Chapter Text
To be honest, I’m just really confused by any fanon that says Thorin would keep someone from joining the Company?
Like, let’s be real here, this is the biggest most dangerous goal of Thorin’s life. He literally says, “Loyalty, honor, and a willing heart, I can ask no more than that.” His issue with Bilbo was not his lack of physical prowess (he’s bringing Ori and his slingshot along by the way), or that Bilbo can’t fight or fend for himself (that was Dwalin talking, Thorin only listened), nor does he question the intelligence of those who chose to follow him (that was Balin). He listens to all sides, and when Gandalf insists he tells them to give Bilbo the contract. At no point does he question anyone who chooses to join.
In my opinion, what Thorin was questioning was whether Bilbo willingly came on the Quest. Never mind what a kick in the teeth it must be to be told you have a volunteer, only for that volunteer to “back down” the minute he meets all of you (in truth, Bilbo hadn’t agreed in the first place, but Thorin didn’t know that and to his eyes it was Bilbo changing his mind). Thorin isn’t saying Bilbo shouldn’t have come when he says, “He’s been lost ever since he left home,”, that’s Bilbo’s interpretation, but what he means it that Bilbo has a chance to leave and if he’s going to he should just do it already, and stop shoving it in Thorin’s face that they’re probably doomed, and risking the entire Quest falling apart because one person can’t make up their mind. Thorin’s priority is to keep the Quest together, which is why in my headcanon he was trying to get Bilbo to make his decision one way or the other, so that Bilbo’s eventual desertion didn’t cause a domino effect where all the other dwarves left too. Keep in mind, Thorin just failed to get the Iron Hills dwarves, his own damn cousin, to join him. He’s not some proud, unquestionable figure with a ton of followers. He’s a quasi-failure who is taking one last desperate shot and the only people willing to follow him are his immediate family, and a few opportunists.
Thorin is not in a position to keep anyone from joining the Company, and in my opinion, he knows it. He’s actual very respectful of those who came, but he doesn’t coddle them. His position is to be the leader and the quest will succeed or fail based on his leadership (and, incidentally, Bilbo’s quick thinking which is why they’re perfect for each other oops). This characterization of Thorin as a proud tyrant imperiously saying who can or cannot join is just so weird to me because there’s basically no in-movie support for it at all (as ever, the book is another matter).
