Chapter Text
deustiel asked: Please meta about a half-second clip?
Meta below the cut
Ok, let me get my thoughts in order here.
So what’s happening here? Narrative convenience aside, Balin and Dwalin are trying to curb Thorin’s irrational search for the Arkenstone by confronting him as respectfully as they can. They’re very nervous to point out that Thorin is essentially accusing the dwarves of having stolen it as Thorin falls further into the depths of paranoia. This is a huge blow because “loyalty, honor, and a willing heart” and the fact Thorin said he would trust the dwarves of the company over “an army from the Iron Hills” seems to have gone out the window. This is not the Thorin they know.
Much Bagginshield discussion has surrounded Bilbo’s placement in this scene, and rightfully so because it’s really weird. I somewhat blame narrative convenience again, all of BotFA is setting up the emotional punch of the Ramparts Betrayal and the Death Scene, so Thorin and Bilbo are suddenly visually a lot closer than they’ve been in the previous movies, it’s almost jarring as the film sets up the new status quo which is a bit of a leap from DoS and AUJ. That being said, there is some logic behind it. Bilbo has shown himself to be a trustworthy non-dwarf on many occasions, probably the only one Thorin has ever met. Why he leaps from suspicion of Bilbo in DoS to trusting him in BotFA with regards to the suspicion of him stealing the Arkenstone is a bit of a leap, but let’s just assume that in the course of the dragon chase scene he figured Bilbo didn’t have it. That means he’s got one person he’s fairly certain (not completely certain, see the acorn scene) hasn’t stolen from him. He’s had no similar encounter with the other members of the company.
Furthermore, and this is more my theory, he is assuming that it has a greater obvious value to the dwarves than to Bilbo. If Bilbo doesn’t value the Arkenstone as an expensive/pretty jewel, there’s not much more it would mean to him. However, Thorin did say that the oath of the dwarves was sworn to the one who bears the King’s Jewel, which could theoretically mean that any dwarf there could supplant Thorin’s right to the throne by simply taking and holding the Arkenstone. Maybe the Ur’s and the Ri’s wouldn’t be able to make much claim as commoners, but specifically Balin and Dwalin are of the line of Durin, Thorin’s cousins, so if they possess the Arkenstone they could conceivably steal the right to kingship out from under Thorin, which is what his dragon-sickness afflicted mind sees as a real possibility.
Ok but on to Bilbo, because otherwise I go down the dragon-sickness rabbit hole again.
Bilbo has the Arkenstone, the thing Thorin is currently screaming about. I’m not sure how others saw the film, but to me it had been obvious since DoS that he picked it up from under Smaug’s feet. They have the scene in BotFA (not 100% sure if it’s just before or just after this scene) where we have it confirmed that Bilbo has the stone at this moment.
There’s a lot of really fascinating extrapolations from that fact.
- Humor. Ok, let’s just get that out of the way. Martin’s awesome face is fantastic at conveying the awkward humor of this scene. This is Bilbo’s “oh shit” face. Possibly his “oh shit what have I done” face. He probably reeks of guilt right now. If Thorin wasn’t totally batshit, he’d know in an instant that Bilbo has it, I mean just look at him. From a visual storytelling perspective, this look is bringing levity to an otherwise tense scene.
- Ok with that out of the way, let’s break down what this means. Bilbo is at Thorin’s right hand, the only person Thorin thinks he can trust, and Bilbo can’t even fully contemplate this for the honor it is because he knows he has no right to be there. He is the thief.
- Thorin doesn’t notice Bilbo’s shifty look because of the level of trust he bears him now. Bilbo has supplanted Balin and Dwalin as his right hand man as a result. He is literally placing Bilbo above his family and the company as a result which idk is kinda romantic if the situation wasn’t so dire.
- Balin and Dwalin may be utterly baffled or they may suspect that Bilbo has the stone, Balin has it more or less confirmed by Bilbo in the next scene. Simply put, regardless of who has the stone, they don’t want Thorin to have it. I’ve pointed out why this is a bad idea on their part elsewhere.
- The most interesting question, and what I’m trying to get to I guess, is why does it fall out like this? On the surface, Bilbo is afraid for himself. It’s super awkward that he took the stone and now things have spiraled and there’s really no good time to set it right by giving it to Thorin and now Thorin’s getting crazier by the day and more vengeful, and only now are Bilbo, Balin, and Dwalin, his closest peers (his nephews are not Thorin’s peers) are realizing just how bad it has gotten when Thorin is threatening harm to those closest to him. Bilbo is afraid for himself, which on its own would be enough to explain the scene and honestly to dismiss Bagginshield as a motivation.
- Except Bilbo isn’t just afraid for himself. He’s afraid for Thorin. Regardless of the peril of that moment– I mean it would be a very bad idea right then and there to bring out the stone and “Here’s the burglar!” the thing like he did after the Goblin Tunnels– but he could easily just duck around the corner, root around in the treasure room for a bit and then exclaim Oh, here it is! Haha silly us, under this vase the whole time! If Bilbo was only afraid for himself, that’s exactly what he would do next.
- Let’s be clear, Bilbo wants to give Thorin the stone, he’s desperate to. But Smaug’s warning about it driving Thorin mad is literally ringing in his ears. He’s literally more afraid for Thorin’s sanity and safety than he is for his own physical wellbeing, because certainly he’d be out of harm’s way if he gave up the stone. Keep in mind, the stone as a bargaining chip to save them from Thranduil isn’t even an idea yet, that necessity hasn’t arisen.
- (Oh, and lest we should think that “I think it would make Thorin worse,” just means Bilbo is afraid Thorin would be more violent with the stone and potentially physically harm him and others (thus negating the idea he’s afraid for Thorin’s health rather than their safety by withholding it), let’s remember his declaration to Gandalf, “I’m not afraid of Thorin!” He seems so startled and outraged during that declaration that Gandalf would even bring up the possibility that it totally negates the idea that his main concern is anything except Thorin’s safety (and that of the company). Also as seen with the ramparts betrayal, Bilbo is honestly shockedwhen Thorin threatens and then lays hands on him. So physical harm was never a major fear in his calculations about revealing the Arkenstone as much as the fear for Thorin’s sanity.)
- Anyway. So Bilbo goes to Balin, the most level-headed dwarf who knows Thorin well, who is basically Thorin’s father figure, and asks him what to do. Balin tells him not to give the stone to Thorin, and you can see Bilbo is crushed by this. Not only that he can’t dispel this nightmare and bring peace to Thorin’s fears by giving him the stone, but also that Balin thinks that it would make Thorin’s already frightening descent even worse, and Bilbo would literally risk personal harm to himself rather than allow that to happen.
So that “Oh shit” face I was laughing about? It’s a sad laugh, because this is the moment Bilbo realizes how bad it is and just how stuck they all are. They don’t have a cure for Thorin, they can only try not to make it worse, but Thorin is getting worse anyway by the day. Thorin just basically said he would physically hurt anyone who keeps it from him which is so OOC as to be frightening on its own. They don’t know what to do. And Bilbo doesn’t even have the comfort of the moral high ground that Balin and Dwalin have. They can at least voice honest bafflement and give assurances that they’d never betray Thorin and they’d never steal.
Bilbo is saddled with the guilt of doing this to help Thorin, but also knowing he’s betraying his trust at the same time. He can’t even take refuge in the idea that this is the one time he’s ever stolen, because he’s also got the Ring weighing on his conscience (hence the beginning of the acorn scene we really don’t know if he’s looking at the Ring or the Arkenstone because both are weighing on his conscience and changing his view of himself as an honest person). Bilbo knows he’s in deep shit here and he doesn’t know how to get out of it. It’s what propels him eventually into Thranduil’s tent to try to do anything to break this stalemate and probably buy Thorin the breathing space to get some help. Of course it goes disastrously.
He’s a thief but he’s an honest one, that’s the moral quandary Bilbo faces until he gives up the stone to save their lives. It’s in some ways the lie he tells himself so that he can still recognize himself. In some ways it’s a disservice he does to himself to even consider himself a thief, as Thorin points out when he absolves him in the death scene, pointing out it was no theft at all but rather the actions of a true friend.
Overall the message of that face is: sometimes it’s harder to help your friends than to hurt them, and he’s damned if he does and damned if he doesn’t. Which is not a comfortable place for a Baggins to be.
