Chapter Text
Anonymous asked: meta request: how long do you think it would take bilbo and thorin to reconcile post-botfa?
*rubs hands together with glee* oh this is a fun one! I’m sorry for taking so long to get to these but they are such a nice treat to come to on a slow day.
Funny enough, I would have given a very different answer before BotFA came out, as is somewhat evidenced in PTBS. The first third of that fic is Thorin and Bilbo learning to forgive each other again because I like many fic writers assumed a much more violent and rage-filled ramparts scene (when instead we got a far more sad and emotional one, with very little actual attempt by Thorin to do harm). If I wrote that fic after BotFA it would have been a very different story, not the least because the whole first third of them learning to admit they care for one another would be unnecessary. In BotFA, they never stopped.
My answer now based on BotFA would be: immediately. Even before that on Ravenhill, the nod between Thorin and Bilbo spoke to me of instant forgiveness. Thorin was immediately apologetic for his actions once they had a moment to speak of them aloud, and Bilbo looked frankly baffled by the idea that Thorin would need to ask for forgiveness at all. It was very clear that contrary to what many fic writers anticipated, Bilbo never gave up on Thorin for a second and had no trouble telling the difference between Thorin’s actions while sick vs how he would act under his own power. Likewise Thorin immediately stated without equivocation that Bilbo did the right thing with the Arkenstone.
That being said, I think there are other reconciliations beyond forgiveness for the Arkenstone/Dragon Sickness/the Ramparts that could happen that they might need to work through. Thorin exhibited a very scary suicidal streak that I think Bilbo would struggle with (granted that behavior is tied up in the whole Heroic Warrior King thing, but Bilbo may not quite grasp that given his background). And though the cliche has been done to death, I think Thorin would struggle with accepting Bilbo’s forgiveness? I could see some self-doubt there, especially if it got tied up in the question of whether or not Bilbo’s going home immediately.
TL;DR I think they’d each be totally fine with each other immediately, in fact that’s basically true in canon as far as we can see. They may have other lingering questions between them but I don’t think it’ll be tied up in the other’s “crimes” as much as it would be with how to go forward now that they’ve clearly shown that they care for one another a great deal.
