Actions

Work Header

The After Effects of Amortentia

Chapter 6

Summary:

Thorin says one specific story and Bilbo meets the Gamekeeper.

Chapter Text

The second Thorin had suggested Bilbo the private tutorials he knew it was a mistake. To favor a student was probably not approved of by other teachers. Yet before he had considered the consequences, he had already asked. Truly he was fond of Bilbo and saw that indeed he was horrible at the subject, and even though Bilbo had said these stuff were not going to be useful to him later on, the thought of him graduating without properly knowing how to defend himself made Thorin uneasy.

There was also his own selfish reason: he enjoyed being with Bilbo. There was something about the creature that he admired. Bilbo was a bright being with flushed cheeks and curls the color of gold. Even in the hardest struggle he’d stand up again and try. His eyes would always avoid his, but when he met them, he’d see them wide and honest, a shade of gray with blue that reminded Thorin of clouded skies. His laugh was something he could not get enough of. Bilbo intrigued him, and Thorin always felt better when he was with the student.

The hobbit himself was not helping the situation. Bilbo, who had first blushed at the smallest provocation and who shied away from Thorin’s touch, now goaded him. Personal space now meant nothing to him when practicing with Professor Oakenshield, urging casual brushing of fingers when passing books or parchment. He would not hesitate when asking Thorin to make a demonstration when Thorin gruffly knew he had no problem with the spell whatsoever.

“Show me,” he would croon, a confidence that did not reach his sheepish smile or reddening cheeks. And Thorin, as annoyed as he’d be, would consent.

What annoyed the dwarf were not the hobbit’s requests, or his acquired boldness, but Thorin’s own willingness to consent no matter what. He wondered once in disdain if he’d be willing to jump from the Astrology tower if Bilbo were to ask.

***

With every passing day, Thorin would miss the Blue Mountains more, something he thought he would never hear himself say. He missed his kin, the laughing younglings who would greet him and the elders he met in meetings. Of course he had his nephews as well as Bofur and Ori here, but he missed joking with Dwalin. He missed Bofur and Dwalin and Nori and Bifur. He missed all of them, under the foggy darkness that came with night, around a fire, remembering that kingdom the young were too small to even have memory of.

When Gandalf had came to ask him if he’d like to take the job as a Dark Arts teacher, it had seemed the wizard had been waiting for a right time to ask. Thorin in that moment had just succumbed to the soul-sucking routine of being a human’s silversmith, they turning somehow such a beautiful art to a nightmare of petty jewelry designing. He had just accepted the strenuous work of his days instead of the calm enlightening ones under his palace. He had learned to pretend his pain gone in order to help his people move forward. And despite all this, he had never felt so useless to his people than in there. They deserved so much more.

So when being offered a truly honorable job, with his kin’s blessing he went off. And now not two months had passed and Thorin a homesickness that would only be compared to when he lost Erebor.

Only that which would help was the halfling with his eagerness with stories of his people.

In their first lesson, Bilbo had lingered on when he’d clearly been dismissed and had mumbled “Thorin” with such gentleness that even a dragon could not have said no.

And by the week Bilbo’s request would come to be a chant, a ritual that came after the tutorial. “Tell me a story,” he would simply say, and Thorin, no matter his mood, would comply. When he would finish, Thorin would cheekily ask him to reciprocate and tell him a story back, and Bilbo would happily do it. And so their little ritual began.

Sometimes the stories would be brief, and some nights they would last for hours, swapping anecdotes and personal moments and laughs and deep riddles.

And one night, one particular night, only one story was told.

***

It had not been a good day.

After supervising the sixth year Apparition practice, teaching four classes, and attending three meetings, Thorin had already wanted nothing more than to curl up in his room. As if that was not enough, an owl swooped behind him, nipping his ear too strongly with a letter apparently too urgent for it to come for him on the morning.

His sister Dis was sick.

Thorin took a sharp breath, crumbling the paper unconsciously under his fingers. His only sister, and Thorin was hundred miles away, unable to do anything about it.

He felt so useless, collapsing into his chair in dismay.

Bilbo had entered and seeing the dwarf’s face he immediately knew it was not a day to mess around. He frowned, confused and concerned, approaching and sitting next to his desk quietly, choosing only to review from the book today. Almost all the lesson was of Thorin speaking in a strained tone he probably did not even notice.

The moment the lesson had ended, Bilbo let his hand hover over Thorin’s only to retrieve it and mutter softly, “Tell me a story?” It was not a demand, but a tentative question.

Thorin wanted to say no. Not because of his day, but for the thoughts his day had brought. Dark thoughts of guilt and regret and homesickness. He was genuinely in no mood and he did not wish to show it.

But again Thorin had fallen prey to Bilbo’s pleading eyes, and so, weary and demure, the dwarf went on to tell him a story. And what slipped through his tongue came with natural ease, speaking the story with the most importance in his life.

Thorin cleared his throat, looking up at the past as Bilbo stayed silent, waiting.

The line of Durin, eldest of the Seven, survived the harsh ages, folk who in their merriment had grown to prosper on to rich lands to be known as a kingdom in a lonely mountain.

The kingdom was ran by a king who was withering with age yet as strong as iron, blessed with a secure lineage with both son and grandson.

The grandson was but a boy, burdened despite his youth with the well-being of his people, with his destiny to be king. But he loved his people, and even then he would have done anything for them. His people, they were happy in their prosperity, therefore so was he.

For the slightest second Thorin smiled, only for it to disappear as he went on.

But their happiness did not last. The great king acquired a thirst for gold, and his greed…was his destruction. In a day not more extraordinary than another, the king’s grandson could not help to notice the blood red dot on the evening sky and had only thought it the sun, but as it grew bigger and bigger and the sky grew a fading scarlet, he knew something was wrong. Wretched screams filled the air; all was lost to chaos in moments. The king’s grandson did not get to see his charms teacher that day.

Everyone had forgotten the prince amidst the debris and ruckus. A nurse, who had taken care of him when a toddler, stumbled upon him when passing the royal doors. She found him banging the royal doors, trying to get out and help, sobbing broken incantations, wand on hand, to get it open. After being reunited with his brother and sister, all was a blur of cacophony and soot. His last memory of his home is seeing crumbling to the ground when leaving forever.

Time did not start to pity the king’s grandson. The war took his grandfather, the king, and his brother for his own. Pressure shoved his father to insanity, leaving to never be seen again. Even his own sister left him in a way, who married and had children, leaving the king’s grandson—now king—to govern alone.

But to govern what? There was no place to rule anymore. The king with no kingdom, now older and wiser, tried his best to lead his people to prosperity like before, but for the love of Mahal, nothing he ever did ever brought them close to bringing them back home.

After years of pleading, of wandering with no direction, they found a land to settle. He gave them a place to live, but not a home. The king…had failed them.

The story ended and Bilbo was out of words. He did not know what to say. He knew Thorin’s words to be heavier in meaning that he let on, and he suspected the story was of a great significance to the dwarf, even more than the usual can’t-tell-you-dwarf-stories-because-they-are-not-to-be-revealed-to-not-dwarf-creatures matter, and he simply did not know what to say.

Thorin did not expect him to, and frankly he had not intended to tell that story anyways. So with surprise he snapped his head up as the hobbit gently spoke weighed words.

“I did not know this king.” He reached to drape his hand on Thorin’s larger one. “But I am sure of one thing about him.” Bilbo looked at Thorin firmly through his eyelashes. “And that is he did not fail his people. He could not have. He loved his people too much.”

Thorin blinked, then could not help to grin. What a delightful liar this hobbit was.

Self-consciousness bloomed again in the halfling, noticing his hand still over Thorin’s and jerking away immediately. He started babbling, “Well I should go, it is getting dark. I have to wake up early tomorrow for class. Actually no, tomorrow’s Saturday. Silly me.” He laughed nervously.

Professor Oakenshield smiled warmly. “You can go now, Mr. Baggins.”

Bilbo nodded, already standing and walking away when he hesitated, biting his lower lip. He turned around.

“Goodnight, Thorin.”

At the sound of his name Thorin’s lips parted in shock, but Bilbo had already closed the door behind him before he could have even thought to respond.

***

Bilbo moaned miserably, hiding his face under his hands. What had he been thinking, acting like that? Every time he tried to calm down his mind would bring up the image of Thorin frozen and his own horror immobilized him again, wanting to throw himself off the Gryffindor tower. Had he ruined everything? Would Thorin have seen through him then, so obvious and longing? Would he call off the tutorials?

At the thought Bilbo could not help but to groan into his pillow, not wanting anything else but to be swallowed by the ground.

Hamfast and Paladin found him in this state, banging his head on the wall. Hamfast raised his eyebrow slowly and Paladin sighed, carefully placing his bag and books on his bed before walking towards Bilbo and firmly pushing him away from more harm.

“So how was the lesson?” Paladin chirped.

“Oh shut up.”

“Sounds like a treat.”

“Leave him alone Paladin.”

Paladin huffed, but thankfully let it go. At least, until next morning at breakfast, when Bilbo had been ignoring his omelet and tea completely as he hid between his crossed arms. “Want to talk about it?”

“Not in the slightest,” came Bilbo’s pained voice, muffled by his arms.

“Right,” said Paladin. “Changing the subject completely then, when are you coming with us to meet Bard?”

Apparently Hamfast and Paladin did not have such an appalling detention either. The Gamekeeper had believed the two along with Fili and Kili would be alarmed simply by walking through the woods, yet he had not been aware of one single and the greatest flaw: the two brothers.

Fili and Kili knew the forest more than any other student ever had, even recognizing what places to keep untouched. The two masters of mischief had been Radagast’s living nightmare, some claiming they had been the last straw that pushed the poor wizard to retire. Bard had not yet been warned of the two brothers. Fili and Kili were conversing happily with some centaurs by the first quarter of an hour. Bard, instead of being disconcerted or outraged, had grinned in his surprise. The five had to leave after that when they met other less friendly creatures as Fili and Kili had persuaded the gamekeeper to let them give him “a tour of their forest.”

“Apart from almost having our throats ripped out, it was ever so pleasant,” Hamfast had deadpanned.

“So dramatic,” Paladin had sighed.

Long story short, the five had befriended Bard and Paladin and Hamfast were keen on Bilbo meeting him. Paladin would simply not let it go.

“Fine,” Bilbo finally grumbled sitting up reluctantly. “When? Tomorrow?”

“Can’t,” said Paladin. “I have Quidditch practice today and tomorrow, then homework.”

“Monday?”

“I rather not. We are finishing that Potions project that day and then we promised Beorn we’d help with those mandrakes.”

“Well I can’t do it Tuesday!” Bilbo spluttered. “I have—“

“—tutorials,” Hamfast and Paladin droned for him. Paladin rolled his eyes. “Bilbo, I get you are pants on Defense Against the Dark Art class, but you can’t spend half your time on tutorials simply because you want very much that Professor Oakenshield would—“

“Fili and Kili,” Hamfast hissed.

“—educate you more on such wonderful subject,” Paladin finished, looking up to the two standing brothers. “Hullo.”

“Hullo,” both said cheerfully. “We are going to go bother the human gamekeeper for a while. Do guys want to join us?”

“As tempting as that sounds,” Paladin said. “I can’t. We are going Tuesday instead.”

“Oh, and you were not going to invite us, hobbits?” Kili accused.

“You are invited, but you have plans already,” Hamfast snipped.

“What?”

“Detention.”

Fili and Kili blinked. “Oooh, right.”

“So what about it, Bilbo?” Hamfast looked at Bilbo pointedly. “You are falling behind classes too. It would do you good to skip a tutorial or two.”

Bilbo sat up, dully responding. “Fine, but I first have to talk to Professor Oakenshield and I don’t really—“

“Oh don’t worry about that, here he comes!” Fili suddenly said. He waved his hand wildly, yelling, “Uncle! Uncle!”

Bilbo gasped, instinctively dropping to the ground. Under the table he saw Thorin’s unmistakable boots before Hamfast grabbed his collar and yanked him up.

Bilbo squeaked, squirming as he faced the dwarf.

All except Thorin glared at him, making Bilbo want to dive down the table again. Fili cleared his throat. “Bilbo wanted to ask you something.”

Thanks, Fili. Bilbo spluttered, “Yea I, er, I wanted to see if it was okay with you Professor Oakenshield if—because if it’s not then I understand—“

“I feel like we had settled on you calling me Thorin,” Professor Oakenshield interjected, amused.

Bilbo blinked, stunned. “I-okay well—“

“Bilbo wanted to see if it was alright with you if he could take a week off tutorials,” said Paladin.

All turned to Paladin, Bilbo glowering at him furiously.

“Is this true, Mister Baggins?”

Bilbo continued to glare at Paladin, who looked coolly back. Bilbo turned to Thorin. “I-yes,” Bilbo said, adding. “And if I am to call you Thorin, you might as well call me Bilbo.” Thorin’s eyes grew slightly wider, both holding a lingering gaze for a long, silent moment.

Fili’s mouth dropped open and Kili stared. Thorin stood up straighter. “Very well then, as you wish.” His voice was normal, but his mouth, which just a moment held a delighted smirk, now tugged down at the corners in an unmistakable frown. Bilbo (or everyone else for that matter) could not help to notice this, but Bilbo blinked and it was gone. “I do not see why not. I’ll see you and Mister Took on Monday then. And you two,” he added to Fili and Kili, looking at them gravely. “How is your mother?”

“Mmm? Oh, mother is fine. She’ll be up and about in a week,” Fili responded, nodding kindly.

Relief flickered on Thorin’s face. “Good. Farewell then.” He turned around, walking out of the hall.

Fili and Kili watched as their uncle left, bewildered. When he was gone, both turned to look at Bilbo, who had also been seeing Thorin leave too. He was also frowning unhappily, pushing his untouched food away from him, muttering, “I’m not hungry” and leaving too.

Fili and Kili were completely flustered. After the most awkward moment of silence Kili blurted out towards Paladin and Hamfast, “Er, did we miss something?”

***

The three had settled on meeting in the Gamekeeper’s hut. If they were to meet before, it would intervene with Hamfast’s Herbology club and Bilbo squishing in some more time on finishing homework he had previously neglected. Hamfast had told Bilbo that they would meet at noon sharp. Bilbo came half an hour after that just to avoid the uncomfortable event of him being the first to arrive.

Of course when Bilbo had gone on to the Gamekeeper’s house neither Hamfast nor Paladin were there. If both had agreed to punish Bilbo’s neglect on them by this or they simply had come before, Bilbo did not know.

He knocked on the door of the shabby hut, waiting anxiously for Paladin or Hamfast to answer, but instead the Gamekeeper, Bard Bowman, opened the door abruptly. He did not seem quite surprised at Bilbo’s appearance.

“Ah, Bilbo Baggins, am I right?” He smiled pleasantly. “Mister Took told me you would come, along with Mister Gamgee.” He looked around, frowning. “Yet I see they are not with you.”

“We were meant to meet here, er.” What was he to do now? “I can just come back later if—“

“Come in,” Bard said, ignoring his request. He went inside himself, letting Bilbo step nervously inside.

The hut was not at all big, a humble, crowded thing yet comfortable in every way. There was a bow hanging next to the door which Bilbo almost hit. All the walls were draped with rags that had stories and gorgeous patterns weaved into them. The hut was not at all ordered, but not dirty either. Visibly next to the largest couch there was a picture of two girls, most probably related and smiling, and an older boy, who probably was the Gamekeeper when younger.

“Are those your sisters?” Bilbo curiously asked before having time to shy away from the question.

Bard looked up distractedly, his eyes falling on the picture. “No, those are my children.” Bilbo raised his eyebrows. Bard appeared back with two steaming teacups. “Tea?’

Automatically Bilbo wanted to say no, but tea sounded like a good excuse to not be talking and therefore not be accompanied in awkward silence, so he said yes. Bard seemed calm and did not understand Bilbo’s constant nervous shuffling. To stop Bilbo sat down.

“I understand you are a friend of Bofur too?”

“I am,” Bilbo said. “I know him since I was in first year. We both had Potions class. It was also our first class so you can imagine the first day, entering that eerie classroom with the mysterious fumes coming from cauldrons. Bofur and I sort of helped each other survive in there.”

“So you are good in Potions then?”

“Not at all,” Bilbo laughed. “The first day I set my cauldron on fire.” Bard joined him in laughter.

“I am guessing Professor Thranduil put you in detention?” Bard said after the laughter ended.

“Oh no! He put me in detention the second time, when I set the classroom on fire.” Both laughed. When the laughter died, Bilbo felt like he had to leave something clear. “Professor Thranduil is not that bad, you know.”

“Oh I know”, Bard said casually, serving the tea.

Bilbo stared at Bard. “I thought you were not fond of him.”

Bard grinned. “You are mistaken. I believe you mean to say it is Professor Thranduil who is not fond of me.”

“I have to say I quite do not know why he holds such an attitude towards you,” Bilbo wondered aloud.

Bard did not answer, but proceeded on giving Bilbo a mug of tea, who gratefully took it. It was beginning to get chilly even inside the hut.

“Hamfast tells me you are fond of gardening.” Bilbo noticed Bard changing the subject.

“You could say that.” Bilbo thought the word fond was being moderate, yet he did not feel on correcting the Gamekeeper.

“What do you think of my garden, then?”

Bilbo looked up at Bard questioningly. “I did not see it.”

“It is in the back. You can see by the window, if you’d like.”

Curious, he leaned in and twisted his head in order to see through the window properly. Bilbo held his breath.

The garden was crowded with the most beautiful of flowers, camellias and violas and russell lupines. They clung to the fresh earth, right next to an even bigger garden of tomatoes, squash, lettuce, and colossal pumpkins that were probably being grown for Halloween. He squeaked in delight when he saw that Bard had his favorite flower, a rare crocus species that Bilbo thought only flowered in the Shire winter. Beorn himself did not have these.

“How did you get those?” Bilbo said, not taking his eyes of the flowers.

“I am afraid I cannot take much credit,” Bard said. “The former Gamekeeper cultivated most of the plants here.”

Bilbo still had his face pressed on the window, practically drooling at the sight of the breathtaking garden. Bilbo was starting to notice even more exciting fauna species he had only seen in textbooks.

“The garden has done well on keeping itself well in the summer, but winter’s approaching and I am afraid I am no expert in gardening. It would be a shame to leave it to the winter’s mercy. Would you mind—?”

In the blink of an eye Bilbo was leaving his cup of tea on the table and rushing outside. Bard could not help but chuckle, following him to the garden.

***

The clouds had ceased to cover the skies and the sun loomed over freely. The rain left the pleasant smell of humid earth hanging around the air, the horizon of the Forbidden Forest chirping with life as Thorin strolled by. He closed his eyes and breathed deeply, moments such as these being the closest for him to remember a land far away from here. Thorin failed to see the horror in the Forbidden Forest, to him simply mysterious and infinite; he had that in common with his nephews. The trees reigned tall and old, holding secrets the dwarf would never hear.

He would never tell his nephews that he wandered inside the forest, of course, for that would make them believe they could also roam freely. He rather not be yelled at by the new Gamekeeper for encouraging them.

Heading towards the castle, the hut of the human could be seen from afar, and Thorin gazed at it in thought. He had heard very little of the human, except for the ridiculous quarrels of him and Professor Thranduil the staff could not help but gossip about at dinner tables. Thorin sneered. If he had to deal with that elf as much that human, Thorin could not have helped getting in a quarrel or two either.

Thorin stopped, scowling as he noticed the human chatting happily outside his hut with a smaller being…a hobbit? Thorin walked carefully closer, keeping his distance yet close enough to identify whoever the creature was.

Indeed it was a hobbit, and Thorin could recognize those curls of honey anywhere. Bilbo was kneeling on the earth, inspecting tall flowers with evocating, lavender petals. He held the stems dearly, staying quiet in concentration for what felt like minutes, then taking the earth from the top of the roots and putting it between his fingers. He turned to Bard and said something, and the human barked a laugh. Thorin’s eyes narrowed, his throat suddenly turning dry.

Bilbo, eyes still on the flowers, spoke something Professor Oakenshield could not hear and beckoned Bard to see something, and the human did. In his eagerness to hear their conversation, Thorin must have been careless in being discreet, for the Gamekeeper had suddenly glanced towards him and grinned, calling towards him, “Professor Oakenshield!”

Thorin jumped, suddenly very aware of him having been staring. He walked towards them smoothly. He could see Bilbo’s shocked, pale face.

“Mister Bowman,” he paused a second before saying slowly, “Mister Baggins.”

A muscle in Bilbo’s jaw twitched. “Professor Oakenshield,” he shot back quietly.

“And what reason brings you here, Professor Oakenshield?”

Thorin raised his eyebrow. “It is a beautiful day. I felt compelled to walk through the woods,” he said shortly.

“Ah,” Bard nodded. “You share that with your nephews. They like wandering the Forbidden Forest. They enjoy it too much if you ask me.” Bard laughed.

Thorin did not laugh. “They are quite the troublemakers, I admit.” He turned to see the hobbit, who was looking at him blankly. “I cannot think where did they got it from.”

“I have an idea,” Bilbo could not help to mutter, yet it seemed the dwarf did not hear him.

“It seems that I should return. It was a pleasure seeing you, Mister Bowman.”

“Likewise,” Bard smiled, taking Thorin’s hand in farewell before Thorin left towards the castle.

Bilbo said nothing.

By the time Thorin had reached his classroom he felt sick, an uncomfortable feeling that did not let him concentrate in the slightest.

He gave up on trying to plan next month’s lesson and stared at the ceiling, musing over what was the cause of his uneasiness. Slowly, the image of Bilbo and Bard speaking over the flowers appeared dimly on his mind, and the image made his blood boil.

Thorin huffed in annoyance. Deep inside he knew his…whatever this was, to be illogical. It was simply ridiculous. Impossible, even. Bard would never dare. And the hobbit much less, for in the end Bilbo was…

Thorin grunted and pinched his nose. Bilbo was a student and he was a teacher. The thought crowded his mind, repeating itself cruelly over and over, and now it all made sense. Suddenly the dwarf’s throat went dry and he felt his insides withering. It became hard to breathe.

Another image appeared in his mind clearer than anything else, what he wanted so obvious now and yet so terrifying: the image of the garden and the flowers, of Bilbo explaining enthusiastically of the fauna and where they came from and how they were taken care of just as he had only moments ago, except that he was not with Bard, but Thorin. Thorin would listen carefully and attentively too, and when the halfling would finish explaining, the dwarf would answer by meeting Bilbo’s lips with his tenderly.

A fluttering panic grew inside Thorin enough to burst.