Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 41: How does Thorin view the race of Men?

Chapter Text

madametortilla asked: I'm thinking about the way Thorin says in the EE of DOS: "This, Master Baggins, is the world of Men", which may suggest a possible dislike of Men in general or of their ways. I'm assuming that this pertains to the terrible exile years where Thorin and his kin had to wander laboring in the villages of Men. I wonder a) what Thorin and the dwarves think of Men (not just the people of Laketown) and b) how dwarves are regarded by other races.

I think the short answer to both a and b is “poorly.” :P

I actually really loved that line because it was such a reminder of the exile. I don’t think Thorin hates Men the way he hates Elves, but clearly it’s not a good relationship. He is wary and distrustful in every instance we see him interacting with Men - from the Prancing Pony in Bree, to Lake-town, to Erebor. Exceptions made for the cute waitress, but I mean how can you not love Katie Jackson. 

If I had to give my theory, which would be better informed by re-reading LotR but my brain is too bleary right now, I’d say Beorn pretty much summed up the general view of Men (and Elves) towards dwarves: they’re greedy, disdainful of others, and prefer their treasure above all else. 

It should go without saying that I see this as an insulting and unfair criticism. I think dwarves are disdainful of others because they’ve been shown disdain in return, from the very earliest days of their creation shunted aside and given second fiddle to literally everyone else. I think gold and jewels are not just currency to them, but actually a legacy of their people, akin to our great masterpieces of art. Substitute ‘gold’ when dwarves talk about it to the equivalent of the Mona Lisa, Erebor to the Louvre, and I think you get a much better sense of why Thorin is protective than by just assuming it’s about monetary value. For one thing, the latter just doesn’t make sense, the dwarves are clearly not spending it on very much outside of Dale, nor could they even if they wanted to, their wealth reserves are so laughably ahead of everyone else in terms of billions. 

As for why dwarves like Thorin would be distrustful of Men I’d point out that in many instances the dwarves are at a disadvantage. Sure they’re strong and tough as hell, but they are smaller, and there are a lot fewer of them. A dwarf can probably out-class a man in endurance and possibly strength, but a group of Men together can probably overwhelm a dwarf, especially one who is alone on the road with none of his fellow people around. I think that’s what Thorin was aware of in Bree, that he is essentially alone, and dwarves are rumored to be very rich, and he is in fact a perfect target until Gandalf shows up. I got the sense that he has been mugged, or nearly mugged, in the past most likely by Men. It’s not a stretch to imagine that word of Erebor’s refugees would have spread, and given its fabled hoard that would have made them targets for many unscrupulous sorts, either by theft, overcharging for goods, or violence. 

As for Lake-town, I got the sense that Thorin was warning Bilbo about a place of chaos and low standards. The Shire is a very homogenous place, everyone is pretty harmless and gets along, they have standards of behavior and can expect a modicum of decency from one another. Dwarves I imagine are similar, in that they are a relatively homogenous culture with a low population, with the rest of the world against them and culturally (perhaps even biologically) so different from them that it creates a sense of close kinship even between different Dwarven clans. They have laws and standards that are generally obeyed, they all look up to the same kings, heroes, and leaders. 

Men by contrast have no centralized culture or government. They are heterogeneous, untrustworthy, and have a huge population compared to every other race. Culture clashes would be inevitable between Dwarves and Men, not to mention Elves and Men, and Hobbits and Men, for that exact reason. The word of one Man does not protect you from his fellow, or even from him since oaths are less binding than they are to dwarves (extrapolated by the Company’s unwillingness even in the face of danger and death to turn on Thorin). To Dwarven culture, this would be as a rule seen as dishonorable and untrustworthy. Thorin is warning Bilbo that in this place, the rules of good conduct do not apply, they may be robbed as easily as looked at. Thorin is clearly expecting Bard to turn on them at any moment, which speaks to other bargains broken in the past in a way that left him and others in danger. It means heightened alertness and a preparation to go down fighting, because if the dwarves cannot use their superior fighting prowess to get out of the situation, then being in the midst of settlement of Men they can be easily overwhelmed, robbed, beaten, imprisoned, or killed. And you get the sense Thorin has not had very many Men stand up against such poor treatment.

I would argue that during the exile and on the road, Thorin met good Men as well as bad (again, see his reaction to the waitress, this isn’t a categorical racial hatred as it would be with Elves. He can tell the difference between those who do and don’t mean him harm) but with their superior numbers that equation can always turn, where the bad outnumber the good. That, at least, was my sense of those words.