Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

 

Actions

Work Header

Everything is fine.

Summary:

When Billy Hargrove wakes up in the afterlife, he's shocked to find himself in the Good Place. Soon he realises that nothing is as it seems, from the way the clouds move to his supposed soulmate. Now, if only Steve Harrington would stop showing up.

Notes:

my contribution to the billy big bang :))

thank you to my beta squid, who once again, came in clutch (ily so much thank you xx <33)

and my artist highlywastedbluejeans who created the incredible banner

i love the good place and i couldnt stop thinking about the st characters in the show :)

hope you like my take <3

Chapter 1: Everything is fine.

Chapter Text

Chapter One – everything is fine.

A faint orange glow filtered through his eyelids, a gentle sweep across his face. Billy struggled to wake, confused as to why he’d been sleeping in the first place. He’d been doing… something else, he couldn’t quite remember. When he finally forced his eyes open, he realised that he was lying on some sort of couch. A very nice couch…

I didn’t go home with some random guy last night, did I?

He sat up. Beside each arm of the couch were potted plants – which, at closer inspection, were fake. In front of him, something was written on the wall in front of him in giant green letters: ‘Welcome! Everything is fine!’

Everything did not feel fine. Billy did not know this place, and Billy did not like this place. It was too… clean. Like a show room, or a rich person’s house, or both. It made Billy feel itchy and weird, like a stray dog who’d wandered into the wrong home.

Even the couch he laid on began to feel like silk beneath his hands. He rose uncomfortably and as he stood, a door he swore hadn’t been there before opened on his right. An older man, with silver hair like the stars and a smile plastered on his face as fake as the showroom Billy woke in, poked his head out.

“Ah, Billy, come on in.”

Stepping into the man’s office felt like meeting the principal, a principal who thought he was ‘down with the kids’ and ‘one of you’, including a random poster of Dolly Parton (signed!) and a framed picture of Tupac (not signed?).

Billy stiffly sat in the chair in front of the large dark desk, staring straight at the wall just behind the man’s ear, a technique honed from years of Neil Hargrovetm. The man clicked his retractable pen, once, then twice and flipped open a file, still smiling his odd, aimless smile.

“Now, to the good stuff. My name is Martin Brenner, and you, Billy Hargrove, are dead.”

Billy stared. Blinked, bit the inside of his cheek, and blinked again. The action hurt but when he ran his tongue over the bite, it seemed to have healed over instantaneously.

“What?”

Brenner smiled again, a patient smile, like a cat watching a bird from the window. “You, Billy Hargrove, are dead.”

“I heard you the first time,” Billy snapped, anxiety rocketing up. “I’m asking what the hell you mean!”

“You are dead,” Brenner repeated again. Billy swore if he said it one more time, he’d knock his stupid teeth out of his head.

“Where am I then?”

“You are in the Good Place.”

Immediately, Billy laughed. It was long and loud and terribly real. He began looking around for a camera or a crack in the wall where Syd or Leo or whoever were peeking through and laughing at him. But there seemed to be no cameras, and the walls remained quiet, as if waiting.

Brenner was still smiling.

“The Good Place,” Billy said flatly, throat sore and chest tight. “Like heaven?”

(Neil believed in heaven, just not heaven for Billy.)

“Sort of,” Brenner replied, still obnoxiously cheerful. “The Christian concept of heaven is only around five percent correct. Same goes for all other organised religions.”

“Was anyone correct?” he asked, mind racing. Heaven was and wasn’t real. Billy was dead and was apparently in Not-Heaven-But-Also-Heaven. He got into heaven despite everything his father said. Billy… belonged in heaven?

“- and let me tell you, we were all so surprised when he started to talk, high out of his mind, and was getting most of it correct! Keith, from Indiana, a legend.” Brenner’s gesture towards a portrait between two windows broke Billy from his thoughts. Billy turned to stare at the face of a man blitzed off his tits, long hair like an oily bowl around his skull.

“Him?”

“Him!” Brenner responded cheerily.

Instead of entertaining whatever was happening over there, Billy turned back to the matter at hand. “How’d I die?”

“Ah, that’s the hard part.” Brenner flipped through the file, not looking incredibly put out by this ‘hard’ task. “Let’s see…” He drew it out, like a parent hiding a present from an excited child, only the present was death. “Ah, a car crash. You were hit by a drunk driver and crashed into a tree.”

Billy blinked. “A car crash…?”

“Yes.” Brenner stood suddenly and said, “Well, you’re here now, Billy Hargrove. Let me show you the neighbourhood.”


The neighbourhood was so picturesque it was sickening. Brenner explained, as he guided Billy down the street, that the setting was tailored to the majority of the residents’ wants and needs. “There might be some things that aren’t for you specifically,” Brenner said as Billy scowled at the pink awnings above every store, “but there’s something for everyone here!”

“Where’s my thing then?” Billy asked, not bothering to pretend he wasn’t angry.

Brenner smiled his fake smile and led him down another fake street and gestured with a ‘ta da’ to…

“Is that a church?”

“Yes,” Brenner’s smile turned tight around the corners, eyes darkening into something cold. “As I’m sure you remember, you were a very religious man in your life, Billy Hargrove. I wouldn’t want to take that from you.”

Billy went cold. The sun shining down on them, which was not a real sun and lacked real warmth, turned cool and dead against his skin. He dug his nails into the palm of his hands, feeling the prick of pain against his flesh.

(Was it real flesh? Billy was dead. Billy was dead and standing in front of a Church specifically built for him in a heaven that wasn’t heaven. But if he was dead, does that make this real? Was he real right now? He’s breathing, why was he breathing? Does he need to breathe?)

(But also… an insidiousness… a feeling of wrongness that beamed down like the fake sun. Neil Hargrove forcing his head down at the dinner table every evening, forcing him to pray to a God he didn’t believe in and telling his son that despite it all, he wouldn’t get into heaven. That now, standing in this heavenly place, after dying in a drunk driving car crash, he was realising that maybe, after everything, Neil Hargrove was right. That Billy didn’t belong.)

“Thank you,” he bit out. He could not tell Brenner what he understood, because he probably was dead and if he didn’t belong here in heaven, then he might belong in… the other place. The bad place.

Brenner smiled, like he knew what Billy was thinking about anyway. “I’m sure many people would love to hear your sermons!” And then, “Let me show you the rest.”

They moved on without a second glance, Billy trailing behind with trembling hands shoved in his pants’ pockets.

There were more disturbingly cozy, pink shops, with people milling around with smiles all across their faces. A weird dystopian world where somehow everyone was happy. Maybe everyone was really happy, but Billy wasn’t sure how long it would last. Wouldn’t people get tired of three frozen yoghurt shops and no alcohol (because this was the worst thing Billy had heard after the fucking Church. No alcohol? What was this? A monastery?)

After Brenner explained that the fountains were all diet coke (what the fuck?), Billy tentatively asked, “How do you decide who gets here and who goes to… the other place?”

Brenner smiled like he’d been waiting for this question. “Well, there’s a point system, you see! Every action on earth has a positive and negative correlation. Save a cat from a tree? Add one hundred points. Cut in line at a checkout? Minus one fifty. Only the top point getters, like you, are selected for these neighbourhoods.”

“Only the top?”

“Yes, about five percent of all humans after death are in the Good Place. Everyone else goes to the Bad Place.”

That didn’t seem right, but Billy didn’t know enough about this whack ass system to dispute it.

Brenner led him down another street, into a row of suburban houses, all neat and formulaic. People were sitting in their gardens and there was a faint scent of barbeque in the air. They waved as he walked by, but the wrongness didn’t leave. All these people were so young. Birds were singing, the sun was beaming down and yet there were no children, no cars, no pets, no life beyond the garden walls.

“Another important aspect of the neighbourhood, one that is our most successful integration, is the soulmate initiative!”

Billy stopped. “The what?”

“Soulmates! Everyone has one! A person suited for them, to love them and be with them for eternity.”

A soulmate. For Billy. The boy so angry and ashamed that all his love had been beaten into the dirt, squashed into the ground along with everything else soft and hopeful. A boy, a man, who would have him and hold him despite everything, despite how angry and ugly and broken he was. Maybe Billy could be happy here, if he had a soulmate.

Brenner opened a baby blue gate and led him down a cobbled path. Small flowers were growing between the stones, almost following them with their heads. Brenner smiled again, like when Neil first introduced Billy to Susan. He knocked on the door.

Nothing.

“Ah, they’re not here right now. Oh well, let’s just make our way in,” and he just opened the door.

“No locks?” Billy asked, eyeing the handle.

“Why would we need them?” Brenner asked with that smile of his.

The house was a stereotypical home, with off-white walls and beige furniture. Billy raised a sceptical eyebrow, but Brenner prattled on about how “each home is a combination of both your likes and tastes. If there’s something you don’t like, please don’t hesitate to ask!”

Billy didn’t like any of it, but the realisation he had by the church was still looming over his shoulder. “It’s perfect,” he gritted out. He didn’t know what would be worse, that he didn’t belong here, or that his soulmate liked beige.

Brenner continued with the tour, showing Billy the kitchen (where there were teabags rather than coffee granules, like a prison), the lounge (the couch was an ugly maroon) and the bedroom (only one bed, and the duvet was leopard print). Billy was growing increasingly concerned about his soulmate’s mental state if this was how he decorated.

In every room, in the centre of the wall, framed rather ominously by a halo of light from nowhere, was Jesus Christ nailed to the cross. It was hung above the toilet, over the bed, distractingly placed above the television. It felt like his eyes were tracking Billy wherever he went.

Brenner stopped in front of the television, a massive flatscreen mounted to the wall, that looked oddly out of place for a home pulled from a show made in the 1980s. He turned it on, smirking at the screensaver (another image of Jesus blessing someone), and said, “If you would like, there’s an option that allows you to view your life on earth. The good and the bad, or in your case, mostly good.”

Filled with apprehension, Billy took the remote and fiddled with buttons. The screen flickered and changed, voices and images distorting until it settled on an image of a ceiling. Billy clicked the play button and closed his eyes.

“Billy, are you awake?” A voice, a kind maternal voice echoed around the room. Billy was hit with the sudden shame that he couldn’t actually recognise his mother’s voice anymore.

He opened his eyes and took in the woman before him. Soft cheeks, soft lips, brown eyes and brown hair curling beneath her chin. A maternal face. A motherly face. A face that… wasn’t his mother’s.

“Billy?” she said, and it felt wrong. Like music played with a different chord.

“You did so much good, Billy,” Brenner said, gently taking the remote. The screen changed again, people Billy didn’t know passing before him, places and things he’d never been to or done blinking in insignificant seconds. A life flashed before his eyes. “Your missionary missions to Africa saved so many lives.” Small faces of hungry children peered up at him. “So many schools built, children fed, and lives changed, all because of you.”

Someone was handing him some sort of award; the name Billy Hargrove printed in gold beneath the words ‘human relief and aid’.

Shame, thick and sour, welled in his chest. A life he hadn’t lived, deeds he hadn’t done, yet here he stood reaping the rewards of someone performing miracles. Because (and this was a truth he could admit about himself) Billy Hargrove was not a good person, and he didn’t say a thing.

Brenner passed another good deed, another life saved. A dog from a flood. A cat from a fire. This other him had been to protests for gay rights and child abuse and war crimes in countries he hadn’t known existed.

“You saved lives,” Brenner repeated.

“Thank you,” Billy replied.


Brenner left him shortly after, cycling through memories like a film reel.

“Your soulmate will be back soon,” he’d said, patting Billy on the shoulder. “I’ll give you two some privacy.”

So now Billy was left to stew in his own selfishness, the sick shame now a consistent tack at the back of his throat. But all he could think about was his soulmate.

What kind of man would he be? A tall man, with broad shoulders and muscles the size of Billy’s head? A man with a thick head of hair and kind eyes? Someone who could argue back? Someone who could calm him down? Keep him safe? Love him anyway?

The door clicked open. Billy tensed and squared his shoulders, ready to meet the man destined for him.

“Hi,” the woman said, seemingly just as shocked as he was. “Who are you?”