Actions

Work Header

Remember Me

Chapter 7: Forever Hold Your Peace

Summary:

England, 1888
15th Life
The marquess and the valet

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

The snow had started to melt. Spring was arriving, bringing with it long-missed sunshine and blooming flowers. As Edmund Holland wandered through the gardens that surrounded his home, he smiled, occasionally stopping to inspect a plant that had begun to poke its way through the ever-decreasing snow. His gardens were his pride and joy, and he took great care in ensuring their upkeep.

Straightening from his inspection of a bed of quickly growing tulips, Edmund pulled his watch from the pocket of his coat. It was nearing late afternoon, and he would soon have to return inside. A small group of his cousins were coming for dinner, invited by his mother, and she would expect him to be there to greet them when they arrived.

Edmund absolutely despised these dinner parties—he had since he first began attending them as a teenager. His parents had hosted dozens of them a year, the guests always made up of the wealthy social elite. His mother still talked of the time the Duke of Cambridge had visited, back in 1867 when Edmund was only a toddler.

As a child, he had found his parents’ parties intriguing, mainly because he had not been allowed to attend—to his young mind, an air of mystery had surrounded them. He would often sneak away from his nanny and hide at the top of the grand staircase, watching as the fancily-dressed guests arrived and were lead to one of the sitting rooms by the butler. He attended his first dinner party the summer before he turned eighteen, when he was home from boarding school. He remembered being rather disappointed by how boring it truly was, and dreaded attending them afterwards.

When his father fell ill and died only two years later, and became Edmund the new Marquess of Exeter, he was expected to continue his parents’ tradition of hosting lavish dinner parties. Edmund had never anticipated becoming marquess so soon—he had been barely twenty years old at the time, and believed his father would still be alive for another decade, at least.

Edmund had undoubtedly failed at maintaining the reputation of his family estate as a social household. He had guests over occasionally, but very rarely hosted any parties, and never to the degree his parents had. It had been five years since he inherited his father’s title, and it seemed he had all but destroyed the standing of his estate, Wybourne Hall, as a sociable home. His mother had insisted he invite his cousins over for dinner, and he knew she would raise hell if he did not.

“It shall be a reunion, of sorts, before the wedding,” she had said. “It has been so long since you have seen some of them, and it will be nice to do some catching up.”

Edmund, of course, had been unable to invite all of his cousins. His mother came from a large family, the ninth of twelve children, and while most had gone on to have only one or two children of their own, one aunt had had seven children, and another uncle five. It was rather unreasonable to invite all eighteen of his maternal cousins, and so he had invited eight, knowing some would be unable to make it.

He checked his pocket watch again as he approached the front doors, sighing. He had about an hour and a half until the first of his cousins were expected to arrive. A footman opened the door just as he reached the front step, closing it behind him as he entered into the main entryway.

Wybourne Hall was a grand house, with four floors and dozens of bedrooms, sitting rooms, and drawing rooms. There was a masterful library on the house’s west side that spanned two floors, and a ballroom on the east, where receptions and parties had often been held. Hundreds of paintings hung throughout the house, some from as far back as the early 17th century. Over twenty servants maintained the home, not including those who worked outside and in the stables. Wybourne was the largest house in the area, and his parents had been incredibly proud of it—his mother still was.

Removing his hat, Edmund headed for the main staircase, a piece of artwork in itself, with its stone carved banisters and luxurious carpet. He passed by Mr. Wakefield, his butler, and paused, smiling warmly at the old man.

“Ah, Wakefield,” he said, and the butler looked towards him. “I have been meaning to ask you, do you know when the new valet is due to arrive?”

“He should be here on Sunday, Milord,” Mr. Wakefield answered, after a moment’s thought, his hands clasped behind his back.

Edmund frowned. “Could he have not been here sooner?” he asked. “It’s only that Mr. Barlow’s condition seems to have worsened, and I feel awfully bad making him work.”

“I understand, Milord. Unfortunately, Mr. Lewis has been required to serve out his notice before being allowed to come work here.”

Edmund nodded, his frown deepening. His current valet, Mr. Barlow, was an old gentleman—he had served Edmund’s father for several years before his death. He had been planning to retire in a short while anyway, but the onset of a debilitating illness had forced that plan to be expedited. As the months wore on, it became more and more difficult for him to perform his duties, until he felt he had no choice but to hand in his notice. Edmund was sad to hear that he would be leaving, but agreed it would be for the best. He offered to provide care to the aging valet, in return for his years of loyal service to the Holland family, but Mr. Barlow had politely refused, insisting that he would be well looked-after by his sister.  

“Well, there is nothing we can do, then,” Edmund said with a sigh. “Thank you, Wakefield.”

“Of course, Milord,” Mr. Wakefield said, giving a nod of his head. “Will that be all?”

“Yes, thank you.”

Mr. Wakefield turned and left, and so Edmund continued up the stairs. He had little idea as to where his mother was, though he suspected she was already getting dressed to receive their guests. She was a very kindly woman, his mother, and he loved her dearly, though they did not always get along. He would miss her company, however, when he married and she finally moved from Wybourne Hall to the Dower House in town.

Edmund frowned, his hand curling unconsciously into a fist at his side. Thinking of his wedding never failed to make him anxious, and so he pushed all thoughts of it from his mind; there would be time enough for contemplation later.

◊◊◊

Gethin Lewis could not wait to be rid of this job.

It was, in all honesty, one of the worst he had ever had. The pay was fine, yes, and it was not the position of valet that he despised. The problem lay entirely in the man he served—an insufferable, over-demanding earl, whose presence Gethin could just barely tolerate, which presented a significant issue, as his entire job was to care for the despicable man.

As such, he had jumped at the opportunity of a new job, far away from his current employer in the south of England. He had only three days left in his current position, and as the date of his departure grew nearer he found himself growing happier. It was as if simply being in the same building as the Earl of Carlisle sucked all joy from Gethin. He would be gone from this place by noon on Sunday.

Sighing, Gethin shifted in his seat, straightening the newspaper laid out on the table in front of him. It was evening, and the family were eating dinner. Many of the other servants were milling about in the servants’ hall, reading, chatting, and doing extra work. The Countess’s lady’s maid was replacing a button on one of the Earl’s jackets, and Gethin looked up from his paper every now and then to watch her work, her forehead creased in concentration.

“It’s lucky you found the button, after it fell off,” the lady’s maid, a middle-aged woman named Mrs. Spencer, commented, holding up the jacket to admire her handiwork. “I don’t think I would’ve found a match, which would’ve made things difficult.”

“Thank you very much, Mrs. Spencer,” Gethin said, taking the jacket when she offered it to him. “I’m very grateful.”

“You can thank me by learning to sew,” Mrs. Spencer joked, smirking. “You don’t know how friendly the maids at your new place of employment will be. They may not be too keen to do your mending for you.”

Gethin smiled, though he could hear a small amount of bitterness poisoning the edges of Mrs. Spencer’s voice. No one said anything, but dislike for the Earl seemed to be a commonly felt sentiment among most of the servants. It could be seen in the way people often scanned the jobs postings in the newspaper, and spoke longingly of working in another household. The butler tolerated no ill word against the Earl, but Gethin suspected even he often tired of his ill temper and demanding personality. It was obvious that many of the servants were jealous of Gethin’s new position, and had been since he handed in his notice two weeks ago.

“I feel as though I would be absolutely useless at sewing,” Gethin admitted, carefully folding the jacket and standing. “Now, if you’ll excuse me, I must return this to his Lordship’s dressing room.”

Mrs. Spencer nodded, and he turned to leave.

The servants’ hall and kitchen rested on the lowest level of the house, and so he had to climb several flights of stairs to reach the floor that housed the Earl’s quarters. The servants’ stairwell was small and plain, interspersed with landings that stopped at each floor. A wide door lined with green baize separated the stairwell from the upper-class world of the Earl and his family, the felt-like fabric muting any sound and trapping cooking smells from the kitchen—things which might disturb the family.

Gethin adjusted the coat in his arms as he reached the second floor. The family would still be downstairs, eating dinner or lounging in one of the sitting rooms, chatting and drinking after their meal. As such, the hallways of the upper levels were quiet, save for the few maids going from room to room, lighting fires and preparing beds. Gethin made his way quickly towards the Earl’s dressing room, wishing he had remembered to grab a candle as he hurried down the hall in the dark.

Thankfully, the fire in the Earl’s dressing room had already been lit, casting a warm glow across the room. Gethin returned the jacket to its proper place in the wardrobe, checking several other pieces of clothing as he did so. As valet, he was responsible for the care of all the Earl’s clothes—he ensured that shirts, pants, and jackets were mended when they needed to be, and that all shoes were shined and did not lose their shape.

Satisfied that there were no other missing buttons or ripped sleeves, he closed the wardrobe with a careful click. Yawning, he rubbed tiredly at his eyes—his days often began early, and ended late. It would likely be another hour or so until the Earl retired, and so he would have to find a way to keep himself awake until then. He leaned against the wardrobe, and sighed; he could not wait to be rid of this place and its unpleasant master.

◊◊◊

Edmund’s mother was already sitting in the drawing room when he arrived. She stood when he entered, walking over to greet him with a smile on her face.

“There you are, my dear boy,” she said. “I feel as though I haven’t seen you all day.”

“I do apologize, Mother,” Edmund said, leading her back towards the couch and sitting beside her. “I have been somewhat preoccupied.”

His mother smiled, placing an affectionate hand on his knee. Though Edmund’s father had been dead for several years, his mother still retained the title of Marchioness of Exeter, and would until Edmund married. At that point, she would become known as the Dowager Marchioness, and would move from Wybourne Hall to the Dower House, located in the nearby village.

“Have none of your cousins arrived?” his mother asked, looking around the room as if one of them might be hiding somewhere.

“I suspect they shall be here soon,” said Edmund. Of the eight cousins he had invited, six had accepted, five of whom lived nearby. The sixth, Harriet, lived further east, and was arriving by train. She was supposed to have arrived a few hours earlier, but her train had been delayed, meaning she would arrive just in time for dinner. “I have sent a coach to pick Cousin Harriet up at the station, so she should be here momentarily.”

“Excellent.” Edmund’s mother, Eugenia, had always been a very upbeat and kind person. Her father had been a politically-ambitious earl, and while she grew up in what some would say was a grotesquely large family, she still had all the characteristics of a woman who had been aristocratic since birth. She was very serious about certain things, as such, particularly when it came to social standings and reputation.

When Edmund had inherited his father’s title, she became unnecessarily anxious for him to find a wife, and she didn’t bother hiding it. She had said he needed to produce an heir as soon as possible in order to ensure that the title and estate didn’t pass into the hands of his vile cousin, a man she was certain would drive it to ruin. There was no doubt in Edmund’s mind that once he was married, his mother would not cease her pestering until a son was born.

He sighed, taking the offered drink from Mr. Wakefield. It was early spring, and he was to be married in the summer, a year after his engagement was announced. The marriage was essentially arranged—his fiancée, Miss Clara Fitzosbern, was the beloved niece of a daughterless duke, and while she was untitled she came from an obviously wealthy and prestigious family. Her uncle, the Duke of Hereford, hoped to secure a good future for her, and Edmund’s mother, knowing the Duke was looking for a prospective husband for his niece, had arranged a meeting between Edmund and Miss Fitzosbern. Both the Duke and Eugenia had been pleased by the potential union, and Edmund had proposed a few months later. It wasn’t a marriage born of love, but rather necessity—Edmund needed a wife, and by extension an heir, while Clara needed security.

Edmund was pulled from his thoughts by Mr. Wakefield re-entering the room, his cousin Arthur and his wife Georgia behind him.

“Lord Arthur Home and his wife, Lady Georgia Home,” Mr. Wakefield announced, bowing slightly as Arthur and Georgia entered the room.

Edmund stood, smiling widely at the two arrivals. “Cousin Arthur, Cousin Georgia,” he said, walking forward to greet them. “I’m so glad you could come.”

“It’s our pleasure,” Arthur said, shaking Edmund’s offered hand. He looked over to where Eugenia sat. “Hello, Aunt Genie.”

“Hello, Arthur,” Eugenia said, her hands crossed on her lap. “How many times must I tell you not to call me Genie?”

“I’m afraid it’s a habit, and one I’ll likely never shake,” Arthur admitted, going over and kissing his aunt on the cheeks.

“How unfortunate,” Eugenia said with a shake of her head. “And how are you, Georgia?”

Georgia smiled, walking over to sit beside her husband’s aunt. “I’m very well, Aunt Eugenia, thank you for asking.” She looked to Edmund. “I thought Harriet was supposed to be here by now. Has something happened?”

“Her train was delayed,” Edmund explained. “But she should be here soon, and in time for dinner.”

“Oh, well that’s good.”

Their conversation was light and cheerful. Georgia asked about the wedding plans, and Eugenia was all too happy to talk of them. She was more excited by the coming wedding than Edmund, and even more than Clara, it seemed.

Edmund listened to their conversation with polite interest, and suffered through his cousin’s talk of politics. It was the sort of social gathering he had been raised on, and yet he found it all so unbearably stifling. He would certainly be glad when the night was over.

◊◊◊

Gethin stared up at the grey sky as the train whizzed past the blurry countryside. The clouds were dark, promising a coming rain; he only hoped it would hold until he arrived at his new employment.

Wybourne Hall, it was called. A grand house in the south of England, looked after by over thirty servants. It was home to the Marquess of Exeter, a man who had inherited the title from his father when he was quite young, as Gethin understood. He had yet to meet any of the other staff members, though he had corresponded with the butler, Mr. Wakefield, through several letters.

It was nearing evening when the train pulled into the station. Gethin stood, retrieving his one piece of luggage from the overhead compartment as the other passengers slowly began making their way off the train. The air on the platform was cool, and smelt of damp. Gethin replaced his hat on his head as he quickly made his way through the crowd gathered at the station. It was not difficult to find directions to Wybourne Hall—the village appeared to be small enough, and the Hall was, after all, the largest house in the area, if what Gethin had been told was to be believed.

The house was easy enough to find, though it was situated a ways outside the village. The drive leading up to it was long, and as Gethin trudged up it a light drizzle began to fall. He quickened his pace, his shoulders hunched up to his ears and his feet crunching loudly on the gravel.

It was certainly a great house—one of the largest Gethin had ever seen. He could hardly believe it even qualified as a house; to him it appeared more like a palace. He stared up at it as he passed by, catching glimpses of delicate curtains and faintly glowing light in the windows. A small courtyard circled the back door, full of buckets and a small shed, tucked into the corner. Gethin rang the doorbell, and a few seconds later a hall boy answered. He seemed to be barely out of his teens, with a young face and limbs too long for his body. He looked at Gethin expectantly.

“My name is Gethin Lewis,” Gethin said. “I’m the new valet.”

The hall boy nodded. “Yes, Mr. Wakefield has been expecting you. Come in.” He stepped aside, closing the door behind Gethin. “The servants’ hall is down this way,” he said, pointing down the dimly-lit corridor.

The hall at Wybourne did not seem much different than any other servants’ hall Gethin had been in—it was simple, with a large board of bells resting on the wall behind the table. Each bell was labeled, and there appeared to be well over thirty.

There were several maids and other servants gathered around the table, and they all looked up as Gethin entered.

“Ah, Mr. Lewis!”

Everyone’s heads towards the doorway, where a middle-aged woman was standing, her hands on her hips. She was wearing a simple, dark-coloured dress, and a set of jangling keys was hanging at her hip. Her hair was pulled back into a tight bun, a few tufts of greying hair sticking out over her forehead.

“It’s nice to finally meet you,” she said, entering the room and walking towards him. “My name is Mrs. Lynch. I’m the head housekeeper here at Wybourne Hall.”

Gethin bowed his head. “The pleasure is all mine,” he said.

Mrs. Lynch hummed quietly, nodding. “I’m sure you’ll be very comfortable here. We are a large household, yes, but I find most new arrivals settle in quickly.”

“You needn’t worry about me,” Gethin assured her. “I’ve worked in many a large household. I’m sure I can handle this one.”

Mrs. Lynch pursed her lips, as if trying to decide whether Gethin’s comment was rude or not. “Yes, well...” She looked to one of the maids seated at the table, who stood quickly. “Eliza here can show you to your room so you can get settled. Mr. Wakefield is upstairs serving dinner, so he will not be down for a while, but I’m sure Eliza can introduce you to Mr. Barlow, and you can speak with him, if you’d like.”

Gethin looked from the maid—Eliza—to Mrs. Lynch. “Mr. Barlow?”

“His Lordship’s valet,” Eliza explained. She frowned. “Or... I suppose former valet.” There was a brief moment of silence, before Eliza straightened, the smile returning to her lips. “Now, let’s go... Mr. Lewis, is it?” He nodded. “I’m sure you’re exhausted from travelling.”

Gethin remained silent as Eliza led him towards the stairs, pointing out various rooms as they walked by—the boot room, the laundry room, the kitchen. While the servant’s hall was situated on the lowest level, the servants’ quarters were at the very top, reached by several flights of winding stairs.

“I’m sure this is similar to many houses you’ve worked at,” Eliza said as they walked by a baize-lined door. She glanced at him over her shoulder. “Have you worked at many houses, Mr. Lewis?”

“Quite a few, yes,” said Gethin.

Eliza sighed. “I’ve only ever worked here. Don’t misunderstand me, though—this is a wonderful place to work, and I’m very lucky to have a position here. But I simply wish I could see more of the country. It’s tiresome, being stuck in the same house day after day.”

“Unfortunately, we cannot always get what we want.”

Eliza laughed quietly. “Yes, that is certainly true,” she murmured. When they reached the servants’ quarters, a few moments later, she led him about halfway down the corridor before stopping in front of a plain wooden door, identical to all the others lining the long hallway. “Here’s your room. Come downstairs when you’ve settled your things.” She smiled brightly at him, before turning and scurrying back down the corridor.

Inside, the room was simple, but livable. Two iron beds sat pushed against the wall, each with a small nightstand beside it. A large oak dresser stood in the corner, and a table and two chairs took up much of the remaining space. The ceiling was low and sloped, with a high dormer window letting in a faint amount of light. Gethin set his suitcase down on one of the beds and stretched to peer out the window, his fingers gripping the ledge. The glass was warped, blurring the world outside so that he couldn’t tell which part of the garden he was looking at. He sighed, falling back onto his heels and letting the curtains slip back into place.

◊◊◊

Edmund walked from the dining room, his mother’s arms wrapped daintily around his elbow. They had a routine, his mother and him; every evening, after dinner, they would sit in the drawing room for perhaps forty-five minutes, chatting while he had a drink and she played a game of patience. His drink was already poured when they arrived, and he gratefully took it from Mr. Wakefield as he sat down on the couch. His mother went to her usual spot at the small, round game table behind him, where a deck of cards was already waiting.

“Can I get you anything, Milady?” Mr. Wakefield asked, and Eugenia shook her head.

“No, thank you, Wakefield,” she replied, carefully laying out her cards.

Mr. Wakefield nodded, and then turned back to Edmund. “Milord, I must inform you that new valet has arrived,” he said.

“Ah, yes, very good,” Edmund said, smiling. “Send him to my dressing room when I go up. I should like to meet him.”

“Certainly, Milord,” Mr. Wakefield said, bowing his head.

His mother went up earlier that evening, having quickly finished her game and finding she was too tired to start another.

“I shall see you in the morning, Mother,” Edmund said, standing as she made her way towards the door.

“Yes, yes,” she said. “Goodnight, my dear.”

Edmund smiled. “Goodnight, Mother.”

He followed her soon after, reminding Mr. Wakefield to send up the new valet as he headed for the stairs.

“Oh, and Barlow, as well,” he added, grabbing a candle from the table that sat at the bottom of the staircase and lighting it.

“Of course, Milord.”

Edmund started up the stairs, his hand dragging on the banister. His dressing room was not far, but when he arrived Mr. Barlow and the new valet—Mr. Lewis, he recalled—were already there. He could hear them talking through the door, though they stopped when he opened it. He saw Mr. Barlow first, standing with his hands clasped behind him. Then his eyes wandered to the tall, dark-haired man standing behind him, and he felt all the breath leave his body.

“Thorin,” he murmured, barely taking his eyes off the man as he set the candle down. He could see the shock and surprise on Thorin’s face, and wondered what his own expression must look like.

“Milord?”

Bilbo’s gaze flicked to Mr. Barlow, and he nearly stumbled back when he found himself looking instead at Dori. He was much older than when Bilbo had seen him last, a time which felt as if it had happened centuries ago, but he was still so clearly himself.

“Is everything alright?” Dori asked, and Bilbo straightened, trying to wipe the surprise from his features.

“Oh, um... Yes, of course.” He paused for a second. “Of course.”

Dori stared at him a moment longer before smiling. “Very good,” he said, and then he stepped aside, placing one hand on Thorin’s back.

Bilbo allowed himself to smile, and took a few steps towards Thorin. “Lewis, yes?” he asked.

Thorin nodded, and it seemed it took him a moment or two to find his words. “Yes, Milord,” he answered, bowing his head. “Gethin Lewis.”

Bilbo’s smile grew. “Ah, you’re Welsh, then?” he asked. “It’s only that Gethin is a very Welsh name, though your accent is barely noticeable.”

“Yes, Milord, I am.”

“Whereabouts in Wales do you come from?”

“Bala, originally. It’s a small town, in the northwest.”

Bilbo nodded, wringing his hands together and shifting from foot to foot. It felt odd, speaking to Thorin in such a polite way—like a master to his servant. He glanced at Dori, who was watching the two with slight interest.

“Barlow,” he said, drawing the old man’s attention. “Have you told Lewis everything he needs to know?”

“Most of it, Milord,” Dori replied, “though he seems very capable, and I am certain he will do an admirable job.”

“Excellent.” Bilbo’s smile faltered slightly. “You will be leaving us soon, then?”

“Yes, Milord. On Wednesday.”

“I’m ever so sad to see you go.”

“I’m sad to be leaving, Milord,” Dori admitted, glancing down at his shoes.

“Wybourne will not be the same without you,” Bilbo said. Dori straightened, his chest puffed as if he had just been given a great compliment—Bilbo suspected he was pleased, in a way, to know he would be missed. He continued, “I simply wish there was some way I could help you.”

“Your Lordship has already helped me enough,” Dori said, “and I am ever so grateful for everything this family has done for me.”

There was a new layer of sadness to the loyal valet’s departure, now that Bilbo knew who he had been—an old friend, in more than one lifetime. He took in a deep breath, clasping his hands together behind his back. “We shall have a proper farewell on Wednesday,” he said, and Dori nodded. Bilbo continued, “Until then, you go rest. I do not want to trouble you any further.”

“It is no trouble to me, Milord,” Dori said. “No trouble at all. I have always enjoyed this work, and am sad to be leaving it.”

“I insist, Barlow. Rest, and relax. You have done your service to this family ten times over.”

Dori coughed, and it seemed for a moment that there were tears in his eyes. “Will that be all then, Milord?”

Bilbo nodded, a sad smile on his face. “Yes, Barlow. Lewis can take over from here.”

“Very good, Milord.” The elderly valet nodded, and Bilbo watched him leave, his steps steady as he walked towards the door. He closed his eyes as the door shut behind Dori, before turning to look at Thorin, who had remained silent throughout the whole exchange.

“I do not know whether to laugh or to cry,” he admitted, though a small chuckle escaped his lips.

Thorin smiled, crossing the room to Bilbo in a matter of seconds. They stood in front of each other for a moment, both unsure of what to do.

“I... I must admit I am uncertain of how to act,” Thorin said, his voice still one of a servant speaking to his employer. His gaze stayed focused on Bilbo, but it was obvious he was uncomfortable.

Bilbo watched him as he fidgeted with the hem of his jacket, thinking of how strange it was to see him in such a role. Thorin was always a person who commanded respect. Even when he was a coppersmith or a carpenter, it was easy to see that he had once held great power—that he had once been a king. Now, however, it was difficult even for Bilbo to see that. Thorin was a servant in this lifetime, and no longer in control of himself; he catered to the whims and fancies of those above him, of people like Bilbo.

Bilbo frowned. “Please,” he said, reaching up and brushing his fingers through Thorin’s hair, “do not act like my valet; at least not when we are alone.”

“I do not think I could if I tried,” Thorin admitted, and Bilbo smiled.

“This is certainly a... interesting situation,” he said, moving his hands to Thorin’s shoulders. “But at least we can be together, in some way.”

Thorin let out a noise that sounded like a strangled laugh. “Yes, the marquess and his valet.”

Bilbo scowled at him. “What issue do you have with it?” he asked.

“I simply mean that... it is dangerous for us to be together, in more ways than one.” Thorin sighed, taking one of Bilbo’s hands in his own. “If anyone finds out, I’ll likely be thrown in prison. I’ll most certainly lose my job, and won’t ever work again.”

“No one will ever find out,” Bilbo argued. “And if, somehow, they do... I’ll protect you. I’m wealthy and powerful here, Thorin; I could keep you from jail.”

“That isn’t the only problem.” A pause, and then, “I don’t want to be the reason you die.”

Bilbo’s brows furrowed together and he stared at Thorin, silent. “What are you suggesting?” he asked, after several seconds had passed. “Certainly not that you’re going to leave.”

“It may be for the best.”

“No.” Bilbo’s voice was decisive as he pulled his hands away. He took a few steps back and began pacing the room, his arms folded across his chest. Thorin watched him, the look on his face torn.

Bilbo stopped in front of him, visibly agitated. “I won’t allow it. I won’t let you leave.”

“I can leave if I wish.”

“But you don’t need to.”

Thorin sighed, leaning against the nearby wardrobe. “Do you not remember 1714?” he asked. “The West Indies. You sent me back to England, and told me it was because you didn’t want me to die.” There was a brief pause. “That’s what I’m hoping to do now.”

“This is different,” Bilbo argued. “Our lives are not in immediate danger here. There are no battles, no volcanoes, no... no revolution or piracy. We’re safe.”

“That’s what I thought as well, when I was the son of a nobleman in Denmark,” Thorin said. “Do you remember? You were a painter.”

Bilbo bit down on his bottom lip, nodding. “Of course I remember.”

“We lived peacefully then, too, and yet I still died, drowned in a creek after being thrown from my horse. What’s to say something like that won’t happen again?”

“But you don’t have to leave. Leaving won’t save us.”

“How do you know?”

“Because it never has before. I sent you away in 1714, back to England, and I still died, only a few months later.”

Thorin paused, an expression of surprise crossing his face. “I didn’t know that,” he whispered.

“So stay.” Bilbo’s voice rose as his desperation grew. “Enjoy the time we have left together, no matter how long that is.”

“If that’s what you want,” Thorin said, though Bilbo could see the conflict on his face. He stood in front of him for a moment, before Thorin reached over and slipped the dinner jacket off his shoulders. As he carefully replaced the garment in the wardrobe, Bilbo began to undo the bowtie knotted at his throat.

“I would do whatever you asked of me,” Thorin murmured, taking the silky white tie from Bilbo.

Bilbo looked at him, a small smile on his lips, before leaning forward and wrapping his arms around Thorin. “I love you,” he whispered, the weight of Thorin’s arms settling on his back. “More than you know.” His eyes slipped closed and he took in a deep breath, his nostrils filling with Thorin’s ever-changing, yet always familiar, scent. He thought briefly of Clara and their impending marriage, but quickly pushed her from his mind—that was another problem, for another day.

◊◊◊

Thorin did not sleep well that night. He had already been awake for three hours, staring at the slowly lightening ceiling above him, when there was a knock on his door and the hall boy’s voice announced, “Six o’clock.”

He dragged himself from bed slowly, exhausted from a lack of sleep and the thoughts that had run through his head all night, like a laudanum addict who thought only of their drug. He washed his hands and face in the cold water that sat in the washbasin, and dressed quickly.

Downstairs, breakfast was a speedy affair. Most of the maids and footmen had already eaten when Thorin sat down, accepting a cup of tea from a kitchen maid. He had just finished eating when the bell for Bilbo’s room rang. He stood, wiping his mouth on his napkin, and headed for the stairs.

Bilbo was already in the dressing room when he arrived, staring out the window with a grim expression. “It’s going to rain,” he said as Thorin entered, his gaze flicking up to grey clouds floating by overhead.  

“Something warm and casual, then?”

Bilbo nodded. “Yes, I don’t think I’ll be going out today, unless I must.” He turned away from the window and walked over to Thorin, placing a gentle kiss on his lips. “Good morning,” he greeted.

“Good morning,” Thorin replied, and gave Bilbo a small smile.

Bilbo returned the smile, though it was strained and quickly fell from his face.

“Is something the matter?” Thorin asked, and Bilbo didn’t reply. He pulled away, walking over to the chaise longue and perching on its edge, his gaze once more falling on the world outside the window.

Thorin watched him for a moment before heading to the wardrobe, opening it and scanning the clothes inside. They were both silent, the ticks of the clock sitting on the dresser impossibly loud in Thorin’s ears.

Several minutes passed, as Thorin collected various garments and inspected each one carefully, ensuring it was free of holes or stains. He heard Bilbo shifting behind him.

“Thorin,” said Bilbo, and he turned to face him, his eyebrows raised inquisitively. Bilbo continued, “I thought you should know...” A slight pause, and then, “I’m engaged. To be married.”

Thorin took in a deep breath, letting out slowly as his chest filled with dread. He wasn’t surprised—not really. Bilbo was unmarried, heirless, and titled. That was not something that often sat well with the aristocracy, and if he was honest it was really a greater surprise that Bilbo wasn’t already married.

“When?” he asked, turning back to the wardrobe.

“The summer. July.” There was another long stretch of silence. “Her name is Clara Fitzosbern.”

“I don’t care about her name,” Thorin said, realizing too late how harsh his tone was.

“No,” Bilbo whispered, and Thorin glanced over his shoulder to see him staring at his hands. “No, of course you don’t.” He stood, walking slowly towards Thorin. “It’s a marriage of convenience, Thorin, not love. I hardly know her.”

Thorin sighed, lowering the shirt he was holding in his hands. “I understand,” he said. “Of course I understand. I shouldn’t let it bother me so much; I don’t know why it does.”

“We have both been in this position before,” Bilbo said, his hand coming to rest on Thorin’s shoulder. “And no doubt we will be in it again. It’s simply something we must... become used to.”

“Just as we must become used to everything this hell throws at us,” muttered Thorin.

Bilbo sighed. “I know. It’s... it’s unfair. It makes no sense. But it’s what we have to live with.”

Thorin was silent for a moment, before straightening, smoothing the shoulders of the shirt in his hands. “Let’s not talk of it now,” he said, turning to face Bilbo. “Like you said, let’s enjoy the time we have left, without worry.”

“Let’s at least try,” Bilbo said, smiling.

Outside, rain began to fall. Thorin closed his eyes, listening to the sound of it tapping against the window and shaking through the trees.

◊◊◊

Five Months Later

The air outside was hot and sticky with humidity, though the sun had set hours ago. Bilbo sighed, resting his head against the headboard of his bed. He was sitting on top of the covers, an open book that he was struggling to read on his lap. In less than one week, he would be married. The closer it drew to the set date, the more dread he felt and the more he wished he could simply back out of it.

“You alright?”

Bilbo lifted his head slightly, looking to where Thorin sat at the foot of the bed, perusing through yesterday’s newspaper. He had removed both his jacket and vest, and they lay draped across the baseboard. The sleeves of his shirt were rolled up to his elbows, and Bilbo felt himself blush at the sight of him. He had been a pirate and a Romanian revolutionary in the 1980s, among countless other things, but his recent Victorian upbringing still told him that a man in his shirtsleeves was indecent.

He looked away, his gaze dropping to his book. “I was simply thinking of my wedding,” he replied. “I have been thinking about it a lot lately.”

“As one does, only a week before their wedding.”

Bilbo glanced at him, and shook his head. “I’ve been thinking about Clara more often,” he specified, “and how this entire... arrangement isn’t very fair for her.”

Thorin scoffed. “Fair? She’s going to be a marchioness. Most women would die for that chance.”

“But I doubt she’ll be happy,” Bilbo countered, “stuck in a loveless marriage with me.”

“Perhaps she’ll start an affair with her lady’s maid,” Thorin suggested, snickering.

Bilbo glared at him. “That isn’t funny.”

“It is, at least slightly.”

Bilbo didn’t reply, picking at the pages of his book. Thorin shifted, moving closer to him. “You’re marrying her because you must,” he said, “and she’s marrying you because she must. Even if I wasn’t here, I doubt any great love would have ever developed between you and Clara.”

“Then why am I marrying her?” Bilbo asked, looking up at Thorin. “I’m condemning her to a life of unhappiness.”

“Plenty of marriages are unhappy. And who knows, perhaps she will find happiness. It does not have to be through love.”

Bilbo frowned. “You do not seem to be terribly bothered by the fact that I’m to be married in less than a week,” he pointed out. “Certainly less so than you were five months ago.”

Thorin nodded slightly, looking from Bilbo to his hands. “I’ve made my peace with it,” he explained. “It is not as if I can oppose it, at least not openly. It will happen, regardless of how I feel.”

Bilbo’s frown deepened and he closed his book, setting it aside. Sitting up, he leaned forward and reached out his hands, grabbing Thorin’s and pulling him closer. “I care how you feel,” he whispered, wrapping his fingers around Thorin’s.

“No one else does,” Thorin said, “and certainly not when it comes to your marriage to Miss Clara Fitzosbern.” He looked down at Bilbo’s hands, sighing. “Besides,” he continued, “I told you; I’ve made my peace with it. We have both been married and had families before, and no doubt it will happen again.” Another pause. “I understand. I really do.”

“I’m sorry,” Bilbo murmured, raising Thorin’s knuckle to his lips. “Truly, I am. I wish I could change this, or fix it, or something.”

“It is alright.” Thorin smiled, laughing quietly. “This is certainly not the worst life we have had. It has been a while since we’ve had so long together.” He paused for a moment, before continuing, “But... you must promise me this.” He leaned closer, his grip on Bilbo’s hands tightening. “One day, you will marry me, wherever and whenever we can.”

Bilbo’s eyes widened, and his mouth fell open. “Did... are you proposing to me?” he whispered, his face heating up.

“Well, yes... in a way, I suppose. Of course, who knows when it will happen, or even if it will. This is more of a promise, really—a decision that we will get married, one day. If you want to, that is.”

“Of course.” Bilbo out, wrapping his arms around Thorin’s neck. “Of course I’ll marry you. You needn’t have even asked, really. The minute—the very second—that I’m able to, I’ll marry you.”

Thorin laughed, his face pressed into Bilbo’s shoulders. “I’m glad,” he muttered. “Yes, I’m very glad.”

◊◊◊

Two days later they left for Birmingham, where Bilbo’s fiancée lived with her family. They travelled by train, accompanied by Bilbo’s mother and her lady’s maid, an elderly woman named Mrs. Tompkins. She reminded Thorin slightly of his grandmother, from when he was a young boy. She was kind and very chatty, speaking endlessly about her nieces and nephews as she worked on her knitting.

“Do you have much family, Mr. Lewis?” she asked him, about an hour into their journey.

“I wouldn’t say I have many relatives,” he replied. “But I do have a family, yes, though it has been a long time since I last saw them.”

Mrs. Tompkins gave a sad smile. “We do not get to see our families nearly enough.”

Thorin nodded in agreement, and his gaze returned to the window. He did not like to think of his family, always so far away in Wales. His nephews had been toddlers when he saw them last, in this life, and now Fíli would soon be nearing ten. He sighed, resting his cheek in his hand.

It was nearing noon when they finally pulled into the station at Birmingham. Thorin stood, stiff from sitting so long, and grabbed both his and Mrs. Tompkins’ bags from where they had been stored overhead.

“Thank you, Mr. Lewis,” the elderly woman said, gratefully taking the bag from him.

Thorin grabbed his hat, nodding. “Not a problem.”

On the platform, he was quick to gather Bilbo’s luggage, and helped Mrs. Tompkins collect the Marchioness’. There was a driver from the Fitzosbern household there to meet them, and he and Thorin carefully loaded the luggage onto the carriage, while Mrs. Tompkins went to greet Bilbo and his mother.

“Is everything loaded?” Bilbo’s mother asked, arriving at the carriages with her lady’s maid and her son in tow.

“Just about, Milady,” Thorin replied, securing the belts around one of the trunks as the driver hopped down to open the door.

“Thank you very much,” the Marchioness said, allowing the driver to help her up into the carriage. Bilbo followed suit, shooting a quick glance at Thorin before he disappeared.

The luggage was all secured only a minute or two later, and Thorin and Mrs. Tompkins climbed up onto the front seat, alongside the driver.

“It’s a wonder how you got it all up there,” Mrs. Tompkins muttered as they drove away, her own small carpet bag clutched in her lap.

“It’s all about practice, Mrs. Tompkins,” the driver said with an amiable smile. “After a while, you become accustomed to fitting even the most ludicrous amount of luggage onto one carriage.”

Mrs. Tompkins scoffed, and Thorin smiled as they trundled off down the busy city streets.

◊◊◊

Clara’s family home was not far from the station. She was there on the front step to greet them when they arrived, alongside her parents and brothers. She smiled widely and excitedly at Bilbo as he climbed down from the carriage, and he felt a sharp twinge of guilt as his eyes flicked over to Thorin, who was busy unloading the luggage.

“Welcome to our home,” Clara’s father greeted, a warm smile on his face. “Please, do come inside; you are no doubt tired from your travels. We have tea ready to be served.”

Bilbo’s mother hurried up the steps. “Oh, how wonderful,” she said.

“Come, Edmund,” said Clara, descending the few steps to Bilbo.

He looked at her, and then glanced once more over his shoulder at Thorin. “Yes,” he said, turning back towards his fiancée with a smile. “Tea sounds marvelous.”

Clara grinned, and led him up the steps into the front hall. It was a grand, wonderful home, for a townhouse; Bilbo had never visited it before, but Clara had often spoken of it with great fondness. It was, after all, the home she had grown up in, and as he followed her to the drawing room Bilbo agreed that it certainly was comfortable. There was a simplicity and homeliness to it that one would struggle to find at Wybourne Hall.

His mother was already seated with a cup of tea in her hands when they arrived in the drawing room. She was engaged in deep conversation with Clara’s mother, no doubt over some aspect of the wedding. It was a topic she had rarely strayed from in the past few days. This wedding was to be a rather grand social event—there was a long list of guests, almost all of them wealthy aristocrats.

“It will be the wedding of the season,” his mother often proclaimed. “Second only to a royal wedding.”

Bilbo swallowed thickly, sitting down on one of the couches between Clara and the Duke. He took the offered tea and held it tightly in his hands. He felt as if he was living a lie, one that had gone on for decades, and he honestly didn’t know how much longer he could let it continue.

The conversation carried on around him, and he remained generally silent, lost in his own thoughts. Guilt had been steadily growing within him over the past few weeks, and now with the wedding mere days away he felt consumed by it.

He was relieved when the tea was finished and he was shown to his room. He collapsed onto the bed with a sigh, his eyes slipping shut as his mind ran circles around itself. He could faintly hear his mother speaking down the hall, her loud voice drifting in through his closed door. Groaning, Bilbo grabbed one of the many pillows lying on the bed and pressed it over his ears.

◊◊◊

The day of the wedding was sunny. Not a cloud could be seen in the sky, and as Thorin walked to the church he could feel himself growing hotter in his dark suit. It was not far from Clara’s home to the church where the wedding was to take place, and though it was still morning the air was already hot and thick with humidity. Mrs. Tompkins walked beside Thorin, her face steadily reddening as sweat began to bead on her forehead.

When they finally arrived at the church, almost all of the guests were already there, with Thorin, Mrs. Tompkins, and the other servants from Clara’s house entering last. They sat at the very back, and as Thorin settled into the pew his eyes focused on the altar, where a lone clergyman stood, making final preparations. His gaze never strayed from the front of the church as they sat, waiting for the wedding party to arrive.

The music began only a few minutes later, and all the guests stood in unison as the church doors opened. The ushers were the first to walk up the aisle, followed by the first bridesmaid and the groomsman. The rest of the bridesmaids came after, and then finally Bilbo, with Clara’s mother on his arm. Thorin’s eyes followed him as he walked up the centre aisle, barely even glancing at the bride when she entered. It felt as if his heart was being torn from his chest, and he took in a shaky breath as his hands gripped the back of pew in front of him. For months he had been telling himself that he was alright with Bilbo’s marriage—he understood why it was happening, and he thought he had made his peace with it. But now that it was actually happening, he felt as if he was being destroyed; watching Bilbo stand at the altar across from some woman was more painful than dying ever would be.

As the bride and groom came to a stop at the front of the church, everyone slowly sat back down and the music ended. The priest stood and began to address the guests, but Thorin barely heard anything he said. All of his attention was focused solely on Bilbo, standing beside Clara at the altar.

It was a wedding, something that was supposed to be a joyous, momentous occasion. Though he tried to appear happy, all Thorin felt was a profound feeling of loss.

He hardly noticed when the ceremony finally ended, what felt like hours later, and everyone rose to follow the newly-wed couple outside. The reception was to be a breakfast, held at Clara’s family home. Of course, neither Thorin nor any of the other servants would be attending, though Thorin didn’t particularly mind. He doubted he would have enjoyed it, surrounded by people who deemed themselves to be better than him, endlessly congratulating Bilbo and his new wife.

Thorin liked to think that he wasn’t bitter, but still, he despised it—the way Clara could so casually promise to spend the rest of her life with Bilbo; the way she could kiss him in front of other people; the way she could have everything Thorin never could.

He scowled, shoving his hands into his pockets. He sounded so petty and jealous, but it frustrated him to no end that other people could so easily have what he knew was impossible: A life with the person they loved, without the constant fear of death hanging over their heads.

When they arrived back at the townhouse, Thorin retreated upstairs to his room, unsure of what else to do. Most of the other servants were helping with the breakfast, or else had some other work to do. Thorin would not be seeing Bilbo again until later that day, when he changed into his travelling clothes to leave for his honeymoon, and all the luggage had already been packed. Both Thorin and Clara’s lady’s maid would be going with them to Paris, where they would spend the next week. Thorin, in all honesty, would rather not go at all. Of course, he had little choice in the matter—that was the duty of a valet, after all. But the fact that he was actually going on the honeymoon felt almost like someone pouring rubbing alcohol over a fresh cut.

Thorin collapsed onto his bed with a sigh, staring up at the ceiling that had likely once been white, but was now a dingy, grey colour. A spider was lurking in one of the corners, and he glared at it; he had never been very fond of spiders. He screwed his eyes shut and took in a deep breath, wishing that everything, for once, would just stop, even if it was only for a moment.

◊◊◊

2 Weeks Later

Bilbo was exhausted. He felt as if he hadn’t slept properly since the wedding, already a fortnight ago. He supposed it was likely the guilt, still weighing down on his mind; while his wife slept in the next room, Bilbo would lie in bed with Thorin. He was too cowardly, however, to do anything about it, and he could feel the strain it was creating in both his relationship with Clara and with Thorin.

A knock came at the door that connected his room to Clara’s, and he startled at the sudden noise. “Yes?” he called, clearing his throat and setting his book down. It was late at night, and he expected Clara to be asleep. Though they had only been married for two weeks, it was already becoming uncommon for them to share a bed.

“May I come in?” Clara’s voice was hesitant and shy, and Bilbo straightened.

“Yes, of course.”

The door creaked open, and in slipped his wife, dressed in a silk dressing gown she had bought in Paris. “May I speak with you?” she asked, her eyes focused on the ground and her cheeks pink.

“Certainly,” Bilbo replied, his brows furrowing slightly. “Come, sit down.”

She nodded and scurried across the room, settling uncomfortably onto the other side of the bed. There was a moment where neither of them said anything.

“What would you like to talk to me about?” asked Bilbo.

Clara frowned, biting down on her bottom lip. “I, um...” she began. “I really have no idea how to say this...”

“Just say it. It can’t be that difficult.”

“But it is,” Clara argued, looking up at him with an almost desperate look on her face. She took in a deep breath, letting it out as a loud sigh. “I... I know.”

Bilbo looked at her, expecting her to say more, but when she didn’t, he asked, “Know what?”

“About you,”—she paused to take in another shaky breath—“and the valet.”

Bilbo felt his heart sink. “What... what do you mean?” He tried to quell the panic quickly rising in his chest, his hands curling into the sheets.

Clara frowned at him. “You know what I mean,” she said, her tone turning defiant. “You and your... your valet.”

“Clara, darling, I don’t know wh—”

“Oh, stop,” she interrupted. “I know it’s true, and you cannot deny it.” Bilbo looked away, squeezing his eyes shut.

There was a long stretch of silence. “How...” Bilbo asked, after what was probably only a few minutes, but felt like decades. “How did you find out?”

“One of the maids,” Clara explained. She was staring at her hands, picking at her nails. “She caught the valet—”

“Lewis.” Bilbo could feel Clara staring at him.

“Yes,” she said, after a few seconds. “Lewis. She caught him leaving your room, early one morning, before anyone else had woken up.”

“That doesn’t prove anything.” Bilbo could hear the desperation and fear in his own voice, and brought a hand up to cover his mouth.

“She caught him more than once,” Clara continued. He still couldn’t bring himself to look at her. “Over the course of several months. She was too frightened to talk to anyone else about it, but one morning she got up earlier than usual and, well... found the two of you... to—”

“That’s enough,” Bilbo interrupted. “God, Clara,”—he heard her gasp softly in shock—“please, you have to understand.”

“I... don’t know if I can,” Clara admitted. “I certainly won’t pretend to. But I have known for several days now, and have spent many sleepless nights thinking about it.” She paused, taking in a deep breath, as if reassuring herself. “You love him, do you not? He makes you happy?”

Bilbo looked at her, and then glanced down at his hands. “Yes,” he breathed. “I do love him. Very much.”

Clara reached over, placing one hand on his shoulder. “I know this was not a marriage born of love,” she said. “We married because we both needed to. But that does not mean we cannot be happy together.” She paused. “If this... relationship with your valet—with Lewis—makes you happy, then, my darling, who am I to... to stop it? I am your wife, yes, but I feel in reality that means very little. We have only been married a fortnight, and I realize now that you cannot ever love me, not in the way a husband usually loves his wife.” She shifted, so that she could look at Bilbo directly. “If I forced you from him, it would not make you love me. So why should I?”

“Clara.” Bilbo took Clara’s face in his hands, giving her a sad smile. “My dear wife. What sort of life have I forced you into?”

Clara scowled. “Oh, please,” she scoffed, gently removing his hands and holding them in her own. “You have not forced me into anything. I married you of my own choice, Edmund Holland, and I am doing this of my own choice as well. I want you to be happy, so do stop being so gloomy and depressing.”

Bilbo laughed, despite himself. Though he did not know how well it would turn out in the end, for the moment all he felt was a strong sense of relief—someone finally knew. While she didn’t know the entire story, the fact that she at least knew some part of it was enough, in that moment, for Bilbo.

◊◊◊

The next morning, Bilbo was already out of bed when Thorin arrived, a tray of tea in his hands. He set it down on the reading table and began carefully pouring it out, as Bilbo stared, almost mesmerized, out the window to the garden below.

“Good morning,” Thorin greeted, and Bilbo hummed, nodding.

“Good morning,” he mumbled, several beats later.

Thorin looked at him, his eyebrows raised. “Are you alright?”

“Hm? Oh, yes, of course I’m alright.” He took in a deep breath, letting it out quickly. “Really, I’m more than alright. I’m... quite happy.”

“You don’t sound as if you’re happy,” Thorin said. “Did something happen?”

“No, no, I am happy.” He paused and worried his bottom lip between his teeth, before finally turning to face Thorin. “But... I need to tell you something.”

Thorin nodded, as Bilbo took a seat at the reading table. “Of course.”

“Before I do, promise me you won’t get angry, or upset.”

Thorin’s brows furrowed, a look of apprehension briefly crossing his face. “What is it?”

Bilbo took in another deep breath. “Clara... knows. About us.”

The teapot clattered onto the tray, and Bilbo winced. “What do you mean?” Thorin asked, his hands gripping the edge of the table.

“I told you not to get upset.”

“Well, unfortunately I’m a bit upset. I wasn’t exactly expecting that.”

“You don’t need to be upset,” Bilbo argued.

“Please elaborate.”

Bilbo sighed, resting his head in his hands. “What do you think she’ll do, Thorin?” he asked. “If she told anyone, it would likely be just as ruinous for her as for us. There are few people who want it to be known that their husband had an affair, let alone that he had an affair with his valet. You must remember, my love, that status is everything in this world—an arrested valet and a disgraced husband would make her the object of ridicule, and would likely bring harm to her uncle, as well.”

“You believe, then, that she will remain quiet on the matter?” Thorin asked, his doubt obvious.

Bilbo nodded. “I do. There is little reason for her to tell anyone. She wants this marriage to be content, just as I do, and she feels that forcing us apart would only create resentment and mistrust.”

“She’s likely correct,” Thorin murmured.

“So you see, there is no reason for you to be upset,” Bilbo continued, ignoring Thorin’s comment. “All is well.”

Thorin sighed, running a hand over his face. “But how did she find out?” he asked. “You didn’t tell her, did you?”

A look of hurt briefly crossed Bilbo’s face. “I would never do something like that without talking to you first. It was a maid who told her.”

“Which maid?”

Bilbo shrugged. “Clara wouldn’t tell me.”

“How can you be sure the maid won’t tell someone?”

“The girl found out months ago, Thorin, but was too scared to tell anyone until Clara arrived,” Bilbo said, sounding exasperated. “I doubt she has the nerve to tell anyone else. But if it would make you feel better, Clara told her that if she breathes a word of this to anyone, she’ll be fired immediately without reference. She’s one of the maids who lights the fires in the morning, so she’s most likely very young. There’s no reason to think she would tell anyone.”

Thorin didn’t respond, and Bilbo sighed. “Please, just trust me,” he said, leaning forward and staring up into Thorin’s face. “This is not as dire as you’re making it out to be. Everything will be fine.”

“I hope you’re right,” Thorin muttered, returning his attention to the tea. He carefully removed the strainer from the cup, before passing it to Bilbo. “If I’m to be honest, though,” he said, sitting down on the chaise longue and resting his head against the window, “I don’t particularly care for this life.”

Bilbo’s eyebrows drew together as he took a sip of his tea. “Why’s that?” he asked.

“I’m a servant, Bilbo. All this Victorian etiquette and propriety is much too stuffy for me and, frankly, I’m tired of it. I’ve spent this entire lifetime bowing and serving and catering to the wishes of others. It isn’t very enjoyable.”

Bilbo hummed thoughtfully, nodding. “It’s certainly a far cry from the life I lead in the Caribbean.”

“From a pirate captain to an English marquess,” Thorin said with a quiet laugh. “Yes, it’s most definitely a change.”

“Sometimes I find myself missing that life,” admitted Bilbo. “Not all of it, mind you. I’m quite content without the murder and constantly fearing for my life. But the freedom that life offered me was quite nice. I could do whatever I wanted, and no one cared.” He laughed. “I also miss the swearing quite a lot. I said ‘God’ last night and Clara seemed rather shocked by it.”

Thorin looked at him and smiled. “You know what I miss? Swords.”

Bilbo laughed again. “Why do you miss swords?”

“They’re nice,” Thorin said with a shrug. “It’s not that I miss fighting in battles, though I do miss that sometimes. It’s more that I miss training with a sword, and having one.”

“Maybe if you’re lucky you’ll get one in the next life.”

“I don’t know if that would be a good or bad thing.”

Bilbo gave him a small smile. “Whichever it is, I’m really quite happy with waiting to find out.”

“Yes,” said Thorin, nodding. “I am too.”

◊◊◊

2 Weeks Later

It was early evening, and a soft yellow glow was filtering through the windows into the servants’ hall. Thorin sat at the table, carefully sewing a button back onto one of Bilbo’s shirts. Shortly after his arrival at Wybourne Hall, Mrs. Tompkins had sat him down and taught him how to sew. He hadn’t been very good at first, but over the past few months his skills had greatly improved. He was quite proud of himself, really.

He grinned slightly as he tugged on the string one final time and cut it free from the needle. Looking up, he glanced at the clock hanging on the nearby wall. Dinner would be served upstairs in about an hour, and so it would not be long until Thorin was called upstairs to help Bilbo change. He quickly put away the sewing tools that he had borrowed from Mrs. Lynch, and stood to return them to her office.

It was locked, however, so he headed towards the kitchen where Mrs. Bramley, the cook, was busy preparing dinner for upstairs.

“Have you seen Mrs. Lynch?” he asked, sticking his head in through the door. “I need to return her sewing kit.”

“What? No,” Mrs. Bramley replied with a scowl from where she stood in front of the oven. “Can’t you see I’m busy? Shoo!”

Thorin frowned and made to leave, but as Mrs. Bramley opened the oven door there was a violent eruption of flames. The cook cried out and fell to the floor, and Thorin rushed forward, dropping the sewing kit and shirt onto the counter. The oven was in flames, and Mrs. Bramley’s eyes were wide as she crouched on the floor, shaking. Both of her arms were covered in vicious burns, up to the elbow on her left.

“Oh, shit,” Thorin cursed, kneeling in front of her. Both kitchen maids were standing on the other side of the room, looking from Mrs. Bramley to the flaming oven with scared, wide eyes. “What are you doing?” he cried to them. “One of you go find Mr. Wakefield, quickly!”

The smallest of the two girls nodded, rushing from the room. “You!” Thorin said, pointing to the remaining maid. “Come over here! Quick!”

She scurried over to him, her eyes jumping over Mrs. Bramley, as if she was scared to look at her. It was obvious that the cook was in shock, and Thorin quickly removed his jacket and placed it over her shoulders. “Mrs. Bramley, can you stand?” he asked. “We need to move you somewhere safer.”

“Y-Yes, of course,” Mrs. Bramley murmured. Thorin helped her to her feet, careful not to touch her burnt arms, and moved her from the kitchen as quickly as they could. They settled her onto the couch in Mr. Wakefield’s office, her feet elevated on the armrest, and Thorin instructed the maid to stay with her until she could be brought to the hospital.

“Talk to her; keep her awake,” he told the girl, as two of the footmen ran past. They were followed by Mr. Wakefield and the other kitchen maid, who was talking so rapidly she wasn’t understandable. “Don’t give her anything to eat or drink. Keep her warm, but don’t touch the burns. Don’t put anything on them; just leave them.”

The maid nodded, though she looked terrified out of her mind, and Thorin raced from the room. “What happened?” Mr. Wakefield demanded, his eyes bewildered.

“I’m not sure,” Thorin replied. “The oven seemed to just... burst into flames. I think whatever was inside must have caught on fire. But Mrs. Bramley is very badly hurt, and needs to get to the hospital as soon as possible. I have one of the maids looking after her.”

“I sent Stephen to fetch the fire department,” Mr. Wakefield said, referring to the youngest hall boy. “They should be here soon, likely with an ambulance.”

Thorin nodded, and Mr. Wakefield sighed, pulling out a handkerchief and running it across his sweaty forehead. “I must go explain this to His Lordship,” the butler said. “If you’ll excuse me.”

“Of course.” As Mr. Wakefield turned to go back upstairs, Thorin hurried to the kitchen. Several buckets of sand hung on the hallway wall, and he grabbed one on his way. The fire had already spread from the oven to a nearby cabinet, despite the footmen’s efforts, and the sand that Thorin tossed onto the flames did little to quell them.

“Fill the buckets with water,” he ordered, looking at the two footmen, standing there with empty sand pails.

For the next several minutes, they ran back and forth from the well to the kitchen, tossing the bucketfuls of water onto the fire. The flames continued to spread, however, moving too quickly for them to control. Mrs. Lynch began evacuating everyone from the building shortly before the fire department arrived, gathering them all on the front drive; Mrs. Bramley was carried out in an old blanket.

“You need to get out of here, now,” Mr. Wakefield said, appearing in the kitchen doorway. Most of the room was overtaken by flames, and it would soon spread. Thorin could feel the smoke slowly suffocating him, burning his throat and lungs.

He still had a full pail of water, and so he tossed its contents onto the nearest group of flames, though he knew it would be useless. Mr. Wakefield was still standing in the doorway, an anxious look on his face as he held a handkerchief up to his nose. Thorin hurried towards the door. All around him, the wood of the cabinetry was crackling as it burned. Several of the cupboards had glass panel doors, but all the glass was shattered now, littering the floor alongside piles of coal and soot. It seemed incredible how quickly the fire had raged out of control.

One of the cabinets, pushed up against the wall, began to teeter, the legs too burnt to support it. Thorin didn’t notice until he was beside it, and then it was falling. It crashed down on top of him, the ceramic dishes inside smashing to pieces as he was buried under the burning wood. He felt a searing pain all along his body, and for a brief moment he was brought back to the halls of Erebor, all those years ago when the dragon attacked and his people burned.

He sucked in a deep, panicked breath. His lungs filled with hot smoke, and then the pain became unbearable and the world slipped away.

◊◊◊

Bilbo stood in front of Wybourne Hall, the gravel of the drive crunching beneath him as he shifted from foot to foot. Smoke could be seen billowing from the bottom windows on the east side of the building, where the kitchen was located, though there no flames. Hoses ran from the fire engines parked near the door into Wybourne, where they had been dragged several minutes ago; a small group of firefighters remained outside, pumping water through the hoses.

Mr. Wakefield stumbled suddenly through the front door, accompanied by a firefighter and followed by two footmen. He was coughing, his face black with soot, and Bilbo could see his hands shaking violently as the firefighter set him down gently on the grass.

“Wakefield!” he cried, rushing over to the butler. “Are you alright?”

Mr. Wakefield looked at him with wide eyes, and made to stand up, but Bilbo stopped him, one hand on his shoulder. “No, Wakefield, please,” he said, and knelt down beside him. “Do not exert yourself.”

“I’m perfectly fine, Milord,” Mr. Wakefield said, holding a handkerchief to his mouth as he let out another hacking cough. “It’s only a bit of smoke.”

“Should you go to the hospital?” Bilbo asked, looking to the footmen. “Charles, David, are you both alright?”

Charles nodded, wiping soot from his cheek. “Yes, of course, Milord.”

“Did everyone make it outside safely?” Bilbo looked to Mr. Wakefield, who took in a gasping gulp of air, as if he was struggling to breathe. There was a brief moment, where no one said anything.

“No, Milord.” It was David who spoke, his hands clasped behind his back and his head bowed.

Bilbo rose slowly to his feet. His eyes automatically began scanning the crowd of people gathered around him, searching for Thorin; he didn’t find him, and he felt his heart drop. He looked back to David. “Who?” he asked. “Who did not make it?”

“Mr. Lewis, Milord,” Charles replied, confirming Bilbo’s fears. “A cabinet fell on him as we were leaving. We tried to help him, but then the firefighters arrived and sent us away. I’m sorry, Milord. He was in an awfully bad state.”

Bilbo felt the world slow around him. He turned, looking back towards Wybourne Hall. The steady stream of smoke had lessened, and more firefighters were emerging from inside. He watched, not even daring to breathe, as one pair stepped outside, a stretcher in their hands. The body on the stretcher was covered in a sheet, once white but now stained black with grime. Bilbo choked back a sob as the body was carried to a waiting ambulance and placed inside. He knew, without a doubt, that it was Thorin, and though he felt like falling to the ground in despair he held himself back.

Blinking away the tears pricking at his eyes, he turned away. His eyes caught Clara’s from across the drive; she looked from him to the ambulance and her shoulders fell, a look of pity crossing her face. She started towards him, but he shook his head, and she stopped. He could feel her eyes on him even as he looked away. He would talk to her, later, when he was ready. For now, he simply wanted to be alone.

He had known this would happen—of course he had known. Nothing had changed, in the end. Somehow he had convinced himself that they were safe; that nothing could hurt them. But no one could evade death. It was always there, lurking around the corner.

The setting sun shone brightly in his eyes as he turned and walked away—away from his smoking house and his wife’s pitying eyes and the ambulance that held the body of the man he loved most. He walked until the people gathered around Wybourne were only dark figures, and then he fell to the ground with a shudder. His fingers dug into the grass, and as he breathed in he could smell the sickly sweet scent of the flowers that grew all around him.

Notes:

Characters
Edmund - Bilbo
Eugenia - Belladonna Baggins
Gethin - Thorin
Mr. Barlow - Dori