Actions

Work Header

Everything is fine.

Summary:

When Billy Hargrove wakes up in the afterlife, he's shocked to find himself in the Good Place. Soon he realises that nothing is as it seems, from the way the clouds move to his supposed soulmate. Now, if only Steve Harrington would stop showing up.

Notes:

my contribution to the billy big bang :))

thank you to my beta squid, who once again, came in clutch (ily so much thank you xx <33)

and my artist highlywastedbluejeans who created the incredible banner

i love the good place and i couldnt stop thinking about the st characters in the show :)

hope you like my take <3

Chapter 1: Everything is fine.

Chapter Text

Chapter One – everything is fine.

A faint orange glow filtered through his eyelids, a gentle sweep across his face. Billy struggled to wake, confused as to why he’d been sleeping in the first place. He’d been doing… something else, he couldn’t quite remember. When he finally forced his eyes open, he realised that he was lying on some sort of couch. A very nice couch…

I didn’t go home with some random guy last night, did I?

He sat up. Beside each arm of the couch were potted plants – which, at closer inspection, were fake. In front of him, something was written on the wall in front of him in giant green letters: ‘Welcome! Everything is fine!’

Everything did not feel fine. Billy did not know this place, and Billy did not like this place. It was too… clean. Like a show room, or a rich person’s house, or both. It made Billy feel itchy and weird, like a stray dog who’d wandered into the wrong home.

Even the couch he laid on began to feel like silk beneath his hands. He rose uncomfortably and as he stood, a door he swore hadn’t been there before opened on his right. An older man, with silver hair like the stars and a smile plastered on his face as fake as the showroom Billy woke in, poked his head out.

“Ah, Billy, come on in.”

Stepping into the man’s office felt like meeting the principal, a principal who thought he was ‘down with the kids’ and ‘one of you’, including a random poster of Dolly Parton (signed!) and a framed picture of Tupac (not signed?).

Billy stiffly sat in the chair in front of the large dark desk, staring straight at the wall just behind the man’s ear, a technique honed from years of Neil Hargrovetm. The man clicked his retractable pen, once, then twice and flipped open a file, still smiling his odd, aimless smile.

“Now, to the good stuff. My name is Martin Brenner, and you, Billy Hargrove, are dead.”

Billy stared. Blinked, bit the inside of his cheek, and blinked again. The action hurt but when he ran his tongue over the bite, it seemed to have healed over instantaneously.

“What?”

Brenner smiled again, a patient smile, like a cat watching a bird from the window. “You, Billy Hargrove, are dead.”

“I heard you the first time,” Billy snapped, anxiety rocketing up. “I’m asking what the hell you mean!”

“You are dead,” Brenner repeated again. Billy swore if he said it one more time, he’d knock his stupid teeth out of his head.

“Where am I then?”

“You are in the Good Place.”

Immediately, Billy laughed. It was long and loud and terribly real. He began looking around for a camera or a crack in the wall where Syd or Leo or whoever were peeking through and laughing at him. But there seemed to be no cameras, and the walls remained quiet, as if waiting.

Brenner was still smiling.

“The Good Place,” Billy said flatly, throat sore and chest tight. “Like heaven?”

(Neil believed in heaven, just not heaven for Billy.)

“Sort of,” Brenner replied, still obnoxiously cheerful. “The Christian concept of heaven is only around five percent correct. Same goes for all other organised religions.”

“Was anyone correct?” he asked, mind racing. Heaven was and wasn’t real. Billy was dead and was apparently in Not-Heaven-But-Also-Heaven. He got into heaven despite everything his father said. Billy… belonged in heaven?

“- and let me tell you, we were all so surprised when he started to talk, high out of his mind, and was getting most of it correct! Keith, from Indiana, a legend.” Brenner’s gesture towards a portrait between two windows broke Billy from his thoughts. Billy turned to stare at the face of a man blitzed off his tits, long hair like an oily bowl around his skull.

“Him?”

“Him!” Brenner responded cheerily.

Instead of entertaining whatever was happening over there, Billy turned back to the matter at hand. “How’d I die?”

“Ah, that’s the hard part.” Brenner flipped through the file, not looking incredibly put out by this ‘hard’ task. “Let’s see…” He drew it out, like a parent hiding a present from an excited child, only the present was death. “Ah, a car crash. You were hit by a drunk driver and crashed into a tree.”

Billy blinked. “A car crash…?”

“Yes.” Brenner stood suddenly and said, “Well, you’re here now, Billy Hargrove. Let me show you the neighbourhood.”


The neighbourhood was so picturesque it was sickening. Brenner explained, as he guided Billy down the street, that the setting was tailored to the majority of the residents’ wants and needs. “There might be some things that aren’t for you specifically,” Brenner said as Billy scowled at the pink awnings above every store, “but there’s something for everyone here!”

“Where’s my thing then?” Billy asked, not bothering to pretend he wasn’t angry.

Brenner smiled his fake smile and led him down another fake street and gestured with a ‘ta da’ to…

“Is that a church?”

“Yes,” Brenner’s smile turned tight around the corners, eyes darkening into something cold. “As I’m sure you remember, you were a very religious man in your life, Billy Hargrove. I wouldn’t want to take that from you.”

Billy went cold. The sun shining down on them, which was not a real sun and lacked real warmth, turned cool and dead against his skin. He dug his nails into the palm of his hands, feeling the prick of pain against his flesh.

(Was it real flesh? Billy was dead. Billy was dead and standing in front of a Church specifically built for him in a heaven that wasn’t heaven. But if he was dead, does that make this real? Was he real right now? He’s breathing, why was he breathing? Does he need to breathe?)

(But also… an insidiousness… a feeling of wrongness that beamed down like the fake sun. Neil Hargrove forcing his head down at the dinner table every evening, forcing him to pray to a God he didn’t believe in and telling his son that despite it all, he wouldn’t get into heaven. That now, standing in this heavenly place, after dying in a drunk driving car crash, he was realising that maybe, after everything, Neil Hargrove was right. That Billy didn’t belong.)

“Thank you,” he bit out. He could not tell Brenner what he understood, because he probably was dead and if he didn’t belong here in heaven, then he might belong in… the other place. The bad place.

Brenner smiled, like he knew what Billy was thinking about anyway. “I’m sure many people would love to hear your sermons!” And then, “Let me show you the rest.”

They moved on without a second glance, Billy trailing behind with trembling hands shoved in his pants’ pockets.

There were more disturbingly cozy, pink shops, with people milling around with smiles all across their faces. A weird dystopian world where somehow everyone was happy. Maybe everyone was really happy, but Billy wasn’t sure how long it would last. Wouldn’t people get tired of three frozen yoghurt shops and no alcohol (because this was the worst thing Billy had heard after the fucking Church. No alcohol? What was this? A monastery?)

After Brenner explained that the fountains were all diet coke (what the fuck?), Billy tentatively asked, “How do you decide who gets here and who goes to… the other place?”

Brenner smiled like he’d been waiting for this question. “Well, there’s a point system, you see! Every action on earth has a positive and negative correlation. Save a cat from a tree? Add one hundred points. Cut in line at a checkout? Minus one fifty. Only the top point getters, like you, are selected for these neighbourhoods.”

“Only the top?”

“Yes, about five percent of all humans after death are in the Good Place. Everyone else goes to the Bad Place.”

That didn’t seem right, but Billy didn’t know enough about this whack ass system to dispute it.

Brenner led him down another street, into a row of suburban houses, all neat and formulaic. People were sitting in their gardens and there was a faint scent of barbeque in the air. They waved as he walked by, but the wrongness didn’t leave. All these people were so young. Birds were singing, the sun was beaming down and yet there were no children, no cars, no pets, no life beyond the garden walls.

“Another important aspect of the neighbourhood, one that is our most successful integration, is the soulmate initiative!”

Billy stopped. “The what?”

“Soulmates! Everyone has one! A person suited for them, to love them and be with them for eternity.”

A soulmate. For Billy. The boy so angry and ashamed that all his love had been beaten into the dirt, squashed into the ground along with everything else soft and hopeful. A boy, a man, who would have him and hold him despite everything, despite how angry and ugly and broken he was. Maybe Billy could be happy here, if he had a soulmate.

Brenner opened a baby blue gate and led him down a cobbled path. Small flowers were growing between the stones, almost following them with their heads. Brenner smiled again, like when Neil first introduced Billy to Susan. He knocked on the door.

Nothing.

“Ah, they’re not here right now. Oh well, let’s just make our way in,” and he just opened the door.

“No locks?” Billy asked, eyeing the handle.

“Why would we need them?” Brenner asked with that smile of his.

The house was a stereotypical home, with off-white walls and beige furniture. Billy raised a sceptical eyebrow, but Brenner prattled on about how “each home is a combination of both your likes and tastes. If there’s something you don’t like, please don’t hesitate to ask!”

Billy didn’t like any of it, but the realisation he had by the church was still looming over his shoulder. “It’s perfect,” he gritted out. He didn’t know what would be worse, that he didn’t belong here, or that his soulmate liked beige.

Brenner continued with the tour, showing Billy the kitchen (where there were teabags rather than coffee granules, like a prison), the lounge (the couch was an ugly maroon) and the bedroom (only one bed, and the duvet was leopard print). Billy was growing increasingly concerned about his soulmate’s mental state if this was how he decorated.

In every room, in the centre of the wall, framed rather ominously by a halo of light from nowhere, was Jesus Christ nailed to the cross. It was hung above the toilet, over the bed, distractingly placed above the television. It felt like his eyes were tracking Billy wherever he went.

Brenner stopped in front of the television, a massive flatscreen mounted to the wall, that looked oddly out of place for a home pulled from a show made in the 1980s. He turned it on, smirking at the screensaver (another image of Jesus blessing someone), and said, “If you would like, there’s an option that allows you to view your life on earth. The good and the bad, or in your case, mostly good.”

Filled with apprehension, Billy took the remote and fiddled with buttons. The screen flickered and changed, voices and images distorting until it settled on an image of a ceiling. Billy clicked the play button and closed his eyes.

“Billy, are you awake?” A voice, a kind maternal voice echoed around the room. Billy was hit with the sudden shame that he couldn’t actually recognise his mother’s voice anymore.

He opened his eyes and took in the woman before him. Soft cheeks, soft lips, brown eyes and brown hair curling beneath her chin. A maternal face. A motherly face. A face that… wasn’t his mother’s.

“Billy?” she said, and it felt wrong. Like music played with a different chord.

“You did so much good, Billy,” Brenner said, gently taking the remote. The screen changed again, people Billy didn’t know passing before him, places and things he’d never been to or done blinking in insignificant seconds. A life flashed before his eyes. “Your missionary missions to Africa saved so many lives.” Small faces of hungry children peered up at him. “So many schools built, children fed, and lives changed, all because of you.”

Someone was handing him some sort of award; the name Billy Hargrove printed in gold beneath the words ‘human relief and aid’.

Shame, thick and sour, welled in his chest. A life he hadn’t lived, deeds he hadn’t done, yet here he stood reaping the rewards of someone performing miracles. Because (and this was a truth he could admit about himself) Billy Hargrove was not a good person, and he didn’t say a thing.

Brenner passed another good deed, another life saved. A dog from a flood. A cat from a fire. This other him had been to protests for gay rights and child abuse and war crimes in countries he hadn’t known existed.

“You saved lives,” Brenner repeated.

“Thank you,” Billy replied.


Brenner left him shortly after, cycling through memories like a film reel.

“Your soulmate will be back soon,” he’d said, patting Billy on the shoulder. “I’ll give you two some privacy.”

So now Billy was left to stew in his own selfishness, the sick shame now a consistent tack at the back of his throat. But all he could think about was his soulmate.

What kind of man would he be? A tall man, with broad shoulders and muscles the size of Billy’s head? A man with a thick head of hair and kind eyes? Someone who could argue back? Someone who could calm him down? Keep him safe? Love him anyway?

The door clicked open. Billy tensed and squared his shoulders, ready to meet the man destined for him.

“Hi,” the woman said, seemingly just as shocked as he was. “Who are you?”

Chapter 2: The Soulmate Conundrum.

Chapter Text

Chapter two – the soulmate conundrum.

This has gotta be a joke.

Billy couldn’t stop staring at the woman. She was obviously a woman, because the thing she said next in the most disgusted tone was, “You’re a man?”

“Yes. Billy Hargrove.” He stood and held out his hand, like they were two business partners meeting for a conference and not supposed soulmates meeting for the first time.

Now, Billy was new to both the Good Place and the concept of soulmates, but he was sure that you probably should be attracted to them in some capacity. And, not from lack of trying, Billy was attracted to men.

Only.

“Robin Buckley,” she took his hand. Hers was soft, nails painted a light blue, and he wondered in the back of his mind if she’d woken up with them painted.

“Right.”

He let go and took a step back. On the screen, it had paused on one of his ‘missions’ where he was performing a sermon to a village in Kenya. Robin eyed this with apprehension. He fumbled and turned it off.

“I suppose you’ve been here by yourself.” Billy tried to sound casual.

“Yes. Brenner showed me around a few days ago. I – uh,” she stammered for a moment, fingers twisting in the fabric of her t-shirt. “I wasn’t expecting you.”

There was an odd accusation on her voice that made Billy bristle. He swiped a hand through his hair, and the curls settled perfectly once again. He swiped his tongue across his teeth and crossed his arms, regarding Robin once more.

“Not what you expected in a soulmate, huh?”

She let out another choked wheeze, eyes frantically glancing around the room as if looking for an escape.

Trying to let some his tension out, he tried to joke, “I personally thought my soulmate would have better interior design taste.”

Robin’s face turned red immediately and she screeched, “Me? What about you? This house is full of beige and bland things.”

“Uh – no, this is all you.” He gestured at everything. “I would never have this couch.”

“Neither would I!” She snapped. Then, she sat down on said couch with a sigh, burying her head in her hands. “Sorry,” she murmured. “I’ve barely comprehended this whole being dead thing, and now this.”

She jumped lightly as he sat beside her. Billy didn’t touch her but sat close enough that he could press his shoulder to hers if he leans sideways. “Tell me about it.”

“So,” Robin perked up again, forced cheer lacing her words, “tell me about yourself, Mr Hargrove.”

Billy fiddled with the remote in his hand, debating whether he should lean into the story presented to him, or tell her the truth. But that wasn’t him, her soulmate wasn’t him. Her soulmate was a man who liked beige and Jesus, who travelled to poverty-stricken towns and donated all his money to charity.

“I… uh… I have something I need to tell you, but I need you to promise that this stays between us.”

He wasn’t looking at her, but Billy could feel her gaze drilling through the side of his head. He fiddled again, pressing the buttons with shaking fingers.

“It’s okay,” Robin replied softly. “Soulmates, right?”

“Right.” From the corner of his eye, he could see her small pinkie creeping in, stretching out to him like an olive branch. He hooked his pinkie through hers and bluntly said, “I don’t think we’re soulmates. I don’t think I belong here. These aren’t my memories and I’m really, really gay.”

She didn’t move. He looked up to find her staring at him, mouth agape as she struggled to form words. “Wh-what?”

“I’m really, really, really gay,” he repeated like this was the most important part of his truth bomb.

“I… me too.”

Their pinkies were still linked. Neither made to move away.

“Yeah?” His voice sounded gruff, even to his ears.

“Yeah. A big lesbian, it’s honestly unreal.”

Robin giggled then, hand moving from his to cover her face, as tears started streaming down her cheeks. She was caught in a weird laugh-sob combo and Billy did not know what to do. Awkwardly, he reached his arm around her shoulder and patted it carefully.

“Maybe the Billy Hargrove I’ve accidentally taken the place of is a girl?”

“No,” she said, swiping tears from her eyes. She took a deep breath, curling into him. Despite the fact that something had quite obviously gone wrong here, it was nice she still took comfort in him. “The second-best soulmate I could ask for is a man who isn’t attracted to women at all.”

“That makes sense.” Billy squeezed her shoulder.

She rested her head on his shoulder, staring at the screen, now displaying a date the other Billy was on. “You said you didn’t belong, why?”

“According to the old guy who showed me around, you have to be a pretty fucking good person to get into this kinda place. I was not a good person.”

“At all?”

“Good enough, I guess, for a guy like me.”

She peeked at him with her wide blue eyes, scrutinising him. “You seem alright to me.”

“Alright doesn’t seem to be good enough. This other Billy was a pastor who helped the disadvantaged, donated all his money to charity, fed starving kids! I stole money from a homeless man when I was fifteen. I’ve said racist and sexist and homophobic things right up until I died. I died in a drink-driving accident for God’s sake!”

He was getting angry again, could feel the familiar tremors coursing through his body. But now, he was also aware of Robin resting against him, looking at him.

“And you think you deserve hell?”

“It’s called the Bad Place.”

“Okay.” She rolled her eyes but continued, “So you think you deserve to go to the Bad Place, instead?”

“Well, I certainly don’t belong here,” he snapped. “And you deserve a proper soulmate.”

Robin sat up then, scowling and punched him square in the shoulder. Apparently he could still feel pain.

Before she could say anything, there was a knock on the door. Robin went quiet and moved to open it like they were criminals hiding in the shadows. It was Brenner at the door, smiling wide and eyes dark and curious.

“Ah, I see you have become acquainted.” There was a pause where it seemed like he wanted them to say something, but when they remained quiet, he continued like nothing happened. “Well, I just wanted to let you know that now everyone has been settled into the neighbourhood, one of your neighbours has decided to throw a welcome party, and you’re both invited!” He held a gold embossed invitation.

Robin took it with a pursed smile, and Billy finally made his way over to stand behind her as she opened it. “To Mr and Mrs Hargrove, you are cordially invited to the Harrington Welcome Party at the residence at the end of the cul-de-sac. Formal wear. Doors open at seven pm.”

“Mr and Mrs Hargrove?” Robin asked dryly, folding the invitation aggressively and shoving it in her pocket.

Brenner’s smile widened somehow. “Due to the nature of soulmates, many residents automatically assume marriage or a similar partnership. You can, of course, ask for people to call you something else, but it is the norm.”

Then he left, humming a merry tune as he walked down their path and out the garden. Robin shut the door and then made a rude gesture with her finger, flinging herself dramatically back onto the couch.

“I hate parties! And why is the ‘norm’ for soulmates to take the man’s name! We aren’t married! And! And platonic soulmates could be a thing. What happens if an asexual or aromantic get here, do they just not get a soulmate?”

“Platonic soulmates?” Billy asked, cutting her off.

“Yeah,” she replied, tracing the edge of the invitation with her thumb. “We obviously aren’t romantic soulmates. So, we’re platonic soulmates instead.”

Struggling for a moment, Billy tugged at the loose curls that framed his face. There was a sharp bolt of pain that disappeared almost as quickly.

“But what about this?” Here, he gestured to the rest of the house, to the beige furniture, the off-white walls, the maroon couch, the sermon paused on the screen. “What about your soulmate? This soulmate? Someone meant specifically for you?”

Robin looked around, shrugged and scoffed, “Given what I’ve seen about this mysterious other Billy, I don’t think I’d get along with them at all. They seem super religious, to an off-putting extent, and like we both said, this interior design isn’t it. I’d rather have you, if that’s alright?”

He slumped down beside her. “What happens if I’m taking someone’s place? Someone who deserves to be here?”

“Then,” Robin placed a warm hand on his arm and squeezed kindly, “we’ll deal with that when it comes.”


The Harrington house was a mansion, a mansion so big that it was practically a castle. Billy and Robin stood at the base of the path that stretched before them, winding towards glittering lights in the distance.

“If we don’t want to be extremely late, we better start walking now,” Robin said grumpily, staring at her heels.

They’d both panicked hard about the attire, throwing on the poshest things they could find in the closet (that were conveniently in their sizes). Billy was wearing a tux he wasn’t entirely sure was fitted correctly along with trousers he would struggle to get out of later. Robin was in a pastel pink dress that fell across her body like flower petals, with strappy heels, dotted with diamonds.

Billy held out his arm to her in solidarity, and she took with a sigh.

The ground was uneven underfoot which seemed inconvenient for paradise, and somehow they were both sweating when they arrived at the door. Robin took out a bottle of fragrance from her little bag and spritzed them both before she knocked.

The grand doors opened without anyone to greet them, which they took as their sign to enter. There was music coming from further inside, echoing down a marble hallway. Statues lined the walls, holding a myriad of weapons and having no conceivable link between them.

Above them was a portrait of a man and a woman. Beneath the frame was a placard that read, ‘Steve Harrington and Nancy Wheeler’. The supposed host, Steve Harrington, had a large head of brunet hair coupled with moles and large, brown, doe-like eyes. His smile was wide, showcasing straight, white teeth, and his eyes seemed to judge them as they looked down upon them. Nancy Wheeler looked like she’d rather be anywhere else, lips screwed as if she’d tasted something sour. She seemed small and delicate, and Billy wondered how long it would take for her to disappear in this large mansion.

“She didn’t take his last name,” Robin muttered petulantly.

“We’ll ask them to change it, don’t worry,” Billy said back, forcing his eyes from Steve Harrington’s.

At the end of the hallway, another door opened, music and light and laughter spilling into the cold shadows. Billy tugged her forward, leading her into the warmth.

There were so many people. A cacophony of noise washed over Billy, slipping between his ears and underneath his skin. Each laugh seemed grating, and the scent of food and alcohol was thick in the air. Neither he nor Robin knew anyone—Robin hadn’t felt inclined to explore the neighbourhood before Billy arrived.

“There’s the food,” she whispered, breath low and hot in his ear, gesturing to the banquet table laden with food at the other end of the room.

They started making their way over. Even though they’d dressed the most formal they could, it still seemed to Billy that they were outclassed. Everyone else seemed to have dusted themselves in shimmering gold and silver, and in comparison, Billy felt like he pulled his suit from a dumpster.

Slouching inwards, he forced himself to keep moving, instead of slinking into the shadows like he desperately wanted to do. Robin stuck to him, fingers clenched so tightly in his elbow they were turning a pale white. Her nail polish was chipped on some fingers already.

The food was small. So tiny. Tiny pieces of cheese and meats and pastry with tiny skewers in them. No one else seemed bothered by this, swallowing down bite after bite between conversation. It seemed impolite to pile a plate full of them, so he took a few and clutched them in his hand as Robin went off to get them drinks.

“My name is Steve Harrington.” Billy turned and almost knocked the glass from the man’s hand. He was slightly taller and standing way too close for a stranger.

“Um, what?”

Steve leaned closer, smiling wide, teeth white and smelling faintly of oranges. “Steve Harrington. I’ve never seen you around.”

“I literally moved in this morning,” Billy said dryly, taking a bite from the tiny cheese on sticks.

“Ah,” Steve nodded to this revelation like it was the most important thing, “that makes sense. Who’s your soulmate?”

Billy rolled his eyes but scoured the crowd anyway. Robin was awkwardly shuffling back through the mingling crowd; glasses clutched firmly in hand. “There,” he nodded.

Steve wrinkled his nose. “She seems… nice.”

“She’s lovely,” Billy replied shortly and went to meet her.

“How’s it going?” Robin whispered, handing him the drink. It tasted slightly floral. “Some random lady cornered me at the bar and wouldn’t shut up about her bestselling self-help book. Which I’ve never heard of, by the way.”

Billy snorted, wrapping an arm around her waist. “Yeah. The host himself cornered me to interrogate me about my place here.”

They turned back to the table, where Steve Harrington was still lingering. The man turned away when they caught him looking.

“Weirdo,” Robin muttered and shoved a block of cheese in her mouth.


At some point someone switched the music from classical to some beat that got people on the dancefloor. Also, it turned out you could still get drunk in the Good Place without actually consuming any alcohol, something Billy realised as he was swinging Robin around without rhythm.

At some point, another drink is pressed into his hand. At another point, a woman brushed against Robin, and she was spinning away into someone else’s arms. Billy downed his drink and swayed in time with the beat in an attempt to dance by himself.

A hand brushed his arm. “Can I have this dance?”

Billy turned and almost bumped noses with Steve Harrington since the man was standing so close. Steve’s pupils were blown, and the stench of floral alcohol flooded the air around them, mingling with the citrus scent seemingly stuck in his hair.

“What?” Billy asked.

Steve laughed. It lit up his eyes.

“Can I have this dance?”

His hands were already snaking around Billy’s waist, pulling him closer.

“What about your wife?”

“Nancy?”

“Yes. Your soulmate.”

Steve smiled again, as if Billy had told a joke. “She’s around.”

He may be drunk, but Billy couldn’t help but thinking of how these people had somehow ended up in paradise and were already reenacting some strange period drama.

“How long have you been here?”

“Like, four days,” Steve replied, fingers twitching against the small of Billy’s back.

Four days and he seemed to be bored of his soulmate already.

Billy started to sway, letting Steve guide him in the dance. Everything felt warm and stuffy.

“Your soulmate,” Steve whispered in his ear. “Where is she?”

Billy snorted against his shoulder. “Dancing. What’s it to you?”

“Just can’t believe she’d leave you by yourself.”

Billy suddenly took a step back, stumbling from Steve’s grasp and trying to shake off the dizziness. “I don’t know what you’re getting but I know her. I trust her. Leave me out of whatever this weird regency roleplay you and your soulmate have going on.”

He stepped back, and Robin spun into him.

“Hey,” she giggled, “I think we need to go home.”

“Yeah.” Billy wrapped an arm around her waist, holding her against him and helping her stay upright. Steve was still standing behind them, but Billy walked away before he could say anything else.

Chapter 3: Hello, neighbour.

Chapter Text

Chapter 3 – Hello, neighbour.

Gentle hands stroked over his forehead, brushing loose curls against warm skin. Eyes, shining with hurt, peered down at him, a blue bruise blooming fresh over tan cheeks.

There was a stinging in his side, a pressure against his chest, a ringing in his ears.

Everything hurt. And then it was dark.


Billy woke up, lying on the hideous couch in his hideous house, head clear but ears ringing. A phantom pain ached across his chest, and he rubbed it until it dissipated. He never thought he’d miss the concept of a hangover, but the post-drink clarity struck him quicker without a headache to sift through.

Snores echoed throughout the sunlit house. He sat up fully and could see through the open bedroom door, Robin sprawled across the double bed, fast asleep. It reminded him of Kali, and the thought of Kali reminded him of his own death.

He wondered, suddenly, how time worked. Whether he was already buried six feet under and a passing memory for people who were still fresh in his mind, or if they were still pulling him from the wreckage as his spirit passed from the mortal world. Did Max miss him? Did Argyle? Would they tell his mom? Would she care?

He laid back down and stared at the strangely patterned ceiling. Brown eyes flashed behind his eyelids. Shame was still a prevalent feeling in heaven, he supposed.


Neil Hargrove was an angry, angry man. It was an anger that bled into everything, even his own son. It was easy to be angry in the Hargrove household, and it dogged Billy like a shadow. It was heavy and heady and encompassing.

It was a shock when Neil passed away. Part of Billy thought Neil would outlive him. Part of Billy thought Neil would kill him. So, when he’d got a call during his shift at the mechanics, Billy almost hadn’t believed it — had to see for himself.

But it had been Neil Hargrove on the cold table, skin pale, eyes closed and body still. The nurse was kind as she explained he’d had a heart attack and took Billy’s shameful relief as grief. He stood there and watched his father’s still chest, his calm face, his knuckles still bruised from the punch he’d thrown the day before.

Susan was grief-stricken when he walked through the door, sitting at the kitchen table with her head bowed, sobs shaking her thin frame. Billy stood in the doorway for a moment, debating whether he should comfort her. Then, she looked up and he remembered the years where she’d sat by and let Neil hurt him.

Susan and Max left shortly after, leaving Billy in a big house with the ghost of his father around every corner.


Robin leant over him, poking his shoulder with the point of her nail. Billy sat up with a start, blinking at the smile that appeared on her face as she leapt out of the way of his swiping hands, laughing all the while.

The sun was clearly up now, hanging in the sky with small, fluffy clouds passing by. Were the skies planned? Was there a generator somewhere that dictated the amount of blue? Or the cloud coverage?

“There’s a brunch happening in the centre of town and everyone is invited!” Robin said, dragging him from the ugly couch with unnecessary enthusiasm.

He barely had time to rearrange some of his curls before she was dragging him out the door, the sun shining down on them. It was strange how bright everything seemed, like someone turned up the saturation of the greens and blues. It hurt Billy’s eyes.

As they rounded a corner, the chatter of the brunch event burst forth, like there'd been something covering it and they broke through. It was the type of event Billy wouldn’t have attended when he was alive, too suburban and domestic and soft. But when he caught Harrington’s large head of hair above the crowd, he decided the food was a good starting point.

Robin already piled her plate high with meat and bread and a pastry that was oozing melted chocolate. Billy scooped a portion of scrambled eggs from where the little sign read ‘cooked to your standards!’. The bread was toasted exactly how he liked, and the bacon was slightly crispy. The jam was ‘your favourite’ and the coffee was ‘as you like it’.

They sat at an empty table near the outskirts, watching as the residents of their utopian afterlife mingled with one another. Billy sipped at his sweetened coffee with a slight smile, which dropped as soon as he saw were making their ways over.

Steve Harrington, with a plate predominantly piled with pastries, followed by Nancy Wheeler and two other people. Billy took an angry swig, practically draining his entire cup, as Steve loomed over them, asking in a genial voice, “You mind if we join you?”

Robin nodded whilst Billy remained quiet, glaring at the meager liquid left in his cup. He lurched when Steve sat beside him, knee practically pressing against his own.

“I’m going to get another cup,” Billy said, standing quickly, not even pretending that he wasn’t running away.

Steve stood as well. “I need a refill.” Then he looked Billy in the eyes and drained the rest of his drink.


Billy would like to say handled his father’s death and Susan’s subsequent departure well, but it seemed to bring back his fear of abandonment.

Sure, he was relieved that Neil was dead, but also he was upset. His therapist, if he had one, would’ve said that Neil died before Billy felt he’d proved himself to him. That Neil passed away before Billy figured out how to make his dad love him.

Billy didn’t have a therapist, so he drank instead.

Argyle was there, because he was Argyle and he cared. Billy was cruel to Argyle during those moments. Becoming dangerously close to the spectre of Neil that followed him like a shadow.

If he’d lived longer, Billy thought he would’ve pulled himself together. Stopped drinking for Argyle and for Max, went back to work and bought a new house. Maybe he would’ve liked himself enough to get a boyfriend, then a husband. And then he might’ve died of old age.

Instead, he got behind the wheel, bottle of whisky between his knees and he kept going faster and faster down the highway. He’d turned, just for a moment, to take another swig from the bottle, and before he even realised, his Camaro crashed directly into a tree.


Billy tried to ignore Steve’s hovering, as he poured himself another cup. Across the yard, Brenner stood with an odd, analytical look on his face, but he waved his hand in greeting when Billy caught his gaze.

When Billy put his arm down, Steve coughed, apparently tired of being ignored.

“What?” Billy snapped.

“How was the rest of your night?” Steve asked, leaning close. There was a rising scent of oranges and hairspray that tickled Billy’s nose.

“I was asleep for most of it,” Billy replied dryly.

Steve grinned. “Dreaming good dreams, I hope.” He took Billy’s cup from his hands, took a sip and winked. He handed it back. “Surprisingly sweet, just like you.”

“Shut up.” Then, “What do you want?”

He shrugged, smile coy and eyes glinting with interest under the artificial sun. “I think you’re interesting.”

“Why?” Billy peered over Steve’s shoulder, feeling slightly put out about the other man being taller. Robin wasn’t even looking at him, too busy leaning over and laughing at whatever the new woman was saying. Nancy was engaged in conversation with the other guy.

Billy looked back to Steve, whose eyes crinkled in amusement. A hand came to rest on Billy’s shoulder, then Steve’s thumb started to stroke the fabric of the red shirt. “This is a good colour on you.”

Heat rose to his cheeks immediately and Billy tried to lift a hand to cover it, but Steve caught it in his hand (with a bigger palm and longer fingers, which felt nice against his shoulder blade and might also feel nice if it slipped further down to rest in the small of his back). He opened his mouth to say something, maybe about Brenner watching across the crowd, or Nancy sitting at the table three feet away still talking to another man, or the fact that Billy now thought everyone was watching.

“I think you’re interesting,” Steve said first, “because you don’t seem to fit in.” Billy lurched back in offence, but Steve pulled him back. “When I first saw you at the party, you looked angry and uncomfortable, despite being in literal heaven with a beautiful lady on your arm.”

“This isn’t heaven,” Billy replied, slightly helpless against Steve’s intense gaze. “It’s called the Good Place.”

Steve smiled again, “See. You just don’t want to be here, and I want to know why. Who you were then, and who you are now. I think you might be the only real person here, Billy.”

It should’ve been comforting, to know someone watched Billy stumble and decided they wanted to continue to know him, but the sense of dread that was hanging over his shoulders dropped until the inching horror crawled over him. Steve had seen him and decided he didn’t belong.

Billy took a step back. “Don’t say that.”

Steve rolled his eyes. “It was a compliment.”

“That I don’t belong here?”

“That you’re real.” Steve was reaching out again, but Billy could see Brenner, and he could not let this man before him tear down the only afterlife Billy had. It may not be right, and it may feel empty, but Billy was as happy as he could be, and he wanted to keep hold of that feeling as long as he could.

“Nancy’s real.” It came out like a whipcrack, and it struck. Steve flinched and stepped back, hip banging against the table. The teacups rattled and the milk jug toppled over.

There was a hand on his elbow and he turned, catching the fiery glint of Robin’s hair before his fear consumed him completely.

“You okay?” Her voice was soft, gentle, pulling above the surface into the sun.

I wish I was in love with you, he wanted to say, I wish you could make me happy.

From the look in her eyes and the way she’d been leaning into the woman at the table, he guessed that Robin thought the same. She squeezed his elbow gently. “Do you want to leave?”

Desperately. But he couldn’t, not again. Couldn’t spend eternity running from Steve Harrington whenever the man so much as breathed near him.

“No, it’s fine. I just want to finish my breakfast.” Robin nodded and released his elbow. Steve was still watching as they walked over to the table. He trailed after them, eyes still fixed on Billy.

Nancy’s eyes were wide as they sat down. She asked in her sweet, gentle voice if Billy was okay. He nodded and focused intently on inhaling the food before him, trying to ignore Steve’s presence as the man sat opposite.

“I don’t think you’ve met,” Robin said, voice high-pitched as she tried to break the tension. “Billy, this is Jonathan.” The awkward looking man beside Nancy waved but remained silent. “And this is… Heather.” There was a pause there, Robin smiled brightly as the woman, Heather, leaned against her and reached out to shake Billy’s hand.

“Billy.” He took her hand but couldn’t stop looking at the glint on Robin’s eye.

The guilt he’d been trying to ignore settled like rock in his stomach. Robin shouldn’t be stuck with him.

“So,” Heather leaned back, angling her body more towards Robin than Jonathan, “how are you enjoying paradise?”

Robin went beet red immediately, wiping her hands on her shorts even though you couldn’t nervous sweat in the Good Place.

“Oh,” she stammered, “it’s good. We’re good. Everything is good and normal.” She laughed awkwardly and her eyes flicked to Billy’s, panic obvious.

“It’s good,” he agreed. Steve snorted across the table.

Heather turned to him fully. “You have a familiar accent. You from Cali as well?”

“Oh, yeah.” Billy sat up straighter, smile more genuine as Heather launched into a play-by-play of her life, asking at points if Billy also experienced those things. When he admitted he also surfed, Steve also leaned in closer. But it didn’t matter.

The sun shone brighter, the air was sweeter, and Billy could finally talk about himself without the burden of another life looming over his shoulder. He wondered (briefly, insignificantly) if Heather was hiding something, like Robin was, like Billy was. The way she leant closer to Robin, the way she spoke about her life, the way Jonathan didn’t even seem to register to her despite him being her soulmate.

As Billy started to launch into a story from his freshman year, footsteps grew louder behind him and Heather’s smile slid from her face.

“Ah,” Brenner said, smile etched like a plastic doll. “I see you’re all enjoying yourself.” They all murmured an agreement. “Billy? May I speak to you?”

Robin opened her mouth, but Billy stood before any noise came out. “Sure.”

Brenner didn’t seem to fit quite right, anymore. The way he stood in his black suit against the greens and blues like a spectre or shadow. The pursed lips, the cool glint to his eyes, the way he seemed to barely resist reaching out and taking.

“I hate to speak ill of any residents,” Brenner said, in his strange, calm voice, “but I recommended staying away from Heather Holloway and Jonathan Byers.”

Suddenly, it was Neil before him, warning him away from Argyle, Max away from Lucas. Spitting words of vitriol. Warping it into caring, like they were so dangerous the only way to be safe was to avoid, avoid, avoid. It had taken Billy a shamefully long time to learn he was wrong.

“Why? I thought only good people were in the Good Place.”

Brenner’s eyes sharpened and a tinge of fear shot up his spine. “Yes. But sometimes we make mistakes. If residents stop getting along, or there are problems, positions can be redistributed.”

“To another Good Place?”

“Sure.” Brenner’s smile was reminiscent of bared teeth. A dog baying for blood.

Billy turned then, desperate to get away.

“Oh, and Billy?” Brenner called after him. “People are looking forward to your first sermon!”

Chapter 4: Two gays vs the heteronormative agenda.

Chapter Text

Chapter 4 – Two gays vs the heteronormative agenda.

0-

There were quite a few issues with paradise. One being that soulmates all seemed to be romantic. The first (and only) time Billy and Robin suggested their relationship was platonic, the couple beside them had gasped like they’d admitted to murder, and Brenner appeared from the shadows with malicious concern in his gaze.

They’d tried to be less obvious, sat beside each other in public, awkwardly held hands when everyone else did, and tried their best to cuddle during the weekly ‘drive-in movie night’ experience. It wasn’t the best, and the idea of doing this for eternity was their own personal hell, but they’d agreed to stick it out with each other.

“Heather, huh?” Billy asked as they awkwardly laid in the same bed.

Robin’s flinty glare was obvious despite the darkness. “Steve, huh?”

They did not talk about it.

 

1-

Tina, who used to be a marriage counsellor, was the first to notice their awkwardness and offered her services. It was interesting, although Billy would never say it out loud, that paradise had a marriage counsellor. But, if you were stuck with the same person for eternity, no matter how perfect you were for each other, counselling was probably recommended.

Neither Robin or Billy wanted counselling, but Brenner, who still materialised from nowhere at the slightest hint they weren’t doing things the proper way, had stepped up and agreed on their behalf.

So, now they sat on a sofa that was unfortunately reminiscent of their own, knees touching at Tina’s request as she scrutinised them over her desk. There was a photo of her soulmate, Tammy Thompson, on her desk, smiling beguilingly out at them.

When they’d entered, Robin’s eyes had flicked between Tina and Tammy’s photo, jealousy and longing and fear flashing across her face. Billy squashed the familiar pang of guilt and avoided Tina’s gaze as her crystal blue eyes swept across them.

Billy didn’t understand. He’d thought, half-heartedly and in the shadows of night, that Neil was correct, that faggots and dykes and all other queers couldn’t be in heaven. That he was here by mistake, or as punishment, but he couldn’t understand why Robin was here. Or why they were sitting on a sofa facing a woman who had another woman as a soulmate.

“Brenner has told me that you two might be having problems,” Tina’s fingers were laced together as she spoke in a calm, condescending voice.

“That’s none of Brenner’s business,” Robin snapped.

Tammy had thrown her off; she was as confused and scared as Billy. He wondered faintly why she’d let him in so quickly. Why she hadn’t marched straight up to Brenner and told him there was no possible way Billy could be her soulmate.

“Unfortunately, it is,” Tina said serenely. There was an oddness about her, the same oddness that encompassed Brenner. Like she didn’t quite fit right. “You see, as the creator of this neighbourhood, it is his responsibility to maintain the livelihood of the community. To make sure everything functions how it’s supposed to.” Something cold flicked in her eyes but it was gone almost as quickly. “If something goes wrong, the consequences could be catastrophic. Plus,” she softened her entire body, almost on cue, “soulmates can often seem too perfect. We always have to remember; we are ultimately human here.”

“How do you determine soulmates?”

It came out before he could fully understand what he was asking. But he needed to know, for Robin.

Tina smiled like she was waiting for them to ask. A screen emerged behind her, and funky music began to play as the title card ‘So, You’re Soulmate Feels Wrong’ appeared on screen. A petite blonde girl, face sweet like an angel stepped out.

“Hiya, I’m Chrissy and my role in the Good Place institution is to work with neighbourhood architects to determine each residents’ soulmate. Now, what is a soulmate?” Billy felt he was back in school, watching his classmates group projects. “A soulmate,” Chrissy continued, “is the one person on earth specifically meant for you. This might seem improbable, impossible even, but in the grand scheme of the universe, it makes perfect sense.” She seemed proud of herself.

“Now, at the beginning of your time in the Good Place, it can be confusing and disorientating. Maybe you had a partner on earth, maybe a family, someone you thought was the one. And now you’ve woken up with someone new for you and that can be confusing. Just know, there are no mistakes. Your soulmate is your soulmate for a reason, your missing piece, the other half of your soul. And all you need to do is try.”

The screen flicked off, and Tina turned to them once again. “It can be confusing at first, but you’ll soon learn how to live with each other, and then eternity will feel like nothing when you’re with each other.” She stroked a finger along Tammy’s cheek.

Billy and Robin made eye contact when she was distracted, confusion and grief on Robin’s face presumably mirrored on Billy’s own.

Whatever mistake had brought him here had truly replaced Robin’s soulmate. Maybe a conglomerate of bad listings had replaced someone with him and implemented someone else’s life as his. Maybe Robin’s soulmate was a sexy lesbian being tortured for eternity due to a clerical error. Maybe Billy should tell Robin that, but the fear that she’d hand him over, the fear of darkness and fire and pain and Neil Hargrove kept him quiet.

Robin turned back to Tina like she already knew. “What about platonic soulmates?”

“Platonic?” It fell from Tina’s mouth like a slur.

“Soulmates who aren’t romantically involved,” Robin prompted.

Tina stared, and stared, and stared, like she couldn’t even comprehend what was being asked. “Why would you not be in love with your soulmate?”

“I said platonic. You can still be in love with your soulmate, without romantic feelings.”

Tina’s face turned an alarming shade of red and her voice cracked like a whip in the cool silence of the room. “Platonic soulmates do not exist. The universe does not make mistakes.”

They didn’t mention platonic soulmates for the rest of the session. Tina ended by asking them not to come back again.

 

2-

They received a booklet for free couple massages in their post-box, which didn’t make much sense, considering that the economy was non-existent. Robin flipped through it like a mystery book, oddly fascinated by the heterosexual erotic displays.

“She’s secretly gay,” she said, showing him a double-page spread of a man and a woman in a steamy room, the woman’s head seemingly looking anywhere but at her partner’s naked body.

“He has a foot fetish,” Billy contributed, pointing to another page, where a man was getting a foot massage from his partner, neck rolling back in ecstasy.

Once the glee wore off, they tossed the booklet down the side of the couch and forgot about it until Heather and Jonathan came to visit. Robin and Heather sat side by side on the ugly couch, knees and heads pressed together, talking in low voices like they were the only people in the universe.

Billy and Jonathan hovered on the fringes, and Billy startled when Jonathan nodded at Heather and Robin with a knowing glance. The other man was quiet, an intensity to him that melted into an odd casualness. Like he knew too much and couldn’t be bothered by the implications.

Before Billy could ask, Jonathan suddenly bent down and picked up the discarded booklet. He flipped through it, face blank except a faint eyebrow twitch that could mean a myriad of things. But it was Heather who plucked it from his hands and held it out to Robin.

“We got one of these,” she said.

“Oh, um, I – uh…” Robin stammered in response.

“We should do it.” Heather then turned to Billy and Jonathan. “We should all go.”

Billy and Robin exchanged looks and there was something pleading in her eyes. Reluctantly, he agreed.

As expected, it was incredibly awkward and practically unbearable. There was a ‘double trouble’ package which resulted in Billy and Jonathan, shirtless, hands sticky with oil, rubbing Robin and Heather’s backs as they continued to gaze at each other like they were alone in the universe.

At one point, when Billy was trying to get a knot out in the centre of Robin’s back, Steve and Nancy passed by. Steve looked in and when they looked eyes, an odd sense of shame flashed through him.

“Keep going,” Robin mumbled, eyes lidded. “I can do you next.”

“That’s alright.” When he looked up, Steve was gone. Heather stared though, something like relief shining up at him.

 

3-

“Welcome to the first annual Soulmate Showdown!” Brenner stood on stage, black suit specked with faint, translucent sparkles, microphone in hand. “The chosen couples will answer a series of questions to see which soulmate duo know each other best!”

It sounded like they had an option to sign up. Billy and Robin did not. Brenner was at their door that morning, presenting them with ‘invitations’ and not-so-subtly hinting they were participating whether they liked it or not.

So, when the time came, they dawned their fancy clothes once more, the same ones they wore to Steve’s party the week before. Robin kept fluffing her hair in the mirror, the action uncharacteristic for her. Billy waited impatiently behind her, also wanting to fluff his hair.

“What kind of questions do you think they’ll ask?” Robin asked, looking at him through the mirror’s reflection.

“Probably things about our lives on earth,” Billy said after a moment of thought, nudging her out the way so he could do his hair. There was a curl that wouldn’t lie flat. He tried to flatten it, and it sprung out again, coiled like a spring.

Robin sighed and said worriedly, “But what if it’s questions about your fake life?”

“Then I guess we lose.”

Turned out neither Billy nor Robin liked to lose. Especially when Steve and Nancy stood on one side of the podium, Tammy and Tina beside them.

“Robin, which church did Billy frequent as a child?”

Robin stared. “Um…” She glanced at Billy who was no help because he didn’t even know the name of the church he actually used to go to. “The Catholic one?”

Brenner laughed heartily like she’d made a terrific joke. “I’ll give you a half-point for the correct denomination. The correct answer was St Mary’s Catholic Church for the Disadvantaged.”

“Oh, of course.” Robin replied.

“Of course,” Billy echoed, trying to sound like he knew that all along.

Brenner looked at him then, and Billy had the sudden thought that the man (Deity? God? Unknowable entity?) already knew. That now he was trying to catch Billy and Robin out, to see how far the charade would go.

“Nancy,” Brenner turned away, “what was the Harrington net worth?”

As Nancy answered with unwavering confidence, Billy watched Steve flinch at the question. It made him ponder, for a moment, the nature of the Good Place. Steve’s family seemed to have a large fortune, and it seemed like they didn’t do much with it. Why was Steve in the Good Place?

Why was Robin? Nancy? Tina?

“Billy,” Brenner said, cutting off his thoughts, “what was the name of Robin’s first boyfriend?”

Robin went rigid beside him and Billy clenched his hands beneath the podium to stop himself from vaulting over and attacking Brenner. He had to think, wondered how deep this odd sexuality coverup went. They never looked at Robin’s memories of earth, finding it a violation, especially when his were all fake.

“Vick,” he announced, nails digging into the flesh of his palms. “His name was Vick.”

Her name was Vickie; she had been Robin’s first and only girlfriend. They’d been on a break when Robin was killed by a man on a motorbike. It wasn’t clear if it was an accident or a malicious attack, but Robin had closed her eyes on the cold, wet sidewalk and opened them in the Good Place. She missed Vickie, of course, but there was no way she’d ever see her again. Vickie had a lot more life left to live.

“Correct.”

It seemed to hurt him to get the word out. Maybe Brenner expected Billy to trip up or hesitate so he could poke and prod and expose his own mistake.

But that also meant that Brenner did know that Billy and Robin couldn’t be soulmates. If Vick was Robin’s first boyfriend, there was a record somewhere.

“We might need to watch some of your memories after this,” he murmured, watching as Tina and Tammy laughed in exaggerated joy at their win.

“Sure.”

Steve and Nancy walked over as the audience in the clearing below dispersed.

“That was intense, huh?” Steve said, running a hand through his perfectly coiffed hair. “I’m surprised we did that well.” Nancy scoffed and Steve glared at her.

“Yeah,” Billy agreed, eyes drawn to the stray strand of hair that was now blowing in the faint breeze, “but Tina and Tammy were on another level.”

“At least you both got a question right,” Nancy spat, turning on her feet and storming away. Jonathan slipped from the sparse audience and trailed after her.

Steve didn’t turn to watch her, staring at Billy’s face. “You have freckles,” he said, a finger tracing the bridge of Billy’s nose. “I’ve never noticed before.”

“Neither have I.” Robin’s voice was dry, and she too walked away, with a smug smile tugging at her lips.

Steve’s thumb stroked across Billy’s cheek, a gentle swipe which sank beneath the skin, settled against the bones. Then Steve blinked and came back to himself, taking a quick step back and clearing his throat.

“I’m surprised you got every question wrong,” Billy told him before Steve could say anything.

A frown crossed his lips. Billy resisted the urge to lean forward and kiss it away. “We don’t really talk much about before.”

“At all?”

Steve shrugged self-consciously, “Nancy wants to focus on the now, I guess?”

“But she’s still upset?”

Smiling wryly, Steve leant forward and mock-whispered, “She said soulmates should just know this stuff.”

His eyes were bright up close, light reflecting like the moon in a deep night sky. “I don’t think that’s true,” he whispered, leaning close.

Steve’s eyes crinkled, eyelashes fanning against his cheeks. “I think the universe works in mysterious ways.”

Billy was beginning to think so too.

Chapter 5: Steve's Perfect Paradise

Chapter Text

Chapter 5 – Steve’s perfect paradise.

Steve’s death was stupid. Because he was stupid. Because Tommy was five drinks deep and Steve was drunk on tequila when Tommy dared him to jump into the Quarry.

“Bet you’ll die,” Tommy said, arm around a giggling Carol who was barely aware of her surroundings.

Steve did another shot of tequila. “Prepare to eat your words.”

Then he leapt into the black, plunging depths of Hawkins Quarry. There was no false body. No Upside Down. No telepathic girl to lift him from the darkness. Just Steve, stupid and dumb, wind in his hair, alcohol in his veins, falling to his death.

At least it didn’t hurt.


Nancy Wheeler was exactly who Steve expected to be his soulmate. The girl his parents had demanded he find in life, who finally came to him death. She was smart and strong, precisely like he predicted. They moved into their eternal home, a mansion bigger than the Harrington household, with a large garden and a fountain and a driveway despite there being no cars.

It was paradise, the life he’d been expected to have, and now he could have it without the annoying life things that destroyed his parents’ marriage, like jobs and money and affairs. If everyone had a soulmate, then no one would be disappointed.

But Nancy didn’t seem to like this life like Steve did. She would walk the halls of the big house, staring at the portraits of her and Steve, together in a way they’d never truly been.

Sure, Steve thought it was weird that they were there when they moved in, but it was a symbol of their love! Proof they were soulmates!

But he inevitably covered them at Nancy’s request, their odd, false faces behind deep, red velvet. A strange secret to keep, in a paradise like this.

And despite their soulmate connection, Nancy did not want to sleep in the same bed.

“I just want to be by myself right now. You understand, don’t you Steve?”

He didn’t but he let her drift away every night to her cozy room by the library, and he walked to the master bedroom where the bed was too big for one person and there was an odd draft that had him shivering through the night.

They spent the days together, doing things Nancy wanted to do. It wasn’t that Steve didn’t want to do them, and he enjoyed spending time with Nancy, but the thought of spending eternity at poetry readings and writing circles didn’t sit right. But it was what Nancy wanted to do, and all Steve wanted was to be with Nancy.

One day, Brenner came by.

“We’ve settled the last resident into his forever home, and I was wondering if you’d like to throw a little neighbourhood party? You know, for some neighbourhood bonding?”

Nancy seemed decidedly uncaring about it, but Steve wanted to talk to some other people. To fill the empty house with more than two people, at least for the night. At his agreement, the mansion itself glowed with delight, the candles lighting themselves and the drapes covering the portraits fell in a smooth down sweep.

Steve wrote the invitations himself, debating whether to sign them with Mr and Mrs Harrington. But something told him Nancy wouldn’t like that, so he scrawled his signature reminiscent of his father and pretended he was happy with what he had.

How selfish of him, to want more from paradise. To want more from soulmates and afterlife and eternity.

(“Why did you and dad stay together for so long?”

“He was comfortable and safe. I knew where I stood.”

“But you weren’t happy?”

“Happiness comes in many forms. It can be difficult to chase pure happiness. I’d settle for comfort, Steve, rather than a fleeting feeling that doesn’t know how to stay.”)

He wondered when his mother swapped comfort for fleeting happiness, when she decided the chase was worth it. When she decided to walk out on him and her life to follow an artist to France. Steve didn’t know if the happiness stayed, if she settled into a familiar complacently like before, or if she left once more, chasing another happiness.

Steve, back when he was alive and bitter, swore he’d never chase those moments, once he had a safe life. The party was in full swing, people laughing and talking, full of a joy only paradise could bring, and Steve stood with a glass of fake alcohol, watching Nancy talk to other people, never once glancing at him.

For a moment, he wondered what it was like for her, to stand so far from him without fearing he would disappear. Because, when Steve looked away from Nancy Wheeler, he dreaded, so fierce and strong, that she wouldn’t be there when he turned back.

Just as he made to cross the room to pull Nancy away from the guy with shaggy hair, a glimpse of blond so blinding sent him stumbling. He scrubbed a hand across his eyes. There across the hall, entering through the large doors was a man with a gorgeous head of blond hair. Even from where Steve stood, he could see the curls, the faint quirk to his lips, the way he pressed his hand gently to the woman’s back (that’s his soulmate Steve, what are you looking at?).

The music swelled and Steve crossed the room, leaving Nancy without a second thought. The man stood in the corner, an awkward hunch to his shoulders as he surveyed the room with a glass in his hand. He startled as Steve made himself known, a faint blush spreading quickly across his cheeks.

Steve found himself enthralled. “I’ve never seen you around.”

The man seemed distinctly unimpressed. “I moved in this morning.”

Made sense, Steve definitely would’ve noticed him around town.

“Of course,” he breathed, eyes still fixed on him.

His eyes were bright and blue.

He asked about his soulmate, trying to gauge how attached the man was to her (what are you doing, Steve? You have a soulmate. You are in paradise.) She was at the banquet table, piling a plate with food beyond what was socially acceptable, and Steve tried to stop his nose wrinkling in disgust.

Yet, the man walked away. Steve made to follow him, but soon, too soon, she returned, staring at Steve with similarly blue eyes, calculating and wary.

Suddenly, the room felt cold and dreary. Steve turned, swallowing something bitter as he tried to find Nancy once again. She was still talking to the shaggy-haired man, face lit up in a delight Steve had never brought out from her.

An ugly, vicious emotion welled from his chest, slipping across his face as he came up to them. The other man’s eyes widened, he took a step back with a stammered, “Nice to meet you, Nancy,” and slipped back into the crowd, hopefully to find his soulmate.

“Steve.” Nancy crossed her arms and raised an eyebrow. “You interrupted an important conversation.”

“Couldn’t have been that important,” Steve mumbled, staring back across the room, eyes drawn like a moth to a flame to the blond hair through the crowd. “He didn’t seem very interesting.”

“I thought he was interesting.”

“That man,” he pointed at the blond, “you know his name?”

She appraised him with her cool brown eyes. They softened at times, when they looked at him. But they’d never lit up with joy or laughter or lust when they were on him, just a look you’d give a child when they played pretend.

“Billy Hargrove,” she answered, turning away. “He moved into the neighbourhood this morning. He’s Robin’s soulmate.”

“Billy,” Steve said to himself. The name sounded right on his tongue. “Billy.”

The music switched to something slower. People gestured to soulmates and soon the dancefloor was full of waltzing partners, enthralled with each other, like they were in a paradise. From the corner of his eye, Steve saw Nancy slip away, wondering faintly if she’d left before he could ask her to dance.

Billy’s soulmate, Robin, was twirled onto the dance floor by an unknown woman. Steve crossed the space without a second thought, sidling up to Billy once again.

“Can I have this dance?” he whispered, scared all at once of this strange forwardness.

Billy turned in surprise, face so close to Steve’s that he could see his own reflection in those blue eyes. Everything was warm, blooming like a summer’s day.

“What?” Billy asked.

Steve laughed.

“Can I have this dance?”

Billy’s waist was warm beneath his hands, soft with flesh and a solid backing of muscle. He never wanted to let go, wanted Billy closer and closer until they were entwined.

(What is happening to you Steve? Where is this nonsense coming from?)

“What about your wife?” Billy’s lips were shining from his drink, tinged pink and moving distractingly.

Steve stopped himself from looking for her then, afraid of being caught. Doing what, he wasn’t sure, but a gut feeling told him Nancy wouldn’t be happy with any answer.

“Nancy?”

“Yes. Your soulmate.”

Steve smiled, finding the frustrated pout oddly cute. “She’s around.”

He took the pause to start swaying with the music, pulling Billy with him. The other man didn’t seem to notice as the music swelled once more, and the crowd began to move.

“How long have you been here?”

“Like, four days,” Steve replied.

A stray curl fell against Billy’s forehead, dancing softly as they moved. Nancy never liked it when Steve tried to do anything gentle with her, always batting him away with ‘I can do it myself!’. If he tucked the curl behind Billy’s ear, would everything come crumbling back down.

“Your soulmate,” Steve whispered in his ear. “Where is she?”

Was Billy like him? With someone who might be wrong for him?  

Billy snorted against his shoulder. His breath was warm and moist. Steve shivered, told himself it was the heat.

“Dancing. What’s it to you?”

“Just can’t believe she’d leave you by yourself.”

She’d been stuck to his side since they walked through the door, and yet, when the most romantic aspect of the evening started, she disappeared.

If you were my soulmate, he wanted to say, I would never let you go.

They turned in time to the beat, turning and turning with a melody like a whisper brushing against their ears. He saw Nancy, for a moment, back in her corner, still talking, not a hint of bother at where Steve was. If he kissed Billy right now, would she even care?

Then Billy ripped himself from his grasp. The room went cold, quiet, a faint ringing in Steve’s ears that muffled everything but Billy as he said, “I literally don’t know you. I know her. I trust her. Leave me out of whatever this weird regency roleplay you and your soulmate have going on.”

“No,” Steve murmured. Told himself Billy was wrong. But Nancy still hadn’t looked his way, and the music changed to something faster and Robin spun into their conversation, flushed and vibrant.

And Billy no longer looked at him, eyes fixed firmly on his soulmate. They started to leave; Billy’s arm wrapped around Robin’s waist like it belonged there. Steve remained where he was, couples spinning around him like puppets on oblivious strings.

Soon after, the party dispersed. Steve had downed four drinks in that time. Now he was slumped over the empty glasses, where if he was self-aware, in a position reminiscent of his own father. Nancy fluttered around the room bidding farewell, lingering by the man from earlier and his soulmate, who seemed to have appeared from nowhere.

“You can’t pull a face like that when your own party is ending,” she told him, plucking the drink from his hand and placing it on the table, where it vanished instantaneously.

“I can if I didn’t have fun.”

Nancy quirked an unimpressed eyebrow. “Didn’t seem like that to me. You seemed to enjoy dancing with that man.”

“So, you did notice.” He scowled at his hands.

“Did I notice my soulmate spending the entire night following another man around the room? Of course I did, Steve.”

“You didn’t do anything.”

She rolled her eyes. “Why should I? It didn’t bother me.”

“Why?”

How was she okay with that, when the sight of her talking to someone else had sent Steve into a spiral?

“Because you’re my soulmate,” Nancy replied simply. “I know at the end of the day, it will be you and me.”

Steve wasn’t sure if he believed her. There was a routine to their lives, despite the few days they’d spent together. They woke up in their own beds, safe in the knowledge the other was down the hall, safe in the knowledge they had a soulmate.

Maybe it wasn’t the paradise, maybe it wasn’t soulmates or Nancy. Maybe the problem was Steve. Maybe paradise couldn’t be handed to you and expected to stay the same. (When he blinked, Billy was there, behind his eyes, blond and blinding and real.)

Maybe Steve was exactly like his mother, because there was a taste on his tongue sweet, like happiness, and he wanted to chase it into eternity.

Chapter 6: Here in eternity, damnation looms.

Chapter Text

Chapter 6 – Here in eternity, damnation looms.

Robin kissed a girl on screen, and nothing made sense anymore. Billy just couldn’t comprehend what was happening, why they were being lied to. To their faces as well.

Beside him, Robin rewound her memories, watching as she lunged across the table in the diner to kiss Vickie. Her eyes were soft and heavy as she watched, shadowed by sadness. It was an odd feeling, to grieve your own death, to not know if you were the only one to do so.

To grieve what you could’ve lived, if only you had more time.

He left her there, rewinding her life over and over. Told himself he was glad he couldn’t do the same (wondered if somewhere, out in the great expanse, was a memory of his mom).

The house seemed cold now, like this revelation broke through a barrier that held up the façade. That all the colours and warmth and joy they felt for a moment were built by the hands of a liar, for a purpose still unknown.

It went to the bathroom and tried to splash his face with water, but it was scalding as it came from the tap. The shower water was freezing cold as he stepped into it, the wooden floorboards now left splinters in his bare feet, the towel kept falling from the hook and the shampoo seemed to run out immediately.

Later, Billy emerged from the shower, trembling like a baby, mind still unclear, to find Brenner standing in the lounge. The screen was dark, and Robin hovered before it, face reminiscent of a child  trying not to be caught.

“Ah, Billy,” Brenner said, smiling. There was an obvious fakeness to it now; it didn’t meet the cold in his eyes. It twitched into a sneer before pulling back. “I was hoping to see you.”

“You are in my house,” Billy responded, dry.

“Well,” the other said, “that’s by the by. Let’s talk about your sermon.”

“Let’s not.”

“Well, as I’ve said many times already, the Good Place is here to allow each person to reach their potential, to do the things that will bring them bliss forever more. And I do believe that this is your purpose.”

“And if it’s not?”

Brenner bared his teeth in a vague resemblance of a smile. “You’ll never know if you don’t try.” With a pointed look around the room, he left, calling behind him, “See you Sunday!”

“I don’t even know why we still have weekdays,” Robin said, settling back down on the couch. She patted the space beside her and Billy fell into it, folding in on himself. Her hand brushed his hair in soothing motions as they stared at the black screen.

“I don’t understand what he’s getting from this.” His reflection looked exhausted. Leave it to Billy Hargrove to be drained in heaven. “Do you think we’re being paranoid, or taking all this for granted? I mean, we’re in the Good Place, heaven, paradise, and here we are, complaining it isn’t exactly what we expected.”

“Because paradise was promised to us.”

The house seemed to struggle with what it should be doing, brightening like the sun had risen before dimming in quick succession. It fluctuated between a cozy, loved home and a dreary unrenovated house. Before their eyes, static appeared on the screen before it started to play fake-Billy’s memories, speeding through them faster and faster until it stopped. Rewound. Started to play at a normal speed.

The other him stood in front of an enthralled congregation, shouting about fire and brimstone and other hellish entities. “And if we continue to live a life rich in sin, the heavenly gates before us will not open. There will be no paradise, no eternal reward, for you will not deserve it. All that awaits the sinner is fire and ash and suffering so unfathomable only the devil himself could come up with it.”

“What’s the point of preaching in the afterlife?” he pondered. “The entire point of religion is to try and get to whatever concept of heaven you believe in, whatever eternal reward your God promised. But we’re here now. What’s the incentive? What’s to stop people from sinning now? Unless the Good Place/ Bad Place dynamic isn’t as static as presented.”

“You think if someone does something wrong, they’ll be sent to the Bad Place?”

“Makes sense.” Billy could feel the excitement coursing through him now. “Eternity is a long time for a person to be good in an unchanging place. If the weather remains the same, the seasons, the neighbourhood stuck in a pastoral limbo, what’s to stop someone from pushing at the boundaries. I don’t know about you, but being stuck here forever sounds boring.”

“So, you hate me.” Her laughter was sweet, then she said seriously, “If he’s making you do a sermon anyway, maybe you should talk about that.”

“What else would you say? God and heaven don’t seem to be real, and they seem to be the two big components of religion.”

“Morality and ethics.”

“What everyone loves to think about on a Sunday morning.”


The most pressing moral and ethical question on his mind was fundamentally; could he be attracted to someone who had a soulmate? Was Billy’s presence in the neighbourhood upsetting the balance of other soulmates as well?

Because he could not stop thinking of Steve Harrington. His large, gentle hands. His kind eyes. Even out and about, Billy found himself peering over people in search of Steve and his large hair.

Sometimes they saw each other. Steve would light up if he was alone, arm waving over heads. If Nancy was there, Steve would smile at Billy but always angled his body to face Nancy, like a compass pointing north. Nancy never extended Steve the same grace, always walking ahead, always talking over him, always so sure in herself that it was recognisable from metres away.

There were moments when Billy swore Steve would come to him. Convinced he’d be weaving his way through the crowds to catch Billy in quick conversation, but Steve stayed away. Billy pretended it didn’t bother him.

Sometimes, when he wanted to indulges in his imagination, Billy told himself that him and Robin being soulmates had put everyone into mismatches. That in another paradise, Billy would’ve woken up and been introduced to Steve. Then he would be satisfied.

But those fantasies were locked firmly away. They were not allowed to fester more than they already had. Billy might’ve been a mean person in life, but he wouldn’t be cruel enough to rip someone’s paradise away on a presumption.

(And yet.)


Brenner skulked, sending reminders to Billy everyday leading up to his passion fulfilment day. Someone pasted posters around town, advertising his sermon like it was the answer to everything.

Find bliss in eternal happiness, the slogan read.

People Billy couldn’t remember were coming up with excited grins, grasping his hands and thanking him for the service. “I haven’t done it yet,” he told one woman, who laughed so loudly she startled a bird from a tree.

There was a religious fervour unleashed, crosses appeared on walls like they’d always been there, and the café only played hymns. No one else seemed bothered by it, going on their merry way like it was a normal everyday occurrence.

Robin refused to go to the café. She was twitchier, looking over her shoulder and jumping at shadows. Guilt was a constant companion for Billy when he watched her, contemplating time and time again how he managed to ruin her afterlife in a matter of minutes.

Then, before he knew it, the day had come. It was bright and beautiful, like a filter over a photograph. The birdsong sang sweetly on a looping sound Billy couldn’t unhear.

There was an outfit in his closet, the familiar black gown of a preacher with the white collar and vestments. Billy refused to touch it, spending minutes staring at it, trying to beg his hands to move and yet they didn’t. He couldn’t do it.

Instead, he pulled on the familiar red shirt, unbuttoned the top few buttons enough so his necklace was visible. He pulled on the skinniest jeans imaginable and decided he didn’t quite care anymore. Brenner would have to admit he knew Billy was a mistake in front of everyone if he didn’t want Billy like that.

Pretending didn’t seem as important anymore.

A knock at the door.

Robin made no move from the couch to answer. Billy sauntered over instead, opening the door and finding Steve on the other side. Steve, who couldn’t keep his eyes off Billy’s bare chest.

“Hey,” Billy said, casual as ever.

Steve’s eyes finally moved to meet his. “Hi. Just came to wish you luck for the sermon. But I guess you aren’t ready yet?”

“No, I’m ready.” Billy shrugged and leant against the doorframe with a smirk. Steve’s eyes tried to not look down but didn’t quite make it. Something hummed in Billy like a satisfied cat stretching languidly in the sun. “Want to come with me?”

“What about your soulmate?” Steve said. He tacked on, “Robin,” to prove he knew her name.

“She’s coming later.” He wasn’t sure she was coming at all.

Steve agreed, moved his arm like he was going to hold it out for Billy to take, but took a step back. Billy followed with one last glance at Robin. The air was thick with sweet citrus, and the sun beat down on them like it was the height of summer. Further down the path, where it split off either to Steve’s house, the lake or the town, Heather appeared, walking in the opposite direction.

“Your sermon’s soon, isn’t it?” She cocked an eyebrow and looked him up and down in amusement.

“All ready,” he said, waving a hand at his outfit.

She laughed. It softened the sharper edges of her face. “Brenner won’t like that.”

Confident in what he knew about her, he said, “He shouldn’t have made me do this then.”

Appraising him, Heather’s eyes flicked back to Steve who was hovering at the edge. “Afterwards, you should come round mine. I think we need to talk.”

“I don’t know where you live.”

She pointed at the lake, where a boathouse was tied to the dock. “I live in a boat.” She did not look happy about this.

“It’s a nice boat,” Steve offered.

“How many bedrooms do you have?” Heather asked. She turned back to Billy before Steve could respond. “My house. After. Jonathan won’t be there.” Steve scowled as she winked and continued along the path.

If Billy turned around, he would’ve seen Heather turn on the opposite path to the lake, up his own driveway and through his door. Steve saw and Steve pondered, and Steve decided something that would change everything.


Practically the entire neighbourhood was at the church, a thronging crowd like a mass of ants, scrambling and pushing. Steve stood in front and shoved his way through like he was Billy’s bodyguard, physically bodychecking a woman when she reached out to touch Billy. Like he was something holy.

Brenner was waiting by the large oak doors, a brass key the length of Billy’s palm on his belt. As Billy stepped up the stairs, Steve trailing behind still forcing people back, Brenner clapped Billy on the shoulder like he was his son.

“You ready?”

Billy wanted to smack him.

He took the proffered key. It fit into the lock and opened the door with a heavy thud. Inside, the church was beautiful, like the inside of a storybook. The stained glass shone a myriad kaleidoscopic sunrays on the grey stone floor. The pews were a deep black wood and the pulpit matched.

Behind him, the crowd surged, barrelling over Steve like a wave. He fell into Billy, sending them both stumbling. Billy hit his chin on a pew, but the pain faded quickly. When he stood, everyone was seated, facing forward with passive faces.

Steve stood, shaking his head in disbelief. Brenner was at the pulpit already, beckoning Billy forward. Suddenly, Billy was deeply, deeply afraid. Without thinking, he reached behind him, grasping for Steve’s hand. He felt Steve’s fingers slip between his and squeezed gratefully.

In his dreams, Billy was in a church like this, in a suit and tie. Max was there, hair glowing red in the candlelight and his mom walked him down the aisle, light haloing her like an angel. Steve was waiting for him at the end, hair brushed and beaming so brightly that Billy can’t look at anything else. In his dreams, Billy took Steve’s hands, turned to the priest and woke up.

This was nothing like Billy’s dreams. He felt like he was walking to his doom. The candles flickered as he passed, but no one turned to face him. Their placid faces didn’t move; empty smiles plastered on their faces.

As he stepped up to the lectern, where the Bible waited for him, Billy swallowed down rising vomit and turned to face the congregation, still holding hands with Steve. They stared up at him with blank eyes, and in one movement, they all opened their bibles.

Amen. Amen. Amen. Amen.

It echoed and echoed, crawling over his skin, slipping into his bloodstream. Billy placed a trembling hand on the book, tracing the words he vaguely remembered from a life that now seemed so long ago.

“Don’t,” Steve muttered, grip tight.

“I have to,” Billy said. He felt like crying.

Because he never told Robin the letter Brenner sent him. The letter with the word Vickie in thick, black marker. Names were written and then erased but when he held it up to the light, he could make out the scrawled words. Steve and Heather and Nancy and Jonathan.

When he read it, he believed it was a test, maybe the final test, but one none the less. And if he failed, Billy wouldn’t go to the Bad Place, but those four names, written so faintly, would. But the hours he’d spent pacing, a slow, slinking realisation settled in his bones.

He never managed to put it to words before.

He tried to say quietly, so only Steve could hear, “I don’t think this is the Good Place.”

Steve tried to let go of his hand, but Billy clung on. The people before him, Tina and Tammy and Andy and Jason and Edith and all the others that Billy realised were not real, waited.

“When do we stop sinning?” he asked, voice ringing loud. “When have we earned our place in heaven? Does it end with our time on Earth?”

Amen. Amen. Amen.

“What makes heaven, heaven? What makes hell, hell? How are neighbourhoods created? How are points calculated?” He was asking all the questions that had built within him over the last days (Weeks? Months?). “Do they stop? Or are they still going? If they’ve stopped, what’s to stop us from doing bad things?”

Unable to help himself, he turned to Brenner. “I don’t think we’re in the Good Place.”

“Where are you then?” The man asked coldly.

“Purgatory.”

Amen. Amen. Amen.

Brenner’s smile was pleased. It didn’t make Billy feel better. He pulled Steve close and inhaled, letting the faint scent of oranges soothe him.

The congregation rose as one, hands open in prayer, but the words they said were garbled. The candles went out, one by one, until they were standing in darkness. The stretch of colours from the windows formed a figure and Billy wondered when Jesus began to look like the devil.

“Thank you for today, Billy. I’ve learnt a lot.”

“If you send them to the Bad Place, you’ll have to send me too. I’ll commit as many sins as needed to get there.”  

“Go home, Billy.” Brenner said.

Steve pulled him from the building, arm around Billy’s trembling waist. The world seemed stifling.

“You’re crying,” Steve said. He pulled to a stop and turned Billy to him, cupping his face and wiping the tears away with his thumbs. “I don’t understand what really happened in there, but I think I got enough. This isn’t the Good Place?”

“No…” Billy sobbed and lunged into Steve’s arms. The tears weren’t stopping, and he didn’t know what to do.

“How did you know?”

“Because I’m here.”

“And I’m here.”

Billy looked at him through the tears. “What’s that supposed to mean?”

“I don’t think I’m a great person, either,” Steve smiled sheepishly.

“I was so mean to my sister,” Billy said.

“I was a bully,” Steve responded.

“I was so angry at my dad and she was there,” Billy continued.

“I was an insecure little shit, and I needed other people to feel that way too.”

“I slashed his tires once.”

“I used to steal money from my parents.”

“Sometimes, I hate my mom.”

“So do I.”

“I was such an asshole to all my friends.”

“I was a brat.”

“My dad beat me.”

Steve kissed him then, quick and desperate and so warm. Billy pulled him closer, hands gripping the thick locks that had been taunting him for ages. It was slick and hungry and everything he wanted, everything he hoped and dreamed.

Maybe he was wrong. Maybe this was the Good Place after all.

 

Chapter 7: Lavender marriage and all its complications.

Chapter Text

Chapter 7- lavender marriage and all its complications.

Steve left to find Nancy.

Billy knew a conversation was needed, and he understood Steve didn’t want to keep it a secret but watching him walk away made his chest ache, nonetheless. Billy stood at the crossroads, one road leading to his ugly house and the other to the lake. He turned to the lake.

The entire world was still as if holding its breath. He walked the path to the lake, kicking loose stones, body still tingling from the kiss. He didn’t know what he’d done, or what it would change. He didn’t know what Brenner would do now, whether Billy failed the test, whether the target actually was Robin and Steve. He didn’t know a lot of things. It hit him how young he’d been on Earth.

Before he decided what to do, he needed to talk to Heather. Maybe she understood better than he did.

The lake sprawled before him, glittering in the sun, blue and green swirling together. But it was still and quiet. It didn’t lap against the golden sand. There were no winds to create waves. No birds or bugs. Just water and the sun and the boat afloat by the dock. It rocked beneath his feet when he stepped onto it.

Heather peered through the window as he walked the length. The door was open. Heather sat on her couch, a deep blue like the ocean.

“How’d it go?” she asked. She didn’t bother to move so he could sit with her but gestured to a small stool tucked beneath the breakfast bar.

Billy perched on the uncomfortable stool. “Not very well. I think I’ve pissed Brenner off.”

“How?”

“By suggesting this isn’t actually the Good Place?”

Heather’s eyes widened and she slumped dramatically backwards. “Oh, thank god I wasn’t the only one who noticed!”

“You knew?”

“Not specifically, but I’ve been suspicious of this paradise since I got here.” She looked around her boathouse and scowled in exaggerated disgust. “This is not my paradise.”

“And Jonathan?” Billy noticed he wasn’t there. There weren’t a lot of personal touches on the boat, everything seemed stale and stagnant, like a hotel room that got cleaned whenever you went out.

“Not here. And I knew when I saw him the universe was wrong.”

 She appraised him, leaning forward with her elbows on her knees, chin perched on her hands. She peered through her lashes, fluttering them as she waited for Billy to ask.

“I knew when I saw Robin,” he said instead.

“I’m a lesbian.”

“I’m gay.”

They both relaxed. Heather moved up the couch, leaving enough space for Billy to fall into it.

“This is much better than mine.”

“Yours is horrendous,” she agreed.

“So,” he nudged her shoulder, “you and Robin?”

She blushed and shoved him back, harder. “Whatever. You and Steve?”

“We kissed,” he admitted. Saying it out loud filled him with joy and shame and pride and sadness, it made his stomach clench and his heart beat faster.

“We’ve kissed as well.”

He tried to decide whether or not it was his business to know. Billy and Robin had known about each other from the beginning, knew about Steve and Heather before the other person even understood what was happening. But still, a small bubble of betrayal tried to escape. He swallowed it back down.

“When?”

Heather understood anyway. “Whilst you were doing your sermon. I went to check on her.”

“How is she?”

“Sad and guilty.”

“About kissing you?”

“Yes and no,” Heather said. “It’s complicated. I think it’s something you need to talk about together.”

It was Billy’s turn to study Heather. Her body held a tension which never fully let up, an engrained fight or flight she was reacting on subconsciously. He wondered how she died, because the neighbourhood seemed disproportionately young.

“What about you and Jonathan?”

“We spoke about it, when we first arrived. Agreed to keep pretending. Honestly, I think he’s been waiting for Nancy and Steve to implode.”

Jonathan and Nancy. Heather and Robin. Billy and Steve.

“That worked out well,” he joked.

She smiled but shrugged. “Depends on what happens now. Because this isn’t the Good Place. Everything has been off, mildly inconvenient or uncomfortable. Something you can’t quite put your finger on until afterwards.”

“Like the houses and shops. Nice enough but definitely don’t cater to me.”

They fall into a comfortable silence, letting their bodies move with the gentle sway of the boat. They could make this place a Good Place, Billy thought. If they did some reshuffling, rearranged certain households (and it was a selfish thought, he could admit that now. Because maybe Billy wanted to be soulmates with Steve. Wanted to have a happy afterlife even if he didn’t deserve it).

“What happens now? Do we just go back to pretending?” Billy asked.

He could say now that he would agree to remain as Robin’s soulmate if it stopped them from going to the Bad Place. But it would change their relationship, the knowledge they both had someone else, they could’ve had someone else, but were together for selfish, self-preserving reasons. He also didn’t know what would happen if Steve asked him not to.

“I don’t think I can keep pretending,” Heather replied and buried her face in her hands.

Footsteps sounded out on the dock and Robin’s face peered through the window. She brightened when she saw them, coming through the door moments later. She paused as she took Billy and Heather in.

“You okay?” She seemed nervous.

“I told Billy,” Heather said.

“Oh.” Robin turned to him, reached for his hands. Billy took them, warm hands in warm hands, looking into her pale, anxious face. “I would’ve asked you first, but it got all emotional and sappy, and I couldn’t help myself.”

“I kissed Steve,” Billy cut her off.

Robin dramatically slumped, “Oh, good. Now I feel less bad.”

Heather shifted along the couch even more and Robin wiggled herself between them. Soft hair tickled Billy’s nose.

“How did the sermon go?”

“Billy might have destroyed the neighbourhood,” Heather said cheerfully.

“Nothing major then,” Robin agreed. “Wait, what?”

“I told everyone we aren’t in the Good Place.”

“We aren’t?” She looked between Heather and Billy. They didn’t have to wait long before she slumped. “I knew something was off.”

Heather stood, bent down and pressed a kiss to Robin’s hair. “I think the two of you need to talk.”

Alone, Billy and Robin turned to each other. Robin pulled him into a hug, tucking her head into his neck.

“Are you doing okay?” he whispered into her hair.

“I am now,” she whispered. “It was hard for a while.”

“Why?” he asked gently.

“Because I was quick to reassure you I was okay with all of this. But I wanted a soulmate and when it was you, a part of me was crushed. And you were in the same place as me and were willing to stick it out for a semblance of happiness. I thought I could do it too.”

“And then Heather?” Billy prompted, resting his chin on her head.

“And then Heather,” she agreed. “And I tried so hard, but Heather saw the way you looked at Steve and Steve looked at you, so I thought maybe there was a chance of having both.”

“You can have both, once we figure it out.”

“Okay,” she whispered. “Okay.”


It was Nancy who found him next.

He gave Robin and Heather their space and walked down the strange beach with sand that seemed to get everywhere. The sun was trying to set as he settled on a rock, skipping rocks across the still water.

Someone sat beside him, and from his peripheral vision, he could see Nancy. She tucked her skirt around her legs and rested her hands on her knees.

“Steve’s in love with you,” she said, staring at the horizon.

“I didn’t know,” he said. There was a warmth in his chest though. He smiled at his reflection in the water.

“He said he kissed you.”

“That I did know.” He could feel her glaring and skipped another stone. “What are you actually annoyed about? The fact that he doesn’t want to be with a fake soulmate who didn’t care about him in the same way, or that he didn’t ask your permission first?”

“He’s sweet and kind of a dope,” she said quietly. “If I was alive, I would’ve been happy with him as my boyfriend. But this is eternity we’re talking about. Truthfully, I was disappointed.”

Because she was Nancy, Billy wanted to goad her, but he couldn’t lie to her. “We all were. I think that was the point.”

“You were?”

“I’m gay,” he said simply.

She hummed. They fell silent, watching Billy skip stones. “I am not mad at you or Steve. I was just hurt that he didn’t think he could come to me with his problems.”

Billy didn’t know what to say. He knew Steve probably would’ve tried with Nancy, if she was willing too. But Billy wasn’t as willing to let Steve go now.

 “What’s happening with Jonathan?”

She went bright red. “He’s interesting.”

“I think he’s interested in you.”

“He is,” she admitted. “He told me a few days ago.”

“And?”

“I told him I would think about it.”

As he went to speak, the pale orange sky suddenly flared red. A siren blared, exploding the landscape with a cacophony of noise. Both Billy and Nancy covered their ears as the sound rattled their bones.

WARNING! WARNING! SIX HUMANS HAVE BEEN COMPROMISED! WARNING! WARNING! SIX HUMANS HAVE BEEN COMPROMISED! WARNING! WARNING!

The message repeated over and over, the dead, robotic voice echoing across the horizon. Robin and Heather emerged from the boat to stare at the sky, and two figures raced down the hill towards them.

Billy pulled Nancy up with him and they ran back towards the boat. Billy didn’t know why the boat felt safer than anywhere else, he was sure if he really wanted to, Brenner could find them. Drain the lake, land-lock them.

They reached it at the same time as Steve and Jonathan, both panting and wild-eyed. Steve shoved them all in, sending the three of them stumbling down the stairs. Heather and Robin helped stabilise them as Steve slammed the door behind them.

Heather and Jonathan closed all the curtains bar a slither of glass that showed the path to town. The noise was muffled in the boat, but the sky still flashed the warning red.

“So, definitely not the Good Place,” Heather panted, collapsing back on the couch.

“It still could be,” Nancy pointed out. “It could be they made a mistake, and we aren’t supposed to be here.”

“All six of us?” Jonathan asked.

“They called us humans,” Steve said. He leant against Billy, tugging him close. If it was anyone else, the gesture would’ve been constraining, but because it was Steve, Billy folded himself further into his side.

“What did you say to them?” Heather asked Billy. The joking tone in her voice was completely gone from earlier. She meant business now. “The exact words.”

“I said it was a test I needed to pass to get into the Good Place and implied we were still stuck in purgatory. Brenner seemed pleased.”

Jonathan frowned from his shadowed corner. “Why would they not just tell us it’s purgatory?”

“Why are there only six of us,” Robin also asked.

That gave them all pause.  Why did Brenner form a purgatory for six humans and fill it with over a hundred entities, most who they most likely have never met? Why not just gather one hundred people and say, ‘hey, you’re in purgatory, good luck getting out!’?

“Tina,” Robin said, sitting up suddenly. They turned to her and Billy gestured for her to elaborate. “Tina was specifically trying to get us to stay in a horrendous romantic relationship whilst flaunting her own sapphic relationship in our faces.”

“So, people have been actively hindering us?” Nancy asked. “Like, Jason.” Here, Steve’s eyes lit up in a revelation.

“I don’t think this is purgatory either,” Heather said. “I think purgatory would be neutral. This place has been actively working against us. I think this might be the Bad Place!”

That… made sense. A horrifying, dreadful amount of sense.

(Of course, Billy Hargrove wouldn’t even make it to purgatory.)

“What do we do?” Robin whispered.

“I don’t know,” Billy said.

Outside, the siren blared and Brenner’s eye searched for them using the moon and stars.

Chapter 8: Make a heaven out of hell.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Chapter 8- how to ruin paradise in five easy steps.

Step 1- leave on a boat

Heather sprang into action immediately, pulling Jonathan with her. in the slither of window through the floral-patterned curtain, a large crowd was gathering. The sky flared red in regular intervals and with every flash, more and more figures swarmed the hill like flies.

Jonathan, face set in grim determination, unhooked the rope from the dock. The entire boat trembled slightly as the current beneath the water caught it. Billy stared at the floorboards, adrenaline coursing through his veins. The instinct to race up the hill to fight whatever Brenner was sending was immense, but he managed to quell the urge as the figures slowly faded into the distance.

Heather and Jonathan talked in hushed whispers, heads closed together. Billy wondered what they’re agreement was; whether they would’ve agreed to be soulmates for eternity as well. They were never that affectionate in public before, so sometimes it was easy to forget they lived together. But as they communicated in short words and gestures, Billy was struck with a sudden wave of sadness.

If he’d woken up and was soulmates with Steve, would he and Robin be friends? Would Heather and Jonathan, if they were with Robin and Nancy, be able to talk with such familiarity? Would Steve and Nancy be pressed against each other in comfort? Would they be any happier?

The boat drifted and their bodies settled. At intervals they’d peer out the window, announce the sky was still flashing and turn away. No one was trying to plan or discuss what was happening beyond the walls. They instead turned to the next best thing—Monopoly.

It was the only game Heather and Jonathan had, and it was the Easter addition. Billy rolled his dice, moved his rabbit and promptly went bankrupt as he handed a smug Nancy all his money.

Steve was the first out and was sitting on the couch. Billy joined him, pressing their legs together.

“What do you think is going to happen?” Steve asked.

He leaned his head against Billy’s, close enough that he could feel the way his lips moved against his hair.

“I don’t know. I don’t even know if this is a piece of land floating in space, or if it’s connected to anything. But I think I’d like to try and find a new paradise.”

“Any place with you is paradise,” Steve said softly. He pressed a kiss to Billy’s curls. Billy tipped his head upwards and kissed Steve gently on the lips. Steve cradled him close as they took comfort in each other, warmth spreading through them.

Then the boat rocked, tipping dramatically to one side. Billy startled, sprawling backwards as objects fell from cabinets. Monopoly money went flying as the boat groaned in protest. Robin was under the table, spitting stands of hair out of her mouth. Jonathan and Heather were awkwardly lying on each other in an odd embrace, limbs tangled together.

Nancy was the first to stand, brushing herself off and stepping daintily over the mess to look out the window.

“I think we’ve made it to somewhere new.”


 

Step 2- get lost in the fog

Billy got off the boat first, squinting through the thick mist that seeped around them. The sky was inky black, no stars but a faint glow from a circle struggling to be the moon. But it was quiet, with no alarm blaring.

“I think it’s alright,” he called back.

The others scrambled out, coming to stand by him. The boat beached itself on a bay where the sand grains were fine glass. The cliffs where the mist crawled down were sheer, jagged rocks sticking out at jutting angles.

“There,” Robin said.

Following her finger, in the side of the cliff was a staircase. It seemed unstable and thin, winding up through the rocks and disappearing into the white.

They all looked at each other, shrugged and walked towards it. Glass tinkled beneath their feet as they walked, stopping at points to shake the shards from their shoes.

Calling it a staircase was a kind description; it looked like erosion had tried its best to recreate stairs. They were all different sizes, some were crumbling and they went up and up with no barrier between them and the ground.

“We can’t die again, can we?” Steve asked. He slipped his fingers into Billy’s hand once again.

“No other way to find out,” Heather replied.

She placed one foot on the first step and pressed down, testing them. Then she started to climb. Robin started after her, before she fully vanished into the fog.

Jonathan glanced between them before gesturing to Nancy. She rolled her eyes but brushed her fingers against his cheek gently. Jonathan followed shortly after, hands out in front of him, as if ready to catch her if she fell.

“You go,” Billy whispered. The air was thick, and he feared his voice wouldn’t reach Steve.

Steve looked at him, eyes wide. Billy gave him a shove, letting go of the hand and missing the warmth immediately.

“You’ll be behind me?”

“All the way,” Billy murmured.

Without thought, he pressed a kiss to Steve’s chin. Steve swallowed, turning to the looming steps. With one more look, he made the first step and then didn’t stop.

For a moment, Billy stood in the glass, surrounded by fog winding its way around his legs like a cat. The boat rested on the beach, dark against the horizon. He didn’t know what was up there, didn’t know what he would find, but he took the first step anyway.

The first few were fine, wide enough to fit his whole foot. He squinted into the thick fog, staring at Steve’s back further up. But it was getting further away. Billy started to climb faster, heart thumping in his throat as Steve seemed to move further and further away.

A wind picked up, whipping around him. Billy stopped. Looked down. Nothing but white. Nothing but white all around. He looked back up but Steve was gone. The stairs were gone. He felt weightless, suspended, and so, so alone. He leant forward like he did as a child and used his hands to find the next step, pulling himself up.

“Steve!” he called, but the wind stole the fear from him.

Hands grabbed him, voices frantic as they pulled and pulled. Then Billy could breathe, inhaling lungfuls of air, thick with brine and soil. Steve was curled around him, frantically whispering, “Billy. Billy. Billy.”

“I’m here,” he repeated. “I’m here.”


 

Step 3 – trust a stranger

“Well, there,” a voice said, amusement potent, “you look like you’ve been through hell.” Then the man laughed like it was a hilarious joke.

Billy tried to sit up, but Steve clung to him, so he ended in a strange half-up pose. The fog was gone, and they seemed to be in a field after it was tilled. The earth was dry and crumbling beneath them. A man, with thick, wavy hair smiled at them, hand waving.

“Hiya, I’m Eddie.”

“Fuck off,” Heather said. Robin seemed to be trying to curl into her lap, face wet with tears.

“Look, y’all just climbed the misery steps, and it’s my responsibility to provide a semblance of care.”

“That’s what that was?” Nancy snapped. Her hair was ruined, buffered by the wind and caked with dirt. Jonathan was beside her, head buried in his hands.

“Uh, duh?” Eddie chuckled again, hands spreading wide. “You’re in the Bad Place, after all.”

This was not what they wanted to hear. The mild theory Heather presented on the boat felt like months ago, and they took comfort in the fact it might not be true. But it was. They were in hell, miserable, terrifying hell.

Billy held Steve’s hand.

It’s fine. Steve is here. He is paradise. He is here.

This did not comfort him.

“I told Brenner it wouldn’t work,” Eddie continued, seeming to smile wider at their obvious despair. “He said, ‘I’ll just tell them they’re in paradise and make it wrong for them’ and I said, 'that’s dumb and stupid and they’ll figure it out quick.’ I was right, of course, but I thought it would take you longer.”

As he spoke, they drew closer and closer together. Huddling close like dogs in the winter, trembling, frightened and ready to bite.

“Hmm,” Eddie tapped his chin. His movements were always exaggerated, like someone trying their best to be a person but not quite doing it. “Now, what kind of demon would I be if I didn’t go against the regime? Tell you what, I’ll help ya out!”

“Why?” Heather whispered.

“The Good Place. The Bad Place.” Eddie tipped his hands like weighing scales. “Both serve the same function. Judge, judge, judge. Only good. Only bad. Only black. Only white. Forced conformity, the afterlife’s favourite pastime.”

He looked at them expectantly. They all nodded.

“Well, me and a couple of buddies decided to pull a Satan and diverge from the rules set in place by our cold and angry universe. We thought to ourselves, because us demons have that advantage, and decided, why not have a Medium Place. Not for extraordinarily good, not for exceptionally bad. But for humans like you, who just lived lives.”

“Is that why you’re here?” Billy asked. Steve relented in his grip for a moment, allowing Billy to fall further into his warmth. “To take us to this Medium Place?”

“Yup! If ya want,” Eddie chirped, hair bouncing like the ears of a very fluffy, very excited dog.

“Of course we want that,” Heather said. She stood up, pulling Robin with her. Jonathan and Nancy slowly got up as well. Billy struggled, but he slowly stood with Steve still attached like a limpet.

“Great,” Eddie said, gesture wide and sweeping once more, “if you’ll follow me.”


 

Step 4 – realise it’s all broken

The Medium Place was a trailer park on the edge of the woods. It was large, the trailers looked spacey and welcoming and there was an atmosphere of joy that hadn’t been there in the fake Good Place at all.

They weren’t the first humans to arrive; Eddie had told them as he led them through the brass iron gates. There were symbols on the iron, protection from the two oppressive fractions (Eddie’s words) which prevented them from being found.

There was an elderly couple tending a fire, faces youthful despite their age, like the vitality of life was still coursing through their veins.

“Got sent to the Bad Place because they never had kids,” Eddie said as they walked by. “Minus two hundred points for each unborn child you could’ve had.” He mouthed ‘unprotected sex’ with wiggling eyebrows.

A small boy throwing a basketball. “Died before he told his parents he was the one to break the vase. Minus fifty points.”

A teenage girl strumming a guitar. “Killed herself. Minus three thousand.”

Two men, both sitting in deckchairs and reading books. “Gay. Minus ten points for every gay thought.”

“Sorry,” Nancy said at some point after being told a five-year-old boy lost ten points because he told a teacher his dad hurt him, “what is this point system? How do you even get into the Good Place?”

“You don’t,” Eddie said bluntly. “No one’s got in for over one hundred years. But none of the higher ups want to admit something’s wrong. So, they just blame the humans.”

“They can’t do that!” Robin protested.

Eddie shrugged. “We’re not actually human. So theoretically the point system is unbiased and fair.”

“It lacks nuance,” Billy said.

“Sure,” Eddie agreed. “Human life is complicated. Every action has a chain reaction. Rejecting a girl in middle school leads her to believe she’s ugly which gives her self-confidence issues which makes her suicidal and then she kills herself. Not only is that negative points for her, but for you as well.”

“I’m guessing there’s always more bad reactions than good,” Jonathan said quietly, still staring at the little boy who was excitedly telling a black woman (filed a complaint against her boss for harassment, minus thirty-five points) a story.

“There’s a threshold for the Good Place. Essentially, you can only get in if you haven’t lost any points.”

“And that’s impossible.” Heather’s face warred between disbelief and grief. “We had no chance.”

“You have one now.” The soft voice was oddly familiar. When Billy turned, a tiny blonde girl emerged from a trailer, holding files.

“Chrissy!” Eddie lit up and scampered over to her, hugging her enthusiastically.

“You haven’t been gone that long,” she laughed, hugging him back.

“Are soulmates real?” Billy asked.

Her face softened into something sympathetic when she saw him. “Yes and no. There are hundreds of potential matches spanning hundreds of years, but humans are fickle and stubborn. Any attempt at a soulmate initiative failed. You lot like to choose.”

“I choose you.” Steve’s voice was quiet, like a breath that wasn’t meant to be heard.

“I choose you too,” Billy said, squeezing his hand. “For as long as you’ll have me.”


 

Step 5- make a heaven out of hell

Billy and Steve’s trailer was at the edge of the park. From their kitchen window, they could see the pond where the kids liked to feed the ducks and catch tadpoles. From their bedroom was the forest, the Medium Place’s defence. It lit up with orange in the morning, light kissing them gently in farewell at night.

Pathways led into these woods, where they led to other trailer parks. The Medium Place was expanding at a rapid pace, filling with more and more people, fresh to the afterlife and those who’d been there for centuries, finally pulled from eternal punishment into something more deserving.

The Medium Place wasn’t perfect by any means. People from varying walks of life, in varying shades of grey, lived together. Arguments broke out, enemies were made, crimes were committed. But the Medium Place never loomed with the threat of the Bad Place. Crimes were dealt with in house and punishments dealt accordingly, namely a place worse than torture called ‘a therapist’.

Billy was never sure what agreement Eddie and Chrissy managed to wrangle from the figures up high, but the Medium Place was medium. The water was always lukewarm, television played adverts (mainly local ventures like the new café opening down the street which only opened for three hours during the week and never on the weekend), the sky was always overcast, and every crime novel was written by James Patterson.

But it was perfect for Billy because Steve was there, in the bed, in the kitchen, in the lounge, smiling his dopey smile, spraying his hair with thick hairspray and singing in the shower despite the water pressure being middle road.

They would curl up on their couch, no longer an ugly maroon but a soft lavender. Billy took up knitting, he wasn’t very good, but he had all of eternity to improve. Steve admitted through tears that he wasn’t dyslexic anymore and was now reading all the books he couldn’t before. He and Nancy had formed a book club.

Jonathan and Nancy ran the local newspaper, a chirpy reporter called Ben joining their team after a few months. Robin and Heather were ‘backpacking’ whatever the Medium Place equivalent was, probably camping in the woods, but every time Billy saw them they seemed more and more in love.

He wondered at times, when it was too dark out and the shadows stretched into something sinister, whether his mom was here. Whether Max would arrive soon. Where Neil was.

Eddie offered to show him Neil’s point total once. Billy declined. He didn’t want to see his life in a series of tally marks. Didn’t want to see how little Neil lost in comparison to Billy.

Steve reunited with Tommy and Carol, who made it to their fifties before dying in a car crash. They lived three trailers down and were often round for wine and game night (the wine being the cheapest Store-brand and the game being character-themed Monopoly or Ticket To Ride).

One night, as Steve kissed down his throat, hand spread across Billy’s chest, Billy found the courage to ask, “Would you choose me if you were still alive?”

Steve tweaked his nipple. “I’d choose you in every universe.”

“That’s gay, Steve.”

“I love you.”

“I love you too.”

Outside it started to rain and the lights flickered before going out completely. But they still had the candlelight and each other for company as they made it through another night.

Notes:

comments, kudos or anything else you're willing to give is very much appreciated

i hope you all liked this fic, I really adored writing it. I thought it was such a fun concept and I hope I did it justice :D

thanks again to Squid for betaing, i really do appreciate it.

and a huge, huge thanks to HighlyWastedBlueJeans for her beautiful fanart despite the bad timing <3

follow me on tumblr for more big bang adventures :))

Series this work belongs to: