Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 40: On "Grubby Soul" Thorin

Chapter Text

From Indigoire: Kind of a tangent, but the Thorin bit reminded me of the scene in BotFA where Thorin’s talking to Bard about giving his word and he goes “what choice did we have but to barter our birthright?” Which makes me think maybe Thorin’s done so in the past.

 I completely agree. Here’s the thing, I felt like we get these tiny glimpses of the sacrifices Thorin has made over the years to keep his people alive. But the thing is, his narrative tends to stay on sort of an Aragorn-like progression of a noble king in exile. They faced hardships, but at least to me the story feels like it doesn’t quite want to acknowledge the true depths of privation and what that would actually do to someone. The exile is a sore point for Thorin, but it never stopped him from being a hero.

But what if that wasn’t the case?

Because sometimes when Richard speaks the lines, I get this sense that he saw Thorin at his lowest points, and that those lowest points might have included true desperation and not the shiny, fantasy style poverty which is some tasteful rags and a lot of burning anger, rather than true bleakness. Richard even talked about how Thorin was facing a death of the soul before Gandalf showed up, that he had this burning need to reclaim Erebor but it was fading and threatening to go out, and with it the last spark of who he truly was. 

I don’t know about you, but to me it seems farfetched that someone as strong as Thorin is portrayed would be worn down simply by living in Ered Luin, even after Azanulbizar. I like to constantly stress that Thorin went from the prince of the wealthiest nation in the world to a beggar. Not even just a beggar on his own, but one who was most certainly overcharged and spat on, because the dwarves of Erebor are rich, as everyone knows, and desperate, so why not overcharge them? Everyone knows dwarves are greedy, why not take them for all their worth in their time of need? A huge, jarring shift of circumstances, from a kingdom that even Thranduil must bow to for an alliance to someone who even churls among Men would cheat. 

I’m actually very interested to see a realistic look at what such a change of circumstances would do to a psyche. I actually believe that had Thorin lived  he would be very careful about risking the kingdom again, or changing any circumstances for the things that are going well. He may not even realize he’s doing it, he’s just trying to grasp onto any stability for good things. As much as I see him as a very reckless hero, there’s some glimpse of that cautiousness which comes with living on the edge of ruin in that Gandalf had to convince him to try to reclaim Erebor. In that light, I can see his fighting in battle in two ways 1) trying to reclaim lost glory, after all he was a hero at Azanulbizar and rightfully so, but also 2) fierce, almost suicidal desperation and perhaps not a wholehearted belief they’ll get through this without it. I dunno, again I don’t want to woobify or anything, but I enjoy adding additional dimensions to the character that actually work. 

So here’s a thought - what if one of the reasons the dwarven clans refused to help Thorin is because he’s known for breaking his word? Also, his grandfather led them to ruin, the goodwill towards the line of Durin is probably running quite thin at this point. But I was talking with striving-artist and we were talking about what would truly crush Thorin’s soul and we came upon this - needing to break dwarven closely-held morals in order to survive. Hence we discussed Thorin being forced to flee towns where they have debts, being forced to run off with payments before delivering on the goods because he’s trading on dwarven reputation for honesty but if they don’t make enough soon they won’t survive the winter, and he’s needed elsewhere. What about making shoddy swords, because good swords take longer, and only learning later that the town that commissioned them faced an orc hoard? What if some of the bad dwarven reputation for lying and cheating is based on the Erebor dwarves in exile being forced by desperation to renege on their words, something that is taboo to dwarves, because they’re being taken advantage of and they’re at the end of their resources?

THAT sort of thing I think would drive Thorin low and wear him down. That’s why I’m really fascinated by the idea he might still be carrying these burdens when he meets Bilbo. You’ll notice that Dwalin doesn’t claim Thorin will keep his word in Lake-town. He only says that Thorin has a hereditary right to the mountain. What if Dwalin knows that Thorin won’t? He’s seen it before, and while he understands the circumstances that made it necessary, I kinda love the idea that Thorin has a slightly grubby soul. That the joy we see in him at Bag End is about shedding a lot of that, but then they just hit failure after failure under his leadership and there’s a real question if they’ll get through this because he can’t go back to who he was forced to become during the exile. Just the idea of Thorin actually caught between a rock and a hard place. 

We constantly talk about ‘why’ Thorin is going to Erebor when it’s demonstrably such an unhealthy place for him. What if going back to Ered Luin is worse? What if Thorin wasn’t just dying inside, but he was actually morphed into something that would have once been unrecognizable to the prince of Erebor? What if all that dead weight has sloughed off on the road, but the Dwarven Clan Chiefs know him, they know he’s not actually trustworthy anymore? So of course Dain is happy to see him, once he’s reclaimed the mountain. They all want the Thorin they knew back, including Thorin! But he’s been stuck in inaction for years? 

Anyway, Thorin who has seen true poverty and has had to make moral sacrifices in order to survive it is an interesting concept to me. It somewhat defies Tolkien’s world where money seems to have no particular value except insofar as Smaug sits on a bed of gold. How Bilbo supported himself before the quest is unknown, the true cost of the dwarves in exile is unknown, considering theoretically one ruby in their pockets should have been enough to set a family up comfortably for years just about anywhere else. So why wasn’t it enough? Do you know how much a day laborer makes? It would not be unreasonable to assume that he would see one gold coin in years as a blacksmith based on ancient standards. 

 

A talent, a unit of weight for gold or silver, typically weighed about 33kg … which would take an ordinary laborer 6,000 days (16 years). X

Imagine Thorin going from a world where he has coins just lying around to one where he must work as a smith for weeks, if not months, to make a few silver. Where because his people are known to be desperate, a ruby which should have equaled many gold coins isn’t enough to buy them enough bread for the whole refugee camp. The thought makes me a bit dizzy to be honest, but I feel like the movie world only hints at this, and Tolkien barely even mentions it and seems to have little to no sympathy for his dwarves.

When Thorin was trying to reclaim Erebor, he was doing it for Gimli’s generation. Gimli is what dwarves normally are, what they should be - stalwart, brave, never reneging on a bargain, who says things like, “Faithless is he that says farewell when the road darkens.” I feel like that is dwarven morality. But I can’t help but think that’s their morality in prosperous times, “it’s easy to be a saint in paradise”, and Thorin saw the darkest depths and fought to claw his people out of them, but may have gotten grubby himself along the way. To me, that’s a far more inspiring leader, but I think also one who would have some self-loathing issues.

That one to me is fascinating if he meets a truly unpleasant and selfish Bilbo, and both of them become better through their meeting. Bilbo sees Thorin as he is trying to become again - a prince and a hero on a noble quest. Maybe he doesn’t see or know about the depths Thorin sunk to (at least in his own mind). So when he stands up and says that the dwarves deserve a home, Thorin is actually thunderstruck. Likewise with the vouching scene. Perhaps that’s Thorin realizing that somehow, this impossible person believes in him, perhaps a small and grubby part of him is thinking “Oh good, we’ve got someone to lie for us, so we’ll get out of this in one piece” while another is thinking he actually wants to be that person, he wants to be worthy of that faith?