Actions

Work Header

Everything is fine.

Chapter 2: The Soulmate Conundrum.

Chapter Text

Chapter two – the soulmate conundrum.

This has gotta be a joke.

Billy couldn’t stop staring at the woman. She was obviously a woman, because the thing she said next in the most disgusted tone was, “You’re a man?”

“Yes. Billy Hargrove.” He stood and held out his hand, like they were two business partners meeting for a conference and not supposed soulmates meeting for the first time.

Now, Billy was new to both the Good Place and the concept of soulmates, but he was sure that you probably should be attracted to them in some capacity. And, not from lack of trying, Billy was attracted to men.

Only.

“Robin Buckley,” she took his hand. Hers was soft, nails painted a light blue, and he wondered in the back of his mind if she’d woken up with them painted.

“Right.”

He let go and took a step back. On the screen, it had paused on one of his ‘missions’ where he was performing a sermon to a village in Kenya. Robin eyed this with apprehension. He fumbled and turned it off.

“I suppose you’ve been here by yourself.” Billy tried to sound casual.

“Yes. Brenner showed me around a few days ago. I – uh,” she stammered for a moment, fingers twisting in the fabric of her t-shirt. “I wasn’t expecting you.”

There was an odd accusation on her voice that made Billy bristle. He swiped a hand through his hair, and the curls settled perfectly once again. He swiped his tongue across his teeth and crossed his arms, regarding Robin once more.

“Not what you expected in a soulmate, huh?”

She let out another choked wheeze, eyes frantically glancing around the room as if looking for an escape.

Trying to let some his tension out, he tried to joke, “I personally thought my soulmate would have better interior design taste.”

Robin’s face turned red immediately and she screeched, “Me? What about you? This house is full of beige and bland things.”

“Uh – no, this is all you.” He gestured at everything. “I would never have this couch.”

“Neither would I!” She snapped. Then, she sat down on said couch with a sigh, burying her head in her hands. “Sorry,” she murmured. “I’ve barely comprehended this whole being dead thing, and now this.”

She jumped lightly as he sat beside her. Billy didn’t touch her but sat close enough that he could press his shoulder to hers if he leans sideways. “Tell me about it.”

“So,” Robin perked up again, forced cheer lacing her words, “tell me about yourself, Mr Hargrove.”

Billy fiddled with the remote in his hand, debating whether he should lean into the story presented to him, or tell her the truth. But that wasn’t him, her soulmate wasn’t him. Her soulmate was a man who liked beige and Jesus, who travelled to poverty-stricken towns and donated all his money to charity.

“I… uh… I have something I need to tell you, but I need you to promise that this stays between us.”

He wasn’t looking at her, but Billy could feel her gaze drilling through the side of his head. He fiddled again, pressing the buttons with shaking fingers.

“It’s okay,” Robin replied softly. “Soulmates, right?”

“Right.” From the corner of his eye, he could see her small pinkie creeping in, stretching out to him like an olive branch. He hooked his pinkie through hers and bluntly said, “I don’t think we’re soulmates. I don’t think I belong here. These aren’t my memories and I’m really, really gay.”

She didn’t move. He looked up to find her staring at him, mouth agape as she struggled to form words. “Wh-what?”

“I’m really, really, really gay,” he repeated like this was the most important part of his truth bomb.

“I… me too.”

Their pinkies were still linked. Neither made to move away.

“Yeah?” His voice sounded gruff, even to his ears.

“Yeah. A big lesbian, it’s honestly unreal.”

Robin giggled then, hand moving from his to cover her face, as tears started streaming down her cheeks. She was caught in a weird laugh-sob combo and Billy did not know what to do. Awkwardly, he reached his arm around her shoulder and patted it carefully.

“Maybe the Billy Hargrove I’ve accidentally taken the place of is a girl?”

“No,” she said, swiping tears from her eyes. She took a deep breath, curling into him. Despite the fact that something had quite obviously gone wrong here, it was nice she still took comfort in him. “The second-best soulmate I could ask for is a man who isn’t attracted to women at all.”

“That makes sense.” Billy squeezed her shoulder.

She rested her head on his shoulder, staring at the screen, now displaying a date the other Billy was on. “You said you didn’t belong, why?”

“According to the old guy who showed me around, you have to be a pretty fucking good person to get into this kinda place. I was not a good person.”

“At all?”

“Good enough, I guess, for a guy like me.”

She peeked at him with her wide blue eyes, scrutinising him. “You seem alright to me.”

“Alright doesn’t seem to be good enough. This other Billy was a pastor who helped the disadvantaged, donated all his money to charity, fed starving kids! I stole money from a homeless man when I was fifteen. I’ve said racist and sexist and homophobic things right up until I died. I died in a drink-driving accident for God’s sake!”

He was getting angry again, could feel the familiar tremors coursing through his body. But now, he was also aware of Robin resting against him, looking at him.

“And you think you deserve hell?”

“It’s called the Bad Place.”

“Okay.” She rolled her eyes but continued, “So you think you deserve to go to the Bad Place, instead?”

“Well, I certainly don’t belong here,” he snapped. “And you deserve a proper soulmate.”

Robin sat up then, scowling and punched him square in the shoulder. Apparently he could still feel pain.

Before she could say anything, there was a knock on the door. Robin went quiet and moved to open it like they were criminals hiding in the shadows. It was Brenner at the door, smiling wide and eyes dark and curious.

“Ah, I see you have become acquainted.” There was a pause where it seemed like he wanted them to say something, but when they remained quiet, he continued like nothing happened. “Well, I just wanted to let you know that now everyone has been settled into the neighbourhood, one of your neighbours has decided to throw a welcome party, and you’re both invited!” He held a gold embossed invitation.

Robin took it with a pursed smile, and Billy finally made his way over to stand behind her as she opened it. “To Mr and Mrs Hargrove, you are cordially invited to the Harrington Welcome Party at the residence at the end of the cul-de-sac. Formal wear. Doors open at seven pm.”

“Mr and Mrs Hargrove?” Robin asked dryly, folding the invitation aggressively and shoving it in her pocket.

Brenner’s smile widened somehow. “Due to the nature of soulmates, many residents automatically assume marriage or a similar partnership. You can, of course, ask for people to call you something else, but it is the norm.”

Then he left, humming a merry tune as he walked down their path and out the garden. Robin shut the door and then made a rude gesture with her finger, flinging herself dramatically back onto the couch.

“I hate parties! And why is the ‘norm’ for soulmates to take the man’s name! We aren’t married! And! And platonic soulmates could be a thing. What happens if an asexual or aromantic get here, do they just not get a soulmate?”

“Platonic soulmates?” Billy asked, cutting her off.

“Yeah,” she replied, tracing the edge of the invitation with her thumb. “We obviously aren’t romantic soulmates. So, we’re platonic soulmates instead.”

Struggling for a moment, Billy tugged at the loose curls that framed his face. There was a sharp bolt of pain that disappeared almost as quickly.

“But what about this?” Here, he gestured to the rest of the house, to the beige furniture, the off-white walls, the maroon couch, the sermon paused on the screen. “What about your soulmate? This soulmate? Someone meant specifically for you?”

Robin looked around, shrugged and scoffed, “Given what I’ve seen about this mysterious other Billy, I don’t think I’d get along with them at all. They seem super religious, to an off-putting extent, and like we both said, this interior design isn’t it. I’d rather have you, if that’s alright?”

He slumped down beside her. “What happens if I’m taking someone’s place? Someone who deserves to be here?”

“Then,” Robin placed a warm hand on his arm and squeezed kindly, “we’ll deal with that when it comes.”


The Harrington house was a mansion, a mansion so big that it was practically a castle. Billy and Robin stood at the base of the path that stretched before them, winding towards glittering lights in the distance.

“If we don’t want to be extremely late, we better start walking now,” Robin said grumpily, staring at her heels.

They’d both panicked hard about the attire, throwing on the poshest things they could find in the closet (that were conveniently in their sizes). Billy was wearing a tux he wasn’t entirely sure was fitted correctly along with trousers he would struggle to get out of later. Robin was in a pastel pink dress that fell across her body like flower petals, with strappy heels, dotted with diamonds.

Billy held out his arm to her in solidarity, and she took with a sigh.

The ground was uneven underfoot which seemed inconvenient for paradise, and somehow they were both sweating when they arrived at the door. Robin took out a bottle of fragrance from her little bag and spritzed them both before she knocked.

The grand doors opened without anyone to greet them, which they took as their sign to enter. There was music coming from further inside, echoing down a marble hallway. Statues lined the walls, holding a myriad of weapons and having no conceivable link between them.

Above them was a portrait of a man and a woman. Beneath the frame was a placard that read, ‘Steve Harrington and Nancy Wheeler’. The supposed host, Steve Harrington, had a large head of brunet hair coupled with moles and large, brown, doe-like eyes. His smile was wide, showcasing straight, white teeth, and his eyes seemed to judge them as they looked down upon them. Nancy Wheeler looked like she’d rather be anywhere else, lips screwed as if she’d tasted something sour. She seemed small and delicate, and Billy wondered how long it would take for her to disappear in this large mansion.

“She didn’t take his last name,” Robin muttered petulantly.

“We’ll ask them to change it, don’t worry,” Billy said back, forcing his eyes from Steve Harrington’s.

At the end of the hallway, another door opened, music and light and laughter spilling into the cold shadows. Billy tugged her forward, leading her into the warmth.

There were so many people. A cacophony of noise washed over Billy, slipping between his ears and underneath his skin. Each laugh seemed grating, and the scent of food and alcohol was thick in the air. Neither he nor Robin knew anyone—Robin hadn’t felt inclined to explore the neighbourhood before Billy arrived.

“There’s the food,” she whispered, breath low and hot in his ear, gesturing to the banquet table laden with food at the other end of the room.

They started making their way over. Even though they’d dressed the most formal they could, it still seemed to Billy that they were outclassed. Everyone else seemed to have dusted themselves in shimmering gold and silver, and in comparison, Billy felt like he pulled his suit from a dumpster.

Slouching inwards, he forced himself to keep moving, instead of slinking into the shadows like he desperately wanted to do. Robin stuck to him, fingers clenched so tightly in his elbow they were turning a pale white. Her nail polish was chipped on some fingers already.

The food was small. So tiny. Tiny pieces of cheese and meats and pastry with tiny skewers in them. No one else seemed bothered by this, swallowing down bite after bite between conversation. It seemed impolite to pile a plate full of them, so he took a few and clutched them in his hand as Robin went off to get them drinks.

“My name is Steve Harrington.” Billy turned and almost knocked the glass from the man’s hand. He was slightly taller and standing way too close for a stranger.

“Um, what?”

Steve leaned closer, smiling wide, teeth white and smelling faintly of oranges. “Steve Harrington. I’ve never seen you around.”

“I literally moved in this morning,” Billy said dryly, taking a bite from the tiny cheese on sticks.

“Ah,” Steve nodded to this revelation like it was the most important thing, “that makes sense. Who’s your soulmate?”

Billy rolled his eyes but scoured the crowd anyway. Robin was awkwardly shuffling back through the mingling crowd; glasses clutched firmly in hand. “There,” he nodded.

Steve wrinkled his nose. “She seems… nice.”

“She’s lovely,” Billy replied shortly and went to meet her.

“How’s it going?” Robin whispered, handing him the drink. It tasted slightly floral. “Some random lady cornered me at the bar and wouldn’t shut up about her bestselling self-help book. Which I’ve never heard of, by the way.”

Billy snorted, wrapping an arm around her waist. “Yeah. The host himself cornered me to interrogate me about my place here.”

They turned back to the table, where Steve Harrington was still lingering. The man turned away when they caught him looking.

“Weirdo,” Robin muttered and shoved a block of cheese in her mouth.


At some point someone switched the music from classical to some beat that got people on the dancefloor. Also, it turned out you could still get drunk in the Good Place without actually consuming any alcohol, something Billy realised as he was swinging Robin around without rhythm.

At some point, another drink is pressed into his hand. At another point, a woman brushed against Robin, and she was spinning away into someone else’s arms. Billy downed his drink and swayed in time with the beat in an attempt to dance by himself.

A hand brushed his arm. “Can I have this dance?”

Billy turned and almost bumped noses with Steve Harrington since the man was standing so close. Steve’s pupils were blown, and the stench of floral alcohol flooded the air around them, mingling with the citrus scent seemingly stuck in his hair.

“What?” Billy asked.

Steve laughed. It lit up his eyes.

“Can I have this dance?”

His hands were already snaking around Billy’s waist, pulling him closer.

“What about your wife?”

“Nancy?”

“Yes. Your soulmate.”

Steve smiled again, as if Billy had told a joke. “She’s around.”

He may be drunk, but Billy couldn’t help but thinking of how these people had somehow ended up in paradise and were already reenacting some strange period drama.

“How long have you been here?”

“Like, four days,” Steve replied, fingers twitching against the small of Billy’s back.

Four days and he seemed to be bored of his soulmate already.

Billy started to sway, letting Steve guide him in the dance. Everything felt warm and stuffy.

“Your soulmate,” Steve whispered in his ear. “Where is she?”

Billy snorted against his shoulder. “Dancing. What’s it to you?”

“Just can’t believe she’d leave you by yourself.”

Billy suddenly took a step back, stumbling from Steve’s grasp and trying to shake off the dizziness. “I don’t know what you’re getting but I know her. I trust her. Leave me out of whatever this weird regency roleplay you and your soulmate have going on.”

He stepped back, and Robin spun into him.

“Hey,” she giggled, “I think we need to go home.”

“Yeah.” Billy wrapped an arm around her waist, holding her against him and helping her stay upright. Steve was still standing behind them, but Billy walked away before he could say anything else.