Chapter Text
Anonymous asked: Okay, so: I know Thorin's your favorite character, but that you also like Bilbo. Now you've said that you don't even think Bilbo is a good person, which is a little puzzling to me? Maybe because I come at this from the other side (Bilbo is my fav, yo) but I find it increasingly difficult to parse what you and a lot of other Thorin fans think Thorin would get out of a relationship. All I'm hearing lately is that Thorin makes Bilbo a better person and so on, and quite frankly it's a little
2/2 upsetting. I am NOT accusing you of hating. I just want to know what you think made Thorin fall in love with Bilbo, and not just that Bilbo likes Thorin for himself, because that’s not a good basis for a relationship. Sorry if this doesn’t make sense, or came across more passive-aggressive than it was meant, I’m not a native speaker.
Hey Anon, I know I can’t expect everyone to have read all my meta, there’s so damn much of it since I tend to talk at length, or all my fics. But I’d like to think that my fondness of Bilbo comes across in the copious amount of writing I’ve done about him? And if I don’t over-stress my love of Bilbo it’s because I assume it’s a given that I love him?
The thing is, as a darker character, Thorin tended to draw a lot more fire. Most of my meta is responding to mischaracterization of Thorin as a bad person, and the mischaracterization of Bilbo tends to be that he’s all sweetness and light, which is baffling to me because he can be a snarky little shit. It bothers me a lot when people reduce complex characters and relationships to “The sweet one & the aggressive one, the light & the dark one” because I think Thorin and Bilbo are equals and have equal, if different, mixes of those qualities. I abhor the polarization which leaves Thorin a shattered mess that Bilbo needs to clean up, or Bilbo so weak and shy and fragile that he’s at Thorin’s dark mercy. It’s just not how I see them. (mostly I see them as grouchy, grumpy nerds who adore one another and strengthen and inspire each other through tough times).
I would never say Bilbo’s a bad person. I’m just against this characterization that says he can never do bad things, or be held to blame for anything. The Arkenstone could have been better handled, but then again it’s a stressful situation that would be almost impossible to navigate. Likewise Bilbo can fight and defend himself, and he’s clever as hell and tricked some very powerful and dangerous people (the trolls, Thranduil, Thorin under dragon sickness, etc.). Pretending that good = helpless, incapable of killing or defending his life or those of others, or incapable of lying or making a mistake and hurting his loved ones, is so weird to me and it’s so weird to me that by saying Bilbo can be a complex person I’ve somehow come across as saying he’s bad?
I said the other day that I think contact with Thorin, his cause, and the other dwarves, via Gandalf, made Bilbo want to become a better person and he did become a better person in the course of helping them. I think Thorin is an inspiring figure, especially in the movies, and Bilbo fell for him for that reason. That being said, I think Thorin was inspiring to Bilbo before he knew anything about Thorin’s rank or title, which would mean nothing to a hobbit in any case, so it’s particularly touching to me that he would believe in Thorin as a person, because I think Thorin ascribes most of his own positive qualities to his lineage, race, and responsibilities, ie, Thorin considers his “best” quality to be that he is Thror’s heir, and he struggles to uphold that legacy and thinks little of himself as a “person”, whereas to Bilbo the legacy of Thror means little or nothing, he believes in Thorin’s courage and honor (vouch for it, and fights to defend it, even when Thorin cannot because of dragon sickness).
But you asked what does Bilbo give to Thorin - I guess I could say a hell of a lot? I mean, to say the least, how could you forget him saving Thorin’s Quest on multiple occasions, trolls, spiders, elves, and his willingness to face Smaug alone? Even if that’s no basis for a relationship, it’s still a considerable tribute to another person. As for their relationship, I think Bilbo fulfills something in Thorin that he very rarely encounters - someone who believes in him who has nothing to gain in doing so. Thorin can dismiss or minimize the respect he gets from the other dwarves because they have 1) an obligation to do so because of his title and 2) because they have something to gain for themselves if Erebor is reclaimed. For himself, Thorin’s barely able to ask anything when not acting as a leader or in their interests (”I have no right to ask this of any of you.”).
After the Goblin Tunnels, Bilbo stands up and says he wants to help Thorin and the dwarves, not because he hopes to gain anything in return, but because they’ve lost their home and he thinks they deserve to regain it. This would have been huge for Thorin. I truly doubt he’d ever heard an outsider or even a non-family member profess that kind of love and faith in the same things Thorin has love and faith for. Not to mention, outsiders who should have offered their help (like Thranduil), failed to do so in a fantastically traumatic way. This is taking steps to heal a wound inside of Thorin that’s probably ached since Erebor fell - someone else actually giving a damn about them for some reason other than treasure.
On his own though, outside of the Quest, Bilbo does offer a lot more. He’s smart as hell, well-spoken, caring, practical, and has immense respect for Thorin. When they’re together and alone they don’t have to worry about the trappings of their broader lives - Thorin isn’t a hobbit to judge Bilbo on his “propriety”, and Bilbo isn’t a dwarf to get hung up on or expect things from Thorin because of his rank. They are uniquely themselves outside of societies that are very complex for both of them.
That’s even if you ignore everything they went through together on the Quest, seeing the best and worst of each other, multiple times saving each other’s lives and the lives of people they care about, and becoming a team. RA specifically calls Bilbo Thorin’s confidante by the time we get to BoFA, they are incredibly close as people.
So, I dunno, if you don’t think that’s a good basis for a relationship, that’s your prerogative, but if I don’t highlight a certain aspect of their relationship, for example what Bilbo gives to Thorin in return, it’s because I thought it was fairly obvious to anyone who has seen the films?
