Actions

Work Header

And in the Darkness Bind Them

Chapter 5: The Halls of Mandos

Notes:

Warnings for disturbing imagery involving child death.

Chapter Text

 


 


 

CHAPTER FOUR


 THORIN


 

 

IT BECAME APPARENT to the Company that they would travel no further that day. The sun had set, and as they were still somewhat overcome by their visions in the cavern, a rest and hot food would do more than a measure of good. Though he was impatient to continue, Thorin conceded readily enough to Gandalf’s suggestion that they break camp and start afresh in the morning.

Kíli and the she-elf returned with news that there was a meadow hemmed protectively by cliffs that would suit well for a camp. It was distant enough from the cavern to be safe, yet not so far that they would have to walk in the deepening dark. Their party plodded sluggishly along, and Thorin was too weary to take umbrage at the perturbing sight of the elf walking so closely to his sister-son that their sides brushed with every step.

Frerin was clinging to Thorin’s heels nearly as fiercely. After the third time he almost pitched over his brother’s boots, Thorin turned to dismiss him, his patience worn thin by the day’s misfortunes. When he beheld his shadow properly, however, his ire ebbed away; Frerin looked as though he’d been shut in a pen with Dáin’s most hellish battle-boar.

“Are you hurt?” he demanded.

“No!” Frerin fell back a few paces, his face pinched.

“Do not lie to me.”

His brother sounded the loud sigh of one truly put-upon, but he spoke willingly enough. “What did you see?”

Thorin winced despite himself. “Things that I would prefer not to speak of.”

“I saw Azanulbizar,” Frerin murmured, so softly that Thorin strained to hear him. “I was on the field again, and I saw them fall.” A shiver crawled visibly across his shoulders, but he met Thorin’s eyes with no shame. “You and Dís too. And Amad. The lads. All of you were gone, and I was alone.”

“It was a cruel vision, nothing more."

The huff of breath he received in response might have been a chuckle, but there was no smile on Frerin’s face when he said, “I’m sorry.”

“For?”

“I don’t know. For leaving you alone, I suppose.”

On impulse, Thorin seized his brother’s hand. “I am not alone now, am I?”

This seemed to ease Frerin’s agitation. Thorin could admit to himself that there was solace to be found in the familiarity of walking as they once had, when Thorin’s footsteps were followed by Frerin’s and a tiny, often sugar-sticky hand had been all but permanently attached to his.

“Brother?”

“What?"

“Are all halflings so small? I thought it was only an old dam’s tale, like how Men believe there are no dwarf women.”

Very reluctantly, Thorin’s eyes were drawn to the little figure trotting along beside Gandalf, the top of his dark, curly head not even brushing the wizard’s elbow. “I have not known many halflings."

In truth he too had been taken aback by how frail the hobbit was, once he had recovered himself enough to properly study his saviour. Bilbo had been no taller, surely, but he had always been hale and sturdy and comfortably stout. Young Frodo, however, was wan and wide-eyed, with childish features so delicate as to be almost elvish. Had Thorin not know better, he would have scoffed at the notion of such a creature vanquishing one of the greatest evils to ever threaten Middle-earth. But if Thorin had learned anything from their burglar, it was that the spirit of hobbits was not proportionate to their stature.

“He seems a good-natured sort." Frerin brightened then, tugging his hand from Thorin’s. “Do you think he’s met the Elf-Witch of Lothlórien? She’s in so many of Ori’s tales, and he says she’s old as death itself. Imagine meeting her!”

“How should I know?” Thorin grunted. “Go and ask him yourself if you’re so keen to hear about elves.”

With that, Frerin loped to the front of their party, visibly startling the poor halfling when he popped up beside him.

Thorin shook his head and resolutely looked away.

The clearing under the rock-shelf proved dry and well-fortified by the cliffs, and with the aid of a few withered branches, Gandalf soon had a bonfire crackling cheerily in its centre. The Company made themselves comfortable, pooling together scraps and crumbs from their stores for a more extravagant pot of stew to celebrate their lucky escape.

Thorin made a few rounds through the camp, relieved to see that a safe shelter and the prospect of a hearty meal had restored some gaiety to them all. Conversation flowed freely as they settled their packs, attended to their weapons, and began to spread their bedrolls, and Fíli was even pestering Bofur for a song or two once the meal was done.

The only blemishes to sour Thorin’s peace of mind were the suspicious presence of the elf, who was addressing Gandalf in lowered tones, and the sight of the halfling loitering uneasily by the tight circle of bodies clustered around the fire.

Balin seemed to notice him nearly at the same moment Thorin did, and he ushered the halfling to a choice seat. The Company welcomed him amiably, pressing him for news of Middle-earth and speaking over each other in their eagerness to acquaint themselves with him. As Frodo spoke, haltingly and then with more confidence, Thorin found himself accounting for each small gesture, each turn of phrase, each subtle mannerism that spoke of Bilbo’s influence. The young Baggins seemed softer than his uncle, more earnest, less forthright, and truthfully did not much resemble him, but there was enough of a likeness to make it difficult for Thorin to look at him long. When it became too much to bear, he abandoned the merriment of their camp and retreated out into the open air.

The night was tranquil, the stars unclouded enough to provide sufficient light without a lantern. He found a flat-topped boulder that made for an adequate seat and set to cleaning his weapons. There were no bloodstains, no hint that his sword had been used hours before to pierce a fire-drake’s heart, but Thorin would take no chances. He refused to carry anything of that foul beast with him. He scoured and oiled and buffed the metal until it shone silver, but no amount of polishing could cleanse the purr of Smaug’s voice from his ears. With a rather black humour, he decided that perhaps this blade had earned itself a name at last -- Dragonsbane would serve as a reminder, both of its mightiest deed and the wyrm’s persistent intrusion into his life.

Light footsteps scuffed the grass. His fist tensed reflexively on the hilt, but a moment later Gandalf emerged from the brush. Thorin inclined his head to him in voiceless acknowledgment. Without so much as a by-your-leave, Gandalf perched beside him and patted down his cloak absently before producing his long-stemmed pipe from within its folds. It pricked Thorin with something akin to nostalgia to see it in his hands once more.

“It has been a long time, Thorin."

Thorin regarded him long enough to say, “I thank you for saving my kinsmen,” and returned his attention to his work.

“So formal? We parted on fraught terms, I grant you, but I am glad to see you again nevertheless.”

“I bear no grudge toward you if that’s what you’re asking."

Gandalf was quiet for a spell, puffing away diligently, and a film of marbled blue-grey smoke began to rise with the wind. “I believe you may labouring under a misapprehension."

"Is that so?"

"Shall I tell you of Erebor as it is now?"

"Save your breath."

"I thought that might be the case. Our last meeting did not mark a failure. To have you think that your last act was not worth---"

“It was not,” Thorin interrupted. A fierce anger flared in his gut -- an anger that always seemed to simmer in him now, seeking release wherever it could. “Nothing could be worth such a price. My kin, my honour, my ---” He stuttered to a halt and screwed his eyes shut against the look of pity the wizard no doubt wore.

“If you had not gone, Erebor would never have been reclaimed. The East would have crumbled under the forces of Mordor if the three kingdoms had not been there to stand against them together. The Ring would never have come into Bilbo’s safekeeping; likely it would have been taken by Sauron before we even knew his full strength had been recovered. Middle-earth would have fallen.”

“You cannot know that.”

“No,” Gandalf said. “And no one will ever know, given that it did not come to pass.”

Thorin dropped his gaze to the sword lying across his thighs, its bright steel polished to a glow under the moon’s light; he rubbed a thumb against the runes of protection. “Did you give me my father’s key, knowing that I would fail?”

For an eternal moment, Gandalf was still. Nothing passed between them but spindly plumes of smoke. “You did not fail,” the wizard said at last, heavily. “Did I know that the line of Durin would perish? No, I did not. Did I know that the Lonely Mountain would be won, or Smaug slain? No. But I hoped.”

“Your faith was misplaced,” Thorin said bitterly.

“I asked far too much, expecting you to overcome what all your forefathers could not. My thoughts were so fixated upon how the days hence might develop, on how events would unfold, that I did not devote enough attention to the happenings of the present.” Gandalf lowered his pipe and cradled it in his palms, its light casting pale shadows on his cloak.  “Great knowledge, I regret to say, does not always produce an equal share of wisdom. My poor brother Saruman was proof enough of that.” He peered at Thorin beneath careworn brows. “I was not there to help you when you most desperately needed my help. For that I am sorry.”

“Pray don’t mention it,” Thorin said gruffly, for lack of anything better to say.

From beyond the brush, a strain of a melody reached their ears -- it seemed Fíli had won his way. Bofur’s voice mingled with his fiddle in an old forge-song, meant for keeping the rhythm of hammer-strokes steady. Gandalf sang along for several verses, and then, very suddenly, turned to pin Thorin with a piercing look. “You are as hard-headed and haughty as your grandfather, with none of your mother’s graces nor your father’s reconciling temper. Yet you would have been a good king, Thorin Oakenshield. Your strength would have served your people well.”

Thorin’s eyes burned. “You cannot know that either.”

“That is one thing of which I have no doubt.”

The air seemed to settle between them, and Thorin accepted the offered pipe for a quick draught of the oddly spiced leaf. A gale of laughter filtered through the trees, a high, unfamiliar voice fluting above it all. The wizard’s smile widened. “I am glad to see your company welcome Frodo so heartily. This has not been an easy task for him, and good friends will lighten his burden.” He blew one last frothy ring and then neatly extinguished his pipe. “He is afraid. And I am afraid for him.”

“Is he in danger?”

“No,” Gandalf said, and his amusement seemed to turn inward. “But he is only a very little fellow.”

“Any of us would protect him with our last measure of strength.” For himself it was an earnest oath. This was Bilbo’s child, and Thorin would deny his place in his Maker’s Halls before he let him come to harm.

“I know.”

Gandalf had always valued directness (even above politeness), and so Thorin plainly asked the question that had been troubling him all evening. “How came he to Valinor? Dís had understood that he survived the War.”

“He was not killed,” Gandalf confirmed. “Sometimes a wounded spirit cannot be healed.”

“He left of his own will?”

“He could not stay in Middle-earth. To bear such evil so close to his heart. . . . He made the only choice he could, under such circumstances. The chief Eldar granted him passage and permission to dwell in Valinor until his life is spent. He is young; it will not be for many years.”

“Can he not return?”

“Crossing the Sea is as final an act as death itself. He cannot go back.”

“Then I am sorry for him,” Thorin murmured.

“As am I, I assure you. It was not how I wished to see his life unfold, but I must respect his choices -- they speak of a wisdom far beyond his years.” He paused and smiled ruefully. “And mine, apparently.”

The forge-song ended, and after a moment’s lull, Dís’s voice rose in the night-air. Thorin recognized the tune before the first line was through: a cradle song, penned by their mother after Thorin’s birth and sung to each of them until they grew old enough to sleep apart from their parents. Even now, so far removed from the royal keep of Erebor, the song carried with it the softness of Freís’s touch, the bristled brush of his father’s beard against his forehead, the warm, sleeping weight of three small dwarflings, tumbled together like tired pups in their bed. It soothed another knot of tension from Thorin’s heart, dispersing the cruel taunts of the dragon that lingered there.  

They were mute until the song ended, and Gandalf hummed appreciatively. “Lovely. Dís’s voice reminds me very much of your great-great-aunt Môir’s. She had a singing voice likened to silver bells by more than one poet, and she sang the crowning song for Thrór’s grand coronation. If I recall correctly, she received twenty-two-and-a-half offers of marriage when the ceremony was done.”

Thorin snorted.

“Music runs deep in dwarvish veins, I’ve found,” Gandalf mused. “Your line has something of a particular talent for it.”

“Most of us. Adad croaks like a toad.”

Thorin could not say which of them was more startled by that pronouncement; Gandalf tipped his head back and laughed aloud.

“You shall have to ask Frodo to sing one of these nights. He has a good ear for song.” He knocked his cooling pipe against the stone to empty it and swabbed the bowl clean with his robe, indifferent to the ashy streaks it left on the white cloth. “You have not asked me about Bilbo, Thorin.”

“The air grows cold,” Thorin said, and he began to gather his things about him. “We ought to return to the fire.”

“It would be the sensible thing to do,” Gandalf said agreeably, but he gave no indication of stirring from his seat, and Thorin turned to go. As he stepped into the warm ring of light around the fire, he heard a faint murmur behind him:

“But when have you ever done the sensible thing?”

 

******

 

Thorin passed a restless night, and it was not yet dawn when he woke. More sleep was a fruitless wish, and so he rose quietly. He might as well be useful if he could not be well-rested.

Of their party, only Dís was awake, readying the stew-pot for breakfast. The fire was already kindled and the pot sloshed with fresh water to be boiled. Thorin wondered whether she had slept at all. Slinging on his overcoat and belt, he went over to help. Wordlessly she handed him a knife and a chunk of dried venison, and he knelt beside her to carve it into thin slivers while she sifted oats. They worked with easy efficiency, and soon enough the water was hot enough to soften the grains and meat. Knowing very well that neither of them were cooks of much renown, Dís kept an attentive eye on their porridge. Occasionally, however, her gaze flickered over to their sleeping company -- and more particularly to the fall of red hair that peeped above a tall tangle of blankets.

When Dís saw that Thorin was watching, she sighed. “Kíli gave her my blessing-stone."

Thorin longed to be more surprised by this revelation, but Kíli had always run recklessly toward battle and love alike. “Did Fíli tell you?”

“He told me himself. He spoke of her so often, but I thought it was another of his fancies, something to shock Grandfather with. You know how he loves to rile him with outlandish tales.”

“You seem very calm about this."

“I am not pleased,” Dís replied dryly, “and, Mahal, I can only imagine the fit Víli would have. But it seems senseless to stir up a fuss about it now.”

“I can speak with him if you like.”

“Don’t you say a word to him -- you know how he is. Tell him no, and he will do his best to do the opposite.” She fed another twig into the fire and glowered at the pasty, bubbling gruel atop it. “If the boys are to be believed, she saved Kíli’s life. Whether I like it or not, I owe her a debt.”

“No doubt he made a false idol of her in his memories. He hardly had a chance to know her. It will come to nothing when they learn more of each other and find that they are not suited.”

“And he might have married her, had he lived,” Dís snapped. “We shall never know, shall we?” There was a bristling silence, and Dís reached for her spoon to stir the pot violently.

“They will be parted when our quest is done,” Thorin said stiffly, wounded.

“All the more reason not to interfere.” She rubbed at her forehead in rage and frustration, and Thorin wondered when the threads of weary silver had crept into his sister’s hair. “Are we never to have peace?”

He had no reassurances for her.

The rest of the Company began to stir as dawn scattered the early fog, and soon enough a yawning crowd was gathered impatiently around the pot. Not even a smart warning smack from Dís’s spoon was enough to deter them from the twin temptations of the warm fire and the promise of breakfast. Bowls were produced, and Thorin was consigned to dishing up the watery porridge.

The halfling thanked him very politely when Thorin gave him his share. He lingered by the pot, shuffling his large feet with the air of someone who had something to say but no idea how to go about saying it. Thorin filled another bowl hastily for his brother and left. Frodo stayed by the fire for a moment, visibly flustered, and then slunk away to sit between Bofur and Balin.

Thorin’s flight did not go unnoticed.

“What's wrong with you?” Frerin hissed under his breath, though he accepted his bowl eagerly enough. “Are you worried that he’s afraid of you? I’ll grant you, he is a scrawny thing, but he doesn’t strike me as the sort to frighten easily. Bofur plucked him up to carry on his shoulders last night, and he didn’t let out so much as a squeak.”

“Eat your breakfast,” Thorin said shortly.

They didn’t linger over their food. The camp was broken and neatly packed again within a half-hour, and Gandalf cast a satisfied eye over them all as they shouldered their baggage. “Well, this should make for a merry party! It is not too terribly far to Mount Taniquetil, if memory serves me. We shall go on north from here, and there ought to be a road that joins with the riverbank that will take us directly to the mount.”

His phrasing gave Thorin pause. “You’re not certain?”

“It has been some time since I have travelled this way. After five thousand years, I can hardly be expected to remember every twist and turn in Aman. Oh, don't trouble yourselves now. Did I not lead you safely across Middle-earth?”

“Aye, If you don’t regard the trolls," said Bofur.

“Or the goblins,” Óin added. “And those giant bloody rocks.”

“Ah, and Mirkwood. I didn’t much fancy elvish prisons.”

“And ---”

“That’s settled then,” Balin called loudly from the rear of the huddle. “Please do lead on, Master Gandalf.”

“Thank you, Balin,” Gandalf said, with great dignity.

They marched quickly, eager to leave the barren, treacherous country behind, but the edge of panic that had driven them before was quite gone. They amused themselves with telling increasingly unlikely tales as they walked. Fíli and Kíli seemed to have taken it into their heads that Frodo required their company, and they hovered about him, drawing him into their conversation at every opportunity. It brought a distressing tightness to Thorin’s chest to see them prodding and teasing, eager to be liked and approved of, just as they had done with Bilbo.

Unlike his uncle, the young Baggins did not seem intimidated or annoyed by their overtures; he dealt with them as though he were accustomed to overbearing friendliness. He laughed obligingly at their jests and offered up a few stories of the escapades of his cousins in return, which Thorin thought rather explained his tolerance. He did, however, turn down requests to tell tales of his own journey with profuse apologies, and he looked so discomposed by any mention of the quest that even Ori, with his historian’s thirst for stories, declined to press him further.

They passed the morning pleasantly in this way. The dry, rocky land was put behind them and the grassy road rose and fell in a series of gently rolling hills and valleys as they returned to the riverbank. Gandalf seemed taken aback by the new scenery and left their party with assurances that he would return promptly; he only needed to scout ahead a little and get his bearings.

It was not very reassuring.

They kept to the path, trusting that the wizard would be able to find them, and went down into the deep valley the river had carved into the banks. Over the low hillock, a large pond swelled out from the river, its water the colour of the purest-cut aquamarine. It was beautiful but clearly not a natural feature; the hue of the water changed very suddenly as it cut into the bank, and, supposing that it was better to be careful, Thorin cautioned the others away from it.

Kíli, however, was already poking curiously about the water.

“Kíli,” Dís said warningly, just as the elf called his name with some alarm. They both paused and glanced at each other uncomfortably.

“I only want to look at it,” Kíli protested, locking his hands behind his back emphatically. “Just look, that’s all.”

Thorin sighed and quickened his steps to join Kíli to the pond’s edge, ready to pull him back. He’d barely touched his sister-son’s elbow, however, before his eye was caught by a shadow on the pond’s surface. Beneath the water, an elf-child swayed with the gentle current, dark hair spinning in spidery rivulets around his still, waxy face. Kíli reared back with a wail of horror, but Thorin lunged, hands already outstretched to scoop up the drowning elfling.

“Thorin Oakenshield!” Gandalf roared, voice roiling like a thundercloud over the valley. “Do not touch the water!”

“There’s someone in there!” Kíli cried, but in a blink, Gandalf was beside them, pulling them both away with an astounding and unrelenting strength.

“He is already gone,” Gandalf said firmly, not loosening his grasp, “and in all likelihood he has been so for many, many years.”

With dawning revulsion, Thorin saw now that there were other figures in the pond: dozens of small, motionless bodies, bobbing calmly below the water’s surface. His stomach turned. Dís gripped his shoulder as the others huddled around, and her hand shook with fury. There were several startled breaths, and a low, vicious growl from Bifur.

“This is a burial ground,” Gandalf declared, throwing up his staff between the dwarves and the water. "It is under the protection of Vána the Ever-Young. Now step away and compose yourselves!”

Óin’s cheeks were bloodless beneath his beard. “This is -- this is -- who would do this? What twisted, despicable ---”

“Hold your tongue!” Gandalf interrupted, very sharply. “This pool is a hallowed place.” After a tense moment, he lowered his staff, apparently satisfied that none of the dwarves were going to dash headlong into the water. “The death of an elfling from illness or accident is a very rare tragedy. They cannot stay in Valinor, as their spirits have already fled their bodies. They cannot go to Mandos in his Halls, for they were neither slain in battle nor fit to be judged. Vána created this pool that they might rest peacefully here, under her protection until the Remaking.”

It seemed a rational explanation, but still Thorin trembled with anger. “To leave them here, where any creature might see them . . .  to leave them to the open air . . . . "

“Elven burials are not like yours,” Gandalf said, more gently. “I realize it is a distressing sight, but I give you my solemn word that no dishonour is dealt here. Now does that satisfy you? Any more questions?”

“I’ve one,” Bofur said, in tones of sudden alarm. “Where’s wee Frodo?”

 

***

 

Thorin was the one to find him, after only a few moments of searching -- the hobbit was on the path, trotting nervously back and forth and wringing his small hands. “Master Baggins,” he said, loudly enough to catch his attention and softly enough not to startle.

“I’m sorry,” he sputtered, upon spotting Thorin there. “I’m sorry, I didn’t mean to run off and worry anyone. I couldn’t stay there a moment longer.” A powerful shudder rolled through him; his jaw worked soundlessly for a moment before he said, all in a rush, “I saw marshes once. There were bodies in the water, all of the fallen soldiers. It was -- it was -- it was useless, senseless. It wasn’t glorious. It was pitiful. They were left there, with no one to return them to the earth, no one to sing for them. Did no one love them enough to search for them and take them home?” The halfling rocked back on his heels and looked at Thorin, but his eyes were distant and unseeing. “All I could think was if Sam and I fell, would someone else come across our bones someday and think the same thing of us?”

“Those are heavy thoughts,” Thorin said. “But I have no words of wisdom for you. Dwarrowkind always lay their dead to rest under stone. Only the foulest dwarf would deny even his worst enemy the dignity of a proper burial.”

There was an uncomfortable stillness when the halfling did not reply. Thorin cast about for something to say. “You need not be ashamed. Even the most battle-hardened among us struggle with the shades of what we have seen.”

“I doubt you run away so foolishly. I didn't think of how it would seem. We should go back."

“Retreat is sometimes the braver course,” Thorin said. His heart began to pound a hurried rhythm in his breast. “I told your Uncle so, once. Perhaps he mentioned it to you.”

“No, he hardly ever spoke of you.”

The hurt that lashed Thorin then was shocking, as accustomed as he had become to the rawness of his grief. It was as he had long feared: Bilbo’s kindness had led him to speak words of forgiveness that he had not truly felt -- a well-meant deception to pacify a dying king.

A slender hand on his wrist made him raise his eyes.

“I misspoke, Master Oakenshield. I always thought Uncle could not speak of you often because he felt your loss so keenly.” His own boldness seemed to catch up with him then, and he timidly drew back and shuffled his big feet shyly. “You needn’t address me as Master Baggins, you know. I’ve asked everyone else to call me Frodo. Formality has no place among friends.”

Thorin managed a small smile. “No, it does not. We should return to the others, if you are ready. If not, I will tell them you are safe and you may stay here as long as you like.”

The hobbit was already straightening his waistcoat, mouth set stubbornly. “No, I’m well now. I only needed a minute.” He bobbed his head to Thorin like a little bird. “Thank you.”

Thorin returned his gesture gravely, and together they went to rejoin the Company.

 



FRODO


 

 

IT WAS AN UNEXPECTED boon to travel with a large company once more. Frodo had forgotten how comforting it was to journey with the safety of decent numbers, and he felt far more at ease having so many seasoned travellers sharing the road with him. Certainly the dwarves were no replacements for Sam and Merry and Pippin, nor Aragorn or Legolas, but with such interesting companions, Frodo did not want for entertainment to distract him from his worries. By the end of their first week together, Frodo liked all of them, and each in their own particular way.

When Frodo sheepishly rejoined the others after the incident at the pond, Óin had hauled him over for an examination, ignoring his protests that he was fine, thank you. Satisfied that Frodo had not somehow managed to mortally injure himself in the few minutes he had been separated from the party, the old dwarf had clucked over his thinness, told him to eat more, and given him a clap on the back that nearly sent him sprawling.

Balin was a particular favourite, as Frodo had faint but fond memories of the dwarf from his early childhood. He recollected pleading with his mother to visit Bag End so that he might see Uncle Bilbo’s friend, who looked nothing like a proper hobbit and always had sweets tucked in his coin-purse. Balin was as warm and approachable as he remembered and was probably the most knowledgeable of all the dwarves; if there was a question to be asked, Balin could likely provide the answer. Still, he was kept busy consulting with Gandalf and Thorin and Dís, and Frodo was often only able to catch him for conversation when they broke camp in the evenings.

As one of the dwarves who had been dearest to Bilbo, Bofur had apparently designated himself as caretaker and guide in his friend’s stead. He slung an arm about Frodo’s shoulder while they walked and took pains to see that he always had the choicest spot to lay his bedroll. Frodo might have appreciated the fussing less if Bofur hadn’t gone about it so mildly and with such obvious pleasure. His cousin Bifur rarely spoke to Frodo -- or at all, so far as he could tell -- but he always set aside a small portion of his plate to spoon wordlessly onto Frodo’s at every meal. It was a gracious gesture, and though he felt awkward eating more than his fair share, he was very grateful nevertheless for the extra food. Hunger now brought with it too many unpleasant associations.

Thorin was a strange puzzle. Kingly he was, certainly, and his company looked to him with a love and respect that were obvious to Frodo -- though perhaps, he thought, not to Thorin himself. He wore an aura of melancholy about him like a cloak, his sorrows old and entrenched, with a heaviness in his bearing that savoured strongly of poor Faramir. Or perhaps he was merely sad in the way of all beings aged beyond their years. He did not often smile and laughed even less, and his frown was fierce in its haughty displeasure. Still, he took pains to speak gently to Frodo, and he treated his nephews with a gruff affection that went a long way in dispelling Frodo’s wariness around him.

Thorin’s brother and sister kept their distance as well, though it seemed more out of preoccupation with their tasks than any ill-intent. They were both kind to him. Dís’s indulgent and watchful eye fell on him almost as frequently as it did upon her sons, and despite his protests, she gifted him with a pair of her woolen mittens when she saw that he had none. Frerin was charming and open, if a bit brash, and always made a particular effort to draw him into conversation.

Naturally, Frodo found himself most often grouped with the younger dwarves. Kíli was loud and merry, brimming with good cheer and mischief and a sweetness that showed itself in small, thoughtful ways. His brother was calmer, prouder, and had a good deal more dignity, but he was willing to be pulled into Kíli’s schemes if they promised him enough amusement. Frodo liked them both, even if their limitless vigour could become exhausting. Still, he had not spent his childhood with Merry and Pippin for nothing.

Most of all, though, he liked Ori, who was soft-spoken and clever and seemed to know a little bit about everything. He had been quite the scholar once, and he confessed to Frodo with some wryness that he was likely the only dwarf within the last century to voluntarily learn Sindarin. They often talked in low voices late into the night when they ought to have been sleeping instead, and Frodo was relieved to find that there was someone else who understood what it was to be lonely, even surrounded by friends.

“I miss my brothers,” Ori whispered one night, as they all lay tucked snugly in their bedrolls around the banked fire. “I mean to say, of course I’m happy they’re alive, and in good health . . . it isn’t the same, not having them with me. Dori fussed something dreadful, even once I was full-grown, but I’d like nothing more than to have him telling me to wear a warmer tunic or oil my beard properly.” He turned his face into the pillow of his arms; Frodo could hear his beads clinking softly. “Do you have brothers, Frodo? Or sisters?”

“I have more cousins than I can count. Sam was as dear to me as anyone could be, and I miss him every day. It’s so strange to be without him.”

“I don’t believe the strangeness ever goes away entirely,” Ori said, "but we’ll see them again someday. We need only be patient.” He paused. “Hobbits do have a hall, don’t they? Or is it a great secret? You needn’t tell me if it is.”

“Oh, no, it’s no great secret. We just don’t talk of it often. When I die I will go to Yavanna in her pastures, as all hobbits do. She’s not our Maker, but she has claimed us as her own.”

Ori looked fascinated. “In a pasture, you say? Is it in Valinor? Have your people always gone there? It’s very hard to find recorded histories of hobbits, you know.” He sounded a little scolding, and Frodo grinned into his blanket.

“It must be in Valinor. I don’t know where else it would be. It's said that the pastures are beautiful beyond compare, with flowers always in bloom and plenty of good green food to eat.”

Ori wrinkled his nose. Frodo laughed aloud before hushing himself and they both looked about guiltily, but Bifur and Bofur, who were sleeping nearby, didn’t stir.

“I don’t know why Yavanna chose us. There is an old story of a hobbit who grew a single rosebush more beautiful than any other rosebush. She tended it for years and years and loved it almost like a child. When she grew old, knowing that her time was nearly spent, she gave it in tribute to Yavanna for safekeeping. The Green Lady was so touched by the offering that she promised that the hobbit and her kin and all her kin’s kin would have a place in her garden along with the roses.” He wound his blanket tighter. “There’s another story that says the first hobbits sprouted from the ground one day and Yavanna claimed them as her own. The first one makes for a better story.”

“Yes, I like that one better. Dwarrows have a very similar tale, only we sprang from the rock, hammered out by Mahal’s chisel and shaped by his Great Forge.”

“Maybe we all began the same way,” Frodo said.

“Maybe.” Ori stretched and rolled over to face the sky. “It’s very odd -- I never thought I would see the stars again.”

There was a comfortable pause. The low murmur of voices from the others and the steady, snapping crackle of the fire made for a pleasantly drowsy backdrop.

“No,” Frodo said slowly. “I didn’t know what to expect when I crossed the Sea, but I suppose I didn’t either. It feels, sometimes, as though I didn’t leave Middle-earth at all. And it’s . . . well, it is a little strange to think of how I’m here talking to you when you’re . . . um.”

Ori chuckled. “I don't remember that I'm dead half the time. It’s not so very different from being alive.”

Frodo paused a moment for think on that absurdity, and he felt a little better for it. “It isn’t, is it?”

They smiled at each other. Fíli’s voice rose suddenly to shatter the sleepy calmness of their camp. “Durin’s beard, go to sleep, Kíli! You’ve been nattering for an hour now.”

Frerin had been stoking the fire, but Frodo saw him twist around to smirk at his nephew. “Even asleep you make enough noise to wake the stone giants.”

“Me? You snore like a warg.”

“And you look like one, lad,” he returned, and the camp erupted into loud, appreciative hoots.

“None of you will ever snore again if you don’t shut your mouths,” Thorin growled.

The laughter immediately tapered off. Frodo caught Ori’s eye and had to muffle a snort in his blankets.

All in all Frodo rather liked travelling with dwarves. Bilbo had, as usual, had the right of it.

 

****

 

The snow came upon them so suddenly that Frodo thought he had been caught up in the throes of another false vision. But no, a few rapid blinks didn't whisk away the powdery shelves of snow that glittered on the road before them, and the flakes that had caught in his curls were cold and real enough to melt between his fingers. Even the river was iced into a white ribbon, shining painfully in the light.

Bofur let out a low whistle, and Thorin immediately turned to Gandalf for an explanation.

“The poor weather shouldn’t last,” the wizard said, addressing them all. “Put on your furs and hoods. There will only be snow for this brief stretch of road, and then the weather should clear.”

“It is snow, isn’t it?” Bofur asked.

“What else should it be?”

“I don’t know. Maybe a pond that isn’t actually a pond, aye? Or a cavern that isn’t a cavern and is in fact a dragons’ lair? I’m not trusting my old blinkers much these days, sorry to say.”

“A fair point taken, Master Bofur. No, I can assure you all that this is indeed snow.”

“We’ll take your word,” Thorin said, with a rather hard look.

Obediently the Company brought out their heaviest furs and mittens, and Óin wound his own scarf around Frodo’s neck, muttering about him catching cold. Cautious of any hidden ice patches, they trooped on.

On the opposite riverbank a great citadel came gradually into view, standing lonely and proud in the fields. It looked to Frodo’s eyes as though it were made of black marble or some other polished stone; it gleamed beautifully, its towering walls as smooth as glass, with not a gate or door in sight.

“What is that?” Fíli asked wonderingly.

Gandalf squinted, shielding his eyes against the flurry. “That, young Fíli, is Mandos’s Keep.”

“The Halls of Waiting,” Tauriel breathed, and from the way she stiffened as soon as the words had passed her lips, Frodo knew she had not meant to speak aloud.

Gandalf gave her a curious, measured look before returning his attention to the rest of the Company. “We will go no closer,” he said. “It is impossible to gain entry, and Mandos is not overly fond of guests besides.”

“Mandos?” Frodo asked.

“The Keeper and Judge. Men and elves lost in battle go here to have their lives measured by him before they pass on.”

“Pass on where?”

“Beyond Eä, I suppose.”

“You suppose?” Óin said.

“As I am neither an elf nor a Man, yes."

“Are we in danger passing so close?” Dís asked. Considering their previous mishaps, Frodo thought it a reasonable question.

Gandalf shook his head. “You need not worry yourself. We are safe. You will be glad, Frodo, to hear that Mandos is not as forthright as Oromë. He does his duty quietly and never stirs from his Halls. His task is not a joyous one, but he bears no one ill-will and would not do us harm.”

His words proved true, for they passed the tower by with no trouble. The Keep was not foreboding, exactly, but there was a sombre, funereal air about its intimidating spires that convinced Frodo that he would not wish to tarry there long. It occurred to him that Boromir might dwell somewhere within those walls, and perhaps good Théoden too, whom Merry had loved.

Rest well, he thought. He hoped that Mandos would judge them kindly.

As they walked, the snowfall tapered and then ceased. By dusk both sky and ground were dry and the Company could peel away their over-clothes. The gloomy air of the Keep and the cold seemed to have put everyone in a contemplative mood, and camp that night was unusually quiet.

Frodo squeezed his bedroll between Ori and Bofur and burrowed under their shared blankets, avoiding Bofur’s icy toes and ensuring that Ori’s beard wasn’t caught underneath his head. (He had woken up more than once with the imprint of braid-beads upon his cheek.) Warm and snugged between two very hairy furnaces, Frodo fell asleep between one breath and the next.

It was dark when he woke. The campfire had burned itself down to mere embers, and no one was stirring -- not even Balin, who had been keeping watch, and was now slumped with his chin on his chest, snoring softly. Frodo shifted, cautious of waking his bedfellows, and rolled over to go back to sleep. His eyes turned by chance to the scrub-tree where Tauriel had laid her blankets earlier that evening.

The blankets were gone -- and so was the elf.

Frodo sat up in alarm. Ori stirred and settled with a soft grumble, and Frodo kept himself very still, unwilling to wake the entire Company if Tauriel had merely moved her bed or stepped away for a moment to attend to private business.

But no, the bed and her packroll and bow were gone. Kíli was nested between his mother and uncle, and there was no tall, red-headed bundle curled up anywhere else around the camp. Wriggling out from under Bofur’s heavy arm, Frodo crawled through the bottom of the blankets and stood up for a closer look. Unless some dreadful beast had snatched her up without a fight -- which Frodo found utterly implausible, considering -- Tauriel had left and taken her things with her, no doubt not intending to return.

This conclusion brought with it a measure of hurt, for Frodo had begun to count her as a friend, but mostly he felt fear for her safety. Aman had already proven itself difficult to travel and full of tricks and snares, and the thought of her becoming lost with no one to help her was more than he could stand. The copse they’d made camp in was surrounded by wide, open fields that stretched for miles without a single swell of a hilltop; he was sure that he would be able to catch a glimpse of her and see where she had gone if he would only go a little ways beyond the cover of the trees.

It was the work of mere minutes to slip his bow and a few arrows from his pack and fill a lantern with a spoonful of smouldering embers. Throwing his cloak over his shoulders, he took up his things and crept over the sleeping dwarves. Gandalf sat reclined against the trunk of a tree, wrapped in his robes. His eyes were open (which still unsettled Frodo, even after all this time) but he was clearly deep in slumber -- he didn’t so much as twitch as Frodo stepped past him and slipped away into the shadows of the wood.