Actions

Work Header

And in the Darkness Bind Them

Chapter 7: The Mount of Manwë

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

 

 


 CHAPTER SIX


THORIN


 

 

AS SUDDENLY AS HE had vanished, young Frodo returned to the camp the next morning with the elf at his side. An excited clamour rose among Thorin’s kin, and the poor hobbit was swarmed. A residual strain eased from Thorin’s shoulders at the sight of Frodo hale and unharmed, if rather flustered by the commotion.

Óin had elbowed through the ranks and was now insistently trying to peer into the hobbit’s ears and nose, lamenting that he’d no doubt managed to catch cold spending a night away from the fire’s warmth; Frodo, spluttering and blushing, was vainly attempting to fend him off. Sitting on an overturned log with his ever-present pipe, Gandalf watched the chaos unfold with evident enjoyment. He caught Thorin’s eye and gave him a merry wink.

Wisely, Thorin kept his distance. Once everyone had calmed, however, he could not resist approaching Frodo himself and inquiring if the little lad was indeed as unhurt as he appeared.

Frodo, still apple-cheeked, assured him he was and apologized very earnestly for giving them all a fright.

“No harm done,” Thorin said gruffly, and he was rewarded with a smile.

“Come have some breakfast, Frodo,” Bofur called, uncovering the pot of porridge they’d left to warm over the embers of last night’s fire. “You must be hungry.”

“In a moment, please and thank you!” Frodo said, and he nodded politely to Thorin before scurrying to Gandalf's side. They conferred in hushed voices, and then Gandalf drew the hobbit into a gentle embrace before shooing him away to his breakfast.

When the furor had passed and everyone was content once more, Gandalf tamped his pipe and called the Company together. Mount Taniquetil, he told them, was now only a short distance away; if they left at dawn on the morrow, they could begin their ascent that very afternoon. He advised them to spend one more evening resting and conserving their strength, for it was a considerable climb to the peak.

The thought of being so close to their goal brought renewed determination to them all. Packs were adjusted and distributed for weight, food and water sufficient for a long climb were gathered and shared, and their furs readied for the cooler weather of the heights. In no time at all they were prepared for the last leg of their journey, and Thorin was left with nothing to do. He even applied himself to a little mending when he found a tear in Frerin’s cloak, but that was soon finished and his restlessness would not let him sit idle. He was in no humour for conversation and too anxious to sleep. He circled the camp, stepping out again and again to look out at the horizon, as if the mountain might  appear before his eyes.

The thought of bringing his supplications to Manwë, king of the Valar, was not frightening to Thorin. Though he had a healthy respect for the keepers of Valinor, everything he had seen and encountered in his travels thus far had exhausted his reserves of wonder. He was impatient to be done. His only real concern was that Manwë would keep them there for a while, rather than sending them on their way with their cure. Thorin longed now to leave and see their quest fulfilled, though in his darkest thoughts he feared its end for what he might find there.

As he prowled aimlessly around the camp, his mind turned again and again to the one task he had left unfulfilled. It was not a pleasant one, and he had long pushed it aside. With nothing to occupy his mind or hands, and with their journey nearly at its end, there would be no better opportunity.

That evening, when supper was eaten and the camp bedded down, he cordially asked to speak with the hobbit. Frodo seemed surprised by the request, and quite curious, but he betrayed no nervousness as he walked with Thorin a short distance away from the fireside.

“I have neglected to give this to you, Master Baggins,” Thorin began, once he was assured of their privacy. “I prepared it the night after we escaped the dragon’s lair, but I did not know how to speak of it to you.” From the pocket within his tunic, he withdrew a thick, oiled lock of his own hair, bound with a tough leather thong. It had been a cumbersome weight in his pocket for too long. “It is payment for a debt of honour,” he said formally, offering the neat braid to Frodo.

The halfling took it by rote instinct and looked at it as if he hadn’t the faintest notion of what to do with it.

“It is a reparation. As Bilbo’s closest kinsman, I ought to have repaid my debt as soon as I met you. Forgive me for tarrying. I did not know if I would have to explain the circumstances to you, and I could not find the words.”

Frodo's eyes widened a little, and the look that came over him was guarded and uncertain. “If you’re speaking of what you did to Bilbo on the battlements, I know about it already.”

Thorin refused to wince -- he would face his crimes with the dignity of a son of Durin. “When your uncle defended me from my enemy’s blade, I swore that he would always have my protection. I broke my oath the moment I raised my hand to him in anger. You would be within your rights to ask for another braid on his behalf.” He grasped the slender hunting knife in his boot, intent on making good on the promise, but the hobbit cried out in alarm.

“Oh, no, no! No, I don’t . . . thank you, but I’d rather not, if it’s all the same to you.” He thrust the lock toward Thorin plaintively. “Please, I don’t want your hair.”

A heavy stone dropped into Thorin’s belly. “You would refuse it?” he asked, far too harshly.

“I don’t mean to offend you! I only . . . .” Frodo uttered a squeak of frustration and wrung his hands. “Hobbits don’t . . . we don’t expect reparations if we aren’t the injured party.”

Would the ways of halflings never cease to be absurd? “You do not?”

“No! Well, that is to say, family feuds do happen in the Shire sometimes, though very rarely . . . . Sam did tell me once that the Gamgees and the Hobbiton Burblossoms were at odds for generations over accusations of cheating at a tuber-growing contest. Old Marl Burblossom was  convinced that Gaffer Gamgee’s great-great-aunt had salted his vegetable garden and tried to have her disqualified from the competition. It caused a great scandal. Why, the Gamgees didn’t invite the Burblossoms to a birthday party for nearly a century! Can you imagine? It was a nasty business.”

Thorin sought, and failed, to find an appropriate response.

“Well, in any case,” Frodo said stoutly, “what good would it do to be angry at you for an offense that wasn't done to me? One, I should add, that Bilbo forgave you for?” He pressed the braid back into Thorin’s hands. “You don’t owe me anything.”

“I nearly took his life.”

“I don’t deny that it was very bad of you. But you were sick, and I can see that you are sorry for it.” He sighed, sitting down on a nearby boulder. His toes did not quite brush the grass. “A friend once told me that it is not our mistakes that define us, but rather how we choose to make amends that speaks most truly of who we are.”

“One of the wizard’s speeches?"

Frodo’s eyes lit and his teeth flashed in a grin, and for just a moment, Thorin saw that perhaps he had once been a very merry lad who had not had shadows in his laughter. “I’m afraid it was an elf friend.”

Thorin grunted.

Frodo kicked his furred feet and wriggled aside to clear a spot on his boulder. “There was a Man I was once knew -- Boromir of Gondor.”

Thorin took the offered seat. “The name is familiar.”

“He was the son of the steward of Gondor, and the ninth member of our Fellowship. Now the tale is told that he perished in battle defending my cousins.” He fidgeted and then seemed to settle with another sigh. “That is true, but it’s a half-truth. He died protecting them after he tried to take the Ring from me.”

Thorin was struck by a vision of some violent, snake-eyed Man brandishing a sword at Frodo's neck.

“He frightened me, and threatened me. He looked half-mad, and if I had not run away, I believe he might have killed me. For all that, I didn’t blame him then, and I remember him fondly now. In that moment, he was not himself. He could be harsh, and often arrogant, but he was a good man of honour and courage, and he was kind to my cousins. He would never have hurt me had the Ring not poisoned his mind.”

They sat quietly for a while.

“It’s a pretty night,” Frodo said softly, when their silence had grown deep and comfortable. “Do dwarves ever watch the stars?”

Thorin turned his face to the night sky to hide his amusement. “Do you think we never leave our caverns and halls? Some watch them, and some do not. Our old poets were fond of them. Their light has been compared to every kind of gem and precious stone.”

“We look for shapes in them, like we do with clouds,” Frodo said. “It’s a game, of sorts, to see who can pick out the constellations first.” He pointed at what, to Thorin’s untrained eye, looked like a blurry cluster of light. “See? There is the pumpkin, and the turnip, and the soup ladle . . . oh, and there’s the vine of grapes. That one’s very hard to see if it’s a cloudy night.”

“Are all of your constellations food?”

There was a pause. “Most of them.”

Thorin bit his lip to stem the chuckle rising in his chest.

“Thorin?”

“Yes, Master Baggins?”

“I will take your braid. I’ll carry it safely back to the cottage and then you may give it to Bilbo yourself.” He held out one small palm, and with great ceremony, Thorin laid his shorn hair upon it. Frodo bound the braid carefully in a handkerchief before tucking it into his coat, and this time Thorin did not suppress his smile.

“You are very like him, sometimes,” he said.

“I'll consider it a compliment.”

“It was intended as one.” Thorin came to his feet, his task done and his heart the lighter for it. “Goodnight, Frodo. Rest well, if we are to scale our mountain tomorrow.”

 

*****

 

They left the plateau at dawn, walking in an orderly line down into the valley. The woodlands and grassy banks gave way to a cobblestone road, set with small flecks of silver and mica. A pleasant wind stirred the clouds overhead, carrying on it the scent of tree-bark and clean water.

Gandalf had spoken truthfully; they had not travelled longer than an hour before they crested a rolling hill to find the lush mountain valley on the other side. At its center a tremendous silver peak stretched toward the sky, wreathed magnificently in smoky white clouds. At Thorin’s side, Gandalf exhaled sharply and came to a sudden halt. The Company clustered around him, some rising to their toes for a better view. "Mount Taniquetil. The highest mountain in Arda."

“Beautiful,” Dís breathed, and Thorin had to agree.

“Have you been here before, Gandalf?” asked Frodo, craning to see over Bifur’s shoulder.

The wizard laughed. “If I have a home,” he said, “it is this mountain. From the moment of creation, I served the Keeper of the Skies and the Keeper of the Stars. I dwelled with them here for many, many years, watching from its peak as the world took shape.” He breathed deeply of the air. “I did not realize how very much I missed it.”

With their destination before them like a shining pillar, the Company went down into the valley below. Ori, never one to ignore an opportunity, was pressing Gandalf for more tales as they walked. “You must know Manwë well.”

“I do, though I have not seen him since I went to Middle-earth. It was Manwë who first sent me there, along with my brothers.” Gandalf looked thoughtful, and then he chuckled again. “I did not want to go.”

“Whyever not?” Ori asked incredulously.

“Because I was afraid. And that was why he said I must.”

Dís, who had been listening attentively, raised her brows at this. “Are you certain he will help us?” Her face was pinched with worry. Thorin felt a rush of affection for his sister, who had never met nor loved Bilbo Baggins and yet had become as invested in the outcome of their journey as any of them.

“Will he be displeased with us if we arrive without notice?”

“I would not trouble yourself, Frodo. The Valar are not hardened against the sorrows of the world. Even Mandos was moved to pity by the love of Beren and Lúthien -- though I do not see how any soul could have been untouched by them.”

Ori's face lit with amazement. “Did you meet the Lady Lúthien, Gandalf?”

“Indeed I did, and a fairer sight I have not seen since. Nor, for that matter, a more fearsome warrior. The stories do not do her justice.”

“No stories ever could,” Tauriel said (sounding rather smug, to Thorin’s ears) from where she walked with Kíli and Fíli. “All elflings hope for two things as they grow: to have the honour of Eärendil and the courage of Lúthien.”

Gandalf gave his staff a contemplative twirl and looked down at Frodo, who trotted alongside him. “It was Manwë who gave his blessing for Mandos’s gift of choice to Lúthien. He is not the mightiest, but all of the Valar look to him for guidance, for his chiefest strength is his kindness. He values the sweet air of his mountain more than all the great treasures of Arda together. His compassion is so great, in truth, that it has blinded him.”

“Blinded him?” Kíli repeated, frowning.

When Gandalf spoke again, it was with the eerie cadence of well-learned recitation. “As the Ainulindalë stitched Eru Ilúvatar’s perfect creation together, already it began to unravel. Melkor, most beautiful and powerful among the Valar, became corrupted by the breadth of his own strength. He saw that he was mighty, and jealousy of his Maker consumed him. As his envy grew, so too did his contempt for his brothers and sisters, who were content to follow Eru’s will. His heart was blackened and hardened, and he forgot what it was to love them. He crept in the shadows and wound notes of discord into the Ainulindalë.

“The Valar were distraught to find their song corrupted. It did not take them long to discover what Melkor had done. But Manwë loved his brother and had so little understanding of what it was to be wicked that he gave to Melkor many chances for redemption. For Ages, Melkor intervened in the fates and wrought destruction on Arda and beyond. He sought at every turn to defy the will of Eru. He made the orcs and goblins, twisted mockeries of The Children, and cursed all that was fair and good. Tulkas the Warrior, last of the Valar to descend, realized what Manwë would not: Melkor had become Morgoth, warped beyond all forgiveness.

“Mere imprisonment, far in the deepest depths of Mandos’s Halls, was not enough to contain Morgoth's evil. Tulkas took counsel with Varda, who kept watch from her Starry Realm and saw more clearly, and together they went to Manwë to proclaim that Melkor was lost. It took much persuasion, but at last it was resolved that Morgoth could not be redeemed. Manwë cast his brother, with many cries of grief, into the Void.” An old pain deepened the well-worn furrows of Gandalf’s face. “It was a wound that not even Nienna’s tears could soothe. The Valar do not sit high on their thrones, indifferent to the fates of other beings. You do not need to be afraid, any of you. Manwë will hear you.”

Though it was a familiar story that Thorin had heard before, it had never seemed so immediate. He pitied Manwë. He knew what it was to be betrayed by one beloved.

“If Taniquetil is your home, will you go back there to stay?” Frodo asked, in a very subdued voice.

“I am happy enough to make a nuisance of myself in Valmar for the time being. Someday, yes, I will return to Manwë’s household, for I have been away too long. But it will not be for some time. I have unfinished business still.” The wizard smiled, brushing his hand through Frodo's hair. “I could not leave you and Bilbo now, could I?”

It seemed they had scarcely descended the ridge before the base of the mountain was in reach. To Thorin, who found beauty in the sharp peaks and hollows of mountain stone, Taniquetil rivalled the majesty of his own adored Erebor. At its lowest levels, the rock split in a series of magnificent waterfalls, likely fed by an underground spring. Above the veil of water, the mountain was cut into wide terraces as lush and green as hanging gardens before the foliage parted to reveal a cap of mica-flecked stone. At the mountain’s base, the cobblestone road came to an abrupt end. In its place was a narrow path spiralling up the mountain and beyond the scope of Thorin’s vision. It was a formidable sight.

Frerin shielded his eyes, squinted, and uttered a low oath. “Can you see the summit, Thorin?” he whispered.

“No.”

“Is there a summit?”

“You shall find out soon enough,” Gandalf said, and with a hand on each of their shoulders, he steered them forward. “For now, my dear dwarves -- and hobbit, and elf -- we climb.”

 

 


 


FRODO

 


 

 

In the last years of his life in Middle-earth, Frodo had scaled far too many mountains to take much pleasure in the ascent of Taniquetil. The road was smoothly-paved and rose gradually enough that it was not too great an effort to maintain a rapid pace. Like most hobbits, he was also not overly fond of heights, but he was kept largely sheltered from the sight of the dizzying drop; Bifur and Bofur, determined not to lose him again, had hemmed him firmly in between them.  

The wind grew stronger the higher they rose. Eventually Bofur was obliged to keep one hand firmly planted on his head, lest his hat take flight, and Frodo, as the lightest of their party by far, had to struggle against the headwind whenever they turned into it.

Frodo had no notion of how long they climbed, but eventually the peak leveled off. Built into the tallest spire of the mountain was a towering citadel of golden rock -- sandstone, perhaps, or something very like it. It was very simply-hewn, merged into the mountain itself with only a large glass dome and a row of enormous pillars to draw attention from its staid square walls. As they emerged onto the flat, Frodo saw a small town behind the citadel, its silver-thatched roofs and spires scarcely visible over the high walls that surrounded it.

With no hesitation, Gandalf strode toward the long flight of steps that led to the citadel’s wooden door, overlaid in silver with the image of a scrolled tree. He stopped just before the first step and knelt. Thorin, who had been following Gandalf, lowered himself to his knees as well, and with that the other dwarves hastened to follow suit.

Frodo had to steady himself as he squatted down, and he was surprised to see his own fingers shaking on the ground in front of him. Crouched beside him, Ori reached over and gave his wrist a subtle, reassuring brush.

They waited there, silent and tense, for only a moment before a shadow fell across the rock. Unable to help himself, Frodo peered up to see an eagle drifting serenely on the wind overhead. Its feathers shone gold in the sun, and as if flew past them, the door of the citadel opened. A tall, slight figure emerged, and Frodo’s heart leapt.

Manwë, Lord of Air and Winds, and chief among the Valar, took the aspect of an elf, though his brown cloak was cut in the style of Men. He bore a sceptre studded with blue stones; the fingers holding it were tipped in long tapered nails, like talons. He descended the steps, and as he came closer Frodo realized with a start that his glossy dark hair was not hair at all but slender feathers.

Gandalf lifted his head at his lord's approach, and Frodo saw that his hands shook too.

Manwë drew Gandalf to his feet and embraced him. “My beloved Olórin.” His voice was the rumbling of faraway thunder and the sighing flutter of the wind in the trees. He clasped Gandalf’s face in his claws, brushing over his white beard with a hint of a smile. “Rise, all of you. What a curious collection of guests you have brought me: elves and dwarves and hobbits travelling together.”

Frodo’s breath caught as Manwë’s eyes met his. They were not the eyes of Men, or of elves, nor dwarves or hobbits either -- they were the unearthly golden eyes of an Eagle.

“You have come for the sake of the first Ringbearer."

For one dreadful moment, speech was beyond Frodo; he remembered Gandalf’s story and bore up his courage. “We have travelled very far on behalf of my uncle, my lord,” he said. “We seek Ilúvatar to ask for his mercy.”

“No one may pass through the Timeless Realm, mortal or otherwise, before his time.” Manwë's gaze turned to Gandalf, and Frodo saw that his friend was startled. “You have been away from us too long, Olórin. There is no passage between Valinor and the Timeless Realm now that Arda has been divided.”

Frodo saw Thorin’s eyes close in despair. Desperate panic took him and he dropped to his knees again, bowing until his forehead touched the earth. “Please, my lord! He is very ill.”

Manwë lifted Frodo’s chin. It was an earnest struggle to meet his gaze, for his face was too beautiful and terrible to look upon directly. “There is a great debt to be paid to you, Frodo, son of Drogo, for what you have done. I will tell you this: the Ring is gone. It has no power over its Bearers.”

Frodo trembled. “I . . . I don't understand.”

“The Ring has no hold on you."

He heard the words, but they were senseless, meaningless. He felt Gandalf’s hand at his back, steady and warning, and he took a breath to clear his head.

“What of Bilbo?” Thorin demanded, and his voice was strained. “Have you no answer for us?”

Frodo winced, but Manwë did not seem angry. With his pale eyes he watched Thorin, who did not bend his proud head under the scrutiny. With a flick of his robes and a stir in the air, Manwë began to withdraw. “I will confer with my lady wife and see what is to be done. In the meantime you may stay here and rest within my halls. I offer food and drink and my hospitality.”

"Come along," Gandalf said, and he helped Frodo to his feet.

Manwë led them through the door and into a vast entrance hall of stone, lit with dozens of silver lanterns and windows that stretched from floor to ceiling. He directed them to a door at the hall’s end and departed with a bow, bearing Gandalf away with him. The dwarves began to stir, murmuring amongst themselves, but Frodo stood still, feeling as though he’d been swept over by a violent gale. Balin noticed him first and turned back, drawing the attention of the others.

"Let’s not give up hope now, laddie." He put his arm around Frodo's shoulders. "Not when we’ve come so far.”

“Yes, surely this is good news," said Fíli.

“He’s a strong wee thing, and we'll get our answers soon enough. Don't you fret about him," Bofur added.

They passed through the door into a truly astonishing chamber. To Frodo’s eyes, the glass-domed room looked like nothing so much as one of Olo Proudfoot’s famed aviaries. Birds of all shapes and sizes flitted about the high ceiling: proud hawks and gentle little jays, gulls and mockingbirds and ravens, common grey and brown birds and unfamiliar birds with plumage of magnificent jewelled hues. There were birds as wide across as Gandalf's hat and tiny flitting birds the length of Frodo’s thumb.

The chamber echoed with sweet songs and calls, and Frodo felt a measure of his tension fade. He was here, in the Halls of the most revered Vala in Arda, and Manwë had given his word to seek an answer. If he could not have hope here, he would have hope nowhere. He listened to the birdsong, and for the moment, he let his worries be soothed.

Under an elaborate tent of cloth-of-gold was a low, round table, surrounded by a profusion of cushions and silks. Twelve golden plates and goblets were laid around it. No sooner had they seated themselves than a beautiful white owl fluttered into the tent, a stoppered decanter of red wine clasped in its talons. With a rather lofty hoot, it offered the bottle to Balin, who took it with an obliging nod and a word of thanks. After a moment, a brown barn-owl followed, bearing another bottle. Frodo could not help but smile as a flock of chattering magpies brought them platters of cheese and fruit and hot, crusty breads, suspended in gossamer netting that they clutched in their little claws.

“It’s like Beorn’s house!” Fíli accepted a butter knife from a tiny bird that was puffing under its weight. “Do you remember his animals?”

“And the hounds that walked on two legs,” Kíli hooted.

Before long, their feathered servers had overfilled the table with good things. The food was delicious and the wine heady and tart, and the melodious twittering of the birds made for the most pleasant sort of dinner-music. As they ate and drank, a fat, speckled little sparrow made itself comfortable in Frodo’s breast pocket, and happily exchanged a warbling song for crumbs.

The dwarves seemed equally charmed by their attendants. If he hadn’t been told once that the denizens of Erebor had long revered birds as valued pets and messengers alike, Frodo might have been startled by Ori cooing as he patted a bold bluejay that had helped itself to his plate, or Balin indulgently allowing a robin to peck at the snowy strands of his beard. Certainly he would have been amazed to see Thorin with a raven perched on his shoulder, speaking to it softly as he fed it a generous palmful of plump red berries.

It was without a doubt the strangest dinner party Frodo had ever attended.

After eating their fill, and with nothing else to do until Manwë or Gandalf returned, they settled down to rest. Brimming with wine and good food, Frodo curled up on the silken cushions, the sparrow already dozing in his pocket, and was asleep almost before his eyes closed.

He did not know how long he slept, but when he woke everyone was asleep, and slender silver lanterns hung at the corners of the tent. He rubbed his eyes and shifted, producing a sleepy, indignant little chirp from the sparrow. Stroking its downy head apologetically, he stretched, careful not to move too suddenly, for Tauriel slept soundly at his back with Kíli’s head propped against her shoulder. Frodo yawned and blinked; he pulled up the blanket over his chest, and realized that it was Thorin’s fur mantle. Thorin himself was lying at the other end of the tent in a pile with his brother and sister and snoring loudly. Frodo touched the soft fur, smiled to himself, and drifted back to sleep.

It wasn’t until the birds had cleared away the remains of a hearty breakfast the next morning that Gandalf returned, ducking into the tent with a pigeon clinging to the top of his staff.

“Come now,” he said, with no preamble. “Thorin, Frodo, come with me. Tauriel, you as well. Manwë has called for you.”

Frodo hurried to make himself presentable, shooing the sparrow away, straightening his coat, flicking stray crumbs from his breeches, and bemoaning his lack of a brush. Now that it was time to have his answer after so many long weeks of travel and doubt he found that his nerves were fraying. What would Manwë say? What if he had no good news, or no solution at all? He startled as a brisk hand smoothed down his curls, and he twisted around to find Dís behind him.

“There,” she said kindly, and she tucked another curl behind his ear. “Have courage for your uncle now.”

He nodded, throat too thick for words. After a murmured conference with Balin and Frerin, Thorin joined them, and Gandalf led the three of them from the chamber.

 

****

 

In a lush courtyard at the citadel’s centre, Manwë waited for them. As Frodo and the others arrived, he nodded to each of them and politely inquired if there had been enough food and adequate bedding and if they had rested well.

For once, Frodo had no patience for pleasantries; in his mind he resolved to thank Tauriel later for graciously answering Manwë’s inquiries when he could not.

“Be easy,” Manwë said, and Frodo thought with mortification that perhaps he had not hidden his impatience so well as he thought. “Yestereve I called a council with my brothers and sisters so that we might send you home with hope. We are in agreement. Listen now: take a flask of the headwaters of Sister Nienna’s river from the valley below this mountain, and seal it securely. Carry it back to your kinsman. Have him drink of it, and he may find his cure within himself.”

Silence greeted this pronouncement.

A red flush was rising under Thorin’s beard. "If this is a jest, it is a poor one."

As one, Gandalf and Tauriel glared at the dwarf. But Frodo had no attention to spare for any of them. He was thinking of Nienna and her white hood. He thought of the cool weight of the river-stone in his pocket. He remembered feeling unbound, how the numb, bleak shell of pain had cracked inside him beside the water, and suddenly he understood.

“I couldn’t forgive myself,” he said aloud. Thorin and Tauriel turned to look at him; Frodo closed his eyes against their stares. “I couldn’t let go of what I had done. The Ring was gone but I couldn’t let go. That’s why. That’s why I left. It was me all along.”

Manwë was watching him again, and his gaze was full of tender sorrow.

“Oh,” Frodo said, and he hid his face in his hands.

There had always been pauses in Bilbo’s stories, things left unsaid, blank lines on the page. Bilbo had turned away in horror the night he gave Frodo the mithril shirt; how bitterly he had wept as the Fellowship left Rivendell. In some way Frodo had known that his uncle felt responsible for finding the Ring, that he believed that he had passed on an unfair burden.

The Ring had not been holding onto them. They had been holding onto it. Little wonder that both of them had been eaten up by their own grief.

“Frodo,” Thorin said. His hands hovered in the air between them. “What is it?”

“It will work, Thorin. The water will cure him.” Frodo knelt at Manwë’s feet and took up the hem of the Vala’s cloak. He kissed it with all the gratitude in his heart. “Thank you,” he said. “Thank you.”

“I have done nothing.” He drew Frodo up and touched his lips to Frodo’s brow; his skin was cool, the brush of his feathers soft, and warmth spread down to the tips of Frodo’s toes. “A thousand blessings on your head. For what you have done, may you know peace and contentment until your mortal years are spent.”

He released Frodo then and turned to the others. “Thorin, son of Thráin,” he said, “do not despair. Brother Aulë is as unmoving as stone, but his love is enduring in equal measure. The winds of home do not change course.”

Thorin bowed low.

“Tauriel, daughter of Taulién, I bear you a small token from my lady wife.” From Manwë’s talons dangled a crystal pendant that glowed with an unfaltering golden light. “It is a beam from the favourite star of she whom you call Elbereth Gilthoniel -- light from one lover of the stars to another.”

Tauriel accepted the gift with trembling hands.

“You may stay as long as you choose as my guests,” Manwë said, “but I suspect you wish to return to Valmar.”

“I would not wait,” Thorin said, “but let it be Frodo’s choice.”

“I would like to leave today, my lord,” Frodo replied at once. The shock was beginning to ebb and joy and relief swept in to take its place. He was filled with impatience and eager to be away. Oh, that he could whisk himself back to Bilbo this instant!

“As you wish, so it will be done,” Manwë said gravely. He extended his hands out before him, palms turned to the sky. The amber of his eyes sparked like kindling. The clouds overhead stirred and the air around them grew heavy, like a humid summer day before a rainstorm. A gust of warm wind fluttered his cloak, darting playfully through the courtyard and ruffling Frodo’s hair.

“Call for your friends,” Manwë declared, and below his flickering eyes, his smile was soft. “I will send the easterly winds at your backs to hurry you home.”

 


 

 

Notes:

Hypothetically, if there were to be a rather . . . explicit one-shot sequel to this fic, would that be something that people would be interested in? Hypothetically.