Actions

Work Header

And in the Darkness Bind Them

Chapter 8: The City of Bells

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

CHAPTER SEVEN


 

THORIN



 

 

IT WAS THE WORK of mere minutes to gather the Company together. Though Kíli and Frerin pestered him for news of the council with Lord Manwë, Thorin would not spare them more than brusque reassurances and an admonition to hasten their steps; his every thought was fixed upon the elvish city and the little cottage on the coast Frodo had described so fondly.

Frodo seemed just as impatient to be away, and his obvious agitation did more to hurry the Company along than any of Thorin’s reproaches. The hobbit was bobbing about and fretting over collecting enough water.

“We’ll worry about that when we get to it,” Balin said, reeling him in with a tolerant hand. “I think we’ve enough water-skins between us.”

With everyone corralled, the Company followed Gandalf through the winding halls and out onto the steps where Manwë waited for them.

“Are you ready to return, Frodo Baggins?” he asked, and the hobbit crimped himself into an earnest kowtow and declared, "Very ready, my lord, please and thank you.”

“Then I shall send you on your way. Collect the water as I have told you, but do not stop to rest. Thorin Oakenshield, Brother Ulmo has crafted three boats to bear you and your kin on the Sea back to Aulë’s Halls. They will be waiting for you in the Bay of Eldamar when you should have need of them.”

Thorin bowed and repeated his own thanks.

To each of them, Manwë gave his blessings and well-wishes. The clouds overhead began to churn, the winds sped around their feet, and the air seemed to draw together with coiled tension. “Farewell, Ringbearer! Farewell, King Under the Mountain! Farewell, Daughter of Taulién!” He raised his hand, and the skies opened in a shrieking gale. “Farewell, my Olórin, and may you return home to us soon.”

“Walk!” Gandalf exclaimed over the howling of the winds. He was clutching his fluttering hat to his head and looked entirely too gleeful. “Take a step, and keep walking!”

They did, and it was the strangest sensation Thorin had ever experienced in his long life. He walked, yet his feet did not touch the earth, and the ground shrank below them. Each step felt that it spanned a mile, every movement as buoyant and effortless as a stroke through calm water. Through the winds, he heard Kíli and Fíli hollering in delight, and he was nearly tempted to join them. How astonishing it was to be as weightless as a leaf carried on the wind!

In a few strides they were halfway down the mountain; a few strides more brought them to valley below. The magnificent waterfalls bubbled and churned beneath their boots.

“Your water-skins!” Gandalf said. “Do not stop walking, but uncork them and let them drift through the falls as you pass.”

Thorin wrested the stopper from his skin and let it dangle from its strap as the spray of water neared. It skimmed fluidly through it, and when he drew it up, it sloshed heavy and full. He sealed it and heaved it back over his shoulder.

Ahead of him, Frodo was having some difficulty. The heft of the water-skin and the lightness of his own figure kept pitching him forward, windmilling in the air, though he struggled valiantly to stay upright. Finally the elf, who was nearest him, slung the poor hobbit onto her back like a furry-footed knapsack.

Down they passed into the mountain valley, over the plains, over rocky cliffs and thick brush and fields of blooming flowers and grains. They passed still, mossy lakes and fierce rapids, walled cities of gold, fields of snow and barren, arid deserts of shifting amber sand. They passed the green canopies of forests and trimmed gardens, hills and vales, and they watched as the solitary peak of Taniquetil diminished on the horizon. All the while the river glittered below their feet like a beacon, guiding the winds east.

As they drifted over a forest of towering oaks, the wind began to slow. The current bore them gently down to the road that curled around the wood, and at last their boots touched down. It felt odd to be on solid ground once more, though Frerin, green in the face, looked as though he were tempted to kiss it. Frodo uttered an audible sigh of relief as Gandalf helped him down from the elf’s shoulders.

Kíli was breathless with laughter, his cheeks wind-burned. “Gandalf, could we do that again?”

“Once was enough,” Dís said, her own face rosy pink.

“Look at those beasties,” Bofur exclaimed, shielding his eyes from the sun as he squinted up at the colourful canopy. “I don’t think I’ve ever seen trees so tall. What is this place?”

Thorin's attention was diverted by rustling in the trees; a dim light bobbed beyond the cover of brush. He caught his sister’s eye over the heads of the others and let his hand fall to Dragonsbane’s hilt. Immediately she stepped up to stand beside him, sheltering the lads from the sight of the forest, and her fingers hovered casually over the handle of her war-axe. Frerin was too far away to call over without attracting notice, but he was standing near Frodo, and Gandalf was close enough to ably defend them both.

His caution was overly hasty. At the next breath, an elf-maid in a silver cape emerged from the woods, a lantern aloft in her hand. Frodo let out a glad cry. “Lady Galadriel!”

The famed Elf-Witch of Lothlórien -- Thorin had read mention of her in so many of the ancient poems that she was a figure of legend more than anything else. The witch appeared harmless enough (soft and frail in the way of elves) and her gold-spun hair, he had to admit, shone as purely as diamond. Still, there was an unsettling depth in her eyes, and Thorin knew enough to be wary of that piercing gaze. He leant to the side to shuffle Dís behind him and did not flinch when she elbowed him roughly in the back.

“Welcome,” the elf said coolly, and she did not bow. Her attention flickered first to Frodo, and the indifference of her countenance eased into something warmer. “I see your journey has served you well.”

Frodo beamed at her, hoisting his overfilled skin aloft. “We’ve brought water for Bilbo!"

“I see too that you are resolved to waste no time. Take the path to Valmar, dear one. You will not find your uncle at the cottage on the Bay. He is dwelling with Elrond.”

Frodo’s face fell. “Did something happen?” he asked, and Thorin caught his breath.

“We wished to have him closer while you were away. He knows of your quest. We have been following your progress, for Lord Lórien gifted me many visions. He is eager to see you -- all of you.”

Thorin’s heart stuttered.

The witch paused and lowered her lantern. She studied Frodo with a placid sort of curiosity. Something seemed to pass between them, and she smiled. “If that is truly what you wish, I will go ahead and bear the cure to him."

“Please,” said Frodo, surprising them all. “You will be quicker than us. Let him drink it in peace.”

To be so close and endure another delay. . . . “Frodo."

The hobbit's chin had a stubborn tilt. “I want to see him too, but solitude is what I needed most. I imagine it must be the same for him.”

Thorin nodded despite his gut's relentless churning. It was not his place to make demands. “As you say.”

Frodo addressed the wizard. “Will you go too? Tell him that I love him.”

“Of course,” said Gandalf.

“I shall see it done, Frodo,” the elf said. Her gaze fell to the rest of the Company, clutching their water-skins. “One draught ought to be enough.”

“There is no harm in being cautious, my lady," Gandalf said, as Frodo relinquished his water.

“And we both know you are always cautious, Mithrandir.”

Gandalf chuckled and held out his arm. Lady Galadriel fitted her delicate fingers into the crook of his elbow, and they strode into the woods without a word of farewell. They vanished, not even the sound of footsteps accompanying their retreat. The Company shuffled uneasily at being abandoned on the outskirts of an unfamiliar wood, but Thorin had no time or interest to spare for the bizarre behaviour of witches and wizards. There was a more pressing matter at hand.  

“Do you know the way to the city, Frodo?” he asked, and a hush fell over the others as they realized that their erstwhile guide had left them with no directions.

“I travelled this road with Gandalf when we left, but it was only the once,” Frodo confessed. His eyes drifted over to the elf, who stood before them with her bow and water-skin still in hand.

The indignities I endure for you, Burglar, Thorin thought, not without some irony. “Mistress Tauriel,” he said, “if you could lead us to the city, I would be in your debt.” Seeing the surprise on her face, he found that the sting of debasement was not so fierce as he had believed it would be. Perhaps I truly am growing soft in my dotage.

“I can take you,” she replied. “It is not far.” She slung the strap of her skin across her back and walked with steps firm and sure, Frodo trotting along after her. One-by-one, the others began to follow. As Kíli passed by, he gave Thorin a grin as bright as a sunbeam, and Frerin, following behind him, was insufferably amused. Balin fell into step at his side.

“Steady on, laddie,” he murmured, and Thorin did his best not to hope.

 

*****

 

The city of Valmar was a vast cluster of lofty wooden buildings, terraces, and gardens, walled by the towering trees of an ancient forest. A series of slender wooden walkways stretched through the air from home to home, for the city had been built upon the banks of a tremendous lake, clear as crystal and smooth as glass.

The streets were silent, with few figures stirring on the bridges; the long boats bobbing on the surface of the water were empty. It was disquieting, and Bofur said as much.

“It is high noon.” Tauriel ushered them toward the central bridge, a wide wooden platform that stretched through the middle of the pond and splintered off into dozens of individual piers. “Everyone has gone home to eat and rest. The streets will be crowded again within the hour.”

“It’s beautiful,” Dís marvelled. Thorin was taken aback to find that he agreed. The architecture was too spindly, too frilly, too elvish, and it lacked the majesty of a proper dwarf keep. Yet there was such a calm that laid over the city . . . . something old and settled and safe, as though this place had never been touched by war or illness.

“It is,” said the elf. “Just outside the city, there are springs that feed the lake. They separate into a series of rapids and make a soft, sweet sound when it’s quiet and the wind is right. It sounds almost like bells being struck.”

Dís leant on the bridge's railing to look into the water; the elf paused next to her. When his sister spoke, Thorin heard the wistfulness in her voice. “There is a bedrock found in Erebor that is easily worn away by trickling water. Small cracks form in the stone until winds begin to push through the holes, and it sounds like a chorus of a thousand voices.”

Thorin remembered those caverns. He remembered his mother taking him there as a lad and telling him that it was the singing of the mountain itself. How beautifully Erebor had sung in those days. He prayed it always would.

“I would have liked to have heard it myself," Tauriel said.

Dís drew back from the railing to continue on, but there was a small smile on her lips. “I believe you would have.”

The bridge led them past a market square, its stalls deserted but piled with fruits and bolts of cloth, past a quieter row of homes. Tauriel stopped before a palatial house flanked by hedged, flowering grounds. “This is the household of Lord Elrond,” she declared.

Scarcely had Bofur said “Do we knock?” before Frodo scurried up the stairs onto the sweeping veranda, tapped perfunctorily on the tall mahogany doors, and let himself inside, calling for Gandalf all the while.

There were a few chuckles as the rest of the Company followed, but Thorin, twisted up with nerves, could not bring himself to share in their amusement. The inside of the house was as airy as the outside, and as Fíli drew the door shut behind them, a familiar figure appeared at the top of the winding staircase.

“Upstairs, Frodo,” Lord Elrond said. “It is done. You will find them both in the Blue Chamber.”

Frodo was off like an arrow up the stairs, though apparently politeness was ingrained enough in hobbits as to oblige him to stop halfway up and bid a proper hello to his host before hurrying on. Elrond continued down the stairs to meet the rest of the company. The elf-lord looked unchanged by the years that had passed since last they met, tall and sober in his plain robes.

“Lord Elrond,” Thorin said gravely. Despite his meddling, the lord of Imladris had once offered his help freely, without expectation of favours in exchange. Thorin could not like Elrond, perhaps, but he could respect him.

“Thorin Oakenshield,” Elrond returned. “I had not expected to see you again. You and your companions are most welcome in my house.”

“A pleasure,” Balin said amiably. “Might we ask how Master Baggins is faring?”

“Quite well. I should be happy to tell you more, but I must return to him now. In the meantime, you may stay here and avail yourselves of whatever refreshments you desire.“ He turned his knowing gaze onto their party, a tiny glimmer of good humour in his eyes. “I only ask that you do not dance upon my tables. It haunts poor Lindir still.”

It was an unexpected kindness, and Thorin thanked him as graciously as he could. They were directed to a waiting chamber that led into the open air of the garden. Trays of bread and cheese and nuts were brought to them. Thorin could not eat, but he accepted a goblet of wine and restlessly paced the terrace, back and forth, back and forth.

He could not settle under the veiled glances his kin were giving him. He could not listen to the conversation, or taste the wine, or sit quietly on one of the long benches. He longed to move, to run, to fight, to do something to dissipate the hard knot in his chest. When he could bear it no longer, he brushed aside Frerin's look of concern and stepped back inside the hall. He thought to ask a servant to bring him news, but he found Frodo before him instead.

“I came to get some tea,” Frodo said, lifting the tray in his hands unnecessarily. “Uncle’s not . . . it’s not quite done yet after all. You may sit with me upstairs, if you like. It's difficult sitting alone and waiting. You’re not obliged to, of course -- I didn’t mean . . . .”

“I should be glad to.”

They sat on a bench in a small alcove opposite the door to Bilbo’s bedchamber. They shared the tea between them. It was an elvish blend, weak and overly sugared, but Thorin drank it anyway, and Frodo kept anxiously refilling his cup every time he took a sip.

“Aragorn told me once that Elrond was one of the finest healers in Middle-earth,” the hobbit said, fiddling with the teapot. He had been rambling almost without pause for breath, but Thorin had not interrupted. Talking seemed to comfort the lad. “Only his daughter Arwen was his equal. Bilbo couldn’t be in better hands. And Gandalf is there too. He always knows what to do. Nearly always.”

“Was it painful?” Thorin asked. The thought of Bilbo suffering beyond the door was difficult to endure.

“Pardon me?”

“The healing.”

“Oh, yes, of course. Or, no, it wasn’t. Not really. Not to my body, if that’s what you mean. I cried a great deal, and then I felt better.” He swung his feet, and then said, inexplicably, “That’s lovely.”

After a moment of confusion, Thorin realized where Frodo's gaze had fallen. Without being aware of it, he had been skimming his own hand over the braid behind his ear, fingering the wooden sunflower bead.

“May I?” Frodo asked, clearly eager for a distraction.

Awkwardly, Thorin dipped his head. He felt Frodo very carefully lift the edge the plait to examine the bead. It felt uncomfortable to have someone look at it after so many years of keeping it concealed. “I carved it for your uncle, though you can see I am no whittler,” he admitted. There was no response. He lifted his head to find Frodo with the braid still pinched delicately between his fingertips, staring round-eyed at Thorin. “Have I said something amiss?”

“I . . . no,” Frodo said, still with that same startled look. He released the braid hastily, sat back, and took a loud gulp of his tea.

Behind the wall a faint shuffling sound pricked Thorin's ears. The door cracked open -- a white-haired, wizened figure emerged, wobbling on unsteady legs.

“Bilbo,” Frodo cried, and he was up from the bench and across the hall like a dart to support him. “Sit down, you’ll fall over!”

“Stop your fussing, I’m fine! Give me a moment to catch my breath so I can scold you properly for running off without so much as a blasted note.”

That voice! Oh, that familiar voice, thin and reedy though it was, pierced Thorin through the heart. He was standing before he realized it, striding down the hall toward the two hobbits. The body might have been stooped and bent, the face so furrowed with age as to be almost unrecognizable, but those clever, unclouded eyes were as full of life as they had ever been in Thorin’s memories -- though they watered as Thorin drew closer.

“Burglar,” Thorin breathed, reaching out to hold that beloved face in his palms. He could have wept. “Bilbo.”

Small, trembling hands touched his jaw in wonder and then rudely yanked his ears. “Took you long enough to find me, you confounded dwarf.”

And Thorin laughed.

 

***************************

 

When Bilbo came downstairs, it seemed to Thorin that the shouts that erupted from his Company would bring down the ceiling of Elrond’s elegant receiving room. There were hoots and hollers, embraces and back-slaps, and a great deal of merriment all around.

“My dear, dear dwarves,” Bilbo cried, planting a smacking kiss on Bofur’s nose to the raucous amusement of all the others. “Gracious, Ori, look at you! Such an impressive beard! And Óin, how are you? Oh, for me? Bifur, my darling fellow, what a lovely flower -- thank you, thank you kindly. Fíli! And Kíli too, of course -- oh, my lads, how marvellous to see you again. Come here and let me get a good look at you. Goodness me, how I’ve missed you degenerate lot!”

“Am I forgiven, Bilbo, now that I've brought such visitors home with me?” Frodo cried.

“You’re forgiven a hundred times over, but mind you don’t do it again!” Bilbo did not let go of Thorin’s hand even as he reached out for embraces from the others, and Thorin was perfectly content to be dragged hither and thither with him, for the tiny fingers linked to his were real and solid and kept him tethered when his joy should have swept him away. Bilbo looked as frail as a cobweb, and nearly as colourless, but his wit, his hearty laugh, and the brightness of his eyes were all unmistakable -- it was their hobbit, and no other.

“Balin,” Bilbo said affectionately, having received a careful head-bump from the dwarf in question. “It's been much too long, my dear friend. My hair is as white as yours now! What’s left of it.”

“Aye, but you wear it well.”

“Always the diplomat.”

Once the initial commotion had calmed a little, Bilbo was delighted to make the acquaintance of those whom he did not know. “So you are the Lady Dís! I’ve heard such things about you, courtesy of your sons.”

“Fearsome things, I hope?”

“Absolutely ghastly.”

Dís laughed aloud. It was plain enough to see that she was charmed. Frerin darted several curious glances down to Thorin’s hand, still linked with Bilbo’s. As they were hauled away next by Kíli and Fíli, Frerin gave him a very impertinent wink.

Gandalf joined them after a time, looking pleased with himself. Behind him, a queue of elves followed with goblets and plates, dishes and bowls, and steaming pots of good-smelling stews and baskets of fresh bread. “Compliments of Elrond,” he announced as the elves began arranging their burdens on a long side-table. “A feast fit for a reunion of friends.”

Bilbo was seated by the fire with Thorin on one side and Kíli and Ori practically stacked atop each other on the other, and Bofur’s hat was perched jauntily on his head. The others carried over long benches, and settled in. With so much to talk about, it was a wonder that any of them could eat, but eat they did, and the conversation flowed as freely as the wine. They feasted and danced and sang long into the evening, and even the Lady Galadriel appeared for a short while to gather a plate for herself and listen, with evident amusement, to one of Bofur's bawdy recitations. The evening passed in a haze of wine and laughter and starlight. Thorin doubted that Elrond’s stately home had seen a merrier party.

Frodo could not stop exclaiming over how much better Bilbo looked, how his old energy seemed to have been restored to him. "I haven't seen you look so happy since you went away," he said, and he cried a little on his uncle's shoulder. Thorin smiled at the lad's tender heart -- or perhaps his weak head for wine.

Even so, as one hour slipped into three, and then five, Bilbo was visibly beginning to tire. He waved away Frodo’s concerns flippantly. “Too much to drink and not enough air,” he said, and he turned to Thorin, who still sat at his side. “Take a walk with me, won’t you?"

There was a larger garden attached to Elrond’s back terrace, its hedges and quiet pools lit with dripping silver lanterns and moonlight. For some time the two of them wandered the winding path, stopping every so often for Bilbo to admire a particular bloom or leaf. Flowers had never been a particular pleasure of Thorin’s, but it was pleasure enough to have Bilbo at his side again, his hand tucked securely into the crook of Thorin’s elbow.

At length Bilbo conceded that he required a sit-down. Indeed, his breath was becoming worryingly laboured. Thorin found a low wooden bench suitable for the purpose; it was so perfectly matched to a halfling’s height, in fact, that Thorin briefly wondered whether it had been installed with Bilbo in mind. After they had settled, Bilbo held out his hands, and Thorin took them up. They felt as fragile as vellum against his own rough paws.

“You feel real enough,” Bilbo said, staring at their linked fingers, "but I cannot help but think that this must be a dream, or some mad old fancy of mine.”

“You feel real enough to me.”

“Look at you. You look just as remember you.” He grinned then, a sudden, startling flash, painful in its familiarity; the Bilbo he had known had smiled as though he thought someone might rap his knuckles for it. “I cannot say the same for myself.”

“You have lived your life,” said Thorin. “There is no shame in it.”

“No, no, there isn’t. And I have lived a good one.” His smile became a thin, inscrutable thing, and he released Thorin’s hands to rub his own knuckles, a fussy gesture that had apparently never left him. “But it’s late and you’ve travelled far today. I doubt you want to listen to an old hobbit’s rambling stories.”

“I would listen to an old friend’s stories.”

Bilbo blinked at him, and the deep, tense lines around his mouth seemed to ease. “I had forgotten . . .” He trailed off.

“Forgotten?” Thorin prompted.

“Nothing important. At my age, one forgets many things.”

On the wind a song rose, yet it did not come from the gay party they had left behind. Instead it drifted from the west, across the lake. Elvish voices were so high, and their choruses had such odd and discordant harmonies that there was something haunting about them. “Do they always sing through the night?”

“Very often,” Bilbo said fondly. “The elves of Imladris love dancing and music above all else. There was always music in Elrond’s household, and so there is music here. He has been a cherished friend to me, all these years.”

“He is more reasonable than most of his kin,” Thorin conceded. He had expected a laugh, perhaps, or maybe a scolding, but Bilbo was looking out over the garden and seemed not to hear him.

“Did you know that I became something of an adventurer after our quest?" he said, with an almost absent tone. "I went home but I could not be easy there. My smial was so empty. Hobbiton was so small, so predictable, so uninterested in the wider world. How could I spend my days weeding tomatoes and dusting the mantle when there were mountains to climb and forests to wander? It is strange how life twists and turns. I travelled Middle-earth, here and there, wherever the road led me, until Frodo came to me.” He tugged his coat more tightly over his narrow shoulders. “There was one place, in all my travels, that I never revisited. I couldn’t return to the Lonely Mountain, no matter how many invitations I received. I couldn’t bear to go, knowing that you were not there on its throne.

“Your death was a grief I have carried with me all these years, my dear friend. And I carried it gratefully, for it meant that you were still with me in some small way.”

Thorin did not know what to say or what to think. “I didn’t know that it would have affected you so.”

Now Bilbo did chuckle, but it was an incredulous sound. “Don't be absurd, of course it did. You were stubborn and contrary and horrendously rude, and I loved you.”

A tightness that was half alarm and half elation swelled in the pit of Thorin's belly. His heart pounded. He could not speak.

“Oh. Oh, Thorin. You didn’t know? I was sure that you did.”

“I didn’t dare hope,” he rasped.

“I’ve had a long life for a hobbit. I travelled many places and met many people, but I loved only once.” Bilbo was silent for a time. “I didn’t know how to tell you, at the time, or whether I even should. I didn’t know whether you would welcome it.”

“I would have. I would have begged you to stay.”

“I had no notion that you felt that way. I would never have known it!”

“I had no idea of what it was to fall in love. I had been unlucky in courtship.” Even in his youth he had been plain, and he had had no natural graces like his brother and sister to mitigate it. Once Erebor had been lost, the offers for his hand had all but dwindled to nothing. “When I met you, I was well past my prime, and I had already named Fíli as my heir. Devotion to my people was enough. You were . . . . My affection for you troubled me.”

“I see the years haven't stripped the silver from your tongue,” Bilbo said dryly.

“That is not what I meant.”

“Oh hush, I know. I couldn’t have ever loved you to begin with if I didn't know that you rarely mean what you say.”

“When did you first . . . . when did . . . .?”

Bilbo laughed. “You didn’t make a very charming first impression. I had already settled it with myself that I should be a bachelor, living contentedly with my garden and the company of friends and never wanting more for myself. I didn't go on our adventure expecting -- or wanting, I might add -- to fall in love. You took me by surprise. But by the time we reached Rivendell, at least, I was fond of you, and well on my way to more.”

Before Lake-town. Before Beorn’s house. Before they had reached the foothills of the Lonely Mountain. Bilbo had loved him before any of those things. They would have had weeks, months, if only Thorin had not been so stubborn. Perhaps it would have still ended with the great battle, but they would have known happiness for a short while.

“You have no notion,” Bilbo said suddenly, “of how wretchedly sorry I am. I don’t regret stealing the Arkenstone, Thorin. It was necessary, whatever you may think, but I regretted hurting you so. I've wanted to tell you that for years.”

Would it always come back to the Arkenstone, the bane of his line? Once the thought of it had been enough to sustain all of Thorin's dearest hopes. Now the mere mention of it sickened him.  “In the halls of my fathers, I’ve never wanted it. I’ve never spared a moment to wish for it. I know why you did it. I knew it on the battlefield when my mind had cleared.”

“They buried you with it."

“I know.”

Bilbo sagged forward to rest his head against Thorin’s shoulder, and for some time they were quiet. “It seems a dream. Gandalf told me that you cannot stay.”

Thorin ached. The weight of Bilbo's head against him, the sound of his voice, the press of his hand -- those things alone anchored him.

“You are happy in your Halls, aren’t you, Thorin? It would give me comfort to know that you're going away to a good place.”

The ultimate futility of his journey had been something on which Thorin had not allowed himself to dwell. He had not wanted to acknowledge it. He had fixed his thoughts on seeing that Bilbo was freed from the Ring, and now it was done. But now, with Bilbo in the last stretch of his life, it was clear that this would end in pain for both of them. He could not take Bilbo with him to the Halls, nor could he follow Bilbo to the resting grounds of the hobbits. They must always be parted. Their meetings were fated to always end in goodbyes.

As if he could feel the helpless anger burning through Thorin’s veins, Bilbo lifted his head. “None of that,” he chided. “We have a few days yet. I would be very cross with you if you brooded away all of our time.”

Thorin rose to pace fitfully before the bench. Why had the Green Lady come to him? Frodo had intended to go to Manwë all along -- there had been no need to pull him from the Halls and stir up so many old wounds. He felt betrayed, in some foolish way, that he should have been permitted to find Bilbo only to part with him again. It was a cruelty, not a kindness!

“Thorin, please,” Bilbo said, and Thorin could not resist such a plea. He knelt before Bilbo's bench, and after a moment's thought, he asked the question that had plagued him for over half a century. “If I had asked you to stay with me in Erebor, would you have stayed?”

Bilbo’s chin trembled a little, and he had to blink away the bright sheen in his eyes. “I was a different hobbit in those days. I was still in love with the Shire, with Bag End and my books and my garden. It would have taken some time. But yes, of course. I could have loved Erebor as I loved her king. Of course I would have stayed with you.”

“Forgive me,” Thorin rasped. He rested his head on the wasted plane of Bilbo’s thigh. “We could have had happiness had I not been so blind.”

Bilbo sighed, and his fingers stroked tenderly through Thorin’s hair until Thorin looked up at him again. “It’s enough for a thousand lifetimes to know that you loved me. Can it be enough for you?”

“You have always been more sensible than I,” was all he could say.

Bilbo’s smile was a brittle thing. “We must accept small joys where we find them and hold them close.” Very gently, he withdrew his hand from Thorin’s. “But we ought not allow ourselves to regret it once those joys slip from our grasp, as they must. Our time has passed, Thorin.”

“I know,” Thorin said. He rose onto his knees and pressed a kiss to Bilbo’s mouth. With a heart torn between fulfillment and sorrow, he broke the fleeting kiss and returned his head to its resting place against Bilbo’s knee. After a brief pause, Bilbo’s fingers began to card through his hair once more, and Thorin closed his eyes.

 



FRODO


 

 

HAVING DANCED UNTIL SUNRISE and imbibed more of Elrond’s excellent wine than was strictly wise, Frodo awoke early in the afternoon with a throbbing head and a strange feeling of displacement.

When he ventured out his rooms, the austere halls were still and silent. Lindir was kind enough to direct him to the kitchens, where he might get some breakfast and ‘something for his head.’ He reported that the dwarves were still in their rooms, presumably sleeping off their own revelries, and that Bilbo had risen early, taken a hearty breakfast, and was currently walking out in the southern garden with Gandalf and Thorin. Another reassurance that Nienna’s water had been fruitful, a hot breakfast of honeyed porridge and fried potatoes, and an herbal remedy for overindulgence that one of the elves slipped ever so discreetly into Frodo’s tea were a sufficient boon to his mood; by the time the last crumbs were gone and his tea had been reduced to dregs, he was feeling more like himself.

The afternoon was sunny and warm, and feeling the need for a little air, Frodo wandered out onto the veranda that circled the house. The marble was cool beneath his feet, and the air was filled with birdsong and whispers of far-off conversations from the walkways below. His task was done. Bilbo was healed. His adventures were over.

But some slight disquiet scratched at Frodo still, the niggling sensation that something important had been left undone.  

Turning the corner, he came upon Elrond reclined on a chaise overlooking the garden, a book open in his hands and platter of peeled fruit balanced upon his lap. He turned as Frodo approached, lowering his book with a half-smile. “You look hale this morning. Did Lindir direct you to Ardan and her tea?”

“He did. Am I disturbing you?”

“Not at all.” He gathered his light robes and sat upright, clearing a spot on the chaise. “Have a seat. Would you like some fruit?”

“Thank you, I’ve already eaten breakfast.”

Elrond held the plate out toward him.

Frodo laughed and took a generous handful of grapes from it as he settled himself on the cushions. They sat together and watched the street below as the elves went about their business.

“You know,” Frodo began, placing the bare stem neatly on his plate, “Valmar is beautiful. I’ve always thought it was beautiful. But it wasn’t the Shire.” He tried to put the feelings to words, but it was no easy undertaking. “It still isn’t the Shire, but I feel like I could stay here. Like I could be happy here.”

Elrond closed his book and set it aside. “I'm pleased to hear you say so. It is limiting to think of home as one place, or that home must only be one place at a time. One can have many homes. The Shire was your first. Valmar can become one too.”

“When I said goodbye to Sam and Merry and Pippin, it felt like forever. It seemed as though I should never see them again. Seeing the rest of Valinor . . . I don’t know. I suppose it’s not as dire as I thought. I can wait for them. What is a hundred years in a land that’s been here for hundreds of thousands?” He huffed out a laugh. “I must sound very silly to you.”

“Not at all. For what is six thousand years compared to Eä’s Ages? I am quite young, considering.”

“Positively sprightly,” Frodo agreed solemnly, and he was pleased to receive one of Elrond’s rare chuckles.

“I am glad to see your good humour restored.”

“I do feel better," said Frodo. "It's made it easier, somehow. Not so difficult to go on.”

“Perhaps not all adventures end distastefully.”

“Maybe not. Elrond?”

“Yes?"

“Did you know? About Uncle and Thorin.”

Elrond stilled, and Frodo thought he’d managed to surprise him. “It was no business of mine,” he said at last, with that chastising, fatherly tone he used on his sons when they were being pert.

“You knew, then,” Frodo said. “Bilbo never breathed a word of it to me. All the stories he told, and I never once considered it. Foolish of me, really.” What a shock it had been to find a braid in Thorin's hair bearing a bead carved with sunflowers -- sunflowers, the most ardent representation of passion. And for Thorin to say he had made it for Bilbo, with his own hands! Well! It was a bold declaration by hobbit standards. That level of directness would have caused some second glances in the Shire, though Bilbo probably would have enjoyed the scandal.

“Does it disturb you?”

It was strange to think of his solitary uncle as having loved anyone, let alone someone like Thorin, who was so gruff and grim and serious. Then again, Frodo supposed that most matches seemed incomprehensible to outsiders; his own parents, a wild Brandybuck and a mostly proper Baggins, had been considered an odd pair in Buckland. And what did he know of it, after all? He had never been in love himself. “No, not at all. Thorin has been kind, in his own way, and he’s always spoken of Bilbo fondly. So long as he treated him well, I shouldn’t see why it should concern me.”

“Yet something does.”

Frodo dropped his gaze away from Elrond's too-knowing eyes and added a few more grape stems to the platter. “Ori told me that the dwarves cannot stay here, or they won’t be allowed back into their Halls."

“I heard,” Elrond said. "If the dwarves made a promise to return at a certain time, I would assume it is binding.”

“But if it wasn’t, would Thorin be allowed to stay here?”

Elrond's face softened. “You forget one thing, Frodo. The dwarves are dead. They have passed beyond already. You and Bilbo live yet, and you are mortal. One day you shall both pass on, where he cannot follow. And Bilbo, I am afraid, is very old -- that day will come sooner than any of us wish.”

Frodo looked away. Elves were streaming away from the afternoon market, satchels and baskets in hand. He spotted Tauriel and Kíli in the crowd, for his height and her hair made them rather distinguishable in the sea of elves. He watched them. They walked with strides perfectly matched, their heads bent close, and every so often a peal of laughter rose on the air. Frodo had not known Tauriel long, but he was sure he had never seen her face wreathed with such bright smiles. An enormous daisy sat behind Kíli’s ear, no doubt tucked there by slender, battle-scarred hands. They crossed over onto another bridge and melted back into the crowd. “It seems very unfair that it should end like this, after everything," he murmured.

“So it was when Beren and Lúthien were parted. So it was when Arwen chose a mortal life. So it must be again.”

“It's unfair. Why should anyone be parted from one they love simply because they don’t share the same Maker?”

“It is the way of the world.”

"Love ought to be enough." Frodo unfolded his legs and went over to the edge of the terrace. It was the way of the world, but the world was sustained by the Valar. All the great kindnesses that he had received from them were impossible to reconcile with their role in such heartbreak. “Gandalf said that you cannot have grief without love, or love without grief, for they are the same. If love always ends in pain, why should any of us want it?”

There was a pause. Footsteps padded softly across the marble floor, and Elrond came to stand beside him. “I had a short time with Celebrían, in the full measure of my life," he said quietly. "Her fading was lingering and painful, and as long as I live, I shall never forget her suffering. We lost her twice: once when she sailed West, and again when we came here to find that she had already gone to the Halls of Waiting. Yet, given the choice, I would not sacrifice a single minute that I shared with her. Your uncle is a wise hobbit, with a good understanding of the world. Do not be sorry for them, Frodo. Nor Tauriel and young Kíli. They have known love, and that will sustain them. Perhaps one day, when the world has been remade, they will find each other again.”

“It ought to be enough,” Frodo insisted again.

For a long moment Elrond did not speak, looking out across the gardens. “Yes,” he said at last, and beneath the wry acknowledgement was the whisper of an ancient grief. “It ought to be.”

 


 

Notes:

A thousand apologies for the big posting delay, everyone -- it’s the busiest time of the year for academic libraries, so I really haven’t had any spare time for writing. (Even though this chapter contains lots of salty old Bilbo dialogue, and salty old Bilbo dialogue is my favorite thing ever to write.) Anyway, the last two chapters may come a little more slowly, but that one-shot sequel is definitely forthcoming as well.