Chapter Text
madametortilla asked: I really like the ugly!Durins troope. It's very interesting to notice how attractive they're to us, but I do wonder how they're regarded within their own race, and just how they cope with their insecurities and by generally feeling so unattractive that it's hard for them to believe someone might regard them as handsome. Talk about double standards.
I admit, I loved exploring this trope in “The Company of Mad Baggins”, though I believe alkjira did it first? It’s certainly a tantalizing idea. I like to believe that Dori, Bombur, and Gloin are the hotties of the Company by dwarven standards. Tolkien said that long hair is the aphrodisiac of the Elves (someone once joked very cleverly that Luthien being able to magically grow her hair was the equivalent of being able to knot a cherry stem in her mouth for elves, lol). My opinion on dwarven standards is:
- Round and/or muscular bodies. In truth, a good medieval warrior’s body would not be cut like a modern underwear model, a minimum of fat is necessary for any truly extreme physical endeavor, and dwarves have toughness as a virtue. To them, Elves would look unnaturally elongated and stretched, like aliens. A handsome dwarf is one who’s form runs to bulk with some combination of fat and muscle. Ex. Thorin does have a warrior’s muscles, so he’s not hopeless, just a bit on the lean side (which is not as desirable), Ori is thinner but his potbelly is probably considered cute, Fili at least has his hair and his youth excuses his leanness, Kili looks extremely adolescent by dwarven standards. Not hopeless, necessarily, just… young, like baby-faced and acne-ridden by our standards.
- Lots of hair, which they share with elves if in a slightly different form (Legolas and Gimli lack a lot of shared standards of beauty, but they can agree on this one). Big bushy beards, long luxurious locks, mustaches, braids. Each clan is different, so Bofur’s long mustache is a bit unusual but just as good as anything else. Fili’s hair and weapons skill makes up for his youth and skinniness. Gloin is a dreamboat, Bombur’s huge loop braid is the human equivalent of six-pack abs, etc etc. Kili looks extremely young and is probably considered the most unfortunate looking of all the Durin line, though he could grow out of that with time. Thorin’s short beard is a bit like ritually scarring - it’s not that dwarves don’t maintain different beard styles, but there’s usually something that’s longer, like Bofur and Fili’s mustaches, in order to show off. That Thorin as uncrowned king of the Longbeard clan (which, true to its name does pride itself in long beards like Thror and Thrain’s as seen in the flashbacks), would have one so short when he can clearly grow it longer is a advertisement of mourning. It represents an honorable gesture, but it’s a little hard to look at if you’re a dwarf, a bit like if a human had scars on their cheeks to represent mourning, as some cultures do. (I wrote this in more depth in my fic, “Shorn”)
- Gray hairs. Dwarves get tougher, not weaker with age, and I imagine they have their children fairly late, so gray hair mean a long life and experience rather than a loss of fertility, as it does for Men. Dwarves would never cover up their gray hairs, rather it makes them look distinguished. Thorin is just starting to come into his “full bloom” of beauty, so to speak, with the oncoming silver of his hair, Thror was a silver fox, Balin is fine as hell. Being younger with dark or red hair isn’t necessarily ugly, but the signs of age do add a certain something for dwarves, basically their “peak” attractiveness.
- Battle scars. Not to the level of orc scarification, where it’s done deliberately, but a missing eye or lost limb would not be a turn-off to dwarves, but rather it would be seen as a mark of a heroic lifestyle and honored as such. For example, Bifur’s axe-in-the-head, or the scar after it’s removed, would not be treated as a blemish. Nor would Thrain’s lost eye, or Dain’s presumably iron prosthetic foot. Only non-dwarves would see those as a problem, and dwarves have a much better track record with wounds and disabilities (not to mention gender equality) than the other races. A dwarf who considers himself ugly, like Thorin in Mad Baggins, might at least look forward to battle to add some “beauty marks”.
- “Unusual” Noses (by the standards of Men). Long pointed noses, snubbed noses, potato-shaped noses. The fine, aristocratic ski-jump of the elves is not appealing to dwarves. Give them a nose with a bit of personality. The line of Thror is particularly noted for the “Durin nose”, which is quite distinguished, though Bombur’s rounder one is equally attractive if in a different way.
So basically as I see it, Thorin is plain and his most attractive features are his nose, his battle scars, his long hair and the gray beginning to show up in it, however the short beard does take away from his overall aesthetic beauty and it is meant to be so.
Fili has a lot of potential, nice hair, the beginning of warrior muscles, fighting prowess, a good nose and attention to his looks in the form of his braids and beads. He could fill out a bit more, but he’s hardly a bad catch.
Kili basically looks like a pimple-faced teenager. There may be hope for him down the line, but really it’s a face only an elf could love (and they do).
Honestly, since my own standards are pretty broad (I personally have a terrible thirst for rounder figures, male or female, in addition to more conventional muscular ones, though of course it depends on the personality first and foremost) I have a great time subtly shifting “our” conventional standards of beauty a few degrees over to reset “true north” to something more dwarvish. It’s far more enjoyable to me than simply assuming that because Richard is gorgeous that Thorin would be to his own people. On a side note, I personally see Bilbo’s taste running to “odd” for his people as well, where he is completely mad for Thorin’s solid, muscular build, whereas most hobbits prefer softness. Bilbo, minus his lack of beard, actually runs pretty close to what dwarves find attractive (so like… he’s hot but has the equivalent of a shaved head to make him slightly unusual looking, but not unattractive by any means) to Thorin, who goes utterly crazy over his belly and body. Bilbo is a bit self-conscious, because he assumes that because he finds Thorin hot, Thorin must be hot by dwarven standards, and it takes a bit of clarification for him to understand that while Bilbo’s average for his people, Thorin is by no means all that special for his own. Bilbo considers himself a very lucky hobbit.
Similarly, with elves Kili’s biggest awakening was finding out that he’s about as hot as they get for dwarves, which is a welcome (even tearful) realization for him who always thought himself hopeless. Tauriel can’t get enough of him, and he can’t get enough of her, even if the other dwarves are confused XD
