Chapter Text
CHAPTER THREE
THORIN
TRUE TO ULMO’S WORD, the river of Nienna trickled out from the sea and carved a winding path that was simple to follow through forest and flatland alike. Even to dwarrows, who tended to mistrust any body of water large enough to drown in, the river was a beautiful sight; it was clear as glass-crystal and tasted cool and sweet.
Its banks, lush with green grass and flowers, made for a very pleasant walkway. The distances felt shorter, and it seemed to Thorin that surely the calm swiftness of the river hastened their steps, for by the second day of travel their party had passed away from the coast entirely. They followed the river into a placid floodplain, their apparent progress bolstering their spirits mightily.
Or at least it was so for most of them. Fíli and Kíli, bringing up the rear of the procession, had been quarreling in hushed voices for the majority of the morning. Several times Thorin glanced back at the sound of a muffled exclamation only to receive two very innocent smiles. Dís seemed equally bewildered by the discord, giving Thorin a look of exasperation whenever he happened to catch her gaze.
Thorin, with a fatherly instinct born of many years of experience with their mischief, kept a wary eye on them as the company stopped for the noon meal and a brief rest. If he hadn’t, he might not have seen Kíli creep over to Frerin’s abandoned pack and pluck out Ulmo’s conch.
Later, Thorin could not recall precisely what Kíli had done, nor how exactly he had touched it. He knew only that before he could growl out a warning, the shell released a loud stream of shrieking wind under Kíli’s fingers.
“Kíli!” Frerin barked, but it was too late. Another burst of air rushed out of the conch, throwing Kíli onto his backside. Startled, he fumbled with the shell, and the whistling gave way to a howling tidal wave of wind as it broke apart in his hands.
Thorin’s feet were swept out from under him, and the next few moments were a terrifying blur of colour and sound. He regained awareness to a chorus of moans and curses and lifted his face from the dirt with a grunt.
“Is anyone hurt?” He took a quick count of the dwarrows sprawled around him. All were present and accounted for, thank Mahal, though understandably windblown and shaken.
“Where are we?” Fíli groaned, holding his head.
“Somewhere very far away from where we were a few moments ago, presumably,” Balin said wearily.
Dís reached for her sons, patted them down efficiently to search for injuries, and then twisted her youngest’s ear with a furious snarl. “Is your skull made of molten lead? What were you thinking?”
Kíli was very pale. “I’m sorry, Amad!” he shrilled. “I’m sorry. I only wanted to look at it.”
“Well, you did a mite more than that,” Bofur observed as he helped Ori out of the bramble-bush he’d landed in.
“I told you not to do it."
“A fine use of a Vala’s gift,” Óin grumped, plucking leaves from his mustache.
Kíli flushed miserably and cast a baleful look at Frerin. “I’m sorry, Uncle.”
Frerin sighed and rubbed his forehead. “Considering the things I’ve done in my day, lad, I suppose it would be a bit much for me to be angry with you. ”
“What is done is done,” Thorin said. “The more time we linger arguing about who is to blame, the longer we’re delayed. We must find the river again.”
There were murmurs of agreement, and the company collected themselves and their things as best they could. Frerin’s and Balin’s packs had been lost in the flurry along with Ori’s water-skin and Bifur’s spear, but otherwise their losses were small.
“At least we all landed in the same place,” Balin remarked, accepting a few provisions from Thorin to tuck into his coat. “Imagine all of us scattered across Aman! We were fortunate.”
On they marched, eyes straining for a sight of the river, but everywhere they looked the grass was parched and dry, the trees grey, the thin plants shriveled. It looked as though water had hardly ever touched this ground. That supposition, unluckily, proved inaccurate. As the afternoon wore on, it began to rain hard, sending clouds of choking dust into the air. The downfall was quick and icy cold and within minutes the company became a sodden mass of drenched, unhappy dwarrows.
“Keep up the pace!” Thorin called over the pounding water.
“We need to find shelter,” Óin returned, “or we’ll all catch our death of cold.”
Bofur laughed, and Óin shot him an indignant scowl. “Oh, you know what I mean!”
Balin quickened his steps to walk beside Thorin, shivering under his heavy cloak. “I hate to say it, laddie, but Óin makes a fair point. We cannot travel in this weather. With the rain in our faces, we’d be liable to walk right past the river without seeing it.”
Reluctantly, Thorin agreed. They had to go on for a half-mile more until they found a suitable spot: a cavern burrowed into the side of a hillock. Bofur crawled in with a lantern and axe to check for any occupants, and as soon as he hollered that all was clear, they climbed gratefully inside.
It was damp and cold but mercifully drier than the open air. The walls were slick with musty water, and the air smelled strongly of iron and rust. A small tunnel extended from the entrance chamber, stretching back into the dark, and the company filed out toward it. Bofur, perched at the opening to the tunnel with his lantern aloft, however, did not seem inclined to budge, and he startled when Thorin called to him.
He turned around, his eyes wide. “Pardon, pardon -- but maybe we ought to stay in the outer room right here, aye? I can’t say that I care for the feel of this place.”
“It isn’t large enough for all of us,” Dís said impatiently, wringing out her dripping braids. “And we wouldn’t be protected with an entrance so easily accessible. If we’re going to bed down here, we’d do better to find a more enclosed area.”
“I don’t care if we have to fight an army of goblins down there,” Fíli grunted, “if it means we can get dry.”
There were rumbles from the company, and into the tunnel they went, their weapons at the ready. Thorin paused next to Bofur, who lingered near the entrance with a pinched brow.
“What sort of feeling?” Thorin asked quietly.
“It sounds mighty silly, I know. But mining folk get a sense for these things, buried down in stone all day -- we learn good rock and bad rock, and which is which. And this is very bad rock.”
“We won’t linger,” Thorin assured him. “We’ll stay only until the rain stops and then be on our way. I will stand first guard myself.”
Bofur nodded and jammed his hat down a little tighter before following Thorin into the tunnel.
*****
Awareness came back to Thorin slowly. It took more than a moment for the dizziness to abate, and when he finally wrested open his eyes, it was to find himself alone, staring up at the high, vaulted ceiling of Erebor’s great treasury room.
“Fíli, Kíli!” he cried, sitting up and twisting round in alarm. “Balin? Dís!” But no voice answered, no sound but the echoes of his own shouts filtered back to him. He cautiously rolled onto his knees, relieved to find his sword still sheathed snugly in his belt, and surveyed the chamber.
No, his eyes had not led him false -- this was Erebor, down to the faded gilt-paint upon the stone columns. Bewildered, he came to his feet and took a few steps, loose trinkets shifting under his boots, before coming to a tense halt. A massive pile of white-bleached bones, dry as dust, lay at the end of the chamber atop a tremendous mound of gold coins. The sheer scale of the gaping ribcage and the length of the tail made it impossible to suppose that it could be anything but the skeleton of a dragon.
Taking a steadying breath, Thorin tore his eyes away from the gruesome sight. This had to be a fever-dream, some madness brought on by the wind, or perhaps a noxious fume in the cavern. Still, the uncut jewels and precious metals under his feet seemed real enough, gleaming in marvelous tones, and he picked up a single coin bearing the mark of Thrór.
It felt real, a familiar weight in his palm. As he held it, it seemed to warm against his skin, humming with a voice of its own and whispering sweet promises. He dropped it as if it had scorched his hand and retreated to the tall door at the hall’s end.
The entrance was sealed. No matter how he pushed or pulled at it, the wood did not give. Fear curdled in his belly, and he pounded angrily upon the door. “Release me,” he demanded. “Let me out!”
The sound of cascading metal drew his wary eye reluctantly back to the treasure hoard. At the other end of the chamber, the skeleton was stirring.
Bones rattled and trembled, skittering across the coins to fuse together. The empty skull rose, teetering on its corded neck, and leathery, blood-flushed skin began to wrap round the bones, sinews and muscle intertwining to take an all-too familiar shape, even as Thorin watched in astonishment. The spectral fire-drake bowed its neck to fix an eerie lantern-like eye upon him, and this fragment of a nightmare became flesh -- the great serpentine neck, the glittering scales, the jagged spikes wreathing its sly, fearsome head -- no, it was Smaug, and no other.
The horror that consumed Thorin’s heart in that moment was altogether beyond words.
“Well met, King Under the Mountain,” said the dragon, its sagging jaws peeled back in a mockery of a smile.
“No.” Thorin’s hand flew to his sword, and he hefted it warningly before him. “No. You were slain by the Bowman, and you lie mouldering in the lake. You are dead. This is a cowardly trick!”
“You are dead, Dwarf, pierced by an orcish blade And yet here we are.”
“I will not hear your lies,” Thorin said. “You will let me go at once.”
The dragon seemed not to hear him. With his cold eyes burning upon Thorin, he lowered himself onto the coins and stretched out in a mockery of ease. “Well, well,” he sighed, something almost indulgent in his silken voice. “Isn’t this extraordinary? The little king leaves the safety of his Maker’s palace to wander where he should not go.”
“Open the door.”
“But what could have spurred him on a fool’s errand?” Smaug mused. His tip of his cunning tail slithered down the mound of gold and flicked around Thorin’s feet. “Ah! Of course -- the halfling.”
"Open the door!”
“You are not in any position to be making demands of me in my own domain, o King. And such a violent temper! I had forgotten what a churlish creature you are.” He dug his claws into the gold and let the coins sift through them, clinking musically as they fell. “Does my treasure make you uncomfortable, Dwarf? You quite seemed to like it, last we met.”
“It was not your treasure,” Thorin growled. “And I want nothing of it. Free me, and you can rot here in your jewels undisturbed.”
Smaug blinked lazily. “Deny your lust all you like, though it convinces no one. But then I suppose you have had much practice pretending not to covet what you most desire. You cannot hide it from me. This is yet another attempt to satiate the greed that flows so freely in the blood of your line. There was once something you desired even above gold.”
Thorin’s hands shook on his sword, but he did not lower it. “You are false, and I will not listen!”
“When did that fire of wanting first kindle in you, I wonder? In the shape-changer’s garden? The halfling was a queer-looking thing, with his furry toes and beardless chin, but how pleasing he seemed to you then, with the sunlight on his face. It was difficult for you not to look after that.”
“How do you know this?” Thorin barked. “Who told you?”
Smaug tossed back his head with a coughing roar of laughter that seemed to shake the pillars to their crumbling roots. “Why you did, O mighty King. Poor, poor little dwarf, so unlucky in life, so unlucky in love!”
Thorin snarled and lashed out with a furious strike at the dragon's creeping tail. Smaug evaded the blow easily. “How the truth stings you! No doubt your regrets are many, for a life so pitifully spent.”
“My only regret is that I did not fire the arrow that stopped your poison.” Thorin swung out again fiercely, but Smaug only laughed again.
“Bold words indeed! What do you expect to do, little king? What can you do now for your halfling? You could not even keep your own crown.” He slunk to his feet and his wings unfurled, fluttering like banners of war. “How could you have imagined that you could keep him? He was too good for your grasping ways, so soft and pampered and yet so very clever.” For a moment, the dragon almost looked irritated, as though remembering full well how clever Bilbo had been. His cavernous mouth twisted in disgust. “Not clever enough, by far, to carry such power in his fat little hands, with no knowledge of how to use it, no ambition to milk its full potential. What a terrible waste. Perhaps you were well-suited after all.”
“You could not hope to amass an ounce of his strength or courage if you lived for ten thousand years,” Thorin cried, careless with rage and hatred. “I almost wish you could have found that thrice-bedamned Ring, that your greed would have made you a slave to it!”
Smaug's tail whipped out and caught Thorin up by the waist, lashing his arms to his sides and hoisting him into the air. His sword clattered to the floor. “Miserable, crawling rat!” the dragon spit, shaking him like a leaf as he struggled. “I am a slave to nothing! Nothing!”
As abruptly as it had surfaced, his temper seemed to melt away. He puffed out a rasping chortle, his tail squeezing tighter, and Thorin choked on his own breath. “Oh, you thought your lungs should burst from keeping those words held back! How you longed to ask him if he would stay with you when your mountain was won. For he was the finest prize of all: a soft little hobbit to warm your kingly bed. But you would not ask, for you knew what he would say. You knew that he would turn away from you in confusion and distaste, that he would reject you kindly, and shatter you.
“What would the halfling want with Thorin Oakenshield, King of nothing? A dwarf past his prime -- no great claim to beauty,” the dragon sneered, “nor wit nor pretty manners, with a greedy soul that knows little of love and even less of tenderness. You would bathe him in your riches, but you would not know how to say a single fond word to him. You and your mountain of gold would crush him, steal away his soul of green grass and sunlight, until his heart became as cold and unfeeling as yours.”
“You are false,” Thorin gasped.
“How passionate and tender your love, as you held him over the wall, wishing with every part of your being to see his body broken on the rocks below --”
“Stop!”
“Murderer,” Smaug sang out, his eyes aflame. “Kinslayer! Oath-breaker!”
Thorin fought and clawed and kicked at the scaled flesh, but it only seemed to draw tighter until his breath stopped altogether. I cannot die again, he thought wildly, and almost felt like laughing. And yet, it was so very much like dying, his body begging for a draught of air, and his fingers falling limp and useless against his thighs. His vision began to blur.
Smaug let out a shriek, and Thorin fell. For several moments he could not move, lying with his face turned against the gold and sucking musty air gratefully into his lungs. His sight focused, his hearing returned, and he rolled onto his side with some difficulty. Under the fall of his hair he could see Smaug clawing in a panic at his own head. He thrashed in agony, and Thorin caught a glimpse of the shaft of an arrow, driven straight into the center of one massive eye.
There was a blur of movement beside him. When he turned to look, his only thought, half-hysterical, was that he had somehow, against all reason, been killed once more -- it was surely the only explanation for what he was seeing.
For there, clutching Thorin’s sword in determined little hands, was a hobbit.
FRODO
The sudden, violent gust of wind that thrust icy skewers into Frodo’s cloak forced out a shiver from the tips of his ears to his toes. At his side, Gandalf, between one breath of pipeweed and the next, reared back and began to cough.
Tauriel immediately produced her water-skin, but the wizard waved her away. “Father of All, have mercy on us,” he groused, and gathered up his robes in one hand. “Hurry, hurry! We haven’t much time.”
Frodo and Tauriel exchanged a baffled glance before hastening after him. As they left the calm banks of the river behind and ventured deeper into the flat plains, the pace quickened to such a degree that Frodo, with his stout legs, was nearly sprinting to keep up. Tauriel, in no apparent distress, measured her steps to stay at his side; he wasn’t entirely certain whether he ought to be grateful or irritated.
“Gandalf, what is it?” he cried at last, breathless. If they must run, then they must, but he would rather like to know why. “What’s happened?”
“Dwarves happened,” Gandalf declared, and did not slow. “Remind me to box young Kíli’s ears when we reach them -- I am far too old to be running hither and thither, and rest assured I fully intend to impress that fact upon him!”
Tauriel faltered, stumbling with unusual gracelessness, and then her strides seemed to lengthen with renewed vigour.
On they ran. The rich greenery by the river bled slowly away until the land was brown and caked with dust, the earth so dreadfully parched that it cracked into rough shards under Frodo’s feet. So consumed was he by the pulse of his own footsteps and the dry burn in his lungs that he nearly plowed into the elf’s back when they came to a sudden halt.
Gandalf was poking a barren cliff-side with his staff, mumbling to himself, and when he drew away, a rough hole gaped in the stone. He tugged the brim of his hat down, hiked his robes up, and climbed into the opening, ducking his head and vanishing from sight.
“Come along,” his voice called back to them. “Hurry, now!”
Frodo glanced over at Tauriel, who frowned and then crouched to step through the hole with visible reluctance. Frodo patted the dagger at his side to reassure himself and crept through after her.
Inside was a dank, musty hollow, lit only by the steady glow of Gandalf’s staff. “This way,” he said, and led them down some manner of tunnel, so small that Frodo was the only one who could walk through it without unpleasant contortions. The air was appallingly humid, and the heat grew more oppressive the farther they went. Frodo’s toes sank into something on the rock floor, and he couldn’t contain a soft groan of revulsion as his foot pulled away with a wet little slop.
“I thought hobbits lived in the ground,” Tauriel murmured, her hands pressed flat against each wall to keep her balance.
“Hobbit holes are not like this.”
“Quiet,” Gandalf said.
The heat and damp worsened until each step was a chore and Frodo began to grow dizzy. He blinked once to clear the sweat from his eyes. When he opened them again, he let out a cry of horror, for he was standing on the crumbling walkway of Mount Doom.
The air billowed up hot and red, the stone scorching his soles as he gaped in mute terror at the churning pit of fire below him. The empty socket of his finger ached and burned; he swore he could feel the dragging weight of the Ring encircling it.
“Gandalf!” he screamed, and his friend’s voice filled his ears.
“Take my hand -- it is right next to you. What you see is not real. Both of you, come here. Take my hands, come. Do you feel the warmth of my skin? Can you feel how I squeeze your fingers? That is real. But the fires, the mountain, the remains of the town -- they are not real. They are false visions, and they cannot harm you. But you must focus now for them to pass away. Listen to my voice, and hold tight.”
Frodo held on with all his might. Slowly, gradually, the heat drained away, the red light lowered, the phantom tightness around his finger eased and then vanished. The dripping, dark walls of the tunnel returned. He clung to Gandalf’s hand, and bent over to clear the faintness from his head.
Tauriel, gripping Gandalf’s other hand with white knuckles, was the sickly colour of ash. “I saw Lake-town afire,” she breathed. “Everything was flame, everything was lost. How?”
“Fire-drakes,” Gandalf said. “They are cunning creatures, with a talent for planting unpleasant doubts in one’s heads. It is best not to disturb them here in their resting place, for they weave illusions as easily in death as they did in life.” He gently tugged his hands away and took his staff up from the floor. “It is difficult to fight a glamour, when it has been cast -- you both did very well. But I fear our friends were ensnared in the same manner, with no one to free them. We must hurry.”
It took only a few moments to come across the first of Thorin’s company. Around the next bend, a dwarf lay fallen on the stone, a lantern smashed nearby with its light still flickering faintly. Gandalf hastened over, and the orb in his staff flared.
“Dís, daughter of Thráin,,” he said sternly, “wake this instant. Cast the dark shadow from your mind. Wake!” He followed these words with a fluid string of Quenya, and the dwarf’s eyes opened. She gasped and choked, and her hands flew to her throat.
“There now,” Gandalf soothed, helping her turn onto her side. “You are safe.”
She pushed coils of dark hair from her face and stared at him in a blank bewilderment that swiftly melted into recognition. “My sons,” she rasped. “My brothers . . . .”
“We will find them. Sit here for a moment to regain your strength.”
Tauriel discovered two more dwarves lying a few paces away, half-concealed in the shadows. It took considerably longer to wake them, and Gandalf began to look worried.
“Go,” he said. “The tunnels are short, and we will find the others sooner if we each take a different path. Make haste -- the longer they linger under the dragons’ glamours, the harder it becomes to pull them from it. Scream, shout, sing, do whatever you must, but try not to touch them, or you may be pulled into their vision as well.” He handed the cracked lantern to Frodo. “And if you do end up in another vision, remember that you are in control of what you are seeing. How the dream unfolds is entirely up to you. The fire-drakes can only conjure a memory; they cannot control what happens within it. Go now!”
Tauriel’s hurried footsteps soon faded away, and Frodo ventured down further into the dark until he reached a forked split in his tunnel. On instinct, he took the left path and rounded the corner into a large alcove.
Another dwarf lay curled up there, twitching and crying out hoarsely, clearly caught in the throes of some dreadful vision. Frodo flew to his side, and saw he looked very poorly indeed -- his breath was laboured, his trimmed beard glossy with sweat and his silver-threaded hair plastered in knots across his grimacing brow.
Frodo shouted and pleaded and banged his own fist painfully on the rock, but nothing seemed to rouse the dwarf. There was nothing else for it! Frodo took hold of him, his small fingers swallowed up by the dwarf’s large, rough hand. His head spun, and then he was kneeling amidst a pile of treasure, gold piled high like the sands far to the East. The cavern was now a vast, lofty chamber of stone, but Frodo had no attention to spare for the beautiful arches or mounds of jewelled trinkets.
A dragon stalked across the chamber, its spiked wings stretched nearly as wide as the hall itself, and its great bulk rattling the floor with every agitated step. Frodo stared at it in numb awe -- no storybook could do justice to its sheer size, to the terrible beauty of its glittering underbelly, to the cold wickedness of its flaming eyes.
Oh, Bilbo, he thought wildly. How frightened you must have been!
The dragon bellowed as it turned, and there, trapped in the coils of its enormous tail, was a tiny, thrashing body -- even as Frodo watched, the dwarf’s desperate struggles slowed and then ceased altogether. With an angry exclamation, Frodo reached for his bow. Swiftly he brought it to his shoulder. He imagined piercing the monster’s cruel eye, drew back the string, and let loose one single arrow.
It met its mark faithfully. The dragon screamed a billow of flame at the high ceiling and promptly dropped its prize.
Galadriel’s dagger surely could never pierce such tough hide; Frodo cast about and saw a long sword lying nearby, and he snatched it up. The dragon threw itself onto its throne of coins, wings flapping frantically as it rolled about, trying to pull the shaft from its eye. Frodo watched it warily, sword upraised, but its belly was crusted with so many hard scales, and he didn’t know where to strike. He could hear the dwarf stirring behind him and turned long enough to say in a panic, “It’s wounded! What do I do?”
The dwarf staggered upright and braced himself with great effort. “The sword -- give it to me,” he shouted, and Frodo scrambled to obey.
Though he wavered on his feet, the dwarf heaved the blade up high as soon as it was in his hands. With an inarticulate cry of fury, he charged toward the writhing dragon, climbed its nearest leg in short bounds, and thrust the sword into a tiny puncture in the armoured scales of its breast. It bellowed, flames spiralling in a panic from its throat, and crumbled to dust.
Nothing remained but a handful of scales scattered amongst the gold.
The dwarf stood for a moment, swaying drunkenly, before dropping down to his knees to pick up one of the scales. It glimmered with a light brighter than diamond, and the dwarf tossed it away and bent his head, breathing hard.
Frodo scurried up the mound after him, slipping a bit on loose coins. The room whirled and shifted until he was on the damp cavern floor once more, treasure and tall stone pillars and scales vanished into thin air. He wobbled over to his companion. “Are you hurt, Master Dwarf?”
The dwarf stared at him, his dazed blue eyes darting from Frodo’s ears to his feet and then back again before meeting his gaze. “You are real,” he said slowly, as if expecting a demurral.
“Well, yes,” Frodo replied, a little awkwardly.
A strange look passed over the dwarf’s face, but he gathered himself and rose. Once he was firmly planted on his feet once more, he bowed his head gravely. “My thanks, Master Hobbit. Thorin, son of Thráin, at your service.”
So this was Thorin Oakenshield! Frodo supposed he was not too dreadfully surprised, as the dwarf, even disheveled and bathed in sweat, had something regal in his bearing. He did look younger than Frodo had been led to expect -- and his beard certainly wasn’t long enough to tuck into his belt! -- but nonetheless it was quite thrilling to meet a member of Bilbo’s old Company. Remembering his manners, Frodo bobbed a bow of his own. “Frodo Baggins, at yours.”
Thorin’s eyes widened.
“Frodo? Oh, there you are, gracious.” The call startled them both, but the sight of Gandalf peering around the rock-bend was an instant relief. Frodo beamed at him.
Thorin now seemed utterly confounded. “Gandalf?”
“Yes, yes, lovely to see you again too, a pleasure,” Gandalf said, ushering them swiftly back into the tunnel with a firm hand. “Greetings and well-wishes may wait, and you have leave to ask all the questions you choose once we are freed of this foul magic.”
“My kin,” Thorin rasped. “Are they --?”
“They are quite well, I assure you. Come!”
Never had Frodo been so glad to see sunlight and fill his lungs with fresh air as he was when they finally emerged from the tunnel. A half-dozen dwarves were clustered about the entrance, and they surged forward as one.
“Thank Mahal you’re safe,” said the first dwarf to reach them, and he gripped Thorin’s shoulders as though to reassure himself that they were not mere illusions. He noticed Frodo then, and the smile beneath his snowy-white beard shifted into a look of astonishment. “Why, it’s Bilbo’s wee laddie!”
A cry rose up among the dwarves, and Frodo was swarmed by stout, be-furred bodies, shouting words of welcome and smothering him in rough embraces. Gandalf laughed heartily when Frodo spit a stray braid from his mouth and then thrust his staff into the huddle of dwarves so that he might make his escape. His eye was caught again by the dwarf who had first recognized him, and, still quite flustered, he blurted, “I know you!”
The old dwarf beamed. “And I know you, though you were a very little fellow when last I came visiting your uncle. Balin, at your service.”
“Do you know me too, Frodo?” another dwarf asked.
“I . . . I think I’ve seen your hat? Or something like it.”
The dwarves laughed uproariously at that. Frodo felt himself redden, though the one with the curious hat seemed amused rather than offended. “Aye, it’s more memorable than my pretty face. Bofur’s the name, dear Baggins.”
There were a chorus of introductions after that. They were all familiar. Tales of Bilbo’s adventure to Erebor had once been Frodo’s favourite bedtime stories, and he almost felt that he might have been able to pair names with dwarves without help, for they were nearly just as he had imagined them as a fauntling. The only ones not known to him at all were Thorin’s brother, a merry dwarf with a long, braided beard, and his sister Dís, who smiled at Frodo warmly.
He bowed when they were done. “Frodo Baggins, at your service.”
“We all know your name,” the one called Óin boomed. “How could we not after hearing so many stories of you? What a brave lad, and a true Baggins!”
There were rumbles of agreement, and Frodo’s ears positively burned. It was a relief when the party’s attention was diverted by a commotion as a rather wild-looking dwarf and Tauriel abruptly appeared from the cavern.
The young, scruffy dwarf -- Kíli, Frodo thought -- let out a loud shout. “Tauriel!” He shoved past his brother in a blur of unkempt hair and leather to throw his arms about the elf’s waist. That was astonishing enough, but then Tauriel -- implacable Tauriel! -- tangled one hand in his hair and looked as though she might weep.
Gandalf cleared his throat loudly. “Tauriel, perhaps you would be so kind as to scout ahead for a camp? I do not believe we shall get much farther today, and we should all feel better for a good rest.”
With remarkable speed the elf vanished into the sparse trees, Kíli clinging tight to her hand.
There was something of a stunned silence left in their wake, and Frodo bit his lip against a swell of ill-timed laughter at the collection of sour faces around him. Balin coughed delicately and clapped Frodo on the shoulder. “Now laddie, what brings you here, hmm? Not that we’re not very grateful for the rescue, mind you.”
“Perhaps we ought to be asking you as well,” Gandalf said dryly.
Bofur doffed his hat and shrugged. “Thorin heard that our burglar had gotten himself in a wee spot of trouble, so we packed up and off we went!” He nudged the wizard. “Though I’d bet ore-to-gold that you knew that already.”
Gandalf cast a discerning gaze at the circle of dwarves and frowned. “You look as though your journey has not been half so pleasant as ours. I can lead you safely back to Aulë before we go on.”
There was an instant outcry. Thorin, who had been standing back from the company, silent, spoke then, and the others hushed immediately. “Do the elves have no hope for him?”
“They sent us,” Frodo answered. “We’re going to Lord Manwë to ask for his help on Bilbo’s behalf.”
Gandalf hummed thoughtfully. “If you are determined to go on, Thorin, you may as well travel with us.” Though his words were sensible, he wore a peculiar look, one that Frodo happened to know very well. It was the look Gandalf always had when he had weighed all the odds and decided that the outcome was going to amuse him.
“Then it is resolved,” Thorin said gravely, and his gaze caught Frodo’s for a breath before flitting away. “We shall go together.”
