Chapter Text
It was snowing, the big, clumpy flakes slowly drifting down and covering the ground in white.
Christian Ræder watched the snowfall from where he was sitting in his family’s main parlour, a book open in his lap that had long been abandoned. It was the first snowfall of the year, though it would most likely be gone in two or three days—rain would come soon enough, melting it all.
He sighed, resting his cheek on his hand. Across the room, his sister sat at a desk, writing out a letter, most likely to her fiancé. They were to be married in the spring, and his sister spent most of her time planning the wedding or writing her fiancé, who was currently away in Germany.
“Are you writing a letter to Frederik, Lillian?” he asked, looking over at his sister.
She nodded. “I am,” she answered. “But hopefully it shall be the last for a while, as he will soon be returning home in December.”
“Will he be staying with us?” Christian asked as he flipped idly through the pages of his book, not reading anything.
“For a while at least, I believe,” Lillian said. “Though he will most likely be with his own family, as well.”
“Ah,” Christian said, nodding in understanding. “They live up near Aalborg, do they not?”
“They do,” Lillian replied. “It’s a very lovely home, with a large, beautiful garden. You shall have to visit one day, when I am living there.”
“Oh, I will definitely have to,” Christian agreed. “If only to get away from Mor and Far.”
Lillian grinned, glancing over at him. “You make your own life difficult,” she said. “You and Oskar both. It is no wonder Mor and Far are always angry at you, with the tricks you both pull.”
“I am not nearly as bad as Oskar,” Christian argued, though he smirked. Oskar was the youngest of the three of them, though he and Christian were close in age, being only one year apart. They had been troublemakers since they were children, causing havoc for their nannies, parents, and even Lillian, who had been four at the time of Oskar’s birth.
“You are both equally bad,” Lillian insisted. “Honestly, it is a wonder that this house is still standing.”
“We have gotten better as we’ve grown, however,” Christian said. “You must admit that.”
“I admit nothing,” Lillian said, lifting her letter and blowing on it gently to dry the ink. Once she was satisfied, she carefully folded it and stood. “Now, I must make sure this gets in the post today, so I’m afraid I cannot continue this wonderful conversation. I will see you later, at dinner, if I do not see you beforehand.”
Christian nodded, and she disappeared out the door and down the hall. A few seconds later, his mother appeared in the doorway, looking frazzled and exasperated.
“Have you seen either of your siblings?” she asked. “I have things to discuss with both of them, but I have not been able to find either.”
“Lillian just left to post a letter,” Christian explained, closing his book and setting it down on the table beside him. “If you hurry you can catch her down the hall.”
His mother nodded. “And Oskar?” she asked, gathering up her skirts and looking down the hallway in the direction Lillian had gone.
Christian shrugged. “I have not seen him all afternoon,” he said, and his mother sighed.
“All right,” she said. “Thank you, min kære. I shall see you this evening.” With that, she was gone, the thud of her footsteps audible as she hurried down the corridor. Christian left soon after that, as well, going in search of his brother.
Unfortunately, there was a multitude of places that he could be. Christian’s father was a rather wealthy member of the Danish nobility and their home was not small, by any means. There were dozens of rooms Oskar could be in, and he might not even been in the building—he could have gone to the village for the afternoon and neglected to tell anyone, as was his usual habit.
It was, however, worth it to try. Christian had little else of greater importance to do, and knowing Oskar it would be near impossible for anyone else to find him. His best chance was most likely Oskar’s bedroom, up on the third floor and across the hallway from Christian’s own room. And so he made his way towards the staircase, checking each room as he went along and asking the few servants he came across if they had seen his brother—they all said no.
The third floor hallway was all but deserted when Christian arrived. It was nearly three o’clock in the afternoon, and few people were up there that time of day, as that was where the majority of the bedrooms were located. By one o’clock, most rooms had been vacated and cleaned, so there was little reason for anyone to be in that part of the house.
Oskar, however, was probably on the third floor the most of anyone in the house, usually because he was hiding from their parents. Christian and Oskar had realized together what a good hiding place the third floor bedrooms had been when they were seven and six and trying to escape their governess. They had run from her while in the library downstairs and, while trying to think of a good place to hide, Christian had suggested one of the spare bedrooms. They had hurried up two flights of stairs and into one of the more secluded bedrooms, crawling under its tall four-poster bed. No one had actually ended up finding them, and they had come out of hiding after nearly three hours simply because they were hungry. They never told anyone where they had been, and had continued to use the various bedrooms on the third floor as hiding spots when they were in trouble until they discovered the attic some four or five years later.
While Christian had, for the most part, outgrown their hiding, Oskar was still known to do it on occasion. Now, however, he tended to stay away from the spare bedrooms, mostly hiding in his own room or, more commonly, the attic.
“Oskar!” Christian called out, opening the door to his brother’s room and stepping inside. “Oskar, are you here?”
He waited for a moment—there was no response. Sighing, Christian bent down to check under the bed, but he wasn’t there; the closet was empty as well, which meant Oskar was, in all likelihood, either down at the village or in the attic.
Despite the large size of their house, the attic was remarkably small. Christian didn’t even know exactly why they had one, as it was used for very few things—he hadn’t even know it existed until he was around eleven, when he and Oskar had discovered its steep, narrow stairway, hidden in a back corner of the servants’ corridor on the very top floor.
They were not, technically, barred from going to the servants’ corridor, but it was simply accepted as a thing that was not done. Their father had great respect for their servants, and thus he preferred that his sons did not go about invading their privacy. Unfortunately, their father’s disapproval had never stopped them before, particularly when they were younger. Of course they never entered any of the rooms—they had simply been curious as to what the servants’ corridor looked like. The door to the attic stairway had looked different than the others, being narrower and lacking any names to determine whose room it led to. From that, they decided that it could not possibly be someone’s bedroom, and therefore it would be alright if they checked what was inside.
Later, they had decided to not tell anyone about their discovery. It would become another one of their hiding places, much like the spare bedrooms, though with considerably more space. Since then, the only person they had broken down and told was Lillian, and that had been years later.
Christian still felt like a trespasser every time he wandered up into the servants’ corridor, though he had been there many times since the attic’s discovery. Whenever he climbed the staircase to the house’s highest floor, he was breaking an unspoken rule, though no one save his father and mother would punish him for it, and they were unlikely to find out. Still, he crept along the hallway in silence, careful not to disturb anything or alert anyone who might be lingering nearby to his presence.
Unfortunately, the doorway to the attic was as far from the staircase that led up from the third floor as it could possibly be. The servants’ corridor was divided in two, with one side for the men and one for the women, separated by a locked door that only the head housekeeper could open. Thankfully, however, the staircase from the third floor led up into the male quarters and, though the hallway was long, when one reached the dividing door they only had to turn right into a branching corridor and, at the end, the door to the attic would be waiting.
It was that path that Christian took now, careful to move as quickly and as quietly as possible. It had been sometime since he last ventured up there, and he nearly forgot that the attic door needed to be opened as slowly as it could, or else it would give a loud, screeching creak. The stairs were rather squeaky as well, and Christian took care not to step too heavily on them.
If Oskar wasn’t up there, he was going to kill him when he did find him.
Another door stood at the top of the stairs, and Christian took less care with this one, though it was just as loud as the first. Inside, a sea of white drapes obscured the floor. The items stored up here were, for the most part, old paintings that had become torn or discoloured and were not valuable enough to repair. The only reason they had not been thrown away, Christian suspected, was because of his mother’s sentimentality—though the paintings no longer hung on the walls, he supposed she took some comfort in knowing they still existed, somewhere in the house.
There were three small windows in the attic and, to Christian’s relief, Oskar was sitting in front of one. He had turned at his brother’s arrival and was staring at him now with narrowed eyes, a frown tugging at the corners of his lips.
“What are you doing here?” he asked, and Christian scowled at him.
“I came to find you,” Christian explained, crossing his arms over his chest defensively. “Mor was looking for you.”
Oskar’s frown deepened. “I know,” he said. “Why do you suppose I am here?”
“I do not think you are in trouble,” Christian told him. “She didn’t seem angry—more urgent, in fact. She had been looking for Lillian, as well.”
Oskar let out a loud sigh, rolling his eyes and letting his head fall back against the wall behind him. “I know,” he repeated, and Christian raised an eyebrow at him. “She wishes to talk about the portrait that Far has commissioned. I have been hiding up here since late morning.”
Christian laughed. “You were acting as if it was something serious,” he said. “I thought you had done something horrible, but you are simply hiding from a conversation about jackets and pants.”
Oskar glowered at his brother. “You are so easy to dress,” he argued. “You do not know how terrible it can be, talking with Mor endlessly about boots that will not even been seen in the painting.”
Christian shook his head, smirking. Several weeks ago, their father had decided that he wanted a portrait of his children to be painted before Lillian got married and moved away, as the most recent one of all three of them had been painted several years before. Oskar had complained and moaned about it for days—he always hated getting portraits done, as he despised sitting still for hours on end with nothing to do and he was absolutely impossible to dress. He disliked whatever their mother picked, and she disliked whatever he picked. It was always a constant battle between the two of them when a portrait was commissioned.
“Hiding will not make it better,” Christian told him. “You might as well face her before she becomes even angrier.”
“Portraits are so dreadful,” Oskar whined, letting himself slowly slide down the chair he was sitting on until he was nearly lying on it.
Christian gave him an overdramatic sympathetic look, sighing wistfully and collapsing onto a nearby stool. “Oh, however do you live?” he asked, one hand placed over his heart. “Having to sit through all those portraits. Life is hard, is it not, in this large house with all these servants?”
“I did not mean it like that,” Oskar argued, scowling. “They’re just tedious and boring. All you do is sit in the same position for hours on end.”
“Oh, stop,” Christian said, jumping to his feet. “You’ll survive. Now come on—there is no sense in hiding from Mor forever, and it’s freezing up here. You’ll fall ill if you stay any longer.”
Oskar frowned, but didn’t argue, standing and following Christian back down the attic stairs and the servants’ corridor to the third floor.
◊◊◊
Jakob Nielsen’s paintbrush glided over the canvas, adding colour to the sketched face of the elderly woman sitting in front of him. He had been working on a portrait of her for several weeks now, and he would soon be finished; after the main part of the painting was done, he had only the details to add in.
The woman shifted in her seat, and Jakob glanced up at her. She was a member of Copenhagen’s upper class, well-dressed but incredibly talkative. She chatted the entire time Jakob worked, about trivial things he knew little about and didn’t care for. Her husband had commissioned the portrait, and he was paying well, so Jakob didn’t complain.
It had been nearly six years since his graduation from the Royal Danish Academy of Fine Arts. His focus had always been on portraiture—to him, the ability to capture someone’s image and likeness was an incredible thing, and he was able to create scenes around his subjects. Most of his work was commissions, and though he did not often get many most paid well enough that he was able to live comfortably.
The elderly woman sighed, moving her hands about in her lap. Jakob looked up at her, his brush hovering near the canvas.
“I am nearly finished, Fru Øster,” he said, turning his attention back to the painting. “Then you shall be free.”
“Will there be need of another session after this?” Fru Øster asked, trying her best to stay still.
Jakob thought for a moment before shaking his head. “I do not believe so, no,” he said. “I will be able to finish the portrait up quite easily.”
“May I see it after we are done today?”
“Of course,” Jakob said, smiling.
Less than an hour later they were finished, and Fru Øster stood admiring the portrait as Jakob cleaned his supplies and packed them away.
“It’s marvellous,” she said, one hand on her chest as she leaned in to get a closer look. “It’s a very beautiful scene.” Straightening, she turned to Jakob and smiled. “You are incredibly talented.”
“Thank you,” Jakob said, bowing his head slightly. “It should be finished within a fortnight.”
Fru Øster’s smile widened. “Wonderful,” she said. “I shall see you then.”
Jakob nodded, and departed soon after the elderly woman had left. A carriage was waiting for him outside her home, and he sat silent throughout the entire ride, staring pensively out the window at the city’s busy streets. It had begun to snow, the flakes lazily falling from the sky before melting on the cobblestone roads.
He was glad when the carriage finally reached his home. It was a small building located on one of Copenhagen’s quieter streets, but it was comfortable and it suited him. Inside, everything was quiet save for the continuous ticking of the grandfather clock in the parlour. A fire had been lit in every fireplace, so it was warm, though his maid, Ane, was nowhere to be seen.
Figuring she had gone to the market, he wandered upstairs to his studio. He put all his supplies back into their rightful place before going over to the small roll top desk shoved into a corner of the room. Its surface was covered in several letters of correspondence detailing various commissions and, searching through the letters, he tried to determine which he would be doing next. It appeared as if, in just under three weeks’ time, he would be starting a portrait commissioned by a nobleman of his three children. They lived nearly an hour outside of Copenhagen, but the pay was incredibly good and a carriage would be provided to take him to and from the house whenever needed.
Nodding to himself, he dropped the letter back unto the desk at the sound of the front door opening and Ane’s voice downstairs, calling out for him.
“Ja,” he replied, hurrying out of his study and back down to the first floor. “What is it?”
Ane looked up at him, shrugging her coat off her shoulders and hanging it up on the nearby wall. “I am making stew for dinner,” she said, picking up the basket she had set on the ground. “Is that alright?”
Jakob nodded. “Would you like any help?” he asked.
“If you have nothing else to do,” Ane said, shrugging. “I always enjoy cooking with you.”
Jakob smiled. It had been just over a year since he had hired Ane, and he had quickly found that she was more of a friend than a maid. His parents had never been particularly rich, and hadn’t had the money to hire a maid until Jakob was eleven. After he left his hometown of Aalborg, in the north of Jutland, and moved to Copenhagen, he had lived alone until he had hired Ane, though she didn’t actually live with him. She had her own home a few blocks away, and she split her time between him and a family down the street, as he didn’t have enough money to pay her for a full week.
Still, he enjoyed her company immensely. He was often alone, and have her around was comforting. They often cooked together, something which Jakob had always loved, and there were many times where he forgot Ane was his maid.
He followed her to the kitchen, where she began unpacking the basket, piling the various vegetables on the counter. Turning to him, she smiled.
“How is your painting?” she asked, handing him a handful of carrots to begin cleaning and cutting.
“Very good,” Jakob replied with a nod. “I will be finished very soon, and she seemed rather pleased with it.”
“That is good,” Ane said. “Do you have a commission after this one?”
“Yes, for a nobleman,” Jakob answered, and Ane’s eyebrows shot up in surprise.
“Where does he live?”
Jakob shrugged. “Only an hour outside the city,” he said. “He will be sending a carriage for me.”
“Who is the portrait of?” Ane asked, grabbing a bowl and filling it with water. “His wife? Or someone else?”
“His children,” Jakob explained. “Two sons and a daughter.”
Ane nodded in approval. “That will probably pay very well,” she said.
Jakob laughed, shaking his head. “You are just wishing for more money.”
“Of course,” Ane said with a loud laugh. “I have to eat.”
“Oh, I know you eat just fine,” he argued. “I would never let you go hungry.”
Ane flicked her wet fingertips at him, spraying him with water, and they both laughed. It was at times like these that Jakob was glad he had Ane—she always made him much happier.
◊◊◊
3 Weeks Later
Like Christian had predicted, that first snow had come and gone in only a matter of days, and it hadn’t snowed since, though the temperature still remained low.
“Why is it so cold?” Oskar asked as the two of them walked along the road, heading towards the nearby village. His hands were shoved into the pockets of his large frock coat, and he glared at the cloudy wisps his breath made.
“It is nearly winter,” Christian pointed out, and Oskar scowled. “And it could be much colder. Do you not remember the Christmas we spent in Norway with Far’s cousin?”
Oskar shuddered. “I despise the cold,” he said. “I cannot wait until spring.”
Christian scoffed. “I am afraid you have a long wait, then.” It was not even December yet, though that month was soon approaching. Their mother had already begun planning various events for Christmas—relatives from Jutland were planning to stay with them for the holidays, as was Lillian’s fiancé.
Oskar pulled a face. “Do not remind me,” he said. “Winter has not even begun.”
“It is not so bad,” Christian argued. “The snow is very beautiful, when it doesn’t melt after a few days. And usually it is not even that cold, so you have nothing to complain about.”
“I can complain if I want.”
Christian scoffed. “I have no trouble believing that.”
Oskar glared at him. “Why are we even going to the village?” he asked. “The portraitist will be here soon, and Mor will be furious if we are late.”
“Lillian asked me to check the post office for any letters for her,” Christian explained. “And I would like to visit the bookstore and see if they have any new arrivals.” Oskar let out a loud, exaggerated sigh, and Christian added, “You didn’t have to come with me, you know. I am perfectly capable of going to the village on my own.”
“I came to make sure you are back on time,” Oskar said, and Christian laughed.
“Yes, because you are so responsible yourself.”
“I can be,” Oskar argued. “I sometimes simply choose not to be.”
“Whatever you say,” Christian said, shaking his head.
◊◊◊
The house was absolutely amazing—one of the largest Jakob had ever seen. The grounds themselves were wondrous, but the interior was astounding. Paintings lined every hallway and hung on every inch of available wall space. Most were portraits, most likely of ancestors and relatives, Jakob guessed, but there were also several incredible landscapes. He could spend hours wandering the house’s corridors, observing each and every piece of artwork.
Unfortunately, however, that was not what he was there to do. A butler met him at the door and lead him to a small parlour, where an imposing man with dark hair streaked through with grey stood by the fireplace, his hands clasped firmly behind his back. On a nearby couch, a woman with silver hair sat in conversation with a younger lady who, for some reason, looked strikingly familiar to Jakob, though he knew he had never seen her before in his life.
He could not contemplate that for long, however, as the man had turned his attention to him and was walking over to where Jakob stood, hand outstretched.
“Jakob Nielsen, I assume?” he asked, and Jakob nodded, quickly taking his hand.
“Yes,” he said. “It is a privilege to be here, my Lord.”
The Count nodded. “My wife, Lady Agathe,” he said, motioning to the older woman, who bowed her head in greeting. “And my daughter, Lady Lillian.” The girl smiled. “Unfortunately,” the Count continued, drawing Jakob’s attention back to him. “My sons seem to have disappeared for the moment. No one is able to find them.”
“They will turn up soon,” Lillian said, and Jakob startled at her voice—it was almost definitely one he had heard before, though he could not think of how that was possible. “Fisker has gone to the village looking for them.”
Her father nodded in understanding. “In the meantime,” he said, nodding to the butler who had remained standing by the door. “Bjarnsen here shall show you to the room where the portrait will be painted, and you can begin your preparations. Hopefully it will not take too long to find the boys.”
“Thank you very much,” Jakob said, bowing his head before turning to the butler, Bjarnsen, who opened the door and motioned for him to exit.
He led him up a nearby staircase and down a maze of hallways to a room empty of nearly all furniture, save for a couch, an armchair, a table, and a stool.
“Will you need assistance with anything?” Bjarnsen asked as Jakob set his supplies down on the table.
“No, thank you,” he answered with a shake of his head, and Bjarnsen nodded, quickly leaving the room and closing the door behind him.
◊◊◊
Lillian arrived ten minutes later with her mother, obviously trying not to laugh as Agathe huffed into the room, a deep scowl on her face.
“Do not be so cross, Mor,” Lillian said, sitting down on the couch. “It is not nearly as serious as you make it out to be.”
“He was simply told to check for letters at the post office,” Agathe argued. “But instead he spends an hour strolling through the shops.”
“It is alright,” Lillian said, her voice quiet. “It is not a big problem. They returned soon enough, and all is once again right in the world.”
Agathe gave a long-suffering sigh, going over to her daughter and adjusting the short strand of pearl wrapped around her neck. “Let us hope they will be here soon,” she muttered.
“They are just getting changed,” Lillian assured her. “They are rather fast at that.”
Agathe said nothing, her lips pursed unhappily, before turning to Jakob. “My sons have just returned from the village,” she explained. “I am so sorry to keep you waiting like this.”
Jakob shook his head. “It is perfectly alright, my Lady,” he said with a smile.
“They can be dreadfully troublesome, my sons,” Agathe said with a sigh. “They are twenty and nineteen—one would think they would have learned to look after themselves by now.”
A few minutes later, the pounding of footsteps sounded in the hallway and two boys burst through the door, one pushing the other through with a disgruntled growl.
“I knew I couldn’t trust you,” he was saying, his voice a hissed whisper. His back was turned on Jakob, so he could not see his face, but his brother looked annoyed. “And now we are both in trouble because you couldn’t keep yourself from wandering off and chasing after the village girls.”
“You knew—”
“Christian, Oskar,” Agathe snapped, striding over to where the boys stood. “That is enough. We will discuss this later.”
Oskar frowned, but nodded. “Ja, Mor,” he said, going over and sitting beside his sister. Jakob watched the two, his eyebrows furrowed slightly. There was something about them both that was eerily familiar, and no matter how hard he thought he could not figure out why.
“Christian, please sit down,” Agathe said quietly, pushing her son towards the couch and drawing Jakob’s attention back to them. “You have already held everyone up enough, and there is no need to argue right now.”
Christian grumbled something unhappily but complied. As he turned towards the couch, he glanced at Jakob and paused, his eyes going wide and his mouth falling open in shock.
“Oh.”
They stared at each other for a moment, and Bilbo opened his mouth to speak before quickly catching himself. Thorin’s siblings were staring at him expectantly, and his mother still stood by the door, an exasperated look on her face.
“Christian.” It was Dís who spoke up, drawing both Thorin’s and Bilbo’s attention towards her. “Are you alright?” she asked.
Thorin said nothing at first, glancing back at Bilbo for a split second before nodding. “Yes, I’m fine,” he answered, hurrying over to the couch and sitting down.
“I would love to stay,” Agathe said, and Bilbo turned to face her. “But I have things to attend to. You are ready to start?”
Bilbo nodded. “Yes, thank you, my Lady,” he said.
Agathe smiled. “Organize them however you like,” she told him, motioning to her children. “My husband spoke to you about how he would like it to look?”
“Yes, he did,” Bilbo said with another nod.
“Then I shall leave you to it,” she said, before looking at her sons. “Behave you two. Please.”
With that she was gone, and Bilbo turned back towards the three siblings. Oskar—Frerin, Bilbo reminded himself—already looked bored, and was inspecting the knotted floorboards under his feet. Dís was saying something to Thorin, too quietly for Bilbo to hear, but he didn’t seem to be paying her any regard. All his attention was focused on Bilbo, who gave him a small smile before doing his best to school his features into neutrality, and stood.
“Your name is Christian, correct?” he asked, walking around to the front of his easel and looking at Thorin, who stared wide-eyed at him as if he had been expecting him to say something completely different.
He nodded, and Bilbo smiled again. “Would you mind standing behind the couch?” he questioned, and Thorin shook his head.
When he had moved to the back of the couch, Bilbo turned his attention to the other two. “Now, could you sit closer to each other?”
“Of course,” Dís said with a smile, shuffling closer to her youngest brother, who did the same.
“Thank you very much,” Bilbo said, bowing his head and returning behind the easel. “I think that position will do just fine.”
Grabbing a piece of charcoal, he began sketching the outline of the portrait onto the canvas, turning the couch into what looked like a garden bench, glancing up every so often.
“Could you put both hands on the back of the couch, Lord Christian?” Bilbo asked, breaking the silence that had permeated the room for the past several minutes. “One on top of the other, just like that.”
Thorin complied, putting his hands together on the couch back and straightening his posture in the process. “Will I have to stand here like this all day?” he asked, and Bilbo smiled slightly, shaking his head.
“Nej,” he answered. “Only until I have drawn the positions, which will not take long.”
Thorin nodded, and no one said anything else for a long while. Bilbo was bursting to speak—he longed to talk with Thorin, to actually say something meaningful to him. But painters did not speak with their clients, especially if they were the sons of noblemen. So he remained quiet and focused on his work, trying not to get lost in the thoughts racing around his mind.
The minutes ticked by in silence. Occasionally the siblings would talk quietly amongst themselves, but never for long before they fell quiet again.
For a moment Bilbo wondered how his time with Thorin would end here—would he somehow end up lying once more on the ground, bleeding and in excruciating pain, or would everything, in some extraordinary way, end well for once?
Though he wished he didn’t, he was quite sure he knew which once was more likely.
◊◊◊
The sun was beginning to set when Bilbo finally announced that he was done for the day. Frerin was the first on his feet, giving Bilbo a quick thanks before all but running from the room, a look of immense relief on his face. Dís stayed for longer, talking with Bilbo about the painting and other work he had done while Thorin held back, lingering near the couch and wringing his hands together anxiously.
When Dís finally turned to leave, she gave him an expectant look, as if wondering if he was going to be coming with her or not. He shook his head, and told her he would see her at dinner. She looked confused, but said nothing, leaving the room with one last nod at Bilbo.
Once she gone, Thorin quickly hurried over to the door, closing it quietly before turning and running to Bilbo. He threw his arms around him, pulling him as close as he possibly could.
“Bilbo,” he breathed, his fingers twining into Bilbo’s hair.
Bilbo laughed, clutching tightly to the back of Thorin’s jacket, not even thinking about the charcoal covering his hands. Thorin could feel the tears welling up in his eyes but he held them back, burying his face in Bilbo’s shoulder.
“I missed you,” he whispered. “I’m so glad you’re here.”
“I am too,” Bilbo murmured, turning and kissing the side of Thorin’s head.
Thorin lifted his head and smiled, cupping Bilbo’s face in his hands. “I cannot believe this keeps happening,” he muttered, and kissed him.
They broke apart quickly when a pair of footsteps sounded outside the door. Thankfully, however, they kept walking, but Bilbo still frowned.
“You should go,” he said, turning towards his supplies and nervously gathering them up. “People will begin to wonder where you are, and I must get home before dark. We will talk more another time.”
Thorin’s eyebrows furrowed together. “Where do you live?”
“Copenhagen,” Bilbo said. “Someone will be up any minute to bring me to the carriage.” He paused for a moment, sighing loudly. “I hate this. I hate having to hide and lie every time.”
“What else can we do?” Thorin asked and Bilbo’s frown deepened.
“All we can do is live with it,” he said after several seconds had passed. “At least for now.” Dropping his supplies back on to the table, he walked over to Thorin, one hand reaching up to sweep the hair away from his face.
“I love you so much, you know?” Thorin whispered, and Bilbo nodded.
“I love you, too,” he replied, kissing him gently. Pulling back, he let his hand drop to his side. “Now you must go. Quickly, before someone comes looking for one or both of us.”
Thorin nodded. “When will you return?” he asked, backing towards the door.
“Two days,” Bilbo answered. “I shall see you then.”
Thorin smiled and, after only a moment’s hesitation, turned and hurried out the door, leaving it open behind him.
◊◊◊
Thorin sat in front of a window in the library, an unopened book in his lap. His gaze was focused on the world outside, where a light, misting rain was falling, making everything damp and cold. It was mid-morning, and soon the carriage that had left a few hours before would be returning with Bilbo inside.
He felt a bit odd, sitting by a window waiting for Bilbo to return. But there was little else that he could do—whenever he tried, he found himself constantly returning to the window, looking for any sign of the carriage.
“What are you looking at?”
Thorin jumped at his sister’s voice, turning to see her standing in the doorway, her hands clasped behind her back.
“You had a very intense look on your face,” she noted, leaving the doorway and walking closer to him.
“I was watching the rain,” Thorin lied, looking back out the window.
Dís smirked. “You looked like a wife pining for her lost husband,” she said, and Thorin glared at her.
“Who would I be pining for, Lillian?” he asked, and she shrugged.
“I would not know,” she said, still grinning.
Thorin’s scowl deepened. “What are you doing here?”
“Mor sent me to find you,” Dís explained. “The portraitist will be here soon, and you must get ready.”
Thorin nodded, setting the book he had been holding down on a nearby table and standing. “Is Oskar dressed yet?”
“I’ve no idea where Oskar is,” Dís said with a sigh. “I have looked all over for him. I suppose he is trying to hide for as long as he possibly can.”
“I’ll find him,” Thorin said, casting one last look out the window before walking with his sister to the door.
Dís nodded. “Get dressed first, though,” she told him. “It would be better to only have one of you late than both.”
“Alright,” Thorin said. “I shall see you in a short while.”
“Be quick about it,” Dís advised as he turned and wandered down the hallway towards his room. “Let’s try not to keep Mr. Nielsen waiting again.”
◊◊◊
All three siblings were waiting in the room when Bilbo arrived, lead by the same butler as two days before whom, he realized quite suddenly, had a striking resemblance to Balin, only slightly younger. He had tried his best not to stare as they had wound their way through the ornate corridors to the same room that had been used only a couple of days prior. The butler held himself in much the same way as Balin had, and when they entered the room he gave both Thorin and Frerin a look that very much seemed to tell them that they should watch themselves. Frerin looked very insulted by that look, and glared at Balin like a child would glare at a tutor, though the butler ignored it.
“Will you be needing anything?” he asked Bilbo, who shook his head, smiling.
“No, thank you,” he said. “I think this will be just fine.”
Balin nodded and quickly left the room, closing the door behind him. Bilbo got to work quickly, arranging the siblings into the proper positions and getting out all his necessary materials.
Frerin and Dís were much more talkative than the previous day, chatting quietly with each other while Bilbo worked, planning to add some final touches to the charcoal drawing before he began painting. Thorin, however, was for the most part very quiet, and whenever Bilbo glanced up he seemed to be lost in thought, though his eyes never strayed from where Bilbo sat.
Over an hour later, Bilbo finally finished the charcoal drawing and began mixing the paint, getting the right colours he would need and setting out his various brushes. He started with Dís—her hair was dark like Thorin’s, though her face was much rounder and her nose less prominent. She looked nearly identical to Elspeth, though her hair and dresses were very different. It was odd to see this woman who looked so much like one of his closest friends, and yet who didn’t know him at all. And in a way, he didn’t know her either—she was no longer Elspeth, and didn’t remember the life she had lived over eighty years ago in another country. She had the same looks and personality, but she was a different person.
“Could you please look at me, Lady Lillian?” he asked, and Dís complied, a small smile tugging at the corners of her lips. Bilbo looked up at her, and smiled in return. “You have very beautiful eyes,” he observed. “They are a very rich colour.”
Dís’s smile widened. Her eyes were much darker than either of her brothers’—where theirs were an icy blue, her’s were a deep, nearly indigo, colour. Bilbo added a small amount of purple to the dark blue he had already mixed, bringing it closer to Dís’s true eye colour.
Looking up again, he turned his attention to Frerin and Thorin. “You two may leave, if you wish,” he said. “I am afraid there is little reason for you to stay—the rest of my time today will most likely be spent painting Lady Lillian.”
Frerin was on his feet and out the door in seconds, muttering a quick thank you to Bilbo as he passed by. Thorin, however, seemed to hesitate, his gaze jumping from Bilbo to Dís to the door where Frerin had disappeared. Bilbo smiled warmly at him, trying to assure him that he would see him later. Thorin left a few seconds later, after pausing by the easel to thank Bilbo, who reached out and touched his hand, lightly and quickly enough that Dís didn’t see.
◊◊◊
Thorin stood inside the doorway of a room next to the one where Bilbo was working, the door open just enough for him to see outside into the corridor. It was mid-afternoon, and he had been sitting in the front parlour trying to focus on a letter to his cousin when, in the hallway, a butler had told one of the footmen to go tell the stable boys to prepare the carriage for Mr. Nielsen.
He had hurried upstairs and, hearing Dís and Bilbo talking behind the closed door, had slipped into a nearby sitting room to wait until his sister left. When the door did finally open and Dís walked out, Thorin watched her quietly until she disappeared down the hallway before he practically ran to the room where Bilbo now stood, collecting his various supplies.
He looked up when Thorin entered, blinking in surprise.
“Thorin,” he said. “How did—”
“I just spent the last ten minutes hiding in a sitting room,” Thorin explained, a smile stretching across his face. “Watching the corridor until my sister left.”
Bilbo stared at him for a moment before laughing. “Why?” he asked.
“I wanted to see you before you left,” Thorin explained. “To talk to you like a real person.”
Bilbo smiled. “I’m glad you did.” Setting the brushes he had been holding back down and going over to Thorin, he cupped his face with his paint-covered hands. Rubbing one thumb absently along his cheek bone, Bilbo’s expression softened. “How long do you think we have this time?” he whispered.
Thorin said nothing for a moment, his mouth falling open before quickly closing again, unsure of what to say.
“In Middle-earth, we were together for... what, seven months?” Bilbo said, dropping his hands and shoving them into his pockets. “And you spent half of that time hating me.”
“I never ha—” Thorin started, but stopped at the look Bilbo gave him.
“Then in Scotland it was only five... six months,” Bilbo continued, chewing anxiously on his bottom lip as he paced the room. “We were apart for most of that, anyways. Then it wasn’t even a day. Thorin, I died less than a day after meeting you again.” He paused, looking at Thorin with his eyebrows creased. “What about this time? Will I die again? Or will you? I don’t want to lose you for a second time, Thorin.”
Thorin stared at him, blinking. “Why are you talking like this?” he asked, and Bilbo sighed, burying his face in his hands.
“Because I’m scared,” he mumbled. “I love you so much, Thorin. When you first showed up on my doorstep back at Bag End, I never thought I could like you, let alone love you as much as I do. And I was so happy when I saw you walk into the room two days ago. But now... when I look at you I feel scared. I don’t want you to die, and I don’t want to die either. But that’s what has been happening—we meet, and then we die, whether it is months or hours later.”
Thorin swallowed thickly. He wasn’t sure what to say—what could he say? They were both silent for a moment.
“Do you think this is Hell?” Thorin asked after several seconds had gone by.
“What?”
“This... cycle,” Thorin explained. “Do you think it’s Hell? That this is God punishing us?”
Bilbo was quiet, staring at Thorin with sad eyes. He looked as if he was about to reply when the door opened and a butler stepped in. It was Bjarnsen—the man had worked for Thorin’s family since he was a child, and he had realized quite suddenly the day before that he was, or at least had been, Balin.
“Oh, Lord Christian,” Balin said, noticing Thorin and giving a slight bow. “I did not think you would be up here.”
“I was just talking to Mr. Nielsen about the painting,” Thorin lied, nervously glancing at Bilbo, who had turned away from him and was quickly gathering up his supplies.
Balin nodded in understanding. “I just came to fetch Mr. Nielsen,” he explained, turning to Bilbo. “Your carriage is ready, sir.”
“Ah, yes, thank you,” Bilbo answered, his words coming out rapidly and all at once. “I will be ready in just a moment.”
“I can take Bi—Mr. Nielsen to the carriage,” Thorin offered. “I am sure you have a lot of work to do, Bjarnsen, and it would make no sense for you to stand here waiting for Mr. Nielsen to clean up.”
“It is perfectly alright with me,” Balin argued. “There is no need for you to bring Mr. Nielsen to the carriage.”
“Do not worry, Bjarnsen,” Thorin assured him, resting one hand on his shoulder. “I can do this.”
Balin seemed to hesitate for a moment, glancing from Bilbo to Thorin. “Is this alright with you, Mr. Nielsen?” he asked, and Bilbo looked up from where he had been sorting his brushes.
“Yes, of course,” he said, nodding. “I would be delighted to get the chance to talk to Lord Christian some more about the portrait.”
Balin watched him for a moment before nodding himself. “Then I shall leave it to you, Lord Christian,” he said. “Be sure not to keep the carriage waiting for too long. It appears as if the rain is soon going to grow heavier.”
Thorin nodded and with that Balin excused himself, letting the door close gently behind him. They stood in silence for a while, neither of them entirely sure what to say.
“I love you,” Thorin whispered after a moment had passed, his voice just loud enough for Bilbo to hear.
“I know,” Bilbo replied, closing his brush case and clicking it shut. “I love you, too. But I’m just... I’m scared for what’s going to happen.”
“You don’t need to be,” Thorin said, stepping closer and putting both hands on Bilbo’s shoulders. “I love you, and I will always try my best to be with you. It does not matter to me if this really is Hell, so long as I have you, even if it is only for a short while.”
Bilbo took in a deep breath and let himself lean in towards Thorin, wrapping his arms around him. “I know,” he repeated, his voice hushed. “Of course I know that. And we’ll... we’ll have to get through this together. There isn’t anyone else we can turn to.”
Thorin smiled, though it was small and sad, and gently kissed Bilbo, his lips lingering on his skin. “You will be back tomorrow?” he asked, and Bilbo nodded.
“I’ll paint you next,” he murmured. “Then we can speak more.”
“Alright,” Thorin agreed, pulling back slightly. “Now, we should not keep the carriage waiting any longer, or else Balin will be angry with me.”
Bilbo perked up at the sound of Balin’s name, a grin pulling at the corners of his mouth. “I knew that was Balin,” he said, clapping his hands together happily. “He looks so different, without the forked beard and tall hair.”
“His nose is quite a bit smaller, as well,” Thorin said, and Bilbo gave a quiet laugh.
“Yours is as well, you know,” he pointed out. “Much less Dwarvish.”
Thorin smirked, shaking his head. “Come,” he said, motioning to the door. “If all of your things are collected, I will take you to the carriage.”
Bilbo nodded and, grabbing his supplies, followed Thorin out into the hallway. “I do quite miss the braids, though,” he mumbled as Thorin lead him towards the staircase. “And the beard. They suited you.”
Thorin laughed, and glanced back to look at Bilbo. “Maybe one day I will grow a beard again for you.”
◊◊◊
Dís sat poised perfectly still, her hands resting delicately on her lap. Bilbo studied her carefully, noticing how the light bounced off the strand of pearls on her neck and carefully highlighting the necklace in the portrait.
“You are a very good subject, Lady Lillian,” he told her with a smile. “Most people fidget endlessly, but you stay completely still—few people are so good with getting their portrait painted.”
“Oh, thank you,” Dís said, smiling in return. “I suppose I have had some practice, and my mother told me when I was a child that if I sat still, it would be over sooner.”
Bilbo nodded in agreement. “That is certainly true,” he said. “I am nearly finished painting, actually.”
“Ah, very good,” Dís said. “You seem to be very skilled, Mr. Nielsen.”
“Thank you very much, Lady Lillian,” Bilbo said, smiling at her gratefully.
“I can never understand how some people are so talented,” she said with a sigh. “I can hardly draw, let alone paint such a realistic portrait.”
“It is all a matter of practice, my Lady,” Bilbo replied. “I spent most of my youth drawing crude portraits of my family, and I was simply lucky enough to have the opportunity to pursue it as a livelihood. I have had many wonderful teachers throughout my life, and I put much of my time into practicing.”
“I do not think I have that dedication,” Dís said, momentarily pursing her lips unhappily before looking at Bilbo, a curious expression on her face. “Tell me about your family,” she asked, quickly adding, “If you would like.”
Bilbo nodded. “I would love to, my Lady,” he answered. “I grew up in Aalborg, where my father owned a rather successful shop. I have no siblings, and my few cousins were much younger than me, so my home was very quiet when I was young. I enjoyed it, however—in addition to portraits of my parents, I often drew scenes of various rooms in our home. It was always very peaceful and calm.”
“That sounds very nice,” Dís said, smiling. “Aalborg is a very lovely city. It is where my fiancé lives.”
“Then you shall soon be living there as well,” Bilbo said, and Dís nodded.
“It seems a lovely place to grow up,” she said. “I feel as though I would get lonely, however, without any siblings or cousins. My home has always been very busy.”
“It is nice, though, to know you always have family nearby,” Bilbo pointed out, setting his brush down. “They are there when you need them.”
“That is true,” she said with a nod. “You are a very kind person, you know, Mr. Nielsen, and incredibly easy to talk to.”
Bilbo stood, nodding in thanks. “Thank you very much, my Lady,” he said. “You are very kind yourself. Kinder than most.”
Dís smiled. “Have we finished for today?” she asked, standing as Bilbo nodded again.
“Would you like to see what I have done so far?” he questioned, and Dís nodded enthusiastically, hurrying around to the other side of the easel.
“It’s amazing,” she said, staring at the painting in wonder. “It looks so... realistic, even if most of it is unpainted.”
Bilbo smiled gratefully. “Thank you very much, Lady Lillian,” he said.
“It is no wonder Far commissioned you,” Dís said. “You are incredibly talented.”
“Thank you.”
“I am very grateful to you for doing this,” she told him, before turning and heading towards the door. “I will tell Bjarnsen to send Christian up. He should not be long.”
Bilbo nodded once more. “I shall see you in a few days, my Lady,” he said, and she smiled at him one last time before opening the door and walking out into the hallway.
◊◊◊
2 Weeks Later
Bilbo stood to the side, his hands crossed behind his back as the portrait hanging on the wall was inspected. He had finished it the day before, and it had been hung on the wall of the main sitting room less than an hour ago. Thorin, his siblings, and his parents had all hurried in to see it, commenting on how beautiful and perfectly done it was.
“You are incredibly talented, Mr. Nielsen,” Agathe said, smiling warmly at Bilbo.
“Thank you, Lady Agathe,” Bilbo said with a polite nod. “It has been my pleasure.”
“We shall have to commission you for other works,” Thorin’s father—Thráin—said. “Your work is highly commendable.”
Bilbo nodded once more in thanks, turning to look at the portrait himself. It was one of the largest pieces he had worked on, with three subjects and a sizable canvas, but one that he found it was easy to be proud of. A large part of portraiture, he felt, was being able to capture the essence of someone in a painting and, having known both Thorin and Dís for a long period of time, he thought that he had done just that. Frerin had been more difficult, but Bilbo had been able to piece together a nice enough picture of him from what Thorin told him and the few conversations he had had with him.
It was also, of course, a very beautiful portrait, though he felt odd thinking that. Ane always told him that he was too humble—he was extremely talented, she said, and should allow himself to recognise that occasionally. And as he observed the painting, he let himself be prideful for once. There were parts that he would like to change, but that was true for all portraits, and he found that this one had fewer than most. The background complimented the subjects very nicely, and it matched the style of the rest of the sitting room as well. So, for once, he allowed himself to think that he had done a relatively good job.
“Thank you very much,” Agathe said, drawing Bilbo’s attention from the painting. “We shall enjoy this portrait for a very long time.”
“It had been an absolute privilege to paint it,” Bilbo told her, bowing slightly. “Thank you.”
Agathe nodded in acknowledgement and smiled, before turning to leave. She was followed shortly by her husband, who gave Bilbo one final nod as thanks before leaving, a footman close behind.
“It is very nice,” Frerin told Bilbo, shaking his hand shortly before hurrying out the door into the hallway, casting one last look at the painting.
Dís approached him soon after, thanking him earnestly for his work. “I shall hope to see you again soon,” she told him. “I am to be married in the spring, and perhaps I shall commission you to paint a portrait of me and my husband.”
“I would be honoured to do so,” Bilbo said, taking her hand and lightly pressing his lips to it. “You are an absolute delight to work with, Lady Lillian.”
Dís smiled widely. “Then I shall see you soon,” she said, and Bilbo nodded as she slowly left the room, turning several times to look back at the portrait before stepping into the hall, closing the door behind her and leaving only Bilbo and Thorin.
“Have you always been this talented?” Thorin asked, turning look at Bilbo with a smirk on his face.
“Not always,” Bilbo said, slowly moving closer to Thorin as he spoke. “I could draw relatively well before, but most of this came after years of practice and training.”
“It appears to have been well worth it,” Thorin observed. “My family was very impressed, and I am sure that will mean more work for you.”
“Then perhaps I shall be able to see you more often,” Bilbo said. “For I don’t know if we will be able to meet for a while, as I have no reason to come here anymore.”
Thorin frowned, his arms crossed over his chest. “Perhaps I can find a way to visit you in Copenhagen,” he suggested. “I have many friends there, and my parents will believe me if I say that I am going to visit one for a week.”
“But would you have to tell them the name of an actual friend?” Bilbo asked. “Otherwise they might become suspicious. And even if you do, what if they later talk to that friend and realize that you lied?”
“My parents will not care if they have heard of the person or not,” Thorin assured him. “Though Frerin and Dís will be much more difficult...” He paused, running his teeth over his bottom lip. “I shall have to think more deeply about it. Give me your address, so I can write to you. It will likely be some time before my father commissions another portrait, and I would like to see you before then.”
Bilbo smiled, and followed Thorin over to a nearby desk. A pen was already laying there, and Bilbo dipped it in a well of ink as Thorin procured a piece of paper. He hastily wrote his address down, blowing on the page in order to quickly dry the ink before folding it up and handing it to Thorin.
“Write as soon as you can,” he said, his voice quiet as he glanced towards the door. “I’m afraid I must go now, but I will see you soon. No matter what.”
Thorin smiled and kissed him quickly, carefully putting the slip of paper in his coat pocket.
“I love you,” Bilbo said, taking Thorin’s hands in his own.
“I love you, too,” Thorin whispered.
“Stay safe, until I see you again,” Bilbo told him, and Thorin nodded, letting his hands drop to his sides as Bilbo turned towards the door.
“I promise.”
◊◊◊
1 Month Later
Thorin watched as the streets of Copenhagen passed by, the carriage jostling down the cobblestone roads. A thin layer of snow covered everything, and from the grey clouds gathering overhead it appeared as if more was to come. Despite the oncoming weather, the city was still full of people, bustling about on errands and visits. It had been a long time since he had last visited Copenhagen—it was near enough to his home, but there was little reason for him to go, so he rarely did.
The driver pulled up in front of a tall brick townhouse, bringing the horses to a halt and climbing down from his seat. He wasn’t Thorin’s family driver, as he knew where Bilbo lived and would ask why Thorin was visiting him. Instead, Thorin had had him take him to the house of a friend that he had said he would be staying with, and had borrowed his driver. Thankfully, neither of them asked questions—his friend owed Thorin a favour, and had likely concocted some story for his driver.
As Thorin stepped down onto the street, the house’s front door opened and Bilbo appeared, a wide smile on his face. His coat was unbuttoned, its collar skewed as if he had thrown it on in a hurry, but he still rushed down the steps to greet Thorin, clasping his hand tightly.
“It is so good to see you again,” he said, his voice quiet as the driver unloaded Thorin’s luggage. It was only one trunk, and Bilbo quickly assured the driver that they could bring it inside themselves.
“Then I shall see you in one week, my Lord?” the man asked, turning to Thorin, who nodded.
“Thank you very much,” Thorin said. “It is incredibly kind of you do to this, and I am so sorry for inconveniencing you in any way.”
The driver smiled, bowing his head. “It is no trouble at all, my Lord,” he assured him. “Farvel.”
“Thank you,” Bilbo added as the driver returned to his seat, nodding once at Bilbo before flicking the reins and driving off.
Once he was gone, Bilbo turned to face Thorin once more, his smile growing wider as he broke into a laugh. “I cannot believe you are here,” he said.
“It is very wonderful to see you,” Thorin replied, resisting the urge to kiss him then and there.
“It shall just be you and me for this next week,” Bilbo said. “I have given my housekeeper some time off, though that means we shall have to make our own meals. Fortunately, I am a rather good cook.”
“Oh, yes, I know,” Thorin said, nodding. “I do vividly remember you once emptying your larders for a large group of rowdy Dwarves, and that the food was quite good.”
Bilbo laughed again, and shook his head. “Come, let’s go inside,” he said, going over to the trunk and taking one end, motioning for Thorin to take the other. “It has gotten rather cold.”
Thorin complied, helping Bilbo carry the trunk up the steps and through the door. They set it down in the main entryway, and as Thorin straightened and looked around he had an odd feeling, as if he was stepping back into Bag End.
It wasn’t the exact same, of course, as this was an actual house and not a Hobbit hole. But it very much had the same feeling—brightly coloured rugs on the floor, books stacked against the walls, and random pieces of paper on all the tables. Turning to Bilbo, he grinned.
“I thought you said you had a maid,” he said.
Bilbo glowered at him. “My house is very clean, thank you,” he argued. “And it’s organized. I know precisely where everything is.”
“It reminds me very much of Bag End,” Thorin pointed out, looking around at the various paintings and maps hanging on the walls. “I should have liked to go back there one day, you know.”
“That would have been nice,” Bilbo said with a small smile. “But you are here now, even though this is not Bag End. It shall have to be enough.”
Thorin smiled in return. “It is,” he said, leaning in to gently kiss Bilbo’s forehead. “You should take me on a tour.”
“Of course,” Bilbo agreed, taking a step backward and dramatically gesturing towards one of the doorways that branched out from the entryway. “If you will follow me, my Lord, into the front parlour.”
Thorin laughed, trailing after Bilbo as he backed into the parlour, his eyes focused on Thorin the entire time as a wide smile spread across his face.
◊◊◊
Bilbo woke up in the early hours of the morning to a dim, grey light filtering into the room. The quiet rap of raindrops against glass could be heard, and as he turned to face the window he could see a light rain falling, covering the window in droplets that rolled down in long rivulets. The air in the room was bitterly cold and Bilbo shivered, trying to bury himself deeper under the pile of blankets covering his body.
Beside him, Thorin mumbled something incoherent and rolled over onto his stomach, wrapping his arms around a pillow. Bilbo turned to face him, a slight smile on his face. He watched him sleep for several minutes before forcing himself to get out of bed, quickly pulling on a housecoat. He hurried over to the fireplace, his feet cold on the bare floor, and restarted the fire as quietly as he could, hovering nearby as the flames roared to life. When he turned back to face the bed, Thorin was awake, blinking blearily at Bilbo.
“Good morning,” Bilbo said, and Thorin smiled.
“Good morning,” he replied, pulling the blankets up to his chin. “It’s so cold in here...”
“That’s why I restarted the fire,” Bilbo said, crawling back up onto the bed and laying down beside Thorin. “It is winter.”
Thorin’s eyes cracked open as he glared at Bilbo. “You do not have to be so sarcastic,” he said.
Bilbo laughed. “I’m sorry,” he said, before sitting up again. “Come, get up. I am going to make breakfast.”
“I will be down in a moment,” Thorin said, humming unhappily about the prospect of moving.
“If you are not downstairs in ten minutes, I am coming back,” Bilbo threatened, climbing off the bed and walking over to the door, quickly glancing back at Thorin before disappearing down the hallway.
◊◊◊
Thorin woke up to Bilbo hovering above him, a scowl on his face. He blinked, rubbing his eyes sleepily.
“I fell back asleep,” he said, and Bilbo sighed.
“You did. An hour ago. But I decided to leave you alone while I cooked, as you appeared to be tired.”
“Sorry.”
“You had better be,” Bilbo said, like a parent berating their child. “My breakfast is going to be cold, and we only have a few hours before your driver returns.”
Thorin groaned. He had forgotten that he was leaving to return home that day. It was hard to believe that an entire week had passed—it felt like it had only been a few days.
“I do not want to leave,” he moaned, forcing himself to sit up.
“I do not want you to, either,” Bilbo said. “But unfortunately you must. You cannot stay here forever.”
“I know,” Thorin said with a sigh. “I simply wish I knew when I would see you again.”
Bilbo gave him a small smile. “Soon enough,” he promised, giving him a quick kiss on the cheek. “Now, come and eat. Your driver will be here in only three hours.”
◊◊◊
2 Months Later
Thorin laughed, watching as, ahead of him, Frerin flew through the trees, nearly standing in his saddle as he urged his horse to go faster. It was incredibly warm for March, and the ground was wet and covered in mud from recent rain. There had been no snow for weeks, and it appeared as if there wouldn’t be until winter came again. Frerin had been incredibly excited by the coming of spring, and had convinced Thorin to go riding with him.
He had, of course, soon turned the affair into a race, disappearing into the nearby forest and goading Thorin to follow him. He still had a lead, but Thorin was catching up to him quickly and could soon overtake him.
“Where is the finish?” Thorin called, leaning forward in an attempt to make his horse run faster.
“The fence near the field!” Frerin cried, turning to look back at his brother for a split second, a wide smile on his face. “We’re almost there!”
Thorin kicked in his heels. He and Frerin had always been staunch competitors against each other, always wanting to see who was the best at this or who could do that the fastest. They were very good competition—they often tied, and if one did win the other was often close behind. This, however, meant that they were constantly trying to prove themselves to be better, particularly when they were young.
As the fence came into view, Thorin realised he most likely wasn’t going to win this one. If the finish had been only a bit further he might have had a chance, but Frerin’s head start had been too great. Still, he attempted to quicken his pace one last time before Frerin passed the fence, slowing down only after he had passed it as well.
“Ha!” Frerin yelled, lifting his hands above his head in victory. “I knew I would win.”
“That is because you are cheating,” Thorin pointed out, glowering at his brother. “Let us do something else, more fairly.”
Frerin looked at him for a moment before nodding. “Alright,” he agreed. “I will go home around the forest, and you will go home through the thickest part, along the river. Let’s see who will get there the fastest.”
Thorin nodded in agreement, looking down to where the river entered the forest, several metres down. “I will go over to the river, near the tree line, and when I am there and ready we will start,” he said.
“Let’s do it,” Frerin said, and watched as Thorin galloped off to the river. When he arrived and was in position, he lifted one arm and Frerin nodded, preparing himself.
“Go!” Thorin cried, and they were gone, Frerin riding off along the edge of the forest and Thorin crashing through it.
The way around the forest was longer, but there were few obstacles and so Frerin could go faster, while Thorin had to constantly slow down so that he did not fall. He stayed as close to the riverbank as possible, speeding up when there were fewer obstacles, wishing to move as fast as possible.
As he came upon a clearing, with no trees standing anywhere near the river, he increased his speed even more. The forest blurred as he galloped by, clumps of mud flying up under his horse’s hooves.
Then he was in the air, the river’s bank gone underneath him. It had grown soft from the rain and melting snow, and had given out under the weight of his horse, throwing them both into the river. Thorin hit the icy cold water with a splash, gasping for air and sucking in a mouthful of water instead. As the strong current began to pull him downstream, his head was knocked into a large rock jutting out of the water. He passed out less than a second later.
◊◊◊
They found his body nearly five hours later, washed ashore several hundred metres downstream from where he had fallen in. The horse survived, having managed to climb out of the river and run home, where Frerin had found him. Most of the forest had been searched before a farmer found Thorin’s body lying alongside the river bank, sopping wet and with a large gash on the back of his head.
◊◊◊
Bilbo stood looking down on his desk, flipping idly through a sketchbook. A newspaper sat on a nearby table, open to a page with a headline proclaiming the death of a count’s son two days ago. Bilbo had hardly left his studio since he had read the article earlier that morning, locking himself away and refusing to speak to Ane when she came to the door with tea and food. His tears had subsided long ago, though his eyes were still puffy and red, and had been replaced by a numb shock.
He had known that this was going to happen. It seemed that, no matter the circumstances, death appeared to finds its way into their lives, and one of them ended up dying only months or even days after they met again. Bilbo should not have been so surprised, and he wasn’t—not entirely. He had been expecting it to happen, and had been more saddened by the news than shocked, though he had still tried to believe that Thorin wasn’t actually dead.
Bilbo wondered, for a moment, if God was punishing him. He knew that it was sinful to love another man, but if that was what he was being punished for, why did God keep allowing them to meet, again and again and again?
Perhaps it wasn’t God, but rather some other power, like the Valar or the old Celtic gods, that was punishing them and allowing them to suffer so. Bilbo thought back to what Thorin had said, over three months ago—that this was Hell. An eternal cycle of losing the one you love most, over and over. It seemed, in that moment, to be a description more accurate than that of a pit of fire and brimstone that he had been taught in church. Bilbo felt that an eternity of burning would be more desirable than one he was being forced to suffer through.
Sighing, he slowly turned the sketchbook’s page, running his fingers over the charcoal drawings that covered the sheets. Most were quick sketches of random people he had seen on the street, or of a scene that he had found pleasant, but the later pages were littered with drawings of Thorin. The majority had been drawn during Thorin’s visit, already two months ago, and Bilbo gently traced the scratchy lines that made up his head and upper body. Some were more finished than others, and one had a complete background—it was of Thorin in the parlour, reading a book in front of the window while tiny snowflakes fell outside.
Bilbo sniffed, scrunching up his nose, and promptly shut the book. He grabbed the newspaper from where it still sat on the table, crumpling it up into a ball and tossing it onto the floor. An armchair sat in the corner of the room, and he sat down in it, gazing out a nearby window to where spring was finally awakening. The snow had all melted, and the sun was shining down on the street, where a group of children played. Their laughter rang up to Bilbo’s ears and, despite himself, he smiled.
It was odd, he thought, for such a beautiful world to have such terrible things in it. And if this truly was Hell, it was a strange sort of Hell, for there was always the possibility for happiness, even though darkness continued to thrive. Though he felt terrible at that moment, he knew it would not last forever. Grief was painful and overwhelming, especially in the beginning, but it eventually dulled. If this was, in actuality, a punishment from God for loving Thorin, Bilbo did not see how it would work—the more he lost him, and the more he suffered, the more Bilbo loved him. While it was painful to lose Thorin, Bilbo now knew he would see him again, even though they would likely be separated shortly after. But he had lived for over fifty years after losing Thorin, and he could do it again if he had to.
Furrowing his eyebrows, Bilbo looked up at the sky, where large white clouds slowly drifted across an expanse of blue. If this was to be his eternity, he knew it would not be easy, but even if he did not always have Thorin beside him, he would not let it destroy him. He would carry on, as he always had, and he would somehow make it through.
