Chapter Text
Anonymous asked: psst hey do you have any thoughts on why Thorin prefaced his "I have never been so wrong" declaration with so many insults? like, he sounds pretty angry right before he hugs Bilbo; was he angry at himself for having treated Bilbo so rudely? was he going to end with something different and changed it at the last moment?
Pfft, I have a lot of feelings about that scene, Anon, but the majority of my opinions on *why* it played out that way come down to, “narrative suspense.”
After all, Bilbo is clearly relieved that Thorin is ok, and he has some awareness that he did something fairly out of character in order to save Thorin, and if his expression on the eagle’s back is anything to go by, he hasn’t stopped worrying since Thorin took those first steps down a burning log.
So it’s heartbreaking for him to do all that, and find out that he might have done something wrong, that there’s literally no pleasing this person he resepects. I felt that look in my soul the first time, when you’ve done everything you can and not only had your efforts thrown in your face, but told they’re not good enough, a mistake, from someone who’s opinion you actually respect. You can see his heart sink to his feet. It was a very cold moment of horror, at least for me sympathetically, that confusion that comes from doing everything right and still getting in trouble for it.
But Bilbo is not in a place to really know if kind words are coming? Thorin’s been pretty cold towards him since the start, his thought processes largely impenetrable to Bilbo. He can hope to do well by Thorin, but he can’t *know* if he has, which makes that moment worse as he believes he hasn’t. In fact, he’s only made Thorin angrier with him.
But honestly, outside the story? The line was clearly constructed to *give* us that cold feeling, to make *us* wonder if Thorin is really angry with him, if we’ll ever understand what is good enough for Thorin, if Bilbo ever can be or if he’s just doomed from the start no matter what he does. We’re very much in Bilbo’s “shoes” in that scene. So honestly, it makes little sense for Thorin to about-face like that and phrase it quite that way “did I not say you were a burden, that you had no place amongst us?” is a very weird way to launch into saying you’re wrong, because that sentence construction is designed to *recall* something, not contradict it. So it’s a bit of writerly cheating, in my opinion.
But, eh, it is *explainable* for Thorin’s character. He’s just had a bad scare with the weakest member of the Company throwing himself in front of Azog, a creature that brutally murdered many stronger warriors than Bilbo. Thorin’s also been whacked by shame before and after that fight, with Bilbo professing his faith in the quest and then saving a person who more or less insulted him and told him to go home earlier that very day. Thorin was also constructed by RA to be a “contradictory” character, and to have mood swings and be a bit inconsistent, perhaps given to flights of passion, hence his hyperbole with “NEVER been so wrong” (or is it hyperbole? if you want to go with a romantic reading, misjudging a person who saves your life, who you fall in love with by calling them useless and nearly driving them away is a HUGE mistake, especially if you go with a fanon “his One” reading (though I hate that fanon term, it does work when referring to dwarven monogamy)).
Anyway, I think it was the script writers cheating to build suspense, but Thorin *giving* someone a scare like that by changing his tune so quickly is in itself an in-character thing, maybe just not with that exact grammatical phrasing. I forgive it, though, since it is in many ways the emotional climax of the story ;)
