Actions

Work Header

there are voices in my head (the loudest one is mine)

Chapter 5: halloween

Chapter Text

Chapter 5: Halloween

Jonathan could scarcely admit to himself, but he regretted taking the upgrade. Not just because he missed Argyle (although he did a lot. When he’d been distracted by Heather’s schemes, not noticing that Argyle wasn’t there, it had been okay. But now that he was actively ignoring him, Jonathan couldn’t help but look for him in the throngs of students. He couldn’t tell if Argyle’s non presence was because of Jonathan or the nerve blocking. (( he hoped it was the latter)). However, because of the upgrade, the Flayer shocked him more frequently.

He would look in the mirror in the morning, shirtless and horrified. Although the Flayer could remove them, in private it kept them for Jonathan to see. Deep, black electrical burns that started on his chest and sparked outwards like a tree branch or lightning bolt, arcing over his shoulders, down his arms and back.

“If you would just listen to me,” the Flayer would say, “then it wouldn’t hurt as much.”

Nancy, Jonathan told himself every morning, you are doing this for Nancy.

Not that Nancy seemed to take notice. She and Steve were wrapped up in one another like a sappy rom-com couple or a Hallmark movie. It was kinda gross to look at, sitting opposite them at lunchtime.

The only advantage Jonathan now had was a link to Billy’s F.L.A.Y.E.R. who kindly informed them that Heather was unimpressed by Stancy, because of her loyalty to Billy – who, now that it was brought up, had a completely obvious crush on Steve it was almost embarrassing to watch.

So, the Flayer encouraged him to cultivate his friendships with Heather and Carol instead, who had settled into a natural rhythm between pet-project and actual friend. The only times Jonathan interacted with Nancy directly was during debate, where they were the first two members. These conversations often started stilted before shifting into a more natural state, usually once the Flayer prompted a dialogue.

The Flayer’s next point of development was the Halloween party.

“It’s very important,” it said, “that you participate appropriately. These sorts of events are important to your peers.”

So, Friday afternoon was spent picking an appropriate costume for Steve’s party. Not too nerdy, and not trying too hard, but not so thrown together that it looked as if he’d forgot. Finally, they settled on a knight, not too cartoonish or Disney.

This would be better as a couple’s costume.

“Just wait and see,” the Flayer responded with that knowing wink of his.

*

Steve’s party started between six and seven depending on how you interpreted ‘evening’. By the time Jonathan got there, people were spilling out onto the street, giggly and loud and obnoxious. Unsurprisingly, Jonathan was uncomfortable, something the Flayer hadn’t been able to shock from him yet.

Instead of greeting people he recognised, Jonathan stuck to shadows, trying to spot Nancy or Argyle. But she didn’t seem to be there yet, Steve flitted from person to person in a Han Solo costume, a partially dressed Billy Hargrove trailing after him like a guard dog.

Jonathan settled into a corner, to the Flayer’s disgust, but he couldn’t bring himself to pretend. All the criticisms, the shocks, the pretending was exhausting, and Jonathan would take advantage of the quiet when he could.

“Drink?” someone asked. It was Eddie Munson dressed all in black cloth like a homeless vampire.

“No thanks.”

“Come ooon,” he wheedled, tipping the red cup side to side in an attempt to be enticing. “We can’t let Harrington catch you looking bored.”

The Flayer nodded its assent, still pissed that Jonathan ignored it before. With a long-suffering sigh, Jonathan took it and drank. Although he and Argyle partook in plenty of weed variations, alcohol was still a strange substance to Jonathan. He let it burn down his throat and settle in his stomach before taking another sip, and then another.

Soon, he finished his cup and Munson switched them with a coy tilt of his head. As he drank more, Jonathan took stock of the room he was in, settling down to watch in amusement as Billy Hargrove stumbled into the room.

He did not look well. His eyes were dark, skin sallow and veins black in the warm, orange lamplight. There was a light sheen of sweat covering him.

“Do you have any red dew?” he was asking, gripping people’s shoulders. He stumbled when they shoved him away, and there was a growing mania to his actions.

Jonathan turned to the Flayer for guidance only to jolt back when he noticed the Mick Jones form dispersing into loose pixels.

Holy shit! Are you okay?

“I am – I am f – fine.” Its voice had a robotic quality to it. Then, before Jonathan could ask anything else, it disappeared completely.

It was odd. Jonathan hadn’t realised how dependent he’d been on this thing before it was gone. It may have been in his head for a few weeks, but now that it was gone… Jonathan didn’t know what to do.

Suddenly, the party seemed louder, brighter, overwhelming. His hands shook as he drained the rest of his cup, standing and tossing it near the trash can. He needed peace and quiet.

There was a bathroom at the top of the staircase, and Jonathan stumbled in. The door slammed behind him, and Jonathan sank to the floor, burrowing his head in his knees and breathing. All that he could hear was a dripping from the faucet and heavy breathing.

“Jonathan?”

He looked up and locked eyes with Argyle, who was sitting uncomfortably in the bathtub.

“Hey,” he said, weakly.

Argyle cycled through a series of emotions so quickly that Jonathan could only tell what he settled on – pity. It was an unusual emotion on his face, which is why Jonathan could pick it up so quickly. Argyle never pitied him before.

“You okay, dude?” Argyle unfurled himself from the porcelain container, wobbling before sitting next to him. He was warm, Jonathan never noticed how warm he was, or how much he missed it. Argyle looked better since the last time Jonathan saw him, less death-like.

In comparison, Jonathan was sure he looked like a mess.

Instead of responding to the question, Jonathan said, “Why aren’t you in costume?”

Something slipped on Argyle’s face, but he forced it away with a wide grin. “I am! Isn’t it good?” He spread his arms out to showcase his jumper dotted with the weed symbol.

Jonathan shrugged lethargically, returning to stare morosely at the ground. “I guess.”

They sat in silence for a moment, Jonathan soaking in the warmth from the shoulder pressed against his, when Argyle asked, “What did you mean when you chose Nancy?”

“What?”

“That day, when you ‘chose Nancy’ or whatever, then blocked me, then pretended i didn’t exist.” Argyle didn’t seem angry, but he never got angry. Trying to anger Argyle was like trying to drown a duck in water, it rolled right off him.

Jonathan swallowed convulsively. “I’m trying to get her.”

“Get her to what?” The patience in his voice rankled him.

“Date me. Fall in love with me. See me as more as the creepy weirdo with a crazy mom!”

Argyle looked at him, endlessly calm and asked kindly, “Did she think of you like that before?”

“She had to, why else wouldn’t she date me?” Saying it out loud, the desperation reeked so thick, it was palpable.

He could’ve thought about, narrowed down precisely what incentivised him to do everything he’s done so far, but the small, bitter part of him that was tired of trailing after Argyle like a lost puppy pushed back.

“You’re just jealous,” he spat.

(he wondered if this is what the Flayer wanted him to say. Wondered if he was holding himself correctly, whether he was hunched too low.)

Argyle moved suddenly, warm press of his shoulder leaving a cold pit like a ghost as he stood. Jonathan never saw Argyle startled, but looking at him now, it was as if Jonathan had struck him. His shoulders were up by his ears, fists by his side and a tight clench to his jaw.

“Why would you say that?”

“It’s the truth.”

“How long have you known?”

Jonathan blinked but didn’t clarify. “For a while. It’s obvious.”

Argyle’s eyes were suddenly wet, and Jonathan tried to reach for him. “Argyle, wha -?”

But Argyle squared his shoulders and said, “I looked the F.L.A.Y.E.R. up online, and it’s sketchy as fuck, dude. Like they did clinical trials on children kind of sketchy. I don’t know what we put in your body, but I don’t think it’s safe. I think we need to deactivate it.”

“Deactivate it?” Jonathan scoffed. “You really are jealous. Its helped me more than you ever have. I am not getting rid of it.”

Argyle rolled his eyes. “You need to get over yourself, dude. You’re so convinced that there’s more that you deserve.”

“You think I don’t deserve this?”

“No. I don’t. I can see what it’s doing to you.”

“What it’s doing to me? Unbelievable!” Jonathan felt himself fold inward.

“Show me your arms.”

“No.”

“Jonathan.” Argyle reached forward and tugged at his sleeve. “Show me and I’ll let it go.”

It should’ve been simple, but the thought of Argyle seeing the dark veins racing up his arms scared him.

“Leave me alone, bro.”

“Jonathan,” he whispered, “please.”

But Jonathan was panicked, angry and backed into a corner. “You need to leave. This is pathetic. You’re weak and scared and so lonely that you’re crawling on your knees, begging for me to acknowledge you. Well,” here he turned so he didn’t have to see Argyle’s face, “well, I don’t have to do that anymore. We aren’t friends.”

There was a deafening silence and Jonathan opened the bathroom door, the click of the lock behind him like a gun shot.

*

Nancy was downstairs, sitting by herself in a renaissance princess costume. She smiled when she saw him, gesturing for him to sit beside her.

“Nice costume,” she said, tipping her drink to his armour. “I see we match.”

He laughed. “What a lucky coincidence. But I thought you and Steve were coming in couple’s costumes?”

She sighed. “So did I.”

They watched as Steve flitted around the room, an odd twist to his face. He came over at some point, with two drinks in hand, handing them both to Nancy and Jonathan.

“Where’s your costume?” Nancy asked.

Steve frowned, eyes scanning the crowd as he mumbled, “I’m Han Solo.”

“I thought we agreed to be a prince and princess?”

This pulled Steve from wherever he was looking. He looked Nancy up and down. “I thought you were coming as Princess Leia?”

“Why would I come as her?”

“Because you said you would!” He threw his hands up in exasperation. “You said, ‘I’m going as a princess’ and I said, ‘like Leia?’ and you said, 'yes, I guess’.”

“Yes. Like Leia.”

Steve rolled his eyes. “Why do you always act like I’m stupid!”

Jonathan hunched in slightly as they continued to snipe at each other. Nancy’s hands were gripping the hem of her skirts as Steve drained his cup and mumbled something about finding Billy.

Nancy slumped against the couch; eyes slightly damp as she sipped forlornly at her drink. “I think Steve Harrington’s someone who doesn’t live up to the fantasy. Like when you get a cute puppy and realise you have them forever now, even when they aren’t cute anymore.”

“Are you – are you going to break up?”

She shrugged. “I don’t think we were really together in the first place.”

Jonathan wished the Flayer was there, to lead the conversation correctly. But Jonathan had to navigate it himself now, something he hadn’t done for an embarrassingly long time.

“I’m sorry.”

Nancy sighed. “It’s okay. I think I was desperate to understand why everyone around me is so obsessed with dating. Truthfully, I still don’t get it. It feels like a friendship with extra steps and more expectations. So, I think I’m going to be sticking to my regular friendships – like Barb, and you.”

There was… something. Jonathan wouldn’t call it rejection, but the sting in his chest was just as palpable. It wasn’t unsurprising, the feeling. It was as if he’d gone into it knowing he would be rejected.

“Cool. Glad I could help.”

“You – you are – you are – s0 – s0000 pathetic.” Before him, the Flayer was materialising. It seemed to pull itself together, pixel by pixel until the flashing form solidified into something more tangible.

I’m not. I’m just realising –

“ReALising ThaT wE HaVE W0Rk t0 D0?”

No.

A sharp burst of electricity coursed through his body. It wasn’t the short bursts he was used to, but a long-drawn-out line. Jonathan gasped slightly and curled in on himself, clutching his forearms in pain.

“Jonathan?” Nancy asked, hand resting gently on his shoulder, “Are you okay?”

“S33? ShE LIIiikes y0u. she’S just TRAPPED! Fr33 hER! fr33 Heer!”

“I’m fine. Just have a headache. I think I might sit outside for a bit.”

“Okay,” she relented, still worrying her bottom lip. “Let me know if you need water or anything, okay?”

“Yeah. Thanks.”

Jonathan stumbled his way outside, the glitching Flayer following, repeating ‘free her’ like a mantra. It hadn’t stopped shocking him, but the pain was a background to the anger coursing through him.

“What the hell was that?”

He didn’t care that he was talking out loud. Nothing mattered anymore. Nancy didn’t like him, and he’d ruined his friendship with Argyle in the process. Jonathan was truly pathetic.

The pain stopped and the Flayer stopped glitching, standing straight and smirking. “I needed to get you out the house.”

“What?” Jonathan asked, just as the house burst into flames.