Chapter Text
Northern France, April 1917
The earth was shaking. With every dropped shell and fired gun, the ground above and around Duncan Thornton shuddered. Flakes of dirt trickled from the ceiling and fell into his face, and the men around him shifted nervously. He closed his eyes, and pretended he was somewhere else; the rumbling above him was only thunder, and he was back home, safe with his family.
Someone beside him coughed, and Duncan opened his eyes. It was dark—the nearest lantern was several metres away, and much of its dim light was blocked by the bodies of other men, who looked to Duncan like shadows. Their features were shrouded by the dark of the tunnel, so that he did not who was who.
Nearby, a man began praying. Few of them were talking, and those that did, did so in whispers. It was as if they were too afraid to speak loudly, though no one above the surface would be able to hear them. Duncan took in a deep breath. The tunnel smelled oppressively of cigarette smoke and sweat, and he felt the overwhelming urge to smoke; he had run out of cigarettes the night before.
He wondered what time it was. Likely 5 o’clock in the morning, he decided. They were set to begin their attack on the Germans at 5:30, when they would surge from the tunnels close to the enemy’s lines. Duncan had been in battles before, but that did little to lessen his fear. He had seen men blown to bits by exploding shells, or struck in the face by bullets. He knew it could happen to him, as quickly as it had happened to them.
He leaned back, resting against the cool, chalky surface of the tunnel walls. His hands were shaking violently, and he clasped them tightly together to stop their tremors. He wished he had saved at least one cigarette.
◊◊◊
Weeks later, when Duncan thought back to it, he remembered little of the ensuing battle. Bits and pieces of it came back to him in fragments—his feet slipping in the mud; the wind and the sleet stabbing at his face; the constant sounds of gunshots and screams. He remembered the sun rising, obscured behind grey clouds and smoke, slowly illuminating the horrors unfolding around him.
He didn’t remember the shell falling towards him, but he remembered it going off, only a few metres away. The pain as the flesh was torn from his foot and the shrapnel dug itself into his back seemed to be forever seared into his mind; he remembered collapsing to the muddy ground with a cry, but little else after that.
He woke up hours later, on a cot in a casualty clearing station. His back and leg felt as if they were on fire, and when he tried to move they screamed out in agony. He felt hot; too hot. The world around him seemed blurry, and he thought he could still hear the sounds of battle, muffled in the distance.
A nurse was hovering over him, a concerned look on her face. It sounded as if she was saying his name, but Duncan couldn’t be sure. He could see her lips moving, but it was like he was underwater, and she was above the surface.
He opened his mouth to speak to her, but before he could get any words out he drifted away. For a reason he couldn’t quite understand, he imagined himself being carried out to sea by a gentle current, as sleep and exhaustion overtook him.
◊◊◊
Nova Scotia, Canada, June 1917
It was mid-afternoon, and the air was hot and humid as Peter Taggart walked down the sidewalk. The shops were busy, and people were crowding the streets, going every which way and driving past in motor cars. Peter kept a tight hold on his youngest nephew’s hand, making sure that he stayed close. Up ahead, his oldest nephew was expertly dodging those in his path, swinging around the suitcase clutched in his hands.
“Jack!” he called, and the boy stopped and turned to look back at him. “Don’t get so far ahead.”
Jack scowled, but did as he was told, rocking back and forth on the balls of his feet as he waited for his uncle and younger brother to catch up. “You’re slow,” he said, falling into step beside them with a loud sigh. “Are we almost there?”
Peter nodded. “We should be there soon, yes.”
“Why do we have to go live somewhere else?” asked his youngest nephew. “I wanna stay with you.”
Peter frowned, and tightened his grip on his nephew’s small hand. “I told you, Harry,” he said. “I have to go be a soldier, and someone has to look after you while I’m gone.”
“Why can’t we go with you?” Harry asked, sniffing.
“We’re too young,” Jack said, peering around his uncle to look at his brother. “Kids can’t join the army.”
“Then why can’t Papa stay?” Tears were welling in Harry’s eyes, and he wiped at them angrily with the sleeve of his coat. “It’s not fair!”
Though he knew that Peter wasn’t his real father, Harry had always called him Papa. Peter had given up correcting him when Jack began calling him Papa too, though up until then he had always called him Uncle. In a way, Peter supposed he was their father—he had raised them since they were five and one, and was really the only parent they knew. He thought of them as his own children, just as they thought of him as their father.
“I know, Harry,” Peter said, stopping to lift the boy into his arms. He was five years old already, but incredibly small and skinny; he seemed to weigh next to nothing. “But I have no choice. They need soldiers to go fight. You’ll be alright, though. Mrs. Chisholm will take good care of you, I promise.”
“But what if you don’t come back?” asked Jack. His eyes were wide, and Peter could see the fear and worry in them. “George Murphy’s dad went away to war, and he was killed. Victor Collingwood told me he was blown up, and there weren’t enough pieces of him left to bury.”
That, of course, sent Harry into a panic, and he began bawling, screaming about how he didn’t want Papa to be blown up.
“It’s alright,” Peter said, as Harry buried his head in his shoulder. “I’ll be okay, I promise. There’s no need to worry about such things.”
“I don’t want you to go.”
“I’ll be back before long,” Peter promised, ruffling his nephew’s hair. “Don’t you worry.”
Harry sniffed, and Peter glanced over at Jack, who looked guilty and was picking at the cracked leather of his bag. “I’m sorry, Papa,” he murmured. At nine years old, Jack often liked to act as if he wasn’t scared of the war or of his uncle going away to fight, but Peter knew he was. He was still only a child, after all.
Peter placed his free hand on Jack’s shoulder. “I know. But you shouldn’t believe what Victor Collingwood tells you, certainly not when it comes to the war.”
Jack nodded, running his sleeve across his face.
“It’ll be alright,” Peter told him softly. “Trust me.”
◊◊◊
Mrs. Chisholm lived in a large, Queen Anne revival style home on a quiet street in the north of Truro. The sign outside proclaimed Stanby Children’s Home in big white letters. Peter had been there twice before, the first time to meet Mrs. Chisholm and the only yesterday to drop off extra luggage for the boys. Mrs. Chisholm was a kind, middle-aged woman, who had run the home with her husband for the past twenty years. They both lived in Stanby’s, alongside the eight children currently in their care, all of whom were orphans or had parents unable to care for them. Jack and Harry would bring the number up to ten.
Peter’s knock on the door was answered by a young woman, likely in her early twenties, who he recognized as one of two caretakers hired by Mrs. Chisholm and her husband. “Mr. Taggart,” she said with a smile, opening the door wider and stepping aside. “Please, come in. We’ve been expecting you.”
Inside, the house was cool. The caretaker—Nellie, Peter thought her name was—lead them through to the parlour, and left them sitting on the couch while she went to fetch Mrs. Chisholm. Harry refused to leave Peter’s arms, and sat curled up on his lap, clutching the front of his shirt. Jack was unusually quiet, staring solemnly at his scuffed shoes.
“Ah, Mr. Taggart.” Mrs. Chisholm appeared in the doorway to the parlour, her hands clasped together in front of her. She smiled warmly at Harry, who quickly looked away, pressing his face into his uncle’s chest. “You must Harry,” she said, her voice kind and gentle; Harry didn’t move.
“I’m sorry,” Peter apologized, as Mrs. Chisholm sat down in the arm chair across from them. “He’s normally not this shy.”
“It’s alright. I understand.” She looked at Jack, who continued to stare pointedly at his feet. “You’re Jack, correct?”
He nodded slowly, taking his bottom lip between his teeth and chewing on it nervously. He pressed himself against Peter’s side, as if hoping his uncle would block him from Mrs. Chisholm’s view.
“And how old are you, Jack?” Mrs. Chisholm asked.
“Nine.” Jack’s response was quiet and barely audible, but Mrs. Chisholm didn’t press him further.
“What about you, Harry?” she asked. “How old are you?”
Harry didn’t say anything, and Peter nudged him gently. “Go on,” he whispered. “Tell her. She won’t bite, I promise.”
Harry lifted his head to look at Mrs. Chisholm. “Five,” he murmured, before ducking back towards the safety of his uncle.
Mrs. Chisholm’s smile grew. “How wonderful,” she said. “There’s another little boy here who’s five. His name’s Albert.”
“Isn’t that great?” Peter looked down at Harry, who shrugged.
“Are there any who’re nine?” Jack asked, finally looking up at Mrs. Chisholm.
She shook her head. “There is one who’s ten, however, and another who’s twelve,” she said. “I’m sure they’d love to be your friend.”
Jack seemed to brighten at that, and glanced at his uncle with a small smile.
Nellie arrived then with a tray of tea and biscuits, and Mrs. Chisholm told the boys all about what life would be like at Stanby’s while they nibbled on their cookies. It would be much more regimented than what they were used to, but she had no doubt they would adjust quickly. Peter assured them that it was only for a little while, though of course he didn’t know that for sure—no one knew how much longer the war would last. It could only be a few more months, or it could be another three years. In reality, Peter had no idea how long his nephews would have to stay in the care of Mrs. Chisholm.
He felt horribly guilty leaving them there, though he had little choice. He had no family in Canada he could leave them with: Their few remaining relatives still lived in Ireland. Peter had left the country of his birth four years ago, after his sister died and he was entrusted with her children. The war began less than a year later. He had avoided the draft as long as he could, ignoring the disdainful looks of neighbours and strangers, all so he could continue to care for his nephews. When conscription was introduced, however, he was one of the first called to action, and he had no option but to answer.
Mrs. Chisholm stood, smoothing the front of her simple cotton dress. “I’ll leave you now to say your goodbyes, then.”
Peter lifted Harry off his lap so he could stand. He took Mrs. Chisholm’s hand in his own, shaking it gratefully. “Thank you, Mrs. Chisholm,” he said. “I’m very grateful.”
Mrs. Chisholm gave a sad smile. “You leave for training tomorrow, correct?”
Peter nodded.
“I wish you the very best of luck, Mr. Taggart.” She patted his hand. “Nellie will be down in ten minutes to collect the boys. I promise you, we will do our best to look after them in your absence.”
“Thank you so very much.”
She nodded, and turned to leave him alone with his nephews. The door closed quietly behind her.
Peter knelt down, gathering Harry and Jack into his arms. “I don’t want you to go,” whispered Harry.
“I know,” Peter said. “I don’t want to go either, but we don’t always have a choice when it comes to some things. You’ll be alright here, though. You have each other, and Mrs. Chisholm will take right good care of you.”
Harry nodded, his chin digging into Peter’s shoulder.
“When will you be back?” Jack asked. His eyes were full of tears, and Peter reached out to smooth his unruly blond hair. He’d meant to cut it before his departure, but had forgotten.
“I don’t know,” Peter admitted. “But I promise I’ll write every chance I get. Okay?”
Jack frowned, but still nodded. “Okay.”
“Look after your brother for me, will you?” asked Peter, and Jack nodded again. “Stay out of trouble, the both of you. I won’t have you causing mayhem for Mrs. Chisholm or anyone else here.”
“We’ll try,” Jack promised, with the hint of a smile on his face.
Peter pressed a kiss to the top of both his nephews’ heads. “I’ll miss you both terribly. I already can’t wait ‘till I’m back here with you.”
“We’ll be good, Papa,” Harry said, pulling back and wiping the tears from his cheeks. “Promise.”
“I know you will be. Listen to what Mrs. Chisholm and the other adults tell you, alright?” Peter smiled.
Jack sniffed, his bottom lip trembling. “Please come back, Papa.”
“I could never leave you boys.” He leaned forward, kissing Jack’s forehead. “Never.”
There was a soft knock at the door, and it opened to reveal Nellie, her eyebrows drawn together. Peter stood, lifting Harry up with him.
“I have to go now,” he said, and Harry began crying again, his face scrunching up as the tears fell down his cheeks.
“No, Papa. Don’t!” He wrapped his small, skinny arms around Peter’s neck, and clung to him tightly.
“I’m sorry, love. I have to.” Peter gently unhooked Harry’s arms and set him down, placing a kiss on his wet cheek. He knelt down to give Jack a tight hug before standing once more. “Be good,” he told them. He could feel the tears welling in his own eyes, but he held them back. “I’ll be back as soon as I possibly can.”
Jack nodded, and went to pull his little brother into his arms.
“I love you both very much,” said Peter. “Just... know that.”
Harry’s cries grew louder as Peter turned to leave. He screwed his eyes shut, wanting nothing more than to take his nephew into his arms and comfort him. He didn’t look back as he stepped out of the parlour into the hallway—he knew if he did, he wouldn’t be able to leave.
◊◊◊
Halifax, December 1917
December arrived in a cold chill blown in from the sea. Duncan had been home in Canada for nearly two months now; after the casualty clearing station, he had been sent to a nearby field hospital for surgery. The wounds on his back and leg had been extensive, resulting in the loss of his right foot, and when it was determined he would need more time to recover he’d been sent to England, to a convalescent home. There was no way for him to be a solider with a prosthetic foot, and so he’d been honourably discharged and sent home.
Duncan shivered as he walked around the kitchen, leaning heavily on his cane. According to the doctors, he was lucky he’d only lost his foot and not his entire leg, though it was unlikely he would ever walk properly again. The winter cold seemed only to make it worse, and as he sat down at the table he winced, rubbing the stiff muscle.
He knew he was lucky—he thought about it every day. How he was lucky that he didn’t die, that the shrapnel that embedded itself in his back didn’t injure his spine and paralyse him, that he didn’t lose his whole leg. Most of the time, however, he didn’t feel lucky; he just felt pain.
Sighing, he lifted his mug of tea to his lips and sipped carefully. From where he sat, he could see out the window, to the houses that sat around his and down to the harbour in the distance. Ever since the start of the war, the harbour had been busier than ever—there was a constant stream of ships entering and leaving, either heading to or returning from Europe. Most Canadian soldiers headed to the front lines came through Halifax, and he would often see them around the city, enjoying their last bits of freedom before leaving for the war.
He didn’t like to think about how many of them would never return.
Duncan frowned. The war had been going on for over three years now, and it didn’t seem as if it would be stopping anytime soon. He often thought that it would never end—the fighting would go on forever, and the world would never again know peace. The idea seemed plausible, and cripplingly terrifying, when one had actually been to the battlefields of war-torn Europe.
Outside, the milk wagon trundled past, metal cans clanging together in the back and the hooves of the horse beating against the road. Duncan watched as the milkman, an elderly man named Forrester, waved and called hello to those he passed. He was a friendly person, Forrester, and Duncan had known him since he was a young boy, when he had lived only two streets away from his current home with his parents.
The house he had grown up in was owned by another family now—a woman and her four young children. Her husband was away overseas, and had been since the start of the war. He was an army doctor, Duncan had been told. He often walked by their house while the children were outside playing, and the youngest would stop and stare at him for a moment, the man with the cane and the funny walk, until the oldest scolded them for being rude.
Duncan didn’t mind their stares; not really. He had gotten used to them, since his return home. The adults would look at him with pity, and would whisper to each other about what a sin it was, such a young man with such a crippling injury. The children would watch him curiously, and ask their parents what was wrong with him; they’d be shushed quietly, and pulled away.
Sighing, Duncan wrapped his hands around his mug. The tea had gone lukewarm, and he frowned, wondering if it would be worth it to brew another pot.
◊◊◊
The wind blowing off the harbour was biting. Duncan sat on a bench in Point Pleasant Park, the collar of his overcoat lifted to protect his neck from the cold wind and his gloved hands shoved into the pockets. His cane was leaning beside him on the bench, and he could already feel his leg beginning to ache. Though he couldn’t walk for long, he still enjoyed visiting the park. It was nice to just sit, watching the ships in the harbour and the people walking by.
Reaching into his coat pocket, he dug out a box of cigarettes and some matches. He quickly lit one of the cigarettes and held it up to his lips, taking in a deep breath. As he exhaled, the white smoke drifted up to the sky, mingling with the puffy clouds sailing by overhead. Duncan thought of his father—the man had begun smoking when he was only ten, and didn’t stop until he was dead. Duncan had vivid memories of his father sitting in the dark red armchair in their living room, smoking a pipe as he told Duncan stories about his childhood in Cape Breton. He’d been able to blow smoke rings, a skill which had amused Duncan to no end as a child. He’d never learnt how to do it himself, however.
Out in the harbour, a tugboat began pulling in the anti-submarine net. The boat waiting to enter the harbour was some sort of supply ship, and Duncan could see the words BELGIAN RELIEF painted on its side in huge letters. He watched as it chugged slowly into the busy harbour, and the tugboat began to drag the anti-submarine net back across.
A group of soldiers came wandering up the path, laughing and talking loudly. It was impossible to go anywhere in Halifax without tripping over a soldier or a sailor. There were about five of them in the group, all dressed up in their uniforms. They seemed to be slightly older than most of the recruits Duncan saw around the city, meaning they were likely conscriptions. He knew that men who didn’t sign up for the draft voluntarily were often looked down upon as cowards, but he understood their hesitation—he had seen the horrors of war first-hand, and they’d left him without a foot.
He nodded to the soldiers as they passed by him. Though they were older than the usual eighteen- and nineteen-years-olds, they were still young enough: Most looked like they were under thirty. They glanced at him and nodded back, and Duncan could see the fear in their eyes—the worry that they’d end up like him, sitting on a park bench with a cane, unable to walk for too long because of the pain and discomfort of a prosthetic.
And then he felt his heart drop to his feet, as he stared into a pair of all too familiar blue eyes. Thorin paused, and Bilbo felt a split-second of joy before a blanket of dread settled over him. He opened his mouth to say something, but found that no words could come out.
“Taggart!” It was one of the other soldiers. They had stopped, and were looking back at Thorin with expectant faces. “Are you coming?”
Thorin looked from Bilbo to his friends. “I, uh... Just give me a moment.” His accent was Irish, and thick, taking Bilbo by surprise.
“Taggart, come on!” one of the soldiers called, sounding exasperated.
“I’ll catch up with you later!” Thorin replied. He muttered something incomprehensible under his breath as his friends wandered away.
“You’re Irish,” was all that Bilbo could think to say.
Thorin looked at him, his eyebrows raised in amusement.
“And you have a mustache. I don’t think I’ve ever seen you with a mustache.” Bilbo was used to Thorin having facial hair, but with only a mustache his face looked bare, and different.
“You’re very observant,” Thorin commented with a smile. He glanced quickly up the path; his friends had disappeared around a corner.
Bilbo chuckled quietly, lifting his half-burnt cigarette to his mouth as Thorin sat down on the bench beside him. Bilbo stared at him for a moment, his emotions torn between happiness and concern.
“You shouldn’t smoke,” Thorin said, looking at the cigarette dangling loosely in Bilbo’s fingers. “It’s really very bad for you, though of course no one here knows that yet.”
“I know,” Bilbo mumbled with a sigh. He tossed the cigarette onto the path, crushing it beneath his foot. He glanced at Thorin. “You’re a soldier, then?”
Thorin nodded. “Though I would hardly call myself one. I only just finished basic training last week.”
Bilbo frowned, his eyes focused on the ground in front of him. “When do you leave?” he asked.
“Friday.”
Bilbo felt his heart sink. “Only two days from now.”
“It’s not long, is it?” Thorin asked, leaning forward and resting his elbows on his knees. There was a brief pause where neither of them said anything. “Do you think I’ll die over there?”
Bilbo took in a deep breath, his eyes slipping shut. That had been the first thought to pop into his head when he saw Thorin—that he was a soldier bound for Europe, where he would die on the battlefield. “I...” He swallowed, his mouth dry. “I don’t know.”
“It’s an awfully morbid thing to be thinking about,” admitted Thorin with a sigh. “I’m sorry.”
“No, it’s fine.” Bilbo placed a hand on Thorin’s shoulder, leaning towards him. “I was thinking that as well. The moment I saw you... in this uniform... my first thought was that you’d be the one to die, and it would be in the war.”
Thorin looked at him, his face grave. “Have you been there?” he asked, his eyes darting to the cane still leaning against the bench. “To Europe?”
Bilbo nodded. “I have. I lost my foot to a shell.” He lifted his right leg, his pant leg slipping up just enough to reveal the leather brace that kept his wooden foot in place.
Thorin’s face fell. “How long ago were you injured?”
“It was in April. At Vimy Ridge.”
Thorin looked pale, and Bilbo squeezed his shoulder. “Come on,” he said, hoisting himself to his feet and grabbing his cane. “If it isn’t urgent that you rejoin your friends, I’ll take you back to my house and we can talk more over some tea. It’s much too cold out here by the water.”
Thorin nodded and stood. A look of worry crossed his face as Bilbo began walking, leaning heavily on his cane.
“Don’t give me that look,” Bilbo scolded, shooting a glare at Thorin. “I can walk perfectly fine, you know.”
Thorin smirked, though he still looked anxious. “Yes, I’ve no doubt of that.”
◊◊◊
Bilbo lived in a small, two-storey house in the Richmond neighbourhood of northern Halifax, only a short walk from Fort Needham. From his front window, Thorin could clearly see the train tracks that ran along the harbour front, and the ships chugging through the Narrows and into the Bedford Basin. It was the early afternoon, and the harbour was as busy as it always was.
Bilbo pushed open the front door and gestured for him to step inside. To Thorin’s surprise, the interior was remarkably simple and plain—the furniture was sparse, and there were little to no decorations hanging from the cream-coloured walls. It was a home that looked remarkably unlived in.
Bilbo seemed to notice Thorin’s confusion, and frowned as he led him through into the kitchen. “I’ve only lived here three weeks,” he explained, shuffling about the kitchen as he lit the stove and filled the kettle with water.
Thorin’s brows furrowed. “So you’ve only just come back from Europe?”
“No, I have been back for about four months.” Bilbo said, placing the kettle onto a lit burner. “I lived with my cousin, Alice, for the first few months. I... wasn’t well, and couldn’t have lived on my own.”
“What do you mean you weren’t well?” Thorin had heard stories of soldiers returning from the war, plagued by nightmares and unable to readjust to normal life. The horrors that haunted them were what now made many men unwilling to join up.
“I was barely sleeping,” Bilbo said, the smallest hints of shame creeping into his voice. “When a door closed too loudly or the trains went by I’d become terrified. I struggled to do anything.” He didn’t look at Thorin as he settled into a chair at the kitchen table, his eyes focused on the kettle.
“How are you now?” Thorin asked, sitting down beside him. “Are you better?”
Bilbo frowned, his hands twisting nervously in his lap. “I still have nightmares,” he muttered. “I’ve become used to them, though. It’s been getting... easier.”
Thorin reached over, taking one of Bilbo’s hands in his own. He didn’t really know what to say—he could only imagine what Bilbo had gone through, though soon enough he would be experiencing it as well.
He thought suddenly of his nephews, in the care of Mrs. Chisholm back in Truro. If something were to happen to him in Europe, they would become wards of the state. They could potentially remain at Stanby’s, or they could be moved to another home or even to an orphanage. If they were adopted, there was no guarantee that they would be kept together. Though they had relatives in Ireland, it was unlikely any would send for them. His nephews could remain in state care for years.
It was that thought that frightened Thorin more than war. He wasn’t afraid of the fighting or the trenches or even of dying. He was afraid of what would happen to his nephews if—when—he died.
The screeching of the kettle shook him from his thoughts. Bilbo stood, quickly removing it from the burner. Thorin moved to help, but Bilbo shot him a glare that told him to stay put, and Thorin knew better than to argue.
“I don’t have any sugar,” Bilbo said, fishing two mugs out from the cupboard. “You’ll have to do without.”
“That’s alright.” Thorin watched as Bilbo placed teabags in the mugs and poured the boiled water overtop of them. With one hand on his cane, he brought the cups of tea over to the table one at a time, setting the first down in front of Thorin.
He smiled. “Thank you.”
Bilbo sat back down beside him, carefully stirring his sugar-less tea. Thorin’s smile grew and he leaned forward, resting his arms on the table. For some reason, he felt a certain calmness settle over him. They were a country at war, and Thorin was about to be shipped off to fight. He had his life and his nephews to worry about, but in that moment he felt more peaceful than he had in a long time, sitting there watching Bilbo stir his tea.
“I love you,” he murmured, and Bilbo looked up. He seemed sad, even as he smiled, and Thorin wondered if he was thinking about the war.
“I love you, too.”
◊◊◊
Bilbo sat with his head against the back of the couch, his fingers picking at the worn fabric of a pillow. Most of the things he owned had belonged to his parents, salvaged from his childhood home by Alice after his father’s death. The couch he sat on was old and springy, and there was a large tear in the arm of his father’s armchair, pushed into the far corner. The coffee table in front of him was covered in scratches and stains, and the leg often wobbled; Bilbo was waiting for the day when it finally collapsed.
Beside him, Thorin yawned. It was evening now, and Bilbo tried to imagine what the setting sun looked like dancing over the harbour. The blackout curtains were drawn across all the windows, keeping light from getting out. Soon, it would completely dark outside, the entire city absent of any light from houses or streetlamps.
Bilbo looked at Thorin, who was staring at the flames dancing in the fireplace. His forehead was wrinkled, his eyebrows drawn together, and Bilbo leaned towards him, placing a hand on his shoulder.
“Are you alright?” he asked.
Thorin turned to face him. “What happened to you, after I died?”
The question took Bilbo by surprise, and he frowned. “In England, you mean?” Thorin nodded. “Does it matter?”
“I want to know,” Thorin said with a shrug. “Were you alright? Were you happy?”
There was a brief pause. “I was happy enough, I suppose,” Bilbo admitted, “after a while. Clara and I had three children, two boys and a girl. I died rather young, as I have a tendency to do.”
“How?” The look in Thorin’s eyes was distant and sad.
“Some illness,” Bilbo said. “Likely cancer, now that I think about it.” He sighed, looking down at his fingernails. There were bitten to the quick, the skin around them torn and red. “You know, it’s interesting. After I was injured, I spent several months in England, in the house of an earl that had been turned into a convalescent home. It felt strangely familiar to me, being in a great house like that, though of course at the time I didn’t understand why. Now I realize it was like being back at Wybourne.”
“Do you miss it? Being a marquess?”
Bilbo thought for a moment, before shaking his head. “No, I don’t; not really. I’ve always preferred a simple life.” He gave a small smile. “I suppose Thomas, my eldest, is the marquess now. He’d be twenty-seven. It’s odd to think about, isn’t it? Your child being older than you.”
Thorin’s brows drew together. “How old are you now?”
“Twenty-two. Thomas was only four when I died, in 1895. The twins were one.” He frowned, picking at a mangled nail. “Do you find yourself missing the children you had in a past life? Neither of us have had very many, but...” He trailed off, his teeth digging into the skin of his bottom lip.
“I find I miss them quite a bit,” admitted Thorin, “and what I find saddest is that, once we die, we’ll never be able to see them again. I’ve never married the same person twice, and so I will never have the same children.”
“I regret that I wasn’t able to watch them grow up,” Bilbo said. “I likely wouldn’t recognize them, if I were to see them today.” He remembered how happy he’d been when they were born—first Thomas, then the twins, James and Helen. The happiness had ended rather abruptly when he fell ill, and he supposed his children had no memories of him. His death had brought him back to Thorin, but it had separated him from his children.
He looked at Thorin, and leaned towards him, resting his head on his shoulder. He winced as a sharp pain shot up his back, and he quickly readjusted into a more comfortable position.
“I haven’t asked your name yet,” he realized, twisting his neck so he could look up at Thorin’s face.
Thorin glanced down at him and smiled. “It’s Peter Taggart.”
“Duncan Thornton.” Bilbo reached over and took Thorin’s hand, shaking it. “Pleasure to meet you.”
Thorin laughed, and Bilbo felt some of the dread and sorrow resting on his shoulders lift. He hated to be so sad and gloomy, especially with Thorin leaving for the war so soon. There was no knowing when they would see each other again.
A sudden realization burst into his mind and he sat up, his eyes going wide.
“The war!” he cried. “I’d completely forgotten—it ends in 1918! Less than a year from now!”
Thorin’s eyebrows shot up. “You’re right,” he said, his voice and expression stunned. “November 11, 1918. World War I ends.”
Bilbo felt as if he was going to cry. For so long, it’d felt as if the war would never end, but now he knew it would. He laughed, throwing his arms around Thorin’s shoulders. “I can’t believe it,” he whispered.
Thorin pressed a kiss into the side of his head. “I’ll come back from this war,” he muttered. “For you, and for my nephews.”
“Fíli and Kíli?” Bilbo lifted his head. “Do they live with you?”
“They do, yes,” said Thorin, nodding. “They’re more like my sons than my nephews, in this life.”
Bilbo smiled. “Tell me about them.” He reached up, brushing hair from Thorin’s forehead. He looked tired, but brightened when Bilbo asked about Fíli and Kíli.
“Fíli’s name is Jack here,” he said. “He’s nine. Kíli’s Harry, and is five,” From the way he talked, Bilbo could tell how much he loved them. “I’ve raised them since they were only wee little things, when my sister and her husband died of typhus. They’re wonderful boys, though they haven’t changed much since you last saw them. I wish you could see them now, though.”
“Are they the reason you didn’t enlist?” Bilbo asked.
“I wanted to,” Thorin said, picking at the lint covering his pants. “I felt like a coward... but I put my nephews first. I haven’t got any family in Canada, and I couldn’t well send them back to Ireland. I knew that if I went overseas to fight in the war, I’d have to put them in a home or an orphanage, and that was the last thing I wanted to do.”
“Where are they now?”
“A children’s home in Truro,” answered Thorin.
Bilbo frowned. “Could you not be exempted from service?” he asked. “You are unmarried, yes, but your nephews are your dependents. You’re their only caregiver. Why would they still force you to serve?”
“I did apply for an exemption, but it was denied. Likely due to the Conscription Crisis. Hundreds of men have applied for exemptions, but obviously they can’t all be granted.” Thorin shrugged. “It’s bullshit, but I have to make do.” He sounded miserable, and Bilbo felt terrible for bringing it up.
“I’m sorry,” he apologized. “I didn’t mean to upset you.”
Thorin shook his head. “No, no, it’s alright. I don’t blame you for asking.”
They were both silent for a while, the only sounds filling the room the crackling of the fire, and the ticking of the clock on the mantle. Bilbo sighed, closing his eyes. “Will you tell me about Ireland?” he asked.
Thorin smiled. “Of course.”
Bilbo listened as Thorin talked about Ireland and the life he had there. He told stories about his parents and siblings, and about his childhood in the countryside of County Galway. He talked nostalgically of the rolling green hills and springs near his home, and of the fairy stories his grandmother would tell him when he was a child.
“We were poor, but happy,” he said. “I would’ve stayed and raised Fíli and Kíli there, but I just couldn’t. I wasn’t making enough money. So I sold my father’s farm, and used the earnings to start a new life here.”
Bilbo took Thorin’s hand in his own, pressing a kiss to his knuckles. “I’m glad you came to Canada,” he murmured. “I don’t know how I would’ve met you otherwise.”
“We would’ve found a way,” Thorin said with a smile.
“Will you stay tonight?” asked Bilbo.
Thorin nodded, his arms around Bilbo’s waist. “I was hoping you would ask me,” he muttered.
Bilbo laughed, and Thorin launched into a story about a mangy old mutt he and his siblings found when they were children, and how they had begged their parents to let them keep it.
◊◊◊
Bilbo awoke with a gasp. His breathing was heavy, and he could feel sweat beading on his forehead. It wasn’t unusual for him to wake up like this, terrified from some nightmare he could only partly remember. This one had been no different than the others—a replay of memories, bits and pieces of battles stitched together in his mind to create a horrifying collage.
He sat up, running a clammy hand over his face. The darkness surrounding him felt oppressive and suffocating, but he resisted the urge to turn on the light; Thorin lay beside him, still sound asleep. Bilbo could hear his calm, steady breathing, at odds with his own. He sighed, tossing off the blanket and throwing his feet over the edge of the bed.
His back was aching and he stretched. He was only twenty-two, but he already felt like an old man—he couldn’t walk without a cane, and his back was constantly causing problems. But he was lucky, he’d been told; he could walk, his face hadn’t been damaged beyond recognition, he was alive. The nightmares would go away eventually; things would go back to normal soon enough; he just had to put what happened over there out of his mind.
Carefully, Bilbo began rummaging through the nightstand drawer, pulling out a pack of cigarettes and a box of matches. Holding the cigarette between his teeth, he lit it, quickly shaking out the match. Beside him, Thorin stirred. He let out a quiet sigh, and Bilbo turned to look at him. The end of his cigarette burned orange as he sucked in a breath of smoke.
“Bilbo?” Thorin’s voice was hoarse with sleep as he lifted himself up onto his elbows. Bilbo could just barely make out his outline in the dark room.
He let a stream of smoke escape from between his lips. “Sorry I woke you,” he said.
“Are you alright?” asked Thorin.
Bilbo shrugged, though of course Thorin couldn’t see him. “I’ll be fine.”
“What happened?”
Bilbo fumbled around on the nightstand until he found an ashtray. He tapped the cigarette on the edge of it before bringing it back to his lips. “Just a nightmare,” he said, sniffing.
Thorin sat up and leaned over to the nightstand. Bilbo could hear him fiddling with the gas lamp and the pack of matches, until he managed to light the lamp. The room filled with a soft orange glow as Thorin carefully slid the glass cover back into place. He climbed up onto his knees behind Bilbo, wrapping his arms around Bilbo’s torso.
“Was it about the war?” Thorin whispered.
Bilbo nodded, leaning back into Thorin’s chest.
“Do you want to talk about it?”
Bilbo shook his head. “No... It was no different than any of the other nightmares I have.”
Thorin nodded and brushed his lips up against Bilbo’s shoulder blade. “Do you want me to do anything?” His voice was soft, and Bilbo could feel his chest vibrating as he spoke. Bilbo let his eyes slip shut, suddenly overcome with exhaustion. He reached over, smushing his half-finished cigarette into the ash tray.
“Just talk. Tell me one of your grandmother’s stories.”
Thorin took in a deep breath, and let it out slowly. “I’ll see if I can remember one...” He was silent for a moment, and moved to sit with his back against the headboard, pulling Bilbo with him. Bilbo rested with his head on Thorin’s chest, and listened as he told the story of Tuan mac Cairill, a man who was one of the first settlers of Ireland and passed through many lives as various animals.
He fell asleep with the rhythm of Thorin’s heartbeat, and the whisper of his voice in his ears.
◊◊◊
Thorin woke up just after dawn. He could see the faintest haze of light peeking in around the edges of the blackout curtains, and as he stretched he could hear the clock out in Bilbo’s living room chime. Beside him, Bilbo mumbled something incomprehensible and buried his face into the pillow. Thorin smiled, and leaned over to place a soft kiss on the side of his head.
Quietly, he threw back the blankets and climbed out of bed. He gathered up his uniform, folded neatly on top of the dresser, and headed to the bathroom to change so he wouldn’t wake Bilbo. It was likely sometime after six, and Thorin frowned as he pulled on his pants and buttoned up his shirt. While it certainly wasn’t... unusual for a soldier in Halifax waiting to be shipped overseas to spend the night away from the barracks, he was always expected back early next morning.
Of course, night-time escapades weren’t actually allowed, but no one seemed to care either way. After all, in just a few months these men would be risking their lives on a hellish battlefield; let them have their small bit of fun. Thorin just hoped nobody would ask him too many questions.
He considered waking Bilbo to say goodbye before he left, but decided to let him sleep. He wrote a short note instead, explaining that he would be stopping by later that afternoon, and left it on the kitchen table. His coat was hanging on a hook by the door, and he grabbed it as he stepped outside onto the front step.
The morning air was cold, and Thorin quickly put on his coat and buttoned it up. Frost covered the grass and the roofs of the houses. It was early December, but there had yet to be any lasting snow, as any that did fall melted within a day or two.
The neighbourhood was quiet as Thorin walked down the street, his hands shoved into his coat pockets. He could just barely see a sliver of the harbour, already bustling with activity despite the early hour. From dusk until dawn, the submarine nets that blocked the mouth of the harbour remained shut. With the sun rising, many waiting ships were now able to enter and leave.
On Young Street, only a few blocks from Bilbo’s house, Thorin caught an early trolley. It was mainly filled with people from the nearby area who worked near the harbour front or in the South End. He sat near the back, watching out the window as the North End blended into southern Halifax. His was one of the last stops, and it was nearly 7:30 when he got off on Spring Garden Road, in front of the Public Gardens.
He walked the rest of the way to his barracks. The streets slowly became busier, with people heading to work and the shops opening up. As the sun rose higher, the sky turned bright blue, and not a cloud could be seen. Thorin let out a sigh, the fog of his breath rising to mingle with the air.
◊◊◊
Bilbo sat at his kitchen table, a mug of lukewarm tea and a piece of dry bread in front of him. He was slowly reading through that day’s newspaper, spread out across the surface of the small table. He’d woken up about thirty minutes ago to find Thorin gone, his clothes missing from on top of the dresser. A hastily written note had been left on the kitchen table, with Thorin promising that he would be back later that day.
Bilbo reached into the pocket of his sweater, where he had stored the note. There was a conflicting tide of emotions within him—he was happy to be with Thorin again, but at the same time he felt a heavy sense of dread. In only one day, Thorin would be leaving Halifax and sailing across the Atlantic to Europe, where he would join the brutal fighting.
He had promised Bilbo he would write whenever he had the chance. Bilbo knew, in the back of his mind, that Thorin would die in the war. He didn’t know how or when exactly, but he was certain it was going to happen—there was no reason for him to believe otherwise. Part of him worried about how he would find out when Thorin died. His next of kin was a cousin in Ireland, and there was no doubt that Fíli and Kíli would find out, likely through a telegram to their caretaker. But there was no reason for anyone to notify Bilbo.
Every weekend the newspaper posted a Casualty List, with a dozen different categories: Killed in Action, Wounded Severely in Action, Wounded Slightly, Reported Wounded, Died of Wounds, Gas Poisoning, Gas Poison Severe, Gassed and Wounded, Killed, Missing. The list could sometimes go on for pages, with more names that Bilbo recognized than he could count on two hands. Thorin, however, wouldn’t be included on that list: He was from Truro, and the newspaper only listed those who came from Halifax.
The other part of Bilbo reasoned that it didn’t matter if he found out when Thorin died or not. If the letters ever stopped, that would likely be a good indication; that was all he would need.
Sighing, Bilbo lifted his mug to his lips, the tea even colder now than it was before. He still drank it, though, not being one to waste tea, no matter how cold. It could be a difficult thing to get a hold of, what with the war rations. Often it was more expensive than he could afford.
Outside, he heard the tell-tale sounds of Forrester’s milk cart coming up the street. He stood, grabbing his cane from where it was leaning against the table, and fetched the near-empty milk jug from the icebox. He quickly threw on a jacket before stepping outside, just as Forrester came to a stop in front of his house.
“Morning, Duncan,” the old man greeted, a warm smile on his weathered face.
“How are you?” Bilbo asked, as Forrester hopped down from the driver’s seat and took the jug from Bilbo.
“Oh, I’m just fine, thanks.” Forrester wandered around to the back of the wagon, holding the jug under the spout coming off one of the cans. “I’ve got some eggs and cream this morning, if you’re interested.”
Bilbo shook his head. “No, that’s alright. Just milk is fine.”
“Of course.” Forrester wandered back to where Bilbo was standing, the milk jug now full. “Would you like me to take this inside for you?” he asked, glancing down at Bilbo’s cane.
“No, I’m alright,” said Bilbo, shaking his head again. “Thank you, though.”
Forrester gave another smile as he handed the milk jug over to Bilbo. “I’ll see you on Saturday, then, Duncan.”
“I wouldn’t miss it.”
As Forrester climbed back up into the driver’s seat and trundled off down the street, Bilbo returned inside and replaced the jug in the icebox with little difficulty. He had only just sat down, however, when a few minutes later a knock came at his door. He stood and made his way back to the front door, opening it to find his neighbour’s thirteen-year-old daughter, Rose Stainthorpe, standing on his front step.
“Mr. Thornton!” she cried, her eyes wide. “Have you seen the ship? In the harbour?”
Bilbo frowned. “Rose, what do you mean?” he asked. “There are quite a few ships in the harbour.”
“No! Mr. Thornton, this one’s on fire!” She threw her arms up into the air, gesticulating wildly. “Come see!”
Bilbo’s frown deepened as he stepped outside. There were dozens of people out on the street or leaning out their front doors and windows, all looking in the direction of the harbour. Just as Rose said, there was a burning ship floating on the water, near the Dartmouth side.
“How long has it been burning?” asked Bilbo, looking from the flaming ship to Rose.
“Just a minute or two. Mum saw it collide with another ship when she outside buying eggs from Mr. Forrester. That’s when it caught fire.”
“Jesus,” Bilbo murmured. He hoped nobody was hurt—the fire was quickly burning out of control, with plumes of steam and smoke shooting up into the sky. Some of the flames were blue, and as he watched the entire ship became engulfed in fire.
“Rose!”
They both turned to see Rose’s mother leaning out her front door, glaring at her daughter. “What are you doing bothering Mr. Thornton?” she demanded. “Get over here!”
Rose smiled sheepishly at Bilbo. “Sorry, Mr. Thornton,” she apologized. “Coming, Mum!”
Bilbo chuckled as Rose ran back towards her house. He remained outside for a few minutes more, watching the blazing ship; blue and orange flames were leaping into the air, and the black smoke seemed to reach miles into the sky. He could see people massing together on the harbour front, and there was a group on the roof of the Acadia Sugar Refinery. People were running down the street, heading to the harbour in the hopes of a better view.
Eventually, the cold became too much for Bilbo and his leg started aching, so he returned back inside. He stood at the window for a while more, watching as the burning ship drifted closer and closer to the Halifax side of the harbour. There were still dozens of people outside, watching with rapt attention or rushing towards the harbour. Bilbo frowned and stepped away from the window. He wandered into the living room, sitting down on the bench in front of an old upright piano. The fire would no doubt be sorted out quickly; firefighters had likely already been sent to take care of it.
The piano was one of the nicest things he owned, despite its age. His grandfather had bought it decades ago for Bilbo’s grandmother, who had taught Bilbo to play when he was young. After she died, the piano went to his mother, who had sent Bilbo for lessons with a real teacher. When his father died, one of Bilbo’s cousins had taken the piano, but after Bilbo returned from the war she’d given it back to him.
He smiled slightly as he lifted the cover, his fingers brushing across the ivory keys. He hadn’t played at all while away in Europe, and so he had been out of practice when he came back home. He’d been trying to get in the habit of practicing every day. Reaching up, he opened the folder sitting on top of the piano and pulled out the sheet music to Waltzing Matilda. It was a song his mother had often played when he was younger; Bilbo remembered sitting on the bench beside her while she played the piano and his father sang. His mother had scribbled notes on the music, and her writing could still be seen on the paper, faded only slightly.
Bilbo had learnt to play this song perfectly a long time ago, and could easily play it without the sheet music, but he liked to pull it out sometimes and see his mother’s little notes; it was as if a piece of her still lived amongst the notes and lyrics of Waltzing Matilda.
Outside, someone was yelling. He looked towards the window to see a group of children run past, their faces excited. He turned his attention back to the piano. Placing his fingers on the keys, he pressed down, and the first chord of Waltzing Matilda sounded.
The room exploded. The windows shattered and the walls collapsed, pieces of wood and plaster and glass flying everywhere. Bilbo was thrown from the piano bench as the upper floor came crashing down and he was buried beneath the piano. He died instantly.
The explosion was over in seconds. As the dust settled, an eerie silence fell across Halifax.
◊◊◊
Thorin was at the foot Citadel Hill when the explosion happened.
He was with a few other soldiers, walking along the docks when the two ships collided and one caught fire. It was a rather mesmerizing spectacle, with flames that seemed to reach the clouds and a great column of dark smoke. Balls of fire were jumping from the ship into the smoke, where they would pop without a sound.
“Would you look at that!” one of the soldiers, a man named Horne, proclaimed.
“What ship is that?” Thorin asked. It was a couple of kilometres further up the harbour from where they stood, in the Narrows, so all he could really see were the flames and the smoke.
“Not sure,” replied one of the other men, Winslow, “but she sure is burning, isn’t she?”
“Quite a bit, yeah,” Horne murmured.
They continued along the waterfront, their eyes fixed on the ship. People were gathering around them, leaning over the railings in an attempt to see better. Cars and wagons were stopping in the streets, and there were people pouring out of nearby buildings or leaning out of windows. Thorin even saw a group of men on the roof of a building.
They turned left after a while and began heading towards Citadel Hill, hoping that they might have a better view from up high. They could still see the flames and smoke as they walked up the street away from the harbour, and Thorin kept turning to look back at it. The streets were full of people, all pointing and looking at the fire.
All of a sudden, the flames stopped. Thorin turned to see a white flash shoot up into the sky, followed by a blast of wind so strong it nearly knocked him off his feet. Every window around him shattered, the pieces of glass flying everywhere. Though in reality it lasted only a few seconds, to Thorin it felt like eternity until the glass settled and the wind stopped.
There was a heartbeat of silence. No one moved.
Then someone screamed, and that piercing noise broke through the shock. Thorin sucked in a deep breath of air, and it took a moment for him to realize what had happened.
“It’s the Germans!” a woman cried, her hands in her hair. There was a piece of glass stuck in her cheek. “The Germans have attacked us!”
Thorin’s brows furrowed together. “It wasn’t the Germans,” he said. “It was the ship—the burning ship. It exploded.”
“Why would a ship explode?” the woman asked, obviously distraught.
“He’s right,” a man said, looking from the woman to Thorin. “It was the Mont-Blanc, a munitions ship from France. It’s a wonder the entire city isn’t in ruins.”
The woman frowned, and wandered off, muttering something about needing to find her family.
All around Thorin was panic. Most people seemed unhurt, but there were a few with cuts and scrapes from flying debris. He saw one woman lying on the ground, her eyes full of glass.
“We need to report back to the barracks,” said Horne.
“We can’t just leave these people,” Thorin argued, motioning to the injured woman. “We need to help them.”
“I understand what you’re saying, Taggart,” Winslow said, “but I have a feeling that there are more people elsewhere in the city that need our help. We were quite a ways away from the ship, but think of the people in the North End. No doubt the entire neighbourhood’s been levelled.”
It seemed as if the ground suddenly dropped out from under Thorin’s feet. He froze, and felt himself go pale. Bilbo—he needed to make sure Bilbo was alright. His house was in the North End; you could see the Narrows from his front window, less than a kilometre away.
“I need to go,” he said. He was aware of people crying and yelling around him, but it was as if there was cloth over his ears, muffling everything he heard. All he could think of was that he needed to find Bilbo and make sure he was safe.
“What do you mean?” asked Winslow. “We have to go back to the barracks.”
Thorin shook his head. “No, no, I have to go find someone. I need to make sure they’re alright.”
Horne frowned, his eyebrows drawing together. “Who are you talking about, Taggart?”
“It doesn’t matter. Just... go back to the barracks without me. I’ll be fine.” Thorin turned and started walking away, weaving his way through the crowded street.
“What? Taggart! Taggart!”
Thorin ignored Winslow’s calls, until he and Horne had vanished into the chaos behind him and their voices were drowned out by everyone else’s. He quickened his pace, turning onto another street that headed north. Though it was only minutes after the explosion, those who were uninjured had already jumped into action. He passed by a fish truck, pulled over onto the side of the road while a man with a face full of glass was helped into the back. A woman stood outside a restaurant, sweeping glass from the sidewalk.
A fire truck raced by, going in the same direction as Thorin. All the trolleys were down, so he would have to travel to Richmond on foot; he was nearly running by the time he reached the northern end of Citadel Hill.
When he reached Cunard Street—ten or twenty or thirty minutes after the explosion, he couldn’t tell—the damage became much more extensive. He could see smoke rising into the sky, only a few blocks away. Toppled power lines lay sparking across the street, and he passed a huge oak tree that had crashed through a house. A teenage boy ran past, his face streaked with tears; Thorin called out to him, but the boy kept running, until he disappeared around a corner.
The further north he went, the worse the devastation became. Bodies began appearing on the streets, and the injuries became more gruesome. People were being loaded up into cars and trucks and onto wagons; anything that could take them to the hospital. The air was filled with the sounds of people crying and screaming. Someone was yelling something about Wellington Barracks, the munitions magazine, being on fire, and that it was going to explode any minute. People began running, herded by soldiers and firefighters, but Thorin kept heading north.
He reached North Street, and stopped dead in his tracks. For a few blocks, there were houses with collapsed walls, some that were reduced to rubble, but then there was nothing—it was as if all of Richmond had been blown away, and all that remained were the power lines and piles of debris. He felt his heart jump to his throat, and he choked back a sob.
What little that was left of many of the houses was burning. There were bodies everywhere, covered in blood. A man was laying, impaled, on a wrought iron gate. Those who could were running around, calling names and sobbing that the end of the world had come. Those who couldn’t limped down the streets, dazed. A black, oily rain was falling from the sky, thick and sticky. It soaked through Thorin’s clothes and clung to his skin, but he barely noticed.
Somehow, he began walking again. He couldn’t remember what street Bilbo lived on, or where his house was. There were no more street signs, and no more landmarks of any kind—everything was gone.
“Bilbo!” he cried, and his voice sounded hoarse in his ears. He racked his brain, trying to think of where Bilbo lived. His house had definitely been further north, past the bridge, not far from the train tracks. Thorin quickened his pace. Bilbo had to be safe—he couldn’t be dead; he couldn’t be hurt. That wasn’t what was supposed to happen.
“You aren’t supposed to die now,” Thorin muttered. “Not like this.” He could see the tracks in the distance, his view unobstructed by any houses. He turned onto another street at random, and broke out into a run. “Bilbo!” he called again. “Bilbo!”
He could feel tears pricking at his eyes, and his chest was heaving. The air smelled of blood and smoke, but he kept going. He didn’t stop even when his lungs began burning, screaming at him to slow down. He knew he was becoming frantic. Nothing around him was familiar; he couldn’t remember if there had been a tree in front of Bilbo’s house, or how far he’d lived from the corner of the street.
Finally he stopped, leaning forward and bracing his hands against his thighs. His breath was coming in gasps, and as he breathed out they turned to sobs. Thorin crumpled to the ground, his knees digging into the cold asphalt. He buried his face in his hands as his sobs shook his body.
◊◊◊
The worst winter storm to hit in years blew into Halifax that night. Thorin barely slept, though he was exhausted, as the wind howled and rattled at the walls. He had spent the afternoon digging through the ruins, looking for survivours and for the dead. By noon the hospitals were overflowing with people, and a mortuary for the unidentifiable dead had been opened up in a school basement. Newspapers had already begun circulating lists of known survivours and victims. Thorin had checked every list he could get his hands on, looking for Bilbo’s name, with no success.
The storm was still raging the next morning, but Thorin and dozens of other soldiers were back in the devastated area soon after the sun had risen. Now, however, they were mainly looking for bodies—it was unlikely anyone would have survived the night, with the cold and the snow.
It was gruesome work, looking for bodies. Some were in a terrible state when they were found, crushed beneath the collapsed houses. Some were so badly crushed or burned that they were unidentifiable, and so they were sent to Chebucto Road Mortuary, along with any personal effects and a card that said where they had been found.
Thorin almost wished he was on a ship heading for Europe, like he was supposed to be; hundreds of soldiers ready to depart had been held back to help with the rescue work. He didn’t know when they would be leaving. No ships were allowed to enter the harbour, and few were allowed to leave. Halifax Harbour had grown quiet for the first time since the war began.
At noon, Thorin took a break from the digging and went to Chebucto Road Mortuary. Dozens and dozens of cloth-covered bodies were laid out in rows in the basement of Chebucto Road School, on Cunard Street. Each body had a number and a corresponding bag, holding all the items found with the body, a description of them, and where the body had been found. People were shuffling around the room, looking through the bags, hoping to find a friend or loved one.
It was highly likely that Thorin would find Bilbo here, amongst the dead too crushed or burned to be identified by their faces alone. He had yet to see any mention of him in any lists published by the newspapers, and it was possible that no one had yet come to the morgue looking for him. He had dozens of cousins, but most lived in the North End, and could be either dead themselves or injured and in the hospital.
Thorin frowned as he approached the table holding the bags and began sifting through them. Most of the items were generic—a necklace, a wedding ring, a watch, a pair of glasses. This one was found on Columbus Street, that one on Livingstone Back Lane, another on Prescott Street. After nearly half an hour of looking, he was beginning to think that maybe, just maybe, Bilbo wasn’t there—that maybe he was in a hospital, and no one had taken his name yet; that maybe he was alive. But then he opened one of the bags, and his heart sank.
Inside, was the note he’d written to Bilbo, only the previous morning. It was smudged and splattered with blood, but still legible. Thorin could make out his own name at the bottom of the page, along with Bilbo’s at the top. There was a watch in the bag, as well, scratched and with a cracked face. Two pieces of paper had been placed inside: one was where Bilbo had been found, and the other was a short note—Victim had prosthetic right foot.
Thorin dropped the slips of paper back into the bag and closed it back up, as if that could hide what was inside. He squeezed his eyes shut and took in a deep breath, trying to keep himself from crying. He didn’t know why he had let himself hope that Bilbo might not be dead. It was a foolish, stupid thing to wish for.
Biting down on his bottom lip, Thorin reached back into the bag and pulled out the note—the one he had written to Bilbo. Neither the body nor the personal effects found with it would be released to Thorin, as he wasn’t family, but he would at least take the note with him. Checking to make sure nobody was looking, he shoved it into his pocket.
While he couldn’t take possession of the body, Thorin could at least identify it. That way, if no one came to claim Bilbo, he would at least be buried with a name.
“What’s the number of the body?” the woman sitting at the desk asked, when Thorin went to identify Bilbo.
“103.” Thorin placed his hand in his coat pocket, his fingers curling around the note.
“And the name?”
“Duncan Thornton.”
The woman scribbled something down on a piece of paper. “Are you a family member?” she asked.
He shook his head. “A friend.”
“May I have your name?”
“Peter Taggart,” he replied. He almost felt as if he’d been cheated; he was the one who was supposed to die, not Bilbo. It seemed cruel, for a man to survive a brutal war only for him to die in his own home. “Will you be able to find his family and contact them?”
The woman sighed. “We’ll certainly try, Mr. Taggart,” she said. She sounded tired and worn down; Thorin supposed that working in a morgue would do that to a person. “I’m very sorry for your loss.”
He nodded, his grasp tightening around the note. “Thank you,” he murmured, turning and quickly leaving the mortuary.
Outside, the air was cold, and snow was still falling thickly. Grey clouds covered the sky, and from where he stood Thorin could see much of the devastated area. He let out a loud sigh, his breath escaping from his mouth in a plume of vapour. He sniffed, wiping at his eyes, which were welling with tears. There was no point in crying—before long he would see Bilbo again, hopefully in a time free of war and death.
Until then, there was work to be done.
