Chapter Text
CHAPTER FIVE
THORIN
“HE’S GONE! THE LAD’s gone!”
Although it was not the cry itself that woke Thorin (that dubious honour could be attributed to a reflexive kick from Fíli’s iron-capped boot), the words nevertheless struck a chill into his sleep-fogged mind. He sat up to find Bofur and Ori rifling frantically through their blankets, the other dwarrows groggily stirring around them.
“What are you yammering about?” Óin groused, rolling over and shielding his eyes from the early morning sunlight.
“Frodo’s gone!” Ori wailed, and in an instant Thorin was on his feet.
The next few moments were utter calamity and confusion. No bedroll was left overturned, no scrub-bush undisturbed, but the halfling was nowhere to be found. Gandalf, who had woken with a snort and a startle, seemed as bewildered as the rest of them, if not remotely as alarmed.
“Where would he have gone?” Óin yanked at his beard in consummate frustration. “Why would he leave in the middle of the night?”
Ori lifted his blankets for the third time in as many minutes, as if he expected Frodo to suddenly appear underneath them. "How did he leave camp without anyone seeing him?”
Balin’s look of horror was answer enough.
There was a clamour in the trees. Kíli tore through the underbrush, wild-eyed. “Tauriel’s gone!”
Frerin looked to Thorin blankly before cutting a warier glance at Kíli. “Could they have run away?”
Mahal, Thorin had not sworn to keep Bilbo’s kinsman safe even a week ago and already he had lost him! Inflamed by his helplessness, a ghastly suspicion was beginning to creep into his heart. “Or the elf forced him to go.”
This caught Kíli's attention. “She would never!"
“We know nothing about her, nor her purpose here.”
Kíli slapped his brother’s placating hand away with an incensed snarl; Fíli fell back, looking hurt. “You know nothing about her!”
“Watch your tongue,” Frerin cautioned.
“Watch your own! You shame me, behaving as though she doesn’t deserve your esteem when she's trying to help you.” He whirled on Thorin next, and the fire of his temper was all his mother's. “You most of all, pretending that you don’t know what it is to love someone who isn’t a proper dwarf!”
“Atkât!” Dís bellowed. It seemed to Thorin, who scarcely felt able to draw a proper breath, that everyone had grown very quiet.
Gandalf's staff came out then, nudging Kíli back a few paces. "Indeed! You are being absurd, the lot of you, and I have had quite enough of this. Frodo is a capable, fully-grown hobbit, not a fauntling who has wandered away from his parents. Think for a moment. He has taken his weapons and his coat, as well as one of the lanterns. He is neither unarmed nor unprepared. Calm yourselves and find something useful to do. Breakfast wouldn’t go amiss, I think. Frodo is not in danger -- nor is Tauriel,” he added, when Kíli looked fit to erupt. “Let them be. They will come back when they wish it, and no sooner.”
“And you know this how?” Dís said curtly.
“Because I make knowing things my business.” He lowered his staff and looked at Thorin narrowly. “Again, I ask: do you trust me?” At Thorin’s brusque nod, he cast his eyes over the others. “Our companions will return in their own time. We will wait here for them. Rest. Eat, avail yourselves of a bath in the river -- Bifur, my dear dwarf, I strongly recommend that bit in particular -- and tend your weapons. We are in no hurry today.”
With much grumbling and glaring and several mutinous grimaces, the search was abandoned. Bofur lingered behind. “I’d be willing to wager a vein of silver that you enjoy being as clear as obsidian, Master Gandalf," he remarked.
“At my age, one takes enjoyment where one can. Rest assured that no harm will come to our friends. I would be first among the rescue party were it not so.”
“Aye,” Bofur conceded. “I can see you love the wee lad. Still, next time, mightn’t you suggest to him that he leave a note? Near to gave Ori and me a fit.”
“You may suggest it yourself, when you see him.”
Bofur seemed satisfied then. For a moment, he looked as if he might say something else, but then he tugged down his hat, gave Thorin a rueful smile, and rejoined the others.
Gandalf broke the silence with a mild, “Perhaps you might like to avail yourself of the stream as well, hmm?” and courteously left Thorin to tend his humiliated wounds in peace.
*****
“May I join you, laddie?”
Thorin waved a listless hand to the grass beside him, and Balin sat with an exaggerated, creaking groan. For a little while they each kept to their own thoughts, watching the river that rushed past them, bubbling softly and sending up clouds of white lather where it dashed against the bank.
“If nothing else, our folk do know how to make a pother," Balin murmured.
Thorin exhaled slowly. “You knew.”
Balin nodded.
“Did everyone?”
“You’ll have to ask,” he said, after a brief hesitation. “I can only speak for myself.”
A rush of scalding shame swept Thorin from head to toe, and his face grew hot. That his most intimate feelings should have been a subject of gossip around the fireside was unbearable. His Company, his kin, had made a laughing-stock of him, sniggering over his clumsy missteps, his pitiful failure of a courtship. “I have been made a fool of.”
“Now, Thorin, it’s not what you’re thinking.”
“How did you know?” His cheeks burned in the cool air, and it was pride alone that kept the wetness from his eyes. Was he so uncouth? He had been certain that he had concealed it well. It had only been a selfish wish, after all, easily put aside for the sake of the quest.
“How many years have I known you?” Balin admonished. “How long have I served the throne? How many years have I stood by you, and followed you, and loved you?" He gripped Thorin's arm and gave it a stern shake. "No one was laughing at you. No one thought ill of you for it."
“I only knew him a year,” Thorin said. “One year out of nearly two-hundred. I hardly liked him for some of it. It's daft, after all this time.” Yet . . . yet for all its brevity, it had felt real, and true. His folk did not give of themselves lightly. "But I felt the rightness of it. I did.” It had been sheer exhilaration, the satisfaction of producing a blade without flaw or placing the purest-cut gem squarely into its setting. Deep in his weakest self, he longed to feel it again.
“I cannot advise you in this,” Balin admitted, his hand still fast and firm. “I never had the desire for that companionship. I had my friends and my kin, my treaties and books and the inner workings of kingdoms. I lived a good life and never felt the want of someone to share it with.” He paused. “A vein of gold can be found in the most unpromising rock. You recognized his worth, Thorin -- aye, the time was brief, but that does not make it any less genuine.”
In truth, Thorin had been affronted that Mahal had given him a round, finicky halfling, a thief who was not a thief, a clever teller of riddles and a lover of food and green growing things -- a creature who had neither a beard nor braids of honour, who cared nothing for gems and could not comprehend the beauty of stone. Surely it was some error, some poor jest at Thorin’s expense. They were nothing alike, as different as fowl and fish. But the Thorin who had dismissed a spineless green grocer with one glance had not been the same Thorin who found his eyes straying toward their Company’s smallest member at every turn. He was not the Thorin who had sought and trusted a hobbit’s counsel above all his kin, who had looked to him for guidance and advice, and who had dreamt tempting dreams of soft, damp flesh and a welcoming body curled sweet and warm beneath his. He was not yet a Thorin who wished for impossible things.
“Did he mourn for me?”
Balin looked tired. “We all did. My brother was never the same after losing you and the lads. I cannot speak for Bilbo. I saw him perhaps once every five years or so, if we were fortunate, and hobbits are different. They are quieter in their grief, and not much given to displays or ceremony. But yes, in his own way, I believe he mourned you. For many years he could not speak of your death, and he once told me he treasured the mithril corselet as something to remember you fondly by.”
“Fondly,” Thorin echoed.
The edges of Balin’s mouth curled. “That shirt could have bought the Shire four times over, and he kept it in an unlocked trunk under his bed.”
Thorin managed to find a small, incredulous laugh for that thought. How very like Bilbo, who valued biscuits above jewels and treated a priceless treasure like a knick-knack. No matter what became of it, it had been worth the gift. Through the dizzying haze of the dragon-sickness, the sight of the hobbit in his gleaming mail had been a dash of cool clarity; in that instant Thorin had wished for nothing more than a coronet to place above Bilbo’s queer pointed ears.
“Did he . . . do you think he might have . . . “
“I don’t know,” Balin said, very delicately. “I’m sorry.”
Thorin nodded and took a measured breath. The tightness in his chest was not gone, but there was some relief to be found. Perhaps speaking of it was not so terrible as he had feared.
“What do you expect?” Balin asked, apropos of nothing.
“What?”
His friend made an encompassing gesture to the water and lush flatlands around them. “When we see young Frodo returned to the elvish city -- when we arrive in Valinor and bring him home to Bilbo -- what do you hope for?”
It was a question that Thorin did not have an answer for. What did he hope to find in Valinor? One very old hobbit, whom he had loved long ago and who might possibly remember him as a departed friend, if he were very lucky? “I do not expect anything from him. But I would like . . . I would like to know, I think, whether I was alone in what I felt. I wish to go back to the Halls with a settled heart. Is that too much to ask?”
“No. No, I don’t believe it is. But he will be changed, Thorin. You will not find him the same hobbit you knew then.”
Thorin looked away. Balin leaned over, his hand at Thorin's neck, and brought their heads together somberly. “You cannot go back.”
“I cannot help but wish that I could.”
“As do we all.” Balin gave his brow a firm bump and withdrew.
“Uncle?”
Kíli stood at the edge of the trees, sheepish and uncertain of his welcome; Fíli, always the protective shadow, hovered at his brother’s back.
“I’ll leave you to it." Balin rose and shook the loose grass from his breeches. With a nod to Thorin he went away, giving Kíli’s shoulder a bracing clap as he passed.
“Come here,” Thorin said.
Kíli came willingly enough, brave lad, and Fíli followed. Kíli folded himself down to kneel on the grass and bowed his head. “I'm sorry, Thorin. I spoke out of turn and offered you insult.” His hand darted up unconsciously to rub at one reddened ear -- no doubt Dís had given it a smart tug.
"You did, but you weren't alone in it." Thorin looked at the birds-nest of the lad's dark hair and the proud curve of his nose, and for the first time it occurred to him that he had wronged them both. So many long years he had looked at his sister-sons without seeing them. His eyes had been filled only with the memory of their spilled blood and the fog of his own terrible guilt. They sat before him now, breathing, alive, their faces filled with light. How had he not seen them before? How had he not recognized this great blessing? “Kíli, if the elf -- if Tauriel has been chosen for you by Mahal, it is no power of mine to call your bond unworthy. For my own part, you were right to call me two-faced.”
Kíli’s mouth dropped open. Thorin might have smiled under other circumstances, but Fíli was not so circumspect: he chuckled into his fist. His brother seemed not to hear, or to care, for he was staring at Thorin with amazement. “I . . . you . . . .Thank you, Uncle. Thank you.” He paused then, and the delight in his smile was shadowed with regret. “I meant to be cruel. I knew the mention of Bilbo pained you. I will go back to the others and tell them that I was talking nonsense.”
“You weren’t, though he was never mine.”
Kíli sat frozen on his haunches, and this time open astonishment was painted on both lads’ faces. Kíli rocked forward to rest his cheek on Thorin’s shoulder. “I’m sorry,” he said miserably.
Thorin reached out to cradle his bristled cheeks and soothe his worried brow. “You are braver than your uncle,” he murmured, “who had happiness in his grasp and no courage to take it.”
Kíli clung to him on one side and Fíli on the other, and Thorin held them close. They were a gift he did not deserve, his lads, but that he had been given it nonetheless and would waste no longer.
“We have missed you,” Fíli said, voice muffled in Thorin's coat. “I know you didn’t want to upset Amad . . . .”
“But we do miss you,” Kíli finished.
Thorin clasped them a little tighter. He thought, with wistful amusement, that Dwalin would have laughed and told him that he had gone soft as pudding in his dotage.
***
As they gathered around the fire that evening to dry off from their bath, Fíli settled in front of Thorin and wordlessly handed him his comb. There was a moment of tension as all eyes turned to Dís. She regarded both of them piercingly before returning her attention to Kíli’s hair, which she was attempting to arrange into some semblance of a braid. Thorin felt Fíli let out a soft, grateful sigh.
Thorin closed his eyes briefly before taking up the comb. With the ease of decades of practice, he smoothed down the wet strands and divided them neatly into Fíli’s customary braids: one in memory of his father, one each for his mother and brother, two for honour in battle, and finally the thick, four-stranded braid of Durin’s folk, wound together with a thinner Longbeard plait. When the golden strands were properly bound, Thorin added the only ornaments Fíli ever wore: a misshapen silver bead clumsily forged by Kíli for his brother’s coming-of-age day and a large ruby clasp made by Thorin and Dís together, a gift to signify the standing of his chosen heir.
When he finished, Fíli shifted to kneel at Thorin’s back.
Sitting patiently as Fíli teased out the knots -- his hair, like his mother’s and Dís’s, had always had enough waves and curls to be a trial to brush -- Thorin cast his eyes around the fire. It was quiet tonight, all of them still anxious about the continuing absence of their smallest companion. Bofur plucked idly at his fiddle while Bifur wove beads (and somewhat inexplicably, twigs) into his hair; Balin and Óin were playing a game of chess with differently-sized pebbles, Ori keeping a watchful eye out for any dishonesty.
Fíli moved in front of him to separate strands for Thorin’s customary forelocks, and Thorin looked down -- his eye was caught by the flash of his signet ring, its crest glinting in gold and black.
He had once been a dwarf with pride, even with his beard shorn in remembrance of lost Erebor. What had happened to him that he had let himself wear nothing but two practical plaits to keep his hair from his eyes at the forges of Men? Why had he put away his beads and unraveled his braids, set aside his history and forgotten his place? His love for his home had become a need for the mountain itself rather than the dwarrows who had once filled it.
“Fíli,” he said, “be a good lad and fetch my pack.”
Fíli obliged. In the very bottom of the bag, stitched into a little hidden pocket, were a handful of beads that travelled with him from Erebor to Ered Luin and back, a meagre but beloved treasure that had followed him into the afterlife. Plain and intricate, gold and stone, jewelled and unadorned, they were the beads of his history, given to him by his mother and father, sister and brother, friends and kin.
He offered his open palm, heaped with beads, to his sister-son. “It has been far too long since I’ve worn these.”
Fíli made quick work of it, nimble fingers not prone to pulling too tight like his mother’s were. “There,” he said, voice brimming over with pride. “You look very well.”
Thorin reached up to feel the heaviest braid at the hollow of his nape, tied with two beads, and drew it in front of himself to study -- a five-stranded plait of courage in the Longbeard style, woven with simple marble clasps given to him by Fíli and Kíli. His throat felt tight.
“One more braid, I think,” he said. “A small one, three-stranded, behind my left ear, with Fârfil’s Knot.”
Fíli’s hands paused, the comb halfway through a stubborn tangle, but a moment later he resumed his task. “With a bead or without?”
Thorin plucked up a wooden bead, carved one idle night at Beorn’s. “This one.” It was a rough, uneven thing, with a poorly-done engraving of a sunflower scrolling over its length. He remembered whittling it with his paring knife, modeling it after one of the massive blooms that Beorn had allowed Bilbo to take with him as a talisman. Bilbo had carefully pressed and dried the flowers between the pages of one of his jealously-guarded books. As they travelled through Mirkwood, Thorin had often caught him looking at them longingly, touching the withered petals as though the mere shade of something green and good could cast away the sickness of that cursed forest. Trapped in the dank prison of Mirkwood, Thorin had often rolled the bead between his fingers and wondered what Bilbo would say if he made a gift of it to him.
Fíli dutifully wove the tiny braid and slid the bead on the end before looping it around and tying it back. He drew away and looked at Thorin uncertainly.
“Well done,” Thorin told him, fingering the new braid reverently.
At the fire, Frerin drummed his spoon loudly on the side of the iron pot. “Stew’s ready!”
“Stop that. We can hear you fine.” Dís released her grip on Kíli, who shot off toward the promise of dinner with his hair no neater than it had been before. Frerin gave her a look and dealt the pot one more slow, deliberate wallop. Fíli laughed, and Thorin shook his head despairingly to conceal his smile. His beads clinked pleasingly with the movement, and in that moment, he felt just as he had when he had seen Erebor from the Carrock -- as if a piece of himself had been taken up, dusted off, and put back in its proper place.
Fíli scurried up to claim his portion; Thorin had risen to follow him at more dignified pace when Gandalf drifted over, bearing two steaming wooden bowls. He handed one to Thorin.
“It will be dark soon.” Thorin took a sip of the broth, dark and rich, and rooted out a few sizable chunks of potato and venison, seasoned with some herb or another. Frerin had always been a decent cook. “I could take a lantern and wait for Frodo and the elf by the edge of the camp.”
“They will be back soon,” Gandalf said patiently. “By morning at the very latest.” He cast his eyes over Thorin's hair, smiling faintly, but when his gaze fell on Thorin's ear, his brows crept up his forehead. “Should I congratulate you, Thorin?”
Thorin could not quite prevent his hand from rising instinctively to the tiny braid behind his ear. “No,” he said shortly.
Gandalf gave him another look, and into his too-knowing eyes came a light that Thorin had learned to heartily dislike. “Forgive me. Perhaps my knowledge of dwarfish hairstyles is not as accurate as it once was.” With a mocking little nod, he wandered away to observe the chess game, which had evidently become heated if Ori’s raised voice was any indication.
This day had brought with it far too many upsets for Thorin to trouble himself over an infernal wizard. He sat back, ate his dinner, and resolved to find a good lantern.
*****************
FRODO
UPON LEAVING THE CAMP, Frodo had fully intended to wander no farther than the edge of the wood to see if Tauriel was within sight and to call for the others if she wasn’t. He had not gone far, however, before it occurred to him that the modest forest seemed much denser than he recollected it being. Lifting his lantern high, he studied the thick tangle of pale birches with rising alarm. Had they not been tall, sturdy oaks before? He must have been travelling so long that his memory for surrounding scenery had begun to fade. Uneasily he went on, certain that the canopy would eventually open out into the fields.
It did not.
With no sign of Tauriel, and no clear path to follow, Frodo reluctantly decided to turn back. Having no reliable manner of retracing his steps, he promptly grew disoriented. Which way had he come? Which direction was he going? He stopped and peered around desperately, but there nothing in sight but old trees and shadowy underbrush, without so much as a footprint in the dirt.
In a matter of moments, Frodo had become well and truly lost.
“Bramble-headed, soft-heeled bumblebroth!” he swore. What a doltish faunt he seemed, running off on his own at night, leaving no note, and getting himself turned about before he’d hardly gone a mile! He had journeyed across Middle-earth with some of the finest Rangers and travellers and learned their skills and tricks of survival, and now he’d run off senselessly like the greenest adventure-seeker.
Gandalf would be furious!
“Where is your head, Frodo Baggins?” he scolded himself, bending to hurriedly rekindle his lantern with twigs. The last thing he needed now was to stumble about in the dark. “A fine thing it would be if everyone should have to waste time rescuing you.”
“Calm yourself now.” He turned this way and that, and stared up at the stars as if they might helpfully arrange themselves into a map, or perhaps a useful arrow to point him in the right direction. “This is not so very different from that time you and Pip got lost in a rainstorm in Buckland, and Sam had to come and find you.” But it was different, wasn’t it? This time there would be no timely rescue from Sam, no indulgent relatives to cluck and scold and ply him with warm blankets and piping hot tea.
Oh, even Pippin would laugh at his foolishness now.
No doubt the dwarves would discover their missing companions and come looking for them. Oughtn’t he wait here that they could find him more easily?
“Should you ever become separated from your party,” Aragorn had told him one day, as the Fellowship had struggled through the rocky terrain outside Imladris, “or lose your way on the path, wait for us. Do not wander any farther, but allow us time to follow your tracks.” He’d huffed one of his rare laughs then, and had given Frodo’s shoulder a gentle nudge. “Unless you are being tracked by orcs. They can follow trails as well as we can.”
“In which case, flee as fast as your legs can carry you,” Legolas had added dryly.
It had seemed like reasonable advice at the time, but Frodo was not keen to settle down in an unfamiliar forest in lands unbound by Middle-earth’s rules and reason, lest there was another pack of spectral wolves lurking about. No, he would keep going and hope that the dwarves would think to let Gandalf lead the search party. Frodo was not afraid that they wouldn’t find him -- he was too accustomed to his friend’s preternatural ability for appearing when he was most desperately needed to believe that -- but the humiliation of requiring rescue from his own rescue attempt was no paltry thing.
Disheartened, he wound his way gradually through the trees. He could not say how long he walked. The moon was still high when he finally broke out from the woods to find himself right back at the river. It was undoubtedly the same river they had been following -- it was the same size and clear blue-grey colour -- and he eagerly slid down the steep incline to its grassy banks. The starlight on the water was brighter than the glow of his lantern, and it was calm and quiet. Though he strained his eyes in every direction, there was no yellow glow from the dwarves’ campfire anywhere in sight.
Tired and thirsty and longing for a good breakfast, Frodo sat on the grass with his head in his hands.
If he could not even step away from his companions without getting himself thoroughly lost, how in the Green Lady’s name did he expect to go on to the Timeless Halls? He began to doubt that he would return to the Bay with any answers. Perhaps Ilúvatar would not find him worthy of an audience and turn him away unheard. He ached to think of coming home with no good news, forced to watch his uncle shrivel into a twisted shadow of what he had once been. The thought of his own fading sent thrills of sick fear through him. The Ring would break him too. He would linger for centuries as something less than himself.
What had he been thinking? How had he ever believed that he was capable of finding a cure when Galadriel and Elrond and even Gandalf could not?
The more he thought of it, the more his anger and sorrow throttled him. He saw Sméagol, melting into the fire with shrieks of joy. He saw horror steal over Sam’s face as Frodo held Sting to his throat. He watched Gandalf fall down and down and down, the Balrog’s fiery whip still lashing behind him. He felt Mount Doom’s scorching heat under his toes and bent under the agony of knowing that he was helpless, that the Ring had won after all.
Frodo wished desperately for Bag End, for Brandybuck Hall and his laughing, carefree cousins. He longed for his grandmother’s embraces and his father’s songs. He missed his childhood, those days when he had known nothing beyond the Shire and had not yet learned what it was to feel pain. He wished he had never even heard the word ‘adventure’. He wished that he had not spoken out in Rivendell, that he had let his uncle bear the Ring to Mordor. He wanted Sam. He wanted his mother.
His despair overwhelmed him, and he began to cry.
Frodo cried until he thought the tears would choke him, but he could not stop. He wailed and clawed his fingers into the dirt. He shook and trembled. He mourned for all he had lost, all that the Ring had stolen from him. He cried for what he had become. When he had no more tears left to spend, he lay limp and exhausted on the grass.
A bubbling sound made him lift his stinging cheek from the ground. In the middle of the river stood a tall woman in a white hood, weeping.
Frodo blinked the dewy film from his vision, but the figure was still there, swaying back and forth against the current. Her slender brown hands hid her face. Tendrils of inky hair dripped in straight line from her hood, rippling out in the water with the folds of her cloak. Her sobs were pitiful, and Frodo's eyes spilled with tears again.
He could not have said how long he sat there watching the woman weeping in the starlight, but after a time her sobs slowed. Her hands fell away from her face -- no tears stained her skin, and her eyes were as the void of the night sky. She looked at Frodo, and the air prickled against his wet cheeks. She turned her head, and slowly, slowly she sank into the river until the top of her white hood vanished and nothing remained but the swift tumble of the current.
Frodo sat up and wiped the dampness from his face. He watched the water, sniffling, and took account of himself.
He felt raw and sore and weary down to his bones, but the hurt was pleasant in some strange way, as if the pain was no longer so overwhelming as to leave him numb. His hand rose unconsciously to his chest. Something hard and blackened had fallen away, a knot inside him unbound at last. Perhaps he was no great adventurer, and no great hero. Perhaps Ilúvatar would not see him. Perhaps he would return to Valmar with no answers. But he would try, as he had always had.
“Thank you,” he said fervently, and he swore he heard a soft, silvery laugh.
************************
A brief nap and a quick wash in the river did much to renew Frodo’s determination. As dawn broke, he felt confident enough to try his luck again.
He gathered up his things and reverently lay a sprig of wildflowers at the water’s edge as an offering for the Lady of Mercy. As he set it among the rocks, a river pebble washed up next to one foot, nearly on top of his toe. He plucked it up. It was a pretty turquoise stone, polished by the current to a diamond-shine. He slipped it in his vest pocket and climbed back up the slope of the bank. He followed the river, declining to venture into the woods again, but it was not long at all before he heard a faint call behind him. He turned to see Tauriel running up the incline, one hand raised high and the other clutching her bow.
“Tauriel!” She looked unharmed, and so heady was his relief that he hugged her around the waist before he could the think better of it. She seemed more surprised than displeased and even gave his head an awkward, amiable pat as they parted.
“Why are you out here alone?” she asked sternly, drawing back to look him over with a discerning stare. “I found your trail and saw that you had left the dwarves’ camp.”
“I was following you, but I'm afraid I made a muddle of it.”
“You came looking for me?”
“I was afraid something might have happened to you to make you leave so suddenly. Not that you can’t do what you wish, of course, but friends look out for each other.”
“And are we friends?”
“I would like to think so.”
There was more warmth then in Tauriel’s countenance than Frodo had seen from her before. “I would like to think so too.” She bent to grasp his shoulder and gave him a scolding shake. “But kindly refrain from running off from the party by yourself again. You are no woodsman.”
“I have no intention of going away by myself again,” Frodo said fervently. “But are you quite sure you’re well? You did leave of your own choice?”
“I did, and a poor choice it was.” She slung her bow over her back. “Will you give me a moment to find the words? I will tell you all.”
“You don’t have to tell me anything.”
“No, I owe you an explanation, seeing that you left camp for my sake.”
Tauriel claimed that she knew where the dwarves were, and Frodo was content to follow wherever she led. They walked for some distance in silence before she said, “I went to Mandos's Keep."
Frodo looked up at her in astonishment. “How did you get inside?”
“I turned back before I reached it. I had hoped to gain entrance to the Halls of Waiting and find my mother. I heard what Mithrandir said, but I thought, if there was slightest chance . . . . “
“He wouldn’t deceive you. If there were a way, he would help you find it.” Frodo cast about for words of comfort. “If he says it is not to be done, then it isn’t.”
She closed her eyes and nodded curtly. “I know.”
“I'm sorry,” said Frodo gently.
“I was very young when she died.” Her steps slowed, and the look in her eyes was far-away. “She was a wine merchant, and we were bringing the barrels through the Greenwood. We were set upon by thieves outside the kingdom’s gates.” Frodo saw her hand stretch back to touch the curve of her bow, as if to reassure herself that it was still there. “I do not believe the Men intended to kill us. But my mother drew her sword, and one of them fired an arrow into her heart. They took to their horses and fled without taking anything.
“A guard found us, headed by King Thranduil; I did not recognize him. I must have looked like a wild thing, half-mad with my grief. I held my mother’s bow with an arrow pointed at his throat and told him I should kill him if he came closer to us.” She smiled a little, and the corners of her lips trembled. “He asked me if I would like to come stay in his palace. He was kinder in those days, less hardened."
"Did you go?" Frodo asked, though he already knew the answer.
Tauriel looked out over the trees, her face distant. "I have never been blind to his faults, as they are many. He is as unforgiving as he is strong, as prideful as he is clever, and there is greed in his heart. For all his flaws I loved him and served him gladly for the mercy he showed an elfling.
"I did go with him. He buried my mother with all the honours of a king and kept his word; I was raised in his household by one of his couriers, to become a member of his Guard when I was grown. Aratha was good to me, and I did come to care for her, in time. But I could not love her like I loved my mother.”
“I'm sure she didn't expect you to."
“Maybe not,” she said. “She wept when I told her I was sailing West. She begged me not to go, but I would not hear her. All I could think was of myself, and how weary I was, and how I longed to be among my family again. I left her alone. It was a poor repayment for her kindness.”
Frodo felt she would neither heed nor appreciate more empty assurances, but he shifted to walk a little closer to her and felt some of the tension leave her.
“I went to the Keep. I looked up at the walls and knew what my mother would say if she saw I had given up before my time was spent. When I see her again, I thought, I could not face her, nor go to the Halls of Waiting with pride, if I fell without a fight. And so I turned around and came back.”
“I’m glad you did,” Frodo said. “I should have missed you.” When she smiled at him, he ventured to add, “And I’m very glad you came to find me. I don’t think I’ve eaten for an entire day!”
Tauriel laughed. It was a pale, half-hearted sort of laugh, but Frodo was glad to hear it. “I do not think you shall starve, for the camp is not much further. You need not thank me. Truth be told, I was glad for an excuse to stay away a while longer. I do not know what I will say to Kíli.”
“The same things you've said to me? He will forgive you, if he is as fond of you as he seems. Family is very important to dwarves. He will understand why you left.”
She tilted her head curiously. “Are all hobbits so wise as you?”
Pleased, Frodo turned away to hide his reddening cheeks. “We’ve been called many things, but wise is not usually one of them.” His attention was captured then by a wisp of grey smoke, trailing boldly in the clear sky. “Do you see that?"
“Someone has left a beacon for us.” She quickened her steps with fresh energy, and Frodo hastened to keep pace. “Come then, Master Frodo -- we will find our camp, I shall speak to Kíli, and you may have your dinner!”
