Chapter Text
kanonsymphonia asked: 1/2 You do an absolutely marvelous job in your analysis, I find that I cannot help myself. There is a scene in Desolation of Smaug that has confusing for me, and I was hoping to get your opinion <3 It's the scene where Thorin states "I will not risk this quest for the life of one burglar." We see Balin scold him, "Bilbo. His name is Bilbo." After the mountain quakes, Thorin runs inside in what seems to be an attempt to save him, only to hold him at sword point as he demands to know about the
2/2 Arkenstone. Moments later, Smaug appears, and it shifts as Bilbo inches behind Thorin and likewise Thorin seems to shield him to a small degree. In following scenes, there is no trace of the prior malice and he even goes to lengths to call Bilbo by name and protect him as the Company works to outwit the dragon. What exactly transpired in this scene that led up to him treating Bilbo so highly in the third movie? I can’t put my finger on it, but something clearly happened beneath the surface!
Gosh, thank you for the kind words, and for your patience while I responded to this.
Ok, as to part ½ I actually find that moment between “His name is Bilbo,” to Thorin running in to save him, to holding him at sword point extremely heartbreaking, especially in the context of BotFA, since on its own it’s a bit confusing, and I’ll address the second half of your question in a moment.
I think, what we’re seeing immediately after they get the door open is this moment of Thorin finally returning to Erebor, and it’s a joyous moment but to paraphrase Richard, the smell of his home is now laced with death and it’s a “spiritual” moment for him. I think there we get the beginning of the light and darkness that’s going to be wrenching Thorin apart over the rest of the story, something we only saw hinted at in Bag End with how his terminology for Erebor shifted back and forth between retrieving the great wealth vs. reclaiming a homeland. I think the dragon sickness began to catch hold when the smell of death came up to Thorin from the tunnel, and when his moment of joy at being home transitioned into the immediate concern of getting the Arkenstone back. Though to be sure, there was also a moment of it in Lake-town too when he’s brooding over the windlance.
So I think he’s hovering between sickness and health there, with dragon sickness holding him paralyzed when he sends Bilbo down, because dragon sickness actively keeps its victim from seeking danger (thus subverting Thorin’s courage and honor), and it gets worse ever time Thorin believes someone he loves has died, which he may very well have in that moment before Balin snaps him out of it by reminding him of the very real emotional bond he shares with Bilbo. So we see him healthy, briefly, as he comes back to himself and goes charging in, no longer paralyzed.
And then he sees the gold.
I would say that we’re seeing Thorin tilt wildly between dragon sickness and health in the following moments. The sight of the gold makes him worse, actively fighting Smaug makes him better.
However, I also have a cynical view. I think the dwarves fighting against Smaug was a later addition, so I also think it’s a product of sub-part editing and later scene additions that don’t match the tone of the first take, and the first take was not updated to reflect the changing moods of the re-shoots.
As for what happened between the second and the third movie to make Bilbo the most trustworthy of the Company? *Shrugs* I literally have no idea and I hope the BotFA EE will clarify. There’s some clumsy editing at the beginning of BotFA too, where Thorin is first shown in his Thror finery, but then they flash back to him giving orders to find the Arkenstone but it’s kind of presented as being the present, except he’s wearing his DoS outfit. It’s kind of a mess and all over the place trying to pick out what happened in those intervening days before Fili and Kili et al. arrived. Clearly Thorin fell fast and hard, but why Bilbo was taken into his confidence during that time is not entirely clear and a little bit sloppy without clarification. As a shipper, I’m ok with it but… eh… long story short, I don’t have an answer to why Thorin trusts Bilbo so much at the beginning of BotFA :-/ I guess I could headcanon it to “He believed Bilbo was telling the truth when he said he didn’t have it, which leaves all the other dwarves as suspects.”
