household, or marriage because you may decide not to… basically, because we’ve lost the rite of passage, we’ve lost a certain level of certainty within our lives.)

To take it back to Bilbo, he lives in a society that still has that certainty. When you’re married, it’s real. Before then it’s improper to show too much emotion or attachment before the formalization. We see time and again in 19th c. literature and (modern looks at said literature) how there’s such focus on courtship. There’s chaperones to defend one’s honor, there’s formalized interactions, there’s dances designed to expose people to potential partners in a controlled environment. There’s a hell of a lot of romance around the idea of repression, of not being able to do what you want with the person you’re in love with (which Richard absolutely loves talking about, and I think he subscribes to it somewhat as a romantic method if you consider his “acorn face” as his strong suit in portraying romance across multiple roles). We’ve kind of lost that too as a formal part of our society, there’s really no reason to wait to show intimacy anymore, and while much is gained there is a little that is lost in the fact there is no waiting until marriage (again, I am speaking from a western-centric viewpoint and only about my own culture and tangentially similar cultures). 

Anyway, long long story short, I rather like the idea that Bilbo does see it as a threshold, that is, crossing the threshold. No matter how much he loves Thorin or yearns for him, until they’re married such displays remain very strictly controlled. Perhaps that’s why he finally opts to call Thorin his “friend”, when he knows within the strictness of his society he can’t claim any more, given that it is all a “might have been”. It could also be why he hesitates to show affection for Balin, Thorin’s extended family which would have become his family, for whom public displays of affection would then have become acceptable, because again they’re a “might have been” for him, almost his family. But for all the rewards of crossing the threshold there is the down side of what happens when you never get to cross it, you are stuck without the formal declaration, without being to make any real claim and if you’re from such a structured society, that’s all it will ever be - you cannot make that claim if the marriage doesn’t actually go through, not on the dowery, not on the family, and not on the title of betrothed or husband. At the end, you must fall back on “friend.”

But if when they get married, that would all change. Bilbo, who grew up with Bungo and Belladonna within a house built by their love for one another, would I think feel very comfortable finally expressing that love now that threshold is crossed, now that is is “allowed”. That is the goal, ultimately, why it is put off so carefully, why it’s called “marital bliss”. The suspense is meant to enhance the final joy. At that point, there would be no barrier, formal or otherwise, to being completely demonstrative with his affections in the privacy of his home, and outside it (though with somewhat more propriety, some exception made for joyful newlyweds).